Skip to content

BBAB-E - Board of Directors Self-Evaluation Instrument

Policies · Adopted policies and procedures · 6 pages · 1,435 words · all RSU 5 documents · the district's file →

Text copied out by software, not the document itself. Layout, tables and figures may not survive. The district's copy is authoritative; check it before relying on this text.

NEPN/NSBA Code: BBAB-E

BOARD OF DIRECTORS SELF-EVALUATION INSTRUMENT

Introduction

The Board of Directors Evaluation System is based upon the National School Boards Association Standards of Practice.

There are five key standards of Board leadership incorporated into this model:

● Vision, Leadership & Accountability

● Board Governance & Policy

● Communication & Community Relations

● Fiscal Resources, Staff Recruitment & Environment

● Ethical Leadership

Timeline Month

End of July            Distribution of evaluation (electronically)

July/August             Individual board members complete the self-evaluation electronically for compilation
                        by the Board Chair or designee.

August/September           Board reviews compiled results. Results will be used by the Board as part of its
                           annual goal setting and planning for the year.

PART I: Standards of Leadership

These standards are rated using the following scale:

4 - Exemplary ratings are reserved for performance that significantly exceeds proficiency and could serve as a model for leaders district-wide or even statewide. Few Boards are expected to demonstrate Exemplary performance on more than a small number of targets.

3 - Proficient ratings represent fully satisfactory performance. It is the rigorous standard expected for most experienced Boards and the goal for new Boards performing at the basic level. Proficient Boards demonstrate acceptable leadership practice and meet or make progress on all outcome targets.

2 - Basic ratings mean that performance is meeting proficiency in some components but not others. Improvement is necessary and expected.

1 - Does Not Meet ratings indicate performance that is unacceptably low on one or more standards and makes little or no progress. Ratings of ineffective are always cause for concern.

RSU No. 5 School Department

Page 1 of 6

NEPN/NSBA Code: BBAB-E

Standard 1: Vision, Leadership & Accountability

Descriptor: The Board of Directors commits to a vision of high student achievement and effective instruction, specifies clear goals to realize that vision, demands accountability for results, and supports continuous improvement of the district.

Possible Data Sources:

● Alignment with District vision and mission statement

● Adherence to Standards of Ethics

● Established goals

● Board agendas

● Board presentations

● Board retreats

● Board communications

● Annual evaluation of the Superintendent

● Board self evaluation

Rating for Standard 1: Vision, Leadership & Accountability

4 3 2 1 Exemplary Proficient Basic Does Not Meet

A. The Board develops a shared mission and vision that reflects student achievement and community priorities, and communicates it to the community.

B. The Board develops annual District goals in alignment with the District vision and mission and adopts a strategic plan developed by the Superintendent to meet those goals. Goals are communicated to the community.

C. The Board regularly monitors progress on District goals, effective instruction, and student achievement with data-based information.

D. The Board keeps informed about what children are learning through reports on scholastic achievement, vocational programs, and the impact of extra-curricular activities.

E. The Board annually evaluates the job performance of the Superintendent and monitors the progress made on the Superintendent’s goals.

F. The Board conducts a self-evaluation to monitor its own performance and participates in professional development, including Board training and seminars. Comments:

RSU No. 5 School Department

Page 2 of 6

NEPN/NSBA Code: BBAB-E

Standard 2: Board Governance & Policy

Descriptor: The Board of Directors works effectively as a team and collaborates with the Superintendent, exhibits a shared understanding of Board and Superintendent roles, maintains a set of Board operating procedures, and leads/governs the District through policy.

Possible Data Sources:

● Date and agenda of annual orientation

● Policy review and updates

● Board policy manual

● Board orientation materials

● Attendance and state-mandated trainings

Rating for Standard 2: Board Governance & Policy

4 3 2 1 Exemplary Proficient Basic Does Not Meet

A. The Board and Superintendent participate in an annual retreat to . build team relationships, review roles, responsibilities, and Board operations, and orient new Board members.

B. The Board has a procedure in place for regularly reviewing . existing policies and developing new ones.

C. The Board closely adheres to its own procedures, protocols, and policies for effective Board operations.

D. The Board clearly understands its governance role and . responsibilities, adheres to open meeting laws, and delegates district operation responsibilities to the Superintendent.

E. Board members publicly support the decision of the majority and speak with a unified voice.

F. Board leadership acts as a mentor to new members to help them learn the ropes and provides new members with a detailed explanation of the Board’s mission. Comments:

RSU No. 5 School Department

Page 3 of 6

NEPN/NSBA Code: BBAB-E

Standard 3: Communication & Community Relations

Descriptor: The Board of Directors effectively communicates with the Superintendent and the local community, represents community interests and values, and ensures District information and decisions are communicated to the community.

Possible Data Sources:

● Communication policies or procedures

● Schedules or invitations to community forums

● Reports or presentations on programs that demonstrate community partnerships

● Legislative meetings. Letters or advocacy efforts

● Newsletters and website

● Survey results

Rating for Standard 3: Communication & Community Relations

4 3 2 1 Exemplary Proficient Basic Does Not Meet

A. The Board develops a collaborative relationship with the Superintendent, keeping cooperation and respectful discussions at the center of its deliberations.

B. The Board establishes effective communication with parents, students, staff, and community members while respecting the chain of command and lines of responsibility.

C. The Board works with the Superintendent to gain input from the community using forums, surveys, or other vehicles, following agreed-upon procedures.

D. The Board actively promotes support for the District through its vision and promoting educational opportunities for all students.

E. The Board is an advocate for the District’s interests with legislators and other elected officials. Comments:

Standard 4: Fiscal Resources, Staff Recruitment & Environment

Descriptor: The Board of Directors oversees the fiscal conditions of the District, aligns resources to meet District goals, ensures appropriate policies for staff recruitment and retention, supports district wide learning and promotes conditions for health and safety.

Possible Data Sources:

● Process for budget development and adoption

● Communication materials, website, newsletters

● Facilities plan and schedule for updates

● Audit report

● Policy on recruitment and hiring

● Professional development plans RSU No. 5 School Department

Page 4 of 6

NEPN/NSBA Code: BBAB-E

Rating for Standard 4: Fiscal Resources, Staff Recruitment & Environment

4 3 2 1 Exemplary Proficient Basic Does Not Meet

A. The Board adopts an annual budget that adheres to the provisions of the law and allocates resources based upon the District’s vision, goals, and priorities for student achievement.

B. The Board keeps the community informed about the financial needs of the District, seeks cost savings and operational efficiencies, and invites community input.

C. The board monitors a facilities plan that meets student and staff health and safety regulations and guidelines.

D. The Board ensures that the finance committee functions in accordance with regulatory requirements, reviews internal audit findings, and responds appropriately.

E. The Board supports the recruitment of highly effective teachers, administration, and staff and provides professional development and support. Comments:

Standard 5: Ethical Leadership

Descriptor: The Board of Directors promotes the success of all students and staff, and conducts District business in a fair, respectful and responsible manner.

Possible Data Sources:

● Articulation or publication of plans and programs for student success

● Code of Ethics Policy

● Standards of Ethics

Rating for Standard 5: Ethical Leadership

4 3 2 1 Exemplary Proficient Basic Does Not Meet

A. Board members are able to speak their minds without fear of being ostracized.

B. Board handles conflict openly and constructively.

C. Board members actively promote the belief in the success of all students in the district.

D. Board members act as conscientious role models and exhibit professionalism.

E. Board members exercise authority only as a board as a whole and recognize that no individual board member has authority to take individual action on behalf of the Board.

F. Board members avoid conflicts of interest and appropriately disclose if one arises.

G. Board has adopted and annually reaffirms its code of ethics. Comments:

RSU No. 5 School Department

Page 5 of 6

NEPN/NSBA Code: BBAB-E

Board of Directors Self-Evaluation

Annual Evaluation Rating Form

Standards                                         SUMMATIVE SCORE

Standard 1: Vision, Leadership and Accountability                       4   3    2    1

Standard 2: Board Governance and Policy                                 4   3    2    1

Standard 3: Communications and Community Relations                      4   3    2    1

Standard 4: Fiscal Resources, Staff Recruitment &                       4   3    2    1
Environment

Standard 5: Ethical Leadership                                          4   3    2    1

ANNUAL EVALUATION SCORE                                                 4   3    2    1

Approved: December 11, 2019

RSU No. 5 School Department

Page 6 of 6

Source: , linked from www.rsu5.org/board-of-directors-and-policies/adopted-policies-and-procedures. Text copied out by software (pdftotext); no wording corrected.