Skip to content

TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 4 February 2026

Board meeting · 3 h 5 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →

Computer-made transcript, not a record of what was said. It mishears names and figures and drops short words, such as the "not" in "does not carry". Click a time to hear the recording, which settles any disagreement. The district's minutes are the official record.

25,426 words in 36 five-minute windows.

0:08

good evening welcome to the RSU 5 board of directors meeting it is Wednesday February 4th 2026 we are here in the Freeport high school library and we have a full complement of the board this evening with the absence of the Durham seat that's still vacant hopefully we'll be getting that filled in the in the

near term but let's get started with the Pledge of Allegiance allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

We don't have any minutes from the last minute. It's weird. Okay, maybe we'll get them next time. Maybe we can only vote on those at certain meetings. That's fine. Moving along. Adjustments? None. All right, so we will move on to noon for a student rep under good news and recognition.

So to start off, last week, students had a curriculum fair in the gym, like all grades, high school students, to see all the new classes that Freeport High School is offering for students. So some of these classes are like AP Human Geography, a Mapping Elective, and like a Fundamentals of Music class.

And then also we have four new student council members who are representing the class of 2029. And our new reps are Cooper Ajamo, Alex Robinson, Lucy Erskine, and Lily Matluck. And if you don't know, student leadership are like a group, a part of the high school that help plan events such as like homecoming and pep rallies and really like anything related to school culture.

And then also on February 12th, we have the option making Valentine's Day cards for the elderly. And the track team has a Western Maine Conference championship this Friday at USM at the track at 6. And then this Monday from both the middle school and high school had a walkout against ICE.

Thank you. All right. So item seven on our agenda is public comment. So if you have anyone who is interested in speaking, we ask that you come up to the microphone. You tell us your name and your town. And you have three minutes. And Erica's checking to see. No, nobody wants to speak.

Okay. All right. There is another public comment at the end of our agenda. So there will be another opportunity. So we will move on to item eight, a report from the superintendent. No long report tonight, just a few hires to inform you about. Jamie Gershik is joining us in the central office

as our instructional support administrative assistant. Colby Best is coming on board as a laugh and learn teacher, and Maren Gardner is also coming on board as a laugh and learn teacher. Wonderful. All right, so we have no administrative reports, no board comments or committee reports,

policy review this evening so we will jump right into unfinished business which is the fiscal year 27 I just started saying 26 now we're talking about the fiscal year 27 budget with you and I believe we are starting with community

programs Peter Wagner very well thank you for giving community programs a shot to go first in the budget review cycle this is fantastic this year and And hopefully this will be super quick and direct for you all. Looking at where we've been and where we are for the coming year, for fiscal year 27, we're remaining flat in our request for the local share at $88,000.

5:27

There are no appreciable changes foreseen in our adult ed program right now with our total number of English learners and HiSET students remaining stable and our coordinator and instructional staff hours forecast to be consistent with fiscal year 26.

Just for your information, we're at roughly, give or take, around 30 English learners in the program right now, and we have about eight HiSET students that are engaged with us at this time, and it's been pretty consistent with those numbers, and it's light years beyond

where we were before the pandemic, where we just had a handful of each, so the program really has grown and sustained. So looking back at fiscal year 26, we had a reduction in the local share by $24,000, which represented a little more than 21% of the money that we received from taxpayers,

primarily to reflect the shift from a full-time adult ed coordinator to a part-time coordinator. That coordinator is remaining and also remaining half-time. And there were no staffing adjustments for fiscal year 27. so we're staying flat and steady as she goes and also looking well in the world of adult ed

happy to answer any questions that you might have about that questions for peter really this is unheard of i guess my question for you although i did promise to someone i wasn't going to ask questions tonight we all know that was not true um so with the reduction in the current year of

from full-time to part-time are you able to meet the needs of of the position with with less yes So the reduction, along with the reduction in hours for the coordinator, pretty much corresponded to one another, and along with the state subsidy,

which is a little hard to predict. It's very formulaic. Different categories of expenditures are subsidized at different rates, and it's on a two-year look back. So it's a little hard to predict. But that plus the local share has been, yes, is adequate for adult ed right now.

Great. Why are we letting Peter off the hook this easy? All right, Sally, thank you. So I guess my question is broader in terms of the document says community programs, but you keep saying just adult ed. Is that the only purview that you're covering today? So our community programs has a super wide range of programs that we offer.

We're the rec department, so recreation and enrichment. We have our laugh and learn program, the preschool for three- and four-year-olds, the before- and after-school care for K-5, all of our summer camps. And all of those are self-sustaining, 100% self-sustaining. So the only money that we receive from taxpayers is allocated specifically to adult education activities and nothing else.

In past years, I would give some updates about those other parts of the budget, but I'm not going to say that taxpayers aren't interested in that, but that funding is not coming from them. It's all elective revenue-based programming.

Thank you. That's the clarification I was looking for, so thank you. thank you Peter okay thank you all right we will move on to school nutrition hello hear me okay I'm also planning to keep this a bit brief I don't know if

I'll beat Peters but I'll try thank you so I'll give you a current status for the nutrition department and then where we're headed for school year 27 consistent with previous year's budgets our program is in a great spot year to date we have

served over 185,000 meals with over 3,600 pounds or so being from local Maine food school year 26 year-to-date stats our average monthly operating expenses are at around a hundred and twenty thousand dollars we've spent 49% of our

budget with 51% remaining so given that it's early February we are right on par our average breakfast participation in the district is at 38% and lunch is at around 67 I'm looking ahead for school year 27 I have two small increases for

our staff hours an additional hour was added for two positions one at Freeport High School and one at Freeport Middle School these incremental you know smaller increases are really just to help improve kitchen kitchen efficiencies

and stay ahead of any changes that we might have with staffing going forward Looking at budget for school year 27, I know it looks scary that it's like a 50% reduction from the general fund. It's really important to just remember that most of our funding comes from other sources other than the local contribution.

10:51

And just to give you an idea, about 92% of our revenue from last year came from other funding sources other than the local contribution. So we get state and federal reimbursements for all of our meals served. We have our a la carte and our catering, and we do receive interest on our school nutrition

bank account as well. So even with this cut, I have multiple equipment replacements and repairs in the pipeline for this school year. A couple of things at Moore Street School, Mass Landing is getting a new condenser and evaporator on their walk-in freezer and an oven out in Pownal. We're continuing to

serve even more local foods than before. We've expanded our purchasing to include more farms and broaden from more suppliers. Today, for example, during our professional development time we had a district-wide staff training we used the brand Maine Good

Crest which is a completely local Maine made grain company out of Skowhegan and we're going to start serving these small little they're kind of like mini pizzas and they'll be primarily breakfast options served in those and with those

we receive reimbursement using the local food funds who we actually get 50% back for every dollar that we spend on main-made products. So it really helps us to bring in more local foods while keeping costs down. So this is all to say that even with a decrease in local

contribution, our program is still moving in a positive direction, serving a larger variety of local and fresh foods, offering more taste tests to students, providing meaningful professional development for staff, and keeping our kids fueled. That's all I got. Questions for Erica?

I guess I will just say that I appreciate the continued growth in the program and growing the lunch and the breakfast participation. That 92% number is good to know. I guess I never knew the percent that came from other sources. I knew the majority of it came from other sources other than the local budget.

similar to Peters you know most of the most of the funding for Erica's program does not come from from our local budget so I appreciate the willingness and the ability to reduce the local share that you're taking but still be able to

accommodate the increased needs you know while they're not huge increases but to support your staffing so thank you I have no doubt we'll still be we'll be but other questions for kelly yeah and i just also wanted to express appreciation for your

expansion of the local foods program in our schools i really think that that we as a board value that and so we like to see that you're making those efforts thank you no questions for erica you're good thank you thank you all right so we will move on to uh superintendents proposed

budgets. Right? Yeah. 83. Are you? I'm going up there. Are you? Okay. Thank you. What's the room number again? 238. 238. There it is. It says 238 Math Lab. Isn't that right? No. 238 Library. Hmm. Oh, okay. Look at that. It's the first one.

Okay. So. Thank you. Okay. How do we feel? So, last week, I walked you through the entire budget, including an overview of all three of the tiers that the board asked for back in November. That was a tier at 6% increase, 7%, and 8%.

16:30

After walking you through the whole thing, I drilled down on the tier that I recommend, which is the middle tier at roughly 7%. Tonight, I'm going to go back and remind you first of what that tier included, and then talk about the other two tiers, the 8 and the 6, and talk about why I

don't think they are as appropriate as the one I recommended last week. So, this is basically just a review of what I just said. I want to start by reminding you, again, there are additions to the budget, and I broke those down by necessary and recommended additions. The necessary additions are all items that the

board has at one point or another either voted to approve or we have talked about. Some of them are special education costs that are currently being paid for out of reserve, but need to be transferred to the general budget because of specific student need for next

year. And those are 1.0 full-time equivalent speech-language pathologist, 0.5, full-time equivalent teacher of the deaf, out-of-district placements for special education, money that has already been approved for our energy audit

plan and our vehicle replacement plan, and funds for a board-approved sabbatical leave. Those add up to $807,000 roughly. And then some recommended additions, most of which are actually cost-neutral, are funding Moore Street Summer School, which was previously in Title

one, adding a small stipend for a middle school swim team in response to very strong demand from kids, deferring some facilities maintenance of painting and carpet requests, deferring some, I'm sorry, I said we are planning to defer some facilities maintenance, but we

are still hoping to add some painting and carpet and defer some of what we think we need and keep... I'm not saying this very eloquently. I'm sorry. I talked about it last week. Now I've gotten myself all tongue-tied. There's a certain amount we would like to do. We are adding... I'm recommending that we do some of that, but I'm also recommending later that we hold back on some of that.

Yeah, that was better. Same with technology. I'm recommending that we, in the interest of not letting this completely drop off the radar, add in some money for technology, but not as much as we would really like to do. I'm also recommending that we add money for a facility study, but then pay for it

out of capital reserve. And last, that we add a half-time transportation administrative assistant position, but offset that at central office by the reduction of a half-time port keeper, which would essentially shift the roles of staff that we currently have and be neutral to the

budget. Now let's review the tier that I recommended last week. In my view, this is the best move for us right now because it positions us the most strongly to respond to needs that will come up in the future. So it does make real reductions now. It avoids kicking the can down the road on decisions

that are hard. It preserves our core programming and services. And again, it will let us think about things that we know are coming down the pike like early childhood or buildings that we may need to make serious investments in within the next handful of years. This is again a slide that you

saw last week, but this is the projected enrollment for next year, and you have that in your packets obviously. This is the historical student enrollment, and if you're looking at the bottom row, the trend is that enrollment has gone down. And in 2023, we had almost 2,100 kids. That has gone down to 1970,

which is what we're projecting for October 1st of next year, of this year. So reviewing what I presented to you last week as the recommended tier. Again, what's in red is the 8% tier, which I'll talk about in more detail shortly. What's in blue is what's added to that to get

21:31

us to 7%. So I want to talk a little bit more about some of the things we discussed when we landed at recommending that tier. Again, deferring a decision now means potentially harder decisions later. And we may even be in that position now from where we were last year. One of the key

considerations we looked at was keeping our class sizes within the policy guidelines. And at tier two, we're able to do that across the board at every grade level. One of the really key features of this proposal is changing the schedule at Freeport Middle School to make it more efficient,

but to also allow more time for what I, with my social studies teacher bias, consider to be very critical, and that's social studies. It did provoke rich discussion about how to address unified arts or specials at Freeport Middle School, and we have a recommendation about how to do that,

which we discussed last week. And I think the overall way I would like to characterize it is that, yes, these reductions would have impact. The impact will be manageable from a programming perspective, And in some ways, at Freeport Middle School, there will be strong benefits for reworking the schedule.

And another factor that I considered about how to bring that from Tier 1 to Tier 2, if you remember that at Tier 2, the reductions in staffing are nearly all ed-tech positions. And we currently have 5.5 open special ed ed-tech positions.

Those are not the same kind of positions that are recommended for reduction in Tier 2, because those are general ed tech positions, but we have open positions for the folks who are already in the general ed tech positions to go to if they wish. So I feel that tier is the best balance.

And now I'd like to go back and talk about the other two tiers. So tier one, which is what I have up there for you now, one of the things to bear in mind with regard to the math again is that the status quo budget was over 10%. You asked for 6, 7, and 8%. So the 8% is actually halfway down to 6%.

So that amount by itself is the biggest single bite. It's a big increment of reduction. Some key themes here again. The elementary schools are where it's already the tightest in terms of staff to student ratio and class size.

So there aren't as many reductions to be found at the elementary schools. Class sizes at the middle and high school are where we can stay within the policy. So we looked at all positions. We looked across the entire grade span. We looked at teaching positions. We looked at non-teaching positions, support positions.

We also, I know that many people would naturally ask this, we did look at administrative positions. We don't have any recommendations for reduction administrative positions, but we did have rich conversation about that. And I've broken it down here by staffing reductions and non-staff reductions.

Just bearing in mind again that staffing costs are roughly more than 80% of the overall budget. So to bring it down even to the top tier, it's really not possible to do that without looking at staffing. So these are some of the things that are prominent in my mind about that top tier.

So the benefits are it's fewer reductions in staffing and programming right now, which means it's just less difficult in that regard at the moment. It's less change in the short term. And it also maintains the ed techs for general ed,

which is a key component of our MTSS structure as we currently have it. MTSS being support for students who need extra support in a particular subject area. They don't necessarily need special ed, but they're a little bit behind and they need extra support, maybe temporarily, to bring them, catch them back up.

26:36

But I think there are some cons to going that route. And the first is that it just defers decisions that might come back to make other decisions more difficult in the future. It means that in the future we may risk having to do a more abrupt reduction or a larger reduction.

So it's a delay rather than fundamentally addressing the structural issues that we face. I think it just makes it more difficult over the long term. And if I figure in, it's not on the slide, but it's in my head, if I figure in knowing that many of the people who would face a loss of their job at Tier 2,

we have another job for them to go to, that figures prominently in my thinking. So now I'm going to talk about Tier 3, and as I said last time, And as I'm saying again now, this tier is not recommended. I don't think it would be, I think it would be very disruptive to reduce at this level

right now. I'm offering this because if the board wants to come in at that level, this is the kind of thing we would need to do to get there. So as I said before, it's much more difficult to make reductions like this at Palo because

of its size. But, you know, we have to look at the big picture, and we have to talk about areas across the district. So if we were to go to that level, we would have to look at Powell, and we have some ed techs there who also serve in other roles, which I discussed last week.

And we could do something fairly out-of-the-box thinking. we could move the Powell fifth grade to mass landing school where the class sizes would allow them to be distributed among the fifth grades there and still be within the class size policy.

I don't recommend it because it's a big transportation issue that we don't yet have the answer to, and it would be disruptive to the kids to move them for just one year in that way. But it is something that is possible. We would have to reduce another position from the middle

school, and the option there would be to reduce the health position and try to embed health in other content areas. Could it be done? Yes. Could it be done and do health as effectively? I do not think so. And then at the high school, we could reduce a half a social work position,

with mental health needs being what they are, and the amount of benefit that we gain from the work of that person. I don't recommend doing that, but it is something we could do if we needed to. So, strong points why I do not recommend this tier. I just think it would be

staffing losses in really critical areas at this point. It would limit our flexibility to respond in key areas, special education, what if our enrollment went up, what if there was some kind of unforeseen need. I think at Powell in particular, the RTI reductions of those ed techs would be strongly felt. Moving

normal fifth grade to mass landing, possible, but disruptive and difficult, and we don't have all the answers yet of how that would work. And then at the middle school, removing two unified arts positions would be too much change and compromise the overall student experience.

And I just believe that the community would not support removing these positions. I don't think we need to do that. be on the footing where we need. So a look at class sizes. This slide is the class sizes at tier 2, the recommended

level. We'll look at how that changes at tier 1. It's similar because most of the changes from tier 1 to tier 2 are edtech positions and an instructional coach position. And then going to tier 3, the major change here is shifting that pound of

5th grade to mass landing. So you can see at mass landing, if I go back slide. We have 18 fifth graders in Palomel. It's right in the middle of the screen and five fifth grade classrooms at mass landing with 17 to 18 kids in them. We could distribute those 18 kids

32:03

at Palomel across five classrooms at mass landing and that would mean class sizes of 21, 22 at mass landing. Not ideal but within the policy guideline. So coming to the end of the presentation for tonight but a reminder that what is not included in my presentation are community programs and

school nutrition which you've just heard about but also region 10 region 10 will be presented to you later this month I don't know what their numbers are yet but I do know that they're planning on expanding and they're planning on adding a program in HVAC plumbing down at the landing

this year which is a great offering I just don't know yet what the budgetary implications for the in the schools would be. So next week, here's what I will present on. The board had asked for a concept about longer-term sustainability, and I will share ideas about that next week.

I want to emphasize that next week, the ideas that I'm going to share are conceptual, but they are not finely tuned. And in fact, the point of the presentation would be to ask the board, do you want us to even run further down these rabbit holes and flesh them out with the understanding, which I'm sure you'll appreciate that fleshing all of those, fleshing those ideas out takes a lot

of time. So if they're not even ideas that sound good, we can just move on and spend our time on other things. But if there are ideas that you'd like to hear more about, we can do that work. You had asked for at one point, look ahead scenarios, like what would the budget look like,

not next year, but the year after, if we do, depending on what we do now, and I will share that with your next week as well. And I can talk about next week the local tax impact of the budget I'm recommending versus the local tax impact if we keep just the status quo budget. In addition to just strictly budget

considerations, we'll have an update about strategic planning, and then there will be a time for extended questions and discussion from the board about the entire budget process. And before I close, I want to again just emphasize a theme I tried to draw out last week, but I just want to repeat it because

I just think it's really important. Talking about reductions is really hard. It's incumbent upon us to keep our discussion about positions, not about people, but every position has a person in it, and that's very difficult to separate. What I have to think about is, and

what the admin team has really given lots of thought to, is every position that we've talked about as a reduction has all the positions behind it that aren't written that we would be keeping and i in particular i don't mind saying it i keep i am mindful i was a high school teacher

but i'm mindful that the places where the kids need the most is in the early grades and it is prominent in my thinking to keep our class sizes for our littles manageable and our supports in place there. Questions or discussion

before I... Can you just remind us what the class size policy is for each grade level? I can, although I might have to rely on people who know it more intimately than I do. It's definitely smaller at the number of grades, and there is, within the class size policy, there's a level that you're allowed to get to before you have to take any action, and then there's a threshold above that where it's allowed, but you have to Does it come to the board? Somebody remind me. Will, help me. Kate's nodding. Yeah, we'd have to come to the board for clearance. So all of the class sizes that you see are before the level that the board would have to grant a clearance.

Thank you. So from pre-K, the threshold action level is 16. And that's by law. That's by law, yes. For K to 2, the target level is 18 and the threshold level is 20. From 3 to 5, the target level is 20 and the threshold is 22.

six to eight. The target is 21 and the threshold is 24. And there we go. And that's it. I don't see high school. I don't know if it's in there for high school. No. No, it's not in there for high school. It wouldn't be higher than the middle school. I'm holding my question

37:51

until you come back if you're coming back. Are you waiting there for questions? I was trying to stop mirroring. Okay. So this question might be more for Kelly than you anyway, so ask it while you're walking. So the discussion of taxed impact next week implies we have

the EB279? Okay. I know what I'm going to be checking tomorrow. She said yes. So how does that change with the budget, the state budget not being completed yet? Is that in flux or potentially in flux? Thank you for giving my moment to shine, Michelle Wright,

you know the answer to this question but yes 82 79 are actually preliminary numbers especially in a year where the budget has not been passed by the it's a proposed governor's budget that still needs to be passed by the legislature so

just want to say that we are receiving additional funding with the current proposed budget the way it's looking well we really haven't gotten time to do as a team is to kind of look at what the proposals look like and how to push

those through I mean I've looked at them individually but I haven't had time to sit down with cabinet or any members of the administrative team to kind of look at look at what that fleshes out to and part of the troublesome process for us

is because we do this so early as a board and you're typically setting the warrant articles in March is there's very little time for anything to really happen with the governor's budget right between now and then it will still be

in flux so if there is any sort of curtailment then we would have to deal with that say it happens in late May or June and we're already through our process a curtailment ultimately which means we wouldn't get as much money as

we were expecting we can't tax more right because where the assessments are set when the when the budget gets passed the very next meeting you guys suddenly assessment warrants out with the taxes and as part of the warrant

process when you're kind of walking through that you are establishing the amount that we can assess taxes for based upon expenditures that we're approving at the budget meeting and then any anticipated revenues so if any of

those revenue factors change, you just have to be responsive within the year. So, for example, we haven't had one year, so we're going to knock on some moon. There hasn't been a curtailment since I started around in 2010 here at five. I think it was 2011

that year we dealt with the curtailment, and we were looking for a couple hundred thousand dollars. And basically, we ended up freezing council of capital projects. We froze book money. We froze supply money. Those types of things. So that's something that we would have to consider. And again, if we get too far along in the process, all the contracts have been issued.

There's not a whole lot of at-will employees within the district. The majority of our staff are under collective bargaining agreements. And so it's typically not going to hit the areas of salaries and benefits if there's a

curtailment. Other than we may choose to not fill open positions in the meantime. correct thank you is that is that a case where we would use undesignated fund balance to sort of fill some of the gaps or how does that work so we don't have

authority to use undesignated fund balance except for during the budget process so one of the other potential benefits of having the article reserves that we've established over these past two budget cycles would be you could

potentially tap into those for those resources. So that will also be coming to you as a discussion at a later meeting about whether or not we're going to increase those reserves, what does that look like, where are they at currently. That will be at a future meeting as well to talk about so we

can deliberate that. And if there was a catastrophic drop in funding that we couldn't work our way around, we could hold another annual budget meeting sometime in the year to get authority to access more of the undesignated fund balance, but it would require. You do the entire process that you do now. It's just a special meeting. Thank you.

42:57

This is why we have also some of that buffer of, like, we're saying 7%, but it's slightly lower. Is this to help us with that potential gap as well? Yeah, and I think also the numbers that we don't have a firm grasp on, right?

Like region 10, those types of things. But once March comes and you actually vote, that sets the cap of expenditures. Right, we can't go above that, right. One of my other questions that jumped out was you mentioned there might be actual benefits

from the the shift in how we're looking at the middle school with the with the schedule yes and how the the adjusted schedule might work I think that was one of the items the board had mentioned last week that we would love to hear a little bit more about if if and when you guys were ready to do that and pens so

so I think maybe she's ready. Pam and Bill have worked really hard on this, and so they do have something to show you. I've got kind of, I don't want to say, a long thing to share, but Bill and I spent a lot of time and a lot of consideration into this,

and I just have a slideshow I want to show you guys. It's going to be a little bit to digest. I'm going to slowly walk us through this and certainly give an opportunity for any questions, but first of all, I just want to thank you for the opportunity tonight for us to share this with respect to the budget. We want the board to understand the scheduling

concept for FMS and how we are confident in offering a strong product despite the proposed budget cuts. Is this just Apple screen sharing? All right, library. All right, I just went to room 212. Okay, got it. Yep. 3124. Do I have that right? Sam might need help there.

So, like I said, a lot to digest. I'm going to kind of walk us through this slowly. A lot of thought has been put into this. Just want to give Mr. Ridge a big thank you to him and I have spent a lot of time on this. Well, if this is the most challenging part, I'm doing pretty good.

Sam gave me a faulty laptop. It's his fault. And, again, thank you for giving me the opportunity tonight. I know it wasn't really built into the agenda, but I just, you know, you guys had asked last week, so I wanted an opportunity to shut the light. with some visuals here.

On the whiteboard, we can just draw it. We, I mean, I know Mr. Gray's really good with the markers on the whiteboard, right? And the Tom's email. Bill has it on his laptop, too, so maybe we can. So I definitely want to show you guys the visuals as we can do this.

48:16

We're doing better, you guys? So a Freeport Middle School schedule concept. So follow with me. So I'm going to give you an overview. I'm going to walk you through the 6th, 7th, and 8th grade structures along with some key comparisons.

So prior to the last meeting, we talked about some budget cuts, so trying to figure out how to creatively create the best product for our kiddos here at Freeport Middle School. So the 6th grade structure, as referenced above, would be daily core classes with 50-minute periods

and optimized class sizes for foundational learning. Seventh grade would be continued daily core instruction in smaller math classes to support skill development and growth. Eighth grade, and that'll get a little tricky, but I'll talk you through it, but we'll have a rotation still, but an innovative rotation system with extended class periods and language opportunities for high school readiness.

So key comparisons will give you a visual analysis of class sizes, instructional time, and scheduling benefits across all grade levels. So, 6th grade schedule, 50-minute daily periods, all core subjects meet every day for 50 minutes, ensuring consistent instructional time,

math class sizes between 18 and 20, smaller math classes allow for individual instruction and skill development, core class sizes 22 to 23, ELI, Social Studies, STEM, Science, classes maintain optimal learning environment,

The unified arts rotation will be JMG, health, PE, art, digital media, and music. So class sizes are below the threshold action level that Tom was talking about earlier set by policy. Students will have access to rotate through the listed unified arts.

Math class sizes will be slightly smaller due to the accelerated math class. So they'll see every class every day that's including that social studies piece. Let's go on to 7th grade. So again, 50-minute daily periods, maintains consistent daily schedule structure for all core academic subjects.

Math class sizes 17 to 18, reduced math class sizes provide enhanced support during a critical learning year. I mean, every year is a critical learning year. Four classes 19 to 21, smaller class sizes across all subjects compared to grade 6.

Again, we have the unified arts options below, ranging from JMG, health, PER, and digital media. Remember, two students have access to band and chorus as well. All right, bear with me here. I'm going to explain this really well. Eighth grade rotational. So eighth grade currently does this and has historically followed this rotating schedule model.

Our sixth and seventh graders are living it this year. And as it may seem a little bit confusing, these kids knock it out of the park. Out of full transparency, when I first onboarded, it was a different model for me. But the kids really do a great job with it. It's communicated really well by staff. There's visuals in classrooms. There's visuals on the flat screen boards. The kids just, they really do a great job of it. So what we'd be looking at, and I know this might sound a little confusing at first, is

a rotation breakdown. So if you look at rotation one and rotation two, that means either the morning chunk or the afternoon chunk. And we still got to figure out how those rotations will fall into place. But what it will look like is math for 60 minutes, LA for 60 minutes, social studies

for 60 minutes in that first rotation. Each class will meet two out of the three days a week. Keeping class sizes at 17 to 18 kiddos. The second rotation, which would be the other half of their day, they'd have STEM, science, and Spanish for 60 minutes. So Spanish becomes a core class. Again, these classes would meet two out of the three days a week.

Class sizes 17 to 18 students. Unified arts include the JMG, health, PER, and digital media. So math, while this is a shift, we have had teacher input. We've spent a lot of time getting some teacher input. We'll continue to align with surrounding schools in terms of instructional time.

In addition to instructional class time, we have the ability to offer intentional math supports through our BCS model. If kids would require more support and review. We're looking at E-oriented social studies. So in the 8th grade model, we view these curriculums as aligned.

These teachers work really closely to structure classes in a way to support each other's curriculum. Some schools will refer to this as a humanities-type model. With that said, students will have access to social studies and ELA, one to two classes, periods, each day. So it's a really, really good experience for that. Here's a chart. I'm kind of talking about the class threshold. So you can see that red bar up top. So class sizes still fall below the threshold set forth by policy.

53:30

The eighth grade rotation, class sizes across all subjects promote personalized learning and project-based learning styles. So some of you are very, very familiar with Freeport Middle School. We've got the National History Day, the Dairy 30s, the kids do the science board games,

the STEM clocks, robotics, independent end-of-the-year options. This will give us some opportunities to even be more creative with some other ideas with that. So if we're looking at instructional time comparison, and I've got it graphed out here by 8th grade, 7th grade, and 6th grade.

So 6th and 7th grade daily model provides consistent daily instruction with the 15-minute periods. seeing every core class every day. The 8th grade rotation model offers an extended 60 minutes allowing for deeper exploration, project-based learning, and activities while meeting two of

every three days. Extended class periods and rationale schedule in the 8th grade support high school readiness, skills, and learning. So the 8th grade schedule kind of gives them a little bit more of a transition into what they feel like at the high school. So you can kind of look here,

the two shades indicate the differences between how rotations fall in the 8th grade schedule, meeting the minutes the kids need in each core class per week. So if we look at another diagram with the 8th grade rotation. So if you look at the two rotation models, classes will be divided into a rotation 1 and 2 for a balanced curriculum every day.

The 60-minute periods, extended class time allows for deeper exploration and hands-on activity. And for what I've learned from this 8th grade team, they knock it out of the park with these super-duper creative ideas. Meeting two out of three days, each class meets two out of three days, providing time for processing.

That includes Spanish being one of those core classes. And the class sizes meet the target sizes. Key benefits of the schedule structure. So what class sizes? Class sizes for 6th to 8th grade remain within the limits set forth by policy

and more often align to the target class size set forth by policy. 8th grade flexibility. The rotation schedule with extended periods allows for that deeper learning and project-based activities. high school language readiness. Spanish language introduces into the eighth

grade rotation and prepares students for the high school language requirement. So they would see Spanish as a core class. And then finally our schedule comparison summary. So breaking it down by grade levels. Comprehensive overview

comparing the scheduling framework across grades six to eight. Highlighting key differences in structure timing and class configurations. So we've got the The class duration, 6th and 7th grade 50 minutes, 8th grade 60, meeting frequency daily and daily for 6th and 7th graders, 2 out of 3 days for the 8th graders, which they already do.

We'll go look at the class sizes, those fall right into policy, really fair. Other core classes, 6th grade's a little bit high, but we're still not hitting that threshold. Spanish, the kids will have that more. They won't suffer from any summer gap, from anything they've learned through 7th grade meeting as more of a unified arts.

8th grade can just kick off and not have to worry about rebuilding those skills from the 7th grade. And you really can start building to get that robust foreign language experience for them. To get them ready for high school Spanish. That was a lot. We've put a lot of thought into what we have to work with.

We've put a lot of thought into the amazing staff we have. The skill set the staff has. The creativity the staff has. And what's really good for kids. And we've taken all that, and we feel we have a really strong product to support the learning of our 6th, 7th, and 8th graders to prepare them for the high school.

I just wanted to present to you tonight to let you know that we're taking the cuts seriously, and not just the cuts. We're taking our job as building administrators, educators, and everybody on the team who works hard to deliver the best education and experience for our kiddos.

And I just stand here today to appreciate the confidence, because I am so confident that we are going to rock this school this year and next year. I'm just feeling really, really good about it. And that's what we have here tonight. Thank you. Thank you, Pam. I love that you had the different visuals, like to see it in different ways,

because that was great. And to pull that together since last week is pretty impressive. So thank you. I know that's a lot of work to put all those puzzle pieces in a way that works. Again, thank you for the time tonight. Questions?

58:39

Sorry, Pam, I think I have a question for you. Just give back Bill's laptop and come back. So thank you so much, you and Bill and everyone who's been working on that. That's really, really helpful to see the visual of how that would look

and hear the plan around that. That's really helpful. I'm still wanting to hear more, I guess, about the language change. And currently, sixth graders, I believe, are exposed to a language in a World Cultures class. Right. And would that World Cultures class be absorbed within that Social Studies class that would be happening?

It would really be absorbed with that Digital Citizen course that we're going to be implementing in, which won't even just be digital citizenship. It'll be better research skills, communication skills. I'm still looking at a creative way to figure out how to bring that to sixth grade, just

looking at the cards we have, but we certainly feel it's also important to bring that digital component and citizenship to kids, especially in the world we're living in now with the AI component and the cell phones, et cetera, et cetera. So that would be an absorption mix. Okay. And currently, seventh graders get to choose between J&G, Spanish, and French, correct?

That's correct. And so with this plan, seventh graders would not have a language. Seventh graders wouldn't have a language, and we really thought hard about that. So there's a common misconception that sometimes more years equals more learning.

When we look at this, the way they're getting whatever foreign language they're choosing now, it's a UA option. And so you're just getting, I don't want to say a minimal amount, but less amount of that core instruction with the foreign language in that summer gap.

So the way we're looking at it, while we're putting Spanish as more of a core class, they'd be aligned with an 8th grade team. It wouldn't be a UA option. We can really start setting those skills and really take it off with that with the kids.

So we're hopeful that that model will be more beneficial. It actually calculates to more minutes of Spanish instruction that way. Can you say more about how Spanish was the chosen language? And is that an enrollment-based decision? Or can you say more about that? I mean, really hard decisions, right? All of them are really, really hard decisions. And certainly if you're looking at the high school, too, right? The theater program. And I know that in hearing from different administrators, too,

sometimes we're filtering kids in and they have that different skill set, which can be a benefit and certainly can be a challenge if you're a teacher trying to get kids here to here. It's hard, right? You don't want to have to pick one or the other. And I could maybe have a better prepared answer, but I think when we're looking at it, it's going to prepare the kids for a more equitable experience.

And I don't want to use DCS, but DCS has that Spanish experience, too, and it kind of filters that in. And the kids still have that foreign language option when they get to the high school. Pam, am I correct that there are more kids right now choosing Spanish than French, too?

So, I guess I'm wondering if DCS and FMS students are all coming into the high school with Spanish experience, would that impact the Spanish language teaching needs? Is that making sense? And then kids who want to learn French, would they, they would all be coming in, needing a different level?

Probably like an intro to French, and I guess I'd have Mrs. Gugel maybe talk more about their programs, but that would be my strong assumption. And I would imagine the kids coming in, that would make the program even a little bit robust,

because they're going to have a setup on those skill sets that are already kind of commonly foundationally set from filtering into the high school. It's a tricky one, right, Kara? It's like, you know, you don't want to cut any programs, and, you know, I'm coming into this school,

and they've just got an awesome opportunity with all these different options and opportunities, and no one wants to sit here and have to choose what programs are being cut. And unfortunately, you're tasked with doing that and looking at data and what's least impactful,

and then it's like you're making the right decision. You're second-guessing, but you do the best you can to make that best-informed decision. This isn't necessarily a budget issue, but I'm just thinking for those 8th graders

who, maybe in the past, have gone on a sort of a capstone trip to Montreal, I'm sorry, to Quebec City, I'm assuming, without a fringe program, that might not be something that the 8th graders are able to do anymore. So I'm just thinking if we go to Spanish exclusively,

1:03:47

it would be really nice if we consider something similar. I agree. I agree. I agree. And I'll just throw in, because from an equity perspective, the Durham kids don't have any access to those types of programs, So if there was one for a replacement for the Quebec City one,

or it's Quebec City, right? Yeah. Yeah, but maybe they'd go together. You know, I was always open to fresh ideas and exploring new things. That's what we do, right? And I'm always open to that. I'm always open to trying to figure out how to provide opportunities for kids,

no matter how big they are. Small opportunities, medium opportunities are worth thinking way outside the box. Mike? Not a question for you, Pam. Sure. but Tom I would love to hear maybe next week when you talk more about some of the

long-term plan the strategic thinking that's gone behind this the language decision and how it will then affect the kind of the high school course of studies the the the French the French language reduction at the middle school

the one that I'm having the hardest time kind of wrapping my head around right now just love some more information about that sure don't need it right now yeah I think that that is something that we have to we have to flesh out because it would certainly impact the numbers

going forward to the high school there's there's time to think about that and not that I necessarily want to take too much time to editorialize and I hope that when I say this it will have some credibility with people I'm personally actually very passionate about language I had the opportunity

to take German from fifth grade, and at this point I'm fluent in German, and I would love for us to be a district that had world language going down to kindergarten. I just don't see that as possible right now, and I think that's a great topic to talk about in a strategic plan as an aspirational,

you know, something we could aspire to. The short answers about why we would propose this are, The schedule at the middle school really does need streamlining. And Pam and Bill have done a great job thinking about how to make that happen. It really makes the social studies teacher in me happy. I don't think what they're getting right now in social studies is nearly enough.

And everything is a really difficult tradeoff. This is a painful one to consider. Yeah, it would be interesting to see, you know, numbers for enrollment between the different languages at the high school. It would be interesting, I don't know if they can track this, but to see how many kids come from Durham that then choose to move to French, right?

Because they never had French in middle school. Maybe they choose to do it in high school. Maybe they don't. I don't know. I appreciate hearing that it's actually more minutes of Spanish instructional time than splitting it over the two years.

Because one of my questions was going to be, as I know, I know coming out of Durham, and I imagine it's probably similar coming out of FMS, you know, kids who have, you know, taken to the language can move into, you know, Spanish 2 as a freshman and get all the way up through Spanish 5 as a senior if that's their desire.

And so I guess my question would be, you know, with only 8th grade, does that still cover all of the Spanish 1 curriculum? So that if kids so chose and maybe had a recommendation from the teacher, could move on to Spanish 2 as a freshman.

So that was one of my questions. Definitely a wonder. While we have Pam up here. Yeah. Thank you. The visuals were very helpful and appreciate you putting that together in such a short amount of time. a few questions one is you mentioned in seventh grade there's no music that's

offered but they do have chorus and band yeah so that's similar to the model we have this year as well so they definitely have access to that band chorus grouping and are pulled out for individual lessons with band and chorus

as well so similar to what we have this year and that's during the school day Yes. Okay, got it. And then could you, not related to this schedule, but in terms of the ed techs, looking at the Tier 2 reductions, could you walk us through just a little bit about how many ed techs

you currently have and the different categories of them? Sure. So I can focus on when we're talking about the Tier 2 with the two general ed ed techs. So we have three. We kind of align them by grade level, 6th, 7th, and 8th grade.

1:08:56

They work really closely, they attend all the team meetings, they work very closely with supporting kids, they pull kids out for structured support, which is really helpful a lot of times during our BCS time. We work really closely with the teams, we meet twice a week with each grade level, that includes administration, school counselor, social workers, ed techs, and we identify some kids that, and it may just be a motivation thing, it may be an obstacle that's really getting in their way to

get those academics done and those those staff members who again a huge shout out to an excellent job not just helping the kids academically make some really solid connections with them and kids that even struggle maybe attendance wise coming to school that's that person right so they do a

really great job with those connections and so the two reductions that we're talking about at tier two that would be to grade level general ed techs. Got it. And currently how many are there? Thank you. Last question is it looks like the largest class size is actually a grade six if you're

looking by it's still below the threshold but just under. Could you talk about if you do you have any concerns about that? So enrollments up in grade six you know there's always concerns when class sizes get larger, you know, not speaking to prior experiences, but I've come from school

districts where unfortunately class sizes can be 27, 28, which is like mind blowing, right? I've had experience as a classroom teacher where I've had class sizes in a science classroom 27, 28, right? It's like so hard to wrap your head around that. So I look at this and it's

really ideal to keep those class sizes minimal. I look at the team of teachers that we have in grade six, you know, definitely do some further conversations with them and, you know, where do you see there being some obstacles? How do you see us supporting you? Because this is a little bit new for the staff with having those class sizes bump up a little bit. Do I have concerns? I don't

have concerns. I have faith and I have faith that we'll figure that out. But we certainly want to keep an eye on some of those class sizes that are a little larger than normal and support the teachers, support the curriculum, support the materials, and support the connections that the

it will generally have with the teachers. Thank you. Thank you. Other questions for Pam or for others? I think I have a question that's probably more for Tom, because it's kind of about that group of ed techs as a whole, because we call some of them general ed ed techs, we call some of them

RTI ed techs, we call some of them bench sub ed techs, and I think I understand the bench sub. Thank you, Ray Grogan. What's that? Yes. It is kind of funny because I feel like the bunch slug name came from Ray. Ray's no longer here. Will had his own name for him. I can't remember it now, but... Flirty. Oh, that's the floating. Okay. Yeah. So maybe once you leave, we'll take your name.

Oh, no, we're getting rid of it, so maybe not. So I guess I'm interested in knowing, are those essentially the same positions in different schools, or are they doing different things depending on the school they're in? So, in general, there are two categories. There's special ed and general ed. RTI is general ed. And so they are... And for new board members, RTI, response to intervention? It's basically extra help for kids who are behind. So they may not have a disability, which is what special ed would be, but if I think about likely scenarios, these may be elementary school kids who have not been exposed to language in the same degree as home as other kids, and they don't have a disability, they just need to be read to, so they need extra support in that area.

They provide a lot of small group instruction and individual instruction and support. And that's, so whether we call it an RTI ed tech or a general ed ed tech or, well, the bench sub is a bench sub, right? They're filling in with people out there. But an RTI ed tech and a general ed ed tech are essentially the same?

An RTI ed tech is a version of a general ed ed tech. Okay. So general ed is anything outside of special ed. And a special ed ed tech is going to be in a more specialized role in one of our special education programs like life skills, for example.

1:14:01

So they'll be directly serving kids with IEPs, and it's just a different beast. Okay. And then the RTIB, that is also a general ed tech, yes? Correct. And we are not in Tier 2 recommending any reductions in that programming.

Well, that was at Poundell, an RTIB. Right, right. No, but I don't believe Poundell is the only school that has RTIB ed techs, correct? I don't think so. Yeah, because I feel like that's something that's been added in the last, you know, as we were seeing more behavioral issues, but not necessarily special ed behavioral issues, the support of the RTIB ed techs.

So I was just clarifying that none of the recommended reductions are in those positions, assuming we don't go all the way to the 6% tier 3, correct? Correct. Not true. No, there's a proposal in Tier 2 that the RTIB EdTechs have had that most great amount of money.

Okay, it just says RTI EdTech, so those are RTIB. Yeah. Sorry. So behavioral versus academic. Okay, so those are both Bs. That was my question. Thank you. Those are Bs. Thanks, Pam. Thank you, everybody. But just to be clear, these positions are not filled right now, is that correct?

No, they are. So the RTI, the general ed tech positions that are in the recommended area to be reduced, are filled right now. But we have 5.5 special ed vacant ed tech positions. And I feel like the appropriate question is, how do we meet the needs of the stuff that's being done by this group without them?

That's for you, Tom. Or anyone else who wants to jump up and help. Well, it would certainly be an impact that would be felt. We'd have to do more RTI within the classroom. Most of RTI is supposed to be done in Tier 1, which is right in the classroom with differentiated instruction, and that extra person does help. So I certainly wouldn't pretend it wouldn't be an impact. It would be a manageable impact, and given the other choices of where we would reduce to achieve that level,

I think that's the most appropriate place. The last thing I would want to do is be cavalier about saying that any of those reductions wouldn't have an impact. Oh, yeah. I mean, I think we can all agree that we don't have any positions that don't add value.

And I appreciated you starting the presentation last week, you know, putting that front and center. Every single position has value, and every position will be felt. It's, you know, what's manageable, how do we continue to provide the best services we can with the resources we have.

So, yeah. Chris? Something I would like to see for next week is kind of a thought on a, I don't know exactly how to word this, but kind of a blend between a 7% and 8% tier. Because there's a lot I see in this 7% tier that I very much question. And I know, again, every position has value.

An example of this is that I see us cutting two of these general ed techs from Freeport Middle when there are three total, which is two-thirds of the ed techs that we have there. And so I'm curious if there's kind of a balanced proposal in that with those two tiers.

Well, maybe what might be helpful is what do we have now? What are we proposing for next year? So what I don't know is, you know, is there only one, and we're cutting one? Is there three, and we're cutting one, and we're cutting two? It might be helpful to know, you know, kind of what do we have now versus what's the proposed.

Yeah, you had mentioned that, like, one of the things we don't see on this list is what we are keeping. It might be good to know what we are keeping to understand that, you know, the cuts have this proportion of impact versus this proportion.

Absolutely. So you're asking to see something between Tier 1 and Tier 2. How would we get something between Tier 1 and Tier 2? Yeah, I think it would be helpful for me with some of these positions, particularly the behavioral ed techs, to hear directly from the administrators

1:19:24

about the actual impacts that they perceive would be from eliminating these positions because I know we can talk in generalities here, but it would just be helpful for me to know exactly how they think this is going to impact

their kids in the classroom. Can I add to that? And a plan for mediating that. Mitigating. Mitigating. Thank you. What's the impact on how are they going to deliver in the absence of that person or people? I haven't really heard anything much about the instructional strategist,

So just making sure that's included. Sure. For the instructional strategist, correct me if I'm wrong, this is one of two, correct, that we have at? It's actually one of three. One of three, okay. And at the elementary level, and the plan is to go from three to two. See, that would show up in the wooden recieping pile. Yeah.

Yep. It's a strange thing to ask for, but if there was any way we could hear about facts that we will see reflected in test scores that are brought before us sometimes later in the evening in which we're talking about this, and then ones that are not really testable or are not tested or are not, maybe we put it this way, are not shown to the board or not something where the board can say, oh, we really see what that impact is. Not to say that, again, the... Like how kids work in groups. Yeah, I mean, it's not to say that, I'm in no way prioritizing the testing scores as an educational measure,

but just, like, we do see those, and so we can talk about them, but if we don't see other measures and how they sort of, like, operate year to year, we kind of don't really have a sense of that. So I think that, because I found myself as I was going through this, just sort of, like, one logical way to look at this is, like, if our scores, if our test scores are not where we want them, probably reducing our teaching staff is not a great way to get them higher.

Again, that's oversimplified, but it's, like, one way of looking at it. But maybe that's just, again, maybe, like, we're not, we wouldn't see that. We wouldn't see a play out in that way. So, I don't know, I think that might be helpful to have some sort of sense of that.

And, yeah, I think I would just, I would also say that the, I think the, on the hand, the mitigation question is the much harder question. unfortunately that is that is the question um it's not like that your initial question kelly of like

what's the impact going to be is like important but it's like the mitigation and like can it be mitigated or can it not be and is the mitigation satisfactory um uh the administrators and then we eventually get to determine whether or not that mitigation is satisfactory in terms of

Our responsibility, I'm all, will be serving the children. Yeah, I just want to mention that the question about how we measure all of this is really important and one that the Strategic Planning Committee is taking seriously this year with the strategic plan, is how are we measuring everything? How are we measuring the goals that we have? So I appreciate this being brought up again, and we still have a few months to develop that plan.

But I think that this process will help that process, too. In the ESL position, I know that we have a few board members who are definitely attached to that for good reason. But could you give us a sense of, like, the number of students that are in that program over, I know, the last couple of years, I know you said it's dropped.

But, again, seeing numbers, as well as the number, we can't predict the future, but kind of as we project out to get a sense of why. I think it actually has some numbers. Okay. Yes? Yep. We can look at that really quickly.

1:24:34

You want the over-year numbers as well as, sorry, Erica Maccio, Assistant Superintendent. You would like the over-year numbers as well as the current or projected? Okay. Let me start, so I don't have the trend numbers up, but I can grab them in just a minute.

I can start with our current population that we serve. I don't have a presentation for you. Okay. So we're currently serving 44 students. 13 of whom are at the pre-k 2 span 12 of whom are at grades 3 4 and 5 at the middle school level it's five students we have 10 students in grades 9 through

11 and 4 in the cohort that are meant to graduate in June so if we don't gain any new students we can anticipate retaining about 40 if we do we're certain you know this is the level at which we are currently serving and then inside of

those counts they have different levels of need as determined by their annual assessments and so those range between one and two service hours instructional service hours which is not necessarily measured in a 60 minute increment but rather standardized comparison to their regular general

education schedule. And we have 14 students in the two-hour range and 30 students in the one-hour range. Is that per day? Uh-huh. Yeah, instructional hours. And they can be served in groups. And primarily our students exist in the Freeport schools. So MSS, MLS, FMS, and FHS. I'll look

up the trends. One of the things that I think we learned about last year, and I don't know if these numbers pick those up was there's a group of kids that are like I'm sorry if I'm using the wrong term monitor or is that in this number as well or is

that separate from this it is separate because that is not a required service area and so we are currently monitoring 16 students okay so they don't have any I know one to two hours a day no required service structure is typically

the guidance is that those students are served through what we're referring to as RTIA academic services or MTSS which is essentially the same thing yeah thank you okay so historical numbers and this was in the spring sorry in the

September presentation but I'm going to pull up so the service count in 2425 this was over year total, so there could have been some coming and going, was 46. In 23-24, it was 116. In 22-23, it was 101. And across all of those years, and including this year, there were 3.0 FTE serving, for reference.

In the kind of projections on that, do we have a sense if the CDS transition is going to increase those numbers? Is that something we can get a sense of? I don't know the answer. I would be very surprised if it increased it back to 100 plus where we were before.

Yeah, interestingly, what is referred to as the, I don't know why the screen is flashing, but it's not me. The home language screener, which is what we use to do the initial identification, is administered by us, and I don't know that CDS has an equivalent to that, because they're

not providing educational services, so I don't know how they would record that. Certainly, we do it on our screening and our onboarding through the enrollment process. And I don't know how Erica's numbers have that she has her finger on.

I can go back to 2017. I was going to say, because there was a point in time where we had a .5 ESOL teacher for the whole district. 2021. And how many students was that? 14. And we did have some ed tech supporting in those really high volume years.

1:29:37

I don't know what exactly their schedules look like, but i do have a note of that it's not my lived experience so somebody else would have to probably clarify that but we had 2.0 fte and 21 22 with a total count of 24. it's the most recent time

we have two and i do think in the sort of the the peak year of 23 and 24 um i think we had three full-time and then we had a contract so we were almost up to four people yeah somebody was hired I heard in December, and I don't have enough context about that.

Yeah, so I think we've been as low as a half-time position for the district and as high as essentially four full-time. I think there was some mobilizing to register students at their place of residence, and that was also part of the need. Yeah, that was the year that, a week before school started, we got a call.

But I think we had 40 kids that needed to be registered for something like that. Did that answer your question, Chris, on that? Yes, thank you. I think two questions. One might be able to answer now and the other probably would be next week.

But has DCS ever had a French offering? Not since I can recall, but we've got 23 years of experience, so. No, no, we've not had French. No. No, okay, the answer is no, it's had French. Okay. My other question was, I know that there's a collection of schools that we like to kind of, like, keep up with, if you like the better word.

I would be curious to know, among those schools, what sorts, what sort of offerings did they have at the middle school level in terms of languages? And I suppose, yes, I guess it would be nice to know and be shamed if we don't.

If everybody else offers Latin in kindergarten, that would be helpful to know. But I'm really interested in that. The district that I just came from, my previous position, is RSU 40, 1,700 kids across seven schools, a much lower tax base.

they had Spanish going down to kindergarten in every school. So I am shamed. Okay, great. Thank you, John. I needed more shame to carry around. Thank you. They have 30 kids in kindergarten now. Sorry. They do. I was trying to get me a little better. Can I add on to that, the middle school language, but also high school language?

Sure. All right. Any other things they've... Oh, Valerie, sorry. I looked right. I know it's weighing patiently. While we're talking language, do we have enrollment numbers for Latin or the three languages I noticed? I thought I remembered that we all have two Latin teachers, and that's why we thought maybe reducing to one might be less painful.

Do we have enrollment numbers for their languages in the high school? I don't have them at my fingertips. I don't know if Jen hasn't met her fingertips. And as a former world language teacher, I'm sure it's difficult for Jen to even think about reducing a world language.

position. So we'll start with that. We know this is hard. Yes, thank you. Jen Gokel from the high school. So I think the thing that we have to consider is what's the balance of the class sizes across the three languages? Because right now, our students almost always get their first

choice of a language. Both of the other districts that I came from always had students pick a second choice for a language and did not guarantee their first choice. Now, at some point, if they didn't get their first choice and later on in high school said, okay, I've taken two years of Spanish, I'd

like to switch over to French, they were able to do that. You didn't have to be in ninth grade to get into an intro level of a language. Actually, we offer an award here at Academic Awards for students who take on multiple languages. So there will be an impact of the number of ninth graders

1:34:49

who can get the language of their first choice. That is a definite that will happen. What we see right now is that when we get up into, because currently we offer Latin 4, we offer Spanish 4 and 5, and we offer French 4 and 5. Currently our numbers for French 4 and 5

are very low, and so they are combined into one class. Last year, that was the case for Spanish 4 and 5. We've increased Spanish by a little bit, and so we have a large enough class for Spanish 4 to be a class by itself,

whereas Spanish 5 is very small. And so I do think that we are going to see a benefit of those numbers growing in terms of the upper levels of French and Spanish. what the impact would be of not offering French at the middle school level

is that we would not offer French 5 in person. And right now, the numbers, I can say, in the last four or five years, they have been under 10 students every year in French 5. Right now, the number is, if I pull that up right now, sorry for one sec.

The number of students in French 5 is 4 students. And so we'd love to see that be 20 students. 20 in that class, 20 in Spanish 4. And we would also have the opportunity, which we have right now, is that students who have had a strong foundation in Spanish in the middle school

will be able to start here in Spanish 2, which they can do right now. And so then they would go level 2, 3, 4, 5. So while we are reducing the number of sections that we're offering for Latin, the hope is that we will still have a robust program

and number of students who are able to take Latin with our one Latin teacher and also potentially see those numbers grow at the upper levels for French and for Spanish at the same time. In terms of the number of students who are taking Latin, will say that Latin is they they have done our Latin teachers have done a

phenomenal job of growing that program and having students a large number of students in that program and so but we feel that we would be able to balance that some students might not get to take Latin in their freshman year but they

they might then be able to join we would prioritize them getting it in their sophomore year so that they would be able to do that so right now for example um we would need to configure who teaches um well with one teacher which how many sections they would need of latin one versus two versus

three versus four we currently don't offer latin five so that would be the case next year um and so So right now we have a section of Latin 1 that has 13 students. We have a section of Latin 1 that has 8 students. And then we have a section of Latin 1 with 16 students,

and another with 11, and another with 13. And so those are small class sizes, you know, as we compare. And we're talking about other grade levels. And so some of those classes would be combined to be in one section, and then some of those students may not get their first choice and may be in a place where they're choosing French or Spanish as their language.

Thank you. All right. Have we exhausted our questions for this evening? All rights are reserved to continue asking questions next week. Okay. Thank you. All right. So we will move on to Unfinished Business 12B, which is the Early Childhood Special Education.

So we will get a motion on the floor, and then we will have Tom provide us an update. So do I have a motion for consideration and approval to join Cohort 3, 2026-2027 of the Early Childhood Special Education, EDSE, Transition from Child Development Services, CDS, to RSU-5.

1:39:55

Kelly and Kara, thank you. Okay, I just have 13 children, so I'm going to go put it up. Okay, so at long last, we come to it. You might need a cookie. Okay, so long story here, and we've been sort of following it week by week,

but we, sorry? Bigger? Make it bigger. Well, let me... How am I going to make this bigger? It didn't like it. Oh, it doesn't like it. Here, we'll do this. Is that going to work? Because then you can see it. I'll move it around. So, without recapping every single detail

that I've already shared several times in previous weeks, When we did our task force process, which we really, we did for the sake of getting lots of input and transparency, we didn't know that we were working with a faulty spreadsheet from the state.

We didn't know that until just the beginning of last month, and we had, of course, in that process received guidance from the state several times about what it would take, what we felt was, quote, reasonable and necessary, unquote, to assume responsibility for four-year-olds

for next year. This is, of course, to take on the special education responsibilities. Upon discovering their spreadsheet error in January, go ahead, Sam, we had to, do lots of last-minute planning and thinking with them and collaboration to try to make

adjustments based on their new guidance. So the new guidance from the state was not only working with a much smaller number, but it was also much more granular about what they would approve in our budget. We had run our plan by them before and had gotten their approval based

on the original numbers they gave us, but when it was evident to them that they had less money to work with to give not just to us, but to other school districts, the guidance that came from them all of a sudden became much more specific about what they would fund. So we finally got, just a few

days ago, final confirmation from the folks at DOE that after a lot of back and forth, what they will approve. So this is what I'm bringing to you, and let me see if I can make this understandable. One of the biggest needs that we have is a director

administrative oversight. The state has determined now, they had not determined this in December, but they've determined now that they will really only support in the early childhood allocation a certain proportion of administrative time

to oversee that program. And what you see up there is .2 of an administrative position where we can put into the Early Childhood Education Fund which is from the state. The rest... This entity that is making these determinations, are they the ones that also have administrated in the past? No. So who's administrated in the past is CDS and they're diverting that funding from CDS to school districts. So this is coming into the DOE in a way that

it did not before. I see. So it's CDS's efforts that they are downplaying, not their own. Sure. So what you see up there, the cost of $176,000 for an ECSE coordinator. I just want to be clear, that is not the salary of an ECSE coordinator. It's the salary plus the

benefits package. And that is at the level of an assistant principal in our district. So we can push 0.2 of that into the early childhood fund. The rest would have to come from the local fund. Now, our local taxes. But spoiler alert, they have at the same time approved other expenses

1:45:15

for staff that we are already paying out of our local budget to go into the CDS money. So all of that is broken down in this spreadsheet. So one of the needs that we have is a 282B teacher. That's a special education teacher for a special purpose classroom.

Most of that would go into the Early Childhood Education Fund. Point two of it would have to come out of local. We've asked for two special ed ed techs to serve in that program. Those would be brand new on top of the ed techs we already have. Those would be fully in the early childhood fund.

A speech-language pathologist. We already have a speech-language pathologist serving pre-K, and that person is paid for it right now entirely out of local money. But we can put .9 of that salary into the early childhood fund.

So there is some offset with the director in what you're seeing here. We would have to set aside some money for contractors like psychologists, teacher of the deaf, etc. That could come out of the special allocation. Some hours for drivers. And another addition which they had not told us they would approve back in December,

but they have told us now, is a portion of a general ed pre-K teacher could go into the special ed early childhood fund. And that is because many of the kids with IEPs and pre-K need to have access to a general education setting for the least restricted environment.

So that is a half of that salary could go into early childhood. So what it all shakes down to, if you see the orange square, the $17,300 is a net impact to the local taxpayer. But what we're getting out of that is to be able to enter the cohort in a separate pot of money that is not reflected here that's 100% from the state.

We can get all kinds of necessary equipment and assessments and curriculum to get that started. And we're adding an assistant special education director, most of whose duties would be in early childhood, Despite the fact that we have to break the budget down by line items in that way.

So that is an impact that Kelly and I have talked about. That's $17,000. That is an impact that Kelly and I have talked about and feel is fairly represented in what we are bringing to you for the budget as it is. Because many of those costs in the budget, and Kelly and I would say this better than I could, are estimated staffing costs.

So, this represents a good deal for the district. It does enable us to join the cohort at this time and start, most importantly, I think, when we focus entirely on money, we lose sight of the work. And the earlier we start this work with kids, the more we're serving the kids who need it.

And that will pay off and move on with kids getting their needs met earlier, Getting earlier interventions and being able to move out of special education earlier, thus saving us money over the long haul. Is it fair to say that, obviously, having a director on next year to cover the launch of the program,

that is a position that wouldn't necessarily need to increase in the following year when we add the three roles. So would we be able to shift a larger percentage of their time into that funding formula because they're supporting potentially twice as many kids going from four-year-olds to four and three?

That's a possibility because what they're telling us right now is that far too logical. I want to be really respectful. I think the folks at DOE are really doing their best with a hard situation and they were very gracious when that spreadsheet error was discovered

and they owned that it was on them, but us in a hard position. The guidance they're giving us specifically is that they can only improve costs based on the per pupil. And, you know, the back and forth that we had with them is my explanation to them that we're trying to build a program that's not just for four-year-olds that come next year, but for the threes

that come the year after that we're promising to take on. And with the fours, we do have an early childhood intervention team already on staff that meets most of that need. Where we really need help is the oversight to build the architecture for the threes that

1:50:21

will come, and that's where we still have a lot of work to do. I think that the person that we hire, even though it says .2 of their salary would come out of that allocation, most of their work right now will be in building a childhood

program that we will be mandated to take on in 2028. And then potentially once that's up and running, I mean, you know, essentially having the cost of an assistant principal for 50 kids, right, which we wouldn't typically have.

We wouldn't have a school with 50 kids and say, you guys need an assistant principal. Obviously, it's not apples to apples because these are kids that have higher needs. But, you know, is that something where some of that could be shared, since the cost is being shared with the local side, could be shared with more, you know, general special ed support?

I think so, yes. I don't want to overpromise because I just have to be mindful that this is all coming from the state. it would take a change in the law to do this laws can change, administrations can change we will have a new administration in Augusta by 2028 we are basing all of this on the assumption

that we have a mandate to fulfill by 2028 I was just thinking less about the state and where they're going with early childhood education We're thinking, we can't really hire a .2 administrator. Nobody's going to do that, right? So we will get a full person, which the majority of their time,

certainly in the next year or two, is going to be about building out this program. But presumably there will be some capacity after that to support the district as large as a special education. Yes, for sure. My hope is that we definitely need a whole person who has extensive knowledge about early childhood and special education and that we could have that person now build this program for us, but also be able to assist us with special education in general.

That's what I was hoping for. Okay. Thank you. And thank you guys for kind of finding a way that works within their parameters but also gets the needs for the program met to get it launched in next year. I know that was no easy feat and a lot of back and forth. And I guess my last question, how confident are we that they're going to stick to that?

Well, Sandy Flack, who is the person at DOE that we've done most of the discussion with, emailed me yesterday and was pretty effusive about this plan. So we were very specific in making sure, you know, the reason we didn't do this a few weeks ago

was that I didn't want to bring you numbers that were not accurate. I am confident, based on what I'm told from the authorities, that this is accurate and doable. Okay. And this isn't recorded, so. Okay. I see you added the driver hours. Is there any other transportation requirements for this?

So there are? Just on our regular pre-K buses that we're running right now? It can operate on those buses right now because we are meeting most of the need already through our current pre-K program. I do think when we talk about three-year-olds, we have more thinking to do.

But one of the costs that we also had had in our original ask for this pot of money was for a van. And we've been told, take the van out of this pot of money, but there's another pot of money that is 100% state-funded where you can get the van.

And the money, not necessarily this pot of money, but the pot of money that would contribute towards our supplies and materials, the other pot, that we would need to build out this program. We are at an advantage if we start this year because if we don't, that money is going to be distributed to other programs.

So that is correct, and others in the room who've worked with this, Ted's here somewhere, right? Hey, Ted. I'll try it, but save me if I say this the wrong way. So when this entire proposition was put forward, there was a special pot of money for districts that joined early,

and the incentive was if you join early and commit to taking this over from CDS, there's more financial support for you to get all that stuff that you just mentioned. So the earlier you join, the more incentive there is for startup support.

1:55:34

A lot of that money is dwindling. So there is not as much of a promise if we wait that we will be able to cash in on that. Is there a promise that if we do join this year, we can get that money? Or is that, like, I'm coming up with numbers, but, like, let's say there's, you know, $3 million left in that,

and all of a sudden there's a $7 million ask, and they're like, actually, you only get, you know, three-sevenths of your money. If I'm completely honest, so that could happen. Because I can't stand here and tell you that I know how much money they have in that fund or how they're allocating it.

All I can tell you is that the promise is the earlier you join, the more likelihood that there is that that money is available. So what happens if it's not? So what happens if we go, okay, we need a van, we need chairs, we need tables, we need big fat crayons, whatever we need. And they go, oh, sorry, money's gone, and we've committed. And now we have to fund those things because we have 41 showing up. That is the case. Okay, so what are you doing? Because if we find out after we adopt the budget... Well, Kelly and I would sit back, Kelly and Alicia and I would sit back and think of what

we would need to ask for, and we would have to come to you with a plan for that. I don't have that backup plan now. I do have an assurance from them that that money is there for us now. Do we have a... I see the face you're making. Hopefully I'm not on camera, I'm over here.

Do we have a sense of what that number could be? Like, what do we think the sort of startup costs for this program are that we expect to get? I don't have it right at my fingertips, but we had that worked out in our earlier proposal and itemized.

I don't know if you had it in detail. I'm just curious of kind of, you know, what was stuff that we would like to have that would be nice to be able to get us off and running at a great start versus what do we absolutely must have in order to take this over

when the kiddos show up on the first day of school. and to me that what we have to have is the potential we're on the hook for if they say there's no money left and i'm not saying we shouldn't do this i'm just saying we should

know what that number is in case we have to find it somehow so it's there's curriculum assessments in pd um adding up about thirty two hundred dollars um can we can find that there's forty three thousand dollars for a van there is a special request form for a van um there's car

seats and boosters. They add up to about $380. That's like one car seat. What are you guys buying? We have about $150 a piece. There's some technology equipment and PD. There's some iPads, some teacher and staff computers, and some programs. All of that together is

about $10,500. So compared to these other line items, they're not, those aren't hugely expensive. I mean, the biggest one is the van, right? So if we had to, could we do it with the number of ends we have now, do we think? It would be tight. It would be tight, for sure. And the ends, well... I mean, this is just a worst-case scenario, you know. Not that they never go back on what they're saying. They're important questions, and I don't know if it, like, makes me look any better, but we don't have the answer not because we haven't done our homework. It's just because the answer isn't clear. Yeah, we just don't have it yet. We just don't. Okay. Yeah, I just think it's important for us to know what, you know, we could potentially be looking to cover if we had to. How quickly after this is approved does the funding actually get dispersed?

So, there is the option to have the funding disbursed quarterly. They have extended an option to us to disperse the quarter one bit of money early, I think as early as April. Now, I don't know that that really helps us that much because we will need that money at the end of the year.

So, yes. That's true. It doesn't make it start coming, even if you don't blame on it. What about the little pot of money for the special money? The special money. Can we start sending in our requests and invoices tomorrow?

Not tomorrow. Do you have them tomorrow? I'm just going to ask you to come up to the mic because the folks at home can't hear you in the back. So that stuff, we had a site visit from Lori Whittemore. I suppose she's the director of preschool programming. She went through all the pre-K rooms. She made a list of what she believes we could use. She won't come back until the commitment form has been signed. At that point, she will order stuff for us and deliver it. For that amount of money, that stuff, we don't have to pay first.

2:01:04

They're going to order it, deliver it, help set up. The stuff that you want to cost through a one-time allocation, that can start at April 1 through the early allocation funds, which takes away from the first quarter, which is July.

One thing to keep in mind is July, you don't have any students starting responsibility until September 1st, so you don't have a lot of expense for July and August, potentially, so that the money you take from there, you may not have to push down the line.

reckon with a year from June. So things like a van that we would need? So a van is a special requisition form. Okay. It's outside all three of these funding streams, and it's existed for longer than this initiative, so that's probably going to stick around. Again, I don't know, but...

Okay, so that's not specific to early childhood. No, it was around before that, so yeah, It wouldn't be, at least at least three funds that are coming through this law. This is probably a question I probably should have asked before we got all the way to this point,

but does this, taking over the CDS, it prompted the question when you said they're not responsible until September 1, are most of these kids extended school year kids that we would now have to have a preschool program running through the summer?

Absolutely. I don't know what most of these. There will be a significant portion that will be ESY. There are some stuff that the EIP does already. One of them contracts to do services for students. So yes, short answer is yes. You'll have to have an ESY program that's available. It has to be six weeks in length. They don't know when those six weeks are.

Actually, you know what? I need to check that. That is a law right now for CBS. But as it transfers over, I don't know if that comes with it. So that's a good question. You will need to provide ESY services. I'll have to figure that out. It sounds like they're already doing some of that. Right. I mean, I guess what I would want to make sure of is that our staff that are already providing services to these kids are on contracts that don't require necessarily somewhere.

So there could be incremental costs to that and want to make sure. Because that would be, I presume, covered by the programming costs. Or no. That's already built into how much they're giving us per student, so the difference is on us to figure out.

Yes. The services themselves, when they go up, should increase. So there's that high-cost allocation, which is exclusively reserved for kids that are high-cost. And for one student, that's a high-cost. And then if it pushes over the total allocation for the year, then it kicks in. So there's enough ESY work that even if those kids aren't high-cost in the amount of needs that they need in their IEP,

That if that amount takes it up above what the quarter allocation was, then there'll be more money. We could recapture some of that cost. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Tom, if you, just tonight, is there a relatively straightforward way to present this as an accompaniment to the budget going forward for this year?

Is there a way that we can kind of, like, at what point, I guess it would be helpful to know, like, is there a point before we pass the budget where we're passing the budget with knowing exactly what we are signing up for?

That's likely. Okay. Because you wouldn't be voting on the budget until March. And so we would, certainly by that time, we would have more information back from the state. So, with the moment, I can share that would be that $17,000-ish cost, and we would have an answer about all the other special things I would hope that they're approving.

Okay, great. Thank you. I think we should probably include that, like, in your future, as we look at the budget. I think that needs to probably get added in there, so we're capturing it. I would think Kelly and I were talking about this. I would put it under the additions part. I want to borrow Ted's phrase and say, since we get to do this, is the intent, to Michelle's point, for outfitting our special ed classroom in the short term to keep that off the budget, to include it in the budget, and then anything that we get reimbursed falls away?

2:06:21

How are we managing those funds in our budget? So, the technicalities that I would have to ask Kelly about, but the intent is to keep it off the budget as much as possible and in the CDS money. Okay. I'm wondering, the money that we're getting, is that a year after year after year?

It's quarterly, and it's based on student numbers per quarter. Okay, so this, we're guaranteed that we're getting money every year. I mean, guaranteeing that. Yes. Yeah, so this would be, this would be. annually, and it's based on the amount of students that we can project for the first quarter of next year, so, you know, by the end of October, and we can't, we're not allowed to project having more students as the year goes on, so it's a projection based on what we are expecting for the first quarter. Do you know what the numbers are at this point? Yeah, I think it was 25 it was? I don't remember

It was right around 25 kiddos. That's what I remember also. Yeah, I think it's going to be really interesting when we start guessing how many three-year-olds we have showing up. Like, the four-year-olds is a little bit different because we kind of have screeners and pre-K, and I think the three-year-olds is going to be... Three-year-olds, there's a lot of unknowns with that.

My sense is whatever we can quantify, there are actually more that will come because we have a program where we don't now. Right. But I do think, and correct me if I may, to your question, Karen, if we have to, you know, we have to say 25, but if 30 show up, we do get to recapture that in, like, the future quarters. We can catch up because we have more kids. We can't assume we're going to have 30 and hope they come. We can say 25 because that's what we have confirmation or information for. But if 30 do show up, we are able to, like, capture those numbers. Kelly?

Yeah, so that raises a question. Are we sort of budgeting a certain amount of space for a certain capacity looking forward to the future? Right now, with the four-year-olds, it's pretty easy because we have the capacity to absorb the numbers that we will be getting.

That's because we already have pre-K, and, you know, if we compare it to this year, we are already serving three quarters of the kids with IEPs in our district through our existing so we can tap into what we already have to make that work for next year. I think the real question

that we have to do a lot of work over the ensuing year here to figure out is three roles because we don't, as we're up right now, have a space to put them in. But we're on that next week when we talk Not the longer-range vision. And the only, I think, added classroom for next year would be the new special ed pre-k, but there is a space at Moore Street for that. So yes, right now we are proposing to add a special ed classroom

that's a special-purpose classroom. It's for children who would have a higher level of need, and if we don't do that, we would face having to send those children out somewhere else where they could access that, which would be a cost to us. So we can make space for that at the moment at Moore Street. It will be tight, but we can make that work, and we can then serve those kids, and it will be a lower cost with our own people.

I'm happy to hear more about that next week, then. Other questions on the motion on the floor, which is to join Cohort 3 based on the information we have right now. Seeing none, are folks ready for a vote? You got the motion in a second? Okay, great. All those in favor, none opposed. Thank you. And thank you to the group that was involved in that task force, to Tom, to Erica, to Tim.

I do that every time. Ted, sorry. I don't know why I do that. I apologize. Just to, I mean, this was a lot of work. And Kelly, this was more work than anticipated, but it started as it always is. So thank you for everybody's hard work on that.

I kind of like sitting in the dark over there. Durham Bickett. Durham Bickett, that's me. all right so um new business on the agenda is item 13 the district scorecard and erica's going to present that to us my meeting again you might want to go back to the dark So in your packets, you had the district scorecard,

2:12:03

and then you had a presentation for career college readiness. What wasn't in your packet, Ginny's call, is that this presentation specifically about the key findings in the scorecard, which we're going to RIP tonight, because this is the

last scorecard presentation, we're going to evolve into a different style of presentation going forward, unless that's no longer what you want, but this is the last presentation the scorecard as we've known it for 10 or 12 years now, forever. So the first

findings I'd like to share with you tonight are with or are coming from the traditional scorecard report that you are familiar with if you've been on the board for a while. And I wanted to just caveat this entire presentation with

these are standardized test scores and not students, children are not standardized humans and so there is you know an element of there isn't a test in here that's that's appropriate for all kids all the time so we're working with data

that is you know in a human environment that comes through as maybe it's not always the right fit or the best way to measure our profession is a science I believe and science there in science there's measurement so we are trying to

measure things. And to your earlier point, there are other things we could probably measure to paint other pictures or shine light on other areas. So I'll caveat some of these data pieces with more of that, but just an overarching statement about standardization.

So this is all, again, coming from your scorecard as you knew it. So the graduation rate for you, the state average, I believe, is trending at about 86%, so we're in a good spot in comparison. The scorecard does a lot of comparisons, so you'll see that throughout this one.

The scorecard has continuously elevated for you the Fountas and Pinnell reading scores, which are our benchmark assessments that we are utilizing K-5 primarily. And these data carry over into the new report that I'll be sharing, but you can see the trends there, and you received this in advance, so I'll pause at the end of this one and ask for your questions.

The Maine through-year assessment, so in the scorecard, there was an emphasis on the through-year. Maine's had quite a moving target when it comes to how they're measuring students in Maine and where those cut scores are falling. So it's, frankly, less reliable than hitching on to what the assessment creators have indicated as national norms.

So we're going to be paying closer attention to that going forward. So this is where we stand per the main three-year assessment, which, again, has some challenges in terms of validity and reliability longitudinally. The Maine State Science Assessment has also evolved over the years.

And the tricky thing I just want to caveat. So the new assessment, the new instrument, is attached to the Next Generation Science Standards, which are now legislated by the state of Maine. We are a little bit slower to the game than other states. So this was then passed not too, too long ago,

and there wasn't a ton of implementation support for this from the state. So districts have sort of taken it on themselves and taken different approaches to it. But the big challenge with the Maine State Science Assessment is that the approach is interdisciplinary. So earth life, physical, engineering, all the things are in one assessment every year.

And that's not necessarily how we're teaching science. So a child's sitting for an assessment that's exposing them to content that they may or may not have been experiencing relative to the assessment. So this is a tricky one, but we're still trending better than state average.

PSAT and SAT, I really want to highlight that we are not a state that does this statewide any longer. So when we compare ourselves with the state average, that becomes no longer a super credible norming group or linking study.

2:17:07

And so this is how we compare to the state amongst colleagues, schools, who also administer the PSAT and SAT universally, meaning for all students. We do do that in grade 11. And that's why you can see that when you put all the kids in the pool, the scores are comparatively a little bit lower.

I did do a statewide study to see where we fall on this in terms of offering it universally. So we subsidize that locally, and we do it universally in grade 11. I had 23 responses from high schools across Maine, including Bangor, Portland, Augusta,

South Portland, Ellsworth, Auburn, Biddeford, Brunswick, Herman, and many others. And universally, we have 11 of those, sorry, 6 of those administering universally PSAT and 5 of those administering universally SAT in 11th grade.

So just as a comp. And then this one is an interesting one I think we're going to want to follow going forward is that persistence rate once kiddos matriculate into their first and maybe even more importantly their second year of post-secondary studies.

If we go back to these scores, we'll dive into PSAT and SAT a little bit more, but the threshold is meeting or exceeding a predicted likelihood to perform successfully in a 100 level class with a grade of a C or better so

this is the SAT and PSAT cut scores are intended to predict whether a child is ready to persist successfully meaning earning a grade of a C or better in a 100 level coursework right so then when you go into when you go into the

advanced placement and post-secondary persistence rate we can you know sort of make connections that readiness matters potentially for students I will say that this data set is coming from 2022 and these are COVID years and a lot more

kiddos would have taken us up on the state subsidized access to two-year colleges right so we've got other kids in this data set that might not have otherwise been there and it was coded years so there's like it'll be interesting to follow this going forward so I take this one with a grain of salt again questions key takeaways those were highlighted for you in the in the data

set but I did want to point out that on pages 5 and 6 there was an error on a header and that is maybe I can open it up here just want to just show you so if you are looking at your packet I just want to make sure in full transparency

here that there was an error oh it was corrected on this one that I have my apologies but here if you're looking at these columns on page five and six the 24 25 was reading 23 24 when it says spring count in grades 3 4 5 6 and then

on to the next page are you seeing that in your packet potentially yeah just wanted to point that one out okay so questions about the scorecard data as has presented, knowing that some of it lives in the next presentation as well.

Just so I understand, the PSAT and the SAT sheet that you have, so the test is the same for 10th and 11th graders. It's the same test. For PSAT? Yes. But the cut scores are different? So the PSAT is a different assessment from the SAT.

No, no, no. I'm saying, so we have PSAT grade 10 and PSAT grade 11. Given in the same year, that's the same test, right? So if you have an 11th grader sitting here and a 10th grader, they're taking the same test. Yes. Right. So I'm trying to, but, you know, we don't have their scores on here.

2:22:14

We have the percent meeting or exceeding the benchmark. So based on the 92.7 for 10th graders and dropping to 66.2, maybe that's a cohort issue. Or is it that the cut scores are different to be meeting or exceeding for a 10th grader

as it is for meeting or exceeding as an 11th grader? Great question. So we don't require our 10th. We don't offer it universally. We don't subsidize it in grade 10. Okay, so the only ones who make grade 10 that choose to do it. Those who wish to engage in it. Okay, that makes more sense because that was a huge swing.

Right. When you all had asked for a presentation in September and I came back in the next meeting, If you might recall that I showed those differences, that will appear in the next report as well. Indeed, that is the case for grade 10 for the PSAT, and then we have an optional participation for grade 12 SAT.

Not showing on the scorecard for whatever reason. On the secondary, those percentages are both of the graduating class, right? or in other words, 55.2% of the graduating class continue on. It's not 55.2% of the 69.5% that go.

Correct, of the class of 2015. Yeah, I was always going to be like, something's going. Yeah. Great, excellent. Great. I mean, not excellent. Yeah, and part of this is really important because readiness to persist successfully

in 100-level coursework also matters a lot for financial aid. So remedial coursework, not 100-level coursework for students who need it, is not covered through FAFSA. It's just a barrier, potentially. Do we see any trends with our students who were entering school during COVID and academic learning versus those kids coming in now or kids who are already here?

Like, when we were shut down, is that two- or three-year cohort kind of performing differently than everyone else? That's a really interesting question. You're going to see a little bit of that in the next one, but I'm afraid some of that data may take more time.

If you're looking at it from, like, all the way out through post-secondary in the lag in which we get these data, I think, I mean, yeah. I haven't studied those specifically here. So like birth year 2015, who would have been kindergartners in 2020, kind of like watching them go through time.

Kids who were learning to read while wearing a mask. Yeah. There are some trends, because you all had asked about some trend data in September, so I did prepare some of those for the next slide deck. But I'm not sure it totally captures or answers your question.

We can look at that more. Ready for the next one? Okay. So in September, and through the work of the Strategic Planning Committee, there's been a lot of talk about readiness, and so the indicator for readiness when it comes to academic achievement

is like the benchmark that would be career and college ready, indicating of career and college readiness. So the assessments that we use from third grade up do have those benchmarks. They have studied what is the predictive level of meeting or exceeding expectations for career and college readiness.

So we are able to use what we have from our data sets to look at that from third grade onward. And the assessments that we are using, I don't know that the Fountas and Pinnell Benchmark Assessment does a career and college ready predictive indicator,

but maybe I need to look into that more. But so our third grade assessment onward would be the NWEA primarily, which many of you are familiar with, and then the PSAT and SAT have that. For the purpose of this presentation, I'm looking at the subgroup called Economically Disadvantaged specifically.

2:27:16

The scorecard previously had gotten into a subgroup of students receiving special education services. that felt a little bit global because not all students receiving special education services are receiving them in academic areas and not necessarily in

both academic areas and so this is from you know from looking at our data this feels more important and you know we can always look at the other subgroups as well but trying to state it just just one for right now for a through line we

obviously look at the other subgroups okay so you're going to see economically disadvantaged as a subgroup and then I'm attempting to offer you some cohort data that you had requested earlier this is just another way of looking at

that these are these are where the assessments are administered universally and again you see our PSAT and SAT commitment sorry 10th is checked off it shouldn't be because it's not for PSAT it's not you know it's universally

available, but it's not universally administered. Okay, Fountas and Pinnell reading data, this is a carryover from the last report. There's nothing really different here. This is that same data set with a descriptive, and the dotted line then is going to be the district total average. What we're

shooting for when you start to see these line charts is, like, we want 80% or more of our students at that level. Like that's the goal. And if you're looking at like MTSS structures, that's the goal. Prepared a year-by-year comparison for the Fountas and Pinnell assessment. We've just updated to the

most current copyright of this assessment instrument. And so we're staying with most current research in those tools. And we've been working on implementing that this year. That again, the FMP is a K-5 assessment. As we move into our NUIA data this is where things start to fall on

that career and college ready indicator line rather than the state's sort of moving target of what is meeting or exceeding the state's expectations so it's staying true using our longitudinal data still. So NUIA has always had this

indicator and that is when a student is performing at the 61st percent or better. The bans in Nilea are 0 to 20, 21 to 40, 41 to 60, 61 and up. And there's a band above 61. But for the purpose of career and college readiness, this is looking at the band of 61st or better.

Reading trends per NWEA from grades 3 to 10. If you remember from September, I caution you, grade 10 caveat, it's a tricky application of NWEA. a little bit of a stretch in terms of how that test is intended to be used but

this is what our state uses again no longer the SAT we used to be an SAT state these are our math trends per NWEA then again these PSAT and SAT assessment no longer really worried so much about this the comparing to the state of Maine because it's not universally utilized as a high school

assessment instrument anymore and then the career and college trends when looking at these different assessments so we like I pulled in F and P the Fountas and Pinnell piece because it as it are they meeting grade level expectations so these are students at or above grade level expectations per the

Fountas and Pinnell NWU a map with both reading and math sorry that's a lot of lines and then the PSAT you see the differences there in grades 10 and 11 10 being that elective but we subsidize and SAT I'm only showing you grade 11

2:32:38

because the grade 12 was a was like it's the same story as with the PSAT but probably fewer because by that point a lot of kids are already in their application stage not taking us up on it and then pulling in the career and

college ready snapshot across all grades trying to create a through line across different instruments reading and math this is a cohort analysis so you're going to start to see those bands of cohorts a B and C and their graduating classes

and the great spans that are represented I know you've had some time with this beforehand so happy to answer any questions you have but looking at reading data across k5 and then reading data 3 8 again we don't use the NWEA

until grade 3 so that's why that's starting there the changes across those cohorts so how much those kiddos have grown across their cohort band and the small print reads each bar represents the percentage point change in career

college ready rates for a single cohort of students tracked over multiple years positive values indicate improvement for example the plus 20.6 means that 20.6 percent more students in that cohort met the benchmark at the end of the

tracking period compared to the beginning of the period it found to some panel cohorts span five years and the NWEA cohorts span four years just for the fine print piece of that and then this subgroup economically disadvantaged

subgroup we are getting more tuned on the identification of economically disadvantaged needs as a district which is fabulous but for these data you will see that there is a range of like I our identifications depending on grade

levels and creating some volatility in the data so I'm hoping this becomes more steady over the years but yeah just a note that when it's a hundred percent It's just a super small sample size. We tend to as a best practice not present anything that's just that's a group size

under 10 10 or lower This is that same kind of math, but with the economically disadvantaged subgroup represented as well and then in a line representation for reading and math as as represented through NWEA and the comparison for students who

Are meeting that economically disadvantaged threshold and then an equity comparison in the SAT The cohort and reading over time the cohort and math over time and then a summary of What you probably saw as well, but in case it's helpful And a note again that the PSAT and SAT Vary across Maine because the SAT is no longer the state's assessment nor is the PSAT

I will add one important reason for us to continue or to support, I won't predict the future, to support the PSAT is that at this grade level it is also the NMSQT qualifier, so that's the National Merit Scholar Qualifying Assessment.

So that's one reason why schools maintain access to it, whether through universal or elective subsidy. Happy to answer any questions you have. question about the well thank you for putting all this together it's a lot and for breaking out the key takeaways for us as well as far as the areas for attention and the

first two there about math are there some guesses as to why those have gone down has the curriculum changed has the test changed love to hear more about that um so this is my first year in the district, so there's probably a lot of context that I don't have. I do know that with most

2:37:52

standardized assessment, there is a matter of timing of like when is a child learning things in a curriculum versus when is the assessment being administered and do those things line up. So we should definitely, you know, consider that we're not teaching to

the test and SAT isn't really that kind of test, you know, so we're not taking like released items and like, well, at least not in school cramming towards them, right? I suppose we can do that privately. So there's that part, right? And then the fact that it is no longer the state's

assessment. So it's got a different weight. And post-secondary institutions are no longer en masse requiring it. The SAT is no longer like 100% required, right? They're giving other options. so maybe the gravity of the assessment other than that I think we have work to

do across the board in math so you know there's there is systemic math conversation happening the need for math programming committee was identified last year we've been doing that work and we'll be bringing to you later this year a presentation on some of the systems level work that we're doing with

math but the SAT is not a best fit assessment for all kids that time Yeah, we see this equity gap pretty much year after year, and it doesn't really seem to change too, too much year over year. And I'm just curious what the thought is about how we address this kind of persistent gap.

Meaning the economically disadvantaged gap. So it's our MTSS, or formerly called RTI systems, or both called RTI MTSS, Response to intervention in multi-tier systems of support, creating comprehensive, timely intervention systems and tuning those through continuous improvement, not just on the remediation end, but on the end where kids need more, keeping them engaged as well.

So that is the work of MTSS. Yeah, thank you so much again for bringing this together. This is so helpful. Do we have any data on better concentrations of students when they are leaving? I guess I'm asking because if there was any kind of,

we usually look at the relationship between, you know, if the kid's leaving for poor high so they want to go into engineering and then we're seeing these math scores and then, you know, whatever, we're seeing a drop we're seeing a drop in we're seeing a drop in the areas that could be traced in any way back to these kind of indicators, right, as we're saying like do you think we have anything like that to hear? In terms of what they do post-secondary Well, yeah it looks yeah, I mean, is there any, do we ask students

what they're thinking of studying when they leave, or do we know what their concentrations are, I know you don't declare it in freshman year necessarily, but I don't know, it just struck me that that data point is concerning, the number that don't go on to persist in the second year, particularly the two-year colleges, that was really disheartening, and I was just sort of curious whether there's any sort of way we could link those. I mean, again, it points to we need some work, do some work in math, but I'm just curious.

Yeah, to your point, declaration of a major in the first two years of school in post-secondary is variable depending on the institution. Liberal arts schools will often say, you don't have to declare to be a third or fourth year. So we could get a lot of not super reliable data, but we do have disaggregated data.

Engineering lives in the science standards, so it's earth-like physical and engineering. And we do have disaggregated data about all of those domains that we can look at. And then we have this aggregated data for the NWA math assessments that shows us the domains of math in which trending is needing our attention.

2:43:00

So we are able to look at that as well and know that because it is attached to career and college ready indication, whether they're actually ready to persist successfully or not per that assessment. There are certainly other ways to do it, but we would need to be very scientific in our approach.

Yeah, I'm not sure if that answered you. So you're saying you need math skills to figure out about the math skills. That's what I'm hearing. Thank you, Erica. One thing that I learned about on the curriculum committee was more about the RTI and MTSS

and just how much of the general classroom should be served, like all different tiers. And I was wondering if you could just discuss that a little bit more for the whole board and how you see, particularly math, where we're lagging behind a little bit,

how you feel like that can be addressed in the general ed classroom as opposed to the pull-out method. What's being done now is pull-out. I'll stop talking now. I think that's my question. So multi-tiered systems of support typically have three tiers.

It's tier one that's universal that happens in the classroom setting That is, kids who are somewhere within grade level range, typically, they're needing just some real-time support. Tier 2 tends to be a kiddo who's about a year-ish or below grade level into the year prior, at some part of that year prior.

And then Tier 3 tends to be kiddos who are approaching two years below grade level, tends to be. Where those interventions are supported is what is different in different settings. So Tier 1 should be in the classroom setting. Depending on the human resources, Tier 2 is often with push-in support in the regular classroom setting.

Tier 3 is needing to have a very specific isolated skill set intervention in a small group setting outside of the classroom because it doesn't fit in with just the sort of business as usual in the general education in that classroom setting so those three tiers are really important

and I think us of the work that we're doing right now to make sure that we know like what are the non-negotiables for grade level expectations is really critical when you're moving in to do intervention on grade level expectations

so we're getting clear about the non-negotiables at grade level and then what are the resources we are pooling both human and print and sometimes digital to support kids in each of those tiers so our classroom teachers are

doing a lot of work every day it looks really natural in the classroom setting you might not know that tier one intervention is happening those small groups with teachers at the tables if you've seen them, and that is very organic. Tier 2 is very targeted inside the classroom, saying

this group of kiddos are really needing this skill, or else by the end of the year they're going to be yet more behind. So we're going to really focus on that. And then Tier 3 is we know that they're not likely to make grade level expectations, and we need to

capture further back down the line. And throughout those tiers, we are serving multilingual learners and students identified with IEP support as well. So MTSS serves all students. So if you were thinking about it as a pyramid, then multilingual and special education run through all of those tiers.

Did that answer your question? I think, well, there's kind of one part further, I think, that I was trying to get at. And that, sorry, it's getting late at that time where I start fading away, is how can we use the MTSS or maybe better utilize it, I don't know, in thinking about trying to address these inequities in the classroom?

Because I think for me, I think, oh, well, we need more staff, we need more people to come in. But from what I've heard from you at the curriculum committee, it's like, well, maybe, but that's not necessarily how we would do it with the MTSS model.

And are we, I know we're currently doing some of that, but is there a world in which you see us being able to do it more? Yeah, I think it begins with a whole lot of clarity about what is, when is the need determined and what is the isolated need for the child.

2:48:09

And it's not all about pushing out for support. It's knowing how to support small groups differently. And so with clarity, with a lot of clarity. And we're already good at that. We need more clarity about the grade level of non-negotiables. And we're using all the best research out there to tune that right now.

So we have all the right people. And I feel very confident that we have all the right people to get that done, to build those systems. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Erica. Do you know what happens when I move 18 times?

I lose my agenda. I got it. I found it. Oh, good news, guys. Only eight more things. No, I'm just kidding. We have no personnel items, so we're back to public comment. We do have a few folks that hung in there, so if you'd like to speak, this is another

opportunity. We ask you to come to the microphone, tell us your name, where you live, and three minutes is allocated for each person. And Erica has a paper which tells me we have someone. I didn't find that on myself. You can do it after. This is generally when we have like 50 people who show up so we can do it in an orderly fashion. When we have two, we can work it out. All right. Thank you, guys. It's a long night. I know you guys do this a lot. I do not. I wrote some comments down here. I sent you an email. I'm John Jakes, by the way. I'm a parent of a 2017 graduate and currently have an 11th grader.

I'm a retired teacher. I taught social studies in American history with Donovan Valley for a while, which I know you're familiar with. And then I moved on to Falmouth High School, retired a while ago, which was before your time, when I was out of the Donovan Valley.

So I'm very pleased with what I heard tonight from the superintendent about increased emphasis on social studies at the middle school. That's, you know, being a former social studies teacher, it's near and dear to my heart. And I think a lot of what's going on these days is evidence of the lack of social studies education.

And I am not pointing the finger at Freeport High School, or this district, or this state necessarily, which is an overall problem that we have as a nation, you know, needs to be addressed. So I really appreciate all the hard work that you guys put in.

these meetings are long and your dedication is appreciated. It's a big job. I appreciate it very much and the community appreciates it. So as you all know, numerous criminal actions by the Trump administration require citizens of conscience to protest. I'm extremely proud of our 150 of our

high school students that participated in the recent anti-ice protest. We're all aware of the fact that we had a large number of students walk out at noon during a school day and march along Main Street up to McDonald's, back to the bridge, and they missed a couple of classes, right? So

students should be supported to exercise their constitutional rights to protest. Any form of punishment by the school system is unacceptable, in my opinion. These are not normal times, and the school board should recognize this. Our high school students know what has happened in Minneapolis.

Videos have been watched by millions, millions of teenagers, millions of times. You know, the evidence is out there is what's going on. They know what's in the Epstein files. They read this stuff. It's all available. And school boards should pass whatever is necessary for students to attend any anti-ICE

protest and suffer no repercussions from their school. Diverge a little bit from my remarks here. So what the consequences were for Freeport High School students that participated, it was an unexcused absence. It's a pretty small thing, but I think it's a gesture that I would like from you all to make an excused absence for anybody that participated in that.

All they did was get an excused absence, and if there was an extracurricular activity that they were participating in, they couldn't do it the next day. I've heard from other parents in other districts that they got three hours of detention.

And I don't think it's really what you all intend to do, is to punish students for participating in something like that. So you have to take some action to either change your policy, create a new policy. You have no policy that covers such a thing. I got sent by some of the attendance officers form that it was apparently developed over a decade ago

2:53:32

that says that this is our policy if you're going to have your kid out. Well, I taught at Falmouth High School 20 years ago, and it used to tick me off as a teacher when the parents would say, we're going to Switzerland for a ski trip for a week. March 1st, we just had a vacation if they were, and they chose to go at a different time.

I'm supposed to put together some work for them to do while they're in Switzerland or France or wherever it is. That's a different circumstance, and that's a different scenario. I do understand being a former teacher, spending many, many years dealing with, you know, parents' requests for time off and you have to have rules and all of that.

And kids coming in with Starbucks cups to the first period of class late over and over again. I know all of that stuff happens. Dealt with it. This is definitely a different time that we're living in now and a different scenario.

So please, please do something. So this is not an unexcused absence for these students. I'll just ask you I know I'm close to the three minutes I'll let you finish your thought Let me wrap it up So since students are minors, parents' permission should be enough for an excused absence to attend. Currently the school policy does not allow parents to excuse an absence I think this policy should be changed Social studies curriculum needs immediate improvement to cover the crimes of Donald Trump and his administration particularly the high school curriculum as a retired teacher painfully aware of the fact that most high school graduates do not study the

last 20 or 30 years of American history. It doesn't happen. They never get to it. They never learn the last 20 or 30 years. This is not acceptable. I'd also like to comment about what I heard here earlier. I'd also like to comment about the

proposed elimination of middle school franchise. Studying enrollment here and surrounding districts is a good idea. I'm in agreement that if we're worried about dropping enrollment, cutting out middle school French could lead to unintended consequences, which you brought up. Parents choose this community based

on the schools. If you cut middle school French, I think it's not be a good thing. I think you can probably find somewhere else to go for that. Savings, and I'd like to see the middle school French remain. Both my children went to the 8th grade Quebec City trip, and it would be a great loss to our students. Thank you, and I'm

Sorry, I took a minute of my time. It's okay. Thank you, John. Thank you. All right, if you'd like to speak, here's your opportunity. Okay, I don't want to speak. It's Sarah Davis. I don't know. Can you hear me? I don't think. Is it on? Yes. Oh, my God. All right, and I'm on camera. Great. Okay, so I'm going to pull it all on.

Thank you. Okay, so I don't know how you do this because I can barely stand up. I'm so tired. I didn't want to talk today, but I heard after Pam's presentation, I just wanted to clarify a couple things. I'm Sarah Davis. I teach French at the Freeport Middle School, and I live in Auburn.

And I'm going to have to sleep here tonight because I'm exhausted. Okay, so first of all, I think this is the toughest thing for Bill and Pam in my building. Beyond any other administrator, they're brand new, and here they are telling people that they have to go.

especially with dinosaurs like me. And I, but I do have a hard time hearing people talk about, you know, really like that it's really just more benefits to all the cuts. Like, no, it just kind of sucks around, you know, across the board. You don't have to come up with, like, ways that it's helpful and beneficial to students because it's not. So it really upsets me to hear, like, oh, well, it would be great because we'll have more continuity from no summer lag from eighth grade Spanish to freshman year, which is absolutely not true. But a couple things. I just want clarifying. I just want to put some clarifying things out there. Sorry if I'm just tongue-tied because I'm exhausted. I am concerned that there are only five UA teachers listed

in grades seven and eight because that's going to make numbers pretty high, especially in art. And I, let's see, Spanish numbers have been higher since I've worked at Freeport Middle School, which is 20 years. And before that, we didn't have Spanish for a very long time before I arrived at Freeport.

It was French. And I think that's just because globally we have more people speaking Spanish as a first language in the country. In Maine, of course, more people speak French as a first language. But I think parents' perception is that their kids should take Spanish.

to be more global citizens. I have a hard time with having just Spanish in eighth grade. And the fact that it would be a core class means every kid has to take it and you need a phenomenal amount of support. We don't typically get a lot of ed tech support in our classes.

2:58:49

So that's a concern to me, because it's going to be large class sizes with kids of a huge range of ability and motivation. I always have kids who are, like, really into French and really good at it naturally, and the same thing in Spanish. So that's tough for me to make. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Oh, God. Okay, a couple things. I really promise I won't be long.

I don't actually think that eighth grade rotation works out great for language in terms of continuity. And I do want to make sure that we're keeping students in mind, And that should be our ultimate, that should always be what comes first. But my other issue is we currently have a .6 Spanish teacher at our school.

So I don't understand where we're going to get a full-time position. I didn't know if you were aware of that. So that means you're going to be hiring, you're adding to that Spanish position in order to have it in the core classes.

So that was the biggest thing to me. It's like, well, where is that going to come from? Because our current Spanish teacher, that position was cut when Amanda Robson left Spanish to teach, to do GT. And so Ray turned the Spanish position into a 0.6, and I started teaching rural cultures, which is Spanish and French in 6th grade.

So every kid gets Spanish and French in 6th grade at Freeport Middle School, and then they get Spanish, French, or JMG at 7th and 8th grade. Does that make sense? Okay, and I think, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, special ed students, art numbers, oh, I'm sorry, kids' willingness to learn another language, 8th grade is like the worst time to introduce that if you've taught middle school, there's like a progression, 8th grade they think they know everything and they're just like too cool for school and it's really hard to get them out there into that comfort zone, like a discomfort zone.

So I just feel like, oh, my God, that's like, I'm glad I don't have to do that. Okay, so thank you very much, and have a lovely evening. Thank you for all you do. Thank you, Sarah. Hi, my name is Chantel Best, and I have kids at Power Elementary,

and I also have a student that's a junior at high school and two students that went up through the middle school and high school. I just want a quick comment on the Tier 3 reduction. I know that's not recommended but I feel like I need to advocate for panel a little bit. I'm sure

I'm sad to hear everybody about their positions and budget cuts and I know it's not great anywhere but what sticks out for me is the suggestion of possibly moving fifth grade panel to mass landing. I personally know all of the kids. I'm also a substitute teacher at PES. I do the after school

program and I am the president of the PTA so I'm at panel a lot um I know all the fifth graders personally and me picturing every single one of those 18 kids going to another school for just one year and leaving panel their fifth grade year whether it's for their individual needs or because

they're looking for their sibling coming into the class we have other programs at panel that other schools don't have which I know we're very lucky to have those but just see thinking about them missing out on all that stuff just seems like there's not a lot of pros to that um and also just

that tier has a lot of cuts in the RTI positions and panel alone got paused just this year which is where the kids on behavioral plans get to utilize that and seeing the impact it has on even specific classrooms, them having that space for them to choose to go there or to get that one-on-one help or to be sent to that classroom, it makes a big academic difference

and behavioral difference to all the other kids in that classroom. So thank you, Chantal. Thanks. I'll just try something out. What's going on? Private. Reporting for duty. All the talk of social studies, I just want to push out there, if you're not aware. Tomorrow evening, the 8th graders from Freeport Middle School and Durham Community School

3:03:59

will all be presenting their National History Day projects at Durham Community Schools starting at 6.30. For the last two years, they've been hosted down here at Freeport Middle School. We're thrilled and grateful to FMS to make that transition up to DCS for the presentations tomorrow.

And the student work is great. So you'll get to see the theme. If you're not familiar with the process, there's a broad theme. And then students can choose within that theming a topic that they want to then research and present about.

And the theme was revolution. And there's a lot of really interesting interpretations about what garnered a revolution or what constituted a revolution, everything from, as one might imagine, the American Revolution, which I think is actually a civil war, but that didn't go down great, and all the way to revolution goalkeepers using gloves in soccer games.

So there's a broad range, and kids have done an amazing job. So if you'd like to get a boost of what actually goes on with some of the humanities and social studies work, 6.30 tomorrow at the dawn. Thank you. All right. Anyone else? Okay. Well, then I would take a motion to adjourn. Kara and Steph, thank you. All those in favor.

Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.