TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 25 March 2026
Board meeting · 2 h 33 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →
21,850 words in 30 five-minute windows.
Good evening. Welcome to the RSC5 Board of Directors meeting. It is Wednesday, March 25th, 2026. We are here at the Freeport High School Library. We have a full board here this evening. Steph will be joining us shortly. And we will get started with the Pledge of Allegiance.
Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay, so do I have a motion for consideration and approval of the minutes from March 11,
2026 as presented barring any errors or omissions? Thank you, Valerie. Kelly? All those in favor? None opposed? Thank you. Adjustments? No? No. Moving on. So we will move on to item six, good news and recognition, and we will hear from Maria for our student report. So we had
the career fair today, and we had over 30 businesses attend the fair. We had people from L.L. Bean, Central Maine Medical, Bath Savings. All four grades had the chance to visit their career fair and meet the guests. The Student Leadership Committee had their annual trip to
MIT for a workshop with Cortico and the Center for Collaborative Communication at the Media Lab of MIT. Our FHS students presented the team's work this year and also had a chance to meet the MIT graduate students and hear about their research projects. Our team works with MIT to code the data
for our student-led conversations which helps the team action steps for our school. The team is coming to a board meeting in May to share their work and action steps moving forward. The student officers of the class of 2027 and 2028 are hosting a parents night out April 3rd from 5 30 to 8 30
p.m at FHS. It is open to children through kindergarten and fifth grade and will include a movie, an icon, crafts and art, face painting, and more. There will be many Freeport High School student volunteers there to supervise and run activities.
It is $20 per child, and it's a great opportunity for parents to enjoy a night out and supporting our students that are fundraising for prom. Thank you. I heard it was quite the race to the GPL this morning, because all the seniors couldn't park in their lot because of the career fair.
Yeah, that's what I hear. Yes? Laura, could you repeat the date of the parents' night out? Could you repeat the date of the parents' night out? It's April 3rd. I think it's next Friday. Do people have to sign up ahead of time?
Yes. So for the student volunteers, there would be a QR code on the posters that are hung around the school. And I think that they were also sent out. And I don't know if you have to sign up parents-wise, but I think you could check with the QR code that's on the poster.
Okay. Thank you. All right. So we will move on to item 7, which is public comment. I will do a quick update like we did last time because we have two, well technically three, opportunities for public participation this evening.
We have our public comment, as we always do at the beginning and the end of our agendas. That is where we ask you to come up to, if you'd like, we won't make anyone, but if you'd like, come up. we asked for your name the town where you live and to you have three minutes to
talk about any educational item that you would like to share with the board we also have on our agenda this evening public input as it relates to the budget so as we've gone through the budget process the last meeting in this meeting
we wanted to provide an opportunity for folks to if they had comments specific to the budget that they would like the board to to consider before the adoption of the budget this evening this is an opportunity for that if you had a clarifying question as it relates to the budget feel free to ask those as well we
will we will answer all questions to the best of our abilities but just just a reminder that it's not necessarily a conversation but more more if you have a question we're happy to respond and we only have one sign-up sheet so I think
what we did last week works pretty well which was I will go down the list that I have here for public comment if you would prefer to hold off your comment until the public input portion which is just a few minutes down the road just
let me know that and we will just keep you on the list for public input for the budget. So, with that said, we will start Daniel Feind. Good evening. My name is Daniel Feind, and I live in Freeport. You need my street address? Okay, I live in Freeport. I've spoken before the
board before, and I'm back about the same issue, which ultimately does affect the budget, and therefore, everything else that can happen. My goal is simple. It's to ensure that RSU 5 board, and all the members thereof is exercising the level of fiduciary responsibility required by
main law when reviewing the expenses and operations of the health insurance trust. At present, the board's review process relies almost entirely on information provided by the trust itself without any independent verification of expenditures, pricing structures, plan performance, or cost
savings alternatives. This is not a criticism of the trust. It is a statement of fiduciary fact. Incidentally, I'm not an attorney. I'm a certified financial planner. I've been in the insurance business for 44 years, but this is not a legal opinion. When tens of millions of dollars of
taxpayer funds flow through a system, review cannot mean we ask the trust what they spent and they told us that does not satisfy the standards established in Maine law. Fiduciary law, under the Maine Probate Code, which is what prevails in this situation,
lays out the governing fiduciary responsibility for trustees of the trust. These fiduciary responsibilities are not suggestions, they are law. They reflect legal requirements for impartiality, verification, accurate allocation of expenses,
and a duty to act in the best financial interest of all the beneficiaries. A fiduciary cannot simply accept representations without review. They must verify the expenditures and allocations are fair, accurate, and compliant.
I've inquired multiple times over the past several years about these matters. Every attempt is met with an excuse for not addressing the most important budget item after wages, and that is the cost of health insurance. Multiple towns have told us the trust is too big to question or that it's someone else's job to request an audit. And as a result, taxpayers and teachers and staff pay millions.
On a state level, it's about $150 million or more. Taxpayers, teachers, and staff pay millions more than necessary year after year when identical health care plans for the union, identical plans with identical providers could replace the current vendors at something like
20% less cost. We are not talking about determining whether we are overpaying for those benefits, something we can not know about without an independent fiduciary review, what I've been asking for for years, getting the medical claim data. That's the heart of the matter,
along with explaining the expenses, seven and a half million of overhead, okay? In my opinion, which is not a legal opinion inquiring about expenditures i previously mentioned as well as sourcing medical claim data would be sufficient thank you and i'll just leave my cards here
in case anyone wants to get thank you daniel jill highland no one filled in the second spot i'm sorry someone apparently wanted to be fifth also because we skipped number four that's what it's all come down to good evening everybody my name is jill highland i live in
Brunswick and teach here at Freeport High School. Privilege is when you think something is not a problem because it does not affect you personally. RSU 5 says that equity is at the center of our new strategic plan, yet we are cutting a position that supports our most vulnerable students.
We are cutting a position that's vital to multilingual students' daily success. We are cutting a position that is protected by laws, just like special education. When we remove that support from students whose voices are the easiest to overlook. That's not equity. That is the
privilege of others. I'm speaking maybe for the last time tonight about the decision to reduce the ESOL staffing from three teachers to two. Our team has proposed to the board to reduce the position by 0.5. By saving 0.5 of a position, our team will have three people to serve five schools, to serve
students in a way that is effective and to serve students in a way that they deserve in the first meeting I spoke of our new Wow plan and how it protects our students I spoke that if we made this cut we would not be in compliance my
comments were dismissed which again shows a perspective of privilege not awareness of the reality this district faces in the second meeting I spoke of structure and how if we made this cut two teachers will not be able to adequately serve our students this point too was dismissed what does all this dismissal say about
the value our community places on multilingual learners when i arrived at rsu there was barely a program in place schools were not in compliance there were no individual language acquisition plans there was no viable wow plan students cannot be adequately supported with the bare
minimum of teaching staff over the past four years when appropriate staffing has been prioritized we have watched students thrive it doesn't make sense to return to the bare minimum now kids are working getting what they need now kids are pushing themselves and are invested this is what equity
looks like this is what priority looks like the rsu5 administrative team has proposed this cut and the ESOL team has opposed this cut. Admins aren't there. They're not in the rooms. They're not in the classrooms. They're not driving between buildings, talking to parents, caring for students,
building trust, and doing the work. Admins will see this result on paper. The students will see this result of the cut in their grades, in their understanding, in their trust, and in their everyday reality. This is the work that I live and breathe. This is the work that I was brought here
to do, and this is the work that I will never give up on. These students are the students that I will continue to advocate for. The reality of this cut is that we're going back on our promises as a district. Tonight, if we cut this position, we are living in privilege, not in equity. Thank you, Jim.
Casey Ellis. Good evening. My name is Casey Ellis. I live in Freeport and I have two children in our school system. I was formerly a high school math teacher and I have a master's degree in educational policy. I'm here tonight to speak out against the cuts in staffing that this budget
proposes. No one wants to cut teaching positions. So let's get creative. Let's think outside the box and let's see if there are a few places in this budget where we can tighten our belts. Let's say it costs the district around $100,000 per teacher position. On computer materials, we spend $345,000
on MacBooks. Funding from the Maine Learning Technology Initiative fully covers the cost of Chromebooks, whereas MacBooks cost about $500 per student. I asked my son, a seventh grader, if he would be comfortable using a Chromebook instead of a MacBook, especially if it would save
teachers' jobs. Without hesitation, he said, absolutely. Another consideration is purchased professional services, a vague category, but I believe it accounts for things like consulting, testing, training, legal services. Some of these feel unnecessary at a time when we are tightening
the budget and trying to save teachers' jobs. We have $249,000 allocated for purchased professional services across the district. $114,000 of that is spent at the superintendent's office. Let's cut back on purchased professional services and save a couple of teachers instead. For instructional
supplies and books, we spend close to $400,000 annually. Keep in mind, the single most important thing we can do for our kids is to keep a teacher. If we were to cut this spending in half, we could gain back two teaching positions. To recap, if we trim back the budgets for computer
materials, purchase professional services, instructional supplies, and books, we could save six teacher positions. Grade one, grade two, grade three, French, Latin, math. And this is just the tip of a 47 million dollar iceberg. You cannot tell me with a straight face that there are no
other places we could make cuts. For future budget considerations, two more actions we can take. One, let's put a pay cap on the salaries of our highest paid administrators. Two, let's offer an early retirement option for our teachers who are close to retirement age. Both would offer budget
relief during this difficult time. You all have the power to do something here. One person among you has the power to effect change don't approve this budget as it stands make a motion to make a change we don't want to lose any of our incredible teachers
thank you thank you Casey Emily Sampson my name is Emily Sampson and I'm a Durham resident I'd like to share my thoughts about the possible school redistribution particularly the benefits I see from scenario two if the efficiencies gained
from co-locating pre-k eventually make full-day pre-k or on-site full-day care possible that would significantly expand equitable access to high-quality early childhood education, not to mention a better experience for threes and fours with IEPs. For families with two
working parents in Durham and Poundell, there are very few full-day options to bridge the half-day program, and I think the number of transitions required for a half-day program detracts from the value that the curriculum provides today. That will be even more important now that
kids will need to attend pre-K to receive services they previously could have received at their regular daycare, which I think is a great idea, but it would have been very challenging to manage for our family. I also strongly support earlier middle school integration for all the social,
academic, and operational reasons Superintendent Gray outlined. I have a lot of empathy for people in Palma right now. However, I am detecting a fear that moving to DCS would mean a lower quality education for their children. I want to share that everything the commenters have shared that
they love and consider unique about panel, caring teachers and staff, a strong culture cultivated over decades of consistent leadership, an active parent community, beautiful outdoor space, and ample outdoor time are all things I love about DCS.
While I don't put much weight on rankings, all of our district's elementary schools are in the top 10% of Maine, with relative ranking bearing by source. I also appreciate what DCS's slightly larger size offers, things that panel students could
benefit from. Enough classes per grade to give flexibility with teacher-student matches, to address tricky social dynamics, and to help kids find their social circle. It also means more administrative and instructional resources. Personally, there were moments when my children would have been underserved in a one-class-per-grade model,
something I might not have recognized without exposure to a slightly larger school environment. If Durham and Poundell joined, the combined school would have grade sizes similar to Freeport's, still very small by local comparisons.
That would expand our clubs, sports, and cultural opportunities for both towns. A panel parent mentioned recently that they hadn't heard people speaking in support of Scenario 2. I have heard many people ranging from very excited to feeling like this is the best plan in a tough situation,
but it feels uncomfortable to stand up here and say that when it's already going to be explored and our friends and neighbors have reacted so negatively to the idea. I wish we weren't in a cost-constrained environment, but we are, and we're seeing the impact that inefficient school distribution plays out this year,
where Durham and Freeport are experiencing serious guts to teachers, including elementary classroom teachers, while Poundell cannot share that burden. And finally, I want to say this directly, I care deeply about my friends and the community of Poundell and your children, and I cannot change the fact that DCS is 10 minutes away, but I would love the opportunity to build a new community together, and I'm confident your children would thrive in a combined school. Thank you for your time and everything you do for our students. Thank you, Emily. Wyeth Pillsbury.
Hi, my name is Wyeth Pillsbury. I'm a 7th grader at Freeport Middle School. I've gotten a lot of people at my school to sign this petition to save French and world cultures from getting cut from the school budget. 86 students and 5 teachers have signed this petition.
A lot of people at my school were very surprised that French and world cultures were getting cut. For me and my classmates, French is one of the most enjoyable classes in the entire school. Even if you don't know French very well, you can still have a lot of fun.
I also believe that it's important to learn about other languages and cultures. For all of my classmates seemed upset because French is such an enjoyable subject. Our French teacher is such a kind person who is always making the day better.
Thank you. Thank you, Wyatt. John, Jakes. I feel like we always put you after a hard act to follow John's side. Yeah, yeah. Nice, nice job. That was really, really powerful. Good stuff, having students come in. So I'm John Jakes. I'm from Freeport. I have Nico, who is in 11th grade, and Henry graduated in 2017.
And I am also here to, like this woman shared, advocate for you not passing the budget tonight, that you put it off and do a little bit more work to find some other cuts that we can make. There were some really good, fresh ideas, I thought, shared about that tonight.
So, you've proposed a 7% increase in next year's school budget. Considering the current situation, I believe that is an acceptable number. What is not acceptable is getting our foreign language program and reducing upper-level math.
That would also eliminate computer science. At FHS, currently, we offer French, Spanish, and Latin at this middle school. At our middle school, we offer French and Spanish. and this should be maintained. This young man spoke very eloquently about the middle school French program.
It's extremely important. Your proposal could very well lead us into a Spanish-only school system. This could also mean reduced enrollment as families choose other schools instead of Freeport High. A hit to our reputation can have economic consequences, making our declining enrollment situation worse. As I have stated before, I feel that the current teacher cuts are unwise
and should not go forward. The FMS French position should be retained as well as the FHS Latin position. We should restore the FHS math teacher position too. Ed techs will unfortunately have to be scaled back. Cuts here are unfortunately needed to prevent a 10% hike in property taxes.
And I'm going to digress from my prepared remarks there. I don't, we all would like to save everything for sure. But we do understand the reality. a 10% increase would probably not pass, and we would be in a bad position.
I do think you run the risk of not having a budget pass for also cutting these teaching positions that are so important to somebody. So there's several of these that I think, the ones that I'm advocating for, people are advocating for the different positions, but these I think are critical for it to pass, and we all want the budget to pass.
And so 7% seems reasonable. There's going to be some hard cuts, but I don't think taking the foreign language hit the way it is is the way to go. There's other places we can find the money. Back to my comments here. I'm also making several other suggestions for areas to cut. Technology, first and foremost, the RSU should not spend any more money purchasing Apple products.
MacBooks or iPads should be phased out. Chromebooks should be purchased at a new lower cost, and the district technology plan should be developed. And we are working with Google products already. The Google Classroom, our students are using that. It runs perfectly on Chromebook. The Chromebook has the functionality that we need in order to keep our programs going.
There's a whole other discussion. Do we want to continue with 1 to 1? There's some debate around that. But the cost savings for the Chromebook is kind of a no-brainer to go there. I want to thank Superintendent Gray for providing me with the Energy Efficient Contract from ESCO.
I reviewed it yesterday. In July 2025, the district signed a contract for $3 million to save money on energy and mobile calls. Unfortunately, this was a very costly and perhaps unnecessary expense, in my opinion. Frankly, I'm mystified about the cost of this efficiency expense report.
You know, this, I know I'm taking over my time, so I'll skip forward a little bit. I'm not sure that the $3 million needs to be spent. As I read the contract, there are opportunities for that contract to be, the change of the scope of the work to be changed.
So there could be some savings that we can get out of that $300,000 contract. That's a big, big chunk of money. Transportation is another area for reducing spending. It's unfortunate that we might have to run older buses, vans, and mowing equipment, but it's better than cutting teacher programs.
These are fairly painless cuts. I understand the energy-efficient contract was signed less than a year ago under a previous superintendent, but I think finding these additional cuts to restore these teaching positions, they're just too important to cut.
My last point is that most costly of our long-term financial problems is maintaining the town of school. I don't think it is cost-effective to keep it open, not as a K-6, nor as a preschool. Sending all of our smallest children to Palma, I know this is just one proposal, means longer car bus rides for children.
As a parent, I would not send my three or four-year-old to Palma on a long bus ride. As I stated last week during my public comments, Palma has the ability to withdraw from the RSU and maintain its town school. That is an option. Not a great option, but it is an option if they are adamant that this school should not be closed.
they have a way out. I appreciate your consideration and my suggestions. I also recognize the amount of time you spend serving as a school board member. Not an easy job in tough economic times. You do very important work, and it's most appreciated. Thank you.
Thank you, John. Okay, so that was all I had for the sign-up. I'll give folks a second, see if the spirit moves them. So we will continue on. We will still have the public input portion of the budget if someone wanted to ask a question we can certainly take
that up but in the meantime we will move to item 8 which is the report from the superintendent evening everybody okay so tonight's big night I'd like to start by reflecting on the conversations that I've been having with our communities
in the RSU about this idea of long-term potential reconfiguration and the most important thing I want to talk about is to share the experience I had on Monday evening when I went out to panel and attended the select board meeting there and I had done that in Durham prior to that the Durham meeting was very heavily
attended as I mentioned but I think that was mostly for the the dump night issues not so much for me I think in panel it was different panel there were it was standing room only there and there was another room that I wasn't even in where it was being televised so there were lots of folks it was three hours long
roughly it was very thoughtful it was very candid there were lots of questions and concerns which are totally understandable as we consider this potential facilities and demographic study and the direction that we may go
in as a district I really want to say that I appreciated the tone with which I I was received, because I don't mind admitting I was nervous walking in, but people were very, very respectful and curious and really engaged in a very healthy way, and I appreciated that
personally very much. And I could tell that people want to approach this issue with a lot of intention and thought, and that's the way we'll get where we need to go. And there were a few things that I picked up on strongly, and also a few things that I said that I would bring back to
this body, so I want to certainly follow through on those promises. First, when I was there, there is definitely a clear interest ensuring that as a board, you all are explicit about the values that will guide future decisions. And you may remember that in a previous meeting, I suggested
that it would be a good and profitable exercise for us to take some of our agenda time and talk about the values that would underlie your own personal values, and then talk about how they intersect as a board as we go forward. I still think that that's a worthwhile idea. And to do
that publicly, to articulate what matters most to you as members of the board and to the district, and then how you would weigh your values when you bring them to bear on important decision, that would be difficult, but it would help this work. And I think it would help us continue to mold a shared framework for decision-making over time. So I recommend that we dedicate some time on our work plan this year,
which we still have some time left, to engaging with a weighted values tool. There are many. If you aren't familiar with that, we can talk about it. You can Google it. There's all kinds of stuff to consider. That would frame some candid conversation about values.
It would not be a vote. It would not be a binding decision. It would be you as a board talking in front of the community so that they can understand what your thinking is. It would support transparency, reflection, and discussion.
So I will work with Jenny to look at the work plan and figure out when that might work. And if you have questions or concerns about that, please email me. But for me, that's a priority. Second theme that came out of that meeting is a strong desire for clarity about timeline.
And that's also very understandable. Many of the folks in Palma are concerned about the outcome, but the concern is actually magnified by uncertainty about when and how decisions might be made. And so to that end, my recommendation is that this spring we focus on laying foundations,
first talking about weighted values, but second and more concretely, the task in front of us now is to develop a clear and thoughtful RFQ for facilities and demographic study and then again publicly discussing how that demographics what that RFQ would include now I would add a caveat to that
I don't think it would be a good idea for us to try to create a document together as a board I think that working with the administrators and the facilities committee I would like to bring you a really really strong draft
and have you provide input on that rather than try to write a document together as a board. But doing that publicly is not necessarily a step we would take for every RFQ we put out there, but I think for this one, given the stakes of the conversation, that would
be highly valuable. And then, once that work is completed, what we have to do is be patient, because the purpose of that is to get objective opinions and perspective on the data we would need to make any informed decision, and that takes a lot of time. I would predict that we would have
that, I would hope that we would have that, by early next winter, so we're talking the better part of a year. And I also want to be very clear about another aspect of timing, which is that we should not try to merge a decision about configuration with the timeline for any other
major decision, i.e. early childhood. I think that, you know, understandably, when I presented scenarios, one of the benefits of scenario two in particular was that it presents a nice solution for early childhood needs, and we are on a timeline for bringing three-year-olds into the district
by the fall of 2027. That does not mean we should try to rush our reconfiguration conversation to match that timeline. We will find a solution for three-year-olds whether we reconfigure the district or not. We might not find the best long-term one, but they just simply would not do
to try to ram through a decision on anything because of early childhood. Each process needs its own independent and due consideration. And I also feel related to that, it's important to reinforce that we have not made any decisions about reconfiguration. The scenarios that I
shared earlier this year were starting points for conversation. They were what the administrative team and I thought of in the time between November and January when I presented, February when I presented. And there was no vote by the board. There was discussion by the board. And granted,
that discussion did signal enthusiasm for one idea that had been raised that evening. But as I said then, and I need to continue to say, there are many possible paths forward, including many that haven't even been thought up yet. And one that I did not mention in my original presentation but
should really be thought about more carefully is redistricting, which would simply be drawing the lines on the map within the district differently so that potentially students from pre-Porter Durham attend panel. We have not fully run down that thought process yet. We should in the course of
things. So I feel it's incumbent upon me, but also upon us, to keep communicating that this is a broad and open exploration of possibilities. It is not, at this point, narrowing toward an outcome. That's probably a next year conversation. And the more we can lower the temperature of the conversation,
the more we will build trust and make sure that people feel good about our process. I would also like to offer a reminder that came up in conversation after the meeting. When we talk about the impact of any of these ideas that have been discussed across the
towns, we really have to bear in mind that the lines on the map, the lines that divine Freeport, Pownall, and Durham, don't exist on the earth. They exist on paper. We all live here. We are all connected. All the schools in this district are excellent schools.
Every single one of them. I'd be proud to send my kids there. And any of our students would be very well served in any of those schools. And I think it's very important to hold that value as we continue to talk about this because it's a shared responsibility to keep that tone.
And when it's all over, no matter where this lands, whether one town stays, whether one town goes, where we have pre-K, where we have this, where we have that, we're all going to see each other at Shaw's at some point and we need to be able to shake hands.
So that leads to a broader point. I would like to encourage everybody, leaders, students, community members, to speak about all the schools with respect and appreciation, because every school in the district matters. Every community in the district contributes to who we are, and maintaining that sense of shared purpose is really vital for us to go forward together.
I also want to touch on the strategic planning process, which of course has been underway since roughly this time last year. So as we move forward, it is important to ensure that the strategic plan reflects the reality that these discussions about possible reconfiguration are part of the landscape.
Last fall and last spring, when we were having focus groups and surveys, these ideas had not been laid on the table. And so they weren't part of those formative parts of the discussion. And I've talked with our facilitators at Great Schools Partnership about a way to ensure that now that they are on the table, they have to be part of what's considered by the Strategic Planning Committee.
So that is not to say that the Strategic Planning Committee should be making decisions about how we reconfigure. But it does mean at this point that that committee needs to create space within the plan for an ongoing process, for ongoing conversation about these important topics.
Not predetermining any outcome, but we just need to make sure that that thread is in the plan. The committee meets again this Friday morning, and that will certainly be part of the conversation. And finally, the budget. I'm going to say something that you might find funny now, because I found it really funny.
The sentence that I wrote in my predetermined remarks is, if all goes as planned, you will adopt a budget this evening. But whoever put this binder together for me crossed out if all goes as planned and wrote, you will adopt a budget this evening. It wasn't me.
So, you will adopt a budget this evening. That is no stuff. And we know who we answer to if we don't. The process that brought you here has, this has been a lot. This has been a lot for, certainly for me. You'll notice the administrative team is not here tonight. I think they've paid their dues. I told them to stay home tonight. If there are questions, I will do my best to answer them without backup.
It's certainly been a lot for teachers. It's been a lot for board members. I know that it's a lot, and it has required a lot of endurance. And we're all sitting with very difficult trade-offs. And there are any number of really good perspectives on what the best trade-offs are.
And now's the time when we need to decide what the trade-offs will be. I know it's really hard, and I just want to say that if it felt easy, I would be worried about that. This should be a really hard decision, because it's not an easy situation.
It's not a budget that you can just sort of pass on in the way that often we can. And a decision like this involves a lot of tension, And I don't even think that the tension between individuals is the hardest tension. It's the internal tension that now rests with you.
But that tension is not a sign that we failed. It's just a sign that we care. And there's been a lot of disagreement as we've gone through this process. And the disagreement is healthy. The disagreement is okay. Disagreement is far less toxic than groupthink.
So I'm thankful we don't have that. And we can disagree and we can go on and respect the board's decisions. Certainly, my goal has been to represent the administrative perspective transparently, to provide information that is accurate to the best of my knowledge,
and to offer the recommendations that I think, with as many inputs as I could gather, that are the best set of trade-offs. And I respect different opinions about that. And I certainly respect your role as the deciders. So I want to thank you for the way you've approached the work. You've shown a lot of curiosity, a lot of respect, A lot of genuine commitment to making sure this district is healthy for the long term.
And I think that the district is well served by that spirit. So, thank you. Before I'm finished, they're not printed on your agenda, but there are a couple of resignations that I need to report to you. Cheryl Sleeper, who is the Mass Landing School RTI MTSS math teacher, has resigned.
And Martin Huertas, who is the Durham Community School EdTech bench sub, has also resigned. Thank you. Okay, so we are at the public input portion of the agenda around the budget. I know most of the commentary from public comment was
surrounded the budget as well. I don't think we had anyone that deferred to the budget portion, but I will give people an opportunity if they wanted to get up and speak. Same rules apply. We just ask that you give us your name and where you're from.
Is that seven seconds? I think that's the amount of time you're supposed to wait. Okay, thank you. All right, so we will move on to item 10, which is Administrator Reports. And the only one we have for this evening is Finance. Kelly.
I sometimes feel like a broken drum. Oh, you'd say one all the time. Included in your packet this evening are the expenditures through February for the district, expenditures and revenue. We do appear to be on track to where we were last year. I don't have any concerns or issues at this particular time. But while I'm up here, I will take the opportunity under my report out
to talk about an emergency situation that's originally at Mass Landing School. It was supposed to be part of the superintendent's report out. But if you don't mind, as a board, I will ask if Director Reynolds will be able to come up and talk about that situation. So I do feel that within some of the underperforming lines
within the facility's budget, we will be able to cover the repair, but I will let Mr. Reynolds talk about the repair. Good evening, everyone. Glenn Reynolds, Director of Facilities. So as Kelly alluded to, fortunately we had a situation over at Mass Landing where the high-efficiency hot water boiler system has failed.
We do have two quotes. I do have from CCB and Mechanical Services. Present that with Kelly. We'll sit down and go over and select a vendor. But right now, currently the building, excluding the kitchen, there is a hot water boost for the kitchen.
So the dishwasher does have hot water, but the building as a whole does not currently have hot water until we can get this fixed. We do have two of these types in the district, over at Mass Landing and over at the middle school.
took the liberty to have mechanical services go over and do a inspection of the current one over at the middle school. That one's currently okay. But unfortunately, just due to age, wear and tear, we just ended up losing the one
over at mass lending. Any questions? Always. Was this on the list of projects over the next few years to be considered? Not on the, so it was at, what the boiler itself was not identified during the original audit, but the tank, the holding tank, was. The holding tank is a concrete-lined tank, and it leaks. So that was on the list for Phase 2 to replace.
Unfortunately, now that the boiler is fair, we would replace that entire system as a whole. Do you have a rough estimate of costs? I do. One from CCB is around $23,000, and the estimate from Mechanical Services is $34,000. Thank you. You're welcome. Willis, can you tell me, please,
what the required temperature is for hot water in a school? So for the basic temp for one school is 165. Now that varies on the size of the school. So the larger the school, the farther the classroom, you have to bump up the temperature at the tank to have that required temperature for the classroom. So we usually set it around 200. So the temperature at the farthest out point will get to the required temperature.
So am I understanding you to say that there is no hot water in any of those classrooms? That is correct, ma'am. How are you dealing with that if the standard is to have hot water in a classroom? Without that system, we do not have it. The only hot water that we do have is we have a hot water boost for the dishwasher in the kitchen
so we can sanitize the equipment. But as far as the classroom, until that system gets replaced, we do not have it. Do the classrooms have water in the classroom? They have sinks. So they have... All of them? Yes. Same thing over at Poundless, same thing over at Wall Street.
And how quickly could this get fixed? Mechanical services, the equipment is in South Portland. CCB, when they talked to their supplier, it wasn't in stock, but they were looking for an ETA to see if they can get it overnighted. I did not give that information prior to tonight's meeting, whether or not they could have it overnighted or not. And then how long does it take to install? We can start the, once we get approval and sign it, we can start the dismantle of the Curtis system tomorrow, and we can have the new system up and running by Wednesday of next week.
Is the hot water boost to the kitchen, is that something we had to temporarily install, or is that just something that we normally have? In other words, did we have to pay money to get that in place? Nope, so that's a separate system. Basically, it's a miniature hot water system within the hot water system to get the temperature for that dishwasher to required temp.
So it's just a hot water boost. So it'll just boost the temp up to 210, 220, whatever for that particular machine needs for temperature for hot water. Are we replacing like-for-like here then, or is this an opportunity that we can do something with more technology?
Absolutely. Yep, so that technology at the time, I mean, that one system that failed was running roughly around 95% to 98% efficiency. Very good piece of equipment, just age got it. So we took the liberty to see what else is out there, and what they're proposing is high-end efficiency equipment,
much like we did when we replaced the boiler here at the high school, and when we replaced the 50-year-old, we installed two high-end Wiesemann efficiency boilers. We did the same thing over at Pommel. When we replaced that boiler, we installed two high-end efficiency Wiesemanns.
Before, they only had one. Now we have two, so we have some redundancy. If one boiler goes down, the other one can carry the load until we're able to get that fixed. So we're taking every opportunity when systems fail to look for high-end efficiency equipment.
Would the new one you're putting in have that redundancy for mass landing, or no? No, not for the hot water system, no. But, I mean, typically that's all it serves is just the hot water. So some of the heating... Exactly right. That's completely separate. It's a standalone just for hot water. So the life expectancy out of that is twice as much out of a regular heating system.
Can you see a hand over there? It was me, but you asked my question. I thought I saw another one. Okay. Well, we look to you to expeditiously get this. Yes, ma'am. Thank you. Is that it for you, Kelly? Yeah. So I just wanted to clarify, there have been two employees that have been out on workers' comp that we haven't been paying for.
So that's where the two custodial positions. So that's where the money is going to come from to cover the cost of the replacement water here in the emergency situation. So we're not looking to access the capital reserve for any of this? Will they cover this? Correct, I scrubbed the numbers and was able to find it within the local budget itself.
Other questions for Kelly or Glenn? Thank you. All right, so we will move on to board comments and committee reports. Board information exchange agenda requests. I know we have a few of the committees here for report out, but if we have other members that are on other committees that want to share an update, happy to hear it.
No? We've done enough sharing? Oh, Kara. Well, I will just say that we do have a strategic communications committee meeting on Monday, I believe. And if anyone has any suggestions or proposals or feedback on communications,
then we're happy to hear those by email ahead of time at board at rsu5.org. Thank you. All right, so we will move on to... Oh, yeah. I do have another question. Yeah. And I know I've emailed about this, but I'm AI. Yes. At the board retreat, we had talked about AI being as part of our work plan this year, talking about that, and I'm wondering when we might be talking about that, roughly,
so that we can be prepared to come to the board to discuss. Well, we already had a presentation on it in the fall, so I think that was the original, what we had at the retreat to add it to the work plan. And that, I think, got satisfied when we did the presentation that Erica and Sam presented.
But I do think there was some question about, like, what's, okay, now what? Like, what are the next steps? So I don't know if that necessarily entailed a whole other presentation to the board or just updates. I guess I'd see clarification about what, in addition, we might like to do this year on that topic.
That's a question for us? Yeah. Beyond the presentation that occurred already. Well, it sounded like there, I mean, from the presentation, it sounded like there were some opportunities for learning for staff. It felt to me like that was kind of the first step of getting, you know, the teaching and the staff more up to speed on potential use cases or proper usage.
And then the next step would be, okay, then what does the curriculum look like for students? And that was kind of what I took away from it. I don't know what others did. Looking at Maria, but I don't think she was on the board yet. I think it was before you were elected. So can I return to that at another meeting after I confer with the team?
Yeah, and I appreciate that summary, Michelle. I didn't remember what next steps we had talked about, so I'm curious if anyone else on the board has any thoughts on what direction we should be going with that or what decisions you might be needing to make. I thought we had talked about, in addition to the staff learning pieces, thinking about maybe an AI committee and talking about, but I don't seem to recall exactly what that discussion was going to be about with the committee.
I actually had a similar but different, I thought we were doing something that was going to be incorporated with our education around the cell phone policy and trying to have the stewardship of trying to disconnect from our devices be also integrated with our AI education and having all of that be in one technology kind of bucket, I guess.
Yeah, what Kelly just said, which I think is right, sort of the concept of the digital citizenship piece, right? Thank you, Kelly. Clearly, we all should probably go back and re-watch that meeting to remember what we walked away from.
I remember there was a lot of really good information that felt like a lot, and so I'm guessing that may be why we all kind of left with little different tidbits on what we were going to do next. colin yeah i mean i think um i would like to go back and look at that look at that video um but
i do remember being personally being annoying about a thing so i'll just be annoying about it again um which is that i think one of the flags that i threw up was um just a cautionary uh note about taking uh as we go forward taking lion's shirt of our guidance on ai policy from uh
institutions that gain monetarily from AI including MIT and so I think that was one of the things that that I a board member asked that we look at is just as we are thinking about how I mean one of the things I do remember us saying in one of the in the presentation was that a lot of staff just feels not trained in
in how to incorporate AI pedagogically, but also how to understand the benefits and risks thereof. And so as we do that, to not be looking to the people who want to sell it to us for how we would use it. I remember that too. Thank you.
Okay, so you'll come back to us with... Yeah, I mean, I remember these conversations, too. The strongest thread that I remember was the digital citizenship, the intention for direct attention to digital citizenship, particularly in connection with the cell phone policy. And we definitely need to flesh that out. We haven't turned our attention to that yet since that meeting. But I would say that focusing on AI needs to be a priority as we go forward.
So thank you for reminding us, Kara. All right. Any other, before we move into committee reports? All right. So first up is, we have the finance committee from February. So we met on February 25th. We meet just prior to the board meetings, the second meeting of the month. We discussed the assistant director for
the early childhood special education component that we spoke about that prior to the board voting to create that position. We also talked about the beginnings of the facility study starting to prepare that RFQ that Superintendent Gray mentioned and so we had sort of a draft and that
we were going to continue to refine and it sounds like we'll be sharing that with the board in advance of its release. We did our annual cost sharing review where, so you guys may or may not recall that the review of the cost sharing formula spanned many, many, many years. And
probably two years ago, we sort of came down to a view of how to look at sort of total contributions of our current uh cost sharing formula to the district by town um and um and it felt uh from the board at that time that that that felt like a fair way to um to ensure that it was a fair
formula for for the communities um and part of that decision a few years ago was that on an annual basis we would sort of rerun those same calculations to make sure that things hadn't gone out of whack as it relates to contribution versus students
in the district and I believe that the review this year showed pretty similar pretty close correlation between those calculations so the Finance Committee felt like that that met the met the standard for our review so that was so
we'll do that again next year, but that we did take, take that up in February. Insurance bidding update. So not, not to be confused with the health insurance piece. The finance committee this year has, we are in the process of sending our property and casualty liability insurance out to bid.
And so the Finance Committee is working through that process right now. And in the minutes, you'll see kind of the steps of that process. We sent out a questionnaire for interested parties to provide information back for an RFQ to see if they're qualified.
So the committee, I'm going to give you a little teaser for the next minutes. met tonight and we did get those qualification packages so we will continue to move on to sending out bid packages which will be come back to the
finance committee in the district will get scored and then we'll continue on with that process through May and then we just did a budget review for where we were at that point in time in February feels like forever ago and then our next
meeting was actually this evening so there's our finance update yeah did you see what kind of insurance property and casualty yeah so this this is the insurance that covers obviously all of the buildings etc all of our vehicles it also includes the educator educator liability sometimes called
school board liability but oftentimes the claims under that are actually not related to the school board it's more special education items so our cyber our cyber coverage all of those things are part of this insurance just because I'm Dan came again to speak
I'm just wondering what's the latest update on the health insurance and I guess I look to Kelly to that I don't know the frequency with which we're expected to send that out to bid. I do know our contract specifically discusses the current
insurance that we have, so I don't know if that would be a challenge to change that insurance given the contract. So we talked about it at the Finance Committee on October 22nd. Did you just pull that date out of, like, well, again, remember I told you I had looked it up.
So, it was October 22nd, 2025, and we actually talked about it, and I have to go back and review the Finance Committee meeting minutes from it, but I had sent out a survey to all of our, out to my business managers listserv network that we have through the state of Maine.
I got 53 respondents. All 53 are currently using the MEA Benefits Trust. None of them had, I asked the question, had you varied from it and come back? We didn't get any of those. We went over an analysis of the breakdown between the employee portion of the cost of health
insurance and the employer portion of the cost insurance during that meeting. And then where we settled was, is that we would like the MEA BT Trust to actually, a representative from the trucks to actually come and talk about the process, because part of what they undertake
throughout the year is actually they go out and do kind of like the looking into all of the other cost plans, and they kind of do their own form of bidding, much like we're doing with our general liability. So we wanted to get a better understanding of that process. So it's on Kelly to actually
reach out and set that appointment up and i have unfortunately not done that because budget kind of took over sorry so overtaken her life i know you're doing so much so thank you no okay wasn't wasn't sure if you were putting your hand up um okay thank you um yeah and i guess one thing that
popped out in my mind from uh our public comment earlier about that when they were talking about fiduciary duty of the trustees we are members of that trust we are not trustees of that trust there is a board I imagine very similar to the property and casualty trust board that are trustees
that are that do have that fiduciary duty to for you know to look into all of those items I am sort of cognizant of what Colin just said about asking the person who's selling you something to do the background check to make sure what they're selling you is good is it you know it's
it's a fair comment on both AI and the insurance piece but it'll certainly be a question that we pose when when they come to our Finance Committee meeting I wish you couldn't help it no it can't help it sorry I sat on the truck I
remembered to turn it on um I sat on the trust for a number of years and if you're concerned about I don't know how to put this exactly so I'll try to do what you did if you're concerned about the person or the group representing
benefits trust selling you something the trust purchases the health insurance from anthem and does do a thorough read-through and puts it out to bed and so every few years I can't even remember sorry it's probably every five years they
put it out to bed maybe it's every four so just gonna defend the benefits trust for a minute here so um i think you can trust them thank you okay um as usual i've lost my agenda all right facilities kelly so michelle and karen if you have anything to add since you were at the
meeting please jump in where appropriate facilities and operations committee met on wednesday march 11 at five o'clock prior to the board meeting and at that time director reynolds gave us an update on the FHS tennis courts told us that the site survey is underway course sampling should it was
going to be happening has it happened yet not but it will be happening soon yeah right lots of snow lots of cold um they went over a preliminary layout of the current three court layout and also a possible four court replacement option they the committee reviewed and discussed early
concept estimates for two different types of materials, asphalt and post-tension courts. And the women's tennis coach, Molly Meyer, gave the committee an update on additional steps that might need to be taken if we were to apply and receive a USTA grant application. And so that
will include additionally some technical review of the original set of drawings, final review of the bid documents by USDA before bidding can commence and of course that might push the timeline back a little bit. Director Reynolds was also asked to
provide some information, additional information on the layout of the courts and the possibility of using a curtain instead of fencing between the courts. Anything else to add on that? Nope. Okay. Energy Audit Phase 1, project update. Glenn
Reynolds told the committee that the lighting vendor was currently working at Freeport Middle School, and will be soon moving to Mass Landing. He also shared that the lighting project at Mass Landing is complete. When it is complete, the vendor will go to Freeport High School.
And that's a little bit of a change due to the length of the time that the lighting project will take and the availability of the FPAT. So a little bit of a change there. EMC is also preparing an updated Phase 2 projects listing.
Facilities study update, Director Reynolds shared with the committee a draft of the proposed facilities study request for qualifications, the RFUQ document, and they also shared the overall concept of the facility study process, which will begin with an overview of all the
facilities, determination of the current conditions, the educational analysis of needs, a demographic and enrollment study and community feedback listening sessions. And then once all of that's completed, they will suggest and rank possible space reuse to meet our educational and economic conditions in the next 10 years.
And in order to serve that purpose, our illustrious committee member over here, Karen Breer, shared that she has access to some other RFQ, facility study RFQs, and she has since shared them with the committee. So the committee is going to review any revisions to the RFQ at the next meeting, which will be April 8th.
Questions on facilities? The light guys didn't break the hot water tank, did they? Okay, making sure. All right, so we will move on to policy. Colin. Evening. So we met on Thursday, March 5th via Google Meet at 4.15. It was our full committee with Superintendent Gray and Assistant Superintendent Mazzaro.
We're also joined by Tim Gravois, who's a teacher at FHS, who was there to talk with us about the policy that we're going to be talking about a little bit later tonight, IMB, teaching about controversial issues, and I'll talk a little bit more about his feedback on that.
But we talked about JJIF, student concussions and other head injuries, and the accompanying concussion information sheet, which is a policy we're bringing before you tonight that's based on law change. We also were going to look at IHBAC, which is child fine, but we tabled that until the next meeting, and then we spent a good bit of our time talking about IMB, teaching about controversial issues, which is a new policy that, again, we are also bringing for you to read tonight for first read.
It's not on this particular piece of paper unless I am blind to it, but we have our next meeting, Policy Committee meeting, on Thursday, April 2nd, also at 4.15 p.m., and the link will be online. Questions before we move into the actual policy review?
Okay. Oh, sorry. So Curriculum Committee met, but we don't have a report in here. Was someone supposed to provide it? because Danielle George was the former chair, and I did not realize, was I supposed to do that? Because I'm happy to. You became the chair. Sorry. No, I'm just kidding. I was there, so I could write some notes, but I didn't.
Yeah, no, that's okay. So how we have historically done them is certain committees will always have the written minutes included for discussion, and sort of 11A, so board information and agenda requests, That's historically, and I'm sorry, I should have mentioned this, historically where if you were on a committee that isn't listed
but wanted to provide an update, you certainly could. We've done that with Region 10. We've done it with the DEI committee. So if there's something you would like to share about the curriculum committee, we'd love to hear it. Don't feel obligated since we put you on the spot. Could Erica, since she was the one who was really running it?
Do we have minutes? do we do you guys okay so um does it make sense i mean we certainly could i don't uh now we're putting erica on the spot um no i passed it yeah doesn't pass the buck i like that um does it make sense to maybe just pick that up on the next um that'd be fine okay yeah we'll just make sure um
we put a note on there to add curriculum so we so we don't forget and so that the minutes get included in the package all right um yeah just a quick thing on uh just the practice on this i think could we bring the um uh jea and jic for uh just have them be separate motions i think that
will be cleaner for the second read okay all right so do i have consideration and approval for second read for the following policy JEA compulsory attendance Valerie and Chris great so we're bringing for you tonight JEA compulsory school attendance for a
second read this is we did not make any additional changes for this the reason I've asked to sort of segment it out is just we did get a very thoughtful email from Maureen Erskine, the FMS nurse, about some of the wording in the document and its relationship
to the state law regarding this. So I just wanted to draw folks' attention to this, as it's something I know I wanted to talk about. If there are any other things that folks would like to talk about on this that arose for you between first read and second read, we can also talk about that.
But Maureen drew attention to, on page 104 for JEA, under two excusable absences from school. A is listed as personal illness, which, on the one hand, that is a very clear sort of statement of when the person that you are is ill, that would be a reason to be excused.
What Maureen pointed out is that the law, the state law under truancy, states that excusable absences are excused for the absences for the following reasons. And then the first one is listed as following, I'm going to quote it, quote, personal
health, comma, including the person's physical, mental, and behavioral health, And so Moraine's, I think, very valid point was that when a parent or guardian goes to look at this policy to understand about attendance and what is an excusable reason, personal illness might not for them mean something related to, and this is what Moraine particularly noted, mental health.
even though I believe that we're getting closer to a culture in some ways, that is recognizing mental health as part of sort of personal wellness in general. So she just raised the question about that, and I said I would bring that before the board.
I'm not sure, Sumitra Gray, if you have any thoughts on that. Initially, what I have, just to be very blunt, I have no particular reason to stick with personal illness. I would be fine going with the state's language, but if there are any thoughts about
that, I would like to hear what they're... Since you asked, I have no qualms at all about reiterating language that's in a statute. Was this the draft from the attorneys? And usually they would pick the same language, right? Yeah, this was the sample policy from Drummond-Woodson, and I do find it curious, but I'm looking at the language that Maureen forwarded to us, and it, I mean, it's close to what's here. This says personal illness, and the language, as Colin just said, is personal health, including the person's physical, mental, and behavioral health.
And just to be clear, the other B through E, I'm just making sure this is a true statement, track directly to what is in the state, or I'm not going to say letter for letter, but they track to what is in the statute, and F is additional to that, just to be clear.
F is not in the language that Maureen sent. It's not in the law? Meaning that is not in that particular law. It's not in the truancy law. So what I was going to say other than... Oh, I just was going to make a point that one of the ways I talked to my students about how Aristotle defines rhetoric as understanding all of the tools at your disposal to convince somebody of something.
And Maureen made a very particular use of rhetoric when she used my own words against me in the email by saying that she says, as you say in many a meeting, that statute trumps law. And I appreciated the attention to detail on that, because indeed it does.
So even if we did say personal illness and a parent who looked into it phoned up and said, well, I'm not sure if mental health falls under personal illness, but it's protected under the state, I need to have a day off for my child, that would be legally what we would be required to do. So, I would believe that we change a personal illness to, how do we want to phrase it?
Yeah, we're just saying, quote, personal health, comma, including the person's physical, mental, and behavioral health, end quote. So, to clarify, are you moving, well, we already have a motion on the table. I guess I'm, yeah, historically we haven't required a motion.
I mean, we're being, you want to vote on it? I don't, I don't, it's great. Whatever will make Maureen happy. Yeah. I mean, I think, you know, historically we have, you know, tinkered as a technical term with the wording in these policies,
even at second read. And I think the motion would support what said tinkering. Fantastic. Let's tinker. I would like to tinker in that particular way unless Stephanie wants to fight me about it. No, I guess I'm just having a stray thought of was personal illness possibly more broad?
Intended to be more broad? I don't see it, but the question's in my brain, so I'm asking it. Yeah, I mean, from when Lorne asked, I didn't remember having a particular conversation from that. I didn't remember Tom bringing from our council
a particular reason why we were saying that. So, I mean, yeah, I mean, I think, I think, I think Maureen's point is the one that I think I would go with, which is the sort of like, what's, what's clearest for parents and guardians to best protect the rights of the students. And so that made sense to me.
I just have a Clary question on E. A planned absence for a personal or educational purpose which has been approved. What does that actually look like? So you're asking for approval from the school for something, then they approve it, and then you use it as an excusable absence?
That is usually a vacation, or a trip, a special trip, a cultural trip that, you know, parents will say, we're taking our child on the week before April vacation to an extended trip to France, or whatever, and it's a cultural trip, and it's an educational experience.
Or a college visit. College visit is a really common one. But I guess my question is, you have to get that approved ahead of time, and then you ask for the... No, that is the excused absence. that's how it becomes excused once they say yes it then becomes excused okay yeah i don't think
that's currently being practiced well i think maybe well maybe it depends on the school okay because it certainly is at the high school okay because it used to be at the high school it was like three days if you're going to be gone three days or more you had to fill out the
planned absence form and now i think it's actually like if you know ahead of time one day like you have to let that go. I remember when we had the Moore Street report out that Mrs. Nickerson had explicitly called this part of the policy out as something that they typically will excuse one week
but not two. Right. And we have been trying to, quite frankly, tighten up on this because it was having a huge impact on our attendance and that has come way down since we've been trying to encourage people to take vacations when school is not in session.
I've personally used the form for mass landing. I had some family matters in western New York, so I had to fill out the form. But all the schools have them, so if you can't find them, they can find them for you. Pick them up at the office. I wouldn't even know where to find it myself. They just give it to you.
I was just going to say, other than my not motion to change that language, Any further questions about that, unless Valerie had a thing? I was just going to say that I really like the more specific language of the health excuse.
I like calling out the various ways you might be unhealthy, because not everybody agrees on that. I think explicitly saying it makes it clearer as an end user. I also like the personal health. I actually think it's a broader term, which I think is a better in this situation.
But do you know if it says included but not limited to? No. It says personal health, including the person's physical, mental, and behavioral health. Okay. Did we want to add? I mean, yes, I don't know what other health there are, but. Financial. Spiritual. Spiritual health. Here's where I would advise. That's what's in the law. Yeah, okay. That makes sense. Kind of like spiritual and financial as additional healths.
But I think for a moment, let's be conservative and stick with what we have. Okay. Any other questions, comments, recommended adjustments other than that sort of replacement in A? Okay. We have a motion and a second on the floor, so we will vote on this one. This is second read. So all those in favor, none opposed. Thank you. all right so we'll move on to our other second read which because you still want
to do that one right thank you very much okay great so do I have a motion for consideration and approval for the second read of the following policy JIC student code of conduct and Steph thank you we bring before you a second read of
JSE system-wide student code of conduct we have not made any changes to this nor have we been made aware of any concerns about this so we bring it to you as we left it at the first read. Thank you for the updates. Sometimes it's hard to remember from
a month ago. I did recall this was when we talked about a fair amount, because there was some pretty substantial adjustments from the previous to the new, so with no changes from first read to second read. Are there any additional questions, comments? All right, then all those in favor? None opposed.
Thank you. Do you want to do these separate also, or are these ones okay to put together for first read? Let's keep them together. Great. All right. So do I have a motion for consideration and approval for the first read for the following policies? JJIF, Student
Concussion and Other Head Injuries, JJIFE, Concussion Information Sheet, and IMB, Teaching About Controversial Issues, New Policy. Valerie, thank you. Malik? So we bring for you these three, um, these two policies for first reading and accompanying information sheet. Let's talk
about JJIF, first student concussions and other head injuries. Um, this is one that we had with us at the, um, the committee for a while as we just wanted to make sure we really understood, um, what the law changes were. I'm going to draw out the, um, uh, a few notes here regarding,
um, the major, sort of some, the major points that came up in terms of the law change, and then make a few other points. The first is that this new policy has a broader scope in all of the settings. Where and when don't matter to the same degree
that they were in the previous law. This revision requires a written diagnosis of concussion by a specifically licensed, someone specifically licensed for concussion management. This revision also includes defined terms that were not previously defined.
It also outlines a graduated school re-entry protocol. It makes clear the district must track every concussion. The updated form allows us to accomplish all of the needs that were articulated in the other points that I was bringing up.
And also just as a point, every employee is required to participate in concussion management training with a recognition that concussions occur everywhere. And a concussion is not just going to occur in the company of a medical professional.
So those are the main points. And just a few other things I wanted to note. One was that Erica and the nursing teams and the trainer have all gone over this and have given it their sign-off. And also, I wrote down a complete sentence here in my notes, which is always something to celebrate.
It says, we didn't just go with the sample, exclamation point. We really, really got into it. It was an old school policy meeting. We really kind of got our fingers dirty. Let's see, what else do I want to say? Oh, this was the Maine School Management Association draft, not Drummond.
Anything else, Tom, that you can remember that we needed to share about this before we ask for any questions? Great. So, what was unclear to me, and maybe this is semantics, is I know of at least one student this year who was injured severely during a school vacation week,
but did get concussed. Would they then have to step through all of these, or is this applicable to a student that's injured in the course of school business? I would imagine we'd want them to still do all of these steps because it's about the concussion, right?
Erica was point on this one. Yes, I'm not going to try to answer that question. So if an injury occurs outside of school, then typically we know about that accompanied with a treatment plan and we would support the treatment plan. If an injury occurs in school, there are certain protocols we need to follow to reenter both school activities and athletic activities,
including physical education. So all of those, there are pathways for all of these scenarios in the new policy, whether those medical recommendations are provided by the physician or we're working through that here with our...
Yeah, that was my understanding. I think on page three of five, I think the third point on, the third bullet on that is I think where I kind of wrap my head around that, which is the quote, the student and their parents, guardians will be informed of the referral to a licensed healthcare provider for medical evaluation for possible concussion or brain injury before the student is allowed to begin the graduated school re-entry. I'm just going to end the quote there, but also the bullet before
that is also referring to any student suspected of having sustained a concussion or other hand injury, and note that it does not say at school is prohibited from further participation until they're evaluated by the school nurse. So yeah, that was my understanding of how that was meant
to work but i think that's a really good question it also specifically points out in the front that the board acknowledges that concussions may occur during any activities of the school or outside of the school so those concussions would apply because we acknowledge that they happen outside
of the school and therefore these points would apply so i guess my maybe natural follow-up is what happens if our if this occurs and maybe the family doesn't notify the school that this has occurred do we have that has happened um and so uh a nurse or another provider so at this stage
our nurses are trained and our athletic coaches and our athletic trainer is trained in concussion management signs and symptoms starting next year and in accordance with this policy every staff member will have concussion management training as a as part of their portfolio of mandated training
so anybody would be likely to see these symptoms and report them or more people would be sort of aware of the symptoms and in that case we have a protocol in this to address things that aren't made known to us. Thank you. So are our school nurses authorized to make that written diagnosis?
You should just stay standing, Erica, sorry. No. Yeah, no. They are simply executing the protocol and the plans and attending to those, but they are not the medical professionals offering a diagnosis or a release. So if having a concussion requires a written diagnosis
and we don't have someone who can provide it in-house and a parent chooses not to go seek it for any number of reasons, access, cost, whatever, how do we manage that? So say we see the symptoms and we recognize this is likely a concussion, but we don't have the written diagnosis that's
now required. How do we handle that? We can respond to symptoms to the extent that we know what we're working with, but there is not, in the absence of a diagnosis, our staff will not be making a diagnosis so then referring to potentially a clinic that provides
support at low to no cost or consulting with our district physician but I think also directly to your point that student would not be allowed to return to activities that required this reentry plan if we if we have the discretion to
say even though you don't have the piece of paper we're pretty sure you have a concussion and you can't go out and play out. Yeah, that's my understanding. Yeah, there's a lever if symptomatically the presentation is such that we should
treat this as if it is a concussion, then we have a protocol for that to not allow entry into physical activity or school-based activities if they are problematic. So what's the goal of the written diagnosis then? If we don't need it to enact the policy?
We would not want to be using the policy in lieu of written diagnosis of concussion on a regular basis. We would be utilizing those protocol in these instances where we don't have other medical recommendations. So that's not where we want to usually be traveling through our process.
And there's often treatment plan recommendation accompanying the diagnosis with a sort of prescribed return to the physician for a checkup or expected recovery. And you said Eric was involved in this policy as well? Eric as well as Antonio and as well as our entire nursing staff.
And Drummond reviewed it as well extensively even though it was written by Maine School Management. They reviewed ours or they reviewed the Maine School Management one? Because it sounds like we went off script from Maine School Managements. We went off script with the support of Drummond Witsum. Perfect. Yeah. Other comments or questions on this one
before we move to the next? Okay. I probably should have just at least, I mean, JJIFE is the parent information sheet and acknowledgement form. I think that logically connects, it does connect to the policy we were just talking about.
And if there are minimal changes to that, you'll see that it's underlined. It's a good thing to be clear that all concussions are potentially serious. Which we think we should add, because they are. Love, Colin. Okay, that's the end of that particular one. Let's go to the next one. The next one is a new policy, IMB, which is teaching about controversial issues.
So this was a policy that was suggested by our superintendent as a policy that I believe a number of the districts where you worked previously had this and found it to be important and so brought it to our attention. So we had a good long conversation about it. And this was also where Tim Cravois from the high school came to talk about this because in the context of the humanities and so
And social studies is sort of where some of this might, not that a controversial issue might not crop up anywhere, but this would be the place where, from a kind of curricular point of view, it would be the most logical.
And so he brought up a few really helpful points there. I think just maybe to kind of begin, just a few things that we sort of had consensus on. not that we had a lot of not consensus, but just some things that were very clear to us,
was first, that schools should not avoid controversial issues. We were clear about that as a committee, and that was reinforced by also Mr. Gravois, and that teaching them is very much part of our mission, but must be done responsibly.
So a few things in the draft policy we wanted to sort of bring to the surface. One is sort of an emphasis on civil discourse and respect and educational purpose. And I think particularly that last one is one that, again, I might return to a few times tonight.
And also a clear note that teachers are to act as facilitators, not advocates. So again, this is where we're bringing this up in an educational context. So the idea is that if we are bringing up a controversial issue, it is so that we can discuss that as an educational, as a piece of educational, as education.
And so therefore, it's not for the teacher to be advocating for one side or the other of the issue. It's to facilitate the conversation of that as, as pedagogy. And just a clear thing we wanted to make sure was this point that students should encounter multiple perspectives, and that should be part of the design of any sort of discussion of this.
I think a few other, I'm not sure how much to get into this right now, I think maybe I'll just flag that one thing that was very important to Mr. Revoir was making sure that this policy does not enable what he, I think, appropriately referred to as bad faith challenges or sort of false equivalencies that would be brought up.
And I can get in a little more detail about sort of how we try to address that in this draft. But I think the idea there being we are not wanting to create a policy that creates a unligorous and non-academic context of sort of both-siderism,
where just because there is an issue that people disagree on doesn't necessarily mean that is something that is recognized by the educational community or by the academic community as being something that fits this definition in this context.
Obviously, there's nuance within that, but that was something that I felt was really important for Mr. Groufois to bring forward been something you wanted to address here. So I'm going to stop there and just see what thoughts came up for folks as they were looking at this. I'm not going to put me on the spot
exactly, but I would be curious if at any point in this conversation if you had any thoughts on this. But not, you don't need to speak now, but just at any point, I'd love to hear your thoughts. I think that it's a good policy. I definitely think that, you
know, the humanities and social studies curriculum can touch on controversial issues, but I think that they're always handled with a lot of respect and, like, does not have a bias, so I definitely think that this is a good policy just to make sure that things are, you know,
taught well and without a bias, so, yeah, I think it's great. You can criticize it also. Criticism is fun. We had a good old chinwag about it at the policy committee so other thoughts or criticisms yes yep for high school maybe for middle school
i think this is really appropriate having been primary and intermediate teacher i think this is more difficult when you have a child who says my mother says that and aims it at a child in the classroom that fits the description there has to be a place where the teacher can i'll say give
their own opinion and not give both sides. Because there are not two, my opinion, there's not two sides to it. But there are those discussions that you get into with little kids about why that's not okay to be saying. So just a few points about that. The policy actually does allow for teachers to be
able to share their points of view. And there are some who would contend that a student in a class should never necessarily know any of the educators' views on anything. I don't actually agree with that. I think that it's much more real for students if they actually know their teachers as a person and can take their teachers' biases into account when they discuss an issue. And that's certainly the way I often handle things as a teacher, especially when some of these kids would come to my house and knew who I was anyway outside of school. What it does say is that the teacher is not to use the classroom as a platform for a captive audience, if I summarize the language. That's number five. The reason that I actually felt we needed this policy
is that I am, I'm going to go back a little bit in time, and I was a high school history teacher, and there was an instance when I was teaching APUS history, as Mr. Grivois does, these bald guys that teach history and have names that start with GR.
And, you know, I was teaching a whole unit about modern Supreme Court cases that are about the right to privacy. And I had a colleague actually suggest that that was too risky, I shouldn't do that. And I thought, that's ridiculous. And I thought, there must be a policy that says, I should teach about controversial issues.
My district at the time didn't have one, but the Kennebunk district did because I researched it. And that's how I became aware that this policy kind of existed. And then there was a reason a few months ago for me to think here when a situation came up,
I thought, oh, well, we probably have that controversial issues policy. And lo and behold, we didn't. And that's why I bring it to you because I feel it's very strongly that we need to be able to endorse that teaching about controversial issues is our job and to have kids know how to discuss them and think about them
And to have teachers be able to be fair and real about that in the process is really important. And the first point also does note that the discussion shall be appropriate to the age, grade, and maturity of the students.
So I think it would look really different at the primary grades. But, you know, one of the points that we discussed about, Colin mentioned false equivalency. I think this is where we get into the point about where it says that we're obligated to try to expose the kids to multiple points of view.
The danger could be that somebody could say, well, you had a lesson about the sky being blue, but I think the sky is black and my point of view wasn't represented. Well, that's nonsense. That's not a controversial issue. That's just, that's fringe. That's not the intent of the policy. So it was number, if I may, it was number five that concerned me.
Because it says, educators shall not use the classroom as a forum to advance their personal views. But it then says, they are not prohibited from their own views for legitimate pedagogical purposes. I mean, I think the way, I guess, I guess just to talk you through the way we thought about it as a committee,
was that, was first for number one, was that discussion controversially should be appropriate to the age, grade, and maturity. And I think the way we thought about that was around, and again, it's not, I don't want to create a false binary on this,
But one is that when that is a curricular decision, right? When there's a curricular decision, if you're going to talk about a controversial issue at first grade, you are going to do that in a different way than you're going to do that at fifth grade. We sort of like talked about that. I think the other is to say that if an issue comes up, I think as you were talking about,
the kind of more organic kind of human thing of a student coming in with a certain idea and sharing that. Again, I think the idea there is that the teacher's response should still be appropriate to age. I think that was sort of the way we were thinking about that. And I think, yes, the way that, I think probably it gets down to verbs
and the question of advancing and proselytizing and expressing. So I think as a committee, we were saying that advancing and proselytizing are different from expressing. And I think there could be nuance in that, but I'm not sure how else we would make clear that first point, which is that it's just because I'm the teacher
and I am the teacher doesn't mean I can use this form to advance my position, sort of regardless of the sort of educational context that was sort of how we were trying to think about it does that make does that follow i can move with it all right vali i think something
that's unsaid here and i don't know if it's worth mentioning or not um uh protected groups and and referencing a bullying policy um just because sometimes people think that some protected groups either aren't real or shouldn't be protected.
And I'm wondering if we should mention and call out those protected groups as maybe not something we have a healthy debate about whether they exist. Yeah, I mean, I think that's a really good question. And I think one that I'd like to pick up and maybe take back to the committee is sort of how we might reference that. I think, again, with Mr. Grouvoir's,
what he sort of led us to was this idea of really defining for ourselves controversial as actually being a definable thing, which is being an issue of legitimate public debate with credible scholarship. So I think that's where what we would be referring to
as sort of more fringe ideas around, um, uh, maybe certain populations, um, that would not, that would not, that would never be considered, um, a controversial issue that is appropriate to discuss. Um, does that make sense? But I think we should, I think we should take it back and sort of look at how that maybe crosses over with the, with the bullying policy or any other, uh, policies having to do
with, uh, individual rights of students or staff. And we, we can definitely do that, even if it passes a first read um my question was on number seven um yeah i think this is i think this is a good policy i think it is one we should have in place um i'm curious how seven is accomplished is
there any obligation to notify in advance of a controversial topic discussion to allow parents the opt i mean we say that if they object based on particular sincerely held beliefs they can request the accommodation, similar to the exemption from required instruction.
I just want to make sure we're not putting any sort of onus on the teachers to, like, we're going to talk about, I mean, I don't know. I wouldn't want to do that, because I think that that's just way too cumbersome, and it depends on who's defining what a
controversial issue is. Well, it sounds like there's a defined definition of what a controversial issue is. We did try to pay some attention to that, and Tim provided some really good language about that. Yeah, I'm not suggesting that we should, but I just want to
make sure that we don't get pushback from parents that then come back and say, well, you have it in here that I could opt out, but you didn't tell me it was happening. Yeah, I mean, I hear that. I guess the way I was thinking that through was sort of like, it's sort of like the, forgive me for,
Which is the policy that covers, um, I know, exactly. I am not, I am not the, I am not the dork, uh, that I wish I was in terms of, in terms of policy. Um, but, uh, so for example, we, uh, parents and guardians are allowed to, um, to raise questions about texts that are being, that are being, um, looked at in school.
However, we do not, to my knowledge, include, send out in advance of the school year, a list of all of the books that are in this library. There could be books in this library that any number of parents might have a concern about,
but I do not believe it is our obligation to flag all of those books ahead of time So that if Maria's parents, you know, don't want her to be learning about the American Revolution, you know, she has to go through and can't read the American Revolution books, right? I think that's the way I would think about it.
I just want to make sure we... Yeah, no, I think it's a really good thing. And again, I think just to, I think the point around the, again, the, um, I really want to thank Mr. Griswold for coming, um, because I think it really did, it was a really important
point to raise, um, about how, how, one of the things was also that we acknowledged as a committee, um, that this, uh, there are issues that have always been charged, but we are operating in a rather charged moment right now from a number of
directions and sort of just acknowledge that and to own that as a school and I think I really appreciate him bringing up this question giving us some of this language around evidence-based inquiry or disciplinary scholarship historical accuracy so for example because I just sometimes this can be a little abstract
for folks. For example, something that would not be considered a controversial issue under this policy, because it would not meet the criteria of evidence-based inquiry, disciplinary scholarship, or historical accuracy, would be Holocaust denial. There are individuals who deny that the Holocaust of 6 million
European Jews and 5 million additional folks of different classes that the Nazi government deemed less than human, that that did not occur. And they have published books on it. But the scholarship, academia, the folks who are
responsible for helping us to better understand how to understand our own history and the world that we live in, have determined that those texts do not past muster. So if, I think, if a teacher were to say, I'd like to talk about the question of
whether the Holocaust happened or not, that would be a violation of this policy. Because it is not, yes, it's a controversial thing to say, but it is an idiotic thing to say, it is an historical thing to say, it is an anti-Semitic thing to say, and it's a
wrong thing to say, in addition to also being controversial through one particular definition of that. That is not how we are defining it in this text. Other comments or questions on this policy? Okay. So that is the last one for
first read. So just on that, so we will take, we will go back to committee and we will uh just look at this question of how does this uh crisscross with uh questions of protected classes and um and uh i believe unless we determine that there's something um extremely
different um we will be bringing this back to you for second read all right um so we have a motion and a second for approval of the first read of both policies and the fact sheet or information sheet all those in favor none opposed thank you okay so we are uh up to uh item 13 unfinished
business um for a budget um we as a board last week um provided the direction to uh the administration around the level that we felt appropriate for the budget I did give give people the the flexibility to to adjust their opinion between then and
now nothing was there was no official vote taken so I do want to I do want to honor that that offer the proposed budget that you have in front of you today so we do have an updated workbook from from Kelly which reflects the
discussion of the board last week so what we referred to as tier 2a the 7.1 percent expenditure increase over the prior year and then the associated impacts of that budget by town the estimation on page two of that summary so
those numbers have all been updated from our discussion last week for for a reminder basically that was the tier two with the addition of the the instructional strategist, turning the .6 Spanish .4 ed tech into a 1.0 Spanish full-time teaching
position, and the two ed techs at the elementary schools in Freeport. So I did want to give folks an opportunity to provide any commentary. I know we've talked about this a lot. We continue to hear feedback from community members which we um which we all read and obviously hear this
evening um and and appreciate um one thing that uh i think might be helpful not necessarily for the board because i think most of the board is pretty familiar with this process but maybe tom might be able to provide um or maybe even kelly just a brief um one of the things that
we heard about tonight was other line items could we just cut them in half or could we just eliminate them completely and you know my understanding of the budget process is that those items have been have been reduced to the level that
we that we feel like we can and still deliver before any positions are proposed for elimination, but maybe you could just give us a quick view of how that looks or what that looks like. Sure. I mean, I think the really quick view is that we definitely have, before we looked at
staffing, knowing that we would still have to look at staffing because it's 81 percent, more than 81 percent of the budget, we looked at everything else. And we took everything else, we reduced everything else first to the degree that we felt it was responsible to do. And part of that is
maintaining a long-term vision of what we will need and not wanting to get us backed into a corner at some point when, if we have some kind of catastrophic failure in our fleet of vehicles or our facilities, etc., that we would either have to tax or borrow our way out of a problem.
And that's what the energy audit is about. It's what the life safety plan is about. It's what the vehicle replacement plan is about. And it is also, I mean, what the various reserve accounts are for. And, you know, as we have seen, when something fails, it fails. And it's a good thing
to have something in reserve so that we aren't facing a huge cliff. We faced that earlier this year with a condition on the track that we really needed to fix. Unfortunately, our tennis courts are not playable. They couldn't have picked a worse year to become unplayable, but they are
unplayable. And we have to contend with that now. We have kicked technology down the road. That was actually a pretty painful choice, but it's a really substantial choice. And in the tier 2A that you've talked about, before we looked at staff, we have $125,000 worth of
computers that we kicked down the road, in addition to another $125,000 worth of computers from the previous tier, which was tier one. So we really looked at that strongly. We can get by with what we have for computers right now. I don't know if you'd like more than that at the moment.
Well, I think that's helpful. And the other thing I always want to make sure that I mentioned, specifically as we're talking about the facilities and the upkeep and the maintenance of the buildings i don't know if i don't know if it was kelly or maybe it was dennis but
our previous facilities director used to say that no one no one advocates for the buildings right they can't they can't get up they can't write us an email they can't and the the importance of maintaining safe buildings is is a obviously a priority for us and i think it's an area where
some districts have potentially misstepped and that they will kick things down the road to avoid difficult decisions now and they end up with bigger issues down the road which costs a lot more money to fix and deal with so I
think the the creation of both the vehicle replacement plan and the the facility audit to improve I mean as as we heard about tonight I mean these these things are are not new these these pieces of equipment are are aging and if
we don't have a plan for them then we end up sort of in a in a scramble so it's like with people's you know so many people and maybe some of us in this room have lived a large portion of life having to pay debts every month.
And you can work a long time to get to a point where you're paying yourself every month first. And when you're doing that, you feel better and you're saving money and you're better equipped to deal with any contingency that might come up. And I have known districts that have limped along that way.
And we're in a position where we're not doing that and it would not be in the best interest of the district to become a district that lives that way other comments questions yeah yeah on the topic of facilities I know we're going to be talking about this next but I'm wondering if maybe is Glenn still
here if he might be able to share with us like the biggest ticket items here are the air handler replacements can you tell us what would happen if those failed before we had a chance to replace them sure absolutely so uh here at the high school on the science wing we have a rooftop unit that
provides ventilation for this whole half of the wing solely this whole half of the wing so if that unit was to fail you wouldn't have that to be able to provide the necessary and required ventilation for the side of the building that unit's around 37 years old over at mass landing we have air
handlers that are older than that um and the life expectancy is since passed you know we've been keeping them going if you will but um the energy audit when i first got here um that we were asked to present i welcomed it from a facility guy coming from other districts where you know they
didn't ask those type of questions so like michelle just said i'm the guy up here advocating for the building saying hello we need to work on this stuff and so i was thankful when they asked for that, and it provided the backup data that I needed to be able to reassure that we do have
aging infrastructure in this district, and this is a proven point. So, we have a hot water heater that has since failed over at Mass Landing. Same thing with that rooftop unit here at the high school, or Mass Landing, or the air handles over at the middle school. Those things are 41 years old.
Those things are, they need to retire. They are just, they're still running, don't get me wrong. mechanical services, and we've been doing a great job keeping them going, but they've outlived their life expectancy, so they're no longer as efficient as new pieces of equipment that are out there,
and there is a ton of equipment that are out there that we can be getting those savings and also providing the building infrastructure that we need to provide for our students and staff. I'm going to read this. I came onto this board of directors as an interim because I want the
students in RSU 5 to have the best available education and opportunities that our three communities can provide. I spent 40 years in education, 26 of them in this district. When I came on as an interim board member, I said that I believe in public education and that it's the
most important thing we can do for our kids' futures. Over the years, I've said it both publicly and privately, that I'd be willing to pay more in taxes if I knew that every cent was going to the schools and that it would improve students' lives. In the past few weeks, I've listened to people
speak about the importance of a strong district and varied programming. I've read so many letters, as has the rest of the board. I counted them up a couple of days ago. It was 70. We've gotten more since then, I'm thinking it's 90. Those people support RSU-5, and they've made it clear what
they want for our communities, for our schools, and most of all, for our students. They want their kids and their grandkids, and their neighbor's kids, to have every opportunity for an exceptional education. Not essential services, exceptional services. Lots of those people have been clear
that they do not want classroom program cuts. In all those comments, in letters, and from that podium over there, the vast majority of people want to keep programming that gives kids a chance to have new experiences in math, in languages, and in life in general.
Therefore, when I vote against this budget, it's not because I believe it's too high, and I don't think that more cuts should be made. I'm voting against this budget because we need to preserve what we have and provide a wide array of opportunities for our students.
Only way we do that is to not classroom positions. Thank you, Liz. Okay, I'm going to get a motion on the floor. That's certainly not meant to stifle conversation, question, or comments, but just so we have it on the floor. Do I have a motion for consideration and approval of the FY27 superintendent's proposed budget as reflected in the handbook that we have from today?
Thank you. Kelly, and Steph. Okay, so we have a motion on the floor, giving people their opportunity to think if they had any remaining commentary. Um, I, once again, Lois's words, um, resonate with me. Um, but also last year, I was over there fighting for exactly the same thing Lois said,
and last year, no one showed up to say the taxes were too high. Everyone that came, mostly just me, but a few others, said that they supported no cuts. This is the first year that we've had people brave enough to show up and say the taxes are too high, which makes me concerned
that there are people at home who are watching this who feel differently than those who've come in droves and said no cuts. And those folks vote just the same as the ones who come here and tell us that they don't want to to see any cuts and I tend to be a very pragmatic person
a hopeful learning pragmatic person um which is how I got to 2a um but I still have a lot of concerns that our primary is the same day and that folks who haven't heard us talking about it who don't have students in the schools or don't care as much as we do about the education of the
students, will just see the number and vote no. Or that we'll have a split and those who want no cuts will also vote no. And my concern is that the students don't win in that case. People who don't care and care a lot will be saying the same thing to us in June.
if they vote no. And that's my concern. I am really worried about this, because it's conservative, but it still cuts a bunch of really great teachers. We've heard the testimonies, like really great teachers. And I don't like it. I don't think anyone on this board is celebrating
the potential of doing that. I think it's a reality of the world we're living in right now, where competing, competing morals and competing, maybe not morals, maybe competing ideas, what is most moral is causing us to make a decision that we don't want to make.
There's no wrong answer. There are two right answers. And it's, it's, it's keeping me up at night. I'm not doing this with joy. And I think you'd be hard pressed to find a board member who is. Thank you, Valerie. Okay, so we have a motion and a second on the floor.
Let's take it to a vote. Are those in favor opposed? Thank you. Okay, item 14, new business. This is related to what Kara had mentioned previously around the lease, the resolution. So, do I have a motion for consideration and approval for the resolution entitled, Resolution to Authorize Lease Financing of $2,429,416 Energy Conservation Project for RSU School Facilities be approved in the form presented to this meeting and that an attested copy of said resolution be included with the minutes of this meeting?
Kelly, thank you. Tara? So before you tonight is actually the motion that it takes in order to move forward with phase two of the energy audit, which included in your packet also, there's two sheets. One is the sheet from EMC, which is a listing that kind of like just kind of goes down the
list and lists all the items. And then based upon our discussions that we'd had previously, we had kind of moved it into a different format where you could see the items, but then you could see them in bicycle columns. I will let Glenn speak to the items. I just wanted to speak to the motion that you're actually making tonight.
And it allows us to move forward with phase two of this project, but it also allows us to seek the financing for phase two of the project. The process will go, if it's approved tonight at the board level, then EMCR vendor will start the beginning, the process of bidding the projects out, seeking bids on those projects so that we can, so that they can then come back and return those results to us so that we can pick the vendors that we want to move forward with and to get the actual cost of the project.
again these are estimates with some contingencies built in for the for the market because we're not sure they weren't sure when we would actually get to the bidding process on those and then the authorization for the superintendent and I to seek the financing for the lease purchase
financing for it once that has been once the actual project amount has been determined the total project amount do we want Glenn to talk about the items sure let's see if any questions for you first yeah I'm just can we get like a
one-minute history of like the financing plan overall of the energy on it sure we talked about it briefly last time so I'll talk a brief again and maybe we'll get more pieces. So last year, the Facilities and Finance Committee met together to talk
about once the energy audit was done and the phases were brought forward and presented to the Facilities Committee, we jointly met as a Finance and Facilities Committee to talk about how to move forward with the phases of the project. And the Finance Committee's
goal and my goal was with the lease impact to the to the taxpayers because obviously we're taking on debt service payments as we as we phase these projects in and at the same time you might remember we were doing the life safety projects proposing the the life safety projects and we
were also proposing the vehicle and equipment replacement plan the life safety projects were we're part of this this past year's budget and part of phase one of the energy audit so those got taken care of um the vehicle and equipment replacement plan we talked about last year
and then the the energy audit the energy audit there are four actual phases of the energy audit then we kind of chunk them off in about three million dollar pieces at a time um and we would lease finance them, lease purchase finance them over 17 years for each phase of the project that
the board approves and we then move forward with. So we took that plan with some estimated payment amounts and put in the, in addition to that, we included the vehicle and equipment replacement cost because we are lease purchasing them for three-year agreements to get into a cycle where
we can build up funds within the budget to eventually not have to lease purchase those vehicles and just purchase them outright. We are stepping into that also over a four-year period and to level off the financing into taking on about, at last year, it was a 0.75% increase per
year, which is around the $350, $360, $370 mark, we are utilizing some undesignated fund balance to help offset and step into that incrementally so they're even payments and there's no spikes to the budget. While there may be spikes in the use of undesignated fund balance,
there would be a leveling of what would come into the budget for the taxpayers. did that help thanks for the reminder yes I appreciate it all right I will pass it over to Glenn so because he knows more about all of the particular items that are listed did you want the
little cheat sheet any questions go ahead yeah um Kara actually brought this up but I think it might be a good idea to talk about um we have a lot of projects on this list that aren't necessarily energy related we have some numbers that are showing us how much energy savings
we will get out of replacing some of these items but obviously we're spending a lot more money than we're going to be saving so can you just address some of the other reasons besides simply energy savings why we're in performing some of
these projects some of these changes are due to age of the current equipment that we have so some of the equipment we can't get a given example of the automation system in phase one we had an automation system upgrade for here at
the high school and here at Freeport middle school the reason why we did that he was noted in the energy on it but those system has failed and you couldn't purchase those systems anymore so that was one reason for the upgrade very
little energy savings for an automation system but it's it's crucial from a facility standpoint so we can manage our HVAC systems to make sure that they're running correctly another example is the fire alarm systems we did a fire alarm
panel upgrade over at Freeport middle school we also did a fire alarm upgrade over at Durham Community School both of those systems were obsolete couldn't get parts for them anymore they just didn't make them or they were just outdated so that was also noted in the energy audit and it was also again very little energy
savings but crucial to the overall function of the building because we need a fire alarm system that works so a lot of these upgrades some of them the lighting project, air handlers, boilers, unit ventilators, reheaters, reheat units have savings
with those, the variable flow devices. Michelle? There are energy savings with those. There is an upfront cost with that, but your savings is over a period of time or over the lifetime of the equipment that we'll be installing. I hope that answers your question. Perfect. And those savings
aren't in the spreadsheet, correct? Because it's sort of like, it's hard to quantify future savings of electricity. Right, so yeah, so we're going to need, you know, a year's worth of data to collect the CMP's bills to actually see the savings overall. You know, you're not going to see that up front. You're going to have to see that over a period of time in our savings through our energy bills from CMP. Yeah, I mean, most of
the items on the spreadsheet that show energy savings seemed to be like weatherization things, right? Like easy fixes to keep basically heat from just flying out windows and doors. Exactly. When we did the initial energy audit
of the district, EMC came in and they did infrared scans of all our buildings for potential heat loss. They did roofs, they did doors, windows, and that led to door replacement, weather stripping and so forth. And that is continued in phase two. You'll see that here on the sheet. It's also
continuing in phase three and so forth down the line we did the worst areas first there are some areas that didn't have quite so much that would so that will be in a phase two in a phase three so the number that I'm looking at here
when it says energy savings am I to assume that that's per year what period of time estimated estimated per year that is correct yep Chris I know that the catalyst for moving the facility study was mainly due to the reconfiguration of
the district but that that facility study will also provide us with kind of an overview of the actual structures and facilities that we have and so kind of a couple questions in here one do we have an idea about how that will play into
what to this and how that would change this and two do we do we have the ability to incorporate this information and data that we've gotten already for this into that facility study so then there's maybe less work and potentially less cost into that facility study too i mean i certainly imagine glenn would share glenn sure
yeah absolutely yeah um i i envision sort of them going hand in hand i mean i think the study that um emc did for this was probably a little more a little more technical than or a little more targeted maybe right than than what we're looking for for the for the full
facility study but there's i particularly as it relates to condition of the buildings i imagine there's a fair amount of overlap correct um you know the age of the buildings the age of the infrastructure all of those things i think would come into play absolutely so they're going to be
looking at similar stuff and you know we'll share the data that we did the energy audit so they'll see that up front uh but they're clearly going to see it when they do their own study so and there is an overlap yep so i was curious on um the uh the back sheet where we break it up by schools
why there was, I don't know, four or five lines that had nothing in, were those items that were originally in phase two and we moved them up? So some of these, so this is just a phase two. So some of those you're going to see that were in a phase one. Some of those are in a phase three. So that's why you see some blanks. So these are the ones that we captured for a phase two. When we propose a phase three, you'll see different blanks because we would have addressed those in a phase two.
Glenn did a great job. This was just the format we used when we put it in four phases for you. Okay, okay. So we just cut out the phase two ones? Okay. Correct. So we just isolated down to phase two, so the list remains the same no matter what phase you're looking in.
It just, right, like the total items, like the line items. So, yes, we used it as a template for all four phases. Just so you could see where the work is actually being applied. Yeah, okay. That's helpful. So I guess my question was, in addition to this,
we do still have our amount that runs through the budget for facilities. So those items are less, yes, there's $382,000 that is in the current budget to support other things that are not on the energy audit list that needs to happen.
Yeah, okay. You get to say what those are. Exactly, yeah. When we presented it to the facility committee, we had roofs that were on for Freeport High School to bid out to be able to do it. It was also on major maintenance and capital projects to do here. That was what prompted when I saw roofs on here. I was like, there are roofs being done, it's just not through this project. Correct. Are there questions?
We have a motion and a second on the floor to allow Kelly and Glenn and Tom to move forward with this. Anna. Oh, you're voting? Okay. All those in favor with Anna. Anyone opposed? Thank you. Okay, so we have no personnel items, right?
Nope. So we are back to public comment, and we do still have a few members of the public, if we had anyone who'd like to speak, yeah. Good evening, thank you. Michael Metzger from Poundell. I had not planned to speak tonight, and I debated whether to come up here after such
a hard budget discussion, but I did want to say a few words. First, thank you, Superintendent Gray, for coming on Monday to Pownall. That was well-received and a very worthwhile conversation, so thank you for that. PES is an excellent school. DCS is an excellent school.
While I can't speak for everyone in Pownall, I can certainly apologize on behalf of myself and others if we have given any of them the impression that we felt otherwise. But it is not our school. It is not the school that many of our community members grew up going to
and looked forward to sending their own children to. It is not the school that many members of our community moved specifically to Pownall to send their children to. It is not the school that years ago was promised would remain open when the middle school programs were moved to Freeport Middle School. It is not the school that truly serves
as a central pillar of community life in our town. The central pillar. It is not our community elementary school. While we strongly disagree with any scenario that leads to the closure of PES as a community elementary school, like many here, we also value the goals of middle school equity, early
childhood education expansion, et cetera, highly. We value those things highly. What we strongly object to is a process that presupposes that the only way to achieve those latter two goals is to sacrifice on the first principle of sacrificing our community school.
Rather than coming to the table with those problems in hand and an open mind on how to solve them, this board was presented with only two options for change, both of which involved the closure of PES. Even though Superintendent Gray found limited savings at that option, an additional further analysis by members of the panel community have estimated that they may even cost us money in the end.
We are eager as a community to continue to constructively problem solve with the board, Superintendent Gray, to make the RSU as strong as possible because we truly believe that we are better together as an RSU. As Superintendent Gray stated earlier tonight, and I just want to truly emphasize, it is the fear of the timeline that we're talking about today that's driving talk within the town of Poundell toward more radical solutions to protect PES.
And I'm sure to some of the stronger emotions that you have been the brunt of, I'm sure, through emails and other things. And again, I apologize for that. So please, when you can, I would just emphasize what Superintendent Gray said.
When you can, state publicly that no matter the long-term decisions that are made by this board, the PES will remain open for the 27-28 school year. When you can, please state publicly that lots of options will be considered, including many
that do not include closing PES. And please help us prevent a premature fracturing of this district when it's not necessary. Thank you. Thank you, Michael. Okay, seeing no other public comment, I would take a motion to adjourn.
Kara and Chris, all those in favor?
Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.
