Skip to content

Cost Sharing Analysis by Suzan Beaudoin

Board meetings · Agendas · 20 pages · 1,995 words · all RSU 5 documents · the district's file →

Text copied out by software, not the document itself. Layout, tables and figures may not survive. The district's copy is authoritative; check it before relying on this text.

RSU #05 COST SHARING

Prepared by Suzan Beaudoin Consulting LLC sbeaudoinllc@gmail.com 2/8/2023

• School funding in Maine is based on Essential Programs and Services (EPS), which are defined as the programs and resources that are essential for students to have an equitable opportunity to achieve Maine's Learning Results.

• The EPS formula determines both the State and local share of funding needed for each School Administrative Unit (SAU) to have Essential Programs and Services. The funding formula is designed to respond to student needs and is based on State School Funding years of research and information gleaned from high EPS Formula performing, cost-effective school units.

• Each year, every district in the State receives a document known as the “ED 279”. This is the annual State Calculation for Funding Education (PreK-12) Report which shows the various components that go into the funding formula.

Key Operating Cost Components to Determine EPS:

• Student Demographics (School Administrative Unit (SAU) Pupil Counts for PreK-K, 1-5, 6-8, 9-12 and Specialized Student Populations)

• EPS Per Pupil Rate for Each SAU (Per Pupil Amounts Tailored for Each Unit Which Reflect Costs for Personnel, Administration, & Instructional Support)

• Weighted Amounts (Additional Per Pupil Amounts for English Learners and Economically Disadvantaged Pupils)

• Targeted Amounts (Additional Per Pupil Amounts for 4YO/PreK Determining EPS Pupils, 4YO/ K-2 Pupils, Student Assessment, and Technology Resources)

• Other Adjustments (Isolated Small Schools, Adult Education, and Equivalent Instruction) Other Cost Components to Determine EPS:

• Other Subsidizable Costs (Gifted & Talented, Special Education, Transportation and Buses)

• Teacher Retirement Costs (Normalized Costs)

• Debt Service (State Board approved bond payments and approved lease payments)

• State and Local Share: EPS calculates the share of the costs between State and Local: EPS Costs – Local Share* = State Share. *Many local units raise above and beyond what the State requires for local share.

Determining State and • Key Factors in Determining Required Local Share: Local Shares Percentage of students by town within a combined district, used to determine distribution of Total Allocation by Town Valuation by town as provided by the Maine Revenue Service each year, which determines ability to pay Mil Expectation set by calculated recommended funding level each year

• The Required Local contribution is established by the EPS school funding formula.

• There are two calculations the State makes to determine the State and local shares for the Required Local

1. They determine shares based on pupil count

2. They determine based on valuation, the ability of the REQUIRED LOC AL towns to afford the required cost

• If a town’s ability to pay exceeds the required shares based on pupil count, then those towns do not get State subsidy; they are considered Minimum Receivers. Freeport falls into this category.

• The Required Local share is then based on Pupil Count.

RSU #05’s the Freeport member town is also eligible for the Minimum Special Education Adjustment (20-A MRSA Section 15689, sub-section 1-B) This adjustment guarantees that Freeport’s State share must equal at least 50% of Freeport’s share (based on Freeport’s percentage of pupils) of the Special Education Cost as calculated by Essential Programs & Services

Minimum Special For 2022-2023 Freeport’s EPS Special Education Allocation (ED 279 Section 3 A, lines 2 plus 3) equals Education Adjustment $3,278,567.62 times 57.26% (Freeport’s percentage of pupils) equals $1,877,308 time 50% equals $938,654 for the minimum special education adjustment. This adjustment increases the amount of State subsidy and lowers the Required Local Contribution for Freeport and the school administrative unit as a whole.

School units often have additional costs beyond EPS.

• Durham has DEBT service from New PreK-8 Elementary School and this non-shared debt is solely the responsibility of Durham.

• RSU #05 also has an ADDITIONAL LOCAL amount to raise since the cost of education is greater than the EPS formula. (Over 80% of school Additional Local Share administrative units raise additional local funds.)

• RSU #05 shares the additional local amount based on the percentages established in their approved 2008 RSU reorganization plan.

• Durham 21.42%

• Freeport 65.68%

• Pownal 12.60%

RSU #05 Historical Review of Additional Local Raised

Town            2010-2011 to      2015-2016 to       2019-2020 to 2021-2022 to
                 2013-2014         2018-2019          2022-2023    2022-2023
                  Average           Average            Average     Percentage
                 Percentage        Percentage         Percentage    Increase
                  Increase          Increase           Increase
Durham              2.37%             10.93%              8.45%            16.20%
Freeport            2.37%             10.93%              8.45%            16.20%
Pownal              2.37%             10.93%              8.45%            16.20%
RSU Total           2.37%             10.93%             8.45%             16.20%

Note: Due to the set percentages of cost sharing in RSU #05, the percentage Increase for the individual municipalities will be the same as the RSU Total.

Factors that can impact the additional local raised amounts:

• Increase or decrease in the unit’s total budget.

• Increase or decrease in the amount of State subsidy. Revisions in the State school funding law can significantly impact the amount of subsidy a school Factors that can unit may receive. impact Additional • Increase or decrease of the required local Local Share contribution. This can shift funds from the required local contribution category into the additional local raise category.

• Increase or decrease of debt service obligations.

• Increase or decrease in other revenues that support the annual budget – such as tuition revenue and balance forward.

Factors that can impact additional local raised

Town                            2010-2011 to   2015-2016 to   2019-2020 to   2021-2022 to
                                 2013-2014      2018-2019      2022-2023      2022-2023
                                  Average        Average        Average       Percentage
                                 Percentage     Percentage     Percentage      Increase
                                  Increase       Increase       Increase
Total Budget                       3.32%          4.85%          3.02%          4.24%
Adjusted State Subsidy             2.52%          4.85%          2.21%          -2.79%
Required Local Contribution        5.32%          3.35%          0.83%          -3.70%
Additional Local Contribution      2.37%          10.93%         8.45%          16.20%
Total Local Contribution           3.14%          5.21%          3.27%          2.90%

Common Cost Sharing Components

• The 55% of RSUs based their cost sharing on percentage of valuations (fiscal capacity).

• However, 48 of the 75 RSUs were formerly School Administrative Districts (SADs) that reformulated into RSUs and kept their existing cost share formulas. Many of these SADs established their cost sharing at a time that the law required it to be based solely on valuation.

• Of the 27 remaining RSUs: Common Cost Sharing • Ten RSUs are based on some combination of percentage of Components valuation (fiscal capacity) and percentage of resident students.

• Five RSUs are based on percentage of valuation (fiscal capacity).

• 10 RSUs are based on some other formula that may include percentage of valuation (fiscal capacity) and percentage of resident students, per-pupil costs or are the same percentage as the EPS formula

• The remaining two RSUs’ cost sharing formulas were unavailable.

RSU #05 Percentage of Pupils*

Town          Current         2010-2011 2015-2016               2019-2020    2022-2023
            Cost Sharing       to 2013-   to 2018-               to 2022-    Percentage
            Percentages          2014       2019                   2023       of Pupils
                               Average    Average                Average
                              Percentage Percentage             Percentage
                               of Pupils  of Pupils              of Pupils
Durham          21.42%           30.02%         31.12%            31.42%       32.06%
Freeport        65.98%           59.94%         58.60%            57.94%       57.26%
Pownal          12.60%           10.04%         10.28%            10.63%       10.68%

*ED279 Average Subsidizable Pupils from Section 4

RSU #05 Percentage of Valuation*

Town                  Current          2010-2011 2015-2016             2019-2020    2022-2023
                    Cost Sharing        to 2013-   to 2018-             to 2022-    Percentage
                    Percentages           2014       2019                 2023       of Fiscal
                                        Average    Average              Average      Capacity
                                       Percentage Percentage           Percentage
                                        of Fiscal  of Fiscal            of Fiscal
                                        Capacity   Capacity             Capacity
Durham                  21.42%            17.12%          18.05%          17.39%      17.12%
Freeport                65.98%            73.71%          71.49%          71.84%      72.41%
Pownal                  12.60%             9.17%          10.46%          10.78%      10.47%

*ED279 Fiscal Capacity from Section 4 – valuations as defined by law

RSU #05 Comparison of Percentage of Valuation and Percentage of Pupils to Current Formula – utilizing 2022-2023 data

Town                 Current      2022-2023 Percentage    2022-2023    Percentage
                   Cost Sharing   Percentage Difference   Percentage   Difference
                   Percentages     of Pupils    from       of Fiscal      from
                                              Current      Capacity     Current
Durham                21.42%        32.06%     10.64%       17.12%       -4.30%
Freeport              65.98%        57.26%     -8.72%       72.41%       6.43%
Pownal                12.60%        10.68%     -1.92%       10.47%       -2.13%

RSU #05 Comparison of Percentage of Valuation and Percentage of Pupils to Current Formula – updated to preliminar y 2023-2024 data

Town                 Current      2023-2024 Percentage    2023-2024    Percentage
                   Cost Sharing   Percentage Difference   Percentage   Difference
                   Percentages     of Pupils    from       of Fiscal      from
                                              Current      Capacity     Current
Durham                21.42%        31.63%     10.21%       17.18%       -4.24%
Freeport              65.98%        57.60%     -8.38%       72.31%       6.33%
Pownal                12.60%        10.77%     -1.83%       10.51%        -2.09

Recommendations:

• The RSU should consider establishing a cost sharing formula that adjusts for changes in fiscal capacity and pupils for each municipality from year to year.

• Utilizing a combination of percentage of resident pupils and percentage of fiscal capacity (valuations) would provide an equitable method of sharing the additional local costs.

• Resident pupil data, it is best to utilize the pupils indicated on the ED279 Section 4 for consistency. Recommendations • Fiscal capacity data, the RSU should use that same calculation that is used under current EPS School Funding law (below) presented on the ED279 Section 4. This method buffers any large increases from year to year and recognizes the loss of taxable valuation resulting from recent declines.

• Property fiscal capacity. "Property fiscal capacity" means the average of the certified state valuations for the 3 most recent years prior to the most recently certified state valuation or the certified state valuation for the most recent prior year, whichever is lower.

• Should the RSU choose to move forward in changing the cost sharing formula, it would be prudent to phase this change over a three-to-five-year period.

RSU #05 Possible Formulas for Cost Sharing – utilizing 2022-2023 data

Town                 Current            25%            30%            35%       Percentage
                   Cost Sharing        Pupils         Pupils         Pupils      Based on
                   Percentages       75% Fiscal     70% Fiscal     65% Fiscal   EPS 2022-
                                      Capacity       Capacity       Capacity      2023*
Durham                21.42%           20.86%         21.60%           22.35%     18.72%
Freeport              65.98%           69.62%         67.86%           67.11%     69.82%
Pownal                12.60%           10.52%         10.53%           10.54%     11.46%

*ED279 Adjusted Local Contribution from Section F

RSU #05 Possible Formulas for Cost Sharing Formula – updated to preliminar y 2023-2024 data

Town                  Current            25%            30%            35%       Percentage
                    Cost Sharing        Pupils         Pupils         Pupils      Based on
                    Percentages       75% Fiscal     70% Fiscal     65% Fiscal   EPS 2023-
                                       Capacity       Capacity       Capacity      2024*
Durham                 21.42%           20.79%         21.52%           22.24%     18.49%
Freeport               65.98%           68.63%         67.89%           67.16%     70.21%
Pownal                 12.60%           10.58%         10.59%           10.60%     11.30%

*ED279 Adjusted Local Contribution from Section F

R SU #0 5 H is torical Comp aris on of Pe rce n tage of Valu ation an d Pe rce ntage of P u pi ls to Curre n t Formu la – 20 09- 20 10 an d p re limin ar y 2 02 3- 2 0 2 4 d ata

Town                    Current      2009-2010 Percentage     2009-2010     Percentage
                      Cost Sharing   Percentage Difference    Percentage    Difference
                      Percentages     of Pupils    from        of Fiscal       from
                                                 Current       Capacity      Current
Durham                   21.42%        29.37%       7.95%        16.31%          -5.11%
Freeport                 65.98%        59.82%       -6.16%       74.39%          8.41%
Pownal                   12.60%        10.81%       -1.79%       9.30%           -3.30%

Town                    Current      2023-2024 Percentage     2023-2024     Percentage
                      Cost Sharing   Percentage Difference    Percentage    Difference
                      Percentages     of Pupils    from        of Fiscal       from
                                                 Current       Capacity      Current
Durham                   21.42%        31.63%       10.21%       17.18%          -4.24%
Freeport                 65.98%        57.60%       -8.38%       72.31%          6.33%
Pownal                   12.60%        10.77%       -1.83%       10.51%          -2.09

R SU #0 5 H is torical Comp aris on of Valu ation / Fis cal Cap acity an d P u pi l s f rom 2 01 8- 2 0 1 9 an d p re limin ar y 202 3- 20 24 d ata

                                                                                                                                      2018-2019          2018-2019
                                                                                                                                         to                 to
ED279 Pupil Counts                       2018-2019       2019-2020       2020-2021       2021-2022       2022-2023       2023-2024    2023-2024          2023-2024
Durham                                       594.0           599.5           619.0           622.0           626.0           640.0                46.0           7.7%
Freeport                                    1,118.0         1,140.0         1,164.0         1,126.5         1,118.0         1,165.5               47.5           4.2%
Pownal                                       203.0           211.5           209.0           205.5           208.5           218.0                15.0           7.4%
Total                                       1,915.0         1,951.0         1,992.0         1,954.0         1,952.5         2,023.5           108.5              5.7%

Increase/(Decrease) over Prior Year
Durham                                                       0.93%           3.25%           0.48%           0.64%           2.24%
Freeport                                                     1.97%           2.11%          -3.22%          -0.75%           4.25%
Pownal                                                       4.19%          -1.18%          -1.67%           1.46%           4.56%
Total                                                        1.88%           2.10%          -1.91%          -0.08%           3.64%

                                                                                                                                      2018-2019          2018-2019
                                                                                                                                         to                 to
ED279 Valuations (Fiscal Capacity)       2018-2019       2019-2020       2020-2021       2021-2022       2022-2023       2023-2024    2023-2024          2023-2024
Durham                                 365,000,000     376,000,000     393,900,000     419,483,333     442,083,333     469,766,667      104,766,667           28.7%
Freeport                              1,491,750,000   1,526,466,667   1,618,700,000   1,733,083,333   1,869,816,667   1,976,683,333     484,933,333           32.5%
Pownal                                 231,575,000     236,100,000     246,500,000     257,383,333     270,400,000     287,316,667       55,741,667           24.1%
Total                                 2,088,325,000   2,138,566,667   2,259,100,000   2,409,949,999   2,582,300,000   2,733,766,667     645,441,667           30.9%

Increase/(Decrease) over Prior Year
Durham                                                       3.01%           4.76%           6.49%           5.39%           6.26%
Freeport                                                     2.33%           6.04%           7.07%           7.89%           5.72%
Pownal                                                       1.95%           4.40%           4.42%           5.06%           6.26%
Total                                                        2.41%           5.64%           6.68%           7.15%           5.87%

Source: , linked from www.rsu5.org/board-of-directors-and-policies/board-agendas-and-minutes/agendas. Text copied out by software (pdftotext); no wording corrected.