10.A. Cost Sharing Formula
Board meetings · Agendas · 34 pages · 12,219 words · all RSU 5 documents · the district's file →
12/14/2017 Regional School Unit No.5 Mail - Corrected Documents
(5) Ginny McManus <mcemanusg@rsu5.org> Corrected Documents
E. William Stockmeyer <billstockmeyer@dwmiaw.com> Thu, Dec 14, 2017 at 11:28 AM To: "lickteigm@rsu$.org" <lickteigm@rsu5.org>, Ginny McManus <memanusg@rsu5.org> Cc: "foleyb@rsu5.org" <foleyb@rsu5.org> Michelle and Ginny, Here are the corrections to the documents distributed to the board last night. | have also provided some comments below that may be of some assistance to the board in considering the cost sharing question. Please distribute the attached materials to the board and make sure the board replaces what was distributed last night with these two documents. To avoid confusion, everyone might either discard, or mark “DO NOT USE” on the document emailed yesterday. The only significant change is to the last example on Table 2 (100% Pupil Count Model). | also found some other very minor corrections, on the order of rounding errors. After hearing the board’s discussion last night, | offer the following comments and clarifications:
1. The board may consider changing the formula, but has no obligation to change the formula. Under section 13-B of the Plan, “Cost Sharing in the RSU,” the Board is not even obliged by that section to consider changing the formula. if there is an obligation to consider the formula, that would be by virtue of section 14 of the Plan, which states that the Board “shall conduct a comprehensive review of the Plan in the 5 year of the RSU’s operation, to determine if any amendments are appropriate, except that any changes to the cost sharing method under section 13B will be governed by the procedure outlined in Section 13 B.” Section 14 would apply to any Plan amendment, not just cost sharing. But section 14 further provides that amendments to the Plan may be considered at any time. Given that we are now in the ninth year of the RSU (four years past the 5 year), it would seem that there is no strict mandate to do anything at this particular point in time. It is up to the discretion of the board. Should there be any particular objection, the board may consider an amendment to the Plan at any time.
2. As|noted, Pownal this year is paying slightly over its valuation percentage, which is unusual. The difference is not much. Its valuation is going up as percentage of the RSU total valuation (10.27% in FY 2017 and 10.75% in FY 2018). It is paying 11.2% of local costs vs 10.75% of valuation in FY 2018, a difference of under % of 1% (NOTE: as ! explained at the meeting, Table 1 shows 12.6% of the “Additional Local Monies,” but if all the local share is considered, Pownai’s share is 11.2%).
3. To be clear, however, there is nothing inherently wrong with Pownal paying slightly over its valuation. This may fluctuate from year to year. Also, as mentioned at the meeting, different members came into the RSU contributing different things (such as state subsidy, and such as Freeport's “give back” of its EPS minimum receiver adjustment). Also, members benefit by joining into a district with better education programming and cost efficiencies than they obtained on their own. These relative benefits must be considered, and as discussed in the FAQ, these benefits were considered when the formula was agreed upon and established.
4. If need for a change is identified, it is important to consider what is workable, considering the process outlined to amend the formula and its requirements. https://mail.googte.com/mail/u/0/7ui=2&ik=3 1 Oafcl adi &jever=gNIGSxrCY so.en.acview=pt&mse=16055db7670bcebd &search=inboxdesiml=16055db7670bcebd 18
12/14/2017 Regional Schoo! Unit No Mali - Corrected Documenis
5. It is probably important that this not become divisive. Particularly if the formula is “working,” remember that fairness is somewhat subjective. Perhaps looked at more broadly, the question is whether the formula is working well or not.
6. The materials outline two types of change.
a. Table 2 shows various changes to both the “Total Required Local Contribution” component, as weil as to the “Additional Local Monies” component. These are replaced with the EPS component (shared per the state methodology on Form ED 279) and the additional local funds component used by most other school districts. Table 2 shows different ways to divide additional local funds, ranging from 100% valuation (common) to 100% pupil count (not used to my knowledge).
b. Table 3, in contrast to Table 2, leaves in place the “Total Required Local Contribution” component and the “Additional Local Monies” component, but suggests changing the fixed percentages dividing up the “Additional Local Monies,” to metrics based upon valuation and/or pupil counts.
7. The idea of both Tables 2 and 3 is to show total dollar impacts of various changes. The extra handout takes this one step further by showing the dollar impact, in terms of changes to the tax rates of the communities. For this purpose, | selected just three of the examples from Tables 2 and 3.
8. Conceptually, a third type of change would be to leave in place the “Total Required Local Contribution’ piece, and to retain fixed percentages to be applied to “Additional Local Monies” piece, but to simply adjust the fixed percentages. In some ways, this might be the simplest change to understand. This occurred to me on the way home from the meeting, after listening to the comments of various board members. | can show examples of this if you wish. | hope these thoughts provide further assistance to the board. If you have any questions, or need any further assistance, please let me know. Sincerely, Bill
E. William Stockmeyer
Attomey 207.253.0585 Direct billstockmeyer@dwmlaw.com
84 Marginal Way, Suite 600, Portland, ME 04101-2480 800.727.1941 | 207.772.3627 Fax |dwmlaw.com https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ui=2&ik=3 1 0afe lad] &jsver=gNJGSarCY so.en.&view=pt&msg=l 6055db7670bcebd&search=inbox&siml=16055db7670bcebd 2/3
Memorandum
RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula: Evaluation and Consideration of Amendment
Page 1 of 9
Revisect 1a-14-17
TO: RSU 5 School Board FROM: E. William Stockmeyer, Drummond Woodsum RE: The RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula: Evaluation and Consideration of Amendment - DATE: December 13, 2017 Under the RSU 5 Reorganization Plan (the “Plan”), the Schoo! Board has the legal authority to consider changes to the RSU 5 cost sharing formula. This memorandum explains the components of the current formula, the legal requirements to change the formula, how the RSU 5 cost sharing formula currently works, the considerations applicable to a “fair” formula, and how the current RSU 5 formula compares with school district cost sharing formulas based on valuation or student count.! Finally, the Memorandum provides a Worksheet to compare tax impacts of amendments the Board might wish to consider as compared to the current cost sharing formula. The goal of this Memorandum is to provide the RSU 5 Board with background information to assist the Board in its periodic evaluation of the cost sharing formula, as provided by the Plan, and whether a change should be made to the current formula.
PART 1: COMPONENTS OF THE RSU 5 COST SHARING FORMULA
The RSU 5 cost sharing formula applies to the portion of the Total Operating Budget and Adult Education Budget that remains after first deducting all other available revenues. The non-tax revenues, deducted first, are as follows:
e State-Supported Debt. The debt service on this debt is a portion of the subsidy provided by the State under its Essential Programs and Services funding model. This subsidy exists for certain state-approved school construction projects. Currently, the state- supported debt consists of debt on the Durham Elementary School that qualifies for State subsidy (see Maine DOE Form ED 279, sections 3.C and 4.A).
‘ Due to time constraints all table calculations are subject to final verification of the RSU 5 business office.
Memorandum
RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula: Evaluation and Consideration of Amendment
Page 2 of 9
® Other State Subsidy. The State provides further subsidy through its Essential Programs and Services Funding model.” The subsidy amount appears on Maine DOE Form ED 279, including the debt service subsidy described previously.
© Miscellaneous Revenues. This includes various non-tax revenues from miscellaneous sources, and may also include some portion of the RSU’s undesignated fund balance applied to the budget. These revenues reduce the local! tax burden.
After deduction of the above revenues, the remaining costs of the Total Operating Budget and Aduit Education Budget are funding by the RSU cost sharing formula. Pursuant to section 13-B of the Plan, the cost sharing formula consists of three different components, each of which requires local property taxes to be raised by RSU 5 members, The three components of the current cost sharing formula are described as follows:
e Pre-Existing Debt Component. Under the Plan, debt existing prior to formation of the RSU for facilities not shared by the members remained the responsibility of the town using the facility that had incurred that debt. Currently, there remains about $200,000 in Durham Debt and $170,000 in Freeport Debt. The formula requires these two towns contribute to pay that debt as it comes due without contribution from the other RSU 5 members. About 1/3 of the Durham debt will be retired in a year and 2/3 in 2030. The Freeport debt will be retired in 2021. Notably, a town’s retirement of its non-shared debt will reduce that town’s share of local costs without increasing the shares of the other towns — the debt will simply no longer exist. For purposes of this Memorandum, we have assumed that a cost sharing amendment, if any, would not change this non-shared debt component of the cost sharing formula.
e The “Total Required Local Contribution” Component. The Plan provides for each member to pay an amount equal to its most recent total state adjusted valuation multiplied
2 The EPS model develops an amount, called the “total allocation,” which the state deems to be the costs necessary to achieve desired learning outcomes. The total allocation amount in FY 2018 for RSU 5 is $21,505,554, comprised of a state contribution and a local (meaning school district) contribution. Each RSU 5 town presumptively pays a portion of the total allocation, but not more than a maximum required effort. This happens by the following process. First, the state divides the total allocation of $21,505,554 between the three towns based on their pupil count percentages. Each town presumptively must pay this portion of the total allocation, however, the state provides relief if the town would exceed a maximum required tax effort. The maximum required tax effort is the town’s fiscal capacity (state adjusted valuation) times a statewide mill rate factor (8.19 mills in FY 2018). The most that the town must pay towards its portion of the total allocation is this “cap” amount with the state contributing the amount over the cap, if any, to RSU 5 as state subsidy on the town’s behalf. The state subsidy amount paid to RSU 5 on each town’s behalf, if any, is the balance of the town’s portion of the total allocation. However, currently the amount the State contributes in excess of Freeport’s tax effort for EPS is so low that the State also contributes an additional
| special education minimum receiver adjustment.
Memorandum
RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula: Evaluation and Consideration of Amendment
Page 3 of 9
by the mill rate established by the State (in FY 2018, this mill rate was 8.19 mills).* The Plan notes that a member’s share of the “Total Required Local Contribution” may exceed its local cost share expectation to be paid under EPS. The Plan further notes that any amount of a town’s share of the Total Required Local Contribution that exceeds the town’s required contribution to the total cost of education under the EPS model “shail be for purposes of local cost sharing.” In applying the cost sharing formula, the difference between the members’ Total Required Local Contributions and their required contributions under the EPS model acts to reduce the Additional Local Money amount to be shared as described below. Thus, insofar as Freeport qualifies for a special education minimum receiver adjustment under the EPS funding model (see Form ED 279, section 5.A), Freeport effectively contributes a sum to be shared with the other towns, instead of enjoying all the benefit of that adjustment.
¢ Additional Local Money Component. The remaining portion of the Total Operating Budget and Adult Education Budget is funded by the third cost sharing component, called “Additional Local Money.” The cost sharing formula requires Durham to pay 21.42%, Freeport to pay 65.98% and Pownal to pay 12.60% of the Additional Local Money. Under the current formula, these percentages are fixed. The percentages were derived by the Reorganization Planning Committee (“RPC”) from the amounts the towns were contributing for additional funds without state participation in the “base year,” i.e., the year prior the RSU’s first operational year (see RPC FAQs at page 2, revised September 28, 2008). As noted previously, before these fixed percentages are applied, Durham and Pownal effectively receive the benefit of a credit by virtue of Freeport paying a higher amount as its share of Total Required Local Contribution than if Freeport enjoyed the sole benefit of its special education minimum receiver adjustment. Importantly, and as described above, the RSU 5 cost sharing components differ from most formulas used in the State. Whereas RSU 5 uses fixed percentages to divide Additional Local Monies, and these percentages are based upon prior contribution amounts from a base year, the formulas commonly employed by other school districts in the State generally are based upon valuations, or based on some combination of valuations and pupil counts. Also, the formulas commonly used by other school districts in the State generally apply only to additional local funds. Only about 10 other school districts statewide employ local cost sharing formulas that also apply to the members’ local contributions to EPS, effectively reallocating those contributions.
* Notably, instead of relying upon the State’s measure of valuation, called “fiscal capacity,” which currently is a three year average of adjusted state valuations, the Plan uses the most recent state adjusted valuations to determine the members’ shares of the Total Required Local Contribution. This means that RSU 5 administrators may not rely upon the fiscal capacity numbers in the ED 279, but must use the most recent state valuation figures to compute the shares. Valuations used in the Tables of this Memorandum, however, are based upon fiscal capacity, except for figures used in or applied from the current cost sharing formula.
Memorandum
RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula: Evaluation and Consideration of Amendment
Page 4 of 9
PART 2: AMENDING THE RSU 5 COST SHARING FORMULA: PROCEDURES AND APPROACH
Section 13-B(C) of the Plan, “Changes to the Cost Sharing Method,” fixed the RSU 5 cost sharing method for the first three years’ of the RSU’s existence. Following that period, the Plan provides that the cost sharing formula “may be changed, but shall not be required to be changed.” The Plan establishes two possible procedures for RSU 5 to amend the cost sharing formula.
Under the first cost sharing amendment procedure, the RSU 5 School Board may implement the change by a majority board vote without submission to the voters, provided the board vote satisfies a special “quorum requirement” and a special “vote distribution requirement.” The “quorum requirement” is that at least one Board member from each municipality must be present at the meeting. In other words, a single town could block the proposed change if all its board members are absent from the meeting, even if it were approved by a majority at a meeting attended by a regular quorum. The “vote distribution” requirement is that “[b]oard members representing two-thirds or more of the RSU population must vote in favor of the change.”
Under the second cost sharing amendment procedure, a “simple majority of the RSU Board” may send a proposed change to an RSU 5 referendum vote. This procedure does not have any special quorum requirement or vote distribution requirement imposed on the board vote or on the referendum vote. The referendum election called by the School Board would require a “majority of voters in the RSU” to enact a cost sharing amendment.
PART 3: WHAT IS THE FAIR WAY FOR SCHOOL DISTRICT MEMBERS TO SHARE THE LOCAL TAX BURDEN?
People are likely to disagree about what is fair. That being said, a few observations are relevant to the discussion. These observations are based in part upon our general background experience across the state and in part upon a survey of our client files.
e First, the great majority of other RSUs and MSADs in the state apply their cost sharing formulas only to the additional local funds portion of the budget.
e Second, a majority of the other cost sharing formulas are based in whole upon state adjusted valuation percentages.
e Third, a significant minority of other cost sharing formulas use a combination of valuation percentages and pupil count percentages. In most cases, 50% or more is allocated by valuation and under 50% is allocated by pupil count.
e Fourth, to our knowledge, other RSUs and MSADs do not use pupil count percentages only,
Memorandum
RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula: Evaluation and Consideration of Amendment
Page 5 of 9
e Fifth, it is highly unusual for an RSU or MSAD to use a factor other than valuation or pupil count.
e Sixth, in changing a cost sharing formula, there are various methods to phase in the change to reduce the immediate impact.
The argument in favor of using property valuation is that, as a general principle, property taxes should be assessed in proportion to property valuation throughout a taxing district. Proportionate taxation is generally required by the Maine constitution, subject to certain express exceptions such as tree growth property, farm and open space property, and school district cost sharing methods. In a school district, the taxing district is the school district, not the individual towns. There is a shared school system, and the taxes are raised by vote of the whole district, not by separate town votes. Under this view, the role of the towns is to simply collect and to pay over the school district taxes so as to avoid the need for a separate, school district tax collection system. Proportional taxation means that two restaurants of the same property valuation should be taxed the same wherever they may be located in the taxing district. Under this view, the students are considered students of the district, rather than students of the towns, since they attend a district school system. The argument for using pupil count is a more practical one. In some places, high valuation/low pupil count towns could not easily be encouraged to join school districts with low valuation/high pupil counts. By introducing a pupil count factor in the local cost sharing formula in addition to valuation, it was found that these towns with these differences might be encouraged to form school districts. Under this view, each town’s obligation to support the schools depends on its number of students, as if it had a separate school system and a separate system of taxation for its schools, When pupil counts are used, property taxation ceases to be proportionate throughout the school district. A restaurant in one town may be taxed differently than a restaurant with the same valuation in another town, even though both restaurants support the same school system. [End of Part 3; remainder of page intentionally left blank]
Memorandum
RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula: Evaluation and Consideration of Amendment
Page 6 of 9
PART 4: WHAT WOULD BE THE ECONOMIC IMPACT OF CHANGING THE
METHOD OF SHARING COSTS TO (a) A METHOD BASED ON VALUATION AND/OR PUPIL COUNT FACTORS OR (b) A METHOD THAT CONTINUES TO USE THE TOTAL REQUIRED LOCAL CONTRIBUTION WHILE ADOPTING VALUATION AND/OR PUPIL COUNT FACTORS INSTEAD OF FIXED PERCENTAGES FOR THE “ADDITIONAL LOCAL MONIES”? In RSU 5, the valuation (fiscal capacity) and pupil count percentages are as follows:
TABLE 1: COMPARING VALUATION, PUPIL COUNT, AND ADDITTONAL LOCAL MONEY (ALM) PERCENTAGES, FY 2017 AND FY 2018
| | ‘Valuation % | Pupil% | ALM % | Valuation% | Pupil% | ALM% | 12.60% Note: Table uses state adjusted valuations. Table 1 shows that:
e Durham has a low valuation (18%) relative to its pupil count (32%). A formula weighted towards valuation reduces Durham’s relative costs, while a formula weighted towards pupil counts increases them.
e Freeport has high valuation (71%) relative to its pupil count (58%). A formula weighted towards valuation increases Freeport’s relative costs, while a formula weighted towards pupil count decreases them. Adjustments will not have as great an effect as in Durham.
e Pownal’s valuation is about the same relative to its pupil count. It share is relatively constant whether a formula is weighted towards either valuation or pupil count.
Table 1 further shows that:
e Durham’s current, fixed, ALM percentage is between its valuation and pupil count percentages, but closer to its valuation percentage.
e Freeport’s current, fixed, AIM percentage is close to midway between its valuation and pupil count percentages.
e Pownal’s current, fixed, ALM percentage is higher than either its valuation percentage or its pupil count percentage.
The following Tables compare the existing formula with alternatives. Table 2 compares the existing formula with models that use the ED 279 contributions instead of the current formula’s calculation of “Total Required Local Contribution,” and then apply various valuation and/or pupil count methodologies to the additional local funds component (instead of to the current formula’s “Additional Local Money”). Table 3 compares the existing formula with models that retain the current formula’s calculation of “Total Required Local Contribution,” and then apply various valuation and/or pupil count methodologies to “Additional Local Money.”
Memorandum
RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula: Evaluation and Consideration of Amendment
Page 7 of 9
Table 2: RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula Compared to Various Models Based on Valuation and/or Pupil Count Current Cost Sharing Formula 2018 $202,782 | $2,928,166 | $1,826,251| $4,957,199 | $4,754,417 | Freeport _| $169,708 | $11,560,225 | $5,625,399 | $17,355,332 | $17,185,624 [Pownal = [| si | ~——«$:1,745,183 | $1,074,265] $2,819,449 | $2,819,449 100% Valuation Model, Applied to Addl Local Funds (Widely used in Maine Debt Local Contribution” Funds” MUNICIPALITY if debt were retired $202,782 | $2,892,845 | $1,641,171 | _ $4,736,798 | $4,534,016 [Freeport | $169,708 | $11,040,066 | $6,482,763 | $17,692,537 | $17,522,829 |Pownal =| ~———s $0 | _~—*$:1, 724,131 $978,513 | $2,702,644| $2,702,644 75:25 Valuation:Pupil Count Model, Applied to Addl Local Funds cr 7 al -Shared “ED 279 A “Additional Local justed 1 $202,782 | $2,892,845 | $1,951,565 | $5,047,192 | $4,844,410 $169,708 | $11,040,066 | $6,182,383 | $17,392,157 | $17,222,449 [Pownall =| $0] $1,724,131 $968,500 | $2,692,631 | $2,692,631 50:50 Valuation:Pupil Count Model, Applied to Addl Local Funds $202,782 | $2,892,845 | $2,261,958 | $5,357,585 | $5,154,803 Freeport | $169,708 | $11,040,066 | _ $5,882,002 | $17,091,776 | $16,922,068 [Pownall =| ———s $0 «$31,724,131 $958,488 | $2,682,619 | $2,682,619 25:75 Valuation:Pupil Count Model, Applied to Addl Local Funds + otal 1 Non-Shared “ED 279 Adjusted “Additional Local justed Total: Municipality $202,782 | $2,892,845] $2,571,442} $5,667,069 | $5,464,287 | Freeport —_| $169,708 | $11,040,066 | $5,581,621 | $16,791,395 | $16,621,687 |Pownal | $0] $1,724,131 $949,385 | $2,673,516 | $2,673,516 100% Pupil Count Model, Applied to Addl Local Funds $202,782 | $2,892,845 | $2,881,835 | $5,977,462 | _ $5,774,680 Freeport | $169,708 $11,040,066 | $5,281,240 | $16,491,014 | $16,321,306 |Pownal | —— $0| $1,724,131 $939,373 | $2,663,504 | $2,663,504
Memorandum
RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula: Evaluation and Consideration of Amendment
Page 8 of 9
Table 3: RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula Compared to Models That Ketain the “Total Required Local Contribution” Component and Adjust Only the “Additional Local Money” Component Current Cost Sharing Formula (FY 2018) => Addl Local Money: Durham 21.42%: Freeport 65.98%; Pownal 12.60% Durham ' $202,782 $2,928,166 $1,826,251 $4,957,199 $4,754,417 Freeport $169,708 | $11,560,225 $5,625,399 | $17,355,332 | $17,185,624 'Pownal |. ___-$0 | __ $1,745,183 | $1,074,265 | _ $2,819,449 | $2,819,449 Total Required Local Contribution: Current Cost Sharing Formula (FY 2018) > Addl Local Money Using Valuation: Durham 18.03%; Freeport 71.22%; Pownal 10.75% Durham $202,782 $2,928,166 $1,537,223 $4,668,171 $4,465,389 Freeport $169,708 | $11,560,225 $6,072,157 | $17,802,090 | $17,632,382 [Pownal | — $0[ $1,745,183! $916,536 | $2,661,719 | $2,661,719 Total Required Local Contribution: Current Cost Sharing Formula (FY 2018) => Addl Local Money Using 75%Valuation/25% Pupil Count: Durham 21.44%: Freeport 67.92%: Pownal 10.64% sonality con- « quir “Additional Local TOTAL BY Adjusted Total: Municipality idee weed | $202,782 | $2,928,166 | $1,827,956 | $4,958,904! $4,756,122 $169,708 | $11,560,225 | $5,790,802 | $17,520,735 | $17,351,027 Pownal $0 $1,745,183 $907,157 $2,652,340 $2,652,340 Total Required Local Contribution: Current Cost Sharing Formula (FY 2018) => Addl Local Money Using 50% Valuation/50% Pupil Count: Durham 24.85%; Freeport 64,62%; Pownal 10.53% Debt Local Contribution” Monies” MUNICIPALITY if debt were retired Durham $202,782 $2,928,166 $2,118,690 $5,249,638 $5,046,856 Freeport | $169,708 | $11,560,225 $5,509,447 | $17,239,380 | $17,069,672 Pownal $0 $1,745,183 $897,778 $2,642,962 $2,642,962 Total Required Local Contribution: Current Cost Sharing Formula (FY 2018) | => Addi Local Mone Using 25% Valuation/75% Pupil Count: Durham 28.25%; Freeport 61.32%; Pownal 10.43% cl 5 ocal Non- “Plan Require “Additi Adjusted Totals Municipality $202,782 | $2,928,166 | $2,408,571 | $5,539,519 | $5,336,737 Freeport $169,708 | $11,560,225 $5,228,092 | $16,958,025 | $16,788,317 iPownal | —_—_—$0| ‘$1,745,183 $889,253 | $2,634,436 | $2,634,436 Total Required Loca] Contribution: Current Cost Sharing Formula (FY 2018) => Addl Local Money Using Pupil Count: Durham 31.66%; Free port 58.02%; Pownal 10.32% _ /Durham | $202,782] $2,928,166] $2,699,305 | $5,830,253 | $5,627,471 | Freeport $169,708 | $11,560,225 $4,946,736 | $16,676,669 | $16,506,961 Pownal | $0 $1,745,183 $879,875 $2,625,058 $2,625,058
Memorandum
RSU 5 Cost Sharing Formula: Evaluation and Consideration of Amendment
Page 9 of 9
TABLE 4: WORKSHEET TO CALCULATE TAX IMPACTS OF SELECTED AMENDMENTS AS COMPARED TO CURRENT RSU 5 COST SHARING FORMULA
Amendment A Town (Current Proposed Tax increase/ | Mill rate Tax Tax increase/ | FP Fee Formula: due to (decrease) (decrease) | total school proposed due to proposed | per property tax amendment amendment $100,000 burden (including
home(or | EPS) other prope [Durham [| $49s7,i99[ | Freeport | $17,355,332] [Pownall | $2819449[ PP Amendment B
Town (Current Proposed Tax increase/ | Mill rate Tax Tax increase/ Formula) Amended (decrease) increase/ increase/ decrease as % of Formula: due to (decrease) (decrease) | total school proposed due to proposed | per property tax amendment amendment $100,000 burden (including
heme (or | EPS) other Pro DEITS | Durham | $4,957,199[ [Freeport | $17,355,332[ TT [|Pownal [| $2,819,449} 0 P Amendment C
Town (Current Proposed Tax increase/ | Mill rate Tax Tax increase/ Formula) Amended (decrease) increase/ increase/ decrease as % of Formula: due to (decrease) (decrease) | total school proposed due to proposed | per property tax amendment amendment $100,000 burden (including home ( or EPS) other ‘Durham | sass7,i9[ Sid) SCCr CCCCCCrSCSCS~dY: SSCS
[Freeport | $17,355,332{ | [Pownal | $2,819449[; TP NOTE: Phase-in options exist, such as:
e 3 Year phase-in: Year 1, 1/3 current formula, 2/3 new formula; Year 2, 2/3 current, 1/3 new; Year 3, all new formula
e 3 Year phase-in: same idea: 20%/ 40%/ 60%/ 80 %/ 100% NOTE: The above impacts have not been adjusted to account for shifts when pre-existing debt is paid off in Freeport (in 2021) and in Durham (about 1/3 next year and 2/3 in 2030). Increases in those two towns under a selected amendment would be offset when debt is retired.
EXAMPLES OF TAX IMPACTS OF SELECTED AMENDMENTS AS COMPARED TO CURRENT RSU 5 COST SHARING FORMULA
Amendment A: From Memorandum, Table 2-100% valuation (with pre-existing debt) Formula) Amended (decrease) increase/ increase/ decrease as % of Formula: From due to (decrease) (decrease) | total school Table 2-100% proposed due to proposed | per property tax valuation (with amendment amendment $100,000 burden (including
debt) . home(or | EPS) other prope
[Pownal [$2,819,449 [$2,702,644 | ($116,805) [0.555 mills) | ($55.48) | (4.14%) | Amendment B: From Memorandum, Table 3-75% valuation/25% pupil count (with pre-existing debt) Town (Current Proposed Tax increase/ | Mill rate Tax Tax increase/ Formula) Amended (decrease) increase/ increase/ decrease as % of | sees Table 3-75% proposed due to proposed | per property tax valuation/25% amendment amendment $100,000 | burden (including
pupil count home(or | EPS) other HTOPeITy
Amendment C: From Memorandum, Table 3-50% valuation/50% pupil count (with pre-existing debt) Town (Current Proposed Tax increase/ | Mill rate Tax Tax increase/ Formula) Amended (decrease) increase/ increase/ decrease as % of Formula: From due to (decrease) (decrease) | total school Table 3-50% proposed due to proposed | per property tax valuation/50% amendment amendment $100,000 burden (including
other properly NOTE: Phase-in options exist, such as:
e 3 Year phase-in, Year 1, 1/3 current formula, 2/3 new formula; Year 2, 2/3 current, 1/3 new; Year 3, all new formula
e 5 Year phase-in: same idea: 20%/ 40%/ 60%/ 80 %/ 100% NOTE: The above impacts have not been adjusted to reflect shifts when pre-existing debt is paid off in Freeport (in 2021) and in Durham (about 1/3 next year and 2/3 in 2030). Increases in those two towns under a selected amendment would be offset when this debt is retired.
RSUS5 2017-2018 BOARD OF DIRECTORS' ADOPTED BUDGET IMPACT
With additional subsidy Assessed Proposed 2016-2017 2017-2018 Difference RSU Operating Budget
Total Operating Budget $ 30,908,672 $ 32,207,685 $ 1,299,013 Adult Education Budget $ 100,000 § 103,000 $ 3,000 Total RSU Operating Budget w/Adult Ed $ 31,008,672 $ 32,310,685 $ 1,302,013 4.20% Less: State and Non-Shared Debt F-Non-Shared Local Debt $ 176,207 §$ 169,708 $ (6,499) D- State Supported Debt $ 1,331,957 § 1,313,563 $ (18,394) D-Non-Shared Local Debt $ 206,547 §$ 202,782 § (3,765) Total State and Non-Shared Debt $ 1,714,711 $ 1,686,053 $ (28,658) Less: Local Revenues Shared Revenue* $ 1,100,391 § 1,330,192 $ 229,801 State Aid** § 4,578,301 §$ 4,534,949 $ (43,352) Total Revenues $ 5,678,692 §$ 5,865,141 $ 186,449 Less: RSU Plan Required Local Contribui $ 15,830,728 $ 16,233,574 $ 402,846 Total Additional Local Monies Required* § 7,784,541 § 8,525,916 $ 741,375 Net Impact to Taxation Districtwide $ 23,615,269 $§ 24,759,491 $ 1,144,222 4.35% Additional Local Monies Required Distribution Per RSU Plan Durham 21.42% $ 1,667,449 § 1,826,251 $ 158,803 Freeport 65.98% §$ 5,136,240 §$ 5,625,399 $ 489,159 Pownal 12.60% $ 980,852 $ 1,074,265 $ 93,413 Total Additional Local Monies Required § 7,784,541 § 8,525,916 $ 741,375 *Shared Revenue Town of Freeport Hunter Road Field Maintenance $87,291
State Agency $32,000 Medicaid $5,000 Misc / Interest $19,900 Laugh & Learn $10,200 Contingency $214,541 Undesignated Fund Balance $961,260 Total Shared Revenue $1,330,192 §/24/17
RSUS5 2017-2018 BOARD OF DIRECTORS' ADOPTED BUDGET IMPACT
With additional subsidy Assessed Proposed 2016-2017 2017-2018 Difference
Additional Local Monies Required Distribution Per RSU Plan Durham 21.42% $ 1,667,449 § 1,826,251 § 158,803 Freeport 65.98% § 5,136,240 § 5,625,399 $ 489,159 Pownal 12.60% $ 980,852 $ 1,074,265 $ 93,413 Total Additional Local Monies Required $ 7,784,541 § 8,525,916 $ 741,375 Durham RSU Plan Additional Local Monies $ 1,667,449 §$ 1,826,251 $ 158,803 RSU Plan Required Local Contribution $ 2,906,937 §$ 2,928,166 $ 21,230 Non Shared Debt $ 206,547 $§$ 202,782 $ (3.765) Net Impact $ 4,780,932 $ 4,957,199 $ 176,267 Estimated Impact based on 2016 Mil of $18.80 and a taxable valuation of $341,804,200* $0.52 2.74% Freeport RSU Plan Additional Local Monies $ 5,136,240 § 5,625,399 $ 489,159 RSU Plan Required Local Contribution $ 11,297,960 $ 11,560,225 $ 262,265 Non Shared Debt $ 176,207 $ 169,708 § (6,499) Net Impact $ 16,610,407 $ 17,355,332 $ 744,925 Estimated Impact based on 2016 Mil of $15.80 and a taxable valuation of $1,462,386,520* $0.51 3.22% Pownal RSU Plan Additional Local Monies $ 980,852 $ 1,074,265 $ 93,413 RSU Plan Required Local Contribution $ 1,625,832 $ 1,745,183 $ 119,352 Non Shared Debt $ - $ - $ - Net hnpact $ 2,606,684 § 2,819,449 $ 212,765 Estimated Impact based on 2016 Mil of $16.50 and a taxable valuation of $233,736,000* $0.91 5.52%
* April 1, 2017 valuations and mil rates are not known at this time. Actual impact will be determined when taxes are committed in each town. 5/24/17
» Crst sdARIVE : RSK ST Reeneg PLAV 13-A._Plalisto-reerg AEULZe-9 dministration transportation. Di ildin F and maintenance and special education. .
_ The ahalysis of the reorganization that has been conducted does not provide any clégr assurances of immediate savings. This is due in part to immediate start Up costs associated with forming the RSU (costs for audits, merging of systemsNegal fees) as well as increases in personnel that might be necessary, \
The RSU is unique itNhat it merges one municipal system, one single- town SAD and one town of a fwo-town School Union. There are no full time system administrators in either the SAD (Pownal) or Durham. | For example, where three towns\oining together might have three Superintendents, three Business Managers, three Special Education Directors, and three Transportation Directots, this RSU has 1.8, 1.4, 1.3 and . respectively.
Arguably, the largest cost saving in a merger \pitially is downsizing personnel and associated benefits. There is a possibility the new RSU Board may find it needs to create new staff positions to be cerfdjn these areas receive the necessary oversight, coordination, and review 8q they are in compliance with all mandates that apply. The costs are not Kapwn, nor is it known if the new RSU Board will or will not create new positidus. We cannot bind future RSU Boards to positions and associated costs. ‘Nherefore, all-numbers associated with future positions are speculative in natureNf not conjecture. 13-B. Cost Sharing in the RSU A, Definition of Terms
Additional Local Money shall mean Total RSU Spending Budget minus Total Outside Contribution to the RSU minus Total Required Local Contribution, each as defined below.
Total RSU Spending Budget shall consist of all monies budgeted to be spent by the RSU in a given year, minus principal and interest payments on State- participating debt
Total Outside Contribution to the RSU shall consist of all revenues received by the RSU from sources other than municipal tax revenues for a given year, minus. an amount equal to principal and interest payments on State- participating debt.
September 16, 2008 Page 19 of 28
Total Required Local Contribution shall be the member municipalities’ most recent total state valuation multiplied by the Applicabie Mill Rate. The Total Local Required Contribution for a member municipality may exceed the member municipality’s local cost share expectation under the Essential Programs and Services provisions (Title 20-A, Chapter 606-B) of the Maine Revised Statutes. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Plan, however, each municipality’s required contribution to the “total cost of education,” as defined in Title 20-A, Section 15688 shall be the amount established by Section 15688(3-A), or successor provisions of state law, and any additional amount required hereunder shall be for purposes of local cost sharing.
Applicable Mill Rate The Applicable Mill Rate shall equal the Full-Value Mill Rate, as defined under 20-A M.RB.S.A. § 15671-A or any successor statute. Should the State cease calculating a Full-Value Mill Rate, the - Applicable Mill Rate shall be the prior year’s Applicable Mill Rate. The Applicable Mill Rate shall be identical for all member municipalities in any single year. If the Full-Value Mill Rate is higher than the amount required to support the Total RSU Spending Budget, the Applicable Mill Rate shall be reduced accordingly.
Member municipalities shall pay the following shares of each year’s total Additional Local Money for the RSU:
Dutham: 21.42%
Freeport: 65.98%
Pownal: 12.60%
In addition to its obligation to pay its share of Additional Local Money, each member municipality must pay to the RSU its Total Required Local Contribution (as defined above), and a member municipality whose Pre-Existing Debt (or any portion thereof) is Non-RSU Debt must further pay to the RSU the total for that year of debt service for any such Non-RSU Debt Service payable by the RSU as fiscal agent under Section 6.B of this Plan
C. Changes to the Cost Sharing Method
September 16, 2008 Page 20 of 28
The Cost Sharing Method shall not be changed for the first three years, Following that transition period, the Cost Sharing Method may be changed, but shall not be required to be changed:
1. Bya vote of the RSU Board meeting the following criteria:
* at least one Board member from each member municipality must be present; and
© Board members representing two-thirds or more of the RSU population must vote in favor of the change; or
2. Upon a vote of a simple majority of the RSU Board, proposal for a change to the Cost Sharing Method may be put out to referendum for amendment in accordance with Section 14.
D. Non-Exclusive Criteria for Changing the Cost-Sharing Method In the exercise of its discretion to determine any change to the cost- sharing formula to be used at any time following the transition period, the RSU Board shali consider all factors it deems relevant, but must consider the following criteria:
1, the faimess of the cost-sharing method in light of at least the following factors:
© relative state valuations, representing each member municipality’s ability to raise revenue;
e relative populations, répresenting each member municipality’s board representation in the budgeting process; and e student headcounts, representing each mexaber municipality’s student usage of RSU facilities and programs;
2. the effect of the cost-sharing method on the RSU’s ability to raise sufficient funds to sustain educational programs deemed to be in the best interests of RSU students;
3, clarity of the method, including ease with which the public can understand the method, ease of administration and implementation of the method, and avoidance of uncertainty over the method’s application;
4. consistency of the method with the operation of the RSU as a single, cohesive entity;
September 16, 2008 Page 21 of 28
5. effect of the method on stability of RSU revenue streams and local taxpayer obligations. : er See OE me ume in ] ise-poaTC OF CIPECIONS 7 \ The RSU Board shall be composed of eleven (11) members. Each municipality in the RSU shail elect the following number of its residents to serve gn the Board.
eatery ) Population | # of Board
[Durtyn «4,075
| Pownak(M.S.A.D. No. 62) | 1,596.
Each Board iyernber shall serve a 3-year term, except that the initial. terms of the memberd of the first RSU Board shall be staggered. Since each municipality of the RSY has annual elections, lots will be drawn for the length of term specified ks follows:
A. Municipalities with annual elections. In municipatities with annual elections, 1/3 of the directors serve one-year terms, 1/3 ofhe directors serve 2-yeat terms and 1/3 of the directors séxve 3-year terms. If the number of directors is not exenly divisible by 3, the first remaining director serves a 3-year term and the 2nd remaining director serves a 2-year term,
The directors shall serve their terms 4s determined at the organization meeting and an additional period ‘sptil the next regional election of the municipalities. Thereafter, the ditectors’ terms of office are as established in accordance with the provisions ofTitle 20-A Section 1471. 13-D. Tuition Contracts and Assignment of Tuition Sthdents
1. Tuition Contracts
The following SAUs offer some or all of their students limited\uition opportunities of which school to-attend according to the following ter\s:
September 16, 2008 Page 22 of 28
ED 279 External STATE OF MAINE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION 7/18/2017
AUGUSTA 04333
"STATE CALCUEATION POH FUNDING BUBEIC COCA MON APLAR DELREPORT 3 =
ORGID : 3458 Ree 2027 ~ 2018, Section : 1
Section 1: Computation of EPS Rates
A) Attending Counts: PreX-5 6-8 Prak-8 §-12 Tatal 1} Attending Pupils (April 2076) ae 90 Fg = 1368.0°+ asio , F" Tas6.0
2) Attending Pupils (October 2016) 911.0 + 453.0 s 2,369.0 + 511.0 = 1,880.0 3} Average Pupils Calendar Year Average Ses aes Beh veer i eee 73% 27% 100% Prek-5 Student + 6-8 EPS Student + 9-IZEPS Student = EPSFTE + ActualFTE = %Of EPS x SAUDatain = AdjustedEPS = Elementary Secondary
1) Teachers 840 (171)+ 264 (7+ 313 Gee ars 1396= of0 % 7,817,189 5 5884751 = 4,284,946” 1,568,805
2) Guidance 2.6 (350:1) + 13 {350:1) + 2.0 (250:1) = 53 + 78 = 0.76 x 433,449 = 329,421 = 241,136 88,285
3) tibrarians “12 (001) + 06 (8001) 4S (oo) = 232 49 = 047 x 273928 = taR7ae 2 94,261 34,503
4) Health 11 = (800:1} + 06 (800:1) + 0.6 (800:1) = 23 + 3.5 = 6.42 x 317,506 = 133,353 = 97,614 35,739
6) Library Techs 18 = (500:1) + 0.9 (500:1) + , 1.0 = (500:1) = 3.7 + 25 = 1.48 x 52,487 = 77,681 = 56,862 20,819
7) Clencat 46 @001)+ 22 (200a)+ 25 oo) gay “gel Oe » 4314 = 30M 226,262 82,839
8) School Admin. 3.0 = (305:2) + 15 (305:1) + 16 (315:3) = 6.1 + gg = 0.69 x 720,689 = 497,275 7 364,005 133,270 Elementary Secondary Hementary Secondary
C) Computation of Benefits: Percentage Salary Salary Benefits Benefits
1) Teachers, Gurdance, Ubrarians & Health 19.00% ~ x 4,717,937 1727382 . "996408 S328 193
2) Education & Library Technicians 36.00% x 205,919 76,856 = 75,571 27,668
3) Clencal = 29.00% x 226,262 82,899 _ GEIB = (24,023 4} School Administrators 14,00% x 364,005 133,270 = 50,561 18,658 Elementary Secondary Elementary Secondary D} Other Support Per-Pupii Costs: PrekS $12 Students L__—_# Support, Support
1) Substitute Teachers (1/2 Day) ¢ 42 427 xX - 1,367.0 5010 2 57,414 21,042
2) Supplies and Equipment a73 514 X 1,367.0 501.0 = 509,891 257,514
3) Professional Development = ore 23670 ‘5010. 5 "87,488 32,064
4) Instructional Leadership Support 28 28 X 1,367.0 501.0 = 38,276 14,028
5) Co-and Extre-Curricular Student “a9 1,367.0. Teele. : “5a3i3 0s eb
6) System Administration/Support 135 135 X 1,367.0 501.0 = 184,545 67,635
7) ‘Operations & Maintenance teas " a398 K 1367.0 “SOLA. 4 “1,488,662 "648,294
E) Other Adjustments:
1) Regional Adjustment for Staff & Substitute Salaries “Regional Index= 108. 446,043 163,307
Section 1: Totals 9,472,312 3,684,346 Calculated EPS Rates Per Pupil: s 6923 7,354
Preliminary Enacted Per PL2017Ch284PartC — Adjustments will be made to these printouts throughout FY 18
ED 279 External STATE OF MAINE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION 7/18/2017
AUGUSTA 04333
STATE CALCULAHION.ZOR FUNEING PUBICEBUCATION (ORAM REPORT =
RGA 3858 , Rss "Shee. tone
Section 2: Operating Cost Allocations Section : 2
A) Subsidizable Pupils ( Includes Superintendent Transfers ) _ aYO/PreK CK . 9-12 — Total ee Tee. Tapabaaia ST F? ir ee. ee ee oat ce
2) October 2014 37.0 ‘+ 1,307.0 + 5130 = 1,857.0 ay cnc: 1. sameeren DRG. cal [erg Ta ady > Eee 4 October 2015 ‘990 + 1,297.0 + 4950 = 1,851.0 gy TO ap ZG OT Be TR ae
8) October 2016 , 630 + 1,305.0 + 5140 = "1,882.0 . Ave.Calendar SAU EPS Rates from Basic Cost Allocations
6) Basic Counts ————————— seamen Veet Pupils NN SS ayy ae SAPP aK Pupils: (Get oeiyt , con OB oa" - BSB _ 652700 2) ee ne xX |. A 3} mol OT eae Pup er eanintes oe ORR we BRR DA
4) Adult Education Courses att i eaten ae DE ta Ko ——— a —e ‘sy 4YO/Prek Equiv Insicyetion Pupils. (@ckonty) tie a: ae et bate core = 3 re ) RB Equiv. Instruction Pups i ct Ee nn mente __ 3661.25 | 8 ea ttt gig 8 SI BBR EIR BRS SO RRBLGO
C) Weighted Counts SAU EPS Rates from Weighted Cost Allocations
i) “#¥O/Prek Disadvantaged @ *'G.2346-. a Sis Ko eee ee, re See Ee 20,508.84" a KS Disadvantaged @ 0.2346 ee ee ee 423,500.48 eo 9-12 Disadvantaged @ 0.2446 BAR BE Ge +: ae 4Y0/Prek Limited English Prof. _ peewee AO X 0500 oe 62S OO 5) eB Liniited English Peet. re?) ee Gee: (gg ABET EO 6} 9-12 Limited English Prof. 60 xX 0.500 x 7,354 = 22,062.00 EPS Targeted Targeted Cost Allocations
D) Targeted Funds i pe weap en sne mete Pups EPS Weights eee aen tne nn dy” atepbrek Student Assessment (Ostonly} 8B ae Pag0R = BOB 2 __._..., K8Student Assessment 2302.5 CK 48.00 = _ 62,520.00 = 4Y0/Prek Technology Resources (Octonly) ney SO a 106.00 = 6678.00
- (KB FechiologyResoueres 2 BORE er WO5B. + ce 2 _. -. q.. 9:12 Technology Resources 5075 - Xo 818.00 = (162,385.00 Mo OF PreR Pupils: (ict only ee F o:f0 x B29 = AB BER FO
8) K-2 Pupils 404.0 X 0.10 x 6,925 = 279,931.60 E} Isolated Smail School Adjustment, — —— 4} PreK-SSmall School Adjustment = EKES Sg 96
2) 9-12 Small School Adjustment ee | en. ! Ly ‘Section 2: Operating AllotationTotals. I ge snares oS _ Percentage of EPS Transition Amount: nO O——ee ee _e#aaae..esée.... eee Adjusted Total Opersting Aocation Amount Ly ape i, BOF Prelirranary Enacted Per PL2017Ch284PartC — Adjustments willbe made to these printouts throughout F¥ 18 i
: AL EPART OF CATION 7/18/2017
ED 279 External STATE OF MAINE D MENT OF EDUCATIO /18/ AUGUSTA 04333
- “Sa eee ee ee — ae ‘eae he ee =m ik 7 ees ——. —— = = STATE CACCULATION'FOR FUNDING PUBHCEDUCKMONREIa 12) REPORT ORGID : 3458 asets OER BOLE
Section 3: Other Allocations Section :3
A) Other Subsidizable Costs Base Vear Inflation 1} Gifted & Talented Expenditures from 2015 - 2016. 213,972.95 ct. X 19150% eS 247,131.79
2) Career & Technical Education Expenditures from 2015 - 2016 495,481.50 - x 101.50% ——— = 7 502,913.72 7
3) 7 VK: 9." Special Education- EPS Allocabon a ee Fes pen" 3,527,137.98
4) Transportation Operating - EPS Allocation _ ee, =a 1,176,547.55_
5) Approved Bus Allocation ae im Goo Tota! Other Subsidizable Costs = 5,423,731.04 B) «Teacher Retirement Amount (Normalized Cost) 279,355.06 Total Adjusted Operating Allocation (Page2 } pius Total other Subsidizable Costs plus Teacher Retirement = 20,191,991.17 C) «= Debt Sarvica Allocations ; —_
1) Town / District Payment Date NameofProjact Princisal -- Antares re" Fetal DURHAM 11/01/2017 _ DURHAM NEW PREK-8 SCHOOL 886,467.00 + 218,146.23 = 1,104,613.23 05/01/2018 DURHAM NEW PREK-8 SCHOOL 000 + "208,949.14 = ; 208,949.14 5 2) ‘Total Debt Service Principal & Interest Payments 7 886,467.00 427,095.37 1,333,562.37 -* 3} Approved Lease for 2016-17 ASU 05 n,n
4) Approved Lease Purchase for 2026-17 for RSLEOS on =. Total Debt Service Allocation. = —=s=S=S~=«, 803,562.87 SEction 3 ; Total Combined Allocations (Page 2 Adjusted Total plus Other Subsidizable plus Debt Service) “ e, 21,505, 553,54
Preliminary Enacted Per PL2017Ch284PartC — Adjustments will be made to these printouts throughout FY 18
ED 279 External STATE OF MAINE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION 7/18/2017
AUGUSTA 04333
OnG1DS 358 = RSU8S. sour. za0
Section 4: Calculation of Required Local Contribution - Mill Expectation Section : 4
A) Subsidizable Pupils (Excludes Superintendent Transfers for SADs, RSUs & SDs) by Member Municipality Average Calendar Oper., Othr Sub, & Municipal Debt Total Municipal Year Subsidizable Percantage of Tchr. Ret. Allocation Allocation Alltocation Distribution Co Member Municipality | Pups Total Pupils = Distribution = Distribution ___ 25 2 Percentage of Pupils ._. _... Freeport 1079.5 58.02% 11,715,393.28 + 0.00 = 11,715,393.28 tom. “I ES eT Se ee “ane Bama aa ri pgs a3 49
B) State Valuation by Member Municipality 2014 / 2015 / 2016 Total Municipal Allocation Distribution Average State Mill per Valuation _... Member Municipality —— ae ; . aia Durham PPS rene tht oP at 8.216.667 alt a7 gig = c— oe 2 ft os” om Beg 50 Freeport 1,394,700,000 8.19 11,422,593.00 Powrial ODT pte eigaee BA 1} SMR Te Td / Motal SSB ARERR er Soe ee Og, SBROD
C) Required Local Contribution = the lesser of the previous two calculations : Required Local Calculated Total Allocation by Contribution by Mill State Contribution by Municipality Member Municipality ee Municipality Municipality 7 Rate (Prior to adjustments} - Freeport 11,715,393.28 - 11,422,593.00 3.19 292,800.28 Pawn” | ee " peegeaaag << massO oS: BS PRBBL Be otal 8 agin, = agape a AEE
Preliminary Enacted Per PL2017Ch284PartC — Adjustments will be made to these printouts throughout FY 18
EPA NT OF ED | 7/18/2017
ED 279 External STATE OF MAINE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION /18/ AUGUSTA 04333 A RISARI PLEA Tara Ho, Rat PRY ete a) 2 eg WS 25a i nace Aoi a ol — - = STATE CAECULATION FOR FUNDING FUNC EDLEAHON Ieiek 12) RPO ORGAD.: 3158 nsw ; 2017 - 2018 Section: 5
Section 5: Totals and Adjustments
Total Allocation Local Contribution State Contribution 4} Total Allocation, Local Contribution, and State Contribution 21,505,553.54 16,039,569.00 5,465,984.54
4) Minimum Special Education Adj. for Towns ina RSU -382,527.00 382,527.00 Totals after adjustment to Local and State Contributions 21,505,553.54 15,657,042.00 5,£48,511.54 B} Other Adjustments to State Contribution
1) Plus Audit Adjustments . 7 0.00
2) Less Audit Adjustments 7 _ ae 6.00
3) Less Adjustment for Unappropriated Local Contribution 0.00
4) Less Adjustment for Unallocated Balance In Excess of 3% 0.00 5} Plus Long-Term Drug Treatment Centers Adjustment 0.00
6) Regionalization and efficiency assistance 0.00
7) Bus Refurbishing Adjustment 0.900
8) Less MaineCare Seed - Private (9,260.19) 5} Less MaineCare Seed - Public 0.00. Adjusted State Contribution °21,505,553.54 £5,657,042.00 5,839,251.35. Local and State Percentages Prior to Adjustments : Local Share%>= 74.58% State Shara % = 25.42 % Local and State Percentages After Adjustments : Local Share%= = 72.85% State Shara % = 27.15 % FYI: 100% EPS Allocetion 21,944,384.42 Section F: Adjusted Local Contribution by Town **85* WARRANT ARTICLE ***** Min. Spec, Ed. RSU Adjusted Local = Adjusted Adjusted Member Municipality Towns Adj.Sec.5 Total Allocation Contribution Percentage Mill Rate Line A4 Burham 0.00 7,706,346.77 2,892,844,50 18.48% 8.19 Freeport 382,527.00 11,715,393,28 11,040,066,00 70.51% 7.92 Pownal 6.00 2,083,813.49 1,724,131.50 11.01% 8.19 Totals 382,527.00 21,505,553,54 15,657,042.00 100.00%
Preliminary Enacted Per PL2017Ch284PartC — Adjustments will be made to these printouts throughout FY 18
ED 279 External STATE OF MAINE DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION 7/18/2017
AUGUSTA 04333
STATE CRECULKFION FOR FUNDING RUBLIC EOUEA MOD P idea) REPORT Section ° 6
Section 6: SCHEDULED PAYMENTS & YEAR TO DATE PAYMENTS
MONTH SUBSIDY PAID TO DATE DEBT SERVICE PAID TO DATE
july HO ATR PT ge 900
August 377,140.75 377,140.75 0.00 0.00
October 377,140.75 377,140.75 0.00 0.00
November “grpgaots OT aenaaors: 0 aaetaza ~ ysed,g23 23
December 377,140.75 0.00 0.00 0.00 January FT cn ee or see.)
February 377,140.75 0.00 0.00 0.00
April 377,140.75 0.00 0.00 0.00
— = giesaee -- ma were <2 - sez " oa
June 377,140.73 0.00 0.00 0.00
Preliminary Enacted Per PL2017Ch284PartC — Adjustments will be made to these printouts throughout FY 18
Revised September 28, 2008 | FAQ’s |
1. Where will the funding come from to pay for the costs of running the RSU?
a. Funding to cover the costs of the RSU come from three sources. They are: | , ‘i. Required Local Contribution — the required amount that must be raised locally to qualify for state subsidy. This is usually | represented as the standard mil rate across the state for education. In the base year (2007-2008) used by the RPC for analysis purposes the state mil rate was 7,44 mils. .
ii. State Subsidy — this is the amount of state funding that will be | provided to the school unit if the Required Local Contribution is | iii, Additional Local Monies — this is the amount that will be raised locally in addition to the Required Local Contribution by the members of the school unit.
2. How will each of the components in #1 above be allocated to each of the member towns? .
a. Each town will contribute the Required Local Contribution through the “standard” mil rate determined by the state.
b. The state subsidy will be calculated in total for the RSU, not for each local town, and will be paid directly to the RSU by the state.
c. The Additional Local Monies will be shared among the three towns using a cost sharing formula developed by the RPC,
3. How much of the total RSU expense is represented by the Additional Local Monies and therefore subject to the cost sharing formula of the RPC?
a. Approximately 15% based on the 2007-2008 school budgets for the three school districts. 4, How will the Additional:Local Monies be shared under the RPC cost sharing formula?
a. The RPC determined that Additional Local Monies (ALM) should be shared on the same ratio as those costs were incurred in the base year (budgets for school year 2007-2008). According to the plan, this cost sharing method would stay in place for five (5) years to give the RSU and its board time to gain experience in the operation of new school unit. The cost sharing method could be changed as early as three years under provisions of the plan.
1
l
5. How much of the ALM will each town be allocated based on the cost sharing | formule described above? | a, Durham - 21.42% or $856,80 i
b. Freeport — 65.98% or $2,640,000 ¢. Pownal — 12,6% or $504,000
6. Ihave heard people who favor sharing costs on the basis of each town's valuation and other people who favor sharing costs on the basis of each town's student population. Are towns that are paying less than their share of valuation getting off too easy? What about towns that are paying less than their share of the student headcount?
a. No. The RPC believes the cost sharing formula is the fairest way to distribute the ALM costs across the RSU at this time. While there are | arguments in favor of using student headcounts and in favor of using valuation, there are arguments against each approach as well. The original consolidation Jaw would have required use of the valuation approach. The law was changed to allow the use of alternative cost-sharing approaches, and the RPC adopted a middle approach, between the extremes-of | valuation and headcount, that it believes is the best way for the RSU to get | on its feet. |
b. The percentages used to allocate the ALM are based on the operating cost: in the ALM for the base school year 2007-2008. Each town pays the same | percentage of ALM as the percentage of ALM costs that it generated prior to consolidation in the base year. So, for the base year, Durham, Freeport and Pownal generated 24.42%, 65.98% and 12.6% of the ALM costs respectively and will .be asked to continue to bear those shares in the initial years of the RSU as a fair estimate of the share of the ALM costs attributable to each town. | c, In the early years of the RSU it is unlikely that there will be major program shifts so it can be assumed that the spending patterns will remain similar. As the RSU matures over time the RPC plan allows for the cost sharing formula to be changed should that be necessary.
d. The table below shows each town’s base-year share of student headcount and valuation, as well as its ALM cost-sharing percentage as set forth in the consolidation plan: PY Valuation | Cost-Share | __ Headcount |
7. Were any other cost sharing plans considered by the RPC?
a. The Finance Committee of the RPC developed a financial model that considered seven (7) different cost sharing scenarios for ALM. Many of these scenarios were developed as a.result of feedback received at the public meetings held in the three towns.
2
|
8. What were the cost scenarios that were considered? a, The Finance Committee considered the following cost sharing scenarios:
i. #1 —share ALM costs based on the operating cost ratios for the base year; share debt for the high school and administrative offices starting in year 1; phase in other assumed debt (Durham Elementary, Freeport Middle School and post 2003 CIP) over five (5) years; non assumed debt would be a) debt on existing Durham elementary school; b) pre 2004 capital improvement debt in Freeport; and c) the Mast Landing School debt in Freeport. ii, #2— Same as #1 above, but the only debt to be shared is the high ; schoo] and the administrative office debt. This is the approach | ultimately recommended by the RPC, | iii. #3 — Same as #1 except share the high school costs on a per pupil
iv. #4 — Share all ALM on a per pupil basis.
v. #5 —Same as #1 except share all debt assumed by the RSU ona | per pupil basis. . | vi. #6 — Share ALM on the basis of town valuation — this is as . prescribed in the original school consolidation law, bui was . subsequently changed to allow local RPCs to adopt their own cost sharing formula. i vii. #7 — Same as #1 except share ALM on a per pupil basis starting in i year 4 and phasing this in over 10 years with a cap of 60% of the | ALM to be shared on a per pupil basis. if
9. Is the model that was prepared by the RPC a budget for the new RSU?
a. No. Preparing a budget for the new RSU is beyond the scope of the tasks assigned to the RPC and will be the responsibility of the new RSU board once they are elected. The model is a toot used by the RPC to show the effect of various assumptions and scenarios in determining a fair cost | sharing methodology and in making gross assessments of the financial feasibility of consolidating. The model can show the relative effect a change in cost sharing scenario could have on one member of the RSU vs. another, both in the short term and long term. A budget, when prepared by the RSU board, will be the estimated costs of running the RSU for a particular time frame and will include all of the specific operating and program decisions that only the RSU board has the authority to make.
10. What are the basic assumptions included in the financial model used by the RPC?
a. The financial model used to evaluate the different cost sharing scenarios included the following key assumptions (all in constant dollars):
i. There would be $100,000 of administrative cost savings as a result of consolidating the three school districts. . 3 |
| |
ii. There would be a “leveling up” of contract salaries beginning in : year three in the amount of $250,000 as a result of consolidating the three school districts.
iii. High School students from Durham would migrate to Freeport High School over time and would not all move in one year.
iv. The incremental cost of additional high school students in Freeport would be $4,000 per student. This is referred to in the mode! as | the “capacity cost”. v, There is 2 net cost reduction for each Durham Student migrating to Freeport High School. This is due to the fact that in the base year Durham is paying $7,715 in tuition outside of their district for their high school students. Since the estimated incremental cost for each student when they move to Freeport is $4,000 the net benefit is $3,715 in avoided costs per student to the RSU.
vi. No increase in capacity is required at the current Freeport Iligh School facility.
vii. “State debt” is assumed to be paid for by the state on a dollar for dollar basis.
11. How was the $100,000 of administrative savings determined?
a. For the administrative savings, the three existing superintendents | | evaluated the current administrative structure in the three school districts and came up with a recommendation of the changes that could be made in that structure if the three school units were consolidated into one unit. For example, the three towns currently pay 1.8 full-time-equivalents (FTEs) for their superintendents. The RSU will have only a single superintendent, resulting in a savings of a little over $70,000. Not every function or position, however, will see savings. For example, human resources currently accounts for only three-tenths of an FTE, but in the RSU, we expect there will be a full-time HR professional, accounting for a full FTE in that position, a cost increase estimated to be just over $20,000, In addition to a line-item estimate of these FTE changes for administrative personnel, administrators provided the RPC with an estimate of system administration cost savings. ;
b. There is uncertainty in these estimates, given the uncertainty in how the RSU Board ultimately will choose to staff the RSU. For example, Freeport currently provides contracted curriculum services at a cost of $30,000. The RPC favors, following the recommendation of the Education Subcommittee, the hiring of a full-time curriculum coordinator. \ The additional estimated cost is $50,000. Whether such a hire would be | made lies in the discretion of the RSU Board. Other positions assumed to go from a partial FTE to a full FTE might ultimately not increase that way, depending on workload and staff capabilities. For example, the three towns use a combined 1.25 FTEs for Accounts Payable and Bookkeeper/Payroll, and the administrators estimated two full-time staff serving those functions in the RSU. The difference between splitting
4
J those functions among two FTEs versus combining them into a single FTE is roughly $45,000.
i
c. Netting the cost increases and decreases in administrative salaries, yielded an estimated administrative savings of $64,479, subject to the ; uncertainties described above. For example, if the RSU Board chose to fund curriculum coordination only at the current level, without hiring a curriculum coordinator and chose to use a single FTE for aceounts payable and other bookkeeping functions, the cost savings would increase to roughly $160,000. In light of the uncertainties in the estimation process, the Finance Subcommittee used a figure within this range, $100,000, as its estimate for administrative cost savings.
12. What are “leveling up” costs and where do they come from?
a. The $250,000 “leveling up” costs are the result of evaluating the three different teacher contracts that currently exist and bringing them together under a uniform salary structure. This calculation was performed by the respective business offices of each of the school units.
13. What is the “capacity cost” used in the model and how was the amount determined?
a. The $4,000 capacity cost or, incremental cost per student at Freeport High School, comes from an analysis perforrned by the Freeport school administration on what additional costs would be incurred to bring the Durham high school population into the current high school building. This cost assumes that sufficient staff would be hired to maintain the : cutrent student/teacher ratio.
14. Why is the incremental cost per student ($4,000) at Freeport High School so much different than the average cost per student, which I understand is about $10,000 per student?
a. While it does not cost any less to educate the incoming Durham students, or for that matter, any new Freeport or Pownal students, than it does a student that is already at Freeport High Schoo} (FHS) there are certain fixed costs that do not change as a result of adding more students into a facility that has available capacity. Therefore, the average cost per student will decrease as more students are added to the existing facility. For instance, the cost of operating the FHS building is pretty much the same whether the building houses just Freeport students or Freeport, Pownal and Durham students. On the other hand, the same is not true for teaching staff, Initially, as new students enter the high school they will be absorbed within the existing classroom structure. Eventually though, there will be a sufficient increase in the number of students or class sizes that new staff will have to be hired to maintain the current student/teacher ratios, The capacity cost assumes this new staff will be hired to accommodate the additional students.
5
|
15. What is the projected enrollment for Freeport High School and what is the capacity of the current building?
a. The current capacity of the existing facility is 600 students. The projected : enrollment for the high school using data provided by each of the school units is shown in the chart below. |
FHS Estimated Enrollment | 800 — 2 400-6 ~ 1 3 300. : | - | a 700 a | | 2 3 4 6 6 7 8 9 10 | RSU Year |mGurham w Freeport G Pownel|
. 16. I have heard that the current building isn’t even sufficient for the students | currently at Freeport High School -- students cannot eat their lunch in the cafeteria, classes have to be held in a trailer. Why did you assume that the building has sufficient capacity for 100 or more additional students?
a. The existing building currently has vacant instructional space during every instructional period, and the superintendent and principal advised the RPC that they believed the space was sufficient to accommodate the expected i additional students in the RSU. The RPC commissioned a capacity study | by outside experts to determine whether the opinion of the administrators could be confirmed. And it was,
b. The trailer referred to is not used by Freeport because classrooms are full. The trailer is used for a special instructional program that, for instructional : purposes, is physically separated from the FHS building.
c. The cafeteria is not large enough to accommodate the current population, even using staggered lunchtimes, and even with Freeport's steadily | declining enrollment; it would not be large enough to accommodate the population anytime in the foreseeable future. Freeport has been using a single lunch period, with students free to eat where they choose. That approach can continue, even with 100+ additional students, going forward. No capacity cost was included for a cafeteria build-out for two reasons. First and foremost, based on the fact that Freeport to date has not expanded its cafeteria, it appears that ail of the relevant constituencies (students, faculty, administration and parents) like the current approach to lunchtime, and we expect that to continue. Second, should the RSU Board elect to build out the cafeteria, it is not clear that such a build out would involve any increased capacity cost for the RSU; the State might very well fund the debt for such a project in the RSU. This is the type of capital project, however, for which state funding would be put in jeopardy by the | penalty provisions applicable to any town that does not enter into an approved unit under the consolidation law. |
|
17. How is existing debt handled in the financial model and in the cost sharing formula?
a. Existing debt in any of the school units is handled in either of two ways.
i. High School and Administrative Offices debt — In as much as these facilities will be shared resources at the beginning of the RSU then any debt service costs will be included in the costs to be shared by the RSU members. ji. All other debt — In as much as the facilities for which this debt was incurred are not being shared at the beginning of the RSU then all debt service will remain with the town which incurred the debt. iii, Future debt of the RSU incurred by the RSU after formation will be shared by the RSU based upon the cost sharing formula in use when the debtis incurred. - |
18. How do penalties come into play in the financial modei considered by the RPC? a, First, penalties only apply where a community decides to not consolidate and otherwise does not have an exemption or other approval from the | Department of Education to “go it atone”. Penalties therefore appear as a | cost for a town in the “stand alone” scenario, but not as a cost in the | consolidation scenario.
b. The amount of penalty for each town as estimated by the Department of Education on June 10, 2008 is shown below. This penalty is assessed annually and will change as the student headcount changes and as the . valuation of the town changes. ;
Durham - $105,332 Freeport - $315,192 Pownal - $48,111
i. In addition to the penalty that can be calculated above there are other considerations that need to be included when looking at the penalty provisions of the law, which could include less favorable consideration by the state in regard to future school construction.
7
19. Would my town be better off financially to “go it alone” and pay the penalty?
a. The finance committee looked at each of the scenarios and compared it to each town on a stand alone basis, The selected cost sharing formula vs, stand alone is as follows: | Durham — selected scenario is the same as standing alone; Freeport — selected scenario is 6% less expensive vs. standing alone; Pownal — selected scenario is 3% less expense vs. standing alone.
i. When factoring in the non-financial benefit of consolidation the RPC concluded that each community would benefit fromm consolidation as a whole,
20. What are the size, composition, and voting percentage of the new Regional School Union’s Board of Directors? a, The Board will be made up of 11 members serving Staggered 3 year terms. Freeport will have 6 members with 96 votes each, Durham will! have 3 members with 96 votes each, and Pownal will have 2 members with 58 votes each. 21, How was the structure and composition of the Board decided?
a. The Board must conform to “one person one vote”, so the composition must have proportionate representation. This is why Freeport, the largest i community, has the most members. To ensure Pownal has two | representatives it was necessary to give each of those members a lesser voting power. 22, How will the Regional School Unit Board be elected? . a, Each community will elect its representatives to the Board. 23, What is the timeline for voting to approve the Regional Schoo! Union, selecting the Board, and starting the new school system?
a. An approval vote for the Consolidation Plan will occur at the general election in November 2008. If all three communities approve the Plan, the new Board will be elected at the beginning of February 2009. The Board will then begin its administrative duties to allow the new School Union to be fully functional on July 1, 2009. The Board will be responsible for hiring the new School Union’s superintendent, creating a budget, and =: implementing school policies and procedures.
24. How are budgets and capital expenditures decided under a new RSU? a, The RSU Board will develop proposed budgets and capital expenditures. There will then be 2 School meeting to approve recommendations, and the voters in the three communities will then vote on whether to approve the budgets and expenditures. 8 |
i
|
25. What if one or more of the communities does not approve the Consolidation Plan in November 20087
a. Ifany of the communities vote against the Plan, the Regional Planning Conimittee must consider alternative plans for submission to the State Department of Education, and then, again, to the voters of the communities. This could be with the same partners or different partners. If no consolidation plan is adopted by July 1, 2009, communities and their schools may be subject to State penalties starting with the current fiscal year. Pies ie Geel Onli will th rte ies al eva at TIL He cea paian "Di ahee eci lores dine be a, An Altemative Plan is submitted by an SAU that proposes to meet the required reductions in costs without partnering with other SAU’s. An alternative plan may be submitted only by a unit that is: : i, An offshore island |
ii. A school operated by a tribal school committee
iii. A school administrative unit that serves more than 2500 students or i 1200 students where circumstances justify an exception to the | requirement of 2500 students {
iv. A school administrative unit that is designated as an efficient, high-performing district. A school administrative unit js i designated an “efficient, high-performing district” if: |
1. It contains 3 schools identified as “higher performing” :
2. Its reported 2005-2006 per pupil expenditures for system administration represents less than 4% of its per pupil expenditures cbs Dali ioe apa roar Gia nee aC |
a. The current Plan is an alternate plan. The three towns have less than 2500 j students, but more than 1200 students.
a. An alternative organizational structure (AOS) is a regional school unit and ! still requires communities to function as a single school system that reports a single budget to the Department of Education, receives a single subsidy check, and has a common core curriculum and procedures for standardized testing and assessment. An AOS files reports with the state as ; :
|
|
a single unit and must adopt consistent schoo! policies, and a plan for achieving consistent collective bargaining agreements. (Separate collective bargaining agreements are allowed, provided they are consistent.) j The plan for an AOS must also include an interlocal agreement and a plan for presenting, approving, and validating the annual schoo] budget that ensures K-12 budget transparency for its members and their voters. The law requires a plan to achieve that goal; it does not specify the details of how it must be achieved. | {
Source: , linked from www.rsu5.org/board-of-directors-and-policies/board-agendas-and-minutes/agendas. Text copied out by software (pdftotext, then OCR); no wording corrected.
