Skip to content

TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 5 February 2025

Board meeting · 2 h 59 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →

Computer-made transcript, not a record of what was said. It mishears names and figures and drops short words, such as the "not" in "does not carry". Click a time to hear the recording, which settles any disagreement. The district's minutes are the official record.

25,039 words in 33 five-minute windows.

9:25

Okay. They don't sound very loud. I don't know. Can you guys hear the mics okay? Okay. Good evening. Welcome to the RSU 5 Board of Directors meeting. It is Wednesday, February 5th, 2025. We are here in the Freeport High School Library. We have a full board, so we will get right to it,

and starting with the Pledge of Allegiance. All right. Do I have a motion for consideration and approval of the minutes from the January 22nd, 2025 meeting as presented, barring any errors or omissions? Kara and Mara, thank you. All those in favor? Great. None opposed. Adjustments to the agenda. This evening, I'd like to adjust 8A, which are resignations.

I have three additional resignations to announce, and that is all this evening. All right. Moving right along to item six, good news and recognition. We will look to Moon to provide us an update. I mean, a lot of stuff has happened, you know, over, I guess, the past couple of weeks.

I guess, so far, the boys' basketball team won against Mount Ararat. I think of yesterday and won, so that was a good win, but the season has been cut short. But then also, the Freeport leadership team has finished gathering information about our main topic of school culture

and what it's like, what it's about, and we'll eventually address that to the school board and also to the student body. Furthermore, we're also apparently planning for the spring dance, and we're also gathering, I guess, music ideas and songs that we're possibly going to play.

And also, I guess, the seniors had an auction to raise money for, like, the prom and more, stuff like that. And I guess it ends February 9th, so if anyone wants to auction for anything, that's something. Also, we just had a curriculum fair, so that was, like, the whole school did, I think, of last week, I'm pretty sure.

And that was a pretty cool experience is to see the new classes that RSU 5 and Regent Denner are offering. That was a good experience. And also recently we had like the 8th grade school night, which was pretty good, I heard.

And so it's going to be great to see, I guess, a new freshman coming up. And then also the school also started sharing like advertising. So like school trips that we can do over the summer vacation. For example, like the free Outward Bound trip for Freeport students, which was like a trip where students could, I guess, visit the shoreline and just rock climb, sail, and ski, or sail for like five days, so that sounds cool.

And also like the Youth Maine Wilderness Leadership Program, which is a program where you can just, sophomores and juniors can go to Baxter and learn leadership skills and just hike around and explore the wilderness. And lastly, the Solastics Art and Writing Awards, which was like an annual competition.

A lot of our Freeport, like, students won a lot of awards. For example, Martin Shaderly won gold in two of his art pieces. Then Jane Schultz won gold in two of his inner arts. And, yeah, it's a lot of, I think, about 15, 20 students who got at least mention, honorable mention, or gold.

So that's pretty good. Thank you. Fantastic. Thank you, Maureen. All right. So we will move on to item seven, public comments. Usually I do a brief pause because there's no one in the audience. I do feel like we probably have some public comment tonight. So I will just start with what we ask of folks who'd like to speak.

We ask that you come up to the microphone. You give us your name and where you live. And you have three minutes. We'll have a little timer so you'll know when that three minutes is up. And we ask if there's multiple folks who'd like to speak, if you can queue up behind the speaker so we can keep it moving quickly so we can hear from as many

folks as we can oh yes and uh Cynthia I don't even know where she is okay Cynthia does she have a did you do a sign-in sheet oh did people okay is that what we're going off of okay so are you gonna give it to me that would have been really impressive just paper airplane that right up here on it while

14:42

it's on its way up here if anyone else would like to add their name to it grab their on their way by okay uh stephanie there's only one stephanie so there you go good evening how are you great all right can you hear me okay so my name is stephanie and i live in freeport with my family

i'm the mother of a student in mrs island class and i also have a son who benefited from a multilingual program producing an esl or esol so as a result i have a good understanding of These programs and their teachers and our students benefit from them.

For my children, English is their third language. They speak French and Spanish fluently. Coming from another country and trying to adapt, the multilingual program has been a blessing for them and for our entire family. It's not only English used in various subjects, math, English class, science, etc.,

But also when a student has difficulties reading, with all its levels of nuances, difficulties of understanding or expressing oneself, and the program goes much deeper. It involves understanding different social codes, traditions, customs, as well as learning how to navigate a new environment.

Most importantly, it is about feeling welcomed as a human being and knowing that it is okay to learn a new language and culture without having to arrange the one you grew up with. Ms. Hyland excels in this regard. She tolerates her class to accommodate each student's learning style and needs.

She approaches her work with empathy, compassion, and genuine curiosity, embracing everyone's differences. Over time, students come to realize that these differences are indeed a strength, and they have a lot to contribute. Multi-engine programs are a powerful asset in a school, in any school.

And Miss Island is a tremendous asset to Freeper High School. She's highly valued, experienced, appreciated by her peers, and deeply loved by her students. Any school and any student would be very fortunate to have her on board.

Thank you. Thank you, Stephanie. Liz already knew she was next. Good evening, RSU 5 board members and community. My name is Liz Pierce, and I am one of three school counselors at Freeport High School. As the counselor who has worked closest with our multilingual students, I am here to advocate on behalf of keeping the third ESOL district position

so we can continue to provide a full-time multilingual learner program at the high school. We are projected to have 15 multilingual students next year With an unknown number of additional enrollments, just in the last few months, we have had two new multilingual students join us from other countries.

A full-time, well-structured multilingual program, like the one we currently have, is not just beneficial, it is a necessity for the success of our students. There are legal and equity considerations for maintaining a full-time program.

Under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Equal Educational Opportunities Act of 1974, public schools must ensure multilingual students have equal and meaningful access to education and grade-level curriculum.

Please consider the unique challenges at the high school level. The academic language demands are more complex. students are required to comprehend high-level lectures participate in discussions complete assignments midterms and final exams the high school

19:49

schedule is also complex students juggle six to seven classes with multiple teachers across varying grade levels because teachers already manage classrooms with multiple students with IEPs and 504s an ESOL teacher who is

skilled at the high school level is essential to collaborate with up to 20 teachers in any given week to provide the necessary modifications to ensure student success our current ML program is more than a pullout program it is an

integrated system provided specs providing specialized English reading and writing classes push and support academic support classes content modification critical social emotional support and assistance with access to basic needs I have seen firsthand how much time and energy is needed to affect

run this program. It is not a part-time or even a three-quarters time job. I believe this is a district that values student success and equitable access for all students. Losing our full-time program will diminish equitable access,

could cause an increase in dropout rates as students are more likely to fall through the cracks, increase stress on our teachers, and negatively impact postgraduate outcomes. Many multilingual students aspire to attend four-year

universities, and a lack of a comprehensive full-time language program could hinder their ability to reach those goals. I understand that numbers sometimes drive decisions. In this case, I urge you to look beyond the numbers to understand the complexities of our high school program

and the real impact the loss of a full-time ESOL teacher would have. High school is the last stop before adulthood. Without sufficient multilingual learning support, students risk leaving school unprepared for their future. Thank you. Thank you guys. I'm the senior project advisor so I come

with my own timer here. Good evening members of the board. My name is Rebecca Peterson and I have proudly taught English at Freeport High School for 15 years. Tonight I ask you to reconsider the proposed elimination of the full-time ESOL teacher position. This is not about one individual. It is

about what the role represents. The ESOL teacher is a champion, a mentor, and a critical link between our school and students navigating a new world their impact cannot be replicated by someone divided between multiple buildings last year i taught multilingual learners with without

a co-teacher despite my experience i struggled to challenge them without causing frustration at the same time my other students were impacted without additional support i had to devote more time to scaffolding lessons which took away valuable instructional time this year with a

a dedicated ESOL teacher, the difference was immediate. Student engagement improved. The ESOL teacher didn't just support students, they empowered them. They built confidence and a sense of belonging. They fostered an inclusive environment, held every student to

a high standard, and helped me become a better teacher. With that support, I was able to give more attention and meaningful instruction to all students. With this position in place, everyone benefited. By the end of the first unit on the American Dream, multilingual learners were

sharing their own stories. They boldly spoke to my classes about their harrowing and heartbreaking journeys to the United States and their hopes for the future. They didn't just learn English, they found their voices. For students outside the multilingual learner program, this was more than

a cultural awareness. It was an academic experience that deepened critical thinking. They weren't just reading about the American Dream, they were engaging in real-world discussion making connections between texts and lived experiences.

These moments rely on a full-time ESOL teacher. This position does not end with classroom support. On a day-to-day basis, the role requires modifying and adapting assignments in advance and on the fly for all the teachers they work with, meeting each student where they are. If this position has 18 students and each of the students has up to 8 teachers, They are actively differentiating for up to 144 different combinations of skill levels and content areas at the high school level.

This is not just support. This is an essential, specialized service that ensures our multilingual learners can access their education in meaningful ways. Without a full-time ESOL teacher, the impact will ripple through our school.

Teachers like me will be left to modify and differentiate alone, without adequate training or time to do it. resulting in lower quality instruction and divided attention for all. In this scenario, every student loses access to the best version of me as a teacher.

24:53

That is not equity, that is not excellence, both of which our district promises. I urge you to reconsider the elimination of this position. The workload is too great, the needs too complex, and the impact too significant.

When we fully support our multilingual learners, we enrich our entire school and uphold RSU-5's commitment to celebrate individuality and empower students to achieve their highest personal aspirations. Thank you. Thank you, Rebecca. Good evening, everybody.

My name is Tim Gravois. This is my 12th year of teaching here at Freeport High School. And I'm convinced, so thank you for your time. But really, I'd like to talk about the type of district that I believe RSU-5 to be. I've taught here at RSU-5 my entire career and for the duration of it, we have been a district that adds to the student support system

that we have, not a district that subtracts from it. A fully staffed multilingual learner program at the high school and the teacher who built it are tremendous additions to RSU 5. First, this program allows our students to bring diverse perspectives, cultural knowledge, and multilingual abilities to our classrooms, and it enriches the high school experience.

A strong MLL program doesn't just benefit the students directly enrolled in it, it creates cascading effects i have stood in front of this board before and advocated for a social studies curriculum that better fosters cross-cultural understanding and tries to help

all students thrive in an increasingly globalized world and we got your support in that effort maintaining a dedicated high school program signals our commitment to leveraging those same strengths and intentions and helps us continuing to work towards a school culture

values and celebrates diversity. That's the type of district that I think that we are. That's an addition. Secondly, a full-time MLL program at the high school creates professional development opportunities. The presence of a full-time ESOL teacher benefits more than just our students. It equips our entire staff to

better understand and implement inclusive differentiated teaching strategies. We have been challenged directly by the creation of this program and the person who created it, who is an outstanding educator, to get better at our jobs.

When we walk into the bathroom at the high school, we're reminded to get better at our jobs. Her professional development is everywhere. We need to think about differentiation with a wider lens. We have to build out those scaffolds and support these students.

Inevitably, that supports everyone. That benefits everybody. A strong MLL program doesn't just support a specific population. It strengthens the foundation of our teaching practices in the school. That's in addition to RSU 5. Lastly, I just want to address the reality of what it takes to build and sustain an effective program like this.

It requires the effort of a skilled, full-time professional. Someone who understands the complexity of high school schedules, curriculum demands, and the nuances of adolescent second language acquisition. Without a dedicated position, I believe we're setting ourselves up to have systemic gaps that will hurt our students and even drive them away.

I urge you to consider the long-term vision of what a Foley staff program represents. It's not just a service, it's an investment in the future success of our students and our community. Every MOL student who graduates feeling confident in their English skills and connected to their peers

represents a win for our school and is a plus for RSU-5. That's the type of place that I believe we are. That's why I work here. Addition, not subtraction, keeps us coming back to do the good work that we do here. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Tim.

Dear members of the RSU 5 board, my name is Lana O'Shea. I am writing to express my deep concern and worry regarding the proposed elimination of one of our ESOL teachers. As an ESOL teacher, I have witnessed firsthand how our program has grown into the successful and effective team as it currently stands.

In 2020, I was hired to be the sole ESL teacher to provide service among our six schools. I can tell you firsthand, it did not work. The amount of travel between schools cut down on the time dedicated to students, and there were students who fell between the cracks. Students did not get the two periods of support per day to be successful in the rigor of our curriculum.

We know better now, and we cannot let that happen again. I recognize this is a difficult budget year, acknowledging the reduction of our ML students, but the proposed cut of an ESOL teacher is excessive and sends a message to our most vulnerable

30:03

that an ML student's educational success does not matter. But I do not come here today to speak as an ESOL teacher. I am here tonight as a person who went through an ESOL program. Like so many families who make the difficult decision to leave their home,

their country, their family, and their friends. My parents came here from the Philippines in search of the American dream. And one of those dreams was to have happy, successful children, contributing members of society, and individuals who will give back to their community.

This is what I envision for our ML students. For the first five years of my life, I spoke only Ilocano and Tagalog. I'm sure you can imagine the difficulties of adjusting to my new environment. my new language, while having the expectation and want to do well in school. What you cannot imagine

is the palpable isolation of not being able to communicate with my peers and the growing belief that school is too hard. It wasn't until I started first grade that I had Mrs. Bath. She was my five foot two inch Chinese Hawaiian ESOL teacher and she was my everything. She was the person who could

give me the time to differentiate the work, the time to let me observe first before trying to speak, and the person who believed I had value as a learner and as a person. My time with her was my safe landing space to breathe and become. Over time, my parents and Mrs. Bath developed a trusting

relationship. My parents felt like they were part of the school community. They would be a team working together to make sure i can continue on to pursue higher education feeling supported in our school system and community is dependent on relationships built over time consistency and

trust instead of reducing a full-time teacher i would love to explore alternate solutions to manage the cost of our esol program acknowledging the reduction in student numbers without compromising the quality of our work. Without overstepping, I am proposing to maintain two

full-time ESOL teachers and reduce the contract of a third person. I understand the need to make budgetary decisions, and I welcome the opportunity to further discuss how we can work together to maintain the strong, cohesive team, ensuring the success of our RSU-5 ML students. Thank you for

your time my turn on board members thanks for allowing me to attended attend tonight excuse me my name is Charles Henshaw I'm a Freeport resident taxpayer stakeholder my wife and I have been in Freeport now for about 10 years we have

three grown children none of whom went through the system here in Maine I'm here tonight to speak to a different different issue altogether than the very weighty issue that I found when I got here. I was here a month ago for the budget meeting, and there were quite a few seats available. Not the case tonight. A week ago today on January 29th,

an executive order entitled or titled Ending Radical Indoctrination in K-12 Schooling was issued from the White House. For this citizen and member of the Freeport community, the content, statements, allegations, insinuations, etc. laid out in that executive order are quite troubling.

And I'm simply here tonight to implore all of the members of this board to find the time to read carefully that executive order and to consider. I recognize that there are legal implications to doing something like this,

but to consider, as a board, issuing a statement articulating the board's position regarding the contents of that executive order. Thanks for your time. Thank you. Maddie, welcome back. Thank you. My name is Maddie Vertenten. I live in Freeport. I am so moved by the organization and the commitment demonstrated

35:11

by such a large gathering of FHS staff tonight. This is something I only witnessed a handful of times on my six years serving on this board, and it's impressive. And knowing many of you and knowing the commitment of this board, I implore you to take their words very seriously.

I want to speak to an issue that I feel is adjacent to what they spoke about, but not directly about that. But it's community support for the RSU-5 budget. As a taxpayer, I've always supported the school budget. I believe that students and educators are not where we should focus any efforts to economize.

Rather, I feel that these are the most important places for us to invest our tax dollars. Wow, I'm nervous. This is... Wow! I didn't expect to be nervous. I mean, I am out of practice. Anyway, I'm here to let you all know that I trust you to do the diligent work

of determining what our budget should be, because I know you to be people that have always engaged in such diligent work. And I place my trust in you to take these concerns very seriously. In these difficult times, when our current president threatens to undermine systems of education

and indeed to abolish the Department of Education, I believe that one of the most important things I can do is support my school board, and most importantly, support the budget. That's why I'm letting you know that I trust you to put forward a budget that will provide for, educate, protect, and safeguard our most vulnerable assets, our children.

I also wanted to come here today in hopes that other members of the community might be listening in and make the decision for themselves to support our schools, this board, and the upcoming budget as a way to not comply with the egregious actions proposed by the Trump administration.

And I would encourage anyone in the community who agrees with this perspective to engage vocally now, well in advance of the annual budget meeting in May and the budget validation referendum in June. I cannot believe that we're living in times where supporting our schools feels like an act of civil disobedience.

But there you have it. I don't abide by any arbitrary measures or pre-concluded idea about what percentage our budget should rise or fall by in any given year. Again, I trust you to make that determination and to look beyond the numbers as a previous commenter requested you to do.

it has always been my contention that our students and our teachers must come first although I know we live in uncertain times financially especially with the threat of tariffs looming I still would support our school budget no

matter what the impact is to my personal finances because for the third time I trust you to make the right decisions about what our budget should be and to safeguard the future and the safety of our students in RSU 5 as our most important community investment. Thank you for everything that you do. I know that the work of

a school board director is extremely meaningful and extremely challenging work. Thank you for your service to our community and to our children. Thank you, Maddie. Okay, so that was everyone we had on the list. Okay, great. Thank you. Thank you for everyone who got up and took the time to speak

this evening. We always appreciate hearing feedback, as the gentleman, Mr. Henshaw, said earlier. We don't generally get a ton of public comments, so thank you all for coming and sharing with us today. So we will continue on with our agenda, item 8, report from the superintendent.

We have a few resignations to report tonight to the board. Rachel Medeiros, Moore Street School Ed Tech. Connie Carpenter, bus driver. Kate Michu, Moore Street School Grade 2. It will be for next year. And Jana Glynn, Moore Street School Grade 2 for next year. And that's the end of the report tonight.

Okay. So we don't have any administrative reports this evening or board comments. No policy review. So we will move right into our first session of the budget review with the individual administrators sharing their budget requests for the upcoming year.

And we will start with the Moore Street School. Oh, that's right. Sorry. You told me that. Yes. june's going to give us an update first and then we're going to go to the individual reports we're just going to provide a brief update on the budget last week the board had a couple of requests for

40:31

some data that's provided for you we were asked to provide some class sizes with with the proposed reductions and I'll talk about that in a minute we've also since received an additional request from a board member about staffing at the high school and we don't have that this evening but we'll certainly get that for you for next time by course and the other

information we'll share this evening is the proposed budget impact summary for the board the ed279s are in so we know our subsidy as well as we have confirmed information from our towns so we'll be able to provide that information for you

as well tonight and I think that will help sort of set the the stage for folks and what we're looking at for budget so the first slide is also in the handbook on page 3 this is what we presented last week for you for pre-k 8 that was the

class sizes based on the 2024 2025 staffing levels the next slide is the requires at the request of the board this you can find also on page 4 of your handbook that's the projected class sizes with the projected teachers with

the staffing levels with those recommendations and reductions for pre-k So there's that data there for you to mull over later on. Looking at, just a snapshot again, what we presented last week, and you're certainly going to begin to hear from all the different schools and departments starting tonight. We're looking at Article 1, that's all the regular education and all the associated costs, everywhere from salaries and benefits to supplies, books, and so forth. forth, and you can see there's an increase of 2.48% in a request. We look at special education. That's in

Article 2 and all the costs associated with that, and there's an increase of 10.95% there. Career and Tech Ed, that's our portion that we pay Region 10. That one, I will remind everyone, is estimated because they haven't finished their budget process yet, so we added a 9% increase there until we have that

figure from them. Article 4, that's our other instruction that includes all our co-curricular and athletics. There's an 8.14% increase there. Article 5, student and staff support, an increase of 6.25% there. System admin, there's an increase of 7.13% there. School administration, an increase

is 7.36 transportation and buses you'll see an increase of 21.74% there and this evening we're going to talk to a bit about more with the board about vehicle replacement so we'll talk touch on why that's up as as much as it is facilities

and maintenance is up 7.55 and our debt service we're always happy when our debt service goes down as over years as we pay some of those things up so there's a decrease there all other that's where our school nutrition program is there's a

decrease there and reminding folks that that's not the total cost of the school nutrition program that's the cost that that's the portion that in our budget that we put towards the school nutrition budget so overall we're looking at the

proposed operating costs we're looking at forty three million nine hundred three thousand and eighteen dollars for for this 25 26 school year and we let me add in the adult education portion is 43 million nine ninety one oh one eight so

we get to this is the impact summary data some folks will look at these little snippets if you are would like to look at the whole sheet at once which some people like to follow down it's easier if you turn to page eight when we look at

eight nine in our handbook we'll start with page eight and then we just look through here if you if if we look at you see there's our total our proposed 43 million 991 018 is our proposed budget and you look at we're looking remember

this is just the expenditure side it's an increase of 5.72 percent on the expenditure side from last year when we move down and when looking at revenues the shared revenues that we'll talk about that a little bit more I'll go over

that in detail that's at the bottom of page 8 in your handbook but I'll explain what what that 1.59 million dollars is I'll explain where that came from we do know from our ed 279 that we are remember part of a of an educational cost

center so we get extra subsidy for that and we lost a little bit in that this year so it's it's two thousand four and eighty one dollars and sixty cents less when you look at our overall subsidy we had a huge decrease this year for us we

45:41

lost two hundred six thousand nine hundred sixty three dollars and forty eight cents in decreased subsidy that we have so we move on to the next slide and moving down this is sort of in the middle of page eight of your following along there we're looking at we have here we're going to bless our shared debt

that we have which is the 118 908 that's where our debts gone down and then we look at the required local contribution and I know the board had on the finest community did a great job last year you're going through what those all all those mean for us in in order to get the subsidy we have it's 19 million 988

378. So you look down to the additional required local monies for this, which is the operating budget less the state revenue and aid. Take away the state allocation and the non-shared debt and the total required local contribution

and that's in letter E and that's $15,028,602. So we look at, when you take this all, looking at all those factors, what is the actual net impact to the taxation district-wide? It's 7.21%. And this is with the proposed reductions.

We go on to the next slide. This is where we're looking at, first of all, what are those additional monies that are, and this is all based on your cost-sharing plan. So those are by town. If you look, they will tell us additional money from Durham, Freeport, and Ponder, which will be required.

And that will all feed into what the actual tax impact is. And looking at shared revenue, the things that were, this is what we anticipate. We know, as you know, we have a contract to maintain Hunter Road Field. It's up a little bit for next year. We have a five-year contract with the town. so it's a hundred and six thousand nine hundred eighty one dollars and some change a shared employee with a town that remained the same as well as our

anticipated state agency client Medicaid stayed the same miscellaneous primarily looking at interests over time we believe we can increase that amount to two hundred fifty nine thousand to our issue five from laugh and learn they they

They actually pay us to really look at the center near mass landing and other spaces they use. They increase that contribution for next year to $15,000. We believe what we'll get from CDS will remain pretty constant at $79,000.

We have that small aspirations account we haven't totally spent yet for $8,600. An undesignated fund balance, you'll see an increase there. We're still recommending the $900,000 towards the budget, but we're also going to recommend an additional $168,000,

and that's going to be part of the vehicle replacement plan. And later tonight, you'll see what that looks like. So that's also why we have an increase in the budget. We're also going to put $168,000 from undesignated fund balance

so the vehicle replacement will not impact the taxpayer. If we move on, now we're on to page 9, and it's broken down by town. This is where we feed all the required local. We're looking at non-shared debt and so forth. And I'll just read out for what each town, with the proposed budget, with the proposed reductions and additions for the town of Durham at this moment, it would need 7.64% increase.

For Freeport, it would be 4.05%. And panel, the impact, tax impact would be 6.74%. So that's, those are the updates we have for you this evening. I know there's a lot of data in your handbook. Again, if you want to look at, if it's easier to look at that one sheet, it's there for you.

And we can certainly have more, we'll have many more conversations in the budget. And I'll say it's certainly, as we know, as you can see, even where we're at at this moment in time, we're certainly we have a quite an increase that we're proposing we also

have quite an increase to the taxpayers where we're proposing you know you know I certainly want to thank you for but thank you know certainly folks that have spoken from the heart they're very very difficult decisions that the board has

to have has to make but we want to give you the context of sort of this is where if we're at what we're proposing this is this will where we are with the budget okay now we're ready for Julie okay good evening so I don't think I will take the

51:13

full 20 minutes unless you have a lot of questions for me but as we have approached this year's budget and I come with appreciation for all that we've had recently and I'm proposing two staffing cuts at Moore Street based on our

numbers. As we know often it's hard to predict our incoming pre-k and k numbers and consequently we've had particularly low numbers in k this current year and it looks like our net our rising kindergarten class is smaller too so

then we are proposing a reduction in both k and one and our numbers should still align with our class size policy and there is no other asks in our budget other than maintaining what we have that is it do you have any questions for me questions for julie yeah

thank you that was nice and brief um uh i just had a question about the academic leadership stipend could you just explain i'm just curious like what that involves like who that will be i guess and what their role is going to be yeah so that was our addition in last year's budget

And so we added a pre-K team leader to our leadership team, which has meant that, you know, the person who's taken on that role is Asia Stephan. She's our most senior pre-K teacher at this point and has joined our leadership team.

And that addition has really helped. Often pre-K can feel like it's an isolated grade level because the program is so different. programming is so different and so by including Asia on that team we we definitely have seen

already a better cohesiveness between pre-k and and the work that the rest of the school is doing I probably should know this off the top of my head but can you remind me what the threshold is in our class size policy yeah so 18 k2 is 18 is the target number desirable

yeah what's that 20 is the threshold okay and actually as i look at these numbers even you know we have our pre-k screening on friday and um our our incoming pre-k numbers look higher than they've been in a while we already have 40 um students registered for incoming pre-k and

it's pretty early we intentionally do it early because local child cares want answers from people um for the upcoming year and we often get we do a second round of screening because we do it so early so i'm anticipating a higher number um and we had we've kind of vacillated between relying on

live birth data and sometimes it's been reliable sometimes not but it it was i believe something like 62 in the current rising kindergarten grade and 89 for the following year so it it seems that those patterns are a reliable source of information for us right now so it's these two grade levels

that have dipped and then we'll we'll bounce back to our typical numbers following how many did you say we already have signed up 40 okay and we can accommodate 64 okay yeah thanks so much julie um i just wanted to make sure that i'm looking at this correctly so for the 25 26 staffing levels

with recommended reductions i see the number is the same for the pre-k and k well for all of them I guess so does that mean that the rising pre-k class is 64 right now and okay now I'm thinking it through in my head it's 64 right now and then you'll add some students potentially who didn't go to pre-k yeah so actually the current number is we have 48 in our current pre-k okay so on that

first table that first box should be 48 I think the way it's written is to show the upcoming projected enrollment and what it looks like with the staffing there is right now like the current staffing versus the proposed staffing and we always yeah and we always project a full pre-k

because we never know and it's okay and it's that number is typically less than our regular intake we normally get students beyond who are in our pre-k who join us in kindergarten okay gotcha so the 48 is the um or so that amount is lower than what um it currently is are these the current

56:32

numbers yeah yeah so it's look you're anticipating it'll be lower than 70 it will like i would think it's probably between around 70 more realistic based on what i see right now okay okay thank you but it's hard to tell thanks so much julie um uh one question and maybe another if i can get my

brain screwed on right um can you just refresh our memory on sort of the history of teachers in these grades i feel like um how like how long have they been five uh and yes how long have they been five so when i first came uh the 2015-2016 school year we were at four classes per grade

level there was a fifth first grade teacher added that year and those class sizes were very small um they they were kind of like at 14s 13s and 14s where that fifth class was added they probably would have been fours um and then over time not long after that first year we were

starting to add um at kindergarten and then those numbers were morally more regularly around 80 plus for a while i guess yeah that's that's super helpful i guess um what's if if we were to to go with this recommendation um is your sense not only you can't see the future but but can you see the

future. But how long do you think we would remain at four? In other words, are we going back for a year to then have to bump it back up next year? And I guess the follow-up to that would be like, what's the impact of that kind of vacillation back and forth? Yeah. I kind of project that for

the next three years, as those two grade levels move through the school, we would stay at four classes per grade level for those those those cohorts um and if the 89 live births is a number that's reliable then i would anticipate that we're we're bouncing back with the incoming pre-k grade

so it would kind of the bubble would i don't think you call it a bubble when it's shrinking right but we would chase it and then we would bounce back who knows other questions for julie sorry just go back and forth can you remind me um julie if we start to see enrollment increasing

how that's handled so if it's looking like over the summer that there's some more students like even five more so because because with the class being right with the k class being right on the kind of line of the size limits that we aim for what what how do you approach that so i haven't

have this conversation with Jean. So I'm just going to kind of throw this out there right here. So I actually am looking at potential flexibility across different grades and that maybe if we end up with a surprising number of kindergartners that our predictions and projections are not

accurate, we potentially could have the reduction in second instead of. We've just recently lost a couple of our second graders so that number in this moment in time and who knows who moves in next week is at our first grade group are at 76 we've just had a couple kids leave um so they

that grade could go to a four and maybe that makes better sense with the older students versus our youngest but again it's so i i mean i'm sure jean and i would have conversations about what when we're going to start talking about those decisions um but i think there's enough flexibility across

the grades at this moment to really think that we wouldn't be in a position where we'd be panic placing um if there's ever a question and we're watching numbers and worrying that we're going to get too far i would often hold placement decisions like usually we do that at the end of the school

year rolling into the summer but if we're concerned we would wait and do placement in august in case we have to kind of make it make a shift placement of whom placement of students to their future class and teacher and so we would just wait oftentimes it's better off waiting than having

1:01:46

children and families thinking they're going one way and have to change so in other years we've done that where we've had to watch numbers and we've added um in my time we've added teachers a kindergarten teacher particularly late and we just held that placement till august and then let

families know who their teacher was so we're not last minute making different plans um sorry i thought i remember another thing could you maybe speak a little bit about how you and your team your teaching team understand the differences between a class size of 14, 15, and a class size

of 18, 19, 20, both in terms of the learning for the students, but also for the workload for the teachers? I think when we are talking in the team numbers, it doesn't make that much difference um if you asked our teaching team i think they would say the optimal number is 16

like that when you're less than that it's not enough kids like you don't have enough balance in one of our kindergarten classrooms right now who has 15 and a few students who are not in the classroom very much the dynamics in that room it's hard for the leaders to rise and the role models

to shine and um and so it it does become okay we don't have enough children here with not enough diverse learners to really build a um a dynamic cohort um i think i think 18 is absolutely the tipping point in k particularly where routines are being built and established and children

still learning how to learn um but i do think second graders could easily be in 20s without without i mean we we did make a decision a couple of years ago when we had a teacher who left um under a medical a surprise medical situation and we couldn't hire a new teacher

and we we put second graders into classes of 26 while it wasn't ideal the commitment to quality instruction was was what we felt was the priority and so highly qualified teachers can do really good work with those kinds of numbers so i mean i think having started my career in the uk with 32

children and no planning time you know i think what gets compromised is kind of the depth at which you know and have relationships with families and children once you get into 30 32 33 but i think when we're talking these numbers i think we're good any other questions for julie

thank you okay i lost my paper oh no holly good evening i also want to say thank you for all the support that the board has given um to the school uh as you look at um my budget summary um there is one additional thing that we are looking to add,

and that is our summer programming. I noted at the end of it that this programming has been previously funded through grants, and that was through the pandemic. So 2025 is the first year that it's added back into the budget.

So we're looking to provide programming for 65 hours and there's a cost of $1,950 for that, and no other staffing changes. How many students does that support? So I had to kind of look over the trend of how many students.

Typically, we service close to 15 students. There are summers where we've invited more, but families can't make that commitment. So we look at the number of students that we're servicing in RTI currently and then send out invitations and hopefully get,

and if there's a bigger turnout, then we may cut back on some hours. So still working with that same amount of money, but servicing students to the best that we can with that money. Thank you. Questions for Holly? So I guess mine is a flip question from Julie's.

1:06:56

where the where that the key you know the kind of the ideal densities it starts at kind of 15 and we only have one class over 15 in panel how do they how do they build that sort of balance and leaders and when when there's not even enough

kids to get to that 15 level well we deal more but not so much the numbers but many of these students have come through many grades together so we're more like a family and And, you know, I think it works. I mean, as a kindergarten teacher myself for 10 years, and that was when I had morning session and afternoon session,

class sizes under 12 were like, you really didn't want that for sure. And then when I had classes of 18, it was perfect. So I agree with, you know, how Julie summarized that. So, yeah. Other questions for Holly? Thank you.

All right. Mass Landing, Emily. Good evening. And like the other principals, I always kind of feel this moment of gratitude at this point when I think back on the previous year, and it was about a year ago, I think it was Valentine's Day last year, that I was requesting the addition, both of the classroom teacher, to support the opposite of where Julie is right now, which we had some slightly larger than typical cohorts that are coming through, and the addition of an assistant principal.

and both those additions have just been monumental for our school community. I know I've spoken about some of the work that our assistant principal, Scott Emery, has done in the fall, but it's been so valuable in supporting a couple areas in our school.

Chronic absenteeism is at pre-pandemic levels. We're at 8% right now, which we haven't been at. I pulled the data from 17-18 and 18-19 just to make sure I was speaking accurately, and I am. We've been able to provide a level of responsive student support that has both been supportive

to kids who are having trouble in the moment, but also preserving instruction for other kids in those classrooms. We are on track to complete the 140 teacher observations that we, before previously, I did each year. Now we've been able to split those, which results in enhanced support for staff, particularly

new staff, as they are learning our systems and curriculum. And it's also, Scott has enabled Susan Albertini, our school counselor, to let go of some responsibilities she had taken on so that she can prioritize the important work she does supporting students

and families, particularly, and that's been an area she's been able to grow. Her support is parent outreach this year, which has been great. So thank you again for support in that regard. As you'll see in our proposed budget, there is one position that was a reserve position.

So this was added very late last year, as we were closely tracking numbers. And that position is not included in the proposed budget, as well as our bench sub. So we'll say immediately following the pandemic, we added a RTI position in regular education that existed to serve when we were short subs.

you can imagine during that time we were very short subs and we are fortunate in part because we have many committed parents in our community who have signed up to be guest teachers in our school community that we now when we have a vacancy i have 20 people i can call rather than

three or four it doesn't mean we never have an uncovered vacancy i did i pulled the numbers today we've had seven full day vacancies that have been uncovered that we've needed to rely on that ed tech position to cover so it is valuable I won't say it isn't

valuable but when we look at the needs collectively across mass landing and rsu5 as a whole we feel like we can move forward without that position while maintaining the quality of the work we do with kids any questions that was

going to be my question on how we went from 555 to 545 but it was two positions so one it was the bench sub yeah thank you for this um is there any way that you can find out if those substitutes are planning on being back again next year really do you ever

have a sense of that or is there a way you could get a sense of that um i will say our most um consistent reliable guest teachers many of them have been with us for several years i anticipate we may lose them as their students go to middle and high school but we've been fortunate that we

1:12:02

seem to have a consistent cohort of parents for whom that's a great option they enjoy being involved in our school many of them have teaching backgrounds or early childhood education backgrounds so I don't I don't know that we'll always have the same folks but I do anticipate just based on

trends and patterns that we were we're getting folks in as their children are entering elementary school and then they're staying i'm looking at julie i anticipate it's across both buildings more street and mass landing um and that folks feel safer coming back into schools too i think

that's made a difference and and post pandemic that was a huge challenge that we were facing um the compensation for guest teachers has also improved dramatically i think making it a more feasible option for folks as well which grade level did we add to last year so last year we

added so essentially this year i know it's a little bit confusing so this year we have 15 homeroom teachers we have five at each of the three grade levels last year the addition in the budget was adding it at grade four so this year's fourth grade cohort which is our largest

cohorts over 100 students um and then we added that reserve position into the current fifth grade position okay so that's why that one stays at five yeah so those students are going following that large group to the to the middle school the incoming third graders next year will be at five

and then we'll have four teachers like our third grade cohort this year is across five teachers they will be spread across four teachers next year so that's the cohort if you're thinking about kind of who's experiencing a change it's the current third graders at mass landing school

okay other questions for emily thanks so much emily so just making sure i heard you right so So this year, the five third grade classes at Mass Landing will go into four fourth grade classes next year. Correct. And we, one of the things, if you've looked at the class policy closely,

is the lower elementary class sizes are slightly different than the upper elementary class sizes. And so this is an instance when that class transitioned from Moore Street as second graders to Mass Landing as third, they were kind of right on the cusp. I think they were 88 last year.

We're now, I think as of today, they're at 85. And so it's like both at the class size expectation rises a little bit. Our cap is 22 rather than 20. And it can get a little bit tricky when you have those cohorts that are right on that cusp.

Thanks so much for this, Julian. Forgive me. What did I say? I was just thinking about... I'll take that as a compliment. Yeah. So Steve, what are we all doing here tonight? um apologies uh we go with that reduction to four in grade four um and we maintain our

current size of um 89 for grade three um but we'll be looking at a class size of 21 with our 84 aren't we starting to kind of like drive that number back up again like aren't we kind of getting crunched again at grade four it so would they be on the larger side of what

is in our elementary schools across the district yes i don't think a couple of things we consider both at the school level but also the district level is the cohort themselves and this actually came up we had a similar conversation last year with the current fifth grade cohort who had gone

from five classes in third to four in fourth. And I advocated really strongly for them to be five in fifth, even though they're about the same size as the current third grade. Thanks for following. I realize I feel like I need a chart or something to show. Because there are factors that impact

what that 21 looks like. There are factors like how many of those students receive the majority of their programming other settings if you have a few that class size when you walk into a class you're likely not to see 21 kids you might during certain parts of the day but if you walk in in a

reading lesson there aren't 21 kids the behavioral needs of this of the students in that cohort and the academic needs of the of that cohort and so for example this year's fifth grade when we looked at their data it i felt strongly and having seen them exist as both five cohorts and four that they

would be more successful in fifth that's been what's been actualized um this year and so i think once you start getting to those numbers that are kind of close to what our our district policy is then it becomes a qualitative discussion because i'll say like our current a good example the

1:17:12

current sixth grade cohort um we had large larger than typical classes last year and and there are teachers will say like 24 in that cohort still was less less preparation right like the teachers get this than like 16 in this cohort and i think that's like one of the things we want to be careful

of with policy that determines class size is we we still need to be cautious about considering the kids in both directions i think sometimes we're going to have 22 and 23 and i'm probably going to say like this it's okay knowing this cohort and there's sometimes we might be at 19 or 20 and it's

like we've got to talk about what meets the needs of those kids in that moment just one follow up Steve. My recollection also is that y'all can be relatively flexible in terms of the sort of year to year, which teachers are assigned to which grades. And so would you imagine that again, sort of over the next couple of years that it might not remain 545 and that you would have you have the teaching team that you need in order to sort of make those adjustments?

Yeah, I actually think it's an embedded blessing in our school size and the fact that we have these fluctuations because it's really good professionally for teachers to teach across grades. Because the reality is if you're teaching third grade, you're really also teaching first, second, and fourth in any given classroom.

And so teachers, you know, I have teachers who ask to change grades. I have teachers I ask to change grades. And then they like kind of, you know, three months into it go like, oh, I see what you meant. Like this was going to be really professionally valuable. so teachers have been been flexible with that and i also think it's been really good just for their

knowledge of curriculum and scope and sequence and meeting um the diversity of kids in their classrooms any other questions for emily thank you all right uh instructional support alicia can you hear me okay can you hear me uh no a little bit can you hear me now i think you might

just need to talk louder louder is that better that's okay all right so um first off i just want to say thank you to our ESLO teachers. They work incredibly hard. They're passionate about what they do, and they certainly care about the students who they teach, as do other people

that came here to support tonight. So for next year, the special education department is not recommending the addition of the one-year special education position that was funded in fiscal year 25 through article 2 on the reserve account to next year's budget student caseloads for special

education staff will be adjusted accordingly and the second would be due to a decline in enrollment within the multilingual learner population the office of instructional support is proposing the elimination of one esol teaching position from october 1st 2023 to october 1st of 2024 the

multilingual learner population has decreased by 70 students. I'm happy to talk further about that if you would like me just to do so now. Okay. I just had a quick question. I was wondering like if there was a like projection to whether like the multilingual learner population will like

increase or like decrease in the following years. So based on a handout that I had sent around. So based on projected enrollment we will be decreasing again for next year alright so the decision to eliminate one of the endorsed positions is based on the

number of students identified and the level of services needed the data I reviewed and we'll be referencing tonight was put together by our ESLO teachers so I want to start off by reviewing some of the district's historical data this is on the sheet with the October 1st count that you all

have for those of you to there's like to follow along so the data starts in 2017 and is based off of the October 1st count so please keep in mind that the numbers do not count students who are on monitor or exited students who receive an access composite score of 4.5 are placed on monitor slash

1:22:13

and exit status and they are they don't receive direct services as they have reached a level of proficiency to be on monitor exit status so just quickly monitor of MLs it's similar to being on watch for the gifted and talented

population and similar to consult for MTSS and similar to consult for special education so in 2017 2018 we had 28 students identified as of the october 1st count and we had one eslo teacher the following year we had 20 students and we continued with one teacher

and again the year after that 2019 2020 there were 16 students and we had one teacher in 2020 to 2021 the position was reduced to half time because there were 14 students In 21-22, the count went back up to 24 students, and an additional teacher was hired, and the

half-time teacher became full-time again. So there were two full-time teachers in 21-22. In 22-23, we increased to 101 students, and there were four teachers, but three full-time positions. As you can see, there were two positions that were split, 0.4 and 0.6, which makes one full-time

teacher. In 23-24, we increased to 116 students. This year we had four teachers, one of which was hired in December. So the district had posted a fourth position due to the increased enrollment in October. The person that accepted the position wasn't able to start until December. At that

point in time, we had students leaving, but the district had decided to keep that fourth person on. This year there was a decrease. We have 46 students as of October 1st and there are three full-time positions. The district had kept the third teacher for this year as the district was

unsure of how many more students may come in as numbers were still settling. Next year the projected enrollment is to be 37. If we were to move with two positions for next year that would be a total of 18 and a half students per teacher, which is less than the 28 and the 20 students

that one teacher was servicing across the district alone in 2017, 2018, and 2018-2019. So as you've heard, next year the projected enrollment is 37, which is a decrease of nine additional students from the October 1st count. It's important to note that those 37 students do

not take into account students who may be placed on monitor status after we review the results of this year's WIDA testing, which is taking place now. Based on this year's data, if we take into account the number of students who receive exposure only and who scored a four or higher on last

year's WIDA, we may have an additional six students less than projected, bringing our projected number to 31 for next year. Based on the data, the number of students, and the level of service they require, this can be successfully supported with two teachers. Currently, the high school has

the highest number of projected enrolled students, which is 15, for next year. The middle school currently has four projected students. Based on the number of students, and again, their level of need, these two buildings would share a teacher, with the teacher being

predominantly at the high school, and students will still have meaningful and equitable access to their education. The second teacher would provide services for the remaining elementary students at Moore Street, Mass Landing, and Durham

Community School. There are many factors that must be considered when determining the most appropriate support for our students, which includes the level of service time. And again, not all students receive the same amount of service time. It's based on

their scores. To name a few, we would be looking at the student's age, English level of proficiency, amount of interrupted schooling, excuse me, schooling in the student's background, and the student's developmental level. This information is located in our allow plan policy,

1:27:14

which was last updated by the board on January 25th, 2023. As far as scheduling goes, it's evolving. We would need the latest WIDA scores, which would help us determine the level of service and need, and I would be collaborating between buildings

to determine scheduling. Any questions? I'm curious how the scheduling block works amongst different buildings. Yeah, so at the high school, there's block scheduling. and so I'm going to refer to my handout. Students typically would receive the same level of service

as the class that they were in. So if a student is in 30 minutes daily of an ELA class, they would receive the 30 minutes daily of the service. However, again, we have to take into account different factors, so developmental level, all of those pieces. At the high school, if they would

receive an ELA class every other day that would be appropriate for them to receive the same service every other day for the ESLL programming so it's really dependent upon the age and the the class time that students would be receiving in

their general ed setting only as it relates to ELA well that they would be receiving an ELA service so a service to help support their language development in english so there are other there are other factors so there's push-in services but

if we're looking at a direct service where we would be pulling students out of the class it's appropriate for them to receive the same amount of service that they would have received in the gen ed setting but again there's other factors that we would take into consideration okay does

that makes so it's not like there's it's one of the blocks on their schedule it could be it could be yep it could be built it's built into their schedule so it could be a block every other day of a service okay and so the thought is the there would be certain blocks that the teacher

i mean similar to other specialists we have that go between different buildings and and the other esol teacher who covers three buildings they would have blocks at one school travel to the other and have blocks at that school yeah so we so we would be working with the the building

administration to look at the scheduling to determine times you know of times of service time of day that students would be pulled to receive their services I just have a question about the meeting the policy and allow things I'm not I

don't have it all in front of me so I apologize but I feel like there was something I read that said that they were the multilingual learners needed two periods of instruction per day? So, again, it's all based on the factors of what they're

scoring, their developmental level. This is all part of the Lau plan as well. Not all students, not every student needs to receive two hours every day of a direct service. I guess, like, a period doesn't necessarily mean an hour, I guess, but I'm just curious, like, how is that

translated with the different scheduling at, say, the different schools? So, like, if there's somebody in the middle school that you know needs more and I guess I'm not going to come up with a great example but you know it's just kind of it seems like it might be really tricky and I guess

I just want to be a hundred percent sure that we are meeting all of the need that is out there yeah absolutely we we are able to meet the needs of all of our students who we currently have um with two teachers next year yep sorry one more question i was just going to ask um how many

because you're saying the um on these number counts it was um not including the ones who are on monitor or exit and you were saying approximately there's 15 at the high school next year and four at the middle school that will share one teacher how many additional are going to

be either monitored or exited would be added to that load? Sure. So next year at the middle school, we have students that are very close to being proficient. So the number at the middle school next year could actually go down potentially to two students requiring

1:32:20

ML services. And at the high school next year, we also have several students who are scoring very high or who scored very high last year on the access who might be at their proficiency level this year. So the numbers next year could actually be much less than 15. But there's already some on

monitor, right? Yes. That's what I'm asking. Oh, I'm sorry. Any on that monitor and exit? Yes, we have. There's going to be, there's one student next year on monitor at the high school. And remind us again when those scores will come out so that we will have more concrete information we should have

them in May yeah yeah follow-up question about the monitoring support that's needed it looks like there are a couple of paragraphs in the Lyle plan that talk about the monitoring needs and that they're they're numerous it looks like that there's still quite a bit of guidance that's

needed when they're on monitor status so so when yeah when a student is on monitor status the teachers are checking in with other staff they're they're making sure that the student is still succeeding um if at any time there's a lot of regression then we they can go back and implement

the the service that they had last received um but if there's no direct service involved in that okay i mean it looks like more based on on this and i'd be curious to hear more from the the teachers around that um but and so i guess i'm wondering why that number is not included

the monitoring number isn't included in the overall numbers because it's not a direct service they're not directly being taught by the teacher but there's an expectation that they're providing that they're doing there's time involved in what they're doing in the monitoring it's just not

face-to-face with the kids it's not face-to-face it's it's really it's having a conversation with the teacher? How's, you know, the student doing? And so one at the high school, and what are the on monitor status at the other schools? So let's see. We don't have any information for Moore Street

for any students being on monitor next year. Are there direct services? We had the 15 and the 4, but i didn't hear what the so at um more street for next year there's nine students and none on monitor none on monitor okay no mass landing we have one student on monitor and no direct services

and eight okay yep at the middle school we have five students on monitor and four students and then at the high school we have 15 direct service and one student um that we know of now on on monitor right yeah because again the monitor numbers could change based on the the scores

that we receive in may in durham um there's one student in durham and um one on monitor so one in one and panel had none either correct yeah okay and just so i'm clear the amount of work required for monitoring students is considered fairly minimal. Yes. I said a quick question. So like

when, like how do you determine like when a student is like kind of proficient? So when they reach a composite score of 4.5 on their, their testing, on their WIDA testing, and that's once a year. Can you tell us more about what that looks like to reach a score of five? Are they, does that mean

that they can, they can then follow all the lessons in their classes and they can have conversations with their peers and yeah they're considered proficient across all levels including socially and yes yep um I was wondering just for my quick math it looks like there's no thought

that there will be any addition to MLL students like at the pre-k level or say at the kindergarten level or based on the information we have now no thank you for this information um how are the three positions divided up now in terms of which students they work with at which

1:37:38

schools so we have we have one person that's solely at the high school and our other two are split between buildings I don't have the information as to which buildings that they're split between but they do split they split the other

buildings okay and the proposed position so I'm just maybe this is a question for Jean, if we have a proposed reduction going from 3 to 2, correct? How is the decision made which position gets eliminated? And I just want to say in terms of when we're talking reduction in any

of positions staff, we know that we're talking positions, but we also know there are faces behind those positions. So what we would do is we follow the contract. And in a case, for example, I'll use an elementary case. We have lots of elementary folks across the district, and there are lots of, because there's a larger group of folks, sometimes those folks move on. They retire or resign, as you heard tonight. So oftentimes, there's a shuffle there. But what we would do in the case, in any case, is we look at the area of impact they're in. And what happens in this particular case, then we have three teachers, so we look at what the contract says, and you're looking at who is on in terms of we look at how long they've been in the district,

we look at their education, and that's how that's determined directly by what the contract reads. Currently this year you have one full-time at the high school. How many students does that person support? I don't have that information on me right now. I prepared for next year. In terms of the certification for an ESOL teacher, what is that like? Could you talk about that in terms of is it just across all grade levels when you get certified? It's K through 12?

I'm not exactly sure of the certification process. I know there's a certification. I don't know if it's across all grade levels or what the schooling entails. Okay, I guess I'm just asking, because we have a teacher at the high school,

and so, well, I guess I'm thinking if the positions were to be shuffled around, it could be teachers working with different populations, and I was wondering about the skills and the certification. We do have an ESLO teacher who has worked with across grade levels

when we just had the one teacher here. Can you say a little bit more about this year? How much time do our multilingual learners not have access to an ESOL teacher at the high school? And then next year, what would that look like if we eliminate that position?

How many days or how much time would these students not have access to an ESOL teacher? So this year, we have a full-time teacher here. So I would say that at any time, unless the teacher's busy, students would have access.

Next year, I would expect that we would have a teacher here daily as well, not full days, because they would have to split some time. But students would have access to a teacher every day. Do you know how much it is in the budget that we're moving for that position?

$102,000. Sorry, I turned my mic off. The $102,000 includes benefits, salary, sort of the whole cost of an employee. And I did see from the back that the certification for the ESOL from Cynthia is K-12. Danielle. I have a question in regards to the policy that we have, and it talks about having a

district language assessment committee. And I'm wondering, do we have such a committee? It says that this committee is encompassed of not only the teachers and students, but some parents. And they go over things that are going to be done. And I'm just wondering if we have that. And have they had some thoughts about eliminating one of the teachers?

1:42:48

So we have not met as a committee. So we haven't had that discussion as a committee. Does the committee exist? I haven't been part of a committee. mean so I would say yes the committee does exist it's but I haven't been part

of that committee this year so then my follow-up is do we also have the school language assessment committee I would have the same answer to that I have not been a part of a committee this year and that's an allow that's where you're

seeing that that might be a document for us all to have for our next discussion about and can I just make I know you had some we had someone provide some documentation with the law plan in it I will say we'll make what we'll do if you next time if the policy was updated I just want to make sure you have the current one and it was adopted in 2023 we'll just make sure you have the most

recent one it's also for anyone looking forward it's on the website as well it just the board had updated I just want to make sure everyone has some document they're looking from and if I recall it's a rather lengthy document I don't think we need the whole thing I think we're just looking for the part that speaks to this piece right because there's more is it just this no okay okay

maybe I'm thinking of another document that sometimes Cynthia brings in that's this big okay wrong one okay it's it's six pages oh I can handle six pages thank you okay yep I if I'm reading it correctly it is saying that the language assessment committee the school language assessment committee is to recommend modification of ESOL support services or

reclassification of multilingual learners so i think great questions from danielle about those two committees and that it should be a these should be committee discussions um and so i would like to see if that's something that could happen is this policy being more closely followed yeah

alicia i just wanted to thank you for the presentation and also just acknowledge the um the the place that you and and jane and the other administrators are in in terms of having to um, look hard at our, look hard at these numbers and make recommendations around it. I think

my question may be, um, uh, for somewhere between you and Gene, um, I think, um, I'm sensitive to, um, the, the question surrounding how with a certain, with two teachers, um, we would be able to um meet our requirements under law to um uh the students that are in our care um i think

where i find myself is just struggling a little bit to um as i have with some of other conversations around um in this in this area in terms of support for students is just how particularly with a population like the ESOL population where these are students that

are potentially a vulnerable population of just how to understand where sticking to the letter of the law on what we need to provide and when recognizing the benefit to these young people of having the additional support and I guess I'm

using the word additional, I mean, I guess, above what is required by law. I guess I'm just asking how do you propose that the board balance those concerns? Because I think we, as we've heard from some of the folks tonight, and also some other folks who are communicating with the board,

there's a feeling of, in the current structure, that there is great support, right? That there's sort of feeling of of of feeling seen and feeling um like uh the services are what they were required to give but also um more than that and that we're preparing them really well and so you know hearing

that our current setup serves our students really well is wonderful right that's a wonderful email to get we don't get that email every day um um so then thinking about what happens when we reduce that of then thinking about our inability to provide the same structure um so i guess yeah

i guess i'm just asking um again either of you if you have thoughts on just how we can consider um balancing those two needs um so so again we certainly want to make sure that we're providing what students need for support um and we do have a great team and they've all gone above and beyond

1:47:58

and the scores that we have have have shown that. Really it would be we really need more data from this year's testing to determine what level of support and what level of service and need that students are going to have before I can be very like specific around this is how much time we're

going to be in this building or this is how much time. So we won't have that information until May but certainly with the numbers that we have and the level of service and need that the students currently have and receive based on last year's scores we can certainly make it work with two teachers That's a great question, Colin, on that

In terms of the letter of the law with two teachers do I believe you could to the letter of the law yes, I do believe you could with two teachers but here's this other conundrum when you hear you know certainly there's this other piece as well and that's what

you're talking about that how do you wrestle with yes is what we have to do but by law just like we were for special education kids have an individual education plan and they have so many service hours on that plan but then you

look at there are some of those those untangible things those in the moment things that that are that are harder to measure or though certainly you know you know we saw our great you know some our great high school kids here tonight to

show love and support for their teacher who also loves and support them those are those those things that are just not change but we see it we feel it um but in terms of letter of the law yes we can meet the letter of the law but it's that other part that we have to wrestle with and you know

it's and we're looking at this is a really really tough tough budget time for us and we have to You know, figure out, you know, making our best decisions possible for our kids to make sure that we're meeting those needs.

And still, that's, you know, we get back to, you know, I was glad to see Maddie stand up and say, you know, people get out, get a sport, our budget. Looking now where we're at, even with our reductions, I worry because we lost so much subsidy.

are really worried um even in the great support that we have um you know how far is enough and that's a really that's a really difficult um question for the board to wrestle with because i think there are so many and this in particular there are a lot of um it's you know on you know

those things that are not so tangible it's not you know we certainly were doing you know wonderful wita scores but there those those other pieces that's that are tough i just had a quick question kind of about like the students like kind of like mental and like emotional well-being kind of like

by um like removing this third teacher as like um some people stated like miss highland is like a great teacher and i already know miss highland but um it's just kind of like wondering about how like removing this teacher will like affect their emotional and like mental well-being as like the students and teachers already have like a deep connection with each other with how much time they spend together i'm just wondering like by removing them like will this like negatively

impact them some way shape or form? I think potentially I think it's hard to say with with any student who has a strong connection with a teacher when that teacher is no longer you know within the district or within the school there there is a sense of loss. So we've given a lot

of focus in this discussion on the impact to the high school. Remind me in the middle school how many students we had last year we're going down to four and possibly less than four next year I'm just kind of curious about what support has looked

like for those students in the middle school so I haven't necessarily had access to one full-time teacher for their entire day right so I don't have access I only did the numbers for next year so I don't have the numbers in

front of me I can get them to you for this year's population but I will say recommendation to because I know there are questions around and I think that's really really important questions so I think like we did with the class size that the board asked we'd like to see that for the elementary that you know

you know we'll have Alicia pull that data together for what it looks like this year with a number number students and also where the teachers are if that's helpful for the board and I think it's in again I like I'm a visual person myself so I think seeing it would be would be really helpful and we can provide that for next time. Yes, that would be great. Thank you. I'm happy to do that, but I will

say based on scores from last year, the students that we have next year at the high school are all almost at proficient. So not having a full-time teacher within the middle school hasn't seemed to impact, have impacted those students negatively. They're all making great progress. Yeah, I'm

1:53:18

interested to see, you know, just sort of the visual piece of what the supporters look like at the schools to date. I appreciated the teacher who got up and spoke that, you know, one person covering six schools was not ideal or tenable, which I can understand, you know, learning more

about how these programs work. But I'm also interested in seeing, you know, with 15 at the high school and 22, I guess, across the other schools, um, how does that break up with three, right? Do we have an ESOL teacher that has a caseload of nine and nine and, you know, or 10

and 10 and 15? Um, I, I, I'm torn because I do think there's, you know, it sounds like we have some really great best practices that are working well. But in the scope of the whole thing, I don't know how that works with the numbers that we have.

Yeah, I guess I would just like to see maybe some potential breakdowns of what those might look like, understanding that we won't really know until, you know, we know what those scores are in May, but we knew where they were. So we have a good sense of kind of where they are on that continuum,

what the you know what a breakdown of two teachers might look like across five schools and what a breakdown of three teachers might look like across five schools and I also appreciated the idea of you know is there is there another

way you know is there a creative alternative solution we can look at to maintain that you know the people that we have but also address the very real you know tax impact um that we're looking at early on in the meeting of you know almost almost

eight percent in some places yeah yeah i guess i just wanted to flag i guess to to all to all involved that i guess i'm just reflecting on that in the even just amongst the presentations tonight um from uh julie and julie number two um uh that um steve sorry that some of the way in which we

were talking uh uh those administrators were talking about the impact of the reductions um felt to me uh and y'all can throw something at me if i'm really misspeaking you can always throw something at me it felt very much that we were talking quantity we were talking

qualitatively about the the impact of saying of the the difference between 12 and 16 or between 16 and 18 is really hyper hyper it's like almost ecological in terms of like though the relationship between the teacher and the students and

the particular students in that in that realm I guess I'm just I just wanted to flag that I'm feeling in the way that the, and I understand why, but I feel like in the presentation of the sort of rationale behind these cuts, or this recommended cut, this

is an, this is an, it feels like a really quantitative, a really quantitative argument. And just to note that that difference, not that one is right and one is wrong, but just that there's a difference, and that if we're, I don't know, I guess I'm just, I guess I'm

saying that as much to my colleagues on the board, of just how do we, how do we balance that understanding of saying, we hear that, we hear a rationale given to us by Emily and Julie that, that talks about this sort of ecological understanding of who the students

are, and how they relate to the teachers, and who the teaching staff is, and how flexible they can be and then what seems like a very kind of a very by the numbers kind of quantitative question of what we're required to do that just feels a little dissonant to me all these hands

up over here we'll start with more I also have a question in my mind in addition to the impact that we've talked about on the students we had heard from some folks about the professional development available to the teachers and I'm wondering if if that would be lost and it sounds

like it has been really valuable and I guess I'm I'm wondering about that too was that something that it sounds like that was something that was new that wasn't in place previously and what would be the plan going forward to make sure that that that wasn't lost sure yeah I'm assuming we don't

1:58:34

have a professional development plan in place for next year yet right yeah I just I appreciate your your point, Colin, and I also really appreciate everyone who sent us emails and everyone who's here tonight. I'm concerned about this recommendation that it goes against our goals of

providing equitable education and fostering a culture of inclusion and belonging, and I think there was someone that spoke about the welcoming aspect of having someone, a full-time person here at the high school, and there's welcoming, there's also belonging, and I think there's a lot of work

and time that needs to go into relationship building with students that really makes them truly believe that they belong not just that they're welcome but that they actually belong um and i think that eliminating the position sends a message that i'm not comfortable sending

on the board that that these students don't um don't deserve this especially in a time when these students and families are getting a pretty consistent message in our culture that they that they don't belong or that they don't matter and I would really like to see our district

take steps to want to bring more multilingual learners into our district and as opposed to driving them away and I'd like to see how else we could make up the money for that since I hear that real concern as well yeah Cheyenne and as a board our duty is to look

after the students right and so getting rid of this position that doesn't really match that right these students need this position they need this teacher to lean on and if we get rid of that what are we doing it's it's a challenge i mean i budget is mean is that what our main concern is

so there's there's a couple of things that we're responsible for um one of those things is to pass the budget. And, you know, if, if we argue that any cut is counter to our goal of supporting kids, then, then we are looking at much bigger increases and we run a very real risk of not

passing the budget. I love that Maddie will vote for our budget every year. I, I don't think she's, uh, in the majority in that, in that stance. I hope she is, but, um, so it is a balance, right I mean we have to we have to weigh all the different pieces because we are not we are not

supporting our kids if we put a budget out there that we can't then pass right that creates even more more chaos so we need to balance and weigh all of the pieces and with the you know meet our our goals meet obviously start with the needs and then we have aspirational goals that we're trying

to meet um you know i'm not i'm not convinced um that this would be the best place to cut a position right maybe there's another way um you know to that to that qualitative versus quantitative point um i think we also might owe some some um grace to the administration who made this

recommendation knowing the data knowing that the majority of the children we have that we're servicing are on that cusp of proficiency. Now, does that mean they don't need services? Absolutely not. But, you know, I'm listening to what Kara's saying about belonging and welcoming, and we have

four other schools that don't have a full-time person. We want those children to feel welcome too, right? So we need to find a way that is sustainable, that meets the needs, but also is, you know we can get it we can get it done um kelly yeah i i definitely want to make sure that

we meet the needs of all of our mll students and i guess maybe it would be helpful for me to hear more details about how this reduction would actually impact all of the areas that people are concerned about um the actual schedules um the one-on-ones whatever it is that you think

could be potentially impacted by this reduction i agree um you know i think that that would help understand you know i was happy to hear that even in the two teacher model that there would be someone in the high school every day right like i see that as a huge gap if we have a we have a

school that has no support at all on any given day i don't know if we have that at the other schools but um you know that seems like that would be concerning to me if it was like you know on tuesdays there's just nobody here um but i i think to your point understanding what it might

2:03:38

look like might help us understand like that just doesn't work for who we want to be and we'll find another way to make up that that hundred and two thousand dollars beth um maybe this is a question for when we deliberate um but i these are all questions okay i know i was like i don't know

um this yeah yeah i guess it's not really a question for alicia i guess it's more for kelly if um you know what kind of because we just got our impact to the yeah kelly wentworth sorry we just got our impact um to the towns and whatnot and so if just like you know as a something that

we could look at for comparison value what would it impact if we added the 102 back in for this position i'd like to see that other that's a good point beth we're not here to deliberate tonight we're here to listen to the different parts and ask our clarifying questions um are there other

questions not that we won't have another opportunity but any other questions that folks have tonight for alicia or we carry on with our next no okay thank you all right uh infrastructure planning jean okay uh we're going to provide the board with a lot of data um this

evening sort of what we're looking at for the for our infrastructure needs the finance and facilities and operations committees have had a couple of joint meetings so they've seen a lot of this information in detail so we give a lot of information this evening and we do have some of

our administrators departments heads who are in really helped to develop these plans present if we get stuck with any questions tonight so there are three areas that we need to address in our infrastructure. One is vehicles and grounds equipment replacement. So we've developed a plan

to update our aging fleet. We're looking at what are those really useful life recommendations. We're also looking at the energy audit phases. As you recall, we had EMC that completed an energy audit for our district, and they made some recommendations on things that we need to do

to be more efficient. And another chunk of life safety projects. And that's where we're really looking at how do we address student and staff safety by further securing our buildings, increasing communication, and expanding visibility within and around our buildings. So we're going to talk about

these three separate buckets tonight. We're going to start with looking at vehicles and grounds. So there are a couple of areas in here. First of all, we're going to share some information about How do we update our student transportation vehicles? As you can imagine, we run the wheels off our buses and vans.

We also have some facilities, grounds, maintenance vehicles. That's everything from trucks, a maintenance van, our tractors, our mowers, our utility vehicles, and other very small equipment things that we need to maintain our facilities, our grounds, and our sports fields.

Let's talk about transportation vehicles first. Let's talk about buses. So we looked at, what we did is we did a thorough inventory of the year of our buses, how many of those we have of that particular year on the average mile on our buses. And you look at the bottom, we do have a 2026, and yes, it really is a 2026, not a 2025. We have confirmation, you think it's really a 26. It doesn't have any miles on it at this count. But if you look at it, we have some really old buses all the way back to 2012, and the average mile is over 149,000 miles on it.

So you can look through there, and we have a bunch, the 2019 era, that have over 100,000 on them, and so forth down the line. We're looking at vans, because we also transport a lot of kids in vans for a variety of reasons. What we did here, we did the number of vans again by year, and also looking at the average miles on those. And again, I'll say our vans are very well loved and used very often.

2:08:58

For example, we have two 2014 vans, and their average mile is 169,300, which is a lot of miles when we're transporting kids. Our total fleet, we have 22 school buses and 11 passenger vans. And on average, buses have a 10-year cycle and life cycle,

and we should be replacing about two every year to keep our fleet up to date. Vans have a six to seven year life cycle. If you have a vehicle of your own, a van, you know that it's lucky we last that long. And we should be replacing two every year as well, and that's what our plan is for that. When we're looking at our grounds and maintenance vehicle, that's where we put in our, we have a dump truck, a couple other trucks, and a van that we use specifically for maintenance we have one of each one of those all the way back from a

2011 our most recent our van is a 2020 so of those four vehicles those should be they have a six to seven year life cycle and we should replace one of those a year we have lots of other other little equipment you know for example the gator you'll see driving around on the football field we got

mowers and tractors and trailers and all sorts of other things these are the years on the side But instead of saying average miles, we say average hours. So it's not, for example, average miles on the gator. It's the average hours that we're looking at the lifespan. Generally, mowers and tractors have a 10 to 20-year life cycle.

And we should replace one a year so that we keep up with that. So the recommendation that we have for a replacement plan is to use a three-year term leasing purchasing for three years. Year four and beyond, we would be able to purchase replacement vehicles as part of our annual budget, so you wouldn't have that interest that accrues.

What we're recommending is use undesignated fund balance as an offset so we can incrementally step into a consistent annual appropriation. And then we would present the plan annually to the board for consideration. And that's where you saw that $168,000 that we said on both the expenditure side and revenue side.

That's the offset there. That's our recommendation to use that so it would not be an increase to the local budget. And that's on the next slide. We will say add that $168,000 and offset it. So we're looking at a three-year lease purchase for next year,

which would give us two buses, two vans, a truck, more tractor, and then other miscellaneous field maintenance equipment. But I will say that this is not an additional 168 to the budget because we're offsetting it with undesignated. When we look at the energy audit, we have lots and lots of information from EMC

who did our energy audit, and they have a four-year phasing plan. We have a recommendation that we're going to look at phase one only for next year, But I want to explain a little bit about what that looks like for each year.

This planning will allow our district to address the capital needs that were identified. So phase one, and that's actually a lease purchase payment, and it would be $303,095 a year. And this is what it would get us. So the high school needs some heating plan improvements. We need building automation upgrades at both the high school and the middle school. There's district-wide building automation. There's an integration plan for the high school and middle school. There's miscellaneous exterior weatherization needed at the high school.

And the biggest chunk of that is LED lighting upgrades at all the schools, including the central office. And the hope with that is, as you know, when you do LED upgrades, that there may be some on the other end. There may be some savings on the other end that we could hopefully see. And then panel does need some ceiling tile replacements as well. That would be the first phase. Phase two later on, and again, we would every year present this to the board.

Phase two would be ear handler replacements at the high school, middle school, mass landing, panel. Terminal equipment at the high school, middle school, and mass landing. Mechanical insulation at the high school, mass landing, Moore Street, and panel.

Building automation upgrades, mass landing, Moore Street, panel, Durham, and the central office. District-wide Building Automation Integration, Mascellany Moore Street, Poundell, Durham in the central office, attic insulation and air sealing at Poundell,

miscellaneous exterior weatherization at Freeport Middle, Mascellany Moore Street, Poundell in the central office, window improvements at Mascellany Moore Street, testing and balancing at basically all of our buildings, as well as duct air leak testing,

2:14:08

and then a building generator at the high school. When we go into year three, we'd be looking at air handler replacements, terminal equipment, roofing, heat pumps, ADA-compliant bathrooms, electrical panel replacements, exterior restoration, walk-in cooler freezer at two of our schools, a building generator at the middle school. We need some exterior restoration at Pownall, and asphalt paving at five of our schools. The final phase, phase four, we'd be looking at domestic water heating upgrades,

air handler replacement, walk-in cooler freezer at Durham and we need some building generators at Moore Street, Poundell and Durham. So that's the whole big picture of of all those things that were identified through the energy audit.

So our recommendation is to use a 17-year term leasing purchase for four phases and to use undesignated fund balance as an out as an offset again so we can incrementally step into a consistent annual appropriation. And it would be presented for all those phases. Whatever we're going to do, it would come back to the board and be presented annually. For next year, what we're recommending for the budget is to approve phase one, all those things listed at the beginning, and enter into a lease-personage agreement. The first payment would not be due until the 26th, 27th school year.

That's how that works. So we recommend getting started on these projects and then in 26th, 27th, that's when you start your first payment. So we need to know that we have approval before we did that because it would, future budgets, it would impact.

But all things that need to be done in our schools. The third bucket we're looking at tonight, and I would say probably the most important that also ties in with our vehicles and we're talking about keeping kids safe, keeping staff safe, is what we're calling life safety.

This addresses our student and staff's safety by further securing our buildings, increasing communication in our buildings, and also expanding visibility within and around the buildings. We're recommending doing this in a single phase.

Our estimates are that it would cost $2,434,376. What that looks like, cameras at our schools, door access, phones, paging, AEDs, door replacements, fire access and devices. Our recommendation for this so it doesn't impact the budget is to use undesignated fund balance to complete projects outside of the local FY26 budget.

And then again, that's our for next year, is make a one-time transfer from undesignated fund to capital reserve account. And then we can do all those projects which need to be done. And we'll look at sort of here's their funding proposal for the 25-26 budget.

As I mentioned before, there's $168,000. That's for the vehicle equipment replacement. Your energy audit won't cost anything. Your life safety would be the $2.4 million for a total of use of undesignated fund, $2,602,376.

And to have a picture of what we have now, what we anticipate of having, what's allowable and what would be left. So the unaudited 23-24 undesignated fund balance is $6,710,182. That's the unaudited. And we allocated for 24-25. If you remember, we allocated $900,000. And we also transferred $1,334,500

to all those reserve accounts that we created. For example, you heard tonight Emily mentioned a teacher that was added in a reserve account to mass landing, and Alicia mentioned a special ed teacher that was added. Those are through the reserve accounts. We're estimating at the end of the year, we're estimating approximately $1,175,000 that will be expended

that will be added towards that amount to give us an ending balance of $5,650,682. that's our estimate our allowable as you know 24 25 you can have five percent is allowable um so that what's allowable by by the state would be 2 million 75 thousand 23 dollars so then we looked

at so how much if we have this 5.6 that we're anticipated having and we're allowed to have two 2 million 75 then how much is how much do we have extra and that's the that's where you see the 3 million 575 689 so we're looking again ending ending that's where we found the estimated

2:19:24

unallocated we just carried that number over the 5.6 this is what we're proposing we're proposing the 900,000 towards the local budget plus 75 to the high school tennis court and track field reserve that's the amount that we've put in for the last several years to build up that reserve

account. We're recommending $168,000 for vehicle replacement and then the $2.4 million for, that's the life safety we're recommending to use to take care of these things for our kids and our staff. So our estimated, when you take that all out after the budget process, would still be $2,073,306.

That's what you would have left. And if you look back, what we said was the allowable amount, It was $2,075,023, so you're right at that sweet spot for there for what you should have in the bank. That's a lot of information to digest, lots and lots.

And we can take some questions now. The other thing we can do as well is you really have time to digest. Are there additional questions you'd like us to look a little more deeply, and you can let us know, and we can address that as well because it'll be important for my team to look at what the board is thinking

because if we're going to change any of the any anything especially we're looking at the energy audit that would require some work for us to go back to EMC and look at that as well I don't know if the board has any questions for our team at

this time okay yeah I'm wondering if you can explain that allowable balance again that's from the from the from the Department of Education that's what they they're saying that we should have for a fund balance or up to five percent it Remember, during COVID, it went up to 9% for a while,

and it's dropping back down, and it used to be 3%. So the ending balance after last year's budget process was $5.6 million? I couldn't hear what you said, Cara. Yeah, I'm just saying that the ending balance... Oh, never mind. Which line would you let me look at? Yeah? Okay.

The equity audit, all the recommendations from the equity audit... Energy audit. Energy, thank you. Different audit. Are all of the recommendations they made in here, or are there some that they made that we did not? So what we do is we group things that are alike, so they're all there, but however, there were some things that we've already done. For example, the freezer cooler at the middle school was in there,

but we've done it, so we took it out. So anything we've already done, we took out, but everything else is in there. And also, correct me if I'm wrong, some things under the life safety bucket were things that were identified through the equity. Now you got me doing it. the energy on it yes um so uh so those were sort of changed buckets but uh they were identified

in that so somewhere either we've done it or we moved it to life safety but it's all everything identified is there plus other things our team went out actually they went um they went like every school every door everybody looked everywhere to make sure that that that was

captured in there as well for that life safety piece. Thank you so much, Jean, for all this information and everyone for all the hard work that you did. I know that was a lot of work for the facilities committee to look through all of this, so thank you. I'm wondering about our

capital plan, if we still have one, and how this fits into that, and if this is our facilities presentation or if we're getting a separate one of those? So there's going to be a separate facilities presentation and Glenn will present as well on the local side what are those because

you know it's it's this isn't you know tell about this isn't everything we need to do as you can imagine there are other things as well so we're also looking at what are those other things we do and those are funded through the regular budget and Glenn will present what he'll tell you what

those projects are. Okay and then when we have the reserve account for those projects that's what that's for it's it's that's actually in the local Glenn's gonna say what's in the local for capital and then we'll have we'll have more details about you

know for the reserve a capital reserve account and the big one in there right now that's still the money that's still sitting there is for the panel septic we're actually ready to go up for bid for that so that they can break ground

on that in June so that's how that's out of the that's out of the capital reserve okay and so is there do we have still have a capital plan where we're looking ahead what we need for the next five years, ten years, and where this fits into that?

I think this is it for that part, but there are those other projects that we just have to do to keep up in our buildings, some bigger maintenance projects, but for the big pieces, this is it, which is really driven by the energy audit and those other identified needs in life safety.

2:24:33

Thank you. Other questions? Any other information, folks? Thanks so much for this, Jane. It is a lot, but it's also quite clear. So thank you to you and everybody else who pulls together. My understanding is that, I checked it with Malik because she's the smart one,

is that the phase one, what we'd be committing ourselves to, is the $303,000 starting next year. The following, yeah, not this budget, the following, and for 17 years. I mean, we had a conversation a bit about this, I guess, last year,

budget in terms of how we kind of understand a decision we're making this year impacting uh how how much flexibility we have coming down uh the pike um i guess my question is just um how how much are you estimating that 303 000 is going to like become something that really

we have to then build a very creative budget around because we'd be locking ourselves into it um that you're absolutely right you're committing that's why we have to be really clear like it's not this year's budget but it's future budgets um it is a way for the district to do the projects

that we desperately need to do these are things we really need to do in a more affordable way um and i look at some of the things that we've had to do this year um that we had to make sure had money for to cover this would allow these things less i think of like less surprises going

on we and the other um nice thing about the phase plan um let's say for example like if we have a walk-in freezer cooler that's way out i was like holy cow that thing is about to die we're going to shuffle it to another phase we have the options for that after the year one but it does commit you

know it does commit you like this is what we're going to do but the i i always say it's it's sometimes it's nice to know because the knowns are good because then we know what we know like we've got to have that for that so it'll always be that amount for that amount of time just like

when we do lease our buses like we do now we know what that amount is and i think i don't know if kelly has a plan to share sort of the funding strategy around this but there's there's like the next step which is how do we how do we put these into the budget without tanking everything

else we want to do um i don't know if that was planned for tonight or another day or um so we we weren't really sure how we were going to work that full plan that was presented to the facilities and finance committee in because really what we did with that full group was i projected out um

on the sheet the full like well it goes beyond 10 years but what i presented to them was 10 years and really we looked at implementing and that's how like with the vehicle replacement we came up with using the three-year leases for a three for three years in a row and then increment and then

in that fourth year by that point by using undesignated fund balance to help assist with kind of stepping into the 400,000 as you saw that is really the true total cost so we'll work at how we can present the full kind of like fate step in phase process it doesn't

affect what we wanted to present tonight is what what affects 25 26 right but if there's a larger picture that I presented to those to the two committees to the Joint Committee that actually shows us how we can incrementally step

into this by utilizing our undesignated fund balance for the kind of like these one-time purchases which will help stabilize that undesignated fund miles because as you know in a typical year we don't spend our budget down to zero thankfully because nobody wants to be wearing orange when we're done if we

go in the opposite direction so there's always a little bit that gets added into fund balance annually and so what we've done is kind of worked out a plan that we feel is is sustainable over the next at least four year period that helps us

step into all of these projects so we'll figure out how to put it on a PowerPoint which is a little harder but but maybe maybe we'll just do a handout and then have to speak to it because it's really it's not I don't know how I'm gonna like put it into a PowerPoint that if you're not here and

looking at all the components you're really gonna understand which is why we didn't include it tonight because this is the 25 26 like kind of like budget rollout so we didn't want to and this was enough data we kind of felt like it was enough data to digest tonight but it is there is a

2:29:40

thought out plan for how we would step into this without seeing a major spike in the in the um the budgets but it does it does um include us committing to about 295 000 a year talking about future budgets Colin right we would be adding two hundred ninety five thousand dollars a year

by committing to these things but by utilizing fund balance we level that out for four years to step into all of those payments so we incrementally take that on as a taxpayer and as I recall this first three hundred three thousand does not actually include any potential

rebates that we may get from the LED lighting correct correct because we do not know if they will be available by the time the projects are complete we are hoping they will be but that isn't that is we're hopeful that that will this number may

actually be less than 303 for the first year at least correct correct and just to point out second that secondly that three at least three of these projects on this first phase are going to impact us in other areas of our budget such as

our energy usage like savings savings yes so which I don't think we've built in because we don't know what they would be because we don't know what we're truly going to recognize for savings um so what we would want to do is is look at a pattern um i'm the advocate of looking

at like kind of a three-year average and seeing where we're at because of the you know when you have a great heating you know like a heating season's great and you save it's it's not that cold out and you save money on heating oil but then the next year it completely tanks so um you

know i'm really more of like looking at patterns and and trying to have like a consistent average in your budget um to utilize and not have the spikes in valleys thank you kelly for for doing all of that and being creative about how we how we spread it out to um mitigate that impact to

the taxpayers um i was wondering if it would be possible to see the breakdown also by like building is that something that could easily be done i'm just thinking about just ask are you talking dollar or what's what what what is it your i guess dollar amount and and project yeah i'm

thinking about the age of our facilities like i'll ask my my follow-up question i'm thinking about the age of some of our facilities and whether there's been a conversation around like when is the tipping point where we and i know we're coming up on our strategic plan and this is a significant

amount of money to being to be doing in upgrades to our facilities and I'm wondering if there's been a conversation around that tipping point of putting more money into keeping our facilities updated or if there's a conversation on

the horizon about new schools and I can't we have that broken if you want to know for life safety we have that broken down by building and by what the the item is as well um so we can do that by life safety and you'd like to see that for the energy

audit items as well yeah that would be great and is that a conversation that is that is going on about the age of some of our facilities and the difficulty of continuing of continuing to update them is that a challenge that um i guess the facilities i guess that's a question for glenn

isn't it um and i think it's what's you know but what's interesting i'll give i can give you a snippet just because i have it in front of me for life safety i'll do just the total for each building um because it's always interesting we always talk like like durham's a new school well

durham's been around for a while but so for for life safety um of that um that whole chunk we're talking 224 535 that's for durham and i'm just talking life safety not the other stuff moore Street is 364-088, Townell's 327-694, Mass Landings 487-943, the middle school is 404-128,

the high school is 590-914, and the central office is $35,075. That's by life safety, and I don't have that other data in front of me. We'll have to dig in and do that, of that I just happen to have other information people would like them to have on hand when we

revisit this during our deliberations all right thank you this was this is the product of many many months of work and so thank you for that lost my agenda again oh here we go um Cynthia uh okay so we are at the um item 13 new business do I have a motion for consideration and approval

2:35:16

for the first read of the 2025-2026 school calendar. Cheyenne and Malik, thank you. Okay, so item 13A is your gray handout in your purple folders. So I'm just going to highlight, can you hear me okay? I'm just going to highlight some of the changes that you'll see from this current year's calendar to this proposed calendar for FY26.

We, I think you remember that sometimes we start before Labor Day, sometimes we start after this current year, and the next year are the ones that we start after because of when Labor Day falls. Next year, or the following year, which I won't go into because I won't be here,

but that year, the next year, the Labor Day would be on the 7th, so then you would want to start earlier, for example. So, this stays the same for this proposed calendar as it is this current year. And then I'll just bring you to November. And if you see, as you can see, this year, because it was a presidential election,

we chose to follow a line with Brunswick and 75 because, you know, it was one of those more, I'll just say, it was an election that we just wanted to make sure that the kids were not in the schools. And so this coming year, this was discussed with the administrative team.

Our administrative team wanted to pair it up. Because of Veterans Day falling on the 11th always, and it's a Tuesday, they wanted to put the PLD instead of Election Day, which would be the 4th, they wanted to put it on the 10th.

So no students would come to school on the 10th or the 11th because that's a holiday. So there would be back-to-back. So you don't have as many broken-up weeks because we know those solid five-day weeks are much more beneficial.

So that's November. And then the other thing I want to point out is the winter vacation. So if you look at December, we have the 22nd through the 2nd, which is 10 days. This current year, we have eight days, and I think the trickiest part is because of the way it falls.

We had some discussion with, you know, Brunswick and 75 and RSU-5. We had discussion around that, right? We were all willing to kind of look at it both ways. The administrative team here, we had a discussion back in December, I think it was,

at one of our BT meetings around the pros and cons to the 10-day, to doing the two full weeks. If you look at this calendar, I think we'll start with January because you have January 1st falling on a Thursday. It's really awkward to come back for that one day for that whole week.

So that was taken off the plate. And that was across the other two districts as well, Brunswick and 75. So we all agreed on that. Then you go back to the 22nd and 23rd, and we had discussions both ways. Our administrative team felt that they felt stronger that it should be.

Every once in a while, you'll find a calendar like this, and then there are the two weeks, and you can kind of see it both ways. This is where we landed. This is where Brunswick landed as well. They brought this already once to their board as just a cursory look. They're in favor of

the two weeks as well. So I knew that would probably be a discussion or something you were thinking about tonight. So that's December and the winter vacation. And then I think that's all I wanted to highlight for you for the changes and the rationale. And so I can open it up to

thoughts questions uh the end of year is always tricky because of juneteenth now it's it that's that's always uh going to be a conundrum right and we never know the snow days and so um you know so far except for we know tomorrow right but our first one uh but so far so bad to get to february

for your first one we haven't had any yeah maddie would like to know what if we're getting rid of the vacation in february oh my god it's all nice for you to come she's here so so um you mentioned that okay first i'm going to step back a second uh for for anna's benefit the

2:40:38

reason we are talking about this with brunswick and 75 if you're not familiar is because we all go to region 10 uh we have to we are required by law by law i don't know by somebody uh that cynthia says so that we have we can't be more than five days out of sync because um we don't

want some kids from some districts not in the in region 10 some days and versus others so um we all every year get together and coordinate um our our schedules as best we can um to align them um i noticed you said brunswick is approving two weeks is 75 not uh let's see uh this was the most

i thought this was going to be the easiest year i was not thinking of it and it was probably the most challenging of the nine years in the discussion um they wanted to start originally before labor day so we were nine days off when the very first time we met so um we have you know

now we're all on the same page as the for labor day um and i 75 you know this is hard because you're not synced you're not synced on the same days right and whoever gets the first vote but we try to say what are you thinking have you have you kind of floated this by your board and all of that

so um brunswick is solid and we have shared that with uh 75 and so uh there's an awareness right now we're two days off from each other which is within the five or which is great which is great okay yes two days two days yes not seven but not two extra two only right so it's the election day

um and then oh so they were still keeping election day yes they are because their situation is a little bit different with their schools with their schools so yeah questions i may have asked this last year but i forgot what you said why is there an early release day in february and not in the

middle of the very long month of march uh so um i think i might defer to um i might we had one today today was the early release day um i think we have a pld in march so i think it was i think originally when we started we were looking at you know spacing them out right because if we're going

look at student data we want to have you know and we don't always look at student data every single time like this march 14th this year we're looking in the morning we're going to be looking we're going to be doing some work around the strategic plan for an example but in the afternoons those

schools may or may not i don't know what their agendas are yet uh be looking at student so there's there's points in the year so it's spaced out so that you wouldn't have like two or three in one month. So it was more, it was really more about spreading them out. So we have that PLD.

We always have a PLD day in March and in October. October, as you know, we, or if you were on the board, you know this, before this year, we always have, we belong to GC, the Greater Sebago Education Alliance. And so we coordinate together a group, a team of us work on the professional development

day for, um, the areas that are like PE, art, music, et cetera. All those, I think we're going to be putting pre-K in there this year and gate this year, right? So we're trying to find those kind of solo type of, or more, you know, you only have one PE per building typically, except for the

high school, we have three, but, um, you know, you're trying to get the like people together in like the Cumberland County area so that they can bring in maybe professional development sometimes it's the a teacher or two that are running the professional development so that's really what

we've done in October so that's really kind of like that standard one that most 90 percent of the districts in Cumberland County keep once in a while if like there's some initiative a district is working on they may say we're not going to opt into that this year and that happens March we've

typically pick that day because Region 10 has had some professional development for their staff. I don't think it, I'm not exactly sure, I think it's in Massachusetts, but I'm not 100% sure. I haven't talked to Sean about it. It was Nancy Weed before who I used to talk to about it, but

so we've kind of kept that consistent for the benefit of Region 10 and it, we could move that one day or one week or another, but we've always just said when is this and we align with that that date so that's why those two are there and then the early releases we put in different months

2:45:39

than that and i think may was chosen because we get our data some of the data back to look at i don't know if you want to add anything no i don't want to put them on spot but um why we spread it out i mean that is why we spread it out but if they wanted to add i was just gonna right because the early release is another way to get professional development for the teachers

without having a whole day without kids in school and wednesdays were chosen i'll just add this piece Wednesdays were chosen because it can line up like today I don't know how many how many schools today had a staff meeting as well or used it as a staff

meeting day as well so if they get of them and forgive me the minutes because some schools get out at different times but let's just say that they early release and the kids were you know they were starting at 1 right on the early release day 1 to the end of the school day and they had scheduled staffing they

could get another hour in it. So, you could get a three-hour, I'm estimating the minutes, but a three-hour chunk of time if you're working on something big in your school. So, that's why we had picked the Wednesdays in case you have that question as well. I did, you know, it's funny. I

had that same thought this week. I was like, okay, so we had a late start, a early release, and a no school snow day. That's what happens when you schedule things in February, unfortunately. other questions on the schedule um just one question though i remember uh it seems like our

chronic absentee uh concerns have been uh i mean folks have been working on that kudos to all the administrators and everybody who works on that um but one of the concerns for that has been folks taking advantage of uh of existing times in the schedule where they can then take additional

vacation and pull their kids out i'm just looking at that like november 10 and 11 um was that considered at all sort of like how this i guess a little early for skiing but like like you know just like how how tempting how tempting those two those two consecutive days uh would be for

you know um folks to start pulling out is that i would argue maybe like this these are all hypotheses right but i would argue that even if you had the day on the 10th some people might still take the two days off right long weekend they would just do that anyway i see i see so

we're gambling either way okay thanks cynthia could you remind me did we used to have more early release days and then we paired that back since i've been here no oh okay we we proposed it at one time many years ago and it was there was a big discussion around child care and it ended up

just not being sold so we always have when we've had them we've always had the two and then we spread them out okay great because I know we've talked in the past about the impact to parents and I'm I'm forgetting do we have do we offer anything I know I've seen the great ones at

wolf's neck where they have like the one day camp or something do we have anything like that on early early states i don't know if pete if uh through community programs we have anything gene do do you know i really just don't know off the top of my head peter could answer that yeah okay i was

just wondering because that seems like maybe be helpful but i think it's great that i'll tell peter when we see him it's great that they've offered those one day ones um can i just ask one more question um could i hear a little bit more about the um decision around because i know you

said it could go either way on the 22nd 23rd um and it'd be great maybe to even if the administrators wanted to weigh weigh in or um gene about the thinking um behind that because i'm i'm already thinking like i know my kids will be going to school on the 19th and that's the day before

vacation now so instead of that day being like like so instead of the 22nd and 23rd being like the fun last day before break now it's the 19th and it just like creeped a little earlier so i'm just i'm wondering about that aspect and then if it was if we were to go those two days or

something would that just come off the end of the year would that um yeah it will it would come off end of the year it it what's tricky is not knowing what the other two you know and technically it would create it could create four different days so if we see what i mean yeah if we went one of

days we could probably work like if we did the monday but then you'd have that same or you could have that same conundrum of the january 2nd would somebody right you talk about the extending the vacation so yes we twirled all of what you're twirling now yeah and i can twirl and i think

2:50:42

with the the administrative team part of it was really thinking that some staff members and families families sometimes they take they want that long chunk at during that week and it's really tricky and then so you say well then you go back for the one day and it's just like that doesn't that

doesn't feel right either for people and we said did we do staff development that day we thought well that might not be the best either so that was this was a that was a big discussion thank you for the consensus on the team welcome okay thank you for having that whole discussion all

good questions we have the same other comments questions this comes for two reads it doesn't technically have to it's been our practice it's not a policy so technically you could do it in one vote but this gives you the opportunity to think about it we just followed the and we're

bringing it next so our policy on policies says says that you have to leave it have at least two weeks in between this is not a policy so it's coming back to you next wednesday okay um can you just quickly review with us what the policy or procedure is around days when we don't take

a full school day, how those impact our snow days at the end of the year. Yes, yes, exactly. It counted as a full school day. Also, we do like, or like today, it was a full, it counted as a full school day. Yeah, as well as early releases. You know, like today. Tomorrow they're

on the end. Yeah. Right. If we feed them lunch, it counts as a day. Okay. Even if we give it to them on the wait. No. Any other questions, comments? We have a motion and a second. So all those in favor? Moon likes the two weeks. All right. We have no personnel. So we have

another public comment. If we had anyone who would like to speak, we will. is like the sole person representing right now um so again i'm liz pierce i'm one of the three school counselors i'm at freeport high school and i just want to say thank you so much for

all of the thoughtful comments and questions regarding the presentation about the esol position at freeport high school and i just wanted to address a few things you all had some questions and i was taking notes and you know we do have a lot of the answers because we are here at the high

school. The first thing, there was a lot of talk about a WIDA score of a 4.5 being proficient. And I think what's really important to understand is, although that might be proficient, I'm going to use quotes, it doesn't really provide student enough information where students

are capable of often accessing that complex language that they need at these high school classes that really are at that higher level language so proficiency at a 4.5 might mean something legally but I don't think it tells the whole story and

Colin thank you for bringing up the qualitative versus quantitative I think that really is an important debate on this whole topic so we do support other students aren't in our district who are proficient on their NWEA or their main through years tests that they take here and they might be proficient but we do

provide them with a higher level of support they go into a lot of our support classes even though they are technically proficient so I just wanted to bring that up as a point that sometimes that score doesn't tell the whole story additionally student numbers should not determine those services as

I've already said we also need to consider that a number of multilingual learners next year also have IEP's so at Moore Street it is my understanding that five of our multilingual learners also additionally have IEPs, they are going to

require a much higher level of support, not just through special ed, but at that multilingual level. And it is also my understanding that Freeport Middle, two of their four students also have IEPs. And my understanding is that there is one at mass landing. So there really is a higher level of need within that number of 37 that I think you

all should be aware of. 30 minutes of instruction that is required under law or whatever was brought up before that really is not enough for these students who are trying to go on to higher education and so i just really

want that to kind of be known i do want to give a shout out to moon for bringing up mental health these students absolutely will be impacted by the loss of a position i think just across the district. So this is more than just like the one position here, but I think our district does need

2:55:50

the three. I know there were a lot of numbers about past years. When we had 14 students to a half a position, I was here. I worked with that teacher. It did not work. When it was a 12 to 1 ratio, when we had two teachers with 24 students, that did not work. I know of examples of students

here. We had one dropout of one of our multilingual learners, and I really think if we had had a program here, we might have been able to capture that student. We have another student who came into the high school who really had been here enough years that they should have been at a

higher level, and we really believe it's because our program was not robust enough, so those numbers really do not tell that whole story. We know the ESOL certification is K-12. However, as you all know, students in elementary school and high school have very different needs, and the skill levels

of those teachers really should be where their specialty lies so really just again please think about the numbers in a different way we really appreciate your time and we hope that you will gather the information you need when you are

moving forward with the budget and the recommendations for this program thank you thank you and thank you for everyone who hung around for the whole meeting the last one I promise and then everyone gets to go home and really what

I just wanted to say my name is Jill Hyland I'm the ESOL teacher at fruit for high school I live in Brunswick and I want to say thank you for your time for your effort and for everything that you put into this community into this board and these thoughts I also want to invite you into our classrooms I have

spoken to the other two ESL ESOL teachers in the district they would like you to come to our classrooms come to our schools come to our meetings come to our homes text us email us do whatever you need to do don't do that board

members please you know we're open whatever you need we want to provide that information for you and we want to make sure that you have enough information to make a decision that lies in front of you and again I just want to say thank you thank you joe all right i was just giving everybody a moment in case anyone was inspired

all right then i would uh take a motion to adjourn kelly cheyenne all those in favor thank you

Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.