Skip to content

TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 10 September 2025

Board meeting · 2 h 53 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →

Computer-made transcript, not a record of what was said. It mishears names and figures and drops short words, such as the "not" in "does not carry". Click a time to hear the recording, which settles any disagreement. The district's minutes are the official record.

25,275 words in 33 five-minute windows.

3:42

we will get yes what i think you guys forget how 90 of our meetings go this is it why is this mic good evening is mom coming through the sounds perfect great thank you uh good evening welcome to the rsc5 board of directors meeting it is wednesday september 10th 2025 we are here in

the Freeport High School Library. Just wanted to give a quick welcome to two board, new board members since we finished last year, Valerie Williams and Chris Saliano. So we had our board retreat, so they are well immersed into the group, but for folks watching at home, they are new

members, so welcome. Anna and Ma are both not with us this evening, and Steph is running a little bit behind so she will be joining us shortly uh phoebe is still our student rep uh until elections when she will i'm sure have a landslide victory again but uh so welcome back phoebe welcome to senior

year and we will get started with the pledge of allegiance do we have a motion for consideration and approval of the minutes from august 27th 2025 as presented barring any errors or omissions Kelly and Valerie, thank you. All those in favor? No, opposed. Adjustments? None. Great. All right, so we will move right into good news and recognition and start with our report from Phoebe, our board student rep.

So I'm just flying by the seat of my pants. But a week and a half into school, people are so excited. Like, the energy in the hoist is awesome. We have our amazing upperclassmen paired with their freshmen and transfer mentees.

We've already done some really fun activities, including on the Tuesday, our school started where it was just freshmen and their mentees. They were able to walk through all their classes, learn their lives without all the scary sophomores there.

We also have club meetings all started this week. we have at least one new club and i'm sure there'll be more like as the school goes on um lots of club recruiting is happening to especially active ones and sport is starting

i think all teams have had their home openers except for football which is on holiday um and oh we had open house last night um which families got to come and meet teachers and um get a little peek into the high school so yeah not too much to report but things are going well

and been a good week and a half thank you all right um public comment this is where we look at the empty audience in case someone comes flying around the corner all right we will carry on uh item eight report from the superintendent good evening everybody is this picking my voice up

Okay, my first one of these. So, I'd like to just share some updates with you since the start of school. I'll talk a bit about the strategic plan, about how we're thinking about going forward with the budget process this year.

There's some enrollment data to look at, and talking about some longer-range planning on some critical issues. So, several board members were able to attend the staff opening day, the PLD day. We took pains this year to make sure that event was really inclusive. We know that we have a number of staff for whom English is not the first language,

and I really need to point out that Erica back there really worked hard to make sure that we had translation available for those CERP folks so that they could feel and be fully included. I think that was really important. It was a great day. The district here does a fantastic job making that meaningful. Not every district that I have worked in actually has the entire district come together.

8:47

in person to open the school year and everything that happened in the cafeteria everything that happened in the auditorium the longevity awards it was i thought it said a really good note it was a privilege to be there and i spoke i shared a little bit about myself and my journey and my

values and um i had been making it a priority as school has started to be as visible in the schools as i can be um i put some of those in my weekly update to you and i don't need to rehash them all but I'm going to continue to do that. Serving lunch at the high school was particularly cool. I don't know if I served you lunch, but I served lots of people lunch. It was fun. It was the sticks and the Bosco sticks.

And honestly, I think they knew that it was me, and they're like, we should make it easy for this guy. Two sticks. It was fun. The whole team has really, administrative team, has worked hard to make school open, And I don't know if you noticed, but I noticed school opened pretty darn seamlessly across the whole district.

Some people who really deserve shout-outs, Sam Rigby had a huge lift this summer with lots of tech updates. And most of those have come to fruition. Some of them will have to be spaced out as the school year goes along during times when kids are not in school.

But Sam's really worked hard, and his team have done a great job. Glenn Reynolds and the facilities crew and the custodial crew have had a ton of updates across the district, and those have been in place so that school could open efficiently.

Really, really good work there. I didn't get a single call about bus problems when school opened, which is a huge thing. Thank you, Jeremy. Jeremy did a fantastic job, and this seems like an opportune time to point out that he

is that even though we had anticipated, and I say we, but I wasn't here yet, the district had anticipated that we would need more drivers and more vehicles and got an extra van and replaced an old van, we've still had to push a van that has 200,000 miles back into service, and we're using every driver we have, and we are fully maxed out, and Jeremy has made that work seamlessly. So a lot of credit to Jeremy. So, again, I could go on and on, but it's been an auspicious start to the year, and you should know that.

A little bit about the strategic plan. So, we have, obviously you know that work began on that last winter and spring. We are continuing to work on that now, and in fact, just today, I participated in one of the focus groups at the middle school,

where we had kids in small groups, and they were asked a series of questions that were largely about, What are your hopes and aspirations for this district? What do we do well? What do we need to improve? And not surprisingly, kids are really candid. And so we got a lot of good feedback from those conversations that we will carry forward in figuring out the plan.

I also want to point out that this is for the whole community. We have focus groups scheduled for the end of this month. They're really important. The dates and times of these are on our website, but I'll announce them here now too.

On Monday, September 22nd at 6 o'clock, we have a focus group at Pounder Elementary School. Thursday, the 25th at 6th at Durham. Saturday, September 27th at 10 a.m. at the Freeport Community Library. And Tuesday, September 30th at 6 o'clock here at the high school.

So those are opportunities for any community member to join in a conversation about what our district should look like and how it should continue to grow. And you don't have to attend the one like where your kids go, right? So if a Saturday one works better for you, you're welcome to come to any of the, right? Yes, absolutely. And those are not the only opportunities to weigh in, but those are important ones. There will be other, there will be surveys, there will be other community input events. So please engage in the process because these are your schools

and it's their future. We have also, we tried to push the word out for this as much as we can. We have a newsletter. We've done a media push. We've done that through the towns. We've done that through the schools. We've done that through social media. We've had a banner put up on our website that literally every page on the website you click through, this banner comes

up. So there are no excuses for missing these dates. Again, the strategic planning process itself, whatever plan you come up with, the process is really important. So I would ask people to engage in it. So, budget. One of the priorities that I remembered and took to heart from the board

retreat was that the voice of the staff is very important to the board, and rightly so, in identifying priorities for the budget. So I've been thinking about that and talking with our team about how to develop some procedures that give the staff meaningful opportunities to weigh in

14:07

on what the priorities that should frame the budget from their point of view should be. So one of the things that I feel I need to emphasize as I talk about this is that we are actually not starting from scratch with this

because our administrators and directors already do have and have had mechanisms to get input from their staff. And one of the steps that I've asked those folks to do to start us off is to codify those for me. In other words, to write down, okay, how is it that you, what is your standing practice of getting your staff's input?

And then we'll take a look at that and see where we might be able to do better, but we'll also be able to inform the board about what those practices are. We're also planning to add a few other steps. So later this month, we're going to be scheduling voluntary listening sessions at each school

where the staff from the school can, this would be after school, not included in regular staff meeting time, the staff can come to provide their perspective about budget priorities. And I framed a series of questions, four questions that are very broad that would frame those conversations.

And the questions are, in a nutshell, what strengths do we need to maintain? What challenges do we face? Where should we grow? and where could we find efficiency. And the staff will have an opportunity to weigh in on that, and then we'll also have a survey. Part of that, however, is that we need to acquaint everyone

from the board of the community to the staff about the pressures we face with the budget. And we talked a little bit about that at our board retreat. So I have a little information to share now about that, and more will be coming. But it's important for us all to know that this year, the overall district budget is approximately $44.5 million.

And by far the largest part of the budget is wages and benefits, well more than half the budget. That's true in every school district. That's just the nature of education. So our negotiated contracts for wages and benefits that we already have are going to go up by 8.6% next year.

And because wages and benefits are by far the biggest part of the budget, that means when wages and benefits go up 8.6%, the overall budget goes up 7.1%. That's without figuring anything else in. And some of the other things that we will likely have to think about are we have not yet negotiated a contract for our support staff.

Everybody out there is talking about anticipating that health care costs, health insurance costs are going to go up again. The price of everything going up again. And given what we went through earlier this year with federal funding, which thankfully all came out fine in the wash, we don't know what's going to happen with that this year.

So there are unknowns. So that's just, I think, an important piece for everyone to know going into it. Those are factors that we know about. That should not stop us from being aspirational. It shouldn't stop us from thinking about new things that we might want to do.

But it's a big part of the puzzle. So pause for a minute if anybody would like to ask a quick question about that. Hearing none. So again, the intent here is to make sure that there's transparency in this process. And we're all working with common information, and then everyone's voice can be heard in a meaningful way.

Another part of that puzzle that I forgot to mention, but I should, is when I say the overall budget would go up 7.1%, where does that fit in historically? So if we were to go back 10 years in time and look at how the budget has increased over time, what we find is an inverted bell curve.

And if I go back to before COVID, let's say the mid-20 teens, budget increases were going down. In other words, the percentage that the budget went up each year was going down each year. Then we got to COVID, and it bottomed out because we had a bunch of federal grant money, COVID relief money, that was temporary, that came along, and then over a few years got spent.

And that happened to coincide, as we all know who have lived in this country, with inflation. So the COVID money was going away, inflation was going up, and budgets in schools, not just here, but everywhere, started to increase again,

19:08

and the rate of the increase started to accelerate. So to put that in perspective, last year and the year before were the two biggest years of budget increase. So last year, it was a 6.48% increase. The year before that, it was a 6.83% increase. And of course, how much of that you felt as an individual taxpayer depended upon which town you were in and how that computed to your individual town's share of the budget.

So we are already looking at the moment at a 7.1% increase without all the factors being weighed. So another factor that we consider, and this is the enrollment. And basically, one of the things that I've uncovered that this district experienced in recent memory

was an influx of, was a spike in enrollment, but that spike then went down. That was largely due, as I understand it, to an influx of new mainers who moved into the community, but many of those folks, not all, but many have moved out. So if we keep that in mind, the enrollment has basically been flat

with very minor fluctuations, and the best guess we have right now is it's going to continue to be flat for the next handful of years, like a fraction of a percentage point off here and there. So enrollment also determines state funding,

and it determines how big our classes are. It drives a lot of decisions. So these are some factors that we will be considering as we look at the budget. Um, so, there's a lot going on as I transition into this room. Um, these are some of the new things. I want to emphasize again, the strategic planning process is very important to the district,

and I hope people buy in, and I'll stop there. Any questions of what we've heard so far? Yeah. I just wanted to thank you for being forthright about all this early on, so that we have a lot of time to think about it. have a time and this is going to be probably one of our biggest challenges this year and so i just

appreciate you being very honest and open about it all right um yeah i feel like once i have some time to digest some of these uh enrollment numbers i might have some questions specifically around like pre-k what's happening there because that's an interesting that seems to be the biggest shift

from what we thought to what we got and i know that's always a hard guess that's the hardest one against. Because we don't know them yet, right? They haven't been here yet. But that's interesting. The good news is, you mentioned pre-K. So the good news is that our enrollment for pre-K is solid,

in that we have decent class sizes. I mean, at Mass Landing, we have an average class size of 13.75. At Poundell, it's 8. At Durham, it's 11.7. The maximum class size for a pre-K classroom is 16. And that's a teacher and an ed tech. You have to have two adults in there. You have to have

one adult per eight students. So we're doing fine in terms of enrollment with pre-K. Thank you. All right. Do you want to go through the designations and hires? Sure. I know that was in our packets. It is. So I don't know if it's been past practice to read out all the names,

but you have in your packet on a green piece of paper a list of summer staff hires. And for those who are new, it's the practice in this district that when over the summer months when the board is not meeting, that the superintendent is empowered to do hires without the board.

So for most of the summer, that was June Scarapa, and since August 18th, that's been me. So you have a list here of the people that have been hired over the summer and a list of resignations. And maybe this isn't fair to throw at you, and I know Kelly's not here who usually keeps the running list,

but in terms of openings, how are we feeling about, do we have a, are we pretty well staffed for our openings? Are there still spots? There are still some spots, but all things considered, we're not, we're pretty good. The hardest area we've been having is ed techs.

And we have several positions, and don't ask me to get too specific about it without digging into my laptop, but we have several positions for which there are postings for one or two ed techs in a school, but we actually have maybe three vacancies and it's not worth posting the third one because we have two postings out there that we don't have any candidates for.

24:22

But we continue to search for people. Thank you. All right, so we do not have any, we're easing everybody back into our regular board meetings here. We don't have any administrative reports. We don't have any board reports or committee reports because most committees haven't met yet. We don't have a policy review yet. So we will move on to unfinished business.

And the first thing we are going to undertake is the work plan. this was originally on a retreat agenda but as usual we sometimes struggle to get to that item because we spend lots of time talking about other things in that in that retreat so in an effort to

give it the the time it deserves I will tell you I think Jimmy originally had this on the agenda for 10 minutes I laughed at her I was like do you know us what are you talking about so So, yeah, so in your packets is the draft work plan, and what this includes so far is kind of the standing items that we talk about every year.

So, you know, we try to get an update from each of the school administrators and each of the directors around their goals for the year. usually the the school administrators will tell us like how their beginning of school has gone

those types of things those are all in here um we do have a few other items um already kind of plugged in in terms of the of the work plan um as we mentioned the cell phone usage is on there for the next meeting in september um i also noticed the multilingual learner update is in here in

October. There were some discussions. I think Erica had mentioned something about providing a presentation to the board. Now I'm trying to remember exactly what it was relative to. I believe it was a curriculum as, does anybody remember from the retreat? It was a great idea.

Chapter 104, which is GATE. Oh, it's like, what? Okay. So, yeah, so the practices in the district around our GATE programming, obviously the strategic plan is in here in a variety of places as well as the budget process so far.

So, you know, one of the things that we try to do is provide information to the board around you know things that are happening in within the district that we might not see at a surface level you know some more detailed information we have

had presentations about social emotional supports that are in the schools you know talking about the social workers the the counselors that all of you know what do we have that's available what you know what our kids accessing those types of things we've had program we've

had presentations on pretty much anything you can think of and we want to make sure that the board feels informed about what's happening in the district all the great work that's happening these these presentations also can

provide an opportunity to highlight maybe something that we'd like to be doing better and to give the board sort of that initial look to say like hey this is what we're doing now this is some gaps we're seeing so just be

prepared when we come back usually around budget time with how we're gonna propose filling those gaps or things like that I think maybe the other thing we had talked about was the review of was it around sort of consistency of

programming across the different towns and districts and schools and not districts but towns and schools to to make sure that we're looking at sort of the equity piece we talked about that a lot during the budget process I feel

like maybe that was something that Erica had mentioned what she said yes MTSS right so multi-tiered systems of supports the replacement for RTI for folks at home who may have just figured out what RTI means now we're moving on

to MTSS it's always a new act yes yes one of the things that we should I would strongly recommend we consider in the work plan probably early is that we need to talk about the requirement from CDS that school districts assume

responsibility for providing FAPE free and appropriate public education to preschool age children right so right so that I don't think is it picked up anywhere yet in here right um but that is one that i think one it's new um and it's not it's

29:37

not effective yet but it's coming pretty quickly we have to plan for right so um but it is something that i think we will see in in budget cycles in the you know if not this year soon after that um so understanding what does that mean what is it what are the implications what are i mean not that

we have to have it all figured out and solved yet because i think that might be a bit of a uh, um, Herculean task at this point without more information, but at least to get it on everybody's radar, um, so that we're ready for those conversations when they, when they do

require us to take action. Um, okay. So, so CDS. Um, I think, I think this draft work plan has most of the requests for for presentations that we have heard over the last year but maybe not okay which what was another one um what about student leadership i think we've talked about that in the

past i mean phoebe is a good person to ask that but i enjoyed their presentation and she's leaving she's leaving bye bye phoebe um i think it's good to hear from the students and i think that would be great if the you know we get the high schoolers definitely do it maybe once maybe twice would be

guys. I think that, how about some of the other schools, too? Does, you know, can the middle school kids present something? Do they have that ability? I'm trying to think if they have any kind of groups that, I mean, they don't even, well, I guess I don't know

this for the middle school, but I don't believe Durham does even like student council. Do they? At FMS. I know that Mass. They definitely does. So that could be an option, at least for that school yeah i don't know that fms does does not okay and yeah and i don't think durham

does either um for the middle school components um i definitely think you know some sort of involvement or presentation from that leadership team here at the high school is a great idea i'm going to say that i think we're going to definitely be pulling them into the the cell

phone usage debacle I don't know is that the right word let's be optimistic rich discussion because I think you know one thing I think it was actually the the group in the community for the responsible use for technology I forget their full name but the folks that reach out to us about the

of technologies in our schools those types of things one of the things they provided us had some great links to how other districts kind of the process and learnings and what went well what didn't and it does seem like the the inclusion of the of the student body particularly at the high

school level is key to successful implementation regardless of which way you go so i think i hope that our process will include that um as a as a part a key part of the of the process so yes on that note i was wondering if it would make sense to have the cell phone usage discussion be the

following meeting when the middle school and the high school are here to give updates and goal reviews i said a bad idea since larry to be here yeah it might that might be a good place if we of cell phones to talk about cds right well we have more street yeah does that provide enough

time to put together because that's the other thing i i'm trying to be respectful of is the time it takes to put together these presentations you know we sit and listen for 20 minutes or so and ask questions for you know another 20 minutes or so but i know that a ton of work goes into the

background to prepare those presentations so um does does that provide enough time i mean not that it has to be the most in-depth presentation we've ever seen but is that enough to get us yes okay yeah all right so we think cds here on the 24th and then yeah the cell phone i guess i just

want to i would advocate for um having kind of having a designated uh presentation for the student leadership that isn't connected to cell phone usage like yeah that would that would be great to have them involved on that but I would rather have to give them an

opportunity to say all right like in terms of suit leadership what do you want to we want to talk about what do we need to know what does the district need to know rather than just have it no I 100% agree with that yeah because I

know that I mean in prior years they've had sort of like groups within the group that have focused on a variety of different things I don't know what those things maybe you guys don't know what those things are yet this year off the

34:38

top of my head, I feel that, like, the December first meeting, and this is the only meeting in December. I was going to say, there's only one in December. Yeah. That might be a good fit. A good spot there. And does that give the, I'm looking at Phoebe because she's on this group, does that give you guys enough time to, one, figure out your goals and plans for the year, and two, come up with something you could present to us? Yeah, so I don't want to speak for my whole team here, but I will.

Yeah, December, wait, December 10th I think would be a good time so our typical trajectory is um in the December time we are kind of in the middle of our conversation recordings um so we're like really like posting um all these different conversations about whatever we choose we don't have that

topic yeah our first meeting is tomorrow um so we can give you like a mid-year update during that time i think in the spring we could give like a whole year update but we're our work is usually cutting pretty close to last day school um we have a spirit week or anything like that

we do yeah first week this october yes and i think we do no yeah that's it i think there might be one in the spring yeah maybe depending on if we do a spring dance that isn't probably um is something really friday this year yes um so yeah but i honestly think our team like

can put together whatever we can at the time if you pencil us in i think it actually might be helpful to like have something more like working towards and like we have to get to this spot by this time so wherever you feel like you can put us i think it has in the past been very valuable

for the team to um come here and present because we feel like you know being listened to it helps get a look out to like the broader community um so if you are willing to have us i think um the team would be very excited to present so maybe um may 6th so that's after we've adopted

the budget so all of the budget sort of deliberations are done um we have our q a but then um there there's not a a huge agenda of items on the 6th does that work because it's that's kind of you don't want to do the annual budget meeting and then the last two tend to get a little busier

at the very end so what's that is it yes it is it is an AP exam time but in the past it's kind of been like yes we will be um prepping our meetings for this presentation but in terms of like the actual presentation I feel like it's been like less than 20 minutes before I feel confident that

then prioritize it um okay yeah why don't we put it in and then you know if you guys are getting to that point when everyone's hair is on fire and you're like we can't do this then let's talk about it okay yeah thank you um they're gonna be really happy okay so december 10th and may 6th

and you will share that with your team oh wait well so the december 10th is out No, December 10th, that was like sort of your mid-year one. Oh, you're saying that you prefer to just do it in May, you think? Maybe. Why don't you go talk to them tomorrow and see how they're feeling and let us know. Perfect. We would love to hear from you twice, but we know you guys have very full plates, so, okay.

This is more of a question, but I'm just thinking about the work plan and thinking about past years and kind of how the, I guess, kind of the arc of kind of like what we work on or what we learn about. And I guess I'm wondering, especially this year where we don't have a, we're sort of out of strategic plan.

There's nothing we're executing in terms of a strategic plan that we established, you know, we finished that cycle. So we're a little limbo-y on that, but yet we're moving toward, or we're in the process of developing the next strategic plan.

I guess I'm just wondering, I guess kind of like what the goal reviews will really be at a kind of macro level, like kind of what they're going to be about. Because I would think in a sort of thinking back in a year where we're in the midst of a strategic plan, I think there'd be some sense that the goals are like, how are we doing toward that?

40:02

are kind of like, and I guess, so I guess that's just sort of a general question, and I guess the other question is just, is there a way that we could make use of those, without giving extra labor to the admin staff, to use those sort of as part of the strategic planning process for the

board? In other words, sort of a way of kind of understanding, like, these are the things we're thinking about, like, these are the things we're currently, like, here's a snapshot of what we're working on, and these are the things that are important to us, we're not quite sure where this is going to go, but I don't know if either of those things make sense.

The way that kind of sits with me at the moment is that as we're shaping the new plan, and we're detached from the outcome, and we don't know what that will be yet, I do think we're in this limbo area where the building's goals that come forward are somewhat free-floating.

But my hope and expectation would be that next year, once we have the plan, the building goals would have a clear link to the overall strategic plan. And I say that they're free-floating. I would be highly surprised if the goals that come forward from the schools are just completely out

in left field. I've seen the high school's goals. They are all about... They're their own strategic plan. They do, which came out of an interesting configuration, but Jen explained how that came about to me the other day.

They're going after good things that we would all agree make sense. I haven't heard from the other principals yet about their specific goals, but I will be over the course of the next month or two. So I think my recommendation at the moment would be to,

as the principals come forward and share their school goals, to ask good questions about how they may have aligned with the strategic plan in the past, and they will know that in the future we have to make explicit connections.

And I mean, I guess to your point of being detached from the outcome, I would be surprised if our next strategic plan was completely divergent from the one we've been working through for the past several years. I imagine it's an extension and an expansion of that. No more hope. Yes. We're going completely in a different direction. I just pulled up the email that Anna had sent, and then also Kelly had sent some additional ones around ideas.

Some of these I think we have captured, the CDS kind of pre-K piece, the, I think Kelly mentioned major curriculum changes from the equity lens, I think that's a good one, I think that's what I was recollecting from our retreat, so I don't know where folks are

feeling about that one, if that's one that we want to find a place for. and then the other two that jumped out at me is sort of the AI technology piece as well as PD that was the other item that popped up in some of those emails and I was wondering if some of these could be captured

within the building goal release for example when our building administrators come up they can talk about what kind of PD they're doing so we don't necessarily need a separate session right that's a yeah way to capture kind of because i i know in the past some um you know we had for

example we had a year where um every every goal update we got from a build administrator we didn't have a specific presentation for all the districts but each one we said what is your everyone was dealing with attendance in some form or fashion so how are how are they how are they dealing with

that? What was their approach? So maybe something similar to that. Same with DEI, right? We were like, what are each of the schools, regardless of the grade span of the school doing, within their schools around that? Student voice is another one. We said, hey, sort of a prompt that

we gave every administrator when they presented their goals was make sure you key in on that. So maybe PD could be kind of the prompt we look for from them this year. How does that feel to people that sound works for you absolutely okay um so i think we have cd cds baked in we have

cell phones uh i imagine cell phones is probably going to be more than one meeting but we'll they'll get in there first yeah i guess just just on that maybe we'll just linger for a second to say like what we like what we mean when we talk about cell phone when we put that on the work

plan like what do we mean by that like are we saying um at that meeting which we moved it up right or back where did we october 8th yeah october 8th right um i mean it seems sort of early enough to kind of i don't know be kind of like um laying out a plan like talking about

45:23

whether a plan is needed because i think i just i i want to just make sure we kind of continue on from our conversation last spring where one of the things that we kind of came to was with the understanding that, yes, it's very important to have engagement from all of the

different stakeholders. There's at least some opinion on the board that there's not a whole lot new to be learned about what the options are. So I guess I just want to make sure when we're saying, like, this is part of the work plan, like, what does that mean? And I know that we're required by the state

to have a policy about cell phones, so that's slated in. I think you could say that's maybe the genesis. Yeah. I mean, it's kind of, yeah, yeah. Policy by July 1st. Right. And that, I mean, I think we can start working on that as a, we can start working on that, I guess, slightly agnostically in terms of saying, at least if we had to write a plan about what, you know, this is what we, or what's our policy

currently, we can articulate that and put that on paper. But yeah, I guess, what do we mean when we say we're going to talk about cell phones in October? Yeah, I mean, I think our, was it our last meeting? No, it was our, I think our second to last meeting in June, I went

back and re-watched that meeting to refresh my memory on our conversation there. I think there's a couple things. There was there was some folks that were going to do some work around finding out costs of options if we chose to go yep or alternatives alternatives to those just so we know what those look like

I think Anna's point in her email was a good one I don't think we had full feedback from the staff around their their preference um of of next steps i think that's key um you know maybe phoebe can throw something else on their agenda tomorrow for the student leadership team to start you guys

brainstorming around you know collecting feedback or thoughts or you know procedurally how we might move forward um yeah like are you wanting us to like go forward with like hosting conversations or like provide like the kind of templates we go by that like students know already or

yeah i mean i i think i think maybe uh you guys can just start be preparing for the fact that we're probably going to be tapping you to solicit whether it's feedback from the students or whether it's your, you know, your thoughts on the best way for us to share information

with the students about a change like this, you know, kind of a, I would envision a two-way conversation there, right? I think we have a pretty, to Colin's point, I think we have a pretty good idea of what the general feedback is going to be when we say, hey, what do you think?

But maybe, you know, some thoughts around, you know, what might a communication program look like to, you know, share the whys, the, you know, I think that was the other piece we talked about in June was, it sounded like there was some, potentially some really good

speakers that might be good to start the process with around, like, why is this important, Right. So, I would love to hear more about that on October 8th. Right. Is that feasible? Is it, you know, 50 grand to get the person here and that's not, you know. Yeah.

It seems to me just having, I mean, I wasn't here for the previous parts of this conversation, but it seems to me that October 8th, you probably want to decide as a board whether you're still in listening mode or whether you're in talking mode.

Are you at the point where you're still seeking information to inform how you feel, or do you have enough? I think I heard Colin say, you've learned a lot already, don't know how much more there is to learn. And I think that one question, are you still listening or are you talking, will help you decide what you want to do on that day.

So I did not watch this previous conversation, so I'm coming in fully blind. That said, do we have a way to reach out to districts who have already implemented solutions to see how that's going for them? I mean, you know, we know who they are, so it could, and I think there's been some sharing of information.

50:26

Yeah, I mean, I would just say on that that, I mean, I think part of the impetus for even having this conversation is that the vice principal at the high school was like, we talked to Bath, and it's working really well not having cell phones in the high school.

And so I think that is, I would say that's a large data point. That's not the only one that we could look at or should look at. But I think it's just important to acknowledge that I think that is, that was one of the precipitating pieces of information.

And I wonder if they have a counterpart to our leadership group that our leaders might, just to get, because I would imagine that the teachers and the administration are happy with that. But we also want to make sure that we are – and not to say that it would necessarily say, oh, geez, the kids are, you know, unhappy that they can't use their phones during the day, so we should just scrap the whole idea.

We do have to make a decision at some point, but it might help us understand, like, is there a better way to implement it? Is there a better way to message it? Or is it just, you know, prepare? Yeah, I don't know if Phoebe's hands up or she's – yeah, and then I'll go to Steph.

Uh, I would say, um, to Superintendent Gray's question of, like, list every time listening, I would feel pretty strongly that I think there's still some more information to be gotten. Um, not necessarily that, like, our phones are bad.

I think we were feeling pretty, like, solidly there. Um, but in terms of, like, the hows and the who's and when's, um, I think, getting student feedback is going to help even if you don't even take any of it showing students in

any situation like showing students you're listening and you want to know i think it's going to help with the buy-in um but i wouldn't like discount like what the high school and even middle school students would have to say because i from the conversations i hear in class and in

like people have a lot of different opinions and i don't think they're all like like a punk like high school kid like i do think that people like you know but i think you could get a lot of good information and then i also think um that communication with other schools and maybe

getting some like actual like other than just hearing like path is doing great um hearing some like either something like real data points or like um testimony from teachers because we know that is like a big thing is we don't really in terms of like the bags like teachers don't want

to be like having to enforce other policies so like hearing from teachers in districts who have had other policies that don't require as much like teacher enforcement hearing from them hearing from some students um yeah i think there is some some still some information to be gotten

yeah and i think that that's a great point thank you phoebe um you know just like what are the concerns around it right and maybe there's ways to meet those needs um but if we don't even know that it's a concern or a need then how do we address it so thanks for that seth i attended the

MSBA regional meeting last night and two representatives from other districts Raymond Windham and York just implemented policies as well and there was talk that MSBA is going to put together it's like draft sample policies of like

varying kinds and they'll be made available so I think that that could be another resource to consider and some of those folks from those schools were willing to share what they've done and information so it seems that like there's dialogue that's starting to be shared amongst districts as well it might

be helpful yeah there's MSB regional meetings might be a really good because the I don't know if you found it to be helpful but I have in the past I wasn't able to join last night but people I mean they're just other board members and

people are really happy to share you know what's working for them what's not working for them and York and Wyndham Raymond were those for Bell to Bell bands for both of them interesting yeah but they started when school started this

fall so they're both you know school board members not students they both reported that it was reported as successful and you know two weeks that we've been back but yeah so yeah I agree that we're still in listening mode for a

bit and we'd love to hear more from students here and from students in other schools and from the teachers in the other schools as well so that's the information that I would like to continue to receive and that if there's a way that we could make that happen on the 8th I think that would be helpful I know that's the policy committee will be looking at our work plan on and I

55:54

don't recall where the cell phone piece falls on that if it's there yet but yeah Yeah, and so that committee will be looking at a variety of policies in that process, but I think it would be really helpful to hear how those policies are being implemented

and how it's working. Yeah, and not that I want to make him come to another meeting, but it might be helpful to have Will also for that conversation if our plan is to have Pam and John from the high school and FMS because I do think it's important that, you know, Obviously, there's a variety of schools this impacts. Not so much the younger, younger grades, although maybe it does, I don't know.

But certainly the middle schools and the high school. I was just thinking in terms of the actual work plan, if it would make sense, since it sounds like we do have a lot of information we could still yet gather if we used that October 8th meeting as sort of the listening piece,

and then we schedule another session somewhere later in our work plan. Yeah, the talking piece. Or preparing for the talking piece. Yeah, so you think about policies and procedures. Yeah, and I think, I mean, I want to thank you, Phoebe, for articulating the importance of that, and I think I stand kind of, I'm going to say, sort of morally corrected on the sort of importance of that, and I didn't mean to suggest that we don't need to hear more voices.

We do, I think, so I think we are still in listening mode. I think probably what I'm realizing I meant was that I think the board knows why we are talking about it, like that we kind of know that what we are concerned about is the social

and emotional well-being of our students and the quality of the education, the educational experience that they are receiving. So I think that, again, perhaps I'm assuming too much, but I think that is where at least I'm coming from. So I think that if that's true, I think that that maybe is an important thing for us to talk about at that October 8th.

It's sort of like, well, why are we even having this conversation? And sort of being able to say to the community, but also to be able to say to the students, these are our concerns, and this is why we are considering a belt-to-belt ban, right?

And sort of it's not because, like, how do you put it if you do that cell phones are bad? Like, yeah, they are, but that's not the reason we're doing it. Well, that's not the reason we're exploring it. we're exploring it because we care about these particular, um, the impacts of them on the

students in a couple of ways. So again, I don't know who is the appropriate person to articulate that or kind of to like share that. I don't know if that's, I don't know if that's you, I don't know if that's one of the guests, you know, the possible guest speakers that we spoke

about. Um, but I don't know. I think that should be something that is, that is voiced by someone who can really speak to the importance of that and why we're even talking about it? I think it's probably me with input from the team.

Okay. Phoebe. Sorry, I know I was kind of dragging this one point out, but I got us 45 minutes on the agenda. We can use it. I kind of have an idea for your cell phone-like conversation. I think maybe I could be a liaison to the high school at least,

and I'm curious if I were to organize a group of high school students where they could, you know, just keep it in their mind, start thinking about it, maybe meet together, have an informal conversation, and then come to the October 8th meeting.

Maybe they'll share that public comment to start, maybe we'll listen to y'all's conversation just to share maybe at the end maybe not just like a group like a kind of focused group of students um you know it could be a student leadership team

but i think um and from what i've seen with the polarization of this topic especially with high schoolers um i think i would be able to find a lot of different types of students who'd be willing to um help with this work and like have a say in it um so i'm curious if that's something people

would be interested in like just getting a group of high school students like starting to think and maybe it could form up a little more later on once we start talking more formally about it i love that idea yeah i'm phoebe good thing i accidentally got a canva premium account so i

1:01:07

can make some posters accidentally i'm gonna pick you up because i i need to get better at canva so well i'll have it till next month so so bearing in mind kelly's comment might i suggest for the november 5th meeting we put in a follow-up yep um i wouldn't want to let it linger too long

and um the other thing i was thinking about and maybe this is just sort of a standing thing that we can put you know maybe it doesn't need to be on the work plan but um the the strategic plan doesn't pop into here until june 3rd right um i think we probably maybe want some kind of

intervening updates sure so i don't know if it needs to be in here or it can be I can certainly put it in here I can also promise you it will be in my updates to you and a number of folks are participating in that which I think is super great and valuable and I appreciate everybody who's spending their time doing that but I also think it's important for community members to kind of hear that update while they could look at those the weekly updates we get I think we surprisingly get a lot of people that watch these meetings Don't be fooled by the empty seats. They're watching from home on the couch with popcorn. Did you mean his updates in the beginning of the meeting? Well, I meant my weekly updates to you, but also my superintendent's reports. Yeah, so maybe we just sort of make it, you know, like a standing item once a month on the superintendent's update just for where we are with the strategic plan.

Absolutely can do. Yeah, great. Anything else that's jumping out at folks? i i would like to visit um ai conversation at least once and and to colin's point of about the cell phone item on the agenda what would that look like would we be having would we be in

learning mode or would we be in talking mode what would that look like we might need to have that on here more than once yeah i mean i don't know about everybody else on the board but i would certainly be still in learning mode i don't feel like i know nearly enough to to weigh in on where

I think we need to go with that. Yeah, maybe that's a good one for Sam. Oh, for sure. You know, I don't want him to feel neglected on the work plan here at all. Absolutely not. So February 25th is a budget review. Technology is part of that. December 10th, yep. Actually, I almost feel like that's a curriculum issue, too. So maybe that would be one that he might want to share with our assistant superintendent.

Yeah, how they come together. He's also on December 10th. Yes. Yeah, I was going to say the same thing, Keller, but I think that that's, I think, again, I think what I'm primarily interested in on that is understanding how is AI impacting the schools currently?

Like, what are the different schools? How are they addressing it? How are they making noise? How are they using it? But I think that would be helpful to know just kind of like a state of the state of the state and then a little bit of a sense again from

a curricular perspective and maybe a little bit more broadly beyond or maybe well beyond the district of sort of like how are people talking about this like I mean I have read my own collection of things about AI and education but to really understand from a from within the school what

kind of things are are we are we thinking about and should we be aware of so that um when it pops up on the strategic plan which it will do uh detached from the outcome detached from yeah uh but like when it pops up we sort of have some context for sort of like where is that

where's that coming from and what are we trying to achieve with it and you know that sort of thing yep um so so on december 10th i can ask erica and sam to collaborate on presentation around ai yeah and then the only other one that we haven't really talked about that um was the the curriculum

kind of overview um that erica had mentioned as she's sort of digging into all of the different curriculums that we're doing across the district with the idea around sort of equity and what does that look like across the district um i don't know if that is too much to lump in with the

1:06:11

technology and ai piece or that is a separate day kind of feels like it's a separate day that's a big it's big yeah so and i don't know how much time that one takes for her to you know i i know she's dove in deep starting on july 1st it might not be bad to put that on january 14th

So we have, you know, progress on district goals, the district scorecard, the high school program of studies, it might be a good fit. Yeah, actually with the district scorecard, that's probably a great spot to put that. And that just reminds me of something else that we have seen, I'm trying to remember if it was on this year's board eval or not,

but we've certainly seen in prior years sort of this thought that we only get sort of that district update once a year. And I don't know what's a better way to accomplish that, how we get more frequent updates, or if, you know, if the data is so massive that really once a year

is the best we're going to get, right, because there's lagging and, you know, those sort of things but um and tell me if if i'm completely off base and we've never heard that in the feedback but i feel like we have um yeah i wonder if erica has any ideas actually on how to present that

information i know she's she's keeping track of how many cookies we all eat hi so erica mateo assistant superintendent um welcome erica also yes and i didn't i welcome any board members but i'm superintendent and assistant superintendent so welcome to everyone

thank you um so the question specifically is with regard to what beyond the sort of curriculum study is there something else that you're looking for um one of the things we've heard is just sort of a more maybe frequent but i don't know what the right frequency is just kind of overview of

where we are so we have this right now in our in our work plan we have this district scorecard that we look at once a year yeah and we all have to remind ourselves like what do these mean what is growth what you know all those things i don't know if there is a different more holistic yeah maybe

not so data-driven i don't know yeah um so growth data versus achievement data versus some sorts some sort of social emotional indicators or climate and culture pieces um not everything is a thing we're currently studying or following or measuring so some of it might be we'd like to

learn more about these areas or have some more universal or standard measures um my recommendation would be that we do a beginning and end of year data debrief so that you know what is the growth looking like where is the starting place and then where is the delivery at the end of the year so

as we set about our summer work and our planning for the year to come like how we have you know how we've delivered in the year prior and how we are establishing those goals and priorities based on the data in areas we see as identified needs

or opportunities for growth. Yeah, and all of that will fall into that broader context of MTSS structures and our cut scores and all the pieces. So some of it's soft with our climate and culture pieces and some of it's a little bit more traditional academic achievement and so-called growth. And I can get into the whole growth indicator thing in more depth at some other point. We'll need a refresher. I do every year, so I'll apologize up front. You don't have to tell me every year. There's a lot to it. But, yeah, like the climate and culture one, I don't think that's ever anything we've ever gotten in the past. So, you know, I think everything you said sounds great.

I don't necessarily think it's fair to throw a beginning of year one at you. I could probably give you something pretty surface level for beginning of year if that's of interest. Just tell me when. Okay. we'll be looking at recommendations for other pieces, I'm sure.

Okay, I think we're throwing, yeah. Yeah, just on that voice over there, Erica, I think I'd love that idea of having something in the beginning and something in the end, both because I just like that arc, but I also, I think, I'm realizing I would love to have

as many moments this year when we can have an integration between an understanding of where are we right now and as we're moving toward both the budget for next year and we're also moving toward the strategic plan to have a little bit more of a sense of how do those pieces fit together? Because I think, honestly, I think I don't often have a feeling

1:11:20

going into budget season that I really understand And kind of the link between sort of some of the education indicators or sort of that and where the budget has, again, not that the budget is only in relation to that, but I think as many points as we could kind of integrate those things or have sort of connections would be excellent.

Yes. It might be a good opportunity for just the surface level. Sure. Yeah. It feels important, yeah. So that's also where we put CDS. Because I feel like that's going to be you too, right? That's both of you guys together on that one. So we're not trying to drive anybody, you know, off the edge too early in the year.

So, yeah, who come? Here you go. Yeah, if you guys think that that's doable for the 24th, great. If not, we'll figure out a spot for it. I think it works. Yeah. Next meeting. Okay. Anything else that we do? Yeah, stuff. I wanted to revisit the conversation about the Strategic Communications Committee and its, like, role of what it, I, I understood it to be board to public communication or district to public communication, but it doesn't seem like that's what it's been historically, um, yeah, and so that kind of comes from, like, my own surprise at that, and also just in kind of going through the budget process at the tail end,

And last year, for the first time, how, and this is more like, you know, hearing in the community stuff of folks that I know that are really engaged with the school who still were experiencing confusion. And so to me, that tells me that we could maybe communicate better if the folks that really want to support us and like be here and come to the votes and all of those things are and they're still confused.

So I just kind of wanted to bring that up as a topic, and maybe it's through the Strategic Communications Committee or something else, but especially hearing Tom's budget updates and knowing where we're going, and I think that that's like a really, and all of these policies that are very contentious sometimes, I think that that's like a piece that could

really help us have a smoother path for the year, if it's an option to consider or look at. I'm chuckling because you've basically channeled the person who you replaced on the board like Candy Soapbox was like communicate, communicate, communicate. Like we need to tell people more

things. So I love that. I'm glad that that is not lost with her departure from the board. So thank you. Where did we come down on that committee? I felt like we decided it wasn't meeting because That's what I remember. I was thinking my recollection, which is always fuzzy.

This is the problem we don't have a video. Were you going to email us a suggested meeting date? It was not in your head. I think the fact that we left off was that we were going to defer to Tom and he was going to have a little brainstorm session with himself.

That made us with Ginny. or Jenny, and kind of determine what role and goals that committee might take this year. I did actually know that you say that. So I did go back the next day and talk with Jenny about it, and she had a lot to say about communication that's already happening. So I will revisit that with Jenny. Yeah, I think, I mean, I'm not on the committee, so I don't want to obligate people to time, but I do think it's important.

And I do think the conversation, the communication does go both ways with that committee. It's probably in the last few years been, well, the outward communication has mostly been the budget brochure, which rightly or wrongly, that's what it has been to make sure

we've been getting that out every year. And then the information in has been the various surveys, whether it's the parent survey or the staff survey on the alternating years. So I do think they're kind of, it is a two-way conversation vehicle, but it can always be better.

And I do think your thought process around sort of thinking ahead to wanting to make sure that, you know, people who want to engage with us have the information they need to do it, and are there better ways to do it. I do sometimes think we get a little bit of, you know, over-communication fatigue, like, well, every meeting is public.

1:16:24

every meeting is videoed. We send stuff to everybody's email. We send stuff to their house. And, you know, there's sort of knocking on people's doors. Like, what else can we do? But it's not the right way to think about it. There are always other ways. So, yeah, I would be

really supportive of that committee meeting, even if it's just to brainstorm about other ways to communicate. Yeah, I don't recall what questions are on the survey or are planned for the focus group right now for strategic planning but i'm hopeful that this topic will bubble up and that

we'll hear feedback from the community about how effective all these communication channels are and it might even be helpful to have that list from jenny of what what is happening what are we doing already but the question really is is it effective that's what we want to know and if that

if we can have a surface-level data conversation in the Strategic Communications Committee, that might be helpful. Yeah, I was just going to mention, I'm not really sure if we need a separate agenda item for this, just because normally throughout the course of the year, we do have committees report out regularly. So if we define what the role of this committee is and we actually have some work to do, we'll be reporting that out throughout the year that's a yes thank you for that and that's a good

that prompted something else to pop into my brain around um wanting to ask folks that are on subcommittees policy finance and facilities always have sort of a designated spot in those board committee updates um but i think we have committees that we don't hear from um do people on other

committees would it be helpful if we schedule maybe not every month but maybe twice a year like region 10 or um dei or the curriculum committee um to to report out okay it's a little bit more challenging i think for the ones that don't meet regularly because we don't know where to put them

on the on the calendar so maybe we can get together and try and figure out when they are and then we can slate them to make sure that they have a designated spot on on the agenda and i will try to do my best to remind folks that are on those committees that they're coming up for a report

so we don't surprise anybody in the meeting bye i recently started following the town of freeport on instagram and they literally are just disseminating information about the town like nothing just like hey don't forget there's a three-way stop happening soon hey don't forget

we're having the town council meeting tonight i'm wondering if it could be something like that leveraging a informational not asking for opinions this is what's happening don't forget this kind of social media presence not i mean not that feedback isn't welcome but maybe that's not the forum for

it and on social media it's actually this is this is my opinion but it's also like other people's opinion um on social media you don't want it to be two-way communication because bad things can come in you know so yeah and if you i mean if it is sort of a push out of infinite i mean we do

have a social media like we do have a facebook page i don't know if we have a instagram page it would be very simple to tie them together so it posts to both because i know not everybody has both um and so you know there are i don't know who's responsible for that i don't know who posts

jenny okay um jenny has a pretty full plate so let's we'll think on that maybe maybe we can get her some support in that are you volunteering call no okay i'm volunteering uh two points one well yeah well that's what i was i wanted to give you an opportunity because you are

Because you're probably not on camera currently, so people can't see that you're working at a dance routine during the school board meeting. I just wanted to make sure that you felt like you had time to share that later.

But second, perhaps this is a statement of bloody obvious and everybody else knows this or knows that it is currently happening. But I guess I'm just realizing I don't know whether part of strategic communications remit is an analysis of effectively every communication that happens across the school between any part of the school and the public.

Because I think when I think about strategic communications, that's what I think about is basically sort of like, how do the letters that are being sent out for mass landing connect to later things that are sent out by Tom, by how does that connect to sort of what is the, what's our overall strategy for how we're communicating with the public and that the budget is then one piece of that, but it's not.

1:21:52

So, I guess, in my mind, I don't think we need to do, as you say, we're doing a lot on the budget. I don't think that's the, for me, I don't think that's the particular issue. I think it's sort of a larger question of just, like, how are we communicating, and how could we do that, perhaps in a more integrated way, in a more effective way?

I guess I just wanted to narrow my comment to, like, where I see where I'm confused is, like, board communication to the public, right? And that's, I think, something that we all have, or that has felt, like, even though the information is out there, that sometimes it's not landing in the way that we would hope or that we would expect or that we would like.

And so maybe there's something that can be done there. And I don't know if that's within the scope of the committee, but... We can make the scope of the committee. Right, exactly. And then it comes back to the philosophical question of, like, the fact, what should we be communicating to the public? Like, what is our role, right? I mean, we certainly want people engaged in the budget process because that is their role to play in that, is the vote, right? And that's why we want to make sure people are informed and have the information they need to make an informed vote. But then, you know, is it our job to reach out and share other things, right?

Like where we want their feedback around, say, something like the strategic plan it is, right? Because we run that process and we solicit the feedback. Yeah, that's an interesting question. There is an argument to be made that it strengthens the district for the public to know more broadly what's happening in the schools.

And, you know, what a number of districts that I have known have turned to is actually somebody who's taking this on as a primary role, not just doing it off the side of their desk. And as the world of communication becomes more complex, you know, there are arguments to make that investment.

that's an investment to think about in the context of every other investment you want to make when I think of this what makes me want to pursue that more as a board member is when I hear us talking about why we want the high

school students and other students to have buy-in with the cell phone policy is because then it feels like we're collaborating collaboratively making a a policy choice and as we're heading into places where we're going to continue to see budget

increases having a greater collaboration with our communities feels like it would be useful to us as a board and as a district yeah it certainly doesn't hurt right the more people know about what we're doing that you know when all they hear when all they see is 7.1 and they know nothing

And other than that, well, that's easy to make out in the schools. And, you know, most people, it doesn't cost their PR. Yeah, and just to be clear, I think that's also part of kind of what I meant about the strategic communication

as I'm sort of thinking about it is like, yes, what does the board communicate about because it's not being communicated elsewhere? Or what is the board communicating about because we really want to amplify something? And then what's not our lane? Because that is being handled by the superintendent's office, or that is being handled by the high school. So just again, to understand kind of like the full picture of that, to sort of know, oh, this is when these communications are going out, here's how they're integrated, here's how they reinforce each other, or here's how they contrast. I think like having an understanding of that would be really helpful. I mean, all I'm saying, any posters, Instagram graphics,

I got all of the gifts, like, I'm ready. But only until next month when they charge you, I guess. We gotta get this done before I feel better. Isn't there a bus we can sell to, like, get her the account? Like, did we sell that bus already?

We may have been talking about selling a gator today. I'm like, maybe we can get Phoebe to buy that. Stay tuned. I have one more question. The sheet that's, like, all of the committees and the times that they meet and who's on them, will that be updated so that, um... I'm sure it already has been. Um, I'm guessing once we all changed who was on what, she probably did.

uh and as sure she did yeah uh she's she's pretty speedy on that um where it lives is a great question other than on jimmy's computer so uh maybe we can ask her to share that absolutely i don't know if it is okay um because it's really kind of a tool we built to make sure

i got confused at one point like what do we have to have what is a choice that we have um we color coded them based on like like the amount of time effort you know like the freeport cable tv one was green and then negotiations for the teacher contract was you know bright red you

1:26:59

know just in terms of time and stuff like that so um anyway uh so how do people feel about the work plan i think we picked up student leadership once maybe twice we picked up cds at the meeting on the 24th um ai and technology we're going to tag that on for sam in december 10th uh curriculum

with sort of the equity lens is going to be a part of the district scorecard on january 14th we'll capture the pd offerings when the administrators are doing their their updates slash goals when we hear from them in the fall.

Cell phone, we put on twice, once on October 8th, and then again on November 5th for a follow-up. Did I miss anything? Yeah. Well, a couple of things. The AI and technology one, would that make sense to also ask the administrators to add to their reports, or is that too much? Since we were talking about how it would be nice to know how each... I don't know if they're all equipped to really give a lot on that right now.

And I think it could be something that Sam gathers as a part of what he's presenting. Kind of how we're using it. What's that? And Erica. Yes, and Erica, yeah. Okay, and I think Erica had also mentioned GATE earlier. Is there something? Oh, yes. Chapter 104.

You're just filling your own plate here, Erica. Yeah, we could, it is a specific program written into statute, so I don't know if you want it bundled with MTSS or if you'd like to do it separately. Does it, in my head, they're different, but does it make sense to bundle them together?

So multilingual programming is separated. I would say keep it as two separate items, but potentially on the same night, if that makes sense. Okay. So multilingual learners we have on October 22nd. And then did we say the MTSS piece would be part of that curriculum overview or is that a separate? I can do that at any point. Deeper in the year a little bit would offer maybe some more direction. So March 11th is sort of a budget deliberation.

So that's the only thing we have on that meeting. Not that we won't fill all those moments with exciting budget talk. But maybe it would be good for us to have something else to think about. Is that enough time into the year? It is. And then what about the Chapter 104 at that point or at some other point? Does it make sense to keep those two together on the 11th? Yeah. Okay. So March 11th, so MTSS and GATE.

Okay. Danielle, did I see anything? Are you good? Have we bitten off more than we can chew? A lot. We'll give you one out when you two get out of this meeting in the next couple days and you look at this and you're like, oh my god, why did we agree to all that?

We can revisit if we need to, but we'll put this, this seems like a great work plan in the meantime. Okay? Thank you. Yeah, I just wanted to give everyone an update on my tiny group that I'm making. It's going to be called the Scoop Special Committee on our phones, and I'll lure them with ice cream.

So, it will be here. O-U-P. S-C-O-U-P. Oh, oh, our. I can't say that. Wow. Scoop. Okay. All right. So, now that we've done all of this work plan, we are to the district goal, which I think it's in our folder, isn't it? Oh, it's literally on the... isn't that hilarious it's on the agenda but yeah i think it's the same thing that's on that page

yeah to engage stakeholders in the community of rsu5 in a comprehensive and inclusive process to collaboratively develop the five-year strategic plan i think holland's previous concerns about sort of the lack of teeth of of that being the whole district's goal for the year are um are

1:32:19

understandable but i will turn back to our work plan of lots of great work that will be done this year um that while we may not have a shiny you know four goal bucket to like tag each one of these things to yet progress will be made my i have a rewording suggestion for this for this one

because i feel like we're doing the board is responsible for more than engaging the stakeholders in this. I think, and I guess my question is, is the goal ultimately to develop or approve a strategic plan this year? It is. Rather than just engaging the stakeholders. So I would propose

saying that our goal is to collaboratively develop or approve, whatever word we want to go with, a five-year strategic plan through a comprehensive and inclusive process that engages stakeholders in the rsu5 communities i'm not adding too many words there i'm really just just reordering that

but with the focus being on developing it and approving it but also making it comprehensive and inclusive nothing mind shatters i really like that say that again yeah uh to collaboratively develop do i have a motion for consideration and approval for the rsu5 district goal for 25 26 to

here's where you say it to collaboratively develop or approve whichever word we all agree on a five-year strategic plan through a comprehensive and inclusive process that engages stakeholders in the rc5 communities develop and approve i would i like that yeah i think i like you're

going to want to approve it yep are you making that motion thank you second from malik so motion from kelly second from malik any other comments other than thank you for the rewording kelly Yeah, well, that really better defines what the goal actually is.

It puts it front and center. Thank you, Kara. My other note is, do we all like the word stakeholders, or do we want to change that to just people? That could be a whole conversation, but does anyone have any? Kara, have you ever considered joining the policy community? I like to be the word. You don't like stakeholders? I think everybody is a stakeholder in our district, right? Some may not see themselves as such, but... I think it's a huge range of people, and I think stakeholders.

I like stakeholders. Yeah, I think it kind of gets everyone. You think it's put office or something? Okay. Is it too corporate? We're looking at the stakeholder policy tomorrow. It's the first on our... No, we're not. Yeah, I think that's fantastic. Like, and also I think, you know, to your, to your, um, to your point about the work plan and also your sort of gesture to Superintendent Gray to sort of be like, is this too much?

I think, like, I think actually at the end of the day, I think the evaluation of, like, does the work plan serve that is the determination of, is the work plan right? Um, so I think, like, based on the conversation, I think the work plan does serve that end, um, from a variety of different angles.

Um, so I think, again, that would be the only thing I'd be wary of pulling anything out that we've talked about in the work plan. Um, sort of just check it against that first before we chuck it. Okay. You can call me, Tom. And it's up to you. We don't have a policy on that. I always tell people in our new board member orientation, we are only, like, quasi-formal.

There would be no, like, I agree with the former speaker. Let me do those hands, because, you know, it was a school board after all. All right. So we have a motion and a second on the floor. Any other comments, questions? All those in favor? Thank you. All right. So new business. Budget timeline. Take paper in your packets. This should look pretty familiar at this point.

And I don't think we have changed anything on here other than we did add the date for the leadership meeting with the towns in December. December 3rd, we extended that invitation to the chairs of the select boards and the town councils

1:37:22

and the administrators from each town. I don't know if they've RSVP'd yet, but it's always a great conversation. And that's probably the only change from the last time you saw this. Comments, questions? Steph, what happens at that? What is that? So that was born out of kind of some, to your point, confusion around like what's happening,

what are we seeing for budgets, what are they seeing for budgets, other things that are happening across the communities that maybe we could collaborate on. we ended up with a um position for a person who is a fields person for us in the summer

and is a driver for power trucks for the town of freeport in the winter so we don't both have to find somebody we share that position um i'm just giving you some examples of things that have come out of those meetings in the past we have done some shared purchasing for like paving those sort

oh we're doing a big project so we like you know you get cheaper when you buy in bulk um and we just you know kind of throw out things that are happening in the individual towns or in the district because you know we have our own budget that we're responsible for but it's not in a

vacuum you know each town is doing something each you know that the town of durham is moving to a July 1 fiscal year this year, right? So, everyone in Durham just got an 18-month tax bill that blew everybody's mind, right? So, which is fine, because it's 18 months. It's not,

taxes didn't go up 50% for anybody who's watching and hasn't figured that out yet, but just different things that are happening so that we can kind of plan, you know, just having all of the information, I guess. So, it was just a way to share information and see if we could find

deficiencies. Any other comments, questions? Yeah. I think just a comment, and I don't think it's anything to add to the, or anything that would need to be reflected in the document, but just as I was thinking about last year's budget process, and where we might have been able to

do better in terms of communication within the board, but also between the board and um, the superintendent is sort of like maybe a kind of, um, uh, identifying for ourselves sort of where in the process, um, if we are asking the superintendent to go back and adjust

something, like when is that moment? Kind of when is that, um, again, because my sense is that's a little bit where things maybe got a little awry, um, is that it's sort of, that maybe didn't happen early enough, or I guess would mean too late.

But I'm just sort of wondering whether, like, that kind of March 11 date is sort of like something where we can kind of, again, not to have anything, like, set in stone, but just to say, like, all right, coming into that meeting, can we as a board be thinking about, you know, if we're thinking about adjustments

Or if things are looking, if there's a sense that things are not, the board is not looking like it is going to support the proposed budget, sort of just have a moment where we could all kind of say, you know, let's look at that moment.

Again, nothing set in stone, but that we all might kind of know that that would be part of the conversation there. Like, before we leave that night, it's sort of like, are we more or less going in the direction of supporting the budget,

or are we really saying this is not what the board wishes to pursue? If you're asking me, I mean, I think it's somewhere there in March. Since we adopted it in March? Yeah. It's going to happen sometime. It's not going to be later, I think, probably that March 18th date is a good, is a sort of a good make or break date.

Yeah, I would say, I mean, my only hesitation, like, I understand the concept and the idea around it, and I agree. In reality, how it plays out, I would say usually that March 11th date is that date that we're kind of like, hey, we'd love to see, you know, if you were going to do this, like, what might that look like?

1:42:24

and they come back with some options for the next one. Because if you guys recall, generally how it works is that coming out of that 18th meeting, we have basically decided because we tried to know that number of what we're going to adopt the following week

so that the papers were all ready for us to go. Now, we don't have to, and this year we didn't. We were spreadsheeting on the fly there up until the very last moment. But absent this year, I would say typically that March 11th date you've identified is

usually where there would be some questions around, you know, oh my gosh, this is too high, we need to see something, you know, how might you address this and not have it this big, or oh geez, this is way too low. Or at that point, you'll have actually seen it six weeks before.

Right, we've seen all the presentations, because really that's the key, right, is the presentations is where we hear the why, the why, because the first one is sort of the overview i mean you will get the bottom line number usually around you know the budget increase

um but you know really the the rubber meets the road if you will when we talk when we hear from each of the administrators and the directors around like this is their recommendations and this is why um so you know i i think that march 11th date is a is a good one to be shooting for

and i think that's historically kind of that point in the in the process where we do that just didn't happen this year okay yeah but that does bring a good point that when we get those budget presentations from the various buildings and departments that we should be a little bit

maybe a little bit more proactive about raising those questions in those meetings while they're there while they're there yeah so we can sort of get people thinking about our our input a little bit earlier in the process if possible yeah it's it's it's tough right because part of it is i

don't want to make a decision in a bubble right I want to look at the whole the whole story which is I want to hear from everybody because I think one of the one of the things our district does do well is the collaboration amongst the admin team it's not like siloed budgets it's like they have

come together and said you know for the good of the district this is where we really need to prioritize this in this school and I'm willing to I'm willing to sort of sit back on something maybe i'd love to have this year because we really want to do that for them um so it's hard to kind

of pick individual ones out of the but yeah we can certainly be asking more questions in those yeah and i think again i think the spirit of my comments are not to adjust the timeline but also i think it's to just for us to be having this conversation honestly just so we as a board are

thinking about this ahead of time and i guess it even makes i mean maybe just the only thing i might, I don't know, maybe it's not appropriate, but I was thinking if, like, if we get, we'll get the present, we'll get the budget on the 28th, and then the week later is when we first

start getting presentations, I wonder, if I'm remembering the process correctly, there's no moment, basically until March 11, where we actually have a conversation about anything, so I wonder whether it might not be a bad idea to build into, like, February 4th, sort

of initial gut check yeah sort of like you know what are people thinking about coming out of that like what are the things that have kind of risen to the surface um and you know maybe even have that before the before those presentations right because otherwise that wouldn't really be fair

no we're not no but yeah so in other words i was trying to set it up that logic um yeah just to sort of to say like all right like yeah so again um we have a marker we love it everything's great Like, great job, Tom. Like, you and your team, you nailed it. Or like, oh, yeah, it's way too high. You know, like, just have a little bit of a thing. Like, oh, okay. So that's kind of where we're going. And then the administrators and directors know what they're presenting to.

And we also have a little bit of a sense of kind of what our compilice is going forward. Again, nothing final on that, but again, just sort of. I think it would be helpful if that gut check could be framed in terms of what you're curious about.

Yeah. Right, and maybe it's actually on the 28th, because generally, we get that on the 28th, and we ask no questions other than, like, clarifying questions, and we don't really weigh in on, and I think that's intentional. I agree with that. Because I don't want to give a gut check before, you know, Julie gets up and she's like, oh, Jesus, that's not what I would have said if I'd known this was what they were thinking five minutes before. Right. So, my only hesitation is it's hard, I don't know, I think we are open-minded enough as a board to not, you know, not drop the hammer on the 28th before having all the information in front of us, right, without hearing all the presentations.

1:47:37

But I do think it's fair to maybe just give a sort of a superficial perspective on what we've heard about sort of the full proposed budget, because maybe that will then help the presentations target what some of our questions are earlier.

I agree with that. As long as, like you said, they're really more like the questions, really not like, oh, we don't like this because it's not below 8%. That's too bad. So, yeah, just kind of thinking about it with very broad brushstrokes coming in, not having heard any of the information from the presentations yet, I would be very cautious about drawing conclusions, gut check conclusions.

Right, because we, you know, I'm trying to think back of what we would have seen on that meeting in January last year where we could have said, like, okay, I want to know how they're going to meet these needs based on eliminating this teacher, right?

Like, I'd love to hear more about that when they're presenting to us, that kind of thing. I think that would be really helpful, because I feel like I remember leaving that meeting where it was presented, and then kind of no context beyond just that, and wishing that

we had had more, or had been able to have some sort of discussion. Yeah, it's, I mean, I think it was specifically designed that way to just, okay, here's the top, and then we're going to give you all of the information you need, as opposed to like, just starting with a specific school, or a specific line item, or, you know, it's

sort of like as a district this is this is what we're tackling and this is how we're kind of tackling it as a group and then we'll hear all the details over the upcoming six weeks so I can see the benefits of both approaches but

obviously last year's how it rolled out you showed up on the con side of that is that we ended up very much at the end with a lot of moving parts so I'm not sure how it would have been different had we done it this way but maybe it would have so we're happy to try it i think it absolutely would have been different because i

think we would have said in that meeting why is this why are we aiming for this percentage nobody asked for this percentage and so why are you making these cuts and then the then the the presentation could have been made um oh because it will improve these learning outcomes

and then we would have proceeded from there yeah so i think i mean i guess that's where i would disagree a little bit kelly i think that is the moment where we where we say like oh that's like Again, not to say, like, go back and change the number, but just to say, like, this doesn't, like, this feels low.

This feels, this feels, again, or I'm trying to think of how to, I'm curious, I'm curious about this number. I'm curious about how, where this number came from. Right, and not to say sort of directed, but to say before we start hearing any of the administrator presentations on really where this is coming from, what's the board thinking about?

I think, I don't know, I think that's a, I don't think we need to get into the new show, but I think like a little bit at that level, because honestly, I think that would have saved us a lot of headache. I think it would also be fair in the interim for you to sit with it and then email questions in writing

that you hope may come up and be answered in the presentations. You know, speaking as an administrator who has been through that. Ringer, as they call it. I mean, well, one of the reasons I feel really good working, I know you will be fair and kind, and it's not easy to, you know, be in the spotlight that way,

and especially if there are controversial things to be discussed or proposed, and, you know, our administrators are human beings, and any kind of lead time that we or they can get to be able to anticipate and get good answers will be helpful.

Okay. So that was FYI in your folders. oh sorry yeah and if this is a this is a public facing document correct like this is on our website national for the public I wonder if I'm not sure what the two lines are on this document but I'm wondering if we if this would be if that

second line would be a good place to say when the budget brochures go out if we added something saying that at this point you would expect to receive. Yeah I mean it definitely happens at that line because they have it before the Q&A's. You might not know the exact date but

if we might want to add. What was that? The budget brochure. To add into that point too this I'm airing my ignorance of town meetings and voting in town meeting forum. Me the annual budget meeting does not tell me that I as a public a member of the public would vote at that meeting

1:53:00

and also the validation referendum like I think explicit these are votes where the public engagement really matters it's important to explicitly state if possible yeah I mean it could even be I mean because the Q&A's are too right so you know maybe it's uh what is a public

input so we could put you know an asterisk and you know asterisk is where you know this is this is your part to play so i mean just on that again going to the kind of strategic communications piece of saying like is there is there a moment where somebody whether it's um tom's office or us

sends out a narrative version of this um as an email to the whole community and says of the timeline and says like you know we're starting this process here's what these things mean like this like during this chunk of time we're going to be represented the board delegates and here's

things then these are opportunities to come there's a half hour like just narrating it um because i think to stephanie's point that's not necessarily obvious um and i think it's probably only if you go looking for it i'll check with jimmy about that now one of the things she was just telling

me this morning is that she was you know explaining all of the different ways that we do communicate about this and i know one of them was a brochure that goes out to people's mailbox. It's like a snail mail brochure. That's the budget brochure. That's this. Okay. And that's another place where I think explicit statements that you can vote as a town. This is where you come. Yeah, exactly. This is where you come. This is where you can vote and etc. But also last year's budget, we didn't send it out in the mail because it was protracted.

yeah yeah we um we posted it we had it at every town we had printed copies at every town office we just let people know where they could find it because we couldn't get it to print because because we didn't have the date here and we changed it here we weren't able to print it

because it's a pretty tight timeline yeah it seems to me like last year or maybe the year before maybe she does it every year but jean did such a thing like a narrative in the forecaster and maybe somewhere else too but just yeah i'm pretty sure that that did happen on some platform and i also

call everybody's house and tell them to vote i do that i ruin everyone's dinner yeah one back and also i'm not sure what's going to be as effective this year i don't know if anybody else is getting no recalls from the irs but i am like multiple a day they do a 30 second voicemail

it is, well, I don't answer my phone anymore, regardless of who's calling. The good news is it does say RSU 5 when I call, so generally people will pick it up. It does say RSU 5 IRS. Alright. Are we good with that one? Okay, so the next item we have, and had I thought this through, we probably would have

done this on a day where Maura is here and not not here. So, I don't know if we want to i went to the meeting on monday so i have a little bit of info okay great yeah um so this this is a bigger packet than we usually get of information um but this is the msba uh delegate

um delegate assembly we talked a little bit about this at the retreat um this is the body that basically, um, develops the plan of, the work plan, if you will, for the, um, the MSBA lobbying arm, um, and, uh, up at, up in Augusta, um, and so each year they, uh, undertake a slate of resolutions,

sometimes they, um, adjust others, uh, previous ones, sometimes they have fully new ones, um, This one, it looks like they've done a fair amount of rewrites for previous ones and some new ones and some for deletion. So that's interesting. So what we have done historically is kind of talk through the resolutions as a board

and given some instruction indication to the delegate, which is Steph this year, and Maura is the um is the backup because she'll be there anyway because she's on the msba board um around how we would like folks to vote on these um so um that's kind of the that's kind

1:58:05

of the overview of what we're looking at um and then i'll ask steph what she learned there's also um we can suggest modifications until like the start of october if there's something that we didn't like or we wanted different language on that's also something that some other districts

did at the meeting that i was at and we can still do via email i think it's until like october 8th or something october 10th maybe yeah something like that anyway october um okay so um and then i can the the there's like the new ones uh the deletions they gave me a little bit more

information about what the deletions are around and why they were deleted okay and then some folks asked questions we didn't get into all the um edits are like not substantially changing the meaning of something it's just more like language or grammar consistency um and then rewrites there

is more substantial um reasoning and it's changing more substantively uh what the resolution is um and so those were there's a lot more of those but those were gone over a more high level so anyone had any specific questions i could maybe ask answer some of them or um yeah pause there

okay um have they is this the most up-to-date there's one other version that um had one small edit but this is otherwise the most up-to-date the edit is on the first page um in the bottom rationale section uh second line regardless of immigration status instead of regardless of

education status that's the only edit that i was made aware of okay just if we really just wanted to be pedantic we also could suggest that at the top of the title spells proposed correctly perso's is fine that may have been uh updated too but i didn't catch it either

that's not even close to spelled right that's not even a word is it What happens when you use all caps, it doesn't pick it up as a misspelled word. Okay, so proposed resolutions. The first is the role of the U.S. Department of Education. So the MSBA fundamentally supports the original mission of the U.S. Department of Education

to promote student achievement in preparation for global competitiveness by fostering educational excellence and ensuring equal access. MSBA opposes any effort that reduces federal funding to main schools. Any such change would disproportionately harm rural students,

those with disabilities, and children from economically disadvantaged communities. And then they provide the rationale, talking about certain federal funds have already been withheld, creating budget challenges in many districts. Other proposals from the federal government would effectively restructure many federal funding streams and reduce funding from current levels. These grants serve a valuable

purpose, helping to fund positions such as math and reading coaches, interventionists, guidance counselors, and before and after school activities. Any cuts would result in the loss of programming and or increases in the local school budgets. So sometimes their proposed

resolutions are kind of philosophical um which i is the category i kind of put this one like they're just like what do we stand for kind of of statements um do we do we have any concern with with a yes vote on this proposal or do we have any recommendations to make it even more strong

one recommendation that another board suggested as the last sentence of the resolution is any such change would harm all students disproportionately, rural, those with disabilities, and children from economically disadvantaged communities. So they thought it was important to say that it would negatively impact all students as

well, not just the ones specifically named. I could be in play with either of those. So, yes on one? I would say yes on one, and for Steph, no on anything watering it down. Yeah. So, this level or, I guess, up. Just stronger. Yeah. Yep. Okay. Two is a tax policy. The Maine School Boards Association believes revenue sources to fund the public schools

2:03:06

should be raised in a fair and equitable manner based on a taxpayer's ability to pay. So, that's the resolution. The rationale is the Maine Legislature is considering several proposals that would impact the EPS funding formula. So for our new board members, the EPS funding formula is the essential programs and services.

That is what the DOE uses to determine how much they would say it costs to educate a student. And that is what is used to determine subsidy. So that formula is currently under review. So multiple bills call for the creation of a new state funding streams to fund K-12 public education.

more state funding for schools is badly needed, local property taxpayers already face substantial burdens, yet school districts face growing expenses such as rising special education costs and the maintenance and upkeep of aging school infrastructures. This resolution would provide

more guidance to the MSBA's legislative committee as it evaluates legislative proposals affecting main school funding. I don't know, I mean, I guess I'm not a no vote on this. I don't think it says anything particularly interesting um i mean fair and equitable manner based on a taxpayer's ability

to pay i mean that's always the question is is what is a taxpayer's ability to pay based off of so i mean this is a obviously a deeply complex issue around the eps formula and and how funding for education is is determined um i'm not sure how this resolution helps guide anyone's decision

making it was meant to be more for the legislative process that's currently um underway or those who are advocating for different legislation right so maybe some of the bills out there are completely unfair and unequitable and so this i guess comes down on the side of we think it should be at least

fair and equitable i mean i'm i'm not a no on this i'm just not sure how helpful it is but I guess I just have a question, maybe, I don't know Steph if they went over this, and maybe Mara could, Mara if you're watching this video, get back, this makes me, of just whether the MSBA has issued any further, has made any further statements about these new potential revenues.

resources, or proposals, right? Because if this is the only one, I find that a little curious. If sort of the only thing that the MSBA is saying is, like, make sure that taxes are fair and equitable, and not saying anything further about, effectively, what's in the rationale, right? Like,

what's in the rationale is much more substantive, in terms of it seems like what we're, or what a body could be saying, right, is that, like, um, this is needed, um, and it needs to be shifted, or not, uh, additional support needs to be given, um, beyond, uh, what the state

is currently providing. Okay. I don't have any other information to add on that one. Yeah. Okay. Okay, uh, number three for newly proposed resolutions. I'm sorry, do we have a, do I have a proposed vote on that, or are we, what you were waiting

for tomorrow on that? I mean, I don't see us voting no on that. I mean, I'm not sure what the recommendation could change to that would switch your vote from a yes to a no. I mean, if somebody made the motion that, you know, RSU 5 should pick up the bill for all the surrounding towns, that's a definite no vote from you. But, yeah. Yeah, I guess one question I have about how it's worded

that might better capture the rationale is It says more state funding for schools is badly needed, but the actual resolution doesn't address if we're asking for more than we were already asking for or if we're just going to change formulas somehow.

You know what I'm saying? Are we saying that we're trying to support bills that will increase state taxes in a way that they... I guess I'm just wondering, how is the more get addressed? Yeah. Well, I think the implication is that more from the state is fair based on taxpayers' ability to pay, right?

2:08:09

So there are districts where the local taxpayer ability to pay is very different than other parts of the state. So if it's too reliant on local taxes, those students are at a disadvantage. So revenue sources to fund it should be raised in a fair and equitable manner.

I don't think it's saying that more money needs to be raised. It's just how, like, where it's coming from. But that's what the last month says. Right. Well, more state, right. So I think the implication, when I read that is, is that it should be less local taxpayer funded, more state funded.

And how do you capture that? I mean, part of what the EPS formula does is it says, like, you know, this is how much it should cost to educate a student. And some of those numbers are significantly lower than it actually costs to educate a student.

So if those numbers or those formulas were more inclusive, it would flow through that you would get more subsidy, right? Because they would say it costs more to educate these students. This is the total bucket we think it costs to educate them. How much you're required to pay through the local requirement would not necessarily change.

So the difference is your subsidy. So that would leave less to be paid through additional local monies, if that makes sense. I see what you're saying. Yeah, I guess it just goes back to the vagal that you mentioned in the beginning. I guess it doesn't really say a lot about what this means. I wonder if they should consider adding the third sentence in the rationale to the actual resolution.

More state funding for schools is badly needed. For some version of that. They just seem to be, I mean, I think the title, right, tax policy, I think is kind of, well, is both vague, but also I think they're actually trying to be specific.

They're sort of like, this is the only thing we're commenting on. We're only commenting on, like, whatever tax policy gets created, it's not, like, the title of it is not need for new revenue sources, right? It's sort of just saying that whatever tax policy the state has regarding education, this should be true.

I agree with you, it doesn't mean nothing, but it doesn't really mean anything. It's like, yes, because if you take the opposite of it, it's a ridiculous statement. I think it should be unfair and inequitable. There's another edit later about school construction, where it's like the last one in this packet,

where it's like very clearly they're taking a position that the funding should come from other sources besides property tax, particularly for school construction. and so there's sort of like some language there as well. So there's other places where, I guess,

their rationale is reinforced. A little more specifically. In specific ways, yeah, for what that's worth. All right. Are we good with a yes on two then? I'm just wondering if it makes sense to actually insert that more or suggest that as an edit between beliefs and revenue,

just to put beliefs and more revenue sources to fund should be raised in a fair and equitable manner since that's in their rationale i'm not sure i mean because they're not saying believes revenue sources to fund public schools so that's all

revenue sources that's the state that's local that's all the things i'm not saying i'm not sure what they're saying is that more revenue needs to be generated i think they're saying it how it's like where those different buckets comes from needs to be fair and equitable

but maybe i'm misreading it yeah to me it sounds like they're trying to say we need to be we should be less reliant on local taxes if it's less equitable to do that meaning if the if the local i don't know community can't support the basics of education where else are we going to get that

money because we still need to support that education right so that's what the crux of it It seems to be. I think so. Yeah, I don't think they're taking a stand on, like, how much is spent on education. I think they're taking a stand on how the revenue is spent. But it's talking about revenue sources. We're talking about more revenue sources, not necessarily the total pot.

Right, exactly. Yeah. I agree with that. That would be the wording change. Say it again. More revenue sources, not necessarily more revenue. Oh, I see. Yep. Believes more revenue sources to fund should be. I think that changes the rest of the sentence.

2:13:39

Yeah, I think the raised makes it weird. I could ask for clarity. Yeah, and maybe that's the question. It's like, you know, what are we trying to get at here? Is there a way to be more clear in what we're trying to accomplish? You know, maybe that third sentence belongs, in some form or fashion, moved up to be more clear.

Immigrant students. The Maine School Board Association is committed to maintaining a safe and secure learning environment for all students, staff and visitors, and believes that regardless of their immigration status, no student should

be denied a free public education. Rationale, the 1982 Supreme Court case player, Rideau, declared that all U.S. children have a constitutional right to a public education regardless of immigration status. In Maine, schools have seen a growing number of immigrant students in recent years in the midst of changing policies at the local, state, and national levels.

This resolution affirms a commitment to providing an education to all students in Maine and aligns with the MSBA's core mission of enhancing the education of all students in Maine's public schools. Yeah, Chris. My only thought on that would be, it's a negative statement at the end.

Instead of it being a negative, have it be a positive. As in, instead of saying no student should be denied a free public education, say something to the effect of... Every student should have access to a free public education. Yeah, I like that. I like that.

Any other thoughts on that one? I think we are firmly a yes on this. Yes? It feels like a yes or plus. Yeah, I was going to say, yeah. Definitely nothing watering that one down. Great. Okay. I don't think I'm going to read through all the deletions.

Yeah. I do have a question about the rationale for 2A1A. Did they talk about that one at all? It's the first one on the... 2A1A. Yes, so it's now required by statute, So they no longer need to have a policy on it, a resolution on it.

And then the others essentially is the same. It's either like there was a statute or it happened at the federal level or there's another policy that's replacing it or adding more emphasis to it and another modification later in the document. Or in the second one, parenting education, you can see it was last amended in 99. The shift has been to parental involvement. So there's, like, rationale for all, or it's being addressed in another way for all the removals.

It does make you wonder why nobody's thought to get rid of this in the last 26 years, but I guess it's only fair. We probably have a fair number of policies, too, that we're working our way through. Okay, so we then have edits, which don't substantially change the intent or meaning.

Any concerns on any of those? so i have a question yep so the one uh it's 2a 3f on the business employment of students yep who's regulating that like who's are we keeping a list of who's working and if or not they actually

are working too many hours and if they have bad grades and can't be working those hours like how is that well this one is not a law this is just their resolution right yeah but so what does that So the Maine School Board Association reminds, don't forget, local school boards of the statute.

So there is a statute regarding employment of students during the school year, as well as limits to work permits for students with inappropriate attendance or grades. I haven't dug into this yet, but if we're like any other district, we do keep a record of where we issue a work permit.

Yeah, and that, I mean, you would only have a work permit if they're under 16, right? So there's no, how would you govern a 16-year-old who doesn't come to you for a work permit? You would have no idea if they had a job or not. Yeah. Right, and you could go to the town, technically, for a work permit, because my daughter did that, because school was out. So, interesting.

2:19:00

Yeah. I do think there is a law, though, that you can only work up to, I want to say it's like 30 hours if you're, is it 20? Yeah, it depends on how old you are. This is more for if the student works for them? Well, that's what I was wondering. Because, I mean, we do have some students that, like, work in Laugh and Learn. On the F-PAC. On the F-PAC, right? So it's an interesting question. Particularly if we are their employer, is there any tracking of their grades or attendance to ensure that they are compliant?

Right, maybe we could get clarity on what this is trying to, what type of employment this is trying to get at. Is it all? Is it by the district? I'll just note, too, that this is an edit, which means that this is already in place. And so the modifications that there's, the only thing that they're asking us to approve is modifications, is the red language. Yeah, so I think it's more of a question of, like, I wonder if we're doing this. Yeah, totally. I didn't even know this was a whole question. Are we doing this, and who's doing this? Sorry, Tom. That's a question for Kelly and the folks in HR. yeah, around employee, I mean, I don't think, I'm not sure there's any possible way, if

they don't work for us, that we could ever track it, or should be expected to track it, but, I mean, I wonder what the statute they're referring to says, because it doesn't reference the statute. Because what could be one recommendation is that they include what statute?

Yeah, so we know to look it up and see if we're good. boards uh school boards of statute blank i certainly feel about the statute i also just want to give you something to do because it's fun to kind of raise your hand and

be like in the meeting he means that's just in general in your life i mean it does say businesses and potential employers so i think maybe it is the entire community well i mean we can certainly control it when they come to us for a permit to say no you don't come to school

we're not going to issue you a permit. We don't think you should have a job. Your job is to come to school. But like once it's issued, I don't know how we would ever track it. You can't revoke it, I don't believe. Can you? I don't know.

How about as a business owner, I'm pretty sure no one's ever asked us about kids' grades or how much they're working. Right. Yeah. Or that family loophole when you work for your family. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, the rules don't apply.

They can work you as much as they want. You should see how much Danielle works her kids. I see rich more than I see the kids. All right, so AI, the next one, I looked at that one just because, you know, we were talking about AI. And this one is new. This was a new one last year that got put in place.

And it looks like the only change is, you know, adding awareness of potential dangers. So, okay. There was talk about this one, too. another district suggested that at the end it end with AI is not a substitute for schoolwork period and that they remove the that requires original

thought from it yeah and then they also said that they'll likely be revisiting this policy quite frequently for a while so I think it will keep this one more What if, could we pose, AI is not a substitute for schoolwork, semicolon, schoolwork requires

original thought. I'm happy to send that email. And add in schoolwork again. Okay. So we have a few more adjustments. Yeah. Air tapes. On the, what is it, 2A, 2E advertising in the schools, did they give you any justification

on that? because for me it substantially changes the meaning of that i mean before they said that they're encouraging us to prohibit advertisements and now they're saying you should adopt the policy which is a very different meeting in my mind and a meeting that i don't think i would approve

like i liked the prohibition so i would vote no on that edit yeah i didn't get any additional info on that one yeah i wonder what's the underline of the one they then crossed out i'm confused it looks like that the prohibition was on certain products not you know it wasn't a universal prohibition

2:24:02

so instead i think it sounds like they want people to be more thoughtful and have more local control over that and instead of just a broad prohibition on these certain nutritional products right like yeah because i said before right adopt policies on advertising in schools including a prohibition

on advertisements for products that do not meet the minimum nutrition standards or which are otherwise incompatible with educational mission of school. So no smoking, no booze, no coke. My curiosity around that one is whether the, I wasn't there,

but this is just what comes to me. Did that discussion intersect with anything going on with the Department of Health and Human Services federally right now? I can understand that justification. For me, though, I see it, and I liked it before the edit better.

So now it would say, adopt policies on advertising, especially for products that do not meet the nutritional standards. Incompatible. I'm pretty sure the sample policy that we reviewed a year or two ago speaks about prohibiting advertising.

yeah so it is it is you are right it's a it is a little weird because it is it is pulling back because it's like so for example if like if that had been the language before we adopted our policy we might you see what i mean like we might have been like oh okay like we're just going to make

sure like we're going to allow some advertising you know or whatever it is but which we do which we do but the prohibition yeah i don't know it's i i agree i think it's an odd i think it's an odd back. I think you wonder about the rationale like is there a situation where you would allow

this kind of advertising in our schools? I mean I guess I can give you an example that I'm pretty sure is out on our track right now is like when we have our sports teams that have like a a sponsor banner and main beer company likes to donate to things in the community.

I mean, that should be prohibited, or? I think New Yorker has a self-prohibition on that. I actually think they do, too. But that's an example of, you know, like a community member, you know. Or Pepsi or Coca-Cola with your sports signs here.

Right. So that, I mean, that one actually was an actual event here. When we need to replace, in the gym, we replaced the scoreboard. And those companies will donate the scoreboard if you have a name on it. So I think ours says Powerade instead of Coke because we have a policy.

I just, I wonder if you mentioned local control. And I wonder if this revision was keeping in mind what local communities might be inclined to do if minimum nutrition standards nationally, if the definition of that changes in a dramatic way.

But, I mean, the other thing to remember is these are just the resolutions, right? I mean, these are not rules. These are not things we live by or we're required to or policies we have to adopt. I mean, this is just kind of what the MSBA uses as their guidelines. Yeah, I may make a rare suggestion that we have.

Yeah, rare suggestion. No, just that I think we're talking about this a little long. Yeah. Again, just so that's on the record, I have said that once. Once in his life. Again, I think it is important, but I think we're, I think the issues we're getting into here are, like, I think we're really talking about, like, how do we feel about it in terms of how it impacts our district, and that's not really what this is about. The MSB, right. Yeah. Yeah, so, I mean, I don't think, I can still ask, right, like, the rationale, it would

be useful for us, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Any other comments on the edits? The reads rights are more substantial. Did they have any kind of highlights on that section? So there was one discussion that happened on these, maybe more.

2:29:05

So the first, the one that, there's something else added. Folks asked questions about 2B1I on the bottom of page 5. I'll just give you a minute to read it. it is actually let's start about like an hour that's my new proposal yeah that was super interesting that's a really they provided just additional information so the question was why did you delete the last sentence and they thought there was ambiguity around which documents and who are they to say which values which documents so it was meant to give some suggestions but also allow suggest freedom of choice for what those identifying your own values. U.S. foundation documents, I'm not sure what that means. Is that like the Declaration of Independence? That's essentially what it's deleted. Okay. Because my first thought was foundations that do work around this, do they have documents? Yeah. So like our foundational documents as a country?

I see. Is the Bill of Rights, is that values? Like, those are rights, not... But they come from what we feel is valuable. I like it. I think it's cool. Let's keep it in there. I said, pulled out that and added some more specific ones like respect, compassion, so not necessarily...

Yeah, essentially, like, U.S. Foundation documents could be interpreted a lot of ways to a lot of people. And so, um, it's clear which values they're suggesting. Well, I have a quick question. Sorry, Colin. Just some clarification, because I think you can read into it a couple different ways, but...

2A4, is that an O, I guess? 4O. The email stuff? I mean, it says school board business may not be conducted via email. So how specific is that, right? So I can't say, thanks, Tom, for the update. I have an additional question I want you to look into. You can do that. But what you can't do is kind of a concrete limit. If you get enough board members chiming in on a conversation that you reach a quorum, then you've had a meeting outside the meeting. So you just have to be mindful of that. It's just a weird sentence, in my opinion, because it's so vague. I mean, it is vague, but I think it's specifically, yeah.

I think once you're having conversation, like back and forth conversation with multiple people weighing in on opinions about things that probably should be done in public, it's one thing to say like, hey, found this interesting article, thought the board might appreciate it. That's not a conversation. That's just providing some information. But if you're like, yeah, you know what I thought was really interesting? It was the fourth paragraph. Oh, that's when you start getting into a conversation, and that's conducting business outside of a meeting.

And I try to make sure that we don't do that. You're very good at doing that, Michelle. Very mean, I know. Oh, it is. I have a question about the first one. It's actually, and my biggest comment still stands. I don't want to talk about this forever. but i just i just don't understand i just don't understand that one from a i mean i understand

what the words say but um the board teacher relations one yeah like fully support statutory meet and consult requirements contained within teacher contracts regarding proposed education policy changes uh while maintaining board authority to make changes to education policy

i don't know i guess i understand that i just i don't understand why that's a issue or like why is it um i think it's probably it's a good question um my guess is they were consolidating two specific resolutions into one um and uh because it's a completely eliminating

because that first one exists right and they're just adding to it but eliminating the next one um you know one of the one of the things that we're always trying to be cognizant of when we're reviewing and negotiating new contract is to make sure we're not adding educational policy to contracts because it doesn't belong there educational

2:34:15

policy is the is the the purview of the board and the administration not the not the union so but certain things dictate us to have this meet and consult right that is a you'll find that in our contracts several places like we're

happy to have a conversation with the union and explain why we're doing what we're doing but this is if it is educational policy it is not grievable it is not something that can be you know brought to the brought to the board to say like we disagree with this

um that is the board's um the board's right so i think this is just sort of confirming like yes we we are fully supportive of the meet and consult requirements um while still understanding that we maintain. Yeah. Let's see. So we talked about emails, facilities. So this is another one that looks like it's, it's not, well, is it really replacing that? I don't even know. I'm confused when it says it's replacing one with the same numbers as what it says, but it's not all new. Do you know how that works? Yeah. So the one, and then the new one, if it's not in vertex, it was a part of the previous one. Okay. So instead of like underlining, capitalizing, they're just saying, they're just restating it, but highlighting the changes. Okay, administrate it. Okay. On 2b, 5b, learning support, the last sentence is

funding should be provided to support implementation. And I'm wondering where that funding is coming from, or what they're recommending, if the DOE is to provide that funding, or if the district should be providing that funding usually the recommendation is not the district um so yeah

the previous sentence is the do we need to identify existing resources appropriate measurement tools and share effective interventions funding should be provided to support implementation so my assumption is that yeah we provides the funding yeah so there's a common thread through a lot of

their resolutions of avoiding unfunded mandates right so the state will say you have to do this and you're like well you're gonna help us pay for that no we're not so like trying to avoid those things yeah so the previous policy the last sentence was considers consideration of appropriate

funding provided by the main department of education is also recommended so it's a change to funding funding should be provided to support implementation from that which is funny because it's actually even more vague like before it's coming from the do or like they would consider it

I guess that part of it is vague, right? So appropriate consideration of appropriate is recommended. Like they should at least think about giving us the money. Now they're saying they should give us the money but not telling us who they is.

So maybe that's a recommended change. Like the department of it should be providing funds to support implementation. I'm going to try and read what this was before. So MSBA continues to oppose mandatory merging of school administrative units.

Did that mean it previously said MSBA mandatory merging? I've got to understand. Maybe just the continues. Technology. 3B2C, talking about, on page 8, maximizing federal and state assistance through economically disadvantaged rates. They talk about continuing to use best available poverty data and accurate identification through available

and acceptable methods is essential. I'm just wondering if this is about relying on other data than the free and reduced lunch forms that parents no longer have to fill out. Yeah, I think that's why this is being considered. And I guess I'm just curious what the other data they're talking about. They just

2:39:23

don't refer to those forms at all. Or do they? I just wanted to make sure I was understanding that, but if you have more My guess is that's why they're trying to capture that, because they don't have to fill out those forms anymore i'm itching back there because they don't fund mtss to begin with that was a

couple items back so that was i was like um so the ses forms have now um it's gone to an identification of household income as opposed to the former system of having like requesting that access to free and or reduced lunch depending on the number of children in the household and the

in the economics of the household. So we've had to do that. We defer to the SES, like that baseline indicator. But the state has been exploring other ways to capture that information without any of the ask. And it's a very tricky path for them to try to navigate an alternative because the information is not readily available.

So my understanding is they haven't made any progress. That's what I know about that. I logged in today to power school just, you know, for fun. And because I like to torture my son. But anyways, we did ask, it popped up right away.

And it asked if we met, it outlined incomes above and asked if my son met any of those. And it was a simple yes or no. I mean, obviously, I hit no. But so I guess that's another way to track some of that data, right? If people are actually throwing that out. Yeah, that's how we track it right now. We happen to believe we're not properly capturing the need.

Yeah, I think that, you know, I imagine that is, well, I don't imagine, I know, that even with the forms, I think most districts under count because people don't fill it up. While free food in schools I think is absolutely fantastic,

that is sort of one of those unintended consequences that I'm not sure people thought about ahead of time as to what it might mean without having to capture that data anymore. So are we looking at more questions on that one?

Yeah, I think so. I appreciate the change in that next one around vouchers and diluting the power of public education in the 3B, 3G. So the probationary period, did they talk about that? Yeah, they know that the current statute says two, but they're suggesting that their opinion is that it should go back to three.

They didn't give any additional information other than that. I would say that's a good move. Yeah? Yeah. Interesting. Professional development to support student achievements. Move to section four. Are there different sections of the resolution?

I'm just trying to figure out why that one's in blue. Around the charter school one. It's just like their little directory of what we're moving to different categories. Okay. Were they talking about the charter school one at all? Around what drove that? No. I mean, it seems like the last time it was touched was before the charter schools were in place, so it would make sense that they would have some updates, but it's interesting.

Unfunded retirement costs. Not a surprise. The superintendent agreement one? Yeah, the intention there they shared was that they support and suggest superintendents decide on it annually so that it's not just a one-and-done decision that they're revisiting it every year. It already has to be done every year. I wonder if the intention of this

2:44:47

is to remove the state's rule and the appeal process even more. Is this 4.8? Yes, sorry, page 11. I was wondering if there was ever a legislative review or commission to create the criteria to that? That's what they're... Oh gosh, I'm not sure. I mean, really the criteria that's in statute to the best of my memory is that it's just supposed to be what is demonstrated to be in the child's best interest. With that said, either superintendent can put the car wash on it.

But then they bring it to the department, the main DOE, and they can override. Right. Which they often do. Yes. So basically, they're just saying it should rest with the two superintendents making the decision. That's the way I'm reading it. Yeah. Okay. And then... So there's some stuff around the construction one. Yeah, well, I just read, quote-unquote, we support superintendents deciding on this. So, yes, Tom, to your point.

Yeah, so this one I just... To me, it puts the proposed regulation about taxes. I think that it gives you a little bit more transparency into their thought process around school funding. Yeah, I mean, the current, what's it called?

The thing where you send them pictures of how bad your school is and you get in the lottery? Oh, yeah, it's the lottery. It's basically what it is, right? Literally, that is what it is, yeah. I mean, I think this seems different, though.

Like, what they're replacing seems like a different thing that they're talking about and then they run. Yeah, it's different, but to me, my point of connecting it is that it gives you language around where funding for some of these projects should come from. Yeah. Right. Yeah, where they think the source of funding needs to be coming from. What I find interesting is the second bullet. Alter the project approval process so that smaller projects can move forward as well as massive building replacements. the trap that schools can, districts can fall into is that, let's say you have this, you know, ailing building and you're far down the list.

So that leaves you with this impossible choice of, well, if we put money into this building to repair something that, or upgrade it in some way that we really need, we're then shooting ourselves in the foot because we're going to go down the list.

So that seems to be a remedy for that. Except then the last bullet is to incentivize districts to put money into the building so that you don't have to get replaced. It's just kind of, what are you going to give? Can you get some money for that? Right, right. I mean, what's interesting to me is, like, this is about the major capital school construction program, right?

I mean, I understand the dilemma of, you know, do we just tip away at this in big chunks and replace the whole big schools that need it, or, you know, what we replaced was basically a fund, the recommendation for a fund to fund small projects across the state. I don't know. Clearly that one didn't work, so we're going to move on to this one, but to improve transparency and predictability in the funding process by extricating construction funding from the EPS formula. Yeah, because, I mean, it is in there now, right? So we, the state-funded school in Durham, that's a whole separate item in our EPS, 8279.

And just on that one, I wonder whether there is matching legislation to this one because it's so specific. Yeah, maybe. Like, it seems pretty granular, you know, to be like, these very particular things which maybe might want to have in the bill like it seems like i

don't know it sounds like somebody's got a plan yeah to steph's point that first one was like we want fair tax policy and what do we mean by that we mean a main yeah this one exactly there's so there's two bills that they're expecting will have um more resolution i guess i'm bad with

2:49:56

terms um about the eps formula and then also the school construction so they're considering bills in the legislature now about those two things so i think that's where this this one came from yeah okay so so i i'm i'm hearing that we didn't have any we were a hard no too

we had a couple of maybe clarification or recommendations or maybe even strengthening a few but none that we felt strongly you should oppose is that a fair assessment of our conversation that according to Collin went way too long okay do you have what you need Steph yes

and I'll try to get answers for some of the other ones for our own continued conversation um anything about the change in the bylaws we should think about we saw that was in here too those are mostly like consistency okay um or clarification and then there was a few on like

what they can do in an emergency situation with replacing members or with needing an emergency vote on a policy emails i see that yeah so that was that was it it was all mostly like consistency okay and then this is just the minutes of last year's meetings okay that's the current copy of

the resolutions as they stand okay yeah all right any other comments around the msba delegate assembly other than big thanks to staff for doing it all right it was very interesting so your suggestion was correct all right so we don't have any

personnel items oh look we're back to public comment anyone alive no all right so then I would take a motion for consideration and approval to enter into executive session as outlined in one MRSA section 4056 a for the purpose of

discussing the superintendent's evaluation. Kara and Colin, thank you. All those in favor? Great. No one opposed? So we'll take a quick break so that they can break down and go. Did they tell you where they wanted us to go? Yeah, across the hall. Across the hall? Okay.

Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.