Skip to content

TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 26 March 2025

Board meeting · 3 h 47 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →

Computer-made transcript, not a record of what was said. It mishears names and figures and drops short words, such as the "not" in "does not carry". Click a time to hear the recording, which settles any disagreement. The district's minutes are the official record.

31,637 words in 44 five-minute windows.

0:00

It's pretty good. Yes. How's he feeling about eating? He's hoping it's a little 1.30. Yeah, me too. I told him I'm going to pull it right. He's got a bunch of tests this week. We were away last week. Yeah. So if you're making a sweater, you may have another piece to show up. Yes. I just didn't bother. I think that looks fine. My friends were like, this is a really long. You should check. Sure enough. Oh, good. Yeah. I just didn't bother. I think that looks fine. My friends were like, this is really long. You should check. Sure enough. good evening welcome to the RSU five board of directors meeting it is Wednesday

March 26 2025 we are here in the Freeport High School anyone who was here or saw us last week will appreciate that we have lights not all the lamps in the building in the room so thank you Glenn for for making that happen for us we

have a full board this evening and a lot to talk about so we will get started I will start with the Pledge of Allegiance for consideration and approval of the minutes from the March 19th 2025 meeting as presented, barring any errors or omissions. Kara and Danielle, thank you. All those in favor? Great. None opposed. Adjustments? I have one this evening under number eight,

reports from the superintendent. I would like to move the current letter C, which is update on FY26 superintendent's proposed budget. I'd like to make that letter D, and I'd like to add a C because I have a resignation to announce that seemed like that was a better flow for the meeting this evening and that's

it all right so we will get started with good news and recognition and we will look to moon for an update well I guess recently as of today two girls from whose names are we a wheeza and my growth from Tanzania visited our school

for part of the day and they're from a part of the secondary education for girls advancement program and they're here to just I guess learn and study here and I guess this girl named Edie Kaplan started the secondary education for

girls advancement club here FHS recent last year and it's a part of her senior project to I guess tie fundraising and awareness for this program to I guess increase its longevity and then also the main congressional delegation are hosting

service Academy information night on April 10th at 6 p.m. to learn about the application nomination process and then O's and like represent a representatives from the US Merchant Marine Academy and other federal services will be there to answer questions and then also annually main

the main art teachers are asked to select one student to work to showcase at the main portland museum of art uh for the young the youth art month in march and um elliot anderson won the award and her art piece is being displayed up there and then also lastly um there's a food

drive at the high school that ends on april 11th and um be really helpful for baby diapers sizes three four and five canned soup and cat and dog food to be donated thank you okay so we will move on to public comments, which I think Cynthia is coming to bring me this paper. So we do have a

couple opportunities for folks to speak this evening. Similar to last week, we have our normal public comment, one here, one at the end of the agenda. Those are our traditional public comment where we ask you to come up to the microphone, give us your name, where you live, and share

whatever you'd like to share with us within three minutes and then we also have another opportunity for public input on the budget a little bit after a little bit further down the agenda after the superintendent's report so folks had specific questions they wanted asked or concerns or items specific to the budget

5:06

public comment you could speak to anything around education the public input is really around budget commentary but you can talk about the budget during public comment too if you like. So we will get started. I have four folks listed for

public comments and we will start with Trevor. Hi everybody. My name is Trevor Bean. While I am the CEA president, I am here today as a 12-year employee of RSU 5. I love RSU 5. I love the students. I love the community. I love the supportive board and the district's commitment

to supporting growth of educators um i'm concerned that recent discussions around the budget kind of have a tendency are seemingly almost pitting building versus building or town versus town um and those talks around like specific changes and and things what i i think um are maybe having

a tendency to lose sight of the forest for the trees so i'd like to talk about the big picture um just as you're considering uh budget uh decisions research shows that smaller class sizes mean better outcomes for students and this is more true the younger the

students are our class size policy reflects that and regardless of the exact class numbers the spirit of the policy is that younger kids need more individual attention than older students do so district-wide I would ask are we

thinking about what is best for kids and moreover just noting that most schools actually have an increase in student numbers for next year and district-wide we're only down 21 students in the project projected enrollment so if you

could please consider all this as you make your decisions I would appreciate that on a separate note qualitatively I just want to say this is a conversation that I've had with several colleagues but one particular today teaching has

gotten harder living through so many unprecedented moments has an impact on anyone. And it clearly has an impact on our students. I think parenting is harder. Teaching is harder. Being a kid is harder right now. And while I am a better, stronger teacher than I was

five, ten, or more years ago, the job has not gotten easier for that. Thank you. Thank you, Trevor. Let me see. Let me just, sorry, I didn't ask Trevor, just your name and the town where you live. Trevor lives in Auburn. Thank you Tracy. Good evening Superintendent Scarappa and members

of the board of directors. My name is Tracy Tremblay though my fifth graders at Mass Landing School call me Mrs. T. I live in Durham. This is my seventh year teaching in RSU 5 and my 26 year teaching elementary school. I love this district. I respect and appreciate Emily Grimm and all my

colleagues and wholeheartedly adore the children in my care. I arrive at school each morning by 6.50 and leave after 5 every day. I have never been employed at a school with teachers who work harder than my colleagues at Mass Landing. Without question, the variable that is most impactful

to me as an educator in terms of teacher effectiveness and therefore positive results on my students is classroom size. This year I have 16 students in my room and I've been able to establish indelibly strong relationships with each of them because of the smaller class size.

My readers and writers are experiencing a great deal of growth and success because of the support I can provide them, each of them, daily. To add on, the culture of kindness and mutual respect is palpable within my room with my students because of our small, tightly knit community. Juxtapose

that to my homeroom last year. I had 24 students in my room, which is eight more children than this year. That meant I needed two more tables in our classroom and we couldn't even sit on the rug together for our morning meetings because we didn't have the physical space. My students did

not make the academic and social emotional gains they would have had I been able to provide more support in a smaller classroom setting. In my heart of hearts, I know a large class size has caused me to be less effective than when we went through remote learning during COVID. Imagine that

a large class size caused me to be less effective for my students than during a global pandemic. I am sharing all this with you because you're planning to eliminate the one-year fourth grade teacher position at Mass Landing. That means the fifth grade, the five third grade classes will

funnel into four classrooms when that group matriculates. Inevitably, that also means the extremely talented fourth grade teachers will not be as effective for those students. It's impossible. Lastly, as I've said, I live in Durham, and that's where I pay taxes.

10:12

I would rather my taxes go up so students in RSU 5 can get the support and education they deserve. To do that, class sizes need to remain at 20 or below, and we need to keep five fourth-grade teachers at Mass Landing School.

I'd like to close with this. My fifth-graders are currently in the middle of writing persuasive essays, and I challenge them to end their drafts by providing their audience with action steps. Here's an action step I'd like to share with you. Keep all 4th grade classroom teachers at Mass Landing School next year. Then, moving forward as a board, work toward creating smaller yet equitable classroom sizes across RSU 5.

It is simply what's best for kids. It has taken us at Mass Landing a while to find our voice, but we're here tonight. Thank you for your valuable time and your thoughtful consideration. Thank you, Tracy. Janice. Hi there. Janice Flynn from Freeport.

I'm a grandmother to a student in elementary school. I want to thank the board for letting me speak tonight. And I have to say, I attended last week's rather lengthy meeting, and there was a lot of talk about programs and positions.

And what I witnessed, I have to say, was pretty impressive, a wonderful example of the community coming together to try to figure it out. I listened for four and a half exhausting hours as the school board members agreed and disagreed.

in. I both applaud and I appreciate all your efforts because you worked hard. I listened as the chair and the board members express anxiety and concern with the ever-increasing tax burden to bring the district property taxpayers. And I also heard one board member

express the increase as just a pizza a week. I disagree with that cavalier dismissal of the ever-increasing tax burden that the property owners in the district have had to bear year over year to maintain the public school system, and I also had one, actually more than one

board member, wonder why more district people hadn't come to express their opinions or concerns so that the board would have more community input to work with, and I have to say, I have an idea why, because at least from my perspective, we come, and I see that you guys are listening,

but I don't think that we're being heard. I hear, and I have heard these people concerned about positions and programs, and what I haven't heard is any concern about where we are in the nation as a state. We are lost. We are lost. I don't hear talk about education. I hear talk about

special education. I hear talk about English language learners. I hear all of this time and attention and passion going to everything but the 81% of the students in the district that are not getting an education. They're not moving forward. I'm not, I think the educational system is dead

for the 81% of those students, and I'm sorry for that. I'm not sure what's wrong. We need a new path. You need a new direction in education. We need to, I hear about equity, that word all the time. What the education these kids are getting is not equitable at all. All the attention time

is being spent on how do we feel? Are we belonging? But we are dead last in the nation, and I don't hear any concern for that at all. It's like you're all in a vacuum of everything is just fine, and we can't cut this one position. I think we need a new path forward. We need a better map that works.

I think the teachers are wonderful here. I think my grandson loves the teachers. I just think that the ability of the programs that the teachers are getting to teach are terrible. And I think you need a new path forward. And I hope we find it.

And I am going to vote no on the budget because I don't see anything here that's going to help the 80% of the kids get a better education. They are still dead last and I'm going to talk to everybody I know about the budget and ask them to vote no as well. And until you come here and you show me something that is going to bring up the educational level of the students in the state of Maine, I'll continue to vote no on the budget.

Thank you, Janice. Crystal. Good evening, and thank you for allowing me to speak tonight. My name is Crystal Bushy, and I am a third-grade teacher at Mass Landing School. I sent a letter to all of you last evening expressing my concern

about the fourth-grade teacher elimination that's being proposed. I have been teaching at Mass Landing School for 23 years now, and in that time, I've come to realize that the most important things are communication, collaboration, and community. And this district

15:14

is a wonderful place to work. I have so enjoyed my time here. I totally agree with what Trevor said that teaching is getting harder. 100%. It is so different than it used to be. And so as a third grade teacher in that cohort, working with them every day, I'm begging you to not cut the

position. I think it would be an astronomical devastating decision. I feel that teachers are working so incredibly hard the teachers at mass landing and i think in rsu 5 are committed we're dedicated we're hard working we put in so many hours and i i just i'm asking you to rethink it

and to speak to what was your name janice to speak with to what janice is saying i wonder if we can stop thinking about cutting positions and think outside the box a little bit and maybe look at other things like curriculum, right? Like rethinking where we're at and where we want to go

because that's not okay that we're dead last, right? So I just am wondering there's got to be other ways that we can think about things without cutting the people who are most important in these children's lives because I can guarantee you everybody who works at Mass Landing is amazing

and does incredible things for your children so thank you for your time thank you for sharing your kids with us and i hope you really reconsider thinking about the budget cuts at mass landing thank you thank you crystal okay so that's who we had on the uh initial public comment

list and like i said we have a few more opportunities if if someone is is moved to speak but we will continue on with the agenda and move on to item 8 report from the superintendent hey we'll start with 8a this has some information this

isn't being non-budget information but just some some celebrations that believe some celebrations of things that are happening in our school list and some updates planning for our extended school year our ESY programming is well

underway. This annual programming provides continued educational support for our special education students to ensure they maintain progress during the summer months. This year, our program will run from July 7th to the 31st, Monday through Thursday, 8 a.m. to 11 a.m.

And if there are folks out there who would like to work in our ESY program this summer, they can apply right online, or if they want more information, they can contact our Director of Instructional Support, Alicia Morris, for more information. Our Director of School Nutrition,

Erica Mullally, held a focus group with fifth graders from Mass Landing School. They had provided some lunch feedback on our most recent student survey, and she thoughtfully listened to their ideas. In addition, through her collaboration with the Maine Coast Fishermen's Association,

She hosted a fish-taught tasting at schools, at all schools, actually, and it resulted in many of our kids experiencing new food for the first time. I am pleased to announce that our Ness Landon staff, in collaboration with families,

the chronic absenteeism rate is at 5.5%, and we shared this is at the lowest in recent memory. So, well job for staff and families. Our first graders at Moist Street had an opportunity to see a live performance of Frog and Toad at Merrill Auditorium.

And I think that's a phenomenal experience for kids who may have never seen theater production before. I wish I could have gone with them. And over the last few weeks at Moist Street School, as you know, they have a family engagement goal that Principal Nickerson shared with you this fall.

They have families have had an opportunity to go into school and experience some special classes. So kindergarten, families of kindergartners got to see music. First grade families got to see PE and second grade families got to see art.

So those are some positive things that are happening in our schools that I wanted to share with the board. Letter B, support staff new hire. I'm always happy when I say we've hired a bus driver. we welcome Alicia Bennett to our team and I just want to say in general for our bus drivers a

special shout out to our team and to our director Jeremy Arsenal because Monday sometimes what's predicted for weather like warming temperatures and rain does not happen and that did not happen at all Monday afternoon and they did a phenomenal job getting our students home safely so I just

20:24

want to shout out to them. Letter C, resignation. I'm announcing a resignation in Amy St. Pierre, principal of Freeport Middle School. So now our new D, review of the superintendent's budget. What I think I'd like to do is I've collected the questions from you folks from last week,

so we've prepared some answers to some of those. Let's start with, if we could, I'm going to have Dr. Fournier from Freeport Middle School come up. There were two questions that were posed by the board. There was a question about differentiation, and there was also a question regarding the wellness content.

Can you get this up? I'm going to lean. So do you all have a copy of the wellness? Okay, great. So these are the wellness, or the health education standards. you're gonna have to figure out the mic for you no i'm sorry that better not as tall as you

yeah so health education standards you all have they're pretty um broad in the way that different schools have um addressed each of the topics have varied so we've started some of the work at looking at how those could be attacked in different manners so for instance like nutrition

that's just one example it could be flowing into like the digestive system unit and um you know environmental health and awareness some of that work could possibly fall into stem and science too and then we talked about how our advisory activities our guidance counselor

and the work that we do um across that sel work that we do in our building could attack some of the things like stress and worry or empathy and mental health so we've sometimes had the speakers do that work or different teachers have addressed those things so there are specific things connected

to the health standards that this is the preliminary work that we're talking about at looking at ways but there's some excitement around it looking at it through a different lens are you pausing for questions on this part okay do do folks have questions okay this might be more

of a question for you Dr. Scrappa is there a wellness committee still in our district we have struggled with our wellness committee in the district and I last year I think I'm when Erin Dow was here she as the school nutrition

director was heading up that committee and I know Kelly was on it as well and the struggle was getting people to serve on that committee I was on it right cages there we helped like adjust one of the policies like we had some momentum

and that's required by policy some of the work you have to do every so many years look at that but there's not another district level other than this group that we've it was like kelly and aaron and i on a zoom meeting okay um and i should have asked that before i was at a school

wellness conference not too long ago for another for my own work reason and sounds like that's required to have a district wellness and we have that you required in their main functions really to look at that policy at what every so

many years which they do and so we have this committee but they don't meet regularly and part of it is as Paige said it was Erin Kelly and Paige despite Erin did a lot of efforts to recruit. Yeah one other parent we had on and off so it had some

momentum and then I'm not currently active in it but I'd love to be. It's great work. Sounds like you're still on it you just haven't met. Yeah yeah sure. Other questions for Paige on the health piece? So these are the these all the health standards or are these the specific health

standards that that health two was doing? This is like what our state tells us. Oh okay so this is both health one and health two accomplish these okay thank you thanks page um so it would be fair to say that uh as y'all are figuring out how to address if if the um if wellness two is cut um

25:37

would be fair to say that you all are going to be looking at this as kind of your guide for um what standards and performance expectations are going to be knit to what other specific classes and so theoretically in September um uh you or someone like you uh could come back and kind of

tell us that absolutely and could say like all right these showed you the standards we need to meet them this is how we're meeting them yes because we haven't always had a wellness to teacher so we've had this a the thought of looking at it through a scientific lens is sort of a new

one that we that's where the excitement might be is thinking about how you know tech might absorb our internet safety piece that's addressed in here there's so many that sort of overflow other topics as you can see they're really broad it's not like a curriculum that we're like ditching

it's another way of looking at how are we addressing health and prioritizing in our building and so through our PE which that person has done health in the past and so has done a mix of things excitement there around that to human growth and development that's something

that we would stick you know to what we've always done make sure that it's a rich approach to that but some of these other things could fall in a bunch of different ways in our building I have to say I kind of like the idea of weaving all of these different topics in throughout the day in

different classes just because it means that the conversations keep happening throughout the day, throughout the, you know, just everywhere. And I think it could be a very effective way of addressing these if it's done well. Okay, I think you can carry on. So the other piece is just the

differentiation question. So yeah, thinking about how we differentiate for students. It's a passion of mine actually it's something that i've studied for many years um and i lean back into just some data like how do we think about the best way to approach different kinds of learners right

and so we've gone back and forth on this so if we're thinking about one of the ways we've addressed it this year um we've looked at um some one of you know different classes and how we're going to serve students and really when we look at best practices having students like clustered

or tracked really like doesn't have the you know if we're talking effect size or like this impact that we're looking for for students that isn't our best practice really like this tier one and then tier two in our mtss system of how we approach students that have a variety of learning

is the best way to make sure that students are reaching these things and so currently we've had these pieces of jobs and some of them have just been built around numbers and now I think our goal is really to dig into RTI particularly now that we know that we'll have these two specific

teachers doing that work and just ensuring that we're building that tier one support within the classroom and then having tier two be really prescripted and intentional and what is our system to do that we've been picking away at that for years but we have met again just in the last

few weeks we're meeting again on friday talking about next year what kind of programs can we be looking at progress monitoring supporting students in a variety of ways and i think that's going to be ongoing work to make sure that we're you know pushing students that are at the higher end of

our spectrum that we're thinking about and also supporting students that might need a little more so so I'm clear what you're saying is that these little part-time positions that have basically been the classroom teachers for these smaller classes that is perhaps actually not best

practice for supporting these types of learners I mean John Hattie he's like the guy that I lean to is visible learning he would say that effect size is almost negative to cluster kids because then you're you might be having students not that rigor of having a diverse community of learners

now not all of those small pieces were that some of them were blended in and this is where it's messy upon like me explaining how these pieces got added along the way but some of them are just for big cohorts too. So now it's a bit confusing about what each of them are, but I think in moving

30:43

forward, clustering kids on their ability levels, we would want to be thinking about differentiation at tier one and at tier two instead. Questions for Paige on that? Don't go far. I'm sure we'll have more questions for you, but thank you. Okay. We had a couple of questions

today was about projected enrollment so there's a question about is a projected enrollment we have for schools per grade level enrollment numbers of October 2024 and that's correct we always have it's our October 1st count and that's

where we always build our budget from and part of this at some point you have to put a pin in it for like you know what's what's when we're looking at our actual October 1 count we put a pin in our data and then what we do is we roll

those kids up to the next grade a tricky spot for us is always pre-k and sometimes K because those are those are incoming students so that's how we start that process and then when's the earliest date prior to next school year

that schools have realistic numbers of what that will really look like and really it settles down when we really know it's about after the first week of school because we have kids all it actually today I just found we're losing

three students after April vacation they leave and then we have kids come in so there's an ebb and flow and then until we really start school really have kids in seats and then then it's it's more of it slows down a little bit but it's

constant throughout the year and in the summer as well that sometimes there are families that will let us know they're moving sometimes they don't let us know they're moving until school starts we found out or until we get a request for records the sit in the same with the kids that are coming so that's where it's

really it's it's that ebb and flow which is it's not scientific but that's really what what we when we observe also asked about the number of filled and unfilled at tech positions so we pulled our data and I'm gonna separate them

into two buckets Janet and then we'll do special ed separately and at this moment in time for gen ed positions there are six that are vacant to a posted and then the floor that a proposal reductions aren't posted and they haven't they haven't been posted for special education as at this moment in

time there are eight that are vacant right now I'll say eight plus two because if you recall we made requests a few months ago to take two positions that are vacant at the high school because they struggled to get positions and combined with to make a teacher position I'm so really there would be ten we can

count those two that are vacant at this moment in time and as I shared before our priority is filling those special education ed techs first those are required some students need adult support in their IEP so that that is our

priority over those others but those are the numbers I always say at this moment time because I know today that Alicia was interviewing people for special education and text I always get hopeful when I see see that happening but again

that's been an ebb and flow for us the other thing that I was asked last week that I couldn't immediately put my hands on but I can now I was asked by the board what are other districts looking like looking at for increases so I'll

say again this is at this moment in time that I can share share with what they have publicly shared with their communities sad 75 and this is the percentage of increase year-over-year four point seven three percent at this

moment sad six is four point seven seven in the most of me that that people are saying that it's evolving they're not done Brunswick is at 508 Sebago is five South Portland's 525, RSU 14's 539, Portland's 567, Falmouth's 597,

NSAD 15's 676, Gorham's 69, Westbrook's 695, SAD 51, 747, and Yarmouth's 756. The only one that's done at this moment in terms of their school community is Yarmouth has adopted it as headed to their town council and all the other

folks some of these haven't been they have an update I asked for a new update they haven't been updated since March 17 so they're still in process and that's what I see from notes for my colleagues they're still in process and some folks

are saying they're likely like they're you know looking at may go down no I see may go down below 5% not ready to vote yet so they're all still in process so I I wouldn't want to say that those are definitely what they're happening.

35:57

But looking at, as you notice, I sorted them for us. So I'll just go with the, not the items that the board was considering last week to put back in, but just the superintendents proposed to give us an idea where we were. We were at the 573, and of those folks, there's one, two, three, four, seven that are below us,

one, two, three, four, five, and six that are above us at that data, which was last week. So I had that information. And then it was one more request that we're going to actually ask Michelle to respond to, talking about state valuation,

equalized money rate, 279. So we're going to let Michelle do that one. I'm going to ask Maura to just ask her question, just so everyone knows what the question was. Because I feel like this is, we go through this generally every year around what are the differences and why is it different and change. so happy to happy to tackle that great thank you so much for all the

information um so on the I had been looking at the 8279 form which is the form that has the amount that were required to raise by the state and has like the how the state calculates basically EPS essential programs and services and what we have to provide in order to get the state funding and they have a way that they calculate the valuation in each of our three towns and

then we have on our documents the way that I'm assuming the towns calculate it and those two figures are different and so just looking at them there seemed to be quite a discrepancy and I know that's because the state has their own way of

calculating the value and they equalize it across the whole state but I'll let you speak further yes so um because towns across the state don't necessarily mark to market if you will on their valuations um you know the goal is to be a hundred percent of the current market

valuation right um but particularly smaller towns don't often do that because there's a cost to revaluating revaluing all of the properties in town um some places do it but most don't um and the the biggest discrepancies uh i think is probably what you're referring to is

durham's uh valuation per the per the state is uh just shy of 600 million dollars and our valuation from the towns, which I probably should have had right here in my hand. Yeah, maybe. I'm used to being the last page. The valuation per the town of Durham as of April 1, 2024, which was the last valuation

date, or date that they had a value for, was $383 million, so materially less. And I believe the reason for that is there hasn't been a revaluation done in Durham in many years. There's actually one scheduled for 2027. I believe it's on the docket. So we are

roughly 50% of market value, according to the, it's actually, according to, according to what the town has said, we're at 48% of, of current market in terms of the valuation. So that's one of the reasons I always caution people to just compare mill rates across towns, because that's

not really a fair, it's not an apples to apples, it's not an apples to apples way to look at it, because if the valuation of my house is $100,000 for nice round numbers, but that's only 50% of the market value, but the tax burden that the town needs to raise is the same, regardless of what

the valuation of the town is, so I have to put more dollars per thousand into the bucket to get my portion of the taxes. So my mill rate might be $22 in Durham, but that's on a 50% of the market value. So generally what happens in a revaluation scenario is everyone's, typically,

everyone's value will go up. Taxable value will go up. But the amount of taxes that need to be collected in absolute dollars doesn't change. So how much you need to collect per thousand dollars of value, which is how we, that's what the mill rate is, is how much you're going to pay per

thousand dollars of value goes down. So my guess is that the mill rate right now is 21 and change, 21.75 for the current year. And once they do a revaluation, now it's not next year, it's not until 2027, but that mill rate will go down because the value that they're spreading that

40:58

over is higher. And what it means for individual taxpayers, for those who care, is usually in a re-evaluation, a third of the people will see their taxes go up. A third of the people will see their taxes stay roughly the same. And a third of the people actually see their taxes go down because the amount of the pie doesn't change. It's just making sure

that everybody's value is current as of the same point in time. So that's why the valuation that you see on the ED 279, so that because of situations like Durham's, and I don't think we're unique in this, I think Panels is less than 100% as well, because it's a smaller town,

so they don't revalue as frequently. You know, the state can't, they can't just use what the towns are using because that's not really fair either because evaluate that's that's a under reported number really so the state uses their own calculation and it feels a little black box

calculation to me but we did have a session on it at the MSMA sort of where we tried to nail down some numbers on how they actually use it but they use a consistent model across every town and all the property and all of the state so that they basically get a consistent valuation for all the

towns when they're determining state subsidy. So it's a three-year average. And that has changed over the last 10 years or so. I think it used to be two and then it went to three. And so that's to try and level out any spikes or massive drops in valuation for a particular town so they don't

either get clobbered one way or the other as it relates to their subsidy. So that's really the main, the main difference between the valuation you would see if you pulled up the ED279 for the towns. So just for, for folks' sake, Durham is valued at $599.2 million, and the town has it

valued at 382.8. Freeport is $2,320 million. And according to the state, according to the town, it's $2,548,000. So obviously a lot closer, but still a difference. Actually lower on the state's, on the state's valuation. But that's not overly unusual when they're doing an average, right? So

in a rising value environment, when you're averaging it out, the average will be a little bit lower than the current year whereas Freeports is like the current year as of April 1st of 2024 and then panels according to the the state is three

hundred and fifty seven million dollars and then according to the town is three hundred and five so a twenty percent or so 15 to 20 percent reduction from what the state says to what the town has on their tax rolls that help yes thank you

so much Michelle um I appreciate that you going over that so I had wanted to look at the report that those numbers come from which is like very exciting report if you've seen it it's got like all the values for all the towns in the

state that they do going back like a decade or so and so I wanted to see where those where that average of three came from and whether they were using just I they're allowed to use just the last year or three-year average if it's like lower or something like that I'm not really exactly sure yeah cuz I think they're trying to minimize cuts to subsidies so that would make sense does that Kelly may know the answer to that question she was comfortable in her

chair so I'll just say what Kelly is coming that when I was looking at that sheet and I think this is important for like a few different reasons I saw that last year and this year Durham had a significant spike and so I wanted to talk

about if there had been growth in the town if there are more taxpayers if the taxes will be spread over a bigger number of people but also I think it's good to know because of subsidy and I think like we're gonna be in a similar

situation this year so we had last year terms valuation is lower but now there's two years in a row or sorry the year before now there's two years in a row where the state valued it at over 700 million so we're gonna keep and as I

think we all know like we're gonna get less subsidy if either our student count goes down or our evaluation goes up and so I think we're in a position where if if Durham Durham is growing well if any town is growing that town is gonna collect

more be able to collect more taxes and lose some state subsidy so I just wanted that seems like a piece of the picture or that maybe we should talk about and consider because it's not only going to be an issue you know this year but it's going to continue to be an issue in future budget uh just see it's it's a three-year valuation average or the current

46:16

year whichever is lower is the one they use so they give you the benefit of whichever is lower because the lower value gives you more subsidy correct yeah no and and that is a i mean that's a great point Mara as you know one of the things we've struggled with is the with Freeport being

a minimum receiver right there is there's no technical subsidy for Freeport there's the special ed minimum adjustment but no actual subsidy and and panel is actually probably even closer to becoming a minimum receiver in terms of you know for new folks what a minimum receiver

is basically they tell you this is what we expect for essential program and services EPS is what you have to provide they have a pages 1 through 3 of the ED 272 279 tell you what those things are these are what you have to

provide we have always provided well above and beyond that but and then they say okay if this is what it costs for what we say you have to give this is your valuation this is the expected mill your required mill and that's the same across

the state. Everyone has to raise this mill based on their valuation. And if that amount that they require you to raise is less than the essential programs and services, the difference is subsidy. They go, okay, we require you to provide this. We expect you to raise that. We will contribute

the difference. So if your valuation is at a point where at that required mill, you actually can raise more than what they say is the minimum, essential programs and services, then you'll consider what's called a minimum receiver. You don't get any subsidy. Now, they do recognize that

for special ed purposes, they do provide about a million dollars. I should probably look at that number before I say that. But actually, Freeport is not a minimum receiver this year because they reduced the required mill from the prior year. So there is some actual subsidy here.

and then there's also um a little bit additional for yeah so between the subsidy usually what we get for freeport between subsidy a small amount of subsidy and the um special ed adjustment is between a million and a million two sometimes it's all special ed sometimes it's a little bit

subsidy a little bit special ed that which is the case this year so um so as durham's valuation goes up. I mean, what we hear when we meet with the towns, you know, is the growth, the housing growth. We don't really have any commercial growth in Durham. We have a new farm, that's nice, but

we don't have any commercial growth. But for residential, they have said that the housing permits are roughly 30 a year, and those have been pretty consistent for the last several. I don't know if that number is has changed but that was the last number that

we've gotten from them so I think a lot of it is valuation growing in terms of just market value like the value of homes yes yeah and just for folks reference that figure of state aid allocation by town is on the this beautiful sheet that Kelly prepares for us right yes page 11 yeah page 11 or

page 10 I was looking at the the state aid per town that just showed the numbers oh yes yes breaking down like the amount that each town gets from the state and then the required local contribution that's required by the state for each

town to contribute right and then the additional local monies that we divide up beyond that that we decide to spend okay okay thank you and I believe I've I've provided answers to all the questions you had from last week, but I'm sure as you begin deliberation, if you have more questions, we can at that time respond to them. I do have a quick update on the brochure.

I have a, so Ginny, in her magic that she is able to do, did find someone who is willing to print and mail for us a one-page document, which will have googly eyes to encourage people to look at it when they get it in their mailbox. Looky-loos, not googly eyes, sorry for the non-technical term.

Basically what it's going to say is it's going to have the dates for the annual budget meeting, it's going to have a QR code to bring people to the online brochure, which we are still creating, it's just not going to be mailed to every house, and it also is going to tell people

where they can pick up physical copies of it if they are not QR code savvy. So it's not as, you know, it's great when we can get the whole booklet into everyone's hands, but I think from a timing perspective, it was probably more important for us to come down on a budget that we are all comfortable putting forward. So hopefully we'll get that done

51:38

tonight. But at least this does, if people are looking for that brochure, this piece of paper will tell them where they can get it. So thank you, Jenny, for that. That's really great. I really appreciate that and i was wondering not that i would expect you to know offhand but if there was a cost savings due to sending out the one page versus a big oh i imagine there was

oh is it okay oh printing yeah okay um so is that where we are with updates okay lost my agenda again i should have a print my agenda on a different color so i don't lose it okay um so we are now at the public input on the budget on the proposed budget so if we have anyone who

had a specific comment or question that they would like to share with the board specific to the budget we do ask you to come up to the microphone and still tell us your name and your town but we know Trevor lives in Auburn so that's what I

would take out of tonight's meeting good evening I'm Sarah Kelly and I live in Freeport I sent a longer letter to the board very early this morning and I just really wanted to highlight a few pieces uh that this is really the convergence of value and

resources and that's kind of the conversation that's going on locally in homes in our town in you know this is not the only budget that's feeling crunched and with some uncertainty and unpredictability about what's to come in the future uh i really appreciated um maura and i

also appreciated superintendent scrappa you and your staff that dynamic spreadsheet that you shared last year that really could calculate for folks what a tax burden increase would mean in real time looking at these budgets that

was such high value work to present to this board so thank you for that I mean this is incredibly complicated but I really want to lift up the way Julie Nickerson shared about the assistant principal role. Her argument last week was this is high

value for money. And I think that is the founding principle that we need to be looking at any of these positions, cuts, any of the budget items. It was really interesting to look into some of the deeper dives on cost centers. Durham's annual report is very detailed line by line showing

some of the town-based cost centers that are going up, and they project it out to 2026, health care costs over 200% increase. You know, just the cost of keeping the lights on in these buildings is going up. This is not a surprise. And so when we're facing these incremental cost

raises, and we feel like the only way we can do that is to cut positions, you know, my heart goes out to all of you for these decisions. And I hope that we can just continue to keep value for what we're offering at the center. I did have an opportunity to kind of do some math and look at

this argument of a pizza per month and whatnot. And a 1% increase, there's already going to be a 5.73% increase. So I appreciated, Colin, that you brought up that straw man last week about, is anybody willing to go a little bit higher to consider here? A 1% increase for a median tax

bill burden for Durham would be $40 per household beyond the 5.73. So already knowing there. But knowing if there's any appetite to go up and hear that some schools are going between 4 and 7%, you know, I think that's the conversation that you have to have tonight. The median tax bill for a

1% increase for Freeport would be $50 and same for Pownall. So that's kind of some of the napkin math that I did as best I could deep diving into where we're at and I think that's really important to consider when you center the conversation around value for money and what taxpayers can

bring forth so thank you. Thank you Sarah. Giving people a moment. Beth is counting to seven for me. So we will move on to item 10 administrator reports. Kelly. I'm usually right at the podium And the budget just got me all discombobulated today. What's in your packet is actually the expenditures through February 28th, 2025.

56:48

We are on track as to where we were spending and revenue-wise fairly close to last year at this time. We are, as an administrative team, I have asked principals to start looking ahead. I kind of mentioned this at the last meeting, looking ahead as to what we need for that last semester of the year.

And to try to get all of those, as much of those monies committed as possible before we all, for the students leave on April break. Just so that we can kind of get a better handle on what we're looking at for what we might have left at the end of the year.

So that we can kind of do that final look of what projects and items can we actually get done before the end of the school year with what we have. knowing that there's many items on the list. And sometimes as costs of some capital items go over,

we have to put things off and wait towards the end of the year. So we're really kind of looking to try and get some of that stuff done as well before the end of the school year. So everyone's being mindful of budgets and trying to get as much committed as possible that they need for the end of the year. Hi, I have a quick question.

I just noticed, just looking at the interest revenue, how we're up 30 percent or so this year um and i notice for the project for next year you have it at around 259 000 but this year it's already up over 273 and so i'm just wondering is there

something that you know or are anticipating maybe an interest drop or something because i didn't know well again the interest one is always like rolling the dice right it depends on what's happening in the economy. And as we know, there's a lot going on right now. Um, and,

and I am at, you know, at the time we're, we're in January of 25, trying to look out to July 25 through June of 26. So while I, you know, um, was willing to move the mark a little bit based on some past history, there, there was some concern about what we may do as an economy and whether

there might be some sort of recession and then, you know, some interest rates dropping. I didn't want to overcommit on that. Yes, thank you very much. I was just curious. I figured that was the case, but yeah, I appreciate it. And as you know, if in fact we collect more than what we had

budgeted, it ends up in undetermined fund balance for a future year's potential use. I think the general economic expectation, the Fed, they think the Fed is probably dropping rates once, if not twice this year so I think when I got on the board the interest income line was

$25,000 so it's moved up markedly since then you know who knows exactly where that'll end up being but I think it's always it's always better to be a little conservative on the on the revenue estimate you don't have to make that up

somewhere else so questions for Kelly thank you all right so board comments and committee reports we'll start with board information exchange agenda requests any other committees that have met that would like to report out yet more we did

have an MSBA regional meeting and I've been forgetting to do updates on these sometimes but I did have a request so I wanted to make sure to share it we had a good group they've started combining different districts so it's nice to have an opportunity to hear from folks in different parts of the state we talked

about what different folks were doing with regard to cell phone policies and we heard from sad 75 that they had a working group that brought them recommendations and a proposal to be in phones and use yonder pouches and that

the board did approve it and sent it to the policy committee and next year they'll be doing that in the high school and I think the middle school although my notes are not great on that sorry about that but at least the high school and then so I wanted to mention that one specifically since it's part of our

cohort that we usually compare to I mean some other schools differed in their approaches as to whether they were looking at using the pouches or just had still had a policy at the building level like what we have so there were some

differing perspectives on that but everyone agreed like I think with what our board has and administrators have told us that it's an increasing concern um and uh oh i did think something was interesting was that um from sad 75 talking with their um

local authorities they said they'd actually prefer students didn't have phones during a crisis because it can be a distraction i just thought that was an interesting observation and if we had ever spoken with you know um our sro about that um and let's see they gave us an

1:01:57

update on some bills there was one specifically about recalling school board members like creating a process statewide that they were going to be opposing and then they had also shared about a full plates full potential webinar about the local food programs and like FDA or USDA funding

to schools that I had shared with the board and folks shared some of their tax impacts but you've already heard about that so I think that that was about it do we know if anyone was able to listen to the webinar I wasn't but the full plates the food one you know I wasn't but I think some of

the MSBA leadership did so I think they were going to follow up and if they haven't sent information about it they had said that they would share so I can I could ask about that just curious on where that where that's other comments

all right so we will move on to I think it is a joint finance facilities committee I'm gonna report since Kelly did last time on the joint I'm basically just going to read this because there's a lot of information which you guys all heard but I don't want to mess it up so we the facilities and operations

committee and the finance committee members considered two proposals put forth by administration based on feedback from the board of directors to consider the other options that did not include the spend down two million four

hundred thirty four thousand three hundred and seventy six dollars in undesignated fund balance to complete all of the life safety proposals in light of potential federal grant funding losses for the state of Maine so one is

keep original life safety proposal as is based on the high prioritization of the RSU five administrative team to protect students and staffs staff to move the door replacements and fire access devices portion of the life safety

projects back to phase one of the energy audit replace the proposed FY 26 capital projects listing with the phones and paging portion and complete the cameras and door access portion with the FY 27 proposed capital fund capital projects

funds the committee then discussed various options to fund all of the life safety projects the recommendation agreed upon by the joint committee to move to the full board of directors was one complete door replacements and fire

access devices portion of the life safety projects by moving them back to phase one of the energy audit. Two, replace the proposed FY26 capital projects listing with the phones and paging portion in the FY26 proposed local budget, which would add $6,000 to the FY26

proposed budget to fund adequately. Three, move the cameras and door access portion along with the FY26 proposed capital projects to the capital reserve account. Cameras and door access would be completed in summer 2025. Hold on FY26 capital projects until the discussion regarding federal

funding is complete. And four, it was recommended, it was further recommended to move the portion of the recommended $2,434,376 in undesignated fund balance, I'm sorry, in undesignated fund balance not needed to cover federal grant loss to the capital projects reserve account. So there we have

but that's what we discussed. You all heard it last time, but just to say it out loud. And then we had, the Finance Committee had a meeting today, and it looks like the next meeting of the Facilities and Operations Committee is on April 9th. Thank you. Questions for Beth or anyone else on the committee?

All right, so we are on to 13 unfinished business board deliberations on the FY26 superintendent proposed budget. So I'm going to ask, I just want to confirm something around the proposed budget, the vote. That doesn't include any of the items around the capital reserve, right?

Those are just moving money from basically what Beth was just talking about. The move of funds from undesignated fund balance into the Article 1 reserve and the Article 2 reserve and the capital reserve, Those are just warrant articles that the board wants on at the meeting, yes?

1:07:05

Correct. Those will come to you as part of the warrant once this portion of the budget is finalized, Articles 1 through 11. Okay. So our 13B here around the vote is the number, the Articles 1 through 11. Yes, and I believe there's a sample of that in the packet.

Dream. Yep. we should put it on a color yay um so matches the shirt um so yes that that is that that would be what we would be looking for a vote on this evening so that we can then put that all into the warrant along with the articles that were discussed at the previous meeting there was general consensus for that um and then that stuff would get sent off to the attorneys for review and

approval so that we can have it created on april 9th right perfect okay so um but we're doing we're not voting by article we're voting by the whole budget in terms of a dollar amount right or we're the approved budget correct okay but usually you see it on the paper right typically at this meeting

we've agreed we've yeah there is an agreement and we have filled out that paper for you so that when you're voting on a total number you know per article what the amounts are um and you do have a something you just wait till you get three steps away sorry just stay for a

second. But you do have a, the spreadsheet for, to show us this with numbers in it based on the proposed budget. That is correct. I can project that for the board. Once you get a little further in the discussion, I would be able to show you a completed green sheet so you could look through

it. Great. Okay. So first I'm going to ask about additional questions or do people have things that they would like to ask that they feel they need to know to move forward tonight is there anything that they didn't quite get the answer to they were looking for it spawned another question

kelly yeah we've heard from a number of mass landing teachers about their concerns around the grade four teacher reduction and i would like to hear from the administrator kind of a uh how how she's viewing that good evening i'm not as tall as page not even close um so i think

when we looked at reductions when we approached this budget recognizing that that starting percentage that 12 probably wasn't a feasible number for the community i think we tried to be really thoughtful as an administrative team um and principals particularly looking across schools

at finding ways to mitigate impact to kids. So where were places, for example, where cohorts were close to that cutoff of the class size policy? So for example, that third grade cohort, which is now in five classes, is 86 students as of today. I'm looking at places, and I know, for example, Will did the very same thing in Durham. Like where are we at 44s or 45s? It may have historically been three that we could move to two without um well certainly that leads to a shift in increase

in class size it doesn't eliminate programming that's offered to students and so certainly like anytime you reduce a position that has an impact right large or small i won't say that there's not an impact of course there is both to the teachers in those classrooms um who are facilitating

learning of all those kids and to the students i think you heard that from the staff who spoke tonight. I think it's equally important to recognize, though, that we were very thoughtful and intentional as a principal team, particularly at the elementary level, at ensuring that that

reflected equal impact across all of the buildings. So I would say I know while you heard from mass learning teachers tonight, I anticipate that those sentiments very well may exist in other buildings and so to me the conversation is about more than that fourth grade teaching position

because you run the risk if that is added we will then have inequities across the district whereas it it is seen as acceptable to have 23 students in a classroom in Durham but not acceptable to have 21 in a classroom in Freeport. Other questions about that? Thank you so much Emily I appreciate

that. I had this question of all the administrators but since you're up there I'll just ask you And then if others want to chime in, maybe they can. I was wondering, in the approach to the budget, who, I know the administrators had those

1:12:17

discussions about equity across the district, as you just mentioned, but within each building when you were looking at where to make those cuts, like who was part of those conversations and what that process looked like, maybe that was different by building or maybe not.

Yeah, I don't think it's hugely different by building, but if other principal, if it is, they can jump up. So typically, those conversations happen at the leadership team level within the building. So in our building, that includes representation for each of our teams, for special ed, for

grade level teams, for the specialist. And depending on the year, those conversations look different, right? They typically start, in a typical year, they'll start with, where are we feeling like things are going well? Where do we feel like there are needs within the building? And so some of the things that have been added in the past couple of years reflect that. The assistant principal, RTIB ed techs. for example, those are recent additions that come to mind. This year, those conversations

were different because the conversation sounded more like this is not likely going to be an ad year, right? So we are not having that conversation of like, where do we want to go? Where do we want to take this building? It was more like, okay, what has the least impact? If we know that we're

going to have to look at a reduction in the building, where is that least impactful, right? And those conversations, the leadership team is at the center of those conversations. Certainly some of those conversations happen between the coordination of the leadership

team, like leader of that team and the teams. But this year it looked different knowing it wasn't like normally, sometimes we survey staff. We've done that historically where we might sound out of Google form of like, what are things that you're thinking about that would help grow our community and support kids?

This year, knowing we knew this, that 12% number, I'm going to say in October, right? and so it was a different conversation this year and then of course in january early january before the proposed budget comes to the staff i met with all with any staff who wanted to attend to talk

about this is the picture at the district level this is the picture at the mass landing level so staff had that clarity of why certain proposals were made both within our building but also at the systems level as well recognizing that across the board we were looking more closely at enrollment

And where were places that those enrollment numbers would allow for some shifts in the total number of teachers at certain grade levels? Thank you, Emily. One thing that I feel like we heard a lot about from Will, and you as well, and Julie, was about cohorts and how, you know, what might work for one cohort is not going to work for another.

and sort of where the threshold class size numbers were. They were in cohorts that it would work for, is what I thought I heard. And it seems like now we're hearing that that upcoming grade four cohort, from teachers at least, and I think we have heard from a parent, it's not really a cohort that that would work for. And I guess I was just wondering if you could respond to that. Yeah, I think a couple things that have come to mind. mean i think i hope and i i think that you you feel the passion of our mass landing teachers like

they work so hard they care so deeply about the kids in their care um i'm sure that's parallel at our other district elementary schools and so i i expect that like whatever the cohort is they want like if that cohort has been serviced with five teachers they're going to advocate

for five teachers. We look at a couple of things with cohorts though. Like one is what are the social emotional needs of the cohort? What are the academic needs of the cohort? Sometimes you have cohorts who are like concurrent needs. I would say like our fifth grade cohort, for example,

who was serviced as five third grades in their third grade year, then four in their fourth grade year, and then five again this year. Part of the reason we made that decision, that's where that position that was funded out of reserve came from is recognizing when we saw that cohort in four

both academically and social emotionally the the data did not support continuing at four um and so it's it's looking at all of those pieces right and certainly like is it is it more accessible to teach 16 kids than 21 absolutely absolutely it is and it's that balance and i mean that's the

the pleasure you get is as a team to decide where you're comfortable. But knowing we tried to be very kind of equitable and thoughtful in what reductions were proposed and recognizing like we have a lot of cohorts that have been in 20s and 21s without issue. That isn't atypical for a grade

three through five elementary school span. I just have a question because I'm just a little confused that when we were talking about we're cutting this position but in my understanding it was a one-year only position so in respect to the budget that just goes away like we would have

1:17:31

to choose to add it back in correct well it's funded out of reserve but it's actually a fifth grade position so it's a fourth grade teacher filling it but when it was added as a position from reserve it was added to this cohort in fifth grade right now so that cohort's going to the

middle school, right? So it's, it's then looking at, okay, the incoming third grade is going to maintain at five. I think they're at 80, 89 and projected enrollment. And then that shift goes to fourth. So like, yes and no, the position is currently funded through reserve, but it's

actually a fifth grade, the fifth grade cohort, which won't even be at mass landing next year. i just had a follow-up question is the the ed tech position that you're proposing is that currently um filled in your school it is yes and it has been for the duration of the position

other questions for emily on that thank you yep don't go far hold on karen might have changed your mind um was that position unfilled previously or and how long was that the ed tech position the ed tech position has been filled the three years we've had it it was added um post covid some of

You may remember when we were experiencing massive guest teacher shortages, also dealing with mandated quarantines when people got COVID or were close contacts. And so it was added to address that need, that guest teacher need. And we've used it both as a guest teacher when we don't have substitutes or we have

short teacher absences, and also then for RTI intervention when he's not pulled for that position. So we've had a single ed tech in that position for three years. Is this the bench sub position? Correct. Yep. Okay. So my thought is that we get a motion on the floor and then we can talk about it.

That seems like a way to approach it that we can then methodically go through any adjustments or not that we want to make to the proposed budget. Does that seem reasonable? So do you want to put it up on the screen? Just the proposed? Do we have it with the proposed, the recommended section?

So that's the 573. Do I have a motion for consideration approval of the FY26 superintendent proposed budget? Kelly. So we won't vote just yet. I imagine there'll be some discussion here. But while we've, we can, it seems like one area

that the board felt some consistent support around adjusting from the initial superintendent's budget was that ESOL position. How the process of this works is if someone had something they wanted to add or reduce, could make a motion for an amendment to the motion on the floor, which we would get a second for,

1:22:57

and then vote on the amendment. If that amendment passes, the original motion then is the amended motion, right? So the original motion goes the way, the new motion on the floor for consideration for the board is now amended by whatever that amendment was. Does that make sense?

So we can tackle it that way. Yes. I'd like to make an amendment to add in the FTEESOL teacher one time. I'm not sure how to word it, but one. The superintendent includes two and a half. Yes. So you would want to increase it by a 0.5 ESOL.

Okay, so I would like to increase the ESOL teacher by 0.5 to our budget. $51,000 by $51,000. Okay, is there a second to that motion? Danielle, thank you. All right, comments on that piece? I'm sorry, I missed it. Just to clarify, it would restore the proposed cut that then was proposed to be 0.5 to the full whole FTE is the motion.

Yeah, so it would go from 2.5 to 3. people comfortable with that ready for a vote on that amendment all those in favor none opposed all right so that now becomes the new motion on the floor so this this number is now increased by $51,000 okay so other adjustments to the

recommended budget I'd like to make a motion that we add the mass landing the to, I'm sorry, the one FTE fourth grade teacher and the one FTE ed tech position back into the budget. So the motion is to, I'll let Kelly figure out the dollar amounts on those, to increase the

budget by a one full-time FTE educator position and an ed tech for mass landing school. So a full-time educator is 102,000 and the ed techs are 48,600. So it'd be 150,600. Is there a second for that motion? Jayanne, thank you. Okay, discussion on that. Yeah, I guess after hearing

from Emily and seeing the class sizes, they're still within the recommended ranges and I'm hearing i'm hearing from her a a concern about equity across the district i'm i'm hearing a concern that if we put that back in and we have a very low class a 16 student class sizes here

that um that really to be fair we we would need to do something for durham too so i'm not really sure how comfortable i feel based on the administrator comments on supporting that amendment I think for me and obviously this is my first season doing this so

everything seems hard but one of the hardest pieces has been the equity piece and I've really struggled that with that as well Kelly of like what's Durham getting and I I believe it was Trevor from Auburn who was saying like let's

not get lost here of what we're looking at and really trying to put the students first and foremost and if we try to say okay this school is getting this like I just think we're going to get totally lost um you know i had noted that dcs is getting the addition

1:28:06

of the ed tech three um to support rtib in grades five through eight um they do have their class sizes in particular in grade grade four are 18 to 19 that is still less if we're looking at that than the I think it's 21 in the grade four. At the middle school I was more concerned but then

when I went back to Will's looking at the schedule and how they do it they're still keeping class size at 18 or below and I just feel like if we're going to invest in students grade four is the time to do it. I mean it's before they're getting to middle school our test scores are really down

and I just feel like end of a more individualized attention should be looked at it particularly in a cohort where we have a teacher who's taught at that school for 23 years saying this is a difficult cohort that they've been asked

to go down and they go up by their numbers of teachers for various years and they've seen that it doesn't work so I am in full favor of keeping the grade for educator you know the ed tech it's so hard i if we have someone in there who's great and it

seems like we do from what we've heard i would say let's do that too other comments or questions on the mass landing position you think i have something to say i thought you might oh this is so hard i just have to acknowledge how really difficult this is um i i'm still feel like this

is not a time to be cutting teachers and i would like to retain as many of these positions as we can um and that's what i keep coming back to that i i feel like we're hearing that this is this is not the time to be cutting people in the schools and we're concerned there's concern about about scores

and where we stand in the in the nation in terms of education and i don't think it's because we have too many staff i i think that we if we want to get ahead i think we need the people in place to to help us with that um and i think that we mostly agree on that and we we keep coming back to the

concern about the percentage um and i still think that we have room to put something forward that is a higher percentage um i'm also concerned if we don't retain some of these staff uh that some of these positions, that the budget will get voted down as well because of people who want to see

these positions not cut. So I support Maura's proposal for those positions. I also, I'm concerned about cutting positions, the difficulty of not getting them back again, especially when the future of funding is so uncertain. I'm really concerned that even if enrollment goes up and

we need those positions again that we won't be in a place where we can add them back so I am feeling for that reason a more of a motivation to keep those positions and as far as the equity piece I that's that's yes like you said and I've been thinking a lot about that as well and which is

what makes me say let's also include at least one of the DCS positions in addition to the middle school ones? I don't feel very well, so my brain's not working very well, but I'm going to try to say an intelligent thing tonight. This might not be it. Give me 10 shots. I guess I want to, I want to,

I was really struck by our member of the public who was talking about the concern over the the quality of education at our schools. And while I have no gross or particular critique of the way in which we're delivering our education

to our students, it did strike me that the budget was not presented to us nor do I believe it ever has been. So this is not a dig at our current superintendent or finance director or anything, the budget was not presented

1:33:25

to us with an accompanying goal of increased performance. It was not presented to us with a statement of, if we go forward with this budget, we're going to be improving the educational quality of the students. We're going to be improving by whatever measure, whether it's

by test scores or whether it's by some more qualitative measure. But I think, as I said, I take that member of the public's question and feedback seriously. And I think if I put that through my lens of just what I understand about education and what I understand about how

performance can be increased, it's never by cutting staff. So I suppose therein lies the conundrum. I think that there's a number of folks in our community who have critiques of the educational system that we're currently using. However, I think we do know, and as I

appreciated Dr. Farnier, you know, bringing, I can't remember the actual individual that you mentioned, but just bringing in actual experts, you know, educational experts, and that is who we need to rely on. And I guess I would just say to that community member and to other community

members to also, to trust in our administrators and to trust in our educators who are trained in this field. And know that we are trying to also trust in them as much as we are also trying to balance, create a budget that is fair and is able to be passed.

I would echo Pera's comments about keeping the positions and the equity. I would like to have a discussion about the DCS positions as well, but I know that could be a different motion than the one that we're talking about right now I think that it it I

really felt that a community member who emailed us a couple of community members who emailed us and said things that I thought really succinctly explained how my point of view and thinking about this and one of them was that funding our

schools is the most important thing that we can do and I really believe that I really believe that that is true and I know how difficult this is like sitting in this seat and having to make this decision about raising someone's property taxes or cutting

a teacher is is very difficult and I think I always go back to and I think maybe maybe this is my perennial thing that now I bring up every time you have a budget negotiation that like it's the larger system that is putting us in this place and that it should not be this way and

we're being put in this very difficult position because of how our system of education is funded And I know there's a lot of really smart people talking about that at the state level and looking at that. And, um, there's also a lot of people looking at how we tax property and, um, how we

can do that in a fair way. And I hope that some of those proposals go somewhere so that we don't have to keep ending up in this position because it's, it's not fair. It's not fair to ask, uh, to put, uh, you know, someone on a fixed incomes property tax bill going up against a teacher

having larger class sizes and kids getting you know better services like it's like a false choice to me and um that's not going to help us proceed on the budget tonight but I just wanted to say that because it's always true when we have to make these difficult decisions um and then the

other thing I wanted to say was the the community member who said that this is about our priorities and our values and I think that's true um that really resonated with me and it is about what do value as a community and what is important to us and do we want to be a

district that cuts positions or do we want to be a district that that continues to make investments the important investments in our schools and I think we're the latter type of district but I also know again that this is these are

1:38:34

very difficult conversations and it's a difficult difficult decision to make but I think I want to see us continue to move forward in the direction of being a district it says in it in towns that say we're going to invest in our schools and

part and I would just add another concern of mine is that if we don't have as much of an increase this year like I was thinking through this and it kind of sounds like counterintuitive but like if we have a lower increase next year then we're gonna this year then we're gonna come back and we're gonna have to have an even bigger increase next year so we're kind of I feel like we're hamstringing ourselves a little bit if we if we don't take an opportunity to have a slightly bigger increase than than what the administration recommended but I do want to just express my gratitude my deep gratitude for all the

administrators who work so hard on the budget all of the staff all of the community members who reached out to us and gave us your heartfelt comments I know we read all of them and we were really I mean I really appreciate it and know all the board members do appreciate your valuable insights so thank you yeah it's it's

challenging for sure um you know i i think ahead i i don't disagree with maura and you know the philosophical piece on how we fund education i don't maybe i'm a pessimist i don't see that getting better in the any near term and i think it very well could get worse um that's one of my

concerns. I guess I have sort of the flip side of the coin from Kara's comment around, you know, the ability to add things back later. We would eliminate our ability to do that. I think if we can't be more efficient, we're going to end up in an unsustainable situation when federal funding

changes or we have to fund more of it at the local level or any number of things that could add more to our portion of the of the money coming in where that's coming from and you know I think I appreciate our administrators willingness to look and say we can deliver what the board has

asked us to deliver with these resources and you know no no group no entity no business no company has ever said, you know, I want to lose resources. It's not, it's not ideal, but it can be a reality, and, you know, we have, we have been lucky in the growing sort of size of our district. We have been

unusual in that in the state. You know, what we're dealing with now, a lot of other districts have dealt with in prior years much much more impactful you know cuts had to be made and I guess I my feeling on what has been presented to us is it is reasonable it is rational it is effective and it

and is and it is in a more efficient way and you know sometimes when you look at how the resources are divvied up you find other ways to do things better and I think we've already heard some of that from from Dr. Fournier in the last couple of weeks about you know as we've thought about this

we think this might be a good move regardless of what happens with the position changes you know how we're looking at the schedules how we're looking at delivering these these services Kelly's point earlier about maybe weaving these health standards into other places

can actually be more effective than health two class. Um, I'm just really, really struggling with the sort of slippery slope of, you know, well, we should just add them all back. And now we're back up to 12%. Actually, probably even more because the mass landing position wasn't even in

there. Um, because that was a one year only position. It was never intended to be filled again. It was based, it wasn't a position that was added, you know, in perpetuity. It was added as a one-year position. So, I'm really struggling with this request, sort of at the 11th hour

of the process. Clearly, they got feedback from someone to reach out, and, you know, I appreciate it. We do want to hear from people. It's just tough when it's the last day. You know, and so I'm not in favor of this amendment at all at this point.

Yeah, I also wanted to add this idea of just value versus resources that Sarah Kelly brought up. I think it's a really great way to think about it. I think we can, our administrators have told us that they believe we can deliver a very high quality education to our students

1:43:35

and have reasonable class sizes and still be a little bit more efficient and save our taxpayers some money. So I think none of us are saying we don't want a quality education for our students. We're also just trying to think about, you know,

is the amount of money that we're asking our taxpayers to bear worth the increment that we're going to get in higher quality? We haven't heard from that wants to share anything. People feel like they're ready to vote on. We're not voting on the whole budget. This is just the amendment to add the MLS, EdTech, and position, FTE.

All those in favor of the amendment. So that passes. So we're adding that. So the motion on the floor, the main motion passes. The main motion is now amended to include that $150,000. yes yep so I guess yeah we'll do a yes vote please put your hands up again for

yes if your yes vote hand all the way up opposed just right the main motion is now amended twice so we are at 251 600 above where we were yes yes we've just added a quarter of a million dollars back to the budget all right I saw Kara

first I would make a motion to amend to add the DCS grade 3 and grade 5 educator back into the budget. Is there a second? Sorry, DCS, third grade, fifth grade teacher that were reductions in the budget. So two FTE for Durham Community School. Second. So Maura is the

first, Kara is the second. Discussion? I'm kind of regretting having you go first because I thought you were going to say something else, but I just want to recognize that last week I feel like we were at a place where we were talking about the middle school positions and wanting to retain

those and so i i kind of want to keep that on the table i'm concerned if we um are passing these positions that we didn't talk about last week that we will lose the option um to include those positions back in so i'm not sure how to go about that how i'm not sure right i could vote no right

um it's a tough process to know how to work through yeah correctly yeah we haven't had one of these in a long time where we were not necessarily all in agreement on where we were going with it. So discussions about the Durham positions. So I guess I'm going to ask Will to

come up and give us a little bit of background on this third and fifth cohorts. Before Will comes up, there was a request from Sam for people to get a little closer to the mics when they talk, please. What's your question? I didn't quite hear it. I guess I would just like to hear a little bit

more about the third and fifth cohort and um the the thought process around um why we were okay with the class sizes that are represent on the sheet yeah i don't think i have really anything to add from what we've already previously sort of shared um and i think emily spoke very articulately

1:48:53

about the process um we had looked at um these class sizes and i mentioned several times that very cuspy for us we always are in that sort of range and so when we looked at the cohorts that we currently have that would be rising third and rising fifth graders they are in three sections

currently but we felt like they could be in classes of 22 and still meet their needs the you know we talked about if few people move out then the classes get a little bit smaller a few people move in, then, you know, we end up with some tricky numbers, but that was a space

where we felt we could live. And, you know, one thing I guess I would say is that when they've come up through several grade levels as a smaller cohort with three sections, that cohort then benefits from that every single year. So it's not necessarily that, oh, the, you know, whatever

grade fourth grade it has this one-year benefit if there are smaller cohort always with extra teacher that cohort always benefits from those smaller sections year on year and so as such both these cohorts have been in three to this point in time and have had that benefit and it felt like

we could accommodate them in the class sizes we proposed thank you um i appreciate will's comments and the last week I was feeling like that addressed my my concern because as I mentioned last week I looked at the class sizes the proposed class sizes across the district to see and compare them to our I'm sorry closer the mic

compared them to our class size policy and these grades stood out to me but I guess the question that I would ask the board is because 22 to 1 is our threshold action level and I know these project projections for which age group can you just I'm sorry yes so from 3 to 5 the target is 20 to 1 and the

threshold action level is 22 to 1 and I know these projections are just that their projections but I guess I'm wondering is is this class size policy still something that the board subscribes to and wants to aim for it because if we do then it seems like it's not in alignment with this and and the

conversation around equity and adding positions back at some schools that have different class sizes than others that resonated with me and so that's why I i made this motion other comments i just had a question for will um it's been i think you need

to get definitely closer to your leg how's that okay um question for will is we haven't heard from any teachers at durham community school if those teachers were here now do you have any idea what they would say i know i'm really not sure that i can speak for what they may or may not say

i mean similar to emily you know the process she described is very representative um we communicated this with staff uh when we were first presenting the budget and um have continued to you know staff are aware um if you're going to say to somebody would you rather have fewer students

or more students or would you rather have a perceived easier situation or harder situation I think one can hypothesize what a human response would be to that, that equally, you know, I think they're also very aware of the process and what we're trying to achieve in terms of that balance. And so I can't speak for what they would say, but certainly it's been conversations we've presented at the school.

It's one of the things I struggle with, because I think that point is exactly right. You know, if you asked anyone, would you like to, you know, would you like fewer or more of something? I guess in this case, more is not good.

but um but you know it that's the hard part um when we when we zero it into a specific whether it's teacher or position or um you know we hear we hear from our staff that um you know they really appreciate and admire all the work that their administrators do in those buildings um you know

1:54:09

what they do in those buildings our administrative team does across the district on sort of a more global level um and so you know i i guess the the acknowledgement of of their knowing knowing the full landscape knowing the pieces on the board um i i think i think i i would leave it to their

recommendation kelly i agree with you michelle and i know we've already passed the previous motion but I just want to point out that the proposal for mass landing for the 21 students in grade 4 per class size is actually less than the threshold action level.

It's slightly higher than our target, but it's less than our class size threshold action level per our policy. And same with Durham. I mean, if we keep things per the principles and superintendents' recommended budget, we're going to still be in our range, our target range,

and a range that they've operated in for quite some time with much success from what I hear. And so I just feel really uncomfortable asking for classes of 16 and adding that extra money into the budget just to get down to class sizes of 16 to 17 when that's not even our target range.

Danielle. But now, as a Durham resident, I feel stuck, right? So we've added to mass landing. Now I feel like I have to vote to add back to Durham. Otherwise, I look like the bad Durham person who isn't supporting Will, which is 100% of what I do not want to be. So I agree with you,

Kelly and Michelle, I think that, you know, I'm struggling with, I don't want to cut teachers either. I think education is hugely important. And I'm 100% supportive of it. But I also think that we have to be conscious of what's happening in the world around us. I mean, we're asking our

taxpayers, I know that we talked about the $11, the going to Starbucks or whatever, but my world hospitals are closing people are losing their jobs those are our taxpayers they're not going to be able to do this and we're not talking about just taxes we're talking about putting food

on the table and i don't know how we say that that's okay but we're going to have a super high school budget i i'm really really struggling with that i i i just can't and i think that you know we need to go back I would love to take that other motion off the table and and just

because I think where we're heading now is we're just going to add everything back and plus we're going to add those two extra positions and and now we're going to present a budget of 13 percent if if I'm right it's it's not going to pass and it's not doable I think for people and even if

it could pass is it the right thing to do just because you can should you I mean that's that's where I'm struggling. So if we want to look at our class sizes, I mean, we have class sizes of 15 at Moore Street for the second grade with five teachers, right? Do we shift one if we feel like

21 is too much here? I mean, where's the cusp? Yeah, I probably forgot what I very eloquently was going to say at this point but I did just want to say this is a very very very hard thing that we have to do right now and I want to recognize just want to recognize that and

appreciate everybody's really thoughtful deliberation and I know I just want to speak to the motion that you put on the floor specifically Maura as I've been thinking about all these positions I'm thinking about these positions individually and I'm hearing some really good

points from our administrators but I'm also listening to the community feedback that we're hearing from our community members and our our staff members and for the Durham position specifically I haven't heard any feedback so I'm hearing

what will is proposing I'm not hearing from the community that that that is something that they're opposed to so I'm feeling again speaking specifically to this motion um that it's not something i would support um obviously i voted no um against the

1:59:11

last amendment because i feel very strongly when we talk about equity that when superintendent sits down with her administrators or the administrators have sat down with their teams there could be and somebody pointed this out that there could be things that we'd we're not privy to

So we don't have all of the information maybe that because there might be confidential things that they can't share. And when I'm looking at this, I mean, for me, the East Hall teacher is district wide. I mean, that's something the whole district is going to benefit from as far as that

goes. But when we start picking and choosing from schools, that is totally inequitable for me, because they've already made that decision at the level that they have all the information, this is what they've said will work for them in an equitable way, then I'm okay with that.

So I will be voting no on anything else that is added back into the budget. And I hear you, Danielle. But I feel for me, it's important that if I, what I'm saying is, I think that what they've provided to us meets the needs, and they have historically been able

to deliver on that when they've said they could meet those needs. I believe them, and I am going to trust them to do that. So while it, you know, doesn't feel equitable to add all the positions back in other places and not Durham, I feel like for me, I'm going to continue to not support the

amendment. And I'm going to make this suggestion, or I don't even know if this is allowed, But any positions, like dollar positions we add back, I would put that to the superintendent to work with her administrative team to decide where it's best needed. So if it's, we say we're gonna put three positions back, then her and her team can decide where those three positions would have the most impact in terms, instead of us who don't work in the schools,

who don't sit at those tables. We've heard from some teachers, we haven't heard from others. you know, so I guess I'm not comfortable stating this one is more important than that one. Because I don't know. So I don't know if that's a lot. Kelly's looking at me like, oh, God.

I don't, I don't know that Kelly can answer it for you exactly. Because all the positions that have been talked about so far, or were on the cuts, were out of Article One. Kelly's world, for the most part um as far as budgets concerned is concerned is where are the body which articles

are the bodies located in um and so for me and i'll i would defer to the superintendent on the actual like decision of what positions they are because for me it's more about what amount of money right gets added back um towards the article one allocation which is where those

salaries and benefits live. The ultimate decision of who and what those bodies are is not under my purview. I think it would be really difficult for us because you have to, anytime we, let's say we add a position, like I come to you and you authorize me to hire, let's say, you know, a special ed

teacher at the school, or if we added a position, a fourth grade position at Mass Landing, which we did last year you authorized me to do that so um it wouldn't um you have to allow us to hire certain positions or have certain positions so you couldn't do a car blank say add three positions

or four positions it would have to be identified what you are authorizing us to hire what we could do um if we didn't want to wrap this up and vote on it tonight was say you know of those cuts we feel comfortable adding three back come back to us next week with your team on what those three are

right then my question would be if i can if we came back our team came back it was to say three three ed three teaching positions we were adding back and then the board disagreed on that then we're kind of right back where we are so i think it would be although i appreciate that um for us

i know our team would have i'm sure have great feedback on that i don't think it would be practical okay because my concern is is the decisions were were made as a group and we are nitpicking individual ones out which may or may not have been the top of the list had we

2:04:22

prioritized them and and i know that is something we've done in the past is ask you to prioritize like if we could add back one what would be the one you would want added back as a group right um we didn't ask for that this year so shame on us for not asking that but for me that's

important right so because we heard from a from a discrete group of of educators um we're saying this one this one we want to add back but um perhaps there is bigger need somewhere else we just didn't happen to get an email from you know from that group so i'm just really hesitant to to

you know squeaky wheel gets the grease kind of mentality that if we hear a bunch from well okay we'll just add that one back and you know hope the ones that were quiet are okay with it um i'm really struggling with that kind of and that's how it this feels to me um not that not that any of

the work that any of our teachers isn't extremely difficult and i certainly recognize it's gotten harder um but i just i'm just trying to be more systemic in in my view of it um and i'm struggling michelle can you just clarify what you meant earlier when you said that even if we could pass

a 13 budget you're not sure if we should what do you mean by that um i think that the the way that the the finances work across the district with different impacts right and to to mara's point the increase in the valuation in durham drove up the um the required local contribution right

There's nothing we can do about that that is required by the state. So, you know, some of the increases is due to that. And when it plays out in different ways across towns, and the lower impact has a larger voting block, per se, than the one that would see the higher percentage increase,

you know, I guess I'm just cognizant that I think we can pass a budget, but I'm just sensitive to that, and sensitive to what Danielle said about, you know, people in all districts, you know, losing positions, and healthcare centers threatening to close, and it's real,

and there's just so much uncertainty, and I'm just hesitant to layer on, and just a reminder, this is just the school portion of people's tax bill. There's more. I mean, that's the other, I think that's the other driver around sort of the difference in percentages perhaps between the towns because the mill rate is the whole mill rate, not necessarily the mill rate for education.

So it's, you know, I'm just sensitive to that and I'm trying to not push through something just because I think we could get enough people to vote this yes. I believe in being more efficient in our schools. And I think that by being that way and how we are minded, it is built trust with

the community. So when we have to say we need something else, they believe us and they support us and we can add it. I think it's just as important on the flip side to say, we think we can do what we need to do with a little bit less, so we're going to take a little bit less this year.

For me, that feels right. I know that's not how everyone feels, and I respect that, but for me, that feels important. Yeah, I really appreciate what you said, Michelle, and I also just want to kind of just come back to that idea that our administrators have been thinking about

this district-wide and with a lens of equity for a long time before it reached our eyes, And I think that they've put a lot of thought into where they felt that they could make these cuts and still be equitable across the district.

I feel very uncomfortable adding a bunch of positions back into the budget from Freeport that will only benefit Freeport, and then the biggest tax impacts being in Durham. I just think that that's going to create a lot of resentment across the district.

I just want to say that when it comes to how we respond to the input we're given, and this is a democratic process, right? Something's proposed. A lot of work is put into something that's proposed. People are given the opportunity to give their feedback, and there's been a lot of opportunity for that. And we hear that, and we can't not be swayed by that.

2:09:42

That is what the process is all about. And then we vote. And then the town votes, right? So we all, and I guess we still need to give the town the opportunity, the towns the opportunity to weigh in with their vote. And we might be surprised that there are more people who would value their tax dollars going

toward investing in our school district than I feel like the focus has been on the people who won't want to or who won't be able to which and i i don't want to say that's not happening um i still again if if i'm going to vote for a higher budget it's not because i don't trust

the administrators or our superintendent i just feel like i need to say that again i was just going to say that i 100 support what kelly said um i agree with everything that she said. And I guess to Kara, I guess what's the end point though? I think we just stop adding and we

say, okay, we're going to do 13%, right? I mean, we might as well stop voting right now because I feel like this is going to be the same discussion every single time. There's going to be a motion to add back every single person. So is that our next step? We just say, hey, we're adding everybody

back. We're not going to take any of the recommendations that all the administrators worked on and let's go to let's go to the booth um i appreciate all these comments and i can understand like there's a piece of my concerns i think a little bit in everything that everybody

else is saying um but um i also think that as kara said it's a democratic process and we have to take into account the voices of our community including teachers including staff and i do really respect the work that the administrators have done for us, but I also really respect the voices

of our teachers, and it's important to me that we take all of those, and our community members, and it's important to me that we take all of those voices into account. And we did have folks contacting us who did say they felt like, you know, things were maybe hectic with some turnover

were in administrators and that maybe some administrators weren't fully aware of everything they were doing in their role. And so I have always implicitly trusted our administrators. I think we have an outstanding team of administrators and that we're very lucky in RSU 5.

And I agree that because we're not taking their recommendations, I don't think means that we don't, isn't a trust issue. For me, it's related to getting additional feedback that makes me think that the cuts um will be will be more harmful than than what i'm willing to agree to and um as

emily told us i think like i don't think what is the way this budget process or in gene told us the way this budget process was approached they saw that number and they had a discussion about what they had what they would cut if they in order to get it down at each building level and that doesn't

mean that they wanted to do it. It was because it was like a position that the district was in of saying we need to cut something or the whole budget passing will be at risk. So also the idea that any of the administrators like want these cuts to happen, I think the recommendations that

were made because of the situation that we're all in. So for me, I'm just thinking about all those factors. And I also just wanted to add, it's very important to me as a Freeport resident that Durham residents understand that I care just as much about their school as the schools in our

community and that is also why I made this motion because we didn't hear from any so so that was going to be my question for you Maura is um if this is based on feedback we didn't get any um so what are we basing this at back or is it just because we feel like it's the fair thing to do

did you have something else Kara okay we should write ourselves notes I just want to mention that we've heard a lot about equity and making sure we're equitable in every school and I think I haven't been on the board for very long but my guess would be that every year is different in terms of the needs of a school so there may be one year or one school needs more and the next year another school needs more

2:14:52

so I think we just need to keep that in mind too as we talk about this and just because we put we decide to add one position back in one school doesn't mean we have to do that in another school I am all for equity but sometimes it's it's

okay not to be equitable in that realm yeah and i think as a district that's how we've always approached it is what were the needs you know it's not what what do i need it's what is the district need and where's the cut line for how much we can handle in a given year right i mean

the the capital the capital spending has been uh inordinately directed towards panel for the last two years with with the uh the septic and the electrical and hvac and all the other stuff going on over there right like the boiler um that's just the nature of the beast i agree with that

um i think that that system works um when when the people who know all the things happening control the those pieces and i don't i just don't feel like we do so okay oh colin um i'm concerned a little bit about and we've we've been we've been caught in this for i don't know two months

i'm concerned about the circular logic that we keep falling back on which is that um because the administrators recommended the budget that is the budget that should be passed and we should trust them on it um when we know that that was based on an internal to the administration um not to the

Board and internal to the administration target for a budget increase. So it was not, I don't, I think we, I just, it's not fair, it's not fair to the administrators to say that they were coming to this saying, this is what we need. They were coming to this saying, this is what we need

because we have been told that this is the percentage we need to hit. Second, I did not recommend that number i don't remember voting on that so i also am a little frustrated though i completely understand um michelle where you're coming from i think i'm frustrated with the general

um uh stance that it is not appropriate for the board to question the uh additions that are being made when we did not agree on the target percentage to begin with because if if we'd been asked what should the target percentage be this year i would have i would have asked questions about it i would

have said what's it what was it last year what's how is it related to the mill rate what are the things that we're looking at and i would have said probably somewhere between 5.5 and 7 is what i would have said and that doesn't mean that that was what would go forward but that's i know that

that would be the target that i was comfortable with so again i just really don't want us to um i already have a splitting headache but it's it's making my headache worse to just continue to hear this faulty reasoning of

we have to trust the administrators because this is what they told us that they need because that's what they need. That just is not true. It's just not true. Also, we are not meeting our educational targets as a district. I don't believe we are delivering education

that I would like to see our district deliver. That is not a criticism of June. That is not a criticism of the administrators. And it's certainly not a criticism of any of the teachers. But we are not doing it. And why? Because they don't have the resources to do it.

So, to then also say, we can be more efficient to accomplish the goal. To accomplish what goal? To accomplish the goal of not improving our education? That's not being efficient. So, again, I just, I am, as, like, last week,

I really appreciated the conversation last week, and I really appreciated the work that you did, Kelly, really sort of bring that down to allow us to sort of look at those numbers and to sort of understand that impact. And honestly, I feel like we've gone backwards this week. I feel like we

were having a productive conversation last week that was more based around what is a comfortable percentage increase overall. And maybe if my head wasn't hurting quite so much, I would have interrupted the process earlier, but I couldn't think straight. Yeah, I think that the idea of

2:20:11

acceptable percentage doesn't seem like it's on the table anymore it doesn't feel like that's that's a way to approach it but those are two completely different ways of looking at at the budget right I mean is it a numbers or is it is it in the classroom and I think it has to be a

balance of the two and where you put your importance on what ways what side of the balance that is everybody's personal right and decision so kelly i guess what we have heard from the administrators is they believe that what they have given us that they can deliver let's say

they can deliver a quality education for our students that's what they have told us with this budget and i guess if we don't believe them who are we to go in and just tell them well then then you need to add back in this position when we don't see the same big picture that they

have been discussing I guess that's my that's my concern if we don't believe that they can do what they think they can do which is to deliver a quality education for our students then what what I don't I guess I just don't feel like that as a board we have enough expertise to

to know where to add those positions back in. I mean, that's where I'm struggling. Like if we had decided that we weren't comfortable cutting that many positions and we wanted to add some back, I don't feel equipped to be the one to say that's the one or that's the one. But apparently

we have to. So, okay. How are people feeling on voting for the amendment for DCS? Do people feel like they are prepared to vote on that amendment? So this is not the main motion. This is just an amendment to add two positions for two hundred and four thousand dollars to the budget what does

every hundred thousand dollars meet mean in terms of the percentage increase i feel like you had that yeah i knew i saw it somewhere so roughly a quarter of a point okay so 25 basis points to the total budget for each position roughly i just have a question yep the back the um durham community

school looking at the tables of the staffing levels for this year and then the staffing levels for next year where what page one this is the budget worksheet this is the yellow page oh god I don't even know where that it's a long time ago but for instance it says second grade at this year has 53

students with three teachers but then if you look at the projected student level for what would be then the same class, third grade, it has 44 students, which that's kind of what I've been basing the conversation on. So I just want to make sure that's numbers right. Like, do we know that we're losing students? It looks like the student numbers are the same.

It looks like they didn't roll forward a year. Yeah, so what we were asked to provide you with was that it's next year's projected numbers. And it was like you asked for current staffing levels and what that would look like and proposed staffing levels and what that would look like.

So that's what we were asked to provide, and that's what those charts were. Okay, so that makes sense. So it's next year's projected enrollment with what it would look like with current staffing, what it would look like with proposed staffing. I don't have that paper in front of me, but that's what I believe you're referring to. Just the confusing thing is the first table, it says reflects current staffing levels. Yeah, but it's 26 projected enrollment with the current staffing level and the next page so look a line above where it says

current staffing so it was a little confusing table we were a little confused by it too but it was it's what each school provided so you had the same kind of scenario no no that's that's a good so so for what we're talking about here current staffing levels would be classes of

1415 in third grade and 1415 in fifth grade and then the mass landing one would be 1617 to 21 those are the thank you for that clarification question nana okay colin i'm not sure if this is structurally possible or if it is maybe of any interest to us but i i would like to suggest that

2:25:31

we go back to what how we were approaching this last meeting and to have a conversation about the target percentage and to have a, whether it's a straw vote or what have you, have a vote where we say, we know that the majority or all or whatever, right, like vote for, to

say, all right, 5.9 or 6.2 or 6.3, whatever, we name that what it is, and then we have a conversation, a difficult conversation, we had a difficult conversation about, yes, how do we prioritize positions? But I still feel like we're still prioritizing, we're just now having to do it

in a way that's based on the order of things on the spreadsheet, which is we did the mass landing first now a new DCS and like um and that's I guess less holistic in my mind and I guess I just wonder whether we might be able to as a board reach more consensus um if we were able to set

a target um a target number that we were comfortable with um and then work backwards from that again I don't mean to disrupt but that's just something that I thought with my brain Could I suggest that we maybe do a combination of both so that as part of the motions that

we're making about adding positions, we look at the sheet that we had from last week and so then folks that Kelly had brought up so then folks could understand the impact. Just because in the abstract talking about percentages, I feel like that would be difficult

for me personally. Maybe we could do both at the same time, like talk about the positions as well as see the percentages. I think the idea is, so instead of doing them line by line, kind of come up with the number and then say, okay, if we're comfortable with that, what can we get done in that number?

I guess I just wouldn't feel like I know what number to pick. Like, I don't feel like I could just pick up a percentage. Okay. But I also feel like the way we're doing it now, we're just moving in one direction. And it's going to be very difficult for us to, you know, once we get, like Kara said, to the FMS stuff, well, we've already added $300,000, $400,000.

What are we going to do now? So I'm not really sure that this process is very productive for us at this point. I think just, I mean, yeah, I'm with you, Mara. I don't have that magical brain either. But I think we did do that week last, sorry, dear Jesus.

we did do that work last week um of looking at the of looking at the spreadsheet um and we did we went through it and we started we added things in we took them out so we like we know some of that already we have we know what the sort of some of these ballparks are um and again i just think

the i just think that even for the sake of the health of this board i might suggest that we take a different approach i yeah i just have a concern about i mean we've we've voted to keep the mass landing uh to to keep those positions in the budget so um as well as the esol teacher so if

we were to pivot and take a different approach i think we just have to honor the those votes that we've already made well you could adjust them i mean you could make a motion to remove the ed tech at this point if you wanted to if you were comfortable with i mean it to kelly's point

it's money in article one so i guess just respectfully i feel like because the votes we're going to make additions that some folks didn't didn't support that that that we should that it feels like i guess i'm not sure i just i guess i don't have any problem with the way that

we're doing it it's what i'll say i mean i'm with you and i'm not suggesting that this is the uh a perfect solution but i would also say that arguably um anybody that's been watching the last few meetings um and has been hearing us talk extensively about the middle school um would

have a general sense that we're leaning toward um keeping some of those keeping some of that um and the way things are going um no i don't think i would vote for that when it comes around this time because the percentage is getting too high so it sounds like we'd like to chart up

regardless of our our future how we uh attack it okay so that i think maybe the other one might be more helpful to be able to see the individual items that are in there yes i think let me get up to the microphone just so that my voice is projecting. So what I have done on this sheet is

2:31:14

because we started with the superintendent's recommended, that's the entire thing was yellow, right? Okay. Voted on it. That was first motion. And then we voted, then the board voted to add 0.5 ESOL back. So that's the green at the bottom. And so I have taken it out of the

recommended reductions. And so now they're zeros. See? And then the motion, the most recent motion that passed was to add a grade for educators. So I added a line and added that $102,000 because the budget was not reflective of that at all. And then I zeroed out the reduction for the

mass landing education technician that was part of that motion as well. So that is at zero. So right now, we are currently, if we're getting back to the screen that we were showing last week when we ended, we're at 6.21 overall. The net impact of district-wide taxation is 7.84.

And then you can see in line 40, 8.17 Durham, 4.45 Freeport, and 7.25 Poundle. Is that helpful for folks to see on here? And really that above what we can see is not really what we're talking about anyway, right? So, again, this follows the model that was in the budget book

where we had the overall additions, you know, it was all the impact areas of the budget, really. And so, you know, we started with last year's baseline or the baseline budget for last year and really just, you know, put all the changes in that are reflected on the sheets, whether they

were add or subtracts as we've gone through. Okay, great. So scroll down so that we can see this and there. I think that's pretty much everything. So the mechanic is the first position on the list. Yep. Okay. Okay. So is that helpful for folks to see that percentage piece?

We do have a motion on the floor, I think, regardless of which way we decide we want to approach we need to um deal with the motion on the floor um we can vote on it or we can pull it if the person who made the motion in the second want to um but i think yeah um i'm just not sure

i don't think that i can um i'm just trying to figure out yeah i don't know that i can withdraw the motion um i think that we would have to table it or um you can't withdraw motion i don't see it here but I thought as long as the second also withdrew it and then you voted on it but okay

then I'll withdraw it so that's where we stand now Kelly is it possible to make an amendment to an amendment I mean the motion on the floor is now amended for both of these things so that's where we stand so we can make a new motion to to remove the grade 4 teacher from MLS from the budget in

in the the um i guess just to be equitable to durham i mean you could it would have to get a second and pass right so you would have to change someone's mind in turn right because if the same people if people still feel the same way about it i mean that is you could make an amendment to

reduce the budget by 150,600 dollars um and get a second and if people felt like they wanted to prioritize something else they could vote yes on that amendment and that would bring it back to a clean slate before well I guess after the ESOL yeah I guess I'm I'm just looking at that number

there and um I'm just wondering if how people are feeling about 6.21 and we haven't even begun to discuss what we were discussing last week um and if anybody would still feel the same way about their vote now that we have this information in front of us. So I mean the way to find out is to

2:36:22

make a motion and have a vote on it. I mean it was a 6-5 vote so one vote would amend them that could amend it back and then we could have the discussion about FMS or look at it more holistically as a group and prioritize. I mean I want to I want to find the

although Colin tells me there's no such thing as efficiency. All right then I'm going to go ahead and do it. I'm going to make a motion that we remove the grade four mass landing teacher from the budget. So just the teacher? Leave the ed tech? Both. Both the ed tech. So you want to make a

motion to reduce the budget by $150,600? Correct. Okay. So I don't think we need to talk about this one a lot other than do people understand the mechanics of what we're doing? I'm looking for head nods. Yeah. So a no vote is you want to keep it in. A yes vote is you want to take it out.

Yes. Right. Yes. Are you good, Candy? So, okay. So Kelly sounds like she has a way to explain it. No. I was just stretching. I feel like you had something to say. No. So basically the question on the floor is, do we want to remove the action? Basically, do we want to reverse the action we

just took about the mass landing positions and bring it back to basically the superintendent's recommendation with only the addition of the 0.5 ESOL to then kind of look at it more globally the whole the whole picture so if you vote yes on this amendment you want to go back to the

superintendent's recommendation if you vote no on this amendment you want to you want to keep that where it was everybody good and I love Robert's rules okay all right so all those in favor yes yes Beth Beth thank you sorry Danielle and Candy no okay now now we're back to how do we approach

this as a group um I guess I should ask are people comfortable with the leaving the ESOL does anybody want to look to adjust that one at all um all right so uh the idea of a of a percentage so now we're at 5.85 inclusive of that ESOL 0.5 um so I guess now we've come back to what's the

percentage that we feel comfortable putting forward. I don't like to say there's a percentage that is the magic number, but I do think that it is, it's useful to look at this range that that gene has presented to us to see what other districts are doing. I think that whatever we come

up with should probably lie somewhere in the middle of that range. Yeah, I think that's where we are right now is in the middle um four seven three or five eight five yeah so we haven't we haven't moved up a spot but six below five above seven below six above seven below six above so

14 in there so we're right in the middle right now for me i looked at last year's i think last year's was 6.7 am i making that up probably making it up six six and a half that's the expenditures no that's right that's what i want yeah so expenditures last year was let's call it six

and a half six four eight um i was i was comfortable with that then i do think there's more uncertainty in the world now than there was a year ago but i feel like that number seems seems reasonable in terms of of palatability palatability i'm just now i'm just making up words i've made up numbers

2:41:40

i've made up words um i was showing the the history of the taxation because it was in the budget handbook. Was that taxation or was that expenditures? I'm sorry, expenditure year over year. So yeah, the, the, the years of the twos was the COVID funds where we had a lot of funding

coming from other sources and just sort of overall angst in the world. We had a couple of years in the fours or just shy of five and then six and a half last year. Um, I'll go ahead and say I would be comfortable with, um, 7%, um, knowing that we have this, the same needs as we had did last year

and then some. That is a number I would feel comfortable with. I'm potentially higher. I made a spreadsheet last week. It turned out it's accurate, which was really fun. Like we weren't sick when you made that. Yeah, yeah, but it still works now. If, I think this is without considering

the ESOL probably, so apologies on that, but I think if we added in four full-time positions that goes to 6.7 one that's percent change not and that would be 8.45 net impact to taxation so i'm just randomly going to take three the total of three positions yes please check that

it puts us at 683 okay so i think that was yeah because i wasn't including the esol and four no but like no because like carrie just said seven right so like let's just i mean we it does translate into particular things and unfortunately we are prioritizing and that

sucks but that is what we are doing yeah um what is um what's the number on three three was uh taking an addition why don't you just take three 102s why do you take 408 the total is 408 oh what the percent no that's still 683 that's with three three one okay you want to see three 102s i can

it's the same math but we'll get 603 is what you said for four no he asked for four after that yeah i think it was i think i asked for three with the esol so i think that that i think the 6.83 was for so this is three fte is taking that out is six five nine and then if we want a fourth

one it's six eight three and esol is already included in all these numbers yes because you'll see that line 31 and 32 are zero reduction now okay so add so go to three again so i just didn't write down the number six six five nine to six eight three kelly could we see it with a point

five um ft so like three and a half sorry just a half time position and then also with a one ed tech so adding an ed tech back and then you want three position three and a half positions sorry four and a half seven seven point zero seven that was the mls well that was a 48 48,600 edtech

402,000 ftes full fte and then a half fte at 51,000 coming back we spent at least two hours last week doing this and we we ended up with a with what i thought we all felt pretty good about which was the middle school positions with science teachers still to be determined.

2:46:40

And I came here tonight thinking we would be talking about that position in particular. And then certainly in the last 24 hours got a lot more feedback about other positions that we're considering. I'm wondering if we could go back to where we ended last week with those positions,

since we had all talked about that then, And then, and talk about the science position and see if there's, if, if we all think there's room for more or if we, or if, and if the majority thinks there's room for more or not.

So basically the ESOL and one position at the middle school, right? I think we had talked about the 0.25 math, 0.25 math. Well, they all add up to one. Okay, so yeah. They all add up to one, yeah. So sort of as the starting place for the, for the discussion.

i i feel comfortable with that i think there was general consensus around um you know with with those positions in there um i guess for so that would be basic idea would be that we would just be adding in two ftes well it's one and a half because the esal is already in there for a half

we're only increasing it a half and then the the one position at the so just one is that what you're saying so we are we would just be considering the the one FTE for Freeport. Well I mean that's a discussion right um I mean I think that was the general consensus last week um but I think after

what we heard from Paige tonight I guess I would feel comfortable if we wanted to add one back to the middle school and leave that up to the leadership to decide if that's split up between multiple little pieces or if that's split up in a full-time teacher based on what they know and

what they need. That would be my preference. Yeah, I would be in favor of that. I'd like to make a motion that we add the 0.25 math, 0.25 English, and 0.5 English at Freeport Middle School back the budget. Is it easier to do that or just do a one? One at a time? Well, not just one at a time,

but a one FTE to Freeport Middle School. Is that specific enough for you guys? Or do you really, I mean, I guess I don't want to hamstring you and say you need to keep or do this with the money if you would be better served elsewhere, right? I don't know.

I would like to give the administrators the freedom to use the money as they see is best within their building. I'm just going back to hiring and I can only, let's say all these people in these positions won the megabucks. They all won it and they all went away and I have to hire

somebody for something you have to authorize me for what i can hire and we need to do that before now i mean it sounds like as long as the money's in there you can decide how you're going to do it i'd have to come back to you and my only concern is all is like people been really specific on the

board of what they what they're asking for and that may or may not be what we put what our team would propose i feel like this is what's been brought to us these these positions in particular and I feel like we continue with those positions in particular.

As opposed to the full-time position. I guess I would like Paige to speak a little bit more to this, but I think from what she said before, these little positions were kind of left over from being added in during COVID, and the way that we look at them now,

they aren't necessarily as, they're not serving the same purpose that they did at one point. So maybe she can come and talk to us a little bit more about that. Michelle, could I second the motion so that we have a motion on the floor? Yes, yep. Second. Cynthia, or Ginny, whoever.

So it was a motion from Kara and a second from Maura. No, to add the pieces, 0.25, 0.25, 0.5. Yeah, I think it can be tricky to have all of these little pieces and how you utilize them. It was a question that I had for Jean about that. Is this like, if you all brought that back, would we be tied to those exact prescriptions for it?

2:51:42

Because as it evolves, it's like those are also attached to part-time ed tech roles. It's just complicated to find three human beings that are willing to do that kind of work and how we do that. We currently have that, but as Jean said, moving forward, it feels like there'd be more flexibility in one full-time person.

I'd want to talk to my staff more about that if, you know, it came to it. But, yeah, currently it can be tricky on how those things move. So if we had to ask you now, what would be your preference? Because, unfortunately, we're making you decide now. Between you and Jean. Jean can weigh in, too. I mean, obviously I haven't consulted with the staff and all that,

but I see great flexibility in one FTE and what could be done with that. you're going to add pieces and parts are really difficult to the people lead to hire and so forth it's not speaking about anybody in these positions but certainly you know I would trust Paige and

her team on that if we were there but it's it's just very difficult right now because again where we're doing what you want us to do in the budget if you're adding pieces and parts then we hire pieces and parts it but is it easier to have a one FTE and for for how to find

staff when people leave absolutely is it easier to have a one FTE when you're looking at how people how staff members support kids absolutely it's easier than them little bits of people so how would that work if we have those positions

those people in those positions now, if we had 1.25 leave, so if we approved the one FTE back into the budget and a person in the 0.25 position left, how would that one FTE help at that point? Would you not be hiring a 0.25? Would you fire the 0.25 and the 0.5 so you would have a hole to fill?

I know, sorry, that's not the word that I... If you put a 1.0 position, we would hire a 1.0 person, but certainly there's a process. If there are people who are interested in the 1.0 position, then there would be a process for those people for that. And in the contract in general, any time you're looking at a reduction in force, there are specific things we do by that.

I guess I'd like to see us vote on this motion and then consider one FTE that would be the science separately and then each be able to vote on whether like one or the other um that's just my thought also we currently have these positions staffed so we would have to hire you know if it was one fte like

it would it would i'm assuming change cause change right right uh yes um yes i don't want to make a formal amendment or motion whatever it's called um but i might propose a um in the spirit of the holistic approach, considering in the spirit of what you're saying, looking at full-time positions,

or looking at adding a full-time position at the middle school, adding a full-time position at MLS, and adding a full-time position at DCS at the discretion of the administrators to determine where that need is greatest.

I suggest that knowing that it makes a lot of people unhappy in both in on various uh holes of that but that feels like um at least we're getting into territory of what we could call compromise and there's nothing that says if we add

back in a full-time position that you couldn't choose to keep filling it with 0.25 0.25 0.5 right as long as i asked you that that's what we're going to hire first i mean that's where i think that if that's where you come down on say we want we're comfortable with

three full-time positions wherever they're at if that's I'll use what you know Collins example then what I would would suggest is we come our team makes that determination and we come back and we tell you what those are and we need to have that that is indeed what you want to happen for hiring those positions

because you have to authorize us to hire those folks so I mean I think I mean don't know figure wise you could first I mean because that's what tonight like we need a bottom line in the budget but we also know we need to know what those actual positions are can I just suggest I appreciate that Colin I think that's an

2:56:55

interesting compromise could I suggest could we since we have a motion put forward could we vote on can we vote on that motion and then consider anything else or do we or we could consider withdrawing it but it's just like getting

really complicated to like. Well, I'm just wondering if the idea of looking at it that way makes it, because I think people feel like if I vote on this one, then maybe I won't be able to vote on that one. And if we kind of come to the consensus that we could get comfortable with three,

one at each position or one at each school that we've been discussing, then we could do one motion to take care of all of them. Yeah. And I mean, I really appreciate Han's idea and I do really like that and that does seem fair to me but I also want to honor all the feedback that we've gotten from the community about specific positions being

cut so I'm just thinking about that too I'm just wondering if we vote on what Colin said which yeah their emotions on the floor first okay yeah but if we okay so so what we could if people felt like they wanted to take the route that Colin

was looking at but still want at least one position at FMS they could vote no on this amendment, make a new amendment, which I presume is coming from over there, and then have that discussion, or have the discussion and then make the amendment once there's the general

consensus. So we're sort of crossing lines on how we're dealing with it, but so that's one way you could do that and still get to his, so. So we do have a motion, and we have a second, and your preference would be not to withdraw those and to vote on those and then move forward from there.

Anybody else have any questions? So the motion on the floor is to add back all of the pieces of a one FTE at Freeport Middle School individually without dealing with the other two or other positions. So just that one individually. So if you're supportive of that, that's a yes vote.

If you're not supportive of that, that's a no vote. Or if you're supportive of looking at it sort of as a group, then it's also a no vote, and then there would be another motion, presumably. Potentially. Everyone, know what we're voting on. All those in favor of the amendment on the floor.

Sorry, you have to vote. You got it, Cynthia? No? Yes. No. No, I'm asking for a no vote. Oh, boy. We're really not helping Colin Sinek. Okay, no vote. And we know this fails, but she's just writing it down. So that's why we're keeping our hands up.

Need something stronger. Can we all? Okay. So that amendment fails three to eight. You got the, well, I didn't even notice Moon left. He snuck out on us. I was thinking he had the, oh, I was thinking he had the fun one. Okay. So we are back to the amended original motion

with the only addition adding back the 0.5 ESOL. So do we have any other motions? Colin? I make that motion that I was talking about before. That is one, what do we call it? FTE. One FTE at Mass Landing School, one FTE at Durham Community School, and one FTE at the other one where my daughter goes,

for Boat Mill School. The choice of which would be left to the discretion of the administrator's end of motion. Do we have a second for the motion? Anna, thank you. All right, discussion on this one. We're responding to a school on mass land in your school.

3:01:57

Yes, that's a good... Yeah, I think my logic is that it's a compromise several different ways. It's a compromise... No, it's a compromise in that there has been, it seems to me, there's been support for potentially bringing two FTE into Freeport Middle School.

And so this is proposing number one. There was, we voted earlier on adding an FTE to Mass Landing School as well as an EdTech. Um, and we have been having a, uh, larger conversation tonight about the larger question of equity between, um, um, having to do with class size, um, and, uh, how resources are distributed.

um so yeah i will acknowledge that that is not um uh it's a it's it's it's a compromise um in that i think if i had presented it without the dcs um it would have felt to me uh it would have felt to me less fair um from just an overall equity point of view even though we have not heard from those

folks in that same way again that's my logic i'm not saying it's correct anna if we agree to this can we not add anything else like is this okay no it's not the end all um but that gets us to 6.8 yeah i'm not sure how to i'm just gonna take three off 6.5 that's 5.9 okay yeah so then

you you could um shine so then if we approve of this for the three fte positions so you said that leaves us at six point five nine we're trying to get to seven i'm not okay okay i'm sorry i'm just reeling back and i'm trying to follow here yeah but that is where ideally we would want to be um

i could be comfortable i would prefer that we were at six five or below personally but i could get comfortable with six five nine with this proposal but then for me that's probably i'm tapped out. Okay. In terms of additions. I agree. This is about as far as I can go. Yeah. Any other

comments or questions on this motion for amendment? So this would be an addition of three full-time FTEs, one at the middle school, one at the Mass Landing School, and one at the Durham Community School. Yes. Just in case anybody at home is keeping score, the logic behind this is to balance

the democratic input that we've gotten from the community with an understanding of our responsibility to propose a fiscally responsible budget as well as meeting what we as a board believe are larger educational needs at the school and also maintaining equity across the district.

Everyone feel ready to vote on this one? Seeing some questions. Yes? Ready to vote? No? Do you have something to say you want to share? Okay, then we should vote. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. I'm having a hard time with this one because I'm having a hard time deciding how to vote.

Because I want to vote, no, because it doesn't include everything that I want it to, but I know we could go beyond this. But also I feel like if it's a decision between a DCS position and a position that we've heard advocated for that we've said

um that folks have told advocated for to be kept that like that is a choice as well so i feel like by adding i just i don't know if i can support this motion i support adding back in the staff but um and i think i think jean has also said that it would be difficult for the administrators

because they would bring it back to the board and then the board might not agree and i think that we would just have to defer to whatever the administrators ultimately decided and i think we've gone around and around in circles about how we feel about that so i won't do that again um but anyway i think that's just leading me to say i support adding staff back in but i'm

3:07:06

going to vote no for this motion all right uh all those in favor of this amendment to the motion oh malik just added be easier to record no so that's only 10 so uh so who voted maura and beth were those the only no everyone okay okay so passes so that was three i would make a motion

that we add back an additional i don't know if we don't want to take these separately but that we add back an additional FTE at Mass Landing and at Freeport Middle School. We've already added back the Mass... The second one. They didn't even cut one. I'm sorry, the ed tech... So there's the ed tech and the fourth grade teacher. Okay, so the ed tech position. Yes, the ed tech position and then FMS.

We're not satisfying in this case. Right, because it's not science because what they've already said is they're going to fill all the science positions. Yes, so MLS. But we're going to change the name of that because it's not science. Wellness. I think it's very confusing that it says science gator.

So the motion is to add one teaching FTE, one ed tech. One ed tech at Mass Landing and one teacher at Freeport Middle School. So, okay. So, is there a second? So that was ed tech at MLS, FMS, one FTE. And what would those numbers look like?

Sorry. That gets us to 707. So we're deleting and then... Oh, we had 695. Because we did an ed tech and not a second teacher. You didn't do another 102. You did 486. I thought the number I wrote down for four and a half with the ed tech was 707. And we added three. So we're at 659 because we... That was three teachers. Right. So here, let me just finish where we're doing here, right? So this is... Oh, it's the other halftime position, which I don't even know where that one came from that got us to the 707. Okay. think i'm good okay so you want me to take out so what i'm hearing is we want ed tech at mass

landing and then we want another fte at the middle school yep and i'm just going to add a line and call it one fte fms or we can do this guys to be clear that like could be partial positions right it doesn't have to be i'm not it's hard considering what we already voted on i'm just like struggling

to wrap my head around that like yeah it would basically restore all of those positions right because we're not adding to we're not voting to add anything we're right because we're right so what we have is what we have we wouldn't we would refill that retiring position and we would keep

what we had correct okay so this would add back full-time educator another full-time educator at Freeport Middle, and an ed tech position, the bench sub position at mass landing. So the six openings, the posted openings that we have, just in terms of the people we have in positions,

3:12:21

we do have openings, so it wouldn't necessarily mean a cut to the person, right? We have plenty of spaces for the people. So the ed tech position at mass landing that we're proposing adding back in is one that is currently unfilled no it's filled this one is filled but we have other ones

that are it's a bench sub and it is being used this year but there are other ed tech positions that are not which the person could do okay do people feel like they they have a grasp on this one i'm having a hard time because i'm just looking ahead to the um other position that we

heard comments about from the teaching teaching staff the 0.5 ela teacher at the freeport high school and comparing that to the um the ed tech at mass landing with i mean it's a little bit more salaries but they're somewhat comparable does anyone have thinking on that or input um is jen

back there somewhere i'm sure she told us this before but i would love to hear the rationale on that one again. Hi, you're asking for the rationale for why we are making the CLA cut. Yeah, so this isn't reducing offerings in any way, or is it? We feel that we can maintain

reasonable class sizes with still cutting this position. And looking at what I had shared before is that we're working closely with Paul Roberts, our dad member who works in our technology department, who is going to work on making sure that there are members that are evened out from sections. Because right now, with the nuances of our schedule, there are some classes that are significantly different in size.

And so we feel that we'll be able to maintain class sizes. It looked like an addition of an average of six to seven students per teacher if we lose this halftime position. Not in any specific class, but just their overall teaching load of six to seven?

Yeah, that's an average. So right now there's some discrepancies in those classes depending on what they're teaching, 12th grade class size versus its overall size of that grade level too. So that's an average of what it would look like. Some might see more of a drop than that, and some might see more of an increase than that. Thank you. So what you're struggling with is sort of prioritizing those two pieces?

Yeah, and I'm just remembering we did get an email. I think it was signed by all the English teachers and talking about how it's really an important position also for college essay writing and for, I'm sure I could pull up the email somewhere, have made lots of great reasons for why we should keep it um i'd be willing to entertain a friendly

amendment to my amendment but um i'm wondering what the most um efficient efficient like this meeting with the height of efficiency right now efficiency tonight yeah i'm wondering if it'd be more efficient instead of amending the amendment to like take each one individually or if we should

take them all together and then I don't know I don't know what to do there but I would entertain an amendment to the amendment to add the English teacher ELA position in addition to the other two yeah or in place of the you are wanting to vote in addition to the other two if we are wanting to

vote on all them together and then I suppose if that fails then we could talk about individually looking individually or would the board prefer to take them individually yeah maybe I missed this but the other attack positions the three and the one are those all the rest of

them are unfilled that are on there right now yeah yes so I would support that I would support seconding amendment to the amendment if you wanted to do that so it's really easier to pull your pull your emotion your pull your amendment

3:17:27

and make a new one if you want to look at them all three together okay okay so then I would make a new motion that we add back the full-time FTE for a teacher at Mass Landing, or I'm sorry, Ed Tech at Mass Landing, a full-time teacher at Freeport Middle

School, and a half-time teacher at Freeport High School. I second. Okay. Okay. So now we have a half-time teacher at the high school, a full-time teacher at FMS, and an Ed Tech position at Mass Landing. That's the amendment on the floor. So a yes vote would be to add all three of those back,

and then we're back up to 707, right? Yes. Sorry, June, forgive me, but why is the proposal to cut a currently staffed ed tech when we have three ed techs that are open? That ed tech could, if they want a position, they could have a position, and I think to Emily's point is that was a bench sub. If someone wants to be a bench sub or be a sub, they can sub every single day, and the reason that was initially put in by the board is we were having a terrible time getting substitutes, and we're not having that problem anymore. So that's why the recommendation was this position was removed.

But there's certainly, if anyone wants to be an ed tech in the district, we have positions for people to be ed techs in the district. So the person filling that position would still have a job as an ed tech? We have openings at this very moment in time, both in a share tonight, both gen ed and special education. Right now, we have openings in the district.

So instead of adding it back, we could just fill that position. We could still have as many ed techs as we have in the building in the building. The positions we have opening are not at mass landing for that role. So it would not be a mass landing position, but certainly we have other ed tech roles. But it was the nature of the position that it's a bench sub. So it's not someone working with special education students, and it's not somewhat like we have some ed techs for our TI. not that not that kind of position it is a bench sub position but to be clear if we eliminate this

position it's not that we will be going without subs we will still have plenty of subs yeah that seems like with opening open positions like that we can't fill it seems like that might be one that we wouldn't want to add back in if we have other open positions already yeah i guess um i i understand

the way you explained it i think gene um i just uh it just seems odd to me that we would be we're we're voting to we're voting on whether or not to add back in a position when we already have a bunch of unfilled positions i just don't understand why we just don't take like like i

mean i i understand it in terms of the the bench sub role is different from other ed tech roles but again i guess just structurally i guess are we just are we saying like we just do not need a bench sub anymore that's just like straight up what we're saying that we need these other open

special those are special ed well there's two gen ed ones according to what she had said right so so what we could do if we felt you know that we didn't want to eliminate a position that was currently filled we could eliminate one more of the ed tech roles that's unfilled so for whether

six we're removing four we could remove five leave one gen ed still open looking for people and then leave the special ed ones alone which was always the always the plan and that would be a budget neutral decision yes right that doesn't that doesn't seem like that would be meeting the

need though because i mean they're saying the need or the they don't need the bench sub well it depends on who you ask right so we heard that some people think that that that position is meaningful and helpful to have. So we could acknowledge that in a budget neutral way

versus leaving another unopened, unfilled position, particularly with the number that you told us of how many special ed we have open, which is eight, and your idea that we would always fill special ed before we fill gen ed because we're required to by law to provide these services

3:22:34

for our students with IEPs and 504s, right? I think the tricky part is, as I'm looking right now, we have their, so of the six JMAB, there are four that we're proposing not to fill there. And then there's also, there are two, because there's one, for example, there's one at Moore Street that's open right now that works with RTI position, so you wouldn't want to eliminate that. Where's the other one? Freeport Middle. I'm looking at Kelly, too. We've got our spreadsheet. How many special ed are there open at Freeport Middle?

There is one. Three at Moore Street, two DCS, two high school, plus the two ed techs for a teacher, really four. There, for 10 total. It was just an idea around the ed tech position. I mean, I guess, for me, I was comfortable with the three ads,

so I'm probably a no on this whole ad anyway. Any other comments on the amendment on the floor for ed tech at mass landing, Full-time at FMS, half-time at the high school. Okay, so we're going to vote. Malik's favorite part. Yeah. Okay, all those in favor.

I'm seeing three. Is that what you saw? Opposed? Hopefully it's eight. Great. Okay, so that does not pass. I can make some more motions. So I would make a motion that we... So now I feel like we have to prioritize them, which is getting back to what Anna said was difficult. So, um, I'm sorry, I need a minute. Are you making a motion?

Can I make a motion that we keep the, uh, full-time at Freeport Middle School? Second. Kara, thank you. So one full-time FMS educator. Any questions on that? Yes. Um, I mean, I'll just say that the, just in case people are wanting to know whether we are listening, just personally, I, um,

I was convinced by Dr. Fournier's presentation on how they could make the wellness work through the incorporation into the other. And I know that we're leaving it up to their discretion, but I just wanted to thank Dr. Fournier for that, because I thought that was a very creative

way of thinking about it. So thank you to her team. Yeah, I want to second that, Colin. I think that she did a really good job of blending how they can juggle these positions with fewer staff. And I just wanted to point out that the position

was, we've been calling it a science position. It is not a science position. There will still be science. From what everybody has said, from administrators, from superintendent, this is just up to them to use however they feel would be necessary. But we will still have science either

way. And we aren't losing any of our educators from that because that person is retiring anyway. So we would be hiring a new teacher for that regardless. And maybe it's the health teacher, maybe it's someone else in the school, maybe it's outside the school, but it would be a new teacher in that role regardless of what we do today. I guess I would go back to the feedback that we heard from the staff, from the teachers, that this would be detrimental to the students and staff

3:27:48

to lose this position. And also my concern that we have turnover in administrators this year and that we're going to have a new principal next year and that putting them into a position where they need to change the schedule and hit the ground running and not only be a new administrator in a new school but potentially make all these changes is, to me, that's just not the time to make this change and cut this at the middle school.

Okay. I would echo those concerns and I would like to give them the opportunity to not have to juggle it. Okay. All right. Everyone, I feel like they're... So this is just a, this feels like an easy one in terms of what we're asking for in this one. It's one full-time position at FMS. So basically it restores the second position from FMS.

So there would be no cuts at FMS. What? It is. It's at 683 now. 683. Yeah, so that would add up to four full-time, which would be 683. Yep. The second was Kara. So motion by Anna, second by Kara. Is that right? Kara's like, I don't know, I just... sure yes yeah okay people feel ready to vote on this one okay all those in favor opposed okay so

that passes so six eight three is where we are um i would make a motion that we add back the halftime ele teacher at the high school a second okay and the impact of that f8 half fhs six nine six michelle any i guess we lost beth will let her run to the ladies room presumably

or to grab water i don't know where she went he's literally running out of the building while we're waiting could we just go over what has been added back sure so uh what i have so far is a half-time esol teacher that uh for 51 000 uh three full-time ftes one at uh well i guess

four full-time FTEs, two at Freeport Middle School, one at the Mass Landing School, and one at the Durham Community School. Thank you. Yep. The EdTech, the bench sub. Yeah, I mean, I added the, presumably the, it would be a, it would be K and well, maybe not. I don't know.

I think I got it to, the numbers would be like below 15. So I think that's probably why we didn't hear anything on that glass size yeah we thought you just ran out of the building bath first moon runs out then you run out okay so the motion on the floor is the halftime teacher at freeport

3:33:09

high school we did a quick overview four positions four and a half positions added back to freeport middle one mass landing one durham and then the esol halftime that's where we're at so the motion is to add back the 0.5 ela at freeport high school motion in the second any

other questions on this one? I think for me this is this is probably like I said I was I was done at the three full so I'm probably tapped out but we'll see the the flavor of the board. All those in favor. You good? Opposed? 3-8? Is that what you got? Okay so that does not pass. Can I make one more

motion? Let's just round it out. I'd make a motion to add back the ed tech bench sub position at Mass Landing. Second? Come on, Kara, why not? Okay, so this is for the ed tech position at Mass Landing School. I think we probably, we've talked about this one. I think we have other

openings that we could fill and meet the needs if we need to, as opposed to keeping a position that they have said they don't need based on the change in substitutes. I do appreciate that we haven't seen the massive shortage of substitutes that we had for a couple years though that's great

that it sort of worked itself out of of need great to see yeah i'll just say that i'm making this motion because we've heard from the mass landing staff about the value of keeping this position and having that person in the building and that this means that if that person does fill

another ed tech position elsewhere in the district i hope that they do if this motion fails i hope they do stay but they will no longer be at mass signing they'll be in a different school potentially or could leave the district all right everyone understand the motion on the floor

all those in favor opposed three eight again yes okay have we touched on everything okay so the motion on the floor is for consideration and approval of the 26 superintendent's proposed budget as amended at eliminating the reduction for the esol position adding back fifty one

thousand dollars eliminating or i don't know if it's weird where we're not eliminating so not eliminating what's the right terminology keeping keeping or not reducing not reducing that sounds double negative e2 keeping keeping the full esol position uh both positions at freeport middle

school, one position at the Mass Landing School, and one teaching position at the Durham Community School. Is that what you have as the motion on the floor, Cynthia? Is that everyone's understanding of the motion on the floor? So that is what we're looking at in terms of 6.83 is the expenditure

increase over last year. Anyone have any other commentary or questions before we vote on the actual motion on the floor i'm so sorry um i know that i said i didn't have any more motions or amendments um i'd like to make a motion to amend the one dcs fte to the bench sub at um

to remove that and add the bench sub at mass landing and the halftime f uh halftime fte at freeport middle i'm sorry freeport high school did you get that so taking the one fte i'd make to make a motion to take the one FTE off from DCS

3:38:10

and add the one ed tech at mass landing and the one halftime teacher at FHS. Okay, I think I understand the motion. I'm going to get a second and then we'll talk about it. Second. So the motion was to remove the add back

of the DCS full-time position and to add back the halftime FHS and the bench sub at Mass Landing School. Is there a second? Okay. So without a second, we do not have an amendment on the floor. So we are back to the amended full motion on the floor.

Four and a half teachers, basically four and a half full-time positions added back from the superintendent's proposed budget. Any additional comments, questions? Are we ready for a vote? Colin's going to vote and run out the back door. To the turf, you're fine. All right, seeing none, I will call for a vote.

All those in favor, none opposed. Thank you. Okay, guys, that was hard. I want to thank everyone at this table. I want to thank everyone in the audience. I want to thank everyone at home who's taken the time to write to us multiple times.

You know, pull us aside, give us their thoughts. It's not an easy process. there's no perfect way to go about it. I think Colin's right. We probably weren't overly efficient in how we approached it this evening, but we got through it. And it's, oh, it is after 10.

Darn it. I was hoping it was before 10. But it's not 11. It's not 11. And I just, I just want to thank, like, honestly, thank each and every one of you, because you've all said things that have really made me think. And, you know, go back to how I look at things. And while we obviously didn't

have a bunch of 11-0 votes. I think that's actually a good way to approach this. And I feel pretty good about what we're putting forward. And now we take it to the next step in the process and get out there and explain all of this to everybody else. My question is, what's the

process for explaining this? What's our plan for communicating this out to everyone? So our process is we're gonna mail this which and this is gonna bring people to the actual we are creating the brochure so we will have the actual brochure and

we'll print some of them to have around the district and then obviously it'll be online so we'll send this to every household in all three towns so not just student parents but like all the houses so people can access it we have the the

Q&As in each town. I think we're starting in Durham on, oh, I think I'd have this memorized. Oh, wrong one. Oh, it's in here. Hold on, let me look at Ginny's googly eyes. She did confirm via text that they're googly eyes, by the way. Looky-loos, I think, means something different.

Okay, so Q&As. April 9th is at the Durham Community School from 6 to 6.30 before the board meeting. April 30th is the Pano Elementary School, 6 to 6.30. And May 7th at Freeport High School, 6 to 6.30 for Q&A prior to our board meeting. And then obviously the next step is the

annual budget meeting, which is in Durham this year on May 14th at 6.30, followed by the budget validation referendum on tuesday june 10th yeah uh so in previous years the strategic strategic communications committee has reviewed that budget brochure and i know that since we

haven't been officially meeting this year because we've been working on the strategic plan um will there be a review of that brochure i also know we're a little late in the game at this point yeah i'm i'm wondering if now i know everyone really wants to go home but if there's

3:43:16

anything that if any board members have any particular things that they think would be really important to have in the budget brochure for as a way to communicate uh this decision with this proposal i think last year you guys did a really nice kind of overhaul of the the layout

and got rid of some of the information that was probably not super relevant and put in some additional information that probably is i think the plan was to model after that template it. But, you know, if folks have ideas, I imagine it's going to print very shortly. So really the

only place we might be able to change any of those words, because I know Jean couldn't write her final letter until we had our dollar amount. So, you know, if you think of something tonight, maybe you could send it to Jean by the morning. But I think it's going that quickly, right?

Yeah, and it's, we've had a discussion about what will be in there most of the same. The data you have but really putting it focused on the on the data of the budget and even some of the write-ups that we use there will be a letter from me explaining things but some of the usual writers we've had from some of the schools or departments everything you know but lots of things have changed so

those won't be included because we just don't we don't have that we don't have time to do a real ask them do it all right up but we'll make sure all that data is in there and then we even look at what some other data that might be helpful for voters to include in that just because it we're talking like we

You've got to get it printed in and out to the public, out to all the schools and the town offices so people can, especially with that date coming up, sooner than you know it. Yeah, April 9th. I mean, just quickly, I mean, whether this is in the brochure

or whether it's in the conversations that we have with the different communities, I think we can still own that we are making a number of big cuts um in order to be um with with an understanding of our responsibility to the the taxpayers

because we are we're just not making as many um and so i think that that i think can still be um a key aspect of of the narrative because it is true it's fun the narratives are true it makes it easier to put the red light back on it's listening to you um yeah that's a that's a

good point. I mean, we sort of scrolled down to the section where we were keying in, but there were items up above that were red numbers, that were reductions, and, you know, recognizing that and making sure people are aware. We didn't net add anything. It's, yeah, it's not 12, right? Thank

goodness. Yeah, so if anyone has a brilliant, you know, sentence, they'd like Jean to try and work into her letter feel free to get it to her by 7 a.m um or before or before um we do have public comment still on the agenda so you know if anyone wanted to speak i would i would never cut you off

on that um no one's racing so um i would take a motion to adjourn with thanks kelly and cheyenne not the thanks for the motion to adjourn thanks for everybody's hard work all those in favor there's a unanimous vote thank you guys

Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.