Skip to content

TranscriptRSU 5 budget meeting, Wednesday 19 November 2025

Budget meeting · 4 h 21 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →

Computer-made transcript, not a record of what was said. It mishears names and figures and drops short words, such as the "not" in "does not carry". Click a time to hear the recording, which settles any disagreement. The district's minutes are the official record.

38,139 words in 50 five-minute windows.

4:40

don't touch anything else fine great perfect the evening welcome to the RC 5 Board of Directors meeting it is Wednesday November 19th 2025 we are here at the Durham Community School and we have a few board members that are joining

us as soon as they can Chris will not be with us this evening and we're not sure about our student rep. So we will get started in the meantime with the Pledge of Allegiance. Okay, so thank you for everyone's flexibility in timing. We did add a special budget workshop

starting, well now, until our normal meeting starts at 6 30. Just wanted to provide some updates to the board from the administrative team on where we're at and get some feedback back to that team as they work on the 2027 right yes 2027 budget so i will hand it over to tom good evening

everybody um i'll try to speak up my voice is bouncing back from a cold so i hope you can hear me okay does that help well how about that does that help okay thank you um i also want to thank the administrative team for being here tonight i think it's really helpful for us all to be in the

same room, not only to hear the board's message, but for you to know that we have really been working on this together, and that's part of why I've asked for this meeting. And I really just want to start by grounding us all in the same place with the same facts as we begin working on

next year's budget. So what we've been able to put together are some of the costs that will impact that budget that we already know about. And the largest one is contractual obligations for salaries and benefits, but there are also some increases in required services for special education

that are based on specific student needs that presently we are paying for from a reserve account, but as we know that those students will be with us next year, we can't use a reserve account long term, and we will need to build those into the budget.

So adding those things together, that brings us to a projected increase for next year's budget of just under 10%. If it's a status quo budget, meaning we don't change any levels of staffing, etc. The precise number is 9.82%. So I want to try to put that in context for everybody tonight.

For the past two years, the district's budgets have come in at increases hovering around 6%. Last year's approved budget represented a 6.83% increase over the preceding year. The impact to each community varied based on the cost-sharing formula of the district.

And last year, that 6.83% overall increase showed up differently in each town because of that cost-sharing formula. Durham saw an estimated 8.83% increase. Freeport saw 4.95% and Pownall 7.87%. So again, that's last year.

It's not possible at this moment for us to look forward and project estimated impacts for each town right now, because we still don't have key information, especially the state subsidy and possible revenue adjustments that would affect that picture.

9:54

So to bring that next year's budget into further context, if we were to bring that projected increase down from almost 10% to something closer to the 6% range, we would be looking at reductions of about $1.8 million. And that equates to about 17 teaching positions if

we measured it in that way. Obviously, teaching positions are not the only thing that make up the budget, but that's a measuring stick that I think is meaningful. Reductions of that scale would absolutely have clear effects on programs and class size and the overall

experiences of the district. So this is why I've asked you, this is what I'm asking you to consider tonight. The next stages of this process for us in the room are getting into the weeds to actually develop a budget that makes sense. But before we move deeper into it, I feel I really need clear

guidance from you about what level of increase you believe is reasonable, responsible, supportable by the community, I cannot, especially as a new superintendent, make that decision all by myself. I need you to help me with that. So I also want to look ahead beyond next year. If we look ahead

to the fiscal year, not 27, but 28, our projections show another, if we just kept it at status quo again, that increase would be about 8.48%. And again, that does not figure in the next teacher negotiation cycle, which would happen in that year, for that year. So in other words,

the pressures that I'm talking about are not limited to just this year. So we are trying to look at this from all angles. We're trying to look at it responsibly. I believe that the responsible thing is to acquaint you with these facts as we see them and to acquaint the community

with these facts as we see them. We are also talking seriously about the need to look at long-term solutions that go beyond a single budget cycle. We know that there are structural inefficiencies within the district that we can't really get at by just trimming around the edges

or looking at budgets year to year. And addressing those may require us to examine facilities, how we use the facilities, how we configure the facilities, and whether there are more effective ways to use them. We also have the integration of early childhood services, which is coming right

up. That places more urgency behind all of this. So that, I think, really requires us to look at this as a systems problem, not as a building-by-building problem. It's also an opportunity to really rethink how we are delivering education across the district. So with all that in mind,

I have two real questions for you tonight that I hope you will consider. I'm not asking for a vote on this. This is not an action item. This is a discussion that I'm hoping from which will emerge a consensus about how to proceed. And the first is what level of budget increase should we plan for

As we continue this work, I heard loud and clear when I started here that in last year in particular, that that's not a question that was raised. And I think I have to raise it now. And then second, does the board support beginning, excuse me, a longer term visioning process that can explore structural changes and potential efficiencies over time? And your guidance on this will shape this year's budget. We'll also plan a trajectory forward.

I guess I have a couple of questions before we make a pronouncement about what level of increase is acceptable, because clearly I think that depends on a number of factors. I am curious, the 9.84% or whatever it was, that's just the contractual obligations plus these new special education positions.

14:55

I'm wondering what other pieces that we need to be considering here. So let's just start there. The biggest other piece that we need to consider is that we have not yet negotiated the support staff contract. We're about to do that. I would hope that we can negotiate that and have a new contract ready to go into effect for next school year,

but that will be a factor for sure. Kelly, I might have to ask you to help me out with that one. This one, we have an estimate for health insurance, correct? So we actually do not have an estimate for health insurance in.

What we have in is an estimate for support staff negotiations. Our health insurance, in our collective bargaining agreements, we pay based on previous year premium amounts. The employer's contribution is a percent based on previous year. So because we are currently in 25-26, budgeting for 26-27,

the health insurance numbers are fixed for this year in the process, pending negotiations, right, obviously for the ESP that is coming up, sports staff. Where we estimated the health insurance, Tom, was when we were looking at a projected number for next year, I mean, for the following year, which would be 27, 28. We had to build in an estimated number there because it's not known. So the 8.61, 9.82, does that make any assumptions for general inflation for everything other than

staff? Is there sort of like a 2% on supplies? If you're looking at the sheets, it's strictly looking at what we paid for wages last year, wages and benefits against what the rollover budget with current staffing is. That's the top number. So it's nothing else. So that's not 8.61%

of the total budget it's 8.61 percent of our wages year on just the wages portion of that budget because we don't have any of the other factors that's what the administrative team will be building soon are the remaining pieces that go into that into the ads for the expenditures for

the total expenditures okay we the numbers you're looking at here is just saying with current staffing if we turn it over what was the percent of increase year over year with steps and contractual increases correct and the second number are additional

bodies except for the out of district placement number which is that hundred and sixty five thousand number the other ones would actually be additional positions that we would be adding so it felt like we could compare them with

with previous wages and salary because if you remember last year's budget was a a little over $44 million, almost $44.5 million, and you can see on your sheet how much is represented in just salaries and benefits in the column to the left.

Okay, so that was going to be my question, was the percentage that wages makes up of so $36.7 million of $44.5 million. Does that answer your question? Yeah, so I hear us saying a big unknown is the support staff negotiations, and we haven't

really factored in inflation at the very least. That would be beyond what I just mentioned right here, yeah. Yeah, I guess another question I have is whether or not any inefficiencies have been examined that could be, that could adjust, like something reasonable that you think we as a board

might be willing to accept, because I know this is very challenging, but that would be, I guess, a question I would ask right away of the administrators. I feel I can answer that with broad brush right now, we do have in mind what we're thinking about are where, if we were asked

to make reductions, where they would be. We've developed some criteria to use as a way to guide that. I think conceptually we have some areas that could be reduced in mind, but the amount of those and where they would fall would not necessarily be equal across the schools because

it really one of our aims would be to try to preserve equity across the schools using things like class sizes the amount of money spent per kid the needs of the kids in particular buildings those many variables that impact that I think it's probably too early for me to start mentioning

specific areas but we there are areas where we could find efficiency yeah this is why this is such a chicken in the egg conversation right it's tough it you know a number is a number but what it means i mean i'd love to see a zero percent increase obviously that's not possible without

20:21

slashing tons of of things that we value um you know these discussions always come down to is the is the the you know weighing both sides of the conversation worth it is the cut in whatever we're providing are we able to make it up somewhere else um to to warrant the reduction in the budget

or vice versa is the benefit we're getting worth increasing um you know it's it's hard to say when we don't know when we know this number we know this side of the scale but we don't know what we're either foregoing or not getting or getting rid of as the offsetting balance i don't know

yeah the mics are quiet tonight apologies um what i was saying was now i feel like i'm too hard is that okay um i was thinking of because of my current situation with light um if there is any way to create efficiencies and kind of maybe leverage some work with like i know the free

port can but i'm sure there are other groups in our other towns um to try to create more environmental impact efficiencies like LED lighting and that's the one that comes to mind for obvious reasons at least net some small ones there are we have actually there's an energy audit

that we're in the second year of implementation of that is is working toward a lot of those things Erica Matteo and I have actually been in communication with what's the name of the organization, Green Schools, to try to talk about funding that could be available for some of that

work. And, you know, in places that don't affect people, things like supplies, et cetera, we can certainly look there. I don't think I can sugarcoat it, though, that if you simply look at the amount of the budget that is wages and salary, we are not going to be able to make really substantial

changes to that number unless we go to that part of the budget. And I think it's important to note that the energy audit is really capturing a lot of that stuff already, like the LED lights is happening this year, right? So that's already, we've already captured that. Yeah, that light's

still on the list, I think. One of the things I noticed when I came to the district, and I think this is probably a good time to mention it, is that, and Kelly really deserves a shout out for this, there are several areas in which we have been, we are using fund balance to step into long

term goals that are really saving us money over time and keeping us from having to tax our way out of an emergency because we are saving for the emergency. That includes the vehicle fleet replacement, the energy audit, and several others. So in a situation like this, it is always tempting

to try to think of what can we defer in those areas. This district has a really good plan in place to to keep us on the right side of not paying interest on things that's a good question um so we year one of the energy audit projects are this year so year two is year one's payment

starts i know we're stepping into some of that is it all of that or do we have an increase that we know out of the gate we're going to have for that piece so um as if we not all board members are here so we'll just talk about the plan a little bit it was it was a phased four year plan at least for the energy audit portion we are looking to lease

25:26

purchase that when we put an RFP out and we actually went with the Bank of America for this 17 year lease purchase for the energy efficiency pieces the proposed plan that the superintendent Gray was referencing last year I

presented to the facilities and the Finance Committee jointly and then we brought up before the full board where any additional payment that gets pushed into the budget we would try and offset by using utilizing fund balance and so

the projected amount that we were adding to the budget each year was a was about three hundred thousand if I remember correctly in that in that area I think think it was like 360 something but the good news is is that the projects came in at a lower cost

than we had anticipated so there will be some slight savings there I think it was about 60,000 so I'm kind of focusing on that about 300,000 number but that's one of those outside of the wages and benefits number that we're talking about and there's a plan to help step into that

and offset that um and that's why it's it while it's hard to talk about the budget right now and only look at salaries and benefits and none of the other moving parts because they're not all known yet it's really about being responsive to a board who last year at the very end of the process said

at the beginning of this process i was never asked what an acceptable percentage was what we wanted to see come forward that doesn't mean that we're not going to tell you what was on you know what hit the floor right or what's on the top you know like what we caught or what the proposals were

what the asks were we've always kind of talked about that openly with you all to say like here are the priority you know here are the items that are in in the here are the items that didn't make it i think this is more we didn't include that number michelle because there is an anticipated

revenue offset and then there should potentially be some savings within the electricity article which we didn't factor in when we were kind of projecting that timeline yeah I just wanted to make sure there wasn't like a you know similar to these special ed numbers that we knew were coming I want

to make sure there wasn't an additional number we knew was coming that we haven't accounted for so just for people who like to think sort of globally I just did some quick math so it looks like 82% of this year's budget was salaries and

wages if we look to the 9.82 percent increase for those pieces and keep everything else the same you know it would it looks like it's about an 8% increase to the total budget as opposed to the 9.82 for those two pieces so but

that means nothing else increases and I think anybody who's ever gone shopping knows that that's a to get what you the same things you got you know last year it would cost more money so just for a baseline that's helpful for me I figured

I'd share if others find it helpful okay yeah I just want to thank you is this working yeah because Wow really getting it up and close and personal with these mics I want to thank you for for the transparency throughout this process and

for hearing our feedback I think it was the retreat in August where we were really open about some of our frustrations of the process and feelings around it and and so I appreciate the question of what percentage are we comfortable with it's still

a difficult question to answer for sure it's it's I'm feeling really sad about this information and what to do with it so I just want to acknowledge that I think this is a really tough it's tough to swallow the possibility of losing 17 plus teaching positions to answer your second question

And if I personally would love to see a long term visioning process to evaluate efficiencies, I think in defense of our budget in the past, I've always felt like, you know, there's no greed in the school system. There's no I haven't felt like there's been I haven't seen a lot of inefficiencies, I guess.

And if it sounds like there might be, and I would love to hear more of that to make me feel better about passing a budget that's not what we've done before or not what we in general, you know, we're assuming that 17 teaching positions right now are serving our children in the way that we want them to be served.

So I look forward to more information and more discussion tonight to see if we can come to a percentage, some guidance for you. I guess everything that everyone's saying that this is really hard and difficult and frustrating, but I guess what drives me to say that is that, especially when we look at multiple years, it's the sustainability of this for our district.

30:41

And so when I think of, to me, I sort of think of the questions in reverse. What is the long-term vision here? And if we have a better idea of where we're going, where we could get to a better place, I think that that might change my answer for the first question. If we have to endure a higher

percentage this year, but we have a clear understanding of where we're trying to get to for the district and the taxpayers um that feels different to me um and just knowing knowing everything we have on the horizon with the early childhood stuff um and we've you know it's been

thrown around like the facilities um study as well to me those things are costs but this isn't sustainable for like it's just not sustainable for us to continue to have to engage in this process year over year. And so that's sort of, I guess, my musing currently. Yeah, I mean, clearly there's

the piece of this that's just, you know, what do we value and how much pain are we as a board willing to accept? But there's also kind of the taxpayer piece and what our taxpayers are willing to, their pain tolerance. And so I'm kind of thinking, I'm guessing that this is a problem

that's going to be facing a lot of boards and not just ours. And I'm wondering if you've reached out to any of these other boards and talk to them about what their budget process is and their percentage is likely to look like because I'm sort of thinking if this number is more normal for budgets across the state of Maine

this might be more acceptable to our taxpayers than if we were the outlier um that's a great question I haven't reached out in right now to any other districts but I've been through this before and I've been through it in in

several other places. This is a substantial increase. This is, I think, an increase right now. If we don't do anything and we carry forward a status quo budget, it would be an increase that in any community would give pause. And what I have found useful in looking at these very complicated

situations is, ultimately, it really does boil down to what is the most robust level of a budget that we can carry forward that our community will bear and the last thing that any of us needs is for a budget it's like the price is right you want to get it as close as you can without going

over and if we were to miss the mark and go over and the budget were to fail it would damage the district it would be far more damaging than having a budget that is lean to leaner than we would want it to be. So that's really where I'm coming from with asking for a number that you as community

members feel is responsible to bring to the community. I think actually this is a good opportunity. I hope that this will resonate when I say it. I think there's often a perception that when new school leaders step into their role that they can somehow look brave

by advocating for budget cuts. And I just need to tell you that's not who I am. That is not who I am. I do not want to be the person who comes in and advocates decimating a district. And I don't think that's what needs to happen. But I can't, I can't make this anything other than what it is.

So what I'm inviting you to think about is how much of an increase do you feel this community will bear? And then I can work with that. I think it's too early to get into, because if we, obviously we have ideas in our minds about things we can do to bring this down but if we get into

the point of starting to talk about specific ideas that is where we really create anxiety among the staff and it's too early to do that and the ideas depend on what that what we're aiming for i think i can say again there are there are ways that we could be more efficient that is not

to say that anything that we currently have does not have value. I can say with integrity that everything we have does have value. It really comes down to a question of, at this moment, what can we afford? And if we get to the point where we are making reductions, they will have

to be made in a way that really looks at criteria we've established. Where are there, where can we preserve student-facing positions? Where can we continue to meet the needs of the most vulnerable kids? Where can we make sure that class sizes are equitable and follow our policy? Those are some

35:59

of the big ones. Yeah, I just want to echo what Kara said earlier about just appreciating, Tom, your transparency on this, and appreciate all of our administrators and directors for their help in all of this. I think I'm just going to own that I'm, I mean, I think that the word has already

been used sort of like a frustration. Um, and I guess what I just sort of want to just say out loud is like, I am, um, it feels like in this conversation, we need to do, um, uh, the board needs to own some decisions, but the board also needs to ask some tough questions about what we,

um, what we have been told, um, and what we, and assumptions, um, that we've been operating on that, we did not think to question. For example, I would assume that in the last negotiation with the teachers union, that the

scenario plans that our side ran would have indicated that in two years we would have a $2.2 million increase. and that that would have been something that either influenced the negotiation process or was something that, when the negotiated budget was presented to the board, was articulated clearly.

Because I think, sitting here now, I don't think, at least, I mean, I'm just going to own that, I have no recollection of having a sense that that was the sort of curve we were on. Which leads me to a further question, which is more, which is not our responsibility, but is just in the spirit of community and communal responsibility taking.

I'm very curious how the teachers union understood this negotiation process. If this was understood, that there would be a $2.2 million increase this year. or was the leadership there conscious that that might be leading to potentially 17 positions being cut

because of the unsustainability of that? Again, I'm saying all of that, not that there's any particular entity to blame, or, but just more of, I guess, a frustration with, I don't want to, I'm not interested in blaming anything in the past, but I think also understanding how we got to this place, I think is important in some way, in terms of understanding what this visioning process is like. Does that make any sort of sense? It does. There's not much of that that I can answer for two reasons. One, I wasn't here when it was negotiated. And two, any of the conversations that happen in negotiations would be confidential.

Could be discussed in executive session from people who were here, but I wasn't here. I have had conversations recently with the leadership of the union. Those conversations are also confidential. But I feel I can say that they have been productive.

And the spirit that I've been met with has been one of, it has not been acrimonious. It's been, these are the facts, we have to deal with them. Certainly the contract is a public-facing document, so the amounts of increase over the next two years,

if anybody had really wanted to go in with a calculator and look at them, I can't imagine they weren't discussed at the time. I think it's, and I'm sure there are many staff members watching this right now, so I do want to say to them something that I have said when I went to listening sessions.

This information can cause the sense of it being the fault of the teachers for having generous raises. And it isn't. I would like to say publicly, I have no problem with the raises that our teachers got. That's a way that we are investing in the district. We are in a competitive place where we have other districts around.

41:01

That is not, teachers don't need to feel that it's their fault for getting raises that are competitive. At a certain point, it just comes up against the overall picture, and there's only one pot of money, and it's coming out of all the local taxpayers, and that's where we have to make a decision.

That's a decision that was made a couple years ago. Now we have to keep up with it somewhere. I hear where you're coming from. It must be bewildering to you right now. Well, and just to be clear, yes, and I think that's exactly also where I'm coming from in terms of the,

I mean, I'll just speak for myself, but I have been, yeah, I've been fully in support of giving our teachers what they deserve, and they should be getting paid more. Absolutely. And so I think that's, again, part of, I think that's probably, weirdly, I think that's probably what feeds the frustration, is I think a sense that, at least I think the board has been quite supportive, at least I'll say this as someone who is outside of the negotiating body, but when those contracts are brought to us, they feel like they are fair.

and they feel like they're meeting the needs that are asked for by the teachers, which, again, I think that's as it should be, but also math. So I think, and what I mean by that is to say, like, it's not magical, and it also doesn't hide. And so I think that trying to understand, yes, again, and I really do not think that, I'm not suggesting that, I was not saying all of that. Those were rhetorical questions. I was not asking that to try to

understand it, but more to say, like, should we have a, how did you phrase it? Should we have a strategic visioning process for this? Yes. Yes, we should. Another conversation that I had with the union leaders that just sort of, I think, is another, other people being in the same place

that you are when confronted with this information is a process that we have to go through every year is going through the seniority list because the seniority list is what impacts if there are ever reductions how those reductions get made by the contract it became clear in those conversations that nobody had ever really looked at those seniority lists until this year and the reason is because historically there hasn't been a worry about reductions so you're all you're in new territory this district has not been in this place and that's really uncomfortable Yeah, I mean, one of the things that Kelly mentioned when she said, you know, in terms of transparency and what hits the cutting room floor, as they say, I remember my very first time I got on the board almost 13 years ago, I joined in April, like smack dab in the middle of the budget season, and that was the question they were talking about.

and I feel like since that time we you know it's not what did we cut per se it was what didn't we add we have been in a period of adding programming and teachers and supports and and that's all wonderful right the ability to do that within the parameters of what our our taxpayers can bear

is a good place to be and we were also in a place where we had growing enrollments over that time which a lot of districts in the state did were not lucky to be having so that masked i think a fair amount of um of some of that sort of catch up that that you're mentioning um you know i i can

tell you um i knew what the contract was going to tell us um i feel like we shared that but clearly not well enough um but you know there's so many there's so many moving parts when you're doing a three-year contract, you know, the number of kids today, the number of kids then, the valuation

of the towns, like there's so many moving parts. It's really difficult to say, you know, this is going to be the impact of this contract three years in the future, right? Three plus years, because you're doing it in the year before, right? So that is, that is just one of the natures of the beast,

I guess, for negotiating a contract like that. So some of that you kind of have to put aside and really tried to just negotiate in good faith right like what do we think is fair what can we what can we offer to keep our our incredible teachers here in this district and that's what

46:07

we did um you know so we are we are kind of at a turning point where some districts were several years ago um and to your point kelly like two or three years ago there were several districts that were in the sevens and eights and we weren't we were in the you know four or five and sixes

so you know maybe we're just feeling the pain a little bit later than everyone else because our you know our curve of student counts and those sorts of things were different but these are conversations we need to have and we need to be able to find efficiencies and

you know the idea of a more strategic long-term plan I completely agree Steph like if I can get behind sort of a short-term increase that might feel unsustainable but for one year to know that we're on the other side we have a plan to bring that back in line with you know what what we

consider sustainable um but you know six and sevens and eights and nines um is not sustainable year over year michelle can i just i want to just make sure just because things can get lost in conversation i am not recommending cutting 17 teaching positions i am trying i used a 10 increase

in terms of teaching positions just so people could envision what that means but i am not recommending that we cut 17 teaching positions right because i mean that gets you back to the arbitrary number of where we were last year right i mean that's just how you got that right so

you know you have to start somewhere you have to look at something right um oh everybody's hand just went up uh danielle um so two things so i'll i'll say that i i love them we talk about us being as a community but we are three communities as one district and i think the three communities

are on different, um, positions as far as the increase. I, I, I don't think we've ever been together as one in as far as how the, the budget goes. And I worry that this just will continue to split the communities even more going forward. So I, I don't know how we come up with a number,

of course, that makes everybody happy. That's my one thing. Um, two, I know I'm just wondering, is there so Michelle figures out this other number and okay eight percent is what you said Michelle is there something really big out there that we

have to take on this year that's gonna shift that number even more that you could share with us or do you think there's some big project or the biggest thing the biggest thing is that we have to take on early childhood but we don't

have to take on. We don't have, at some point we do. At some point we do. Within the next few years, and I will talk more about that later tonight, but there's a separate stream of funding that is to pay for those needs. So that should be, based on the assurances we have from the state,

which I'm going to take their word at the moment, should be neutral to our budget, at least in the short term. Yeah. For this year. For this year. But could affect us again. That's part of that long-term planning which I 100% think I agree with Stephanie I

think if if we could somehow have that plan and maybe then show that to the community I think we'd have more people maybe behind us but I think coming with this no I think Durham is unfortunately not going to be behind it and it's not

because they're not supportive of the schools but it's a very unreasonable ask at this point in time. Yeah, I am also 100% in support of a long-term strategic plan to get this number back into what we consider reasonable territory, but I also worry that if we just leave

things status quo right now and we look into next year, we're going to be facing the same conversation again. So I don't know how comfortable I feel just leaving it at almost 10%, which is really 8%. So last spring, we spent, we got to a point where we asked, what would it look like?

What would the reductions look like if we were looking at a 6% budget or 7% budget increase? Would it be unreasonable to ask you to bring forward what 4% looks like, what 5% looks like, what 6% looks like? So yes, it's unreasonable. No, it's not unreasonable. You're talking about

tears. And that has been something that I have experienced in the past. And no, that's not unreasonable. Thank you for asking that, Cara, because that's kind of what I was thinking as I'm thinking about a number. And it's right now, I think it's really hard to say what is a comfortable

number and what's not. And seeing what different levels mean, different numbers, meaning what positions, what things would be reduced, I think would be really helpful as we think about this. I guess I just also, when I was on my phone, I wasn't texting.

51:27

I was looking up the Durham election results. And so I guess just in terms of the question of what can the taxpayers bear, we know that Durham voted that they could not bear the increase last year. At 9%. Right. So we know that there's that, right? And so, you know, we know we're close.

So I think that that's just worth stating, that we were close last year, right? And to Danielle's point, the tension that that creates because of the disparities and percentages that hit each town is another complexity that we're all looking at.

But we know that voters in Durham didn't support the budget last year. And I'm just going to take this opportunity to point out that one of the reasons that Durham's went up almost 9% versus the 6.83 for the whole district was because Durham continues to grow, right?

So Freeport is essentially a minimum receiver, and Pownall is close, right? They're getting closer and closer. Durham still gets a fair amount, $3 to $4 million a year in subsidy. But as Durham's property values increase, that goes down, right?

So what that means is the minimum required from the state goes up. So regardless of what we do to the, if we did a 0% budget increase, Durham's would still go up, because the state, historically, for the last several years, has been saying, you can bear

more. So, when we look at it and say, you know, oh, you know, well, six seems reasonable, but six turns into nine, and now nine probably turns into 12, and, you know, I, mathematically speaking, I understand where they're coming from, and maybe this comes back to how we communicate

to to the communities i can i can tell you for a fact that is not how it feels when you're talking in the community and they see geez why is our tax increase twice as big as as some of some of the other towns in the district i can explain the math to them but that doesn't change how they feel

about it but just a reminder that the for new members and folks watching at home i mean the budget is a district budget. It's not a has to pass in every town, has to pass in two-thirds of the town. It is a straight up and down yeses versus nos. And I'm hesitant to, I mean, I understand

the dynamic in the district on why this causes anxiety, but I work in Scarborough. They fail their budget pretty regularly, and they're all just one town, right? They still can't agree. they're all on the same tax base they all have the same requirements for their taxes and they you know they still struggle to come up with a budget that they can support that supports

the needs of the kids so i don't think this is you know strictly an rsu 5 issue i don't think this is strictly a rsu issue i think this happens in municipality districts as well um i want to throw that out there welcome anna right into the right into the thick of it i was watching online stream

but um sorry to be late you weren't driving watching were you it was on bluetooth everyone had a nice radio voice perfect who does tom because i'm sensitive to the feedback that i got at the beginning of this year that last year when you went through this you didn't get

satisfactory explanations of why um i'm really trying to meet that need i think that the why is in the numbers and once we and then there's another level of why which will be once we get some guidance here tonight, it'll be, all right, team, where are we going to go with that,

and how are we going to bring it overall into line, but how are we going to spread that across all of the different cost centers and schools, and that will be another level of why that we'll have to explain at that time. I do think, a note of optimism, these will be hard decisions. You

you don't have to decimate your schools. You don't have to decimate your schools. You can still make responsible choices here tonight and have very strong, well-supported schools. It probably just needs to look different than it does right now. Yeah, I think the idea about, you know, the more long-term vision, to me, is about how do we

deliver, right? So we deliver it in a certain way now. Are there different ways we could deliver the education that's different but still good that you know that might be cut more cost-effective right I mean we have a variety of class sizes across the

56:32

district for the same age levels we have you know there's just there's other ways that we could potentially be delivering education that is you know beneficial and productive and effective but you know might be more cost-effective and I

think that is what you're asking about our willingness to consider and I think we have to consider it because i don't think 10 is sustainable over time and i don't think we're going to go into our next negotiations and be like sorry guys two percent that's all we got

um you know it it just seems you know a lot of all of these factors we're facing do not seem short term so we have to come up with a different way i don't know how comfortable i feel giving a number tonight having just a very little grasp of all of the details and all the moving parts but

what I wonder is as we're going into the budget process and we're hearing from the administrators if they could give us some of the information about how a teacher reduction say would impact their schools so that we kind of have that

grasp of okay if we cut here this is what it would look like I understand why that question comes forward we really can't do that tonight and it's just because... Oh, not tonight. Okay. Well, we certainly can in the process, but I do need to

put it into context that the administrators normally would be bringing their budgets to me by next week. And we have that on hold because we really need the guidance tonight. And now I've deferred those to December 10th, which is before the next board meeting. And if I don't get a good

sense of a number tonight I'll have to make up a number I'm sorry yeah I guess you know I'm gonna push people who felt like they weren't asked last year what number was palatable and it doesn't everyone's rights are reserved and obviously it's gonna depend on you know what that looks like from from the team

whether that is amenable or not but you know the board asked for this and they're giving us the opportunity to provide it I think we need to provide it and what I said before but I wanted to add like a for I'd like to see a 4% of 5% 6% what

that would look like but to what was just said earlier I think in the presentation of those it would be really nice to not necessarily see I guess in a different way I would like to see how the students needs will continue to be

met? So not necessarily how the schools will be harmed by the reductions, but how will we know that the students' needs will continue to be met? Because I think, Michelle, you had said that Scarborough has managed to, you know, eventually go back and make cuts and the students' needs are

still being met or something along those lines. And I think that's a question we might have to add. We want to know how are these students' needs still going to be met? I think that's a completely fair question. It may be helpful for me to say this answers perhaps a bit more.

We have, I said earlier that we don't have anything that has no value right now. We are getting value out of every position. We do have any number of things in the district that don't fall into the category of must-have, but fall into the category of nice-to-have. And that's where we would need to

look and that's how we would need to prioritize no yeah so I almost feel like we should throw the question back on you since you have the information that we don't have or some of it at this point and that is you know clearly you don't

know what the taxpayers will bear but you have a sense of maybe what cuts we could make without impacting our students significantly I think my My recollection of part of the problem last year was that it wasn't, I think, yes, the

oversimplified way of explaining some of the what went awry was that the phrase, we were never asked for a number. I think that was said, absolutely. The other thing that was said was that it was never made clear how, and I guess this

1:01:37

is where I'm just, I'm really, maybe this is also the frustration. I think we asked really plainly, explain to us how these proposed reductions, why they are necessary in terms of meeting the needs of the students, or how will you, to the question that Kara just asked, how will you continue to

meet the needs of the students with these reductions. And my recollection was that what we were told, which again, I, on the one hand, totally appreciate, on the other hand, I'll own the frustration with, is just, is that, like, we'll figure it out. And that was not, in recollection,

like, as I look back on that, I was like, I don't, like, that was fundamentally, I think, where, or at least part of where I was coming from in that process of saying, let's cut these positions in order to keep us around a number that I think we were looking at in historical context

and was very much taking into consideration the question of the composition of the three towns. We weren't able to have a clear conversation about that. So I think that, I don't know, So I think that, to Kara's point, and to your point, Kelly,

I think that, like, it's another way. As we have discussed before, and as has infuriated some of our members of our community, when we say that our legal obligation is to the needs of the students, and that is who we are here to serve.

And yes, we do that with the help of the teachers, we do that with the help of the community, we do that with the help of the taxpayer, but our obligations are to the students, legally. We're elected to do that. So I think that's probably what I will, I guess what I would say to you, is to say, if we, let's say we give you a number and say,

I don't know, we say eight, instead of eight total, right? To say, all right, like, to take care of this point, how do we meet the needs of the students on that? And can we? And can you honestly tell us that we can? And if not, then say we can't. Because, again, there also is a fair bit of conversation, there has been a fair bit of conversation about who should be trusted with the,

not with the decision-making, but with the rationale, right? And I think that, I think, historically, the board has been very inclined to say that the teachers and the administrators are the experts in understanding what the curriculum should be, what the best way to educate our children are,

and we trust that. So I think that also, I think that is also, I think where I'm coming from in this, is to say, I think we should, I think you're absolutely right, we should give you a number, but I think we should, as part of that, say, tell us what the impact of that is,

And do you think that, as an educator, do you think that's fair or not? Because if you come back and say, you've told us to do eight, we can't do it, it has to be 8.3, I'd be like, fantastic. We'll figure out a way to communicate that to our community, who are responsible for

the young people. I can tell that, I know that last year, you did not get a good rationale, a satisfactory rationale. I think it's, I definitely think it's my job at this point, whatever I bring forward, to give you a rationale. I can tell you right now, if the number is 8, we can do that.

We can do that without gutting the institution. Oh, probably I need to come up here. If the number is 8, we don't have to gut the institution. We'll have to make some hard choices, but we can still definitely meet the needs of kids. If the number is 2, that's very painful.

That's changing the nature of the school system. Could you meet the requirements of the law? Probably. Could you have the schools that you're proud of, that you need your kids to go to? no. I can give you that level of detail right now.

What I really can't ethically do right now is, well, certainly we have contingency ideas that we have discussed. I have ideas in my mind, but the minute I start going into specifics about any of that, I'm putting people into a state of anxiety about, will it be me, will it be my children's teacher

1:06:43

and that's not fair to do right now. And I don't think that's what you're asking. Yeah, and to be clear, I don't, and I just... Can we all just say, as a board, I don't think any of us are asking for that right now. I think, like, just to be clear, I don't think that would not be fair of us, and we would be jerks.

So, could I, I also think, I mean, this was somewhat implied, but let me be more explicit with it. To get the number down to six right now, by saying, to get the number down to six, it would require 17 teaching positions.

That is me saying, that's a big cut. Can we do it? I mean, we can. it wouldn't necessarily show up as 17 teaching positions. It would show up as positions and supplies and some of this and some of that. But that's a lot. But if your sense is looking at this data that we've got to keep it in line with previous years

because otherwise it could be voted down, then that's the facts, and we'll do the best we can with it. To get it down to a 6% increase would be a lot right now. So can I ask, is it a lot in the framework of how we do it today, or is it just a lot?

I mean, is there a different way to do it that could get us to something like that? And maybe it's like, yeah, we could, but it's not going to happen in six months, nine months. It takes longer than that. You know, I'm thinking about, you know, when Glenn presented to us, and we were talking about sort of, you know, doing the mapping of the buildings, and like the use of the

space and you know are we are we maximizing the facilities that we have and you know maybe that's a longer that's a longer term play on how to try and tackle some of these challenges or is it like yeah no six in in the most efficient use of every person in every building we have is still a huge

huge issue it's it's pretty big yeah okay so you know when I hear Kara say you know she'd like to see four five and six i mean that's like huge and then even bigger right so maybe that's i don't know maybe that is the number that you're interested in um you know so we were close to seven last

year um it did pass not in every town but it did pass um you know how do people feel like something like a six a seven and an eight right and then we will have hopefully by the time we're looking at those we'll have some more information about subsidy we'll have and we'll have the ability

to look at impact as well I guess I just want to state that we it's our responsible responsibility to make the call of what we want to send to the taxpayers but there's a guess here for us to we don't know right what will

happen in an election so I just want to name that and also that I think that's kind of I'm happy to say a number as well even though it feels scary but I think the 678 feels like reasonable given what you're telling us would be

substantial and knowing what happened in the election last year I feel like that range would give us places to discuss it would be boundaries and guardrails and then maybe we would be able to have more of a discussion that Kelly I think is looking for which is I need to know more specifics before I can give you a number. So that's my thought. So to be clear, we're talking about a year-over-year increase

with just the wages and benefits in these positions of 8% right here. So this is not really cutting a lot. I mean, of course, there's going to be inflation and some other factors that are going to enter the picture that are going to influence this 8%. But actually 8%

wouldn't be a huge reduction in staff it's my understanding right correct and I just want to say it out loud that my take on last year just as it relates to the administrator I didn't feel like I wasn't given the information I needed I felt like I understood I mean we asked the question and they came back with sort

of the how it would work and what it looks like and how we can deliver on what has been asked of you to deliver to the kids and so I everybody has a different number in their head everyone has a different level of detail they're looking for in an explanation I totally understand and respect that and we need to get people to at least a minimum level of comfort with what we're

1:11:50

presenting and you know I just I just want to say that I didn't I didn't feel like I didn't have the information I was needed I don't want you to feel like it was just like here's the number take it or leave it I know you've watched some of the meetings so you know that's what happened but I just feel like I would be

remiss if I didn't say that I think if I'm asked to do tiers which is totally reasonable that will change a bit of the process about how I roll out the budget to you from what it has been and this is also something the team and I have discussed in the past you've had an initial presentation from the

superintendent and then you've had presentations from each administrator. There's a strong sentiment among us that that actually ends up to, that ends up inadvertently pitting schools against schools and that we would like to present it as just the superintendent's budget and that in subsequent

meetings when typically you would have heard of from individual schools, it may make sense to take those meetings and look at tiers. Here's what the budget looks like at 6%. Here's what it looks like at 7% and 8%. The administrators will still be there to be able to answer questions

about their individual areas, but it will, I'll be the mouthpiece. There will still be a few programs that are kind of different that we would present individually, like school nutrition, like community programs, which are just kind of a different beast. I hope that makes sense

the way i'm explaining it you're quiet how about now um i know something that i'm mindful of from last year as a spectator um is that we did try to cut one program to legal minimum and had quite the outcry as it not meeting the needs so i think that's something that i would like to be mindful

of, of legal minimum maybe isn't our goal always, um, if there's a value add to be a little bit above it, um, for some of the more tailored programs. And I think this approach where we're not necessarily, um, doing such a granular view of these are the very specific places that we're

going to cut, um, makes it a lot less scary on the, from a, a board member. And also I think, i hope from a employee standpoint of oh that's me they're talking about i mean it will get there eventually yeah i i just if it gets that granular i do hope that we're able to hear if there is value

add on something that we're maybe looking at because um legally legal minimum isn't always going to serve the kids in the best way we did have a conversation about But by we, I mean the central office administrators. I don't think this is a district that sees itself as just scraping by with the minimum in any area.

And that's a point of pride, and it should be that way. When we get to any of these decisions, it will always be they're up against, okay, so this or that. And I feel I need to try to be able to explain that. And even if I come forward with something that you disagree with and change, that's fine.

I'll do my best to explain the reasoning behind the initial proposal. Yeah, it's interesting. We were talking about this in the curriculum committee today, and something about the language of meets the minimum, it just sounds really awful. I don't think that's who we are. Yeah, it's not who we are. And so I think whenever we hear that as the board, it's like, oh, no, we need more support. I just know, I mean, I've only gone through the budget cycle once last year, But one thing that felt really tricky was when you're just thinking of things to keep

from the people who show up at the meeting, because it's really not fair, and it connects with meeting the minimum, because sometimes there might be a case to understand from leadership why meeting the minimum is actually good enough, and it actually is strong.

I think that's just important for us to remember as we go through that because when I think of the meetings last year what I remember is just a lot of conflict and like feeling pooled in multiple ways of like well we're hearing this and then we're hearing that and what's true and who can

1:16:57

we trust um and so if we can and I like what someone was saying earlier before I got here about the strategic plan for the budget I think that's a must-have but I'd really encourage us and personally i want to do this is to try to take a higher level view of it um i just think that's

really important because otherwise we're really pooled in ways that are actually biased and not equitable and not uh we're not guided by the wisdom of people who really know more than us yeah and i think um you know i hope one of the the ways it can be different specifically around

that anna this year is the listening sessions you did with the staff and in all of the and all of the schools so you know what do we do really well what do we want to protect what's really important to us I mean you know I struggle with the we want to do

what's absolutely best for kids because I mean it'd be great if all of our classes were 15 kids right but that's not feasible if unlimited funds maybe it would be but so we have to be able to like weigh the what's what's Kelly what's

the EPS for the district what's the essential programs and services roughly 28 28 million something like that okay so when we think about the minimum according to the state's about about 28 million dollars for our budget we're at 44 million dollars we are going well above and beyond what the state says it costs to educate an individual child because we feel like it's important to

have extracurriculars and co-curriculars and reasonable class sizes and and you know all of these things for our kids so I just want to point out that the minimum, and just for your perspective, Valerie, I don't believe we were going to the minimum with what was proposed last year.

We did decide, and I was supportive of it, too, like, you know, expanding it back up, but we weren't even going to the minimum at that point, right? so um you know understand hopefully we can take the learning from what we heard from the staff

right and use that when the you know tom and the administrators are working on this budget to say you know this is what we feel is really important this is what the staff feels is really important how can we honor all of those things and meet these tiers right and then maybe we avoid the

well they say this is just fine and this group says that's not just fine like who do we trust It might be a good moment for me to talk about what we've done with that feedback from the staff. Unapologetically used AI to take all of the data from the survey and also from the listening sessions

and summarize that and then to extract themes from it. I like using AI for that because it means my judgment is not the one doing it. Then the team looked at it, and we also went through the same listening session exercise among ourselves

with the same questions, which were, what strengths do we preserve? What are our challenges? Where should we grow? And where can we find efficiency? And then we matched our administrative team's answers up against the staffs. There was actually a lot of alignment. Not surprisingly,

the administrative team tended to have a more global view when they discussed these things. And staff members, you know, we're paid to have the global view. So the concerns that staff members brought forward tended to be more building-specific, but that also shows up in the

results. I shared all that back with the staff just over this past weekend, and then we used all of that again to extrapolate the themes that should guide our decision-making. Like some of those are, okay, preserving equity among the schools, making sure that the kids who have the

most needs are have those needs met preserving student facing positions to the greatest degree possible and there was a whole list of them but that I think kind of anchors us to be able to go forward when we have our when we make our tough decisions the six seven and eight and apply them

against the criteria that are informed by in part by what the staff told us is important to them so it's not a it's not a wish list of what the staff told us they want it's it's applying the values that came through it and my hope is that that type

of ownership in the process can help people feel better about decisions that are made now it's never easy when it results in a cut in your school your program your whatever but if you know that sort of these these were the values

that were used to make decisions and these were the criteria that everything was considered under maybe we get more buy-in from everybody yeah I guess just two things first quickly I think I mean it goes without saying but the when

1:22:12

we're presented with the 678 if that is what we're talking about I think to Stephanie's point front-ending before that the more of the vision and sort of strategic structure, because I think that then, if we're having a conversation

about, like, and here's how 6% fits into that, here's how 7% fits into that, and I think also as part of that, again, I don't want to, let me just say, I think it would be helpful to know with each of those percentage increases and what they are, like, the granularity of that, what that means for the coming years, with the question

marks in terms of negotiations. I think second, I guess I would just ask you, Tom, as much as you feel comfortable doing this, I guess I'm conscious of just, of being in a, of being in a cultural and political moment where taking responsibility for things is not necessarily something that's done.

I think, I guess what I would ask you is, first, what are the questions that we're not asking you, that we should be asking you, and what is it that you would also say to us that we don't understand, that the staff and the administrative team need us to understand

in terms of our, the role we play and the leadership that we provide? Can I take the second question first? I think that this team, like, throw a spitball at me if I get this wrong. I think that we need you to know that we've worked really hard at this already.

And we have been really collaborative about it. And there are smart people who care in that room. And what I have found is something that I have not found everywhere I've worked. It is not a competitive environment. We don't have administrators in that room vying with each other to try to get as much for their own school as possible.

we have people who see the big picture and who care about the kids and the staff and then another part about it that I this is just from me I am reminded of when I was a principal and I was having to explain a really dysfunctional dynamic

that was happening on the school board to my staff and it was at the first staff meeting of the year and I won't go into the details of what it was but it was something that was having a real impact on the culture of the district and it did involve board

members not really understanding the impact of their the things they said in public and i just started the staff meeting by saying okay folks there's an expression i won't use the word but it's something flows downhill we know what the word is um please you can google it um that really

is true. And the board is, everything from you is downhill. And all of us down below you in the hierarchy then have to be in the role of catchers, because at the bottom is kids. So your willingness to tackle this is really hard, but it means that it is less, it just makes it better for the families

and the kids that we serve. So, and what was your first question, Colin? Questions we're not asking, right? Questions you're not asking. That is not a problem with this group. But I do think once we get into a specific, like once we're ready to bring forward

the specific proposals, I think that you should ask, I won't say grueling, but very pointed questions about why this and not that. How does that decision align with the values that are, I am going to approach this by articulating values first. That tends to be the way I approach decisions. And I'm going to start my presentation with that. And then I'm going to try to tell you how the decisions we've made align with those. And then it's up for debate. But I think that you should hold my feet to the fire about explaining the values behind the decisions.

Yeah, absolutely. I really appreciate that. And again, I hope to be very clear, in no way I was doing the exact opposite of suggesting that our administrators were not providing leadership. That's exactly what they are doing.

what I was asking for was to say, how is it that we as a board are failing? That was the spirit of my question. Just to be clear, that's where I think that's the responsibility that I'm talking about and that's what I want us as a board to own and be open to moving forward.

1:27:31

Just to be very clear. That's what I'm talking about. If I invoke, so my wife is a school social worker. and if I invoke language she uses all the time, you don't, I really would encourage you not to think of you having failed in this because you haven't. I think last year I wasn't here, but I think what happened was you didn't get a satisfactory answer to really important questions and you wanted to preserve education for your kids and you took action that did that. Inadvertently, it has made the financial problem,

which probably wasn't as clear to you as it could have been bigger this year so now we just need to not make it bigger in the future yeah and I just want to express appreciation for the fact that we're trying to finesse this process so that we really do get a lot of input from our fact

from our staff and our administrators early and often in this process so that their input and their values and our goals can guide us in this process early I think that was one of the issues that we faced last year and I think I feel really good about how we're

approaching this and I'm feeling confident that we can maybe not end up in the same place where we were feeling tugged around a lot at the very last minute so I appreciate that thank you so just want to revisit the tiers again I

know where we need to wrap up soon too I would be psyched if if our district voters would pass an 8% budget based on last year's process there was a fight to get the six point eight percent and as Stephanie pointed out Durham did not pass

that so I'm I'm wondering why we're asking for an 8% option again it or I'm just curious if the board is all on board with that or if we want to look at we're just going six seven maybe they're not one percent increments yeah 0.5 or 1.5

percent increments or something I'm curious what other board members are thinking for numbers I think only a couple of us have mentioned ranges Daniel I'm gonna throw out that I would prefer a number similar to last year and

And maybe 7 at the most. As I was thinking about numbers, I was thinking 5, 6, 7. Getting thumbs up from Valerie, 5, 6, 7. No mic, so thumbs up works. I guess I'd like to see 7.5. I think, can I say that we could also, if we're really unhappy with that 7 or 7.5 or whatever we go with,

we can do what we did last year, which is advocate for more. I guess I would say I don't want to do what we did last year. wasn't a part of it I just watched it but I don't think that that was best for our district and when I say you know I we could look at five I guess when I say

six seven eight I'm looking at 17 teachers right that's six right yeah do we want do we want to go below that right I don't I don't so it's uncomfortable but that's why I go to question two of what what does this look like long term. Right, could we get to eight if there was a really strong case to be made for

change? If it's eight this year and we have a long-term vision of how it's not going to be eight again, I'm okay with that. It's very uncomfortable. People aren't going to be happy, but I think that there's a message there that's important for the students. Tom? Yeah, I think, I guess the way I'm

thinking about it is its informational, I guess it's the same thing. The reason I think 6, 7, 8 makes sense is because we kind of already know what 6 is in terms of just staffing, right? So no, we don't know the granularity of that, but we know, and Tom has already said,

that that is a huge cut. And so I think to understand the scenarios, I guess that's more how maybe I would think about it rather than tiers is sort of scenarios of like what does 6 look like from a staffing perspective or what does 6 look like in terms of meeting the needs of the students and what does that mean what is the staffing implication of that what does 7% mean in terms of meeting the needs of the students and what are the staffing what are the staffing implications of that, again if we're looking at that in a larger sort of visioning point of view again I think that's going to make more sense I guess I'll just be the outlier, or I guess I'll just sort of like mark the, I guess for the sort of 8%, again, I think that's on the one hand that is sort of meaningless, on the other hand, it's a way of saying, I don't want us to be, I think it's very cynical for us to be scared of our community,

1:33:17

And scared that they're not going to support the education of our young people. I don't want to be part of that way of thinking. So that's in no way saying let's not exist in reality and let's not look hard at things. But I just don't think, again, that's not a district that I want to be part of, and it's not something that I can't look across the room at Moon, if you were to look me in the eye.

I can't look at Moon in the eye and say that's appropriate. It's not. So I think that, just to be really clear, what is the scenario around six? What is the scenario around seven? What's the scenario around eight? so that we can then, with a straight face, say to our community, when we are advocating for one of those, this is what we think that means, and to have the courage of our convictions on that. I was at the state house today with a group of students, and we got to meet with Senator Daughtry

and also Representative Sachs, and at one point, in a very passing moment, Representative Melanie Sachs said, sort of apropos of nothing at the moment, But she said, a budget is a moral document. It is. And I got out my copy of Herodotus, which I was carrying around because that's what I'm teaching, and I wrote that down in that.

And then I asked her to follow up on it. And I'm just like, I've been thinking about that ever since. And I think that's where, let's be really clear what we're talking about. And again, there are moral questions on each side of that. There are moral questions in terms of the impact that that has on the communities from a financial perspective.

And then there's moral impact in terms of the lives of Moon and the other students in this district. Yeah, I guess to kind of piggyback on that thought, if we're thinking about tiers and sort of what our basement is, we're thinking 6, 7, 8.

You're telling us that 6% is 17 positions. That seems pretty extreme to me. And I just want to know, do you, like, is this something realistic that we should honestly even consider at this point if we're thinking of tiers?

or is like 7, 7.5, 8 more sort of the range that would be realistic for us to consider in terms of meeting the needs of our students? I think a 6% increase is significant cuts that would change things, for sure. Can it be done? Yes. It would change things, and I do think it would have a detrimental impact on kids.

The level of negative impact on kids is inversely proportionate to the level of the cuts. Is that always true, though? That's, I guess, my question is, you know, one of the reasons that the six is interesting to me is because I wonder if it forces different ideas to come up, right?

because if we just say hey you're like great move everybody forward you know it doesn't it doesn't instill a level of discipline to consider what else is possible what other way could you accomplish something um i do appreciate that you've you've said that i do think as i look at certain cost

centers there are ways of doing it that there are places where we're actually spending more than we need to spend and we're not getting the best results for kids and there are few places where we could not only be more efficient but at the same time get a better result for kids and do it

within this budget cycle i don't want to go out on a limb and say what they are right now but i there are some places where i see that could happen am i okay um i'm wondering if maybe we if six sounds super painful if we do six and a half seven eight or six and a half seven seven

and a half i feel like having i mean in addition to michelle's point of the power of creative thinking um i also think while the taxpayers are not our primary concern there's still a level of concern and it's worth at least looking at how painful that really is so that when we go to them

we can say we've looked at the six and a half we we or we looked at the six because we knew it was going to be painful but once we looked at it we realized it wasn't it wasn't anything that we could bear with our students. I think that's healthy. Yeah, I think it's worth that kind of

hard look. I think what I'm hearing, I think as sort of like reading the room, I'm hearing somewhere in the middle is the seven number. And what we could do is aim for a budget that's somewhere around seven. And then we could also look at, okay, what are the other things that would be

1:38:39

nice to have that could float that up? And then what are some further things that we could do without, not without paying, but that would float the number down? And I think for me developing this, if I have that guidance of bringing something that's somewhere around seven, and then

somewhere up from that, and somewhere down from that, is enough guidance for me to go forward. And then we'll still have work to do in the spring when I bring forward a proposal that shows what that is and we won't necessarily be done with it then. Of course not. Although there are districts

who literally... Bingo, bullseye, go. I have heard there are districts that literally put the budget on the table and they talk about it for one meeting and then they vote on it. Could you imagine? That'd be so cool. So much time back we'd all get. Okay, so we're 11 minutes late.

am i reading that wrong i think that is um yeah i mean that seems like the top and the bottom of what we've talked about um and you know everyone's rights are reserved no one has to you know completely stick to it but i think it gives you a direction that you can work towards and

it helps a lot and you know where to find us between now and then if you have clarifying questions. Yes. Yes, I do. Okay. All right. So we are just going to keep rolling. Everybody good with that? Thank you, Tim. All right. So we are on item five of the agenda. So do I have a motion

for consideration and approval for the minutes from the November 5th, 2025 meeting as presented barring any errors or omissions. Was that in motion, Kelly? Thank you. Second, Steph, because I'm staring at you. Thank you for that. All those in favor? Great. None opposed.

Those are moved. What did you need? I think I have everybody but Chris. Okay. Yeah. All right. Adjustments to the agenda? No? No adjustments. No adjustments? All right. So, good news and recognition. Is that up for you, Moon? All right. So, the mics are a little quiet tonight. You might need to get closer than you usually do. So to start off, we had to start the winter sports for the school this week, so that was really nice.

And I guess a week and a half ago, the Something Rotten play happened, and I heard that was really great from the students and family members. And also a week and a half ago, the Freeport student running team ran New England's at Thetford, Vermont, and the boys placed 25th and the girls placed 13th.

So I think the girls had placed the best they'd ever done, so that was very exciting. And then also on Friday, December 5th, the Sparkle Parade will take place. So that's going to be really exciting. And I heard that the cross-country team is going to be walking with the little younger kids.

But are we running on the day? No. And then also student leadership this week started conducting conversations on the topic of school culture and respect. So we're kind of in the midst of that and trying to improve communication between students, teachers, and admin.

But also create new channels of communication or improve existing ones. and then also student coalition which is like the combination of student leadership student council and student advisory leadership and like they meet

together like monthly to discuss like information how each group can support each other and we met to talk about kind of talking about how what each group does to this to teachers and how we could help better kind of help teachers

in addressing hate speech at her school, which has just been prevalent. And lastly, Ms. Skolko has some information that she can share. Thank you, Moon. Can you hear me? Yeah, I can't hear from here. Hi, everybody. I'm Jen Guthbert, the high school. Thank you, Moon. I just wanted to – I'm here tonight for two things.

One is I just wanted to add some information in addition to what Moon said, that we have, it's been unfortunate, but we have faced two recent incidents of hate speech within our school community at the high school. I have sent out a message to all parents, all students and staff to say that this had happened and to talk about how we were addressing it. We have support from Superintendent Gray and from Assistant Superintendent as well to prioritize this as a school and talk about how we're addressing it in the

1:43:50

immediate time right now in the short term and in the long term and so today we had a full staff meeting typically this is a faculty meeting and we invited anyone and everyone from the staff to join us and talked about a number of

things and one that was such an incredible part of the meeting was that student representatives from those three teams that Moon just mentioned came and spoke about their work of each team and then the three teams combined to promote

a culture of respect and and belonging and connection and it was just one of those moments that you're so proud of as a staff member watching the students you know they've gone so far beyond talking about fundraisers and planning an event

to being true leaders in our school and that's a tough crowd for both staff and they did an outstanding job today and we are calling the combination of those three teams the student coalition and they are now meeting regularly and then the focus today for the staff was talking

about what is the professional responsibility what are the district policies and expectations and what is good and right for kids of what we do to address issues of hate speech or bias incidents what people sometimes call microaggressions what to

do in that moment and then also when things are reported how to involve the administrators and so information was clear today about expectations and then strategies to do that and so I don't have that feedback yet I have some

anecdotal feedback but it was a purposeful and helpful meeting today so muscle is in my voice sorry about that just wanted to share that and thanks to moon as moon is a member of the student leadership team who's working on this and

did some initial planning for the meeting today I'm also here because I'm not able to stay for the full meeting and there's an item on the agenda that the superintendent is going to talk about which is an international exchange

between our students at Freeport High School and students in France and I just wanted to let you know it's not just because I'm a former world language teacher but it's something that I care deeply about and very invested in and

and really excited about for lots of different reasons i think superintendent gray has experience of leading these trips we've had some of our staff that have led trips students have been excited about it in the past and it is a phenomenal way to keep students interested and excited about a

language and recruit students and retain students as you know some schools in maine do not require a world language for graduation we do require one year we encourage students a minimum of two years with the goal of four years of a language and you can

imagine our upper language levels tend to lose some students along the way sometimes that's because classes are at competing times and they have to make a choice other times they've just chosen for lots of different reasons not to

continue experiences like this having students from France come to us and then our students go there is inspiring not just for the students who participate in it but for future students in world language classes so I apologize I'm not

able to stay for the ends of the meeting when we're talking about this topic but just wanted you to know that I fully support it and I'm really excited I have have not yet signed up as a shopper. That might be my next step. So thanks so much. Thank you, Moon.

Thank you, Jen. You all set? Was that the end of yours? Great. Thank you, Moon. All right. So we will move on to public comment. If we had anyone who wanted to share anything. All right. Then we will move on to item 9, report from the superintendent. Hey again, everybody. Well, I've said a lot

tonight already, but I guess I have more to say. So first, genuinely, I really want to thank you because I can tell that you've already just, not just for the last conversation we just had, as a board, you are very busy right now. You have, we have a lot going on between early childhood,

the budget stuff. You have been respectful. You've been productive in your discussions. You've kept, that you've been forward-thinking, and I have worked with other boards that are not what I would call champions of education, and this is a board of champions of education, and I feel that it's

1:48:54

time to, I want to acknowledge that because it's really true, so thank you for that. I do want to say a little bit more about the budget, and we've been through the finer points, so this is brief. This is where I'm going to try to be a motivational speaker tonight.

We've been working on this, as I already said, we've been trying to develop priorities. We've noticed a strong alignment between the staff feedback and our own perspective. It's not 100% alignment, but it is aligned in many ways that matter.

Some of the common themes that both groups, the administrators and the staff, emphasize are protecting student-facing positions, maintaining class sizes that are reasonable, but also equity among the schools, access to quality professional development. Those are priorities that are shared among all parties, and so that's a good foundation to build on. This is going to make sure that whatever decisions we make are grounded in principle, and that they are transparent, and that we will keep students in mind as the touchstone for what is best. I also want to take a moment to talk directly to the staff, because I know that there are staff watching. This is a high-stakes conversation for staff. I just want staff to know that the open dialogue that they have engaged in about the budget process is hard. It puts them in a tough position.

Any staff member out there tonight cannot, could not be human, but wonder about what this means. So I want the staff to know that their hard work is appreciated. Their partnership in figuring this out as professionals is appreciated.

The patience that we now have to ask for while we go through the decision-making process over the next few months is really deeply appreciated. These are all things that go into the mix, and the staff are out there waiting, doing their jobs while we do it.

And I feel a need to acknowledge that. And these decisions affect not only their students and their work, but their lives. So the people who are out there being professionals every day deserve our gratitude. So the numbers, as we've just talked about, they require a hard conversation tonight.

that require more hard conversations, and those hard conversations will involve hard choices. I just would like to invite everybody, again, I'm thinking of my wife, who is a social worker. This is not bad work to do. This is good work to do. Good work is hard. These are conversations

that need to happen. Sometimes they're harder to have these conversations than others. This is a hard year. It's a hard thing, but it is not a bad thing to have these conversations and talk in this way. So I'd also, as we think about it, and we think that it's hard, this may sound somewhat cheesy, but it is also a moment of opportunity. It truly is a moment of opportunity, particularly with the onboarding of early childhood, which will happen over the next few years. The intersection of that with the budget pressures that we are now facing, I am heartened to hear, you know, we all realize we need to look beyond just one budget cycle. We need to really look at ways to find efficiency that are going to take more than one budget cycle to realize.

So that long-term aspiration is really important. And that can be invigorating because it helps us become visionaries. It's daunting, but it is invigorating. And it makes us dream rightly so. What is this district now, but what do we want it to be 5, 10, 20 years from now?

That's actually exciting to think about and to be a part of. Several of our administrators, some of whom are actually in the room, have been reading Brene Brown's new book, which is called Strong Ground. I just started reading it. And when I say reading, I mean listening because I heavily use Audible on my mute.

And it was Mr. Pitten who recommended this to me not long ago. Yes, I'm putting you on the spot. I know that you're comfortable there anyway. So last night I was listening to this, to Brene Brown, reading her own book, and there

was one night, one line that really struck me, and it's relevant to what we're doing right now, which is, we're not going to build on dysfunction. And when I heard her say this, I actually said it out loud to myself. She said it, and I said, that's it. There it is. And I really, I really believe that's where we are right now.

1:54:07

Because if you consider how often in an organization, when you're faced with an immediate crisis, do we go for the solution that is ad hoc, that's short-term, that cobbles something together, and what you end up with over time is peach cobbler.

You end up with short-term ad hoc decisions that have been patched together that over time are dysfunctional. And so that's because when we operate in survival mode, we're just solving one problem at a time, but in doing that, we're creating other problems.

And so this moment is just a chance to do something different from that. So if we approach these challenges with openness rather than the style of leadership that Brene Brown called armored leadership, which is just hunkering down, turtling up.

Yes, Kate now knows that I listened to the book. If we lean into this with curiosity and not fear, we can make a budget. We can view this as not a constraint, but a catalyst. And it will build a stronger district. It will be hard right now, but we will be setting up the folks who are on this board 10 or 15 years from now like Michelle

To have to have an easier job I'll be retired by that time so That it will take thoughtful dialogue It will mean that we have to share the responsibility that we mean we need to own our part all of us will have to own our part

We will really have to see the district as a whole rather than individual schools. It will require you board members to remember your oath that when you became board members, you don't represent your town anymore. You represent every child in this district. And it will take us collectively being willing to be vulnerable

as we put ideas out there and then hash them out and talk about what our values are and see how they line up with each other and how they don't and find a consensus somehow. But I think that we truly do have all the ingredients we have,

which is smart, good people, right here, and we can do this. So that's my speech tonight. On the flip side of the inspirational side, do you want to talk about the staff hires? Yes. We do have a new ed tech at Mass Landing School. It's Hannah Anderson, and that is all.

You see another person listed on your packet, but we just found out that that person has changed your mind and is not joining us. So we just had the one. All right, thank you. all right item 10 is our administrator reports so we are going to start with

Kelly and finance oh she's already always I had a name so in your packet this evening are the expenditures from July 1 through October 31 2025 really not a lot has changed since the last time we all met we do you do know as a

a board we've talked about it this evening earlier we are utilizing the special ed contingent the reserve account that we had set up for that for the a couple of items for students that we will bring forward in next year's

budget process but otherwise than that the remainder of the budget seems to be on target and no concerns at this time questions for Kelly thank you all right so we will continue with our um department updates and goal review and we will start with

nutrition with erica reilly good to stand up it's nice to see everybody again my name is erica reilly i'm the director of nutrition and i figured it's worth reintroducing myself as my last name has changed since last time i was here uh which is a good thing because we have another erica m

in our office now too so it's getting a little confusing with the two ems this past year has been full of learning and progress of continued immersing myself in our kitchens and cafeterias building relationships with staff and students while strengthening the

systems that support our program i'm grateful to work with such a committed and talented team looking at last year's goals a reflection of school year 25 our first goal was to reduce the amount of added sugar in school meals ahead of the 2026 USDA final rule. This goal centered on

1:59:21

staying ahead of the federal nutrition requirements, and I'm happy to share that we met these major milestones. We implemented the required product-based sugar limits for cereals, yogurts, and flavored milk that went into effect July 1st. All of our cereals served have six grams or less

of added sugar per serving. Our yogurts contain 12 grams or less of added sugar per serving, and our flavored milk is limited at 10 grams of added sugar or less per serving. With these changes alone, the amount of added sugar has dropped by an average of 13 grams per day,

which equates to a decrease of 31.7% on average. Staff received training and support on the new regulations at the start of the school year. This helped broaden their understanding of these requirements and to help educate students as they come to the line when they see that their milk is

now in an orange carton instead of a brown carton. I don't really know the marketing reasoning behind that one, but these efforts are ongoing because by school year 27, USDA will require us to limit added sugars to no more than 10% of daily calories. Our second goal was to provide meaningful

professional development to support increased scratch cooking. In the past year, we made significant progress strengthening staff skills and kitchen capacity to help support our efforts to offer more scratch-made meals. Several kitchen managers attended the statewide culinary skills

for school meals training. This program is a five-day hands-on intensive training for school nutrition professionals that focuses on the basics food safety knife skills cooking techniques and kitchen efficiencies and you know really dives into some of those scratch made options

the best way to sum up the feedback i heard from my staff who did attend was i'd love to go again can i go back next year we conducted conducted taste tests and nutrition focused activities in the cafeterias. Our friends, actually right down the road at Replinova Farm, came into a few of

our schools to offer taste tests of local produce and educate students about some of the more obscure, you know, veggies that are grown right down the road from us. We had a guest chef, Barton Seaver, come into Moore Street School last spring where we menued a pretzel and herb crusted flounder

served with Maine broccoli. And these efforts were made possible thanks to support from the Fisherman Feeding Mainers program. As a district, we pledged to the DOE Harvest of the Month initiative, which encourages us to menu a new Maine harvest every month. With this pledge,

we've offered things like homemade macaroni and cheese featuring Winter Hill Farm cheese right in Freeport. We had a Rumpelty Thump casserole at Freeport High School, which was a big success, And we also made a scratch-made roasted tomato soup using tomatoes harvested in Maine, just to name a few.

By increasing our partnerships with local farms, vendors, and distributors, it's allowed us to utilize our local food funds more efficiently. This year, Maine increased the amount of local food funds per district annually from $5,000 to $10,000 worth of reimbursement.

Essentially, with this, we receive a dollar back for every $2 we spend on Maine harvested produce, or fish, or actually milk, too. So far this year, we have utilized 220 pounds of Maine tomatoes, 3,100 pounds of local apples, and 180 pounds of Maine broccoli.

With these efforts, we're seeing average participation rates across the district at around 40% for breakfast and 67% for lunch. This work is ongoing, but our participation rates remain stable or rising at some schools, suggesting that our investment in scratch cooking continues to support student satisfaction and meal participation.

Looking ahead to next year, before I get into it, I want to acknowledge the tremendous amount of work that our program has already done. So to put it in perspective a little bit, since the first day of school this year, our kitchens have prepared 108,000 meals for students, which I think is a number worth repeating because I think it just really, you know, represents the daily commitment that our staff is playing and, you know, the essential role that it has in our programs.

For many families, you know, right now, particularly with SNAP benefits fluctuating, these meals are a critical source for nutrition and stability. As we discuss new goals for the upcoming year, it's important to recognize just how much has already been accomplished and the impact it has on our students.

2:04:25

One thing I've learned is that we can't continue moving forward with the program if we have broken systems in place. So this year's goals really focus on strengthening our systems and our infrastructure to be able to make the highest quality meals possible.

And I'll be looking at things like staffing, equipment, and compliance standards. So our first goal for this year is to really look at strengthening our staffing stability and efficiency. We know that consistent staffing directly impacts meal quality and student experience.

This goal centers on creating predictable coverage and reducing the need for emergency director support. I'll admit this goal came to fruition as we were in the trenches of a two-week stretch where I spent the majority of my time along with some others

really just trying to get the food out there, if I'm being honest. There was a rough time there, so it allowed me to take a bigger look at what we need to do to be able to serve meals efficiently. To give you a better idea of the barriers that we face this year, on average, we have had over one and a half absences per day,

every day across the department. When we're constantly working understaffed, it makes it very hard to move forward with new recipes and fun things like taste tests for students when I am being spread and, you know, helping out in other areas.

And like I said, in days like that, we are literally just trying to get food out there for students. So this is one of those areas that I know we need to find a better solution for. So our action steps are as follows. I'll be conducting a statewide, not a statewide, district, but staffing analysis to determine where our needs lie,

working to enhance recruitment and partnerships with HR for subs and to find qualified candidates as positions come up, building a cross-training program so that staff can confidently step into other roles during some of these call-out situations, and working to find ways of strengthening staff recognition and team-building practices.

We'll measure success through improved coverage, higher retention, and stronger staff satisfaction. Second goal is to modernize kitchen equipment, which my staff will be very excited to hear. Really having more reliable equipment is essential, especially as we expand scratch cooking and stabilize meal production across all six schools.

Over the next year, we plan to revamp a full equipment inventory and conduct a condition assessment of all the equipment that we have in the district and build out a replacement plan to prioritize updates based on the safety, the efficiency, and the frequency of use.

And I will collaborate with facilities as needed and reestablish a multi-year replacement plan. And finally, working with my vendors to have a maintenance schedule, a routine maintenance schedule, I should say. And my third and final goal for this year is to help strengthen our compliance with USDA standards.

As I'm sure you've gathered, we have new regulations that kind of are changing all the time and are taking effect every year. It's a lot to keep up with sometimes. But over the next couple of years, we know that there will be some things that we will need to comply with.

And we also have an administrative review occurring in school year 27. So this goal is really to ensure that we remain proactive, prepared, and fully compliant with those needs as they come up. So we'll be training managers and staff on those updated USDA requirements,

reviewing and updating our standard operating procedures in all of our kitchens, conducting routine internal compliance audits, both formal and informal, and then maintaining a close communication with the state agency. They're our best resource for these things. Success for this will be measured by consistent compliance and positive audit outcomes,

internal and from the state, and improved staff confidence in these expectations. To kind of wrap things up, I am incredibly proud of what our program has accomplished in this last year, from staying ahead of some of these federal nutrition guidelines and

working to expand our scratch cooking and strengthening our community partnerships. The goals for this year, continuous momentum, focusing on long-term stability, efficiency, in compliance to keep delivering the best dining experience for our students.

Questions for Erica. I've heard or seen a report at one point that reviewed the equipment inventory. Is there already an equipment inventory? There is an Excel sheet that has a list of all of the equipment in the district

2:09:55

and where it is, and that's all that the inventory is. so there are no replacement timelines there are some rough timelines associated with some of the things um i don't know how accurate everything really is um for example there's there's certain

items in there that you know say that there's a 30-year lifespan on them but we're seeing them failing now so you know really just taking another look at those things and and figuring out where we need to make some adjustments. Carl?

First, I just want to say I really appreciate the clarity of your presentation, both on paper and here. Just fantastic. So thank you for that. I guess I'm just curious. You mentioned that we're, you know, goal three was compliance with USDA standards.

My understanding is that we are currently working with the rollout of the Biden administration policies that have been put in place. I just wondered whether you have any sense of anything that's coming down the pike from the current administration that might be impacting our funding.

I've heard something about the potential termination of local food for schools, cooperative agreements, and things like that. I'm just curious if you could speak a little bit to that. I really wish I had more information on that.

I think not just myself, but all of the directors across the state, we would love to know. We're honestly just kind of taking it one day at a time. The funding is there now, so we're utilizing it. Out of that $10,000, I've spent about $4,500 so far for the school year.

So, like I said, really just trying to utilize it while we have it. I don't know much more than that, though. They don't really share too much about that. No, I wouldn't imagine they do. Just more in the spirit of our conversation of sort of thinking ahead and planning.

But yeah, no, thank you so much for that. And again, thank you for all the wonderful work you're doing. Kelly. I really personally just love that you've taken the initiative to implement and put into our kids' hands these scratch-based meals.

So thank you for doing that. And I'm just wondering if you've gotten any feedback from the kids themselves. Yes, the kids do really love these things, and whenever we do make something new or different, I try and be in the cafeterias that day while we're serving and just asking the kids,

hey, how do you like this, or what would you want done differently? And overall, the feedback is really good. So kind of going back to my goals, I want to be able to do these things more. Sometimes the staffing issue can make it really challenging when I just, I can't clone myself.

I wish I could. But to be able to be in multiple places at once when we are rolling out some of these new things. A couple of years ago, we did a parent survey, and some of the feedback was on a desire to reduce sugar in the food choices.

So, well done. 13 gram reduction of an average of 13 grams a day that's excellent and something worth celebrating and communicate making sure we're communicating that out to the parents so that they know that they know about all these efforts that you're doing and the scratch i've noticed on the menus

you have what the food of the month is or the local harvest of the month the harvest of the month yeah that's awesome so i think any like that communication out there can i really actually ask you guys what what would be the best way to portray that i've created an instagram account i'm

not great at posting on it but is that the best method to getting it out or would you prefer to see it some other way because i we do really awesome stuff all the time it's just a matter of like showcasing it so i mean i think social media is great um and school newsletters that's what i

was thinking is i think each school does a newsletter with i don't know if it's monthly weekly whatever it is you know maybe there's just a little blurb on the nutrition piece every so often when there's something to share thank you i'm curious twofold one around the

scratch cooking um because i have a kid who doesn't get the menu anymore so i don't know what but you know what percentage is there sort of a standard percentage that we're doing for scratch cooking and is where would you like to see it i think with the harvest of the month

2:15:01

initiative what what is the driver there is they um encourage menuing a new item twice a month and kind of my own goal with it is when we're menuing that um harvest of the month item that becomes the thing that we're making you know scratch made um and some things are speed scratch like for example

today was you say speed scratch yeah like it's um i use the term but no what exactly i don't know it's kind of a quick way like today we did roasted cauliflower and it was you know you just kind of toss a ton of seasonings on it roast it up and serve it with their we had pasta and marinara

sauce and all that fun stuff um so yeah i guess what i'm going with there is i tend to make the two times a month that i offer whatever that harvest of the month is that's kind of when i'm implementing a scratch made option um that's not to say those are the only times um but that's my

my goal with it is at least twice a month having a new scratch made recipe with it okay and um around the staffing question um it sounds to me like because i had always kind of envisioned that the biggest um barrier to more scratch cooking was the cost but it sounds like it's also the

staffing it is the cost definitely but also you know having the staff that feels confident in the abilities to do something like that and that's where sending some of our staff to this hands-on week-long training really helped boost their confidence and then be able to come back to

their kitchens and and then you know teach the others how what they learned and how they were doing it um so that's that's kind of what i'm hoping we're able to send three every year so next year i would like to send my other three managers to go yeah and then um in terms of the

absences you're seeing is that just um are those unfilled positions that you're struggling with or are those we have the folks but it's just like managing keeping everybody healthy and well and here and we have all of our positions are full okay and it's a matter of kind of keeping everybody

here life happens you know stuff happens but when you start looking at you know the big picture of just how often those people are out it can make it really challenging thank you have we or i think in the past we've had a list of subs kitchen subs that we kept on hand

don't seems like we didn't hear that we have i i have a list of subs do i receive applications for subs all the time no um and that's part of the reason why i want to kind of partner with um you know hr and and come up with some ways that we can really get it out there that hey come work

in the kitchen while your kids are in school you know we'll train you i'm not looking for somebody that's been in a kitchen their whole life by any means you know i'm looking for somebody that's coachable they can come in and learn some of the skills yeah we do have a handful of subs one of

someone's over there she's really great um but we yeah we have a handful i think you know two or three really so when there's one and a half people absent every day yeah yeah there's a reason they don't have a full-time job they weren't looking to do it every day right yeah other questions for

erica thank you all right so next up is athletics with erica good evening um thank you for having For those who are new or have met, my name is Eric Hall. I'm the Athletic Director of Freeport High School, Freeport Middle School, and Durham Community School. It's been about a year since I've been here, so I just kind of want to fill you in on some of our teams that have done well over the course of since last November.

Last winter, our girls ice hockey, who we co-opped with Yarmouth, was runner-up in the Divisional Finals. Our boys ice hockey team, who we co-opped with Brunswick, they were awarded the Class B Sportsmanship Banner for 2024-2025.

Our boys basketball team missed the playoffs by a couple places. However, they were the Class A South Sportsmanship Banner winners. Our girls basketball team finished fourth in the regionals and lost in the quarterfinals.

2:20:10

Our boys indoor track finished sixth in the states. Our girls indoor track team was Western Maine Conference Champs and they were Class B state runners-up at the state meet last winter. Moving on to spring, boys tennis and girls tennis. We had new coaches for both programs, and we had a huge amount of participation for those two sports, which is great.

Our softball team made the semifinals of the playoffs for Class B South. Our boys missed it by a couple places. Outdoor track, boys finished in the top ten of the states. Outdoor track for girls finished third in the states.

boys lacrosse this past spring finished as divisional runners-up and our girls lacrosse team was the class b state champions for 2025 and as we kind of look at our fall that just wrapped up a couple weeks ago our football team made it into the playoffs our varsity golf team

finished second in the western main conference and finished in the top six for the state The World Hockey Team won the Class B South Regional Championship and was the runner-up in the Class B State Championship game against Belfast in a hard-fought one-zip game that didn't go in our favor, but it was a great game.

Boys cross-country team, which Moon is a part of, Class B South Regional Champs Runners-Up, Class B State Runners-Up for the Class B State Championship. Our own Alex Gilbert was the state champion for the boys race. As Moon said, the boys competed in the New England meet and finished 25th.

Our girls' cross-country team was the Western Maine Conference champs, they were the Class B South Regional champs, and they were also the Class B state champions for the 2025, and as Moon said, they finished 13th at the New Englands, they were the first Maine team to finish that high.

Our girls' soccer team made it to the regional semifinals. Our boys' soccer team made it to the quarterfinals. So, it's been a busy, busy fall, and we just started winter season with our boys' and girls' basketball this week, indoor track, and cheering.

Next week, we start Nordic and alpine skiing, and December 1st, swimming will start, and that's a change this year. because swimming has now moved, so it allows them to compete at the state championship at Corby College,

which I heard is a great facility in the New England area. So they pushed that back, so their state championship will be on the first week of March. So reviewing the goals from last year for 24-25, the first one we talked about, continue looking at how coaches coach

and how coaches communicate to student-athletes, how we're communicating with purpose, appropriateness, talking the same language, as well as supervision. This is an ongoing goal that we have, and we talk about this at our coaches' meetings that we have prior to the preseason,

whether fall or winter or spring, how we communicate with our student-athletes, what is their legal obligation, like if they hear something, what are they supposed to do? There are some things that coaches don't always know, but my job is to make sure that they understand what their directions are, what they need to do, what their expectations are, how to talk to student-athletes, and being consistent with their message,

being consistent in their tone, being consistent in addressing issues as well. One of the big things that's a big thing for me is the supervision piece because we did experience in other schools, not this school, but other school systems that have had some issues with hazing, and that's one of the things that we talk about at our coaches' meeting. And it's one thing that I talk about weekly as I send a Sunday morning email to my coaches for that season

that identifies what the week looks like, when transportation, but what are some of the things that we need to be continuing to talk about. please address these issues please make sure you're having these conversations with your

student-athletes so that there's never a surprise there's never something that we've come down the pike and then we didn't know about or they didn't know about it so it's an ongoing conversation I feel that's very necessary and very important with my coaches the second goal we talked about

2:25:12

and looked at was since I joined here in 2023 one of the things is we now have a full-time athletic trainer and Antonio if you ever met him he's very thorough in his job as a trainer he has a couple things that he uses to help him track with injuries called healthy roster

which is a form that he kind of uses that he can go back and forth to have conversations with the parent of that student athlete who was injured it's a one-on-one conversation piece so that they're on the same path with you know doctor's notes injury prevention

what some of the steps they've taken to address the injury and another thing he uses is called sway and sway is a concussion tool management tool that he uses and that's how he sets the baseline we test all of our student athletes

their freshman year as well as their junior year so if anybody sustains a concussion. He has that baseline to recognize that we have a potential concussion. He cannot diagnose it. That's a doctor's note. Our doctor's job to do that, but allows him to have that data.

So we've used that over the last couple years to kind of get a sense of, are we providing the opportunity for our coaches to coach? Are they meeting those coaching principles so that, you these catastrophe-type injuries that sometimes occur, such as concussions are very important at this age to try to avoid

because we have student-athletes who, regardless of the grade level, they're still growing. Head injuries are very serious at this point where it impacts learning in the classroom. So we took a look at this over the last couple years to make sure that we're also meeting our equipment needs, too,

For our sports that have helmets and pads, we have those reconditioned each year to make sure that they're safe. One of the things is helmets have about a 10-year lifespan, so after 10 years, they're no longer in existence.

So we end up looking at that. We have a data collection of that so that we know going forward what the next few years will look like in terms of replacing those helmets. Since last year, we've seen a 14% decrease in concussions.

We monitor the coaches that have the impact sports, such as football, field hockey, lacrosse, to see what they're doing. And, you know, we're seeing a lot of good coaching, so that's very helpful. And I think having a full-time athletic trainer has kind of helped us to manage that a little bit more.

He senses it, he can direct parents to see the PCP, and we can kind of start that process as well. We're also looking at some ways to help with injuries that have more core and more leg. I mean, one of the things that at this age is a lot of female athletes are susceptible to ACL tears.

And so we're looking at preventions of, you know, what are some of the things that we can do to build that core, to build that strength muscle so that we can avoid those types of injuries. So those are ongoing things that we're still working on and hoping to have some more clarity in the next year.

The third one was to look at the coaching evaluation tool to capture the important criteria to observe and evaluate athletic coaches in the district. and here's something that I've put together. I kind of took what we had previously

and tried to stream it down so that it's more manageable to look at with my coaches and something that's not repetitive with some of the things that was on the old evaluation tool. A lot of it was, you know, listening, responsibility,

and things like that, because when I'm evaluating coach, we want to evaluate almost like the same ways that I used to evaluate teachers and kind of see where, because coaches are teachers as I see it. I mean, they're coaching, but they're teaching on

the athletic field. So those are the things that I want to capture as their responsibilities and what are they bringing? What's their coaching skills? How are they communicating? Are they communicating effectively? One of the things that I will talk about in my other goals for this upcoming year is what are their goals

for the program, meaning what would they see outside of that they'd like to see the program. I mean, it's not about wins and losses. It's about how are they going to direct this program, because as I tell my varsity coaches,

2:30:19

they're the CEO of the program from high school right now, from middle school and even to our youth programs, and how do they structure that and how do they see that for the future. And so those are the things that we have conversation, but sometimes it's best to have them write it down to see on it on paper.

So that was last year's goals. So moving forward to 25-26, one of the things that this being the third year for me here is to review the current, and this is not a district policy. It's the Freeport High School athletic policy, eligibility policy.

I just want to make sure that I have that clear because I don't want to get that one wrong. It's something that I've gone through the process a couple times and seen what our eligibility policy is. And, you know, it was a good chance to look at it. So we started this August with a, no, excuse me, we started the summer, beginning of summer,

survey to kind of survey both student athletes and parents of what they feel is our eligibility policy. We kind of took that data and then we kind of looked at it and started creating a committee in August. We met in the end of October, just kind of start formalizing a

timeline, what we want to look at. What we've also done is we've also got, we've received area eligibility policies from other high schools around here, some in our conference, some up the road in Brunswick and Mount Ararat, just to kind of get a

view of what we have and what are some of the things that other schools have. I can be honest with you and be very transparent, there's not a perfect policy, it's what fits for our school. So when we are sitting down looking at

this that's the question i've explained it to the committee back in october as we will meet again in december january march and april this goal i i don't know whether we land i don't know if there will be huge recommendations or changes but i think it's a good chance to look and have that

conversation about our eligibility policy at the high school for student athletes what does that look like is it meeting our students needs is it not is there some things that we need to address and I think that's the key in this goal is to see if

we're addressing those addressing those needs like I said we may have a new policy we may not I can't sit here on this day and say we will but I want to be very clear and concise with that second goal is to look at and review our

existing athletic facilities to continue providing safe playing fields that will support our athletic programs and this includes durham freeport middle school freeport high school um i'm very fortunate to have jason chisholm as our grounds he knows all these fields all these ball fields and everything

every inch of it and and we have a lot of informal informal conversations about this um you know I spent last summer with him, we took a day, we drove around the district looking at all the fields and stuff like that, and he talked about some of the issues or some of the things that we need to address.

So one of the things that I'd like to start doing is creating an assessment tool with him so that we can start identifying needs or identifying things that are going to need to be replaced in the future or start that conversation.

I know we've started a conversation on the tennis courts. The tennis courts are something that is something that we've looked at, and I think those are something that has some merit behind it. It needs some upgrades. But those are things that we need to start looking at is those fields, those courts,

the things that sometime after a while, the wear and tear of playing on, the wear and tear of being in the Northeast, the wear and tear of the weather sometimes causes these we've been very fortunate we have good fields we have a great facility at the track and turf but like everything else they always

have a lifespan so those are things that we have to kind of start thinking about and start addressing and having those conversations for the future and i know it's kind of on the heels of budget workshop those are things that i i look at as well the last goal and and this is a goal that

is not just an rsu5 or freeport this is a way across the board for a lot of high schools and middle schools in the state of maine is coaching retention um we probably have a hard time finding coaches and then when i talk to a lot of my colleagues and friends who are ab's it's it's

2:35:39

It's something that's very hard to find coaches who want to coach. The days of having a teacher slash coach are not always there because that's just not what it was maybe 30, 35 years ago when I was in school. But as we move now, that's something that we want to address and how do we retain coaches?

How do we keep coaches, especially at the sub-varsity level? And when I say sub-varsity level, I'm talking about our middle school, our JV, our first-team coaches. Because it builds continuity, but it also allows our student-athletes to have the same opportunities as others would.

And I really want to look at that bird's-eye view with Jody, Daryl Rose, and Scott Lorette here. And look at those things of how we can, the three of us who oversee our athletic programs, How do we retain coaches? How do we make it so that they want to stick around?

Is it doing formal or informal coaching clinics ourselves? Is it meeting with the coaches more regularly? Is it communicating? Is it going out and seeking coaches? This is the time where I do a lot of thinking about how we can keep these coaches.

How do we develop these coaches and how do we have the long-term success that we have here at Freeport and RSU 5 and Durham and Powell? Those are the things that I feel is very important. It's a goal that has been weighing on my mind since day one.

So those are the things that really I look at and try to help and see how that affects our student-athletes as well. So those are the three goals and review of the goals from last year. Questions for Eric. So this is a streamlined version? Yeah. I know. It's a little, it's a long, I mean, there's some things that will be added and taken out,

I'm sure, once I go through it. But, you know, I'm always mindful of that. Kelly. Yeah, I guess you're retaining middle school and JV coaches. I imagine it's similar to how difficult it is to find teachers these days, but I'm curious as to whether we're having more trouble than most people are.

Is this kind of like everybody's having the same kind of trouble? Everybody's having the same trouble. A lot of it comes down to, for us, we have a lot of people who are interested, but it's the time commitment. It's the commitment of, I can't be there at that time.

And to get a coach, we actually have done some new mental practices maybe later, especially in the spring when it's not so dark, but a lot of schools have this. And, you know, as I tell the coaches that we hire, we're very fortunate to have you, you know,

because I don't want to be in a position where we don't provide that program. So we're very fortunate here this winter to start off where we are. know everything's starting to work itself out but you know the spring comes and we're going to be

looking for a few coaches um which is which is another no stressor but you know we'll get through it but you know these are the things that a lot of school districts are facing yeah thanks so much for this i'm just curious if you could talk a little bit about the um what sort of factors uh

are going to come up or come up as standard when you're looking at eligibility requirements in this Is that sort of in the area of age, or number of years they've attended school, or is it more behavioral, or does it have to do with attendance?

What rises to the surface there? I think a lot of it comes down to our grades, obviously. are we doing the right thing by having the week monitoring look at attendance as well I know when I first shared here it was habits of work does that come back into play and this could be something that we could look at there's a lot of factors in there everybody like I said if you put them on a table and mix them up none would be the same um it's just which which parts of it or which works best for us is how i see it

2:40:50

i also follow up that's it's maybe a little tangential but it got me like uh the concussion um statistics and what you're talking about there in terms of the evaluation tools you're using and all of that got me thinking about it i'm just curious what is our um what is the standard

protocol in for our high school i suppose for middle school as well in terms of um if a student is injured, who is it that determines when they are able to play again? Is that the coach that makes that determination? Is that the student? Is that the parents? Is that you?

So usually what happens is my athletic trainer treats the injury. For them to get back to playing time or back to practice or allow to resume, I'd like to have a doctor's note because that clears them for them to be able to return to play,

whether it's like a concussion, there's protocols of doing that. You have steps before you actually play. So we have, at the high school level and the middle school level, it is doctor's note. And sometimes parents are versatile at that, but it's about safety.

And as I tell parents at our parent meeting, my job is to graduate your child in the four years you're here at the high school. You know, some will go on to play in college, some won't, but the most part is my job is to watch you walk across the Merrill Alto. And I'll just throw in my two cents about Antonio and the full-time trainer has been

just markedly different to have him available at all of the home games. and actually he traveled with the girls soccer team for playoffs because their trainer wasn't there and that turned out to be very important for concussion issues so um you know i've seen

them use this sway program where they they do the baseline and then literally they reassess them on the sidelines when they feel like they've had a hit to the head like you'll see them testing them on the sidelines to see if they need to sit them um so it's a very very immediate process which i

you know as a parent I really appreciate um you know I think there is a pretty um standardized process for the return to play protocol that you're talking about um you know I think you know gone are the days where parents could be like no they're fine just put them back in um because

parents did that um so you know I appreciate the the rigidity around you know like no I know you think they're okay but we really want to see a note um and then that the note actually starts the protocol of like you know you can you can start practicing yeah you practice and then you

play in a week and so um i think it's um it feels fair but safe yeah congrats on that concussion rate going down i think that's another thing worth celebrating thank you that's all for an You also had mentioned that you were keeping data on injuries in general.

Has the injury rate changed at all? It fluctuates. I think this year we saw a drop, especially with our fall sports, our impact sports. It's really the tower with the winter because we see different types of injuries, especially there's going to be a lot more shin splints from indoor track,

from running in the hallways and outside um basketball tends to have a little bit more with the ankle injuries um so we're hoping that we will see it kind of either flatten or dip a little bit but fingers crossed i wouldn't be surprised if in the first few years of having the full-time

trainer we might actually see it go up a little bit because we're actually recognizing things that previously weren't going that weren't necessarily getting treated um so it'll be interesting to see like once you have a baseline and go from there if we see improvements or not because i wouldn't

necessarily think that i mean maybe catastrophic injuries you want going down of course but sort of minor ones maybe picking them up before they become catastrophic exactly it's okay yeah and assessing the fields and the turks and all of that i think is also really important at reducing the

risks of injuries right right because as I tell people we're very fortunate to have what we have here in Freeport and Durham and so I just want to keep keep it as best as I can and I don't know if we mentioned it in here or if we mentioned it when the facilities reported out but Jason came

2:45:51

and spoke to the facilities committee and you know you couldn't be more right he just knows everything about every one of the fields we have but this year we actually got the the turf impact tested to make sure that for concussion levels that it was still passing and it was like well

above the minimum so they're talking about planning you know what's the lifespan what do we need to be doing to you know to prepare for that so those conversations are happening all right we're good with eric thank you thank you all right i feel like i always say last but

not least no that's better so I realize we don't do good news and recognition anymore when we host but because I prepared it you're going to have to have it I'm afraid and it's a relatively short one for those who have not been on the ball for a while historically the hosting school would do good news and recognition too I prepared it without reading the agenda so just briefly I've been very positive first trimester This year, new pre-K and kindergarten children have all settled very quickly.

New students across the school will also become a part of the fabric of their cohorts. And we're thrilled with the new colleagues we have here at school. Our new staff are also doing an amazing job right away. An area we would like to recognize and celebrate this visit is the great support we receive from families.

It's been super evident really this fall. PTA continues to contribute in many ways. They funded a new pre-K play area out back at the Cup House, provided food and snacks for teachers during conferences, hosted a four-book fair, and ran a great family event for Treat Street.

They currently are planning on preparing for that and will fundraise the craft fair on December 7th. We also had great attendance, as always, at four conferences, where families attended huge numbers. We're always very close to 100%. And we appreciate the time that goes into adjusting work days or evening routines to support their children's learning.

We've also had a great turnout at literacy night for our kindergarten families and family math night for families with children in grades K through 3. And lastly, our parent volunteers who do have in from preparing bulletin boards for our Capital Strong Work

to chaperoning middle school socials. So it really makes a huge difference and we all feel very fortunate to work in such a supportive community. So a shout out to our families this time. Then on to our goal work. So I'll just talk briefly to last year's goals and then I'm going to throw something on the projector in a minute for this year's.

So you have obviously the reflection already in front of you. But this was the work we had done around really focusing on a sustainable system to provide interventions for social skill development and emotional support, really through the

work we did making sure we had a multi-tiered system of support. So bringing in this level of work to MTSS, which traditionally had been more in our academic work. So we'd had MTSS for reading and for math. and although we had some sort of behavior supports, what they were was sort of standalone, and we wanted to make sure it met the criteria of a more robust MTSS model, which means universal screening, which means actionable data, and then specific interventions that can be taught

and tracked over intervention rounds. So the work we had done started with year two, last year was year two of a two-year goal, which we updated you previously on in terms of Character Strong. It is a program we use pre-K through 8. In pre-K through 5, the actual program is called Purposeful People.

2:50:54

And then in grades 6 through 8, it's Character Strong. And it's taught in our middle school grades through the advisory program. But in every grade level, it is delivered by the teachers. It is a part of the fabric of each and every day, from morning announcements to bulletin boards to newsletters home to families each month.

as the focus area changes throughout the year. So the goals that we had put out there as a result of this work, the first would be a multi-tiered system support in place for social-emotional learning, which would support students across the grade levels at DCS. As I mentioned, that has been achieved. We spent year one identifying and researching programs that met the CASEL standards

that we felt had all the criteria required for an MTSS program. Then last year was all about implementation and having a strong implementation year. Each and every class has this on a daily basis from the first day of school through the last day of school.

Teachers are now a standing job with it. In starting the goal, we had to identify a measurable target to this, which we felt was going to be a little bit of a guess because we weren't quite sure what that measurable impact might be.

That's where that second piece comes in. So we had, somewhat arbitrarily, but hopefully with some thought, thought that maybe one measure would be the number of individual students referred to the office for disciplinary

action and had taken a stab at like a 10% impact on that. That statistic, as I wrote in there, I'm just going to read from that. The statistic was interesting to reflect upon. The number of individual referrals for office disciplinary action actually stayed pretty flat. It may have been wishful thinking to expect a drop-off in the implementation year, not only as it was new for students, but also new for staff.

And so new habits had not yet been fully developed. What we did see, though, when reviewing end-of-year data, was that the percentage of students flagged felt lacking coping skills had halved from 22% to 11%, which is a very positive outcome, as it can indicate that more students now have strengths for handling both the internalized or externalized challenges,

which is what we sort of use for the universal screener so in essence the screener identifies students who may have some needs in these areas we then look to teach into those specific areas where those skills may be lacking and so

the measure that actually came back when we went back through the screener was that teachers were seeing evidence in their classrooms of students having more resiliency skills. Then we had talked about anecdotal evidence of students

using strategies to support their own and others learning. I think I shared some of these with you previously but an example that Kay worked with first grader needed to meet with Kay to solve a problem and we shared what happened he then said my teacher's been working with me on my feelings the strategy that I usually use is to breathe in breathe out which he then modeled and it helps me

this time I think I've been too frustrated when he went down to repair the situation with his classmate I'm prompted he started by saying respectfully to the other child when you do that I get really frustrated before going on to apologize for how his frustration came out so

equipping children with language and strategies that their classmates are all aware of too because it's universal another example we've talked about is the tree of choices actually you'd see it when you walk out the cafeteria if you choose to on your right students have

approach different staff members throughout last year we would hear this you know they may be looking to voice a concern about how classmates or classmates may have treated them and when prompted with this sounds like a conflict have

you thought about using the true of choices to solve it again this is all about building agency everything we do right is about building agency for children and students to become independent problem solvers be it be math or social settings, and so when the adults are teaching into the skill, and then prompting

the child, not just giving them the answer, or saying, well, you know, I think that'll be okay, move on, or yeah, we'll follow up, but actually saying, hmm, well, what do you think you could do about that? And, you know, some of the language that goes with that, well, how big a problem is this?

And sometimes, especially for children of certain ages, the littlest thing feels just as big a problem as the biggest thing. Everything's a big problem, and they're just helping them put into context, actually, this isn't a big problem. You're right. And does your response match to how you're now thinking about the problem? Hmm, maybe not. And equipping them with that also obviously helps them problem-solve independently.

2:55:56

Also, you know, how did this make you feel? What action will you take? And the strategies they have, they're like, talk it out, breathe it out, move it out. And invariably, and we shared an example previously, I think, where with some fourth graders, a fourth grader had come across to the teacher at recess

and had said, they're not including me. And she said, how do you think you want to deal with that? It sounds like a conflict. Yeah, I think I'm going to talk it out. And then ran back across to the group. And the teacher said, you could see them talking through and then moving on together as a group.

It obviously is not a foolproof process. But what we were seeing anecdotally was that children were internalizing these skills and using them more independently. And I think that was what was then reflected in the data at the end of the year when we were seeing on the screener

that more students were equipped with strategies to use. So we felt very positive about it. We're thrilled to be well embedded with it again this year. and that language becoming more and more a part of the fabric. The piece we're excited about is that because this is pre-K through 8,

when we get to a place where students have had this for numerous years, the language that they already have will strengthen each year's experience because they're going to come in with these building skills. And the theme, you know, again, in the purposeful people work, pre-K through 5,

so for example, this particular, each month it changes. Not calendar month, we do every four weeks. So, you know, this particular one we're into right now is gratitude, and prior to that was responsibility. So at each age, they're working on this piece of responsibility at their level, with skills for them at their level. So year on year, they'll build that depth of repertoire of skills to sort of utilize. So that's the reflection from last year. I don't know if you have questions about that before we move on to this year's goal.

Okay, too bad. You're all so well trained now. Let me just get to this place. I am going to throw a piece up onto the screen now, hopefully. Oops, not that. Okay, so our goal this year is on cognitive engagement. And really what that stemmed from is recognizing as staff, our school leadership team and in POC meetings,

concern that there's been a gradual sort of decline in students sort of pushing their learning and striving to do the best they can do and so as we looked at that across different types of engagement it's been a really interesting process to dig into because it's not just as simple as do your work

as much as I'd love to say it's that simple just do your work and I think we have plenty of parents who say, I tell them to do their work, but they're not doing it. So I think they're seeing it at home too. But this notion, the definition we pull from is this one up here. Constantly engaged students are drivers in their own learning, their investment mental effort, name and work towards their own learning goals, reflect on their learning, and apply self-regulation skills. It's this combination of skills. And that is pulled from different readings we have done

on different pieces of research, also including work from visible learning. And this is what we've lent into as a school. The, I'm going to have to step out of this for a moment here and go to this. So, Kate's going to be cringing back here

because she's the technology wizard. So, when it came to this goal, one of the pieces that was pretty hard, because it's not like, oh, let's just go and pick up the previously used goal on cognitive engagement that seems to be floating around on the internet. it is much more sort of nuanced than that.

So what we really had to come up with and think about was how do we make this sort of measurable when we think about what will be impact? And so what we have done by, I mean, Kate Harrison, our assistant principal here, took the lead on this with Kate Parkin and our school leadership team, is really to look at the components of this, really come down to when we look on the left-hand column, Habits of work and the engagement and determination are kind of where we currently report out on this sort of work.

3:01:03

When we look at the indicators, when we think about, when we've done research into cognitive engagement, the factors that contribute to that, active listening, participation, responsibility, reflection, and goals and next steps.

So goal setting and targeting, you know, where you want to get to as a learner in very short term pieces is a critical part, for example. So we created a progression that captures all 10 grade levels of our school and asked teachers to reflect upon their class relative to where they might be on this continuum.

Now, one of the things I'd say to you that we had to keep sort of leaning back on that is in situations like this, it's not about the tool, it's about the data you pull from the tool. So the tool will be an imperfect model. We're not going to, we could spend years developing a model to try and measure this,

but we're not research scientists. We're running a school simultaneously. And so teachers understand that coming into this work and go into this very much from that perspective of let's make sure that we are looking at this through the correct lens.

So then to start with, we have done PD with our staff around what is cognitive engagement, what are examples of cognitive engagement. Katie created a tool here this is just a screenshot of a first grade one for example each teacher had this tool for their class and then completed that sort

of reflection of where they think right now their students are this is similar kind of tools what we use for character strong but theirs was obviously specifically from character strong so student teachers just can get into this

where use a pull down menu that gives them the choices of what options exist and then it kind of creates this broad brush one at the end the reason we have done it this way is that we can look at a if you look across vertically if you look across horizontally you'd be able to see a

student that may have great strengths or areas of need when you look down a column you'll be able to see like huh we can see where this is more of a general need or you know where this is more of a general strength that also is going to help us as a school because i would say to you that when we

first did this the thing that really stuck out was the active listening using the language that we created on that progression is a massive area of need and across the school and um um and to be perfectly honest with you apparently in the administration too because I was used as the example our staff meeting and apparently I'm around the kindergarten level when it comes to active

listening which feels like a long long way to go I'm not sure I'm gonna make it so this is the tool we are using to kind of track starting point ending point and driving some of the PD then And most recently, because we've been working on this, it was our launch back work, and then looking at this, we had any time to work on this just last week, and sharing cognitive engagement strategies.

So if we look across, again, in our school, because there's 10 grades, we try to work on some of these goals that are across the school, that kind of contribute to the fabric of the school. And so sharing practices also is a big part of that so that they can be A, learning from

each other, B, people are seeing that, okay, so this is what's going on in these earlier grades or this is what they're working towards in the upper grades. It was framed that each team, as they were working through this, they shared a celebration,

things that are going well so far, a surprise that's come up to them in this work, opportunities for refinement and next steps. I'm not going to take you through all of them, but a couple of examples here you'll see just

from pre-K-K, you know, celebrations at this point in the year, that in pre-K, the math tool used at parent conferences to celebrate learning and determine their goals, starting to see students notice and celebrate their growth with their peers. In kindergarten, you know, lessons on determination under habits of work, spending lessons on

goal setting and writing, taking time for reflection, making time for sharing after each lesson, start of use with some tracking tools and managing production of work. And a big piece of this, I have to say, although I framed it earlier on with, it's not just like, do your job. There is, too, a big onus on us to provide real clarity for our students. It's like, this is what finished work looks and sounds like.

3:06:11

This is what you are aiming to achieve. And whilst we feel like we've done that in the past, that is a piece that we're sort of like doubling down on make sure there's clarity and you can see some of the tools there for the younger

children about self-reflecting on you know have they met their goal are they doing their work or one star two star levels so students using how it's aware increasing stamina students are feeling proud accomplished with their work building reading stamina and writing stamina and volume and then just to jump

right up to seventh and eighth grade the big focus of that work is very much around habits of work as we try to you know sort of prepare them with those skills for transition to high school so students are self reflecting every two

weeks in each class about the habits of work they're becoming more accurate and aligned with teacher scores and feedback the habits of work are more visible and integrated into the classroom so there's really specific examples of what this is

what determination is going to look like in today's lesson this is what this will work like as we're doing this lab work today in the science lab this is what engagement is going to look and sound like so that students have that understanding even though we think they must have this right but where we're

seeing such a big gap in it right we have to teach back into what those expectations and clarity are so in math already we're seeing more students attempting level 4 extension activities when student choice and authenticity has

been increased and in humanities in LA feedback loops and conferring within projects and is providing structure to insight reflection and past to move forward with on their work so that's the goal for cognitive engagement those are

some of the aspects of the work so far our second goal I'm going to have Kate talk about because she very much leads that work even though she very much please this work too okay can't freeze it you have your oh our second goal is on

attendance and our goal is to increase student sense of belonging in school that will impact both well being overall well-being and our attendance rates so as a result of this work we're hoping in a 10% reduction in our chronic

absenteeism from 9.6 percent to 8.64 percent and just to put that into some context right now in the school year we're currently at 4.7 percent we're off to a very strong start with our attendance we have an attendance team

that meets regularly to collaborate on student plans and to track absences and and we do look for patterns and trends whether it's in a grade level or in certain student populations something we've noticed for chronic absenteeism is it's primarily students that face

complicated health concerns so those are ones that even the best attendance plan isn't going to change their chronic illness but we are continually chipping away at it for example last year we had a couple kids on attendance intervention plans and one of

those students went from last year being present for 79% of his school year to this year having a hundred percent attendance rate so that's super exciting and we are recognizing students who have improved their attendance we're doing

things like sending positive postcards home using reach my teach to send some messages about attendance. And I was able to attend the state conference on attendance that was run by Count Me In to get some more strategies and work with

other assistant principals in our district. So I think we're going to have a positive trend in our attendance this year. I feel like you might be sandbagging your goal i'm just saying questions for will and kate i literally had to do that in my head i'm

like that wasn't the show right no it was will and grace sorry yeah i'm i'm just kind of curious about your first goal um you said you noticed a decrease in the last few years around cognitive engagement and i'm curious if you obviously you said you're not social scientists so you may not

3:11:16

have the actual factors that are leading to this but i'm wondering if you've reflected on it at all is it an artifact of covid um are there other things that that are contributing to this that may be addressed outside of the classroom cell phones cell phones for example

well i think i have to go lean on i'm not a social scientist um although i may be playing one on tv right now it's there's i think it's i always uh so i think it's helpful to look at factors that can contribute to it. But I think there's so many that it'd be hard to nail

onto one. So I think, for example, broadly over the last 20 years, the involvement in travel sports of whole families compared to what kids participated in sports as a student athlete has generally changed pretty significantly. And so we have a lot of students involved

in pretty sophisticated programs, whether it be dance or sports or different activities that take up significant amounts of time outside of school, they have also become priorities. And I don't know whether COVID is a factor in it. I think if you read the literature, there's certainly some where to indicate it has been, that a big part of national attendance declines

was really triggered by COVID and where all of a sudden school was deemed as optional and therefore there's knock-on effects from that. So I think for us there's probably factors. I'm not sure there's things that we're leaning on that, oh, if we could address this or that simultaneously.

I think what we're saying is this is what we've seen. What can we control and what can we do to try and impact that? And I do think we're also trying to be much more specific it with feedback to families in terms of ways in which they can also support it we had gathered

some feedback last year at family math night at literacy and at pta in the spring as we were starting to move towards this and one of the questions was about homework for example and you know what makes it tricky to support your child with homework and i would say a significant number

the answers were like, my child just doesn't want to do it. And their parents were not giving up on it. They were looking for ways themselves to engage their child in their learning. So it's feedback to us that is like, A, just like attendance, as Kate said, making school a welcoming place to be,

making lessons engaging, and making the learning relevant, and making sure it's clear what learning will look and sound like just that clarity of expectation and and then reinforcing it with feedback as you know both feedback of like this is going great as a strategy to keep using or

feedback that there's growth here and this is a great strategy to use to get closer to the outcome but not one thing i'm afraid i and the question of um i thought the tool was great and i imagine and it can generate some really good data to use to inform next steps.

I'm curious about the lift on the teachers to, you know, how often do they have to, like, reassess all five of those things and, you know, use the... No, so that won't be a... It's not like a report card thing or necessarily a progress monitor piece. At least two or three will come in. So we're only going to do that as two points, like a start point, end point, to see that growth.

But where we do lean in on it, it was like, what does it show us now? What we do continue through the year is more of the things that you just saw a moment ago in terms of... So another factor we did, which I failed to mention, but I think is important,

is that within our professional evaluation, professional growth model as a district, all educators are required to work on a goal, a specific goal. Or two, they can choose two goals. So what we had said to all our staff this year

was one goal has to be on cognitive engagement. And if you want to choose the second one, you may, but otherwise that's going to be the focus. And they vary. And also some of them did team goals. So for example, a grade level team may be like, we really are going to be focused on lifting cognitive engagement in writing. And this is what this is going to look like as a success. And these are strategies we're going to try. The reason we have done that for Kate and I is that when we have 60 different goals,

3:16:20

giving people feedback and participating in the process of supporting them with reaching their goals is really difficult. Whereas now when we do mini observations and we check in with staff, part of that conversation is how's the cognitive engagement goal going?

Because it's so applied to everything. And then the other piece of that is within our team PLC meetings, more often than not, there's conversations about what strategies you're using for that goal or what strategies you're using around cognitive engagement. So the focus is across, not necessarily from that initial data, but then our hope is that

the growth for collectively is through our staff meeting time, our PD time, our PLC time, and goal feedback. So that's kind of how we try to build in that process of checkpoints. Great. Thank you. Other questions? Thank you.

All right. So we are up to item 11 on the agenda, which is board comments and committee reports. So we'll start with sort of the open-ended opportunity for anyone with information requests or information they want to share, throw it back out there for...

Oh, Valerie? I have two very brief updates regarding Region 10. One is that I asked when we would potentially hear back about the need for the voting for the items that they want to upgrade. And they said last time they heard in late January. So there won't be any updates until probably late January on that piece,

which is something I neglected to ask last time. The other thing, I attended last Friday one of the two celebratory breakfasts for our shared students, for Student of the Quarter. It was wonderful. Met several of our Freeport representatives at Region 10. It was a really great experience, and obviously, I think we all applaud all of those students and their recognition.

And I recall the celebratory breakfast is prepared by the culinary, right? It's always good. Fantastic. Thank you. other requests comments we did put an update on the early childhood education task force here we just want to keep a little placeholder for that we have a couple of folks i think there's four of us

right that are that are on that task force we've met twice and it includes the principals from all of the schools that currently offer pre-k services so moore street panel and durham we have community members I think we have we do have someone from each of the either

town council or select board from the three towns which is great we have local childcare providers and you know we just wanted to provide a quick update to the board about where that work has led us so far sort of the first meeting was

really around understanding what the mandate was what was what was what did we have to do and when um and just get more details around you know what were we dealing with here um the last meeting that we had which was last week that was last week right i don't know

time flies um uh we really talked about you know the the district and all the districts i guess in the state have the options of when they want to start providing these services um so you could start some people started this year you have the opportunity to start next year

in cohort three which would be four-year-olds you could start in which case if you started next year with four-year-olds the following year you would have to pick up the three-year-olds so just a reminder this is for four and

five-year-olds excuse me three and four-year-olds that are currently covered by CDS services so special education services for the kids before they before they hit the school district so so we could pick up the four-year-olds

next year and the three-year-olds the following year and then once it's required for everybody to have everybody that the year of July 1 2028 we would already be already doing those things we have the option of going into the

following year's cohort cohort four which is when we would pick up the three and four-year-olds and then we would be compliant the required year the following year or we could not do anything and just start in 2028 obviously the benefits to starting sooner

3:21:33

is there are there are funds right now available to help facilitate that that transition you know the thing that was really clear to me and and please jump in the other folks that were there is you know we're already providing a lot of these services to the four-year-olds through

our pre-k program right so the meeting we had kind of showed how many how many kids what's the what's the population of kids this encompasses as four-year-olds which ones are we already servicing and what would it take to to reach the level of requirement to move into cohort three

i think the the general consensus of the board of that committee although actually it was unanimous was that it made a lot of sense to move into that cohort three option um we're already doing a lot we want to take advantage of as much of the funds that are available because those are kind of first

come first serve um and once they're gone they're gone um and continue moving the work because i think one thing we heard kind of loud and clear is this move from cds to the school districts while you know state mandates are never fun is actually probably the best things for kids

we're better prepared and better equipped to serve these kids because the kids in CDS just don't there's just not enough staffing so so I think the the committee was interested in moving forward with what does cohort three look like so similar to the budget conversation we just had

you know with that parameter what could that look like for us next year um and i i believe that that is kind of where we sit right now and then we'll meet again in december yeah and we'll hear more about what that could look like what staffing might need to be you know updated in order to meet the

you know we're doing a lot of it now but not all of it so what does it look like to to meet the the needs and be compliant with cohort three so anything else i missed you covered the bases any i'm looking at you guys to see uh um other folks that were at the at the meeting

i think one optimistic note is the potential that we may be getting reimbursement for things that we've been providing on our own yeah true very true um yeah that was kind of the update on that um any other requests i think we're good uh all right so we will move to an update from

facilities and operations the facilities and operations committee met on wednesday november 5th and during that meeting our director glenn reynolds director of facilities reminded the committee that we will be we're scheduled for a facilities tour on december 12th starting at 9

am so if you are available they're always highly informative this year the theme of the tour is going to be reviewing the energy audit phase one projects that the board has approved so we'll get to see where our money that we approved is making improvements and energy savings in our buildings

one highlight of that tour that you definitely won't want to miss is that we will be making a stop and paneled to admire the new leach field and playground. So please don't miss it. Glenn also talked a little bit about the capital improvement plan for 2627 and 2728. And one

particular point he mentioned was that the roof replacement projects for the high school. So the high school roof is was scheduled to be replaced in phases or over a couple of years different parts of it the two different parts that were going to be replaced are now going to be lumped together and done at the same time in

order to experience some cost savings by getting a little bit better pricing so that will be done this next year but the the replacements that were scheduled for this year will be paid for out of capital reserve funds. Questions for Kelly? I feel like

we might switch you to hype up the come to our budget meeting calls that I do because that was way more fun than the ones I interrupt everyone's dinner with every year. All right. Colin. Yeah, just if we could take a moment, maybe we could all close our eyes and you could describe to us

3:26:41

like what the leach field looks like just so we can kind of like like imagine it now so that then when we see it we can't do that you have to come and experience it in person that's the only way thank you we manifest thank you for entertaining the possibility all right um so uh finance you

were the only one who's here that was there so you want to do that one okay okay so we finance committee met on the 22nd of October and at that time our director Kelly Wentworth went over the progress with the FY25 financial audit. Sounds like everything's going smoothly. We're on target

and there were no concerns expressed. Superintendent Gray also updated the committee on the budget process. A lot of what he said there has since been repeated to the entire board, but he explains the listening sessions that have been conducted in the schools with the staff as well as the

administrators and as well as the staff survey that was conducted. We then had a conversation about health insurance benefits and whether or not we should think about switching from the current health insurance plan to investigate whether it would make sense for us to look at any other plans. So Kelly outlined how many people are participating,

what kinds of premiums are being collected, and the district's contribution to the current plan. In short, in FY25, the district spent about $4.5 million on health premiums and cash, and the staff paid about $1.16 million.

And Kelly talked a little bit about how she reached out to other districts to see if they were also still using Anthem as their health insurance provider to see how many of them might be looking at other options. And it sounds like of all of the districts that responded,

all of them were using the MEABT Anthem plan, the one that we use right now. So the committee members present thought that it might be helpful if we had a better understanding of how MEABT chooses its health insurance provider

so that we would know whether it would be worth our while to look further to see if there are other plans that make sense for us to pursue. So at that point, Kelly stated that she would reach out to see if they would send someone to a future finance meeting to discuss the process.

Coming up on December 10th, there will be a joint meeting with the Facilities Committee to review the continuation of the vehicle equipment replacement plan and talk a little bit more about what's coming up in Phase 2 of the energy audit.

Thank you. Questions for Kelly? Either Kelly. Both the Kellys. All right, thank you. All right, and we will move on to our policy update. Hello. We met on Thursday, November 6th at 4.15 p.m. Eastern Standard Time because Eastern Daylight Time ended the previous Sunday, so we thought we should meet at the proper time. We went through a number of policies. A few of them we're bringing before you this evening, including EBCF, automated external defibrillators,

which is a response to a law change. I'll go into the details of that when we get to that actual review. We also looked at EBBD, temperature standards for schools, which is a new policy that is driven by law. I have a note here in my notes that just says meat thermometers.

I think we discussed whether we needed to get more meat thermometers to measure things, but my understanding is we don't. But basically, I think the outcome of that is that our superintendent and is going to run our cousin's, Kate Elizabeth's, policy by Glenn and see whether he thinks

3:31:55

that's good or whether we need more meat thermometers, and then we'll get back to us. We also embarked on a very interesting policy, JICJ, cell phones and other personal electronic devices in schools. Very few people have any interest in or opinions about. So we started

that conversation. We've got more work to do, I think is the real takeaway there. But it was nice to start to dig in there. And thank you to the board for providing the direction for how we're meant to go there. We then also had a brief chin-lag about GICK bullying and

J-I-C-K-R, ability to administrative procedure, which is part of our regular review process. And we're going to be doing a little bit more work with that before we bring it to you. And we adjourn at 6.45 in time for dinner.

Anyway, we're going to get moving on to the next ones here. Anybody have any questions for the minutes before we jump into the policies before us? It wasn't that bad, man. I tried really hard to make it good. Take it off. Good morning out of here. Well done, Colin. Great. All right, you want to jump into the policies before us? You want me to get a motion on the table for him? Yes, please. All right, let's do that. All right, so 12A, do I have a motion for consideration and approval for the first read

of the following policy, EBCF, which is the Automated External Defibrillators, AEDs. Kara, Steph, thank you. So we bring before you for first read EDCF, which is about automated external defibrillators, and this flows from a law change to Maine Department of Education Rule 41, and this change will be bringing us into compliance with that.

And I believe that Superintendent Gray has a few additional notes to kind of clarify where we are on that. it does indeed bring us into compliance and Erica you may have to help me out with this because you've actually done more work on this policy that I have it

means we have a different leader at every school we are working with the nurses on a protocol around maintenance of those and regular testing of those and training of both staff but also in the case of the high school students who

could be able to use them, and that training is happening in PE classes. Did I miss anything important? You got it. Okay. Curious how many schools they're currently in. They're in all of the school buildings, including Laugh and Learn. Oh, so we do already have them. And we're looking

to extend the installations into outdoor spaces that are used recreationally. Those require hard wiring and sort of containers that are weatherproof, so that requires a bigger investment. So those will be phased in over time, starting with the highest use areas.

Our athletic trainers travel with AEDs as well. Did we find the one at the high school? Was that a last year problem? Maybe. Somebody had gifted us one before we even had one, and then we couldn't find it when they took the renovation.

I think maybe we found it. Does this mean that we don't currently, as a general rule, have them at sporting events? We do. With our school-sanctioned events that have trainers present. Yes. So what does that mean for middle school? Because we don't have trainers at the middle school events.

I'm not sure about the consistency of the AED, but there's one in every building. Okay. I just thought that language was kind of weird. At least one in every building. I mean, who decides if there's two or three? Is that your job to decide that?

i think we would like consult with our nurses because i thought i was involved i think in that one of those early meetings talking about that and i had thought you know there was some concern that having one at the high school by the nurse's station um because i know where they are

because i look um they they are that's a difficult get to from across even though it's not a big school right so i thought the idea was to maybe have them kind of strategically placed i hadn't heard that conversation i was we had that conversation with the nurses okay yeah i mean

3:37:05

i think this is where uh i guess we probably this is somewhere between or soundly between policy and then procedure um which is that um i mean as as uh i believe if you care pointed out that the American Heart Association

recommendation is much higher, right, to have many more than is required by state law. And I think this policy does not reflect any statement as to, you know, what we're not saying in this policy currently, that we should follow American Heart Association rules. We could do

that at a level of policy, but I think in the context of the conversation, based on what Superintendent Gray said in terms of consulting the nurses on this, that on the implementation side, that was sort of It doesn't matter, I suppose, from the policy. But again, to be clear, if it was the board's pleasure, we could say something in here to say we would like to bring ourselves into compliance with what was recommended by the American Heart Association.

that would be many more. There would be costs associated with that. But again, that probably would drift into where, as Superintendent Gray has often reminded the policy committee to recognize how to keep the policies as simple as possible so it gives the school as much

flexibility as it can to execute that based on the professional expertise of those involved. I'm not sure if that answers your question, Danielle. No, it does. I just had remembered the nurses saying that. so i want them to be comfortable you know again obviously someone can run and get it they can start

cpr if that's what's necessary um i do like the idea of training students i think that's huge um i would advocate that advocate that i think middle schoolers could do it as well i mean the aed is so simple to use um that that's something we could start even then noted yeah i mean i

appreciate that this is saying we have one at least at least one at every school it looks like previously it was like we may buy one for maybe we'll buy one and maybe for use in one of our schools hopefully you're the lucky one at the school that has it um i do think it's a little

unclear that it's a the way it's written um i'm supportive of having one at least one at every school but the rsu5 school department should have at least one aed at each school and may acquire one or more for use in its schools at the end shouldn't it just be should have at least

one aed at each school for use like i'm just i'm just a little confused where it says should have at least one and may acquire one yeah i mean if you care how things are written you know there's this guy on the policy committee who's like driven it in my brain like the words matter Yeah. I mean, again, yes, I think I will own that this was not one that we, you know, put it up to the degree that perhaps we have done others, but, yeah, it doesn't have as much sense, but I think it's good for the board to, I mean, as the chairperson, to sort of, to know it sort of like, you know, is this level of language something that we, do we

like that? Do we like the kind of boilerplate language of that? Or are we after a little bit more concision and saying what we actually mean as a district? It's just a good open question for us to have. Yeah, I guess my one question is, is should strong enough for

us? Or should it be a must? We'll have at least for use in the school and that. I mean, my understanding is the should is from the state. We can change it to, I mean, I don't think we're going to be, I mean, what do we think? I don't think we can find them. We found them, okay? We found them. We know where everyone is. Danielle does. It's an unfunded mandate, essentially, so I think that might be where that language is coming from. It's my guess.

Meaning it's handed to us as an unfunded mandate. Districts that don't have the funds to do it. So I suppose we're doing it. I don't know. Should we be bold? Should we just say, like, will? Should we do it, guys? Yeah. Let's do it. Let's change it to will. Which I think then. I don't know if it will. Oh, no. So I guess as far as then middle school activities,

3:42:20

Maybe that's something the coaches, right? Maybe we could work. Maybe Eric makes sure that the coaches right now where they are at the school. Are the schools always open during middle school sports? They are. Yeah. It's possible that they're not used to. Just, I'm just, you know. Yeah. It would be nice, right, if there was a way. And, I mean, I think most coaches have had keys or somehow to get in, too.

But I don't know. Otherwise, you know, you're going to have the coach carry it around with them. I suppose maybe just a pointed maybe request coming off of what Danielle is saying, if it would be appropriate to say, and we've talked before about board approved policies,

board approved procedures, and then what the procedures are that are not board approved but are available for anybody to take a look at if they want to. I mean, I think perhaps, maybe even for second read, if it would be appropriate to have between the superintendent's office and Eric's office to sort

of say like, all right, well, what actually is the procedure? What is, what is, what is it that we're currently doing? And just to let us know that so that, again, we then know that, and I suppose then can say, sounds good, keep doing it, or like we have some red flags, actually we're

going to policy the bejesus out of this and make things much more strict. We don't love to policy the bejesus out of things. I know you didn't ask me a question, but in addition to the actual unit cost and the installation outdoor cost, nurses, our nurses, are calibrating these once a month,

checking the supplies so every place that there is an AED we also have a nurse in every building that is not the case across Maine we're very fortunate but we do so there is there are costs of acquiring the equipment maintaining the equipment potentially replacing the equipment

and a lot of the pads that go in with the equipment expire they expire with some frequency like once a year so like there are some other costs associated with this and time do you have a sense of are we talking a thousand bucks we're talking ten thousand bucks fifty bucks um probably

like a thousand for replacement to replace the unit oh the unit yeah about i think they're about a thousand they're about uh well depends i've tried to buy one online um they're about two grand like just how about your house yes i wanted to donate it and i was trying to figure out how

okay the outdoor ones are estimated between three and five okay and our narcan is associated with that unit oh so they're all in the same they're attached okay is that an issue if we have students trained that they would have access to the narcan do they have access to the narcan now this is

probably not part of this policy but it's attached to the aed my understanding it's a separate policy, I believe, but I believe under Rule 41, students are trained in in the use of the NARCAN. Both the AED and the NARCAN. The AED and the NARCAN is my

understanding, but that's just from a very cursory look at it, because it's not relevant to this particular policy. Did you have a question? I admit this may be too in the weeds. There's no such thing at this point. Are we stalking pediatric paddles in this

younger schools as well as the regular battles. Yeah, and we have everything in the kits. Good question. Okay, so... Okay, if we change that to will, how do people feel if we change it to will but we leave otherwise the slightly awkward sentence that Michelle was calling attention to?

I mean, if you're going to change it, you might as well believe a couple more words, right, to make it seem... Yeah, will have at least one AED in each school. One AD in each school to... Get rid of that and may acquire one or more.

Yeah, get rid of that and may acquire one or more. Could you repeat that? Because Colin was kind of like teasing me. He watched the film. No, I mean, I think, yeah. I trust that you guys can make that sound... You'll make it sound better than I could. What do you actually want to say? We're trying to... I wanted to say that we'll have at least one AD. I swear to God, we're trying to get more efficient and just like, and like really kind of, this is not, just take out that whole phase.

3:47:22

Take, take out, and may fire one or more AEDs. So, but then you have school, school. Do we have one at the central office? So maybe it's, we'll have at least one AED in each of our buildings for use in schools and school athletic events.

Does that count where the Laughlin outbuilding? Laughlin has an AD in its facility. We will play with this. You guys are very smart. Yeah, you guys are much better at words than me. Did you ask about Freeport Works? No, I said, so if we change it to building, we do meet that standard?

I might question what is the definition of building. I wouldn't say that because then you're talking like the sheds and like the containers. Occupied buildings. I was going to say actually that I am hearing Ginny's voice in my head in a different conversation but say I just hear Ginny's voice in my head don't we all she has said that in a different context the central office counts as one of the schools so I'll check on that but there's always I guess by default that one's the superintendent that's who you're talking to Okay, so what I understand as the directive from the board

is for us to go back and to zhuzh that sentence a little bit in our next meeting to make it just real good. You will have one at every school. I'll stay at the athletic events because they might not be on site. Okay. Well, that's an interesting one, right? Because what if, like, does that mean you have to bring one to other schools?

No, I don't think so. We don't generally bring our trainer to other schools. No, we're relying on that school. other trainer. The host school will have an AED. In theory. Because as it says, it's a state law. Okay. But maybe they're in the should area. Who knows? Well, that's right, because as it's written

now, it sounds like it's required at school athletic events. It doesn't say where. But it only says you should have one. I know. It doesn't say you will. If we change it, it will require. My understanding is the consistency across MPA school sanctioned sports is that they're the host

school does have an aed okay just just for the record in our meeting um is this how your meetings go yeah no in our meeting i was like i was like hey like let's just like really kind of go with the like simplest language possible and kara was like hey you don't know our board like they're

gonna want to get in there and just like you know mess around and get the thingies into all the you of into all the sentences. And I was like, Kara, you don't, you don't, you're not, you really need to give them the benefit of the doubt, you know?

Just, just, what I've kind of written down here is, if I go to that sentence, your SU5 number five school department will have at least one AED at each school and at school athletic events. Okay. That sounds good to me. Let's just make sure that's actually, like, deliverable.

So that assumes middle school as well, then? I think so. But if all of our middle school events are at the school, we don't have any off-site, right? They're all at the two schools. So the question is, are they accessible? I wouldn't guarantee that the door that they're closest to is unlocked.

Or, you know, I think that there are some complexities there that the committee should grapple with. That's a procedural piece. Okay, so again, I guess I will just, I will be policy committee chairperson and say that this is again a moment where I think we really need to understand whether or not we really want to be directing the school professionals to do their jobs

or whether we want to really micromanage what they are doing. Because I think that this is where, again, if I don't, like, we don't seem to know currently all the details of where all of these things are and what events they are at, but I'm not sure how relevant that is to the policy. So I'm just, I would play devil's advocate on that to say I'm not sure how relevant that is to the policy, and do we want to be making those stipulations,

or are we saying the policy's more or less fine? And also, Tom, at the next meeting, could you come and just tell us what we currently do so that then we know? So you're saying you want to keep should and not will? No, no, it's not what I'm saying at all. No, we're talking about athletic events and middle school events and can you get access to it? And the policy doesn't address any of that. I don't think the policy should address any of that. That's a question of, I believe that's a question of procedure if I understand what Superintendent Gray has been training me in understanding.

3:52:51

So that's fine. I'm just asking if the change from should to will is your problem? No, I'm fine with that. And then you can still leave the rest to procedure. As I'm reading this again, I feel like we'll be okay because it says for use.

It doesn't say they have to be at the athletic events. It says we have them in each school for use at these things. Am I understanding that correctly? I think the question I have is, am I hearing that you want one at the athletic events?

whether we have them there or not. And if you do, that's perfectly valid to have in policy, and we'll work on it. We'll get it done somehow. Well, my concern is, as someone who has coached tennis, I know when I'm out there on the court or at another school on their court, like, I know we don't have access to one of these things. But I don't want to put an undue burden on anybody to make sure that they carry one with them at every tennis or whatever event. And what's access, right? is access within hands. It's access within five minutes of running in the building. Like, I guess I'd rather leave it the way it is and then procedurally we can say, like, in this school, he's back to shit. This is starting to feel like the painted tittle conversation of whatever that thing was. That was such a great meeting. I was telling Valerie about that the other day. It was such a cool conversation. Yeah, I mean, it started with, like,

service dogs and we ended up going down reptiles for like three hours here one night so from a school perspective i would say please be really careful about how big you open this up because it starts i remember when we first

got the ad and it was first donated like whatever 14 years ago and it has been updated since then and um but in a lot of situations the first thing someone's going to do is call 911 And if we're not careful, we're going to be saying, well, do we take one when we do fieldwork?

And then we're asking teachers to take more, I mean, we'll take medical kits. But generally, if you can't do a medical kit, if there's a concern, call 911 and get a professional in there. And if we start to say, you got to run to room B or C or whatever space this is, it may be better just to call 911.

one so i just would just caution how far we go because i think sometimes the more we open it up to like well if you said this this and this it infers we should also have said that or covered that i think it's you've got it pretty good well we'll have one in each school facility or school

department facility and then if we want to go you know it's a floor not a ceiling we can go beyond that should we want to but the policy is set yeah that's my two cents worth that's what i'm trying to get to. Like, that's all I'm saying is we will have one in each building. Yes, absolutely. And I

think also just from what, from, again, when, uh, I think as I hopefully said, if I didn't say it was in my notes, um, that this was run by the nurses and they said yes. So again, we're not, in general, we're not going to bring, we will not bring this to you if, if, if, uh, and if we do, then shout

it does mostly Kara but you can also chat me a little bit so just to confirm it's not in the law to have it at school events no no and we are looking though to install it at our major play services surfaces at each building over the course of a year or so Kelly will be looking

for savings to do the installations over time at all buildings okay so we have a motion we have second. We have a lot of conversation. People comfortable with the vote on first read for this one? And just a quick, for Karen's sake, how our policies work. Is there a two-read process? So

first read, we will take a motion, vote, and it'll go back to the policy committee to judge in this case. Sometimes there's no changes necessary. Sometimes it's small issues. Sometimes it's more material. And then it will come back a month later for a second read. And once it's voted on

the second time, then it becomes policy of the district. All right. Any other questions, comments? All those in favor? Great. One down. All right. Do I have a motion for consideration and approval for second read of the following policies and procedures? IHBEA, programs for multilingual

learners jkaa use of physical restraint and seclusion and jkaa are procedures for physical restraint and seclusion valley thank you malik for a second um we bring these before you for second week well i was straight to the point because they're what we showed you before okay

3:58:26

so no just leave space and he'll fill it um okay i uh i wasn't at this meeting so i wasn't sure if there was material changes from first read to second read these are essentially the same so this is the case where there was no road changes karen and now it comes back for second

read and we have a motion and we have a second and i'm not seeing any questions or comments so we'll move it to a week but also just kind of get in there and start messing around a little bit you know just like is that what you're looking for i mean all right all those in favor wonderful

not opposed uh we have no unfinished business that always makes me laugh when we say that I feel like all we have is unfinished business. But we'll move on to new business. And I believe this is going to you, Tom. It is. So I am thrilled, tickled, delighted to be able to bring this opportunity to you,

which I hope that you feel you can support. So as was mentioned earlier in the meeting, at an earlier point in my career, I took the lead on developing an international program at one of my previous schools. It started out with me just being a teacher who took spring break trips with kids.

It actually started with me being a kid who had a teacher who did this for me, and it changed my life. And so it became a passion for me. As a European history teacher, I got to go all kinds of cool places. I could choose any country almost and have a cool historical, cultural event with kids.

It expanded when, in 2008, I became aware of a program through the Goethe Institute, which is a joint venture by the U.S. Department of State and the German Foreign Ministry, to have intercultural exchanges between Germany and the U.S.

And through that program, I developed an exchange relationship with a school in Germany that, well, it continues in that school in Camden to this day. But the model that we used was so successful that we started to develop similar exchange partnerships with schools in other countries.

So what I brought before you tonight is an exchange partner school that I have worked with several times in the past in Segray, France. I know, anybody here been to France? okay so if you are familiar at all with france segre is in northwestern france um if you were

to fly into paris and get on a train and and go west for a few hours you'll end up in the area of segre um it's a small town about the size of freeport um it's located in rolling countryside full of horse pastures and farms um the nearest city of notable size is angers which is oh about

150,000 people, bigger than Portland, smaller than Boston, just a really delightful medium-sized French city. Segrès lies within the province of Maine in France, or Maine, and believe it or not, there is a direct, formal educational relationship between the state of Maine and the province of

Maine in France that is aimed at cultural exchange and awareness, etc. So we have an opportunity to partner with Lycée Blaise Pascal in that city to have an ongoing relationship framed around several different kinds of exchange. One is what we're proposing is the most immediate,

and that is group visits, exchange of group visits. In this model, we would take a group of, I'd say the ideal size is about 20, could be between 15 and 25 kids, probably in grade, who've had French two, three, or four, somewhere in there,

travel with them to France. Each of them would get a host family and a host partner. Each school vets its host families through volunteer, the same volunteer process that we use, background check all the adults in the home, et cetera. The families get to know each other before the actual exchange happens online. So you have kids talking, parents talking with each other, getting to know each other then they travel with a number of teachers who are

the chaperones they would go for April break plus an additional adjoining week of school so they would miss a week of school but what they get in return is this called authentic cultural immersion in the past when I have done this

4:03:30

particular trip and you'll see included in the slide deck there is a sample itinerary that is actually an itinerary I have run in the past The exchange itself was 11 days, and that left a bit of time to take just our group and have a few

days in Paris on our own to explore the city, which seems really worthwhile to do since you're already there. That would be optional. That could be added or not. It's an additional cost. But one of the benefits of doing this is that it's relatively low cost. It's not free,

certainly, but the only thing you're paying for is the travel expenses, the chaperone expenses. You're not paying for hotels. You're not paying for meals. Those are borne by the host families. And then the thing is, we have to reciprocate. So next fall, sometime around late September,

is pretty much ideal. It's when the French kids have a school break. They would come here, and we would give them a similar experience. The experience involves mostly going to school with your partner and shadowing them throughout a school day. That can get a little boring when the classes are in French, but the host schools also provide enrichment things for their guests.

So when we have gone to France, typically every day the host school does a little something. It might be like a special pull the kids out and have them go and work on a public service announcement in the video production room, like in English, or work together on a project with their French peers

about what does each country do better than the other. That's something I've seen happen. They will arrange field trips for us three or four times throughout the experience. We get on a bus or get on the train and go somewhere that's of a local interest. And I've provided some examples of what those have been in the past. We would do the exact same thing when they come here.

And I can honestly say that it changes kids' lives and the relationships that are formed last an entire lifetime. Not everybody gets a best friend out of it. Sometimes you get somebody, sometimes you match with somebody that's not a great match for you. And you learn from that too. Anyway, I've probably talked enough. I hope you get the picture. we do not necessarily need according to our there's a copy of our policy around overnight

trips just for your reference it does not require board approval but i feel that in this case it's best for the board to be aware of this we are looking into the insurance lens of it again i have done this in the past extensively with another school district but i have talked to

our insurance agency, who is putting together specific liability and travel policies for us that the kids would have to buy into. It's not very expensive. Altogether, it's like $250 and $200 per participant that would cover them. Yeah, and we do have other trips. So I think

Freeport Middle goes to Quebec. I mean, it's not as expensive as this, but it's international travel. know dana bisbee here at durham has done trips to spain with the middle schoolers pre-covid um so but did your kid go yeah garrett was supposed to go the year that would hit yeah um so um so i mean

obviously there's there's ways around that yeah yeah there's solutions for that the cost breakdown i've given you is obviously an estimate i do regret to say when i wrote that up i estimated that flights would be a thousand dollars i just looked the other day and to go to paris from

boston this april the cheapest flight i found was 1500 something um it just you know it is what it is when you book them i think it depends on when you book them i just looked at april break for spain and maybe paris is more expensive than madrid but that was significantly cheaper than

that so oh good yeah so as someone who actually did a program exactly like this in high school it is pretty like life-changing um you know not knowing a lot of a lot of international kids growing up in in connecticut it was it was pretty impressive to you know i went and stayed with her

family she came and stayed with my family um it is it is a great opportunity um i wonder how in your previous districts the cost piece because you know we want to make it accessible to as many people as we can? Like, how have other districts tackled that? So I have a bit of a vision here.

4:08:51

The vision couldn't all have, it would take time. It couldn't all happen with this particular exchange. In my other district, first of all, all trips like this required some level of fundraising, and usually the target was to raise enough for one person to go, and it would be shared among

the group. So, I mean, that kind of shaves a little bit off. A longer term vision was that my previous school was an F-1 visa issuing school. I'm not sure if folks here know what that is, but it enabled the school to recruit international students who would pay tuition to come and earn

credit and get a diploma. There are lots of schools in Maine, including some very close to us, that do this but what i really liked and some of them if i'm honest have done this in a way that has been really just about the money um and figuring that money into their regular budget

to try to count on it for to pay for essential things that's not very wise but in this case the the district took all of the tuition money received from foreign exchange students set it side into a scholarship fund. And then every one of our students who went who was economically

disadvantaged usually ended up getting substantial financial support. It wasn't 100%, but it was often close. So it reduced that barrier by a lot. And when I left, we were in the process of putting together a booster, just as we would for the soccer team or whatever, to continue to enhance

that fund excuse me so there are ways that we could build infrastructure around this and there are other partners if this is an idea that fits well there are other partners that we could work with in other countries and it could be a defining aspect of what we offer for kids and I'll make one last pitch like just as I was as i as i was getting close to the zenith this of this program um if we okay so let's just if one

of these exchanges costs let's say it costs thirty five hundred dollars per kid to go what if we decided we're being really visionary that every child got an experience like that at some point in high school okay so that's thirty five hundred dollars per child but it's spread over four years

that's what per year less than a thousand dollars per year and if you compare that to other things that we consider to be a value and spend money on like the athletic program we spend far more on other kinds of enrichments that are great for kids so i think that if we wanted to just start

with trying the concept there's plenty of opportunity over time to grow in ways to build in mechanisms to make this completely equitable. Questions? So I'm sort of unclear on the ask. Are we being asked to approve the relationship or approve the expenditure? I don't think there's

any expenditure on the boards. I mean, other than, no, because the insurance costs would even carry to the... This would be totally self-pay. Okay, thank you. That's what I thought. And then I was a little cloudy for a little bit. And so I figured I would just ask. The ask is to approve

the relationship. I think he just wants to hear my French accent for the motion because he said we don't even have to vote on this. Waste this up. All right, so we'll get a motion on the floor and then if you have additional questions. So consideration, a motion in consideration and approval for the exchange relationship between Freeport High School, I got that one, and Lisée Blaise Pascal in Sangre, France. Not too bad. France. France. Danielle, thank you. stuff other questions or comments you also referred to an eight to ten week

exchange that is a possibility we haven't we're not there yet but you say Blaise Pascal has they have a program of a number of their classes are taught in English especially in their the tech school is actually attached and a lot of

the tech classes are taught in english and if we wanted to we can have one or two of our kids every year go there for eight to ten weeks basically a quarter and we would then it's direct family to family so we would host one of their kids they would host one of ours i did this

4:14:12

in mount view you have to build you have to figure some things out like so our kid is going to go there for a quarter how are they going to keep up with their classes here you know we just figured that out they did it remotely and they stayed is remote education the best no but it's if it's to

afford an opportunity like that it was worth it so if we wanted to take that step that's available to us I just think it's a super exciting opportunity and particularly I love the visioning for how to be more accessible to more students and yeah I think it's fantastic so let's do it and there's a McDonald's in that town so yeah you should google it it's like it's a lovely little town and I just I've been there several times I feel like I can vouch for it it's a safe place it's a really good community it's good people sounds like you already have one chaperone in jen so i don't know who runs the school when she's

doing it but it sounds like a great idea i guess charlie could do it all right any other comments or questions we have a motion and a second on the floor all those in favor all right wonderful uh so the last piece that we have is organizational business item 15

and basically what this is for is to fill the open spots from committees from Maura's departure from the board last month so the current openings current vacancies on committees are facilities strategic communication curriculum and

program development and then professional negotiations I'll put a caveat about professional negotiations we've talked a lot about negotiations tonight in the budget process, that is the support staff negotiations. So professional

negotiations are not this year. So if you ever want to be on a negotiation, that's a good one because it's not meeting. Generally doesn't meet in its off year. So some of them, so strategic communications, professional negotiations, and curriculum and development, we have kind of

teed those up to be two to three board members on them so we don't necessarily have to fill every one of those but if we have folks that are interested in them we would love to love to add those I believe in your packages is all of the

typical information of the what's you know what each one entails when do they meet hopefully folks have had an opportunity yeah and the curriculum um committee we actually month meet we meet monthly okay with erica taking over oh right

because this now says once per trimester so i think that was previous right yeah so now it's monthly is there a specific time or is it just no we well we just kind of pick times our very first meeting a lot of the days are the same day that we actually have uh board meetings

yeah so we met this morning oh okay yeah all right um and then we also have who's on what committee if you don't remember what you're on already so i will i will look to karen first because you don't currently have any committees please don't feel like you need to pick up

everything mora was on because that's a lot um but if anything jumps out at you of interest or or the other committees sometimes we can get people to you know trade um well the curriculum and program development interests me for sure okay um and then if you

want to put me on another one it's fine with me i will learn as i go um i don't know how many you need to be on there's no minimum like expectations um you know certainly not in your first year because it's a lot to get up to speed right um but you know they're uh i think facilities is a

good one um and it meets right before she's she's in sales mode tonight clearly um so that one meets right before a board meeting it alternates the board meeting one is finance before the board meeting and one is facilities so it's kind of convenient yeah what so it meets once a month yep so so if that's one you're

interested in that's a good one and strategic communications is one that's a little bit in flux yeah Steph I would like to be on the strategic communications committee okay it's available and no one else wants it very interested okay so I'm seeing Steph for strategic communications I'm seeing I'm

writing the wrong words oh my goodness I wrote curriculum next to the curriculum committee Karen it's getting late well okay so all right so we'll put Karen for facilities and curriculum we'll put Steph for strategic communications and And then anybody want to, I don't think we even need the third person for negotiations unless somebody's feeling like they want their name down.

4:19:45

Okay, we'll leave that one alone. All right, so then do I have a motion for consideration and approval to make appointments to the following committees? Karen Breer for facilities and operations, Steph Worth for strategic communications, and Karen Breer for curriculum and program development.

Colin, thank you for the motion. Valerie for the second. all those in favor wonderful none opposed public comment we even drove will away oh this is building he's still left um all right well then i would take a motion to adjourn

which i think anna's ready to make all right so anna and valerie all those in favor wonderful thank you guys have a wonderful holiday next week thank you

Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.