Skip to content

TranscriptRSU 5 budget meeting, Wednesday 14 May 2025

Budget meeting · 53 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →

Computer-made transcript, not a record of what was said. It mishears names and figures and drops short words, such as the "not" in "does not carry". Click a time to hear the recording, which settles any disagreement. The district's minutes are the official record.

5,416 words in 9 five-minute windows.

1:59

Good evening. We're going to get started. My goal is to get you out of here to still be able to enjoy some of the sunshine. You can all help me in this. All right. Welcome to the RSU 5 Board of Directors Annual Budget Meeting. It is Wednesday, May 14th, 2025. We are here in the Durham Community School

Auditorium. We have a full board with the exception of Danielle. She's on her way. She'll join us as quick as she can, but we will get started in the meantime, and we'll start with the Pledge of Allegiance. It's a different mic. Good evening. Welcome to the RSU 5 annual budget meeting for

the 2026 board adopted budget. The RSU 5 board of directors has worked diligently to develop a budget that is focused on the goals of the district and the needs of our students while remaining responsive to the needs of our taxpayers. The board of directors proposed operating budget

for FY26 is $44,455,929, which is an overall increase of 6.83%. The requested budget includes negotiated salary and benefit increases, which equates to 82.5% of the overall budget. Passage of the budget by the voters is critical to continuous improvement in our district. Financial

resources were reallocated or reduced to lessen the tax impact while still strengthening the educational services for our students the board used one million sixty eight thousand dollars of the undesignated fund balance to reduce

the top tax implications of the budget in addition a projected two hundred and fifty nine thousand dollars in interest income was used to further reduce the impact to taxpayers the estimated tax impact on the three towns is eight point

8.83% in Durham, 4.95% in Freeport, and 7.87% in Pauno. The district's first budget priority is to maintain high quality programming for all students. To be responsive to decreased student enrollment, reductions in personnel include four educators, five educational technicians, and the removal of the funding for the district's mechanic. Despite these reductions, we will continue to deliver on our mission and our vision.

Maintaining supports for students is the second budgetary priority. In order to meet the needs of students in the upcoming school year, we are requesting a grade 4 teacher at the Mass Landing School, a response to intervention behavior educational technician for the Durham Community School, and additional days for the guidance counselor secretary at Freeport High School.

In addition, we are requesting funding for summer programming at the Durham Community School, Pauno Elementary School, and Freeport High School, which were previously funded through COVID funding, which is no longer available. Our third priority is to support the district infrastructure to provide a safe learning

environment. We request continued funding of the district's capital improvement plan and investments in the Freeport High School Tennis and Freeport High School Track and Field and Capital Reserve accounts. Further, we are planning for the continued methodical replacement of our fleet,

including buses, vans, and field ground equipment. In addition, we are requesting significant security and life safety upgrades in all of our schools by utilizing funds in the local budget and the capital reserve account. In addition, we are proposing continuing to fund non-lapsing

article reserves, which will allow us to maintain a contingency outside of local taxation that will allow our district to react to facility and or enrollment-driven needs throughout the fiscal year. We will be utilizing undesignated fund balance in order to lessen the burden to the

taxpayer, while at the same time slowly reducing our undesignated fund balances to acceptable levels. These reserve accounts include Article I, regular instruction, Article II, special education, Article V, student and staff support, and Article VIII, transportation. The Board

7:09

of Directors is appreciative of the continued support that our schools receive from the residents of the district. We believe this budget will allow us to continue to focus on building student-centered learning environments that support student growth and promote post-secondary

planning and aspirations, all aimed at improving the overall achievement and success of all of our students. This evening, we are asking for your support for the budget presented before you. I will now ask Superintendent Scarappa to call for nominations of the moderator to begin the

annual budget meeting. Thank you. Our first action is to open nominations for the election of moderator. I nominate Gregory M. Second. Are there any nominations from the floor? I close nominations. All in favor of Gregory M. to serve as moderator of this meeting,

please say aye. All opposed, please say nay. Gregory M. is elected moderator. I'll now ask the moderator to come forward. Please raise your right hand. Do you, Gregory M., swear that you will support the Constitution of the United States and the State of Maine so long as you shall continue

to be a citizen thereof, and that you will faithfully discharge to the best of your abilities the duties incumbent on you as moderator of the Regional School Unit No. 5 Budget Meeting on May 14, 2025, according to the Constitution and laws of the state of Maine? I do. Hello,

everyone. Thanks for having me, and nice to see everybody again. My first order of business as moderator is to swear in the ballot clerks, and I'm going to represent to the meeting that shortly before the meeting, I met with the ballot clerks outside, and they took a note very similar to the

one that I just took and signed a statement very similar to the one I just signed and that was just as a matter of efficiency if someone objects to that and would like me to swear them and again I'm I'm happy to do it again but if there's no objection we'll just consider them sworn in okay I'll

countersign their oaths and give them to the superintendent for her records okay let's see the next order is to set the procedures for the meeting I'm gonna be guided by the main moderators manual which is you know the procedures that are

used pretty universally throughout the state of Maine for town meetings and school budget meetings is there any objection to using the main moderator's manual as a guide for tonight they see none will do that by law a person who's

not registered to vote in the RSU is not permitted to address or speak to the meeting without consent of two-thirds of the voters present in voting however we do have some administrators and staff who may be needed to provide information

or answer questions related to the budget and our business tonight including will pin Julie Nickerson gel Jen Goko Holly Johnson Scott Emery Erica Mullally Cynthia Alexander Bill Ridge Eric Hall Glenn Reynolds Amanda Marsden

Kate Hillman Harrison Sam Rigby and Alicia Morrison so is there any objection to allowing those people to speak just to provide information and answer questions if they want to speak for or against a motion that's not what

we're asking for right now and we'd cover that we take that up as it came up any objection to allowing those folks to address the meeting okay we'll allow that so just big picture this is it's actually not a school board meeting it's

a meeting of the legislative body of the RSU which is the voters who show up and your our goal tonight is to adopt a budget school budget for next year that will be submitted to a referendum vote on June 10th and so the agenda for the

12:26

business for the tonight is the warrant articles and briefly this is how we're going to proceed I'll go through the articles I'll read the article I'll then look for a motion and a second once I have those I'll open the floor up for

discussions questions keep your comments germane to the topic that we're on and you know we'll try to well I'll kind of reserve any other procedural stuff until until you guys get unruly but I will arm you with one one thing

sometimes sometimes discussion debate goes on for a while and it goes on for while and you think wow this is going on too much I don't have authority to stop discussion but you do you can make a motion the motion is I call the question I move the question you can there are no

magic words you can just say can we stop this and vote and it's an extraordinary motion so it requires a two-thirds vote okay well cries a second and a two-thirds vote but just keep that in your back pocket if it can become necessary or useful let's see let's just just as an

overview on the on the warrant articles 1 through 11 are the expenditures that will approve for next year articles 12 through 14 raise revenues to support the budget article 15 is a summary of the total budget and then all the other

articles that follow are are actually not the annual school budget but there are things that the legislative body has authority to decide so while you're assembled we take care of those things all right one last thing when you check

in you with your clerk you should have gotten one of these green cards this is how we're gonna do most of our voting by show of cards I'm not a voter and then one of the ballots one of the articles requires a written ballot and when we

get to that point well we'll go over the procedures but I think you're gonna go up to visit with your clerk and they'll punch your card give you a yes-no ballot and we'll do the voting that way okay so without further ado let's just launch

into this article one to see what some the regional school unit will be authorized to expend for regular instruction the school board recommends nineteen million three hundred fifty six thousand two hundred sixty one dollars sir motion so moved second okay article one's been moved and seconded so I'm

gonna open up the floor for discussion oh I think we're probably are we broadcasting or simulcasting and we're recording so if you were gonna speak please step up and use the microphone state your name in the town you're from good evening can you hear me okay yes my name is Ashley Schumacher I live in

Freeport thank you to the board members administrators educators and community members who worked on this hard-fought fiscal year 26 budget that we're here to vote on tonight. This year's budget process has faced the perfect storm. The

current federal executive branch of government has promised to and actually begun to dismantle our nation's Department of Education. State subsidy is already meager will decrease due to revaluation of property in our towns. RSU 5

educators negotiated fair wage and benefit increases with the district so that they may continue to match the rapidly increasing cost of living within commutable distance of our schools in the face of that financial strain and

uncertainty I believe strongly that our community has a unique opportunity to choose our values and live them even and especially when things are hard I believe that schools are vital centers of community support and often the only

consistent community touch point for some of our most vulnerable citizens I believe that the people who educate our children are providing immeasurable service to the community and that when they secure a new contract with the

district they should be able to do so with the reasonable expectation that neither they nor their colleagues will be laid off in following budget cycles I believe that proposed cuts to educator positions are never motivated by the

mission of service to the students I also believe that I'm not alone in these convictions and that our community deserves the opportunity to vote for a budget that does not eliminate any staffed positions and does not staff any classrooms

at the threshold action level per district policy IIB class size. For these reasons, and I would appreciate any guidance if I'm misspeaking here, I would like to make a motion on Article 1 to restore the 0.5 FTE ELA teacher position at Freeport

17:28

High School for $51,000. The 1.0 FTE Grade 5 teaching position at Durham Community School for $102,000, and these are wages and benefits. And the 1.0 FTE EdTech position at Mass Landing School for $48,000 for a total of $2,001 added to Article 1. Thank you. $201,000. Sorry. Thank you for your

time consideration and commitment to our so okay so let me just so this is I'll take as a motion to amend the article one to increase it by two hundred and one thousand dollars to let's see nineteen million five hundred and fifty seven thousand two hundred sixty one dollars that and before we go on I just

want to and and you stated a purpose or intended purpose for that and I just want to let the meeting know that you have the ability to change the dollar amounts on the budget but any all the decisions about spending are with the

board and so you can suggest something but it's not binding on the board so don't just don't have that expectation so there's a motion to amend article one to increase it by two hundred one thousand dollars is there a second to that motion to amend okay there's second okay so now we're on the motion to

amend and we're gonna discuss whether we want to amend the motion so does anybody want to speak for against amending the motion yeah okay any discussion on that okay seeing none we're gonna vote and we're voting on whether we're not voting on the article we're voting on whether to change the

article to increase it by two hundred one thousand dollars so all those in favor of the motion to amend sure cards thank you opposed okay I'm gonna say article the motion to amend fails and so we're back to the original motion so

So any more discussion on the original motion for Article 1 in the amount recommended? Yes, sir. Peter Angelini from Freeport. Just a basic question. Do you know how many people are here that are impacting our vote? And second of all, are these people, how many of them have vested interest that they work either for the school committee or they work for the school district?

That would be very helpful, because in the last seven years, I have come up here and argued the point about their budget. There's no control over the budget, but it just gets passed. So I just would like to know how many people here actually have a vested interest, other than taxpayers.

Thank you. Yeah, I don't, I mean, I think we can check with the clerks out front to find out a number of how many voters are here, but I don't know if it's possible to. The question was, how many people here how many people are here to vote and I think more specifically

how many people here have a vested interest in the school budget is that a fair summary and so my response was that the clerk's can tell us how many voters are here but I don't know if it's possible to ascertain who has an interest or what that interest is so is there any

other discussion I was just gonna say that I think everyone here has a vested interest in the the schools and if you know if we have community members that also live in the communities where they work they are welcome to come here and

vote as well they are they are taxpayers and community members so I don't think we know how many people have joined us that that actually work for the schools but I would say that everyone has a vested interest in the value of the schools but that's probably not the answer you're looking for so I'll just

repeat the question. The question was how many people in the room work for the RSU and are paid through the budget. Is that what you're asking? Okay, and there may not be an answer. So if anybody wants to tender an answer, they can. If anyone wants to make more discussion on Article 1,

the mic's open. Okay, I'll give this an extra beat. Okay, seeing no discussion, we're going to vote On Article 1, in the original amount recommended, $19,356,261. All those in favor? Thank you. Opposed? Thank you. Article 1 passes in the amount recommended. Article 2, to see what sum the regional school unit will be authorized to expend for special education,

22:38

the school board recommends $6,513,451. So moved. Second. Thank you. So motion and second. any discussion on article 2 okay seeing none all those in favor of article 2 in the amount recommended thank you opposed thank you article 2 passes in the

amount recommended article 3 to see what some the regional school unit will be authorized to expend for career and technical education the school board recommends 307 thousand six hundred forty five dollars so moved second okay is

there any discussion on article 3 okay all those in favor of article 3 thank you opposed thank you article 3 passes in the amount recommended article 4 to see what some the regional school unit will be authorized to expend for other instruction the school board recommends 1 million 119 thousand eighty seven

dollars so moved second so any discussion or comment on article 4 okay all those in favor thank you opposed thank you article 4 passes in the amount recommended article 5 to see what some the regional school unit will be

authorized to expend for student and staff support the school board recommends four million six hundred forty four thousand three hundred and seven dollars so moved second any discussion questions comments on article five okay all those in favor thank you opposed thank you article five passes in

the amount recommended article six to see what some the regional school unit will be authorized to expend for system administration the school board recommends $1,263,587. So moved. Second. Any discussion on Article 6? Okay, all those in favor?

Thank you. Opposed? Thank you. Article 6 passes in the amount recommended. Article 7. To see what sum the regional school unit will be authorized to expend for school administration, the school Board recommends $2,514,485. So moved. Second. Is there any discussion on Article 7? Okay,

all those in favor? Thank you. Opposed? Okay, Article 7 passes in the amount recommended. Article 8. To see what sum the regional school unit will be authorized to expend for transportation and buses, the School Board recommends $1,931,576. So moved. Second. Anyone want to say anything

about Article 8? Okay. All those in favor? Thank you. Opposed? Okay. Article 8 passes in the amount recommended. Article 9. To see what sum the regional school unit will be authorized to expend for facilities maintenance, the school board recommends $5,490,511. So moved. Second. Any

discussion on Article 9? All those in favor? Thank you. Opposed? Okay. Article 9 passes in the amount recommended article 10 to see what some the regional school unit will be authorized to expend for debt service and other commitments the school board recommends one million eighty seven thousand four hundred twenty eight dollars so moved second thank you any discussion article article 10 okay all

those in favor thank you opposed a article 10 passes in the amount recommended article 11 to see what some the regional school unit will be authorized to expend for all other expenditures the school board recommends $139,591. So moved. Second. Any discussion on Article 11? Okay, all those in

favor? Thank you. Opposed? Thank you. Article 11 passes in the amount recommended. So those were all the expenditure articles, and now we're moving on to articles that raise funds to support the budget. Article 12. To see what sum the regional school unit will appropriate for the

total cost of funding public education from pre-kindergarten to grade 12, as described in the essential programs and services funding act and to see what some the regional school unit will raise and assess as each municipality's contribution to the total cost of funding public education from pre

27:38

kindergarten to grade 12 as described in the essential programs and services funding act in accordance with the main revised statutes title 20 a section 15 688 and the numbers are presented in two columns the column on the left is

the appropriation it's it's what the state feels through the essential programs and services funding model is adequate to provide a basic education in the RSU and that total is twenty six million eight hundred forty three thousand nine hundred forty one dollars and forty six cents on the right hand

side is the amount that the RSU must raise in order to be eligible to receive the state subsidy, and it's broken up per town's contribution. The total to be raised in the RSU is $19,988,378.34. In italics, it's a statutory explanation that I'm not going to read, but if

someone would like me to read it, I'm happy to. Okay. Is there a motion for Article 12? So moved. second okay any discussion on article 12 yes um could you just explain what it would mean to vote against this article i think i think if you vote no to this or if you decrease the amount that

you're going to raise in this article then you it could affect the amount of state subsidy that the rsu receives thank you any other questions or discussion on article 12. okay all those in favor thank you opposed thank you article 12 passes in the amounts recommended article 13 to see what

some the regional school unit will raise and appropriate for annual payments on debt service previously approved by the regional school unit voters for non-state funded school construction projects or non-state funded portions of school construction projects in addition to funds

appropriated as the local share of the regional school units contribution to the total cost of funding public education from pre-kindergarten to grade 12. The school board recommends $118,908.77. Again, there's a statutory explanation that I won't read, but I will if somebody would like me to.

Is there a motion for Article 13? So moved. Second. Any discussion on Article 13? Okay, all those in favor? Thank you. Opposed? Okay, Article 13 passes in the amount recommended. article 14 now this is the article that's required to be done voted by

written ballot but let's get through the article in the motions first to see what some the regional school unit will be off will raise appropriate in additional local funds recommend fifteen million four hundred five thousand five hundred

thirteen dollars and thirteen cents which exceeds the state's essential programs and services allocation model by a recommended fifteen million six hundred seventeen thousand four hundred seventy eight dollars and thirteen cents as required to fund the budget recommended by the school board the

school board recommends fifteen million four hundred five thousand five hundred thirteen dollars and thirteen cents which exceeds the state essential programs and services by fifteen million six hundred seventeen thousand four

hundred seventy eight dollars and thirteen cents and gives the following reasons for exceeding the state's essential programs and services funding model of the state's essential programs and services funding model funding formula is a minimum model to support education in grades pre-k through 12. RSU number five

provides additional funds to support lower student-teacher ratios and additional co-curricular activities in addition to complete educational programs for all our students. And again, there's a statutory explanation that I'm happy to read if someone would like me to. Is

there a motion? So moved. Second. Is there a discussion on article 14? Okay, seeing none, we're going to move on to voting and the clerks will correct me if i'm wrong but we have a ballot box over there can someone and it's empty um and i believe they're going to come

see you with their card that you're going to punch and give them a ballot and yeah so that's the procedure we're gonna kind of be in recess while everyone votes okay kelly okay uh last call for votes. Last call for voting on article 14. Okay, I'm going to close the polls and ask the ballot

40:11

clerks to count the ballots. Thank you. Okay, so we'll come back to order, and the results of the ballot vote are 84 yes and 7 no, so article 14 passes in the amount recommended. Okay, article 15. To see what sum the regional school unit will authorize the school board to expend for the

year beginning July 1 2025 through June 30 2026 from the regional school units contribution to the total cost of funding public education from pre kindergarten to grade 12 as described in the essential programs and services funding Act from local funds for non state funded school construction debt

service additional local funds for school purposes under the main revised statutes title 28 section 15 690 unexpended balances tuition receipts state subsidy and other receipts for the support of schools school board recommends forty four million three hundred sixty seven thousand nine hundred twenty nine dollars so moved second is there any discussion on

article 15 okay all those in favor thank you opposed thank you so article 15 passes in the amount recommended so that is the operating budget for next year that will be voted on on June 10th and now we're going to move on to these other articles. Article 16, to see if the regional school unit will appropriate $133,000 for adult

education and raise $88,000 as the local share with authorization to expend any additional incidental or miscellaneous receipts in the interest and for the well-being of the adult education program. So moved. Second. Any discussion on Article 16? Okay, all those in favor. Thank you.

45:16

opposed okay article 16 passes as written article 17 shall the school board be authorized to transfer two hundred ninety five thousand eight hundred dollars from available fund balances to the regular instruction reserve fund and expend from the regular instruction reserve fund as needed in

the discretion of the school board so moved second sorry any discussion on article 17 okay all those in favor thank you opposed okay article 17 passes as written article 18 shall the school board be authorized to transfer six

hundred eighteen thousand five hundred seventeen dollars from available fund balances to the special education reserve fund and spend from the special education reserve fund as needed in the discretion of the school board so moved

second any discussion on article 18 and all those in favor thank you opposed thank you article 18 passes as written article 19 shall the school board be authorized to expend from the student and staff support reserve funds as needed

in the discretion of the school board so moved second discussion on article 19 okay all those in favor thank you opposed thank you article 19 passes as written article 20 shall the school board be authorized to expend from the

transportation reserve funds as needed in the discretion of the school board so moved second any discussion on article 20 and all those in favor thank you opposed thank you article 20 passes as written article 21 shall the school

board be authorized to transfer up to one million five hundred twenty thousand fifty nine dollars from available fund balances to the capital reserve fund and to expend up to two million four hundred ninety five thousand two hundred thirty

four dollars from the capital reserve funds as needed in the discretion of the school board so moved second any discussion on article 21 okay all those in favor thank you opposed thank you article 21 passes as written article 22

shall the school board be authorized to transfer up to thirty five thousand dollars from available fund balances to the track and field capital reserve fund and to expend said reserve funds upon express authorization of the RSU

voters or as permitted by law second any discussion on article 22 all those in favor thank you opposed the article 22 passes as written article 23 shall the school board be authorized to transfer up to forty thousand dollars from available fund balances to the tennis court capital reserve fund and to expend said reserve funds upon express

authorization of the rsu voters or as permitted by law so moved second thank you is there any discussion on article 23 okay all those in favor thank you opposed the article 23 passes as written article 24 shall the regional career and technical education operating budget as approved by the

Cooperative Board for the year beginning July 1, 2025 through June 30, 2026 be approved in the amount of $4,312,957. So moved. Second. Any discussion on 24? Okay. All those in favor? Thank you. Opposed? Thank you. Article 24 passes as written. Article 25. Shall Maine Region 10

Technical High School, Region 10, authorize the Cooperative Board to transfer up to $280,000 from undesignated fund balances to the region 10 capital reserve fund so moved second any discussion on article 25 okay all those in favor thank you opposed

thank you article 25 passes as written article 26 shall main region 10 technical high school region 10 delegate authority to the cooperative board to expend additional balances accumulated in the region 10 capital reserve fund

from time to time on such specific items or types of capital improvements equipment as the Cooperative Board determines to be needed by region 10 so moved second any discussion on article 26 all those in favor thank you opposed thank you article 26 passes as written

50:16

article 27 in addition to amounts approved in the preceding articles shall the school board be authorized to expend such other sums as may be received from federal or state grants or programs or other sources during the fiscal year for

school and other program purposes provided that such grants programs or other sources do not require the expenditure of other funds not previously appropriated so moved second any discussion on article 27 yes just a question this one this is whether or not we agree to accept money from sources

outside of our district at no additional cost to our taxpayers is that correct yeah I think it well the school would be authorized to agree this one will be authorized to do that otherwise we would not be authorized to take money from those outside sources there's arguably you could but this removes doubt

gotcha thank you any other questions or comments on article 27 okay all those in favor thank you opposed okay article 27 passes as written article 28 shall the school board be authorized to transfer amounts exceeding 5% of to the total appropriation for any cost center to another cost center or among other cost

centers for the 2025 2026 fiscal year provided that such transfers that transfer shall not be permitted to increase the total authorized school budget so moved second sorry any discussion on article 28 okay all those in favor thank you opposed okay article 28 passes as written so that's that's

the end of our business for tonight I'd like to take an opportunity to thank everyone for coming out and participating I also want to thank the ballot clerks for doing a very good job and helping us out and Cynthia do you

have everything you need for minutes okay and I will entertain oh I just remind everyone that the school budget that was approved tonight is subject to a yes-no vote on June 11th at your local polling places so I'd entertain him to

attend what did I say June 10th June 10th I'd entertain a motion to adjourn so moved second all those in favor thank you anybody opposed all right the Sun is still out

Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.