TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 25 February 2026
Board meeting · 3 h 55 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →
34,709 words in 46 five-minute windows.
It's gonna be short. That's what you want. I don't know. Yeah. I don't know. It's something that feels like a lot. I'm sorry. I can fuck all that. I'm sorry. Well. I feel like you are a sports fan. Right? I was going to say, you wouldn't have used these versions.
Yeah. It would have been a while, but yes. I mean, David Johnson, I'm more sure. Good evening. Welcome to the RSU 5 Board of Directors meeting. It is Wednesday, February 25th, 2026. We are here in the Freeport High School Library. Currently, Steph isn't with us yet,
but she is on her way, but we'll get started in the meantime with the Pledge of Allegiance. So do we have a motion for consideration? Did I knock that off? Okay, good start. Do we have a motion for consideration and approval of the minutes from the February 4th, 2026 meeting
and February 11th, 2026 meeting as presented barring any errors or omissions? Kelly and Karen, thank you. All those in favor, let Steph vote as she's walking in. There we go. then opposed. Adjustments to the agenda. Thank you. Yes, I'd like to add item 13A, which is a motion to
make a change to the school calendar. Okay, we will get there. So we will start with good news and recognition with Moon. I'd like to say that a lot of sporting events have happened over the last couple weeks, and I'm pleased to say that both the boys and girls did really well in their
respective sports and to start off the girls indoor track team won states the boys indoor track team came in second at states the girls nor team came in first for states the boys nor team finished eighth in state championships and the
Freeport Yarmouth girls are the state champions in hockey and they beat chevris and the boys alpine team got fourth at states and then we also have region 10 students of the quarter and we have Acadia Cornish and the auto
collision repair, Michaela Feltis in the certified nursing assistant, Jacob Hana in the building trades, we got Kaylee McGarry in the creative digital media, we got Logan Proctor in the pre-apprenticeship, and we got Kaya and Santos in the IT slash cyber security. And then also on March
25th, we have a career fair that will be held in the Freeport High School gym from 1030 to 1 for students to learn about careers and hear from different organizations and businesses. And then Also, last will be Freeport High School has a senior class as an auction night,
our auction that began Sunday, February 22nd, and also will run until Sunday, March 8th at 6 p.m. And I have the auction link if anyone wants it, but it'd be great to support the class for their night, I guess, their senior night.
Well, thank you. Thank you. I don't know if anybody watched any of the gold medal hockey games in the last week or so. But I think I was more stressed going into the overtime of the girls' hockey state championship game than I was sitting at home on last week and Sunday. But congratulations to everyone in their sporting events as the winter season comes to a close.
All right, so we will move on to public comment. Did you give me the paper yet? No, not yet. Okay, so we'll do a little bit of housekeeping on how public comment works, particularly because we do have a fair amount of folks, so we want to make sure we can hear from as many people as possible.
And so how it'll work, once I have the list, feel free to put your name on if you'd like to speak, is we will call folks up, and I'll probably call the next person so we can kind of queue up and keep things moving. When you get to the microphone, we ask that you give your name and the town where you live, and that you keep your comments to three minutes per person.
And we will have a timer running, so if you hear the timer go off, we just ask that you kind of wrap up your thought so we can hear from as many folks as possible tonight because we also do have a full agenda as well, but we want to make sure that we hear from folks who came to join us.
And just a note, we have two public comments on our agenda every board meeting. So one's here at the beginning and one is at the end after we've gone through all of our board business so if you weren't inspired to speak now but are so
inspired later in the evening there is another opportunity all right so we will start with lindsey han and heather i just apologize for names i am terrible at it so heather lamaka will be uh will be next after lindsey okay oh i'm sorry so right here at the podium
and the mic is right there we you do generally need to get closer to the mic than you probably feel comfortable with um but we want to make sure that the um not only the folks here can hear you but also the meetings are live streamed and recorded so we want to make sure people at home can hear you as well so uh your name your town and three minutes is yours yeah thank you my name
is mark doley i'm the father of a panel elementary school student i live at 196 merrill road and i'm here to talk about the recent proposal from RSU 5 school board that negatively impacts panel. RSU 5 has a budget shortfall. The top budget goal is to use the six school buildings in a more
efficient manner. At the February 11th school board meeting, the superintendent proposed to repurpose panel elementary school into a new early childhood school for all RSU 5 children. As far as I could tell, 100% of the board members supported the motion to further explore this scenario as the most promising option.
Scenario 2 requires Pownall to give up its elementary school and bus kids to Durham instead. On the other hand, Freeport and Durham get a new early childhood school in Pownall with lots of outdoor space. If the plan is followed to fruition, panel kids will have a longer bus ride and receive a lower quality education.
This will trigger a drop in property values and ultimately a reduction in town revenue. From the perspective of the members of the panel community, this seems like an unjust proposal. Considering RSU-5 as a unit, the proposal appears efficient because early childhood education can be expanded without adding additional buildings.
I'll get back to the costs in a moment, but it's important to acknowledge the quality of the education at Poundell Elementary School. Will sending Poundell students to Durham result in a better education for Poundell students?
It doesn't really seem likely. Poundell is ranked as a top school in Maine. One website had the school at number two out of 288 just two years ago. In addition, enrollment in Poundell increased by about 18% since 2023, but district-wide enrollment decreased by about 5% during the same period.
Last Saturday, I knocked on doors to speak with neighbors and get our petition signed. I learned firsthand that Poundell residents want to keep their elementary school, and that budget is very important to them. This brings us back to costs. I think there are a few big budget risks associated with such a complex reorganization of the district.
For starters, if the plan is implemented, RSU-5 will still maintain the same six buildings, except now they'll have increased programming for three- and four-year-olds. In addition, the change might ultimately require building modifications to account for the change of use space,
transportation redesign, staffing reorganization, and curriculum realignment. Each of those elements carries financial and operational uncertainty and risk. And my time is up, so I was hoping I could pass it to Lindsay so that she could advocate for scenario one. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Good
evening. My name is Lindsay Hahn. I'm a panel resident and a mother to four young children who hope to attend PES one day and presently attend. I'd like to present a case to explore Scenario 1 instead of continuing to explore Scenario 2. Scenario 1
would allow the district to minimize uncertainty by implementing manageable targeted changes with more certain budget outcomes. It would address mandates by encouraging exploration of public-private partnerships for early childhood education. It could resolve cost imbalances by utilizing less
disruptive tools such as opening inter-district enrollment. It could manage the budget in a controlled manner. Scenario one would allow us to explore options to address shortfalls without placing a disproportionate burden on one specific community. Given the inequity of scenario two
of repurposing the panel elementary school for mostly Durham and Freeport use and the budget risks associated with the complex change, it would be very difficult to get the panel community to agree to this plan. The keystone of the plan is to change our elementary school, which is the heart
of our community. It is my hope that the panel community rallies around PES to support a solution to the budget shortfall that does not include dismantling the school and sending our kids to Durham. I appreciate the board's stated commitment to gathering stakeholder input before moving
forward with scenario two, and in that vein, I would like to present a petition created by the parents of panel children to oppose the dissolution of our elementary school. The petition now carries more than 800 signatures, with 500 of those from Pownall, Durham, and Freeport residents.
In a town of our size, that number represents a significant and unmistakable expression of community will. Families have spoken clearly and in large numbers. Mr. Gray's email to the RSU 5 community on February 12th stated that the perspective of parents and children are essential
and will shape the path forward. If that is true, then the overwhelming response from Pownall families is that eliminating or repurposing our elementary school is not an acceptable solution. respectfully any further time and resources spent investigating scenario
two should be redirected to other solutions that do not include repurposing panel elementary I understand the district faces financial and structural challenges we're ready to engage constructively in conversations about sustainability equity and early childhood programming but those conversations must begin with the assurance that our local elementary school will remain intact we look forward to continue dialogue with the clear understanding that parents of panel children are committed to the preservation of panel elementary school and will continue to voice our strong opposition to scenario two until the board had decided to move on from it. Thank you. Thank
you, Lindsay. Heather. And then after Heather, I have Taylor Steele, I think. My name is Heather Limica. I live in Pownall. I'm a mother to two kids who currently attend PES in pre-K and kindergarten. I could not be more happy with our cute little school. The amazing things that
has done for my kids in just the two years they've attended, it's unmistakable. I know you guys have faced a lot of pressure in trying to make decisions and find a way that's going to work for RSU 5 and the communities that it serves. The heart of panel, in my opinion, is our school. We have such
a strong connection with that school. There's adult programs that happen there to other places, But having that as one of our stakeholder resources in our small town is such a big deal to that community. We moved to Powell because of its outdoor kind of leanings and what it has available.
And I think the school has really integrated that, that outdoor play in how they create and shape classrooms for our children so they can grow diligently. We so value what these teachers are putting into our kids. We, um, I'm just so worried that if we pursue the second option that we go down a very scary pathway for my family and a lot of our families.
Um, when you think about what needs to transition to have three and four year old IEP students, um, if they were to, you know, be in that school in that scenario, I think it changes the, the building classification from an educational to an institutional.
and if you look at just fire suppression alone that's easily $200,000 just to think about doing that because you have to have an entirely different system if it's a different code so all of the codes are way stricter and it opens up a huge can of worms and I'm sure you guys have thought of
that but that is a huge financial burden to repurpose that particular building. When I think about for my family, the extra, the travel, it's, you know, 28,000 miles per year extra beyond going to Pennell Elementary School. It is 48 extra hours in the car just to bring my kids to and from,
not extracurricular, not there. That is just the bare minimum. If we're thinking about other solutions, just to put it out there, if we combine with MS-8051 North Yarmouth and we were to potentially use that North Yarmouth Community Center that they have on Route 9 that used to be
a school, so it has a lot of the codes and those things, and it has a gym, and it has all of that space. I don't know how it's being utilized, but wouldn't it be cool if that was one of the things that we could potentially do between districts and other community ideas? I hope that we continue
to remain open to opportunities that people can bring forward from the community so we can find a different option that doesn't give us the loss of the heart blood of our town. Thank you, Heather. So, Taylor, right? Yeah, so after Taylor, I have Rich Brennitol.
Hi, my name's Taylor Steele. I am a mom of two, one who's at Pownall and one who I hope to send there in a few years. I've watched the video from the last school board meeting more times than I care to admit. A few key takeaways stood out to me. you all recognize that PES is a wonderful school. And as you can see this evening, and also the
outpouring of support gained within just the two weeks since your last meeting, the community strongly opposes moving forward with scenario two. I also kept hearing concerns raised about the inequity of class sizes across the district. And when looking at year-over-year class sizes across
RSU 5 grades K through 5, over the last five years, the averages are Moore Street and Mass Landing are 20, Pownall Elementary at 15, and Durham at 16. While the total size of Pownall is smaller, which is also reflective of the population of the town, it is far from the outlier when it
comes to average class size. And on the topic of growth, the Pownall community is growing. In 2021, eight new homes were built in Pownall. Since then, an average of 14 new homes have been built each year with multiple developments planned, one of which is slated for 20 homes alone. Families with
young children, like mine, are drawn to Poundell because of its elementary school. It is why we moved to Poundell and bought a home in Poundell. As that growth continues, average class sizes will reflect it. Finally, I think the board moved past Chris's point too quickly. The idea of repurposing
or expanding Moore Street to accommodate early education. If part of the argument for scenario two is avoiding deferred costs during a high inflationary period, and if Moore Street will require significant investment in the future anyway, then that feels like a very valid path
to at least explore. One that doesn't completely uproot an entire community's elementary school. This is a timely and worthwhile idea that deserves serious consideration. Please do not close a thriving school. Thank you, Taylor. So after which I have Megan Metzger. Thank you. Since I'm the
fourth panel. Oh, thank you. Perfect. Since I'm the fourth panel parent in a row to come up here. I'm going to ask you to just, I know I said your name before, but just so it's for the. Ridgewood and panel. I have a first grader in panel elementary school now, a pre-K
or two B in the fall and a middle school in people at middle school in sixth grade. And I just want to second all of the great ideas and opposition to this scenario, too. I've watched the video, and I also want to acknowledge that these are difficult issues
that the board and superintendent are grappling with, and I really appreciate the work that's going into this. I want to share one just personal example about panoramintry school and the culture that's fostered there. My first grader, it's actually his seventh birthday this evening, and we had the birthday celebration before this and I went to the school board and we've been struggling to talk about the possibility of what might happen to the school
but he really wanted me to come and he also wanted to tell me that his favorite part of his birthday today was one, when his name was announced on the loudspeaker in the morning announcements that's a panel elementary school tradition
and rather that it coincided with the 100th day of school celebration that PES does. He was more excited about those things that made it special in the school today than anything else about his birthday. Save me for the cake. And he also demonstrates that each of these students at PES
is known and nurtured and loved by the staff and a real culture of an individual knowing the student and the learner as an individual is really fostered there. And that kind of culture doesn't take one year or even one decade to build,
and it can be easily and quickly taken apart, and it will take a long time to rebuild. So I appreciate the board's work and want to come to this with an open mind but certainly echo the opposition to the dissolving of Palomar Elementary. Thank you. Thank you, Rich. So after Levin, I have Nicholas Sear.
All right, is that working? Nope, you're going to do it. Thank you. Hello, everyone. I'm Megan Metzger. I'm a Palomar resident and the mother of a current first grader at Palomar Elementary. We've lived in Poundell for 10 years now, but it wasn't until our daughter started at Poundell Elementary that our lives in the community began.
It's not just about meeting and connecting with so many other families there at the school. It's that the school is the core fiber and heart of the Poundell community, as so many others have said. It's not because of the physical presence of the building. It's because of the magic that is created there each and every day by multiple ages learning together and from each other.
in a close-knit, thriving community. I'm here to ask the board to remove all options under consideration that involve dissolving or restructuring panel elementary. It's overwhelmingly clear that this is widely opposed and really affecting the panel community, which has been, I should note, year after year, notably supportive of RSU-5 budgets. We know mindful discussions and compromises will need to be made as a community
to ensure our school district remains strong and sustainable. But it is also important to identify the non-negotiables. Dismantling a thriving school and community hub is off the table. And panel has only started to begin to voice how we oppose this.
So we ask you to please continue to consider option one and take option two and three off the table. Thank you, Logan. So after Nicholas, I have Matt Altieri. Good evening. My name is Nicholas here. I'm a father of Winslow, a first grader at Pownall, a Pownall resident, and soon-to-be Margo pre-K going in this fall.
When this proposal was presented and shared with me for the first time, a lot of thoughts came to mind, and as echoed by a lot of the parents here, just how important the school is to the families and the community in Pownall.
My daughter, Pound Wall Elementary is extremely important to my daughter particularly, and just seeing her flourish there has just been very rewarding. I couldn't describe the amount of pride I have for her developing there.
Trying to think of what to say tonight, didn't really know what I was going to say, but one day staying home with her for the snow day, she kind of told me what to say. Sitting on the floor playing with our dolls, doing a picnic,
she looked at her sister, Margo, and held up a doll and said, Donald Panthers are learners that show. They show cooperation, assertion, responsibility, empathy, and self-control. Go Panthers. I think that just in a snapshot kind of highlights what it means to the kids and the families in panel, and I hope you consider option one and not option two and three. Thank you.
Thank you, Nicholas. After that, I have Andy Seymour, I think. Good evening. I'm Matt Altieri. I'm the proud parent of three current panel panthers. I want to start by observing that I speak from experience when I say I know it's a difficult
position to be in, to be on a board where you're making decisions about which people feel great passion. And I have a proposal, I think it's in line with what everybody else has said, that that would make the next year or so a lot easier for you. Over the last two weeks,
I've seen a community in Pownall that has just been galvanized. I've seen people start text threads, start petitions that have gathered nearly a thousand signatures, nearly as many signatures as there were votes approving last year's RSU-5 budget.
Seen people go door-to-door knocking to talk to their neighbors about their RSU-5 and Pownall Elementary School experiences. We've started parties to get together and talk about ways to both help RSU 5 and ensure that this plan to shutter our school doesn't go forward. And this is just the start. This is a community
in action. It's been inspiring, but it's not at all surprising. Here's why. Shuttering one of the best performing schools in the state in the name of academic success and student outcomes just doesn't make sense. Depriving children of the community in which they've thrived and which they
have started to call their home in the name of equity is simply wrong. The reality is that as long as closing PES remains on the table, the opposition that you see here tonight will just grow and grow and grow. This room is full, and in two weeks, if this plan is still on the table,
it will be double in size. I assure you of that. We'll be here organized, vocal, and passionate for as long as it takes. And I have complete confidence in this. At the end of this process, whether it ends tonight or it ends a year from now, you will conclude that this proposal, scenario two,
misses the mark. It doesn't meet the objectives that Superintendent Gray identified as a simple choice. You can end tonight the proposal to shutter Poundell Elementary School and replace it with something that's altogether and entirely different. And we can move forward as a group to identify
that will work to address the very real challenges that Superintendent Gray has identified all it takes is one member of the board tonight to vote to terminate the consideration of scenario two and any plan that would shut our panel
elementary school as it currently exists and the rest of you voting in favor of that I beg you not to waste another moment on this plan this board and this community need to move forward together on proposals that will actually work
thank you matt andy okay so after andy i have brett all right uh hi my name's andy and usually uh i speak more from the hip but tonight i had to organize my thoughts so bear with me i am i'm a panel resident i have a kindergarten and a fourth grader at paloma i've lived in paloma for nearly
20 years now i watched the recent rsu meeting and i want to offer perspective from the community most affected directly by the proposals on the table. This conversation puts us in a clear ethical dilemma, something Tom mentioned in the last meeting. A simple right and wrong frame that
doesn't reflect what this school truly represents. It's a hard discussion, but panel cannot stay quiet. Our school is special in a real everyday way. It sits on the backside of Bradbury and offers an outdoor learning environment that people across the district openly praise. I've heard
The board members call it an outstanding outdoor experience and a unique resource for students from Freeport and Durham. Yet in the next breath, it becomes an aging, inefficient real estate asset that needs to be repurposed.
That contradiction is impossible to miss. How could something be an incredible resource for everyone else but not worth keeping for the families who actually live here? And here's the part that hits the panel the hardest.
It's being framed as an amazing opportunity, but only when panel children aren't the ones attending. When our kids go here, the school is called inefficient. When the kids from Freeport and Durham are imagined here, suddenly it becomes a district-wide gem. The double standard makes it clear. The school is valuable, just not for the families who built their lives around it.
Equity has been mentioned many times. Equity matters, but it should not erase the community's only local school. Many of us chose Powell specifically to send our children to the school. And this is why history matters. When RSC 5 was formed, the board superintendent promised Pounder Elementary would not be closed.
I've been here long enough to remember when Pounder was an independent school. The current proposal may not be labeled as a closure, but if Pounder children can't attend, then the school is effectively closed to the town.
A school that the community cannot attend, cannot use, is not that community's school. Cost per student has also come up repeatedly. Yes, it is high up in Poundell, but that's not a failing. It's the nature of a small community education. The model that the district agreed to in RSU 5 was created. Families here didn't create that number. We simply set our kids to school in our town. Using a metric to eliminate Poundell's school experience feels less like equity and more like efficiency at one community's expense. So I need to ask, is it equitable for Poundell to be the only town that cannot send its children to grades 1 through 5 in their own community?
Is it equitable to remove the very experience many of us moved here for? If the board chooses to take our school away, please don't call it equity. That is not past the straight face test for the people who live here. For years, we've heard whispers about closing, and I appreciate the board for finally acknowledging them.
But this doesn't feel like a shared sacrifice. It feels like a panel being asked once again to take the largest hit for the advantage of larger towns. So that's probably the sound I'm supposed to wrap up, correct? So I'll read my last sentence. So tonight I'm asking you to see what's right in front of you. Powell has been loyal, contributing part of this district from a start.
A school is not a liability. It's an asset in the community belt, supported and shared. If it's a valuable offer for students from Freeport and Durham, it's valuable enough for Powell's children. If we're asking for fairness, for honesty, and the dignity of being treated as a full community within RSC5,
you have the opportunity to choose the path that honors every town. I'm asking you to take that path and let Powell keep the school that has shaped our identity and our future. Thank you, Andy. So after Brett, I have Rene.
I'm Brett Vickery. I live in Pauno. And first of all, I have to confess to an egregious mistake that I made earlier this evening. In coming in, I was signing my name. And like on so many other petitions, I signed my wife's name under it. And without really considering that she might not want to speak.
So don't expect Rene to come up. And I'll hear more about that later. So I was raised by two teachers in a small school. And we raised our children, our two children in Maine. And when we heard our daughter and husband, who live in Pownall, were pregnant,
We really ramped up our search for a home, and we bought a house three months after our grandson was born. And I know personally what the closure of the Powell Elementary School would mean to my grandchildren, who we take to school and pick up from school,
and to my children, to Heather and Mark Limica. It is the cutest, sweetest little school I've ever seen. It's just amazing. When I think of the experiences that I had as a youngster in kindergarten and elementary school, they were a mixed bag. When I had a chance to chaperone and help the teachers at Powell Elementary School on a field trip outing,
I was so impressed by the kids. They are the sweetest little kids. And when one of their classmates would do something they didn't like, they showed so much patience. I've never seen such a large group of kids behave with such respect to one another.
And as I've gotten to know the teachers, I can understand exactly about the parents in Poundle and the teachers of their children. I'm just speaking from my heart. What I see out there is unlike any public educational institution I've ever seen.
And this goes for charter schools. And, you know, it's just amazing. And for our family to see the skating rink and the playground and have our kids come home. What did you do today? Well, we went skiing. We went snowshoeing. We took a walk in the forest. We went ice skating. It's just like, holy cow. And there are so many activities that involve not just the kids,
but their parents, their whole families. And it's just such an unbelievable treasure. And it would break our family's heart to have the school closed. Thank you. Thank you, Brett. So I'm going to give Renee a second to decide if she wants to speak or not. And she's giving me the, oh, no. So we will move on to Brandon. Perry Ferry. And then after Brandon, I have
Jesse Fisk. I'll do the honors. Hi, I'm Brandon Perry. I'm at 290 Fickett Road in Powne. I have a pre-K and a someday going to be pre-K kiddo at home. So I came here before you guys today to say much of what I've heard a lot of others. So as I was hearing
people articulate things far more effectively than I can, I thought maybe I'd take a different tech as well and kind of discuss economically and in terms of a feeder cycle for our educational staff and the general culture and educational excellence I'm sure you all strive for every day,
how Poundle is kind of a model school for this. And I think starting from the position of Poundle clearly has strong outcomes and that there's a concern about equity, I am dismayed here option two is on the table because it kind of says to me that we are sacrificing excellence
in the face of efficiency or in the face of you know averaging out the experience across the board for everyone but I think you know if we're being honest we'd want all of the children to receive that excellent standard of education they'd all like to be able to experience that level of
excellence. And I think the core, you know, direction, it almost feels like it's a directionally wrong proposal because we aren't moving towards something that's actually going to advance either the children's outcomes. It's going to potentially shatter the excellent staffing that
we've built in panel elementary. What happens with them? Are they well represented here today and in the other meetings. These people have built up their careers, their experience has been in very strong educational settings, and made them come with a very lengthy background. And again,
you've heard how wonderful it is. And the kids, it's unreal. You get a room full of 100 panel kids. It is incredible, like these little adults running around, really. They're so well put together, well adjusted generally, and they are kind and smart and driven.
And, you know, I'd hate to see that lost. What I would like to see is that it's gained across the board. And I know that doesn't really help with the financial lows, you know, inflation being what it is we have some need for either income or you know cut and we also have a passed down um you
know dictate about how we're going to operate even earlier childhood care special education is eating us alive and so i recognize the need for something to be done and uh i recognize you're hearing a lot of just no today and that you probably also need to have a path forward on something that can
actually reach those goals and i don't have that answer for you today but i just say uh there's a concept of uh online if you ever want to get an answer to something uh and you're on a forum post the wrong answer confidently and i feel like that's kind of what made you happen here
is, you know, there is a very strongly proposed option two, and it really, it rankled a lot of people, and I think at this point now, we're all willing to lend a hand to make sure that that doesn't happen, but that something good does come of this, and, you know, you've
got our attention, and you've gotten us involved, and I'd like to see us continue being involved and helping sculpt what the future can look like and be more involved in budgeting and being really present in this process. And I think we can do that together. So, you know, I wouldn't necessarily consider us in opposition, but more that we want to navigate to a strong solution that will actually meet the educational goals for Precourt and Durham in addition to panel. And we would like to propagate these educational stories out to as many kids as we can so we see how valuable it is every generation who has their kids go through they feel that way and we want to make that happen
across the board. Thank you. Thank you Brandon. So after Jesse we have Megan Arena. My name is Jesse Fisk. I am a panel resident and our children are in grades 1, 4, and 6. Obviously I'm not unique that my wife and I chose to move here in large part because of the school system. Having a small
community elementary school and then you know the opportunities of a larger regional middle school and high school made a lot of sense to us and we haven't been disappointed but just as important as what the school does for our
children is you know as mentioned what the school does for our community for a large segment of panel PS is the foundation of our community where parents meet each other and where relationships between families are made At the last board meeting, Superintendent Gray told you community identity is quote
something we cannot underestimate. And then both proposals ignored that. I was confused. Justification, a lot of talk about equity, understandably. Equity of class sizes has been discussed. Panel is growing. The other schools are stagnant
or shrinking. Our building permit numbers are going up. I don't think that'll be a problem too long. The equity of cost per student. Yes, as I believe Andy mentioned, we're a school of 100 students. The economy is a scale. It's not practical that we're going to be, that we're going
to compete with schools 300 plus students. It doesn't matter if you put pre-Kers or sixth graders there. If anything, the cost per student is going to increase with the associated transportation costs to bus them in from across the district. Not explicitly discussed, as far
I could tell last meeting, but I still get the sense there's equity concerns or almost jealousy about how wonderful our school is, the unique opportunities that PES offers. We are blessed to have an amazing PE teacher, Mr. T, but a lot of what allows these activities to be available
to our children is really the community. The parents, as you see, are very invested in our school, and so many of us volunteer with the school in one way or another. We have Impact, who's instrumental in organizing a lot of these programs and don't think that building that the building at 587 Elmwood is intrinsically special if the
building is repurposed I don't think there will be the community support to allow many of these activities to continue you talk about equity at the middle school level understandably you want to help Durham middle schoolers have access to more activities but the elementary level it seems you want to decrease opportunities so we can be equitable across the district to wrap up
and echo Andy one last question is how equitable is it that Freeport will continue to have an elementary school Durham will continue to have an elementary school and panel elementary school be closed that doesn't sound equitable thank you thank you Jesse after Megan I have Julie Baird good
evening everyone Megan arena from panel I'm the proud parent of a panel Panther as well today I'd like to express my strong commitment to maintaining panel elementary school is a pre-k to five school for panel children panel elementary serves as a hub
of our community and pride in our school as you've heard many times tonight our teachers the pride in our teachers our school and our students runs deep it's a place where students regularly play in the forest as noted by several of you at the last meeting and where parents stage a second
impromptu talent show to host a performer who was sick during the school's regularly scheduled one it's a place where families know and look out for one another and regularly share resources achievements, and struggles. It's a place where the community comes together to build an ice rink
each year, to clean out minkleberry so that it's safe for our children, and volunteers as swim chaperones in the middle of the day, in fact most of the day, so that children learn this important life skill. It's a community who cares deeply for each other and our school. The community is
responsible for this, as Jesse just noted. It's not the building itself. If you take away that affinity, that community, the rest of what's appealing about PES disappears too. We may not have a new community programs building, nor a fancy playground like other schools in the district.
The relationships formed at Powell Elementary between parents, students, and teachers are irreplaceable. Community connections and identity must be honored and recognized as important. I watched the recent board meeting with interest, and I know budgets are a concern here and
everywhere. However, I found the board's discussion of the options to be anything but thoughtful. There seemed to be a great deal of concern over equity, presumably referring to cost per student, though that was never stated. What was articulated was the desire to provide Powell's outdoor space
to other groups instead. Swapping one group for another is far from equitable. I also heard it with great interest that equities exist at the middle school level, and I agree that those should be remedied immediately. However, world language STEM and athletic offerings seem to be fixable in far less drastic ways.
While I applaud the importance you place on equity, I urge you to consider the equity as surrounding ripping students from your neighborhood school so that another group of students can simply use it instead. While I heard at the board meeting that these things have been quietly talked about for a long time,
I can confidently share that many other ideas have also been quietly talked about in the panel community and should anyone have reached out to us or engaged us in brainstorming we're to share those viable ideas with you as well. Mr. Gray you opened your remarks by stating your belief
that we should do what's right for kids not for the budget. What's right for students in panel as well as other impacted schools is not to shuffle and rearrange students at all grade levels so drastically. Surely you're well aware of the research surrounding building transitions and
their negative impact on student achievement, growth, and mental health. One article I said in Mr. Gray discusses the chaos factor that naturally comes with upending students. And that's that some students never recover, particularly those with IEPs or those that are underrepresented. Oh, God, I'm only halfway done, you guys. Okay. Thank you for your time tonight. What I'll say is that there will not be buy-in from the Pano community. I'm the 12th Pano parent up here. The room is packed, as you've seen. You've heard that there is a petition with over 800 signatures.
there are lawn signs distributed there are postcards already at homes we'll keep working together hopefully this is not something you have buy-in for thank you thank you so after julie i have kate martins hello my name is julie baird i am a panel resident i have two kids in
the district one in middle school and one in the high school so i no longer have skin in this game but it is still very important to me um i am a panel resident um as a formal full-time elementary school teacher. I was increasingly nervous about sending my school-aged kids to school as they
grew older. Having come from a large district out of state that was labeled one of the best in the nation, I saw firsthand how much this format of education hurt children, especially the littlest ones. I wanted something different for my children than that, and I found it in Pownall. So passionate
for this little rural elementary school that I drove 25 minutes from the Wolfneck Peninsula, where our rental home was to panel and then back again so my kids could attend there and p.s that's without bus stops so think about that for those families um when my daughter was in first grade
and my son was in pre-k that meant six trips there and back again in the morning there and back at noon for pre-k and there and back in afternoon for pickup but it was worth it for me because the community school is so special and that is a word I want to emphasize this is a community school
without panel elementary school panel will cease to function as a community this is a community um a community. Mara Casey-Tinkin, an associate professor at education at Bates College, wrote an article on the impact on closing of rural schools. Now, I will understand that you're not
closing our school altogether, but reconfiguring it. However, you will be closing our community school and turning it to something different, so the impact she cites in her article can be applicable. Quote, although schools are often closed to save money, there are few studies on
whether this actually happens. The little research conducted so far suggests that savings are minimal at best. At a time when fewer than one in five Americans live in rural areas, the demise of local schools can also lead to closures of local businesses and expedite population losses.
Rural schools provide political power and they tie people together. Once the schools are gone, the community loses all of those benefits. There are smaller crowds at the diner and fewer seats on the school board. Property values may also decline. I do want to reiterate that I know you're
not closing the school in the manner that these schools were closed. However, for panel, it will have such as the same impact. In panel, the school is how we get to know our neighbors. It is the core of the community and what holds us together. Without a school that is designated to serve
panel families specifically, there will be irrevocable repercussions in how we relate to one another, interact with one another, and serve one another. Without Pounder Elementary School, I never would have met my friend Malik Farlow, who is my friend and whose children are friends
with mine, but they wouldn't have been because they're in alternating grade levels. Without Pounder Elementary School, I wouldn't know most of my community members because either they had children in the school or had worked at the school. Without Pounder Elementary School, I would not
have had the opportunity to serve as a community through the schools as I did for nine years as a parent volunteer, long-term substitute teacher, and regular substitute teacher. The teachers like Mr. Donahue and his son Mr. T that have impacted my students in a way that will affect their lives
forever will be placed in other positions or will lose their positions entirely. I understand the reasoning behind exploring this decision. Funding our schools is an ever increasingly difficult situation. However, rather than reconfiguring our town identity and firing teachers, I would rather
see that we reallocate funds from elsewhere. I would rather see the money we spend on iPads or any other kind of excess be completely rerouted to our schools and our teachers. Surely there are other avenues we can explore if we just think outside the box of what, quote, all the other
schools are doing and look into what is actually best for our community. I also understand the need for early integration in the school district. Having sent two children through panel, I saw both the benefits and drawbacks to being in such a small school. I still wouldn't change that
experience for them. Their ability to get along with different personalities, serve their community, and have a strong sense of place and identity is rooted in Poundell Elementary School. I urge you to reconsider this decision and the impact it will have on Poundell's community and
identity. My name is Kate Martins. I'm a Poundell resident and I have three children. My oldest is a first grader at PES. Equity is a concept that resonates with me and it's a word I heard again and again when watching the ward meeting on February 11th and again and again tonight.
Before having children, I was a teacher myself, and issues around equity were at the center of the work I did with students and families. The way I have understood the term is as the recognition of individual differences and
systemic barriers and the providing of tailored resources to achieve positive outcomes. This is different from the concept of equality, which simply provides every individual with the same things. Walk in the door at PES on any day, and you will see that it is a vibrant, energized,
and productive school. It is at the heart of the community in Pauno. In fact, in many ways, it is the community in Pauno. I feel that to maintain some kind of equity with other schools in RSU 5, it is essential that Pauno Elementary School continues to exist in its current format.
The things that students need in Freeport are different than the things that students need in Pownall or Durham. Freeport has a library, coffee shops, the Y. Freeport has neighborhoods, sidewalks, and playgrounds. These are all places that build community identity. I grew up in Pownall
and recently moved back after 20 years away. I love living in a rural place and my children do too. The fact that Pownall is a rural town with few institutions means it relies heavily on its elementary school because the school is where community is made and sustained long-term from
pre-k to grade five perhaps the most formative years in our education system to remove the school is to decide on behalf of the entire community that the primary structure and panel that builds lasting systems of education socialization and collaboration is no longer important enough to
fund. It feels both inequitable and unequal to remove this school and force current students, teachers, and staff to lose their sense of stability, belonging, and continuity in their education and work. I urge you to think deeply about the implications of this proposal and the
harm it will cause our children and our community as a whole. Thank you, Kate. Okay, so that was everyone I had on my list. I will give a quick pause to see if there's anyone else who would like to speak. I would. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Bill Bogart and I'm a Pounder resident
and I come to this from a slightly different perspective. I have no children or grandchildren in the school. They've never attended the school but I am a Pounder resident and I recognize the significance of the school to the community. I'm going to take Superintendent Gray at his word
when he made the presentation last week or the week before that the needs for kids and families should always come first before financials. And if in fact that is true, and that's what this board believes, you have no justification for closing the panel school.
You're asking the smallest community in the district to send their kids from kindergarten through high school outside of their own community. When you've heard, I hope, very compelling testimony from all the families whose children go there, how important it is for them to attend.
And if, in fact, this is part of a solution to deal with equity issues between Durham Middle School and Freeport Middle School, if it's a concern about the three-year-olds and four-year-olds, and this is just the consequence of that, then there are other ways to deal with those problems.
But if in fact what's really driving this is a concern about inequality, not equity, between the cost of students, or that this board thinks that panel school is too expensive to run, then be honest about that and say that.
And then we can deal with that, and how you deal with that is a budget issue. But if, in fact, this is just the result of the machinations to deal with the issues in the middle schools, to deal with equity issues in extracurriculars, then there are other ways to do it without closing the school.
Because, being very clear, Pownall will bear the brunt of these changes. The kids in Pownall, the 100 kids who go to school there, are going to have a different experience than they have currently, and a different experience than other kids in the district. And it's fundamentally not fair to them. So if you need to solve the problem in the middle school, there are a lot of bright mounds in all these communities who can help you deal with that. If you need to solve the problems with the three- and four-year-olds and their integration into the system and early education, you can deal with that.
And so this does not need to be the result of that, closing this school, because you can hear how important it is to our community. Thank you. Good evening. My name's Ian Nichols. My wife and I are panel residents and parents of a
two-year-old who will soon enter RSU-5. Last night we read the planning for the future proposal and wanted to share our thoughts in tonight's meeting. We do genuinely appreciate Superintendent Gray's commitment to planning thoughtfully for the district's future. We know these decisions
are hard and that the pressures facing rsu5 are real and we share the goal of ensuring that every child in this district has access to a great education panel elementary school is highly regarded and its reputation speaks for itself per the superintendent's proposed budget for 26 27
enrollment has grown 18 since 2023 and we chose panel because of this school in this community And we believe that that growth deserves to be celebrated in central to this conversation. On the scenarios that were outlined, we believe scenario one is absolutely the best path forward.
Before concluding that it is unworkable, we would love to understand how much space is actually needed for the early childhood requirement and whether alternatives like portable classrooms or office reconfigurations were explored.
Regarding the early childhood requirement, our research indicates that this is in regard to Maine Law 20-A, MRSA Chapter 303, and the Federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. Maine is transitioning responsibility for early childhood special education to local school districts in phases.
This means that children with disabilities found eligible for an IEP between ages 3 and 5 need support. It's not a universal preschool requirement. The district already has space for 4- and 5-year-olds with IEPs, so the challenge seems to be specifically about 3-year-olds.
So how many 3-year-olds with IEPs are projected for 2027? How much space do they need? That number feels like the foundation of this entire conversation. Scenario 2 and 3 both ask panel to bear a disproportionate share of the change.
We're requesting detail on what outcomes these scenarios are projected to deliver for students, for families, and for the district's finances. So there are four questions that we hope the board will strongly consider. One, regarding early childhood programming. What is the projected number of three-year-olds with IEPs for 2027 and how much space is needed?
That single data point would help the community evaluate whether these scenarios are truly necessary. Two, regarding middle school equity. What specific metrics demonstrate a meaningful gap between Freeport and Durham? We're hopeful that there may be ways to address any inconsistencies without full restructuring.
Three, regarding financial sustainability, we're excited about the opportunity for RSU-5 to leverage modern productivity tools to drive efficiencies within its central office. Has the district examined whether it's spending on non-teaching administrative roles
is producing commensurate results for students? And four, lastly, regarding community identity, Powell Elementary School is the beating heart of a small, close-knit community. We ask that proposals of this scale be accompanied by the facts, data, and studies needed to demonstrate
that they've been rigorously vetted and are expected to deliver better outcomes for children. Yeah, thank you for your time. Thank you, Ian. Okay, so thank you for everyone who came tonight, and obviously for those who took the time to share their feelings and their thoughts and their perspectives,
There was a lot of great ideas, so I just want to acknowledge that and thank everyone for doing that. I know it's not easy to get up and speak in front of a group, so thank you for that, and we will continue on with our agenda.
So we will move on to item 8, which is the report from the superintendent. Hi, everybody. I don't know how I can follow much of that. I'm not as eloquent as many of the people who just spoke, And some of my remarks tonight will be aimed at some of the questions that you have.
But I do have some other things to talk about, too. So the last time I gave a formal report was January 28th, because they are usually reserved for the last meeting of the month, which this is. There's been a lot that's happened since then. There's been budget work, obviously. There's been this conversation about longer-term possibilities for district configuration.
there's the strategic plan which had a really thoughtful presentation from Maria and some other board members last time we met and there's the weather which has kind of made its presence known lately I'm going to start with the
weather it usually seems like a safe conversation starter as of today we have used five of four of the five snow days that we have built into the school calendar. And we're about halfway through winter, although it feels like there's still a lot of
winter left. Halfway? About. About. It's Maine. So understandably, I'm getting questions at this point about what are we going to do if we exceed the five days? Nobody wants to be in school on the 4th of July. So I want to tell the board and the public we are looking at options, and we've been
talking about these options, and there is, well, I've asked for an adjustment to the agenda tonight to talk about the school calendar. So the options that I'm going to share with you now are what the team and I have discussed as the most reasonable path forward with this. The first thing is I'm
going to ask you tonight to change the school calendar to convert the March 13th professional learning day, which is a teacher day but a non-student day, to a half-student day. That gets it to count as a whole day, and it makes up a snow day. And we can condense the PD down
to a half day, and it seems to be the best choice that we can make at the moment, at least from my perspective and the team's perspective. We've looked into operationally what we can do to make that work. We can do it with minimal disruption. So if you approve that change
tonight, that is not a done deal because it has to be then approved by the Commissioner of Education, but I have got that application ready to go as long as I get a vote and I can click send and hopefully get a yes on that. So assuming that is granted, right now our last day
of school is Tuesday, June 23rd for kids. That would scale it back to Monday, June 22nd. So that's one day. That would mean we've basically used three snow days. I don't think it's done snowing though. So the next thing we've talked about is, okay, what's the next plan?
We talked about remote learning days, which have not been a practice in this district for some time since COVID. When I arrived here last summer, I asked about whether that was a practice here. It is in some districts. It's not in others. I was told pretty emphatically that that was a
practice that was deliberately moved away from after the pandemic. I get it. I support that, actually. The reasons for that are both instructional and logistical. Remote learning is not the same as in-person learning. It is just not. It is a poor substitute. And that is
particularly true the younger the kids get. And it's also a real burden for working families to have to make up, you know, do a remote day. So that said, what we're weighing, it's all about, like, what's the path, what's the best way to thread a needle? And that seems to be the nature
of my job these days. We're laying that against not wanting to be in school on the 4th of July. So we are looking right now at a school year that ends past the summer solstice already, even with making it up with the March PD day. So I am proposing that we keep remote days in reserve,
and I am going to suggest that we use them if we get past five days. So rolling past that March day would bring us back to three. That would give us two more days and if we get to two more days that would mean the last day of school is Wednesday, June 24th and then if we got to a sixth snow day
we would kick in with remote days and we are putting the plan in place to make that work. Here are the other options that we could do. I'm going to tell you right now they're just far less desirable. We could lengthen the school day by an hour for a week. That's five hours. That is
enough to gain back one day. That has been done in this district in the past, something I've lived through in the past. Is it fun? No. Is it good? Is that last hour of the day really good learning in a first or second grade or even a 12th grade classroom? Nope. Does it disrupt sports? Does it
disrupt everybody's schedule? Yes. Is it highly problematic? Yes. Can we do it? Yes. The other option is you can have school on a Saturday. I've lived through that too. Again, not fun. You have to make sure that enough kids actually come so that you can count it as a day. It's not a great
option. It is something in the arsenal. I think it's better for us to use remote days, but to keep Endman Reserve and go out the full five days that are accounted for on our calendar as it exists. So that's sort of like the plan
for the weather. So part of that involves you voting tonight on the March PD day, and then if we have to go to remote days, I would need to have you vote on that as well, but I'm going to save that for the next meeting. The voting on remote days is not on the agenda tonight.
Okay, so the budget. Talking about just next year's budget not the longer-term budget we have time on the agenda to discuss this more deeply tonight I want to provide some context for that conversation Colin had asked a question I think it was Colin at the last meeting
about what would happen going forward not just next year but the year after that and the year after that if we keep the budget as a status quo budget or if we make reductions. So, to project that far forward, it gets much less precise as you go out
each year. And it's also a heck of a lot of work. And I have to tell you that Kelly is, I didn't do that work. Kelly Wentworth has done that work. So, kudos to Kelly, who has really been doing a lot for our district lately. But I asked her to project what our budgets would look like out through FY29.
So that's three years in two scenarios. One is if we keep a status quo budget with no reductions, and the other is if we make reductions at the level that I recommended, which is that Tier 2 level. So again, reckoning that these are estimates and imprecise and less precise the further you go out, I do have some information for you. So without reductions, the projected increases for next year,
that's fiscal year 27, is about 10.5%, which is not new information to you. But then if we go out to fiscal year 28, it's another 8.5%. And if we go out to fiscal year 29, it's another 8.9%. And that assumes lots of things. It assumes, for example, that the raises across the board for staff
are going up at the level that they are going up now. We have a teacher contract to negotiate in the middle of all that. We're negotiating a support staff contract now. Who knows what's happened, what happens with other things in the world. So those are projections. This contrasts
with the way it would look at the recommended level, my recommended level. If you accept that proposal, it comes in at about six and a half percent for next year, which is again not new information. The year after that, it comes in at about 5.6 percent, and the year after that at
about 5.9 percent. Are those still significant increases? Yes. There are towns that are nearby our district that have been flat for a long time, which means effectively a reduction every year. So those are still significant increases, but I would expect that they are more likely to be
within the range that we can responsibly present to the community. So again, those things, those are not hard and fast figures. Please don't, you know, hold me to those as time goes on. There are best estimates at the current moment. So, and last, I want to talk more about the ideas that got shared
two weeks ago. And I have a little script here for myself that I always make, and I always sort of loosely follow it, but I'm going to go off of it for the moment. And I just want to say that I'm sorry. Genuinely, this is really hard. And I have nothing but the most respect for Palinol, the
school, the community. I didn't come here with the idea of wanting to disrupt a community school. I did open this up because, in my opinion, anything that is not talkable is toxic. And these are ideas that I've, since I arrived here six, seven, eight months ago, whatever it was,
I've realized have been talked about in the margins since before I got here. And it is the moment now that they come out into the open and get discussed here in the board and with the community with full participation. I think the comments that I heard tonight were about the healthiest public
conversation I've heard in a long time. I didn't hear a single disrespectful comment. I heard productive, heartfelt comments. And I don't know what the decision will be, but that is commendable and I respect it. It is clear that this has generated strong feelings and that is understandable.
And as I said when I presented, identity is a non-quantifiable factor and it's impossible for us to know how much it should weigh in the decision until the idea is put out there and we see how it lands in the community. I want to emphasize that there cannot be a decision about this tonight
or the next board meeting or any time soon. This is a conversation starter. It is not a conversation ender because you don't have enough information to make a decision yet. A lot of the questions that were raised here were completely valid questions.
The scenarios that I presented two weeks ago were the three scenarios that have emerged since we started really talking about it at the administrative team level in the few months since I've been here. There could be any number of other ideas that surface. My intention is to, knowing how much effort and investment it takes
to actually flesh out any scenario. It takes investment not just of time, but of district resources, money, to actually figure out how to go forward. And one of those is something I'm going to ask you about tonight as well. So my intention two weeks ago was to make the conversation open
and make the topic talkable and to see if we should go forward with any conversation. I am still hearing that that conversation needs to go forward. a lot of conversation needs to go forward. So here are what I think the next steps should be.
The first step is really what we're doing tonight, which is just that a community had a bombshell dropped on it, and there needs to be a lot of space to listen and to just allow for the feelings that naturally come up around that
and the ideas that surface around that. That's not just a this board meeting thing. That's an ongoing thing. So in addition to public comment like tonight and the opportunity to email the board I do think we should consider some
structured opportunities for the rest of this school year for community input that is sound information for the board I have personally offered to go to the select boards in panel and in Durham I'm in the process of trying to get those scheduled I understand I heard yesterday that I've been in particular going back
and forth with the town clerk in panel to try to figure out a time that works I I understand that it appeared on the town calendar that I was coming there like Monday or Tuesday, but that was a mistake, and then it got removed, and it looked like somehow I didn't cancel a meeting.
We just haven't figured out when the schedules line up yet. Oh, where was I? Let's see. It happens when you go off script. That is what happens when you go off script. Second, there's some concrete information that you need to be able to make this decision
that we just don't have yet. One of the best ways we could get that is through an objective professional facility study by an architectural firm. That is something that I've seen done in other districts that faced this issue,
particularly in RSU 3, where I was a few years ago, that faced the closure of two small schools very much like Powell. A facility study is going to provide a very detailed and professional analysis of the infrastructure of the district.
each building, the capacity of each building, the highest use of those spaces, how much we're paying for them, what the infrastructure in those buildings would cost and what its expected lifespan is, and how else they could be used.
So that's the kind of insight that we need far more than what the admin team and I can think of during our rich and informed discussions on this topic, but professionals who specialize in that are going to be able to give you much more specific information.
So I'm going to ask you to actually approve some money from Capital Reserve tonight so that we can move forward in putting a facility study out to bid, because that's a process that by itself takes months just to get that going.
And then in the nearer term, I just have some advice for the members of the board. And it is simply that I really think each of you needs to reflect on the values that should drive the decision. It's going to be a different mix for each of you. And it's not going to be one value. It's going to be multiple values.
It's not for me to tell you what they are. It's for you to decide what they are. It's for the community to decide what they are. Is it equity? Is it community sentiment? Is it a long-term vision? Those are things that have kind of come up, but I think that's what you need to think about now
and give yourself think time and thought partners in that process. What values will come to bear on your decision and how you will vote? Because as I mentioned before, and I've had some training in ethical decision making, and I want to dig a little deeper into a thought that I laid out last time.
An ethical dilemma is not a right versus wrong situation. That's a moral dilemma. An ethical dilemma is when you have two things that are right in and of themselves, and they come into conflict with each other. It's a right thing versus another right thing, and somewhere one of them has to give, and that's what you have here. And ethical dilemmas typically fall into four paradigms, by the way. Those four paradigms are truth versus loyalty.
Are you going to tell the truth about what your friend did, or are you going to remain loyal to your friend? Individual versus community, long-term versus short-term, and justice versus mercy. I won't go into more detail than that, but I'm sure you can think of a million situations in which
you have two right values, and they come into conflict with each other, and they fit somehow into one or more of those paradigms. Certainly this decision that we have about how to go forward as a district, touches on more than one of them. So I'm going to suggest that at some point this,
before the school year ends, we dedicate some time to awaited, to discussing the values that should underlie this decision. And that is not a binding conversation. It's not a vote, but it's letting the thought process and the feeling process play out in front of the community,
which the community deserves. Because our responsibility is to just be transparent about the tensions between those values and how we see them and in the end how you vote based on them and my role is not to decide that my role is to help frame this discussion and to provide the
information that you need and to do my best to facilitate a thoughtful and open process and the decision itself is yours that's what I got tonight thank you I do have a couple of resignations to announce um meredith hook uh the librarian at moore street school and panel has
resigned and jeremy arsenal the director of transportation has resigned effective the end of the year so we have just posted for a new director of transportation and that will be a big his our big shoes to fill and i believe an email went out to the community if folks are
interested in being on that hiring committee yes yes so check your emails if you're interested in being involved in that okay so we will move on to item 9 which is administrator reports and we have Sean Shabbat from region 10 technical high school welcome
Sean thank you for coming back thank you for having us we have some slides that I'd like to share with the board and the public and there are some handouts too if anybody in the audience would like to see it not this evening so again thank
you for having us here tonight Sybil Brewer our school business managers with us and helped create a lot of this work that we did for you tonight this first information is region 10 four-year enrollment increase over the past four
years and you can see with a totality of we have gained nearly 40 percent enrollment over the past four years at region 10 between the three sending districts so our numbers have grown substantially from 285 and 20 22 23 to
we're just over 400 as we stand today and we anticipate next year being up close to 450 and then the next slide please is the four-year enrollment of freeport high school students and you can see those are year by year and the the total number
is nearly eighty percent more students from freeport high school attend region 10 than they did in 22 23 so i just give that as some context for our budget presentation tonight um that our numbers certainly are increasing and that's a positive thing um and we support that obviously
that's good for students and cte certainly um career and technical education that's an acronym that we all use in education has grown in popularity and I think folks in the communities of all three districts see the value across not only the our
sending districts but across the state and across the nation of career and technical education so the next slide is our proposed budget that we presented to our Finance Committee back in the middle of February and then we had
another meeting this past Monday night with our Finance Committee and our full school committee our cooperative board which Valerie and Colin both sit on and we discussed our proposed increases and of note you can see the we made some
cuts from our initial entry of what we collected for information from our staff with that given given that increase in enrollment initially we felt like we needed to add more ed tech support for those students. And we're simply not able to do that
and still be responsible. So we had cut the one and a half ed tech positions from our budget. We had looked at increasing our EMT program from a half-time program to a full-time program. And while the numbers were probably going to be there, it wasn't a guarantee at this time. And so
we've kept it like that. And then we had one vacancy that we filled and we were able to make some vacancy adjustments. And then you can see on that list in blue, the associated other adjustments that we reduced the budget. And we came in at just over 8.6%, which is more than we
like to be to be quite frank i was shooting for more like five or six percent and um without negatively impacting students um the board was the finance committee was pretty clear with me that they weren't going to support that because what the next cut was going to be
student supplies instructional materials and supplies and in a cte environment you can well imagine you cannot do culinary arts without food or you can't do a carpentry what we call building trades without lumber or metal fabrication and
welding without welding materials and if you built a house or remodeled your house or go grocery shopping every week over the past couple of years you know the cost of that and we face those same costs in addition region 10 was built in
1983 and building is aging like lots of schools from the state we applied for a school revolving renovation fund grant and that's the next slide and that that while we didn't get everything we asked for and most like most people nobody
ever gets everything they want they the state did cost share our upgrade to our fire panel that needs to be upgraded and if you've been to region 10 and you come into the building we have a camera and you get buzzed in from the foyer but there is no visual line of sight
besides the camera for allowing people to access the building and in my in my opinion and others that's not the best safety even though we have a camera and a door locking buzz system we would like to put in a pass-through window so that way when visitors come or guests come we can put eyes
on visually and sometimes you can just limit that interaction of actually coming in the building by passing through a child left their book at home or that something needs to be passed through from the outside and you don't need to allow that person into the building so those two upgrades
were approved by the state and that local share increased the cost cost share up to nine point six three percent that you see there and then the next page is some of our largest budget drivers as was mentioned before in the previous
discussion salaries is one of our main cost drivers like every school budget our salaries are up near over 10% our collective bargaining agreement with our instructors takes the weighted average of our three sending districts so whenever you do rsu5 does a collective bargaining agreement with your teachers
that directly impacts our teachers as well our teachers receive the weighted average of the three sending districts to be fair we also have five vacancies we have retirements coming up which is unusual for region 10 usually we have folks stay until they retire but this year unfortunately have a couple of five
vacancies coming up and they're all retirements and when when you have a small staff you have to budget for the high end we can't do an average of some some look some folks coming in at high some low we have a smaller budget smaller
number so we budget for the high end of the scale and full family because if we hire somebody and then they have a family we have to pay those medical benefits in that which makes sense so that costs we have to budget for that we are starting our hvac
program we tried to do that a few years ago and it wasn't successful our instructor that we had hired left after a couple months and we moved the children us children students high school students into other programs but this year we feel confident fingers crossed that we'll be able to hire an
and we've been doing our recruitment for the past couple of months and that program is nearly full between the three districts so that's that's positive you can see our average teacher and structure instructor is that nearly a
7% average increase and that's a direct result of those collective bargaining agreements and our budgeting for health insurance and dental insurance is we budgeted, we put a placeholder of 12%. I know some districts around are doing 15%. We were at 10%
last year, and so we felt like it was comfortable to be at 12%. Then you can see the SRRF loan payment, if the voters approve that. And then with an aging building, we are facing other repair costs for that building, and we maxed out that budget line early in the fall this past year. And so we
anticipate probably more things. If you own an older home, you know what I'm talking about. You can refer to that. And then the last page, smaller print, and again, there's extra copies over here if anyone would like to look at it in more detail. It's a three-year comparison of the Region 10
budget, so you can compare year over year. There's enrollment numbers in there, our projected enrollment of next year of nearly 450 students and new this year we also put in a cost per pupil and that is not to compare region 10 cost per pupil I just want to be clear to any school
district we don't have a central office we don't have transportation costs per se we don't have a nutrition department we don't have special education English language learners where we have a whole programs for that so to compare our costs and say how come other
districts are so much higher it wouldn't be apples and apples we put it on there to demonstrate and hopefully show that our cost per pupil per year has gone down over the past three years so the point of that is I think we're doing a
decent job of trying to do more with with us without asking the taxpayers for for additional revenue as much as possible, trying to be good stewards of your tax payer's dollars. So you can see in there that Region 10 of overall your school district's budget
is still at less than 1% of your overall budget. And our goal is always to remain under 1%. So we hopefully find you feeling like that is a good value for your high school students to gain a career in technical education. And I'm happy to answer any questions that you
may have now or any time in the future. Thank you, Sean. Questions for Sean? Okay, thank you. I have some. I just try to open it up to them first, so I give them a second first. A couple of questions. One, the loan piece, the surf loan, is this similar to what was done for the bridge
couple years ago where there's a separate question on the ballot for that yes it's exactly the same process the same loan same loan program if you will and so our board has tentatively given us the thumbs up to move ahead with that and they don't approve our budget until the march school
cooperative board meeting which is what the 16th simple 16th but yes if that's approved it will go out to referendum in the June primary along with the other Warren articles that for supporting of the schools okay great and that's a zero interest loan
from the state yes it's a zero percent interest loan from the state thank you for that question I should have said that Sybil would kill me if I walked away without saying that zero percent interest loan in the state and nearly
50%, 47 point, it's in my notes, nearly 50%, 47 point, I can't remember exactly, is forgiven by the state. So we have to pay just under 53%, and the other main balance is forgiven. Okay, great. Thank you. And I know this is primarily a budget discussion, but you're
here so I didn't ask you probably know what I'm gonna ask which is you know the discussion around a centralized regional technical school that's full-time sure so as you know and we've talked about in the past that region 10 has explored the option and we did a feasibility study similar to
what you folks are talking about for buildings but this was is could a four-year comprehensive high school... Comprehensive, that was the word. Yes. Could a four-year comprehensive CTE school be feasible? And we did that work, hired an outside consultant, presented it to folks. It was.
But in order for us to move forward with anything like that, there needs to be legislative changes in Augusta by state statute. We don't issue diplomas. Region 10 CTE schools don't do that. The sending schools obviously do that. So until there would be state statute changes, that is still a goal of ours.
It was a clear goal that the cooperative board set for me when I arrived at Region 10, and we've worked towards that. But that is something that until legislative changes occur in Augusta, that will not take place. They can't move forward. Yeah, so just to continue with that thought just for a second,
We are maintaining that and trying to move forward with that. But at the same time, on a parallel track, working to grow options for students within the CTE traditional umbrella that we've always had. So we're doing two parallel tracks at the same time. Based on the enrollment figures, it looks like you're doing a great job with that. Thank you. Certainly not me. It is the team that we have at Region 10. It's a good team. And the percentage that is allocated to the sending districts How often is that? Is it every year that we figure out the percentage that each sending district has?
Is it a fixed amount that's looked at every so many years? It's based on the cooperative agreement, which is based on the U.S. Census of the total population, not the student population, the total population of the three sending districts.
Got it. Thank you. So it's every 10 years, yes. You may have answered this in the past. This is my second board meeting. Are there a number of slots that are allotted to each of the school districts that are part of your school?
Or if suddenly a hundred more kids wanted to come from Freeport, that would be available for them? The answer is no to that for a hundred more students. So yes to your first part of that question. Based on the cooperative agreement, you can see those percentages based for the percentage of participation for the rates on the bottom of your chart is roughly Brunswick is at 38.17, MSAD 75, which is 36.44, and RSU 5, which is 25.39.
So every year, the slots that are open for new students, we divide those out based on that percentages, and we have an admissions process that we work with all the sending school counselors, the sending school principals, to discuss that.
We try to be very transparent with a number of slots per program that are available for each of the sending schools. Enrollment for what we call phase two closes actually this coming week. And then we meet as a team with each school to discuss how many slots, again, how many slots they have, the list of students that they would like to help prioritize for those slots.
and then after that takes place in mid-March, then whatever number of slots is open at that time is a rolling admissions sort of first come, first serve until all the slots are full. Does that answer your question? Maybe? Yes, it does. Yeah, I think I'm all set. Thank you. So yes, we try to proportion out slots initially for every sending school based on that percentages and then if they're not filled, it's a rolling admissions sort of like college. So the extra 50 slots next year that you're anticipating,
is that the HVAC program? It's not a 50 slots. It's our anticipated number of students that will attend Region 10. We could take up over 500 total, but we're anticipating being at about 450 students. I see. And is it because of the HVAC program? That's one of the reasons, yes. Okay, thank you. Bye. Thank you, Shannon, for your presentation. As you might imagine, most of it is familiar to me. I was hoping you could speak a little bit to the board, because I've mentioned it a few times, but I thought it might be worth coming from the horse's mouth, the expansion, transition to the landing.
Oh, yeah. Thank you. So, this past, thank you for that question, Valerie. This past year, we partnered with Maine Maritime Academy at the landing, the old Naval Air Station in Brunswick. Maine Maritime signed a long-term lease with the realty group that owned the old commissary building, which was the Wayfair building, for a number of years.
And they have turned that into a learning center. We started a new program called Pre-Engineering Architectural Design there this year, where students are earning Maine Maritime credit concurrently. And we're looking at, and the board approved the plan to expand further into on that base and add our HVAC program over there, move our electrical program over there, our pre-apprenticeship program, and our IT cybersecurity.
That would open up space in our main building because we do have a portable up front that they brought in during the COVID time, during the pandemic. And it would allow us, because our lease is up on our portable, our five-year lease, to decommission that, get rid of that.
And so we would no longer be paying that payment for the lease. And the money we were paying for the portable would go for leasing out the space with Maine Maritime. So that's been a great partnership with them. the students have done a great job it seems to have gone really well so we're looking to expand there if that continues and works well we'll look at the
possibility of further expansion on there work our classrooms are completely full we cannot expand anymore inside the building region 10 building without looking at other opportunities and we wanted to leverage Maine Maritime who have been nothing but great partners BIW who has supported us and the space that
they have over there. So we're trying to make it a win-win for everyone. Any other questions for Sean? Happy to come back anytime you'd like us. Thank you. I know last year we had a tour for Region 10. Was that last year that the board did that? I think it was two years ago. Was it two
years? It was great. So I don't know if people are interested in that, but it was very, very educational for me to see the, you know. You're more than welcome to come see the new bridge Yeah, that was not there when we did it. That's right. Thank you very much. Thank you. Okay, so Kelly, Finance.
A little shorter than Sean. Good evening. In your board packets tonight, in your purple sheet, I think Jenny's still color-coded, yes. In the purple sheet are your expenditures through January 31st, 2025 for the current budget
year, budget to actual. I was just reviewing where we were last year at this time, and our percentages are strangely identically on so we are about fifty six point five percent collected on the revenue side and we are for expenditures we're ninety one point eight percent
expended and encumbered I don't see any issues within the budget lines at this time and so as far as the local budget is concerned we do we did talk this evening and we'll talk a little bit later and if you want me to mention it
now Michelle that there's a proposal that you'll see tonight there have been some unfunded positions within the special education department we've had them advertised all year haven't been able to fill them so that's allowing us
to have some additional monies available within article 2 which is our special education line to help facilitate the position that you will be considering a little later and I'd be happy to talk about that later when we come up but the
proposal from the superintendent today regarding the facility study needed to continue the work for the future of RSU 5 that is actually being proposed to come out of the capital reserve account which sits outside of the local budget not reflected in these questions for Kelly and just in case anyone gets like
you know anxiety hearing that we've collected 56% of revenues and expended 91% of expenses, that's encumbrances too. So for full year salaries and things we know we're going to pay for the full year, we encumber those early. So we are not, we're not out over our skis as some
might say. Right. And, you know, our revenue sources are pretty solid. We're funded through taxation and state subsidy. So while we do receive them on a monthly basis, both the subsidy and the taxation amounts from each of the participating communities. So it's
in line for where we would actually be normally. Right. So we haven't spent 91%. We just know we will spend it, so we kind of set it aside. Correct. You notice that when we do our first report out in September and we've encumbered all of the returning staff salaries and benefits, that's when you really see that percent encumbered and expended change. Thank you.
Okay, board comments and committee reports. So board information exchange and agenda requests. So this is where I'm going to look to Anna if she wanted, I think she wanted to share something on a committee meeting. She wanted to provide an update, so I apologize. It was fine. I was just wondering, so the curriculum committee, which is right now just me and Karen, we've been meeting about once a month, sometimes a little bit more, which from my understanding previously, curriculum committee was only meeting like twice a year.
And it just seemed to make good sense to share what we've been learning, if it would make sense for us to kind of have a time to give an update. yes so I think any committee that wants to in this point can always do that but
we can also add it like we have facilities and finance like if you if you think it would be helpful to include that there yeah that would be great and just to share quickly what we did met two weeks ago Karen is that right yeah
and we spoke about next-gen science and learned a little bit about our science curriculum and it's really interesting we've also talked about math that's a big priority area right now for the curriculum and I did make a request to
learn about our reading curriculum as well and we'll just keep sharing updates as we continue to meet great thank you so I'm just going to look to Lois because we were talking about curriculum committee and as a new board member we
were going through orientation and committees and I think I told her that or the shoot said they you guys meet like three times a year so I said I think there's only one more for the year but it sounds like there might be more so if you're interested maybe I'll find out how many more maybe one was it was a
selling point as opposed to monthly fair enough great thank you so then I will found out at the finance committee that I'm apparently I'm the chair of that committee did I miss that meeting is that what happened usually that's what
happens you get you get nominated for something so I will just quickly go over the Finance Committee minutes from our January meeting you know primarily because this was the meeting where the original budget the superintendent's
budget was presented to the board Kelly and Tom provided us with the proposals that were going to be presented to the full board that evening. And so we just got a little bit of a sneak peek before that and were able to ask some initial questions and prompt some feedback.
We met again tonight. But I don't have the minutes for that yet, so you'll just have to wait and see next meeting. I mean, I know, but you don't have the paper in front of you. Kelly, I already told you some of the stuff we talked about because it's going to be coming back shortly with the facility study and the early childhood education.
So I will send it to Kelly for facilities. Facilities and Operations Committee met on Wednesday, February 11th, and as many people know, the FHS tennis courts have been on our minds quite a bit lately, especially since they have been officially condemned for play.
so it's really important that we move forward with a plan to get them replaced quickly. Director Reynolds updated the committee that the contract for design services was signed, and our vendor CHA has scheduled this, or I guess it was completed on 2-18,
although we haven't gotten core sampling yet. So that's the next step before we move forward with the tennis court design phase. The Energy Audit, Phase 1, Glenn updated the committee that the lighting project has been completed at Poundell Elementary School in the district office, and the lighting vendor is working in the middle school right now, and then will, after that, move to the mass landing school to replace the lights with new LED energy-efficient lighting.
Okay, very good to know. New lights are really great, Director says, Superintendent. okay dcs automation um glenn said that the contract has been signed and our vendor emc has bid out the project to um and it has been awarded to main controls so that project will
be moving forward soon and fine uh actually not finally we have a couple more things we have we had a guest come and give us some feedback i'm going to skip to that really quickly Molly Meyer she's our FHS tennis court coat I'm sorry tennis coach and she
shared some information regarding the application for the USTA grant that will be important for helping us offset the cost for the new tennis courts so Molly provided the committee with some documentation showing what information will be needed for the approval of the grant and also shared that the grant
would be estimated to be awarded at between 25 and 35 thousand dollars per court for a maximum amount of a hundred fifty thousand dollars okay back to the baseball dugout roof we've had some money donated by our boosters for the
replacement of the baseball dugout roofs there are two roofs that need to be replaced at the baseball dugouts at Freeport High School and they estimated cost for the replacements about three thousand dollars the new roofs will be
the same as the current ones they are metal and so that makes it easy if the dugouts themselves need to be replaced which will happen sometime in the future it will be easy enough for us to just reuse the metal roofs and put them on the new structures so they are planning on replacing those roofs by mid-march
before the baseball season begins and that's about all we talked about. I think the metal roofs that they're putting in are the same as the current the new ones that were done in the softball fields. I don't think the current baseball fields are metal if I'm correct. I'm seeing him nod so
they've replaced the softball ones a few years ago when they redid the field and those ones are metal. Okay yes I do see that. So they'll match the ones that are on the softball fields now. And then the other thing I don't know if we mentioned this or not because what the last time when we were talking about the tennis court update and we had the vote to initiate the
engineering work, there was some discussion around asking the engineer if they could provide us with some costing information for both of the two different types. And they have agreed to do that at no additional cost. We won't get full prints or plans for any projects until we pick the one
that we want, but we will get general costing for both types, as well as whether we currently have three, whether there's the ability to add the fourth court. So all of the work that they were already going to provide, they'll give us the option of what they both look like, and then when
we decide which way we want to go, then they would draft up sort of full bidding documents to get a full cost estimate. Is it realistic that that's going to be able to be the tennis court revamp done by for next season so next season being 27 yeah yes that's what we're told okay yeah i got a
shrug from the back so my understanding is they're hoping to be done no later than september is that correct glenn september october hopefully so it may not be ready for the middle school season but for the high school season it looks it looks likely yeah it's tough with the weather is that
our timer that we're done talking. Any other questions on the facilities update? Tara? Can you say again what the DCS automation replacement is? What is that? So the system that they use for the swipe cards, what that was put in when they built the school 15,
16 years ago? Actually, that's not it. That's not it? No, it has to do with the climate control in the building. Oh, I lied. And it's the, Glenn's now nodding. Yeah, it has to do with managing the flow of the air within the building so that it's efficient and it's going to
where it needs it. I don't think he believes you because he's coming up to talk. Oh, he's right? It's the building automation system that runs the HVAC, your boilers, your ventilators and so forth. So we just installed it here at the high school and also at the middle school.
So it's not something that failed from the original? It is over at Durham, yes. That's failed and that's what we just signed a contract for and that's going to be installed. We had projected in the energy audit to do that in the next phase, but it's failed, so
we moved it up to this phase because it needed to get done. Okay, so we knew it was coming. Yeah, it was going to be in phase two. We just pulled it out so we could do it now. In phase one. Bye. Are these the pumps that are the bane of Chris's existence or a different thing entirely?
That's the geothermal system. Yes. Wait, those are the bane of Chris's existence? You don't like them? We just kept replacing them. Oh. And they got expensive. So that's what I was talking about. This is the system that runs the pumps. Yeah. Okay. Other facility... Thank you, Glenn. Other facility questions, comments? All right. Moving on. Policy. Colin. Hey, y'all. So we met on Wednesday, February 5th at 4.15 on Google Meet.
And we were joined by a number of administrators to discuss the two policies that we're bringing to you tonight for first read we looked at JIC which is student code of conduct and JEA compulsory attendance and so we'll be talking about those a little bit later after we talk
about the second read and just to note for our public I just I like seeing all of these people here so I'm just going to say that these policy meetings are are open to the public, and we encourage folks to attend, and if they would like to attend,
they can do so and bear witness to what we're doing. The public's not permitted to speak at those meetings because we want anything that the public says to be communicated to the entire board because the policy committee has no power itself. So we encourage folks to attend and also to reach
out with any thoughts that they have to the board email. That's a good point. We don't tell folks as often as maybe we could or should that all of committee meetings are open to the public but run along that same methodology. The policy, I believe, is the only one that's run
virtually. All the others are in person. Is that true? But all of those agendas and scheduling is on the rsu5 website let me get a motion on the floor all right so we will move on to item 11 which is policy review do i have a motion for consideration and approval for the second read
for the following policies j-i-c-k bullying and j-i-c-k-r bullying administrative procedure kelly thank you steph great um so we're bringing before you j-i-c-k bullying and the associated Administrative Procedure, G-I-C-K-R. This is for second read. So at our last meeting, we
presented you the work that we had done in our previous policy meetings to bring, to make sure that our bullying policy procedures were in alignment with all appropriate codes and also just cleaned up to make sure that they represent our best practice of what we're doing currently.
There have been changes made to those policies since you saw them. So we are asking for your approval of those tonight. Okay, so these, we didn't have you changing anything on these. These are exactly what we saw last time. I believe so. I don't, we may have made some periods and there may have been some super pedantic things
that Carol wanted us to get into, but otherwise... Carol does love the pedantic. Hey, you need those people on every committee. Oh, I'm very grateful. Chris is going to up his pedant game. I have no doubt. Just, uh, we're competing currently.
Any comments or questions? Okay, we have a motion and a second on the floor. All those in favor? None opposed. Thank you. Um, we're also bringing two, um, policies for, um, uh, for first read. I neglected to mention that, um, in our, um, and this is for all of you, but also for our guests, um, that there are
three reasons we will review policies. One is a law change, the other is part of a regular five-year process, and the other is at board request. So these two policies that we'll bring before you, JEA, compulsory attendance, and GIC, system-wide student code of conduct,
those we are updating because of law change. So I'm going to just give you a kind of like top-level overview. I'm not going to go through the actual document, but I'm going to give you some highlights of what was changed to bring us into compliance with law. And then my colleagues on the committee would care to share anything, or Tom, if I miss anything, please throw it in. So let's look. What's the first one? Is it JEA? Yes. Just in order? Okay. Ba-ba-ba-ba. Okay. So basically, the bottom line here is that we're updating this to reflect changes in current practice in main attendance and truancy law. And we're making the policy also internally clearer and more usable for us.
And so a few things to note here. We are making some clarification around sort of kindergarten rules and compulsory age attendance. Um, we also, um, were making sure that religious observances, I think we're making changes to religious observances, so now there is no pre-approval required by law, um, for religious observance.
So we're making sure that that is there. Otherwise, we were just working on improving the logic of the policy itself and also making sure that the cross-references are accurate. Let's get a motion on the floor and then we can talk about them. How's that? I already talked about it. Yeah, okay. No, I mean... No, I know, I know, I know. Do you want to take a motion from these two together? Yes, we generally... Because we haven't talked about students. But does it matter? I just want to get it on the floor so we don't forget to... Put it on the floor. Let's put it on the floor. let's get into it erica's itching to write it down i can see it all right erica for you do i have a
motion for consideration and approval for the first read for the following policies jic student code of conduct and jea compulsory attendance kara thank you and chris okay uh so you want to talk about questions for compulsory attendance first yes so just everything that i just said
before. I said just now, and so now we can discuss it. Love that. Questions? On page three of four in the compulsory school attendance section, it's not really a question, it's a comment, and I believe that maybe Kara is also an editor. There's a word missing under the section credit
for attendance at a private school that's then been crossed out the bottom line says from the private is file it should say from the private school I believe I just want to make sure that the language is correct yeah but what you don't understand Lewis is that like I'm a poet so like
I can like I can break the language in like all sorts of different ways and like that sort of thing is just sort of acceptable I'm even new here but that sort of thing is totally acceptable gotten it. For 40 years I used a red pen. Exactly. So can we please add school to that, and it would be a slightly less interesting poem, but a more accurate policy document. It is noted. Other comments or questions? Valley.
On page two, I had two. One is possibly pedantic, and I'll go to that one first because it's easier. B5, At the very end, I can't tell what that punctuation is. Is a period, a colon, some semicolon? Why is it a semicolon? Thank you. That's my question. Again, it would be a cool problem, but let's make it a period.
I was like, what is this puzzle? The other thing I was wondering is, two, just as parent or guardian, do we need legal guardian, or is guardian sufficient? I believe guardian is our standardized language across the policies,
but I'm going to defer it to someone else. Okay. And then I'll just plow right into my possibly final question. I noticed that in this document, we call the district the school unit in many places. Am I slow and just didn't notice before, or is this the first document we started doing this? Okay, so I am slow. That's fine. Well, you may not have looked at all of them. There's a lot of them. It's fine. It reads funny to me, and I kept stumbling on it, so I wasn't sure if that's just a standard that we're using.
Okay, that's fine. Kelly. Since we're going for pedantics, I might as well mention one. On page three of four, actually, if you go to two of four, and you look at the heading for number five, it says attendance at public day school days crossed out,
but at the top of page three, it is not crossed out. If you'd like to be consistent, and again, totally up to you, You might want to cross it out in the actual language, the very top line. Yeah, good catch. Let day be stricken. So maybe this falls into your poetry phase that you're in.
That I'm in. I'm curious about the... I'm super invalidating this one. What, he just said he was. The first sentence, was that from the lawyers? Like, that seems very, like, so compulsory education is essential to the preservation of the rights and liberties of the people and the continued prosperity of our nation.
Like, that's very... No, we just thought that was super cool, man. We just, like, we came up with that ourselves. It was, like, off the dome. No, that came from the lawyers. It was from the sample policy. Wow, okay. I mean, I guess I'm not opposed to it. It just seemed like a very big entrance to this policy.
Just also to say, I'm going to use the singular pronoun. I have been trying to take a note from Tom to sort of reduce the amount of kind of beautifying that we do to the English language within the policies. So when we encounter something like that, we're trying to just kind of leave that alone.
It's a lawyer to write it that way. Yeah, it's really, really, really good. I mean, I found one poem. What poems are you reading? None. Okay. Other questions or comments on compulsory school attendance? All right. You want to move on to the other? Yes, please. The next one is... Hold on. Wait a second. Karen has a... I think you're talking about the semicolons. Okay. So, yeah, page 204. It's okay. Somebody else brought up the semicolons. Because it's one of the following sections, right? So A has a semicolon at the end. B has a semicolon at the end. C does not. D does not. So either they all have a semicolon. Karen, this is a beautiful observation, and I'm totally here for it.
Let, uh, I don't care. Right. So let's make them periods. Let's make them periods. Sure. Or you can trust the committee when we meet next time to have a good, solid discussion of that. Full faith and trust in this committee to figure out the right punctuation. Okay, great. So I can say in good faith, we can adopt the policy.
It's just first read. We can adopt, we can move it forward and clean this up. Absolutely, yeah. We're not tabling this for semicolons. Absolutely not. Lord, help us. Okay. All right, System-Wide Student Code of Conduct. So this is System-Wide Student Code of Conduct,
and again, this is bringing our Code of Conduct into alignment with the state laws, notably from 2021, and with really an eye toward discipline limits for grades 5 and below, and also updating protected class language. That accurately is those two things. Right, Tom? So how much detail would you like me to get into the substance of those?
Because I can get into it if you would like me to. In other words, what the law now requires, just so everybody's clear about it. Would you like me to do that? Is the age defined? Ending at fifth grade, is that specifically defined in the law?
The grade is what is defined, yes. So it's not age, it's grade. Thank you, yes. It limits suspension and expulsion in students' grades 5 and below, which is change in law. I'm trying to figure out, so on page 209, the bottom there, article 5,
so we created article 5, it says X, I think it was already article 5, we just struck the E, so now it just says expectations, but now everything else in that article has been struck? oh this is all still article five oh okay okay yeah good good call so yeah what is under article
five is what we find starting on um top of page five so that's violence threats weapons hazing discrimination harassment um etc and this is as laid out by the law yes uh yes yes my colleague all right thank you um i did have a question page five for weapons it explicitly says
knives and then says it elaborates that things that are not necessarily designed to be weapons and i'm struck similarly with our uh cell phone policy and the non-internet um items potentially being like a calculator instead of an abacus uh are we now banning like knives in the cafeteria
like how the other things firearms and explosives understandable probably no everyday use for those in a school um knives however there could be and is there is this a legal definition that we have to keep or are we putting ourselves in danger of not allowing people to butter their toast
this is from the sample policy that came from our attorneys um and the intent here is to not prevent butter knives in the cafeteria, but to, you know, prevent a makeshift shiv that some kid might bring in whittled out of a, I don't know, whatever. Yeah, I mean, the way I read that is the distinction in the two sentences is that, this is, again, what weapons be on page five. Students shall not possess or use weapons of any kind. So it's the possession and use. And then the second is specifically use. So I think the first is basically saying don't bring weapons. And then the second is saying, don't use something as a weapon. If you do, it will be treated as a weapon. It's not saying if you have a butter knife, it is a weapon. It's if you use a butter knife as a weapon, you've weaponized it, and therefore you will be responsible for that action.
Okay. Because I understand where you're coming from, though. Like, you literally put it as an example of things you can't have or use. It's not in the, like, don't use it poorly. we're a family that carries small knives as a scissor replacement for things like cutting off
tags and not you know stabbing people but benign uses that probably would be banned in school yeah i mean my kids don't currently carry knives then they are not currently in violation of the law that is fantastic for them so yeah, I mean again I think this is coming from the lawyers, this is the kind of language that just we in general do not mess with because as soon as we start messing with it it then creates something where if it is beyond what is legally detailed, then we become liable for those changes. So I think I am not going to modify
knives to knives except other than butter knives. I think we need to keep knives as it is. So I often struggle with these policies where we strike through multiple pages and add two new multiple pages, is there, you mentioned the change in the fifth grade and below, are there
any other material changes that we are either adding or removing? Yeah, let me, there's, what should we say about the restorative aspect, Tom? There definitely were, I made some notes that, that we're including positive and restorative interventions
for punitive steps. So that is just an important part of, again, we think it's an important part of what we should do as a school. It's also an important part of bringing us into alignment. The other is that the updated protected characteristics.
And so that list now includes race, color, sex, sexual orientation, gender, identity, religion, ancestry, national origin, and disability. So again, that is by law what we are. Thank you. We adopted a policy earlier in the year
that was to comply with the new law around restraint and seclusion. So this policy is congruent with that new policy. As Colin mentioned, it adds gender identity to the protected characteristics, which reflects the evolving civil rights landscape.
It has limits on physical restraint and seclusion. It includes, as permitted by law, language throughout the document where appropriate. And it updates all the other policy cross-references. So that was my last question. I would say this policy has probably more cross-references to other policies than any I've seen.
Are we sure that all of those other policies have been updated to be in alignment with this? No, we are not sure of that. um that is a good question um i'm not sure yeah let's take a look at that let's just take a look at what what might be impacted there i mean again the thing to remember for all of us um is that the
law always trumps our policy right so even if uh if like we make the changes to this and this is now accurately respect um reflecting policy i'm sorry reflecting law um and let's say we didn't uh update tobacco use and possession um but the law around that would still apply no matter what
we have in the policy oh absolutely i agree yeah that's for just the world um you know obviously like bullying cyberbullying we just looked at that one so i'm going to presume that one's probably in alignment but there's there's quite a few in here yep and some of them are a little more um
that is frequently looked at like bomb threats yeah um i think the other thing i just want to I do want to actually just go through the grade five adjustments there just because they're like they're actually quite specific and I think they're just important. So again, the limitations on expulsions, out of school suspensions and loss of recess for students in grade five and below. So that is the sort of the what has been what has been changed.
So, um, according to law, um, expulsion for grade five and below, um, is tied to federal, uh, gun-free schools act, um, and also the state policy around firearms. Um, the out-of-school suspension for grade five and below is, uh, is sharply limited, um, and there's an exception for two things.
One is for a Gun-Free Schools Act situation, a situation that falls under that, or, quote, imminent danger or serious physical injury and less restrictive interventions would be ineffective, end quote. So those would be the two reasons that an out-of-school suspension could be indicated.
There's also a hard cap on out-of-school suspensions for greater than three school days, which is important to note. And then also there are limits on recess withholding restrictions. So recess generally can't be withheld for K-5 discipline, except when recess is the only available time for restorative interventions.
And so the emphasis also there is on restorative, and that was something that was clarified for us by some of the administrators who visited us for that meeting. That was super helpful. Yeah, Lilith. Is it three days for each incident, or three days a year?
Yeah, I'm pulling from the law, And it doesn't state in the law, or it doesn't state in the language from the law that I'm pulling from, so I don't know the answer to that. So if you're saying for incident, then that would be each incident. Yeah, because it says any out-of-school suspension, which would be a specific incident, of grade
five or below, can be no longer than three school days. Yeah, yeah, good call. Other questions? So it's not about the fifth grade. Can I go to a different question? On the same page, number 10 at the top of the page above discipline.
Sorry, which page are you on? I'm on page 2 of 9. 2, okay. And I'm actually looking at number 9, not number 10. It says, refrain from cheating or plagiarizing the work of others under the Article 3, General Behavior Expectations.
How does AI play into this, or is there a separate policy for AI plagiarism? That's a good question. we currently do not have a separate policy for AI plagiarism I mean we have we've had conversations over the and we had a presentation earlier in the fall
about sort of the how the school is working to take advantage of AI where appropriate but also create limits where appropriate and my general understanding is that and I will also say this just as a teacher in case I many of my students are listening, that it doesn't matter whether you're plagiarizing with AI or you're plagiarizing, because Stephanie wrote it for you, you're plagiarizing, and
so that applies. So I think that that, and I will go to the mat for that if anybody wants to come at me. That would be my opinion, too, but it doesn't say anything about AI, and I just worry that we're... Yeah, no, I'm with you. I mean, I think, yeah, I don't know. What do you think, Michelle? I don't know. Are you asking, do I think we should have an AI policy, or should we include it here?
I mean, I think here, the generalized refrain from cheating and plagiarizing is appropriate in the code of conduct, and then if, you know, maybe we're adding another cross-reference here to another policy in the future around AI, but I think, you know, it comes down to
teaching within our schools that just asking AI to write your paper for you is, in fact, cheating and plagiarizing and it falls under this so and I do believe that that is yeah and I don't know yeah and I guess I really don't I don't I have not heard a for example there's that we had a really good and rich conversation
around cell phone use in schools and had some wonderful presentations from students who spoke really eloquently about that issue in that case I would say that there is a question of sort of balance, interest, and sort of different sort of points
of view and opinions on that. I have never encountered any, in any academic context, anyone saying differentiating AI plagiarism from any other form of plagiarism. So plagiarism, in my experience, encompasses all of that, I don't think, unless we define it somewhere else,
because we would just be defining plagiarism, which is using somebody else's words. As your own. As your own, even if it's computers. But we're definitely going to be returning to AI, because that is a big concern of ours as a district, and as part of our strategic plan, it needs to be part of that. And so we're building off of the great work that was presented in the fall.
Good note. Yeah, I think it's more likely something that gets embedded into the curriculum, talking about that. Other comments or questions? Okay, we have a motion and a floor, well, a motion and a second on the floor. All those in favor? So this is the first read. These will be back with appropriate punctuation. Great, thank you so much, everybody. I appreciate it. Okay, moving on to item 12, unfinished business, district reconfiguration.
We just wanted to put a brief spot on the agenda here. Obviously, Superintendent Gray touched on a variety of things. In his remarks for the superintendent's report, we had over an hour of public comment. Just wanted to provide a spot for folks to ask some questions
around process, information they would like. We're going to talk a little bit more about the facility study a little bit later on, but I just wanted to open this up. Chris. Yeah, thank you for providing the time for that. I really appreciate it. I do have kind of a list of questions that I wanted to just
publicly ask, understanding that those answers are not coming tonight to start with, but a lot of it is just about process, so kind of outlining the process that we're using moving forward, as well as, and I know you talked about in your, in your report, kind of having us reflect on the values
that we would like to have in this. And I would also kind of understand what the timeline is that we're thinking of for this, what the factors of that timeline include, because I think that's important. I know the CDS transition is one of the factors that's included in that, but that scenario two presented multiple different things that are honestly very different, like the middle school consolidation versus changing a PES. So I kind of want to get a sense of understanding the timeline for that. I'd like to understand how the community can have input on that.
I'm so happy that a lot of my neighbors, most of my neighbors, probably showed up, and I really appreciate the input that they've given us. But how do we have kind of a more formal way of having the community participate?
Especially because we presented three scenarios, but really those three scenarios are just a conglomeration of some ideas um and so stepping back from those scenarios and and ignoring them for a second kind of how do we get to the point where we go what do we want our district to look like and now how do we make that
happen and the scenarios are in the how do we make that happen part but we haven't really figured out the what do we want our district to look like part so like do we want our middle school to be consolidated do we want it seventh do we want it sixth like if we decide our values in that then
we can figure out how then we can use our district to change and the facility study is a big part of that so I would I'd love to have a facility study kind of push forward I think that's great that goes into kind of what other information
we need the facility study will help provide that I think but beyond the facility study is there any other information that we need that we're kind of not thinking of so putting some thought into that I think would be important um and how can again we have these these three scenarios and and and i understand that but
how do we present alternatives whereas they're not fully fleshed out but we have ideas that we like about certain things to then come together and collaborate into that so um i wanted to kind of make sure that we we we thought about this in a way that is very kind of data oriented and the
things we're thinking of are real and not perceptions because i know that there's a lot perceptions between the three towns of of the different schools being in certain ways but actually understanding the real data on some of that whether that's
student numbers or costs or contributions from each town I think that'd be really important so those are not so much questions as statements I guess I think timeline process moving forward how how that looks what sort of
community input we would have on that I think are the three big things so thank you, Chris. Those are all excellent. I would think, for me, those are all things that I would want to know as well before I could come to what I would feel is even the beginning of an informed
decision. I'm trying to think about ideas for input from the district, and I'm trying to recall in my brain what it was around but um we have had in the past um sort of like round table just like facilitated discussions where like anyone who's interested in coming comes and like tables are
given a question and they come up they brains it's basically a lot of brainstorming opportunities that then get shared out and it just provides i mean uh you know several of our speakers said today like we have a lot of really bright minds in this district like let's tap into them and
and think of opportunities and you know I mean there's probably infinite opportunities but there's probably you know a handful or a dozen that have real validity and possibility to move forward like how do we collect them how do we distill them down and for me that probably
that I think can be happening and I don't know I don't know what the right time you know pacing for these things is. I don't know if you need to have the facility study before you have that, or if you do that while we're getting the facility study prepared, or maybe there's two stages to
this. You know, I would just like to see a way where we can try and tap into, like, all of these ideas and these, you know, diverging perspectives and be able to, in an open and transparent and safe place be able to say all the things right like why why this might be a good option for this
group or that group or this this you know constituent or stakeholders or you know um sort of the the right versus right right like understanding what those all look like um because i think while you know we're not all going to love everything we hear i think that
is the core of a of a open you know healthy discussion about something like this so you know I think maybe we can brainstorm on how we brainstorm with our communities and provide opportunities for that to start collecting those you know the feedback and and obviously we have
board meetings and people are welcome at the beginning and end of every board meeting we have the board email which which folks are most folks are familiar with but if you're watching and aren't It's board at rsu5.org, and that goes to all of us here on the board.
So if I might. Yeah. So I want to, just in response to where, this is not a full answer, but this is sort of like my thoughts on how we should go forward for right now. As I said before, none of us here, none of us here,
and none of us here in the room has full information about what all of this entails. we each have a perspective. They're all valid, but we don't have full information yet. So the process of getting the information we need is a pretty long process that takes an investment of
time and money. And so I'm going to ask you in a little while to invest some money in a concrete step, which is the facility study, which will take some time to develop. And the time at the moment is for everybody to be curious about what should inform this decision.
I think what's happened at this point is that the issue has been laid open as necessary for discussion, and the discussion and curiosity. So I think now is the time to be curious and also to be empathetic, and I think it's a very good thing, frankly, that folks in Pownall especially,
we're hearing from folks in other communities too, but we have a preponderance of folks from Pownall in the room, are here to engage in this conversation. So what we can do right now is be very deliberate about listening. I think board members can go back to your constituents and encourage them to come to board meetings, offer public comments, send emails and watch the board meetings and become as informed and engaged as possible. I think it makes sense within the next few months for us to have open conversations
about what we're thinking, what we're curious about, and what our values are, while we wait for the information we'll need, because that information is going to take time. And part of what we'll come up with that is, I have no doubt, you know, I presented three scenarios. That's a
starting place. There are going to be other ideas to consider. Those things may be well in the rearview mirror by the time we actually know fully what we're talking about. So I just personally think the way forward is right now to listen and be curious get the ball rolling on a facility study
and invite people in um yeah i appreciate that um i hope that doesn't sound like nothing i it's actually a lot but it's it's these it's the little snowball that gets bigger over time right and and being being clear to kind of us and some of the members of the public we're not we're not talking
about making a decision in weeks we're talking about making a decision in this is at the earliest Double digits of months kind of things, yeah. At the earliest, it's a next-year decision. And the other thing I'm thinking, one second, Colin, is, you know, tools we already kind of have at our disposal
that feel like they might help inform this is, like, the strategic plan. Like, we have just gotten a lot of feedback from community members all through the district, right? can we look at the feedback we got from that and, you know, kind of key into some of the
questions that Chris said, like, what do we want the RSU-5 to be? Like, what comes out of that that helps inform the values that you said, you know, we need to weigh? You know, I'm trying to think of, you know, groups that are already, you know, involved and doing some of this work that
seems to me feels like it overlaps with that question um so just a thought colin yeah i was also just going to reference the strategic planning process which if any of our guests are not currently involved in it please get involved in that because that is our our uh our work as a
district to try to articulate what it's exactly what you said um that is that is where we do that um, and that we are doing that. Um, and that is in process. Uh, we're working from the, um, the portrait of a graduate that, um, our, uh, high school student presented to us last week based
on that work. So, um, so I just wanted to touch on that. And also, I think one thing that would be helpful, and I don't think this is a, um, a short-term thing, but it might be something to kind of either develop, um, uh, kind of either out of the, um, facility study or kind of in tandem
with it would be kind of an articulation, um, a sort of public facing document of, um, sort of like drivers and dilemmas, um, and questions that we're trying to wrestle with. Um, because I think that is uh the piece that that fundamentally um everything comes down to um is that we are we're
responding to um a constellation of interacting um factors and um trying to navigate those so i think that in terms of also like what chris what you were saying in terms of like how also the community can have maybe kind of a clearer sense of sort of how to contribute um other ideas would
be to, would be in response to those, response to those things. Um, to say if we're, if we're juggling like some of the things we're already, we're already mentioned this evening, we're discussed last week, right? Sort of question of like, um, uh, middle school or equity or
transportation, right? The sort of, um, and sort of aging infrastructure and all those things. So to sort of have that all kind of in one place, um, to get a little bit of a sense of sort of what are we, like, what are we really trying to juggle so that when folks are presenting ideas, uh, to us, um, it's with an understanding that it's that full constellation
of things that we're trying to address. Um, there's no, it's not that, like, if somebody has an idea on, like, a very acute thing, sure, that's great, but, like, uh, very much the, um, the wicked problem we have right now is, like, how to address these interacting
factors, and so I think it'd be helpful to have some sort of public-facing document that could articulate those. I'm curious if you have a sense of how long a facility study would take. Because I think that would be helpful as we think about a timeline and conversations. I can't give you a fully informed answer right now, but I can tell you it's going to take at least a couple of months to put it up to bid and then get in bids. And then the facility study itself is going to take at least,
this is a total ballpark, at least three or four months. So we're definitely looking at next year at the earliest, I would say. And in the meantime, I hope that this is really for everybody who's in the room. I think what has forced, why the timing for this conversation has happened is that we have a confluence of factors.
We have this really difficult budget situation. And, you know, when I came here, I realized I can't be the superintendent who just tries to pass on a 10.5% tax increase, budget increase. or on the other hand, radically slash the budget, which would have a significant impact.
So that's why I had to bring that to you all for guidance to find a target. And having taken in mind what your target is, and then having worked for hours with the team of people in the back of the room to figure out what's the least impactful way to get there.
One of the hard truths of those conversations that shows up in the presentations I gave is that if we start at Tier 1 and then go to Tier 2, and then we go to Tier 3 being the deepest level of cut that I didn't recommend,
there aren't any cuts that are aimed at panel until Tier 3. And the reason for that is because the structure of that building makes the impact of any cut there much more magnified. That's just the nature of the one classroom per grade level structure of that building.
So when we're having conversations about combining classrooms at Masked Landing and Durham and Moore Street, and we can't really make a change at Pownall until we get to a non-recommended tier, it creates a dynamic when we look through the district-wide lens of, we have to make that talkable.
and that's what I need to ask folks here to understand is that through the district-wide lens we have to at least talk about this and the feelings that I'm hearing are I would feel the same way I would feel exactly the same way it has to be a two-way conversation about how do we balance those needs I also think we need to name
some of the feelings that we have that maybe aren't as happy as we would like them to be someone earlier used the word jealousy, which I found offensive. I want all of our children to have a great education. I celebrate it. I'm not jealous of Pounder. My kids had great education
at Moore Street and MLS. I don't do this happily. I don't think any of us do. Even considering it, I don't do it happily. I really, that word struck me in a bad light. And I know that, I know that powder folks are feeling that same ugliness and that they did their best to not use
ugly words, and I appreciate that. But also, I don't think there's a happy way to get to compromise. I think that's why compromise is what it is. I'm not saying that I definitely do what we should do option two. I'm not there yet. I don't think that. I just know that we have this constellation
of needs many of them legal requirements and we have limited resources we're making probably making cuts this year um we have a set number of buildings which is why we need this facility study i it's an ugly thing i it's unpleasant i get it i agree that's why we're all wrestling with
it um and i appreciate the panelized ones coming tonight i really do um all the ones that didn't and still emailed. I appreciate that, too. Last year, I was over there, doing exactly the same thing, speaking out about something that I don't like. And I understand your position. I understand
the passion behind it. We all love our kids. I get it. I mean, every single one of us has family in this district as well. That's why we're here. We don't want to take anything away from you. We're in your community, too. It's a bigger community, I agree, but we're also in your
community. All of us. Even the Freeport people. Even the Durham people. We don't want to exclude you. We want to include you. How that works, I don't want to do this. I have seen some absolutely beautiful emails. Beautiful. The testimonies tonight. Most of them, very beautiful. I think
we all feel the same way. But also, we have a constellation of things that we have to address. and i'm not saying that this is definitely the answer none of us want to do it but we need an answer and we're looking for partners we have to educate our three-year-olds we don't have a place
to put them that's the long and the short of it we also have this pain point of middle school that we addressed at length that some people touched upon but nobody really addressed where our during kids are in a totally different time frame because they're in a school that is
different than most middle school hours. There's more than one problem that we're trying to figure out, and it's a hard thing, and I understand it, and I understand the feelings behind it, and we want to be partners. We don't want this to be adversarial. We want to listen, clearly.
Our doors are always open. Our emails are always open. I read every single email I got, every single word. I'm sure everybody else did too. We're partners in this, and we want to do what's best for all of our kids. That's what we were elected to do. The kids first. We sworn
oath to it. And so I just wanted to level set to that. We're considering the kids first. And anything implied otherwise is kind of offensive to us. So I think, I mean, I think everyone on this board is open to learning more, right? I mean, I think that at the core of the vote that
we took last time was we want to learn more about any scenario that could meet the needs, right? I I don't, I don't, I won't speak for everyone on this board, but I, my sense is that no one is tied to any specific solution. I think we are very much in the curiosity, find out more information,
and if there is other solutions that still meet the needs of all the things we're trying to do in that, in that constellation, then great. And that's what I would love for us to, you know, engage with with our communities to to tap into that so and I think I I think I
put that in every email to everyone who emailed the board I think I've emailed everybody back unless you email me this afternoon I haven't we haven't gotten to those yet but but please know that we do read them all we do appreciate the
feedback we will find a way to get to continue soliciting feedback right like public comment is great because you can get a lot of people through quick but it's not a two-way conversation so I do think we need to have another there'll
be another mechanism there'll be another Avenue to continue that to continue that conversation and you know and you know similar to similar to all the other things we just seem to be tagging into Tom's superintendent reports he gives
us a budget update and the strategic planning update maybe this is a sub title under the strategic planning update that we're constantly you know where are we at what's the next step how can we engage both as a board and as a
community so so thank you for that yeah I've been listening to what everyone has been saying and thank you for everyone showing up it's it's a lot I had a question about the strategic planning portrait of a graduate there were focus
groups, there were surveys sent out to everybody, and we could join or participate or not. And I'm wondering if there's, we could do something like that with this, because I do think that there's plenty of ideas out there. We are not the only minds. There's three communities that have great
minds. And I'm wondering if we could do something like that, where there could be a two-way conversation. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, I mean, that's what I was very inarticulately trying to remember how we did what we were doing it for before but it was it was you know it was
basically a facilitated discussion that anyone who was interested and we had him in a couple different locations a couple different times to provide you know some prompts and and to just basically get to ideas and thoughts and feelings about things and um and brainstorm so somebody
Yeah, I mean, it could be either more personal, you know, face-to-face, but there could be an initial something that goes out to people via email that, you know, hey, if you have any ideas, write them down and send them in, and then we gather all the information. I don't know how much additional work all of that would be, but I think this is such a large decision that it's, I think it's kind of warranted to get some of that information. Absolutely, yeah. Who's on our Strategic Communications Committee?
Seems like a great idea for you guys. Steph? So if I could offer a thought about that, I think the answer is yes, more than once, but with being mindful of what kind of feedback is useful at what time. For example, it would not be useful right now to send out a survey among us or the teachers or the administrators or the public
to say, what do you think we should do? Because we don't know everything we need to know. But the kind of survey that would be useful is what do you value? What questions do you have? What are you concerned about? What problems do you see? That's useful information at this stage.
I think it would be helpful to have what Colin was suggesting earlier, a document explaining the constellation of needs to go along with that so that they don't think this is just another strategic plan survey. some of the questions I'm thinking about the strategic planning process and I'm looking forward
to looking back at the information we collected I don't think there was anything related to space you know it was all like bigger picture what do we hope our students will be learning and who are they developing to be as humans how are they a part of the community but I don't think there's
anything that would really get to what we're talking about here so I look I think it would be great to do another send another survey out but with the context of why we're asking yeah and just to follow up on that I think it would be really
helpful for us as a board if we could close that feedback loop really quickly and get that feedback from those surveys just sort of periodically as we go through the process so we can sort of be thinking about that as we move
through and also if we get some really great ideas from those surveys to incorporate them into our feasibility study so that we're not just sort of railroaded down scenario two so to speak that we're really kind of making sure we
take those into consideration when we do that process I think in terms I'm sorry Steph we've covered up twice let her go I'm curious what you have to say Tom but no I just wanted to jump on the constellation document that's something
that I'm kind of holding I think in this process and just a sort of name where what might have felt like quick jump on a scenario is that these are long meetings and we absorb a lot of different pieces of information at different times and you start to hold the different pieces sort of
collectively in your mind as a board member I'm learning because I'm still very new and so I think it would be helpful for me as I consider something like this and I also think like even if you're completely engaged in all of the meetings it would be hard to hold all of those pieces unless you're
here doing this work on a weekly or bi-weekly basis um yeah sometimes daily depending on uh hiring but um yeah so I just I just wanted to name that as like maybe both um a piece of information for why it felt harsh and abrupt that so many of us were interested in exploring an option like this and also that I think it would be helpful for all of us to have a collective understanding of all those competing priorities because they don't feel easily reconcilable and we've kind of we've named it, but I just want to reiterate that that desire to pursue an option.
I want to hold all options on the table. I think we should consider all options and we shouldn't take any off of the table. I think that that's how we get to the best answer for our students, even the ones that feel impossible and super painful.
I think that that's how we feel better about making a choice in the end is when we consider them all. And then the other, I guess, request that I have is the, on like this constellation of problems document, um, the poet, yeah, the poet, um, is to also like maybe highlight
the limited resources and how they interact. And I, it's sort of like kind of the same thing, but I think it's also slightly different. Like when we're trying to solve this problem, what are the constraints that we're facing when we're trying to solve the problem? Um, I think it would be helpful. I would just try and I'm thinking about when we can accomplish this work so I just want to make
sure the kind of things we're talking about I think they can happen in the next month or so or a couple of months they can't happen by the next board meeting we've just got a lot of plates in the air so I want to make sure our sense of what we can accomplish in the time we have is
realistic. So I will be working on this and I will keep you and I will invite your help with this and try to develop a timeline that works. But it can't be like next board meeting. Two things. One is just to that point of all the things we have in the air
after we finish this particular conversation we are going to have a 120 minute conversation about the budget. Only if you choose to. No, we're going to use every damn minute. No, but, like, I bring that up also, like, to say that, to just emphasize, we do have a number of balls in the air, but also that, like, we also are wrestling with some very, like,
some very immediate questions that I can't remember which meeting. Is it, like, two out from now that we were supposed to make a, like, basically approve a budget that we're then going to take to each of the towns? And, uh, and that, that also, as, uh, anyone who's been watching, um, is an incredibly,
uh, difficult conversation where we're trying to figure out, um, how, uh, to, uh, cut 1.7 million dollars, um, out of the budget that can only, uh, because it has been, uh, looked at very carefully, um, can only come from staffing. Um, so also that, again, just to note that we are,
having that. To clarify, there is a lot, there are a lot of non-staffing reductions. There are, but the lion's share of them, we know that that needs to come from there. The other point, just again, since we're being pedantic, I may have also misheard Kelly, but just to make sure, I see a
big difference between a feasibility study and a facility study. A feasibility study is when we know something that we want to do and we present that plan and see whether we can do it a facility study is saying what do we have what do we have and just
to be clear that my understanding is we're not going into a facility study with any sort of with any agenda of like we want to do this can we do it we're going into it with an understanding of what do we have and then And yes, how do we then take that information and put it up against, for example, the strategic plan to try to understand that?
So again, I just want to, that may be just my, like, nomenclature kind of thing, but I just wanted to make clear that that is a distinction, at least in my mind. Okay. You guys ready for 120 minutes of budget? Let's do it.
Okay. So my understanding is we don't have any updated budget documents. So there hasn't been any changes to the handbook and the budget, the many, many page budget document that we got, I think, at the last meeting from Kelly. So we don't have any additional information
from what we had last time other than the request for kind of that roll forward budget a couple years and what does that look like. So thank you for that. That was helpful to see what that looks like. And to Tom's point, it is 9.30.
It has been a long meeting. I felt like a powerful meeting, know listening listening to to the community we certainly don't need to spend 120 minutes on this tonight if if that is the will of the board we have two more board meetings to discuss the budget before we vote to move one
forward but I do want to provide an opportunity if folks had specific comments or questions they wanted to talk about tonight um i would i would suggest we don't really go into a huge two-hour deep dive into the budget right now because i'm not sure how productive we
would all be in that chris um yeah i i agree with that um i did have a question on and we talked about this before but if you had thought about we'd talked about how to an extent the you know 6-7% is somewhat arbitrary, and if you had an idea
of what you would prioritize if we gave you the sense of going between the 7-8%, and I don't know if you had thought about that, or if that's something you had any kind of thoughts on. Well, I did think about that, and I have to say, I gave an answer at the last board meeting, but I really was over my skis in giving that answer, because I had not talked about it with the team, so I'm going to be not over my skis right now and say, we have
talked about that scenario, we're not done talking about it. So that's the best answer I can give right now. Yeah, sounds great. Thanks. It's just on that, and I appreciate the clarification on that, but to Chris's question, I think the way I'm currently sitting with that question is that
I'm using the peers as the way I'm thinking about that. So for example, the way my sort of understanding is that, um, if we were to say, um, we want to increase, uh, we want to give more leeway and say, uh, a higher, uh, higher percentage tax increase, um, that then the things that, uh, are
currently in tier two, but not in tier one, then, tier one, um, but not in tier one, those would be the things to go. Um, although, I'm sorry, those would be the things that would be, uh, the opposite go. Again, that's not, I'm not saying that's gospel, I'm just saying that's the way I'm
holding it in my head. I think, just to be very frank, just to think for myself at this moment, kind of keep clear what Tom has reiterated a few times, which is that those tiers were developed really carefully by the administrators, and it's their recommendation, it's their best
work to solve a problem, to Valerie's point, to solve a problem we don't want to have. We don't want to have to cut the budget in that way, but if we do, to Tom's thing, you've reiterated a few times is that um the least bad uh things that we can do um so again just to sort
of name that that's kind of the way i'm kind of sitting with it but i i would be curious to know if there are any updates uh next week i guess it would be um from uh from the administrators or from utah i think that's that's really helpful and i appreciate your saying that and i'm sure
others in the room probably appreciate it too um not that our thinking is perfect but i what i can assure you is that tier one is the highest tier is what we consider to be after much discussion from many angles the least damaging to what we offer kids and then tier two is next level it's
a roadmap um so to come somewhere in between tier one and tier two would be you'd get back some of what is in tier two but you would if i why didn't show you this i guess i could should i put this up on the screen if you'd like so this is what i mentioned in my i will do so this is what i
mentioned in my um remarks i'm just gonna stay sitting here four one six two can i sit in the real quick while you're pulling that up yeah so i i totally understand what you're saying colin and i appreciate that i think what maybe a better way of trying to articulate what i'm i'm trying to
get at is instead of forcing you to a seven percent if you stayed under eight percent what would you what would your budget look like then that's kind of i guess right because i understand the tiers are that but the tiers were somewhat i mean those were arbitrary numbers right so i'm
also trying to kind of understand is like are we are we cutting out something that would be incredibly beneficial because we have to stay to that specific number or is there like almost like an under eight percent priority if that makes sense well really you're making a judgment about
the tax increase, you feel you can pass on to the community that will pass. And to use... Sorry, I'm really bad with this. To use really rough numbers, each percent, I mean, you can see. So what I'm showing you here is if you look at what Kelly did, she ran two scenarios at my request. The top scenario is if you make no reductions and continue to make no reductions, what our best guess is for the budget going forward. So I sure can try. Let's see. Hold on.
Do you make the purple just a little more? Oh my word. Okay, so that's as good as I can make it at the moment. So the blue is this year. The purple is next year. Next year, without any reductions, the budget will be $49 million plus a little bit more. So that means that 10% of the
budget is $491,000. So 1% is roughly, you know, a quarter of that. So each teaching position is roughly 1% of the budget. That's roughly what it boils down to. So if you carry forward this year's budget with no reductions, you're increasing the budget by 10.49%. If you do that again the
following year, it will increase by an additional 8.51%. That's, of course, compounded, as these things do. And the year after that would be 8.87%. That does not include the town budgets. It does not include the county budgets. At the recommended level, which is the quote-unquote 7%, the 7%
is actually 6.46% right now. If you take that forward a year out, it's 5.55. And another year out, it's 5.91. So it makes a big difference in the sustainability. Maybe this is a question for Kelly. What was last year's? What did we end up with? Last year's was about 6.5 plus change.
A question not related to this. So does anyone have questions about this? Sorry. So basically, just to be clear, If we added even one teaching position back into this budget for this year, we would be talking about more like 7.5%. I don't feel like I can say that, but I feel that that effect would magnify going farther out.
And what this does not account for is that next year we are negotiating our largest contract, which is the educator contract, and all the other things that are happening in the economy that are affecting the expenses for all of our households and businesses, etc.
I think just the only thing I would maybe add to Chris's question about the percentages is that I think, please jump in anyone else if they think I'm speaking nonsense, but those percentages were based on sort of two things.
one sort of historical data on not just what the increases have been but also what the voters have told us about those different numbers, sort of how much buy-in from the community as a whole and how much buy-in from each of the individual town's voters.
And so I think that the Again, that's the way I am thinking about those numbers, is to sort of know that, like, seven is higher than historically has been something that the voters are excited about. I don't think you've gotten to seven, actually. But I'm saying in terms of the, like, I think we may have, hold on.
What are we holding on? She's going to look up. I think so. This is where I need that. so yeah in the in the budget handbook that we didn't we have a new one because there's no new information but again online as well under the on a district website under the budget
documents for 26 27 the 10-year adopted budget history so FY 26 the year we're in currently it was a 6.83% year-over-year expenditures in FY25. It was a 6.48% increase. FY24 was 4.99. FY23 was 4.22. And then we have those lovely years where we had a lot of additional COVID money,
So we all saw unrealistic budget increases or low increases. FY22 was 2.09. FY21, 2.32. FY20 was 3.43. So you can see kind of like the trajectory that's happened as all the additional influx of COVID money left the district.
But the needs of students did not decrease. They've only truly increased, honestly, since the COVID years. So that's where we were at last year was 6.83, just below the 7% threshold. And if you remember, the budget vote was quite tight.
And I think maybe what I'm recollecting is, what I didn't realize is our chart only goes back 10 years and my brain goes farther. And I think if you went back to the beginning of the district, there is a period between 10 and 17 which is where we start here where we were higher than that seven
percent and in those early years of the district the budget generally failed by a fair amount in both panel and Durham and and passed it I mean we have never knock on wood failed about the budget in total but it has it has varied based on
a variety of things over the life of the district and I just want to remind folks that this 6.46% year-over-year increase actually amounts to a lot larger year-over-year tax impact in Durham and Poundell, estimated at 8.83 in Durham, at 7.87 in Poundell.
So that's going to be really hard for some people to own the stomach if we go even higher than that. So I think we really need to be mindful not only of this number up here, but the actual town-by-town taxation impact. Which was the point I was stumbling to try to make. So thank you, everyone else, for making it more beautiful.
This spreadsheet that you see up there, we just finished developing this this morning, which is why it's not in your packets, but I'll make sure you get it. And I'll just say, Kelly, thank you so much for putting this together. I know that, again, it's not gospel, but it's so incredibly helpful to have that as a point of reference
Because I think that, again, not knowing, but having a professional, a numbers professional, say that this puts us on a track that has a higher likelihood of being more sustainable than the status quo. it's just it's just it's just really helpful and it and it eases my it doesn't ease all of my my
concerns um globally but it just it it's really helpful so just thank you so much for that sorry we were just figuring out some math because we had different papers um kelly the numbers kelly was referencing of the eight percent eight five and seven for durham freeport and pauno tax impact
was actually last year's 6.5% budget and the tax impact for the towns of that. So in our current budget year, that was the tax impact, that 6.5%. This year's, based on the budget brochure, it's 5, 3.5, and 5, 5.25 for the three towns.
So just wanted to clarify that. And that's mostly driven by an increase in the subsidy the subsidy went up um because the required mill from the state went down so how much we were required to raise even though um valuations went up in all three towns
the amount we were required to raise did not okay so yeah anna one thing that i think maybe chris had asked about in a previous meeting that i don't think we've gotten and would be helpful i think is um looking at ed tech positions and what we currently have in the different ed techs
um and then alongside just like the proposal of the different ed techs that we're proposing to cut because that's for me i really want to try to follow what you are all the you know the building administration administrators and tom you've laid out um sticking to as close to tier two as we can
you know just like kelly's point um but i think the ed techs is where i'm having the hardest just personally for me when we're thinking about larger class sizes especially just from memory like freeport middle school we're talking about like 23 kids per class in one of the grades i
can't remember which one um so it just seems like a really strong support staff that then we're cutting with larger class sizes and they tend to have less of a budget impact than teachers so i would like a closer look on that um and then also it would be helpful with that ed tech data to have
to look at how many special ed positions we have open um five and a half right now district total yep okay five and a half ed tech special ed ed techs are open right now got it and like how maybe we've been told this information about how long they've been open for and you know
um kelly was mentioning we're going to be using some of the funding because they weren't and i think actually you michelle in the last meeting and mentioned well could we just since we can't hire them anyways which i don't want to go there but it does merit some conversation of
Like, well, do we just hope that we're going to get five? I mean, at this point, it seems maybe a little unrealistic that we would get all five. So that's a little bit the only thing for me that I feel like I really need more data on.
I feel I can speak to some of that now. So we did discuss as part of our deliberations whether we should just not include those positions and gain a savings that way. we really feel we need to keep trying to fill those positions because many of them are IEP-related, and they're for the most needy kids. And so in good conscience, we have to try to fill those positions. And, you know, as I look ahead to next year, we have some ideas that we can't put in place right this moment,
but that over time we could put in place to try to attract people to those positions. In the meantime, I don't want to get ahead of the agenda too far, but we have budgeted for those positions. We're now more than halfway through the year, so we have five and a half ed tech wages budgeted for.
Even if we hired individuals into those positions right now, we're only going to spend what's left in the school year. So we have some money there that we can dedicate to bringing on an early childhood director as early as possible
because we need that person's help to get that program off the ground. I hope that helps, at least in part. And you can, perhaps for the next meeting, give us sort of a layout of what ed techs look like today and what they would look like under the tiers? Sure. Okay. Thank you. yeah I think I understand what the cuts that are proposed right now with that
text but what I don't understand is how many are what how many are yes and in the behavioral versus the academic etc okay so we're feeling like we're ready to move on from budget for now and obviously we'll have more yep stuff I just have a question of like what we should intend the next couple of budget
meetings to be for us as a board um so typically um i don't have the schedule in front of me but it might be also in here is it in here too okay great yeah and like more i guess a more specific question is like what are what do we need to do as a board yeah at those meetings that's why i'm
checking to see what we've got left um so we adopt on the 25th so um in a perfect world and i love perfect worlds um in the next two meetings uh we would essentially by the end of the 18th have come to a consensus on what we want that budget to be and then we would vote on it on
the 25th because that that uh streamlines a lot of the signing and paperwork and things like that as opposed to if we can still be triggering things on the on the 25th if we need to be and the 25th would be like where it's an agenda item on our agenda that we vote on yes we adopt the
budget on the 25th we are going into that believing that we we know that we have consensus that's the ideal perfect world yeah ideally we we have on the 18th agreed to what the budget should be for the following year and we would adopt it on the 25th then we have the three meetings in
each town to talk about the budget and then we would have the annual budget meeting on May 13th um I see that it says public input on budget on the 18th and 25th yes you say more about that yes so we wanted to highlight the
opportunity for so the where we go to the three towns that's sort of after we've adopted the budget that's to help answer questions inform folks but the we wanted to provide public input on the budget on the 18th and 25th where folks
will be a specific point on the agenda where people can either ask questions they can come and ask a question clarifying question they can give us their thoughts on the budget before we adopt it because you know some feedback
we've heard in the past is like well great I thanks for coming and telling us but you've already adopted it there's really not much we can do other than either vote it down in June or or try to change it at the annual budget meeting so
So that was two public input opportunities for folks that wanted to share their thoughts or suggestions or questions in advance of us adopting. Yeah, makes sense. Okay, thank you. All right, so new business, moving on. I will get the motion on the floor and then Tom will fill us in on the details. Do I have a motion for consideration and approval to create the position of Early Childhood Special Education,
ECSE Assistant Director. Malik, thank you. Kara? Okay, so as I mentioned, we would like to hit the ground running as soon as possible to hire this person to spearhead our adoption of early childhood and fulfillment of our responsibilities under the statute. As I mentioned in the previous meeting,
we have found a way to offset the cost of hiring that person through the money that's coming from the Early Childhood Fund from the state so that it is a minimal impact to our district budget. We are framing the position as an assistant special education director so that they can
be useful in facilitating all of the IEPs and meeting the needs of the kids in early childhood for whom we are required to provide those services. And we can bring that person on board early in this year before the state's allocation kicks in for next year because we have money
available for that we have not spent for special ed ed techs so this vote here is to simply create the position and by creating the position it allows them to post for the position because most administrative or hiring for next year people are starting to do those postings now
so we want to maximize our opportunity to get a great candidate so this isn't to hire the person this is essentially just to create the position and then they would post it and then depending on what that process looks like it's
probably several months before someone would come before the board for hiring and and you know if we could get them to start before July 1 great but the timing will that will depend on the candidate and the process but this just gets it moving. Questions?
I need to have a clear rationale for why we need this position. I don't have a background on this position so I guess I need to have an explanation of why a full time assistant special ed director is necessary. So we're going to be taking on responsibility for FAPE for 3 and 4
year olds, which we currently don't have. And in addition to that, we have in this district, we have a special education director. That's not the actual title of the position. It's director of instructional services. And we don't, for a district
of 1,900 kids, we don't have an assistant special education director. We have coordinators in each district. But quite frankly, that is very lightly staffed in special ed and the needs are absolutely exploding in that area not only in the number of kids we are required to serve but in the needs of
the kids especially since the pandemic so we need an additional person we just need an additional person particularly with early childhood which is a very big we need somebody with knowledge of early childhood special education as well and I kind of asked that question to Lois when it was
proposed. And the way it was explained to me that made a fair amount of sense was this person would also be responsible for sort of kicking off this process, right, for the three and the four-year-olds. I mean, we have four-year-olds now that we provide services
for, but we are not required to do any of the, we don't do the IEPs for those kids. We don't, we are not responsible for any of that right now. That's still CDS. We are basically just the service provider and so the the ability to launch that early
childhood CDS transition to the district this person would be obviously highly involved in that and then once that was sort of up and running their support as a special ed assistant director could help our existing director with the IEPs
around the district right so and a chunk of that position is funded through the additional funding for the early childhood education so we're able to bring on a person that arguably we need already to help support this new program
and get funding through the new early childhood bucket I guess if that makes sense so I mean we don't have a number yet for three-year-olds we do have a rough estimate. It's hard to predict, but I can tell you, I forget what the number is off the top
of my head, but what I can tell you absolutely certainly is that other districts who are ahead of us in adopting this model are finding once you build it, they crawl out of the woodwork. And so I shouldn't put it that way. The way I should put it is that families whose kids are
not getting served right now find that the service is much more accessible when the school district takes it on and they come forward to get services that are beneficial for their kids so we if if this district if it pans out in this district the way it has in every other one there will be more
than we know of right now i agree with that i obviously i mean that's enough that's an obvious so can you estimate what the average full-time assistant special ed director salary is i can tell you that we have budgeted this yes at the rate of an assistant principal because we don't
currently have an assistant special ed director here so we don't have a you know we don't have that already a model for that within the district we've developed this model based on the rate of pay of an assistant principal and the way that um well if you've been on you unfortunately the
timing of it was a couple of meetings ago i think it was like actually the meeting just before you arrived. We went through the finances of it all, but the way it boils down with the state's allocation versus local money is that for the cost of about $17,000, we can gain a whole
assistant special ed director, which is just a bargain. Because of the additional funding that we get that shifts from CDS providing the services to us providing the services, along with the responsibility that they were previously doing the work of partially CDS. I do do the numbers.
Thank you. Go ahead. So currently, so that's, we don't have future because next year's three-year-olds are currently two. Right. So that's how math works in time. Currently three-year-olds, two have been identified through CDS and are receiving services through CDS. And five have been identified but
are not currently being served. So there's seven in district that are three that we would be required to figure out some sort of plan for if we were live with three-year-olds today. And those are the ones that we know about. Correct. Those, I mean, we're not testing them.
People find that all of a sudden people start going through child find more and the numbers increase. So this person would be responsible for child find for three and four-year-olds, doing all of the written notices, coordinating all of those IEPs,
coordinating the transportation that would likely come from some of them. It's substantial. I should actually add another component of it is that to meet this need for special education services for three- and four-year-olds, we also have to provide access to regular education for least-restricted environment.
So there is some oversight responsibility of the general education that we haven't yet developed. We have it for four-year-olds, but some of the things we may need to add to do that better for four-year-olds is full-day programming, and we haven't even begun to figure out how we will meet the need for the three-year-olds when we take those on year after next. But they'll have to have some access to not only the special education services, but a general education environment, and this person would be responsible for coordinating that.
I was just going to follow up with the four-year-old numbers since I also have those in front of me. Four-year-old numbers are 12 that are currently being served by RSC 5, 14 that are currently being served by CDS, and then two that have been identified or are not currently being served.
And I think I recall them saying that this is a lower-than-average number for the year. It is. So if I can just express my concern about taking people who have direct contact with students, and cutting their positions while layering on another administrative position.
That's my concern. Understood. Just on that, I think, again, I really appreciate you articulating that, Lois. I think that, again, my understanding is it just goes to what Tom said about it's $17,000 is what we are committing.
and then we're getting more than the lion's share of that covered from money from the state. So I guess just for whatever it's worth, in my mind, we're not making a choice between an administrator and a teacher. We're making a choice of whether or not we get an administrator and spend $17,000 or don't get an administrator and don't spend $17,000.
That's the choice, which, again, $70,000 is $70,000, but that's the way I've kind of wrapped my head around it. Yeah, and can you say more about what that alternative of not hiring this position, not creating this position? We can't do this without this position. We must have this position. Right, because, I mean, if I'm doing the math right, we're talking about 40 IEPs that we currently don't do that we would be responsible for doing in a district that does not have a very...
We don't have great depth in terms of the people we have at the admin level for special ed, no. Plus taking on that screening that is currently done by CES. Right, yeah. Chris? And if we told the state that, hey, we don't need this position, we don't want to create it,
we don't save any money, we just don't get that money from the state. That's right. It's a reimbursement month, right? Like, they wouldn't just give us... And that's year after year after year going forward. That's not just, like, once. That's continuous, correct? I mean... as far as we know at this point right as far as we know that the 17,000 is
because we've bundled this position in with other direct service positions some of those were already paying for in our budget and we're transferring them to the state's allocation but we're also going to be getting under the heading of
that $17,000, an additional special education teacher, two ed techs, a speech language pathologist. Am I missing anything? About transportation. So, but this, we're basically adding an entirely new grade span to our district, and this is the person who will set that up for us. Okay. Any
other questions on this one? We have a motion, and we have a second. I'm getting thumbs up from Erica. See, this is what I tried to do at the beginning because then I forget. All right. All those in favor? Any opposed? Thank you. Okay, so now we have to put a new motion on the agenda
because we are past 10 o'clock, friends, which means we have a policy that says if we're going to go past 10 o'clock, we need to vote to continue. So I guess, do we have a motion to, so maybe I'll tell you what's left on the agenda. We have two more things on the agenda,
and I would say we want to get through both of them. My suggestion would be do them both. We have three. Oh, we have the addition of the calendar. That's right. I forgot about that one. So we have three. But they should be relatively speedy, I would imagine.
Do I have a motion to continue beyond 10 o'clock, Kelly and Kara? Thank you. All those in favor. Anyone opposed? No. Usually people always vote against that one. Or at least somebody. All right. So that was 13-1. So 13-2, do I have a motion for consideration and approval to expend up to the motion on
the agenda says $75,000 in our finance committee meeting today. We felt it might be prudent. This is an up-to number. We will only spend what the bid comes back at for the capital. The facility study. Thank you. The facility study. But we didn't want to run into a point where we couldn't engage if it ended up being $76,000 and we have to wait for another board meeting to do that. So while it says $75,000 on the agenda, I'm going to ask for a consideration and approval to expend up to $100,000 from capital reserves for a facilities study.
Chris and Colin, thank you. I think we've talked about this a fair amount. This would essentially allow us to put it out to RFQ, which we would receive back. Hopefully, we would get some good options out of that, and then we could engage the work of the facility study.
Do folks have additional questions on that piece? I know we've talked about it a few times throughout the night. Great, so we have a motion. We have a second for $100,000 from Capital Reserves. All those in favor. Great. Not opposed. So we will move on to the adjustment to the agenda, which I did not lose in all that time.
Aren't you proud of me? All right. So do I have a motion for consideration and approval to change the March 13, 2026, 0.5 Professional Learning Day to a 0.5 Student Day morning and a 0.5 Professional Learning day afternoon on the 2025-2026 calendar. Kelly and Steph, thank you. Do you have anything
additional to add on that from what you told us at the beginning? Nope. I have a question. I feel like it would be prudent for us to come up with a plan for if we have three more snow days. I know you said that we aren't deciding on anything more than... So at the next board meeting, we need to
flesh out our plan for remote days, but that's our next backup. Because before the next board meeting, we could have three more snow days. I feel nervous about waiting until the next board meeting. Well, this week at one point, it was like, well, Monday and maybe Wednesday and maybe
Friday, and it didn't turn out that way. But I mean, we are, you know, still halfway through winter. We could do that if you like. Just with full disclosure that we don't have that plan fully fleshed out yet, but we're basically reviving and rejuvenating the plan that existed before
during COVID. We just haven't had a chance to fully flesh out the details of that. If you wanted to authorize us to use remote school days now, we could continue that plan and send it to the commissioner, and we would be equipped to do that. None of these are really ready to go until
the commissioner approves them so my understanding of the remote days was you have to have a certain number of kids participate we did it during covid because we had one-to-one access for every child regardless of age so the younger ones had ipads to access i guess i'm if we say yes to this and
there's just no day tomorrow like there's no way it's a remote day right like because don't we have to provide food i mean there's a lot of pieces that go into it to count we have to send a meal home and so we either need to call it the day ahead um and have school nutrition prepare like
lunch bags ahead of time or we would have to send out our drivers in the middle of the day to deliver it door to door which is fraught because it would be bad weather clearly in a snowstorm so that's not really a good option um so it will take some lead time for us to develop that yeah
I'm just so confused on how some schools do remote days all the time. Like, how are they meeting those needs? I also am wondering about how many kids need to come to school for it to count? Oh, gosh. Is there a percentage? Two, right. So you said both your kids. I think I'm concerned about, let's say, there's school on June 24th and June 25th.
It doesn't matter if they show up that day. Oh, does it not? what i mean is is like i think we should wait on this conversation i think it's late and i think we're getting more into like what if this is what happens i think we should go stick with tom's plan of voting for the march day and then because these snow days it's unlikely that that
will only have to be two right because the plan was we would only go to remote after two more right so we're at three four or five if we do this we're at three yes yes if we do this we're at three and then four or five day six is would be the
recommendation to go remote so we would I mean I guess we could get three days between now and the next board meeting but I could also call an emergency board meeting if we had to do I mean if it's like right I mean if we if we call two
snow days before the next board meeting, I think you all need to have a plan in pocket, and we need to have an hour for you to talk about that. Is your hand up, or are you just like, okay, you're losing things. Yeah, I see it. Can you just tell me, please, if there's any impact on
the collective bargaining agreement between either ESP or the teachers by changing the date and the calendar at this late date? Do you mean for the... For changing the work day to a school day, half day student day, and then I'm assuming moving the work day, I think you said this, to the end of the year. Can you tell me if there's a collective bargaining issue? So what we had originally planned for was a half-teacher PLD day on that day.
This would be turning it into a full teacher day. and part of what we would need to do is have the teachers do plans for remote days but i don't think it would change their number of hours it would change their number of hours it would go
from half a day now um and presumably an extra day in june because if we don't do this we have to make up the day in june right so we would do a full day now and they'd get the time then yeah and it's basically the same with the ed techs i have a question about the 13th i think i remember
that that's district three for band and chorus it is is that yeah and i i regret that sean has left because i know that on monday he stated that it was a weird thing if we do this it is a for region 10 is a wrinkle they already have a plan and they can't change it for that day so we're not going to
be able to send the kids to region 10 that day um so it's a half day with no region 10 um and there is the district three festival at the high school that morning we can work around it can't we jen jen was looking right there's gonna be so much music going on in the school that day it's gonna
be great yes we can but i also wanted to note that for region 10 that is an event called um skills usa so a ton of our region 10 students will be on that trip no matter what whether there's um a student day or not um for the music festival yeah we'll have to make some arrangements but
we definitely can do that. Arrangements. I see what you did there, Jen. Yeah, I know. That was a late night pun. Love that. Thank you. Will's impressed. All right. Any other questions on that? So what I'm hearing is, is we're going to vote on this. We're going to leave the remote days to a
future date. Hopefully not before our next board meeting. Great. Did I get a motion for that one, Erica? I did. Great. All those in favor? None opposed. Great. All right. So now are we on to last item we are on to the last item oh this is my favorite one on the agenda this is a good one
so do i have a motion for consideration and approval to hire a principal at the durham community school for the 2026-2027 school year effective july 1 2026 colin anna thank you i am very pleased to present to you kate hillman harrison um who is currently the assistant
principal at Durham Community School, who absolutely has impressed everyone in that school with her abilities and her dedication and her caring. As you can see from the materials in front of you, Kate has a bachelor's degree from the University of Maine and a master's degree in
curriculum and instruction from the University of Hawaii, which I'm really jealous of. And Kate is, I can't overstate how deeply appreciated and respected Kate is here. So, Kate, are you in the room? Come on down, Kate. Can we vote first? I don't want to make her come up in case, you know. It's like when people, like, ask and propose to someone on live TV and you're like, oh, no.
You don't have to say anything yet. So, we have a motion. We have a second. are there any questions just for for purposes of folks watching or the folks that hung in were there with us we had a full hiring committee as we do for any
principal position which included community members board members staff administrators from across the district we had an open process for collection we uh interviewed um the group met developed questions screened all of the applications
had first interviews second interviews um uh reference checks so it was a full comprehensive uh full comprehensive process um which landed us here with kate this evening so all those in favor not opposed congratulations kate yay do you want to say anything now if you
I just say thank you very much for this opportunity I'm really excited to step into the role of principal at Durham Community School it's a place that I've grown quickly to love and just really looking forward to taking on this new role and I've had a excellent mentor I've learned a lot
and I'm excited to keep growing with the school thank you thank you Kate so my question is is do you kick Will out of his office now? Do you start redecorating? I'm just going to be sitting here for the next three months.
Alright, so we are back to public comment. If we have anyone who would like to speak, you are welcome to. Same rules apply. Name, town. Three minutes. Thanks for giving, oh, I should announce myself again, Brandon Perry panel. Thanks for giving a few minutes. I just wanted to comment back after, you know, I'm sure there's a lot of feedback for you guys, and I really appreciate all of the
commentary that followed, and my apologies especially on the tone of some of those comments, and I know I just wanted to put a cautionary word in about having moved forward with the facilities exploration of an party to enough committees of the sort before that I know that
once that ball gets rolling and particularly if there's only one option that's been explored that tends to just become the option and so we definitely want to stay involved and make sure that that doesn't happen to be the case here where we have a deep appreciation for your work
and everything that's offered up and I think just you know putting that out there I've seen it happen plenty of times where all of a sudden the clock just runs out and you have one option that's actually far enough to materialize and I'd hate to see that here so otherwise thank you guys
thank you all right oh sorry um yeah Mark Doley from 196 Murrow Road um I just wanted to follow up on something I think that Chris was trying to to get at um going going through the um I was trying to figure out what the disparity is in costs for panel and it was really hard to find
that information publicly. I'm pretty good at doing the calculations. I could calculate cost per pupil. I could see the square footage that each student takes in each building. Like I can find that information, but the cost disparity, I wasn't really able to tease that out. And I think
like for me, that's what makes me feel bad. Like I don't want to have, to be getting more than I pay for. And I don't think anybody here wants that. And so if we could figure out exactly what is meant by that, I think it would definitely help the conversation. And some of the items
would be like a cost per pupil. I thought that was really relevant, what the other gentleman said to compare yourself to last year. I think that's much more effective than comparing yourself to the other schools. If we're seeing rises in cost per pupil, maybe we should be also showing side
by side with that. We want to see the courses and the number of teachers teaching those courses. How's the programming changing over time? Because maybe we're heading in the wrong direction in that regards. So that would help because it's not just inflation. There's something else going on.
So thank you. Thank you. All right, we started and we ended with Mark. Yeah, so I would take a motion to adjourn. Kelly and Kara, thank you. All those in favor, no one votes no to that. Thank you. Thank you very much for not only coming and speaking, but also hanging in there with us for many hours.
Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.
