Skip to content

TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 11 February 2026

Board meeting · 3 h 45 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →

Computer-made transcript, not a record of what was said. It mishears names and figures and drops short words, such as the "not" in "does not carry". Click a time to hear the recording, which settles any disagreement. The district's minutes are the official record.

32,113 words in 43 five-minute windows.

0:04

you're gonna tell me when we're good tonight okay see this is where all the administrators sit in the back and i feel like if all of your kids sat in the back you would make them all come up to the front so just saying good evening welcome to the rc5 board of directors it is

Wednesday, February 11th, 2026. We are here at the Freeport High School Library. We have a full board, including our newest member, Lois Kilby-Chesley. I will get that right. She was appointed last night by the select board and quickly got herself sworn in so she could join

us this evening. Thank you so much for that. All right, we will get started with the Pledge of allegiance. Okay, so we're going to move on to the minutes. So I derive a motion for consideration and approval of the minutes from the January 28, 2026 meeting as presented, barring any errors or

omissions. Valerie and Chris, thank you. All those in favor? Opposed? No? Okay. Oh, and for those that were watching last time, and I said I didn't know why we didn't have minutes, and it was because when we have these meetings week to week, there's not enough time to get the minutes done by the

time the package goes out the next morning. So thank you, Jenny, for informing me. Adjustments to the agenda? No. Can you ask something to the agenda? No. You can talk to me beforehand if we want to try to add something to the agenda. I'm curious. Okay. Perfect. I'm sure you can find a

way to work in it. So item six, good news in recognition. So are we having, are you doing Are you doing an actual update and then the strategic plan, or are you just doing them together? There's nothing really for me to update about student stuff, so I'm just going to do the slides, if that's fine.

Perfect, yeah. Okay, so our report from the board's student rep is actually a report out on the strategic plan's portrait of a graduate, belief statements, and mission, and Maria, Kelly, and Kara are? It's really just Maria. Okay, wonderful.

Thank you. Okay, so this is the strategic planning committee update. So just a rundown of the committee, we have faculty, community, school board, students, and leadership. And what you're looking at here is the timeline. So January and February of 2025, it was laying out the foundation and developing the timeline.

Then you have seeking community input, which was March and October of 2025. Drafting the portrait was September and November, which was the time that I had joined the committee. And then we are finally in strategic planning.

So then we have the community input. So questions one and two are the hopes and dreams, which were made to develop the structure of Portrait of a Graduate. And then questions three and four, which was what we're doing well

5:20

and what we need to be working on, which was developing for the strategic plan. And there were surveys and focus groups for all of those. So I'm just going to share some of the data from the first round of feedback. My name is Erica Wallstrom. I work at Great Schools Partnership and started last January working with the committee and the district to help facilitate these conversations.

So what we have is just some information about the survey. And really what I think this data shows primarily is how it represents the community and the different schools that are being serviced in this district. So we, as Maria mentioned, we had a survey. There were 842 responses. The majority of those responses were from students, in part because we gave the surveys to all middle school and high school students.

sort of a captive audience they had an opportunity to fill them out and so the rest of the surveys were parents community members educators the educators also participated in focus groups so I think that represents a little bit of the smaller number they'd already provided their feedback in focus groups alumni and administrators people could check multiple roles so for an

example a parent might also check themselves as a community member as well so you can see numbers kind of duplicating. So these demographic graphs that I'm going to be showing, we took the student body out because we knew that that represented a cross-section of the

schools because we had surveyed all of the students in 6th through 12th grade. So these demographics represent the adult community families, all of that group, just to see if we had gotten a cross section of the communities through various demographics. And I'm not going

to go into too much detail. And again, it's just to stress that the survey and the focus groups really did a nice job of getting a distribution across the community. So this was based on the different roles. Again, I mentioned educators were a part of the focus groups. So that's why that

number is a little bit lower. This is based on schools. So I've put the blue box overlaying and that's the enrollment and the statistics based on student data. So you can kind of do a comparison and see that all of the schools were represented in the surveys. All of the three communities were

represented. The other might be alumni or family members that are in different communities. This is the different programs only parents filled out this question so if they answered that I am a parent then it would move them into this demographic so is your child in one of these programs and has nice correlation with with the

actual student demographics this one is the racial distribution and so you might notice that the white population seems higher I'll just point out that the demographics that I have listed in the blue box is our student body not your

community body and so there is actual more diversity in the student body than there is in the community we did like a little run and it was about 92% white for the community at large so that actually is a closer alignment than it

appears at first still could have been better but pretty closely aligned Demographics. We use a proxy question of how worried are you about food security. So in some ways, the economical disadvantaged category might actually be a little bit more stringent, might have captured a few more than how people might have answered this question. But again, this one is a little bit lower than we might have hoped for.

We also ran a series of focus groups, one at each of the different communities, the different schools, as well as the library on the weekend. And we also offered a virtual one, so 72 community members participated in these various focus groups.

Those were in person, they were conversations, they lasted about an hour for each of them. And then this was drafting the portrait and the supporting documents. So, for this, we used feedback from questions one and two, and then surveys and focus groups.

So, these are our pillars. So, we had these shared out to the community. So, they were intellectual curiosity, interpersonal competence, personal growth, community and global engagement, future readiness. So, for this, this was kind of the second round of feedback that we got.

10:36

and at the bottom right of the screen you can see that if there was a two plus you can if people thought that it fully reflected what the portrait of what their vision was for the portrait of graduate and if you look the majority of the numbers are quite high so 1.71 1.61 so this is

kind of another way of looking at that same data the difference with this one is it shows each of the different stakeholder groups and how they responded and again what these graphs really show is how aligned people are in the community and about how

positive they feel about the portrait that was initially drafted by the strategic plan committee planning committee based on the feedback I'll just point out that this graph the x-axis it stops at 0.8 and so if it was the full line what would happen is those Y's and diamonds and triangles would be

so tightly bound you wouldn't be able to see them so I just point that out to show that it actually looks more spread out than it actually is so then this is our portrait of a graduate and we took feedback from the data and made tweaks

to make these statements stronger I'm not gonna read all of these but you do have a copy of the portrait of graduate in your packets and these also have two rounds of feedback in them so personal growth community and global engagement future readiness

and then this is a visual the visuals and we kind of wanted to represent the natural features of our community the ocean the pine trees things like that this is the mission statement it is to empower and equip every learner with skills curiosity character and purpose to thrive and live fulfilling

lives in an ever-changing world. So then the we believe statements was my first meeting for the strategic plan that I went to. Used responses from questions three and four to come up with these statements and these are sort of about what all members of the planning committee really viewed as

the belief statements. So we had me and Ren who are the student representatives for this committee kind of be very involved in making these because they do affect students directly and yet again use data and feedback for these.

So that's where we are as of today and I feel like a huge amount of work from the planning committee, the strategic planning committee, the community for sharing their perspectives and so now we take all of that feedback and all of that work and move forward into the strategic plan.

The strategic plan is really the, like, how are you going to accomplish these visions that you have? So your portrait, your mission, your belief statements, these are those lofty, like, things that you're striving towards.

And the strategic plan says, okay, how are we going to do that? What are our objectives? What do we want our outcomes to be? And how are we going to know that we're achieving them and when we're achieving them? So monitoring kind of that progress. So the committee is going to be breaking up. Sounds so harsh, but we're going to be in little subcommittees working on the different belief statements.

So each belief statement becomes one of the objectives in the strategic plan. As we flesh it out, we might combine some together if it makes sense, but that's kind of our starting point. And they'll be putting together in these smaller groups the language for the objectives, the outcomes, the progress monitoring,

And then coming back together as a full group, tuning it, getting feedback from one another in order to kind of come up with that final plan, which we plan to present in June. Again, just to reiterate what Maria already said, question one and two were really at the heart of building your portrait of a graduate.

Questions three and four, which is what are we doing really well as a district and where are areas of growth that we want to lean into? That's the pieces of feedback that we're really going to be using to develop our strategic plan and to be thinking about.

In addition to that, we're going to be looking at various sets of data. The faculty back in October already looked at attendance, graduation, NAWIA, the Maine Integrated Youth Health Survey. So kind of thinking about all of the data that's out there that we know about the student body and incorporating that into the plan.

And then lastly, faculty also looked at various white papers, research articles that were saying like, what do we think young people moving into the future are going to need? What are the skills, the knowledge that they're going to need to be successful as graduates

15:42

moving into the future? So looking at that as well. I just wanted to share, these are the top themes from questions three and four. So again, question three, what are we doing really well as a district already? So you can see self-management, empathy, perspective-taking, emotional regulation,

lots of great clubs and interest groups, critical thinking and problem-solving, and a really inclusive, welcoming school climate, so a culture and climate. So those are the things that, from the feedback from the survey and the focus groups,

those are the things that are standing out as real strengths for this district. The themes from question four, so what could we do better to prepare our students? Where is our growth edge? Emotional intelligence and communication skills, character development,

positive school climate and culture, which is interesting because you can see how things don't always grow, but we can parse that out. Holistic student well-being, financial and practical life skills, fostering student agency, field-based and community experiential learning,

curriculum relevance and streamlining so just to pull the screen back the curtain back a little bit on how the committee is going to be working as I said we'll divide up into subcommittees each one will take one of those belief

statements so this is an example for the community and relationships so the belief is we believe in belonging and strong relationships then that group will look at the feedback the data and the research and say okay what are some

of the indicators what do we what do we expect to see if we are making success if we're making progress what are the strategies that we want to employ in order to achieve that what are the action steps that we need to take in order to achieve that and so this will be kind of the template that each of

those groups will put together as they design that strategic plan that's it so any questions from all of you I will start with a huge thank you I know that is a lot boiled into a pretty concise presentation a lot of work done by a lot

of people so thank you to the committee thank you to the people who participated in the surveys and the forums and the feedback loops and it's a it's a ton of work and you know it's not done yet right this is where it gets fun I did

have one question because you know I'm thinking back to the strategic plan we had previously and kind of common objectives or themes that were in that one and one thing that jumped out to me that I didn't see in any of the themes

or the the I believe or objective section was around like around the facilities and around you know more concrete parts of the district literally I guess it did that not come up is that embedded it's somewhere in here how do

do we address that or um so there's a couple of different options but in one it's like if these are the the goals that we have what are the facilities that we need to have in order to support that learning in those objectives and then

another option would be to like have another additional section where we like reach out specifically to facilities people and the ones that would be addressing that and have a conversation and add those pieces but yes you're

right like that piece this was much more about the learning the object what we wanted our students to be able to achieve at the end so but part of that is what are the structures the facilities that we need in order to be able to get those goals so thank you yes thank you for all that work I'm just

kind of curious like how will some of these things be implemented into the school culture or into the day you could speak on that well I'll say first of all that I'm like really impressed with this district and how they've already really

tried to incorporate faculty and getting their feedback there's been multiple rounds where faculty have been a part of looking at the data talking about the research we're gonna be coming back in March and sharing out where we're at and

getting their feedback again as I think part of that your question that you're you're asking is like how do you get people to actually engage in these documents so that it's not just something that like one person is the gatekeeper of or that it's a document that sits on a wall and nobody really like identifies with and in part it's like having them be a part of the creation the thought process

20:49

understanding where we are in that and then and then ultimately it goes to to the district to the leadership that's here to say okay this is our strategic plan now how are we going to do this how are we going to keep people engaged moving forward so does that answer your question i think so i

guess I'm just wondering how this is going to be disseminated through our system here and really impact the students and how that might work. I can say a bit about that. So where we are right now is sort of like the philosophical underpinnings of the plan, and that's what you've seen. And the

next step is, okay, so these are things we believe in and value. Now, what are the actions we're going to turn them into that's what the plan becomes and to me that plan isn't finished in june it's it's a draft of what we think at that time and we'll have a structure in place to keep

following up on the things we said we were going to do and seeing if we're doing them and you know i imagine how they're implemented varies across districts how we use the last plan we had was you know every the district as a whole and every school and in turn every

administrator in charge of those schools or those districts or those departments when they came presented their goals for the year they were tied to these are these are the high-level objectives these are the strategies we're

undertaking now these are the indicators to know for making success so every every time we're looking at someone's goals they should be tied to the strategic goal of the whole district right and it and then and as it relates

to the budget right if we are looking to add something or remove something or you're like how does that stack up against our strategic plan how does that move it forward or not move it forward at the at the pace that we'd like it to

so you know how we choose to use it going forward that's I guess up to us but that is how we have used it in the past yeah thank you so much again for everybody for creating this. It's an amazing amount of work. My question is about the portrait

of a graduate and I'm curious kind of what you all were kind of using as kind of a benchmark kind of current state that this portrait is compared against. In other words, Marie is here and theoretically our earlier plan was partially intended to help educate Maria

and sort of create this graduate and becoming so how's it different like what are we do what are we looking to do what kind of graduate are looking to do now that is the attributes of which are a little different than what we were aiming for in the past I think that that it's really to your point lots of

communities will go through a portrait of a graduate process and come up with similar types hopes and goals right we want well healthy people that can go out they have options they have agency there's there's sort of like they have

the knowledge but they also have those interpersonal skills as well and so but what I think is important is to always have that iterative process with your community to make sure that it's still aligned and that you're still matched

with the population and the people that you're serving and so I don't think you've had a portrait before yeah so so this is actually your first like this community's first portrait and so it will be interesting to see how how might that change right moving forward and there might not

be major changes but there might also be some based on you know advances in society and technology and our community and so forth so having that process and having that opportunity and then the other thing I'll say which doesn't completely answer your question is a lot of people were like especially the focus groups really appreciative of the opportunity to like have these conversations

about what's happening in their schools and so again just opening that door and having that feedback back and forth is really important and valuable um to kind of yeah add on to your point erica i definitely think that i i really did not know that this existed until ren had emailed me

about it, reaching out if I wanted to be a representative. And I really think that this strategic plan has so much student involvement and really values students' opinions. I remember being at the We Believe meetings and Ms. Lucci asking me, oh Maria, how do you feel about this?

And I definitely think that even if this is similar to something that you all have seen before, I definitely think that there is a lot of student involvement going into this and a lot of student care into this I don't know if that answers your question but just putting that out there it's interesting you say that because I love that I don't

26:05

recall that necessarily being as big a piece the last time we went through this process so you know since that clearly is a priority for us in the district good for us that we actually did it and involved it in the strategic plan process I was curious about the chart that you talked about blowing up with the different colors and I noticed that the constituency of student did not weigh in

on those pillars or it was not provided to us I was wondering if that was intentional or or kind of where they landed on that and this was the second round of feedback not the first round and it took place we did it December

into January and so it was opened up we didn't take time out of school to have each of the students like respond like we did with the first round and so it just there wasn't as big of a response from students okay for that second round

of feedback yeah it's just curious yeah where they where they would have landed on what their chart would have looked like I'm just curious thank you so much I'm curious how do you go how did you go through all the data to analyze and

come up with emerging themes I have a team and we have a director of data and she like really heads that up we had like rolls and rolls of chart paper that were transcribed by a whole team of us myself included and then you just kind of

start like theming it you just kind of pull out the common and like clump them all together and then so Brian she's the Whitmer she is the director she put together kind of a summary which included the the main themes and the

percentages for each of those. And then she also had ones that broke it down by stakeholders. Then she pulls out language so that you still get some of that qualitative data as well. So like when I say this theme, these are kind of some of the statements that were clumped into that piece

because there is so much rich data in there. That's for like the focus groups. With the survey, it's much easier. There's a lot of like quantitative pieces because people are putting like a number behind it um but again with the open responses you do a similar process

so do you need anything from us at this point or is this just informative from our perspective i think we're yeah i think we're good um we appreciate um just the time to be able to share with you and looking forward to coming back in june as are we yeah thank you all right thank you

All right. So we are at item 7 on our agenda, which is public comment. And when Erica's walking up, that usually means we have one. All right. Did my name fall down? All right. Jonathan. Is it Jonathan Bell? Oh, okay. So you're good? Okay. All right. Well, then we will carry on. And we do have another one at the end. So if you decide you want to say something then.

will. Thank you so much. All right, so we will move on to item eight, a report from the superintendent. I have a couple of resignations to report. Allison Ginn, our BCBA, has resigned. And although it's not written on your agenda, more recently Paul Kerrigan, a special ed

teacher at Freeport Middle School, has resigned. All right, and we don't have any administrator reports or board committee reports or policy review all right so we will move on to item 12 unfinished business item 1 start with superintendent's presentation

of concept of district reconfiguration that's a mouthful of a title okay so right off I'm going to own that I have taken heat for the colors I've chosen to use for my slideshow I'm told that it might not necessarily translate as

beautifully up there as it does on my laptop, but I dug in my heels, and I like these colors, and it's what we're going with, and I feel good about it, and that's what counts in this moment. Those are paranormal colors. They are, they are. Panther. It's a panther. So before I launch in, and of course you have a copy of this in front of you, I feel I do

31:34

need to start with a reminder of why we are here, and it's because back in November, when I brought you the difficult news that if I were to carry forward a status quo budget, it would be 10-ish percent. You asked for tiers, which we're talking about in an ongoing way, but you also asked

for thoughts about how to make the budgets sustainable over the long term. So what I found, having started here just this summer, is that there have been conversations about that going on at the administrative level, among the community members, and there were already ideas that were

out there being talked about. So what I, I feel that I want to be very conscious of my role here. My lane is to present you with options to consider. And what I'm asking tonight is these are the things I'm hearing talked about. Do you want them talked about more? Because actually going down a

formal rabbit hole as opposed to an informal rabbit hole takes a lot of time, energy, and work. So if you feel any of these ideas are worth exploring, we would gladly take that on. But if you see what's up here and think, ew, I would just as soon leave it alone. So up to you. I'm

asking for guidance here. So I'm going to present to you in a way that I, when I was a teacher of research, taught my students to be solutionary when I was a big fan of solutionary education, which is present a menu of options and then freely discuss what makes these options either

attractive or not attractive and put them in relationship to each other. So that's what I'm going to attempt to do tonight. So there are a number of lenses through which to view the entire sort of gestalt of what we're talking about. First, what I think triggered the conversation

is the ongoing financial pressure that we're facing. And since I have the microphone and I get editorialized for a minute, I think it's important to name that these ongoing financial pressures are because of the inflationary environment in which we live, and they are not the fault of anybody living here in RSU-5 or working here in RSU-5. They are tough times, and costs for lots of things keep going up.

So that is certainly a consideration. Another consideration that is very compelling, too, is What is the district that we want to be in the future? What do we want to provide for kids in the future? So educational opportunity and equity of that opportunity across the district

is a very important consideration. And then, just at sort of a more granular level, we have this early childhood mandate which requires us to assume responsibility for special education for three- and four-year-olds. we have just recently chosen to join cohort three which means that next year we'll bring

along the four-year-olds and then the year after that the threes and we have a good solution right now for the fours that we're taking next year we still have a lot of figuring out to do for the threes for the year after that so that fits in our long-term need in the category of long-term

needs that we've got to contend with so again i am seeking your guidance here about what your overall direction you'd like to go in is. So I think that this is a really important sort of ordering of priorities that among us on the administrative team figures pretty prominently.

The needs of kids should always come first. We have two things here. We've got budget and what's good for kids and families. Budget is important. I think what kids and families need is more important. So neither is unimportant, but as I consider the whole picture, I come back to what's

best for kids and families as my primary consideration, while holding both. So again, the lenses to view, these are the major sort of cross-cutting philosophical issues that have come up as we have discussed this. And when I say we, I mean me and the people sitting back there,

largely, and, you know, probably mostly Mr. Pitten, but whatever. So, early childhood programming, we are required to serve all three and four-year-olds who have IEPs by July 2027, and lest there be, to eliminate confusion about that, the state's mandate is that every district

has to do that by July of 2028, but we've now joined cohort three, so we are committed to doing it by 2027. That's year after next year. Another issue that is prominent in our discussions is that we have two middle schools in the district. And they're both great, but they're not

36:57

necessarily great in the same ways. So the lens of middle school equity and the possibility of actually being more expansive with our middle school offerings, especially as we've had budget conversations, and we're talking about tough choices and trade-offs, the opportunity to switch

from a retractive mindset to an expansive mindset is really appealing, and to ensure that that is consistent for all kids in the district, regardless of which town they live in. Then we have the financial sustainability lens, short-term versus long-term costs, in an environment that is

inflationary, and who knows how long it will continue to be inflationary. And then, equally important to all of these is community identity and the connections in the towns. And I do want to stop there for a minute to just sort of talk a little bit about some experiences that I have

had in my professional life. Before I came to this district, the two districts that I worked in previously both were facing the issue of small, I mean very small, tiny schools that were hard to keep going because of the economies of scale that they lacked. And that is an issue that we are

facing here and we have to talk about. We have to put out in the open. It's happening across the state and it's happening across the country. So first, let me just sum up some of the major considerations for early childhood programming. So we've made the choice to join cohort three.

That means next year we're bringing on the four-year-olds who have IEPs. And we are in good We're in good shape to do that because we already have infrastructure for four-year-olds here, and the amount of kids that we'll be taking on next year is not so dramatic

that we can't absorb them with the existing infrastructure that we have. That becomes tricky year after next when the three-year-olds come on because, quite frankly, we do not have a place to put them. We have not figured that out yet, and I think it's very hard to figure out going on the way we are

with our current facilities use. How are we going to distribute the services for early childhood across the district? And another conversation that should come up in all of this is whether we continue with the exclusively half-day pre-K model that we now have, or should we offer some degree

of full-day pre-K. There's lots of in-between. There's going all half-day, keeping all half-day, going all full-day, having some half-day and some full-day. There's all kinds of, a whole spectrum of how that could be offered. But if we're looking ahead, that should be part of the conversation. And my personal feeling, and I think others in the room would probably agree,

even though most of my career was as a high school educator, I think this is the most important thing we have to do right now. The benefits that will happen for kids and families about doing early childhood correctly are an immediate payoff for the families who have those little kids.

And all of the research suggests that particularly kids with needs, the earlier you intervene, the better the outcomes are. And districts who have already taken on this responsibility from CDS are already finding benefits. Benefits like dismissing kids from special education earlier because their needs have been met earlier. So I just think that's very important. So next, we've talked a lot about middle school stuff,

particularly having a congruent and consistent middle school experience for kids all across the district, to be able to provide equity for athletics and extracurriculars in that mix. And there is also, I'm seeing that I have a capital B before I shouldn't have a capital B on the word before, and I caught it before Kara Kikini, so it makes me proud.

and Ginny, Ginny, you were supposed to go through this. Anyway, there has been a lot of conversation about whether or not it really benefits kids to have an opportunity to integrate as a district before high school, and there is a strong opinion in the room among the administrative team

that that is a benefit to kids. Right now, kids from Durham don't get to integrate into the district as a whole until they go to ninth grade. And that is not necessarily the best scenario. So there are other considerations for middle-level education that we could think about in the future.

42:12

We could build on the very strong model of STEM education we have in this district and integrate CTE, which is Career Technical Education. There is the possibility to embed a teacher from Region 10 into a middle school on their budget. Now, of course, we contribute to their budget, but that is a model that I have seen in other districts,

and it has a lot of benefits for kids. We've had conversations about world language in connection with the budget. If we do something different with middle school, we may be able to make world language truly accessible and expanded in grades 7 and 8.

And I want to take a moment to pause right there while I consider world language, because we've talked about this in other contexts, but I think a dynamic of it that has not been fully fleshed out that we're going to have to keep talking about is that in Freeport

Middle School, we do something that I haven't seen another district do, a middle school do, which is to offer both science and STEM as core classes. that what and that's fantastic but knowing that there's only so many minutes in a day

that's a core class added to the core classes that we don't have for electives so or unified arts and so that's a constraint on the schedule on the unified arts side that forces us to talk about choices so and also in a moving on to the next bullet in a consolidated middle school which is

an idea where we'd be going, you'll see in future slides, there's greater opportunity for interdisciplinary teaching, which is frankly the best kind of teaching. So this is just another aspect of the conversation. And then financial sustainability. So we need to have an eye on the

long term. We're right now contending with decisions that are hard right now, but they only get harder if they're not made now. And so we need to keep that in mind, knowing that inflation has a magnified impact on deferred decisions. And there are efficiencies in consolidating

programming rather than having it be dislocated across the district and using our facilities in a more streamlined way. So again, this was the trigger, I think, that prompted you back in November to ask me to talk about long-term solutions, and it is something we have to

consider, but I think that the things on the previous two slides, to me personally, are more important. And then next, something that we cannot underestimate, which is the fact that feelings are as important as thoughts and ideas, and that is that community identity is very powerful,

and it's real, and it should be honored. So each school in the district is an expression of its community's identity. They're dear to the people in those communities. People have connections and important memories and historical relationships. And all of that is as valid as anything else

in the conversation. So now I'm going to talk about three scenarios. The three scenarios are the ones that we have sort of talked about at the admin level. Scenario number one, steady on, keep on as we are. So this is the current district configuration of grade levels.

And I probably don't need to review it for anybody on the board, but if there are members of the public watching. So in Durham, all kids' grades pre-K through grade 8 are at Durham Community School, and then at 9th grade go to Freeport High School.

For Freeport, pre-K to grade 2 are at Moore Street, grades 3 to 5 are at Mast Landing, grades 6 through 8 are at Freeport Middle, and then grades 9 to 12 are at Freeport High School. And then for Palmel, grades pre-K to 5 are at Palmel Elementary, grades 6 and 8 are at Freeport Middle, grades 9 through 12 are at Freeport High School.

So everybody comes together at the high school level, Freeport and Palmel come together at the middle school level, Durham is the one that does not join until the high school level. So, if we keep this model, we, based on my best, you know, summary at the moment, some things that we preserve. We preserve the sense of community and town identity, which is important to a lot of people. The neighborhood schools remain as sources of town pride and identity as they have.

47:44

we would still have early childhood in each town. Right now, each town has public pre-K. We have it at Powell. We have it at Durham. We have it at Moore Street. Half day. And in providing that, we're giving lots of kids a soft entry into public school in each town

and that mitigates transitions to kindergarten and that has a lot of benefits. And in a time when we're talking about lots of potential changes, it is the least amount of change in the short term and that has value. so our facilities are used this way. We would not have to make a facilities investment to keep

going in the way that we're going other than to keep maintaining our current facilities. I guess I should add a caveat to that. We're going to keep going the way we're going and we're going to add early childhood which involves three-year-olds and that will involve some level of putting them

somewhere and doing something with where we put them. But we're adapted to this model. So again I want to stress the intangibles are very important and that community sentiment has to be honored. So at the same time, the limitations of the current configuration is that it's not very efficient.

For early childhood in particular, as we consider having to bring on and provide special education services for three-year-olds and four-year-olds, as I've said already, we don't have a good plan were a good option at the moment for space for the three-year-olds. But we could gain,

and we lose efficiencies by having the services spread out. We're having, you know, there's some level of itinerant staff, which is not terribly efficient. We have a more limited ability to offer full-day programming for early childhood if we wanted to do that. If we look at the middle

school situation. I would say both Freeport Middle School and Durham Community School are great schools, but again, they're not great in the same way, and they're not equal. And Durham does not have the same level of access to extracurriculars and athletics as Freeport

Middle School. The academic offerings in the two schools are not the same. The STEM situation that i mentioned to you a minute ago is present for freeport middle school kids but not in durham durham offers stem but not at the same level um presently durham has spanish but not french

and there are other things and we have talked a lot about the dynamic of durham students especially enter high school and they have not really been integrated with the other district kids until that moment and just in terms of financial sustainability the trajectory looks very difficult with the

current model because we're operating multi-purpose facilities in an inflationary environment and in some ways we're duplicating staff and resources because of the multiple locations we're paying mileage and another aspect of it is that how dear as it is just does not have efficiencies of scale

because of its size. And there's a disproportionate amount of cost associated with that. So here's the fundamental question for keeping things the way they are, as I see it. Can we address the early childhood mandate and the middle school inequities and the financial pressures if we keep on in this

way? Those are the three pressure points at the moment that I see. Early childhood, middle school stuff and the financial pressure. They're pushing on each other. So which direction do we go with that? Okay, so alternatives. Why should we even consider alternatives? Why should a brand new

superintendent come into a district and touch a third rail? Okay, if I hit pause for a moment, completely honestly with you, when you graciously offered me this job, I thought, that is great. I'm going to come in there. I'm going to learn names. I'm going to figure out where the bathrooms are i'm going to just sort of like step in slow and sort of learn the law of the land and i that's

52:53

just not the moment that the district is in no so i guess i'm just believe me or don't believe me this is not me coming in here wanting to be a cowboy it is just because this is the conversation that i've walked into and what my intention is is to make it talkable so we've got to do something

with early childhood whether we, well, clearly we want to because we decided to last week, right? So we're doing it. The middle school issue is real. I don't think we do our kids justice if we don't talk about that and figure out a way forward that considers all the variables. The budget

pressure is real. Again, I don't think anybody wants to be the brand new superintendent that comes into a district and says, what do you want me to do with this budget that's going to be like two million dollars more expensive than maybe you were counting on so we just we have to deal with

it even if we have to have hard conversations um and we are perhaps the stars aligned in this way we're doing a strategic plan um that's an opportunity to talk about where we are going so this is a conversation starter if you decide that it ends today then it will probably go on in

the sidelines anyway. But they will go on in a formal way. But once conversations start, you never know where they're going to go. So there could be other ideas that emerge after today. Anyway, scenario number two is to repurpose the Powell School as an Early Childhood Center.

This would require shifting all around the district, and I've tried to capture that here. But it does not require us to build any new facilities, and it is pretty manageable shifting. So if we did this, Poundell would become a district-wide pre-K slash pre-school center.

It has enough space for that to happen. We could also locate a lot of the special education services for early childhood in that building, co-located together. That provokes the question, where do the Poundell kids go? Well, the early childhood Poundell kids go to Poundell. Then when they get to kindergarten and go through grade 6, they go to Durham.

What happens to Durham then? Is Durham not overcrowded? Well, no, because Durham's 7th and 8th grade kids are roughly equal in number to the panel grades K-6. So Durham's 7th and 8th would go to Freeport Middle. But wait, do we have enough space for those kids at Freeport Middle?

Well, we do if Freeport Middle becomes a district-wide 7th and 8th grade school. Now, currently, Freeport Middle has 6th grade. But if we shift 6th grade back to mass landing, and have mass landing become grades 4, 5, 6, as opposed to 3, 4, 5.

And then back that up to Moore Street, where, remembering that the pre-K has gone out to Powell, Moore Street becomes kindergarten 1, 2, 3. There is space for all of this. And, of course, the high school remains the high school.

So by consolidating that way, and I should add, how does this create the space for the three-year-olds that I've mentioned? Well, it's because there's enough space at Powell to do that, and to a certain degree you can group three-year-olds with four-year-olds.

And then that might provoke the question, well, if you can do that, why don't we just do that with the existing model? It's because it's very inefficient. I mean, we can do that, but that doesn't solve the problem of co-locating the services in a streamlined way.

So this scenario has some real benefits. It would really be a profound investment in early childhood. But we would dedicate an entire building to it, an entire really delightful building to it that is really well situated to do really cool things with outdoor play, play-based early childhood.

Consolidating the services, perhaps making it easier to have full-day offerings, to expand the outdoor play-based model with the three-year-olds, and that is just a really good fit. And it also solves the issue of middle school integration. All the 7th and 8th graders in the district would be together in one building.

They would have consistent offerings, both academically and extracurricularly. They would get to all come together before 9th grade and establish a sense of, you know, being one district. So there are also financial considerations.

58:14

I don't want to stand here and promise that this will save jillions of dollars, but it will likely save some money. You know, you might think at first, well, we would be eliminating all of the teaching positions at Paranel.

That is not actually the case. Many of those people would go to the other schools where the kids would move. But there would be savings. Having a single early childhood facility versus multiple sites is savings in and of itself.

There are long-term operational efficiencies that are possible if you do this, as opposed to keeping things the way they are. The big downside is that this is a significant impact to communities, especially Poundell, and the Poundell school is dearly loved and for good reason, and we have to consider that.

There would also be a change for Durham. It would be Durham's kids, you know, Durham's Littles and Freeport's Littles going out to Poundell, but for Durham, their middle school kids would be coming into Freeport earlier than they do now,

and that's a change that could be difficult. it would create a shared new identity. So those are just some at first blush of the factors to consider if we did that. And then the next scenario is a very interesting one that I have heard more than one person discuss, and that was, okay, we could do a district-wide 6th grade

at Poundell Elementary School. So in this scenario, we kind of keep things as they are in more ways than in the previous one, but all the 6th graders go out to Poundell and have this one sort of like very philosophically different

sixth grade experience than what we're currently doing. It would have to be philosophically different because all the specials and things, art, music, PE, etc., would have to be kind of folded into the experience. Probably focused on outdoors, adventure, education.

Don't have that concept fully fleshed out yet, but people have talked about it. Poundell Pre-K to 5 would go to DCS. So the Poundell kids are still leaving Poundell and going to Durham in this scenario, but they're coming back in 6th grade. And then Durham's 6th grade would go to Poundell, as everyone's 6th grade would.

And 7th and 8th grade would go to Freeport Middle. So benefits to this, we could potentially have this really cool 6th grade year that is very different from anything that we're currently doing. There's potential for experiential education with an outdoor focus.

It's right up against Bradbury Mountain. That's also a benefit if we put early childhood there. And it could create this interesting bridge here between elementary and middle school. And it could achieve that middle school integration factor even earlier than we talked about.

The shortcomings that I saw are that we don't really achieve the middle school efficiencies in the same way. the sixth grade program, you've got to think about all the things you have to have in a building to have a grade level there. So art, music, world language, life skills, special education, etc.

We'd have to find a way to achieve that with sixth grade. It's not the same. You do have to think about those things for early childhood, but not in the same way. And we still have not achieved the maximum, the best solution for early childhood if we do this. And it's still a

significant change for panel especially, new shared identity for grades 6 through 8. So this scenario has been talked about. Perhaps you can tell. I don't think this scenario is as viable as some of the others, but it has been talked about and it could be talked about more. So bringing us

back to the broader view, we are living in a moment of complexity, both with the budget and with this proposition, the budget for next year, and for the vision for longer term. And I think what these moments are asking us to do is something that's very hard, which is to hold a lot of true

1:03:16

things at the same time. And I think what we see in the world today is that when people are challenged to do that, they become reductive, and they reduce it to rights and wrongs. Anyone who's ever taken ethics courses, which I imagine some people in the room have,

ethical dilemmas are actually never a right versus a wrong. That's a moral dilemma. An ethical dilemma is when you have a right versus a right. It is right, on the one hand, to preserve panel exactly the way it is because it's important. It is also right, on the other hand, to think about changing it because there could be possibilities there. It's how you balance those things and hold them both to be true while making a decision that is what makes it complex.

So, here's where I kind of wrap this up. I need to know where you'd like to go with this. I hope nobody in any of the towns is ready to burn me an effigy right now. I'm just trying to make it talkable. What's most important to you in your decision-making? Based on what you've seen here, are we justified in carrying forward this conversation?

I think I'll just stop there. It's really what it is. Where would you like to go from here? Lewis. Yes. So, I am open to any of these. Let me start by saying that. I would encourage everyone here to start at the end of Flying Point Road and pretend you are on a bus as a three-year-old and drive, or perhaps have the bus take you, from the end of Flying Point Road to Powell with stops along the way.

My concern is that three-year-olds would be on the bus for perhaps an hour or more. It doesn't mean that it wouldn't work. It means that we have to consider, as you say, the child, not the dollar, not the parent. We have to consider what's going on with the child here. And a three- or four-year-old, that's a long drive.

Are we there yet? Are we there yet? Twice a day, in my opinion. Yeah, no, the transportation piece is an important one. I think regardless or irregardless which one is it either regardless regardless of what early education early childhood we end up with how we handle three-year-olds getting them to school

every day and then you know these are also three-year-olds that may have particular needs so whether that's on a bus or not is probably it's probably not a bus it's probably a van but the point is still the same yeah certainly certainly something to think

about because we do have a pretty wide geography I think actually Durham the geography of Durham for the number of people is pretty big not a lot of people so you can be pretty far from any of the schools like yeah that that is true but

I also want to point out I think people often think that panels in the middle of nowhere like hours away on it's from more street school about eight minutes to get to PES I just want to point that out too it takes me ten minutes to get here

I have to drive past the school it's not as far as people think it and we went across the same thing in Durham people think we're you know you know pass Turner and then hang a right and then you get to Durham it's that it's not as far as

you think yes exactly halfway until morning or something I want to start with a big thank you because I this is a brave thing to undertake I mean we told you to but it is still brave you know this is these are not easy conversations and I appreciate the care with which you laid out

you know you didn't you didn't avoid the hard parts to just avoid them right you laid them all out like these are some of the benefits these are some of the challenges we would face in any of these situations and I think you know the idea

1:08:26

of keeping it about what is best for kids in our districts from a whole variety of perspectives of what's best I think will serve us well in this discussion but I feel like this is a really a really sensitive but open way to

to start the conversation. Kelly? So it looks like part of the driver of, you know, thinking about reconfiguring is the early childhood space consideration. And so I would be curious to know, if not Palinal, what does this look like for us in a way that is actually feasible that we can,

you know, not be having to have resources in every school? It sounds like that could add up to a lot of positions. I can answer a little bit of that right now, and there are others in the back row who could answer it better than I can, but so you can, under the state's mandate, for

three-year-olds who have an IEP, they can be grouped with four-year-olds. So they could be brought in where we have four-year-olds to the extent that we will have space. I don't know that we'll fully have the space with the existing facilities the way they're configured.

There is also the option to push our services out to community providers. Those community providers have to have a certain star rating from the state. Not all the providers in the community have that. And when we discussed this with the Early Childhood Task Force,

we run up against the inefficiency of, like, pushing our people. We're paying the mileage. It takes time to get out there. We're paying them to get out there. the setting in those community daycares or providers may not be conducive to providing the services. So it's possible, but it's not ideal. There was a strong sentiment that it's better for those kids

if we do it in our facility with our people. If I may have a moment of Pollyanna optimism, I do think we have the opportunity with Options 2 and 3 to kind of maybe celebrate that we're a district, a cohesive different district. I know that I've heard in this community complaints that the high school is called Freeport and that it's all three of us. And so there's a possibility that all of our students would be enjoying the facilities at Poundell in both options two and three and kind of make us more of a cohesive unit, whereas now we're only joining at the high school.

And so I do like that aspect of these proposals. I think it's nice to kind of reinforce that we are, in fact, one unit. Thank you so much for this. I think this is really well put together, and I really appreciate how you have made it talkable. So thank you for that. And your question, what factors are most important in our decision-making?

The first thing that came to my mind is where is the most developmentally appropriate environment for students? and it does sound like, I do like the idea of an early childhood education center and space. My question is more around the middle school piece, too, and this is the first that I've heard

that there's been a desire for the Durham's 7th and 8th graders to join earlier, and that there might be a challenge in them integrating in 9th grade. And so I'd like to hear a little more about that. And I'd like to hear more about that.

I will start, but then I'm going to ask Will maybe to come on down. So I can just tell you, come on down, Will. When I first arrived here, that conversation was pretty strong. And that sentiment was made really clear to me. And people were asking me to somehow bring that out into the open.

And I don't know that everybody feels that way, but enough people do that it should be talked about. Jen's teeing herself up behind her because she knows she's next. Well, good evening. Oh, it's a little louder this week. So just to circle back to your question, I don't think that there's necessarily a response that says

1:13:38

this is not a conversation that has really necessarily been aired publicly. What I would say is that over the years, it is a conversation that has been discussed at administrative meetings over the last few years. And when Ray Grogan was here as principal at Freeport Middle School and had his own students at the high school involved with sports teams, his own children, I should say,

he would bring up how noticeable he felt like it still was for some of the dumb kids to sort of like hang in their groups of long-term relationships and friendships. Those that were involved in sports or drama or music and other activities would kind of bond or merge in those ways.

But for others, you know, they stayed with their kind of cohorts that they had. And that, you know, you talk developmentally, it's easier to connect with people as an early adolescent, even though that's a tricky time, than as a ninth grader where there's different social pressures and things that people are navigating.

So, it had been a conversation with the last couple of years, but never quite got beyond that piece of being conversations at the administrative level. So, as such, it's not been a topic where we have gone to community members or to families

to say, hey, you know, how would you feel about this? What would this look like? Informally, when we see families, because obviously, as you might imagine, we have some families who have been with the school who have several children so they'll come back to pick up

the younger ones and check in hey how's so-and-so doing up at the high school and I would say that pattern has held true for those involved in specific sort of extracurricular type activities there's a connection for some of those who haven't it's sometimes been a trickier transition

and they've sort of stayed within their particular kind of cohorts. So, you know, it has been in that vein. I can't say to you, oh, and there's all this background information behind it because equally, in the same way that Tom has sort of stressed,

that, you know, we are very committed to making the pre-K experience the best it can be. And so that's sort of like our focus. We certainly don't want to put doubts upon the model in which people are in. The piece, I would say, that goes along with that,

just in terms of the last couple of budget cycles that we've had conversations about, it has been tricky where we've faced conversations specifically about FMS staffing and models and schedules and offerings. And as Tom said, they're both great schools and they're great in different ways.

And I feel that there's been this desire and effort to have shared and similar opportunities for kids. So when they come together in ninth grade, it's not possible in the models that we have. When we share unified arts teachers from pre-K through 8 compared to those who are focused specifically on early adolescence and the kind of experiences they can offer.

Ever since the RSU-5 came together, there's great efforts on behalf of Freeport Middle School and Craig Sickles was the AD at the time, and it's been continued by Eric, to offer some of the sports across both schools. It means that currently for football, Freeport Middle School football players will wait before they can commence practice so that Durham finishes school close to an hour later.

And we dismiss them a little bit early so they can be transported down to meet with their teammates. But those little facets are evident throughout where somebody's waiting, somebody's being slightly compromised, there's additional transportation.

For some of the sports, they're just not possible. We don't have enough. We have kids who ski, but not enough to run a separate ski team or a ski program. And then coming together at a high school level, at that point, you've kind of missed some of those opportunities to connect and to sort of grow those sort of skills.

So there's a range of those sort of facets that exist. In a perfect scenario, as you were just mentioning, you know, that notion of shifting from an RSU-5 to a district type of experience and district kind of thinking, it holds a lot of appeal and potential. But I can't say that we've had big community conversations about it because we haven't. Do you want to add anything, Jane?

1:18:44

No, I met a Jane Gockel from the high school. I think there's lots that I can add. I wonder if there's questions, too, that you have. I think, in general, well said, a lot of the points that I would make that I think I have seen, this is my 11th year here, and I think over the time that I have been here, I've seen this real concerted effort to deliberately have our 8th graders

getting to know each other sooner than just when they're coming in in their first day of school. And I certainly think that that has helped, but that has come from realizing just what he's saying for our students who are not connected to a particular group or activity or athletic team or a drama program or music. We really need to be thoughtful in how are we helping them to create relationships. I also think that there is a lot to be said about going through the same cohort of kids from grades K to eight I have a my own

child did something similar to that in a program in Portland they're a little bit like friends and siblings and so I think that there can be benefits to that I do think that it's a real skill for kids to be able to walk into a classroom with kids that they've never met before and how are

they working with those students? How are they forming friendships, relationships? And that takes effort for us to make sure that all of our students are doing that. And I think it's a different experience for the kids who have done multiple transitions to multiple classrooms versus being

in a smaller program. I think there's benefits to both, but I certainly think there's times where we have seen a difference with that none of those questions that I can answer I know academically that has been another area that we have tried to align the

middle schools a little bit more in terms of trying to ensure that regardless of which middle school they went through they were kind of coming in with the same level of preparation for their academic classes I'm thinking specifically of math has that been enough do I mean I know it's been a

concerted effort but is it um is it showing up in results that that's working is it enough i think that there well i think will can speak to this as well i think that um i would say particularly right before covid that we were doing a lot more work vertical work six through 12. i think that

there has been from my perspective and will can share that there's been a lot of collaboration the two schools but logistically it's challenging just the things of on early release days we tend to be building based because we would have to wait an hour for our teachers to meet with the Durham teachers which we did in this

early release day but then it gives a shorter chunk of time so the whole benefit of the early release is to have this larger chunk of time and so in my mind I think there are some logistical very real challenges of having the

eighth grade teachers from the DCS being able to meet consistently and frequently with the Freeport middle school teachers because we have that challenge within our own building that sometimes if our teachers schedules don't match we're really having to get creative about the time when they're able to collaborate which makes a difference in alignment you know true

alignment comes from when teachers have time for planning and it's consistent and frequent and I think you know again we'll can give more information about that but I think that that's certainly in my mind is still a challenge thank

you I'm not sure if you are asking specifically around so like academic comparisons but certainly from curriculum delivery we try to align programs and as we talked about before there are some where like we don't match the amount of science and STEM that can be offered we don't have that capacity of teaching and but we do certainly with the math and the language arts also has

similar programming approaches to it so that we try to align as best we can so that when children coming in they will have similar experiences to then build upon you know for the high school for freshman classes yeah and that's I

thought what you that's why I thought your answer was going to be which is good right I mean I think it's important to say that you know that the middle school experience that they're getting in German is is not substandard or

1:23:50

subpar in any way but you know could we make it even better for everybody I mean that's a really interesting idea when I think that's part of some of the pieces that Tom alluded to across any of the models What we've been looking at is, budget-wise, it's just really tricky when there's models of inefficiency.

So, in a similar way, when there's a small elementary school, a small middle school is going to be constrained by opportunities it can offer. And so then when we talk about ways to sort of solve challenges that start to push upon inequities,

but then equally feel like, does one place have to lose something in order to maintain status quo? And I think that's, again, sort of like what Tom was alluding to, is there's opportunities to, you know, whenever possible, you want to be able to level up, not level down.

But financially, leveling up in inefficient numbers, schools that have smaller numbers that make staffing inefficient, it's tricky. You know, there's small pieces that really drive our schedule that people may or may not be aware of,

is that because we compete against middle schools with sports teams, but we run on an elementary school schedule because of high school busing, it means that our middle schoolers, at the end of the day, they will often have to leave school early because when we play an away game,

we're playing against a middle school who have finished at 2.20 when we don't finish until 3.15. When we have home games, they play on our schedule, but it's impactful. It means that if we have shared staff with the middle school, which we do, we share a math teacher,

that person runs on a Durham day, but we have to run our schedule around their afternoon availability. And so all of a sudden your school schedule gets locked in because we have a middle school and an elementary school schedule.

And those things become sort of logjams. there's there's small subtleties like that the um and i agree with you michelle i think it is important to really stress um we feel super fortunate we have some outstanding middle

school teachers as you know um and um who really do an excellent job and um and know the children really well um they loop with them they teach seventh and eighth grade both um which is you know i've worked in straight middle schools where we've also looped found a really powerful model

so i don't think we are necessarily compromising children but we're really looking at what opportunities exist that also can meet our district needs for how do we grow efficiently and sustainably so for the for the record my son really appreciated getting out early to go to

soccer games yeah he loved that he missed an hour and a half of school yeah well that was right because he supported mentions united if it had been another team we were to talk about it fair enough. Any other specific questions where we have Lou and Jen right there? Okay. Anna.

I have a quick question about the scenario two and three. Would we have enough room at Freeport Middle School for it to be six through eight? No. So six would go to mass landing? Six would go to, in scenario two, six would go to mass landing. That's right. Durham would stay? Durham would

keep it sixth grade. Got it. Yes. And the panel K to five, go to Durham. K to six, sorry, because the six would have been going to Freeport Middle, now they'd go to Durham. And the offset is Durham's seventh and eighth. Go to Freeport Middle, and it's pre-K goes to panel. And I guess the follow-up

question is, you said that the third scenario with the sixth grade having this experiential year had also been talked about in the margins for a while. Is it just mostly, is it because the sixth grade, thinking like the bridge year between elementary and middle, or like why the

sixth grade? I think that that was what was primarily attractive about that idea, and I could probably call Will back, come on Will, okay, the cat's out of the bag. This was kind of Will Pitten idea but others really well the reason this had come up previously was that

1:29:12

we'd also looked at really in an ideal world six to eight would be together right and to be honest we've brainstormed a variety of different thoughts. You know, how viable are modular buildings short-term? How viable is a financial demand to expand a middle school?

You know, and how long do those things wait? And then if they become, you know, you start talking facilities, is it middle school or is it Moore Street? Is it regional or elementary school? There's so many long-term conversations that could potentially delay an impactful decision

And, again, I think the important thing here is that I can't stress enough how we've tried to always, again, I'm going to turn back to the beginning of Tom's presentation. Focus has always been like, is there a way that we can have a really rich experience for students that doesn't compromise students whilst recognizing the need for a sustainable budget for the communities?

and that is what's sort of like driven the kind of brainstorming and thinking so without the capacity for a six to eight facility in the current model we've also talked about what do you move people around you put the six to eight school in Durham and you know what does that look like but that unfortunately it doesn't leave enough other spaces for what we need so but you

know I guess I would say that if it's any of these conversations as Tom said if there was an interest move forward then at that point people dig deeper into what viability exists but so the idea of sixth grade at panel was um currently um our sixth graders go to um the 4h camp in beginning of

sixth grade i think most landing students go in fifth grade um to camp and um i'm not sure what grade does fms still do a camp piece at sixth grade in the past so there was a sense that like Okay, there's some common experiences, children entering early adolescence, starting to navigate

some of those pieces. In our sports leagues, our schools are a part of sports teams for 7th and 8th grade, so it's not like 6th grade necessarily would be compromised in that regard. They already have some camp experiences in different settings, but through that same

sense of bringing kids together and developing community. So the conversation was, if the focus was upon bringing middle school kids together, early adolescence as opposed to ninth graders. Do we like double down on that and do we take

this rich commitment to wanting science and STEM experiences? And in the previous strategic plan, one of the big features of that was that children are learning in having opportunities for experiential learning and that you've got an amazing setting in Pauno relative to

So it's the school setting relative to Bradley Mountain in the park. Is that a place where you actually bring together all the children to get together to beginning their secondary school years, 6 through 12, in a way that then they go to camp as a cohort or camp experience is designed around that sort of cohort. You've got access to lots of sort of place-based learning opportunities

right there in the park. Do we really emphasize that experiential year of building culture and community in a creative way for their learning that this sets them up as they then travel as 7th and 8th graders to middle school in Freeport. So that was kind of the thinking behind it. Again, none of these things have really been unpacked thoroughly because of, you know, really to be able to just air the conversations and see if there's any desire to pursue them any greater. I'm not sure if that answers it in any way. Okay. I've got some more ideas if you want to hear them.

Your time is ticking down here between here and June. Karen, you look like you're about to hit your button. So I have a question about scenario two, where that would be the early childhood center. And I don't know how many classrooms are in panel currently,

but would that space be utilized fully with an early childhood center, or how does that look? The consensus at the moment is that we would need the whole building for an early childhood center. I can say that on top of that, just sort of another level of this, it's not in the slideshow,

but Peter Wagner and I have talked about being able to expand community programs, offerings, largely after school at Poundell to try to maintain more of a sense of, you know, to keep it a vital place. And there is an opportunity for that to happen out there. but we would I can't remember exactly how many classrooms there are in that

1:34:33

building but let's see we've got one for each grade level we have a library music room art room stem room yeah and then Jim that includes the specials and when we consider that we would need classroom space but we would also need spaces for

services to be provided, because this is largely driven by a special education commitment, we would definitely need all the space. Now, with that said, another aspect that we haven't fully discussed is we may, every district in the state is contending with what to do with

early childhood. Some are better positioned than others with regard to facilities. Those who have the greater challenges may look to contract with other districts. And I have had conversations with other superintendents in neighboring districts who have said that if we had a center like that

and had space, they would have children to send to us, pay tuition. So I don't want to over-promise on that, but that's definitely something that could manifest. May I ask then, do we have any numbers? I know there's nothing solid probably, but for next year, the year after, is this

proposal, I guess, is it not for fall of 26, it's for fall of 27? Well, that would be great if that could happen then. I mean, we have numbers of four-year-olds that are coming in next year, but that number, as Julie mentioned to me the other day, what

we're experiencing now that we've joined cohort three, and I don't know if you want to talk about this, Julie, but it's sort of a, now that we've built it, people know we've built it, and they're kind of coming out. We haven't even built it yet. Yeah, I think what we are realizing is,

is the numbers currently provided by CDS, they're not necessarily reliable. We ran our pre-K screenings last Friday, and we've already kind of identified five more children that will be referred and our early intervention team are part of those screenings they have a really

you know usually if they're unsure we can just wait so the fact that they're recommending that we move forwards the likelihood of them qualifying is pretty high um two of whom you know have more needs than you know just an articulation thing so um i think what i don't think it's really been

talked about but the potential of having an early childhood center is that we can start to talk about whether we want currently we have half day pre-k which is um restrictive for some families who need full day care lots of families choose to have their children in two settings and it works

really well and it and it has been great for many years but i think if we were to move towards a full day four-day program four-year-old program we would see more our numbers would be higher so right now we have eight pre-k classrooms across our district so that's half day i would

imagine once we if we were to move to a full day programming where we would probably fill another classroom and we have restrictions on pre-k so you know when we talk class sizes at all the other grades we can make those decisions whereas we have restrictions on pre-k that are mandated by

the state that we cap at 16 so you know it like the the capacity shifts depending on what we're offering. I had worked, I'm like, you know, just sitting penciling the kind of things we would need in that setting. So if we're then thinking about the mandate is to provide special ed services for

three-year-olds, but if we were to offer kind of three-year-old programming, if we had full-day pre-K classrooms, let's say that moves to nine, and then we were like, maybe we should be offering half day three-year-old programming then we're looking at potentially four sessions two classrooms

that we need to do that and then we've got a special ed classroom that we're already proposing that we're adding it's another space and then you're going to want I mean we're going you need a gym like all movement kind of pieces that you would want as well as the outside um space um

and then you've got your speech and your OT and you know our OTs are always fighting for space in school particularly they would love a big space to have lots of equipment you know they're just the potential of what we could offer in that kind of environment would be is exciting in lots of

ways but I I think without a doubt we would fill that space do you feel that the space would be too small eventually who knows there's lots of space to add on out there so yeah okay thank you just kind of want to share my initial thoughts and I think one of the things

1:39:56

that I love about this district is on how how much we talk about equity and actually we don't just talk about it we are incredibly equitable district and I think that this proposal will really I think it it it makes our district just

that much stronger because we this um we're giving if if we if we make these changes we are giving all our students they're all in the same playing field it's kind of a level playing field for everybody it um it just makes our district more inclusive um and i say this as a palmo resident

um who so i'm kind of thinking of both sides of this and any if we do decide to go forward with one of these options it will disproportionately affect panel so I just want to kind of say that but I think in a in a lens of equity it's kind of a

no-brainer I think it makes a lot of sense yeah I would also just thank you Tom and the administrators for putting this together and for getting this out in the open and I think one of my reflections is just I can understand all

of the reasons why it hasn't been but I just I do find myself saying, like, would have been great to have talked about this three years ago. Which, again, is not a criticism of anyone, but more, we know exactly where it was, because we looked into it.

We had our people up there. I think what I'm over here experiencing is sort of a sense of, like, I have a, as my wife will attest to, I can shift into, like, a hyper-rational mode. that kind of is hard to budge me from. And I'm over here trying to budge myself out of that mode, but I'm finding myself just within that frame of really thinking about this in terms of how the pragmatic elements of this really add up.

The second scenario just seems like... I appreciated you saying all of the things about the it's not right versus wrong, it's right versus right. but I would say the rights in Scenario 2 are just so strong. They're just so, again, and I'm totally owning

that that is coming from a very rational place, just like a place of, like, when you put all of the pieces together, it makes sense in so many ways. So I just want to say that, and I think I would encourage us as a board to urge you to continue to pursue that one.

I'm not as keen on the third, though it kind of, I get, like, a little bit of, um, that one's giving a little bit of, like, old, uh, soul school vibes, um, where my wife went and, and Lois' mom taught, um, and so the idea of, like, having that, like, sixth grade, um, experience does, like, that's sort of, that's very exciting, but, like, um, so I guess it is knocking against my rationality, but, like, the, but the, but again, keeping the, like, the,

fact that we still have the distributed pre-k and all of those other pieces. So I would just encourage us to pursue the second option with a real eye toward, I guess, three things. One, can we push ourselves to do this by the fall of 27?

And what would that look like? Two, I think the number of rational benefits or or prognostic benefits, becomes even stronger if the financials really kind of support that, right? If we can really see, if we really can have an understanding of what, like, what footing does that put us on,

and can we see a real difference between status quo or the status quo, which is not status quo, even though I'm not, like, I agree, yes, we can keep going with that. But I guess the third thing is, like, to just understand if we were to stick with status quo, what would have to change?

Because something would have to change. Because we have to probably build in a building. Blunt. Like, I don't think we're going to get too much farther the way things are going without having to look at that as a question.

So I don't really think that the status quo is status quo. I think it's really saying, what are some of the costs on there? So I think I would just encourage us to, I would encourage us as a board to encourage you to look into that.

And also just, I know the fall 27 seems like a little astonishing as an idea, but it's also like once we sort of have the idea, and once we start to recognize, again, the obligations that we would have to the pre-K with the three-year-olds,

1:45:12

again, I think it just, there's so many things behind that that line up so powerfully. Yeah, I agree with Colin that you've made a pretty strong case that one of these scenarios and scenario two, I'd say, seems the strongest, can be a really positive thing for our district in terms of addressing the inequities as well as really gaining us some financial efficiency.

And my one question, I guess, is if we decide to move forward with kind of fleshing this out more and really getting granular, more granular about what that efficiency looks like, how do we, how, like, what does the plan to sort of get buy-in from the community look like?

Because that's the piece that I think is going to be kind of difficult. I don't fully know the answer to that yet, but I think that that's the next big, like, thing to figure out. And it would need to be figured out this spring. And it would start with what's on the agenda of our admin team

about how can we now bring the community into this process to hear its voice. We would need, I don't know what that looks like yet, but it would have to look like something. It would be a priority for us. That's where we would start. And it would probably start with getting more of these details

so that we can present a strong case to them because at this point it's just ideas and sometimes feelings are stronger than ideas. I mean, I want to return to the original point that my intention actually was to sort of let the scenarios speak for themselves.

It is no skin off my nose what you decide to do. I mean, it's your district, but I felt a responsibility to have you hear what people are talking about and what we see at this point as costs and benefits of these different scenarios.

and to see if you want to run with any of them. I think what I'm kind of hearing, and I have, well, I should stop. I'm hearing some people say they like the idea of figuring out more of what Scenario 2 involves, and we can do that.

One piece that I, I forget who it was who asked the question, it was about, like, the numbers. It's really hard to see very far because the kids haven't been born yet, especially with three-year-olds. A lot of those three-year-olds who would have an issue that we would be responsible for

and develop an IEP for, they're really little. The parents, they're just developing. It's sort of like it's very foggy, and I don't know that that will ever dramatically change. But I do think it's reasonable to conclude that if we have a facility

and if we have services on offer, people will access them now that aren't under the current CDS model. And that's work for us, but it's good for kids. So this is going to be maybe some questions and maybe just some thoughts from me as the other panel board rep with Malik. But I really struggle with a lot of this.

You mentioned that you have two good things. And I do see the equity piece, like Malik had mentioned. i also do feel a lot of just being honest kind of protection of my own um you know as a kind of foundation on that i have a second third grader at panel and they have more years at panel and uh

we really fall in love with the school and and the staff that's there and and then the situation but i i do i do also understand as i pull back of a district-wide perspective um i i would say that there's a couple kind of initial thoughts that come to my mind. One, beyond the CDS transition,

is there a reason that we have a rush for this? Is there a reason that we are trying to do this by, call it fall 27? Or is the CDS transition really our reason for that? I think others in the back row, feel free to speak up. I think that that's the biggest factor that gives us

a timeline. Will the world come to an end if we don't achieve that by fall of 2027? it won't um i do feel like i have to acknowledge we don't have a good solution for the three-year-olds and i don't think we will have a good solution for the three-year-olds without some kind of

1:50:21

reconfiguration so if we go past that fall of 2027 we'll have responsibility for three-year-olds and no really good way to do it sure that makes sense so can we do it i mean sure we can make a million things work, but we wouldn't, we wouldn't have a good way to do it. I think that's the honest

answer. So, yeah, in thinking about that, I know that I'm not the only one at Poundell that has that connection to the school, and I know that that's really, really strong and really pervasive in Poundell. So if this is something that we would end up going for, I think community input

would be, would be really necessary, and I think community buy-in would be honestly really hard. Not that I'm opposed to change, but just being honest with that, that is, if that's something that has kind of glossed over in your mind, it is not something that has glossed over in Powell's residents' minds.

So I also was, in just kind of thinking about a couple different scenarios, I know that Moore Street is potentially coming to the end of its life as a school. It's an old school, and so one of my questions is do we have the potential to, because we

need to maybe build a school there sometime in the future anyways, build what we want instead of adapting what we have for, you know, most of our early childhood is in Freeport, so do we have a potential of using that to reorganize that and make our childhood center

actually there, because we're most likely going to have to put some investment into that school sometimes soon. I guess I don't, I think another piece that we haven't really talked about today, which I think will inform kind of where we go, is the idea of the facility study. Like, what do we

have? What is its best use? What potential do we have at those places? I mean, there are some places where there is room, right? Like, we added the portable for Laugh and Learn at Mass Landing. mean there's there's space in Poundell there's space in Durham I would say the one place there is no space other than potentially adding like a level is that

the Moore Street school from when we've looked in the past like you could add maybe a second level of part of it like you can see it the oak the flat roof which I think we've been told could add maybe four classrooms right which is not

nothing I don't know if it would meet the need but I don't know what the answer to that is. Like, I don't know how close to the end of its life Moore Street is, or if it's at the point where it just needs a major overhaul. I don't know if there's space. I know it's really

tight on every angle at Moore Street to go out, so maybe you can go up. I can't answer that in, like, any kind of justifiable detail at the moment, but I can tell you what it makes me think as I hear the question. The first is, Moore Street is an older building.

It's still very functional. I think probably, I don't know how many years it has left. It's not collapsing, but it's not unsafe. It's not collapsing, but it's not new. So I think that question about at some point, at some point within an amount of time we can think about,

that building will probably either need to be renovated or replaced. I think that's legit to say. The other problem that that does not solve, though, is the inequity of Powell as a small school in the district with larger schools. And I have,

this is playing out in RSU 40, where I just left, where Friendship Village School has 65 kids, and it's a dearly beloved school in a charming, you know, arts and crafts building from 1910, I think or something like that and Moore Street isn't that old no and people love it and for good

reason it's just that it costs a lot per student and when you have class sizes at Moore Street and mass landing that are approaching the upper limits of the policy and you don't have the flexibility to do that in a smaller school it's an equity conversation and that's a hard conversation but

it that would not solve that problem yeah it's um i've struggled for a long time on what this district could or should look like um for a variety of reasons i love the panel school like i couldn't imagine closing the panel school um i what i really like about this and i'm sure

1:55:43

i'm eating these words someday like i actually appreciate this early childhood mandate coming because that's really forced us to think about things differently and really creates an amazing opportunity, I think, for that school.

That, you know, keeping a school under 100 or around 100 kids, it's, I don't know how long it's financially viable to maintain that model, but I love that this could really fully utilize that space in a way that seems like it aligns with what that building was originally meant as right um i think

about scenario three um and i think about how small the bathrooms are in the panel and i'm like i don't know some sixth graders are pretty big um i just like things like that right like it feels like, it feels like an elementary, a small, a small people school. I love this idea. But I totally

understand the emotional connection to it, Chris. And I never want it to come across that I don't respect and fully, fully empathize with that, right? For me, the, the timing piece, one, I don't like having to do things twice. I'm already thinking about, like, if we're looking at this for the

following year do we need to rethink what we're looking at for next year so we're not reduplicating efforts I don't even know if that's that's too far ahead of myself but you know if we know this is kind of a path we're going to go and we can work really hard to get some you know get that

buy-in and and really communicate the need and the benefits and acknowledge the real feelings about it I'd rather get it done sooner because those equity pieces that we're talking about all the way across don't get any better by waiting you know we

might be able to meet the need of three-year-olds sort of in an intermediate way to postpone for a year but it might be a little illustrative for me to talk about an experience I had not last year but the year before in RSU 3 which is very analogous to this so RSU 3 is interior Waldo County that's

where I was the principal of Mount View High School. And I don't know if any of you know where interior Waldo County is, but if you've been to the Common Ground Fair, you've been there. Okay, so it's that area. That district has 11 towns, and it's the second largest geographic district in the state.

It's a third the size of Rhode Island. Rhode Island is very small. Colin with words of truth, always. So, and the towns are, you know, it's Thorndike, Montville, Unity is the largest town. The big city. Monroe, Brooks, Liberty, Waldo, I'm missing some.

But it's very small towns. And the configuration of that district when I was there, which is not that long ago, is that there was a big, there still is, a big, brand new, beautiful building called The Complex. And it houses Mount View Elementary, Mount View Middle, and Mount View High School, all in one

big building. And that building has 1,100 kids in it, and all sharing one really big cafeteria. And trust me, the scheduling of anything really revolves around when kids are in the cafeteria in that building so that's where 1100 of the districts roughly 1400 kids go to

school the rest are in four little community schools that are elementary schools and that's Monroe elementary school Troy elementary school there's one in Brooks the name of it escapes me and Walker School in Liberty and what that

district came up against was they did a facility study, as I've proposed in the next year's budget, and the facility study looks very deeply at every school's plant, physical plant, and the state of the infrastructure there, and the number of students there, and it projects out, here's what

you'll need to do to maintain this building, and here's what it's costing your pupil in that building. And the simple math is just that the smaller schools spend a lot more money per building, which has value, and the district may decide that's a cost worth bearing for very legitimate reasons.

2:00:47

Where they came up against it is, in Walker especially, the boiler was about to go. And the question was, in this building that was built in 1903, it's a beautiful building right in downtown Liberty, do we replace the boiler now, or is that throwing good money after bad?

Because the rest of it, it's like an old car, eventually. So they had discussions about closing two of the four little schools because there was plenty more room in the complex for those kids to come. But that's a hard decision to make. And they did close two of those schools just this last year. They closed Walker School and Liberty. And they closed the school in Brooks, both of which had...

They just weren't sustainable. They were going. And now the Town of Liberty very well might decide to secede from the district. So these things are playing out across the state, and the reasons why people would want to keep their community small schools are totally valid.

They just come up against what it costs to do it. So to be very clear, we are not contemplating closing panel. We are contemplating repurposing panel, right? So it's very different in that, I appreciate the analogy, but it is quite different in the sense that there will still be a small school with a similar number of students.

Yeah, and it would be, you know, it would be Poundell's kids. Right, right. But the per-student cost would be very similar to what the per-student cost at Poundell is right now. Oh, I don't know that that's the case. We haven't studied that yet. course what the facility study would probably help us understand yeah so I

would appreciate I'd love to see kind of our thoughts on on just how different that cost is yeah and that'd be reflected in how the communities bear different cost I forgot what it's called exactly but cost sharing as well

because that's also part of the question yeah when it when it comes to this kind of costs I appreciate all the effort that's done into this it's really helpful especially the way that my brain works is trying to hold a more sustainable picture at the same time that

we're having the budget conversations that we're having so this has been really helpful to me to kind of hold some of those choice points I guess with more long-term vision and my perspective is like option to as well and think that we should investigate that and I say that

with also like respect and compassion for the feelings that would come with what that would mean for different different places and different schools but my reasoning for that is that I feel like if we keep the status quo we sort

of like hold on to these small beloved experiences and the inequities continue to grow across the schools um and it's going to the way that it ties to the budget for me is i think that that's what we've been experiencing these last two years is we're trying to make we're trying to hold on to these special experiences

and it comes at great cost um you have to like trade essentially you have to like have trade-offs um if you want to keep something exactly the way that it is on a small scale And so not only would we gain equity in the actual educational experience of all of our students, I kind of view it as it shifts the inequities to geographical travel, which is very different than inequities in educational experience.

uh all towns and all schools have some benefit and also are experiencing some inequity in the geography right so um even freeport which doesn't exist right now um and so i think it's it's a leveler playing field um with how the inequity exists um and how it gets spread out across the

district that's my two cents i also really like scenario too i think one of the things i get most excited about and thinking about it it sounds like a lot of people are here is um in the early childhood center and the fact that with if we did something like this we could actually think about

2:05:49

full day pre-k is huge for working parents um and game changer really um and also i think we keep talking about oh ever-changing world ai what's going to happen what better place to invest than an early childhood um because the sooner we get kids to school and we're talking about having an

outdoor environment for them play-based it just it really strikes a chord with me so uh i'm hearing general consensus for option two? Does anyone feel very strongly that they want more deep dive into option three? Lois. So I'm not sure if I understood the cost analysis yet. Did you say

that there hasn't been one done or? There hasn't been one yet. Okay. So I guess I am open to change. I'm good with that. Because I've thought that for years, that there needed to be something done differently. But I had never thought about Will's idea of putting sixth grade at panel.

And I'm curious if you even have a sense of what the changes in costs would be to bring all the necessary academic and specialists and everybody into panel, as opposed to bringing the special ed department and everybody in if it's a childhood center an early childhood center we haven't fleshed

that out um and that's part of we we don't necessarily want to invest all that time and energy and if it's something the board just doesn't even like the concept of so what i think i can tell you fairly is that just as we've talked about it and definitely more than on the back of

an envelope. We've had rich conversation about it, but not a lot of research into it yet. The sixth grade option doesn't feel as viable. It feels like a cool idea, but when you think about all of the things we need to do to make it actually work, it just doesn't feel as if it

works that well. Early childhood feels like it could work very well. Yeah, just one of the things that struck me as I was thinking about it is all the experiences, the extracurriculars, the clubs, The sports that the 6th graders currently engage in at the current schools would be, I think, far more difficult to recreate if you had 6th grade off by itself.

You know, it wouldn't be as easy for them to come over to FMS to join the after school club or, you know, it would just be an extra step. It would be a little more difficult. Yeah, I mean, having not looked at the numbers, kind of just sort of visualizing it in my head and what would be required, to your point, to run all of those things, because we'd still have to have special ed at the sixth grade, right? Like, there's still kids in sixth grade who need special ed services and, you know, and the specialists and, you know, unless there's a way to run the program in such a way that the teachers are incorporating art and music and all those things without having the, you know.

Right. I feel like that one, I like the cool idea of it, right? I was telling Tom, I listened to a podcast about, like, how sixth graders' brains are, like, crazy, and, you know, sitting in class is really hard, and, you know, outdoor time, and, you know, maybe throw them on a farm for a year is a

better idea, which I'm not saying Poundell is a farm. I know, they can grow things, we can sell it, would be great. Erica could cook it into the other schools. It'd be great. Nobody wants to eat that. You know, like, I like the idea of the experiential learning piece of it. I just think, you know,

when we look at the components we're trying to solve for, right, equity is one. I think it does create sort of a cool bringing together at that time. I don't think it solves for early childhood. And honestly, I don't think it's necessarily a benefit to that program in the financial stability.

You know, sort of looking at those three things we're trying to solve for it. I think it does one kind of well and in a really cool way, but maybe not the other two as well. So for me, it's two. Valerie? One thing I would like, I know that we most briefly mentioned that we were going to bring in Peter Wagner,

2:11:06

potentially, to look at community services and what they could do at Pownall. I also wonder if that would be incorporated more with, if we went with that model, we would also be transitioning those 6th graders back to MLS.

And current state is that extracurriculars are handled at the middle school for those people. And so those students would now need extracurricular offerings at mass landing, which many of them truncate at 5th grade. So we would need to think about what is age appropriate, extracurriculars offerings that would then be pushed back to our elementary education level for not just mass landing, but also the panel of students matriculating at DCS as well.

I know in Durham, the sixth graders can only participate, like sports, they can only participate if there's not enough seventh and eighth graders to make a team, so they can like fill the team. I don't know how that works at FMS. Is it the same? It's the same, but they do, quite a few sixth graders do participate. Do get to participate, yeah, okay. And there's numerous clubs and drama. I know that many of our sixth graders were in the drama production this year, so just a lot of things that we don't want to create a gap.

Exactly. Yeah, I think two things, just to Chris's earlier point about the fall 27 rush, think just as I was reflecting on that I think I think it does just go to it for me to the to the equity piece like if we if we're trying to achieve equity let's

try to achieve it as as we can just just on that I think that was where my enthusiasm was coming from I think also it's like if we're if we're truth-telling I'm realizing as we're talking about this that since I joined the board one

of the sort of the whisperings that happens sort of offline has been about whether or not the panel school will be able to be kept because of the cost per pupil question. And that has been in the community, and that has been something that has been talked about. Again, it's not something that we have talked about directly in this room, but it is something talked about. And I think what I'm experiencing, and maybe it's what's sort of balancing a little of my,

sort of balancing something a little bit in me, I'm like, I think I'm sort of thrilled at the idea that we could keep the Poundell School. It wouldn't be keeping the Poundell School as what it is, but it would be integrating that school and a lot of what makes it such an amazing school, integrating, we'll be able to maintain that and integrate that into the district. So I think there was like a little part of me that was like kind of like a sigh of relief. that, again, that sort of more whispered question

that goes to all of your sort of the small schools, that that shifts. So I think I'll just, again, own that, knowing that, again, that change would be really hard and we need to have really hard conversations with folks. And it's not just a rational question.

It's really thinking about the whole mix of it. But, again, I just think we really owe it. we owe it to our kids to look really seriously at that second option and as someone whose kids went all the way through from Durham and kindergarten up

through all the way through Freeport High School for one I can say that the Durham school is absolutely incredible the staff they have is there is incredible they would meld with the with you know that the panels staff and

kids and they wouldn't they would be changing it would be different but I don't think they would be losing they would you know they would be going to a great place it's it's not you know a step back right we're not we're not

bringing it down which I think is is huge and for me my my goal is is the same as Collins around the sooner we can get to the equity the better I love the dorm school i i have looked at the sort of disparities in the middle school not necessarily

from an educational perspective but more from an opportunity perspective and i was kind of sad for my kids that they didn't have some of those opportunities and mine are gone or through the middle school gears anyway so um so i would love for more kids to have those opportunities

um because they're incredible and and the sooner we can give that to them in my mind if we can do it in a thoughtful way that makes sense i am on board okay i feel that i have to just i have to thank the team back there because this i mean i'm the one delivering this proposal but this is

2:16:24

really coming about because some very very smart people who are very thoughtful have been thinking about this for a long time and this conversation was already somewhat framed by the time i got here and what i have found is that when it comes to both this proposal but also just the other side

of this which is just next year's budget that dovetails with this the amount of thought and consideration and pouring over data and considering every contingency that has happened on that team is staggering um so i just i i want to take a moment to really recognize that because you know

we we're talking about lots of very complex things and the board has really good great questions about all of them and um i'm you know more than happy to continue to come back with answers to those questions but i need you to know they things are being talked about and considered very thoughtfully

by the team back there, and they really know what they're doing. So, here we go. I feel like Lois has a question. Yes? Microphone. A loud voice, so I don't usually use a microphone. So, some of you know that I was a teacher at

Mass Landing School, and at Moore Street for a while, before we had Mass Landing, for 26 years. So, I need to just ask this question, perhaps of your team, perhaps of you, have staff been clued into this discussion at all okay thank you yes so that is I mean that is a

part of the buy-in process right it's not just community members it's also the staff and what does that look like and what supports do they need and you know okay so my hearing moving forward with more research and diet deep diving into

option two? Just on that, I think, again, it really would be helpful to, as much as is possible without undue labor, to, like, have that be against the benchmark of the, like, the not really status quo. Because I think that's, that's, I think, it's not that, like, I mean, option two has a lot going

for it just on its own, but it's also contextual within the other options. And I think particularly around cost. I think if we can get some of that and if that starts to look like, it seems like what it would look like, it seems, again, it just provides a lot more support for that. I think I have some

really good marching orders and I don't know what the next steps look like yet but we're going to have to huddle and think of that but I will bring you the thinking as it manifests over the next couple of months. Okay. All right. What'd you say? It dovetailed into the budget? Here you

go. 12A2, review of the superintendent's proposed budget. Is this you? Well, it's me, but I think that it's more discussion. So at this point, I don't have another presentation for you. I have shared the three tiers that you asked for. I've explained the reductions that you've seen are,

I do think this is an important framing. Those are the least, what we, that's not the royal we, that really is the we in the room, what we consider to be the least disruptive way to get to each level. So, and again, I think that theme that you saw in the last slideshow of tensions and

trade-offs, they're all choices that are a trade-off. And our intention has been to look at entire situation holistically and think about what is most important to preserve and where we where we keep the best so I think that's the framing that that is

2:21:26

most important for me to stress to you and now is the time for me to try to answer questions or give you the opportunity to discuss I think we do have some new information from what we had last time see Kelly getting up so I

just want to mention that the packets included with in your purple folders and that are out for the public and are also posted on the website there was there's a couple of updates one of which is that we got informed by region 10 they're

still in their budget process but their Finance Committee moved forward with presenting a proposal to the full board on February 23rd which involves a 9.63 three percent increase in our annual assessment from region 10 so on page six

in your packet young the fourth item down says CTE region 10 that had previously said zero because we didn't know and we had just built it in as a flat rate so we've added twenty nine thousand six hundred thirty seven dollars

for the region 10 contribution and then if you look over to page 7 that ultimately puts us year-over-year up 2 million nine hundred one thousand five hundred and twelve dollars which represents a 6.53 percent year-over-year

expenditure increase the other place that you will see that is on page 8 I have updated article 3 because that is where we actually have appropriate the funds for region 10 and then it and then it updated the bottom line there and

then the other important piece that's in your packet this time because we did get the ed 279 and we had talked about it the last meeting but I hadn't had a chance to touch base with the superintendent and the team about that the first round of proposed tax impact is in your packet it is based off of the

superintendents recommended tier two it's not like we see what tier one looks like and we see a tier three well what's in your packet is representative of the reductions which are included in tier one and tier two because that's what the

superintendent was recommending so just some we can kind of walk through it a little bit the year-over-year number which we just talked about represent is that six point five three percent again that's just expenses year over year the

total and then we start kind of going down through the shared revenues there are a few changes there because we've joined cohort 3 we will no longer be including some of the expenses within the budget but we are will also not be

billing CDS for the services that we are currently providing to these four-year olds right now the model is a portion of the the staff members time that is actually attributed to the CDS four-year-olds that we're serving within our pre-k program currently we can turn around and submit for reimbursement

through a billing option and so that previously we've been collecting about seventy nine thousand dollars a year and that we will not be billing for that because again the model is is quote-unquote fully funded and we that

money is going to operate outside of the budget now the other the other change is we used to budget for half of an employee that we supposedly shared with the town of Freeport we were doing this when I was here before the position never

got filled so I took the expense out and I took the revenue out so they're a net zero, but why continue to put an expense in and a revenue in for something that hasn't come to fruition in 15 years? So that has been removed. But so with that said, if we just kind of go back up to the shared revenues, they're down about $159,000, $160,000 based upon those two items.

The shared state aid, that is the portion of subsidy that we get for belonging to GSEA, the greatest Obago Education Alliance and then if you go down to that next box there where we have Durham Freeport and Poundell that's the amount of subsidy

that each community is actually in fact receiving through the ED 279 so if you take the total increase of eight hundred fifteen thousand five hundred thirteen dollars and you net a slight reduction of six hundred dollars for the the

regional service center contribution that's you'll see that's the amount that our subsidy went up so about 814 a little over eight about 815 thousand but with that said we all know that and or you have to give money in order to get

2:26:36

money according to the 8279 so there is a local required contribution and that is based upon valuation and the mill rate set by the state the state and so that you can see the math there regarding each community that's up about

three hundred and fifty three thousand two dollars or three dollars so if we take the total operating expenses subtract out any shared revenues any state aid the amount that Durham keeps for their local portion of the debt for

the Durham Community School, and the amount of local required contribution in order to get the subsidy, that leaves you line E, which is that $17 million number. That's the additional local monies that actually get pushed through the cost-sharing formula, which was set forth in

our agreement. And that breakdown is just below that, where it says additional local monies required. It multiplies the amount. It takes that 17 million, multiplies it by the percentage applicable to each town to actually get what the additional local monies required are. With all of

that said, if you turn to page 10, it then summarizes it by community to arrive at what the taxable, the tax impact is to each community. So the model actually here, it does show, it takes Your state valuation shows you the mill rate in order to get your required local amount

that we saw on the previous page, and then it adds in the additional local monies that were required, which is using that formula of cost sharing. For Durham, it adds the local debt in because as part of that regional agreement, they agreed

to keep that debt, which should be retiring in a couple years, by the way, and then the amount of state aid so if you take the the total derm is responsible for is that 13 million 744 but if you remove the amount of state aid because that's

actually the revenue portion the taxable evaluation the taxable amount to Durham brings you to seven point seven five two seven eighty eight I'm not going to explain it all for Freeport again but Freeport I will just read it out loud it

brings Freeport to $25,646,259, and it brings Powell to $4,448,225. We'll just move out to the next column. The difference is the amount of taxation last year compared to the amount of taxation needed this year. And then the line below the difference column that you see for each community, I reached

out to each town to get their mill rates for the 25-26 year because as we all know taxes are set as of April 1 of the valuations are set as of April 1 of each year and those are set by the communities themselves and then the assessments for taxes are actually done by each community

we to the individual taxpayers we tax the town when we when you guys in June when the the budget gets approved, you sign tax assessment warrants, and what we're doing is we're turning those over to the treasurer of the communities, and they are then adding that in to your total

tax bill. There's three components to your tax bill, the education component, the county component, and your municipal component. So we only, when we are looking at these numbers, while I'm looking at the total mill rate and total valuation, what we need to remember is that for Durham,

it's $1.69 on last year's mill rate, and that represents about a 5.4% increase for the education portion of the tax bill only. There will also still be community taxes that the towns will have to consider and any municipal increases that the towns are considering on their own.

So just to run down through there, for Durham, it's about 5.4% increase on taxation. For 3.04. I'm sorry? 5.04. 5.04, sorry. Every guess what point counts? 3.51. And then for panel, it's 5.27. And again, these are all based upon all of the recommended reductions in Level 1 and Level 2

that the superintendent is proposing to the board. So those are the ads that I have, and with that, unless there are questions about this, I will go sit back down, because I know there's other presentations. Questions for Kelly? Thank you. Oh, Chris. Oh, sorry. So just to wrap my head around it, the percentage numbers for the towns are lower than the total 6.53.

2:31:58

That's because the state... It's because we're looking at it relative to your mill rate, which is everything. assessed valuation yeah and that includes your municipal budget and your county budget so the we're saying our school budget expenditure to expenditure is six

point five three right but when we roll that through with the that's because our state our state allocation went up right well that's part of it but it could also be even if our state subsidy didn't go up the percentage could be less or

more based on the valuation the state gives us and how much we have to raise with the required state mill rate. And then because we're comparing the increase needed to cover the educational portion of your tax increase, but the denominator, yes, is your total tax rate,

inclusive of your whole tax bill, not just the education piece. How did I do? Did great. I had a question. No, I forgot what it was. Oh, I remember. We sort of flew through the shared revenue piece. The undesignated fund balance usage is a very specific number.

I assume that's made up of components. So the undesignated fund balance piece is reflective of step, I would say, phase two of the vehicle and energy audit replacement plan that the board discussed last year. we had talked about utilizing undesignated fund balance

to incrementally step into kind of a leveled amount of taxation impact. And so we typically carry about $900,000 running through there. And so this year, part of that plan, because prices came in on the energy audit a little lower than what we needed,

than what we had anticipated the amount the additional two hundred and nineteen thousand nine seventy eight represents phase two of that incremental step in to the vehicle replace vehicle and equipment replacement plan and the energy

audit that we're working on thank you and just for newer members of the board what that undesignated fund balance represents is essentially the savings account that we have over the years when we we make estimates right on what it's going to cost

for teachers and staff and and supplies and i mean obviously the teachers and the staff are we're pretty locked in on because we know we have a contract but we could have someone who leaves at the top of the scale and replace them with someone who is fresh out of college so there might be

savings there or vice versa um so you know what actually comes in terms of you know expenditures we can't we can't pay out more than we approve in the prior year but if it comes in that there you know we didn't spend everything we allocated it essentially rolls into that undesignated fund balance so sort of tax dollars we

have collected but not needed to spend in that year and that's over you know the whole life of the RSU that those are built and then so this undesignated fund balance basically allows us to offset some of the so we don't have to collect

every dollar of the 47, 269, 441 we're hoping to spend next year, we're saying, well, we're going to, we're going to use a million dollars that we've already collected from the taxpayers to bring down how much we need to collect. Makes sense. Lewis, like a minimum? So, so it's, uh, it,

it varies. Uh, it's depended year to year. Like in COVID years, it went way up because we got funds in from the state um the state actually sets a maximum that they'd like you to keep like they won't they don't want you to keep more than five percent of your again nine again

the legislator moved it back to nine and it's actually over a three-year period so the the average is it's nine percent over three years so if so say if you're above the the nine percent threshold but you actually have a plan for use which is what we're doing here

or in the past two years we've also added to the capital reserve capital reserve accounts with the undesignated plus we established article reserves with the undesignated accounts those actually are like planned uses of it so

2:37:06

would reduce that percent because right right now your audit like we audit on June 30 right which by the way we should be getting that next week I'm so excited about that for last year so we can actually get our definite number but

basically when as part of that audit process they will ultimately land at a number but one of the questions that the auditor asks me is what have you committed right and because we've committed in this this year to use that

1 million 88 so that subtracts out of that overall savings account that i have and then anything that i um the board voted to utilize for article reserves or capital verse reserves those are also considered committed and so those would come out and then they assess whether or not

you're under or over that nine percent threshold so it's varied over time it was as low as three percent during COVID people I mean people weren't spending money because they were afraid of what was going to happen and then we were getting funds so it was way up so they bumped it up to nine percent they brought it back down to five percent apparently they're back up to nine percent again

they were proposing to come back down but they didn't they didn't like because it was a phase down approach okay um but they did not phase down to that they let they changed it so as a board we haven't we haven't had a target number as the Finance Committee to say like we

think we should keep this much in there I think Kelly has done a great time great job in her previous time and her current time back here in the district helping us be thoughtful in the use of undesignated fund balance right we don't

want to you know bring it all the way down we try not to use there's kind of a chunk that rolls through each year because we don't want to run up against not being able to pay everything we want to pay during the year that we've we've

thought if things come in a little bit more expensive so we want to make sure that we're collecting enough so there's always a little bit more and we try to put that back through through this undesignated fund balance right but we

don't want to spend sort of rainy day savings on ongoing operational things right like we might move it into the capital reserve to say like you know if something if a roof goes or a septic system perhaps somewhere we would have

funds allocated for that and we might access that for you know one-time use as opposed to using it to fund operational like positions etc into the future which are ongoing uses with a one-time funding source because then we

just create, as Kelly would call it, a financial cliff. And the other thing which you'll hear about at the next meeting is our, instead of building a contingency within the budget itself for those kind of emergencies, what we've done as a district is create the capital reserve. So we have a true

capital reserve. We have a tennis court reserve. We have a track and field reserve account. We have fuel reserve account which we have not touched since its establishment but then we also created what we called article reserves and it was a way to be prepared

for emergency situations and have authority to spend money with board approval but not tax taxpayers for it and a perfect example of this is special education student moves in that requires a service a speech language service or

and our our specialists are at capacity we could potentially use that money to either one hire staff with board approval or to to use a contracted service provider to get us by for until the next budget year so what we've kind

of done as a board or the work kind of agreed to when I proposed the article reserves, is that they're kind of a one-time funding source for emergencies. So if the emergency still exists come the next budget cycle, we would then add that position into the budget. It also

helps us address those kind of like one-year fluctuations where sometimes you might need a grade four teacher, but we can't loop somebody up because now grade three, you know, the grade three is big, the grade, you know, three moving to four is big, but two moving to three is big, so you need

keep that teacher it allows us to address that but then you know that the smaller class coming up might potentially be a little lower and you could like it just helps us budget better and not tax for kind of one year only positions or and if it if it's tried and true and it's gonna stay then

we're gonna commit to putting it in the budget it's using our savings account for that do you remember your comment sorry yeah but i guess one point to bring up is so do we have sort of a policy for how much we decide to take from undesignated funds to offset our taxation

2:42:24

i'm sure it just depends on how much we have in there and what we have sort of to use it on in other areas but so the largest part of the one thing i will say is no we don't have a policy, so regarding that, but what I will say, and I'll get on my financial

close soapbox that Michelle's talking about, is the majority of our budget, right, are staff and personnel, and they're going to, the need is typically going to continue for those staff and personnel, so if you are quote-unquote buying down the tax rate by utilizing your undesignated fund

balance, and you do that in one year, and you don't add back to that savings account, you don't necessarily have it the next year to use. So you then create a financial cliff, right, where you don't have the revenue, so it automatically has to go to taxation. And I think one of the things

we've learned as a board is our annual rollover number for our staff is the largest driver of our annual increases. Rightfully so, we need to pay our employees, we need to pay them well, because we expect high quality employees, and that's what we aim to hire. But as a result of doing that,

that is the largest driver of your budget. And so I often advise against utilizing undesignated fund balance to pay for salaries that are going to then be needed again. So like I said, the typical number is that $900,000, Kelly, that was rolling through.

That increased over the time that I left, but that's where it was when I got back. But now what we've been doing is we've saved relatively flat with that because we feel like we can support that number. But the uses that we're now moving forward with are to level off for,

so for the energy audit, for example, and the vehicle and equipment replacement, the energy audit is a 17-year lease, but much like we did when we took on the debt service for the renovation of the high school, we used undesignated fund balance over a four-year period to actually incrementally push it on to the taxpayers.

So it was $1 million, right? And instead of saying in one year we need to raise $1 million because we're adding this debt service on, the first year I used $750 in the savings account and put $250 on the taxpayer. The next year we used $500, and then it was $500 on the taxpayer,

and then we went to $250, $750 was in the taxes, and then we used done, and then there was a million. So it's that way to not spike your budget for expenditures, which is exactly why we used it for the vehicle and equipment replacement and the energy audit, so that we could get those done without spikes in taxation to help with the inflationary environment we're in, but yet not create any sort of cliff.

I have a question that connects the talk of this budget year to Tom's earlier presentation where you mentioned a secondary consideration, financial sustainability in an inflationary environment. And I'm wondering if you could just talk more about what an inflationary environment means

if you're talking about more than just inflation. Does it mean more than that? To me, it means, at the surface level, what we're paying for the things we buy, literally, whether it's oil, curriculum, materials, whatever.

But it's also, to return to Kelly's main point, it's to keep our salaries competitive, living in an area where, A, our people deserve to be paid well, and also, if they're not, they'll go down the road where they will be paid well.

And that's just a fact that we live with. It's driving up the cost of living for everybody, means that we have to make sure our employees employees have a wage that they deserve just just because as Kaya mentioned we have the information now

from of what the are the region 10 Finance Committee is proposing to bring to the full region 10 board I just wanted to kind of provide a little a few notes on that I'm on the finance committee for region 10 and I think a

couple of things first just to note that that region 10 is facing the same inflationary environment that we are also some of the increase that we see here is due to the fact that it's due to the contracts that we have signed

2:47:41

because region 10 averages the three sending districts in terms of their in terms of their salaries so we are the decisions we make in terms of our employees impact that number I also just wanted to provide a few details on what

like Tom you did for us Director Superintendent Shabbat gave the Finance Committee three three budgets to serve to look at and including the impact of that. The sort of the least change at Region 10 was going to result north of a 14.75 increase,

and that was only with the reduction of a 1.5 edtech and a 0.5 EMT teacher. So that would have, was that was that was the the least impact to educational environment the greatest impact in terms of the percentages the scenario that we ended

up recommending adds adds a number of cuts to that I just want to sort of like again just to be clear that we that this is as we are doing here they are doing there I'm in terms of really looking hard at this and I really want to applaud

director superintendent shabbat and his team for like really looking hard at this so there's you know we would be if we move forward with this it would be cutting tuition for teacher support teacher PD admin PD software advertising

so we cannot be advertising the same as we would general supplies instructional supplies and books and periodicals so just again just to make clear that the what we're balancing and also just in transparency the the the least impacted taxation would have been a third that would have required the

cutting of the JMG program there and I will just own that that was a that was a bridge too far for me I wasn't comfortable at all with that in addition they would be cutting all of their field trips and also student assessment so

again that was just so again I just wanted to show those details to say that yes where I think that percentage is a little higher than we perhaps as a board will be but I have been looking for on the RSC 5 side just to explain where

that's coming from and again that hasn't been approved that is what we're going to be presenting and I always like to point out particularly as it relates to the region 10 side and how their funding works right so in our budget we have a

line item of about 300 or 330 now is what's proposed so that it it's not insignificant but so it's we're only paying that 9% increase on our contribution to to region 10 so that's about $29,000 that's the increase for for all the students that are attending region 10 the state funds the CTEs

directly similar to how we get subsidy they get direct funds from from the state and then if the programs that they're running have a cost it's very similar to how we have you know shared additional local monies in our budget if they have

additional local monies in theirs that gets split up between the three sending districts based on the number of students each district sends as a percentage of the whole so we used to send far more money to to region 10 but

we also got more money from the state for those kids now they send it directly to region 10 and we just fund sort of that Delta yeah just also on that just for context the proposed the foot the total proposed budget for region 10 with

the scenario would be 4.7 million in comparison with our more than that times 10 my thing other questions did we have other information requests from you that you had there were some information requests at the end of the last meeting

and I I can there are a few things I want to create further context around that are important just in the whole scheme of things one was about you had a presentation from Pam and Bill about the middle school schedule and the new concept for that and then there's

2:52:45

there are naturally questions about that so we're prepared to talk in a little more detail about that obviously what's difficult there are a number of things that are difficult to think about but the So what it does for world language is particularly difficult.

So I think an angle that we haven't discussed this from yet, it's an overall lens, is that Freeport Middle School does something that I don't know of another middle school that does, which is that it offers STEM as a core class. When you offer STEM as a core class, and that's wonderful, and one of the lessons that the team learned,

I mean, I wasn't here, but from last year's discussion is that STEM is very important there. So from the get-go, the assumption was that should be preserved. But when you consider, we've been talking about money, but actually what I would say the greatest resource in schools is time,

educational minutes, minutes in the day. When you add in an additional core class into a school day that has a finite number of minutes, It means that the other side of that, which is the Unified Arts classes, the specials,

there's less time to divvy up among those. And so that's a constraint that figures into the entire picture. So that is part of why it's hard to figure a way to provide world language to every kid with two choices of world language.

Some of the data that we can talk about more fully is that, and Pam and Bill can probably do this, well, can definitely do it more granularly than I can, but we've taken a look at, under the existing model, how many of our kids are getting a world language at all.

And there's a substantial number of our kids who, as we currently have this set up, aren't getting any world language at all until they get to high school. While the proposal that's on the table to consolidate with just Spanish looks like a retraction,

it in fact gets more kids to have world language by the time they get to high school, by a lot. It's like the difference between roughly 60% and roughly 90% of kids getting to high school with some exposure to world language.

And then, you know, I wasn't in a position to sort of say this last week because I hadn't given this week's presentation, but if we now look ahead to the possibility of consolidated middle schools, that means bringing Spanish from Durham into a consolidated middle school

and having double the number of Spanish teachers there, which really means it could be much more robust. So there were just some aspects of that that had not fully come out last week. I see Valerie your hand is up sorry yeah about the Spanish teacher I just had a

question about students for whom I know we have a few that Spanish is actually their first language do we have a plan for those students haven't thought of that angle yet that's a good point we did I also did a look today at there was

a question about, I think it was your question, Colin, about the impact of kids in the high school and how it would impact kids going forward to the high school. So what I found, and I do have, I could open the laptop and give you the numbers, but most, by far, the most kids who take either

French or Spanish at Freeport Middle School, I don't have this data for Durham yet, but we're talking about Freeport Middle School, most of them do not go on to level two in ninth grade in either of those languages. Actually, what the data shows is that the greatest block of kids goes to Latin

in ninth grade, and the next greatest block goes to year one in the language that they took. And then there's literally, I think, one kid per year who crosses over and decides, nope, I'm taking Spanish now, or I'm taking French now, it makes a switch. That data does not suggest that making

the change we've proposed would dramatically harm a French program at the high school. There's some more details about the, I don't know if you want to come on down, Pam and Bill, but there are, there was, there had been thought already given to how to make a plan work for

2:58:01

Spanish next year based on the level of staffing we have for Spanish, which is a 0.6 position that a point that has been considered just didn't get talked about last week. Yeah I mean well said Tommy you kind of covered speaking a little bit about the data on the program at the middle school

and the high school. We do have just the 0.6 position. The 0.6 Spanish works with us being really mindful on constraints and being creative with the time. For example relieving additional instructional and teacher responsibilities for that 0.6 educator taking away things like BCS

responsibilities advisories or duties with this model the point six foreign language teacher although we recognize it's gonna impact seventh grade because they will not be able to access a foreign language it will be a little more

robust for those eighth graders just saying it would be really ideal if we could make that point six a full-time educator because then we'd be able to offer that in the seventh grade so just some food for thought for that and so

So what I always come back to, I probably sound like a broken record. I just want to emphasize, I don't think anybody here, certainly not me, feels that world language is unimportant. If the overall context were different, this is not something we'd even be putting on the table.

But when we looked at how do we get to the 8%, 7%, and 6% tier that the board has asked for, our conversation was in each case what's the least painful way overall to get to that level and so that reduction feels like one we can manage in that way right and i certainly don't want to

come across um that we're sliding with the french program in any capacity so i just want to say that as well i would love to see us have world language all the way down to pre-k um we're not i not everybody agrees with me but um that's just that's a personal thing we're just not there

another area well i don't know any more questions for pam before i go on with the other questions that responding to questions from last week i just wanted to make sure i heard you right so if we have a full-time spanish teacher then seventh and eighth grade could all get spanish yeah we could

offer like an introduction to spanish at the seventh grade level and then build upon that in more robust for eighth grade. And then when they have the option to high school, I mean, certainly they can pick the French to Spanish or the Latin, but then they have that strong skill

set. Do you, do you remember off the top of your head, Pam, or do you have it in front of you? What was the number of kids now who are getting a world language at all? We have combined right now 55% of the kids getting a foreign language at Preport Middle School. And what would it be

if we made the change that we proposed? We could, I would say, just throwing an estimated number out there, probably like 85%, and I say that because what could be driven with some kids not taking a foreign language might be IEP accommodations,

so that would make that number down a little bit in different interventions. So that's why I wouldn't say the 100% because there would be some circumstances that the percentage would certainly go up. Yeah, I guess I am intrigued about the idea of bumping that back up to one full-time employee.

And I'd like to see what that would do to our budget impact. And add it to the list. Kara. Well, I guess I'm curious how, so right now we have 1.6 between French and Spanish. And we're wanting to make a reduction somewhere. Is there, would there be any, what would it look like to have 0.5 French and 0.5 Spanish?

Oh, we haven't, we could, we could talk about that. We'd have to come back to you about what that would look like budgetarily, but also what it would look like logistically in the schedule. Right. I just also want to name that, I did a little math, 33% of K through 8 students are at Durham, and there is no French at Durham. Right. So I just want to name that as well.

one thing i as i've sat with that for what 30 seconds cara is it's hard to hire a half-time person and there are people out there who are certified in both spanish and french actually are i know that the french teacher at the high school is one of them i don't know if the french

3:03:03

teacher at the middle school is one but those people are kind of like unicorns um they're really otherwise you're looking for a half time of each and that's hard to find colin um yeah i mean And I think just on this point, again, knowing all of the pressures

and appreciating all of the work that you and Bill have done, particularly Pam, I think I'll just own that I think the reduction of the World Languages Program is the aspect of the budget of the proposal that I just have the hardest time sitting with.

And I'll own that that is not completely from that earlier rational self that I was referencing. But I don't know. I think I don't really have much more to say about that right now. I think the idea that increasing to a full-time for Spanish would allow for languages to be introduced in the seventh grade,

I think that would be much better. I would, I think I'd just say personally that the only language in the eighth grade just doesn't, doesn't sit well with me personally. And that's no, again, that's no disrespect to the complexity of everything that you all were doing. It's just that, again, for whatever that is worth, that's just the piece I can't quite get with.

This is probably an obvious no, based on the discussion we had last year, but, you know, to Tom's point about the STEM piece, I mean, is that something that's not even on the table for discussion that we would consider? So, you know, I just want to keep bringing it back to the, that's a whole, it's a whole other thing. I mean, that's essentially what creates this choice, right?

And another aspect of it, too, I was talking with a member of our team this morning or yesterday, and I won't put that person's name on the table, but there's also the issue of equity across the grade span, and even with the reductions that are proposed, the middle school will have lower class sizes than the elementary schools do.

and when you have a hundred kids per grade and six specials and that means you end up with you know pe classes with 13 kids in them and that's very different when you go to the elementary schools so that that's this i have to keep panning out to that big lens um another area i don't

unless we want to talk about world language some more that there is rich discussion around is for ESOL, and that's a tough one, too. The numbers aren't tough. We have looked at, for example, what a schedule would look like with two teachers, which is what I've proposed. It's a very workable

schedule based on the numbers that we have. We would be well within the guidance that's supplied by the DOE if we were at that level. There actually is no statute that says what the level has to be, either a state or federal statute, it's guidance from the DOE,

and what I have worked with in previous districts where I oversaw ESOL was similar configuration with multiple school buildings, a relatively low number of students who are identified as ML based on the overall district population. We really need an itinerant model because our people need to be able to go where the kids are,

And right now the kids are in the high school, the middle school, Moore Street, and mass landing. And the building-based model with three people is doing wonderful things, but it is more than we need in that area. And if I just pan back to, again, the big lens of everything else that we're trying to trade off

to get to a difficult place, that's where I have to make the recommendation to look at. So some of the, we've gotten a variety of emails to the board. The way I read some of them is that we would not be compliant. But what I hear you saying is that's not the case. I would respectfully disagree with that statement. Okay.

3:08:20

I'm going to go back just, I have a lingering thought that's rattling around, around world language that I just want to say, I think that this is like a perfect micro example of what we're talking about in option two. We're going to, we're having to make a decision where we're losing something that feels really good and really robust and like really good to some students. And we're doing it in service of a decision that feels more equitable to the district as a whole. And so I think it's important to just name that. Right. And like, and we're talking about it happening because of another inequity, which is STEM, which Durham also doesn't have.

And so I think it's just important to name that. It's like these types of decisions hurt because they mean you don't get all of the things that you love and used to have in order to move towards something that's more equitable for everyone.

So I just want to say that. But also going back to that, when you were talking about STEM and how there's six different things in UA, I know that there was a lot of discussion at the middle school level about the schedule.

was that a piece that seemed like that needed to change in terms of the amount of offerings in United Arts, whether it's STEM or something else, like consolidating some of them or switching it around? I mean, that wasn't really brought to us. I don't think so. Pam, do you? Because I think

STEM is usually a special, right? It's usually, right. Well, in most places, it's a special along with music. Like in Durham, it's a special. It's not a core class. It's there, but not to the same degree. Right, so there is STEM, but it's like, you know, the frequency of music or library or

media, I guess, in the middle school. If I try to turn on my long-term lens, long-term not meaning 10 years from now, meaning two or three years from now, I actually am really excited about the possibility of, in a consolidated district middle school, having a robust CTE program, and STEM is

really part of that I think we have a lot of opportunity to be able to to build on that vision so I think having this is just me personally maybe others would agree or not but that if we can bring all kids into that and build on it from there that that's a fantastic starting place so I think a

little while ago you mentioned that you wanted to consider in the future sometime embedding CTE at the middle school, I hear you say that, with an embedded CTE teacher. Can you tell me if there are other districts around that do that? Yes. Is it within Region 10? No, I've actually talked to

Sean Shabbat at Region 10 about this idea. It's entirely viable. They would supply the teacher, and just so that we know what CTE means, because I don't want to presume everybody does, It's career and technical education. It's both, you know, kind of like hands-on career technical skills

that you might get in a makerspace, and it's also often networking with community businesses and community artisans to bring them into the school to share their craft with kids. A place where I have seen that done, it's just down the road from where I live in St. George, And that little school there has won national awards for their CTE program.

And it's from age three through grade eight. And I have a plan to actually bring a team from our board members and administrators out to visit that school to see it. Because they've also done early childhood there. They have the three-year-olds and four-year-olds in full-day program. They were part of cohort one, I think. And they've done a fantastic job. it would be really worth us looking at.

Yeah. Yeah, I forgot about that part. When I saw that, I thought that was very interesting. Anna? I feel like I'm asking so many questions this meeting. What's happening? Is going back to ESOL, can we see some outline of what those numbers look like

with the reductions proposed? Yeah, actually, Erica has them. Good evening, Erica Maceo, Assistant Superintendent. So, yeah, I think there were two sorts of requests, a proposed schedule and then some comparisons. Yep. Which would you like first? Let's hit the schedule.

3:13:28

Yeah. I might want to movement break. I'm going to make this bigger at the top, and then I'll scroll down. Check out. Okay. All right. So you see a total count there in bold on column B at 43. I just want to call out that there is a student in the original count that I gave you last week

who's not receiving services. So what, out of choice, what we, what has been calculated here is our current caseload that is being served and how we could operationalize with two staff members in our current caseload. So it's not speculating into next year as to like what our

head, you know, our caseload might be or what their levels are, where they fall grade level or all of those things just kind of doing running the scenario with the head count that we have right now um service uh in multilingual programs so at at moore street school 13 kiddos mass landing

12 the middle school freeport middle school 4 and then freeport high school 14 right so if we had two teachers we got teacher 1.0 and teacher 1.0 and column g over there we've got them roughly on an a.m. and a p.m. schedule with roughly two groups at each each side of their

day the duration that they sit with those groups can be elongated according to needs and those needs the service needs are dictated by the level where the student the level of achievement the student has demonstrated on their most

recent WIDA assessment which is the assessment we use we are we are required to apply annually for multilingual learners so we gain a composite level and then we place our service like our service design accordingly there are

other considerations taken in to to designing that we're like what are the other services that the student has what is the least restrictive way to provide those services what makes the sense best sense in their day so if we were to

just put together pre-k and k kiddos for a quantity of six total students and then another group first and second grade seven those are very reasonable group sizes very reasonable group sizes and then in the p.m. side that same

person could travel over to mass landing school and provide two groups services to two groups of six and just to say that those groups could be depending on score grade level other cohort criteria like just depends on what we what we you know where the needs land

so then kind of similarly for that other 2.0 or sorry other 1.0 individual we would have like an am schedule that actually has space for flexibility to service any needs that come up over the course of the year or perhaps land in a different building that isn't already articulated on

this schedule. And then we have a PM schedule as well, potentially at the high school. Keeping in mind that all of these blocks are movable, this is just like a simple way of explaining. So the high school could potentially be in the morning, in the middle school, in the afternoon, but we would work with their schedules to, you know, provide least disruptive services

that are meeting the state's requirements, which are outlined in this brief, like, little infographic. Kids who fall in levels one to three was being considered. We had to see how that would play out. And so, yeah, we did that work based on this year's numbers.

And it's not all one-to-one. No. They can be grouped. Absolutely. It's probably better. And I just, before, I don't want to not pause and recognize, there's been a mountain of work done coming into this year by this team.

3:18:31

We worked, as you may recall, on, like, the LOW plan, the ILAPS, the materials, the, you know, I'm just, like, just making a list, you know, all of the translation, interpretation, the identification sort of firming up. Like, there was so much work done coming into this year.

I'd say we're even better positioned at this point to ensure that the services are sustainable with this number of staff servicing our needs. How does this change? I know that, you know, we have 43 total students, but the actual total number of students in the blocks is more than that, right? Because some students are in more than one block. Yeah, so a block isn't necessarily an hour. It's just so if we think about how many hours a staff member typically works in direct instruction,

it's kind of hard to draw it all out, but like an a.m. period and a p.m. period. So this would be enough time to do like the two-block scenario or the one-block scenario. And, again, it's not directly equivalent to an hour necessarily.

I appreciate this work. And I also, I think this group, more than any other group, especially with the lack of influx of new students for a variety of reasons, are really kind of working toward their own obsolescence in a way that the rest of the teachers aren't. And I think the achievement that they've done in lessening the students who have a lot of need is remarkable and worth louding and I really I think one of the reasons that I think we're so reticent and sad that this cut may be necessary is that this hard work is kind of their undoing and I think that's why we're all so broken up about it in the realm of intervention

work we're always trying to work ourselves out of a job we're hoping that the needs become smaller and smaller fewer and fewer the yeah our staff have done a tremendous job serve serving students in this area of need and it evidence over the years is that more and

more of our students if we look at this kind of pathway and the DOE document more and more of our students are in the green and blue zone than in the red and orange zone um and we continue to like move kids along um towards exit which is that composite 4.5

score that we're shooting for so it is indeed the case that we're we're we own the reduced need and then i think there was also a request for comparison would you like me to share that um So I will, I was able to toss out a survey statewide, so I was also able to capture some

of our traditional comparison districts that we have in our group. There are a list of them. There are seven total in that group. I was able to gather feedback from four of those seven, so you're going to see that in the data, as well as some other statewide schools. The data are anonymized because of the sensitive nature of this cohort, these service areas.

So for all the districts who responded, you can see the cohort ones at the top, A, B, C, D, that's just letters instead of numbers. And RSU-5 is us, so we've got RSU-5 pulled out. And then you can see all the other responding districts down below our RSU-5 bar.

So this is the multilingual population and the number of full-time equivalent English as an other language staff member, right? So this is the comparison that I was able to gather. Oh, sorry. I can go. Is it okay to move on? Are we good? Next, the ESOL staff and then any additional considerations with ed tech staff positions, FTE, in those comparisons.

3:24:08

This is multilingual students per staff member. Teacher, because teachers, ed techs cannot provide the direct service requirement. They can do additional support. This is current, yes. It's everybody's current. It's worth noting that other districts are up against similar challenges.

The qualitative feedback is not coming through in these data because it's equally challenging for other districts. Just this way of looking at things. Happy to answer any questions you have. So there's a district that has 52 to 1?

I mean, to Tom's point, there isn't necessarily a standard for the ratio. I get that. One teacher for 52 kids? We don't want to be there. No. No, we don't want to. I think the recommendation would be what are our typical class sizes

and knowing that this is a high-needs, you know, group, so, like, what does that mean in terms of reasonable service? But we don't have that specific guidance from the state. Other questions on the ESOL? Any other questions that we had hoped to get answers to tonight?

There was one other sort of grouping of questions for me around, at Tier 2, what the impact of the reductions of the ed techs would be, because most of the reductions at Tier 2 are general ed ed techs. So I wanted to share a little bit more about the reasoning of those.

And it also dovetails with another angle, which is looking at administration as an area for potential reduction. So we have looked at, I didn't recommend any reductions in administration. We did talk about them. We did look at them. At the central office level, RSU-5 is actually pretty dramatically understaffed compared to most other districts

in terms of the amount of clerical support that there is and also the number of administrative positions. A good example is Brunswick has a chief academic officer in addition to an assistant superintendent. The reason these two topics come together, and they came together when we discussed them,

is that the general ed ed techs, I can't pretend we wouldn't feel an impact from losing those positions. It's an impact that, given every other possibility that we tossed around, seemed like the most manageable to get to the Tier 2. And the reason it's the most manageable is that we recently added assistant principals

It's more street and mass landing. And I don't know if you remember, Lois, you weren't on the board last fall when all the buildings shared out their attendance data. The attendance data is overwhelmingly positive, a huge improvement.

And also adding those positions has enabled assistant principals to step in in behavioral situations, RTIA and B. It's enabled them to manage sometimes complex behavior situations at school that then require a complex parent interaction after school. There are needs that we still haven't, that I feel we need to lean into assistant principals even further with 504 assistance and management. And then another consideration is that we have five and a half open ed tech positions in special ed where those people who are currently working in general ed wouldn't have to lose a job. we have a job open for them. So that's just some of the reasoning behind why those were,

3:29:52

that's where we landed largely to get to tier two. Again, I can't pretend it won't have an impact because A, those ed techs are really good, and having the extra person there, it definitely helps. But of all the other impacts we could choose from, it's when we felt we could manage the best.

Thank you. Chris? So along that ed tech theme, I think we talked about it, But trying to understand if you had to, let's say, prioritize not cutting two of those ed tech positions, which would they be? One of the things I worry about is that, yes, I know we have special ed positions open, special ed tech positions open.

But that it's really a very different job and that we I don't want to get our district into a situation where we we now have both open ed tech positions, general ed tech and special ed tech positions or open special ed tech positions, but we

have lost some of those general ed tech positions. So just to, I'm going to answer your question, but just to make it clear, that's not a, we didn't discuss that scenario as a team, like we did not, of the ed tech positions that

are listed in tier two, we did not go further and rank them, and, but if I have to answer that question without consulting with the team, and you asked, I would keep the ones in the elementary schools and then kind of on that is if that's something we wanted to do as a board

how do we like kind of go about asking that well I think that you know I don't you guys get to decide how you want to handle this but I just want to um name that it's not our job to run the schools it's our job to support the people whom we trust to run the schools and this is one of

these questions where I understand the the goodness and the like the wanting to make our schools the best that they can be and it feels like it brushes right up against um getting our fingers into something that's not our business and so I just want to name that because it's

I don't want to um I think inadvertently a question like that can send the message that we don't trust the people in this room um and I don't think that was your intention Chris at all But I just want to name that there's this line that is not well defined.

And I just want to, that going there makes me start to, like, feel uncomfortable about that line for me personally. I don't, I appreciate that comment. And, you know, even in what I just said, I mean, that may create the impression that I just, I don't care about the middle school as much.

And that's just not the case. I don't want to create a sense of winners and losers and cherry picking among the schools. If the board asked me to come up with a number that's between one tier and another, what I would really need to do is go back to the team and talk about, okay, what do we do, and come back to you.

I can tell you it would be what you're seeing in the tiers is very, to the nth degree, thought out about, as we go down, what's the least painful thing to get there? And you're seeing the reasoning already. I super appreciate that, Stephanie. I really hope that I don't, it doesn't seem like I don't respect that at all, but as a kind of counterpoint to that, saying we want a 6% or 7% or 8% tier is pretty arbitrary, and so that's kind of what I'm wrestling with in my mind of trying to understand that, well, but is this what we could do if we had just that little bit more, but we needed to stay within that tier, that specific number, so that's why we chose what we chose.

And, again, that's kind of why I asked, like, how do we as a board do that? Because I don't want to be cherry-picking and being like, well, I want this position, and I want this position, but not that position. And, like, I don't think that's what we should be doing. So that's kind of why I mentioned that.

I mean, like Tom said, it is the board's prerogative to choose how we want to adopt our budget. my preference would be if we wanted them would be to put it to them to say like what would be and it might you know I guess from tier two it would they're all in tech positions so one of

3:35:08

them would be in that deck visit but right so it could be that it's you know um the the preference there um yeah the the whole cherry-picking idea I don't love I felt that was that was kind of where we devolved to last year um but um you know we could we could approach it however we liked

stuff yeah it's um and i didn't think that that's what you're doing chris for the record but um uh and thanks for your graciousness of my comment um but i it's almost like the question that comes to me is what what do we need to be comfortable with a suggested percentage and i don't know if

i understand what we need as a board to become comfortable with a percentage and so maybe that's how we could consider approaching it um that's just an idea because it's sort of like otherwise it's like a chicken or the egg situation where we're like i don't know if i like this percentage

because i don't know if i like the things that would be required to get us to this percentage but we don't want to dictate the things that get us to the percentage so i think we need to ask ourselves like what would we need to be comfortable with saying this is the percentage that we're

comfortable with isn't that what we were talking about a little bit last meeting when we were saying maybe that's just punting it down the road but okay hey tom like what would if we wanted something between seven and eight percent what would you what would it look like and then he

goes back and he he makes the position less not us and then from there it's sort of like okay that's that much of an increase like do we feel like that's worth it or go back to tier two and that is how we have approached it in previous years there have been sort of tiers of like this

is this is what we definitely think we need this is what we'd like to have i mean and to be fair this was sort of the inverse of what we're dealing with now it was like additions right and you know the fun days where we could add things um but it was like you know this is what we have to have

this is what we you know we'd like to have and like hey if you're willing this is what we you know, and they were, and they were prioritized in that level. So, you know, not to say that we never moved something out of its order, but typically it was like we sort of picked the level we were

comfortable with, like where did we feel like we were comfortable from a, from a budget perspective and to live within that, the, the admin's team's recommendation is like, okay, with that, this is what we would do with it. And it was less about the board picking specific ones. And, you know,

In 13 years, we've been all over the place on how we've dealt with the budget. But, I mean, that has certainly been a way we have, a protocol we have used in the past, too. You know, for me, as somebody who was an outsider, famously last year and here now,

I think seeing a lot of these positions pop up that were also on the list last year, I know that if I weren't the person in that position, it would be gut-wrenching to have this happen to me. year after year. And so I think for me to be comfortable with a cut, I would want to know that

we're not perpetuating it again next year. We're not going to be sitting in the same position next year saying, okay, well, we saved them last year, but this year we probably really need it. I just, I think that's the worst part of what happened last year that's happening this year is I think

a lot of those same folks are in that same boat that they were in last year, and I can't even imagine it and i know this is bleak i agree very bleak i don't like it none of us do i'm pretty sure um i also don't want to put anybody through that again next year and i think that was the

whole point of meeting in november is what can we do to kind of stop the bleeding and really stop the bleeding not just kind of bandage it up until next year and then hope it's healed if i may sorry i i really feel i want you all to know that the group of people sitting in the back

row would not let me bring a proposal to you that we had not really talked about and believed could work and would be good um and they i just need you to know that um are there maybe holes in our thinking things we haven't considered sure we're human you know and I think having our thinking

3:40:12

probed is healthy and important and I would never want to be defensive about that but just just know there has not been a cavalier moment in any of these conversations I have no doubt yeah I really appreciate that because I think that's where I'm going with my mindset is that I want to know that

if we're going to make these cuts, that we are not seriously compromising the education that we're providing to our students, that we still have ways to meet their needs, even if we cut these positions. And I'm hearing from Tom and from the educators back there that we feel that we can still meet their needs adequately and even more than adequately if we cut these ed tech positions.

And so, although I don't love the idea of these people losing their positions under the circumstances, I feel confident that you guys have done your homework and that you're ready to meet the needs, even when we take these people out of our budget. So, thank you. I'm not sure someone's going to throw something at me.

But I mean, I guess my other question is the way to preserve those positions is, and still stay at the same budget level, is do we eliminate the positions we continue to not be able to fill, the special ed tech positions?

Well, we have to provide the services by law, but presumably we are providing the services now, or are we not? I mean, I'm just trying to be creative here. You know, it's 10-15, I love new ideas. So we have discussed that. And, you know, if I'm getting this wrong, somebody shoot me down. But I think it's really important that we preserve those positions

because that is where our need really is the greatest. And even if the positions aren't filled, I think we have to name it and keep trying to meet that need in the way it should be met. Okay. Colin? I have so many thoughts, but I'm only going to give one. I think that it would be really helpful to have a little bit of a clear sense at the next meeting of, but again, knowing that there's all sorts of factors that could contribute to things. But if we were to go with the current proposal

of 6.5, what does that do for us in the next budget cycle um versus um versus something higher than that um because i think that's uh i don't know i mean i think that um i think we've we definitely have new factors that came in this year like i think

you've definitely made that clear that there have been factors that have come in um but i think there were things that probably um the board could have seen uh coming down the pike um a bit more and so I think that's, I think, I think having a clear sense of, like,

is there really a functional difference between 6.5, 3, and 7 in terms of, like, what we would face next year? Or are we really talking about, like, like, we would need to go to the, like, disastrous one that you're talking about in order to, like, make next year

a year in which we would not have to make these sorts of cuts? We're working on that, and we'll definitely have it ready for you. You know, I never want to cut you off when you want to talk about things. But we do have more budget meetings scheduled. You get two weeks off this time. We'll meet again on the 25th. I'm just cognizant of the time. I think that tonight's conversation was good. I really appreciate the presentation about the potential ways forward for the configuration.

I think we had some clarity, at least I did, on some of the questions on the budget. And as always, it's to be continued. um we have no new business we have no personnel issues um we are back to public comment so come out um all right well then i would take a motion to adjourn valerie and kara thank you

all those in favor no one votes no i hope everyone enjoys their their week off next week

Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.