Additional Information Handed Out at the Board Meeting
Monthly financial reports · Finance Committee · 17 pages · 977 words · all RSU 5 documents · the district's file →
Date: November 6, 2019 To: RSU5 Board of Directors From: Finance Committee
RE: RSU5 Current Cost Sharing Methodology – Assessment of Fairness
A fair cost-sharing methodology distributes the burden of local educational costs resulting in as close to an equal tax rate as possible amongst each taxpayer in RSU5. The Finance Committee sees the RSU taxpayer, not individual towns when assessing that impact, though undeniably it must acknowledge the three municipalities when it comes time to issue the warrants to raise local revenue. The Finance Committee considered fairness of the current cost sharing methodology through a variety of different lenses, as follows:
1. Property valuation is the fundamental way in which public education, and local government in general, is funded in the State.
2. The majority of Regional School Units have adopted a cost sharing model in which the Required Local Contribution as reported on the ED279 is utilized in combination with 100% valuation.
3. Bill Stockmeyer’s presentation to the Board in December 2017 demonstrated in various ways how the current method of cost sharing in RSU5 is very close to what it would be under the methodologies commonly used in other Regional School Units.
4. Per pupil cost sharing methods are intended to protect towns that have high valuation to pupil ratios coupled with a minority voting power.
5. Under the current methodology the percent Total Contribution (i.e., Local Contribution1 + State Contribution2 + Minimum Special Education Adjustment) for each town is close to each town’s percent Pupil Count. This is not surprising since the ED279 allocations for each municipality are determined based on pupil percentage. The fiscal capacity of each town and therefore the impact of local education costs on each RSU5 household are adequately incorporated into the current methodology. For example, the education mil rates in each town under the current cost sharing methodology for FY20, FY19, FY18, and FY17 are presented below, along with a breakdown of each municipality’s Total Contribution towards the cost of education in RSU5 compared to percent Pupil Count:
RSU5 Education Mil Rates by Towna/
2019/20 2018/19 2017/18 2016/17
(FY20) (FY19) (FY18) (FY17)
Durham $14.34 $14.18 $14.08 $13.88
Freeport $10.50 $10.94 $10.84 $12.18
Pownal $11.25 $11.06 $10.23 $10.56
a/
Education mil rates are based on each town’s Tax Bill Distribution Percentage for Schools
in FY20, FY19, FY18, and FY17.1
Local Contribution does not include Non-Shared Debt.
2
State Contribution includes State Funded Debt Assumed by RSU.
1 of 3
Total Contribution to RSU5 by Towna/
2019/20 (FY20)
Total % Total % Pupil
Contributionb/ Contribution Countc/
Durham $ 9,852,607.56 29.84 30.73
Freeport $ 19,678,889.00 59.60 58.43
Pownal $ 3,487,902.49 10.56 10.84
TOTAL $ 33,019,399.05 100.00 100.00
2018/19 (FY19)
Total % Total % Pupil
Contributionb/ Contribution Countc/
Durham $ 9,601,789.49 30.31 31.02
Freeport $ 18,807,122.00 59.38 58.38
Pownal $ 3,265,064.10 10.31 10.60
TOTAL $ 31,673,975.59 100.00 100.00
2017/18 (FY18)
Total % Total % Pupil
b/
Contribution Contribution Countc/
Durham $ 9,567,919.27 31.26 31.66
Freeport $ 17,860,952.28 58.35 58.02
Pownal $ 3,179,129.99 10.39 10.32
TOTAL $ 30,608,001.54 100.00 100.002016/17 (FY17) Total % Total % Pupil Contributionb/ Contribution Countc/ Durham $ 9,434,372.83 31.95 31.53 Freeport $ 17,069,399.44 57.81 58.47 Pownal $ 3,021,755.27 10.23 10.00 TOTAL $ 29,525,527.54 100.00 100.00 a/ Per Section 6.A. of the Reorganization Plan prepared by the Reorganization Planning Committee (9/18/2009), the RSU assumed liability to pay certain existing indebtedness and lease-purchase obligations for Central Office (issued 2001), FHS (issued 2002), State Portion of MLS (issued 1990), FHS Heating System (issued 2008), FHS Portion of Lighting Upgrade (issued 2008), and State Portion of DCS (issued 2009). In the years it was received, the full State Contribution, including the State Portion of MLS and DCS debt, is allocated towards the Total Contribution for Freeport and Durham, respectively. b/ Total Contribution is calculated as Local Contribution (i.e., Total Required Local Contribution plus Additional Local Monies) plus State Contribution plus Min. Spec. Ed. Adj. State Contribution includes State Funded Debt Assumed by RSU. c/ Percentage of Total Pupils as reported in Section 4.A. of the ED 279.
2 of 3
For additional context, the education costs under the current cost sharing methodology for the median homeowner in each town for 2019/20 (FY20) are presented below. Note, though a town assesses real estate taxes for an individual residential property based on the town’s assessed valuation for that property, we calculated the median home education tax based on available data for median home values (i.e., market value) to provide a rough estimate. To calculate the actual median home education tax would require additional information from each town based on their assessed valuations for residential property.
RSU5 Education Costs for Median Homeowner by Town
Education Median
Tax per Home Median
$200,000 Median Home Education Household
FY20 Valuation Valuea/ Taxb/ Incomec/
Durham $2,868 $225,700d/ $3,235 $73,750e/
d/
Freeport $2,100 $307,700 $3,230 $79,500e/
d/
Pownal $2,250 $255,300 $2,872 $83,700e/
a/
Most recent data available. Source: United States Census Bureau, 2017 American Community Survey
5-Year Estimates, Table DP04, Value, Owner-Occupied Units, Median, https://data.census.gov/cedsci/.
Searched by Zip Code Tabulation Areas: 04222, 04032, 04069.b/ Based on each town’s 2019/20 Education Mil Rate. c/ Most recent data available. Source: United States Census Bureau, 2017 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, Table S1903. https://data.census.gov/cedsci/. Searched by Zip Code Tabulation Areas: 04222, 04032, 04069. Also provided by this source: 2017 Mean Income (margin of error): D $84,955 (+/- $8,512), F $111,275 (+/- $21,629), P $94,061 (+/- $8,400). d/ Margin of Error: D +/-$13,604, F +/- $30,141, P +/-$21,690. Source: United States Census Bureau, 2017 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, Table DP04, Value, Owner-Occupied Units, Median, https://data.census.gov/cedsci/. Searched by Zip Code Tabulation Areas: 04222, 04032, 04069. e/ Margin of Error: D +/-$15,996, F +/- $6,849, P +/-$10,956. Source: United States Census Bureau, 2017 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, Table S1903. https://data.census.gov/cedsci/. Searched by Zip Code Tabulation Areas: 04222, 04032, 04069.
3 of 3
Source: , linked from www.rsu5.org/board-of-directors-and-policies/board-committees/standing-committees/finance-committee. Text copied out by software (pdftotext); no wording corrected.
