Skip to content

TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 28 January 2026

Board meeting · 2 h 52 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →

Computer-made transcript, not a record of what was said. It mishears names and figures and drops short words, such as the "not" in "does not carry". Click a time to hear the recording, which settles any disagreement. The district's minutes are the official record.

23,283 words in 33 five-minute windows.

0:01

good evening welcome to the rsu5 board of directors it is wednesday january 28 2026 we're at the freeport high school we have a excuse me a full board with the exception of the vacant Durham spot. I do believe that the select board has sent out an email, a news blast

to the community today suggesting folks that are interested in the six months between now and when the election would happen in June, there is a process to submit a letter of interest. So I would suggest folks from Durham that are interested in that seek that out through the town office.

it would just be, it's a six, well, I guess five month appointment through June. My sales pitch is that this is a great way to find out if the school board is something you're interested in without committing to a three year term. So you can try it out for six months. And then if you

love it, you just run again in June and we're all in our way. So just want to throw that out there as a reminder for folks who may be watching, because we certainly want to get that spot filled. All right. Otherwise, we have a full board here and we will get started with the Pledge of Allegiance.

While the first budget meeting may be a longer meeting, I have heard word on the street is that on the street at 11 o'clock there's a parking ban and I'm parked on Holbrook Street, so we will definitely be out before that.

You're welcome. All right. So, do I have a motion for consideration and approval of the minutes from the January 14, 2026 meeting as presented, barring any errors or omissions? Valerie, thank you. Kara, all those in favor? Great, none opposed.

Adjustments? Yes, I'm going to ask that we table item 12A, which is consideration and approval to join cohort three of early childhood special education, although I do have some remarks about that that I will make in my report. All right. Look at that, making the meeting shorter already. Thank you, Tom. So we'll move on to item six, which is good news and recognition, so we'll look to Maria for that. Hello. So we have officially wrapped up midterm week, thank God, and we have started semester two.

We had the curriculum fair and senior project meetings today. We have some new classes this semester, and this is the last high school semester ever for our class of 2026. Eighth grade student and family night was last night. We had over 40 FHS student volunteers for tours and club organizations,

as well as faculty from every department there to meet eighth graders and families to share information about FHS. The student leadership committee hosted conversations with students and staff to discuss communication within our community and they will share the data and action steps with the whole school in mid-April and with the board in May.

The one-act rehearsals are in full swing. The show is coming up, so stay tuned. I don't know the dates, so please don't ask me, but it is coming up. The winter sports are approaching the end of their season and spring sports will start in late March.

And we have awesome news that Mr. Greer was selected by the U.S. Track and Field and Cross-Country Coaches Association as a 2025 high school cross-country coach for the year of the state of Maine. We are very lucky to have Mr. Greer as our coach and our teacher. That's all. That's great news. Congratulations. All right. We will move on to item seven, which is public comment. When I walk by the list, I didn't see anybody who'd signed up, but I will.

5:04

Okay. My quick pause. will be another opportunity at the end of our agenda so we will move on to item eight which is the report from the superintendent okay good evening everybody I have a lot to talk about tonight so this has definitely been since

our last meeting a very complex stretch of time for the district with many overlapping issues that have arisen I can I very much appreciate the care and the seriousness with which the board and our administrative team who are here

tonight and the staff have approached, have used to approach this work. Tonight I'm going to be touching on four areas. Excuse me, the first is student and staff safety. Next is early childhood education. Third is the budget. And the last is just the broader context of all of that and how

we're navigating that together. So first with regard to student and staff safety, I need to acknowledge the situation that is going on in our area with regard to the presence of ICE in our area and there have been incidents highlighted in the media there has been

discussion about that I need to acknowledge there is a full spectrum of perspective on that issue and it is not my job and it is not the school district's job to take a position on that as a political debate so that's not what my remarks are aimed at doing but I do feel I have a responsibility to be

honest about what we're seeing and hearing and experiencing here in our district, and that is that there is fear. There is fear here. It is widespread. It's affecting people disproportionately. Some people are very directly affected, and our job as a school system

is to respond to that fear with calm, and that is what we're trying to do. So even if there are incidents that are not occurring on our campuses, which there are not so far, the impact and the anxiety that people are feeling are real. So we have, as I sent out to staff and students and

parents, we have taken a look at our protocols around what to do if people come to the schools. In particular, what to do if non-local law enforcement come to schools. We've reviewed what the law is around that. We've reviewed what our students and staff's rights are. And we have

a protocol in place for how to respond that keeps calm and follows the law and protects people's rights. We have worked very closely to make sure that the expectations are clear and consistent, and we are responding to the needs of individuals as they arise in a very sensitive way.

We are doing everything we can that is within the framework of the policies that we have and the law to support individuals who are directly affected and on a case-by-case basis in a thoughtful way. I want to emphasize that I believe we are as prepared as we can be

in the face of a very uncertain situation, and frankly, an unprecedented situation that I don't think we've ever had to contend with before. We certainly cannot anticipate every scenario. We are grounded in respect and empathy and realism about what we're facing, and we are, again, I want

to emphasize, the job of the adults in the school is to maintain groundedness, and that is what we're striving to do and to be thoughtful rather than reactive. And we're also mindful that our actions or communications could draw undue attention that we don't want to draw. So we're trying to stay the

course and be responsive. Now I'd like to talk about early childhood. So I just tabled. I asked to table another motion, as I did last week, to vote on whether or not to enter the cohort three for early childhood. The reason for that is that I still don't have all the information from the

state that I would need to have to lay before you to make that decision informed. Or I should say, as of the time this agenda was written and finally proofed, I didn't have that information. I can report that at 5.16 tonight, while I was in the Finance Committee meeting,

a very lengthy email came in with all kinds of information, but I need to digest that, and I hope to bring it to you next week. I did receive phone confirmation earlier this morning from Megan Welter, who is the Deputy Commissioner, that the allocation that we should expect to

receive will be about half of what we originally requested. So I need to take a look at that with the team and decide what that means for stepping into Cohort 3. To me, it's very important that, particularly in the context of other items that we will discuss tonight, that we can do this

10:11

without impact to the local taxpayer right now. So I need to look at what they're saying that they'll provide us and figure out how that would enable us to step in to that cohort. And I will bring you more information next week when I have that broken down for you.

We would need to, part of the information that Megan also gave me this morning is that we would need to make a commitment to join Cohort 3 by early March at the latest. It is now late January. And if I think about what lies between us and early March, February vacation is also in

there. So to me, early March really means before February vacation. So that means we have two weeks. So we'll be doing our best to look at this and bring you something to vote on, hopefully next week. That also, I'm mindful that we started this process very deliberately in the hope of being

transparent and inclusive by having a task force. I don't know that within the two-week time frame, we have time to reconvene that task force. But I need to at least communicate with the folks on there and invite them to board discussions that we will have. So that's part of what I need to be transparent about now. The timeline of this information from the state has just given us something to contend with.

If I pause for a moment, are there any quick questions about that before I go forward? Sorry, just quickly, you said half of what we requested. Who is requesting what from whom? So the way that the funding formula for early childhood is supposed to work is that the mandate is that school districts take this over from CDS.

The money that is currently going to CDS for these services is supposed to be diverted to school districts. And when we did the work with the task force at first, the state gave us a spreadsheet to work with that calculated what we were supposed to get.

and it was Kelly who discovered a couple weeks ago that their spreadsheet actually had a calculation error embedded in two cells, and those cells were what made it look like we were going to get a million dollars when actually it looks like we're going to get about a half a million dollars. So we have to figure out how to make it work with that reduction. Thank you. Okay, let me talk about the budget.

So we're obviously going to talk about the budget a lot tonight. I want to talk about this very carefully and with a lot of empathy. This has been, this is going to be a challenging conversation, and it's going to be a heavy conversation.

First of all, the staff across the district have, just within the past few days, received news about what the budget, what the impact is likely to be on individuals. There has been great professionalism shown throughout that process.

I really have to thank the people sitting back there, the administrative team. They, for months, we've been talking about this. We've been brainstorming about this. We've been thinking about how to approach it. They've been empathetic. They've been extremely collaborative thought partners.

And they did something, every single person on that team did something which is very difficult, which is to step back from your own lens, the lens of your domain, your building, your school, your whatever, to look back and see what the impact across the board is.

And that can be very, very difficult to do. But it is the lens that we kept as a group, and I'm very grateful for that. the staff have also been very steadfast as information has been shared and I'm grateful for that too because in moments like this again I return to a theme of

groundedness it's the groundedness of the adults in the system that helps coat the kids co-regulate and I'm very grateful when staff even when they have gotten bad news or difficult news have really come forward for their work with

kids with professionalism the fact that we are here this evening again I want to make sure everyone understands, it means that the individuals who would be directly affected by the changes that I'm going to describe in detail tonight have already been informed by

their immediate supervisors. That's the people who would be immediately affected. And obviously, those are not easy conversations. I do have to add in full transparency that the ripple effects of these changes cannot be fully anticipated at this time. And that's simply because between now

and the end of the school year or even the end of concluding our budget discussions, there could be any number of things happen. There could be retirements. There could be resignations. There could be things that affect the jobs that are available. So that will obviously mean different conversations would have to happen.

15:31

I also want to take this opportunity before I present the budget later tonight to just gently remind everyone why we're here talking about the budget the way we are. We have to look systemically at our budget. We also, systemically means two things

to me. It means a view to the organization as a whole, and it means an eye toward not just next year. It means an eye toward the long term. It is also, when you see my slideshow tonight, what will naturally pop out are specific positions that are up for discussion to be reduced. What I

to emphasize is that behind every one of those positions that you see listed hours of conversation around what are we maintaining everything that's listed there is listed because it has come after many discussions of about here's what we need to keep and here are the ways that we can keep what

is most essential and that includes things like keeping our first grade second grade kindergarten etc within reasonable class sizes it means keeping supports for the neediest students And so I feel that that lens is really important to emphasize going into it.

We are talking about reductions, but on the flip side of that, we're really talking about what we're keeping, what our choices will enable us to maintain. You will see that in my recommendation tonight. And the themes that we emphasize are keeping the class sizes

within policy guidelines in each school and at each grade level. And I want to talk a little bit more about our process for doing that. We have more than doubled the amount of hours that are typically spent by the administrative team to consider the budget.

We have deferred other conversations that have needed to happen because we had to talk about this a lot. The first conversations were using the staff feedback to establish criteria for what was most important to preserve.

And then we applied those criteria to the situations we found. Because as Colin recently said, budget is a moral document. So we really tried to ground it in criteria that were established from input from the staff. And we're keeping the long view in mind. And part of why the rationale that I need to articulate is that we need to position RSU-5 to be able to anticipate what will come not just next year, but in future years.

We need to be able to, if I take early childhood as an example, we need to be able to be sure that we can do early childhood in a way that we feel good about. And we may very well need to have the flexibility financially to do that in future years. We need to position ourselves to be able

to do that. We need to think about buildings that we may need to build in the future and being able to do that. We may need to think about programs that we haven't even envisioned yet because the world has not changed in a way that we can have thought about them yet, but they're out there.

We just need to be on firm footing to be responsive and flexible in that way. Some of that work has already been done, and part of what I want to emphasize in this budget is that there are many forward-thinking ideas that you all, and I have to give a lot of credit to Kelly, have already

started on. We have a very forward-thinking energy audit that is keeping our buildings where we need them to be. We have a vehicle replacement plan that is very forward-thinking and responsible. We have reserve accounts for many major capital pieces of infrastructure. That's really important.

Not every district has those. That's a good, solid place to keep building upon. So the budget, I hope, I can tell you that when we talk about the level of budget that I will recommend, it keeps, it will still provide, it will provide a robust education for kids. It will keep multiple

offerings for kids and it will support kids where they need it the most. And it will position us to go forward in the future with stability in mind. So you will see tonight when I present three budget tiers, the three tiers that you asked for back in November. A status quo budget is over 10%

and I don't know how that shakes down in each town, but it doesn't necessarily shake down that at 10% in each town. It could very well be more than that in certain towns. You've asked for roughly 8%, 7%, and 6%. My recommendation is the 7% tier. It's tier 2. It's the middle tier.

20:51

And I'm also going to tell you very strongly that I will present you the lowest tier, which is a 6% increase. I do not recommend that tier. As you'll see, what we would need to do to get there is pretty extreme. So I want to make it clear. It's more an academic exercise for me to present

that rather than a recommendation. It is not recommended. So just to zoom out a little bit, this is a moment that tests, it's not just a test of our finances, it's a test of our relationships. And honestly, the way that any organization makes decisions is what defines

the relationships. That's true in an organization, it's true in a family, it's true in a partnership. The way you make decisions together is in fact diagnostic of what your relationship is. So I go forward hoping that even though I anticipate disagreement

about the proposal that will come forward, because that would be healthy, we will continue to approach the work collaboratively and with care for each other and a commitment to what is best for kids and to working through that.

So I'm grateful for all of you who are engaging with this thoughtfully and professionally and under strain and for the community that they are trusting us to do this even when the conversations are hard. Okay. Thank you. And I do also have a new hire to report. Nate Walrath is coming on board as an

EdTech here at Freeport High School. Great. All right. So that is item eight. We'll move on to item nine, which is Kelly with our finance administrative report. So in your packet this evening is the, are the revenues and expenditures through December 31st, 2025. Believe it or not,

it's halfway through our fiscal year and as you can see on the revenue side we are almost directly even on that as far as what we expected the expenditure side we're still healthy and on track even though it looks at like the eight point

eight percent number that you see that's largely because all of the salaries and benefits for the employees throughout the district are included in the encumbrance numbers so it's really reflecting what we anticipate spending

through the end of the year the other the other numbers that are within those are some debt service commitments and some other open purchase orders that we haven't paid the invoices for for supplies materials and all of those

things that the schools live off of so at this point I do not see any foresee any issues with the current budget as it stands questions for Kelly don't go far I'm sure we'll have questions for you tonight all right so we will move on

to item 10 which is board comments and committee reports the first is board information exchange and agenda requests I know we have a few of the finance facilities and policy are going to give a report but just wanted to

provide an opportunity for either requests information from board members or members of other committees that wanted to provide an update I just have a very brief non-update update um from region 10 we still haven't heard back on this from the state

on our three submissions for funding so were they grant fund requests or yes i think so they were the building fund requests where you submit and then they partially fund and then we would have to fund the rest via probably some sort of town vote so similar to uh and maybe this isn't a fair

question for you since I don't think you're on the board when we did this. The bridge that they did. It is, yeah, they kept mentioning the bridge. It's exactly the same kind of process. I wasn't there, but they kept referring to it. Which is really just the entrance to region 10.

It sure is. Yeah, so I don't know why they call it a bridge, but they do. It was confusing to me until I actually went to site, and I was like, oh, this must be better. Yeah, so it's an elevator, a sawdust removal system and a third thing that i do not recall but i'm sure it's very important

and do they have a deadline for when they would have to have the approval from the state and because i my recollection was it had to go on to the ballot that we did in june so i think they were trying to get the referendum out uh off cycle because the elevator maybe needs to happen over

26:03

this summer while children or students are not in session. So my understanding is the state said by February, which is rapidly dwindling in time. So I don't know. I haven't gotten any emails updating, but we're hoping to have something soon. Okay. Well, more to come on that one,

it sounds like. It's an apt description of a non-update update. So there's an update there. it's just we don't have all the info yet it's a common thing tonight uh any other updates comments all right so um item 10b was the finance committee and facilities and operations joint meeting um

you doing that one kelly well i thought you're gonna do both um okay so um part of we we did a joint facilities and operations committee along with finance in December one because there's only one board meeting in December so one of them would have had to miss out on their meeting and two it was a good opportunity to sort of bring those two groups together and by two groups I mean

Kelly and I are on both so we were already there anyway but the other members of those of those committees to talk about the energy audit and the phasing of that and what the financial impact of that is. So we talked about, you know, what phase two looks like, what's included in

phase two. One of the, I think, good things that was built into the system was kind of a bit of flexibility that as things arose in terms of importance or need to be fixed, they could be moved around through the phases. So some things we thought were going to be in phase two got moved

to phase one and vice versa so Glenn was able to give us an update on those along with the vehicle and equipment replacement plan similarly how those are moving into their next steps and we started the discussion on the the tennis

court replacement with an update on how that RFP slash Q RFQ went and so that went out and was received back at that point the this the district had not yet met with the winning bidder who at the time was the who was the only bidder on

that project CHA architects but since then there has been updates and meetings and Kelly will talk about that in the finance or excuse me in the facilities report from January and then the other thing we talked about which we have

talked about here at the board because we approved a transition excuse me a transfer from the capital reserve for the FA the FHS pumps the variable flow something I don't sorry Glenn I messed it up variable flow device there it is so

so we talked about that in the need for those which then came to the board for an approval which was done so it was really an update on kind of how phase one went and then the work on phase two that's ongoing this was in December I

know in over break a variety of projects were actually able to be done and my understanding is the lights are arriving and some of the schools are getting done so oh that's seniors okay so we'll just kick it over to Kelly for the rest of it

facilities and operations committee met on the 14th of January and the vast majority of our meeting time was spent discussing the updates to the FHS tennis courts Glenn Reynolds reported as has already been mentioned that CHA was the one and only bidder respondent

to the bid for the engineering and design services Glenn did meet with representatives from CHA to discuss the scope of work they submitted a proposal for engineering design services and project management for the construction of the courts and they

recommended replacing the three existing asphalt courts and potentially adding a fourth court if feasible with post tension concrete construction because in In their research, the post-tension concrete provides the best overall quality in terms of durability, longevity, and overall upkeep.

However, there was some concern that the cost of post-tension courts may be more than our district can bear. So some committee members and some guests expressed concerns about that and requested that we also ask the vendor to give us pricing for design and construction of asphalt courts,

31:17

which I understand they will do. They will provide that at no additional cost. Next, Glenn did talk to us a little bit about the Energy Audit Phase 1 project update, which is that we are actually now, and I think probably by now,

have installed the new energy-efficient lighting at Poundell Elementary School. Also, a new fire panel has been installed at Poundell, and fire protection devices have been added at Durham Community School. Finally, an update on the capital project list.

Glenn shared that over the December break, they were able to replace some bathroom flooring in the boys' bathroom at Moore Street School. solve a little odor problem in there so that's about all we talked about questions on finance

or the facility committee updates okay so we will move to policy uh good evening the policy committee met on wednesday january 8th via google meets um we looked at a couple different policies one um for law change uh which is the jicj which we're bringing to you uh for second read um tonight

And we also discussed, as part of regular review, G.I.C.K. and G.I.C.K.R., bullying and bullying administrative procedure, which we are bringing to you for a first read tonight, and I'll speak more about each of those later.

We also looked at GBCC, employee use of cell phones, but there were no changes made to that policy, so we're, as per our usual deal, we're not bringing them before you. Or we are. I think it's included just for information purposes. Yeah, but we're not reading it. We're not first or second reading it, is I think what I meant. But thank you, Kara. Thanks for keeping me honest.

Love, Colin. that's the end of that report brief pause move on to the next okay so do you want me to get a motion on the floor for first are we doing them all together yes okay we can pull one out no which one but if we had to we could um so all right we'll get a motion on the floor for do i have a

motion for consideration and approval of second read for the following policies jicj student use cell phones and other personal electronic devices, EBCF, automated external defibrillators, AEDs, and EBBD, temperature standards in schools. Stephanie and Kelly, thank you. Great, so we bring

before you these three policies for second read. I will just skip for the moment to EBCF and EBBD. We did not make any changes to those policies after first read. So you're seeing them as we discussed them previously. We did, however, make a number of changes to JICJ, the student use of cell phones and other personal electronic devices.

I guess the history lesson is we talked about this in, was that December? November? December? And we had a good chinwag about that and heard a lot of great feedback from the students and from the community. And you gave us a lot of feedback as well. And we went back and reshaped that. So that is what we're bringing to you tonight.

I have a relatively lengthy kind of breakdown of what we changed. But I thought I would just maybe sort of begin with anything that jumped out to any of you that you noticed, and we could talk about that first. Like a quiz of what did we notice? What's that? It's like a quiz, like what did we notice? Well, it's more, I just don't want to, I don't want to, it's like a lecture, and I don't want to deliver a lecture.

We love a new lecture, Colin. So I just want to make sure one thing I, I believe I understand this change, but want to confirm, um, was, uh, in that first paragraph, the, or without internet or cellular was struck through my, my recollection of that decision was around allowing, um, earbuds because they don't have their own direct connection to the internet, but could be used to, for students with their, with their laptops, et cetera, based on some feedback.

36:24

is that is that inaccurate maybe not I'm not sure that's accurate my recollection of that was more for because if we kept if we kept or without it would have meant like a whole collection of electronic devices that do not have internet but are still student-owned personal electronic devices

so I my recollection though everyone please jump in here and correct me was that that was not key to that discussion, but I may be misremembering that. That was not one of my lecture notes. Maybe Valerie remembers. My note is that it would be up to the schools to decide on the headphones. I remember two specific points. One was the headphones and that it would be pretty obvious if somebody was trying to make a call on their headphones because of shouting. And how headphones generally work when you're using them without the device itself um but also because it would preclude things like a pedometer or a calculator or

numerous other things that are kind of the resurgence of the walkman i believe i believe the walkman was brought up she's getting one yeah i think we're bringing back the abacus i think we're in trouble with the without garbage yeah and i think we mentioned kindles specifically

devices so you do have internet access yes that's true you know real old ones that I have so I think just I think of the a point that will keep coming up tonight no doubt is that there are changes that we made to this based on

what the one on what you said but also based on what we feel is appropriate and what we thought the board told us what the board feels comfortable making as policy and then what is left to the administrators to make decisions about

and so again I'll just say at the beginning of the conversation just so it's clear there's nothing in here about the presence or absence of pouches that is a decision that will be will be left up to the administrators to to decide

and then there will there would be a cost if we were to go that route but but that would then be proposed. But we're not putting anything in here that directs that one way or the other. So I just want to be clear about that. So yeah, just to your very particular question, no, the or without conversation was not, that strikethrough was not to allow for earbuds.

That would still be a decision that would be made by the administrators. Okay, but they are not specifically precluded like the watches and the phones are. I think that is accurate. Yeah, that is accurate. You look like you were going to put your hand up, Maria. Are there other noticings from others?

I do think it read better this way because I know you kind of moved things around and separated things out a little bit differently. It felt to me that it flowed better this way. That's good. That's positive. Tom did that, but I helped him do it.

No, I didn't at all. Teamwork makes the dream work. Other reflections or thoughts. As I said, I can go through some of these things just to make sure that it's in the air of what we were thinking about? We have gotten some feedback specifically around the watch piece, and maybe it's helpful to talk to the decision to include those in this policy

because they do have, I mean, they do have, if they're functional other than as a watch, then they have access to the Internet and cellular service. And while some parents may have special modes they can put on, that's not something that could be governed like student to students like

you wouldn't want someone having to check like the mode and because you could go in and you know make it so they can call anybody or you know you can set what those parameters are and the thought around you know communications

going through the office and through the emails seemed seemed appropriate and thank you for pointing out that this doesn't dictate how these are you know how this policy is implemented school-to-school so it doesn't say anything about requiring yonder bags I guess we couldn't make the guarantee

that we would never do that but it's not part of the policy that would be in the school's decisions on how they wanted to implement the policy so that is that is not a part of this policy that we're voting on today so I think that's that's

41:30

helpful to know again I don't think you know correct me if I'm wrong but I think in our policy meeting we were not talking specifically about whether to include smart watches or not I think that in that conversation had happened

here so I think the the logic that you just articulated was the logic that we were taking into it I think again how that would actually play out depends upon the depends upon the decisions the administration makes I think one thing

I would remind us of is that we are trying to one of the goals the the primary goal in this policy is to most first is to provide clarity the second is to create a healthy learning environment for the students and then lastly we want also to make

things easier for the staff to be able to do their jobs efficiently so I think part of the conversation we were having around smart watches was if we start sort of including other items that do have these capabilities that's creating more work for the classroom teachers or anybody who is

uh just in the school and having to police that that's one of the things we are trying to not have to do would you say that's accurate tom and chris and care um other thoughts does um i think i know the answer to this question but uh does the recommendation from the governor last night

to put a legislative bell-to-bell ban in place starting in august change how we look at any of I don't believe so. I mean, that's kind of fresh off the, I mean, slightly older than your 5.16 p.m. email from the Department of Ed, but... Not 24 hours yet. But yeah, I mean, I don't know. I mean, it would seem to me to be that would be a relatively quick-moving legislative process for that to be done by August.

Maybe government is magic, and that will... They know it to be. that will occur um other but i don't i don't think so i mean i think i think if we if we were to if we if we were to pass this tonight and if it uh goes into effect uh july one one um i think we're

perfectly primed for that so um the good news is we don't have to do like we're not caught now with the possibility um like there's some districts that will not have done this and will not have will not be in a place and then they might be like they would really hope that government will will not be efficient because they're not going to be ready for that August date that the governor

gave. Okay. I thought that was the answer, but just wanted to... Yeah. One thing that might be different going forward is that, is how it's implemented. Since this, I believe the state will be providing funding, they'll have some funds for schools to be able to implement this. So that

is still to be determined and might impact how schools are choosing to do that. Kelly, if you wouldn't mind checking their spreadsheet before we spend that money sorry I'm a little cautious about what the money from the state comes yeah Tom is there

anything else that you want to just highlight from the conversation from being from kind of the administration's I think the only thing that's worth mentioning and it dovetails with the presentation I'm going to give later is that we have we're not planning on entering this with yonder bags and we're

not budgeting for yonder bags so right so yes I think practically again for everyone keeping track at home that like if this were to be passed tonight and to go into effect July 1 then at the beginning of the school year it would be

an off and away situation and so then that would be what the some some version of that, rather than a yonder bag. Again, it's not a binary, but it's not, however adorable they are. I'm just glad it's not the one that I couldn't open repeatedly during that meeting.

Yeah. And the other thing is worth mentioning, it's not this policy, it's the one that's actually not up for being read. It's the one about employee use of cell phones that's in your packet. The committee reviewed it, and really the only reason it went before the committee was because Val had suggested actually in a board meeting that we should look at that while we're looking at the student policy just to make sure that we are consistent. And so we looked at it. It is consistent. We don't need to change it. But we've done our due diligence. Other thoughts or things that we could talk about?

46:45

Yeah, Kelly. I think overall it's a really great policy. I think you've done a lot of great work on this. And I just had a couple of comments on some of the sections and whether or not they flowed under the subheadings. In particular, staff modeling is under prohibited uses of electronic devices,

and if we're going to include that section at all, I'm wondering if there's a better place for it. Similarly, with responsibility for personal devices, it's under parent-student communication and responsibilities, and while I can see how that could potentially fit there, Maybe it would belong under the guidelines or somewhere else.

Sorry, Kelly, I got lost in the prairie bead uses. What was the second point? The second point was that the subheading responsibility for personal devices is under parent-student communication. Right. Yeah, both good catches. Anybody have any ideas where they want to put those things? I think the second one is okay. It's parent-student communication and responsibility. So I think responsibility for personal devices. that's true that word does connect yeah yeah I can see that logic I think it

also could belong under the guidelines section I mean I guess if we're if we're getting wonky there are only there are only three top-level headers right isn't that true there's the guidelines for those guidelines prohibited and parent

student communications so I think I think tech I mean I guess just technically the the modeling doesn't neatly fit into any of those um so probably if we wanted to maintain the three of them i would probably recommend putting it in the first just because

it's the most kind of like broad and kind of overarching um so that's one possibility yeah well i was just wondering parent student does that modify both communication and responsibilities and if not should we put responsibilities first and would that make it make more sense in that

section um that is doing it refers to it is modifying both but it is doing different work so that's actually kind of it for anybody for any english teachers uh like uh because it's like you know it's just like parent student is like that part is about like how do parents and students

yeah let's not uh how do parents and students communicate because that was a concern that was that was raised it was an important one that was raised by the students like how like how do they get in touch with their parents so that's what that is about but

then I think parents student responsibilities I think that does apply as well I think it's sort of it's noting that it is but it is but it is a parent and student decision to allow the device to come to to campus and the

responsibility um lies with them so so the dash is a two in one case and an and in another case so what which dash so parent so it would be parent to student communication and then parent and student responsibilities would that be a true statement i'm just trying to parse this

yeah sure um i mean bless you guys but also like we have other we have other things that we have other stuff to do. So I would say unless that truly substantively alters the meaning and is going to confuse any parents or students, I would

say let's leave that as it is. And I think one of the things we've done in the past, even after a second read vote, is sort of grammatical slash clarity edits were within your purview as the policy committee. So if you felt the slash versus the dash versus the ampersand, I trust you guys. Thank you. Thank you for that punctuation gift. You're welcome. We'll have a whole meeting on it. Other thoughts? I think this means you did a good job with the policy.

We aren't talking anymore about it. Also, I just wanted to give credit where credit is due. We were joined by will cross the principal gulko for that meeting and get and they gave us some really helpful sort of on-the-ground feedback in terms of understanding the

51:56

impact and I think one of the takeaways and against me can throw something at me if I'm saying this incorrectly the general sense from principal Crosby was that the in like the the change that this makes to practices at the middle

school or and I think probably that is also true at Durham community school would be negligible, um, because it's not, there's not, like, there are, like, it's tightening some screws, but it's not really changing things substantively. It is changing things substantively

at the high school, um, and I think that, uh, I think one note I had in my, um, notes, uh, was just that, uh, no one is under any, um, uh, any illusion, um, that, uh, there is great support for this among the student body. That's known, that's understood, and I think that Principal Golko

feels that it's the policy that makes the most sense, she supports it, and that we will find a way to implement it in a way that is fair and supportive of the students. Yeah, and I'm hopeful that the sort of the off and away approach is kind of a middle

ground a lot of what we heard from the students is you know sort of a pushback to the to the restrictiveness of the of the yonder bags or some other tool like that so I mean my hope is that an off and away policy can be managed and

implemented without adding more to the teachers plates of policing but also reaches the goal of you know that removing that distraction so hopefully hopefully that's seen as somewhat of a of a middle ground there yeah and I think

one of these we did discuss in that meeting was that the the the minds of several committee members were changed by the the testimony that was given by students and so just again like that is just it's a very important thing for so

we're so happy that the students came and voiced their concerns and even though the the final result is not um what uh a number of them desired um we did hear that and we did make adjustments um based on that feedback any other comments or questions on this policy okay

so aeds we didn't make any i thought we did that one twice did we already do that one twice or did we table it just one word oh right we went from should to will but we're now coming back to should okay yeah yeah valerie um i hate to be the thorn in everyone's side but when you're in aed

it's pretty dire i feel like we should make it well and i know we got an email stating that will is not possible in the event that we need to use it there's a lag period where we don't have paddles anymore and i'm wondering if it's possible to have a spare set of paddles at the

district officer somewhere so that we can achieve will because i assembling health care um i would be loathe to not be able to use an aed because we're in that gap time when we need it erica has a comment erica mateo assistant superintendent so um we've already discussed as a nursing team

to purchase a backup set um so that they can be replenished as needed if used or expired juvenile and adult so will is then possible can we go back to will i just point you at will that's a retirement joke are you talking to me are you talking to me um yeah i i agree it should

it should be will i agree with will um as i always do um um and if it's it's possible and feasible i mean even if the policy says will and for some reason there is a moment in time where we don't have one i mean policies are are what we're striving to be i mean they are not the law they

56:57

are not held us you know we could be like well you have a policy that says you're going to do this and you didn't do it so i mean i think this is will have at least one at each school right like i think we adjusted to say like not at every like event or field or whatever because that was

challenging based on locations but i mean if if um assistant mateo and the nurses feel like will is uh doable i think that's what the policy should be unless i'm missing something as i recall one of the concerns was that there may be legal ramifications if we were not able to meet

will at any given point in time but what i'm hearing from you is that this document isn't legally binding so if we couldn't for whatever reason meet will we wouldn't be yeah i mean i think i think if you if if we had a policy that says we will have one in every school and you went

every school we didn't have one that's we probably have a problem there as if we say we will have one in every school and we have one in every school but one because we just used it that seems like a very different thing to have to go to court and be like oh you're you're liable for that i mean i

i don't know maybe that's an attorney question but i think i'm not an attorney but i think actually as wonky as this is going to sound and is in the weeds as it is where we might actually get into trouble is if we threw in shall, which does have... Really? Just throw another one in?

It does have a different connotation. Okay, so shall's out. Can I retire from the board right now? Is that possible mid-meeting? I think Will is fine. Okay, we have heard Will is what we are going to do we will have it okay so that word is now going to be will just spelled W I L L I think

okay then we have EBBD temperature temperature standards for schools this also we did change We changed loser to lower, which I'm disappointed in, and I would just use this opportunity to say I've only been to a couple of town council meetings, but the town council meeting I did go to, there was a town ordinance that was under discussion, and it was a very long one, and I was going through it, and there's a typo in one of them that's so beautiful.

that I didn't point it out. So it's still there because it's so delightful. It doesn't impact anyone's livelihood or safety or anything like that, but it is a very beautiful typo. Any other thoughts about EBBD? I don't think I asked this before, but maybe because Glenn wasn't here, but I assume this is one that he's weighed in on and feels like we can meet. Yes? Yes. Yes. This was done under advisement that's okay yeah valerie i have no additional edits except a tiny joke

look what i've done or maybe loser to winner since it's the gym yeah i like that that's a good joke that's a good joke tom can you make an oh that joke please thank you all right uh and anything else on ebbd okay so we have a motion and a second on the floor for all three of those

policies uh for approval for second read any yes yeah oh we already have the she's ready to vote she's ready to vote she's moving on she's thinking about that parking down all right um can we vote with the going back to will yes yes with the adjustment yep and then kelly we will

your category categorization is that a change that can be made after we vote i think so yes Yes, we can shift that around. Yeah, I think as long as it's not substantive and as long as we are not going against the will of the board

or making a decision that is substantively impacting the board's direction. I agree with that. All right, we have a first and we have a second. All those in favor? Opposed? You can vote. Yeah. Okay. Sorry we never told you that.

Oh, actually, this is now back to you for the first read. All right, so the next one, if I can find my agenda. All right, so these are for first read. So do I have a motion for consideration and approval for first read for the following policies?

1:02:11

J-I-C-K, bullying, and J-I-C-K-R, bullying administrative policy, or excuse me, procedure. Chris and Anna, thank you. So we'll be bringing J-I-C-K, bullying, and its accompanying procedure up before you. This was a policy that we were looking at, not out of direct legal requirement.

It was part of our cycle of review. And we've spent a great deal of time on this one. And also I will give, as the children today say, mad props to Superintendent. Well, they do. They definitely do. They have their Walkmans on. And they say that. That's what Superintendent Gray told me. I retired for the second time this evening.

Yeah, exactly. It's finished. It's over. At 7.33 p.m. on January 28th in Freeport, it was killed. But as we looked at the credit I'm giving to Superintendent Gray is that he went very deep both into the existing policy and also looking at a number of sample policies and found some areas that we really did need to update.

And I'm just going to read a couple of notes here. So the current, the policy that we did have, we found that there were some statutory gaps. So there were some things that were there were 11 mandates that are made clear in the sample policies

that come from two different directions, from the law is where it's coming from. And our current policy, as it had been written, needs six of those, and we needed to update it, so it meant all 11. So the deficiencies were around no mandatory staff reporting,

no investigation procedure, no appeals process, no parent communication, and no definition of alternative discipline, even though it is mentioned. So that was what we were addressing. Our policy also doesn't currently define what we mean by school grounds. That was also part of the discussion. But Superintendent Gray, I think, because he thought he was beating up on us for our earlier work, he did say, and this is the word he used, that our policy was superior. in one really important way.

And that had to do with the way we were addressing language around gender and sex. And so that remains. I'm going to give a pause there. Anything else on that? Okay, so anything else, anything that jumped out to folks? Kelly, I did have your note around some of the replication of language

between the policy and the procedure. We can circle back to that. As I said, that, I think, came from a desire to just make sure things were super, super consistent because in some of the procedure and policies, they were super, super not. So we wanted to make sure they were. Any other thoughts or reflections? I was trying to wrap my brain around page two

in sort of that big section three there bullying and cyberbullying defined so bullying includes but is not limited to a written oral or electronic expression or a physical act or gesture any combination thereof directed at a student or students that one so basically one is uh physical

or fear of physical harm right two is interferes with uh accessing their education so fear intimidation hostile educational environment right so one is physical two is more psychological I guess or three is based on perceived characteristics so the the or I'm trying to come up with a

scenario of what would be three that's bullying but isn't one or two because it feels like physical psychological or anything related to protected classes so like so like what would like i can't even come up with an example so i'm a is my question super unclear i don't know i

1:07:18

in practical terms yeah i think your question is totally valid i don't know if it helps this is basically right out of the statute so part of the strength of the revision is that it just mirrors the language of the bullying statute that was updated a few years ago.

So, and part of actually what prompted this policy to be reviewed is that last year you reviewed and updated the harassment policy and the older definition, the existing policy for bullying that we have on the books does not have congruent language about protected classes in it that's consistent with the new harassment policy. policy. So that was what originally flagged it for me. It's like, oh, we should at least have this be consistent with the harassment policy in that regard. And then we did the

deeper dive around all of the updated statutory requirements for the bullying policy. So here's my example. And the way I read this, this is considered bullying according to this policy. You are 12 years old. If I send you an email that say, or I tell you that you are 12

years old I have now done an oral expression except age is not listed it is a it is actually personal character I'm only gonna I'm not going to stop you but I'm just going to say that I just I just brought up the legislature and that

language is just exactly drawn from that is exactly what it is so again I'm fine being in compliance with the law because you know I'm a world follower but that seem weird to anyone am i am i misreading the law that like if i tell you you're 12 years old

i am now bullying you and can be can be punished accordingly yeah well it's i mean based on something that has to be physically harming or perceived as physically harming like no that's that's it's or so it's physically harming or psychologically harming or related to any

characteristic about you this might be a simplification but essentially like the word bullying is not repeated in one two or three mm-hmm I think it's implied that this is but this is a mission of bullying it has to fit into one of those

so the way I read this if it if anything I say falls into item three that is considered bullying so anything specific to your personal characteristics including your age i i don't disagree with you i think my point my the point i'm trying to make

i think uh we'll see uh is that um like two would apply to that too like there's nothing that says bullying in two it's just you're interfering but you're creating an intimidating or a hostile environment right like that feels like bullying so if you if you keep reading b so 3b um a

student's association with a person with one or more of these actual or perceived characteristics or any other distinguishing characteristics, and that has the effect described in subparagraph one or two above. Okay, is that clarifying? Okay. Yeah, good call, Kara. Identified and

associated with... Okay. All right, so then you're back to the causing physical harm or intimidating hostile. I'm not sure why we have two A's there, though, for B. AA students. I love that you actually added the second A. Like, it's not like it was already there. You added that and underlined

it. It's really important. It's really important A. Yeah, I think that, I think Kara solved it. I think maybe the only other thing I would add to that is probably if we sort of go deep into that from a couple of different perspectives, it's sort of like if the victim, if the victim feels

bullied, then they are bullied. And it's not, it's not raising questions around what it is about. And so, again, I think that's where, if you start, I think if we start saying, well, like, age, then we can start saying, well, like, hairstyle, really?

You know, like, it's sort of like anything that the individual that fits into this. So I think it's, I think that's also the logic, is that it's not like we don't get to choose, or the bully doesn't get to choose, which are the appropriate characteristics that they can be bullied for.

It would be sort of my interpretation of that. If I'm correct, hairstyle... is actually specifically mentioned no that's why I mentioned it yeah no that's why I mentioned it but that's where it's so like again if we sort of start picking them out and say well how could

you possibly bully somebody about this probably I mean my point was was like it didn't say it had to have any I mean or or or was like there was no necessarily negative impact of saying it was just that that extra line being on the next page was easy to miss okay yeah I think I'm good no

1:12:33

Good call. I'm glad you brought that up, Michelle. That's really important that we talked about that. Thank you. Yeah, Valerie. Just to button it up in my mind, I'm perceiving the third point to be kind of akin to what somebody might frame for themselves as teasing another friend, whereas the friend might feel negatively impacted. It might not be that they are physically harming or threatening.

They don't meet these criteria, but... Yeah, I mean, again, the language we're using is drawn from the statute, so again, we could muck around with it and alter it. No, I'm not suggesting that. No, no, no, just what I'm saying, just so everybody's clear,

we always have the right, as a school board, to mess around with language, and we can change language that is against statute. We can do that. We're just going to get our ass sued. So we can do that. So just to be very clear, like if we don't like something, we can take it out or we could do that, but then we would be opening ourselves up for liability.

And there are school boards that are currently being sued. And yeah, let's not do that. Yeah, I'm just trying to figure out for myself what could be. Yeah, I couldn't take you down that particular rabbit hole. Wonderful. So I was curious about the examples you guys included. Those were all new ads. Did those come from sample policies? Okay. I mean, a lot of them make a ton of sense, right? You know, involuntary loans, donations, extortion. The one that I thought, I was wondering, maybe from a principal perspective, including the not limited to gossip, spreading rumors, or social exclusion.

So I'm curious if, you know, if I could make a bullying claim for my child because someone didn't want to play with them. Like, is that what this means? Is that what principals expect to see? Am I oversimplifying? So the answer is you could. Okay. You'd have to demonstrate the effect. And then just because something is labeled bullying, we still have an array of options for how to attend to it. Okay. So it could be as simple as, you know, when you invite everybody in your class but this one little girl to your party, your birthday party, that's exclusion.

And, you know, you can offer a path to, you know, reset things or make amends. Or, depending on the circumstance, you could have a more serious consequence. Okay. Yeah, I think that what you're speaking to there is that it kicks it over to the procedure.

And then we have these procedures to say, just because someone is accused of something does not mean it automatically is that thing, like as handed down by some divine entity. It's like it then goes through a process, or sorry, it goes through a procedure to determine the nature of that thing, period.

It does equip you with language to be able to talk to kids about when you do that, when you are rumor-mongering about this one person, or when you are purposefully excluding them, it's actually bullying. Yeah. It's even here in the definition. Gotcha.

Um, Kelly, should we circle back to your, um, redundancy? That'd be great, Colin, thank you. Um, all right, can you, sorry, I've just been lost in, I'm lost in yellow. Could you just take me to the, um, the, I guess where it would appear, well, in either.

I believe it's starting with section 5, 6, 7, possibly beyond that to 8. All right, so in the reporting section? Reporting, responding, and remediation? In both the policy and the procedure. It's repeated. I mean, I think what we would...

Does it fit more in one than the other? I don't know. Or does it make sense to keep it into both? In general, in general, my understanding from folks is that you, the policies, wherever possible, should, if something's going to be more general, it will be the policy, because it gives the administration more room.

1:17:51

So if you are not trying to directly mandate something goes a certain way, you leave that out of the policy. But I'm not sure how we would change that to be more general. I'm looking, Kara and Chris, for if they have any musings on how we might change that.

Again, is it elegant? No. does it have any substantive impact on what anybody's experience of bullying or of having to have it be addressed? We got lost in that sentence. Would it have any impact on that process? No, it wouldn't. So I think keeping it doesn't substantively impact anyone's experience.

No, it doesn't. Honestly, these sections, to me, feel more like procedures than they do policies. But we're actually referencing the procedure, right? Like the form? Yeah, I suppose one thing we could do, if we were wanting to, we could take out all of the language in all of them, and it would just say, five, reporting, refer to the reporting forum, G-I-C-K-E-I.

We could just take out all that language. That would be a very straightforward thing, but I think then what we are saying to, let's say Maria goes to this page, and she wants to figure out whether or not something has happened.

Like, we're kicking her from that into another document. So, like, why not tell her right here, this is how reporting works, would be one possible argument. But I am agnostic on this matter. We're going twice. Yeah, I mean, I would agree with that. I think that if we can keep that in there, I would prefer to keep it in. I heard a preference. I heard a preference from Kara, and I like that preference. Let's run with that preference, is what I say, because we've got a lot of work to do, and it's serious work, And also there's the closing roads down for some reason. I don't understand. Is it snowing? They're moving the old snow. Okay. I did have one more question. Let's do it. Sorry. Page three under cyberbullying. Text messaging device and personal digital assistant. Do people still have PDAs? Do we need to include this? Why are you hazing right now is what you were doing. I mean, if we're trying to update this to the current century,

maybe we don't need that. But I'm fine. Just curious. I don't know, man. I don't have a pony in that race. Anybody want to take it out? What do you think, Maria? You're bullying people with your palm pilot. Do you know what a palm pilot is, Maria? Also, your daughter wants a Walkman? And a palm pilot, yeah. We can take it. No, it's fine. I just can't. Yeah, we can't. If that would make everybody. To bully. Because it's not saying they can't use them. It's just saying you can cyber bully with it. That's a fair point. I think we're going to get cyber-beliefs. Let's leave it in. It's going to bring someone joy. Okay. To encounter that. Maria's going to find it, and she's just going to be like, what is that? And just discover so many interesting things. Okay, so... Are you doing the procedure separately, or are we...

Oh, sorry. No, they're... Together? The procedure... It was bundled, and it flows from it. They're not any... Yeah, all the same principles that I outlined of why we are changing it applied to the procedure as well as the this is first read so you will have another chance in a month or so to look at this again I'm definitely going to find a PDA we can talk about POM pilots but in all seriousness this is a very difficult policy, that's partially why we spent so long on it we really wanted to make sure that we were getting it right and again kudos to Superintendent Grove for really sort of making sure that we were understanding the most recent language, but also understanding what parts we could keep,

because they were awesome. So all 11 requirements are now in here. All right, any other questions or comments? So we have a first and a second on the floor for both the policy and the procedure. Yes, I believe it was Chris and Anna, right? Thank you. I remember who it was. All right,

all those in favor and opposed. Thank you. All right, so we are skipping 12a, and we are moving on to 12b which is the second read for the calendar so uh do i have a motion for consideration approval for the second read of the 26 27 school calendar karen and stuff any changes for the last

1:23:10

one we saw no i don't think we were requesting any so i want to make sure nothing had changed from then till now any comments questions great all those in favor not opposed all right now we get down to the fun stuff all right i will hand it over to superintendent gray for item 13a

presentation of the superintendent's 26-27 proposed budget take a quick minute to get set up here i uh one of my favorite poems by robert has called meditation at lagunitas i taught it a number of years ago and the final line of the the final line of the poem is blackberry blackberry

blackberry and when i taught it at nyu um the students were like why is he talking about this blackberry because they that was current uh for them i guess that means i've been teaching for a while. But that really has turned that foam on its head for me. Which screen mirroring is it?

238? I have a 248. Oh, there it is. Yeah. Okay. That's a weird color. Okay. I mean, it is what it is. All right. Well, let's try it again. Oh, I think that does look better. Are we all here? Yeah. Okay. I think we're all here. So let's launch in. I brought it up here. I had another

1:30:15

one behind me. But thank you. Yeah, it was a little dry, could you tell? That honestly is what did it. Okay, well, thank you, everybody. So, Mr. Pitten. Okay, so thank you, everybody. I've had a little more water now, so hopefully you'll be able to hear me well. A great deal of care has gone into

this presentation. I'm really glad Sam was able to get the colors to work, because as Kelly and Erica can testify. We actually had a lot of conversation about colors in a certain part of this. They're very relevant to the way the information is presented. So first, I just want

to start with the history of how we got to this moment. Back in November, the board gave direction that they wanted to see three tiers of a budget. And so we are presenting the budget differently from the way we have in the past. In the past, each administrator would come forward and share

a presentation about their own cost center. My aim in doing it all together as the superintendent's budget is to give a sense that this is one district moving forward, that the cost centers are not in competition with each other, and that in fact we have talked about this as a team very

thoroughly. And that is a true statement. We have really approached it as a team. And I think I can say with fairness that the whole group behind me understands this budget, has thoroughly talked about it, and there is strong consensus behind it. So it's got my name on it, and I'm standing up

here, but it was definitely a group process, and I'm very appreciative of that. So you're going to see three budget presentations, and tonight's presentation will lay out the big picture first. So that means it will lay out the three different tiers that you have asked for, which are at six,

7% and 8%, but then it's going to do a deeper dive on the recommended level, which is the level I am recommending, and that is the 7% level, the middle level, and I'll do my best to explain why I'm recommending that level. So the context. As I explained at the onset of this school year, if we

carry forward a status quo budget, meaning if we take everything we're currently funding and carry it forward, it will be an increase of just over 10% over last year. The cost drivers for that are the contracts that we have. We have multiple special education costs that are to meet individual

student IEP needs, transportation and other operations, and health insurance and other fixed costs. So not everybody, if you're not a school finance wonk like some of us, it may not be readily apparent, but just because the budget goes forward at 10% over last year, that is not necessarily the

way it impacts taxes in each community. The taxes in each community are based on a cost-sharing formula for each town, and it may mean they will not be equal. They may be substantially more, depending on which town you're in. So a status quo budget going forward at 10% over last year

is a significantly higher increase than previous years, and I do have a slide to explain that as well. But that was what I brought to you back in November and asked for direction about. So you'll see more detail about how that shakes down. I wanted to start by saying that we do have

some additions to the budget beyond the status quo budget that are included tonight. I've broken those into necessary additions and recommended additions. Necessary additions are those that basically the board has already voted to approve. So, for example, we have special ed needs for a

full-time speech language pathologist, a half-time teacher of the deaf, and other costs for out-of- district placements for kids who have that indicated in their IEPs. We are currently paying for some of that right now for those kids out of reserve money, but we need to put that in the

budget for next year. Reserve money is something to use on a one-time only basis. We also have energy audit and vehicle replacement plans already that are phasing in important like energy efficiencies for our buildings and keeping our vehicle fleets updated so that if we had a bus

1:35:29

breakdown, or a bus come to the end of its life dramatically just because it gets old and worn out, then we aren't all of a sudden having to immediately tax our way out of that problem. We have a way to level out the tax impact of that over time. There are also included in the budget

funds for a board-approved sabbatical leave that you all approved recently. So those are necessary because you've already voted for those. The recommended additions are things you have not voted for yet, but I'm hoping that you will. Most of these come out as a wash in the budget,

but I wanted to include them anyway for transparency. So first is summer school at Moore Street School. This is a very small amount of money. It's $7,000 basically. And last year it was in Title I. We are not able to, we don't know what will happen with title money right now. And

if title money goes through in the way that we hope it will, we won't even have an answer for that until April. So given the small amount of money and given the necessity really to have summer school at all of our schools, it's important that we put this amount in the budget.

I'm also requesting that we add a stipend for middle school swimming, which is about $2,400, which I would call in the overall context of a $40 million budget a very small amount to serve about I think Eric you said it was about 50 kids who are currently doing this through community

programs but are there's strong demand for this it's a lifetime sport it's good for kids $2,400 seemed like a reasonable thing to add. There are some additions for facilities maintenance painting and carpet replacements, although you will see later that we have scaled back the

original ask in terms of the overall context of this budget. We do want to carry forward with some of that because we don't want our facilities to get too far behind. We are recommending some replacements for devices, technology devices, and audio-visual replacements, although as you will

see later. We're significantly scaling back the ask on that and thinking about hunting that to another year, basically, given what we are up against in the overall picture of the budget. I'm asking for money for a facilities study, which is to really examine a long-term plan to

make sure that we are going forward sustainably. There'll be a lot more about what that plan would be on February 11th, two weeks from now. The cost of that study we're including in the budget, we're going to offset it by recommending that it come out of capital reserve because it is a

one-time expense. So that would be a net zero impact on the budget right now. And we are also looking at providing some what I would call desperately needed support to the transportation department, which is a halftime administrative assistant to Jeremy. However, we're going to

offset that in central office by the reduction of a halftime bookkeeper. This is basically assigning staff new roles. So it shows up in the budget as an addition and a reduction that are equal. And for transparency, we want to show that. So it's budget neutral. So the necessary

additions in the top add up to $807,000 roughly. The recommended additions add up to $154,818. And between the two of them, that is roughly 2% of the budget. In the $40 million budget, each percentage point is $400,000 roughly. I want to talk a little bit about how we have

approached this. And I hope that some of this will jog memory because I've tried to be very purposeful in communicating about our approach to the budget this year. Started out early by acquainting all the stakeholders I could think of with what the overall picture of the budget was.

Then very deliberately asked staff for their feedback in listening sessions and also with a survey. We took the results of that listening sessions and survey and considered them strongly as an administrative team. We met extremely frequently as administrative team. As I mentioned

earlier in my remarks. We've more than doubled the amount of time that we have met to consider the budget, and I came to you for guidance in November when it was clear that we needed to have consensus around this and a way to go forward. A reminder of what that direction was,

1:40:45

you asked to see three tiers, an 8%, a 7%, and a 6%. The tiers I'm giving you are actually each slightly under those respective numbers. So the 8% tier is 7 point something, the 7% is 6 point something, the 6% is 5 point something. The reason for that is that we don't know yet what the state

subsidy is going to be. The big picture is that if we went all the way to the deepest level, that is 1.8 million dollars roughly, and if you're kind of doing some math in your head, if the status quo budget is just over 10%, and we wanted to go to even the least disruptive tier, which is 8%.

Well, that's about half of $1.8 million. So that's about a million dollars just to get to the top tier. And it's not in the slideshow, but I will remind you of just a statistic from earlier presentations that the budget, the amount of the overall budget that is represented by staffing,

and Kelly, correct me if I'm wrong on this, it's roughly 80-ish percent of the budget. So to bring in a budget at those tiers, there really is, we have, I will emphasize, we looked at non-staffing areas first, and we did a lot of work on that, and you will see that show

up, but you can't get to that level of decrease without touching the 80 percent of the budget that is staffing. So all three tiers do indicate staffing reductions. So here, this is a summary of what we did before we looked at staffing to try to minimize that. We asked all schools and

departments to hold their budgets to essential levels, and I've got to tell you, they really did. Jen just shared a spreadsheet with me today about what her departments did, she and her departments did, to bring down their non-staffing costs, supplies, etc. They came, the difference from

previous years is stark. They really, really paid attention to this in every building. We looked at our facilities and maintenance costs. It would not be smart to just decide, as I have seen school districts do in the past, to just completely not attend to ongoing maintenance. That is setting

us up to have real problems later. But we did look at what do we have to do and what do we not have to do right now and we have made reductions where we don't have to do things right now those are mostly cosmetic things like paint and carpets um we have referred deferred we have

deferred technology updates part of the reason that it makes sense to do that now is that ideally we would love to get our devices on a replacement cycle similar to our bus fleet um but the truth is at this very moment we just don't have to do that and apple is giving us an

option to continue leasing at zero percent interest. So that is what makes the most sense for us to do right now. We're also able to make a pretty significant reduction to our school nutrition contribution without at all compromising the quality of the meals that we're offering to

kids. And you'll see more about that in a separate presentation, but the biggest reason for this is that the state gives us an amount that we can't exceed for school nutrition. And we have been consistently over the amount that we have sitting in our school nutrition bank account. And we've

been finding creative ways to spend that money because the state has been telling us to. So we can reduce the amount that we as a district are contributing to school nutrition right now and still not impact what kids are getting to eat. And as I mentioned before, I am suggesting that

we move a facility study, which we really do need to do, to capital reserve because that's a one-time expense, or at least it's a once-a-generation expense, hopefully. So as I mentioned, I'm presenting three tiers. The tier that I'm recommending is the middle tier, what I'm calling

Tier 2, it comes in at roughly 7% increase over last year. And the reason that I'm recommending that tier is because I think our work in approaching this budget is to position the district to be able to make good long-term decisions. Some of those long-term decisions

1:46:04

are about early childhood. Some of them are about the way our facilities are planned as we go forward. Some of them are about programming that we may need in the future. We need to be able to address those in a responsible and in a deft way. So Tier 2 makes real reductions now, but they are

reductions that keep intact our core programming that honor our existing class size policy across the board and ensure that we are still providing a robust education. And tier two does importantly avoid deferring decisions that if they don't get made now will come back later at

another point. So now I'd like to talk about enrollment for a little bit. So this is next year's projected enrollment broken down by grade level and you have it in front of you in paper obviously as well. This is a slight decrease from this year. While we're not projecting massive

decreases in enrollment in the immediate future, neither are we predicting increases in enrollment. So this is the historical enrollment, just so that you have some context. In 2023, we were at 2,084 students. In 2024, that was reduced by almost 100 students to 1,997. 2025, that's this year,

that we lost 20 more. Next year is predicted to be about the same, but the general trend for this area is slight downticks. So this is where we get down to the brass tacks. So this is the overview of reductions that I would recommend if we were to go to tier one, which is the least amount of

reducing right now. That's at 8%. I'm sure I don't need to read them out to you, but I want to sort of point out some of the patterns and some of the major decision points. One thing that makes stand out to you right away is that there are the fewest reductions in the elementary schools.

The reasons for that is that the elementary schools honestly have the least amount of room for reduction right now. Bringing those three positions put our elementary class sizes at the upper end of our guidance for class sizes, and I wouldn't want to go beyond that. Where there

is more availability to reduce and be well within class size limits is at the middle and high school level, particularly at Freeport Middle School. At Freeport Middle School, Pam and Bill have done a really great job at looking how to make the schedule more efficient, and they have a plan

for how to do that, which enables not only some efficiencies, but also some real, I think, opportunities for improved instruction. For example, by adjusting that schedule, we can make sure that all kids there are getting social studies as a core class, which they're getting

in a rotation right now. We can also make sure that all kids get a world language by adjusting that schedule. There are some trade-offs, and one of the trade-offs that's up there that we really thought long and hard about was the proposed reduction of the French position at Freeport

Middle School. The reasoning behind that is that we knew that in order to do reductions there, we needed to look at the unified arts, the specials, and to think about the ways that we could approach that with the least impact. So if we reduce the French position there,

1:51:16

it creates congruence with what is offered at Durham, which is Spanish. And another way that it creates congruence with what's offered at Durham is that at Durham, yes, there's only one choice for language, but every kid is getting it. It's required. And at Freeport Middle School,

that is not the case. Languages are offered there as choices for unified arts, as well as JMG and what else, Pam? Yes. Okay. So by concentrating on just Spanish, we can make sure that every kid gets exposure to world language. At the high school, you see reductions up there that are

driven by the least impact to students based on numbers. The department at the high school that has the most opportunity to reduce and be in line with where other departments are for class sizes is math. And in addition, at the high school in the world language department, we currently offer

Spanish, French, and Latin. We have one Spanish teacher. We have one French teacher who also teaches some Spanish, and we have two Latin teachers. And by reducing one Latin teacher, we can still maintain all three languages. And in addition to that, we have a printing clerk

position, which is part-time, which we can absorb. And we have a full-time community outreach coordinator who does fantastic work, but we can reduce that position to half-time and still have a robust community outreach program. And then district-wide, we have three ESOL teachers,

English as a second language teacher. Our numbers of students who are multilingual have dropped over the past few years and the need for three teachers is just not congruent with the number of students we have who need the service and the amount of service that they need. And in addition

to that, at this tier, I'm also recommending some significant non-staff reductions, deferring painting and carpets, cutting the school nutrition contribution by half, and reducing $125,000 of device replacements. And before I go on to the next tier, I want to come back to a point I made

in my opening remarks. This is the moment where it's very easy to look and natural to look at where I'm proposing to reduce. The background for every single one of those is, okay, what do we need to keep. What is not written up there, but what does reducing here mean we can maintain?

And to me, the things I kept coming back to are, in the elementary schools, the class sizes were already high. We can reduce a little there, but we can't reduce a lot without really compromising class sizes. And that's a perspective that we kept coming back to. And we also really need to

keep providing for special education, because the needs in special education are just continuing to increase. So when viewed that way, this proposal does not mean, it truly does not mean we don't value having that additional math teacher at the high school. It doesn't mean we don't value

having a French program at Freeport Middle School. It means that when viewed against all of the things we feel we need to maintain, these are where we feel we can find an efficiency to maintain really important things. Moving on to the next tier. This is the tier that I recommend.

And what you see in blue are additional items that would be added on to what's in red to get to this level. So if you look at the top, at the elementary and middle level, you see five ed tech positions. The good news is that we currently have five and a half open ed tech positions in the

1:56:34

district. The open ed tech positions we have are in special ed. So the individuals who are currently in those positions, we can offer another position to that's currently vacant. Additionally, at that level, I am recommending that we reduce to two instructional strategists at the K-5 level.

We presently have three. And then last, you'll see under non-staff next to device replacement, a little blue times two. This means that at this level, I'm recommending that we completely defer the device replacement. That together, that's a quarter of a million dollars. So, now I'm going

to go on to Tier 3, and I want to make it really clear when I go on to Tier 3 that it's in red for a reason, and that there are big words in capitals at the top, not recommended. This is what we would have to do to get this deep. We really had to think outside of the box. Now, one of the schools that

you have not seen mentioned until tier three is Paunel. And that's simply because the size Paunel is, it makes it very hard to reduce a whole position. If you're talking about, like, you're going to have to have a first grade classroom. It's not like mass landing where there are several

third grade classrooms and you can sort of spread the impact. In a small school, those impacts are magnified. So we have a few positions at Paunel that we could reduce if we need to, but I don't recommend it. We have two edtech positions. One is an RTIA edtech at .9. The other is an RTIB edtech

at .4. Those odd .9 and .4 are because those individuals actually fill their time doing some other things. The .9 person spends some time in the kitchen. The .4 person, Kelly reminds me, bus driver. So the impacts of those are more difficult to deal with. We did some creative

thinking and realized that at Palmel next year, there are supposed to be 18 fifth graders. Well, mass landing could absorb 15 eighth graders and spread it out over the classrooms there and still be within the class size policy. We could send the Palmel fifth graders to mass landing. I don't

recommend it for any number of reasons. One is what it implies for the panel school. And second, there's a whole transportation puzzle there that we honestly don't have the answer to right now. We would figure it out somehow, but it involves start times and having a driver and lots of stuff.

And could we do it? Well, if we have to, we can, but it's a puzzle. At the middle level, to go this far, we could reduce another unified arts position at Freeport Middle School. And it would be possible to reduce the health position and embed the health standards in other schools, in other disciplines like PE, social studies, science.

At Durham, they have a wellness position that's K-8, and they have embedded those standards in other subjects in the past, but it's much better to have that position. And then last, at the high school, we could reduce a half social work position.

That position is serving such a need, and students' mental health is of such concern right now. That is, all I can say is I don't recommend doing that. But if the board wanted to go to that level, this is how we would get there.

So, again, I'm going to come back to Tier 2 and explain why I think this is the best way forward. The first bullet is really the most important. If we defer hard decisions now, it means harder decisions later. There's also a legitimate question out there about what level of budget increase the community will support.

2:01:55

I don't, I'm not from here, I don't have a crystal ball to that. All I can tell you, and we do have information about this, is that the past two years in a row you had budget increases of roughly 6%. going to 10% is a huge leap. And going back before that, the budget increases were much lower than

6%. We all know we're living in a time of really increasing cost of living. People in the community are feeling that. We have people whose tax bills are rapidly increasing. We have to consider that. And I need to make a good faith recommendation to you about what I'm confident the community

will support and which positions us again to really be in a strong place going forward for the decisions that come next year, the year beyond, etc. So some of the key impacts at Tier 2, again, the fewest reductions at the elementary level, and that's where the individual student

needs are the greatest. It maintains core programming at all the elementary schools. At the middle level, that's the biggest change, but Pam and Bill and I, I really feel that the new schedule actually is an opportunity, that it will enhance the program there. We certainly had

rich discussion about unified arts, French, and health, and how to approach those. And another aspect of that that I will mention that doesn't have a budgetary impact, but has an impact on school culture, is bringing in library as a special, which it currently is not, and really

using that as a place to teach about digital citizenship, cell phone use, etc. And we do have the opportunity at the middle level at Freeport Middle School to reduce the office staff at a level that's consistent with other schools. Right now we have two full-time office staff

at Freeport Middle School. Freeport Middle School has the same number of kids roughly as mass landing. Mass landing has one full-time assistant, and I think 0.15 that drops in is not always there. So it seems to make sense to bring that in line. At the secondary level, I mean, I was

a high school teacher for a long time. Those are really hard to think about. But when I think about the reduction in math, which will be very deeply felt, but it brings that department in line with other departments. And I can't in good faith, if I look at where else we go, I'm looking at

elementary schools. I can't in good faith bring forward a proposal that creates that kind of imbalance. So with these proposals at the high school, the math department can be in line with other departments. We can still maintain offerings in all three existing world languages.

And choosing the printing clerk position and the community outreach position for reduction allows us to maintain core academic programming in other places. So my belief, and I believe the team behind me strongly supports this, is that when we look at it through equity among the schools, this is the way forward that meets that, that checks that box the best.

So if we look at class sizes and what they would be projected at at the recommended level, this is what it looks like. So there are a few places where it's up above 20, but by and large, it's below 20. Those are healthy class sizes.

2:07:07

So just a few things about what this proposal does not include. Early childhood, still a big question mark. Next week, I will be bringing forward something to you with an answer about how we would step into that, if we would step into that, without impacting the local taxpayers. I don't feel that

it's the right, I'll just go on record now, I don't feel it's the right time to impact the local taxpayers with that expense, given the overall gestalt of what we're doing here. And there are certain programs that are, they have a different funding structure, and so they will be presented

separately. They are included in the amount that I've shown you, but in terms of showing you how those programs work. I haven't gotten into the specifics. And those are community programs, school nutrition, and region 10. And if you look at my recommended budget by article,

these are how the increases go forward. You can see the biggest is in special education, and that's because of those special situations that I mentioned. The others are well below the overall budget increase trend that we've seen. And these are the rest. So this is the

level that we're calling a 7% increase. It's really, as of right now, it's at 6.46 to leave some wiggle room for the state subsidy, which may not be what it was last year. So next week, I will talk more about the highest and lowest tiers. You have that information in front of you

to think about. The staff who would be affected by all of the tiers have been talked to. Next week, we'll present community programs and school nutrition. And I am determined we will talk about early childhood cohort three, finally. And then on February 11th, you have asked for a

concept for longer-term sustainability, and that we do have a concept to share. It is a concept. It's not fully fleshed out. It's an idea. And we will have an update about strategic planning. That process has been moving forward, and we'll have plenty of time for questions and discussion.

So as I close, I said a couple months ago, this is hard work, but it's good work. It's hard conversations and hard decisions, but that is good work to be doing, as long as it's done with transparency and integrity. I cannot emphasize enough how impressive the people behind me have been,

particularly as a new superintendent. They've been extremely helpful. And the staff have been gracious and patient, and the staff have, at all points when we've been communicating, staff have been respectful of what we're dealing with.

And now I have a lot of empathy for everyone who is going to now, for a period of time, weeks, await decisions. It's hard to sit with discomfort. Thank you. If there are questions, I'll go up there to take them. Thank you.

2:12:16

Clearly, a ton of work goes into this presentation every year. And I'm pretty sure I can speak for the whole board when I say we appreciate the thoughtful process you guys undertook this year. And I certainly don't mean to downplay the work that's been done in prior years,

because I do believe that has always been presented as a superintendent's budget with the support of the full administrative team. But there are certainly some new components to the process this year, including the the staff surveys and listening sessions and all key to getting a kind of a full

view and of of impact and um i really appreciated um and while i'm i'm sure this was always at the heart of of these hard decisions in the past but really coming back to not just you know what are we looking to to potentially eliminate but what are we protecting and saving um and what you know

at our core do we want to make sure we we keep so I appreciate that that perspective that runs through the whole presentation I know you have a different model for how we're presenting this going forward historically this

first sort of top view of everything is a lot of information and the board usually will take some time to process that and come back with questions we don't typically have a ton of discussion after this first one it's more taking it going back

thinking on it um i guess my question is um while we have the full administrative team here uh is the expectation that they will be at the all of our budget meetings going forward so if we have specific questions we will have access to those answers they are on the hook sorry guys

um okay um i guess i will open it up to board members at this point to just you know any clarifying questions um that people feel like they need before they can even really dive in and start digging through the information we have from tonight chris this is something we talked

about in the finance meeting beforehand but could you kind of just walk us through especially because i didn't know this before we talked about this but when when you propose as an example of a dcs grade one position, it is not necessarily a teacher that happens to be currently residing

in that position. That's correct. So the short answer is that the person who's in the positions that are listed may very well not be the person who is ultimately, who loses a job. And the reason for that is the way that the contract is laid out. And if I try to summarize that, I'll summarize

it for teachers, basically. There are two lists in order of seniority. The first list is a probationary list, and if a position is to be reduced, you looked at the probationary list first. Probationary people are in their first or second year. And then, if, well, I need to back up,

it's also broken down by impact area. So, for example, high school, secondary social studies is an impact area. Secondary math is an impact area. K-5 teaching is an impact area. So for example, there's a math teacher. There's a secondary math teacher. The position is suggested

to be reduced. The way that we have to find who the individual is that that would directly affect is first look at the probationary list. Is there anyone in that impact area who is on the probationary list. And if there's more than one person on the probationary list, the contract

establishes a system of points that we have to use to determine that. And the factors that go into the points are your date of hire, how many certifications you have, how many degrees you have, and your evaluations. And so that's true on the probationary list, and it's then true on

the seniority list. Once you go through your first two years, you move off the probationary list onto the continuing contract list, which is called the seniority list. And it's based on points as laid out by the contract. And if there's a tie in points between two individuals, then you go to

2:17:18

the next criterion, which is in the contract, and that's the date of hire. And so what that means is If we reduce an elementary teaching position in any of the schools, that's the biggest impact area. So you are first looking at the probationary list to see which elementary teachers district-wide are on the probationary list.

And then if there was nobody on the probationary list, you'd look at the other list, the continuing contract list. But it's not necessarily the person who's in the position you're suggesting to reduce. It's the person who has the fewest points in that impact area.

And I'll also point out that in any year, there is a typical number of turnover in positions in teaching as well. We have retirements, we have people that move, we have people that switch districts. So it's also fair to say that it doesn't necessarily mean

that the number of FTEs that we're looking at here, All of those would result in having to go to those lists and physically, you know, a reduction in force per the contract, right? That's correct. I mean, we already know. For example, at an earlier meeting, I think it was December, we announced a retirement of a first grade teacher at Moore Street School.

So that's a position that will be available. Right. So that would be one less person of those three elementary teachers that are on Tier 2. It doesn't necessarily mean that the first grade position would be available. It means that that one person in that impact area has already made a retirement decision.

So another position within that impact area could be available. Thank you for your transparency throughout this whole process and how thorough the presentations have been all along the way. So thank you and thank all of you for your time on this. And like Michelle said, it doesn't mean that we don't think you put that time in last time, previous years, but it's been really helpful to fully understand it. And I'm wondering if you

could walk us through the state subsidy process, and if you have a sense, if there's any way you have a sense if that might come through higher than we think or lower than we think. I may tap Kelly for this, but I don't predict it will be higher just because our enrollment is a little lower. And the state subsidy is based on the number of kids that we have. And then it's also

based on some of those kids are weighted more heavily depending upon whether they're special education, an English language learner, and several other categories. But the state has a matrix that they use that then determines what our subsidy would be. And in addition to that, you may recall

that the governor has made a promise that the state will fund 55% of public education. But that doesn't mean 55% of public education in each district. It means statewide. And so districts that have basically fewer resources are getting more. We're a district that has relatively ample resources, so we're getting less. And then the other aspect of that, just I think everybody probably here knows that, But most districts out there feel that the amount that the state says it requires to educate a student is dramatically insufficient, which is why we're, you know, talking about going to our local taxpayers for more money than what the state allocates.

Yeah, and just sort of in terms of the cycle of the biennial process, and Kelly will jump up if I say anything completely out of left field, but this is the first year of the new budget, right? so last year we kind of had a sense because they had passed the two-year budget so we kind of knew

what we didn't know the very specifics but um yes for the state sorry um i don't think we're going to know that anytime soon um so we don't know what will actually like what the total pot of available money is never mind how much would then come to us superintendents were talking about

this yesterday yeah um you know everybody's awaiting this information with bated breath Part of what is holding it up, I believe, is that there are some districts who have, gosh, for whatever reason, not made their decision about whether to enter Cohort 3.

And entering Cohort 3 affects your subsidy because of will your pre-K kids be in one pot of money or another pot of money? Yeah, which is sort of counter to what they had originally said anyway, that this was separate from the EB-279,

2:22:21

which is the document that tracks what the EPSO essential programs and services that that's where they say like you know a kiddo and you know each kiddo in this age bracket is worth you know needs this much teachers and this much

administrative support and supplies and you know special I gets a little bit more and ESOL students but basically all of those add up to what they say it cost to educate the 1,971 kids in our district that's the EPS piece right and

then the subsidy is actually okay this is how much they say it costs I would agree that it's woefully less you know there's no there's no sports there's no extracurriculars there's you know art and music not required but so anyway so

but essential what they consider essential programs and services and then so that's the that's one number and then your subsidy is actually that number minus how much the state says you have to put into the pot based on your valuation that the

state sets for all three towns and states and sets for all towns in in the state so um the the difference between those numbers is what we actually get in subsidy so there's a ton of numbers that go into that um you know usually we don't have subsidy numbers i think in a good year

until sometime in February, in a bad year, I mean, April, I mean, maybe even later, I don't know, before, I mean, they have to, they have to approve the state budget, and, because they need to know how much of their education is there, because they don't want to, you know, tell you how much you're

going to get if they don't know how much they're going to raise, so, I don't, I, I mean, we don't have growing numbers, in terms of students, I think that has saved this district and this board from some of these really hard conversations in the past several years. We had COVID money that

came in that helped sort of, you know, mask some of that. And then we had years where we had large bumps in student counts and that, you know, masked it a little bit further. All of those things have sort of gone away and now we're faced with these difficult conversations that we haven't had to

have that but other districts have already had to have so I don't I mean be great if our subsidy came in higher but I would be surprised because we are in a rising valuation market so if we have the same number of kids and they say we

need to pay more because we have higher values than we did relative to other parts of the state all of that equals less subsidy and personal things so though our special education increase is significant this would could that impact

the weighted it might maybe if they I mean if they were might we get more in subsidy for the special education needs eventually it but because it lags behind right so when you think of the 8279 that they're creating for the 26 27

expenditures they're actually looking at 24 25 numbers that they're then putting a multiplication factor on for you, so it will take a little while for that to catch up with us and actually be shown through subsidy. Yeah, just I can feel and appreciate the care that's gone into

all of this, and it's really helpful when we're making what feels like a terrible choice, so just knowing that that care and respect is here is really helpful, and then my question is, Can you explain to me the nutrition piece and how we don't cut nutrition by not contributing to nutrition again for me?

I may tap Kelly and Eric O'Reilly again, but basically school nutrition, the short answer, flag me if I'm getting this wrong. School nutrition is mostly funded by state and federal sources. And so we also have a contribution that we've been making. but there are also rules about how much money we can keep in like a separate we have a bank account

we have an account for school nutrition and we're only allowed to keep a certain amount and we've been consistently over that amount so we've been getting letters from the state this year that i've had to sign off on saying you got to spend money so like we've been spending the money um i forget

what we're spending it on like i don't know probably skittles but you know kidding i was but we Kelly well you know you did a great job with that Tom what we have been spending it on is Erica has been updating equipment within the buildings there's and then certain pieces of

equipment sometime require a little extra ventilation or an electrical you know like an electrical upgrade those types of things the nutrition department has been taking care of those as you remember last year we did we did a reduction to this the amount we were

2:27:33

contributing to school nutrition we're continuing that reduction because even with reducing our contribution last year we're still anticipating that carry over balance being too high I believe Erica it was three months expenses that

you can have in so basically they're taking a formula there they're doing it like your three highest months of expenditures and that's what you can legally have in your undesignated fund balance or carryover so that's that's kind of where we're at what we looked at

when we were going through the process is how much money actually got basically the amount of our appropriation to the school nutrition account is what was left over at the end of the year and actually increase the fund balance by. If you would just straight up look at revenues

against expenditures, what we were contributing as a district was over and above and was adding to it instead of allowing it to spend down. So that's why we didn't completely go to zero, and I will be completely honest with that, because it is very easy to take something out

of a budget. It's harder to get something back in, right? And one of the things that's happening this year is we're negotiating the support staff contract and Erica is not sitting at the table with the superintendent and ultimately the board

right when those negotiations are happening of course we build a budget and we put some anticipated expenditures in there but we as the district make the decision as to what those people are making and so we felt that the

contribution that we that is remaining within school nutrition would be able to absorb some necessary changes in salaries for about for the for the staff and nutrition and community programs they're both what we call enterprise

funds so they kind of sit outside of the normal if you call it the profit and loss of the district so Kelly and I both remember times when the nutrition program was losing hundreds of thousands of dollars a year and the school had to

essentially subsidize that and make a transfer which is what created what we have in the budget now and we have reduced that over time some of that is because you know during COVID they changed the funding and how we get money for reimbursed meals and the fact that now all kids are getting breakfast and

lunch funded through the state and through the federal programs all of those have sort of increased and I will say our nutrition program has done a great job to increase increase participation right so the more kids that

get to take the meals the more we get reimbursed for the meals and it's kind of it's a win-win scenario so it you know nutrition has become as Kelly said essentially a break-even proposition right so we don't have to put as much in

there because right now it's it's covering its own expenses because it has different revenue sources questions other information that you would like Tom administrators to come with next time. Valerie. I want to start by echoing how everybody started

with acknowledging and appreciating the amount of work that's been done and the difference in the way it's presented this year over previous years. I'm not saying one is better than the other. This is just more in my lane of understanding. It's easier for me to comprehend what's being

recommend it and why. Um, so I really appreciate different methods of teaching are different and sometimes it's easier to understand and this one's good for me, I guess is the answer. Um, but my question is, um, as Kelly just alluded, um, we do have a pending, um, contract negotiation

and I'm wondering if we anticipate any changes to these tiers after the negotiations and if so, how significant those might be. The negotiations could impact the overall figure. One of the reasons that, again, why we came in under 6, 7, and 8 is to allow some real room for that.

Again, I'll just echo appreciation for all of the hard work and really difficult work. And yeah, there's some very difficult choices ahead of us. I think whatever information could be presented about what we know about coming years in terms of, in other words,

2:32:49

I know we won't know everything about staffing for next year and the year after that, but I can assume we could make some estimates of if we maintain current staffing with our, with the, um, uh, how that would play out. Um, because I think that the emphasis on,

again, I very much appreciate the emphasis on sustainability and sort of structural things, but, um, I think it would be helpful for me to have a little bit of a sense of, like, um, are we doing this again next year? Um, are we, are we effectively doing the same sorts of cuts

because of the same sorts of issues. I think that would just be helpful for us to be able to know that so that we can make some honest decisions about that. Does that make sense, Tom? It does, and we can definitely supply that.

I can't remember at what point it was. Maybe it was in November, but I remember asking Kelly to look at, to project not just next year, but the year after that. And Kelly did run those numbers, and I think we brought them up. Maybe it was really early on. But we can bring that, for sure.

And that may dovetail with some of the strategic updates and the concept of a plan. I hate to say that, sorry. That we're going to hear about on the 11th. I don't want to over-promise on that particular concept. The concept, I mean, I want to wait and to fully explain what the idea is. There would be some savings with that. it's not going to be a silver bullet to solve inflation.

I mean, I do feel like I need to name that right now, and actually for our staff, I really want to name that. I had intended to make a point in my opening remarks about sustainability. Paying our staff well is an investment in our sustainability.

Allowing space in the budget to really give our staff the compensation they deserve is an investment in our district that attracts and keeps good people and keeps us robust. It's just that there are trade-offs to that that we're sort of now reckoning with.

The idea that we have talked about is about, in part, financial efficiency, but it's, in even greater part, it's about really maximizing the way we use our resources for better outcomes for kids. Thank you, Tom and everyone. My question is, when we're thinking about these tiers,

you know, I think my mind goes to, oh, well, if Tom's recommending, you know, for the technology device replacement to put that off for another two years, what if we did that in tier one and then we saved some money that way? Would you recommend not looking at it like, that's just

one example, but like, yeah, just moving different pieces or just for our sake as a board? I would, what I would recommend is that, you know, you have the right to do that as a board. You have the right to give whatever direction feels best to you. All I can say is that the expertise about

what that really means isn't even so much with me. It's right out there, and it has been discussed from every angle. The other thing that the horse trading does is that it ends up, and I wasn't here last year, but I think it ended up, when it played out in public, I think it created a sense

of some schools or people were winning and some were losing, and that was not intended, but that's just the way that these moments are so high stakes for people it can feel that way and what i um i want to come back to a point that i just kept making earlier but all of the we could get to

six seven and eight in any number of ways these are the ways that we feel are the least do the best by kids and and um i definitely don't want to be cavalier to say that there's no impact there There is an impact, for sure. But we will still have robust schools with a reduction at the middle level.

In some ways, I think we'll actually see improvements for kids, especially at the middle school, because not all improvements are about the number of positions you have. It's, in large part, how you use the positions. Are there questions?

2:38:02

Sally. We'll be speaking more about the reduction in the middle school of French I know that when we toured, Principal Crosby had indicated that students had a choice of language or JMG, which struck me as not great. This is probably a good time to talk about that, since I did want to focus on the recommended tier right now.

And I may just call Pam and Bill up. Why don't you come on down, Pam and Bill? Just come to the podium. So, just because they can speak to the specific impact of this better than I can. But the big picture is that when we really looked at this,

there were some ways that we really wanted to improve what students got through the schedule. One of them is social studies. The current schedule has social studies on a rotation. And how often are they getting social studies now? They're on a rotation with STEM and science. So is it every three days? Two out of three days. And just in the world, I mean, I was a high school social studies teacher, so I definitely have a bias. But I just feel like social studies is like an everyday subject.

In middle school. And when we looked at the unified arts, the French position really fits more into a bigger picture. We know we need to look at the specials. So where can we find efficiencies with the specials? Well, what we can do with the new schedule they're recommending is make sure that world language is not a choice.

It's a must. You get it every day. and we can accomplish that by focusing on one world language and can you talk a little bit more about how the choices with jmg work now maybe bill can help a little bit with this just because he's used to the schedule a little bit more but you know depending on the recommendations from the board you know certainly the schedule is something we've been thinking about um through

this whole year um you know it's different for me coming to a school too where we have that rotation schedule so that that took a little bit for me to get used to but we want to make sure that the kids are seeing each teacher every single day and that they're recommended that foreign language every single day. So that's going to be taking a deeper dive into the schedule. That's still a work in progress there. I'm interested because I think it's only been a few years,

but I believe Durham previously had the option of JMG or Spanish. It sounds like now they have the model that FMS is looking to go to where you get both and everybody gets both. I'm interested to hear um how that went and if it was kind of what prompt I mean for you guys

it's a scheduling issue that's why you did it I think as a parent I appreciate that they don't have to choose and they can do both because I think both of my kids would have would have benefited from being able to take both um but I mean that is a shift that happened there and I

I don't think it was a, was it a scheduling suggestion that, or driven then, or? Don't go far. So it's a little bit of both, and last year, it started with last year's 7th graders all taking Spanish, and that was a good, a positive shift, and the, for this year and for next,

is that all 7th and 8th graders get Spanish and they get JMG. It gets a little complicated with all these different schedules because we actually do have to have an alternating day schedule like a high school right now just because of the numbers and the number of teachers that cover all those classes. But I would say to you that specifically in Spanish,

the Spanish teacher was a little unsure about how that was going to work with all kiddos coming in with some different levels of background, but has now found it to be super positive and we're happy for exactly what you said, Michelle.

And I actually remember the wrestling back and forth there, right? So it's great to be able to have the broader experiences that JMG provide, but also to be getting that foundation in another language. And I would say we're fortunate that JMG has supported us with that because they've been pretty flexible with some of their requirements

to help facilitate it. That's what I was hoping you were going to say because it sounds, I mean, it's great when we can take something that's worked well in one spot and shift it over. I mean, obviously it makes a lot of sense with the schedule change

2:43:11

that you guys are recommending at FMS, but I think you can get some benefits from the schedule and you can also get some benefits from the impact on kids which I mean that's that sounds great yeah I think I think as much and as much granularity as would

be possible in terms of understanding this shift at the middle school in terms of schedule would be extremely helpful I think that one I think just one thing if one reviewed the tape from last year I think I think we spent way too long in

a gray area around understanding schedules and impacts particularly at the middle school actually just at the middle school so I think that as much as early as possible in the process it would just be really helpful to understand exactly what we're talking about if we need lots of handouts and

and PowerPoint presentations, like, that's fine. But I think, like, I think we just really need to understand it because I don't think for a variety of reasons we were able to get that. And again, I'm not, there's no blame placed on that. It just, it was not able to happen. And I think that for us to, I think, in good faith,

consider the recommendations that are being made, particularly for Freeport Middle, I think we would really need to understand exactly what is happening and why that is beneficial and how it is beneficial. And that's certainly Bill and I's goal here. And we'll be very clear and certainly putting what's best for kids and putting together a product that we really feel confident that's going to be a great product to present and roll out for the kids next year.

And I know, Tom, you had already kind of given gratitude, but I do want to give a shout out to the Freeport Middle School staff members. that I sat and met with individually yesterday. They were really hard conversations. They did a really nice job listening and receiving the feedback, and they were respectful conversations, and they were hard. And I just want to just give a shout-out to my team on that.

Thank you. And I think similarly, you know, as just in terms for me, additional information I'd want to hear, I would be looking for Jen. It doesn't have to be tonight, Jen, don't worry. You know, what does one less math teacher mean? Does that mean we have less math classes offered? Does that mean the classes are slightly larger, but we still have the same offerings?

You know, the impact of these changes, definitely the middle school schedule, because I think you're right, Colin, there was just a lot of ambiguity. Like, it might be it's this, or maybe it's that, or we don't know. Maybe they only go on Tuesdays. We don't know. Just to be clear, and for not, again, no shade on the folks.

They were trying to respond to really difficult questions and in a time frame that was untenable. So again, I want to just say with all respect that that was a really difficult time, but that's what I'm wanting to avoid. Right, and that made what we were trying to decide even more challenging. Kelly? Yeah, similarly, I think it would be really helpful since we had a really in-depth conversation last year around the ESOL program and how many instructors would be ideal for that program, I think it would be just really good to make sure we get a really thorough explanation as to why this reduction is good for us.

And how it plays out. Yes, and how it plays out across the district with the students that we anticipate we're going to have next year. I can come up tonight because if I do, it means I get a second cookie. That's what happens. So I will share. I also just want to say that our Freeport High School staff has just been outstanding

in this really challenging process in terms of wrestling with the difficulties and understanding the position that we're in and these conversations that we've had with individual people and with staff. So similar to what Pam shared, I just wanted to share that.

One of the things that I shared with staff today to make sure as with faculty after school at our meeting today was in terms of the math position because I shared all of these positions that we are looking at for the proposed cuts and shared that in the 21-22 school year

I came to the board and requested for the addition of a math teacher. We had a full-time math teacher added that year. That was when our enrollment was at 595 and we knew that it was growing. It says on there that the enrollment that year was 632.

2:48:25

That was the time when we measured it. That year at the highest we ever got to was 645. And so now for next year, as we're projected to be 554, it's 91 students fewer. And I actually just did the numbers. We go down in 27, 28. We go down again in 28, 29. And then slightly back up to 555.

in 2030, which is our incoming freshman class next year. Just to give a little insight for the math classes, and this is just some, and we're proud of the wide range of math classes that we offer, but as we had that addition in 2021

and have now reduced the number of students that are in school, our Algebra 1 classes right now, the average class size is 14.8, honors is 12.5, Geometry is an average of 16.6. Honors is 19.5. Algebra 2 is an average of 15.4 students.

Honors is 15.3. And Honors Pre-Kalchus is an example of a class that's larger. That class size average is 22. And so I believe that while it will be a loss for our school and for our students, I believe that we're still able to maintain a strong math program.

We're continuing to work on our math skills and our math scores. And I still think that we can do that if we are reducing this position that these numbers will increase the average class size. But I think that they will still be manageable. It's also something to remember that with the wackiness of our schedule, sometimes you have a class of 11 and sometimes you have a class of 19 it's

just the way that the schedule works but I do think that those averages will stay at a reasonable number thank you enjoy your cookie your second cookie all right everybody's brain full of numbers and budget for tonight I would suggest

to folks as we are all going home and digesting a lot of information if you think of questions that would be helpful ahead of time typically we ask for you know Monday afternoon so Superintendent Gray has two days to try and pull

together the information or delegate to get that information for us not to say you can't ask questions on the fly I know I do it all the time um but if if you know it ahead of time please share it because we can be more efficient with

people's time that way. All right, so we have no personnel issues this evening. We are back to public comments. I don't think we had a large influx of community members. So then I would take a motion to adjourn. Thank you, Kara and Kelly. All those in favor?

Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.