TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 26 February 2025
Board meeting · 4 h 52 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →
41,639 words in 56 five-minute windows.
Good evening. Thank you for your patience while we get the technology set up so our live stream is working this evening. Welcome to the RSU 5 Board of Directors meeting. It is Wednesday, February 26, 2025. We're here in the Freeport High School cafeteria and we have a few folks
that are from the board that aren't with us this evening for work or illness, but everyone who's going to be here is, so we will get started, and we'll start with the Pledge of Allegiance. United States of America, to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, visible,
liberty. Do I have a motion for consideration and approval of the minutes from the February 5th and February 12th, 2025 meetings as presented, barring any errors or omissions? Danielle Cheyenne, thank you. All those in favor? Great. None opposed. Adjustments to the agenda. I have the
One this evening, I would like to move item 12A, 1 through 8, which is under unfinished business, the budget review. I would like to move that immediately following number 8, reports from the superintendent. Great. And six on our agenda, good news and recognition. We will look for a report from our board student rep, Phoebe. All right, so exciting news on Friday.
FHS juniors and seniors are attending a trip to Lost Valley to ski or snowboard, snowshoe, or tube. So we're excited to spend this day outside. Students have been registering for courses next year. We had our curriculum fair where kids could learn about all the classes for next year.
And we're looking ahead, which is crazy that we're already thinking about next school year. Before February break, we had a photo booth during lunches from the PTSO, which was really fun. And a big congrats to the FHS Girls Nordic team, who won the Class B state championship,
and the boys basketball team, who received the Class A Boys Sportsmanship Award. And before break, the Active Minds team partnered with Minding Your Mind and the Kyle Karras Foundation to bring a guest speaker to Freeport High School.
And students were really engaged in Kelly's story about her journey with mental health. And on the note of student mental health, I think I'm concerned for the students at FHS. We have so much hate in the world that we kind of have to bear the brunt of.
And speaking with lived experience, I don't want to lose another friend or a classmate or a community member, so I think it's my job to remind the board and the community that the number one priority should be the students' well-being and all students' well-being, because I think that's the most important thing, so thank you.
Thank you Phoebe. Okay so we will move on to item seven on our agenda which is public comment. So how public comment is going to work this evening is we have a sign-up sheet and I have the first 25 names here if you would like to speak but haven't had an opportunity to sign up yet.
there is still a sheet up here on the on the edge as you came in feel free to go up and sign up and we will we will make sure we hear from from everyone that would like to speak because there are so many we are going to start with members of the three communities in rsu5 but we will hear
from everyone who has signed up to speak this evening and i'll just go through i'll just call I'll probably give the the next three names so folks can queue up at the podium there so that we can keep it moving along I have a brief statement
I'm gonna read just because I think we have a fair number of new folks that haven't joined our meetings in the past and just to provide a little bit of background on our public comment so in order to hear from the largest number of
different voices each speaker will be limited to three minutes for their comments. We will have a timer going. You'll hear the buzz. So when you hear that buzz, that is your cue to finish up that final thought and pass it to the next person. For those of you who have
not participated in our meetings before, I want to review a few rules ahead of time to ensure that the public comments process goes smoothly and there are no surprises. So at the outset, we ask that speakers, when you step up, you identify yourself with your name and your town of residence.
We ask you to try to be brief and try not to repeat yourself. We know that discussions of school-related issues can get emotional, but please remember that our children are watching and that we are neighbors, so please be civil. We will not permit profanity or shouting
at one another or comments that disparage and attack individuals or groups of individuals. speakers should direct all comments to the board this is an opportunity for the board to listen to the opinions of the public that relate to school and education matters it is not a public debate nor is it a conversation no
question should be directed to the board the board will not be responding to it to questions or comments if they're asked we're here to listen this evening the board will not permit complaints or allegations against staff members these
are personnel matters which the board is not permitted to hear in public if there are complaints against staff these will be handled appropriately through our complaint procedure KEB which can be found on our website if you're interested
in a two-way conversation on the RSU 5 website there are individual emails as well as a board email and phone numbers for board members in the superintendent so thank you all for your patience as I made the introduction I have hope and
confidence that your participation will be helpful and constructive to the board this evening. So we will get started. The first three folks I have on our list are Lynn Esler, Janice Flynn, and Kelly Fitz-Randolph. Good evening, everyone. Jean, nice to see you again.
Lynn Esler, Freeport, Maine. I have been in this community. Oh, can you hear me better? All right. Lynn Eastler, Freeport, Maine. I've been in this community for many, many years. I've got two adult children who graduated from the school system. I've been watching the events
unfold on the boys and the men being allowed in girls and women's sports. Very upset about this. To me, it's common sense. Two genders, male, female, and they belong in their own lanes. I believe it's incredibly unfair for our female athletes to be able to be competing in this unfair environment.
That's really all I've got to say. Three minutes, not even interested, but thank you. Thank you, Em. Janice Flynn. Good evening, everyone. Madam Chairwoman, Superintendent, board members, you've seen me here many times speaking.
My name is Janice Flynn. I'm a resident of Freeport. I'm a mother I'm a grandmother and I've stood before here you know many times asking you questions and giving you my opinion and my concerns I want to thank the superintendent can you hear me I'm sorry is that better I'm short I want to
thank the superintendent for responding to an email I sent last week I noticed that on the agenda this evening there were many items for Title IX that were up for reconsideration and I asked for some context into those so thank you for
responding. I appreciate that. Even though you were out of office last week, you responded, as you always do, pretty quickly. However, you know, the explanation didn't, you know, didn't give me any more context. I reviewed the current documents online. I reviewed those
with the agenda, and I didn't get any additional insight. I always write down what I'm going to say, too, so I don't go over my three minutes. Beyond that, they've reverted back to earlier versions to keep the policies related to Title IX, and you want to keep them more in line with
federal law. I didn't see that. I still see gender identity in the documents, so they don't align with federal law. They still don't provide fairness and safety for female students. I'm here also to give female athletes a voice. I want to give the female athletes from Freeport some support.
We witness the commitment that these girls make to their chosen sport, years of dedication, practicing games, because they have a drive to compete. They should be applauded. The adults in their lives should at least commit to provide a level playing field,
but today that's not the case. The girls face a serious competitive imbalance. How many more Freeport girls and Maine girls will lose the opportunity to place a state championship on their college resume? I hope not many more. The Maine's principal association has policies that allow males to compete in girls' sports.
This isn't just about competition, it's about fairness, it's about safety, it's about preserving the integrity of girls' athletics. Title IX was created to protect opportunities for females and female athletes. It's resulted in opportunity and prosperity for women.
But not enforcing Title IX and federal laws, we're going to lose all of our federal funding, and all while degrading our girls' sports as well. I'm asking the board to stand up for our daughters, stand up for our nieces, stand up for all girls,
enforce Title IX and RSU V schools, and to send a clear message to the Maine Principals Association that they should do the same, they must do the same. Let's protect the future of girls' sports before it's too late. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Janice. And our next meeting, I'll come back to talk about the budget. Yes, I was going to do that as well. Okay, next we have Kelly Fitz-Randolph. Can you hear me?
Okay. I'm Kelly Fitz-Randolph. I am a member of the community. have a junior in high school, and I'm also the seventh grade science teacher at Freeport Middle School. I'm here to address you about upcoming suggested budget cuts of staff. Phoebe, you
couldn't have played into what I wanted to say even better. There are a number of cuts suggested in all of the schools. And as a teacher of 35 years, I have, I feel like I am witnessing more trauma and chronic absenteeism than I have seen in a long time. Behavior issues are on a rise.
And I've taught, this is my third district I've taught, and I've taught in some, as people would consider tougher districts. This is not the time to be making cuts. We need all of the ed techs that we have in our school.
We are down in ed tech in the middle school that was not hired for this year. We are scheduled to be cut one, maybe two more. We came up with some great ways for these ed techs to help kids that are chronically absent, to get them caught up, to make them feel more secure, and it would be awful to lose them.
It's been suggested that we lose a halftime English teacher, which supposedly keeps our language arts levels at 21. Well, we counted, and we always get kids moving in, the class sizes would be 24 or larger for language arts. My position, it is scheduled to not be rehired for. I'm the
seventh grade science teacher. What is that supposed to mean? Are we not going to have seventh grade science? Or are we going to lose our STEM to replace the seventh grade science? Already at the middle school, we're playing catch up for kids who are behind in science education because
of the stresses at the elementary school level on math and reading. So any staff that we have is needed for our kids mental health this is not the time to be cutting necessary people it is really the time to be looking at how to best support the mental health of our kids and the
education of our kids so i think we need to really look at the purpose of these cuts and really who's who's going to be hurt the most typically it's the kids that struggle the most that are hurt when we lose staff members. So instead of losing some, I'd say we could use some more. So thank you. Thank you, Kathleen.
Excuse me, sorry, Kelly. So our next three folks up are Melanie Sachs, Jonas Werner, and Jacqueline Priestley. Good evening. Thank you for allowing me to be here. My name is Melanie Sachs, and I am honored to serve as Freeport's state representative. the main house. On October 25th of 2023, this board, the RSU 5 board, after a rigorous public
transparent dialogue, adopted a policy with the stated goal to one, foster a learning environment that is safe and free from discrimination, harassment, and bullying, and two, to assist in the educational and social integration of transgender and gender expansive students in
our schools. I was very proud and glad to come before you and testify in strong support of that policy. Our local policy references and is aligned with Maine state and federal law, including the Maine Human Rights Act. I understand that there is an organization now intruding on our
local conversation and attempting to foment division. This outside entity, of which there's a very nice banner behind me. Parents, Rights, and Education has not filed paperwork in Maine either with the Office of the Secretary of State nor with the Office of Professional and
Occupational Regulation as of even just a few days ago. They state they have non-profit status in Oregon, but they have routinely engaged in political activity here in Maine, which would be an apparent violation of any non-profit status, an inquiry has been made with the Maine Attorney
General. Gender identity has been included in the Maine Human Rights Act since 2005. While interpretation of Title IX has been generally, since its institution many years ago, inclusive and expansive, there may be court challenges to reinterpret settled law, which will be done
at the state and federal level. Our main Attorney General, Aaron Frye, has indicated that he is ready and willing to have that conversation, as am I. I urge you, the RSU 5 board of our local community, to continue to follow the thorough, thoughtful policies you and our community
adopted through a transparent, public, and state-aligned process. I've been very grateful to work with many of you, the members of this board and this community, and I thank you for the time and work that you have done on behalf of our children. Thank you so much. Thank you, Melanie.
Can I just say ditto? My name is Jonas Warner. I live here in Freeport. I'm grateful for the time that you're spending on all of these topics. I stood before you some years ago, the last time major cuts were trying to be made at the middle school and argued about why that shouldn't be
happening. And frankly, the cuts to public education have been happening since the 80s, the cuts from the federal government. And I don't see that getting any easier. A lot of the people that are here tonight are here to talk about transgender children playing in sports, which is
to me the same thing, the same fight that we've been fighting since the 80s, where this is now a culture we're being used to try to destroy our image of our public school system so that more money can be funneled off for private use. It saddens me to have to be here. I have a trans
child. It sucks to feel like I have to fight for them to exist or fight for them to be recognized. There's people in this room that refer to trans girls as boys. I find that very insulting to them. In any deliberations you make about how to proceed, I hope that you'll consider a couple things.
one is what's the purpose of high school sports what's the goal is it only to win or are there other goals to be achieved not just in spite of trans athletes but with the inclusion of trans athletes things like teamwork camaraderie pain of falling down and the thrill of getting back
up as an individual and as a team together it is also my hope that any changes you make will produce a system which creates the least amount of death of our children all of our children. Cisgendered, transgendered, intersex, or otherwise. I have yet to see any evidence of the
danger caused by a trans boy on the wrestling team or a trans girl doing the high jump. Where is the danger to our girls? For me, the real danger is teaching girls they cannot compete against a boy or a trans girl. The real danger is telling girls they are unable to compete when a trans girl
walks into a room or a boy walks into a room. It sounds like misogyny 101 and we are currently up to our eyeballs in it. The rise of Christian nationalism in the U.S. and abroad. It's also dangerous and insulting to keep calling trans girls boys. They are not boys. You don't need
traumatizing transvestigation of a child to tell you that. Trans children have been through enough without the added insult of community members, feigning compassion for their daughters, but refusing to acknowledge the existence of other children. This is not a Christian ideal. It's not
the way Jesus would act if he were here today. It is my contention that the harm done to the trans community by excluding them is far greater than the harm caused to non-trans kids if trans boys and girls are included in high school athletics. I hope you can resist the cries for
homogeny, inequity, and exclusion. Thank you. Thank you, Jonas. Good evening. My name is Jacqueline producer and I'm from Freeport. I'm here today as a taxpayer, a resident of this town, and most importantly a mother of three, two of which are girls. I'm deeply concerned and disappointed by
the main Department of Education and RSU 5 District's decision to disregard federal protections and continue to push policies that strip our girls of the very opportunities that Title IX was created to protect and frankly should never have been enacted in the first place.
Title IX was designed to ensure fairness and equal opportunity for female athletes, not to be twisted into something that erases those protections. Allowing biological males to compete in women's sports is not inclusion.
It's discrimination against the very girls that this law was meant to protect. As parents, we want fairness and equal opportunity for our daughters. We want them to compete on a level playing field. We want their hard work, their dedication, and their dreams to be valued, not sacrifice for political ideology. I urge this board to stand for truth, for fairness, and for the integrity of women's sports.
Our girls deserve better. Thank you. Thank you, Jackie. Okay, not that anyone would know what number they signed the sheet on. I'm just trying to read a name from Freeport. I believe the last name, first name and last name both start with a D.
Dean, maybe? No. Dennis. Dennis? It looks like somebody signed this for us. okay i'm just gonna keep going down and if i haven't called your name by the time we get to the end of the folks in the uh the district you'll know it was you and then you can come up
okay um all right so we will move on to jack brogan and then after jack will be ashley schumacher is this good can people hear me not quite okay uh well my name is jack brogan and um i'm currently the junior captain of the freeport high school soccer team um i also play varsity lacrosse and
I have also run track and field both here and at Deering High School. So you could say I understand the topic of conversation, competition, and fairness in sports. So over the past few weeks, as we all know, we've seen a 16-year-old child, a high school student like me, become the target of
a nationwide outrage campaign. Instead of discussing the real issue, which is fairness in women's sports, people have chosen to harass, dox, and vilify a teenager. And that is not okay. Imagine waking up to see your name, your face, and your achievements dragged across social
media nationwide, not because you broke any rules, but because adults, elected officials, national pundits decided to make you a political weapon. And the impact is real. Greeley High School has increased police presence over the last few days because of these threats. I have kids that I know on my club soccer team that have police at every corner in the
Greeley High School neighborhood. But let me be clear, I fully believe in protecting women's sports. I ran track and field, and I did pole vault, and I know firsthand how much strength and power it takes to compete, and I really think that's why the MPA failed here.
They should have had policies in place to ensure that girls' reports remain fair. Instead, they let the situation, I think, spiral into chaos. And this isn't about left versus right. I don't think it's anything that has to do with politics. It's just about fair competition. Two of our own lost a fair shot at a championship medal because an athlete who had competed in the boys' division two years ago was allowed to compete in the girls' pole vaulting, and I personally think that is not fair.
But when the conversation shifts from protecting women's sports to publicly attacking a child, we lose focus. The outrage becomes the story instead of the real issue. And we need solutions at this point, not any more social media outrage and not any more hate.
I think the NPA, Greeley High School, and governing bodies must step up to protect girls' sports, while also ensuring that no 16-year-old is ever thrown to the wolves like this again. At the end of the day, no child should have to become a martyr for this debate. We can do a lot better. Thank you.
Thank you, Jack. Ashley? Hi there. I'm Ashley Schumacher. I live in Freeport. I'm a parent of a student in the district, and I am a proud queer and non-binary member of this community. I'll be brief so you can hopefully get some of the school board work done tonight that you came here to do.
I sent you all a lengthy email outlining my concerns about school budget cuts and policy reversions that are on tonight's agenda. I trust this board to do the right thing by our students because I've seen you do it time and again.
in turn please trust us the community to support a robust budget that allows educators and staff to meet students needs as they already exist and as they arise along with policies and procedures that offer broad protections for all of our students thank you so much for living your commitment to
this community by serving on the board and continuing to show up for the work despite its many challenges. Thanks. Thank you, Ashley. So next up we have Emily Stiles, Ron Schmidt, and Amelia and Nikki Conley. Good evening. My name is Emily Moker, excuse me, it's Stiles now, and I live in
Durham. I'm the proud parent of three children who are or have been students in RSU 5, and I'm here tonight to urge you, the board, to do the three following things. Include existing support staff at FMS and the ESOL position at FHS in the fiscal year 26 budget. Vote no on reverting back to the
2020 Title IX final rule. And to publicly recommit to the work of diversity, equity, inclusion, and belonging. I've witnessed this board do the right thing for RSU 5 students in the past, and I trust that you'll do the same for them now thank you for the hard work that you all do thank you emily
well i'm ron schmidt from freeport how's that um i am i'm embarrassed to admit this is the first time i've been to a school board meeting and i want to begin by thanking all of you for doing the work to show up so much and to provide this support for our students i i grew up in southern
california i went to an enormous series of public schools and i got a really good education there but they were the schools were very underfunded the teachers didn't have the resources that they needed and a lot of kids fell through the cracks my kid is
having a very good education here in in Freeport but that's due a lot of the time to the heroic efforts of their teachers and I would want to see that level of some level of robust budgeting at the very least to not make it harder
for those teachers to do the incredibly important work that they're doing Providing not just the basic content of an education, but also providing a protective and encouraging atmosphere around students is so key to their success.
At a time when we've got 15,000 kids, I think, without health insurance in Maine, and 55,000 who rely on SNAP benefits that could be cut, We need to be making our students feel safer and more cared for and more capable of doing what they need to do to get the top-flight education that they deserve.
And needless to say, providing that kind of safe space does not extend to a campaign to threaten trans students in order to expose them to national publics who think that either they don't exist or that they don't have a right to.
Thank you again for everything. Thank you very much. Hello, my name is Anuria Connelly. I am a sophomore at Freeport High School, and I do indoor and outdoor track. I was born as a female, and I identify as a female, but I cannot imagine having a different story and being ridiculed and attacked by an entire country
for how I identify and how I view myself. We just finished our indoor season. We went to states. we competed well. I'm very proud of my team and we should not, no one should have that much hatred or misunderstanding of someone to ridicule them and make it seem like we lost. My team did very
well as did every other team and we as a community need to respect others and how they feel because I would so much rather be an athlete who is competing against someone who is succeeding and who is happy with how they identify rather than someone who is not expressing themselves as how they feel.
I don't understand how we as a community can try to tear down this individual just because she was born a boy. And I don't think that we lost anything except maybe some of our dignity after tearing apart this girl just because she wasn't born as one. Thank you, Amelia.
I'm Amelia's mom, Nikki Connolly. We live in Freeport, Maine. I have two other kids who also attend RSU5 schools, and we're obviously here in support of trans youth as well as girls and females. It all goes together. We just care about human rights. I just want to point out that only
five transgender athletes are competing in girls teams in school sports for grades K through 12 right now as of January 2025 and a study founded or funded by the International Olympic Committee found that trans women had greater hand grip strength but lower jumping ability, lung function
and cardiovascular fitness compared to cis women. But I really want to point out the psychological distress that trans youth and trans people experience. It can negatively impact athletic performance by causing decreased focus impaired decision making reduced motivation increased anxiety muscle tension and the list goes on Phoebe you
mentioned mental health for the Freeport and RSU 5 students and I thank you for saying that I think we really need to be aware of the mental health of the trans population in particular there's such a marginalized group they're
harassed and bullied already and if sports can help to elevate them and to give them some pride and a sense of belonging then we as a district and as a community owe that to them um thank you thank you nikki uh kevin jose johannes sorry if i'm messing up people's names
and then um maddie vertentin will be after hi kevin josen hands it's not good close i'm a freeport dad parent of two girls um just wanted to say a few things um you know i i'm saddened on kind of we've gotten here today we keep mulling over the same things and talking about
these policy issues and as I stand this evening I see a fractured community I see policies being brought by people no one in this room voted for drummond and would some main principals Association to give a few examples the policies are
drafted I feel like historically minimally curated I know that's not it's a little abrasive towards the policy committee but we've heard so many varying um uh sides of the story and input from parents um that i've been i've become suspect of
the whole process um i've i've provided feedback to the policy committee recently i never received an email back sometimes i have been given emails back but uh definitely not on that one um i've become suspect when uh community individuals make foia requests or freedom of information requests
and are met with a $55,000 bill to pay. And I think it's sometimes discouraging to see a school board vote in lockstep and unanimously on so many issues when there's so many parents that have expressed concern. I'll be very candid. My frustrations stem from a loss of feeling like I'm being heard, a feeling of loss of control over our kids, and a lack of focus on education. It feels like creep of government and watering down of education. I want to mention what I said in my email on the volunteer policy the the way it's written and proposed I believe is an
expectation that a volunteer is to report kids they think are neglected to the DHHS or the district attorney but they're not trained in that ability to spot those types of things or make the report whereas the school employees have
to be trained in that with a certain timeline it's like four years or but I think it's inappropriate to allow minimally vetted volunteers into the school and then empower them to make reports to DHHS in the district attorney
again it just feels like the watering down of parents rights and relinquishing too much control over to unvetted volunteers ACA policy just real quick is creating environment where girls aren't being allowed to excel we've had quite a bit of parental input over the last year in the policy unfortunately the board voted unanimously to approve it last year when so many parents expressed
their concerns I would like to remind all the parents this policy was very cleverly written to piggyback on the Maine principals Association in reference to gender segregated activities so to clarify it cites interscholastic participation and athletics will be addressed in accordance with the current Maine principals Association guidelines so by design the policy is written to allow for changes to be dictated by an entity
other than the board it's my opinion the board will use this a way to shirk responsibility for upholding the executive order by being able to point to the main principals Association I don't recall voting for anyone in the
main principals Association just so this event is played out in our community resulting in girls not having a rightful place on the podium again it's a degradation of parental rights and students ability to perform at their best and have a shot for the top spot. And again, finally, as we're here arguing over policy that
seems to fall in deaf ears with the unanimous voting records, the expenditure of cost per child versus test scores is a divergent curve. And this is what really matters. I would invite my fellow community members to reference the recent local property tax assessments in Freeport. I know mine
went up substantially. I know we're speaking of the budget tonight, so I figured it'd be an appropriate time to ask what is being done to curb the spending increase and begin to move each of these divergent trend lines in opposite directions we
have politicians playing chicken with federal funding just the timer when I'm not sure you heard it but the time I didn't even hear it okay well I'm just trying to just hope that we can focus back on getting the scores up and
focusing on education and I just feel bad that we've relinquished so much responsibility to people that we haven't voted for we're not making the decisions within our own community and the board. Thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you, Kevin. Good
evening. My name is Maddie Vertenten. I live in Freeport and I know you all very well and I know you do. Every time we meet, work very hard on getting the scores up and focusing on education and it's great when the public shows up to comment like this but it does take a lot of time from your
agenda. That said, I couldn't miss the opportunity to speak on two things tonight. First, I want to talk about the budget, and I sent this to you in a letter, but I wanted to just read a part of it tonight. I see this budget year as a time for the board to act courageously despite trepidation
and take every action possible not to backslide when it comes to how the district serves our students. It took a lot of years of incremental budget actions to get to where the district is today. To cut those very intentional staffing decisions in the face of economic uncertainty
will undermine years of intentional board and administrative teamwork. So I ask you to take on the difficult task of, number one, finding ways to reduce the budget that have a much less significant impact on our students
and or propose a bold budget to our taxpayers. We're not living in normal times. The Department of Education and all government spending is under siege. This has a direct impact on schools. To put forward a budget that clearly shows the impact to our schools would allow citizens to make a choice about what matters to us. Do we value education? Do we want
to invest in our students at a time when the federal government does not? Are we willing to put our tax dollars where our values are? This is a big risk for you as a board, I know. If the budget does not pass, then that means extra work for you over the summer. I don't wish that on any
of you. But I believe strongly that there are much bigger questions at stake and that this is your part to play right now. Regarding Title IXX, yes, over a year ago, you unanimously approved the district policy protecting gender expansive and transgender youth. That policy is sound and
has done a lot of good letting our most vulnerable students know that you want school to be a safe place for them to exist. Title IX is extremely complex. I remember this from the time that I served on this board and on the policy committee. I remember the last time that our current president
was in office, we contended with changes to Title IX, and then I know that happened again when the last president was in office, and now it's happening again. Despite what some people in this audience think, this board does not dictate how Title IX works. It makes
sense to follow what's happening at the district of education level and what's happening in our state. I do think that what you can do is, and I think what I'm asking you to do, is let your voices be heard by the Department of Education, by the Governor, by the Attorney's
General, affirming our values. And importantly, one thing I keep hearing over and over again is do not comply in advance. Do not comply with this President's executive orders. They are executive orders. They are not law. They are not settled law. And I thank you. I just want to close by saying
I know it's very hard to sit where you're sitting on night's light tonight, and I just want to thank you for the work that you do. I know you all do incredible work from the right place. Thank you. Thank you, Maddie. Okay, I'm going to jump back to if you signed the sheet, and I haven't called
your name and you're from freeport i'm very curious of what your name is okay yeah no i have you on the other sheet no all right well then we'll uh we'll jump to samantha everyone my name is samantha bryant and i live in freeport i'm opposed to the policy reversion proposed in item
11c in 2020 the supreme court ruled in the bostock case that trans people are protected through the Civil Rights Act federal law. That ruling helped inspire the Title IX policy currently in place. Executive orders are not laws. Many recent federal actions have already been
found illegal, unconstitutional, and unenforceable. That may yet happen with this one too. Finally, the proposed change would be in conflict with state policy and state law. So I asked that the rsu5 school board we consider making this change at this time thank you thank you samantha kelly
delaney hello everyone good evening my name is kelly delaney and i'm from freeport i just wanted to thank you all for giving us all a forum to come and express our opinions i'm a parent of three freeport students one in mass landing one in middle the freeport middle school and one at
the high school. And I'm here today to show my support for the Title IX programs now and going forward. I applaud efforts to evolve our policies to represent the entire student body and to give our kids the support they need. That means codifying policies around sexual harassment,
pregnancy, birth, and transgender inclusivity. As parents and administrators, you often bravely venture into new territory with an intent to address issues and strive to provide equal access to programs. I came to today's meeting as a show of my support for the hard work you do to uphold
progressive programs and to not give in to the opposition's baseless claims that promote hate and bullying of our children. Thank you. Thank you, Kelly. All right. May Hona, maybe? Hi. Can you here? Thanks. I'm Reverend Mayor Honig and I'm living in Freeport. And I think this
issue for me about the competition, the inclusion of trans, the understanding of trans, I can't isolate it. I see it under the umbrella of the soul of America. I feel like there's so much going on that tugs at the soul of America for me. What's the soul? How do we know that?
We can't really define it easily. To me, it's something in our gut that we know is right, that we have fought for, myself not included in that hard fight, and we have won. You know, less than, a little older than 100 years ago, women were being stoned because they had the audacity to think they could vote.
100 years ago? I'm 77, and most of my, well, a good half of my life, I knew nothing about trans. I never thought about gender. It wasn't in my environment as a topic, and I hadn't met anybody who could teach me. And that's how we learn. You know, we get stuck in thinking we know something, and we know nothing, as far as I can see. We know the limited amount humans know. And then some brave person, a group of people, step up and they teach us. If we have the courage to learn, and we have the willingness to change, we can learn. And frequently, us humans, instead of that willingness, we have fear.
It's different. They're different. They think different. They act different. God, they want rights. Oh my God, what's that going to mean? We're going to lose something. And we react with fear, and frequently we never identify that that's how we're reacting. We think we have the answer.
We think competition and who's winning an award is what we're talking about. What we're talking about is much deeper than who's winning a swim meet. And we're being challenged as all of us are being challenged. To look anew, to understand more deeply, to talk to trans people,
to understand what we're afraid of in the challenges that are coming. I'm asking us to be the better people that I know is the same in America. Thank you, ma'am. I have Brenda Rodvig and Chandra-Jean Robbins. And then we'll move on to folks from outside the district. I am Brenda Rodvig, a resident of Freeport.
I have three young adult children who all participated in athletics in high school, but in a different school district, that competed against RSU-5. The men, principals, associations, and the school board's decision to allow men to play in women's sports is a poor decision and one I ask you to be sent.
First, it affects the safety of our students. Not only the students of OSU 5, but also it affects the safety of students from other school districts when they're competing against Freeport, Pond, and Dorn. The safety of our students should be our first priority. It's completely unfair to our female athletes to be forced to either compete with transgender athletes, or not compete at all, or to give up championship titles to the biologically advantaged, to give up opportunities to shine athletically on a college application, and to stand on the podium and receive a medal.
The number of transgender students who participate in athletics is but a very small percentage of the student population. Yet, every single female student-athlete is affected by the decision to allow men to play a women's sports.
The biological male has an advantage over the female body in size, strength, and weight. Not only does this create safety concerns on the playing fields and courts, must I mention during hotel stays when the team travels, but it creates a safety concern for every single female in the locker rooms and in the women's bathrooms.
Secondly, our schools cannot afford to lose funding from the U.S. government because of the decision to follow the main principals association's league to disregard the federal ruling of Title IX. Our ranking in academics nationwide is already near the bottom.
That's with the ever-increasing school budget. It seems the higher the budget, the lower the proficiency in our students' reading and math. How low can we go? Let's not find out. Let's not take a loss in school funding. Our priorities should be what's best for our students as a whole.
Know what's best for the ultra-minority. Allowing men to play women's sports. It's dangerous. It's unfair to our female athletes. And I ask you to prioritize our female athletes' safety. Return fairness to our female athletes. And keep men out of women's sports. Thank you. Thank you, Brenda. Shonda? You make this for taller people, don't you?
Hi, can you hear me? My name is Shonda Jane Robbins. I'm a resident of Freeport. I'm the mother of a Freeport High School student, and I'm also a business owner in the community. And my daughter is trans, and I have never been so pleased in my entire life that she never had any interest in sports.
I am speaking in support of the current title line. I went through a lot for this last year. I had never spoken to a group before because my daughter came out as trans when she was 14. I'm speaking today to you and also to the parents of children who do love sport.
For whom sport is a guiding light in their lives. For whom sport is something that drives them to be better, to sacrifice, to become the people that we want our children to grow up to be. Because if your child is trans, let's say you have a son right now and you don't know yet that they're trans.
Because I didn't know until my kid came out to me when they were 14. And let's say they love sports. Sports is what drives them. It is their favorite thing about school. It is the best thing. Your lives revolve around sports. And let's say they come out as trans, and then guess what? If this gets overturned, that is the end for them.
There is no more sport. There is no more sport at all. Simply because they had the courage to come out and be who God made them to be. And that's all I have to say. Also, with the doxing thing, as manners, we don't bully children.
Thank you. Thank you, Shonda. All right, I'm going to give one more opportunity for the Freeport person who didn't get called get. Okay. So we will move on to folks from outside the district, and first up is Scott Jordan, and
then Larry Othiero. Good evening, Harry. Scott Jordan, I'm from Cumberland, Maine. I'm here this evening to encourage the young women from the Freeport High School track and field team to freak out, to let their voices be heard.
On the record, we know a biological male and a Greeley team won, but I think everybody in this room knows the truth. I think we should recognize Freeport as the real victor. Congratulations, Freeport. Biological young man, or actually, I'm going to take a step back. the decision to allow a biological male, John, transgender, young woman, Katie, compete as a
female in the recent main high school track and championship is wrong. Biological young man is a non-transgender athlete. Competing in a sport where he clearly has a physical advantage doesn't seem that there was any consideration given by the NPA to where in the process the young man
is in his actual transition. Just from the pictures that were recently posted on social media, And I'll be honest, they were hatefully done in some cases. It's an obvious young man who has a physical advantage inherent to males.
Last year, he was on the podium as a male winner. This year, he topped the podium as a female. And his victory was insubstantial. Eight inches in track is a huge margin for those of you who are unaware. I ask you this. Is it right to hurt the hundreds of other female pole vaulters, competed all season long to be denied because a transitioning student
unsurped them wholeheartedly. As a governing body, the NPA should have figured this out in advance. They should have at least considered it, because I guarantee you their decision made a huge difference to the person who finished second, the young lady who finished second, and even bigger difference to the one who didn't medal at all
because of this. For the record, whatever this young man wants to do is up to him and his family. Can you please silence? can I have my time back please we're not gonna we're not shouting actually I'm sorry I have a point of order are we supposed to be is the public allowed to discuss individuals I don't well I think we're not talking names or any okay okay
there will be no names can I have my time reset please can we please ask the public to stop talking I did thank you can you please listen thank you we were respectful of you. We're directing comments to the board, not to other individuals in the crowd.
Yeah, but they've been disrespectful, ma'am. I understand. We paused your time. I apologize for your interruption, and if you're ready, you have 48 seconds remaining. And then also, just to clarify, point of order, the person who was the former board member, you allowed her to
continue, but you asked somebody prior to that to finish up. So just be fair for everybody. I am. When the time goes off, I... No, you didn't say anything to that person. Alright, so your time is about to start. I try to find a pause in the thought before I ask folks to finish up, regardless of the position that they're taking.
To me, this isn't a judgment call. It was just wrong to let the young men compete. I believe the NPA should at least develop some standards and go tests. They already exist for elite athletes. Read the studies. Talk in terms of anatomy and psychology. Think about it rationally.
I can never say the word, sorry. Not in a liberal, conservative context. Not in a political context. Let's use some common sense. At the end of the day, we had an example with a volleyball player, a male volleyball player.
Regardless if he was transitioning or not, slammed a ball into a young lady's face and broke, I believe, her orbitable bone. Common sense. I was in the military. I served in the Gulf War. And our female American soldiers had to be masked up and always followed behind us.
How is that equal? We couldn't get our pay, our danger pay, because we had female American soldiers with us. Think about that. We want to talk about being inclusive. Let's just say a certain mindset gets treated, gets bullied by certain individuals.
I was already bullied this evening because I have a different point of view. We want to talk about being inclusive. America being the soul of America? Well, let's think about it. Everybody should have a point of view. Everybody should be able to speak and be heard and not be bullied. What happened to being Christ-like? What happened to love your neighbor? Thank you, Scott.
Larry Alfiello, and then after Larry, we'll have Nicholas Blanchard. Carol Alfiello, Cumberland, I've been an educator for over 30 years. I'd like to preface my remarks by saying I empathize and have compassion for all transgender.
I've heard talk about hate tonight. People who agree with me do not hate. We're looking for something different. We're looking for something called fairness. Compassion. I'm going to tell you a story about a woman named Riley Gaines.
Most of you have heard about her. Imagine that you have a daughter who's 18 years old. She's a national champion swimmer. She enters a contest, and amazingly, she ties a biological male, transgender. And they give the trophy, not to her, but to the transgender.
So she went to her coach, and she said, why? How could you do this? And he said, took her aside and said, we have to be tolerant, we have to accept, we have to welcome DEI. Of course we know that men are stronger. We are bigger. Our heart size is bigger. We have 40% larger run capacity.
Our throats are bigger. And that's very important, very critical when you're in any kind of athletic endeavor. But to add insult to injury, when they took the picture of the trophy, they gave the trophy to the transgender and had her hold the trophy.
And with tears in her eyes, Wiley Gaines went to her coach. I'm going to ask that you don't specifically name students, regardless if they're in this district or not. What are you talking about? She's a massive figure. She's on TV all the time. I'm sorry, I thought you were talking about this. give me my time back please give me some time she went to her coach in tears she said i sacrificed
18 years of my life my social connections my diet my practicing every day how could you do this for me and the coach just walked away he said i i can't answer you again he says something about being accepting we talk about pain tonight think about the pain of these young women and girls
who sacrifice so much to be put in a position that is completely unfair, completely unsafe. And we can't say, oh, it only happens here and only happens there. It's happening everywhere. So please, when we talk about empathy, when we talk about compassion,
let's go beyond the transgender community, who I have compassion for, and think about these young women and what they go through. i'd like to talk to the parents and there's a lot of people here who are parents who disagree with
me and i understand that but there are many parents who should be here taking it for their daughters and they have to be brave but of all the virtues in this world it is known out of love compassion patience courage most important one is courage because without courage love will get
nowhere i think we have to wrap it up okay no we're not we're not having a conversation in the crowd okay enough so i don't know what just happened what happened i was just asking you to wrap it up because your time we went over we gave you a little bit of time back but your time is up okay so uh men we are not asked to complete the task but neither are we exempt
i'm trying thank you thank you so nicholas blanchard is who we have up next and after nicholas would be kathleen brown states and school districts that if any teacher or school you can give if you want something to share you can share that with the superintendent she'll
make sure we get it we also don't have recordings if you want to speak you're welcome to your three minutes but we're not going to play a recording sorry it's fine it's pretty much just trump explaining the executive order that he put out that you guys seem to just want to completely
blow off but um this right here is a picture of a biological man that competed against women that stole a championship from a young woman i have a plan of order madam chair yep i believe this is out of order i was just out of order i didn't say any names i didn't say any names
he's using a visual why are you interrupting second time that's not the order okay we're we okay guys how is this fair okay we're gonna take a five minute break to pause yes we are um HR it's okay so they can keep interrupting we are going to we're gonna take a five minute break you will have your time and we just need to relax here for a second they're the ones that's not relaxed it's not us we are we were respectful so thank you uh thank you for everyone's patience i apologize for not
doing the motion to take the quick five minute recess i appreciate your your uh indulgence in that um we will reset your five minutes excuse me your three minutes we will reset your three minutes uh and um i'm just waiting for her to pull up her timer uh nicholas blanchard from
my guys here too am i good all right so um my whole speech kind of got messed up with uh the whole thing so i'm kind of just gonna go off the cuff but um so this is a quote from the uh coach cornwall i know as a coach it's tough i think i would stop coaching the assistant coach said
kind of but but the assistant coach was kind of into it and said he had championship fever to win both boys and girls championship at the state level you know our biggest problem here right now it to deny the fact that it is a competitive advantage for biological men to compete against
women how how is it fair for a young woman that spends all her childhood practicing you know you think if you think they just wake up and become a state champion no that takes work that takes effort to come in and get beat by somebody that placed ninth last year as a male how do you as a
father as a parent how do you tell that how do you explain that to your daughter that she worked so hard to get beat by a man how is that fair you know did you think that man practiced and worked just as hard as she did obviously not because he placed ninth the year before i mean it's kind of
common sense i mean just like the man spoke about military i mean the standard for women is completely different than the standard for men women have to do a different amount of push-ups compared to men why is that our bodies are built different it's a competitive advantage and you
guys are going to die on this and federal funding is going to come from these from all of our districts what about low-income families that that you know want this federal that need this federal funding for free lunch for after school programs you think the state funding is going to
be enough for all that the way janet mills is spending our money really i mean come on guys what are we going to do when are we going to start thinking about our kids again when are we going to go back to teaching again we worry more about same-sex bathrooms and all this than we do
worry about our test scores and everything else when are we going to get back to teaching our kids what is right and what is wrong and right now this is wrong and a lot and you honestly you guys are brainwashing these kids that's exactly what you guys are doing you're indoctrinating these kids and i feel bad for every single one of them because when i was in school this was not a thing
you did not walk down the school hallways and see a private you weren't celebrating what people did in their bedroom you don't have a straight foot a straight flag hanging up do you no because we don't celebrate what we do in our bedroom that doesn't make somebody who they are what makes somebody who they are is their character. You guys have a good night. Daddy's home. Thank you, Nicholas.
Kathleen Brown and then Elaine Dupree is after Kathleen. Good to know you. My name is Kathleen Brown, and I've had the privilege of teaching science in Freeport for almost 20 years. Thank you for your important work on the budget. I want to share my concerns regarding the proposal to
leave the science teacher position at Freeport Middle School unfailed following their retirement. First thing in the background, the next-gen science standards are the guideposts for excellence in science education across the nation.
Maine adopted the standards about a decade ago and has built a state science assessment around those standards. Unlike traditional science standards, NGSS prioritizes science and engineering practices alongside content knowledge.
In other words, it dictates a curriculum that explores both the why and the how of science. In response to the next-gen science standards, the middle school developed a blended STEM and science program. Each year, students are enrolled for equal amounts of time in both STEM and science classes.
We believe strongly that science provides the essential foundation and that STEM allows students to apply that knowledge in exciting and innovative ways. Over the past several years, our middle school has poured its heart into creating a curriculum that ignites students' curiosity and encourages them to think critically.
And the success of this approach is clear. 70% of Freeport Middle School students meet or exceed the standard on a state science assessment. That's not only double the statewide average, it's 20% higher than the district average.
It's a rate competitive with other top-performing districts in Maine. While test schools are but one measure of a student's success, we believe these results speak strongly to the effectiveness of their program. To ensure we can continue offering these powerful learning experiences, maintaining the integrity of the blended science and STEM program is absolutely essential.
This means replacing the retiring science teacher with someone who combines a strong understanding of science with a genuine passion for teaching it, and leaving the STEM complement in place. As you witnessed during a recent tour of our building, learning that FMS is engaging and relevant.
Our model is good for kids. Are you going to tell me more about it and answer any questions that you have? I don't even have hard work to do, and I thank you for it. I respectfully request that the board continue to support strong science and STEM education for our students throughout the district.
Thank you. Thank you, Kathleen. Good day, Green. My name is Elaine DePry, and I'm the 7th grade STEM teacher at Freeport Middle School. I come before you tonight to speak about the proposed cut to the 7th grade science position at Freeport Middle School.
Three weeks ago, it was announced that upon Kelly Fitz's retirement, the 7th grade science position would be cut with no rationale for how the 7th grade science content would still be delivered. To date, we still have not been given an explanation. Knowing that science still has to be taught, we can only surmise that a cut like this means a drastic change to our science and STEM program offerings.
Already, elementary students enter middle school with less science knowledge than they did 10 years ago. Whether it's due to COVID or the emphasis on math and literacy at the elementary levels, it is a marked difference.
We cannot afford to weaken our STEM and science offerings, and we do not see that there's a way that this can be avoided if you cut the science position. Upon inquiring if cutting a science position could mean cutting a STEM position by asking a current STEM teacher,
such as myself, to fill the science void, the response was, it's in the mix of possibilities. So without being given any other information, I feel I have to come before you tonight to defend our STEM program, just so that you keep in mind that if you support a cut in a science
position, you could be supporting a cut in a STEM program offering. By having both science and STEM, we are able to accomplish the science standards the district has adopted. Science classes foster a spirit of inquiry, encourage students to pursue and analyze evidence, and master content that
builds a strong foundation for future science classes. STEM classes go beyond content knowledge. equipping students with vital problem-solving skills, developing those 21st-century skills of thinking outside the box as they engage in real-world engineering challenges.
STEM classes are particularly effective in engaging students who may not thrive in traditional subjects. Hands-on projects and innovative problem-solving activities offer learning experiences that do not exist in other subjects.
These experiences help students see the relevance of their education, fostering both academic success and increased school attendance. If you want to know when students who are frequently absent show up to school, come visit on a daily meal launching rockets, building tiny homes, or coding and programming robots.
The students are there. Furthermore, the specialized skill sets of our current STEM teachers, such as expertise in computer science, hands-on project design, and real-world application of scientific principles, should not be overlooked.
We bring unique qualifications and passions that have built the STEM program at FMS, offering students experiences that go beyond standard curriculum instruction and fostering skills critical for future success. Oops, I'll get this up. Just this year, STEM teachers finally started meeting as a K-12 STEM department,
even attending STEM conferences as a cohort. We are STEM teachers because we are passionate about STEM. Please do not assume that STEM teachers are qualified or want to step into a STEM science position, which we feel we may ask to do if the science position is cut.
A cut of a science position will have detrimental effects on our current science and STEM offerings, which will unfortunately directly impact our students' education. Thank you. Thank you, Mary. I have Amy Colta, maybe? Colton, yes. Okay, thank you.
How is this? Okay? Great. RTI is critically important in our schools. My name is Amy Colton, and I am the 0.5 math RTI teacher at Freeport Middle School. As you may know, it has been proposed that my position, along with the 0.5 reading RTI teaching position, be eliminated,
and then we will both be replaced with one full-time RTI teacher who will deliver both math and reading interventions. I think the loss of having content specialists will outweigh whatever minor benefits there might be in having one full-time teacher in this role.
I also want to mention that this proposal has no impact, positive or negative, on the budget. I love math, and I love my work. I know that everyone has the capacity to understand and be successful in math. When I work with students in small groups, I can identify their misconceptions and help guide them to a more accurate and deeper level of understanding.
I work to create a safe environment for sharing thinking and developing confidence. I have over 20 years of math education experience, most of those at the middle school level. I have been trained in instructional strategies that help learners develop understanding of math concepts.
I know the content of K-8 math very well, and I have a strong understanding of Algebra I. Knowing where students are coming from and where they are going is critical to delivering effective math interventions, as well as making in-the-moment decisions based on observing students and listening to their thinking.
I admire and respect my reading counterpart, and I know that I would not bring the same level of expertise if I were asked to deliver reading interventions. It's my years of training and experience in math specifically that make me such a good fit for my current math RTI position.
When I've asked to understand the rationale behind eliminating content specialists in RTI, I've been told that the benefits include streamlined communication and greater consistency in service delivery. Oh, nervous, sorry. I cannot think of any lapses in communication that have occurred in my two and a half years in this position.
Although I work part-time, I find ways via email or planning ahead to meet in person to communicate and collaborate with other staff members. It is true that I do not attend all meetings, but math concerns are so specific to math class
that when a concern comes up, the math classroom teacher seeks me out, either in person or via email. From there, we make a plan for next steps. Regarding consistency in delivery of services, there are places where consistency makes sense, group size, duration of intervention, progress monitoring, and there are places where consistency is unimportant. Some instructional strategies are critical in math and non-existent in reading, and vice versa. I do think that FMS has some work to do to improve consistency with regard to RTI. But I firmly believe that the 0.5 leading RTI teacher and I can work collaboratively to ensure that where consistency matters, we make it happen. RTI is critically important. Let's make sure we have specialists working with our students to maximize impact on learning. Thank you. Thank you, Amy.
Next up, we have Alan Salvinas. And after Alan will be Jeff Nessie. maybe from brunswick good evening chairwoman richardson rsg5 school board superintendent scrappa i appreciate your time tonight um my name i am the director for parents rights and education
and i'm the proud director of parents rights and education no matter where defamation comes from we are in your district i'm gonna ask you to just give your name and where you're from sorry My name is Alan Salvinas. I'm from Topsom. I live there with my lovely wife and two male children.
So we stand here tonight because we were invited here by your parents who know they have rights and they know we'll stand here and fight for them because they're inherent and fundamental to their life, liberty, and prosperity. We urge you to take a stand for your own girls,
for their safety and opportunities. There is elevated harm. There's great harm that comes to girls when their private spaces and activities are violated. It's laying before you. That's what I handed out. And it's backed by decades of legal precedent upholding Title IX. The Biden
Title IX revisions were ruled unconstitutional, proving that the year of our advocacy is correct. It's right. For far too long, parents have been lied to. I know parents that we've worked with who've left. I've worked with military veterans that would walk through the door and people would
say, that's a big dude. And the one thing they have told the other side's advocacy, what they have told them for years, is that males need to invade girls' spaces in sports because it's a vital part of gender-affirming care. Except last month, a transgender attorney stood in front of
the Supreme Court and said that's not true, that there's no data, that there's no science that proves gender-affirming care reduces suicides. So I'm asking you who made decisions after having this, your goodwill leveraged against you for years, who's going to be accountable for lying
to you, who's going to be accountable to lying to these parents? Imagine being told that if you didn't do what your kid wanted, they'll kill themselves. And then finding out five years later was a lie. I mean, are you going to still listen to the same people who will be leveraging your
goodwill? Mean girl dads have had enough. All parents have had enough. This is about fairness, safety, and the integrity of girls' sports. If this board truly cares about female athletes, you are to uphold title nine as it stands you will send a clear message to the main principal
association that freeport girls will no longer lose their championships to males thank you jeff uh i think it's nessie but i could be messing up the last name does definitely look like it starts with an n from brunswick no okay we will move on to sarah davis okay hello i'm sarah davis
I'm from Auburn, but I teach in Freeport at the middle school. I did not intend to speak tonight. I'm not great at public speaking, except in the classroom, I guess. So I did come, though, to support my colleagues and my students with the budget discussion.
I know it's a ton of work for you guys, so I'm disappointed that we can't have this budget meeting separate from the Title IX issue. My daughter, who has an interest in local government and likes to know how schools run, wanted to attend the budget meeting. She happens to be trans, and I asked her if she was comfortable coming, and she said yes. I wanted to speak so that I could sort of echo what Phoebe said at the beginning so eloquently. I wanted to say before all of this to just remember to be kind because we were talking about children. um and not just children trans adults as well who are people and humans who deserve to be loved and
respected and included um and so i'm a little thrown by the whole um a lot of the hatred that i'm hearing it really upsets me but it's been lovely to see um students who are at the middle school who are now here thriving at the high school and hearing amelia talk so eloquently
and Phoebe and I just applaud you I think so I'm kind of losing track of what I'm saying but I would also like to just encourage you to reconsider the cuts at the middle school and find other budget cuts other ways of cutting the budget
and I think it is possible to be creative about it without cutting staff that helps kids who are at risk so RTI is huge and it's so important and it concerns me when we cut programs that service the kids who are the most vulnerable. And I feel like
that's all I had to say. Just thank you for your work. Thank you, Sarah. All right, so next we have Margaret Estabrook. Good evening. I'd like to thank the board for giving me this opportunity to speak. My name is Margaret Estabrook. I'm a resident of Yarmouth. I'm coming to you today
as a coach and a mother of two NCAA athletes, one of which was able to get a full scholarship for college. Tonight, I'm asking you to demonstrate your support for female athletes by complying with Title IX. This would not only put Freeport in alignment with federal law,
but it would reaffirm your commitment to safeguard the civil rights of female students. As a school board, you have a real opportunity here to take the lead in Maine and show all female students that you see them, you hear them, and you acknowledge them,
and they're worthy of your attention. I'd also like to close with, I don't think anybody here hates anybody. We're here because we are pro-Title IX. We're anti-hate, but pro-Title IX. And I'm asking you to consider what the original intentions of Title IX were.
And I'm asking you to uphold Title IX and acknowledge the civil rights that it bestows on female students thank you thank you margaret uh julia dietrich julia dietrich hello my name is julia dietrich i'm from bristol maine i'm a junior at another mid-coast high
school and even though i'm not a student at freeport high school i would like to show my support for a team that rightfully earned its place in competition only to have that opportunity taken away by an unfair policy that ignores the integrity of women's sports.
Enough is enough. It is time for female athletes across Maine to take a stand against the Maine Principals Association and the governor's policies that are failing us. We have trained, we have sacrificed, we have played by the rules,
yet we are being forced to watch as the rights and opportunities of female athletes are stripped away. If those in power refuse to protect fairness in women's sports, then we must make them understand the consequences of their decisions in the only way they seem to understand.
Through time, resources, money, and undeniable public pressure. For the past three years, I have competed in Congressional Debate, which is another organization governed by the MPA. Even in debate, there's a culture in the state of Maine that is anti-woman and our own state judges making comments such as,
Your voice is too feminine. You would never be taken seriously if you continue to hold yourself that way. Your views are unreasonable. The fight is not just about one team, one championship, or one season. This is about every girl in the state of Maine who has ever laced up her shoes, stepped onto the field, prepared for a tournament, or poured her heart into a competition, believing that she had a fair shot.
It is time to act. Show up for your games, your meets, and your tournaments. Be ready to compete and then stand together in silent, unwavering protest. Let the empty scoreboards and unanswered whistles send a message loud enough to the MPA, our schools, and the state that they cannot ignore it.
I believe that the board should take a public stand against the MPA and the governor's position. We are not just athletes. We are not just students. We are not just parents. We are fighters. Let's keep women's sports for women. Thank you. thank you julia just going down here to make sure we didn't miss anybody on this list and i think
we just have a couple more here uh sean patrick cody good evening my name is revend sean patrick cody and i live in portland but have the honor of serving as pastor of south freeport church here and um love this town i'm grateful for all of you and for the great service that you do um
serving on this board and thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight I just want to speak on behalf of my trans siblings and express my profound love and acceptance for them wherever they are in their life journeys and my dismay at hearing some of the hateful ways that trans folks have been spoken about tonight and in the larger national debate that has come from this.
Things like referring to people's genders, misgendering people, and saying the names that they have chosen no longer to be called by. It may not seem like it to you, but these are really hurtful, really hateful actions to be doing.
I'm speaking on behalf of myself, and not to my church, although my church is an open and affirming congregation of my Church of Christ, a place where we are welcoming all of God's beloved people. But for me, one of the things that's really sustained my faith throughout my life is the diversity of God's creation.
Like just people of different ethnicities, nationalities, gender expressions. The more diverse, the more beautiful, the more better. So I'm just encouraging us to draw the circle wide, to be inclusive and empathetic, and to protect the most vulnerable among us.
so thank you so much thank you sean uh tim grivlaw good evening everybody um so i think this is good news i teach high school civics here uh i figured about that i'm going to ask you to give us your name my name is timothy grivlaw and uh i am a teacher here at freeport high school for the last
12 years um every day i have the privilege of helping young people understand their rights and responsibilities as members of our democracy uh and tonight speaking about title nine and that as a political issue, but as a fundamental question of equal protection under the law,
I'd just like to speak to the way that we have our students think about it. Over the past 50 years, this law has expanded educational opportunities for girls, protected students from sexual harassment, and ensured fairness in many different extracurricular activities.
But Title IX is not just about history, it's about our present and our future. It's a living promise that every student, no matter their gender, deserves safety, dignity, and an equal chance to learn. That means that our schools must continue to protect all students, including those who are transgender or non-binary. But as a civics teacher, I remind my students that our Constitution's promise of equal protection is not static.
It evolves as we recognize the rights and dignity of more people. That circle that the Reverend was just speaking about was a lot smaller 100 years ago. There are people in this room who would not have enjoyed equal protection 100 years ago.
If we go back 200 years, that circle is even smaller. And I encourage everyone, particularly the board that I'm proud to work for, to continue to uphold policies that make that circle larger, not smaller. At Freebrook High School, we teach all of your students.
We don't expect them to be a certain way or behave a certain way to be deserving of an educational opportunity. They walk into the classroom, we meet them where they are, and we teach them to the best of our ability. And that's why I love working here. It's why I love working for this district. Every student who walks through the doors of Freeport High School should be free from bullying, discrimination, and policies that make them feel unsafe in their own schools. And those students who go here should be forced to justify their own existence.
I urge the board to continue to uphold policies that reflect our responsibility to protect our students. That's less about politics, and it's more that every child, irrespective of gender, can learn, grow, and thrive in an environment that upholds their dignity.
Thank you. Thank you, Tim. Okay, so I think we have everyone that was on our list, so I will just take a quick moment to thank everyone who got up and spoke this evening and spoke from their heart. And I would like to just take a special thanks to all of the students who got up.
I know this is, someone said they don't like speaking in public. I don't think any of us do, but to do it as a high school student is pretty incredible. So I want to thank you especially for taking the time to do that. So, yes, thank you all. Oh, we had one more on the list.
Oh, I'm sorry. Sorry. All that still holds after this one person speaks. Hi, I'm Grace. I'm from Freeport, and I want to speak to you today about what a lot of people have been talking about with the Title IX issue. It's been really shocking and appalling to see people from outside of the RSU-5 community speak on this issue because I think this should be an RSU-5 community issue.
As someone who was born female, identifies as non-binary, it's also really, really painful to see adults, adults who've lived longer than me, parents, speaking about the experience of teenagers and young people and telling us what it should mean for us to be safe.
i can't imagine feeling any less safe with my trans and non-binary friends playing alongside me i was an athlete at freeport for most of my life my childhood and i can't imagine feeling any less safe having my trans and non-binary friends on my side where they want to be where they feel
welcome and can have fun and most importantly feel safe um i do not understand why there are so many people here tonight so insistent that my safety as a girl as someone born female should be under their conditions um they do not know about my safety they do not know about our safety um
and i can't um remain silent when the rights of women are being conflated with the rights of everyone else and i believe that we can all work together to work towards a future where we all can feel safe together thank you thank you grace okay so uh we have a full agenda uh which we are
going to continue to work on um and starting with with our budget conversations so i just want to remind folks you are welcome and encouraged to stay through the whole board meeting uh we just ask that um as we continue the work of the board uh we just ask for folks to to remain quiet in the
crowd as we move forward with the agenda with we're going to the report from the superintendent item 8. February 24th the 28th is celebrating public schools week an annual celebration dedicated to recognizing the transformative power of public education. We honor our exceptional
educators and staff who work tirelessly to provide quality education to our students each and every day. We honor our families and caregivers who are champions of their children's education. We honor our community members who support and partner with us to make our work
possible. Celebrating Public Schools Week shines a spotlight on the critical role our public schools play in shaping the future of our communities and our nation. Public education represents opportunity and the shared belief that every child, all children, deserve a chance to learn,
grow, belong, and succeed. Number two, resignations, Jennifer Hayward, FMS Educational Technician. And number three, we have one new support staff hire, Kathy DeGrandpre, who is going to be our community programs office coordinator and we welcome her to the rsu 5 team and
that's the end of my report this evening thank you so this is where we're going to move up the budget discussion yes item 12 so we will move on to number 12 in your agenda unfinished business budget review we are going to start with the
region 10 technical high school good evening hopefully everybody can hear me Great, thank you. My name is Sybil Brewer. I am the business manager at Region 10 Technical High School. Normally, our superintendent director, Sean Shabbat, would be here to present,
and unfortunately, well, maybe fortunately for him, he is in Bangor. He is serving our National Guard, so he has asked me to come in his stay. Normally, he would be up here standing tall and comfortable, and I'm going to stand here not tall and not comfortable. So I'll do my best. I am used
to being on the bench running the numbers and not running the plays. So as a quintessential football mother, I can try to do my best, and I am quite loud, so I will definitely be able to call an audible. There we go. Got a few laughs. I'm good to go. So our budget is before you, hopefully.
It's two sheets. We've got a green here. And then the other sheet is our budget drivers. I'm going to try to make this as brief as possible. Obviously, I'm not comfortable behind the mic. So for our background, we entered all of our gathered data for the initial budget entry,
and that was a little over $363,000 more than the previous year. It was an 8.99% increase. So, we talked with our finance committee and discussed their vision on what they felt was a favorable budget to bring forth, and they had given us some information, and our superintendent
director made adjustments, which resulted in a little over $103,000 removed from the initial entry of the budget. The adjusted budget was presented to our full cooperative board on Monday night. After some discussion, there was a motion to adjust the funding, which was removed,
which resulted in $6,100 being added back to our adjusted draft budget. So the budget you have in front of you shows all of those changes. So our proposed budget for FY26, for Region 10, is $4,312,957. It is a 6.59% increase from the previous year.
We also have our revenues. We do have a new program starting next year. It is called the Engineering and Architectural Design Program. And so that you'll notice that we do have more funding from the state. And that is the reason why. And then our breakdown for the assessments, the local share,
you'll see that Freeport rides in at $307,645. It is an increase of $17,978 at a 6.21% increase. Our budget drivers, which is the second page, our salaries for teachers and ed techs and our two custodians are actually a blended rate of all three schools. Because of that, we wait for the contracts to be negotiated.
We have two open contracts for teachers this year, so we had to kind of look ahead and see possibly what it could be. We did put those in as an estimated 6%. And then we also have our OneMove program, which is a higher step to hopefully attract for that design program.
And we also have a 4% increase for our nurse. The ed techs have a 4% increase. They're also in contracts for blended salaries. And our admin salaries are at a 4% increase. Our assistant director, John Steiders, who's here tonight, is actually going to retire at the end of the year. So we have used the blended rate of our assistant principals at all three sending schools to work on that vacancy salary.
We have our non-contract salaries at 4%, and then our custodians are at, their contract increase is also at the blended rate. We had one open contract, so we put that at 6%, and then a 4% increase for our maintenance foreman. Obviously, our salaries run most of our budget.
Then the other budget drivers, as you can see, We have an 8% estimated increase for our benefits. We have our Maine paid family leave at 0.5% for the full year. JMG, Jobs for Maine Graduates, this is their third year with us.
And after the second year, we had a contract with them, which was half of their normal contracted rate. This year, at the third year, we have to pay the full. So that is obviously a driver. And then we have a new collaboration with Maine Maritime Academy and BIW.
And we are going to hold our new program over at the Wayfair Building with collaboration with Maine Maritime. So that is the one class. That's obviously an increase for our budget. And then our Honeywell Maintenance Agreement for our HVAC system. It's now aging. it's five years old, so we have moved that to a comprehensive service, and that also is a driver.
So that's our full breakdown. The total budget in the last three years for RSU-5, our portion of your district budget has been only 0.70%. So we've stayed at that for the last three years. So with that, I was wondering if anybody had any questions. Thank you.
questions for the region 10 budget thank you so much civil for this information um do you know offhand the 103 that you said thousand that was removed and then the 6100 that was added back yes I apologize if I missed this
but what that was you wanted to know what it was it was actually a program field trips that was one of the things that we had discussed and the board felt that that was an impaired and paramounted piece of the student enrichment so it was put back in the budget so the whole hundred thousand
wasn't field trips no okay no just the sixty one hundred dollars that the board asked to be put back okay the rest of the amount obviously we look through the budget one of the one of the bigger things that we did was look at three year costs and we worked very hard to kind of make sure that we weren't taking
away from programs to make it harder for them. But we also made sure that if, you know, within three years, you know, if things weren't spent, we kind of looked at it with a very fine tooth comb and made sure that we were making the right adjustments. Great. I have one question on the
increased subsidy for the new program. Yes. So is that a sustained subsidy over time? Is that a one time to get you up and running? Is that used for equipment purchases? Like what, how does that work? So usually from what I understand from the state is that the first year of our new program,
it's usually three years that we get influx of money to start that program. And then after that third year, yes, it does come down from there. But we also then have that in the system with a new teacher. And so that also helps our EPS. But the first three years, yes, they do give us a slight
influx to help that program get off the ground okay great thank you other questions on region 10 thank you great thank you very much hold on before you leave colin has something you do an amazing job thank you sir appreciate that thank you thank you all right uh so next we have uh freeport
middle and i believe page is presenting for us this evening got another sub up at bat here good evening uh thanks for having me here to present the proposed freeport middle school budget tonight i'm going to ask you to move the mic up a little bit closer i know we'll move it up and down and
yeah there we go um my name is dr page fornier i'm the assistant principal at freeport middle and i'm here to present on behalf of principal saint pierre i want to thank you all for the hard work that you do to support the amazing teaching and learning that occurs here in rsu5 so thanks
and looking at last year's budget additional days were added to the assistant principal position it's kind of funny for me to be talking about that but here i am thanks for that um it gave valuable work time outside of the busy school year um and that was helpful in preparing for
the coming year particularly with lots of changes at freeport middle this year the 25-26 fms budget reflects a focus on reducing expenditures while maintaining our commitment to delivering a rich educational experience for all students. As you can see in the workshop
presentation, the first reduction mentioned is the retirement position. While this retirement position is currently filled by a seventh grade science teacher, I want to ensure the board and the community that science will remain a content in all grade levels at FMS. Science has been an
important focus, lots of hard work and dedication by teachers for many years, and it's evident in strong main science assessment scores integrating hands-on learning experiences within our community and these experience are valued in our current
model and will continue to be facets at FMS in the coming year. STEM has also been a rich component of our science-based experience at FMS and as we look beyond the budget decisions we'll be creative and collaborative in our
approach to ensure that these rich experiences continue. The second reduction indicated in the workshop presentation is the teacher position currently filled by a few part-time positions. These positions serve as grade level, specific grade levels in ELA and math,
and the class sizes are indicated that will be impacted on the second chart that you have in front of you. It's complicated to look at the calculations for class sizes when we're not looking at a k-5 it's not like a third grade or a fourth grade it's a lot of moving parts to this
and it can be tricky to determine so we're in the early stages of planning for next year and so some of the variables that we're looking at that could impact these are the schedule the adult support the small groups that might be pulled out of that so those would all be sort
of picture chess pieces moving around to ensure that we're keeping an eye on the thresholds and appropriate programming for each of the cohorts and their needs. Thoughtful planning to address all three grade levels will be important as well as flexible approach to staffing. We're also
proposing the reduction of a general ed ed tech. This position has been unfilled all year. Unfortunately, it's been challenging to hire ed techs. I do want to mention that we have been able to fill all the special ed ed tech positions with really strong candidates, and that's
been really beneficial for some of the students that have significant needs in our building. As far as the staffing adjustments to the budget in the RTI position, it is currently filled by two teachers. The shift would be to one teacher in a position to support students across the building in
the grade levels. This would allow the educator to be at team meetings across grade levels, support students sort of the continuum of services and lead the MTSS structures in our building. So happy to answer questions or anything that you might have.
Beth. I'll start with thank you for the presentation. Yeah, sorry, a little noise. Thank you. I was just, my first question, we'll start with this. why the budget neutral adjustment with the half-time ELA and half-time RTI math with it
being budget neutral and we've heard from people that are concerned that that would not be a good idea so I'm wondering what is the justification on your end of that yeah so I can speak to what we're talking about what I mentioned before the idea I think is consistency across the building
um with two part-time people that is a little bit more challenging depending on when they arrive at school or being able to attend all meetings so they'd be embedded in the building all day and so as we've done with some of the coaching that like i was a previous coach that was a
not specific to a content um we've also done that kind of approach where they're generalized versus like a specific to a content and i think i'll just jump in with the other piece of i think Beth's question as well. Beth, they were asking, like, it's budget neutral, so why is it here for
the board? I think that was for the middle school one to be transparent about their thinking for next year. That's why it's on this budget. Cara? Thank you, Dr. Fournier. I don't usually use that. That is what I'm tonight for you all. This must be really hard, like, being told that the budget's
going to be really tight and that cuts need to be made and so I'm I want to recognize that for all of the programs um and I also I'm I'm curious how it was decided that these were the positions that were to be cut how science was the position that was one of the was it was a chosen position to be
cut in particular um and yeah oh yeah I guess we'll start with that I know sorry I'm I'm sort here as a spokesperson but I'm happy to answer like been there for a long time have a lot of historical knowledge about how we value science and it's been a focus for us and it will continue
to be but the process I'm happy to jump in with that answer uh and you're right Carrie it's certainly a difficult budget year we're looking at every program um at each school but also as an administrator we've mentioned before as an administrative team level as well um what we
might do and I think the as the as the middle school was looking at their certainly as we had some retirements coming they're looking at at the number of students and looking at programming we're looking at you know some equity of programming that that made a made sense that that position would be
reduced because there were there were five folks and through some of some structural restructuring that so kids would still continue to receive a high quality education in both STEM and science so that's where they landed on that that particular position so can you say more about how the students will
continue to receive that education between both STEM and science and so that's where the creative planning is going to come what the plan is for the creative planning question so we would have had a scheduling committee meeting
this week but without principal st. Pierre we didn't hold that so there's some flexibility in how we look at things as other schools have talked about particularly like Durham is talking about looking at how you service students with unified arts or with varied
scheduling so the core of science being at every grade level would be the start how we focus on STEM could be like STEM teachers at various times of the day or servicing multiple grade levels if it went that way it could be it's like a matrix that we'll have to build when we know what the
numbers really are and probably start contingency of like how we could build STEM at every grade level in this way or focusing on numbers so class sizes and thresholds meet where we all feel comfortable for that cohort because each cohort's needs can vary too so I know that's not a direct
to answer. Could I have sort of a follow-up question on that? I just want to ensure both for myself and for folks watching, every child at Freeport Middle School will get both science and STEM, correct? They do now. They do now, right? I understand that. But the intention is
that we'll continue. I would assume we would try to do that. We're so early in this. I haven't been a part of all of those conversations i mean if they're part of if they're part of a unified art then that would be a possibility if we prioritize it at a grade level it may fall that way too
it would depend how um we look at those things and you know i mean every day right like they don't get science every day right but um they don't currently get it every day depending on how each grade level does it so this is the thing we've built like so many different schedules we're
actually famous for having a variety of different schedules each grade level has a different schedule and a model that's specific to the needs so sixth graders at our school have you know hex semesters so six weeks of things and they may not have stem during that six week span whereas in
seventh grade it might be they do trimesterly times and so they may move through things in different time frames. So there are lots of creative ways to do these things. The idea would be that every grade level would get access to STEM and science, and making that happen though,
if you prioritized some different need, you might have it be that one grade level gets more than another grade level. So does that make sense? Yeah, no, that sort of, yes, that starts my understanding. And I could just add one other thing, Paige, is that at the middle school you
have your your committee scheduling it's it's also that there there are teachers at the table and having a voice in those those scheduling decisions yes here i'm just gonna i'm gonna and then we'll jump back to you so i saw danielle first and then we'll go to anna so my kids went
to durham and um i'm just a little confused how the science and stem thing works at freeport currently so i was just hoping you can explain it because you know at durham it it um evolved from when my daughter was there to when my son was there to where it was um stem was considered
a special so they had it once a week and then initially or then later it went to every five or six weeks if i'm correct every six weeks um i can't count my specials um so i'm just wondering how it works now so that i can kind of envision how you're gonna move this because i science is
every day at durham community school so yeah you say it could not be maybe at freeport so i'm just kind of wondering where we are now yeah thank you and this is where um you almost need a whiteboard like it's complicated at each grade i will would you like to i know i know he does a good chart for
us because we never understand these things so picture there's language arts math science social studies and STEM are offerings. And how each grade level at our school hits those offerings varies. So in sixth grade, there's hexmesters. So a student for six weeks might have ELA, math,
social studies, and STEM. And then the next six weeks, they would maybe have a different rotation of science, social studies, and STEM. So it's six-week switches. In the seventh grade, they'll have two out of the three trimesters they'll have stem so it would be it's the same ordering of like
a switch of science social studies and stem that rotates but it's trimesterly in eighth grade it's every three days so it's a three-day rotation so it's bananas when you look at a schedule all together but that's how they've programmed and and that's been driven by sixth graders need
consistency every single day having them flow through three different schedules a three-day rotation we found was really hard whereas having the same teachers all day every day in this for six week span was helpful in seventh grade there's a lot of autonomy and like how we've been looking
at these like team needs too so teams felt like that was the best way they could program and I would envision that we would get creative in the same way as cohorts have specific needs teams know what they can provide and how they provide them um and then sometimes they you know they get even
more creative on how they do those things with flex blocks of time where they're building in a whole different schedule and having extended periods where they're immersed in something thank you i'm new to the you probably want to get closer to your mic okay closer than you think you
need to be how's this um thank you i'm obviously new to the board so um this is all new for me but i think what was concerning me the most is all the communications we got directly from teachers at freeport middle school that i would think know the their students the best um and we're talking
veteran teachers here who, you know, have a lot of experience working with kids and talking about how a lot of kids are entering the middle school with unidentified learning disabilities and huge challenges. We heard from a teacher tonight about more kids experiencing trauma in our 35 years of
teaching, and I'm hearing a lot of, like, it's going to be creative scheduling and planning, and I know this is obviously a really difficult budget year but I guess in my naivete as a new board member like is there any other way that it just seems like I'm just concerned that these staff reductions
are going to really hurt the most vulnerable students and I guess wondering if you are concerned about that at all or if it if you feel like there's any other way that yeah I mean I've been a i was a special ed teacher for 20 years of like self-contained students of the most
vulnerable population we have and of course i mean it keeps us all up at night that's why we do the things we do so the level of concern that we have though i mean i think if we can be creative in the way that we move things around we can meet the needs of students um i do think like to acknowledge
it's challenging work it always is and our staff is amazing though and the things that they do are amazing and we um i think an rti position i'm glad that that's not moving that we have that still because that is vital work so that being it's a shift but if that was going to be cut that would
be a worry and we're still going to have some of like that person who's overseeing all of those things and that's really the work that needs to be done um I can maybe this is a question for our finance director but I was I know basically what the full-time
teacher amount is in the budget what is the exist because I'm looking for a dollar amount that the reductions equal out to so we have two full-time teachers which we budget for it like 108 each 104 and then what is the general ed tech position budgeted so just to clarify on the ed tech position
because we did hear some feedback both in letters and I think even some folks tonight had mentioned the importance of maintaining the ed techs that we have at the school because they're helping with absenteeism and which has obviously been
a goal and a focus for all the schools in the district well every year but particularly this year when we were seeing numbers that were concerning my understanding is the position that we're looking to not fill has not been filled so we are not displacing we're not taking away someone that's currently in the building this is basically saying we had a spot that we couldn't fail so
we're not going to collect the money to pay for someone we can't hire anyway is that accurate correct assessment okay so we're not saying you're not cutting anybody after tomorrow says say that again you saw the resignation we actually
have now we'll have two unfilled right right so okay I just want to make sure I understood that correctly that that what the proposal here isn't to eliminate someone in a position but to just not fill a position or not re-up a position that we haven't been able to fill correct okay Maura
thank you Dr. Fournier appreciate you filling in in Amy's absence could you speak to the impact of the absence of having somebody in that unfilled position um it's been the way that we've used ed techs like we have been targeting um some really awesome work around re-entering students when
they've been absent and making them feel wrapped up in their supports um through some of these positions but what they've been used for has varied year to year so um there was initially like they'd be at grade level connected i think was the initial thought behind some of those things
they've morphed into more of like where can where are their strengths of areas of people um what are their skill sets and then that's how all those positions kind of go is like where an ed tech might be placed and what the roles they do but that specific unfilled one it
wasn't like i'm not positive what it was aligned for like the specific it's not like it was a science teacher or something specific ed techs we sort of build the programming as the needs arise okay that's helpful thank you and how many ed techs do we currently have i guess without the
one who just resigned was that resigned that's tricky too because we have some part-time ed techs as well so some of the positions we're talking about there's like a part-time ed tech connected to like a section of a teaching role so and jeans telling me we okay our handbook
so I can I can refer to that the actual yes on page for folks in in your budget handbook on page 5 we did a breakdown for regular ed and special education at each school how many they how many there are there so if Freeport Middle
school for Jen are there if there are 4.3 and we didn't the special as you know so we did a whole total there because there's so they oftentimes text move with it with it with the student for example hip and middle school a big population middle school that went to the high school than that there might be a tech better move there so we did those for for special education the total
number but but for the gen ed ed text we did them by school and that 4.3 includes the unfilled position. So the 3.3. So right now, as of tomorrow, after this resignation, we have 2.3 actually in the building. But hopefully we'll get back up to 3.3 and replace that. But as you said, that's more individuals because it's made up of part pieces of positions. It's that weird point because it's like, yeah, there's some part-time positions that have some teaching bits and some ed tech bits. Right, right, okay, gotcha. I just have one last question about that ed tech piece is there typically like a
ratio so I know we have the ratio like the class sizes but do we have a staffing ratio for ed techs to student population or does it depend on me particularly in gen ed because general ed techs because they can be utilized in
a variety of ways and so sort of school dependent on many of those decisions like I say like some are using RTIB things some are using it in like what we're doing supporting cohorts of students in a variety of ways so yeah they could be in a
classroom embedded there's been a lot of that in our school co-teaching or co you know servicing students pulling them out it could be that they're meeting individually with students for like structured studies or the cool program that we've been doing this year that was referenced was
if a student's been out for more than say three days and a tech will help collect work work with that student for a couple of blocks get them back on track so it's not that barrier of feeling overwhelmed when you've been out which we found was a big factor in absenteeism for
students they just it's overwhelming to see the list of things and so that's been a really awesome thing that's happened this year in our building but we haven't always done that thank you all right I'm gonna go back to Kara because I know I cut off her list earlier um so I have two
questions, but I can try to stick to one. Following up on the EdTech piece, do we know how long that position's been vacant? Was it filled the year prior? We had a person in that position that was shifted actually to a special education role at one point because that was the priority
for that, but we haven't had that particular position filled all year. Okay. And when was that listing for the position removed? Like, has that been up all along and available for people to it has and I'm looking at Kelly because I don't know when that was taken down or
not yeah and I'm not and I'm not sure exactly exactly when that was but we've had difficulty as you know finding a text and the district's priority is filling those special ed texts as well because though by by law we're required
to fulfill students IEP so that's sort of where we had some there for a little bit and they shifted to specialized because that's what they need where the need was can i ask my other question or okay um going back to the creative planning piece i think
i'd like to hear more about the plan for that you mentioned something about you um once you have the numbers like student numbers you'll be able to do that can you say more about how important that part is or is it just a matter of like this is going to be really hard creativity might not actually
meet the students needs it's going to be different um it's going to be different for us to look at it this way um and so being creative means all of us we met as a staff today and i talked about us you know meeting in team meetings not just in our scheduling committee team um meeting because
there are thoughts i think people are daunted by the idea of like a scheduling committee because that's like the structure of building like times and structures in power school feels like yeah not my cup of tea whereas I have ideas about how we can um have students have touch points on
really important things that we believe in and so it's I envision it um and I can't speak to what Amy envisions it as because you know I mean we've talked some about this but what as we've been moving through it would be like what do we value how is this cohort going to do the best with
the things and then what are their needs like in sixth grade like I said we decided that having stem every single day it was better to have a consistent schedule with the same teachers that was what we found worked best and so it'll be that same creative process of looking at how we can
make sure that students are getting stem and science the answer to that is we're still in the developing stages of that so it's and maybe it's too early to say the answer to this but is the envision do you guys envision fewer minutes of those content areas or is it how they're
delivered or when they're delivered is different so you know I guess I always think of with with fewer teachers and the same number of kids we either have more kids in the room or we have fewer minutes to less kids in the room so I guess I'm interested to hear if one I'm completely off
in my how I'm looking at it or to which of those two is kind of where where everybody's heads at at this point right um it I honestly don't know how we're gonna do all that you know there could be there's all kinds of schedules that have an a b schedule where you could have like I was saying
like some teacher could be teaching multiple grade levels like there's lots of different things um investigating other districts kind of schedules and approaches to that as well i'm sure we'll be part of that process um we haven't met as that team yet so i'm not positive
but does i mean and i know it's different because durham only has one sort of set of each content area but um you know the idea of teams and running it the same way is that is that a possibility or is that no it doesn't work for us because of no it's been you know it's been something we've
considered for a long time. As a special ed teacher, it was tricky to have three different schedules, but we also are a really flexible school. We're small enough that we've been able to make lots of different things work and adapt. This year, it's been wonderful because so many of
our students, the special ed staff has been co-teaching. Much of their program is happening in a co-teaching model. And so flexibility around those things also impact schedules like GT, part-time teachers, like all of these things like also impact scheduling. And so to say it's
complicated is like just not enough to say. But yeah, I think we can get creative with the way that we do these things. Thank you. I just wanted to clarify, we recently had the opportunity to visit the middle school, which was really great. And we got to see you and some of your students.
yeah so thank you so much for that yeah and I have an impression from Amy that this scheduling so please correct me if I'm wrong regardless of whether these positions stay in place or not this scheduling committee is going to take
place and you're going to look at changing the schedule at the middle school is that correct I I would assume that that changes will be made okay the scheduling changes oh yeah okay I just wanted to clarify because when we taught had talked about that I wasn't there for that that was my understanding as well
as that they would regardless of what happened here that there was folks that were said we really need to look at the schedule okay and that there would be teacher involvement in that schedule okay that was what I was wondering that
the schedule committee wasn't necessarily driven by the staffing changes but that it might happen regardless of whether the board like I say we've changed the schedule lots of years lots yeah so that is a flex that we're in here great um I had some questions about the RTI too unless my
questions are about the RTI so I'm wondering how many and I understand you might not know the exact numbers I mean this is something you can get to us but you're taking two positions into one is that one RTI person going to be
overloaded with now supporting students on both sides and with two different subjects and is there a limit to again you know you can only have 20 cases I don't know so I guess that's part of my other part of the question um so it's 2.5 positions that would be mushed into one so the you know the
impact wouldn't necessarily the the amount of students that they would service would be similar was that one of your questions yes but if there's 30 math kids and there's 30 English kids right it's English um that's now 60 kids for one person is is that too much is it so there is that really
fair to the kids yeah so we looked at um there's about so the thing about RTI instruction too is that it's typically in like six week stints that we're looking at students as needs arise and that's driven by data, that's driven by teacher recommendations, parent concerns, all of these
different factors. Each grade level, the needs might vary as well. So there's between six and nine students coming from mass landing. That again, when I reached out to Emily, that can vary too depending on, you're hoping they're growing and getting out of that MTSS system and just not
needing the services once they've gotten the intervention at the middle level it's varied so sometimes teachers are pulling students from the beginning of a math block and giving them a pump up sort of or like a pre-teach sometimes the rti model is that they're pulling them out
for a structured study sometimes they're meeting them at bcs and providing that so the numbers are tricky to understand like who's being serviced currently there's five students in RTI ELA in our building as far as the pullout that they're getting but there are also other classes that are
addressing things with supports so RTI is like a complicated framework of how we service students and the services that we provide so picture six weeks there might be 10 students that are getting something and then the next six weeks it might be there's four left that still require those
but the other six are exiting because all they needed was a boost. The one person would be overseeing that though and I think the vision is sort of to embed in team meetings, give some support. We're starting that work on identifying students, setting goals, and then tracking that
with teachers as well and so that teacher could oversee that as well um just thinking also about the rt um shuffle around um and you know thinking about the comment that we heard around um you know being specialized in the math area and then being specialized in the ela area and um is it common
to find somebody that's specialized specializes in both of those um areas like do you think that this is going to be i understand like the consistency argument but i just um also get concerned about the actual instruction yeah i mean you're hoping for that dynamo that you get
i mean i can't speak to who that person would be or what it would look like um lots of the approaches to RTI are sort of like you're looking at, you're identifying skills, you're using some pre-assessment, whether you're an expert in that or not, and then you're focusing on the skills that
that pre-assessment is identifying, and you're targeting them for the next six weeks. That's why lots of times ed techs are highly involved in that process too, because they aren't necessarily like an expert in all of these content places, but they can still give the supports that we're identifying.
that student needs a check-in, they need a frequent, they need a chart, they need prompting to this, they need some basic skill building around those things. And so it just can vary so greatly. I'm going to jump back to Maura's question while we're still talking about RTI.
Thanks. Please forgive me. Could you say the part about the EdTech support again in coordination with RTI? yeah so um that's another way that we've used ed techs so ed techs and general ed have done that side of work i know other buildings have they've identified someone as like say an rtib or an rtia
like academic or behavioral and so some of that work is students might need assistance with writing or initiating the writing task or something and so currently some of the ed techs that we even have do that or they carry over work or they support teachers and their RTI
work mm-hmm thank you that's helpful um and also forgive me if we have this information already but how many folks do we have that provide RTI we have the two right okay okay yeah it is the two moving into one and that's it there's no
one else okay I guess I'm also thinking of folks who provide differentiated instruction but they maybe that's different position embedded in in other their positions yeah how we right I mean the goal is that everybody's differentiating all the time
and that the more our teachers are that was some of the work that that I did as a coach too was focusing on giving all teachers resources and things in their toolbox so they can differentiate so how we differentiate for our students our teachers are great at that we're always exploring
new ways to do that but the RTI is like a much more identified sort of process that we're talking about I know this is not a deliberation but I just feel I feel concerned about these these cuts and I think we've heard a lot from the
community about this and we've heard concerns about the level of services already provided to students at the middle school and I think we've heard concerns about students needs being met so I guess I'll just say if we're I
already have a sense from that there are some families who feel their students are not receiving the services that they and supports that they need so it concerns me to have even further cuts I think if we I think if I already had the
sense so just wanted to bring up that feedback that we had gotten and I don't know if you want to speak to that at all, Dr. Fournier, but if I think if I already had the sense that folks were saying, oh, I feel like we're getting really robust supports in the school,
I would be less, you know, I would, I'd be more open to this, but I guess that's all. Yeah, I mean, we can certainly chat about that more on the deliberation side. I think, you know, very rarely do we get an email that goes, you're doing a great job, thanks for that.
I mean, it's just a different type of communication that we get. I mean, we heard people today get up and say, my kids have gotten a fantastic education here. Thank you so much, right? So, I mean, it's all sort of anecdotal that way, but it's certainly noted to obviously part of the conversation.
Did I see more hands up over here? No, I'm going to move back this way. Questions for you guys? I had a question, and maybe I misheard you. did you say that two and a half positions were going into one position? No, two half. Two half,
pause, two, pause, half. Okay, got it. 2.5. It's like, where's the other half position? Okay. Was part of the, that idea around the RTI, it's an interesting one for me because obviously it's, it's budget neutral. So it's really about the, the delivery of instruction, which is a little more,
you know administrator driven and less board driven because it's not a it's not a finance question but um i know in the past few years we have moved our strategists away from literary strategists math strategists to just instructional strategists um i was curious if this move was
kind of in alignment with that or separate from that do you know i honestly don't know okay i I guess I'll turn it to Jean and us. Jean? I think that's certainly a good analogy that we did just that this past year, change our strategies to they're not specific for math or ELA.
They're looking at the total picture, and I think the piece of this is where the thought behind this was also to look at the total child and the total child's needs. And I know historically we have oftentimes struggled to fill half-time positions.
it sounds like that's not a challenge right now. We have folks in both of those two halftime positions that seem very, very happy with those positions. So, I mean, that was just another thing in the back of my head around, you know, people's life circumstances change. People come, people go.
We see it all the time on our agendas. I was also wondering if this was sort of in place to say, you know, it's hard to find a halftime people if there's ever a transition. I know in the past, we've had that issue as a board, where we couldn't fill halftime positions. And, you know,
a full time position is an easier position to fill. I don't know, I'm sort of, this is an interesting one. I was curious, we've talked a fair amount about the science and the STEM and the delivery, I'm definitely interested in hearing, you know, in terms of other information
we'd like to have. I guess I would like to know, and I guess it also applies to the ELA and the math, but we've kind of seen differing numbers in our chart, right? So our chart says the range, the class size range with the proposed levels is basically 18 to 21, which is the target for six
to eight, threshold being 24. But then we also heard some feedback that that's maybe not an accurate assessment of what the classes would look like. And I'm not sure how we would know that yet because you guys haven't done that scheduling work. But I guess I would just want to see if
there's any clarification or, you know, is there misunderstanding when we're seeing, you know, numbers coming in that no no the classes would be 24 and up because that for me that's a very different discussion than you know 18 to 21 so yeah so say um and this wouldn't this is why it's
still in the matrix but um sixth and seventh grade is the bigger cohorts right so those are the ones that really we need to look at um but say you aligned a stem teacher with just those two and that wouldn't work because we wouldn't be hitting it in eighth. So we'd want to get more creative and thinking around that. But if we did that, the class sizes would be like 19, 20, 23, or 22. So
that would be more within the threshold that we're talking about. You're right. If we, if we didn't do that, um, and we just had four content, we're back to like our whiteboard where we're doing like these four, that would be beyond that. And so it's something that we just wouldn't want to do if it
was like a cohort that couldn't handle that at 20 particularly if it was like 25 right so um and right now our do we have three stem teachers and three science teachers we do oh wow so it's a lot cleaner right right so it's easy to just align whereas durham we have a stem teacher for pre-k
pre-k eight interesting it's a lot of moving parts yes uh we'll start with more and then we'll go to daniel thanks michelle um i i don't think we've touched on the the reduction of the 0.75 ele teacher yet and the 0.25 math teacher could you could you speak to that in depth a little more it's the same
as us talking about these like class sizes um you know they they were bits of things that were attached to different like grade levels so there's a 0.25 ELA teacher in sixth 0.25 ELA in math and then a 0.5 ELA in seven and eight and so you're looking at class sizes that's sort of where it
correlates to it that will be the main impact yeah that is a bit more like in that k5 kind of approach where you're talking about other reductions that we've talked about in the district it's about it's that same kind of feel okay thank you so now i have two questions i'm sorry okay so
so i just like to know the number of teachers so for the middle school you have three stem three science how many ela currently then um so this is where it gets weird again right so we have we have three and then there's some of these extra things so there's a 0.25
in sixth. There's a teacher that teaches one class of English in sixth. There's a teacher that teaches one class of English in seventh and one class of English in eighth. Is that the same person? Nope. Okay. Two different people. So then I'm sure you know my next question. How many in
math? Yeah. So math is even trickier because there's an accelerated math teacher who is shared with Durham so there's a 0.5 there and then there's some GT as well and there's a 0.5 and 6 so which um I mean a 0.25 which is one core class so there's um so in six there's a GT class
or an accelerated sorry an accelerated math class and another core class on top of the math classes that are already happening and then in seven and eight there's um accelerated math for seven and eight on top of the regular core teacher okay does that make sense yeah I kind of
I know this is where it's really complicated with all of our part-time folks and how they service at it so then my real question but I'd raised my hand for was I think there was mention of the minimum amount of substitutes out there
right and that some of these part-time people like the part and I hate to say part-time but the 0.5 RTI people were providing some of that support with substituting do we think we're gonna lose that so that was from the yeah it's
from the ed tech I mean on a tough sub day like today I was two teachers in the morning and then another teacher later like the first two blocks until we got a sub I mean it's all hands on deck so yes subs can be challenging to find and so
it can be like block by block we've had teachers cover during their prep and get paid for that too so that's where that comes from yeah it the sub it continues to be something that's an issue have a gold page enough do we have more
questions I mean I'm sure we will but yeah Kelly has a question is the EdTech dollar amount question yes so I just wanted to respond to that we had originally toyed with 104, so sorry. It's actually 102, 102,000 per teacher, and it's 48,600. And
that's not just salary. I just want to remind everybody that is like the true cost of the teacher, that salary and benefits and payroll taxes and all those types of things. So we use those numbers for when we budgeted. If we were to add, those were the numbers to use. And as we
take away those are the numbers we use as well thank you all right um i don't know who's next who's next uh transportation jeremy the gentleman walking to the microphone good evening i'm jeremy arsenal the intern transportation director the budgetary requests for the transportation
department focus on ensuring students are transported to school and programming safely Staffing adjustments to budget in FY25, reduction of two school year driving positions that had remained unfilled. Staffing adjustments to budget in FY26, mechanic position not funded.
Other significant FY26 requests in budget, in need, supplies, equipment, etc. Fleet maintenance, purchased repairs and supplies, $40,204. Bus replacement lease adjustment, $4,338. The Implementation of Vehicle and Equipment Replacement Plan, Phase 1, which includes a three-year lease purchase, $163,662.
Superintendent's recommendation is to offset with undesignated fund balance. The Phase 1 of the Vehicle and Equipment Plan includes the following replacements. Transportation, two buses, two student vans, maintenance, one grounds truck, one mower slash tractor.
miscellaneous other field maintenance equipment okay um sorry i was writing down two student vans okay i have this tendency to write half a thought and then when i look at it later i'm like i have no idea what i meant um sorry about that so uh thank you jeremy uh my question around the mechanic
piece um is essentially the mechanic piece and the purchase repairs and supplies sort of an offset for each other like we haven't found a mechanic necessarily so without that mechanic we would basically just send out the repairs? Correct. Okay. I feel like we ask you every time we see you,
but how are we doing for our bus drivers? We've actually gained a new one. She started last week. So are we... I didn't use one. It's one for one, but... Okay. So are we... Sorry. So are we... We're still in progress, yes. So we're still looking for how many?
We're still looking for, I think we have two full time... Three. Family, friends, family. I've got applications i'm a school board member i can't do it right but you said friends if you have friends right i have a family member oh yeah rich cannot drive a bus yeah anyone who's seen jean park in
the parking lot knows where she doesn't get to drive the bus um this is i'm not saying a word uh other questions for jeremy thank you very much all right so i think nutrition erica so did you guys eat dinner before this? Just eat the cookies. I love that the nutrition person made sure we were
eating our dinner. Thank you for that. It's important. So staying consistent with previous year's budget reports, our program is in a good spot. We are continuing to feed a high volume of students every day, over 217,000 meals this year to be exact so far. Participation rates across
the district are leveling out and starting to find their place. This is the first year in a few years that the program hasn't seen massive spikes in our mill camps, but as you know, student enrollment across the district this year compared to last year is a little bit lower. A couple of
FY25 stats so far. Our average monthly operating expenses are about $157,000, up about $33,000 comparatively to this time last year. Food expenses are a major contributing factor for that. If you've been in a grocery store recently and seen the price of eggs, I'm sure you understand why. Our average breakfast participation in district is about 38% and lunch participation is around 65%.
Looking at staffing for school year 26, as you can see in the workshop, There are no changes to positions or staffing hours for next year. We are adequately staffed based on this year's meal counts, and we do still have an open position at the high school, which is sat open all year.
Additionally, if we were to see a cut in our federal funding, we would likely expect to see a drop in meal participation, which wouldn't warrant an upward increase to staff hours. We'll see where that goes. Budget for next year, the nutrition program is requesting $139,000 or so from the general fund, which is a decrease of about 25% from the $185,000 or so in school year 25.
This is due to the continued success of the program. We are serving literal truckloads of local food. Apples are coming in weekly from an orchard in Bloomington. I personally picked up fish, Maine fish caught right off the coast here in Portland through
the Fisherman Feeding Mainers Program. I've pledged our program to participate in the DOE Maine Harvest of the Month, which is a campaign that promotes the use of seasonally available local products in our schools. Each month is highlighting a different harvest, local potatoes, root vegetables, Maine protein,
dairy products, to name a few. This is all to say that, rest assured, a decrease in local contribution does not mean we are starting to serve Twinkies to our students during lunches. The nutrition program is in a great spot financially. Even with that decrease, we can
still operate at the same level to serve our students food that meets or exceeds the requirements for nutrition standards and let me just say that it is challenging to build a budget and make predictions for our program with this impending no more free meals cloud kind of looming over us
but as of right now there have not been any changes to our federal funding and regardless of these changes you know if they were to come to fruition our students would still be served nutritious well-balanced school meals every day as things change and evolve we would come up with
solutions to continue doing what we do best which is serving healthy meals to our students that's all i have phoebe so i like pretty much every day get lunch at school which is saying something because i have the ability to leave and go get lunch at home or somewhere in town
but this year the changes i've seen like here at the high school and the school lunch have been like amazing I'm vegetarian and before like the options for me were like salad or uncrustable which like I'm a growing girl so I I need like good stuff but now there's always like a vegetarian
option of the main dish like today there was veggie nuggets and like when we have the like breakfast for lunch there's veggie sausage that's like my favorite brand too and it's so good and i also just so thank you for that because it is a lot better than uncrustables even though
those are good too but also the rumble d thumbs casserole is so good and i'm sorry because i did make fun of it when i first saw it on the menu i was like what is that because could you tell us what it's called again rumble d thumbs castle but i was so hungry that day and i was like okay i'm
just gonna get it and my life was changed it's so good so i want to say thank you for like bringing that to me and for having the vegetarian options and like being in the lunchroom like a lot of kids at the high school are like eating that lunch and it's so important too because we're
here early like getting breakfast here and without that like i would not be learning erica maybe you can bring the rumbly thump casserole to the board name next time i can't take full credit for that part of it was for the um the main harvest of the month in january was potatoes
and i worked with laurie our manager here and she came up with the rumbly thump um meal and i had it and it was like you say it was delicious so we'll have it again definitely I'm going to look at everyone's paper to see how many of us just wrote down rumble we will all be googling it
later I should probably just made up the name and we're never going to find it so it's real it's real it's out there yeah um I had a question about uh the participation rates you said 38 for breakfast 65 for lunch is that consistent with last year I know you said the numbers has gone
down a little bit because of number of kids but is participation percentage in line um our lunch percentage is just about the same we have seen a drop in our breakfast counts um i believe it's around four or five percent from where it was last year um with that said um i've tried to be ahead
of the curve a little bit with some of the changes in our added sugar content in breakfast options and this change is coming next year anyways so we were going to have to do it this year or next year so we've definitely done a lot of experimenting
you know phasing in some different things and we're not serving maybe all of the same things that we were in the past and so I'm not surprised that we've seen a slight decrease in our in our breakfast participation just given that some of the options maybe aren't students favorites yet but hopefully
wonderly felt yes and I feel like I've also heard sort of the ability here at the high school around breakfast to get it and be able to eat it in your first period has might have changed this year like they're not letting them eat yep
class or yep we are right now our breakfast here in the cafeteria students are able to come in until I believe it's 8 45 is that I'm pretty sure that's the time and get their breakfast. It used to be that they could come at any point between start of
school and 11 a.m. when lunch started. There were some concerns from teachers around students not being in their classrooms and being down here in the cafeteria. And so the move at the time was to you know cut back on on how often students are able to come down to the CAF. I have since been
working with the JNG program and we have a vending machine. I was going to ask about the hallway. You're waiting for food. Yes so the vending machine I know has been sitting vacant for two years something like that. It is working and I think literally tomorrow it will be stocked with
second chance breakfast options so there will be um yeah breakfast options available so that way you know our cutoff time is a little bit earlier than it used to be um but the hope is that having this vending machine you know right there that students aren't you know missing out on class and
they're able to just you know go run a quick quick breakfast from the vending machine and get back to class um and we're hoping to see that our participation kind of boosts back up with that so great yeah yes i'm just curious how the vending machine works is it like cash driven
or is it like they put in their code or something um it is uh both technically um to start i'm just going to i'm actually i'm deactivating the cash option for ease of you know starting things um the jng program students are going to be the ones that are you know stocking the machine themselves
um so kind of for ease there we're just going to use students pin numbers that they use here in the cafeteria so they're able to pre-load money onto that account and if you only have cash on you you can always come down here and laurie or somebody can load that money onto your student meal account
and be able to to get a meal that way i would like to make it a cash option eventually but i was actually i'm i was more concerned about them not having the cash and wanting to get something so I'm just happy that they can use the PIN code. Yeah, the PIN, and then everything is all connected with our POS system, so we'll see all of the meal counts and everything that way.
Thank you so much, Erica. I'm glad to hear the options are so great. I'm just wondering if there are any updates about scratch cooking, since I know we asked about that in the past, as well as the chocolate milk. Yes. For the scratch cooking, a couple things to note with that, I guess. I have applied for the Culinary Institute that you had told me about, so I don't think we'll hear back until sometime in April, but the hope with that is to be able to send a couple of staff members to a week-long, hands-on, scratch cooking training in them.
so that would be at some point this summer, but pledging to do this monthly harvest of the month is a really great way that we've been able to showcase some of those scratch-made options, like the rumpelty thumbs, so we're certainly, you know, getting there, there's a lot of challenges
with it that we're still figuring out, but it's improved definitely, yeah, and to answer your question about chocolate milk um i've reached out to oakhurst a few times to try and get a better sense of what their new formula will be to be able to serve it in any schools with next year's um
you know new changes that are going to happen um because they would not the current chocolate milk they would not be able to serve in any school's name the way that it is currently um they've assured me that they are changing the formula but other than that I don't I don't know what that
would look like so yeah so it might it might be back next year right I would it would be great to have it back I think it's a really great way for students to be able you know we have a lot of students that maybe don't participate in the school meal program but would still come up and
get a milk and something to keep in mind is like a milk that's not drank whether it's chocolate milk or you know regular milk is you know it provides nutritional you know value to the student and you know milk isn't being drank just because there isn't a chocolate milk option um i think
it's worth looking at you know what is that nutritional value that those students aren't getting because they're not choosing to have a milk at all anymore so there's there's certainly you know some exploring with it that i'm looking into thank you yeah other questions for erica
Thank you. All right. Facilities. Glenn, thank you for your patience tonight, Glenn. Absolutely. Listen, I got no rumbly-dumbly. I got none of that. How do you top that? I don't. I was telling Jeremy before he left. It's a tough act to follow. So thank you, Eric. Appreciate it. Good evening, everyone. First up, everybody hear me okay? I usually have a lot of voice anyways. I don't need a mic. So the budgetary requests for the facility departments focus on supporting the infrastructure to provide a safe learning environment for all students and staff.
Staff adjustments on budget FY25 were none. Staffing adjustments for budget FY26 are none. Other significant FY26 requests in the budget in these, supplies, equipment, contract increases, and so forth. For an example, like the mechanical services contract ends in June, so that will be going out to bid, so there's a potential change there.
Plowing contract was up to bid, so there's a potential change there. And also supplies and so forth. The FY26 proposed capital improvement plan. Some of these were on last year's plan. Unfortunately, when some of the projects that we did ran over financially, so we weren't able to complete those, so we just moved them into this year.
They are such as the wall over at the music room at Durham, removing that wall, removing and installing new ceiling tile, ceiling in the modular at Durham, putting snow guards on the modular over at Durham. For the bathrooms over at North Street School, back on the audit, it was noted on the audit that the bathrooms didn't meet ADA.
So one of the concerns we had was there may be asbestos on the granuleum. So we had that tested, and that came back negative. In a conversation with Gene and Kelly, we decided to take this opportunity to take that boys' bathroom and make it ADA.
So that boys' bathroom will be ADA, and then future upgrades will do the girls' bathroom as well. We're looking to install a heat pump in the teacher's lounge at the high school. We also need to replace a roof section at the middle school, which is on the back section.
And last year was to replace the roof section over the gym here at the high school. We put that back in the capital budget for this year. So that's the show. I just want to make sure the teacher's room isn't also the library data closet, right? Yes, it's a combination room. That's why we put a split in there for the... Is this like the little room behind, like the fishbowl? I think they put, they're going to put a rack, or they put a rack up in there too, so we're just going to add provided cooling for that room, and the teachers will get a benefit by having that cooling in that room. Okay. It's a shared room. Okay. Closet just sounds really small. That room is not a closet. I agree. Could add one piece to what Glenn shared with the board as well, is that I think it's important
that the board knows that overall last year, you increased the amount that we had in the local budget and this year we're requesting an additional increase again of $30,000 to cover those projects it really we looked at historically where
that dollar figure was and it was $400,000 for a long long time and we all know that the you know materials and labor and all that have increased so that's that's the is up to $475,000 this year yes thank you maybe this is a
question for Jean regarding that what because we were at the $400,000 for a long time did we just last year increase it to 44 okay I couldn't remember thank you I see no staffing adjustments since you know we did ask Jeremy so we'll ask
you how is your staffing levels do you have positions filled are you struggling anywhere for the most part we have all the positions filled we still have two staff that are out we're currently looking at filling one of those with a sub and the other staff have picked up but so all the positions are technically
full. Okay, great. Cheyenne, could you talk about why you guys are replacing the wall in the music room? Just that you're looking to expand? Yeah, so the conversation that we had with the teacher and the principal is the number of students that are in that room with all their equipment and
everything else is just really tight, so they felt if we opened it up and they're looking at removing the wall that is currently the storage room, still using it as a storage room, but just opening it up so the students can spread out a little bit with their equipment. Thank you. Yeah, of course.
thank you so much I just had some questions about the energy audit and the life safety updates and I was wondering in terms of the age of our facilities if making those updates is a challenge if there are any limitations because of the
age of some of our facilities if that's a consideration I'm just I guess I'm thinking about the amount of money we're putting in to aged facilities I'm going forward in that whole conversation. No, so it's not a concern about the age. It's more of a concern
about the age of the equipment. So I'll give you an example. At Durham, that build is only 13 years old. But the piece of equipment that they put in there for the fire alarm panel, which is scheduled on the life safety to be replaced, is obsolete. So we can't get any parts for it. We can't do
anything. So if it fails, we're in trouble. So that's why it's slated to replace the panel. And all the devices have to be replaced as well because that piece of equipment is preparatory so Johnson Controls is the only vendor in town that can work on
that so we want to put a non-proprietary much like we did the bullies over at Pono so that we can get better pricing to be able to make the repairs and that hope to be able to make the repairs and then presumably hopefully it wouldn't be obsolete again so soon okay and just a follow-up
question is the Facilities Committee had conversations about weighing you know because because of these significant new investments in the budget are just large sorry I'm trying to think of different words and my brain is being tired since they are large just the conversation around around that and that
aspect of the budget I'm sorry I'll ask me to speak a little bit more about that Yeah, so I was also glad when I first came in, Gene told me one of the requests of the board was asking to do an energy audit. So a new employee coming in, taking a look at everything, it's nice to be validated, right?
So I'd always go to Gene, and I would always apologize. Like, listen, Gene, I saw this yesterday. I'm really sorry I have to tell you this. And then the audit would come in and validate what I'm telling Gene, but this needs to be replaced.
So there's been a lot of great work that's been done in the district, but there's still a lot of great work that needs to be done. For example, here at the boiler, we had an inspection with our insurance company. We looked inside the boiler, and it's 50 years old, and it's showing every year of that 50 years.
I knock on wood every day when we had that cold spell that it just didn't decide not to fail and not work. We have air handlers, we have rooftop units, we have a non-existent, I don't want to say non-existent, but we have a very poor ventilation system in mass landing, which again, those
are the air handlers up on the roof. Just a lot of part of the systems that need to be replaced, not necessarily because of the age of the building, it's just the age of the equipment and the amount that they're used. You know, these commercial pieces of equipment are running a lot, and they're working a lot.
So it's not like your air conditioner at home where you take it out of the window in the winter and you put it aside and all that other stuff. These things are running 24-7, 365 because they're designed to bring in fresh air.
So you're burning out pumps, you're burning out motors, you're burning out squirrel cages, evaporator coils, all of that stuff. So it's just age catches up with them. So I think overall, I don't want to speak out of turn here, but structurally, I think the buildings are in good shape.
I just think we have to catch back up with the mechanical side that we started to do. We just kind of either got sidetracked or whatever the situation was. And these stages, either the phases, the life safety is going to get us there a little bit quicker.
Does that answer your question? Yes, thank you. That is reassuring because I know, as you all know, I have brought that up a couple of times. So I'm glad to hear that that's just reassuring about making that investment. Could you remind me with the 17-year lease purchase agreement, even though it's the $3.6 million, then in the budget, it's the $303,000 that will be just for this year?
Next year. I'm sorry, next year. Yeah, nothing in the 25-26 budget. There's no payment required. Which is okay. Got it. Thank you very much. You're absolutely right. Yeah, I think the key that I took out of what Glenn just said is that the structural buildings are good, right?
What we don't want to be doing is putting top-of-the-line engines in a truck buddy that's about to die, right? Like, what's the point of that, right? So we want to make sure we're not investing. No, wait a minute. I'm a truck guy. You may want to do that. I'm just kidding. Not with my money. Right, exactly. No, no, of course. You certainly don't want to, if we've got buildings that, you know, we're constantly looking at rooftops and structural for the rooftops and, you know, your walls and your floors and all that other type of stuff. We certainly want to have those conversations. Do we want to continue or not? But I've been in pretty much every small area that you can think of in the district here, and I don't see anything that's extremely concerning. I just think, you know, we've got to continue the good work that started prior to my arrival, and we've just got some work to do. Great. Other questions?
Oh, Maura's got more for you. I wanted to ask about the life safety updates. Given the size and the amount of that, and I know it's coming from capital reserves, I guess I'll just say given the status of our federal funding and what's going on nationally, if we had to shift to wanting to hold on to more of those reserves, how would we be able to do some of these upgrades?
would there be able to be like a phased approach to that in a different way that would not be such a big chunk of money up front yeah I think what we would do if that's if that's if that's sort of what the what the direction the board
wants to go in we would get back together as a team and see if you're saying we'll pause that front of the year then we pause it for another year just say you know can we do some of these or what are the top what will is
rising to the top then we would we would discuss as a team and come back together to the board with a proposal to the board if that's the will of the board absolutely maybe to that end could you and energy you went through some of
these but could you just explain the necessity of them in those sort of the urgency to like protect our students and make our facilities safe I think that that's like something that I would weigh when we make that decision about like how can we wait with this potential federal funding up in the air or what
Yeah, so, you know, that's all about perspective, right? So, you know, there's fire alarm panels that are on there that are extremely important for the safety of staff and students, 100%. You know, access to the buildings, that's extremely important as well.
So I think, like Gene said, we'd get together with a team and figure out, okay, how can we best tackle the list based on what the direction from the board would be dollar-wise, right? what can we accomplish that would still provide the high quality safety and security that the
staff and students are looking for and get some of these stuff done um i i think that's what we you know we would sit down and have that conversation try to figure that out but you know that's a good point you know how do you define how do you decide and define what
needs to happen what have you and i think the three of us can come up with a plan based on whatever dollar amount is given. Absolutely. Yeah. I had the, uh, almost the exact same thought process. I mean, I, I, I hate to even verbalize that, that, you know, all the work
that has gone into that sort of three stage plan, which I think is, um, you know, very, very appropriate. And, but I'm very nervous about, um, something completely out of our control, um really impacting our our funding and us having to make other decisions if we don't have
sort of um a rainy day fund that we could access right like maybe this isn't the time to spend that all down and when so much is is potentially up in the air um you know so i appreciate your willingness to to look at things um you know and maybe some of the stuff in the 475 would get
supplanted with stuff that you said, geez, if we're going to hold off on the life safety upgrade from the capital reserves, I might, because I feel it's so important, push that into the $475 in the local budget, right? You know, I mean, that's sort of the nature of the beast, I guess.
Yeah, that's the beauty of facilities, right? So we're never looking for things to do. There's always things to do. So I'm never bored. Don't want to tell you all that, right? so i'm not sitting back reading the newspaper there's plenty of stuff to do so you know the
life safety the phases you know all of this is a living document so we can decide to do phase one three years from now it's still going to be there you know we're probably going to be repairing some of that stuff i'd love to be able to stand up here and say hey look look what we already did off phase one which changes that dollar note but at the end of the day all that is still going to
be there whenever we're able to get to it you know there's going to be some emergencies don't be shocked there is but there are going to be that's just the nature of the beast but at the end of the day it's a living document we can move things around and do things when when we have the
opportunity to do i will just point out the time value of money things don't get cheaper so pushing things down the road they will never work to do when we do them so just you know something to keep in mind a can gets a little expensive when you kick it farther down that's right so um okay uh
care i want to add to that too that there's also you know downsides to losing teachers and that if this is well first of all i want to validate because i know that you said that that was one thing you really appreciated when you came here is that the validation that facilities are really important absolutely so i want to validate that and i think everyone here would it'd be my guess
we would all say like if we could do this yes let's please do this I think we also probably would say if we can't if we could maybe not lose some teachers that would be great too so I'm just thinking about this side of it with in terms of the other cuts that we're considering in relation
to using the designated fund balance for the life safety or just the 475 the increase for the 40,000 I mean, it's not an increase to 475. Right, I know, I know. Yeah, okay. But in however we, whatever we could be flexible with, I guess. Yep. I am completely flexible. I'll do whatever you guys tell me to do. Oh, Gene tells me to do. All right, any other questions for Glenn? Thank you. Thanks, guys. All right, so we're going to move to Peter,
Community Programs. Hi, everybody. I should have put in for the public comment section because I think I'm going to take three minutes. So as some of you may know or recall, since I joined the office in 2018, the budget has
been flat, so at least since fiscal year 2018 at $112,000, and for the upcoming year, we are looking at taking away 21% of that down to $88,000, and that is essentially to reflect the adult ed coordinator that is working with us now who's part-time, going from full-time person to part-time person.
Usually I provide a little more context and detail with the other things that don't come from local share, but given the size of the agenda tonight, we've decided to keep it just at that one feature with adult ed. So that's my budget report for FY26.
Not even three minutes, Peter. Well done. I guess my question around the adult ed coordinator, is that by that person's choice they prefer part-time? Are we able to accomplish everything we want to do with a part-time position? So the core mission of what we do with adult ed can be accomplished in that part-time position.
When we've had full-time coordinators, our last full-time coordinator, for instance, Was able to grow and grow and grow the role and get into some sort of additional Services and advising and counseling and help that went that go beyond just the core English language instruction high set instruction
and so So we are fulfilling the coordination plus some But just don't get to some of the same additional things with the part-time schedule. But also the population has changed quite a bit since the previous full-time person and the current not full-time person. Makes sense. Other questions
for Peter? I don't have a question, but I just want to thank you for keeping your budget flat for seven years and then decreasing it. I know it's a challenge, I'm sure, and I know that you have a small program comparatively, but it's, you know, thank you. Yeah, sure. Thank you, Beth.
If you could talk to your other, like, counterparts on the admin team on how to do that, keep it flat, maybe drop it a little, it'd be great. Yeah, that's right. We're just going to do adult, it's for all the kids. Other questions for Peter? Thank you. All right, thanks. All right, so we're going to pull Sam away from his current tech duties at the desk, bring him up to the camera. Hope the live stream stays up and running.
You should. Dream. There we go. Was everybody else up there not in front? No, no, no, I just cut to the wide shot because I can't switch between the different cameras, that's all. Hi, I'm Sam. I'm running live stream back there.
And let's get this to a good height. So for the FY26 budget, we're coming in, other than, you know, our non-staffing expenditures are coming in a little bit below where they were last year. We've got, we're kind of focused on infrastructure projects like high school Wi-Fi, some classroom technology at mass learning and the high school, a few rooms at the high school, and then running a pilot program and to kind of pick the direction for which device we're going to go in certain grade levels in the future.
and then new staff devices for the high school teachers. Beyond that, we've got some communication software, some copyright-safe video software, and that's really, you know, that's really that. There's not a whole lot more to it. What's a ReachMyTeach? ReachMyTeach is a communication platform, so right now you all get messages through Bright Arrow.
And ReachMyTeach allows for broader flexibility as well as two-way text messaging with teachers where a teacher or a staff member would not have to give out their phone number in order to accomplish that. It also does translation of documents and translation of all the messages that go through it as well in two directions.
And one of the cool features that it has is that with so many of our families coming, you know, our new main families, they're much more used to using WhatsApp or Telegram or various other platforms and reach my teach and send and receive messages through those platforms as well.
Did you say that the next year is the sort of the planning year for what goes forward for? yeah yeah so so 6 through 12 um we're we're kind of we we're trying to figure out where we go from here because i think that um frankly providing macbooks to every student 6 through 12 is
probably a little bit overkill um and that we are not um we're i think our our teachers are doing lots of wonderful work with those devices but we are not always taking full advantage of them and so we're going to evaluate all of the options out there
and it might be that in, you know, a year from now I'll be sitting here being like, well, guess what, we're going with MacBooks again but in our estimation, just, we're going to kind of evaluate the various other options, so that would be Chromebooks and then an iPad with iPads with keyboard and trackpad on it and I know that iPads are a dirty word in this district but what I will say is that coming from a district that is an Apple is
recognized as an Apple distinguished high school I think it's one of those things that once you see it it's really remarkable once you kind of see how it can be used and how how it can kind of transform what students are doing it's
very powerful I'm not saying that that's the way that I want to go necessarily necessarily, because I think we need, we just need more information. Um, but, uh, Principal Golko and I went on a site visit at Thornton Academy, um, where they had received a similar,
uh, recognition from Apple. And she went in, like, totally closed-minded about, you know, um, about, you know, we're going here to see things, you know, see kids using iPads, and is this really a device that makes sense for high school? And then four hours later, she was like,
we got to figure out how we can try to take advantage of something like this so I think when it's done well and teachers are on board and students are willing to work through some of the pain points I think it's a much more powerful device I also think when iPads were done here
it was about eight years ago I think something something in that room I think there's been two rounds of MacBooks since then and the device has come a long way so that's why we're entertaining that i think the chromebook is a simpler explanation um which is that most of what
students are most of what students are asked to do not all but most is um done through the chrome browser and so paying for macbooks for every student is like paying for a very expensive chromebook in a lot of cases that's not all cases but i think in particularly in stem and science
and some functions for math but in uh the humanities and social studies i think that it tends to be used primarily like a Chromebook. So we'll see. I don't know. We'll have more data in a year's time. So the thing that, not that I'm only listening to one phrase that each of you say,
if it sounds like that, but the thing that popped out to me for you was, you know, getting teachers on board, because that is, I think, one of the areas where, when we've had struggles with whether, whatever it is, whether it's curriculum or whether it's technology or, you know, not necessarily
having the buy-in from from all the shareholders um can certainly be a challenge so i am uh you know i have my initial thoughts but you know maybe maybe we need a board like field trip to learn how to use the the ipads yeah i mean we'll we'll see how it goes i think what what we'll be looking for
um you know we're still kind of figuring out the structure of what that pilot will look like um but what we'll be looking for are um a handful of teachers to kind of help us buy into that and for them to help identify some students who they think this would be a good fit for and some
students they don't think it would be a good fit for and so that we're getting data kind of across the spectrum um it's not you know we'll we'll see i don't know it's one of those things we'll just we'll have to wait and see see what leads us we should do some parent education because i have one
and i hate it i i struggle with it because i thought it was gonna be very easy so i'm sure kids can use it no problem but i feel bad yeah it's not it's not really about it's not necessarily about um kids knowing or not knowing how to use it it's more about um understanding how to kind
of unlock the power of the device and and the ways in which it is much more um the ways in which you know different devices have lots of interesting different functions um it can be used in different form factors and that sort of thing say like a commercial unlock the power bb i fully endorse ipads i'm very outspoken about this i have an ipad and i actually like
love it so much like and i'm trying to convince my dad to get me like the pencil that goes yeah but also like um a lot of well not a lot but some of my teachers use ipads and the pencil um in class like my math teacher that's like the majority of our class he's writing the notes
mr milks yeah and um it's really like um easy to follow because like he's doing it out on the screen and we're writing the notes on our paper um but i also know a lot of college students have switch to the ipads for note taking right yeah it's because you can do the note taking on them
and my brother has one and he like swears by it so i think that can be really helpful it can be like um the digital art which is like another like big thing of the future they can be used for that which i think would be really interesting to see so yeah yeah volunteer for your kids yeah and i
i would love to just have like my ipad like i just go home every day and i just sit there and like type around and you can like go on photos and you can zoom in on people's faces and they're just like really large on the screen i'll buy you the pencil if you come help me learn mine
okay what a deal a deal i don't know cynthia's what is their policy about their policy about that cynthia about trading services yeah i'm not sure um that's cynthia's job um yeah no i i totally uh um i totally hear what you're saying and that was the thing that
i think for mrs gulko that um mrs gulko that that really kind of unlocked things was watching kids take notes and watching kids work on work collaboratively or then a teacher is sitting there take you know doing you know what miss edwards or mr mills or any a lot of the math
teachers do you know writing out kind of the notes and solving problems and then taking that and being able to share that to google classroom for all the kids so they then have they have their own notes that they've taken but they also have a whole documentation of what the teacher has done
as well so it's it's also i i think a lot of the other thing is you know in terms of a teaching tool a lot of the um you know using trying to trying to you know projecting from a computer it's a much more kind of like heads down experience for a teacher they're kind of like you know they're
having to line something up focusing if you're airplane from from an ipad you can have it in your hand have the stylus in your other hand you can be walking around the room you can be you know so you're kind of it's kind of this more of a um you know classroom management by walking around
kind of thing but um yeah i i think you know and that's not even getting into the type of stuff that they're doing in gorham um which i think is sort of at another level beyond just digital note-taking so um or and and is much more focused on creativity um and student creativity so yeah
we'll see we'll see where it takes us sorry just one last thing I've had I think that we had them because I'm thinking back to my oldest child and I think it was like 10 years ago if not more than the iPads because she was in middle school and she's 24 now so you know and and so I think you
know thinking about iPads what they were 10 years ago and what they are today is like you know it's huge difference right and i think the other thing is that you know we would be providing a case with a built-in keyboard and trackpad on it so you can use it like a laptop you could do everything that
you would do on a chromebook on it but then also you can pop the device out of the case and be you know using it as a tablet being able to draw on it all that sort of you know so it's kind of best of both worlds kind of thing but we'll see where we we'll see where we wind up i mean we've got a lot of legwork and we're trying to kind of we're going to be trying to gather feedback from
students and staff at Durham students and staff at Freeport Middle School and here so it's going to be it's going to be um it's going to be a lot of legwork but we're you know the hope is that kind of the first few months of next year we're gathering a lot of that data and getting a lot
of information and working with working with staff and students alike thank you yeah um thanks for all that I was looking through the big hefty line by line and notice that computer materials there's an increase of three hundred and thirty eight thousand dollars yeah so so equipment is
down and equipment is down by a little bit more than that and materials are up and that's really that's really a uh state accounting or you know coding things correctly for for um you know the auditors and everybody else and everybody in between um which is that what's the threshold
five thousand dollars for an individual item yeah so the threshold for equipment is actually five thousand dollars for an individual item so like we will very occasionally have a server that would be that much money but everything else because the individual item costs are much lower that
goes under materials so even like the laptops we're buying for staff that's just under materials instead of being under equipment and that was just fixing something that so if you look under if you look at equipment which is 57 340 or 341 um that's uh yeah you'll see there that there's a
big drop off there i was just showing off with like line item numbers i almost i almost have them all memorized. The whole book? No, no, just mine, but. All right, any other questions for Sam? Thank you. Thank you. All right, so we are technically still on the same item, just so you
all know, because we do have a policy, if for those who may not know. I think my watch just died because it's so late. We can't start a new item after 10 o'clock without a vote of the board, Um, so after we get through, uh, Cynthia's two, um, two sheets that we have here, um,
is it two? It's two, right? Yeah. Yes. Uh, then, then we'll take that up, but. Good evening. I'm the tail end of all of the budgets. I think I'm the last one to present. So, um, tonight, uh, first of all, Phoebe, thank you for, you know, just being you.
Okay. I've enjoyed you tonight. Um, not that I don't, every, every time, but. Okay, so I have, my budget is flat-ish, so I can't say flat, but it's flat-ish. On the first page, you'll see the Curriculum Development and Improvement of Instruction.
There's no staffing involved in that, and the Improvement of Instruction, primarily, Just to give you a little context, Aaron, because you're new and anybody else who may have forgotten. Aaron wasn't here last year at this time. So that's primarily curriculum materials, and it hovers around 53,000.
And so next year, we are going to be looking at some additional science kits. And we are also doing a curriculum review of math. So those would be primarily the things purchased with those materials. And then instructional staff training.
That cost center is primarily, there's kind of like four big buckets in there. So there's purchase professional, and that's flattish. We just moved some money from one level to another level a little bit. but it's overall flattish. The honorariums, so I have several. Those are for typically committees
if they're working after hours. So I have, I think, six or seven committees that I lead, and there might be a couple other committees around the district. So they get paid, if their meetings are an hour and a half, they get paid an honorary amount for that hour and a half over the year each time they meet. So that's what that bucket is. And then tuition. Kelly has used the historical data for tuition. That piece of it has gone up because you're probably going back three years. Yeah, so it's up because the last three years that were looked at was higher than dropping off one year
and including that year before. It must have been lower. So that's why that one's gone up. It just happens to be in my cause center, but I don't really control that. And then the last piece is the stipends. I own the budget for the stipends for the mentors and the local credentialing committee.
So those numbers of people in those slots stay the same and the stipend, as you know, is part of the contract. So that's that side of the page. Any questions on that? No, I should have asked for two years. All right, and then on the other side, We have the gifted and talented, flat, same number of staff in that position.
And so we generally have about 5% of our students who are identified in this category in either academic and or arts and music. Take any questions on that? Okay. Very good. Thank you. We are questioned out, Cynthia. Can I have one piece at the end of the book? yes so that does conclude all of our presentations for folks and throughout
the last few weeks Karen and I've been taking notes on other information that the board has requested so that you can as part of your deliberations and what we're going to do is put that information together in a packet for you
so that when you receive your board materials for the next meeting you you have a packet of that data that you asked us to collect. And in order for us to make sure we have everything that will help you with those deliberations, if there are other
things right now that you know, other data you'd like to have, maybe you could let us know. Or if it's 10, 15, if you're feeling, I think there might be something, I'm a little tired right now. If you could email Kelly and I by March 1st, because there are two
pieces of this we have to collect it and assemble it and find it and then you have to make sure it gets out to your board packet and also we'll provide that for the on the website for the community and so forth but we thought you might
like to have it in advance so that you can start doing some thinking before you start deliberations I was trying to figure out about the middle school and just all the staff and the just because it's so complicated and splitting apart is there any way
we could get like a cheat sheet of what is currently being done and then what's being proposed for next year yeah i mean yeah i just asked clarity for us as we work in the middle school so you thinking you're looking at sort of by grade level but like i guess staffing for that
or I guess maybe by grade level and by subject area because I was like trying to quickly take notes on how she was saying there's three of this and there's it but it got very confusing and then how she was piecing it out so I think that would just a visual would be more helpful
yeah yeah thank you yeah and you know and it sounds like there isn't a defined way forward on what it would look like but even just a potential you know what it might look like from a schedule, like, so, you know, this is what it looks like today, this is what we envision it
might look like, you know, next year with these basically two fewer positions, right, going from 16 and a half to 14 and a half, and kind of inclusive of that, sort of the class size numbers in there. That's right, thank you. Because I do still think there's some confusion, like, I'm not
quite sure, I quite understood what Paige was saying around, like, well, we said the top would be 21 but they're saying well no it's 24 plus so where's the disconnect there is there just some misunderstanding or is it are we does that make sense even at
1015 I think it would be helpful to see the budget impact with some of the positions added back in on specifically the ESOL and middle school positions and is that i know we have the eight educators and the five ed techs and i think some of those are
unfilled so maybe breaking out the unfilled versus the already filled two could could be helpful right yeah i know kelly's already working on sort of the although she looks like she has a clarifying question yeah so so when you when you're saying unfilled is that unfilled including
a resignation at the end of the school year so it's unfilled for next year or are you talking about right now currently if if someone is currently is someone currently doing that job or not so like the science teacher would be yes they are doing that job today yeah but that ed
tech at fms is not yeah and and i think just for the proposed reductions so so for for the all the teaching and all the ed techs the proposed reductions you'd like us to look at what it looks like if we filled all the positions that are currently
filled this year what that would be the difference in the budget impact that would be great thank you top side of that chart Michelle's referring to we talked about it at finances one of the things we were that I had developed to
to help in your deliberations was a sheet that says if we wanted to so say we wanted to get to a three percent taxation impact what sort of reductions would be needed but and I only had that like from our starting point down in the shell at our Finance Committee meeting suggested
that I'd go like from up to the like our original before any cuts and then kind of progressively step down in positions. So this is great that it ties right into what we were working on for you already. And then I guess this is very sort of ambiguous, but I mean, what we've heard a lot of
is around like teaching positions and, you know, the impact to students and really trying to not remove supports in a time when we're we're most concerned about our kids um but i also on the flip side don't think we could come forward with a nine percent you know expenditure and expect to
pass it um i i don't think in good faith i could do that so um you know are there other creative ways that we could keep the the percentage which five and five six seven something like that right is where we are without having to cut teaching positions like what what would we have to
sacrifice otherwise to keep those teaching positions and is that you know is it feasible is it not you know it we could easily just take the capital budget and bring that to zero and use that five hundred thousand dollars for for teaching positions you know that that's obviously a trade
off not that i would encourage or recommend that but you know are there other ways i mean i know you guys have been trying to skin this cat, so to speak, since October. And, you know, this is the best thinking to date, but I'll just be interested in hearing that. Since August. August, well, yeah.
We started talking about this in August. They enjoyed one month of the year before they started this project. More question. Kelly, do you know if there will be that magic spreadsheet again where everybody puts their budget increase in from all over and when that might happen? Districts.
sorry other districts oh yeah I haven't seen anything circulate in in the business managers world yet because believe it or not we're really early like yeah although we're a little further we're early for other districts
you know most districts are just now like compiling everything and coming up with stuff they're not done presenting to their board and ready for deliberations so maybe Jean or superintendent can do it it's fine I have Smith but it's sort of isn't the confidential until they share with their boards and where they're at as soon as it's it's out to the public then we can share that out with you we have that yeah I'll just say it's a tough budget
year in every district in me okay yeah so it emailed the board and gene you had responded before about the question if we could if we could have some numbers that explain the difference between a six percent increase versus a eight
percent increase what does that really look like for the taxpayers and I think you mentioned that that's really tricky obviously because each town does it differently but it might be possible to ask the towns if that's something that
they could put together and how I had envisioned it was someone who has a you know a $200,000 home in Durham you know what would six percent look like what would 8% look like someone who has a $900,000 home what would that look like I
just think that that visual could be really helpful for me and I think for others and also for the voters if we if we were to ask them to yeah pass a higher budget to see what that difference looks like the problem is is
like the you know the media we have like median value right but taxes aren't done on value they're done on the sort of the assessed value from the towns and there's you know they're in varied stages of of equalization with market
value I know in Durham work I don't know 65% or something of market value for our tax assessed which is you know which you can see if you look at the mill rate right of 22 versus 14 and the other towns that's a function of the values we
won't get into that tonight. But it's just a challenging, it's a challenging thing to collect. It's probably even more challenging to explain in a way that doesn't create more confusion than it solves. I don't know. Yeah. I was just thinking about something Michelle's mentioned in finance
committee, because we were talking about all the requests and everything, and just how different each town handles it so the fact i mean durham has been using their undesignated fund balance to keep their taxes low so even though it looks not low i'm sorry keep them from increasing
exponentially sorry um so they're using that to offset the increases is probably a better um sort of thing but it's it's almost like an illusion then because so the durham residents aren't really seeing that school increase in their tax bill if the town is
deciding to take some of their undesignated fund to give tax relief so there's not really you know it varies by the town because each town can do what they want within some of that I just wonder you know if we're worried about
passing the budget if we were if we were to ask folks to pass a higher budget if there are some people who just won't do it because there's a it's a percentage that's higher than what we've done before but not really understand what that what that means and if that means that you know does eat should each town
be providing more education around that like is there an opportunity for us to be helping folks understand what that impact really looks like which it does obviously look different for everyone and I understand that it really does look very different for everyone and we can't pass judgment on on folks for how
they want to spend their money as much as we would like them to invest in education but I'm just wondering if there's an opportunity there for us to be making things a little more transparent so that they can really make
an informed decision yeah I mean you know we might be able to say something like, if your tax assessed value in panel is $250,000, the increase would be this. If it was $500,000, it would be that. You know, so people can find the one that's closest to them, maybe. I
mean, if they even know what their tax assessed value is versus what they think their house is worth, right? Because that's a huge sort of jump in a lot of people's minds on how it works. So, um, maybe, I mean, and then it's less, um, sort of, uh, less about, like, what's the median
value by town, because that varies based on the equalization, but, like, if we just say, hey, you know, when the mill rate is this, the, an increase in the mill rate of this for a hundred thousand, per hundred thousand dollars of your house equals this many dollars, right? Um, you
know, we, we talked about this, you know, they, we did this a lot with the high school renovation, like it's a pizza a month kind of you know give people a perception process i mean it's not always well received even when you give them that information um but we could try i mean that's
probably that's probably more around um how do we communicate the budget once we've deliberated it and and adopted it um less about you know the deliberation piece i think it might make things a little easier or harder to swallow in in our vote to understand that a little bit better as
well and and again the difference between a six percent versus an eight percent in particular i have a really naive question um is it has it ever been done or is it even in the realm of possibilities to take some percentage of the costs needed for the capital campaign and the
life safety projects and do like a private appeal to private fundraisers to have some percentage of that money come from another pot? I mean, we've certainly fundraised for capital projects before, like the track and field, right? I mean, that was two-thirds, three-quarters
um fundraised um so it's not to say it can't be done um i'm not sure we'd have the luck trying to get people to donate to fire panels as we did the turf but you never know um 20 years oh i mean i don't know it got voted down a bunch of times like they well no i mean when it actually got done but
i want to say i mean i jokingly said 20 years but i think the first vote on the track and field kelly may remember i don't know it was like before the before the rsu was almost 20 years ago when they started talking about doing a new field and and stuff like that and it you know they put it
with the school and they got voted down and they separated and they you know it went round and round until it was primarily fundraised um and i think you know we ended up using undesignated fund that we were going to bond it our the you know the the district's portion which ended up
being a million maybe. But then we ended up just using the undesignated fund balance to fund that. So we didn't take on additional debt. But, you know, we're looking at something smaller than that right now on the basketball courts, right? They're doing a fundraising campaign to resurface
the basketball courts. So that kind of stuff does happen. I'm not sure. First of all, it's not fast ever um you know they're looking at you know a hundred thousand dollars for the the basketball courts and it's over a year probably maybe two um that they've been working on it so um i'm not sure
it would give us a quick fix on any of it we appreciate the question because that thought has occurred to me about the tennis courts um and as unbelievable as it is to me this is my seventh year on the board and i we've been talking about the tennis courts since i came onto the
board and I'm like we want to get the kids those courts and I think we have 40,000 going into them this year and I think it's so great that we have the folks doing the basketball project and I wish we could get the tennis courts faster and that could be like maybe one maybe one area I mean I
don't know if we I know Kelly Kelly has a tennis tennis playing kiddo but I don't know if there's boosters there or why not but interesting idea any other requests of Kelly and Jean that would be helpful as we take on the work of deliberating at the next meeting so so
much versus Saturday FYI okay so things we have not gotten to yet the finance report from Kelly says five minutes usually takes 45 seconds we have board committee and of reports so finance facilities policy and curriculum those I
think we could easily push to the next meeting if folks were so inclined I mean obviously the big thing is the policies and I'm interested in hearing people's yeah sorry I just wanted to say I would like to let Kelly give her report this
time because um next time she doesn't she doesn't come to the meeting yeah well actually it's budget so she's going to be here never mind we might still get to you though don't go anywhere um is the policy um obviously we have second read for some stuff there's some uh first read um
new items and then obviously the the consideration to revert back to the former policies um i feel this is gonna prompt a pretty reasonable conversation and I don't know that everyone how everyone feels about undertaking that now or if we want to move that to the next meeting what's on the agenda for the next week yeah I think
my my proposal would be that we move the first and second reads to the next meeting um but we do the um c we do 11c um i also have prepared some notes for that which i'm going to present which i don't think will um uh age well no no it is really well um no but i think it won't
um um we won't have to talk about it at all those notes are not going to solve everything for us but my hope is that those notes will clarify I think some of the confusion around around that particular issue and my hope is that that might be able to speed up
our conversation around that not to say we shouldn't continue to have any conversation we have about it but I really would like to do that with tonight so we can do I take that as a motion to extend the board meeting to for consideration of item 9 on the agenda the administrative report and item 11c
past 10 p.m. I have made I have motioned it okay and Beth has seconded it any questions okay and great so all those in favor oh we have a question this would be the meeting of the 12th right March 12th yes is our next meeting yep okay
uh all those in favor great and um and so we will do that um and we can when we get in to see after we've heard colin's comments if we find that we still feel like it's going to be a very long discussion we can always table it um but at least it gets it started so we'll move to
kelly first for hers good evening is it morning yet you could think it's morning So the figures that you have in front of you tonight are reporting out through January 31st, 2025, for the current year budget that we're in.
And right now we're about 58% collected. You can see that our interest is ahead of projection, and that was one of the things we did talk about in the revenue section of the proposed budget for 2025-2026. We made a small increase in that line based upon historical numbers being a little higher.
And as far as our expenditures, we're about 92.1% encumbered in spent for this school year. We are about 5% higher than we were last year at this time when I look at the numbers. And I think that's largely because everybody's getting used to Kelly being at the helm now, right?
And so I'm more of that active, the monitoring your budget kind of thing, and we did have a request, or I had a request at our last administrative team meeting asking the principals and directors to be thinking about this last quarter that's coming up for us all and to get their ordering in and going for the supplies and materials that they'll need for that last quarter so we can really kind of get a better handle of where the budget's going to land for us.
of the year and you know we can do a couple of things with that because we can if if some items might potentially be tabled by the board during this that we were proposing for this budget cycle do we have potentially maybe some funds that we can get those done with this year if they're high priority and or it
we can have a better sense of what's going into our undesignated fund balance so we have these discussions about the concern about how much might be in un-designated fund balance for future uses we might have a better target for
that so I know it's probably going to be beyond board deliberation on budget but please know that what we're trying you know work we haven't we're trying to get a better handle on where we're going to end at the end of the year in the event
that we have to make some considerations about what we might be able to get done this year so okay questions for kelly thank you thanks thanks for letting me do my part tonight and not have to come back for it okay so um i'm gonna get uh the motion on the floor and then i'm
gonna turn it over to colin yes great do i have a motion for consideration and approval to revert back to the prior versions of the following policies one ac non-discrimination equal Opportunity and Affirming of Action, 2022. ACAA, Harassment and Sexual Harassment of Students,
2020. ACAAR, Student Discrimination Harassment and Title IX Sexual Harassment Complaint Procedures, 2020. ACAB, Harassment and Sexual Harassment of School Employees, 2020. ACABR, Employee Discrimination Harassment and Title IX Sexual Harassment Complaint Procedures, 2020.
Colin and Beth, thank you. Hi, all. If I could just beg the word's indulgence, I have prepared some notes. I wrote them when I was less tired than I am now, so hopefully they reflect that mind. My intention here is to provide you with a little bit of context for why we are being asked to make these changes, what the changes do mean, what they do not mean, and how we may proceed after potentially making these these changes I
also just want to say that these these remarks are my own they were not prepared by the the committee I mean the committee when as I will state we were informed of our legal obligation or the recommendation of our legal counsel to
to change these, and these are my notes in response to that. So the autumn of 2024, the RSC-5 board approved new versions of a set of our policies to comply with new Title IX rules created by the Biden administration. This set of policies did not include ACAAA, transgender and gender expansive students.
This policy was not amended and remains in place in the same form as when the board passed it in the autumn of 2023. On January 9, 2025, the Federal Court of the Eastern District of Kentucky vacated the Biden-era rules, meaning our new policies were technically no longer in compliance.
They reflected rules that were no longer law. In our last policy committee meeting, our board members were informed that we needed to revert to the policies that we had in place until autumn 2024, policies that reflected the law under the 2020 Title IX rules.
Clarify. Our bringing these policies before you tonight was not precipitated by any of the recent events at the federal and state level regarding President Trump's executive orders. It is a coincidence of timing that we are taking this action at a time when many people are concerned
about the questions raised by this executive order. The reversion of these policies has no relation to the executive order. Our work today is to approve the reversion of these policies in order to comply with the law. In short, we cannot have policies that state that Title IX
covers certain things it no longer does. If we use the 2024 rules, we will be liable for violating federal law. Again, this would be true whether or not President Trump had issued his executive order. So what does this mean in terms of protecting our students from discrimination?
Under our reverted policies, students and staff are still offered a great many protections. As stated in the October 2020 version of AC, non-discrimination, equal opportunity, and affirmative action, quote, discrimination against or harassment of students because of race, color, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, religion, ancestry, or national origin, or disability.
Not allowed. And these policies are still supported in part by federal Title IX law. Title IX is a federal law that protects students and employees from sex discrimination education. was passed in 1972 to ensure equal treatment for all students and employees in schools that
receive federal funding. Title IX still provides a wide range of protections for students and establishes processes for investigating cases of sexual harassment and sexual assault. However, the 2020 Title IX rules created during the first Trump administration are less stringent in certain
areas and arguably provide fewer protections for students and staff, particularly women and girls. There is a range of potential impacts to this, but let me list a few. Under the 2020 Title IX rules, schools will no longer be required to provide modifications for students who are pregnant.
Contracted, narrowed definitions of sex discrimination, including for sexual orientation and gender identity. Narrowed definition of sexual harassment. Certain actions that are deemed to create a hostile work environment are no longer forbidden under Title IX. Narrowed scope of potential wrongdoing. Reinstatement of requirements that sexual harassment hearings are live and allow for cross-examination of the victim by the accused.
Decreased privacy rights for all participants, victim and the accused. Decreased responsibility to monitor programs and activities for sexual harassment. Abolished requirement for, quote, prompt time frames, end quote, for resolution.
decreased requirements to provide informal and formal supportive measures. To be clear, these protections apply to all genders, but it's important to note that the highest rates of sexual violence, assault, and harassment are committed against women, and these protections have been decreased. The 2020 Title IX rules make women and girls less safe.
The Trump administration's reinstatement of the 2020 rules creates a situation where it's far more difficult for students to address experiences of sexual harassment and sexual assault. The primary population impacted by this is women and
girls. Some data from the AMHC Sexual Assault Support Network funded by the name DHHS. Approximately 7.1 percent of Maine high school students, 10 percent of girls, and 4.1 percent of boys report that they have been physically forced to have sexual intercourse. 14.8 percent of girls
and 5% of boys report having been forced to have sexual contact in any way in their lifetime. 17.2% of Maine high school students, 23.4% of girls, and 11.1% of boys report having been the target of offensive sexual comments at school or on the way to or from school in their lifetime.
A recent study found that one in five adult Maine residents reports that they have been the victim of rape or attempted rape during their lifetime. Almost 36% of female respondents and 10% of male respondents have experienced this devastating crime at some point in their lives.
That means that there are about 14,000 main victims of sexual assault per year. Statistically, sexual violence, assault, and harassment primarily impacts women and girls and is perpetrated by cisgendered men. The 2020 Title IX rules make it harder for victims to seek justice.
What is the impact of these rule changes on transgender students? Our RSU-5 policy addressing transgender and gender-expansive students remains unchanged and untouched by the Title IX rule change and is not impacted by the reversion of these other five policies.
As stated in ACAAA past October 25, 2023, quote, the Maine Human Rights Act prohibits discrimination, bullying, and harassment against students because they're transgender, end quote. Yes, transgender and gender-expansive students have also lost certain protections by the reinstatement of the Trump administration's 2020 Title IX rules.
Under the Biden administration's Title IX rules, the following protections applied to transgender and gender-expansive students. While these are no longer covered by Title IX and will not be enforced from the federal level,
students in RSU, V, and Maine continue to be granted these same protections under the Maine Human Rights Act. Trans students may not be barred from any covered educational programs on account of their gender. Trans students may not be denied access to restrooms, locker rooms, and showers consistent with their gender. This means dress codes may
not be applied against trans students in a discriminatory manner. Trans students may not be subjected to invasive examinations to prove their gender. To be clear, while these protections have been lost at the federal level, RSU 5 is still
obligated to provide these same protections under the Maine Human Rights Act. These obligations and these rights of trans and gender-expansive students are outlined in ACAAA. Let me be crystal clear. The reversion to the 2020 rules does not change our obligation to transgender students under Maine's Human Rights Act.
The legal authority for the protection of trans students in that policy, which governs our actions as an RSU, flows from the state of Maine, not the federal government. Our responsibilities will be the same tomorrow as they are today, as they were when we passed ACAAA on that October night in 2023 in the Poundell Gymnasium.
So to be clear, what is our work? We need to revert to the earlier policies that were in place until autumn 2024, so that we are not listing Title IX rules that are not current. Simply, we can't say that Title IX offers protections that it doesn't.
Does this have an effect on our students? Yes. and arguably the reinstatement of the 2020 rules by the Trump administration will have the greatest impact on women and girls. Are the federally recognized rights of transgender people decreased
by the Title IX rules? Yes. However, RSU-5's responsibility to provide protections to trans students has not changed. Our policy ACAA remains unchanged. So, we suggest that reversion to our policies there is an amendment to that which I'll explain in a moment however I
recommend that RSU 5 board requests that our legal counsel provide us with feedback on all possible ways that might in the future make changes to these policies in ways that protect the rights of students in ways that title 9 no
longer does this is not a question that the policy committee is equipped to do on its own we do not have the legal expertise to do that work but we believe that it should be done. Then it's a bunch of blank page after which I didn't write any more words.
Let's maybe talk about that. I will start with a huge thank you for that. I think there was a lot of confusion about why we were doing this and what it means. So I still can't claim to be an expert, but I feel like I know more than before you started. So thank you for that. I appreciate
the part at the end about, you know, the parts that we lost by reverting, it doesn't mean we can't have our own policy, right? I mean, we can have policies that are tighter than laws. We do it all the time, you know, where we feel it's appropriate. So I appreciate the thought
around going back so we are in compliance with the law. But then is there another way to provide those protections and assurances that we feel are still appropriate, even if they're not covered by Title IX. I won't say my only question, because I can't guarantee that, but my question is,
Title IX changes every four years, it seems. Why this time, because usually, like, my recollection of how this has happened in the past is, like, there's a change in administration, Title IX changes it takes three years to figure it out and then we make the change and then somebody else
comes in and we do this all again my question is is why the immediate reversion um like what is different about this change where we have to do it on the spot where i don't feel like we've historically had to do that yeah that's a really good question and i think i can answer it it's
because the federal court of the eastern district of kentucky vacated the biden era rules so they didn't just change it, they just said those rules never happened. Those rules were not, were deemed unconstitutional. Okay. So it's not that, yeah, so it's not that the Trump administration has not
presented new Title IX rules. It's simply that just the Biden-era rules do not exist anymore. They just don't exist. They are good words on lots of pieces of paper and on the internet, but they do not exist as any as any law as a law okay more thank you very much colin um i know
you're not a lawyer but is there still an appeal going on in that case i can't answer that question okay an appeal because i guess that's my concern um is um i sought out other legal perspectives on this um other than drummond and woodsons and i i don't know if that's something the board would
like to do. But I think that there are differing perspectives on this. And I think there are some perspectives out there that this is going to continue to evolve. And so sitting tight is an option as well that I would like, I guess, to see us take. I certainly don't want to put anything
in jeopardy, but I think that this is also, um, a matter of, of, of principle. Um, so to make the changes in the event that, you know, this, this is still not, not settled, um, doesn't sit well with me, I guess. How does it work if there is an appeal, right? So is the vacation,
uh sorry um on hold until the appeal is complete or is it the rules are vacated and if the appeal is successful they come back into place i don't know but i'm assuming if the trump administration went through another rulemaking process they could just change the title nine rules anyway
right even if the appeal is successful they could then go and do what we've done every other time there was a new administration and change the rules and then we do it again right but i think that they would have to go through like a process for that to happen um where they put out the rules
and then there's a public comment but um anyway I guess additional legal advice would be helpful at least for me um I guess I would just be um concerned um that we're out of compliance with the law and that we would be vulnerable if we're not um in compliance with the current law um that
we would be vulnerable to that. So even if there is an appeal and things change, then we come back and change things again, I guess, because I, I am a fan of complying with the law. So, um, you know, that's my two cents. Just, I think just quickly on that, I think, um, yeah, I think my, I think
my perspective on it is that tomorrow, our Title IX coordinator has to enforce Title IX. That's her job. And if tomorrow, if we do not revert these policies tonight, tomorrow, she would be required to use the protocol that is established in our policy, which is not in
accordance with law. So I just, I think my perspective is I just don't see a way in which that is a good route to go down. So for example, if a sexual harassment case arrives on Cynthia's desk tomorrow, and she invests, and she initiates an investigation, um, if she uses the 2024 rules,
we are, we're liable. Um, and that doesn't seem like a good idea to me. I think the, um, the question around the appeal, I don't, I don't know. Like, I just, I don't know, I don't know that in terms of process. Um, I think, uh, I think as, as I, as I, I think
articulated, um, it's not that there, there are losses. Like, there are losses, um, to, there are losses in having the 2024 law vacated, but we are not in control of that. And I think I would prefer to be operating, particularly as a policy committee, and I guess
I will speak as the chair of the policy committee, not for the policy committee, but that I would prefer to be operating from a position where I knew we were working from policies that were legal, And that then as we tried to rebuild the protections, we knew that we had that baseline and that we could then work strategically toward that.
That would just seem like a much more comfortable position and a more defensible position. I guess I would prefer for us to have those additional potential expanded protections that you mentioned, Colin, us considering in place in advance of voting to change this.
understanding all the legal repercussions um i um just given my uncertainty about um about whether this is in flux and and the whole uncertainty around around it i it just gives me pause to to vote for it again fully understanding the the legal implications um i guess my concern
is I don't feel like I fully understand what the legal ramifications are, like what are we opening ourselves up to. My initial thought is the recommendation from the policy chair puts us in compliance. I feel like we make ourselves a target if we maintain policies that are knowingly
and clearly out of alignment with the law. I have much more faith that if we make this change, are in compliance with the law, and I have faith in this board and the policy committee that they will bring back, you know, the best way to get those protections back in place to the best of
our abilities to protect our students and our staff as we think is appropriate. I just, I would be, I feel like I would be uncomfortable to put us in a position where I knew we were out of compliance with the law, basically asking someone to test it, you know, which I don't think we want
to do. Question there, Michelle, is when I said understanding the legal implications, is I'm assuming that if we're in violation, they could open an investigation into the school, and it could potentially lead to loss of funding, but I guess I don't know. And I believe I've read that
there's never, that that has never occurred in history, the history of Title IX, where a school was investigated and lost funding, but that certainly, I mean, we're in a new kind of era. It certainly doesn't mean it couldn't happen. I think, I mean, yes, I think that's, I think that's
a very big question. I think the way I'm thinking about it in terms of our liability doesn't have to do with federal funding. It simply has to do with if, if, if Cynthia, if a, if a student comes to Cynthia tomorrow and says, I've been sexually harassed, and names an accuser, the accuser's
family would, in all likelihood, immediately sue us. And that doesn't have anything to do with federal funding. It just has to do with that we followed rules that do not exist. And so therefore, we are not following the law, and therefore, it seems like that is a pretty cut and dry
case just for that accuser's family. So again, I haven't been even thinking about the question of federal funding in terms of this. Not to say it's not related, but it hasn't been part of the calculus as I've been thinking about it. My question is, what exactly is in violation of
the law? Would it be that the policy hasn't been updated yet, or is it that, is it how our Title IX coordinator handled it? And does the Title IX coordinator have to follow the policy, or does the Title IX coordinator have to follow the law? So even if the policy is not updated, you would
still be following the law. And I'm curious, so maybe you can say more like, well, never mind, nope, I'm not going to ask that question. But that, I think, is something to think about or to consider and I guess my question comes back to what part is the invite are we invite would we
be in violation by having a policy that's not updated yet or is by following our policy would it be that we would be following the policy and and I'll say this is a really this is a really difficult this you know discussion and the decision for the board what's difficult for
administrators is that we're required by you all to follow your policies yet you have a policy that is now in violation of the law. So that puts, that would put our Title IX coordinator in a really, really tricky position because she's been obligated to follow your policies, yet
your policy is in violation. And that's what, you know, makes it difficult. And I think Colleen did a nice example. It's not even necessarily the federal funding, but it's the lawsuits that we're not carrying this out by the law.
Well, I had shared this with you earlier, but I feel the same way that Beth does. I think we have to follow the law, and otherwise, I just think that puts everybody at risk, and I don't think that that's worth it. Could it change again? Yes, and then we bring it back, but I think we have to follow the law.
It's the best thing to do, that we could do, in my opinion. I just have one follow-up question. For the ACAA, that's for the transgender, that is still considered to follow the law because it's drawing from the main human rights. Okay. So until that gets challenged, that's fine.
Yeah, and just to be very clear, Title IX is not referenced in that policy at all. Do you have a question, Beth? No, I just answered the question that was brewing in my brain. He just sensed it. I even did one of those searches where you go to the menu on the internet browser
and you like say find you know and i searched for all sorts of different ways in which i could have written title nine and it's not there good okay other comments or questions i just i just want to say this sucks yeah i just want to be very clear and as i tried to outline in my um in my
remarks um the uh students and staff have fewer protections now than they did before particularly the population of women and girls who are most likely to experience sexual harassment and sexual violence. That is not something we control. And so I do not like sitting next to Phoebe and
saying that that is so as a student here, but that is so. But also, as I said to all of you, and again, I'm saying partially to Phoebe, but also all the other students, is that yes, we would like to continue to work to find ways to bring back those protections in a way that is
the way that meets the needs of the students and respects the students and staff while also complying with law. So you said we could like have another policy that puts those protections back? I mean this is where this is where it goes beyond the it goes beyond the expertise of the
policy committee or anybody on the board but we are allowed the board is allowed to have to have policies in place that make stricter rules than what is required of us by either federal or state government. I currently am not capable of going through these documents and finding a way to pull
out those protections in a way that I could have any sense of understanding how it would actually, what law it would follow, or whether it's under state law or whether there's other federal law. Um, that's just, that's beyond our capacity.
Um, but I, but I know that we can do that technically, um, but it would just be a matter of looking into it, um, and asking for legal counsel on what are the mechanisms available to us to do that. So it would take, like, quite a bit of time?
Yeah, I mean, I can't speak to that. I mean, I think, I think initially, I think when I was thinking about this, I was, I was trying to figure out a way, is there some way that, in good conscience, the policy committee could come to you and say, we have a way of revising these five policies so that they meet
Title IX while also maintaining all the protections. But we cannot, we are not capable of doing that currently. And we just need counsel on doing it. So in terms, I mean, I would like to have it happen immediately but i i would not control that particular process so similar to the policy
for pregnant students we changed that's a good yeah that's a good example right exactly so like for that so for example yeah so um under under 2020 um title nine policy students are not required sorry schools are not required to offer those protections to pregnant students they may do so
but they're not required to do so. And so that's why making that one word change was weirdly easy to keep us in compliance, but it's not easy. It's not in any way like that with the other policies. Have we been given a deadline for compliance?
Not that I'm aware of. We're already out of compliance. Yeah, I mean, we're out of compliance as of January, whatever it was, or January 9th. But everybody was out of compliance, so, yeah. Maybe they weren't. Yeah. That's true. I guess I'm just wondering if there's, you know, like a grace period, because I agree with you, Michelle.
I trust the policy committee to go forward and make policies that would help or bring something back to us, consult with legal counsel, but would, again, like to have those in place before we, before I vote to roll back any protections.
but I guess, you know, like, so if we were out of compliance as of January 9th, does that mean that a family could sue us that had a case from January 9th till now? Does it mean if we take another month and develop those policies and then vote, like, is that putting us at greater risk? I guess I just, I'm just wondering about that.
Yeah, I don't, I can't answer all of that, but I think that, I think, and Cynthia just catch me on this, but my sense would be if we tried to do that, if we tried to not revert and quickly try to get our legal counsel or other aid in revising these,
it would be a quite complicated, just even motion, because we'd basically be saying we're reverting except for these other things. Otherwise, we would be going through our normal process of first and second read, which would take at least a month and a half or two months to do.
Once they were done, exactly, once they were done. So I think just, again, Cynthia, I'm not sure how. I see that you are awake, but I'm barely awake. But yeah, I think just in terms of that process, I don't think that could happen any time soon,
So we would just be indefinitely postponing the moment where we would be reverting and we'd be extending that period of time where Cynthia is caught in a position where she's out of compliance with our policies but is trying to maintain compliance with law.
Can I just ask a clarification question? Then I'm noticing the way that the motion is written. When we revert, we don't need to have a first and second read. We just go back to the last policy. All right, thanks. Would you like me to tell you what the little thing is that we would be changing as part of the reversion?
Just because there is a, there's one thing. Basically, between 2020 and 2024, the main legislature enacted LD-598, which is an act to prohibit discrimination in employment in school based on hair texture and hairstyle. So my, I guess maybe it would be an amended motion.
Is it an amended motion? Amended motion would be that we revert with, and I would read the two places where we would insert that language to make sure that we're then in compliance with the main state law as well. That's not to shut down conversation. That's just to say that's the information that I didn't tell you before.
Oh, yes. Cynthia, how much of this do I, how much of this do I read? And when do I, and when, and when do I read it? No, no, no, no, no, no, no. It's just a, um, okay, tell you what, I'm just, I'm just going to read it. I'm just going to tell you everything. Say again?
Okay, great. Number one. Here's the sentence we need to be sure to add back into the reverted policies ACAA and ACAB. Quote, quote, race, the first quote, includes traits associated with race, including hair texture, afro hairstyles, and protective hairstyles, including braids, twists, and locks. The sentence will live between the first two paragraphs on page one.
i believe that's uh yeah i had it yes yes right there right there yes um and then we would be doing similarly uh we would be adding the following phrasing into the um procedures associated with each of those um so into a c a a r and a c a b r um we would be adding uh
The phrase, we add the phrase so that the word race appears. In the definitions, section one. Okay, definitions. Let's all turn our hymnals to... Section one, where it says discrimination or harassment. On the second line down, which for students includes...
Okay, so we're on page one of ACAA. Yeah, sorry, I did write that down because I came over and talked to you about it. You were very nice and told me where to put it. Okay, so yeah, on page 1 of 15 of ACAA-R, under definitions, section 1, under A, discrimination,
harassment, complaint, procedure, definitions, in the second line of number 1, you'll find the word race. It says, which for students includes race, color, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, etc. We need to insert, after race, but before the comma, the parenthetical, including traits associated with race involving hair texture, afro hairstyles, and protective hairstyles, such as braids, twists, and locks, and parenthetical, and then there would be the comma.
And that would happen also in ACAB R. Is that correct, Cynthia? Yeah. Okay, thank you for that. and um they both amended their motions for that so good uh any other questions concerns before we take a vote phoebe has a thing um i guess i'm just wondering like until we're able to
you know hopefully get some of these protections back in place like do we just like sit and wait or like is there anything we can do until then like as a board or as like like the administrators or something like anything yes yes i was just going to say following the vote understanding
like i think i know the way it's going to go like could the board send out a communication to the community like reaffirming our commitment to protecting students and saying that i don't know if we can say that we intend to pursue whatever we're going to intend to pursue but
like something like that in, in, in, um, acknowledgement of the comment that we heard tonight and et cetera. I mean, a few of these things, just to answer your question, Phoebe, I mean, a few of these things are like the first one that I listed was that schools are no longer
required to provide modifications for students who are pregnant. We're not required to do so, but we do, we do that already. We have that policy in place. Um, um, we cannot do anything about the narrow definition of sexual harassment in terms of how it's defined under Title IX.
Could we eventually create a situation where we have a definition of sexual harassment that is broader than that and is covered through some other legal framework? I believe so. I would like to understand that better. I think we would have to comply
with the reinstatement of requirements that sexual harassment hearings are live. We wouldn't have an option on that. The question around privacy rights, I think that's an interesting one. I think that might be something where I might even just ask Gene and Cynthia to think about that, of just saying, like, right now, are there privacy rights that we can offer
that go beyond what is required by Title IX. The 2020 rules means that we have a decreased responsibility to monitor programs and activities for sexual harassment. But I think we could probably just very clearly say to Gene and Cynthia, we would like you to continue to monitor programs and activities for sexual harassment.
The abolished requirement for prompt timeframes, but I think, again, I could imagine that would still be a goal, right? Because, you know, it's not a requirement to do that. And I guess maybe the biggest one is the decreased requirements
to provide informal and formal supportive measures. I mean, I guess I don't think that tomorrow we would be changing anything in terms of the actual support that we would be providing to victims. we would be providing what we would be providing and those would we just would
not be required to necessarily do all of those things but those are just our practices anyway so I'm not sure if that answers your question but and to me I kind of equate it to sort of the ACAA right we memorialized it and we put it
down on paper but we would we were providing those supports to our students already and this just made it very clear that this is what we were doing and how we were supporting them. And I think I envision a lot of those same things the same way. We're not
going to say, oh, we don't have to anymore. We're not going to provide those supports. We're not going to maintain privacy. We're not going to monitor our programs. You know, they may not be the law, but they're probably still best practices. So, you know, we would continue to
do those things. Yeah, that's super helpful. Thank you. Okay. Everyone ready for a vote? All those in favor? Opposed? Thank you. And to Tamara's point about a way that we could communicate our continued support for all the parts that were in that Title IX,
I'm definitely open to a way we can... Who's our strategic communications people? Can we task them with something like that? Danielle's just pointing at people. Oh, it's Kara! So do you think that's something that might be an appropriate thing for them to take up?
I think what we could do is probably draft something and then bring it to the board, and the board could take formal action on that. And if that makes sense. And maybe it comes in a form of a co-signed letter between you and I as the administration and the board.
Absolutely. So thank you for all your work on that, Colin. Any chance you could email those comments to me? Thank you. Or the board, I guess. Could you email them? Yeah, just send them to the board. I will email them to all the email addresses. Individually? Billions of email addresses. 2.3 million email addresses? No, sorry. Is that it? I think that's it, right? Did we have anything else we had to... Oh, we're back to public comment.
Oh, yes, thanks. Okay, so, yeah, I mean, we didn't have new business or personnel, and we didn't vote to tackle those today anyway, So we'll move those other policy ones to our next board meeting. Do they move to the next board meeting, or do they move to the next policy meeting, which would be the second one in March? Either way. Do that one? Do the second one? Or you can make it where we have it. Okay, let's, yeah, find some space. Yep. And we'll get it on. Okay, great. Then I would, with thanks, take a motion to adjourn.
Diane and Beth, all those in favor? Great. Thank you.
Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.
