10-23-19 Cost Sharing Presentation and Handouts
Monthly financial reports · Finance Committee · October 23, 2019 · 57 pages · 5,275 words · all RSU 5 documents · the district's file →
RSU5 Cost Sharing Method
Presented by the RSU5 Finance Committee October 23, 2019
Overview
● Timeline
● Fact-Finding
● Finance Committee Objectives
● Breakdown/Walkthrough of Current Funding Method
● Criteria for Changing Method
● Factors Considered
● Committee Recommendation
2
Cost-Sharing Method Evaluation Timeline 1/10/2018 - RSU5 Board instructs Finance Committee to undertake an evaluation of the current cost-sharing method.
3/28/2018 - RSU5 Board votes on the process for approval of any recommendation from the Finance Committee regarding changes to the current cost-sharing method. Board consensus was to approve via Board vote rather than Referendum.
4/2018 through 6/2018 - Finance Committee holds two meetings with Town Leadership from each member municipality to solicit input on additional factors to consider in its review of the cost-sharing method, sends follow-up letter to Town Leadership requesting letter of input on additional factors.
3
Cost-Sharing Method Evaluation Timeline 9/18/2018 - Finance Committee grants extension and/or allows for revisions to previous letters submitted by Town Leadership from each member municipality.
10/10/2018 - Finance Committee invites Town Leadership from each member municipality to RSU5 Board meeting to present their letters of recommendations. RSU5 Board provides direction on overarching goals.
12/2018 through 3/2019 - Fact-Finding Phase.
4/2019 through 6/2019 - Deliberation on current method and potential factors.
6/12/2019 - Finance Committee unanimously votes in favor of the Recommended Cost-Sharing Method outlined in this presentation.
4
Fact-Finding Phase
● Researched school finance laws regarding minimum receivership, special education adjustment, and EPS funding.
● Reached out to Legal counsel to clarify existing language in current cost-sharing method.
● Established comfort level and common understanding of how the ED 279 report utilizes the “total cost of education” (i.e., EPS Funding Allocation), Pupil Counts, State Valuations, and Mil Expectation to determine each member municipality’s Required Local Contribution and State Subsidy.
● Reviewed RPC Finance Committee meeting notes and contacted/met with former members of the committee from each town.
● Researched the cost sharing methodologies of other RSUs, focused on those that have changed since formation of their RSU and looked for common themes.
5
RSU5 Finance Committee Overarching Goals The Finance Committee considered the following criteria in its evaluation of the cost-sharing factors based on direction from the RSU5 Board, RPC Plan Recommendations, Town Leadership Recommendations, and Finance Committee Recommendations:
● Transparent & Easily Understood
● Variable
● Fair
● Not Overly Burdensome to Any Individual Town
6
Current Cost Sharing Method Required Local Contribution1 + Local Cost Sharing2 + Total Outside Contribution to the RSU3
1. Required Local Contribution per ED 279 Section 4.C.
2. Local Cost Sharing includes:
● Amount raised above Required Local Contribution to meet Mil Expectation (i.e., ED 279 Section 4.B. minus 4.C.)
● Additional Local Money pursuant to the Cost Sharing Formula.
3. Total Outside Contribution to the RSU includes all revenue from the state, except state-funded debt service.
● Subsidy (i.e., Difference between EPS Cost Allocation and Required Local Contribution by Municipality per ED 279 Section 4)
● Minimum Special Education Adjustment per ED 279 Section 5.A.4.
● Any Other Adjustments in ED 279 Section 5.B., such as Regionalization and Efficiency Assistance.
7
Section 13-B. of the Reorganization Plan prepared by Reorganization Planning Committee (“RPC”) [9/18/2008].
Current Cost Sharing Formula Additional Local Money - Member municipalities shall pay the following shares of each year’s total Additional Local Money for the RSU:
Durham: 21.42%
Freeport: 65.98%
Pownal: 12.60%
Per the RPC FAQs #4 & #6 (09/28/2008), these percentages were based on the percentage of ALM costs each town generated prior to
consolidation in the base year (i.e., 2007-2008). 8
Current Cost Sharing Method vs Overarching Goals
GOAL YES NO
Transparent & Easily Understood ✔
Variable ✔
Fair ✔Not Overly Burdensome to Any Individual ✔ Town
9
Non-Exclusive Criteria for Changing the Cost-Sharing Method The RSU Board shall consider all factors it deems relevant, but must consider the following criteria:
1. Fairness of the cost-sharing method in light of at least the following factors:
● Relative state valuations, representing each member municipality’s ability to raise revenue;● Relative populations, representing each member municipality’s board representation in the budgeting process; and
● Student head counts, representing each member municipality’s student usage of RSU facilities and programs;
Section 13-B., Paragraph D of the Reorganization Plan prepared by RPC (9/18/2008). 10
Non-Exclusive Criteria for Changing the Cost-Sharing Method
2. The effect of the cost-sharing method on the RSU’s ability to raise sufficient funds to sustain educational programs deemed to be in the best interests of RSU students;
3. Clarity of the method, including ease with which the public can understand the method, and
avoidance of uncertainty over the method’s application;
4. Consistency of the method with the operation of the RSU as a single, cohesive entity;
5. Effect of the method on the stability of RSU revenue streams and local taxpayer obligations.
Section 13-B., Paragraph D of the Reorganization Plan prepared by RPC (9/18/2008). 11
Evaluation of Cost-Sharing Factors
Required Local Contribution Additional Local Money
Minimum Special Education Adjustment State Valuation
Calculated Mil Rate Pupil Counts
Mil Expectation PopulationTax Increment Financing (TIFs)
Historical Spending
Median Household Income
12
Recommended Cost-Sharing Method The Finance Committee Recommends:
● Total Required Local Contribution: ○ Each municipality’s Calculated Mil Rate from Section 4.C. of the ED 279 adjusted downward by the amount of each municipality’s Min. Spec. Ed. Adj. (i.e., the Adjusted Local Contribution in ED 279 Section F shall be the Total Required Local Contribution).
● Additional Local Money based on the following Cost-Sharing Formula: ○ Each member municipality’s contribution to Additional Local Money shall be calculated as a weighted percentage, with 85% attributed to the municipality’s percent of the total of the member municipalities’ state valuations, and with 15% attributed to the municipality’s percent of the total of the member municipalities’ subsidizable pupils. A municipality’s percent state valuation and percent subsidizable pupils shall be calculated based on the values reported in ED 279 Section 4.A. and 4.B.
● Total Outside Contribution to the RSU revised to exclude Min. Spec. Ed. Adj.
13
Benefits of Proposed Cost-Sharing Formula Achieves the RSU5 Finance Committee Overarching Goals and provides a compromise of the various factors recommended by Town Leadership.
GOAL YES NO Transparent & Easily Understood ✔ Variable ✔ Fair ✔
Not Overly Burdensome to Any Individual ✔ Town
14
Glossary
Additional Local Money means Total RSU Spending Budget minus Total Outside Contribution to the RSU minus Total Required Local Contribution.
Applicable Mil Rate under the current cost sharing method is identical for all member municipalities in any single year and is equal to the Mil Expectation per ED 279 Section 4.B.
Calculated Mil Rate is the mil rate required to raise the municipality's Required Local Contribution, per ED 279 Section 4.C.
Local Cost Sharing under the current cost sharing method includes:
● Amount raised above Required Local Contribution to meet Mil Expectation (i.e., ED 279 Section 4.B. minus 4.C.)
● Additional Local Money pursuant to the Cost Sharing Formula.
15
Glossary
Mil Expectation is the full value education mil rate calculated in MRS, Title 20-A, Section 15671-A(2 ) and is listed in Section 4.B. of the ED 279.
Minimum Special Education Adjustment applicable to Freeport only. This is the additional amount above the State Contribution in ED 279 Section 4.C. which is necessary to meet the guaranteed minimum state share of Freeport’s portion of the Special Education Allocation in ED 279 Section 3.A. Calculated in accordance with MRS, Title 20-A, Section 15689(1)(B) and is the amount listed in ED 279 Section 5.A.4. As established by MRS, Title 20-A, Section 15689(1-B), this adjustment is applicable to municipalities part of a school administrative unit in existence prior to formation of the new regional school unit which received an adjustment in fiscal year 2007-08 or 2008-09. Freeport received the adjustment in fiscal year 2007-08.
16
Glossary
MRS, Title 20-A, Section 15688(3-A)B. For a school administrative district, community school district or regional school unit composed of more than one municipality, each municipality's contribution to the total cost of education is the lesser of:
(1) The municipality's total cost allocation from Section 4.A. of the ED 279.
(2) The total of the full-value education mil rate multiplied by the property fiscal capacity of the municipality from Section 4.B. of the ED 279. Required Local Contribution established by MRS, Title 20-A, Section 15688(3-A)B.
Total Outside Contribution to the RSU under the current cost sharing method consists of all revenues received by the RSU from sources other than municipal tax revenues for a given year, minus an amount equal to principal and interest payments on State-participating debt.
17
Glossary
Total Required Local Contribution under the current cost sharing method is the member municipalities’ most recent total state valuation multiplied by the Applicable Mil Rate. In accordance with the Reorganization Plan prepared by the RPC (9/18/2008), the Total Required Local Contribution for a member municipality may exceed the member municipality’s local cost share expectation under the Essential Programs and Services (“EPS”) provisions (Title 20-A, Chapter 606-B) of the Maine Revised Statutes. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in the Plan, however, each municipality’s required contribution to the “total cost of education”, as defined in Title 20-A, Section 15688 shall be the amount established by Section 15688(3-A), or successor provisions of state law, and any additional amount required hereunder shall be for purposes of local cost sharing. The Total Required Local Contribution under the current cost sharing method is the amount listed in ED 279 Section 4.B. (i.e., the Required Local Contribution plus the additional amount raised under Local Cost Sharing to meet the Mil Expectation).
18
Handout #1
TOWN OF FREEPORT
30 Main Street, Freeport ME 04032 ph: 865-4743 fax: 865-0929 www.freeportmaine.com
August 14, 2018
Dear Members of the RSU5 Finance Committee:
The Freeport Town Council (“Council”) received your May 29, 2018 letter requesting that the Council provide any additional factors to be added to the RSU5 Finance Committee’s consideration of the RSU5 Cost Sharing Formula.
In light of the language in the original reorganization plan creating RSU5 that the fairness of the cost sharing method should be considered when determining any change to the RSU5 Cost Sharing Formula, the Council believes that the following two issues, which the Council became aware of through its participation in the RSU5 Finance Committee’s Cost Sharing Formula reconsideration process, should be brought to your attention and deliberated in your upcoming cost‐allocation formula process:
1. Currently, RSU5 bases the “RSU Plan Required Local Contribution” to fund the essential programs and services provided by RSU5 on the calculation of each RSU5 member municipalities’ average state valuation multiplied by the state’s mill expectation (“RSU5 Required Local Contribution”) rather than on the state’s calculated “Required Local Contribution by Municipality.” This value is currently higher for the Town of Freeport than the State’s calculated “Required Local Contribution by Municipality.” Because Freeport’s required contribution is higher under “RSU5 Required Local Contribution” calculation than under the State’s “Required Local Contribution by Municipality,” this reduces the “additional local monies” that the other communities of RSU5 contribute.
For example, for the 2018‐2019 fiscal year, Freeport’s RSU5 “Required Local Contribution” (average state valuation multiplied by the state’s mill expectation) is $12,694,792.50. Alternatively, Freeport’s state calculated “Required Local Contribution by Municipality is $12,484,914.27. Accordingly, Freeport pays $209,878.23 more under the “RSU5 Required Local Contribution” calculation than it is required to contribute per the state’s “Required Local Contribution by Municipality” calculation.
The Council believes that the RSU5 Finance Committee should consider whether it is appropriate for Freeport’s required local contribution to RSU5 to be calculated consistently with the state’s Required Local Contribution by Municipality. If this were the case, any difference that needs to be contributed to fully fund the RSU5 budget, would then be included in the “Additional Local Monies” category, which Freeport would pay according to its proportional share (i.e. under the current proportional share allocations, Freeport would pay 65.98% of the $209,878.23, which is $138,477.66, rather than 100% of the entire $209,878.23 amount).
1
2. Additionally, the Council observes that Freeport’s minimum special education adjustment (which, for the 2018‐2019 fiscal year is $835,757.00), is not being applied at 100% to reduce Freeport’s required local contribution. Rather it is being credited in the category of additional local monies, which means that Freeport only gets credit for 65.98% of this amount (which in the 2018‐209 fiscal year would equal $551,432.47). This means that Freeport is paying $284,324.53 more toward Freeport’s Additional Local Monies than if Freeport’s minimum special education adjustment were applied 100% towards Freeport’s required local contribution.
Again the Council requests that this issue be further investigated and deliberated by the RSU5 Finance Committee as part of its upcoming process.
The Council is happy to make the Finance Director for the Town of Freeport, Jessica Maloy, available to discuss this issue with the RSU5 Finance Director in the event that further explanation is needed.
The Freeport Town Council appreciates the opportunity to be involved in the Committee’s process to‐ date and we are happy to answer any additional questions that are relevant to the RSU5 Finance Committee’s determination of whether and how to change the RSU5 Cost Sharing Formula. The Council asks that the Committee continue keep the Freeport Town Council, and Board of Selectmen (and women) of the Towns of Durham and Pownal, apprised of the Committee’s work. In particular, the Freeport Town Council and the Select Boards of Pownal and Durham be provided with an opportunity to comment on any proposed revised Cost Sharing Formula when the Committee gets to that point in the process.
Sincerely,
Sarah B. Tracy Freeport Town Council Chair
Cc: Pownal Board of Selectmen (and women) (via email)
Durham Board of Selectmen (and women) (via email)2
Handout #2
Handout #3
Handout #4
ALM Cost-Sharing Factors Pros & Cons Valuation Pupil Count
Pros Cons Pros Cons Consistent with Statewide Could create more drastic practice of allocating tax Does not account for usage Driver of usage
swings burden Does not necessarily Does not take into account
Easily accessible correlate with income of Easily understood effinciencies in Overhead residents
Indicative of ability to pay Readily available Population Tax Increment Financing (TIFs) Pros Cons Pros Cons
Difficult to determine (only Measure of voting power True value of each town Not easily understood counted at 10-year census)
Not a measure of usage Not easily determined
Not a measure of ability to May not be an apples-to-
raise funds apples comparison
Historical Spending Median Household Income
Pros Cons Pros Cons
Helped minimize spikes No longer relevant after 10 Indicator of individual
Typically dated info
during RSU transition years of RSU experience residents' ability to payNot indicative of full tax Static base (no commercial value)
Handout #5
MAINE REVENUE SERVICES PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PROPERTY TAX BULLETIN NO. 1 MAINE STATE VALUATIONS
REFERENCE: 36 M.R.S. §§ 208, 272, 305(1), 381, 683, and 692. 30-A M.R.S. § 5702. September 5, 2019; replaces June 16, 2015 revision
1. Overview
Maine law requires the State Tax Assessor to annually determine the equalized just value of all real and personal property in the state. These equalized values, known as state valuations, are compiled in a report which is certified with the Secretary of State by February 1 each year. The state valuations are used to calculate county taxes, to determine the amount of state funds to be granted to each municipality for education funding and revenue sharing, to establish municipal and school bond debt limits, and to determine municipal contributions to public school systems.
2. Definitions
A. Arm’s length sale. “Arm’s length sale” means a sale between a willing buyer and a willing seller
that are unrelated and are not acting under duress, abnormal pressure, or undue influence.B. Assessor. “Assessor” means a sworn municipal assessing authority, whether an individual assessor, a board of assessors, or a chief assessor of a primary assessing area. However, “Assessor” means the State Tax Assessor with respect to the unorganized territory.
C. Just value. “Just value” of property means its fair market value.
D. Municipal assessed value. “Municipal assessed value” means the total value of property in a municipality as recorded by that municipality. Municipal assessed value may be equal to, higher than, or lower than just value.
E. State valuation. The “state valuation” for a given tax year means the total equalized value of all taxable property in a municipality as of April 1, plus the portion of exempt value of homestead exemptions and Business Equipment Tax Exemption property reimbursed by the State to the municipality, less the captured property value in tax increment financing districts in the municipality.
3. State Valuations
The State Tax Assessor determines state valuations annually, by analyzing municipal assessed values and adjusting those values, if necessary, to make them equal to just value. This is accomplished by completing sales ratio studies for each municipality, which measures the assessed value of recently sold properties relative to their selling price. In some instances, individual ratios will be determined for different classes of property within a municipality (e.g., waterfront, commercial, residential, etc.).
1
The ratios computed from the studies are applied to all similar classes of property within that municipality to determine a reliable estimation of the fair market value of all taxable properties in the municipality.
Data used in these studies are drawn from recent arm’s length sales of property in the municipality, as reported by the municipality and on real estate transfer tax filings. Sales within a 12-month period surrounding the appropriate April 1 assessment date are reviewed. If there were insufficient arm’s length sales during that sales period to conduct a reasonable analysis, the State Tax Assessor may expand the sales period reviewed to 18 months, 24 months, or beyond.
In addition to sales ratio studies, the State Tax Assessor may use additional information from other sources in determining state valuations, including, but not limited to, municipal valuation returns, meetings with assessors, and appraisals of individual properties. This additional information may be reviewed with the municipal assessor and compared with municipal assessed values to determine the ratio to just value on which the municipal assessments are based.
The State Tax Assessor produces a preliminary determination of state valuation, known as the Report of Assessment Review, which provides details of the data and the computations used in the determination of the state valuation. Municipal assessors should review these reports to ensure accuracy of the information and to identify any issues before the proposed state valuation is sent.
The proposed state valuation report is sent by October 1 each year to the chair of the board of assessors and, in municipalities having selectmen, to the chair of the board of selectmen. This report contains a list of the state valuations for each municipality in the county in which the municipality is located.
The state valuation report is then filed with the Secretary of State and published annually. This report includes state valuations for each of the organized municipalities in the state as well as the unorganized territory, which is grouped by county. Property in the Passamaquoddy Tribe and Penobscot Nation Indian Territories is also included in the state valuation report.
4. Appeal Procedure
If a majority of the municipal officers disagree with the determinations in the proposed state valuation report, the municipality may appeal the State Tax Assessor’s determination to the State Board of Property Tax Review (the “Board”). A municipality must file an appeal with the Board by November
15. An appeal must be in writing, must be signed by a majority of the municipal officers, and must include an affidavit stating the grounds for appeal. A copy of the appeal and affidavit must also be sent to the State Tax Assessor.
The Board is independent from the State Tax Assessor and consists of 15 members appointed by the governor. Appeals are heard and decided by a subset of five members of the Board.
The Board has the power to administer oaths, take testimony, hold hearings, summon such witnesses and subpoena such records, files, and documents it deems necessary. The Board’s current rules and procedures may be found at www.maine.gov/dafs/boardproptax/.
The Board must hear an appeal within a reasonable amount of time and must render its decision no later than January 15 following the date of the appeal. Prior to a hearing, the Board will give at least five days’ notice to the municipality and the State Tax Assessor. If it rules in favor of a municipality, the Board may adjust the state valuation for that municipality. The State Tax Assessor must incorporate any adjustment into the state valuation report certified to the Secretary of State pursuant to 36 M.R.S. § 305(1).
2
Decisions of the Board may be appealed pursuant to the Maine Administrative Procedures Act, Title 5, chapter 375. If an appeal to the Superior Court or Supreme Judicial Court results in a lowering of the municipality’s state valuation, the State will reimburse an amount equal to the money lost by the municipality due to the use by the State of an incorrect value used to distribute state funds to municipalities.
NOTE: This bulletin is intended solely as advice to assist persons in determining, exercising or complying with their legal rights, duties or privileges. If further information is needed, contact the Property Tax Division of Maine Revenue Services.
MAINE REVENUE SERVICES PROPERTY TAX DIVISION PO BOX 9106 AUGUSTA, MAINE 04332-9106 TEL: (207) 624-5600 EMAIL: PROP.TAX@MAINE.GOV WWW.MAINE.GOV/REVENUE/PROPERTYTAX
The Department of Administrative and Financial Services does not discriminate on the basis of disability in admission to, access to, or operation of its programs, services or activities. This material can be made available in alternate formats by contacting the Department's ADA Coordinator at (207) 624-8288(voice) or V/TTY: 7-1-1.
(Published under Appropriation No. 1037.1)
3
Handout #6
Handout #7
2020 Board Adopted Budget Handout #8
ALM Calculation Current Methodology vs Recommended Methodology
Current Recommended
2019/2020 2019/2020
Total Operating Budget 34,192,295 Total Operating Budget 34,192,295
Less: Non-Shared and State Debt Less: Non-Shared and State Debt
Durham Non-Shared Debt 155,985 Durham Non-Shared Debt 155,985
Freeport Non-Shared Debt 155,264 Freeport Non-Shared Debt 155,264
Shared Debt (DCS) 1,270,507 ED279 Section 6 Shared Debt (DCS) 1,270,507 ED279 Section 6
Total Non-Shared and State Debt 1,581,756 Total Non-Shared and State Debt 1,581,756
Subtotal: 32,610,539 Subtotal: 32,610,539
Less: Local Revenues Less: Local Revenues
Shared Revenue 805,500 Shared Revenue 805,500
State Aid State Aid
(less State Supported Debt Service) 4,966,862 ED279 Section 6 (less State Supported Debt Service) 4,966,862 ED279 Section 6
Total Revenues 5,772,362 Total Revenues 5,772,362
Total Amount to be Funded Locally 26,838,177 26,838,177Local Funding Allocation
Total Amount to be Funded Locally 26,838,177 26,838,177
Less: RLC Less: RLC
Durham RLC 3,113,280 ED279 Section 4B Durham RLC 3,113,280 ED279 Section 5F
Freeport RLC 12,639,144 ED279 Section 4B Freeport RLC 12,599,192 ED279 Section 5F
Less: Min. Spec. Ed. Adj. 0 Less: Min. Spec. Ed. Adj. 1,015,214 ED279 Section 5F
Freeport Adj. RLC 12,639,144 Freeport Adj. RLC 11,583,978
Pownal RLC 1,954,908 ED279 Section 4B Pownal RLC 1,954,908 ED279 Section 5F
Total Amount Funded via RLC 17,707,332 Total Amount Funded via RLC 16,652,166 ED279 Section 5F
Equals: Total ALM Required 9,130,845 Equals: Total ALM Required 10,186,01185% Valuation / 15% Pupil Count
ALM Cost Sharing %: ALM Cost Sharing %:
Durham 21.42% Durham 19.55%
Freeport 65.98% Freeport 69.44%
Pownal 12.60% Pownal 11.01%
100.0%
Summary by Town: Summary by Town: $ Change % Change
Durham RLC 3,113,280 Durham RLC 3,113,280 - 0.00%
Durham ALM 1,955,827 Durham ALM 1,991,749 35,921 1.84%
Durham Non-Shared Debt 155,985 Durham Non-Shared Debt 155,985 - 0.00%
Durham Total 5,225,092 Durham Total 5,261,014 35,921 0.69%
Freeport RLC 12,639,144 Freeport RLC 11,583,978 (1,055,166) -8.35%
Freeport ALM 6,024,532 Freeport ALM 7,072,764 1,048,233 17.40%
Freeport Non-Shared Debt 155,264 Freeport Non-Shared Debt 155,264 - 0.00%
Freeport Total 18,818,940 Freeport Total 18,812,007 (6,933) -0.04%
Pownal RLC 1,954,908 Pownal RLC 1,954,908 - 0.00%
Pownal ALM 1,150,487 Pownal ALM 1,121,498 (28,989) -2.52%
Pownal Total 3,105,395 Pownal Total 3,076,406 (28,989) -0.93%
10,186,011100% Valuation / 0% Pupil Count
ALM Cost Sharing %: ALM Cost Sharing %:
Durham 21.42% Durham 17.58%
Freeport 65.98% Freeport 71.38%
Pownal 12.60% Pownal 11.04%
100.0%
Summary by Town: Summary by Town: $ Change % Change
Durham RLC 3,113,280 Durham RLC 3,113,280 - 0.00%
Durham ALM 1,955,827 Durham ALM 1,790,891 (164,936) -8.43%
Durham Non-Shared Debt 155,985 Durham Non-Shared Debt 155,985 - 0.00%
Durham Total 5,225,092 Durham Total 5,060,156 (164,936) -3.16%
Freeport RLC 12,639,144 Freeport RLC 11,583,978 (1,055,166) -8.35%
Freeport ALM 6,024,532 Freeport ALM 7,270,573 1,246,042 20.68%
Freeport Non-Shared Debt 155,264 Freeport Non-Shared Debt 155,264 - 0.00%
Freeport Total 18,818,940 Freeport Total 19,009,816 190,876 1.01%
Pownal RLC 1,954,908 Pownal RLC 1,954,908 - 0.00%
Pownal ALM 1,150,487 Pownal ALM 1,124,546 (25,940) -2.25%
Pownal Total 3,105,395 Pownal Total 3,079,454 (25,940) -0.84%0% Valuation / 100% Pupil Count
ALM Cost Sharing %: ALM Cost Sharing %:
Durham 21.42% Durham 30.73%
Freeport 65.98% Freeport 58.43%
Pownal 12.60% Pownal 10.84%
100.0%
Summary by Town: Summary by Town: $ Change % Change
Durham RLC 3,113,280 Durham RLC 3,113,280 - 0.00%
Durham ALM 1,955,827 Durham ALM 3,129,940 1,174,113 60.03%
Durham Non-Shared Debt 155,985 Durham Non-Shared Debt 155,985 - 0.00%
Durham Total 5,225,092 Durham Total 6,399,205 1,174,113 22.47%
Freeport RLC 12,639,144 Freeport RLC 11,583,978 (1,055,166) -8.35%
Freeport ALM 6,024,532 Freeport ALM 5,951,846 (72,685) -1.21%
Freeport Non-Shared Debt 155,264 Freeport Non-Shared Debt 155,264 - 0.00%
Freeport Total 18,818,940 Freeport Total 17,691,089 (1,127,851) -5.99%
Pownal RLC 1,954,908 Pownal RLC 1,954,908 - 0.00%
Pownal ALM 1,150,487 Pownal ALM 1,104,224 (46,262) -4.02%
Pownal Total 3,105,395 Pownal Total 3,059,132 (46,262) -1.49%
CURRENT ALM % Formula Straight ED279 RLC
ALM Cost Sharing %: ALM Cost Sharing %:
Durham 21.42% Durham 21.42%
Freeport 65.98% Freeport 65.98%
Pownal 12.60% Pownal 12.60%
100.0%
Summary by Town: Summary by Town: $ Change % Change
Durham RLC 3,113,280 Durham RLC 3,113,280 - 0.00%
Durham ALM 1,955,827 Durham ALM 2,181,844 226,016 11.56%
Durham Non-Shared Debt 155,985 Durham Non-Shared Debt 155,985 - 0.00%
Durham Total 5,225,092 Durham Total 5,451,109 226,016 4.33%
Freeport RLC 12,639,144 Freeport RLC 11,583,978 (1,055,166) -8.35%
Freeport ALM 6,024,532 Freeport ALM 6,720,730 696,198 11.56%
Freeport Non-Shared Debt 155,264 Freeport Non-Shared Debt 155,264 - 0.00%
Freeport Total 18,818,940 Freeport Total 18,459,972 (358,967) -1.91%
Pownal RLC 1,954,908 Pownal RLC 1,954,908 - 0.00%
Pownal ALM 1,150,487 Pownal ALM 1,283,437 132,951 11.56%
Pownal Total 3,105,395 Pownal Total 3,238,345 132,951 4.28%
RSU5 2020 BOARD OF DIRECTORS' ADOPTED BUDGET IMPACT Handout #9CURRENT METHODOLGY vs FINANCE COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED METHODOLOGY
Adopted Proposed
2019-2020 2019-2020 Difference
RSU Operating Budget
Total Operating Budget $ 34,080,295 $ 34,080,295 $ -
Adult Education Budget $ 112,000 $ 112,000 $ -
Total RSU Operating Budget w/Adult Ed $ 34,192,295 $ 34,192,295 $ - 0.00%
Less: State and Non-Shared Debt
F-Non-Shared Local Debt $ 155,264 $ 155,264 $ -
D- State Supported Debt $ 1,270,507 $ 1,270,507 $ -
D-Non-Shared Local Debt $ 155,985 $ 155,985 $ -
Total State and Non-Shared Debt $ 1,581,756 $ 1,581,756 $ -
ED 279 Section 6
Less: Local Revenues
Shared Revenue* $ 805,500 $ 805,500 $ -
State Aid $ 4,966,862 $ 4,966,862 $ -
Total Revenues $ 5,772,362 $ 5,772,362 $ -
Less: RSU Plan Required Local Contribution $ 17,707,332 $ 16,652,166 $ (1,055,166) ED 279 Section 5F
Total Additional Local Monies Required $ 9,130,844 $ 10,186,010 $ 1,055,166
Net Impact to Taxation Districtwide $ 26,838,176 $ 26,838,176 $ - 0.00%
Additional Local Monies Required Distribution Per RSU Plan
Durham 21.42% vs 19.55% $ 1,955,827 $ 1,991,748 $ 35,921
Freeport 65.98% vs 69.44% $ 6,024,531 $ 7,072,764 $ 1,048,233
Pownal 12.60% vs 11.01% $ 1,150,486 $ 1,121,498 $ (28,989)
Total Additional Local Monies Required $ 9,130,844 $ 10,186,010 $ 1,055,166
*Shared Revenue
Town of Freeport Hunter Road Field Maintenance $95,000
State Agency $40,000
Medicaid $50,000
Misc / Interest $19,000
Laugh & Learn $5,500
Contingency $196,000
Undesignated Fund Balance $400,000
Total Shared Revenue $805,5001
RSU5 2020 BOARD OF DIRECTORS' ADOPTED BUDGET IMPACT Handout #9
CURRENT METHODOLGY vs FINANCE COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED METHODOLOGY
Adopted Proposed
2019-2020 2019-2020 Difference
Additional Local Monies Required Distribution Per RSU Plan
Durham 21.42% vs 19.55% $ 1,955,827 $ 1,991,748 $ 35,921
Freeport 65.98% vs 69.44% $ 6,024,531 $ 7,072,764 $ 1,048,233
Pownal 12.60% vs 11.01% $ 1,150,486 $ 1,121,498 $ (28,989)
Total Additional Local Monies Required $ 9,130,844 $ 10,186,010 $ 1,055,166
Durham
RSU Plan Additional Local Monies $ 1,955,827 $ 1,991,748 $ 35,921
RSU Plan Required Local Contribution $ 3,113,280 $ 3,113,280 $ -
Non Shared Debt $ 155,985 $ 155,985 $ -
Net Impact $ 5,225,092 $ 5,261,013 $ 35,921 0.69%
Freeport
RSU Plan Additional Local Monies $ 6,024,531 $ 7,072,764 $ 1,048,233
RSU Plan Required Local Contribution $ 12,639,144 $ 11,583,978 $ (1,055,166) ED 279 Section 5F
Non Shared Debt $ 155,264 $ 155,264 $ -
Net Impact $ 18,818,939 $ 18,812,007 $ (6,933) -0.04%
Pownal
RSU Plan Additional Local Monies $ 1,150,486 $ 1,121,498 $ (28,989)
RSU Plan Required Local Contribution $ 1,954,908 $ 1,954,908 $ -
Non Shared Debt $ - $ - $ -
Net Impact $ 3,105,394 $ 3,076,406 $ (28,989) -0.93%2
RSU5 2019-2020 BOARD OF DIRECTORS' ADOPTED BUDGET IMPACT Handout #10
RECOMMENDED METHODOLOGY APPLIED TO 2018/2019 AND 2019/2020
Proposed Proposed
2018-2019 2019-2020 Difference
RSU Operating Budget
Total Operating Budget $ 32,946,024 $ 34,080,295 $ 1,134,271
Adult Education Budget $ 112,000 $ 112,000 $ -
Total RSU Operating Budget w/Adult Ed $ 33,058,024 $ 34,192,295 $ 1,134,271 3.43%
Less: State and Non-Shared Debt
F-Non-Shared Local Debt $ 162,486 $ 155,264 $ (7,222)
D- State Supported Debt $ 1,292,035 $ 1,270,507 $ (21,528)
D-Non-Shared Local Debt $ 198,901 $ 155,985 $ (42,916)
Total State and Non-Shared Debt $ 1,653,422 $ 1,581,756 $ (71,666)
ED 279 Section 6
Less: Local Revenues
Shared Revenue* $ 976,136 $ 805,500 $ (170,636)
State Aid** $ 4,659,591 $ 4,966,862 $ 307,271
Total Revenues $ 5,635,727 $ 5,772,362 $ 136,635
Less: RSU Plan Required Local Contribution $ 16,617,747 $ 16,652,166 $ 34,419 ED 279 Section 5F
Total Additional Local Monies Required*** $ 9,151,128 $ 10,186,010 $ 1,034,882
Net Impact to Taxation Districtwide $ 25,768,875 $ 26,838,176 $ 1,069,301 4.15%
Additional Local Monies Required Distribution Per RSU Plan
Durham 19.51% 19.55% $ 1,785,307 $ 1,991,748 $ 206,441
Freeport 69.48% 69.44% $ 6,357,755 $ 7,072,764 $ 715,008
Pownal 11.02% 11.01% $ 1,008,066 $ 1,121,498 $ 113,432
Total Additional Local Monies Required $ 9,151,128 $ 10,186,010 $ 1,034,882
*Shared Revenue
Town of Freeport Hunter Road Field Maintenance $95,000
State Agency $40,000
Medicaid $50,000
Misc / Interest $19,000
Laugh & Learn $5,500
Contingency $196,000
Undesignated Fund Balance $400,000
Total Shared Revenue $805,5001
RSU5 2019-2020 BOARD OF DIRECTORS' ADOPTED BUDGET IMPACT Handout #10
RECOMMENDED METHODOLOGY APPLIED TO 2018/2019 AND 2019/2020
Proposed Proposed
2018-2019 2019-2020 Difference
Last Year
Additional Local Monies Required Distribution Per RSU Plan Increase (%)
Durham 19.51% 19.55% $ 1,785,307 $ 1,991,748 $ 206,441 (per budget docs)
Freeport 69.48% 69.44% $ 6,357,755 $ 7,072,764 $ 715,008
Pownal 11.02% 11.01% $ 1,008,066 $ 1,121,498 $ 113,432
Total Additional Local Monies Required $ 9,151,128 $ 10,186,010 $ 1,034,882
Durham
RSU Plan Additional Local Monies $ 1,785,307 $ 1,991,748 $ 206,441
RSU Plan Required Local Contribution $ 3,095,200 $ 3,113,280 $ 18,080
Non Shared Debt $ 198,901 $ 155,985 $ (42,916)
Net Impact $ 5,079,408 $ 5,261,013 $ 181,605 3.58% 4.13%
Freeport
RSU Plan Additional Local Monies $ 6,357,755 $ 7,072,764 $ 715,008
RSU Plan Required Local Contribution $ 11,558,791 $ 11,583,978 $ 25,187 ED 279 Section 5F
Non Shared Debt $ 162,486 $ 155,264 $ (7,222)
Net Impact $ 18,079,032 $ 18,812,007 $ 732,974 4.05% 3.78%
Pownal
RSU Plan Additional Local Monies $ 1,008,066 $ 1,121,498 $ 113,432
RSU Plan Required Local Contribution $ 1,963,756 $ 1,954,908 $ (8,848)
Non Shared Debt $ - $ - $ -
Net Impact $ 2,971,822 $ 3,076,406 $ 104,584 3.52% 4.27%2
Source: , linked from www.rsu5.org/board-of-directors-and-policies/board-committees/standing-committees/finance-committee. Text copied out by software (pdftotext); no wording corrected.
