TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 18 March 2026
Board meeting · 3 h 15 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →
28,271 words in 38 five-minute windows.
Okay, so we do not have any minutes or adjustments to the agenda, so we will move right on to item 6, which is good news and recognition, Moon. So to start off, recently, Region 10 competed in the SkillsUSA competition, which is where hundreds of main students compete in what the news is called the Trade Schools Olympics.
And for those who don't know, it's like a national leadership and technical organization where students get to compete in like a trades and or leadership contest. And so, recently, we had some people who meddled and did quite well.
We had Sean Gaston-Guay, who won gold in the Diesel Equipment Technology. We had Aaron Allman, Ava Garrett, Savannah Gates, and Mariah Yarbrough, who won gold in the Health Knowledge Bowl. We had Biela Gonza, who won silver in Prepared Speech. We had Landon Whitney, who got silver in AutoTool Identification.
We had Nick Forrester, Harlow Weaver, and Isaac Weed, who got silver in welding fabrication. And last, we got David Mubiala, who got bronze in the internet working. And then also, we have, I guess, a scholarship for juniors.
It's the Freeport Scholarship Foundation, which is a group that works hard to provide FHS students with large scholarships if they're in financial need of it. and so students can receive up to $12,500 a year for college.
And this is also renewable up to four years, and if students want to participate, there's also a registration link that our school gave us, which I'm very grateful for. And also, we also have a curriculum fair next Wednesday on the 25th.
So it's going to be a day where, like, every class is going to go down and see what businesses and different organizations have to offer and different possible careers. And lastly, the Maine House Upcoming Career Compass,
it's a virtual session which focuses on orthopedics and sports medicine, and that'll be taking place on Wednesday, March 18th, from 7 to 8. It's on a Zoom, and students will hopefully learn how to, like, explore a range of careers within orthopedics and sports medicine, your personal career journeys from professionals, And, like, learn how to collaborate through, like, real-world patient scenarios.
And if students want to register, it was sent on, like, Google, or I guess on Gmail, through the school. Thank you. You have 26 minutes to get on the Zoom. Thank you. That is a lot of great information. Congratulations to all the folks in the skills. I've been seeing friends, kids from other districts who are posting about it this weekend as well.
seems like it's a pretty well attended broad scope of skills so it's very cool the Freeport high school the foundation that we mentioned you guys may recall that is the that is the group that the board voted to take the Stetson
scholarship that we had and and combine it with theirs so that they facilitate those scholarships I believe they've increased the number of scholarships that they're giving out each year to both juniors and seniors and they've increased the dollar amount
to the $12,500 a year, which is fantastic. So $50,000 over four years is a huge help to a lot of families. So I highly encourage folks to seek those out. The other great part about that scholarship, well, there's a lot of great things. One is that one of the key parts of it is the
mentorship. Every awardee of that scholarship is paired up with a mentor through their whole college career to help them through that process, which I think is wonderful. And then the other piece is that the fact that they give out junior and senior year scholarships. So juniors,
oftentimes, if you waited until the end of the year, there may be a school they didn't apply to because of the cost um but knowing you could potentially have this um scholarship as you finish your junior year that can help broaden your horizons in your senior year so um highly
recommend folks to um to seek that out if you are a junior and a senior um and the other thing i think is important that it's it's uh two four year call two year four year or technical training um they're very they're very broad in their um in their scope they want to help as many kids as they
can um pursue whatever path um excites them so uh highly recommend folks do that i think the board received an email from jen galetta who used to be a board member uh and is now i think the president for that um and also our previous superintendent is also on that board for that scholarship so
lots of ties to the school and to the board and to the community so definitely a great opportunity for folks to take advantage of. Okay, I'm done with that. Sorry. A little side quest there. All right, so public comment. A couple of things. Tonight's public comment is, well, we have our
regular public comment like we always do, but we also have, thank you, we also have another opportunity for public input because for our budget process on this meeting as well as next week's meeting we also have a public input on the budget item number nine so
how those two things will differ or be similar so for public comment it will run as it always does we ask folks to sign up which it appears folks have we ask that you get up tell us your name tell us where you're from ask you to keep
your comments to three minutes and anything education related if you have something that you would like to share specifically about the budget you can do that during item 9 which is public input from the budget it will run very similarly you can also do it in public comment if you like the distinction
between the two is in public input number nine we're giving folks an opportunity if you had clarifying question about something in the budget that you would like to ask us generally public cut well public comment is always
sort of one way the board wants to hear what the community has to say but it's not a two-way conversation in the public input section we did put that in there to provide folks an opportunity if you had a question to ask about the budget you could do it there I will say this is not going to sort of become a back and
forth debate about the budget between the board and community members present but we did want to provide people an option if they had a factual or a clarifying question about any of the budget proposals you would have that
opportunity to ask so with that said maybe I should have done that before we had you all sign up so I have the public comment sign up so I will go through this list if anyone is on this list and would prefer to hold their comment to the budget-specific discussion on item 9, just let me know. That's fine. I'll make a little
note, and we'll get to you when we get to item 9. Sound fair? Okay, so we will start with Erin Abbott. Okay, so I'm at Erin Abbott. I teach here at Freeport High School, but I live in Yarmouth. That's all the things, right? Okay. First, thank you for voicing your concerns about the loss of
a math position in the last meeting. Michelle and Jen spoke about why, when kids get to the high school level, they switch and sometimes go to private schools. If we as a high school say things like, we used to have computer programming, but we don't offer that anymore, and we used to
have a math team, but we don't have anyone able to do that anymore, and we used to have a crochet club, our math scores used to be higher, that doesn't help us look appealing to kids or parents. As Jen said, there is no one else in the math department who could teach the computer
programming class. In previous years, it was taught by a science teacher. While I believe that all of our current science teachers would prefer to continue teaching science classes, if computer programming is forced into that department for next year, then that negatively impacts all of
the science classes, their numbers, their offerings. Last meeting, admin explained that kids who have 76 or below in any class are shifted into an intervention walk. That a kid struggling in algebra would have 75 minutes of math instruction with their class and then they'd have 75 minutes
of support in some way shape or form. If kids are struggling in math, especially because they have gaps from earlier classes, they don't want 150 minutes of math. They're burnt out and they feel defeated. I want to give you a real glimpse into our current intervention labs as mentioned in my
last meeting. Let's say a kid passes algebra 1 with a low 70 and is placed in the math lab the following year. In that setting, the teacher is trying to fill gaps from the previous year while also helping with their current coursework, while simultaneously assisting other students in Algebra
2, Pre-Calculus, English, Science, History, and others who are chronically absent and therefore behind. That's the reality for many kids now, and will only be worse if we're down a teacher. These interventions may look nice on paper, but they are not the solution to raising test scores.
Pre-algebra, which wasn't mentioned last week, typically has two sections of students each year. Pre-algebra and Algebra 1 are the core foundation of all future math learning. I've taught math for 20 years, from pre-algebra to calculus, and I can confidently say that success in these two early classes determines whether students succeed later on.
When students miss key concepts early, those gaps follow them for years, not only in math, but also in their science classes. It is so important to have these specific classes be as small as possible, with the absolute best teachers, with the teachers that can connect with all students.
If you care about scores, kids' long-term success, and mental health, you start at the core. Increasing those class sizes is literally the opposite of everything you stand for in this district. Almost done, I promise you. I cannot stress enough that losing a math teacher will have only negative consequences on our students.
forget about the scores i'm thinking about the kids i hate seeing them cry because they feel hopeless because they're so frustrated because they know the misconceptions years ago and it's haunting them now we need this position the kids need this position our total population will
always fluctuate but our kids no matter how many will always need to have a solid foundation thank you for your time thank you and i i forgot to mention in my preface but i will uh just as Erin did. If you hear the three-minute bell go off, just to wrap up your thought and so we can
hear from as many folks as we can. So thank you for that, Erin. Next, we have Kathy Richard. Good evening to the members of the RSU 5 school board and superintendent Green. My name is Kathy Richard, and I'm here to represent the World Language Department at Freeport High School
and to speak about the proposed cut of the Latin teacher position for next year, as well as the French middle school position. In 2016-17, there were 500 students enrolled at the high school, and at that time, we had four full-time language teachers.
With the cut last year of the half-time Spanish position and the proposed cut of a Latin teacher this year, next year, we will have only three full-time teachers serving 560 students. We would like our stakeholders to know that these cuts will affect our ability to offer a rich
and extensive language learning experience for our students. Almost all of our students take one year of a language. Students who want to attend four-year colleges like you name need to take two consecutive years of the same language and students who wish to attend elite colleges need to take
four years of the same language. We are concerned that with fewer teachers we will not be able to offer those upper level languages and that will do a great disservice to many of our students and negatively impact the profile of our school. Cutting what few elective students have is not
in their best interest, no matter the level. Additionally, the proposed cut to the French position at the middle school is detrimental to the entire word language department. Having a choice of language at the middle school is helpful to students as they have the
opportunity to explore and test drive a language before committing to it. Languages should be taught at younger ages not repeatedly cut. Research shows that language acquisition at younger ages helps to improve focus and memory
while also increasing creativity and critical thinking skills. At the same time It fosters an appreciation of other cultures, something our world desperately needs in this moment in time. To echo what Jack Brogan said at last week's meeting,
these are the kinds of choices that cause families to choose to have their students attend elsewhere. What are we doing to the Word Language Department? What is the plan for the future of the Word Language Department? What message is the board trying to convey to the students, parents, and teachers of this district about the importance of learning another language?
Thank you for your time. Thank you, Calvin. Jill Hyland. Hi, good evening, board members, Superintendent Gray. My name is Jill Hyland, and I work at Preport High School. Last year, this board determined that the ESOL position on the chopping block was important enough to maintain and not cut.
But here we are again, cutting that same position while serving the same number of students. That decision, while difficult to understand, is even harder to justify. Over the past four years, our program has had four different leaders telling us how to do this work.
Yet the work of this team has not changed. We have maintained steadfast in programming and dedication to the students, and it has shown. Two teachers cannot effectively serve a district of this size. I respect the people involved in this decision, but I do not believe that there is a full understanding of the complexity of what ESOL services require on a daily basis.
This decision appears to be based on numbers, not on students, not on need, and not what the law requires. We currently have only three ESOL-endorsed teachers in the entire district, the ones that are leading our program.
Not admin, general education staff, or instructional coaches are not trained in language development. That means the responsibility for ensuring access to education for multilingual learners falls on the ESOL program. With this cut, we will now have only two ESOL endorsed teachers, who will be responsible for 44 active students,
nine monitored students across five buildings from pre-K through grade 12. Seven of those students are duly identified, requiring even more coordination and support. One teacher will try to cover FMS and FHS. One teacher will try to cover the elementary schools. How will they be able to include monitored students, required documentation, collaboration,
family communication, social-emotional support, and travel back and forth between buildings? Our service requirements call for one to two blocks per day across five, possibly six, schools, and it's not realistic. The services we will provide will become piecemeal at best.
At the high school, this cut eliminates the Multilingual Learner Reading Foundations class. You would never eliminate an English class, an English department, a science department, a math department. Yet you are eliminating the only ESOL English class for the students who need it most.
This cut will also eliminate co-teaching and in-class support. Not because we won't want to provide it, but because there will be no time. When support disappears, students fall behind, teachers lose collaboration, and the burden shifts to people who are not trained in language development.
High school schedule alone requires constant coordination across multiple classes, teachers, and grade levels. Students will fall through the cracks. We are being told to focus on what we're saving instead of what we're cutting, but from where I stand, this feels like balancing the budget on the backs of multilingual students.
We do not currently have the systems, the training, or the staffing in place to expect that this work can simply be absorbed by others. Language instruction differentiation will not happen at the level it needs to. Accountability will suffer, and students will receive less support than we have promised them.
And we are making this decision while the district holds millions of dollars in reserve. I urge the board to reconsider this cut, not for the sake of the position, but for the sake of the students whose access to education depends on the services we provide.
Hi, my name is Thomas and I am from Power. At Power we have a community and taking kindergarten through 5th grade out will be destroying the school more than anything else that could possibly happen. Moving us, including me, I'm in 3rd grade out, will also tear apart the community and cannot happen.
Plus, here at Powder we do tons of fun things, like swimming, skating, sledding, rollerblading, using robots, skiing, movies, personalized learning, making friends, and tons of other things. Taking out kindergarten through fifth grade would be devastating not only to the kids, but also to parents, teachers, and community.
And besides, if we were moved out of Powder, the vibe would be different and we won't be happy. And besides, we like the teachers and staff we have now, and we want to keep them. Our teachers are also teachers we know, and they are super kind. Plus, all of the fun things I mentioned earlier are because of our super cool gym teacher.
He even ran Teacher of the Year. We love Power Elementary. Please don't take us out of our school. Thank you, Thomas. I think, Moon, we might want to make a note for the future speakers. The skills contest a few years down the road, Thomas might be competing.
All right, so next, Lin Shay. Hi, y'all. This is not my thing to do, but I felt like it was really necessary. I've been before you one of your time, and it was during COVID, when during basketball, I wouldn't allow any fans in the gym.
And it was time, after two years of COVID, to allow my fans back with it to show you, and I learned the same page about that. But that has been my only time in the 20 plus years in this district to speak in front of you.
So I just want you to understand that this is a big thing for all of the people who are here tonight, speaking to you all about all of the issues that are really important to us as a community. I've lived here in the Freeport community for over 30 years.
I've had three children, while I'm completely being left script here, I've had three children go through the system. I'm going to go back to this. I've had three of my own children go through the school system. And today, they are all thriving in their adult lives as businessmen, a mainstay game learning, and a power engineer.
I truly believe their success is rooted in the strong educational foundation they received in this district. As an educator, a parent, and a community member, I'm incredibly proud to be part of this school system. It's what has kept my family grounded here in Freeport. When my own children were here in school, I found myself advocating for them, for their academic programs, for their athletic programs, their extracurricular activities.
Like many of you, I wanted the best possible education for my children, their peers, and my students, my own classroom students. And I feel like a lot of the primary parents that are here tonight and students have that same feeling, that same sentiment.
You won't see the multilingual students here. You won't see their parents here. They're not going to be here to advocate for their children because they often don't fully understand the process. They don't speak flu English. They simply believe that the decisions that will be made are going to be made in their child's best interest.
They trust me. They trust the team, the ML team, that has been building this program for the last four to five years. These families have worked hard to stay in FUPA. As you know, we've seen lots of ML families leave this district and go back to Portland and go back to the bigger cities because the resources are there for them.
But these families have worked hard to stay here in Freeport instead of returning to those larger cities because they value the education this district offers. For example, I have a parent who walks over two miles every day to Alabama to catch the bus to go to Portland for her job.
And she does that because she wants her children to stay in this district. She doesn't want her children in the bigger districts. It would have been easier for them to move back to Portland, but they stay here because they came here seeking better opportunities for their children.
And ERSU is providing that for them presently. Given this, I strongly recommend considering a 2.5 future model for the ESOL team. There hasn't been a decline in the movement. We're still at the same numbers that we were at last year. In fact, with our monitor students, our enrollment has actually increased this year.
Additionally, considering the DOE recommended service times for ML students, which is one to two blocks a day, this would mean one teacher would need to travel to three schools daily, while the other would travel between two.
This scenario doesn't even account for any potential new ML students in panel. I'd like to end by thanking you all because I do know the work that you do is really difficult. And having been in the district for a long time and watching the work that this board has done, but also other boards in the past, I do really value your work.
I just hope that you'll hear the conversations that are happening to me and really take it into consideration. And it's not to have a disrespect for the admin team or Superintendent Gray, because we also know that you're doing an amazing job and doing what you feel is best.
But we're the ones that are in the weeds. We get it. We understand it. And I would not be here tonight if I didn't feel like this position was very important. Thank you, Dan. I want to say Susanna, but I'm not sure if it is.
Suanna? Suanna. I'll come later. Okay. So for budget? got it um mike shaw these were some tough acts to follow and i haven't done much public speaking myself either in several years but i did want to mention that there were would you mind just
do me a quick favor with your name and your tongue sorry about that that's okay michael shaw and i'm from freeport uh i wanted to mention there's i think around a dozen students that participated in the statewide math competition up in Fairfield,
and most of them placed pretty highly throughout the whole state. Actually, my son came in eighth in the entire state, I mentioned, and I know I see some parents of some of the other students here too that placed very highly. That wouldn't have been possible without the teachers that he's had throughout the years. He's been in RSU-5 since Laugh and Learn, and I'll be quick.
I just don't think you guys should be cutting any teacher positions. I'm more than happy to pay a little extra of my taxes to have OSU-5 stay whole. And keep the problem at school too. Thank you, Michael. Mount Ellis. Budget, okay.
John Jakes. Hello, I'm John Jakes from Freeport, and I guess I get to play the bad guy tonight. Fun, fun. Uh, I am here also to speak on behalf of Mount Cutting. teacher positions um however there's something else that i would like to address that probably
would not be very popular considering the composition of the crowd tonight um i understand your concerns about raising taxes and the need to make budget cuts in this upcoming year i agree that a 10 tax increase is not advisable please take into consideration the long-term impacts on
the table with recent discussions about cutting french from the middle school curriculum i believe this would be very unwise. Long-term, it is essential to maintain the integrity and reputation of Freeport High School. The damage to our reputation should be considered in cutting
middle school French. Falmouth and Aramouth have strong public support for schools and avoided consolidating for this reason. Small schools are a dream on resources. Over a decade ago, I was part of the Freeport community opposing the consolidation with Powell and Durham
because many of us felt that it would lead to a reduction in quality education in Freeport. This is exactly why we oppose to consolidation. Middle school French is not the place to cut. It should not matter that Durham has never had French.
It should be kept so that our high school can have a strong four-language program. Classes should be maintained. Spanish, French, and Latin. All should be taught without prejudice for Spanish. Maine has a strong connection to the French language and history. Please honor that.
We should not be looking for cuts in teacher positions. I would strongly recommend that you look to reduce costs in administration, transportation, and technology. Now, I did look over the stuff that you proposed tonight, and I see some encouraging things there.
One of the big parts of my talk here was about how much we spend on technology, and I see that's a huge cut, and that's what has to happen, I think. That's part of it. I would strongly look at technology. Over a decade ago, I was the author of the chartered application for the Baxter School of Technology and Science.
At that time, I recommended switching from Apple MacBooks to Chromebooks. This would save thousands of dollars yearly while maintaining a one-to-one environment. The cost of continuing with Apple products is too expensive and frankly not worth the cost compared to the functionality of the Chromebook.
That's another discussion for a long time. It would need to happen this summer to save these teacher positions. Another serious problem is keeping the panel school viable. Those of us opposed to consolidating saw this coming. Pana is a very small town with a region population. The long-term viability of the elementary school was always in question.
If I were a resident of Pana, I would seriously be concerned about the closure and take a serious look at leaving the RSU. If the panel community would like to keep its school, it should be rough. It could withdraw from the RSU. It would give the community complete control over their school and free up Freeport taxpayers from that subsidization of their school.
Thank you for your time. Thank you, John. Miko Jakes. My name is Miko Jakes, and I am from Freeport, attending Freeport High School. I'm a junior. I'm here to speak in regards to middle school French. I believe that it is important to note that cutting middle school French is not just cutting a position, it is cutting a person. Madame Davis is an amazing teacher and an amazing person who is vital to the Freeport middle school community. I was in her advisory for all three years of middle school and took her French class all three years as well.
She changed my life for the better. I thought of her as a third parent during a really hard time in my life. She was a light in my day and truly believed in me when I needed it most. Every other student I know who took her class absolutely adores her. She has a safe space that the Freeport community needs. Thank you. Thank you, Anita. I'm Shana, or Shana Jakes.
The whole family is here tonight. Shana Jakes, Freeport. I'm a graduate of Freeport High School. I have a student at Freeport High School, and I have a graduate of Freeport. And I'm here to speak on behalf of saving middle school French.
And I think it's really vital and important that that position is not eliminated. Freeport has that strong connection to the French language in Maine. And it offered unique opportunities to my kids about going to the Quebec trip and becoming interested in other cultures.
And I think it's really important to expand students' horizons and allow them to think of themselves as global citizens. And I also want to second what my student said about Madame Davis. She's a great lady. Thanks. Thank you. Hi, good evening. I'm Zach Labay. I'm from Durham, and I'm a parent of one child at DCS, and one child here who just started at Freeport High School.
And I'm here to ask a simple question, which is, when I look at the proposed budget and the cuts that are coming up here, or the cuts that are being proposed, I don't see the point. I'm looking at a median taxation increase of $30. When it comes down to actually getting or keeping the service level of our school,
keeping our teachers, making sure that kids have full services, and we're looking to cut some of that, to me, over $30. It doesn't make sense. I've appreciated hearing some of the voices here today. And when I left the house, my daughter had just gotten home.
she asked me where I was going. I said I was coming here. And she immediately started talking and had a lot to say about how worried her and her friends were, how these proposed changes were going to impact their day-to-day lives in class. The last thing our kids need is disruption.
We need to, at the very least, maintain our service levels. We need to maintain our teachers. we need to maintain our programs and if the concern is asking residents for a modest tax increase i say it's time for the board to uh to show leadership and ask for us what you need
we will give it to you and i for one will do so happily thank you very much thank you zach this is the name of record guys mara it's weird to see you on that side of the microphone i know it's weird to be on this side. Is it part of that? Can you hear me? Okay. Good evening board members.
I'm Laura Pillsbury from Freeport. I do have a difficult task ahead of you to make these cuts as a resident of RSU 5. I want my children to be able to learn French and study world cultures in middle school. I want immigrant families to have extra support because of the fear and
uncertainty they're doing right now. I want our beloved community outreach coordinator who spent years building relationships in our community to continue to do so as a full-time staff member. And I want our teachers to have classroom and professional development support they need and all children to have the services and supports they need to thrive.
I understand we're thoughtfully considering these cuts so they will have a least negative impact on students. But that doesn't mean students won't be negatively impacted by them. For example, by losing a teacher that sparked a passion in the subject or by losing a teacher who helped them navigate making a home in a new country where they thought they would be safe.
Or by teachers not having enough support in the classroom to give them the attention they need. We all remember our favorite teachers through the rest of our lives because that's how truly impactful teachers are. They open up worlds to our children they didn't know existed. Impacts on a spreadsheet do not always reflect impacts in your life, and I'm asking you to keep as many staff positions as you can.
You've heard me say before that pitting older and lower-income property taxpayers in our community against the education of our children is a false choice. And it truly is. We live in a wealthy community. We have enough resources to give our children the education they deserve.
And yet I know the choice we must make to either raise taxes or cut positions is very difficult and very real. In Whitman's words, state-level policy decisions have put us in this position. This isn't the fault of anybody in this room. I've followed the work on the school funding formula and property tax reform at the state level, and I know we can't count on the state to fix this problem, at least not in the short term,
and of course not in time for this budget to be made. But we must keep trying. So I'm hoping, as a resident of Freeport, to ask the town of Freeport to establish a town property tax assistance fund funded by taxpayers and by private donations to
help those in our communities for whom property taxes are unaffordable. We do already have a program like this to support older taxpayers in our community that already exists. I hope Durham and Poundell will consider something similar. I believe our communities must take action to
address the inequities in our tax system if the state will not so that we do not continue to be in such a difficult position. There's no one magic solution but I hope we can take a small step to explore something like this in our town and show those in our community that our
community is a place where we value and care for our residents and students and we don't have to choose one over the other thank you okay so that is everyone I had on this list I think what I will do if we had anyone else I will give you
a quick opportunity what I might do is give this back to Erica and if we have I do have the two marked for, for, uh, budget. If there was anyone else who wanted to add their name to the budget discussion, feel free to do that. Um, you've got as long as
it takes for Tom to go through his, uh, superintendent's report. Thanks, everybody. So, I have a few things to talk about to frame the discussion tonight. First, Kelly, if you wouldn't mind, you have thoughtfully prepared some information about
tax impact that is probably Jermaine to share right now. So I'll let Kelly start. Pam, can you turn on the... Can you turn on the... Okay, so there was a request that came from Superintendent Gray to actually put, kind of consolidate, like, the tax impacts of the various tiers in one sheet and then show
the tax implications of that by community for those who are at home this document is available on our website under the budget section of the website of the fy27 budget for those here in the audience there were extra copies left on the table on the entry to the library and then it was
included in the board packets this evening so i'll just briefly walk through it it's color-coded in the level of tiers that have been discussed. The burgundy color, which is actually tier one reductions. Actually, I've got that reversed, don't I? Actually, those are the tier three
reductions, which get us to the lowest tier. Sorry to code that wrong. So 5.77 is tier three, which the superintendent presented but was not part of his recommended budget the blue line is tier two which is actually what all of the documentation has been built off of and the
list of reductions that you see within the handbook that you also received a copy of this evening the budget is built with the tier two reductions that results at a 6.53 percent year-over-year increase what I'm calling tier 2a which is that pink line the third line down which is 7.10
that was based on last week's meeting where the board asked to see the impact of what it would look like for the 0.4 FTE edition of the FMS Spanish position and it adds back the K-5 instructional strategist and it also adds two ed tech general ed techs back one at mass landing
and one at moore street that shows at 7.10 the tier one level reductions because again i've got to fix this on the one that's public is actually the red line those were the ones that the superintendent didn't actually recommend we go that deep and then 10.55 the black line that's
the baseline for the year-over-year budget. So I'll start with that one there and kind of read across the total operating. If we stayed at the 10.55, that would be a total operating budget of $49,148,089. It's a $4,692,160 increase year-over-year. We're going to skip the net reduction
column at this point because that basically is calculating off of what the superintendent's recommended budget is. So if we were to stay at the 10.55%, we would be adding 1.7 million back into the budget, um, to, into the presented materials. The net, net impacted taxation,
that is after, um, you take the expenses and then you subtract all of the anticipated revenue, state subsidies, shared revenues, local required taxation, and, um, locally funded debt that is in there. That's the overall impact. And then it starts breaking it down by community for you.
The first community listed is Durham. It would be a 7.98% increase, which for the median taxation, median household, the taxation increase would be $507,55. For Freeport, that's the middle two columns. 6.77 with a $433.28 increase, and panel would be sitting at 9.03 with 585.90.
Now, I will mention that the calculation that we're using here, we'll see what the asterisks, the amounts represent an increase in all the school portion of taxes. As you remember, your Local taxes within the municipalities are made up of three different components.
State, I mean schools, accounting, and municipal. So we are only talking about what the school's proposed increase would be on the tax rate. And we're basing it on the 25-26 mil rates and taxable valuations. Each community sets their valuations on, determines the valuations on April 1st of each year.
Obviously, we have not reached that for the 26, 27 years, so this is what we typically do. We use the previous year's numbers in order to calculate these for you. I will just walk up into the back to the blue line. So the black line would be had we not made any reductions whatsoever within the budget.
The red, again, are the Tier 3, Tier 1 would represent Tier 1 reductions. The pink is like two with a few ad bucks. The blue line is where the superintendent's recommended budget sits currently. And that is a 6.31% impact taxation.
The expected tax increase in Durham, 5.04, which is $321.01. 3.51, which is $224.34. And in panel, 5.27, which is $342.16. I'm going to pause there before I go into the next document that I was asked to create. I think it's assumed that these are per year, right, for the year of property tax, the amounts?
Yes, yes, yes, it would be the annual increase. Again, only the school portion. I always like to preface that because we are only one-third, you know, a third of the pie. So if there are no other questions, I will toggle over to what I'm calling version 2A
because we kind of called in the previous version. The discussions where the board left off last week where there was some ask of the superintendent what positions, if we were to increase, what positions would be added back.
So we kind of got to what I'm considering a version 2A at this point, which is kind of a semi-board version. I was asked to put it through the formula that I had initially created when we were looking at just the tier two reductions.
So the top box does not change because that is if we do no reductions whatsoever. And then the bottom lower box is actually representative of adding back in the point for Spanish at FMS, the K-5 Instructional Strategists, and the North Street and Mass Landing General Ed EdTechs.
Just for reference, I will toggle over to the original one that was put out based upon version 2, which you can see on the bottom boxes, it's 6.46%, 5.55%, and 5.91. If those positions are added, if version 2A is what passes, the projection would look, again, back down at the bottom box, 7.04, 6.12, and 6.47.
And those are the two notes that I had for you this evening. I will just briefly mention that the handbook that was also in your pocket, there are no changes to that handbook besides the date on the front. We just wanted to make sure that all the board members have a copy for the discussion this evening.
The handbook has information in it, such as class sizes, enrollments. It also has a history of the adopted budget for the 10-year period read. It has all of the proposed requests that came through the budget to make it 10.55 year over year.
And then it shows the list of reductions that the superintendent's recommending to get to the 6.53, which is Tier 2. It then gives you the articles 1 through 11 that make up your total budget. Because as you know, when we propose a budget and we bring it to the annual budget meeting,
we bring it in article form, and that's how we operate. And then at the budget validation referendum, the public is just voting on the total amount of the budget. Do they support it? Yes or no. The second to last page is the tax, the anticipated tax impact.
It gives you the full breakdown of expenditures, revenues, and the impacts to taxation, as we just reviewed. And then the final two, last page, which is front to back, we talked about last week, which are the article and facility reserves that we are holding at the district level.
Could you tell me, or tell us, please, if level one, which is the red line, if that's correct, what that means, putting that into the budget? I heard you say what 2A means. But just a shortcut guide, those on page 6 and 7, there's a little, I'm sorry, I hit the microphone, there is a little rating chart, like M is a maintenance type item, M is a necessary addition, R is a recommended addition, and then we get down to what we would consider T1 and T2.
that's your tier 1 reductions and your tier 2 reductions they're coded on the side and then there's the guide on the edge so you can also follow along there so I do want to go back and I'm going to share my original presentation that got all this started again um while this is up i want to i feel that my job tonight is not to give a hard sell but is to sort
of explain the reasoning and and respect your decision um a big part of the reasoning that i was trying to talk about last week derives from the projections of these numbers and what i have to do in this position is take a macro view and part of that macro view is what do we know we have
to accomplish within the next two, five, ten years as a district. And I know that there are some big ticket items. There are school renovations, if not replacements, within that period of time. There's early childhood to manage. There's one of the things that, you know, as further out you go,
the more we're estimating some key major cost drivers, like what we're going to pay our staff. We're negotiating some of that right now for the support staff. We'll start negotiating with the teachers again next year. Part of what is driving the increase that we're trying to figure out what to do with right now
is very justifiable pay increases for the staff across the board. I think those are things we'd like to be able to continue to do because they're investments in our district and our people. And I think we have to think about how we can accomplish all those big-ticket items
going forward by teeing ourselves up to have as much flexibility as possible. So those numbers speak to me and they're part of why I've recommended what I've recommended. It's to try to preserve that flexibility. So, Kelly, you can have your computer back.
Sure, no problem. Okay, give me just a moment here. I should do this. Yeah, I want to bring up my actual presentation, not just the PDF of it. Okay. So, what am I hitting here? Slideshow. There we go. Okay, so, you've seen this before, and I don't think we need to spend as much time on it as I did before,
but I want to come back to try to explain some of the reasoning that drives the recommendation that I've given to you. And before I even launch into that, I fully respect everybody here, and I fully respect your perspective and your coming to advocate for it.
and that's, I would be doing the same. You didn't know me as a teacher. I would be doing the same. I, again, I have to take a macro view when I look at the entire situation, and that's what I need to try to come back to. So, I don't want to go through the whole recommendation, the whole
slideshow again, but I want to point out some of the things that are major factors in my recommendations. So first is the projected enrollment and even more dramatically this is the historical enrollment. I'll talk about the class sizes in a minute and where the class sizes
are high and when they're low. So this is what I recommended and Laris you had asked a question about the difference between tier one and tier two basically like what the Laris level is. So the way i had structured this is that what you see in burgundy up there is that the tier one that's to
get to roughly an eight percent budget increase and the blue items are what i would additionally reduce to get to a roughly seven percent to get to tier two does that make sense may i just clarify that what i heard was that everything that's in red would still go at tier one yes and in addition
at Tier 2, everything in red and blue would go. Correct. Thank you. Okay. Can I add Tier 2A? And Tier 2A, which is not, this is my original slideshow, so Tier 2A would sort of add back in if I could do a different color right now. It would add back in the instructional strategist K-5 level, and it would add back in the two ed techs at Moore Street School, a mass landing school, and in addition, something that is not on
there at all because it's an idea that further solidified as we continue to talk about the budget after this presentation, would be to make the Spanish position at Freeport Middle School, which is right now port 6, to make it whole by adding port 4.
But I should clarify that, that would actually be, in conjunction with that, we would be absorbing port 4 of an ed tech. The way the role is currently structured is that it's port 6 Spanish, port 4 ed tech. We felt in our conversations recently that that port 4 ed tech
could be absorbed, and then we would add port 4 of a teacher. So if you're following all that back and forth, it's really adding to the budget port 2 of a teacher, which is not a huge amount of money, and likely gets us a big bang for our buck in terms of extending world language all the way to 7th grade. So I think just a major point that I don't want to belabor this, but I feel that what I owe you all is an explanation of my reasoning. I think that the differences between doing nothing and Tier 1 and Tier 2 in terms of the tax impact are substantial, especially as you go out year after year. And we're all making the best guess that we can about what is bearable for the community, and I respect that there are different perceptions
about what that is. Ultimately, the board would decide that. I'll just say that all it takes is one very committed group of voters to come out and change a budget. The total numbers that we had voting last year, I think you and I were looking at this machete, it
was like 1,300 people total voted. The budget passed by a few 300 votes. That's an amount that can change very quickly, depending on who's most motivated to come out to vote. And the harm that would be done to all of us by a budget that does not pass is very great.
So we are making a judgment call. There's no formula. There's no magic eight ball to predict what that tipping point is. But we certainly don't want to tempt that fate. And when I look at these reductions, none of which were joyful conversations,
what we all had to take note of, this really was a team decision. And I think that all the people sitting back there would vouch for that. We looked at, honestly, we looked at the staff feedback, first of all, which we took great pains to collect about what is most important to protect.
And we looked at numbers, as has been suggested. And we called upon our judgment, which is not as significant because we've been doing this for a while. And I just have to tell you straight up that the need that I see, if I were going to add positions back in, they would not be at the high school. And I say that with respect, but I would have a very difficult time adding back positions at the high school, when we look at the numbers, and having first, second, and third grade classes that are right up against the limit of the class size policy.
That's just not something I could in good conscience recommend. That's where the need is highest. And so, if we look at ad backs, you'll notice that when you asked for some ad backs, it's somewhere between what's red and what's blue.
That's where we went. The honest truth is that I believe everything that I'm hearing from folks here about, some of the impacts of reductions, there are also some impacts of reductions that we're not hearing about. And those are things that I have to think about and I have to ask the board to think about.
If I kind of go down a little bit more, this was my not recommended to you, I don't even want to talk about it. But if I look, this is a slide that really speaks to me. So if we look at the class sizes in K-8, if we look at North Street School, and I will have kindergarten classes, this is at the recommended level, that are 17-18, 17, 17-18, pre-K is at the maximum, which is 16.
If I go to Mass Landing, where 4th grade would be right at the maximum of the class sizes, 20 to 21, and then, uh, I'm sorry, that was 3rd grade, 4th and 5th grade at 18 and 19, and numbers slightly lower than that in Durham, except at 6th grade, that's where I feel I would have to add back.
So, if I go back up again to this other slide here, again, these are the items that we felt strongly that if the board had asked for tiers at 8, 7, and 6, this is the 7, this is what seems to, I believe this will pass, and I also believe that, I won't say that this won't have some negative impacts, but I will also say it will be fine.
the district i would not and these people behind me would not recommend cuts that we felt were going to decimate the school system and that's just the hierarchy of need as we saw it and i think that's that's really all i have to explain thank you tom and kelly for the information
this is what happens when i get up i lose oh no i gave my paper back right i did okay i was like i lost the paper um i have one other i have one other piece of information just to pass out to you. So Jen, and Jen can talk about this better than I can, but some of these can go this way. Some can go this way. These are the current numbers from PowerSchool about math enrollment in our current math sections.
Less. So I just want to make sure that I understand. I get the blue, the red. The only way that everything that you showed that was in blue and red comes back, It's on the black line. Correct, correct, correct. What I've just passed around are the numbers from Power School
for our current math enrollment at the high school. So, for example, yes, we do have two sections of pre-algebra. One of them has 15 students, the other has 8 students. That's a total of 23 students, and you can read the rest.
There are, of course, some that are peak a little higher. You know, we have a section in Honors Algebra 2 that has 19. We have a pre-calc section of 20, an honors pre-calc section of 20, an honors pre-calc section of 24, but these numbers still hold up lower than what you would have seen for kindergarten, first and second grade at Moore Street with the reduction of a teacher.
And it's more consistent with what other departments at the high school are dealing with. And, Jen, I don't know if you want to sort of explain this a little bit. Is this supposed to be found on dress? Good evening, Jenko from the East Court. So when I had spoken at two previous meetings about the numbers currently in the math courses and average courses,
there were some questions about each individual section size, what that looked like, and where those averages came from. And when I had spoken, I shared a selection of math courses. When I spoke last week, I shared Algebra I, Geometry, Algebra II, and the Honors sections for those.
Honors Pre-Calculus, Calculus, and the Computer Programming. And this week, what's in front of you is all of our math classes. Every class, every section that we have. And as I shared before, we, in most of our other departments, we hover between 18 to 20 students.
That's the threshold that we look. That's what we attempt to have in the size of the section. And there are some sections, as I explained before, where it might go up to 24 students. We're always challenged when we only offer one section of a particular class, and there
is no other section of that class, and there's 26 kids that are enrolled in that. We do make that one section or two sections, and students often change their minds. We have an odd drop period where they're able to change the course that they're in, but
these are where these numbers stand and as of today and so they have not fluctuated significantly from earlier in the year we always as you know have some students transferring and transfer out of the district or multiple reasons why
they may have had a shift in their schedule and so this is the representation right now and what I had shared previously with the board is that um these average numbers are lower than um or significantly in some cases and some of
our other departments were sharing those numbers last week um and we are feeling that um again in 2022 when i requested the addition of the amount of teacher that's when we were the total population of creeping up to 635 students and these average numbers were higher and now feeling like this is a place where if we were reducing our math department by a teacher we would still be able to maintain reasonable class sizes that are comparative to some of the other departments and we've had some input that if the teacher was cut that there would not be anybody to teach computer programming
Can you address how that might be, how that would be addressed? So one of our challenges right now, I would say we haven't had any discussion outside of the board meeting or made any decisions about computer programming. In some schools, it's a part of the science department because it's considered a STEM program.
And in other schools, it is considered a math program. We had traditionally had it as part of our science program here And then shifted it to a math teacher. And last year was the first year that it shifted to the math department.
Part of that was a balance of the size of classes and looking at current enrollment. Because one thing that significantly impacts our courses is the decisions that students make. So right now, we don't have our current numbers for enrollment for next year's courses.
And so then we would be looking at a total balance because our whole population would be reduced again next year from where it is this year. That has a ripple effect. It impacts all of the numbers in all of the courses. So for example, last year when we had 600 students in school, then we need X number of Earth System Science, which is our 9th grade science class.
This year when we're at 577, we need one fewer section of that class. Next year when we go down to 555, we again will shift the number of sections that are needed. And so we look at that closely based on what students choose to sign up for and then where that class is assigned.
So right now, in the past, we have not cut a class where we have students where there's a high interest level. For example, one of the classes that we cut this year that I thought was unfortunate to cut because I've seen it do really well in previous schools
This is entrepreneurship, where students are creating a business, and that wasn't something that students were signing up for here, and our sections were lower and lower, and we decided to eliminate that course. What we have done in other situations, we have looked at our current teaching staff and
thought about teacher strengths and student need, and then decided who is teaching each course. And so that would be the same case with computer science. Okay. Thank you, Jen. Is that the end of your piece? We'll end this the homily. All right, so now we are back to the public input,
and we do have a couple of names on our sheet here. So I will go back to Sue Ann and start with you. We'll just ask that you give us your name and where you're from. I'm Sue Ann Williams-Lingren, and I'm from Freeport. I really want to share my thoughts here with everybody in the room.
I'm struck by the multiple realities at hand, with the board, with teachers, with parents. I'm going to speak to another part of the community that you may not hear from very often, and that's the senior community. Hi, Steve. You heard similar to last night. So I was at the board meeting or council meeting last night. I'm struck by a passion you have to do what you think is right for your children and really support it.
I think there's some really tough Sophie's Choices that are being made here. And as you know, the tail legs, the dog, and the tail here is money. So last year, you had a 6.2% increase, right? And that was a pretty tough sell. So going much beyond that is going to be a tougher sell this year, and this is why.
And I'm sure all of you have been impacted by it. Electricity, up 20%. Food prices by the Consumer Price Index, up 30%. Fuel. Went to Irving two weekends ago, last weekend, up 50 cents a gallon. It keeps hitting us, hitting us, hitting us. It's going to be more and more and more this year as long as the Middle East is in conflict.
So everything that comes to us is going to be jacked up in prices because of fuel. And we can think, I won't go there. So there's RSU increase coming in. There's a ton of Freeport cola coming in. I want you to be very careful about the assumptions that you're making. about this community and people's ability to contribute to their taxes.
And I'm going to share with you my reality. I've lived in Freeport for 33 years in the same home. So the first 21 years, I paid less than $6,000 a year in taxes. Wow, that was amazing. The past 12 years, it has increased 53% to the tune of $132,000.
I'm paying $11,000 now a year. I pay $30 a day to live in my home. I have a very small home, less than 1,200 feet. I live on 1.3 acres of land. But because I live on a tidal cove, my property taxes have gone crazy. I didn't ask for that. I don't want that. But you guys do contribute 75% to what happens to our tax base here.
I don't have children in the system. I never have. I don't begrudge doing my civic duty, but when it gets to the point where I am now, that's a huge ouch. And Colin, I remember what you were saying in December when I was at one of these meetings.
We don't want to cause too much pain. So I think that there's a fine line between where there's pain and where there's burden. So I just want to raise that. I want you to fast forward and think about, if you were to be here 33 years in the same home,
What are your taxes going to look like? What kind of actions do we need to bring to bear in order to shift that? So I just want to ask and encourage you to make sure that you're putting money towards what we truly need here for our children, and not necessarily just the want.
But what's the true need? And I think that's a very complicated question. I won't begin to try to answer that. Thank you. Okay, Nate. Hi there. My name's Nathan Ellis. I'm from Freeport. I'm going to be very, very brief. I don't know if my notes were leaked to the public because most of my questions haven't been answered, but I wanted you guys to put out. I wanted real tax dollars to be presented so people knew exactly how it was impacted them.
I don't know if you would also present these other projected tax increases as well. It's about your job. You're the schooler to other parts, right, to tax increases. If we know them, it's okay to say what we think they are projected because we need to know the whole picture. I think it's really important. I want to echo what some other people have said on the exact side here.
You know, we are willing to pay more. But as we've said, it's not $30. It's some greater numbers. And obviously with that increase comes even bigger increases in the future. Just looking at what you presented earlier. I'm still willing to do that, but I certainly understand the burden on the senior community
and on folks who maybe can't afford that. So it's a huge decision. I think what needs to be put forward is the option for that. like whether, and where does that stop? I had a quick question on time. I don't know if you can answer this very briefly. You said it's very harmful if the budget does not pass. Can you explain
what the process, not the whole process, what happens if it doesn't pass? I can take that, I think. Kelly will tell me if I can tell you anything incorrect. So basically what it does is it restarts our process. So our budget process is, there's three primary steps in our budget process.
So we are currently in step one. Step one is the longest. We start in January and it comes to an end next week at the end of March where the board adopts a budget. That budget then has to go to the annual budget meeting, which is the three-town meeting in May. And that is where we vote on each article. As Kelly mentioned earlier, we vote article one, article two, article three down the line.
And then whatever comes out of that meeting is what goes to a referendum. And that's the referendum in June, the straight up or down vote. So if it were to fail at the referendum, we don't leave annual budget meeting until we have a budget.
So that one can't fail, but it could change. And then the third step is the referendum. So if it fails at the referendum, we go back to step one where the board then, I mean, we don't have to start from scratch, thankfully.
But we do have to make changes based on what we think is the reason it failed. Do we think it was too high? Do we think it was too low? It could be a variety of reasons, depending on what individual voters feel. And then we would have to go back to another annual budget meeting where we would have to go through that voting, the articles again.
And then we would have to go to another referendum vote. So logistically, I'm not sure what a realistic time frame on that would look like. It has only failed... Ray and Gloucester had to do it this past year. They didn't get a budget until November. Okay. And, well, I cut you off. Yeah, no, that was what I was looking for. The aspect of harm that I was actually thinking of is that it's basically a vote of no confidence in the board, in the board's decision. Not in the board as a whole, but in this decision. And that resonates across so many different levels of how the school runs for a really long time. that just does sort of harm to the social fabric of the schools.
That's great. I mean, it's very important for people to understand that, obviously. It's not a matter of having a backup plan that you then just put up to record. Right. Okay. Again, taxes, putting those things out to the public. You've answered a lot of my questions. I don't really have much else to say. I spoke with Tom earlier on the phone just to the point of presentation to the public,
how I think there are some simple ways to make it much better, much more searchable. It's just data. It's just text. It can be instant for the public to get it without having to pull over hours and hours of meetings like this one,
that'll be on YouTube, or documents online, PDFs of certain names that are hard to search through. I have ideas for that. I'm not going to waste folks time with that tonight. And the other question I had you already answered was the future costs that we have coming down the line.
Obviously, that's a huge factor for folks, right? It's not 10.5% now and then 6% moving forward. It's a lot more. I guess the last thing I'll say, again, I'm more independent. Sorry, just to be clear, I come from a family of teachers, a lot of friends.
It's important. I guess one thing that might be interesting is a priority list of these full-time teachers, the RIFs, from the board. If they're put in order, then we can consider, you know, if it's 6.5 can we increase, can we add one or two?
And what are the priorities from the Board of Recommendations of Superintendents? You guys will go through the reasons for why you think it's important and put those out there. And some of those reasons might just be public opinion, which is extraordinarily valid, obviously, right?
That's the people speaking for the positions they care about the most. Obviously, these full-time positions are the biggest driver when this budget change, right? They are the vast majority of it. So some things are increasing a lot. I don't fully understand, but I'm sure there are great reasons, like transportation, things like that. There are reasons for that. But again, the increase is the full-time staff. That's the real driver. So since we're at 14, adding two or three is not a huge change to this percentage.
I think it should be at least two or three or five or 14 or whatever it might be. But if we understood which ones are the most important and can advocate for them, then we can make a small change to this budget, or a big change. But I think people have put out a lot of really great reasons for why a lot of these positions are important.
And we can take each one in a vacuum, and they're all extraordinarily important, right, no question. But I understand that we have to look at it as a whole, so that's all I have to say, so thank you. Thank you, Nate. All right, Mike Shaw.
Sorry to take two bites of the apple, Mike Shaw from Freeport. I don't want to be the dead horse, but, uh, and I wish my son were here to help me with the math, but I think I've calculated between the superintendent's recommended budget and the 10.5 budget, it's about 50 cents a day for a Freeport average resident, and, um, honestly, um, in regards to Tom's comment, um, the voters, 309 is actually out of 1300 is a pretty good statistic.
I think you should give it to the voters and let them shoot it up or down. And if it's down, then come back to the table. But give us a chance to vote on saving at least all the teachers' jobs. If you can find cuts somewhere else, that'd be great. But I remember as a kid myself,
looking at my son's schedule through the day, he gets, like, say, gym class. He gets that twice a week for only one semester in the whole year. When I was a kid, we had Jim twice a week and art. We switched back and forth between art and music twice a week for the whole year.
So just looking from, you know, I was there in the 80s. I don't want to mention how old I am, but until now, to me. And they did add, you know, he has tech, which we, it was all combined into science back in the day. But, you know, so there are some differences there, but I would just hate to see teachers getting cut and, you know, their opportunities to pick classes that will help them excel.
And RSU 5 has been fantastic, you know, for our kids to be running these math contests statewide. And one of them actually is going to the national championship down in Orlando. These kids are pretty bright. But I don't want that just for my son. We want that for kids behind us. And I won't be having any more kids. But for any of the young parents here now or future parents, we've got to think about them too.
So, thank you. Thank you, Maya. Okay, so that was all I had for the budget. I think I saw two hands go up. So, I saw John's first and then, yeah, okay. Hi, I'm John Jakes from Freeporty. And I have a proposal for you. And it would begin by restoring the Freeport Middle School French position full-time.
Restoring the Freeport High School math position would not discount the fact that you will lose a computer science class. And that does not play well in the community. And you will have votes against the budget for coming to four teachers at the high school.
Or four teachers, and yet one of them, the Latin teacher, should be maintained. And also the ESL district-wide. your full-time teaching positions you really need to maintain because this budget will not pass from people who are not happy with that end of it. And I understand what we're saying. Seniors,
I'm a senior as well, and I've lived here for 20 years as well, and the taxes have gone, I agree. But we've got to be getting something for that. And the fact that the elementary school numbers might be on the verge, but they're not over that. So you can't sell the community on that.
You're cutting four positions. Three high school teachers decimating the language program. The foreign language program. That is not right. Where you can cut, page six of the handout that you gave here. Okay? Here are some things to consider. Just consider these. And right here. $202,560 miscellaneous supplies, books, furniture, subscription, contracted services.
There's no cuts of $200,000 there. So consider something there. You have an energy audit, I'm not sure what this is, for $254,000. No cuts in that. You have continuing vehicle equipment replacement plan, new buses down the line, $168,000. I think we could rape on a bus rather than cut a teacher. Think about it.
Transportation, 20 hours of administrative support with a ton of $15,000. That's another one to consider. So there is places, there are places, and the technology I already talked about. I mean, to spend that much money for laptops for all these kids when a Chromebook will do their job is, frankly, hasn't happened at this time.
And I was really glad to see you took a big chunk out of that, because that's a big chunk of money. So let's find the money and keep these teachers. Thank you. Thank you, John. Good evening. Michael Metzger from Panel. Really, just a quick point and then a couple of questions for you on the budget.
The first, from a point perspective, Superintendent Gray, you had mentioned earlier some of the close votes that have been done recently. I would say, you know, as we have more controversy around a vote, that energy can build on either side.
And I think that you can have seen from some of the more recent energy that has been building in panel with regards to some of the potential cuts down the line regarding panel, that that energy can grow very quickly on the preserve side as well.
And so I think you have a huge community here that has come out to support the budget as it stands today. And I think that we can rally around that. And I would say use that energy, use that if we choose to go with a higher tier, a smaller cut.
So I think there's an opportunity there for us to preserve more of our services. For the second, just in terms of a couple of really quick questions. First, when, Lewis, you had asked, you know, is there any room between the black line and some of the other tiers, right, 2A, you know, tier 3, you know, all of those, the answer was really sort of no.
But I'm not sure if that's really the case. And I would ask, you know, just looking through that list of where the reductions are, it looks like there's at least half a million, if not more, of reductions that have been proposed that are proposed for non-teaching positions, right, for non-educational purposes.
And so is there a tier potentially in there that fits where all of the teachers, where most of the teachers are preserved, but those other cuts or some of the other things that were just proposed are looked at as a potential for reduction there?
Question. Similarly, you know, was there any consideration given to not backfilling the open admin position that a search committee was just initiated for? so two things the first question um it's funny you said that because i actually after i said it
i was like there's a few things so i actually went through the sheet um and the technology piece is non-staff related um there was some facilities that was split into a couple that was about fifty thousand dollars which was non-staff related um yeah facility study i think the uh
the facility say we've actually already moved so um it's counting in these numbers i think though right, just coming out of the reserves instead, but school nutrition is on there, and, you know, printing clerk, potentially, right, you know, so I think, again, teaching positions,
I think, seem to be what folks are most, most concerned about, but, okay, great, and then last, I was just curious what, on the transportation side, if there were some really big increases on transportation this coming year, I was curious if you could shed some light on what So this actually, I'll just let you finish.
Was that your last question? It was my last question. Okay. So I'm actually probably going to grab Kelly for this because this, I think, sort of spans both your question and one of John's about the energy audit and the transportation piece
and what those relate to because those are part of a process. So Kelly, explain it better than me. Okay, so, where to begin? So, we'll talk about the energy audit last, okay, we're going back a year now. So, during last 25-26 school year, the school board voted to move forward with 24-25 school year.
Sorry, yes, 24-25. the RFQ, like for the RFQ for the energy audit, which ultimately ended up being awarded to energy management consultants, which we refer to as EMC most of the time, but I will give the full name. And EMC conducted a complete audit of our buildings, energy out of the buildings,
building envelopes, HVAC systems, windows, doors, furnaces. I know I'm forgetting some of the things. Glenn could probably tell me if I forgot. Yes, lighting upgrades. In order to try and find efficiencies within the budget,
future efficiencies within the budget, but also to address a lot of the deferred maintenance that has been happening as we preserve positions and put other things off. And so the energy management consultants presented the facilities committee
with an extensive comprehensive list which got weighted and broken into four different phases. In 25-26, we began phase one. are in that currently, which largely involves lighting upgrades, a furnace here at the high school, and a few other things. And as part of that process, we are taking on a lease payment
annually for 17 years in order to get these capital project items done, but spread them out over a period of time. What you see here in the budget, because we did a lease payment, is the first year payment, because this is 26-27's budget, is for the work they're currently
doing in 25-26. So that number cannot be reduced because last year at the, I believe it was like the April 30th meeting maybe, or the 9th meeting possibly, the board voted to move forward with phase 1 of the energy audit. This is the payment for phase 1 of the energy audit. So that's not
something that can be reduced. When we look at the next item below, which was addressed, which is the continuation of vehicle and equipment replacement plan, we, when I got back to RSU 5 and did an inventory, a complete inventory of all of the vehicles that are in the district, because it's
not just school buses. We have grounds maintenance vehicles. We have many vans that transport students to and from school because they do the IEP needs. We have many vans that deliver kids to out-of-district placements. We have vans doing shortened schedules for students. So there's several vans as well.
Most of that, there's no plan on replacement for the vans at all. We were trying to do two, maybe one bus a year but depending upon how the budget worked out sometimes we got a bus sometimes we didn't get a bus um and so last year um during the budget process the tournament for what we're
currently expanding this year we presented to the facility a joint facilities and finance committee a vehicle and equipment replacement plan and i would be honest not to mention the tractors that but none of the lawns and plow, because those are also in this plan.
There's no plan for replacement for those. So over last year, we spent a considerable amount of time. We inventoried all of these items. We looked at the list. Had we replaced them on schedule, almost 75% of the fleet should have been replaced in 25-26 that we're in right now.
Based upon their useful life, we've been band-aiding these together, which is one of the drivers that you see for another item that got talked about tonight, which is the, um, contracted services, supplies, that kind of thing. That's where the repairs are. So I'll stick on the vehicle replacement, but I'll go and talk about that one. Um, so the, for $168,000, it's more than a bus.
It's actually two buses. It's the lease payment on two buses, two vans, a tractor, a gator, and a grounds vehicle that was in dire need of replacement. So this is the first year of the lease payment on those items. The board also voted, and you will see it coming back again next year because, again, this was a phased approach to replacement for these vehicles where we're trying to keep a flat amount within the budget to help offset those costs.
Also presented during that time when we were looking at taking on the energy audit costs and the vehicle and equipment replacement plan, we looked at how we could do that incrementally for the taxpayers, meaning taking them on in incremental steps.
So one of the things that we did last year, which was for the 25-26 budget, which was the first lease payment on those vehicles, I'm sorry, this is the second lease payment on those vehicles, we actually increased the amount of undesimated fund balance that we were using, which is a revenue.
Again, get too deep in the layers, but you take your expenses, you subtract out your revenues, and then the net is what goes to taxation. So what we presented to the board and the board approved was to utilize some of our undesignated fund balance in order to level off the impact annually for taking on phase 1, 2, 3, and 4 of the energy audit over a four-year period.
And then taking four years to work into a vehicle and equipment replacement plan where ultimately we will stop having to lease and we will be able to just buy the vehicles outright and not spend money on the interest as well.
So we tried to be responsible last year, but part of being responsible last year locks us into monies for future years in order to implement these plans. That takes care of those two items. I will speak briefly about the transportation 20-hour administrative support.
That is, while it's an add of $51,821, if you look at the line right below it, I am using a half of a staff member within my office, which is transitioning into that role. So you'll see a negative $51,821. So that's a net zero, although the expenses are moving from the system administration article
for that person and being transferred to the transportation article. So that's some of the transportation article increase. The lease payment that we talked about for the $168,000 is also part of that. And then, of course, there are staff within the transportation articles because there
are bus drivers that drive the buses and there's a mechanic, well, there's a mechanic's position who we're filing at somebody in that role next year. And we also have van drivers within that articles. So while you see salary benefits and increases, part of that 3.1 million, it's not just
teachers and ed techs, it's district-wide. It's everyone except for nutrition and community programs because they sit in a separate fund. So there's more of why transportation is up. And then the other piece within transportation, there's an increase within the contracted service
line because as we all know working on vehicles you don't necessarily do that women house anymore all our vehicles are computerized and have to be spent sent out to to a shop to be repaired and so there are increasing costs and we are trying to mitigate those by updating our fleet
so that our buses and vans are not as old but until we can get to that point of where we're actually working with newer vehicles we need to continue to increase that line we all know that fuel costs are up that's part of the transportation line insurance costs are up that's part of that
district-wide miscellaneous supplies books furniture subscriptions contracted services the financial software in my office that we use to to pay all the bills and to pay all the people there's increases there um and the other thing i will mention about that line is that's
basically a net increase line so there the schools were asked to look at their supply lines to look at any unnecessary items and make cuts where they could so while i didn't list every single item because this book would be huge um you see all the lines that are within the budget um that that
amount photos it up. And they did. They really did. They came in at those kind of non-staff items very well. That was where we looked first. I think I got them all in. The only other thing I wanted to mention that we didn't talk about during if the budget fails is you revert back to
your previous year budget. So it gets so you can operate off of your previous year's budget until you pass a budget but as we know and we're looking at you know we had this meeting in November just a year over year staff increases that doesn't mean everybody's wages freeze
right it just means that we are potentially 3.2 million dollars behind because we're only operating off of last year's budget thank you I knew you do a better job of that than me okay any other comments or questions for the public input piece before the board begins their
deliberations mora hi thank you sorry i would be remiss if i didn't bring up the teacher contract and i know you all will be renegotiating that next year and i'm curious what the historic increases have been in the past um prior to the current contract and i know that the um i know
that the current rates are higher, I believe, than they had in the past. So I'm wondering what the future assumption was for those modeling scenarios for the future and what the percentages would be then. And I know you all can't predict the future, but if we think those higher increases will need
to be sustained like we saw in this last contract, that's my question, I guess. So I don't think I have a perfect answer for you because uh i don't have room in my head for all of the numbers that i've ever learned at the board um so i don't know exactly crazy i know um but um the i can tell you
the assumption that i do know uh which was the assumption was that so next year is the last year of the current teacher contract and we assumed that again so we assumed that same rate which i believe was five and a half i'm just gonna sit down yeah thank you so um so it's so it's seven
for the ba level and then 5.5 for the master's level and 5.5 for the cast level okay and that's and that that's just what the scale goes by for those who aren't at the top of the scale there are steps in between so there's the net increase works out to be different depending upon what your
level is and what step you're on yeah okay um and i will just mention that for more purposes 25 26 the uh ba level was seven percent uh the um the ma and the cas were six and in 24 25 the ba level was seven and the ma and cas was 6.5 so it was seven 6.5 6.5 the first year of this contract
Like, the second year was 7.66, and this last year, which is the year we're going into, is 7.5.5, 5.5. And yes, when I did the estimate, I used what was this year's, because we can't predict what we're going to end up negotiating. So I thought that was safe. So, yeah. Yeah, and, whoa.
We talked about this a bit, was it last week? Were you here last week? I think we were. Were you here last week? We talked about this last week in our deliberations, and I think one of the things that came up in that was trying to be transparent about that assumption, and that since we're making that assumption,
we are also effectively signaling to the union that that is what we are approaching those negotiations with, and sort of owning that as a sort of like a starting point those conversations um so that we would be transparent both for the board but for the public
and also for the staff um that uh any negotiated uh increases there above that um would have impact on that um on that assumed increase uh that we have there um which again to be transparent would likely than transfer wouldn't translate into additional staff cuts um i think what we were
trying to do last week and i'm just reiterating is just being clear that um as we said before we want we are very supportive of having uh competitive um contracts for our for our staff um also just acknowledging um that we have to make those assumptions and if um it is higher than
if we say it was 5.5, then there are downstream effects of that. And just for us all to accept that, and also just for the public and the staff to know that. And one other thing I would like to mention is that's one component of a collective bargaining agreement.
Right. So we also assumed that health insurance coverage levels remained the same. That's not what I'm saying that the premiums remain the same. What I'm saying is that the district is covering at the same level. During negotiations, there are many levers that can get played with, right? So there's typically a pot of money that we can then move levers with.
And it might, so when Cohen says that's the starting point, I wouldn't necessarily agree that that's the starting point. It's the starting point for the pot of money, depending upon which levers get triggered during negotiations. Thank you. All right, going once, going twice.
Thank you. This is great. I feel like we've had this public input on our agendas for this meeting for several years, and I'm not sure we've ever had people take us up on it. So thank you for those who did. Thank you for everyone who came and spoke during public comments. We do have another public comment at the end, if you want it to stay. We would encourage you to.
but uh so now we will move um from the public portion of this to the board portion of this so item 13a is the 2027 budget deliberations by the board and i will just start with um i will just start with the uh reminder of our goal for the evening um next week we are scheduled to adopt
a budget and as we mentioned in the process a little bit earlier that is the budget that will go to the annual budget meeting in May so what we're shooing for tonight is for us essentially to come to that number so that Kelly is able to
bring us those articles etc next week for us to adopt and then sign and get that process moving. Um, we are not required. We could come and change some things if we wanted to next week. I would, I would prefer if we didn't, but you know, it's, it's, it's our decision as a
whole board. So, um, I would say that the smoothest process is if we can come to that number tonight, um, and, um, and then we will adopt next week. All right. So, um, I guess I have a request and a suggestion of how we talk about the discussion tonight that I just wanted to talk about.
I think it would be helpful if we maybe spent a little bit of time at the beginning talking about how we want to approach this discussion and how we want it to go. And as you might imagine, I say this because I think it's important for us to remember
that it's not our job to run the schools. It's our job to see that they're well run. And I think the best way that we could do that is by discussing in percentages only and to not get into a situation where we're talking about position by position.
And that feels most appropriate for me, especially because we actually have no say in how any of this money actually gets used. We can only authorize money. And I think it's important for us to remember that as we talk about it. And I think it's important for everyone that is listening and watching us to know that that's the case as well.
I think if we were to go position by position like has been suggested and questioned and talked about in the exploration phase, if we were to talk about that tonight, I'm concerned that we'll continue to erode trust between administrators and us and administrators and staff.
i worry that it is excruciating for people who are potentially being impacted by it um and i kind of think it's a disservice to all effort that has been completed so far to get back to a place where we're going line item by line item person by person um and so for that reason my my ask i
guess is that we talk about how we're going to talk about the budget and my suggestion would be that we talk about a three percentage increase yeah i thank you stephan i think that's a really great way of framing this discussion and i to add to that i just really want to acknowledge all of
the work and the thought and the care that has gone into the process to this point by our administrators and our superintendent because i know um that tom superintendent gray has done an extraordinary amount of work trying to get input up into this point from our administrators from
our teachers and our community to try and shape priorities for this budget so I just want to acknowledge that that there has been a lot of thought and care put into what they feel our priorities to keep and what is going to have the least impact for our students and I really
just respect all of that work and I want to thank you guys for doing that and I just want to acknowledge too that if we don't do this hard work this year, I think we're going to be back here next year. And it's going to probably be at least as hard next year to make this, have this
discussion again. So I just think we need to keep that in mind. The third thing, I wasn't here last week, so I'm not really sure how much discussion was had, but I would really like to hear a little bit about the difference between 2 and 2A in terms of the impact. So if we could get a little
bit of discussion about that, I would appreciate it. Thank you. Sure. So if I go back, not to last week, but before that, there had been some conversation here for board members asking, like, if we were to go somewhere between the least invasive tier and the tier I recommend,
what would, what would I recommend adding back? So I went to the team and we had a discussion about that, and last week I brought forward, okay, if you were going to add something back to get between those four, the priorities would be, and the instructional strategist
K-5, making the middle school Spanish teacher holes, which would enable us to make sure that 7th and 8th graders, all of them, get world language, and the two ed techs, the general ed techs, Etmore Street and Mass Landing, respectively, and that fits in with the, for
me the broader priority but i think the team i think i honestly speak for the team if anybody i'm getting this wrong throw a rotten tomato um only if you have good aim um it it really is that it's the elementary schools and particularly the youngest grades
where the need is greatest there are a few aspects to that that i haven't even brought up yet it's that the behaviors that we're seeing from young kids they are not what they were five or ten years ago at north street we are contending with extreme behaviors all the time from very
little kids who need lots of support and that's what i have to weigh against very valid arguments about a math teacher at the high school i'm not saying that that's not a valid argument but i'm saying i've got to tell you the need at the other places is greater that's where we need
a person more and as i look at all of those possibilities to add back in for me my recommendation would be you're almost adding everything back in before you add back in things that are at the high school right now so what i hear you saying is that having these two elementary school ed techs
for uh to help manage some a lot of the behaviors we're saying would actually be pretty valuable Is that one in here? They would certainly have an impact. We can manage the impact without them. Another sort of strain of conversation that intersects there was the question about administration. And I told it was Mr. Metzger that we had not considered reducing administration.
We did put that on the table in our discussions. But what we really found was that, especially at the elementary schools, We recently added assistant principals at those schools. Assistant principals can intervene with behavior in ways that ed techs cannot.
Assistant principals can call parents, can impose consequences, can help with 504 processes, can follow up on attendance. We've seen dramatic decreases in absenteeism since we added those positions. And having those positions there, it's a valid question to try to, it is a valid priority for sure to try to prioritize student-facing positions.
What I'd have to say very frankly is that those administrative positions are almost entirely student-facing because they're dealing with behaviors that lets the teachers teach. And at the central office level, we are already understaffed compared to other districts.
That's in terms of administrators. For example, in Brunswick, they have an assistant superintendent and they also have a director of instruction. We've consolidated those into one position. We have one special ed director with a district of 1,900 kids and over 400 of them with IEPs.
Of course, we're going to be adding an early childhood director that will also, we've cast that position purposefully as an assistant special ed director because the early childhood mandate from the state centers on special education,
and it's going to explode that need. And the money that pays for that is almost entirely out of the separate stream of money that the state will be sending us for early childhood. We are cobbling together administrative support positions centrally
to try to address the transportation need, which is pretty glaring. Right now, our transportation director is actually doing three jobs. He's directing the department, he's driving the bus, and he's the mechanic. And he does not have a direct administrative support person.
That's a lot of every time a kid needs to change their route, or every time there's a field trip, or every time there's a snow day, that department needs more than it has. We really have to make an investment there. the way we chose to invest it is to basically take somebody who's right now in the business
office and make them half-time transportation and half-time business office to get some much-needed support there. So I think maybe I've digressed a little bit, but I'm just trying to explain some of the calculations that we, the calculus that we've wrestled
with. Yeah, I guess what I'm, specifically it would be nice if you could address the value added of these particular, the instructional coach and the .4 Spanish? So with regard to the instructional strategist, what we have really found is that those,
the instructional strategists in our district are really creating commonality of practice and they're working hand-in-hand with the administrators to really elevate practice and elevate teaching all across the grade span. And we're seeing results of that in our data. Our data are quite strong in those early grades. And much of this comes down to what's, you know,
it's all about the greatest impact on kids. Could we get by with one fewer instructional strategist? We could, and we'd still be in a better position than many districts. We get a lot of bang for our buck out of that position.
And I think another aspect that's been discussed a lot, and I completely get it, you know, we've talked about is world language. And that's across, you know, the entire grade span, K to 12. And as I've said before, I would love for us to be a district that had world language all the way down to kindergarten.
I've come from districts where that is the norm. We are simply not there at the moment. And when we looked at the numbers at the middle school and the high school, we were, yes, we'd be losing a Latin teacher at the high school. But what we have right now is one Spanish teacher, one teacher who teaches French and Spanish,
combination thereof, and two Latin teachers at the high school. We can reduce a Latin teacher, which prevents us from having to reduce somewhere else where the impact would be greater. And we can still have French, Spanish, and Latin at the high school. And at the middle school,
what we found is that the way that the school is configured and time is used in the schedule right now, only 55% of any kids are getting, of the kids are getting language at all. And fewer than half of those are taking French and those who take French we looked at the data most
of them do not go into French too at the high school they actually the greatest plurality of them choose Latin and after that it's French one and some choose Spanish so when we weighed all of the factors and we realized that if we make the schedule at the middle school more efficient
We can, that would, and there are many pieces to that, but it enables us to reduce some teaching positions which truly are not needed, and if we focus on one language by making that one teacher whole, the Spanish teacher I mean, we can make sure that all middle school kids, grades 7 and 8, get Spanish.
So, while it is reducing an option for a language, viewed through a lens, it's actually expanding access to word language. That seems to be like a solid recommendation. First, before I forget, because my brain is mushed sometimes, there was a suggestion that we just upload our numbers without context.
And I think this discussion is highlighting for me how important the context is. Some of the line items were called out, and when we explained the backstory, I'm hoping that they were clearer as things that we've already considered.
But if you don't watch back, you don't hear that context. You don't, like, some of these titles are misleading, but we also can't have a whole paragraph for a line item. I think what might be helpful, and I don't think it currently exists, is if there's a way for us to index our YouTubes a little bit.
So that if you are particularly interested in this discussion, you can click on it and watch that discussion. Because as a new board member, increasingly I've noticed that we have little spurts where the public is extremely interested in what we have to say.
But they don't always have time or energy to go back and see our previous discussions where we've actually hashed it out quite a bit. And I understand that. I've actually been there. Um, but I would love to give them more of a chance to be able to do that, um, and see
that we have done some of this work, um, it's not, while it feels like it's in a vacuum, it's not, and, um, at least give them a chance to see our thinking without us having to relive it in real time again. Um, and we're all busy, and I understand that, um, but it would be great if we could help
them along by indexing or something of that way. I just wanted to get that out before I forgot it entirely. I'm not in a position for that, Valerie. I feel like it might be a fun-time job to try and keep this. I mean, I have something that's been on my brain for the Strategic Communications Committee,
and so I'll be sure to take that to the meeting scheduled. For what it's worth, just while we're on this point, there was a gentleman who spoke whose name was Nate. Yes, Nate was the one that mentioned just that point. So I talked to him on the phone today, and he did have some really interesting ideas about It's nothing we can do quickly or right now, but for the future, how we could take the information that we have made publicly available, but it's dense and it's not necessarily easy to sift through, especially if you're just walking in in the middle of discussions.
I do think that would be a valuable thing for us to work on. And that was a takeaway from his comment as well, because, you know, I look at a fair number of different districts' websites for information when I'm trying to compare things and things like that, and I actually think our website has a ton of information on it, like way more than you find on most districts, but there's a lot, and there's a lot of places, and, you know, so I think any feedback around how we can make that more accessible for people,
or, you know, ingestible in a reasonable way is great. So thank you for taking that back. And then the other thing I wanted to say that I am rehashing from previous talks just because I think it's an important topic here is that while the feedback we've heard is really wonderful on the staff
that might be getting cut, the final dispensation is determined by the contract with the union in many cases and not necessarily position-based, right? So you're talking about which individuals were produced? Right, right, because I love these testimonials so much, and it really is cutting. I know that many of us are sitting here in English because it's a true Sophie's Choice. So that's where it's really hard up here, because, you know, folks can come to the podium and they have their First Amendment rights and they can really say whatever they want, but we really can't go into, We have to follow the contract, which was negotiated. And the way that the reduction of force clause for the contract works
is that staff members all have a certain number of points, and the points are assigned by different categories. And the most significant one of those categories is length of service. There are others, which is how many certifications that you have, and your evaluations is a part of it. But when we discuss, when the team discusses which positions are going to have the least
impact to kids, we were scrupulous about, we cannot discuss this with a name attached to it. It just has to be the position. And so that's how we have to talk about it here, even when we hear very valid feedback that a particular person is really valuable to us. They are, and that's not among the criteria we can use in our decision.
And then finally, hopefully, for now. All rights reserved. Yep. Something that I mentioned last time we have not yet discussed is the LD in front of the legislature that would potentially reduce the state funding. And how that would impact, since we're trying to do a lens of the long view, I think that's most responsible.
I hate to do this to Kelly. Do we have anything that might estimate what that would do long term? I did it. Yes! Haha, I did something Kelly hasn't done yet. It's because she was doing all the other stuff. I kind of ran through, and I didn't run through all three tiers, because I do actually have a job during the day when I was doing this, but I did run through tier two, and I went, so, as you guys shared, there's kind of three proposals that have come out.
All three would, uh, basically what this is, is sort of a re, um, a reallocation of the funding formula and, um, to, uh, to try to get money to, um, districts that have a harder time raising it from their tax base. Um, and so there are three different scenarios, um, that are proposed.
all three would result in a reduction to funding for RSU 5. So I ran through just sort of the tax impact piece of it. So the least painful is a reduction of just under $200,000. And that would be a tax impact of 5.36 in Durham compared to 5.05, 3.86 in Freeport compared to 3.51,
and 5.67 in Pownall compared to 5.27. And the second tier was $644,000 reduction. That goes to $6.1 in Durham, $4.86 in Freeport, and $6.62 in Poundo. And the largest cut to our funding is $1.44 million. And the Tier 2 budget would have a tax impact of $7.41 in Durham, $6.14 in Freeport, and $8.29 in Poundo.
and i always want to put the caveat that kelly puts on this is just the municipal part of the budget excuse me this is just the school part of the budget excluding the municipal and um and the county now to be fair uh in all three towns the school budget is the largest portion of the pie
i know it's she called it thirds but our third is bigger than everybody else's third but it is not the whole and this is just you know the increase from our portion assuming everything else is flat. So it is, it is meaningful. My understanding is, is they are
recommending the lowest tier, the $200,000 roughly decrease. But that, you know, that question has been weighing on my mind too, Valerie. You know, we can make decisions, you know, things we can control, and then there's things we can't control. And, you know, none of the recommendations see us
increasing our funding from the state they all show it decreasing our funding from the state so keeping that in mind as a as a potential you know thing on the horizon that we're going to have to grapple with i think is important i read the article don't forget that would go into effect
for 26 27 i don't think so i can't imagine the plan is it would change the funding they've already provided isn't it i just i layered it on against stars i i couldn't imagine they could even make it happen by then but geez that would be that would be a little rough to pull the rug out after everybody's done their budgets well again that's why they're preliminary 8279 so yes right but
this is not usually what preliminary means it doesn't mean they're going to change the law in the middle they could but i'm just going to get on my soapbox and pitch there is a if y'all want to listen about it tomorrow march 19th is a joint committee on the joint committee on education and
cultural fails and hosting a work session on a number of bill amendments this is one of them one o'clock you can watch it online or you can go in person and i would probably if you have a chance speak to your local legislator send testimony um because it will have a significant
impact my understanding right now is metpro was recommending the 90 10 tier um but that's the hundred ninety one thousand correct which is the lowest impact to us but again we are we are in the minority in the sense of loss right so there are
there are more there are more districts that stand to gain from this change then there are districts that lose from this change and so yes you'll largely see that most of it's southern maine that tends to lose um and it in um in the again i'm not saying
there aren't some southern main districts that are going to gain but for the most part when you look at the impacts of where they are it's largely um central and lower um so i just while we didn't build this budget around that um because this kind of came in late to the process especially for us
If it does take effect this year, and we've gone through our annual budget meeting and voted on a referendum, we're going to be looking at a subsidy reduction, because we've already assessed taxes at that point, and we'll be looking to make some curtailments, to be honest.
Before I lose her for just a second, this thought, would any of the article reserves we have set up be potential offset to that curtailment that we would have access to without an annual budget meeting? Yes, as long as we have the wording appropriate on the warrant at the annual budget meeting, which we'll be sure to have the ability to expand from, but then it would have to come back to the board for a vote even after the voters approve.
I'm just trying to think process-wise. Yeah, sorry, Les, go ahead. Has anyone read the LDs? It should say in there whether or not it's going to be put off right here. They usually put that language in. What are the LD numbers? It's LD 2226. It's on, um, I have, you know, all of it. Are there three different bills, though, did you say? There are other things that they're also discussing. So there's LB 2226, and then amendment review of LB 2175, 2192, and 1892.
So they're talking about more than just one thing. 2175, that's regarding legislative review for credentialing, educational personnel. If you just give me the numbers, I'll read them tomorrow. 92. 92. And then 1892. Those are the, well, technically the four that they're talking about tomorrow at 1 o'clock. It's beginning fiscal year 27-28. Okay, so not next year. Right. But it's something we would be building into our budget next year and having to account for next year.
what I know is that this bill will have the support of the MEA and also the Mainstay Superintendent's Association. So I think it's likely to pass. And one of the factors that accounts for why we are kind of a loser in this, and correct me if I'm wrong, but one of the biggest factors that they're reconsidering is changing the emphasis on property valuation
to some of that would be changed to income as measured by student poverty. And they'd be using basically the federal free reduced form to the data from that as a measuring stick. So, and they're trying to account for communities where people's property values have skyrocketed, but their incomes have not kept pace.
And, you know, like, for a lot of people, that's a good thing. But in places where the income is relatively high compared to the rest of the state, it means you're going to get less. Because the pool of money isn't being proposed to change, it's how it's distributed.
And I think one of the other challenges is pre-launch changed. We don't even collect the form collection rate of two forms. So, right, we do have to, we're in the cycle of we need to collect them again next year. So we will be making a hard pitch for the actual forms.
What's still in question is whether or not the alternative economic status form will qualify or not. Right now, when they're calculating our EE 279, they don't just use the free and reduced applications. We're allowed its districts to circulate what we call an alternative economic
status form, where parents who aren't taking advantage of free and reduced lunch can actually still claim whether or not they qualify for it. And then that helps us through our EE 279 for uh disadvantaged numbers when you're when you're calculating the weights um can they call something
else because it's all free lunch now like everyone gets free lunch it is but it's again that's to me that's part of the complicating factor in is how accurate the fully reduced numbers actually are because like you said most people are confused because lunch is free no i don't need to fill it
out it's always free correct and so that that's worrisome right because how accurate is the data is there local data available from the feds on who gets snap and who gets other services that those are all qualified those are that's right
that's who qualifies in so well can without asking parents to fill out a free and reduced lunch form that people don't understand everybody gets free lunch, can we use other data, like SNAP, like who gets main care, who gets different services, to figure that out? Is that available to us? My understanding is the free and reduced numbers and what auto-qualifies. What I heard discussed last week when I went to a whole dog and pony show about this, was that, okay, this is complicated, and I don't want to presuppose everybody knows the backstory,
to determine who would be eligible for federal free and reduced lunch. So we used to get that form every year. Where that intersects with state funding is that, so we have that data, and the state gives us a multiplier effect
for certain students who fall into certain categories. So we have every student we have who is considered economically disadvantaged, has a multiplier of, I think, 1.25. Special education has a multiplier of, I think, 1.5.
ESRL students have a multiplier, etc., etc. So it's really to our advantage to get these forms in. But then the state came along and made lunch free for everybody, which is super, but it also meant we're not allowed actually to collect that form every year,
and instead, we're only allowed to collect it every fourth year. So next year will be our year to collect it again. But in the meantime, there's this other form that the state developed called the alternate form, which is so that, okay, you're not filling out the federal free form anymore,
but we still need to know your day-to-year-to-year for your state subsidy of how many kids you have in poverty. So we're going to have you do this other form, and thus we create form confusion. And we don't have all the people filling out the forms. And every year we're hounding all of you to turning the form.
It's because that's where our money comes from. So this is where the state wants to draw its data from to make this determination about income level, to revise the funding formula. And one of the things they said to all the superintendents and business managers and people whose heads were swimming with this last week
is that we've looked at a bunch of different measuring sticks for this and this is the best one. I don't know if it actually is, but that's what they're selling. So that's what we have to pick up. I guess the point, Lois, though, is that while there are what we can call direct
cert, like those people who are getting SNAP and stuff, they're on what we consider a direct cert list. So that notifies and qualifies you automatically. There's a lot of people who don't go out and seek SNAP and sneak up, seek other benefits that are potentially eligible, and that's what we're worried about
missing, is that, you know, if they're relying strictly on those forms, and people aren't on the direct cert list, we may be missing those people that we're capturing with this alternate economic status form. And I'm looking at the text of the language of the bill and it does say that are eligible for free and reduced
price meals. It doesn't mention the ability to collect like with an alternate form like we do currently. So that's concerning to me just knowing that we do pick up extra qualifying families through that form and this legislation doesn't allow for it. It's not clear to bring it all back to the budget because they're probably going to get less money in the future sorry I realize
that I'm on a tangent but I'm hoping this will close a loop or at least something that we can maybe table for another time but at least have it in the back of our minds is there any way that we can partner if we're already with FAPE and our early childhood stuff working, I'm assuming, with healthcare providers to identify those kids. Is there any way we can partner with them when they're asking questions about food insecurity? Being like, could you give them this form if they say yes? The form? Yes. Is that something that is possible? I'm not sure. I don't really get into that. I have a lot as somebody who's very data-driven I have a lot of knowledge in the crowd nodding, so I'm going to go with a nod. Okay. I am so there are there are possibilities for sharing information with providers there is another form
involved to allow those permissions the other piece I would recommend is revising our initial point of contact at that point of registration making that workflow for parents simplified and hopefully computer-based because there have been some we've been conducting a lot of our work on
on paper. And I think there are probably more streamlined ways to do that. So yes, we can, through a process with providers, the state created this statewide, I think it was probably about eight or nine years ago. So that can be put into effect, but you're still going to miss some
people because there won't always be those partnerships. So I think our best effort is placed probably at our first point of contact and making sure that the opportunities are understood and easy to access yeah and i think it's important for us to be um very transparent on why we're
collecting this information right i mean i think it's a it's clearly a sensitive topic for families to share um i think it's important for for community members to know why we're asking the question particularly when there is no necessary all the lunches are free it's not for free and
reduced lunch anymore so why are we even asking you for this anymore i think it's really important that we communicate that our funding is driven by this, right? Everyone benefits if we, you know, we know we have communities
and we have, you know, families in our community that fall into these categories where we can be reimbursed at a higher rate, which helps the schools and helps everybody's tax bill, right? Like, that's good for everybody. So, you know, we did a big push on this this fall and we got a significantly increase in the forms
that we got back, increased. So we're pushing it. We're continuing to do the same. Yeah, I think we need to keep doing that. I just wanted to come back to Stephanie's sort of framing of the conversation, and I think it's a really good one. I think that I suppose what I would maybe add to it as a, if we were to say, yes, let's talk about it
in terms of, just in terms of percentages or in terms of just the budget numbers. I guess as I've been thinking about that, I think what that presupposes, and I suppose I just wanted to suggest that we kind of make a decision about it, is sort of whether or not as a board, for the purposes of this conversation, we take the superintendent
and administration's hierarchy of need that they have articulated kind of as gospel for the purposes of this conversation or not. Because I think that that question, I think then it just feels like that question kind of comes before sort of the point that Stephanie's making and I think that there's kind of two paths
that that sets us down. One is we um we then say okay we're not going to be having a conversation um where the board is uh directly expressing um views around the value of certain positions versus other positions um whereas or we go down a path of saying we are going to do that um either just being clear
with ourselves of which of those paths we want to go down um i just think that would be helpful for us to do. Yeah, I understand the reasoning behind thinking about it that way, but as a kind of a counterpoint to that, I feel like this entire discussion is based on these positions, and yes, we will end up at a percentage, but the positions in it matter. The positions are why the public was here talking. The positions are why we have this document in front of us with them outlined and whatnot. The positions are this. That's the discussion. And so I feel like just stating a taxpayer percentage really discounts that we all have our own priorities and spaces
and that, yes, the administration has done great work in this, but their priorities and ours might not match. And that's why we're here. And so I feel like an example of this is the adding back a half-time ESOL position is not something that was a priority of the administration, but is something that I find I am becoming more and more in support of.
And that is me talking about a specific position, but that feels like why I'm here. And that I'm not here for the taxpayer percentage, I'm here for the student impact, And that my view on the student impact is important in that. So I think that when framing that discussion, that's where I'm coming from.
But I think that I want to talk about positions and not specific percentages. Despite then eventually ending up at specific percentages. Because that's what we vote on. And I hear you, Chris, but I think we need to be really, really careful.
Because when we had a discussion and it got into positions last year, It just, it doesn't end well. It doesn't feel good. Where I'm at right now is I tend to support the Tier 2A percentage. I have a few questions about some cuts that would remain.
One of them is about ESOL. I feel as if several board meetings ago we did hear from Erica about the numbers and how the schedule was going to look and how we were following the law, I think it'd be helpful to be reminded of that if that's possible, because I'd like to see that. I was concerned when I heard from a teacher that I think it was an entire USOL class
was going to be going away at the high school level. I wasn't really sure what that meant. I also have a question about what we're losing by the half-time community outreach position, moving from full-time to half-time. And then my other thought that just keeps, I've asked it before, it just keeps coming up for me is we have these five special ed tech positions vacant. If they continue to be vacant, is there a way we can get creative with using some of that funding for what the administration says that should be used for?
So those are my three points that I'd like to hear about, but tentatively, I would like to move down the Tier 2A. I just want to say I like your suggestion, Colin. I think it would be really helpful, Connie, to know what people are feeling in terms of percentage or position.
I personally, and I think it's our job to think about percentage. The administrative team has done a ton of work to present us with budget options that they feel are appropriate and can serve our students best. And I would love to frame our conversation just around that percentage and what we're comfortable with as a board and not talk specific positions.
I just wanted to add that I think that sharing our own personal perspectives is actually not our job. Our job is to enable and to support administrators to do their job. And talking about positions, for me, is very clearly an administrator's job.
I can ask questions about it. I can make sure that I don't think it's negligent or harmful, but I don't think that it's my job as a school board member to weigh in on any particular position. Yeah, I'm thinking about this in terms of what budget our community will support versus what kind of value we will be getting from that budget.
And so in specific, the difference between Tier 2 and Tier 2A is the difference between 6.53 versus 7.1. Is that an extra burden that our community would be willing to bear? And if it is, having these extra positions in here, to me, seem like they would be worth it.
And so that's kind of how I'm framing it, like, is this percentage something that our community will bear? Because if it is, these particular positions seem like they would add a lot of value. Yeah, I think, just to put a fine point on it, is that yes, we all do have our compasses and our ideas on what is valuable, and I don't think in any of this the suggestion is that that's not part of the discussion,
But I think the way I was framing my recommendation is effectively we either as a board trust the superintendent we hired to have run this process and to deliver us what he did do, which is to deliver these different tiers, um, with a careful accounting of the, um, of the, um, the impact of those different choices. Um, and I think, I think, again, it's sort of, I, I, I'm making it pretty binary, and it's not, it's not necessarily that binary, but I think that it's helpful to kind of keep, keep that in mind a little bit, to just sort of say, like, um, uh, you know, to, to Anna's point, and again, I think, I think we have,
We've owned in earlier conversations, I remember a conversation in Durham this fall where we had a very frank conversation about the impact of the way the budget process went last year, and what the drivers for that, and then the process that was, and then the impacts of that.
And my general sense coming out of that was that while there were reasons, and very valid reasons, why the board chose to have the kind of conversation that we had last year in response to some of the information we were presented with, that we don't want to repeat that process.
But, again, that's why I'm saying I'd just like us to sort of decide as much as we can effectively, whether we say, Tom and the other administrators, we know you looked at this really hard, and no one wants to cut any position, and we know that these positions connect to real human beings, and we understand the value of all of what they do.
And yet we're trusting you to make a determination that this is the least impact. Either we do that, or we don't do that. I think maybe my most appropriate ask is that I will not say that we are perfect in our judgment. But what we have really striven very purposefully to do is weigh where the impact...
All these choices are relative to any other choice that could be made. And what we've tried to do is weigh where the impact is the least. And so when we get into these conversations about, I think that adding back the math position has a lot of value,
I won't disagree. But what we've had to think about is, okay, but does it have more value to add that back than it does to add back a second grade teacher? I don't think it does. And I don't think the team thinks it does. And those are the way we've had to approach this. And the same is true for any of the community outreach courses.
leader the esol position etc we've had to really weigh it against what else would we add back first and i think that the fair ask of me is not to ask you like please come in at this percentage i think it's as a representative of the team to um i think i'd like to ask for your trust that
we that's how we looked at it and if you were to ask us we'd like to come in at this level we've tried to tell you what the map to get the roadmap to get there is that is the least impactful all the way around um and that's really not just it's it's it's not about me it's about
the team and how we work together and i think um i appreciate that um and i think that that's exactly why it's really challenging for us to like pick this over that because we don't have the global and and you know fairly to have uh you know someone at the high school they they don't
have the necessarily the value of of knowing what the impact of that that teacher at more street looks like right it's just impossible um you know no shade on us or them or it's just not possible for us to have that global impact i i feel our our job is to say you know we we gave you a charge
in in durham we asked for you to come back with some tears um you've done that i think it's our job to ask the impact of the those tears you've done that um we've asked you to come back with more information you've done that too um and we've asked you to rethink some of that right i think the
the the middle school spanish piece is a really good example of that right like that sort of evolving thinking based on what you're hearing and what is still good for kids and a way that's workable in the scope of everything else. So I think we've, I'm going to go to Kara because we
haven't heard from you yet. And then I kind of want to, we've now spent 20 minutes talking about the process of how we're going to talk about it. So I'd like to get us moving on to the actual talking about it. Yeah, I think I just want to add to the fact that we have so much to weigh,
like there's, we've been given so much to weigh, including public comment, and emails, and conversations with neighbors, and friends, and other parents, and it's a lot to weigh, and so I just want to just acknowledge a few things that this is really hard, so I just want to say that
this is really, really hard, and no one here needs to be told that, and I would imagine not a lot of people in the public or in the schools need to be told that either but there is i i've been going through a grief process actually throughout this i think that we are grieving the potential if this
passes loss of a lot of positions and even though we're not supposed to think about the people we think about the people right and so there's some grief there these aren't decisions we take lightly we make lightly it keeps many of us up at night we're grieving the loss of positions and
also personally i'm grieving the fact that we're in a culture where education isn't valued at the level that many of us would like to see it valued in the sense that state and federal funds aren't keeping up helping more to keep our systems afloat to a degree that we would like to see
um and some people in the communities aren't don't value education enough to be willing to pay more in taxes but i know it's not just about valuing education we are living in a time of uncertainty and rising costs and impacted personal budgets um i'm grateful that our budgets have
passed before but i worry that our luck will run out if we continue to push it and when we look at the tax impact, we might see, oh my gosh, that going from 6.53% to 10.55%, that's only a difference of like $25 to $70 per taxpayer. But really, and I had to take a moment to recognize this,
this is year over year, the total amount that we're asking. And it compounds, as we've heard some people share that how much their taxes have increased over the last 10 years, and that is something to consider. It's hard, but it's something to consider. At the same time, you know, I do have
concerns about specific cuts, and I won't go into those, but I want people to know that it is concerning for many of us, and I don't want to save money just to end up with widening our achievement gaps and reducing workforce readiness and potentially increasing
dropout rates or impacting future enrollment, like, those are all the things that I think about, like, is that what the impact is going to be on that side? We are tasked with striking that balance, right? And there's no perfect answer. There's no right answer. It's just a difficult
one and we're forced to consider all the things that have been brought to us and the long-term sustainability and I think that's the piece that I keep falling back on is that long-term picture and if we are going to be receiving and that
bill has not passed so but I agree Tom it looks like it's heading in that direction I don't see us receiving more federal or state funding anytime soon in with decreasing enrollment and potential formula change and the possibility of taxpayers being
unwilling to continue to pay more and more and more. I don't want to go through this next year again at the same level. So bottom line, coming back to the numbers, I would support a tier 2A and consider that bold to go to tier 2A. That's my long comment. Is your hand up please?
Okay, I just wanted to quickly point out that Tom tricked us a little bit because tier 2A is actually 7%, which is what we originally wanted to say. Well, to be clear, when we put those together, we didn't know what the state's subsidy was going to be.
So we felt like we're going to lose some little room. And then it came to more than we thought. So, okay, extra little room. And I appreciate your kind of forethought in that. And to that point, Anna, that's kind of why I'm coming down around the two-way mark.
Yeah, and I just want to point out, with the adding back in the .4 FTE Spanish, I know it's not everything everybody wants in terms of supporting our world language program, But being able to offer Spanish to all of our 7th and 8th graders,
it seems like that's a really good compromise, that if we can allow them all to be able to experience a world language, it's at least heading in the right direction. And I appreciate the data that was pulled to see, like, you know, do we, are most of our kids that are taking the French Avenue,
moving on to French 2 and getting to French 5, and from what we've seen for the last few years, that's not been the case not to say it never would be but um you know most of them are either going into french one which they could still do um or switching to a different language also great
options um so uh i appreciate sort of the creativity around around that piece um too because i i mean it's for me it's i i feel like it's actually an expansion of the world language program to go from 55% of the kids. And I know Pam was clear to say not 100% of kids will take
language. There's some that still, that wouldn't be a path for them or appropriate for them, but somewhere I think from the 85 to 90% of kids will be taking a world language. I mean, that's a, that's a pretty big pickup in my opinion. So, okay. So, um, I guess my question, oh, Chris,
yeah. Oh, sorry. Um, I appreciate all of your thoughts on, on this and, um, I know it's my first year so this is this is definitely um i sympathize with what you said kara um a lot of a lot of what you said has been just definitely weighing on me um and so i think that's one of
the reasons why thinking about the people is something that i can't not do um but that aside i i agree that i'm i'm at that two-way point i think that the uh the word language especially that adds significant amounts of value for which is what point two um of a full-time educator i
think that's that's incredibly good so okay i'm also first here and it's a lot to understand i appreciate all the hard work that's been put in um very much um i'm not in the schools i don't know how all of that works and so i appreciate tom that you go and meet and deliberate and come up
it the best scenario. So I'm trusting in that process. I wanted to, this may be just because it's my first year, but I'm also leaning towards the tier 2A and it says 7.10. And then it goes over to the estimated tax impact and it says 7.03. And then down below on the other sheet,
It says 7.04. So why are there differences in the numbers? They're slight, but... I'm going to have to ask Kelly on this. It's rounding. So, well, maybe it's rounding. So the first column, that's year-over-year expenditure. So that's like total expenses to total expenses. And that 2.10, that, I think, is rounding. That, I think, is supposed to be...
I don't know what my pictures is. I'm sorry. So, nope, not that page. if you're looking at tier 2a specifically okay so tier 2a 7.1 um i think that's actually 7.05 or something like that um and it got rounded um so it's it's
when i'm looking at the formula it's taking the difference and dividing it by the year before with suits and it comes out to 7.10 but i feel like the other well i think last week it was like for 7.04 or 7.05 it was 7.05 last week and then because i was doing it on the fly okay and then
i only added back a 0.2 spanish teacher but i thought then checked my notes and we needed a 0.4 okay that's the problem with doing it on the fly taking it out taking stuff out and adding stuff in on the fly it's when you go back to double check your math because you need to create
a warrant that's a little document you can find your boobos so we appreciate you doing that 7.1 i don't know that seems a little extra you know i don't i think that just seems a little bit too much to take an exception and then um unless you want to point to spanish so here's so here's my
question then so why is this one still say 7.04 for the new one that says 2a because that's still the the impact one yeah yeah that that might be a large one to do with rounding because it's pulling off of other sheets okay yeah okay so um so that that's the difference in the expenditure
piece the net impact to taxation piece that is a different calculation altogether because one is just expenditures and one is how much flows through to be collected because this is always something we have to talk about every year that that first net impact of taxation that is purely
like how much are we collecting in taxes in total this year versus how much were we collecting last year so there's other inputs in there like the revenues the state subsidy and the next natural question which you may or may not have is like so how come the towns are different like why is the
town why do they okay because they all come from different faces and no rights so um that's why those are different is that moving back there it sounds like a ghost in the water geist what's happening over there you're putting up lights in the other room we just don't know it lois
okay you're not gonna want to hear this that's okay so i heard one of the gentlemen who came to the microphone to speak, say, 50 cents a day increase. So I thought, that can't possibly be right. So I subtracted. And I do still know how to do that in spite of everyday math.
And so I took... I like that one. So I took 507, which is the status quo number, and subtracted away the level 2 number. And the difference for Durham is $186 a year. The difference for Freeport is $209 a year. And I'm sorry, I have a ton of friends in Poundell. Their increase is $243 a year.
Durham, it's 50 cents. Poundell, it's almost 60 a day. I know gas is going up. I know electricity is going up. And to the young woman who said that she was an elder, I'm on a fixed income too. But I'm going to tell you that to me, one of the few things that I get from Durham is knowing that the school is educating our students.
I get trash pickup too. Don't forget you guys. But that's about it. And I can't support 2A or 1. i will support the status quo and when the vote comes if you're voting on too well i'm gonna vote no just want you to hear that because education to me is it thank you i appreciate that perspective
Well, um, last year, me would have agreed with you, famously did agree with you, um, this year, me, as I look at the year-over-year increases, and the last two years, we passed 648 and 683. This year, it's not a clean school budget referendum.
It's also primaries, where people who haven't educated themselves will be seeing this number in a vacuum. And as I've already stated, numbers in a vacuum are easy to dismiss. Easy to misunderstand. If a less engaged voter sees a number that was very high,
in their view, pops on their phone and sees, what is last year's? Sees that this year's is higher. They don't see this regulation, they don't see us smashing our teeth, struggling, um, I have grave concerns that this greater group that we maybe can't all reach with an education of where we got to this number,
they wrote it down because of all the reasons that I think we can all come up with on our own. Which is why I tend to lean towards 2A as well, and it's with great reluctance. I think the same reluctance a lot of us have. Because I don't want us in the position of running next year's school year on this year's budget.
Yeah, I just want to say thank you for that and for that clarity, and also just to say that that's how this is supposed to work. That's exactly how this is supposed to work. Yes, we do each individually need to figure out where we fall.
And I think that I was having a conversation with somebody in sort of a different context about the, you know, the value of consensus. And I think, like, consensus is, like, is a really powerful thing. And I believe that often, in many contexts, like, consensus is, like, really what you should be aiming for.
But I also think that the public bearing witness to, like, good conversation and then folks dissenting from a view that perhaps a larger number of folks are taking, I think it's really important. i think it's really important for us to um uh sometimes joke that if we have a meeting where
like we have all agreed on everything like when we get to the like can i have a vote to dismiss like i sometimes want to vote against it but i do like i just want i want to vote against it because i was like i just i don't like um because i think it's important uh and i don't because i'm
always tired um uh but why aren't we so late if we always all agree that's a good point but i think again i just really i just really wanted to i just really wanted to value that and say that but again i think that i think that's important i think that's important and um um i think also
just to say um uh to your to your question because you got you did that you did get practical there Michelle, like, I also am in support of 2A, and I think that I also just want to say that, again, when, as I say that, what I'm saying is an individual, and if we end up supporting that as a board, I think what we are doing is both trusting in the work that Tom and administrators are doing, and also putting a hell of a lot of pressure on Tom and his administrators to deliver
what he says they can do, and if they can't, then we have to have conversations about that. Like, that's the deal, right? Like, that's the deal, and that is taking into consideration all of the things that have been communicated, and all of the concerns that we have, so I think, I guess I just sort
of wanted to flag that, it's sort of like, if we do end up voting for something that less than the status quo, um, it's with the knowledge, um, that all of the issues that have been raised, um, are not only, uh, that are valid and true, um, and that we will have
to navigate those, and they don't go away, simply because we vote, we vote that way. Um, and I think I just wanted to, I, this is sort of more of a, um, this is very personal, but I think I just sort of wanted to own that through this process, I think I have been, um, very aware that, uh, that a year ago my wife lost her job, uh, through, um, the Department
of Government Efficiency, um, and I've been thinking about, um, and took care as part of us that was staying up late, like, there's moments where I'm just like, I'm like, the amount of time that I have spent thinking about this budget, and thinking about this community, and this
collection of students um not to mention all of the other folks who are decision makers in here um if that entity has spent a pinky full of that amount of of that amount of deliberation um i would actually uh somewhat accept the decision uh for my wife to be fired um because
i'd be like oh there was some there was some reasoning behind it there was like some balancing there was some balancing of, like, all the balancing. We're doing kind of, like, pros and cons, right? We're sort of saying the least impact. If someone said, like, do you know what? Like, we really have to hold on to somebody else, but, like, you're fantastic that we need to let you go.
We're like, okay, I'm going to suck. But I would at least have that to hold on to. And so I think just, I just wanted to sort of air that to say that, like, that's the seriousness with which I take this work. And that's what I want to say.
My initial comments weren't my flu comments because I, too, have trouble sleeping with all of this. And also, I just want to be sure that my humanity is also seen through my request that we use just percentages. So I wrote something down that I'm going to share it. So I'm trying not to be too long. I, too, am in favor of Tier 2A, And it feels like a support of the superintendent's recommended budget with a slight modification.
And I support that because immense time, effort, and care have come into this budget at our direction. And despite all of our questions, concerns, the administrative team's recommendations have remained consistent and confident.
We often ask how we as a board can help our administrators. We've been told what would help. We've needed a recommendation with clear alternative options. And choosing from one of these is a very direct way for us to provide that support.
The Board has trusted and supported these administrators' remover their concerns and asked for additional support and resources. I think we should also trust them and they recommend where reductions can be managed and where they can be made to support long-term sustainability and flexibility for our students.
Cutting staff positions never is going to feel good, but I also don't think that making cuts is inherently bad for students. We also have a responsibility to look at all the components that go into providing equitable public education for all students across the district.
Especially when we know the challenges and uncertainties that lie ahead. And I want to acknowledge that there are many thoughtful and understandable reasons people would disagree with this approach. All of this passionate engagement speaks to how much people truly care about getting this right for students.
It makes me feel grateful to be a part of a community and a board where that care is so evident. And it gives me hope about what will be possible as we continue to face the challenges down the road. So, that's why I'm supporting you with Tier 2L as well.
So, thanks for listening. Other comments. So I also spent a lot of time thinking about this, as you can imagine. And I like to look at trends. I like to look at data. You know, we got an email today from someone who is deeply involved in knowing how schools work and budgets work and impact on kids and teachers work.
and one thing that jumped out at me was the reference to kind of how our budgets have increased over time relative to just general market conditions. And so I'll do a little more math. And I look at page five of the adopted, or excuse me, of the workbook, the handbook,
and I kind of look at what our increases have been over the last several years. 4.22, 4.99, 6.48 6.83 right now we're kind of in the 6.5 to 7 range um and I think about what Valerie said about people who just come and sort of like what was last year's oh gosh they want more they want
more again um I feel like I can confidently say that um you know tier 2a meets the needs of our children. It is respectful of the people in our communities, and I think it's what we need to do to continue meeting the needs of our kids in a thoughtful way. I don't like to see numbers in
the sevens. I don't particularly like numbers in the sixes, if I'm being honest, but I also value education. I also think it's important, the most important thing we can do for our communities. i mean nice roads are great um my car appreciates them but the most important thing we do is
educate our kids um and i fully trust our team that at this two tier two a tier they will continue to do that um there are always impacts um but i think it feels to me like a defensible position i will sleep at night um knowing that i think what we have done has has um is appropriate
and weighs the impact on all of the stakeholders um so and i appreciate everybody's thoughts on this so um so we don't take an official vote today um we will take that next week um but we We do want to provide the insights to Kelly to prepare the warrants.
I will say that everyone has free will. And if seven of you show up next week and say we want to change it, we could. I don't want to eliminate people's actions or agency in this process. But if people are feeling comfortable with their decisions and we can provide that insight,
That is a smoother path forward. I feel like I'm hearing 2A is the consensus. I guess we could do a straw poll. I hate straw polls. So basically, just a show of hands of who is supportive of the tier 2A for a budget. I think that is probably adequate for what can we do. So that would basically add $255,979 to Article 1.
All of those add-backs would be in Article 1. So when that changes the article, I just sort of did the math here. It's $20 million in some as opposed to $19 million in some. But that's what the warrant would reflect next week.
Okay. So I just want to mention, I think last year we changed it at the last meeting. We changed it like eight times at the last meeting. so one consequence possibly if next week we come and we have some other suggestions and want to
change again is that the brochure the budget brochure does not get mailed out but last year that was that was unfortunate to not have that in the mailbox for people interesting actually because i think we talked about this uh earlier in the year actually named it at the dorm meeting
um where we'd heard a fair amount of feedback that they preferred that method um and it's The QR codes, people really liked that. And it was a lot cheaper than preparing and mailing books. We mailed the one-pager, which we would continue to do, which kind of gave people the timeline of where to go, and where they could find if they wanted an actual copy.
It was at all the schools. It was at all the town halls. I think we had it at the library, the mallet hall. so i i don't think the plan was to actually print the whole brochure anyway this year yeah okay there were going to be some at key locations yes yes right so we will print it it will be a printed
but it won't be mailed to every mailbox and historically the strategic communications committee has reviewed that booklet i think last year the finance committee may have reviewed that but is that something that we might have some input on no we are meeting at the end of the
month now and to talk about quite a few things i think yeah uh but i i think that that's one piece that would if we if they're march 30th is when we're meeting i think um okay i also do again trust you tom to to write um your letter in a way that explains what's happening but i i wonder if
there could just if there are ways to explain yeah i i yeah i think that that's ready for improvement yeah yeah no i don't disagree with that um maybe maybe i would say there's probably because i always think of jenny's probably losing her mind right now the fact that we're talking
about this um because there's a lot of spacing issues and like pages and it's so um i'll just apologize now um and when does it need to go to the printer because this might be completely unrealistic and i reckon yeah i don't know i i don't know the answer to that so um i remember
from last year when it got delayed a week it was like we had one day like if you hadn't approved it at that meeting it wouldn't have gone out yeah i think the mail piece is the bigger and i think we're able to get the fewer copies that don't have to go in the mail sooner but so yeah we'll
figure out the details on that I do think it should have a set of eyes on it from the strategic communications it might have to happen before the meeting and here you guys might need to move up the meeting because I do think there is some timeliness around that going to the printer but
I basically have the information I need now to be able to write the letter. Okay. I just want to bring you back to your handbook, the budget handbook. The second page has the timeline on it. So I do know that the first meeting that we're at when we go and visit each town
and have the Q&A session, that first meeting is on April 8th, which is pretty soon, pretty soon, and so, and the flyer mentions April 8th, but it also has the QR code that links you to the budget document, so we need a document to link, right, so we need a
document to link to, what's going to the printer is the one-page flyer, right, that has, like, the budget stuff on it, the most important piece of that are the dates that outline when people, the Q&As, right, and it tells you when the BBR is and it tells you when the annual budget meeting are, but it also has that QR code for people to look at the details so when they come to that Q&A they can have a full look at the budget brochure. So we need to at least have it in PDF form for when those are intended on hitting their mailboxes. Once people have it in their mailbox, right? Correct. So we'll work on that piece of it.
Do you have what you need, Kelly? I do, thank you. And the 7.04 is because you only have 0.2 of a Spanish teacher in that. Okay, so that's what that's up. Yeah, because I did that piece before I actually noticed the error on the other one.
Tom, you had mentioned that we were moving a 0.4 ag tech to a 0.4 for the Spanish position. Is that included in that 7.1? yes okay too many papers um all right so we will we will move on from from that um we have no new business we have no personnel we do have public comments and we do have some folks who who hung
in there so we will reopen public comment if anyone had anything they wanted to share everyone shared out i completely understand um all right well then i would take a motion for consideration and approval to enter into executive session as outlined in 1 MRSA section
4056d for the purpose of discussing administrator negotiations. Valerie and Steph, all those in favor? You voting in? Okay. I'm like, now you're like on Colin's train. Like, no, I don't want to Okay, so 9.46. We're in. And so we are going to move across the hall, yeah?
Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.
