Skip to content

February 12, 2020

Board meetings · Agendas · February 12, 2020 · 18 pages · 2,652 words · all RSU 5 documents · the district's file →

Text copied out by software, not the document itself. Layout, tables and figures may not survive. The district's copy is authoritative; check it before relying on this text.

Item #12.B. Update from Page 3 of November 6, 2019 Memo Updated w/ Assessed Home Values November Handout

For additional context, the education costs under the current cost sharing methodology for the median homeowner in each town for 2019/20 (FY20) are presented below.

RSU5 Education Costs for Median Homeowner by Town Education Median Tax per Median Home Median $200,000 Assessed Education Household FY20 Valuation Home Valuea/ Taxb/ Incomec/ d/ Durham $2,868 $182,400 $2,616 $73,750e/ Freeport $2,100 $310,700 $3,262 $79,500e/ Pownal $2,250 $224,200 $2,522 $83,700e/ a/ Provided by each town’s assessor for the 2019/20 Tax Year. b/ Based on each town’s 2019/20 Education Mil Rate. c/ Most recent data available. Source: United States Census Bureau, 2017 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, Table S1903. https://data.census.gov/cedsci/. Searched by Zip Code Tabulation Areas: 04222, 04032, 04069. Also provided by this source: 2017 Mean Income (margin of error): D $84,955 (+/- $8,512), F $111,275 (+/- $21,629), P $94,061 (+/- $8,400). d/ For the 2019/20 Tax Year, Durham’s assessed value is at 92% of market value. At 100% of market value, the median home value would be $198,800. e/ Margin of Error: D +/-$15,996, F +/- $6,849, P +/-$10,956. Source: United States Census Bureau, 2017 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, Table S1903. https://data.census.gov/cedsci/. Searched by Zip Code Tabulation Areas: 04222, 04032, 04069.

3 of 3

Updated 12/11/2019 RSU5 Total Contribution by Municipality - Including State Funded Debt Assumed by RSU 1

                               State Funded                                             Local
                            Debt Assumed by          State Min. Spec. Ed.       Contribution          Total         % Total   % Pupil
FY20          State Subsidy             RSU   Contribution            Adj. (Total RLC + ALM)  Contribution 2   Contribution   Count3
Durham      $ 3,512,993.89 $ 1,270,506.67 $ 4,783,500.56 $            -     $ 5,069,107.00 $ 9,852,607.56             29.84    30.73
Freeport    $ 1,015,214.00 $            -   $         -    $ 1,015,214.00 $ 18,663,675.00 $ 19,678,889.00             59.60    58.43
Pownal      $ 382,508.49 $              -   $ 382,508.49 $            -     $ 3,105,394.00 $ 3,487,902.49             10.56    10.84
RSU5 Adj    $    37,330.41 $            -   $   37,330.41 $           -     $            -
Total       $ 4,948,046.79 $ 1,270,506.67 $ 5,203,339.46 $ 1,015,214.00 $ 26,838,176.00 $ 33,019,399.05             100.00    100.00

                               State Funded                                           Local
                            Debt Assumed by          State Min. Spec. Ed.     Contribution          Total           % Total   % Pupil
FY19          State Subsidy             RSU   Contribution          Adj. (Total RLC + ALM)  Contribution 2     Contribution   Count3
Durham      $ 3,490,597.97 $ 1,292,034.52 $ 4,782,632.49 $          -     $ 4,819,157.00 $ 9,601,789.49               30.31    31.02
Freeport    $ 835,757.00 $              -   $         -    $ 835,757.00 $ 17,971,365.00 $ 18,807,122.00               59.38    58.38
Pownal      $ 286,710.10 $              -   $ 286,710.10 $          -     $ 2,978,354.00 $ 3,265,064.10               10.31    10.60
RSU5 Adj    $ (84,382.89) $             -   $ (84,382.89) $         -     $            -
Total       $ 4,528,682.18 $ 1,292,034.52 $ 4,984,959.70 $ 835,757.00 $ 25,768,876.00 $ 31,673,975.59               100.00    100.00

                               State Funded                                           Local
                            Debt Assumed by          State Min. Spec. Ed.     Contribution          Total           % Total   % Pupil
FY18          State Subsidy             RSU   Contribution          Adj. (Total RLC + ALM)  Contribution 2     Contribution   Count3
Durham      $ 3,499,939.90 $ 1,313,562.37 $ 4,813,502.27 $          -     $ 4,754,417.00 $ 9,567,919.27               31.26    31.66
Freeport    $ 675,327.28 $              -   $ 292,800.28 $ 382,527.00 $ 17,185,625.00 $ 17,860,952.28                 58.35    58.02
Pownal      $ 359,681.99 $              -   $ 359,681.99 $          -     $ 2,819,448.00 $ 3,179,129.99               10.39    10.32
RSU5 Adj    $ (67,233.28) $             -   $ (67,233.28) $         -     $            -
Total       $ 4,467,715.89 $ 1,313,562.37 $ 5,398,751.26 $ 382,527.00 $ 24,759,490.00 $ 30,608,001.54               100.00    100.00

                               State Funded                                           Local
                            Debt Assumed by          State Min. Spec. Ed.     Contribution           Total          % Total   % Pupil
FY17          State Subsidy             RSU   Contribution          Adj. (Total RLC + ALM)   Contribution 2    Contribution   Count3
Durham      $ 3,528,030.27 $ 1,331,956.56 $ 4,859,986.83 $          -     $ 4,574,386.00 $ 9,434,372.83               31.95    31.53
Freeport    $ 635,199.44 $              -   $ 635,199.44 $          -     $ 16,434,200.00 $ 17,069,399.44             57.81    58.47
Pownal      $ 415,071.27 $              -   $ 415,071.27 $          -     $ 2,606,684.00 $ 3,021,755.27               10.23    10.00
RSU5 Adj    $ (40,862.93) $             -   $ (40,862.93) $         -     $            -
Total       $ 4,537,438.05 $ 1,331,956.56 $ 5,869,394.61 $          -     $ 23,615,270.00 $ 29,525,527.54           100.00    100.00

                               State Funded                                           Local
                            Debt Assumed by          State Min. Spec. Ed.     Contribution           Total          % Total   % Pupil
FY16          State Subsidy             RSU   Contribution          Adj. (Total RLC + ALM)   Contribution 2    Contribution   Count3
Durham      $ 3,188,407.97 $ 1,350,350.75 $ 4,538,758.72 $          -     $ 4,497,198.00 $ 9,035,956.72               31.16    30.29
Freeport    $ 612,902.84 $              -   $ 612,902.84 $          -     $ 16,363,229.00 $ 16,976,131.84             58.54    59.51
Pownal      $ 512,988.39 $              -   $ 512,988.39 $          -     $ 2,476,426.00 $ 2,989,414.39               10.31    10.20
RSU5 Adj    $ (81,994.70) $             -   $ (81,994.70) $         -     $            -
Total       $ 4,232,304.50 $ 1,350,350.75 $ 5,582,655.25 $          -     $ 23,336,853.00 $ 29,001,502.95           100.00    100.00

                               State Funded                                           Local
                            Debt Assumed by          State Min. Spec. Ed.     Contribution          Total           % Total   % Pupil
FY15          State Subsidy             RSU   Contribution          Adj. (Total RLC + ALM)  Contribution 2     Contribution   Count3
Durham      $ 3,138,293.23 $ 1,368,744.94 $ 4,507,038.17 $          -     $ 4,011,911.00 $ 8,518,949.17               32.03    30.34
Freeport    $ 484,051.45 $              -   $ 425,390.45 $    58,661.00 $ 14,885,262.00 $ 15,369,313.45               57.79    59.41
Pownal      $ 527,311.67 $              -   $ 527,311.67 $          -     $ 2,180,508.00 $ 2,707,819.67               10.18    10.25
RSU5 Adj    $ (138,645.45) $            -   $ (138,645.45) $        -     $            -
Total       $ 4,011,010.90 $ 1,368,744.94 $ 5,321,094.84 $    58,661.00 $ 21,077,681.00 $ 26,596,082.29             100.00    100.00

Page 1 of 2

                                   State Funded                                            Local
                                Debt Assumed by           State Min. Spec. Ed.     Contribution          Total                        % Total     % Pupil
FY14              State Subsidy             RSU    Contribution          Adj. (Total RLC + ALM)  Contribution 2                  Contribution     Count3
Durham          $ 2,991,841.19 $     590,067.19 $ 3,581,908.38 $         -     $ 3,673,735.00 $ 7,255,643.38                            29.76      29.71
Freeport        $ 584,510.76 $              -   $ 492,755.76 $     91,755.00 $ 14,093,640.00 $ 14,678,150.76                            60.20      60.38
Pownal          $ 469,069.78 $              -   $ 469,069.78 $           -     $ 1,980,621.00 $ 2,449,690.78                            10.05        9.91
RSU5 Adj        $ (114,067.30) $            -   $ (114,067.30) $         -     $            -
Total           $ 3,931,354.43 $     590,067.19 $ 4,429,666.62 $   91,755.00 $ 19,747,996.00 $ 24,383,484.92                           100.00     100.00

                                   State Funded                                           Local
                                Debt Assumed by          State Min. Spec. Ed.     Contribution          Total                         % Total     % Pupil
FY13              State Subsidy             RSU   Contribution          Adj. (Total RLC + ALM)  Contribution 2                   Contribution     Count3
Durham          $ 2,846,637.47 $ 1,406,244.55 $ 4,252,882.02 $          -     $ 3,219,416.00 $ 7,472,298.02                             31.90      30.48
Freeport        $ 473,050.00 $              -   $         -    $ 473,050.00 $ 13,349,175.00 $ 13,822,225.00                             59.00      59.44
Pownal          $ 371,980.03 $              -   $ 371,980.03 $          -     $ 1,760,851.00 $ 2,132,831.03                              9.10      10.08
RSU5 Adj        $ (213,891.50) $            -   $ (213,891.50) $        -     $            -
Total           $ 3,477,776.00 $ 1,406,244.55 $ 4,410,970.55 $ 473,050.00 $ 18,329,442.00 $ 23,427,354.05                              100.00     100.00

                                   State Funded                                           Local
                                Debt Assumed by          State Min. Spec. Ed.     Contribution          Total                         % Total     % Pupil
FY12              State Subsidy             RSU   Contribution          Adj. (Total RLC + ALM)  Contribution 2                   Contribution     Count3
Durham          $ 2,736,900.22 $ 1,425,347.96 $ 4,162,248.18 $          -     $ 3,034,077.00 $ 7,196,325.18                             31.64      30.24
Freeport        $ 412,820.00 $              -   $         -    $ 412,820.00 $ 13,117,833.00 $ 13,530,653.00                             59.50      59.76
Pownal          $ 345,093.18 $              -   $ 345,093.18 $          -     $ 1,669,340.00 $ 2,014,433.18                              8.86      10.00
RSU5 Adj        $ (15,577.74) $             -   $ (15,577.74) $         -     $            -
Total           $ 3,479,235.66 $ 1,425,347.96 $ 4,491,763.62 $ 412,820.00 $ 17,821,250.00 $ 22,741,411.36                              100.00     100.00

                                   State Funded                                           Local
                                Debt Assumed by          State Min. Spec. Ed.     Contribution          Total                         % Total     % Pupil
FY11              State Subsidy             RSU   Contribution          Adj. (Total RLC + ALM)  Contribution 2                   Contribution     Count3
Durham          $ 2,830,056.18 $ 1,449,326.95 $ 4,279,383.13 $          -     $ 3,192,343.00 $ 7,471,726.13                             32.43      29.67
Freeport        $ 217,608.84 $       284,968.75 $ 264,376.59 $ 238,201.00 $ 12,818,561.00 $ 13,321,138.59                               57.82      60.18
Pownal          $ 497,368.76 $              -   $ 497,368.76 $          -     $ 1,747,074.00 $ 2,244,442.76                              9.74      10.15
RSU5 Adj        $ (435,524.90) $            -   $ (435,524.90) $        -     $            -
Total           $ 3,109,508.88 $ 1,734,295.70 $ 4,605,603.58 $ 238,201.00 $ 17,757,978.00 $ 23,037,307.48                              100.00     100.00

                                   State Funded                                            Local
                                Debt Assumed by           State Min. Spec. Ed.     Contribution           Total                       % Total     % Pupil
FY10              State Subsidy             RSU    Contribution          Adj. (Total RLC + ALM)   Contribution 2                 Contribution     Count3
Durham          $ 2,832,290.37 $     391,511.43 $ 3,223,801.80 $         -     $ 3,080,725.00 $ 6,304,526.80                            28.93      29.37
Freeport        $ 192,226.17 $       304,906.25 $ 497,132.42 $           -     $ 12,622,425.00 $ 13,119,557.42                          60.21      59.82
Pownal          $ 593,609.59 $              -   $ 593,609.59 $           -     $ 1,773,522.00 $ 2,367,131.59                            10.86      10.81
RSU5 Adj        $ (615,653.00) $            -   $ (615,653.00) $         -     $            -
Total           $ 3,002,473.13 $     696,417.68 $ 3,698,890.81 $         -     $ 17,476,672.00 $ 21,791,215.81                         100.00     100.00

1

Per Section 6.A. of the Reorganization Plan prepared by the Reorganization Planning Committee (9/18/2009), the RSU assumed liability to pay certain existing indebtedness and lease-purchase obligations for Central Office (issued 2001), FHS (issued 2002), State Portion of MLS (issued 1990), FHS Heating System (issued 2008), FHS Portion of Lighting Upgrade (issued 2008), and State Portion of DCS (issued 2009) . In the years it was received, the full State Contribution, including the State Portion of MLS and DCS debt, is allocated towards the Total Contribution for Freeport and Durham, respectively.

2

Total Contribution is calculated as Local Contribution (i.e., Total Required Local Contribution plus Additional Local Monies) plus State Contribution plus Min. Spec. Ed. Adj. State Contribution includes State Funded Debt Assumed by RSU.

3

Percentage of Total Pupils as reported in Section 4.A. of the ED 279.

Page 2 of 2

Item #12. B.

RSU5 Cost Sharing Methodology Options February 12, 2020

Option 1: Maintain Current Formula Current cost-sharing method is based upon the following formula applied to Additional Local Monies (ALM):

                    % ALM
FY20            Contribution
Durham                 21.42
Freeport               65.98
Pownal                 12.60

And results in the following:

                  % Total          % Pupil
  FY20        Contribution          Count
Durham               29.84           30.73
Freeport             59.60           58.43
 Pownal              10.56           10.84

Other important points to remember:

• Minimum Special Education Adjustment allocated from the state to Freeport is currently shared across the three towns, similar to other funds allocated to each town from the state (i.e., state subsidy and state funded debt).

• The Mil Expectation (i.e., Equalized Mil) from Section 4.B. of the ED 279 is applied to all three towns’ valuation in calculating the Required Local Contribution (RLC).

               Pros                                                  Cons
•    Fair: total contribution of each town is       •   Difficult to explain the rationale for
     relative to pupil count                            the formula
•    Sharing Min. Spec. Ed. Adj. reduces            •   Static
     variability to tax impact for each town
     year to year

RSU5 Cost Sharing Methodology Options

February 12, 2020

Option 2: 85/15% Formula Min. Spec. Ed. Adj. - Applied to Freeport Only

In this option, the cost-sharing method would be based upon the Required Local Contribution (RLC) numbers shown on the ED 279, Section F (Adjusted Local Contribution by Municipality). The remainder represents the Additional Local Monies (ALM) that will be allocated based on a weighted average cost sharing formula of 85% valuation, and 15% pupil count. This method is based upon the following formula applied to ALM:

                     %                  % Pupil            % ALM
FY20          Valuation                   Count            Contribution
Durham         (17.58 x 0.85) +         (30.73 x   0.15) = 19.55
Freeport       (71.38 x 0.85) +         (58.43 x   0.15) = 69.44
Pownal         (11.04 x 0.85) +         (10.84 x   0.15) = 11.01

And results in the following:

               % Total          % Pupil
  FY20     Contribution          Count
Durham            29.95           30.73
Freeport          59.58           58.43
 Pownal           10.48           10.84

Other important points to remember:

• Minimum Special Education Adjustment allocated from the state to Freeport is not shared and is directly applied to reduce Freeport’s RLC, per the ED 279.

• The mil applied to each towns’ valuation in calculating the Required Local Contribution (RLC) is the Adjusted Mil Rate in Section F of the ED 279, rather than applying the Mil Expectation (i.e., Equalized Mil) from Section 4.B.

               Pros                                                Cons
•    Fair: total contribution of each town is       •   Weighted average is difficult to
     relative to pupil count                            explain/understand
•    Variable
•    More transparent: The required local
     contribution aligns to the ED 279.

RSU5 Cost Sharing Methodology Options

February 12, 2020

Option 3: 60/40% Formula Min. Spec. Ed. Adj. - Shared

In this option, the cost-sharing method would be based upon the Required Local Contribution (RLC) numbers shown on the ED 279, Section 4.C. (Required Local Contribution by Municipality). The remainder represents the Additional Local Monies (ALM) that will be allocated based on a weighted average cost sharing formula of 60% valuation, and 40% pupil count. This method is based upon the following formula applied to ALM:

                     %                 % Pupil             % ALM
FY20          Valuation                  Count             Contribution
Durham         (17.58 x 0.60) +        (30.73 x    0.40) = 22.84
Freeport       (71.38 x 0.60) +        (58.43 x    0.40) = 66.20
Pownal         (11.04 x 0.60) +        (10.84 x    0.40) = 10.96

And results in the following:

             % Total             % Pupil
FY20     Contribution             Count
Durham          30.26              30.73
Freeport        59.62              58.43
Pownal          10.12              10.84

Other important points to remember:

• Minimum Special Education Adjustment allocated from the state to Freeport is shared across the three towns, similar to other funds allocated to each town from the state (i.e., state subsidy and state funded debt).

• The mil applied to each towns’ valuation in calculating the Required Local Contribution (RLC) is the Calculated Mil Rate in Section 4.C. of the ED 279, rather than applying the Mil Expectation (i.e., Equalized Mil) from Section 4.B.

               Pros                                                Cons
•    Fair: total contribution of each town is       •   Weighted average is difficult to
     relative to pupil count                            explain/understand
•    Variable

2/12/2020 RSU5 Cost Sharing Methodology Options

       OPTION 1                                        OPTION 2                                          OPTION 3
Current Methodology                  Min. Spec. Ed. Adj. Applied to Freeport Only                Min. Spec. Ed. Adj. Shared
                                                      85% / 15%                                          60% / 40%

                                                                       % Increase                              % Increase                                        % Increase
                                                                            Local                                   Local % Increase Local                            Local % Increase Local
                                                                     Contribution                            Contribution    Contribution                      Contribution    Contribution
                                                          % Total      over Prior                 % Total      over Prior    from Current           % Total      over Prior    from Current
                               % Pupil Count1       Contribution2           Year3           Contribution2           Year3        Method3      Contribution2           Year3        Method3
FY20          Durham                    30.73              29.84             5.19                  29.95             4.82             0.71           30.26             4.47             2.74
              Freeport                  58.43              59.60             3.85                  59.58             4.04            -0.04           59.62             4.19             0.03
              Pownal                    10.84              10.56             4.27                  10.48             3.69            -0.93           10.12             3.33            -4.68

FY19          Durham                     31.02               30.31            1.36                  30.48            1.97             1.06             30.84            1.10             3.44
              Freeport                   58.38               59.38            4.57                  59.25            3.91            -0.22             59.21            4.28            -0.29
              Pownal                     10.60               10.31            5.64                  10.27            8.73            -0.39              9.95            8.22            -3.81

FY18          Durham                     31.66               31.26            3.94                  31.33            6.37             0.46             31.83            3.89             3.71
              Freeport                   58.02               58.35            4.57                  58.58            3.32             0.41             58.34            4.44            -0.01
              Pownal                     10.32               10.39            8.16                  10.09           12.65            -3.23              9.82            9.53            -6.11

FY17          Durham                     31.53               31.95            1.72                  31.67            0.84            -1.84             32.54            2.78             3.76
              Freeport                   58.47               57.81            0.43                  58.72            0.72             1.64             57.87            0.11             0.11
              Pownal                     10.00               10.23            5.26                   9.61            5.29            -7.08              9.59            5.76            -7.28

FY16          Durham                     30.29               31.16           12.10                  31.00           12.79            -0.99             31.57           12.60             2.68
              Freeport                   59.51               58.54            9.93                  59.30            9.80             1.35             58.78            9.95             0.43
              Pownal                     10.20               10.31           13.57                   9.70           13.54            -7.10              9.65           12.59            -7.72

FY15          Durham                     30.34               32.03            9.21                  31.79            7.74            -1.60             32.37           10.23             2.22
              Freeport                   59.41               57.79            5.62                  58.61            6.40             1.47             58.02            5.54             0.41
              Pownal                     10.25               10.18           10.09                   9.60            7.31            -7.08              9.61            8.80            -6.91

FY14          Durham                     29.71               29.76           14.11                  29.72                -           -0.27             29.95                -            1.27
              Freeport                   60.38               60.20            5.58                  60.62                -            0.73             60.48                -            0.48
              Pownal                      9.91               10.05           12.48                   9.67                -           -4.67              9.58                -           -5.80

FY13          Durham                     30.48               31.90            6.11     ED279 Used for FY13 Budget Not Available              ED279 Used for FY13 Budget Not Available
              Freeport                   59.44               59.00            1.76
              Pownal                     10.08                9.10            5.48

FY12          Durham                     30.24               31.64           -4.96                  32.79            6.29             8.60             32.92            5.22             9.57
              Freeport                   59.76               59.50            2.33                  57.96           -2.01            -2.67             57.97           -1.65            -2.65
              Pownal                     10.00                8.86           -4.45                   9.25            8.03             5.34              9.11            6.95             3.47

FY11          Durham                     29.67               32.43            3.62                  32.03                -           -2.89             32.29                -           -1.03
              Freeport                   60.18               57.82            1.55                  58.74                -            1.65             58.54                -            1.29
              Pownal                     10.15                9.74           -1.49                   9.22                -           -6.84              9.17                -           -7.56

FY10          Durham                     29.37               28.93                -    ED279 Used for FY10 Budget Not Available              ED279 Used for FY10 Budget Not Available
              Freeport                   59.82               60.21                -
              Pownal                     10.81               10.86                -

1

Percentage of Total Pupils as reported in Section 4.A. of the ED 279.

2

Total Contribution is calculated as Local Contribution (i.e., Total Required Local Contribution plus Additional Local Monies) plus State Contribution plus Min. Spec. Ed. Adj. State Contribution includes State Funded Debt Assumed by RSU.

3

Local Contribution is Total Required Local Contribution plus Additional Local Monies.

Page 1 of 1

Source: , linked from www.rsu5.org/board-of-directors-and-policies/board-agendas-and-minutes/agendas. Text copied out by software (pdftotext); no wording corrected.