Skip to content

December 22, 2021

Board meetings · Agendas · December 22, 2021 · 31 pages · 5,990 words · all RSU 5 documents · the district's file →

Text copied out by software, not the document itself. This is an image-only scan, read by text-recognition software, so figures, names and tables are unreliable. The district's copy is authoritative; check it before relying on this text.

SPECIAL MEETING OF RSU NO, 5 BOARD OF DIRECTORS

WEDNESDAY-— DECEMBER 22, 2021.

FREEPORT HIGH SCHOOL - LIBRARY - 6:30 P.M. SPECIAL SESSION |

(Note: This meeting will not be live streamed) ;

1. Call to Order: The meeting was called to order at___ p.m, by Chair Michelle Ritcheson

2. Attendance: ___Colin Cheney __Jill Piker ___ Candace deCsipkes ___ Maura Pillsbury ___ Jennifer Galletta ___Michelle Ritcheson ___ Susana Hancock ___ Valeria Steverlynck ___Elisabeth Munsen ___ Madelyn Vertenten ___ Dung Nguyen ___ Brady Grogan — Student Representative ___Piper Williams — Student Representative

3. Pledge of Allegiance:

4. — Public Comment: (10 Minutes)

5. | New Business: (60 Minutes)

A. Consideration and approval to engage with Maine School Management Association for Superintendent search services. Motion: __ 2nd, Vote:

6. Adjournment: Motion: 2™, Vote: Time:

> SS Si eal ee ee eee ee §=——Ss Maine School Management Association

MSMA Director Search Services ey

MAINE SCHOOL MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATION

Technical Proposal To: RSU oO for Superintendent Search Services December, 20721

Malne School Management Agaocletion

5 Se Te eee E- . ———————_—_—_—_—_— “iii le | 5 2 MS} { Maine School Management Association L 49 Community Drive, Augusta, ME 04380 (ee Telephone: (207) 622-8473 Fax: (207) 626-2568 MAINE SCHOOL MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATION Website: www.msmaweb.com MSMA Superintendent Search Coordination and Consulting Services Proposal to RSU 5

The Maine School Management Association (MSMA) is pleased to have this opportunity to present RSU 5 with a proposal for superintendent search services. MSMA stajf is prepered to conduct your search in the mast individualized and professional manner possible, Secause our work involves providing comprehensive administrative sarvices to boerds/committees and superin- tandents, and directors in this state, we have a vested interest in the success of your search. We went to be cartain thet you and your new superintendent are an excellent match, The children of your community have the right to expect as much from ell of us. The taxpayers of your community have the right to demand it.

MSMA has designed the seerch service to offer maximum flexibility to the Board and to assure that the Board has total control of the decision-making process. We will do the necessary foundation work to make certain the Board is free to concentrate on the most important elements in search—interviewing the most qualified candidates and selecting the next superintendent to lead RSL 5.

Maing School Management Association

Ge INDEX Page 3 Why hire MSMA to conduct your search? Page 4-6 MSMA's Consultant Team Page 7-8 Overview of MSMA Superintendent Search Services Page 9 CTE Director Search Proposed Timeline Page {0 Recent Searches Conducted by MSMA Maine Schoo! Management Association

ST a ee a mr ae eg Why hira MSMA to conduct your search? Probably the single-most important decision a school board mekes is the selection of a superintendent. Since this decision is so important, the procass of selection should be very thoroughly developed and cerefully followed. > MSMA is well-versed in all aspects of Meine laws and statutes that impact the selection process. > MSMA can alleviate the time commitment necessary to conduct a thorough search process. = MSMA has a thorough understanding of Maine public school operations. => MSMAuses in-state and national networking. => MSMA employs a comprehensive in-house steff. => MSMA streamlines the Board's selection process providing the search committee secure online access to review candidate materials, Whether you need advice, counsel, technical assistance, or our complate, comprehensive search service, your MSMA team will guide you through all stages of the seerch process. Maina School Management Association 3

LRP

MSMA‘s Consultant Taam The MSMA staff is a kay part of your search team. They are ell veterans in the administrative, procedural, public relations, commu- nications, and political aspects of the superintendent and diractor search process. Qur in-house capabilitias save you money end time and ensure that you heve direct contact and immediate turnaround in all phases of the process.

Our Office: Maine School Management Association 49 Community Drive, Auguste, ME 04330

Telephone: (207) 622-3478 = Toll free: (BOD) G6D-8484 Email: msmacomsmeweb.com = Website: www.msmaweb.com Araas of Expertise: Superintendent/CTE Director Search Services New Superintendent Oriantation Superintendent and Board Professional Development

Strategic Flanning Education and Legislative Advocacy Types of Search Services Performed: Superintendent Interim Superintendent Interim Business Manager Superintendent/Principal CTE Director

MSMA staff will work with your board throughout all phases of a superintendent/director search end will modify the search to meet your specific needs. You get the seerch services you want—not the seerch process someone has decided you should have. Maina School Management Association 4

See eee MSMA’s Consultant Team—Lantinued Each employee is a full-time employee of MSMA, thus available during regular business hours Monday through Friday. Additionally, lead consultants, Steven Bailey and Eileen King, are aveilable vie email and call phone after hours. MSMA hes extensive resources to assist you at every stage, including analyzing your needs, conducting focus groups, daveloping the process for determining the credentials, background snd candidate profile, questions, screening and site visits. MSMA has been conducting successful suparintandent searches for more then 40 years, and our consultants have decades of hiring EXpBrience. Meat our Consultants

Steven Balley has over 49 years experience in public education in Maine and New Hampshire. He has

— been a Superintendent of Schools and Assistant Superintendent in Maine for tan years covering the fal- F -_ q lowing governance structures: ADS, CSD, School Union, and Municipal and hes participated with many SAD/RSU Boards in trainings and workshops. Steve holds a Certificate of Advanced Graduate Studies in Educational Leadership, a Mesters in Educe- tion, and a Bachelors of Seience in Health/Physical Educetion. He has taken classes through the Har- vard Graduate School of Education focusing on diversity, equity and inclusion

Steven W. Bailey . _

Executive Director He is Past Prasident of the Maine School Superintendents Association and previously was very activa in the American Association for School Administrators (AASA). He was honored as a National Distin- guished Principal in 1996 and Superintendent of the Year in 2015. He currently is a member of the Ne- tional School Boards Association end AASA where he actively participates in the leadership trainings for stata executives and School Boerd officers. Bailey is in his fourth year as Executive Director of MSMA where he continues the strang MSMA tradition of laedership to School Boards and Superintendents. Ellaen King has 43 years experience in public education in Maine and New Jersey. She has bean a Su- perintendent of Schools for 16 years, a Middle School and Elementary School Principal for 15 years and began her career in Education as e High School Spanish Teacher. Eileen holds a Mastars Degree in Education, a Bachelor of Arts Degrea in Spanish and has completad over GO advanced graduate cradits in Educational Leadership, Middle Level Education and Business

= Administration. \ She is a former president of the Maine School Superintendents Association, prior chair of its Profas- : : sional Development Committee and former member of MSSA's Executive Committee for (3 years. She Eilaan E. King was honored as 4 National Distinguished Principal in 2000 and Superintendent of the Yeer in 2009. Ei- Deputy Executive leen is active in AASA, The School Superintendents Association, and raprasents Maine Superintendents Director as their Executive Director nationally. King is in her fourth year as Deputy Executive Director of MSMA and Executive Director of MSSA. Maine School! Management Ageociation 5

SS —ee ee a an MSMA's Consultant Team—Zantinved Victoria Wallack, Director of Communications and Government Relations Victoria Wellack came to Maina School Management Association with more than 3D yeers experience in the newspaper industry, serving 8s editor and publisher of several newspaper groups in Greater Boston after sterting out in the business as a daily report- er. She honed her political skills as editor-in-chief of the Portsmouth Herald covering the first Clinton campaign, and eventually appeared on political talk shows on Boston's Public Broadcasting TY WGBH and NECN. Upon coming to Meine, she started her own news service at the Statehouse in Augusta, reporting on state budgets, the adoption of the Essantial Programs and Services fund- ing formula and school consolidation. She was hired as the communication director at MSMA in 2008 and now serves as Director of Communications and Government Relations for the Association. She ragulerly does communication and legislative advocacy training for superintendents and school boards, She is a graduate of the Ohio State University School of Journalism and took graduate courses in government policy at the Harvard University Extension School in Cambridge. Charlotte Bates, Director of Policy and Research Services JD, University of Maine School of Law MA, University of lows, Child Behavior end Development BA, Betes College, Psychology and History Charlotte Bates has been with Maine School Management Association for over 20 years, providing policy and other consultation services to school boards and superintendents; developing MSMA sample policies, procedures and other materials; reviewing and revising school board policias, board bylaws and internal operating procedures, and student handbooks; and conducting policy ra- lated workshops, She hes completed numerous comprahensive reviews/ravisions of schoo! board policy manuals and governence documents and has worked with school boards and their policy committees around the state. She has served on the Scarborough Board of Education, acting as Vice Chair, Chair of the Board's Policy Committee, and member of its Negotiations Committee, and on the Town of Scarborough’s Comprehensive Plan Review Committee. She is also a member of the Government and Public Sector Section of the Maing State Bar Association. Angie Audatte, Administrative Azeistant Angie Audette has been with Maine School Management Association since 1994 providing comprehensive administrative support for MSMA Superintendent Search Services for aver {I years. She plays an integral support role in MSMA Superintendent Search Ser- vices researching and developing customized materials including all graphic ads and communicating with search committees and candidates throughout the process. Maine School Management Association 6 ee ee ee ee eee Overview of MSMA Superintendent Search Services

Afirst step in recruitment for a new Superintendent is getting organized and consideration of the following paints:

> Whether a consultant will be employed to assist the school beard in the selection process.

=> Whether the outgoing superintendent will be involved in the process,

=> Whether the full board or a subcommittee will be responsible for the process.

=> Whether others (administrators, teachers, citizens) will be involved,

=> Whether the school board will be responsible for the candidates’ expanses.

The search process can be divided into five phases, with the primary responsibility of the search consultant and the school board/search committee clearly delineated. MSMA Director Search Services available from start (phase |) to finish (phase 0) are set forth below. MSMA will assist in developing a timeline for the entira search process.

Phase | - Leadership Profile Development A mamber of the MMA team would provide consulting services to identify success factors, major issuas, and expectations; approve leadership profila and selection criteria; conduct focus groups/surveys and report to the board/saerch committee: and compile salary and benefit data. We would assist in job description development and preparation of publicity materials, Phese 2 ~ Candidate Recruitment MSMA would create a complimentary graphic advertisement to be circuleted to Superintendents, Assistant Superintendents and CTE Directors in the state of Maine and nationally to the 50 state board executives. The vacancy would be posted free of charge on the MSMA website and in tha MSSA Newsletter (dependent upon publication dat). Advertising options would be discussed with rec- ommendations and price quotes made aveilable to the board/seerch committee. Arrangements would ba mede for advertising in other venues by MSMA. MSMA would provide customized application materials, coordinate nominations and applications and build candidate files. MSMA staff would promptly and efficiently fulfill requests for application materials and communicate with potential candidates throughout the application process. An MSMA consultant would assist in conducting reference checks on epplicents.

Maine School Management Association 7 a a — ——_L DE E—e eeee

Overview of MSMA Superintendent Search Services—Lontinved Phase 3 - Candidate Scrasning An MSMA consultant would screen candidates against selection criteria, help to identify semi-finalist candidates, inform successful candidates and schedule interviews. MSMA would assist with delivering sami-finalist candidates to the board. MSMA would inform unsuccessful candidates, provide orientation for the board and assist with the selection of finalists. Phase 4 = Full Board Evaluation of Finalists MSMA would assist the board in preperation for the finelist stage. MSMA staff would schadule interviews. conduct reference checks on finalists, and assist the board in preparation for site visits and final intarviaws. Phase 5 - Appointment In the final phese of the search process, an MSMA consultant would assist with the selection of the new superintendent and announcament of the appointment. MSMA would inform other finalists, assist the board in contract preparation and negotiation of the contract. MSMA would provide support in closing the seerch and processing materials, Assistance from an MSMA consultant would be available to ease transition to naw leadership.

Service fees: $175 per hour plus the cost of advertising, Travel expenses of the candidates at both the semi-finalist and finalist levels ere the responsibility of the school board. Travel axpanses for board visits to candidates’ home districts are the responsibility of the school board. Maine Schoo! Management Association :

= — SS es Se ee RSU 5 Superintendent Search Proposed Timeline

MONTH 1

Confirm Job Description Advertising and/or Brochure Development Launch of Community/Staff Qualification and Experience Survey/Public Forums Recruitment and Advertising Bagins Determination of Seerch/interview Committee Search Update Summary Report of Community/Staff Opinion Survey Determine Key Qualifications and Experiences of Candidates

MONTH 2

Deadline for Applications in MSMA Office Presentation of Candidate Pool end Selection of Semi-Finalists by Cooperative Board to ba interviewed Semi-Finalist Interviews Announcement of Finalist Candidates

MONTH 3

Candidate “A” and Candidate “8” in District for Finel Interviews with Board Reference Checks and Visits by Board Members to Candidates’ Home District Announcement of Superintendent: Start Date:

Meine School Management Associetion 9

———— ee SS Se eee Recent Superintendent Searches Conducted By MSMA “Conducting a superintendent search is always 2 daunting task snd for cur most recent search we decided to hire MSMA ta help us with the process. Not only did MSMA guide us in an efficient search, but they also provided valuable insights thet improved aur decision making. Using MSMA got us more qualified candidates than we have ever hed end we completed our search in half the time expected We will never do another search without them!”

Fred Grant, Chair, RSL 29 2020-2021 ADS 58 Bangor School Department

Cape Elizabeth School Department Cheryflald School Department CTE Region 2 Falmouth Interim Search MSAD 17 RSU 9 RSU 28 Saco Interim Search Sahaga School Department South Partand School Department School Union 76 interim Search 2015-2020 Auburn School Department Hermon School Department

MSAD 49 MSAD 49 Interim Search RSU 21 RSW 21 Interim Search School Union 68 2018-2019 Scarboraugh RSwU3

RSU 14 RSU 58 RSL 78/MSAD | RSU 87

2017-2018 ADS ADS 58 MSAD 75 RSU 9 (Mt. Blue RSD)

RSU 16 RSU 38

RSU 71 Wiscassat Maine School Management Assnciation 10

———a i a ee eee ee a Superintendent Search References Wiscasset School Department Scarborough School Department Michael Dunn, Board Chair Leanne Kazilionis

(207) 350-1028 (207) 749-8618 mdunn@ wiscassetschools.org lkazilionis@scarboroughschools.org Full Search, April 20(8- June 2018 Full Search, February 20{5-April 2019 District Cost: $4,361.50 (includes advertising costs) District Cost: $5,507.50 (does not include advertising costs)

RSU 25/MSAD 25 MSAD 58

Frad Grant, Board Chair/Search Committee Chair Kim Jordan, doard Chair

(207) 532-4030 (207) 265-5014 fred@ whoufm.com kim jordan@msedoB.org Full Search, February 2015—April 2015 Full Search, March 2015-May 2019 District Cost: $3,104.79 (dogs not include cost of advertising) District Cost: $2,450.26 (does not include advertising costs)

MSAD 23/RSU 87 RSU 14

Shannon Knowles, Board Chair Kata Brix, Board Chair

(207) BB4-7108 (207) 892-4629 mkskbk@aol.com katebrix@roadrunner.com Full Search, February 2019-May 20/9 Full Search, February 20/9-April 2019 District Cost: $3,201.88 (does not include advertising costs) District Cost: $10,244.16 (includes advertising costs) Winthrop School Department Harmon School Department Susan Belz, Board Chair Jesse Keith, Board Chair

(207) 395-5490 (207) 944-5586 sbelz@winthrapschools.org jasse.r.keith@ qmail.com Partial Search, Octobar 2019-January 2020 Full Search, January 2020-May 2020 District Cost: $1238.92 (does not include advertising costs) District Cost: $3,249.55 (does not include advartising costs) Bangor School Dapartmant CTE Region Two School of Appliad Technolagy Tim Surette Laura Farnsworth, Cooperative Board Chair

(207) 731-6558 (207) 854-2012 timothy surette@ maine.edu Harnsworth@rsuSl.org Full Search, January 202I-April 2021 Full Search, April 2021-June 2021 District Cost: $9,863.35 (includes advertising costs) District Cost; $2.2717.15 (includas advertising costs) Maine Schoo) Management Association 11

= _ See ee SSS SSS es ——— = Maine School Management Association MSMA Superintendent Search Services ECL EST

Cost Proposal of MSMA Superintendent Search Services for RSU oO December, 2071 Maine School Manegement Association

SSS ee ee ee ee EE ae MSMA Superintendent Search Services Cost Proposal

The RSU 5 School Committee has undertaken the important task of searching for a new superintendent. {tis deemed that the search will be thorough and the procedure efficient. Tha Committee retains full authority and responsibility for all decisions. Search services and support may be tailored to the individuel needs of the District. Consultation end support may be obtained from the Superintandent Search Service of the Maine School Management Association et the following rate:

Professional consultation and guidance, an adaptable structure, brochure and ad development, and administrative/clerical support throughout the search process:

© $175 per hour (plus tha cost of advertising)

Additional search-related expanses to be borne by the School Committee Include:

© Telephone. postage, and consumable supplies (at cost)

© Fee-based advertising (varias, and is to be determined by the Committee in consultation with MSMA)

© Travel expenses of the candidates at both the semi-finalist and finalist levels

© Travel expenses for School Committee visits to candidates’ home district

© Consultant travel expenses

Maine School Management Association

BS SSS OE Se SS Ss ae MSMA Superintendent Search Services Cost Proposal—Lantinved

Tha following estimates are based on the receipt of (5 applications. The “per applications” costs will be adjusted. Meeting with District planning to conduct a search Complimentary Planning Preparation of Superintendent Search timeline, activities and calendar Complimentary Committee Workshops: (typically spread over three (3) workshops—I.5 hours eech) ___ Confidentiality training for all involved in the Hiring Process

© Maine and Federal Laws that address Equal Employment Opportunity as well as how to avoid discrimination of protected classes

© Policy and job description raview, including the following policies, if approved district policies

e Recruitment and Appointment of Superintendent

e Evaluation of Superintendent

e Equal Employment Opportunity

e Confidentiality in the Hiring Process

e Recruiting and Hiring of Administrative Steff

e Recruiting and Hiring of Administrative Staff, Administrative Procedure e dob Description, Superintendant of Schools _____ Interrupting Bias in tha Hiring Process: (MSMA and Consultant) ($1,001.01)

© What's getting in the way of an Inclusive Hiring Process?

o What is Bias?

o Can | get rid of my Bigs? ____ Onboarding Your Superintendent. (MSMA and Consultant) ______ Transition Planning. (MSMA and Consultant) Meine School Management Association

SSS SE

MSMA Superintendent Search Services Cost Proposal—Lantinved The following estimates are based on the receipt of {9 applications. The “per applications” costs will be adjusted.

Forums (In-Person Event) ___ Community: 1.5 hours ($262.50) ___ Staff: 1.5 hours ($262.50) ___ Student: 1.5 hours ($262.50)

Listening Sessions (Ramote listening activities designed to maximize participation fram a wide range of participants) MSMA staff will conduct listening sessions with a variety of stakeholders (School Boards, district staff, community members) to collect data on the characteristics and qualifications that is desired in the next Suparintendent of Schools. ($175/session) _____ Please identify the number of Listening Sessions you would like conducted. Each session is approximately one hour lang. Survey _____ Development of survey questionnaire: 1.5 hours ($262.50) ___ Collation of survey results: 5 hours ($875.01) Advertising/Recrultmant ___ dob Description development with samplas: 1.5 hours ($262.50) ___ Brochure Development: 2.5 hours ($487.50) ____ Development of online and print advertisement and posting both online and in MSSA News: 1.5 hours ($262.51) ___ AASA Premium Job Flash package + Diversity Upgrade: $848.00 ____ EdWeek Online: 80 days online TopSchoolJobs.org $495.00 ____Graphic advertisement development, electronic circulation to Maine Superintendents, Assistant Superintandants, CTE Directors, Special Education Directors, Curriculum Coordinators and the 50 state boerd executives end NSBA Network Compllmantary Application Process ____ Custom epplicetion materials development: .5 hours ($87.50) ____ Eorrespondence with candidates - responding to application requests: $43.75 per application ($856.25) ___ Secure webpage creation: { hour ($175.00) ____ Redaction/scan-upload/link each application packet to secure webpage for 15 applications at $B7.50 per application ($1312.50) Maine School Management Association

SS a EE Sa = MSMA Superintendent Search Services Cost Proposal—Lentinved

The following estimates are based on the receipt of (5 applications. The “per applications” costs will be adjusted, Application Process (continued) ___ Processing applications: 5 hours ($875.00) ___ Background Check service: $150/candidate (cost may very per individual)—typically for finelist(s) Interview Process _____ Development of proposed interview questions, and scoring rubric: 2 hours ($350.01) _____ Development of reference check questions: | hour ($175.00) ____ Scheduling of interviews and correspondence with candidates selected and not selected: $43.75 per application ($656.25) Onboarding Follow-up ___ Setting the Stage for Success: 1-3 consultation conferences w/Superintendent. Board Chair, School Board (typically

1 hour each) Total § Maine Schoo! Management Association

November 23, 2014 Advertising November 24, 2014 Begin Recruiting . December 10, 2014 School Board Workshop (Action: Appoint Search Committee Members) December 10-18, 2014 Focus Groups (See Attached: confirmed) December 30, 2014 Deadline for Applicants’ submissions January 6, 2015 Search Committee Orientation {6:30 PM, location TBA) January 7-9, 2015 Search Committee Reviews Applications (RSUS5 Central Office, various times) January 12, 2015 Search Committee Selects 1*t Round Interviews January 20-21, 2015 Search Committee: First Round Interviews January 28, 2015 School Board/Search Committee Executive Session (Select Second Round Interviews) February 4-5, 2015 School Board: Second Round Interviews February 9-10, 2015 School Board: Reference Checks February 11,2015 School Board: Select Finalists February 17-19, 2015 Finalists Visit District February 23-26, 2015 Site Visits March 11, 2015 School Board Selects Superintendent (Executive Session) March 25, 2015 School Board Elects Superintendent July 1, 2015 Superintendent Assumes Office RTB/WJM

RSUS SCHOOL DEPARTMENT SUPERINTENDENT SEARCH FOCUS GROUP REPORT

TO: RSU5 School Board of Directors

FROM: Ron Barker, Search Consultant

RE: Superintendent Search Focus Group Report

DATE: January 5, 2015

Between December 10, 2014 and December 18, 2014, I conducted eight focus group meetings involving school board, teachers/ non-teaching personnel, administrators, students and parents/community. The following summary report includes the observations and perceptions of the focus groups and additional comments by the attendees.

The members of each focus group were open about their concerns and their hopes for the future. It is also evident that there were shared priorities from group to group.

A total of 85 people were involved in the focus group sessions, and I am very appreciative of their interest and enthusiasm.

The following reflects the various categories for the 85 focus group participants. Several fell into more than one category.

58 - Residents of either Durham, Freeport or Pownal

35 — Teachers/support staff in the RSU5 schools

27 - Parents of students currently enrolled in the RSUS5 schools

14 — Students from Freeport High School

14 - Administrators in the RSUS5 schools

11 — School] Board members

The foliowing is a summary of response statements based on four questions: Question 1 - What makes RSUS5 unique?

-Great sense of community

-Great parent/community involvement

-Nice socio-economic/geographic mix

-Good facilities

-Financial support for schools and school projects -Opportunity to build something here by bringing the three communities together -Positive relationship between students and staff

-History as an RSU — growing pains

-Vibrant and supportive business community

-The responsibility students have for their own education -Interesting demographics

-Columbia University literacy program

-Staff added during recession

-Per pupil cost is favorable

-Strong arts program

-Rural community and suburban diversity

-50/50 vote on Freeport withdrawal

-Kind, caring communities that are not materialistic -Supportive and involved parents

-Potential

-Support for co-curricular programs

-Socio-economic and cultural diversity of students -Community feel and involvement

-Great location (Portland, rural, ocean, L.L. Beans)

-Ability to house unique district programs in various schools -Middle school choice for Pownal students at either DCS or FMS -Connectivity between teachers and students

-Teacher accessibility

-Very personal district where students are known and supported -Quality instruction

-Lack of pressure

-Enjoyment of differences

-Freeport HS is located in the center of town

-Inclusive

-Relatively modern school buildings

-Revenue stable communities

-Perfect size — not too big or too small

Question 2 - What are the strengths of the RSU5 schools?

-Great sense of community and family within each school

-Caring and dedicated staff (creative/professional)

Student centered schools and philosophy

-Community support of schools

-Good quality staff

-Parents who are involved and supportive

-Good students that are known by the staff

-Mostly nice facilities

-High priority placed on things that foster student passion (Arts — both visual and performing) -Resources committed to professional development (Columbia U., strategists) -Size of schools allow staff to respond to student needs -Administrative team (people of integrity that work very well together) -Small class sizes

-Supportive business community

-Students that are ready to learn

-K-5 students based close to home — nurturing environment

-Special education programs

-Music programs — coordinated throughout the district

-Pre-K program

-Co-curricular programs

-Open-minded community

-Welcoming schools

-Personal and caring approach to education

-Socio-economic diversity

-Supportive — rather than competitive approach to education

-Ready for a positive change

-Students are both academically and athletically motivated -sports, theatre, academic teams/clubs ~Excellent leadership at the school level

-Curriculum development

-Students motivated to succeed

-Parent volunteers

-Staff that works well together across grade levels

-Life skills program in a small school setting that builds independence -Staff that has mutual respect for each other

-Innovative/collaborative teachers

-Writing and math centers at the high school

-Morse Street school apprenticeship program

-Humanities and language department at the high school

-Little or no bullying in the schools — nice people

-The arts program (local resources and people that assist)

-Honors program at the high school

-Amazing and supportive faculty that support each other

-Critical thinking/test score

Question 3 - What priority areas and emerging issues do you feel the new RSUS superintendent needs to invest time and energy toward developing and addressing in the first two years on the job?

-Visibility in the schools and community

-Re-establish a positive and supportive relationship with the staff and education association Learn about the school system (listen and ask questions)

-Insure a common and unified vision for the district and towns

-Bring the three communities together in a spirit of good education for all the students -Create a unified vision for the RSU and articulate this vision to all stakeholders

-High school construction project

-Simplify the mission and strategic plan with a focus on student learning

-Work closely with the RSU5 School Board to create trust and a common vision/focus -Try to get more investment in the RSU from residents in all three communities

-Insure that contracts/salaries for staff are in-line with area school systems

-Proficiency based diploma

-Perception of RSUS

-Update and simplify the strategic plan

-Funding (communicate needs to communities)

-Work on retaining students and staff (create more opportunities for students)

-Making our schools more competitive (improve student achievement)

-Increase professional development for teachers

-Create conditions for successful curriculum delivery

-Develop a strategic plan that allows us to compete with area schools and charter schools -Improve the culture at FHS and across buildings

-Common core standards related to instruction and assessment

-How special education is utilized district wide

-Create a more positive culture between towns

-Advocacy/leadership for special education and related services across the district -Create a vision for the future of the RSU that establishes common ground

-A plan that brings the three towns together and honors unique needs and interests -Pownal needs a full time principal

-Engage students, staff and communities

-Listen to all sides during teacher contract negotiations

-Establish realistic and attainable goals with consideration of constituents

-Lead the school leaders

-A good observer and listener

-Communicate goals and needs of the district clearly and effectively to garner support -Need more academic rigor, more | on | attention and more differentiated instruction (especially at FHS)

-Looks at alternative ways of educating some youngsters

Question 4- What won't work in the RSUS school system?

-A top down model of running the schools — top down leadership

-Poor people skills

-Weak leadership

~Perception that one town is “the favored child”

-Starting all over again — need to build on what's in place and successfully working -Someone that is not a good listener and does not possess a collaborative leadership style -Trying to change everything to be just like it was where they came from or to a cookie cutter model

-A leader lacking good communication skills

-Someone that is not approachable

-Continued status quo

-Lack of 2-way communication with staff, parents, community members, etc.

-Lack of opportunities for parental and community feedback on school-related issues

-Lack of funding for staff development

-Looking at our towns as individual units rather than the three towns as a whole

-One size fits all — staff development, decision-making, varied situations

-An “office dweller” - not connected with students, staff or the school community

-Making drastic changes too quickly and not explaining why these changes are necessary -Someone that is not visible in the schools and doesn't value the opinion of students and staff -A person who is so focused on his/her own mission that he/she doesn't appreciate what is here -Trying to put more and more money into the schools without looking more creatively at ways we can save money and use resources more efficiently

-Trying to keep up with our neighboring communities financially with more resources beyond that of ours

-Someone who does not encourage teacher and administrator leadership in our schools

-A leader who doesn't work cooperatively with or inspire the school board

-A manager and not an educational leader

-A leader that never questions the state Department of Education or it's directives/direction -Someone that runs our schools with a business model mindset

-A person who believes that test scores tell the entire story of a district's success or failure -Someone that is heavy handed in dealing with people

The last exercise involved all focus group participants completing an “attributes/qualifications" form. They ranked their four top priorities from a list of thirteen attributes/qualifications that research indicates are found in an effective superintendent. Ideally, you would like to see your superintendent possess all or most of these qualities.

The following reflects the attributes/qualifications in rank order:

1. COMMUNITY RELATIONS

-Recognizes the importance of both stimulating and reflecting community needs/wants regarding education

-Demonstrates the ability to involve the community in developing and implementing goals

-Views the community/school relationship as a partnership

2. SCHOOL IMPROVEMENT

-Commitment to supervise and evaluate school programs in the spirit of continuous improvement

-Understanding of educational practices, research and national/state/local initiatives

-Ability to frame issues for discussion and reach timely decisions to implement positive change

3. LEADERSHIP

-Able to motivate, lead, guide and direct people

-Committed to implementing the Mission and Vision Statement of the school department

4. COMMUNICATION

-Able to communicate clearly with staff, parents, students and community (both verbally and in writing)

5. SCHOOL/COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT

-Visible in the schools

-Aware of current issues and activities in the schools

-Shows an interest in community affairs

6. PERSONNEL MANAGEMENT

-Excellent people skills

-Ability to recruit and retain high quality staff

-Strong personnel management practices and understanding of collective bargaining issues

7, SCHOOL FINANCE/BUDGETING

-Strong working knowledge of school finance, including budget development and management

-Ability to effectively communicate with the school board, staff, community and local municipal officials

-Clear understanding of federal, state and local funding issues

8. CURRICULUM

-Strong commitment to leading the effort to define and deliver an effective, consistent curriculum Pre-K to 12

9. ORGANIZATIONAL MANAGEMENT

-Uses a systematic approach to managing and improving the schools

-Excellent organizational skills, working knowledge of school law, and a proven ability to resolve organizational conflicts

10. STAFF DEVELOPMENT

-Committed to and fosters continuous staff improvement

-Emphasizes both system wide and individual developrnent

11, SUPERVISION/EVALUATION

-Understands the importance of accountability for staff and self

-Uses an evaluation process that establishes clear performance standards and follows through to resolve performance issues

12. SUPERINTENDENT/SCHOOL BOARD RELATIONS

-Understands that the superintendent is responsible for successful management of the schools under school board policies and is accountable to the school board

-Supports and facilitates the work of the school board

-Maintains open communication with the school board

13. SCHOOL FACILITY MANAGEMENT

-Good understanding of facilities management, including development of long-term maintenance plans and budget/planning for future needs

The focus group participants could also comment about a specific attribute that they felt was important to them but not included on the form. Listed below are their comments:

-Integrity

-This is a very warm, personal community where students are given lots of responsibility and freedom. We need someone who will support and encourage that.

-Someone with a proven record of positive thinking and bringing people together. A leader that can rally people with conflicting opinions to work together.

-Someone with a big picture attitude — a visionary, not a micro manager who gets hung up on minutia

-Personable, trusting and respectful to others

-Experience as a teacher and administrator

-A creative thinker — can think outside of the box — who also let's teachers/staff be creative and stay excited about their jobs

-Someone who wants to be here for awhile

-Someone who likes kids and has an honest hope for their future

-A person who is flexible and has adaptability and compassion for human situations — ie., not a big “policy person” — someone that sees the grays — NOT just black and white.

-Needs to understand our towns and lead all of us to better empathize with other who disagree

-We need to get beyond the us/them attitude and work across town lines

-A person that one size does not fit all -Strong support of knowledge about special education and an advocate for these students' needs

-Doesn't overextend staff with multiple new practices in one year

-Someone who wants a professional challenge

These are the top five (5) attributes/qualifications listed by the various stakeholder groups:

ADMINISTRATION:

1. Community Relations & Leadership (TIE)

3. Communication, School Improvement, & School Finance/Budgeting (TIE)

PARENTS/COMMUNITY:

1, Community Relations’

2. Leadership

3. School Improvement

4, Communication

5. Personne] Management

SCHOOL BOARD:

1. Leadership

2. School Improvement

3. Community Relations

4, Curriculum

5. School/Community Involvement & Personnel Management (TIE) STAFF;

1. Community Relations

2. School/Community Involvement

3. School Improvement

4, Communication

5. Personnel Management & School Finance/Budgeting (TIE)

STUDENTS:

1. Communication

2. School Improvement

3. School/Community Involvement

4. Curriculum

5. Community Relations & School Finance/Budgeting (TIE)

Summary Based on the feedback from all eight focus groups, the ideal profile for the next Superintendent of Schools in RSUS5 might look something like this: An educational leader, with prior teaching and school administrative experience, that is committed to excellence in education and continuous school improvement. He/she would be a motivator, a good listener, and have a collaborative leadership style. This person would also possess excellent people skills, be a strong communicator with all constituent groups, and be visible in the schools and at school/community events. The next superintendent must be a positive thinker and someone that can lead the development of a workable and meaningful strategic plan for the school district. The creation of this plan should involve educators and stakeholders from the three communities and reflect the needs/wants regarding education in RSUS5. It should further build on the existing strengths of the school system and establish goals and procedures for implementing positive change in areas identified as needing improvement. An important goal for the next superintendent should be to insure a common and unified vision for the district, one that will bring RSU5 and its three communities together in a spirit of cooperation and excellent education for all of its students.

Source: , linked from www.rsu5.org/board-of-directors-and-policies/board-agendas-and-minutes/agendas. Text copied out by software (pdftotext, then OCR); no wording corrected.