Skip to content

TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 6 May 2026

Board meeting · 2 h 28 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →

Computer-made transcript, not a record of what was said. It mishears names and figures and drops short words, such as the "not" in "does not carry". Click a time to hear the recording, which settles any disagreement. The district's minutes are the official record.

19,151 words in 27 five-minute windows.

0:00

The rest of the board is here and ready to get started, so we will start with the Pledge of Allegiance. Alright, so we don't have any minutes this evening. There are no adjustments to the agenda, so we will move right on to item 6, good news and recognition.

Our student board rep, Moon, will provide us with an update. Hi everyone. So I guess a lot has happened over like the last couple weeks. So I guess Active Minds, since it's May and I guess it's for Mental Health Month, Active Minds has been

doing a lot of activities to help students with their mental health. And so last Friday, Active Minds hosted like a bird feeder making session and a chalk art session in the bus circle. And then also yesterday they also had a taco bar for all students. So that was really

nice. And then also they've been asking students every Wednesday to wear green in support of mental health and so it's been really great to see that our school is taking initiative to really make sure students are having like a great time especially during APs and whatnot. And also on

May 20th we have a charity walk for the Barbara Bush Children's Hospital. We had representatives I think last week or the week before come in with hospital staff and also representatives who talked about um like why how grateful they are for us to i guess support this charity but also talking

about what they do and also the jmg committee who's helped lead that um and we had a person named lila who shared her personal stories with it so that was really cool to hear about what they had to offer and so i'm really looking forward to that and then also on thursday may 14th the

guidance department is taking all 11th graders to the university of maine august college fair And so students will have the opportunity to talk with, I think, around 100 college reps. And so that'll be a great opportunity to see what opportunities that these schools have to offer.

And then also, the school has sent out forms for the, I think, the, I guess, the school's cell phone committee. And so if students want to talk about the cell phone plan that has now been mandated, I think that'll be a great opportunity to see, I guess, next year's plans. And then also, on Saturday, May 2nd, some students have cleaned the Peace Garden.

Busy for sure. Thank you. All right, so we will move on to item seven on the agenda, which is our first of two public comments. So if we had anyone who would like to speak, we ask you, please just come up to the podium, give us your name, where you live, and comments are three minutes apiece.

I have a quick one. All right. I got help this morning last time. Usually it's Colin's job and he's not here, so. All right. Yeah, I'm Mark Doley from 196 Mile Road in Pownall. I have a daughter at Pownall Elementary School. I'm here today to listen to the weighted values discussion.

I performed the exercise provided in the agenda, and I had a little bit of a difficult time understanding how to apply the weighting. I've only ever seen the weights reflected as like a percentage, but I'm interested to see how other people went about this

and what changes are recommended. And I think the concept's a good one, and I think there's a lot of potential, and it's worth putting the time in for this ranking criteria and to get it a little bit more clear and comprehensive.

It can be a tool, not necessarily just for this project, but for a lot of decision-making. With respect to the criteria for evaluating a change to the RSU-5 school district, I think attendance areas is really important, is a really important criteria to include.

When reviewing the 2008 RSU-5 formation documents from the Maine State DOE, Section 13I provides guidance for establishing attendance areas, and maintaining established neighborhood groupings is one of the explicit sub-criteria in that section.

5:10

And I wanted to point this out because value number five listed in the agenda is one aspect of the broader attendance area category. Other sub-criteria including busing, shared staff travel, parent involvement, civic connection, and student belonging.

Those are some of the other items that could kind of fall in with that. And this historical document, it has a lot of detail that might inform anybody who's curious about what to consider as important when evaluating options.

So, I just wanted to bring that up. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Any other public comments? You know the real show. Hi, I'm John Morris. I am the chairperson for the Town of Poundless Luck Board. And I'm here just to speak a little bit to definitions.

And as you work through your weighted values worksheet, which I strongly approve of, I just want to make sure that everyone has a clear understanding that the definition of community is very different for each one of us.

And as a member of Poundell's select board for 20 years, I need to say that community and the school in Palinol means a lot more work to me because since we've been talking or you've been talking about looking at the RSU differently,

I have been privy to bi-weekly meetings from about 30 families. The town warrant has been adjusted to include $50,000 for legal fees for a potential withdrawal from the RSU-5. So I strongly want you to think, if you're willing to,

of what community really means to you. Not a world that is going to be workshopped, not a world that you've read in some kind of document, but where would you really like to live? Because that, I think, is the essence of what community really means.

So I just wanted to pass that along from Powell. Thank you. Thank you, John. Any other public comments? All right. Then we will move on to item eight, report from the superintendent. Good evening, everybody. So I just have some hires to report tonight.

We have Brian Cummings coming on as a bus driver and custodian. So actually, I have one hire, but several resignations. Eliza Bowen is at EdTech at Mass Landing School, has tendered her resignation. And Andrew Chassie, who is an office secretary at Freeport Middle School, has tendered his resignation, effective the school year.

That's it. That is it. That's your quickest report ever. Well, I could get going. No, no, that's okay. All right, so we will move on to item nine on the agenda, which is Administrator Reports, and under that, we have one presentation this evening. It is the student leadership team with Principal Golko and a variety of students who are here to present to us.

It's not hot yet. It's just like double click. Yeah, I mean, it's really hot right now. It'll be good. We're the Student Leadership Committee and all of our names. Maybe we're like our careers. Yeah. Everyone, we're the Student Leadership Committee.

10:26

We're the Student Leadership Committee. My name's Moon Gertusing. I'm Mira Goldman. I'm a senior, Moon's a junior. This is Annie Shelkin, who's a sophomore, Jaden Stoltz, a senior, Eleanor Williamson, a sophomore, and Grayson Hill, who is also a senior.

And we're here tonight to give kind of an update on what we've been doing so far this year and what our further steps are ending out this year and moving into next year. So as student leadership, our main, our little update on our main goal is we are student voices for student change.

We work with students, teachers, and admin to listen and problem-solve, and our main goal is to change how decisions are made by including student voices in the process through admin decisions. Our main goal this year is to work towards bridging the communication gap between students

and teachers as well as students in admin by actively listening through conversations with students and teachers while deciding our topic and gathering opinions and data on what people actually think and through all of our work we hope to organize effective change to

create a better school community by upholding some of our values like honesty respect communication empathy kindness and responsibility okay so um this year we have shifted to basically truly a student-driven group um we definitely have a lot of help from miss golco and miss naheda

um our teacher advisors um but it's mainly us that's like kind of organizing things and mira and phoebe are are like kind of leaders um and they like organize everything and plan everything um we've also utilized uh yearly and weekly agendas where we have like a document in a google

classroom where we keep all of our notes for you from each meeting um which we meet every thursday day and we just like keep track of all like our timeline and just like all of our documents in that google doc we've definitely shifted also towards like smaller group collaboration and

kind of like splitting off to work on like each task that we need to complete and we've started consistently communicating with other leadership groups like student coalition which includes student council student advisory leaders and i think like yeah that's basically it and um we meet

with them on tuesdays i can't remember what like the frequency of it is but we usually i think meet like a couple times a month or so and just talk about like what we're doing um and just like what our plans are for um the rest of the year um okay so i'm going to talk a little bit about like our

process. So we start with collaborating with the other leadership groups that Annie just talked about. So like the student advisory leaders and the student council, student government, and we kind of like have a big meeting and talk with them about what they think the major issues are in our

school. It kind of just gets like a bigger group of students, a bigger input of ideas to just talk about like what do you think is going not so well in our school? What do you think is going well? What do we need to talk about? What do we need to change? And then once we've kind of finalized one of those ideas, we all have, like, a big meeting where we talk about who we want to get information out of.

So this year, and this happens, like, every year, we make a big whiteboard drawing with all the different, like, groups that we think are kind of present in the school. So we have, like, student athletes, like, AP class students, theater people.

So, like, we try and, like, make sure that we are aware of all of those groups so that then we can reach all of those groups. And we kind of have, like, the amount of demographics that we want to reach. And then we look at our calendar and we decide, like, all the time that we're going to allot for each step of our process.

Then we go into hosting our student conversations. So we make a conversation guide with a researcher from another institution who helps us create questions that will get what we want out of students. So if we're looking for, this year we were looking for communication, we made a conversation guide that had specific questions about how students communicate between each other

15:28

with teachers with administration just to make sure that every conversation we had with students got the data that we wanted from them. And then we used a platform called Cortico. We uploaded all of our conversations into there and we go through and we highlight everything that we think is

important which is pretty much everything except for people when people say like yeah I don't know like that was kind of filler words but we basically highlight everything um and then we use codes uh which are kind of like big themes we categorize everything into those themes so that we can better

see and organize our data um with everything organized into codes we can then see how like what the main themes were that came out of the conversations like what did what were the things that people said the most and that kind of guides us into what action steps we implement. So that's

kind of where we are right now is we're thinking about what do we want to do at school now to fix the problems that we heard from students. So we use the data that we collected to make action steps moving forward and then we implement the action steps through talking with administration and

talking with teachers and other students and then we try to keep consistent communication with these different groups to see what's working with these action steps that we've implemented what's not going well what do we need to change going forward and like how is everything going so that's kind of

our process um and as jayden kind of mentioned our big theme for 2025 to 2026 um is communication and connection overall at Freeport High School. And so we initially broke up into three subgroups of student-to-student conversation, student-to-teacher conversation, and student-to-admin conversation, which is where we really kind of focused our conversations around. But we also held teacher conversations this year, and through that we got information about teacher-to-teacher relationships as well as teacher-to-admin relationships.

Okay, I might have to adjust this a little bit. So, some of our findings from student conversations, we found that students feel a slight disconnect from their friends and peers, so they lack a general form of communication where they

can just interact without the feeling of any pressure or anything like that that forces them to feel like they have to say something a certain way. So, students, we want to kind of open this up and let students feel like they can talk

without having, um, talk, like, effectively, but also, like, uh, maturely about things that are happening within the school, but also just, like, anything, um, in itself. So, a possible action step for this was to, like, adjust the options for communication, um, within, uh, FHS. So, like,

some physical spaces that aren't being used, um, which I know a good one that students sometimes like to use it's like the FPAC lobby is a good space for students to like communicate and have time to meet up I know like open gym or open track

sometimes is a good place for students to meet up but that becomes unavailable sometimes with things that happen during advisory and other like moments like that so we just want to open up the opportunity for students to actually

informally communicate and physical and maybe even other spaces and then Some findings from student-to-teacher conversations, we found that students also wanted to communicate informally with teachers. Many had felt that Gmail was just, like, too formal.

They had to, like, write up a whole paragraph and explain exactly what they wanted to, like, let them know. And, you know, a big thing just to, like, ask, I don't know, when something is due or if they have a test next class or anything like that.

So we felt that platforms like Google Chat or other things like that were informal ways that people were able to communicate in the past and things like that would be, like, very well to implement in the future. So, like, things like ReachMyTeach or even, like, some kind of announcement channel

where admin can post certain things that are happening within the school around, like, doing advisory or free periods or anything that is important to students to get more information out there of like extracurricular activities or things that are happening within the school. So it creates both informal for students and teachers, but also creates a form of communication

between students and admin as well. We also notice that students feel a disconnect across individual teacher policies. So this happens between different classrooms and things like that, especially talking about like the phone use in classes. I feel like the varying policies kind of creates like different

20:47

intentions for students when in a certain class period or anything like that. So we are currently exploring individual classrooms and trying to collaborate with teachers to kind of figure out an idea of like uniform policy that might work for every teacher so that students don't feel like

different about certain class periods and can like focus when needed but also have like a way of informal uh like communication or informal like connection with teachers so in addition to um finding disconnect between students and their teachers we found that there was also students

feel um a disconnect between them and admin so we found that students feel that their opinions are not taken into account um by admin and the decisions they make and we kind of found that this causes a cycle of students not wanting to share their opinions because they feel like

um even if they share them they won't be taken into account and um things won't be changed by admin so in order to kind of break this cycle we um kind of like everyone else talked about are trying to implement other action steps that will help students' voices be heard

and create tangible change. And additionally, we found that students are also unaware of how decisions and changes are being made and where to voice their opinions. So students don't really have an understanding of what decisions come from the state or from individual teachers or from you guys.

And we found that if we create a way to share where those decisions are coming from, then students will have a better idea and it will positively impact school culture. So something new we did this year was we hosted teacher conversations in addition to student conversations to kind of broaden our body of people we are hearing voices from.

So we found in these teacher conversations that staff expressed experiences of varying department and admin policies and a lack of connection between staff. And we found that staff had varying experiences with policy and student responses.

And a possible action step we found was while student leadership primarily focuses on students, we're also trying to gather these teacher voices and do similar steps we do with student conversations to implement action steps that will help teacher communication as well.

And this will be kind of done outside of student action to not take away from what we do with student connection, but we will try and find a time to focus on these teacher conversations to see what we can do with them and what we can find and if this is something we will continue to do.

I'm sorry, excuse me for a second. So, I guess, like, the big thing about, like, that we're trying to answer is, like, why does this all matter? And so, like, a big thing we've been trying to focus on, like, as people have earlier mentioned,

is that, like, there's really a big disconnect between, like, what students are feeling and what's actually happening, where students feel so, like, their decision, as Manny said before, like, isn't being heard or taken into account.

And so, like, we really, and so then that means that they're not going to share their voices. And like this year, we kind of really struggled with getting students to participate as it feels as though nothing's going to happen, nothing's going to change.

And so then when these changes don't happen, then it really reinforces the idea that like talking to us or really like trying to see if anything will change is like not going to be an option. And so we're like, you notice that this is really like a self-feeding cycle. And we're really trying to like kind of cut that like the snake off the head, I guess, and really trying to show that like students' voices really matter.

and how, like, there's really, I guess the really big thing is that there might be a gap, like, the gap will widen, and how students will feel as though, like, I guess might resent admin, and so we're really hoping that, like, any actions that might, like, I guess widen the gap will be, like, taken more into consideration, and I guess really the big thing is trying to figure out how we can, like, make sure students' voices are being heard, as I believe that, like, as you guys are really trying to hear from student voices,

25:57

but I guess sometimes when students might not share how they're feeling it's really hard to gauge whether or not the decisions are the right decisions or whether or not they're working correctly or as intended and so that's really a big thing is trying to I guess really root out

the negative emotions that students are feeling and really trying to like create those action steps that students can feel empowered by and I guess like the next steps um right now I guess like as everyone has said we're really on the action step and so we're really trying to figure

out like how can we truly express that students voices are really being heard because they are being heard but students a lot of students have expressed that there's no tangible effect and so we really want to figure out how their voices are being heard and that they really do matter to us

in the school and thank you for your time any questions for the team yeah thank you so much that was really interesting and I just very much respect the work that you put into this I learned a lot. One of my questions was around the finding of, with students, that they felt a

lack of informal communication options, which I thought was, yeah, really interesting and noteworthy. I'm wondering, you know, I think with the cell phone ban, one of the things I've been thinking about is that's such a huge communication tool for everyone, but particularly high schoolers.

And so with the ban going into effect, like, I personally feel like we need to do something else around strengthening informal communication while at school. And just because we're taking away something that, you know, you're used to using for socializing, talking with your friends and all the things you do.

So I'm just wondering, you mentioned using physical spaces as a possible solution, and is there anything you feel as if the board could help with or support with in terms of utilizing a physical space in a better way to have students be able to have that socialization time?

Well, um, I mean, I think you guys are, like, doing a pretty good job. I mean, uh, let's see. How would I answer this? I guess it's, like, I think we already have, like, the available spaces, but it's really trying to figure out, like, how can we safely use the spaces,

as, like, a lot of students sometimes, there's always those couple students who are, like, ruining the experience for everyone else. So it's, like, the FPAC lobby, usually it's, like, it used to be a fun space to be around, but usually students can't be. So I think it's just, like, figure out, like, how can we provide safe places for students,

but also, like, giving them the freedom that a lot of students want to have. And so I think it's really just more like a school thing that kind of needs to be, I guess, teachers and students really need to tackle, because I think we already have the space to do it.

Just thinking about space, when you were talking about the spaces, one of the priorities, when the high school was renovated six years ago now, I guess, um, was to create some, some of those spaces. And then I know when COVID came, we kind of had to

close off a lot of those spaces because you weren't allowed to informally congregate. Um, curious if those, this might not be a question for you, but more for Jen, whether those spaces have reopened to students. I mean, cause that was, that was kind of a design

perk that I'm not sure we ever fully got to, um, take advantage of before they kind of got shut though? Um, yeah, that's a really great question. Uh, I'm someone that definitely, uh, like, uses those spaces throughout my day, I would say. Um, I come to the library a lot, but one thing I do

notice is, like, because we also have the orange passes, and I feel like teachers are definitely a lot more strict about leaving class, or, like, not even leaving class, just, like, using their free time either study halls to go um and there are also like uh like the science wing there's some

tables out there uh I like I've definitely asked to go out there sometimes and teachers will just like be like no I can't allow you to do that not because they don't want me to be or like other students to be able to do that but like it's kind of hard because it's hard to have those spaces

when there's not, um, like, supervision, and they definitely, like, always want students to have a teacher around. So I guess having that is hard, and also having teachers to, like, watch over those students. So I definitely like to see, like, more of those spaces be open to students, and, like,

31:15

trust that they can be productive and use them well, I guess. And you did a great job. She basically answered for me. I think one thing that I just wanted to know, and I also just want to share how proud I am of the students behind me and what an incredible job that we've done. Some of them have

been on the team for three years, four years, and they've just done outstanding work and have really changed the way that we listen to students and engage students in conversations. I think one thing that's a challenge for me, which we actually want to get to talk about a little bit, is sometimes

the conflict between students perspective and parents perspective because the last time that we did a survey we had an exorbitant amount of parent feedback saying that they wanted tighter protocols more safety in hallways more supervision questions about the bathrooms for those of you

who have been on the board you've learned how many years we've talked about bathrooms this year we have not because we have hall monitors and we have digital passes and when you go into a bathroom it's something I would love to get some feedback from students generally there's not a

lot of people in there and there's still issues there but so there are some places as Michelle mentioned the innovation was actually nine years ago which is crazy so there's some places like It's like, it was formerly known as the 700 wing, which is the social studies wing.

There's like a kind of alcove of windows. We don't have any supervision there, and we're really struggling. Our custodians were struggling because students were there, and they were not listening, and the custodians were asking them to leave. The FPEC lobby is a wonderful space. We don't have any supervision there. So it's this balance. What we will start to talk about is what are some solutions to that.

We have the ability to go outside for OpenTrack and OpenGym because we've set up supervision every day. So are there some possibilities for teachers to volunteer to supervise some of these spaces, such as during, it would be a little bit hard during the classrooms, but during advisory.

We have this wall right behind you is the Zen Room. We struggle a little bit to have that supervised, but we moved it here so it would be connected to the library. and though it's under been under utilized so I think we can get more

creative but it is a factor for us to balance those two things how do we maintain supervision and safety but allow students to feel like they have some flexibility we did have some questions this year about open campus I

think the students behind me would say that that's a very important part of our culture for students to have 11th and 12th graders if they have demonstrated they're successful academically that they can have open campus and then they

have the option of where they're spending their time they still cannot hang out in unsupervised locations in school so it's it's some of those things that we have to manage competing priorities but I definitely think their

research this year has made us think a lot more about instead of just saying we can't do this how do we think about are there some ways that we can do this oh michelle i just want to echo thank you um and also um i found the i guess disaffected youth

portion really relatable as a former disaffected youth myself um i i think when you see people in their middle age it's hard to think about them as also having been teenagers at one point um and so i i really relate to them the students as as a whole of feeling unheard um i would like

to potentially give some fodder for that as is i know that i personally swayed to be more liberal with our cell phone policy after hearing from the students after maria went to this rsu one after we discussed those pouches and said maybe we don't need them after all. So I would point to that as a voice being heard for the student body to know that their voices were heard,

that we asked and were answered. That it's not always a losing situation. And that it's worth at least saying something because you could affect change. And that's a hard example of, but not hard, like, unfortunate, hard like concrete example of it worked. So I think it's a lot easier to understand and relate

36:27

to those times when you've created change when you see it happen. And so I would encourage you to share that back to the students. I think that's something that we're that we really want to work on. Like that was something that we mentioned in our presentation about like students aren't aware

of how this is happening. Like I didn't know that until you just said that just now. So like I think that that's something that we want to work on in this whole theme of communication is like what are the students doing like saying that students did come to the board meeting the board

did listen to them and here's what came out of it I think having some kind of outline or something like that that students know what happened with what they said would be really helpful so thank right another thing is like i feel like students are so busy nowadays i can't lift this up um it's

hard to like watch the board meetings i would say they're all usually like about an hour long and i have to like hold this thing um they're very oh my gosh i can't get this okay um yeah they're pretty long, and even, like, 30 minutes out of the day feels like a lot for, I would say, like,

busier students, like, all of these people here, like, are in so many clubs, so many sports and stuff, like, I don't think we really have time to, like, watch very long, like, reviews, so I guess definitely some kind of, um, like, anything online, like, maybe building a better website would be

super helpful to have or like any type of platform where students can just look and like see um like decisions that admin are making or like just so it's easier to access and it was perfect that you were here when we were talking about this before the meeting today during the q a was like you know you're not alone in the desire for more information but without a ton of time to go

digging and looking for it. So it is always a, it's a never-ending battle on how do we share the right information, the right amount, how do we get it out to people, for the people who are interested in it, and even the ones who aren't, because they probably should be interested in it.

It's, just know you're not alone in that, in that, in that struggle, and we are always trying to find new ways to do that, and we are always open to, you know, any suggestions or feedback you guys have on you know what's a great way to reach you you know is it you know is it social media is it the

website is it you know pop-ups somewhere i don't know um but it's it's always a challenge um even for board members to stay involved and the idea of closing that loop around you know we said something and did anything happen with that for me the thing that resonated with me was the piece

at the end there where you said you know we don't always know the reasoning for the decisions right So we might have an opinion, we might have shared that opinion, but we don't know that, hey, this came down from the state, and there's nothing really anyone can do about that.

But if you didn't know that, you might think, well, I said it, and they didn't care. So I thought it was really thoughtful that you guys recognized that there's a lot of competing things that are at play, and the more we can share that.

And I think that's one of the things about the cell phone policy that we really wanted to, to, to make a big piece of it other than just, you know, it's, you know, off and away during the school day is, is the why, like, what's the research? What's the impact? What are we, what are we trying to, you know, what change are we trying to affect other than making your lives harder? Because that's not the goal. So I really appreciated that that was one of your, one of your goals was to try and see the full picture.

sorry kelly yeah i think uh you you you reached a lot of my points already but i think that what i'm hearing is there's sometimes there's a disconnect between the intent and the impact and how it's received and i'm just thinking um from the administrator's point of view and

even from a board point of view like what can we be doing to to make the receive this information the impact received in a way that you feel heard. And so obviously explaining things so that we understand reasoning is really important.

And so I'm sort of curious to hear from the admin side of things how you feel like you're already trying to address some of these concerns. You mean how are we trying to address this communication gap? Are you talking about specifically policy? Not one specific policy, but just in general, obviously trying to help people understand

And when we make a different decision than the one that you might have wanted for us to make for you, how do we sort of help people understand that we are listening and we're trying to include your voice in our decision-making?

41:38

It's a great question. As our team, I don't think we've talked a lot about how could the board do that. We've really thought about at our school level. So I appreciate Valerie's example. I think something recently that just happened, I shared with the board, or sorry, the student

reps shared with the board when we were talking about what information for the updates was that the week before April break, we had a workshop for students with a group called Prevention Action Change, and then we had a workshop for teachers. And the workshop for the students was with student advisory leaders and student council

members and class officers our wonderful team had missed too many classes so they were respectfully asked not to participate in this class for that workshop because they were working on this data and some other things and so those students what and i think that this is something that comes

directly from you know these students get a lot of time with me too and i do a lot of listening of this team. I'm their note taker when they're reading their meetings and helping them with whatever they're working on. But this past Monday, I asked all of the students who participated in

the workshop to come back and meet again during advisory just to share their feedback on the workshop. And I was very clear with them that later that afternoon, I had a meeting with a faculty team and their input was going to that faculty team to decide what we do next. And I think

you quickly see a response from kids. They were much more engaged in that feedback. There was a Google survey and then a discussion in small groups because they knew exactly where that feedback was going. And I think a lot of times we as adults decide what the assemblies are.

And so an outcome of that workshop might be that the students say, we need an engaging workshop where students know why we're doing this, why is it important to be an active bystander, and the whole school is participating. That's just not something we've done. We've really done a lot of adults driving the planning of those things.

Our student advisory leaders plan what we do in our advisory workshops or individual advisory activities. But so I think to your question, we're trying to say in really concrete ways that this is how we heard you and this is what we're doing.

I think our beloved students have been very clear with me that they really read my emails. This team does. But so I know that that's not the most effective way. We've struggled with, I certainly hear the pros of Google Chat,

and you can imagine that that was disabled because there were a lot of cons to using Google Chat during the day. And so I think we're really trying to see how can our students understand these tangible impacts that they have.

One of the things that this team has worked on, which I think has gone well, is for them to share out with students, here's what we're doing with what we heard, and then for me to be doing that, and then to find ways for decisions that come from the superintendent or come from the board.

How do we get those out in a way that makes sense and that students will read it and hear it and know that? And I think this team, whoever is the members of this team next year and the rest of this year, can help with what's the format for that. They communicate very differently. So just to follow up with that on decisions like the cell phone policy, where we did hear a lot of impact from students, but the board ultimately decided to go in a different direction, I can see why that would come across as us not listening to student voice.

Is there, even if it's in an email that they don't read, is there feedback coming from the admin side to sort of try and explain rationale? i think that we are constantly trying to do that and but again this kind of tangible piece

is that we've opened it up to the whole school for all three grade levels who are staying we didn't our beloved seniors are about to leave us so we didn't include them but that any student can join the cell phone committee and hopefully we're getting out the word that we don't have a process

that we're trying to convince them of they're going to be a part of designing the process that falls underneath the granders that have been set by the board and by the state. And I think what we then need to figure out, it has become very clear through my work with

this team that student leaders have direct access to me. These team members had me in a van for five hours as we drove to MAT and they can ask me anything they want. And it's finding out ways for other students who are not student leaders, who don't feel

46:44

like they can just come into my office and say something or talk to me at lunch about a question that they have that's not immediately related to whatever we're doing that day. And I think trying to find venues for that is going to be really important. And how do you get the message

across that because we didn't agree doesn't mean we don't hear each other. And I think that we're constantly working on. We work on it as adults too. That's great to hear. Thank you. First, I just want to say, excellent job. You are all leaders, and you're showing what true

leadership looks like, so thank you for that. I was reflecting earlier before today's meeting on how we can better let the community know that we hear them, and so this is timely. This is very related to the idea of making sure people know that you are listening, because we get a lot of

input we have received a lot of input this year and I know that we all very carefully weigh that input but we don't communicate that very well I think we probably could do a better job of helping them feel heard and that will

certainly be an important thing to consider over the next year to the next six months to a year is making sure that even if we're not making decisions that that are what folks in our community want us to make, we have very carefully weighed their input.

So thanks for allowing us to have more of that conversation tonight. Our group leader talks about this a lot, but she isn't here tonight. But we were talking about how we feel like our senior class this year is really well-connected. Like we have a group chat on Snapchat of every single person in the senior class

um where there we send out like our class president sends out stuff about events that are happening for seniors um anything that like seniors need to attend like senior fees anything that needs to happen um we also have like a student council instagram page that has been

really helpful um and in the past we've had quite a few like problems with social media and like people being rude on social media but I feel like this year it's been a lot better um I I'm not if someone else wants to talk about why I'm not entirely sure why that happened I think but um

but um I feel like it was a like noticing that we had a good way of communicating with everyone and having kind of that connection between every single student was really helpful in, like, getting things across and could be a place of inspiration for grades to come in, just like the school culture in general. Yeah, I think you guys, I mean, you guys have taken on a lot.

I mean, you're like, oh, it's just communication and connection. That's everything, right? Like, so much of what makes a school, like, a place you want to be is that communication and that connection. And you guys are tackling it from all sorts of different angles, which is highly commendable and super impressive.

And I mean, not only, you know, the student to student and student to teacher and admin to student, like you're trying to help the teachers connect with each other. I mean, hugely aspirational. So every time you guys present, I'm always highly impressed.

And today was no exception. And please tell Phoebe that we expected her here this evening. She promised us she would be back for this. That's why we let her get off the board. I'm just teasing, but thank you guys very much. This was great. I just want to add something, too. They might have something to say before we walk away. I just wanted to remind the board that we are incredibly grateful for the board's support

because our budget has included funds to work with Jennifer Chase, who has joined us at some previous board meetings. She leads the Source School and she's connected to Cortico and the Center for Collaborative Communication at MIT. We had the opportunity to go to MIT again this year

so and it's incredibly inspiring for us to be there but also the fact that we are the first high school that connected with the Center for collaborative communication at MIT and so we are able to continue that work the way that they

52:02

code the data and the platform that they use is supported by MIT we are able to connect with some of the graduate students who do their research there they've worked with our students we actually were able to hear some of the

graduate project presentations when we were at MIT and so just wanted to remind the board that we have had financial support to do that and are very very grateful and Jennifer's support for us has been outstanding I wanted to say one final thing kind of to your previous point about like how we're taking on like a really big topic and I think one big thing that we kind of realized this

year that's kind of shaping how we look at things going forward is kind of we can't fix anything else until we fix this. We've taken on definitely different topics throughout the past years but they've always kind of tied back to this general students aren't being don't feel like they're

being heard and that's changing how they interact with us and how they interact with admin and everything and definitely we need to address this general topic before we can fix other things. thank you. All right. You guys good? Well done. Thank you, guys. Okay. So, I believe we are moving

on to item 12. Yes? Our weighted values. Indeed we are. Workshop. Okay. Well, hi, everybody. Okay. So, the students have done a great job sharing their perspective, and now it's your turn. So, I want to just share a little bit about what you have in front of you, what has gone out to

the public. This is an exercise that I adapted from several exercises that I used to use when I was a teacher. And the original genesis of it was decades ago when, as I think I've mentioned at a certain point in time, I, very early in my career, we had an empowerment initiative at Camden

Hills High School where I was teaching. And I was sent along with another colleague to become a certified ethics trainer, and then to work with both students and faculty around framing conversations around ethical values. And a large part of how you then get from identifying values

to decisions based upon them is to figure out how to contend with values that come into conflict with each other. So that's how I'm hoping that this conversation will be framed. So all of this is in your notes, but for the benefit of those listening. This is so

that the board has an opportunity. Actually, let me take that back. This is for the public to have an opportunity to hear the board process this weighty conversation and whole set of issues that came to the fore when I presented options back in

February. As it states in your packet, this is a discussion about values. You're not voting on anything tonight. This is not a decision about anything. It's a chance to share your thinking, hear the thinking of others, and perhaps true conversation allow your thinking to change over time. Anything anybody expresses

is legitimate. The goal is to understand each other and to more deeply understand yourself. And if I think about something, if I paraphrase Socrates, you are both, you are all true disagreement partners in reaching the truth. So this is not intended

to be an adversarial conversation. So when we get to the share-out point, please listen to each other without responding and then discussion will come after that. Please speak for yourself. You are elected officials representing constituents, but this is really

a time when you are presenting as you. And remember that it's a public meeting and we're all on camera and it's all going down for posterity. So you have a worksheet in front of you. So where this starts is with some silence.

And maybe you've already done this, a dry run of this on your own since you've had the materials ahead of time. But I'm going to ask you, even if you have done a dry run, to go through it again. I don't know that it needs to take a ton of time, but this is for you to look at the priorities that

57:09

are listed, but also to identify any that you feel are missing, and to weight them, and then to identify your top three. I hope the instructions are clear. So before we go through, before we begin that, are there clarifying questions about how we want to handle this? So I guess, and I don't

know if my questions about the weighting are similar to our public comment earlier, but is there any target? Like, we shouldn't make them all fours, presumably, right? Or we shouldn't make them all what? There's no prescribed how many fours, how many three. Like, should we try to

evenly distribute things? Because if everything's important, then... I don't think I can answer that for you, but I would say the point is these are competing values, and often they don't fit easily into the same space. So it's to really get you to recognize what comes up against what, as you

could consider the decision in front of you. Okay. So you can all read, and this has all gone out to the public in the board packet, but just because some people out there listening may not have that in front of them. So the ratings that the board members would be using are, to list something as

a one is a relevant priority, but it's a low priority in this decision. A two is moderately important. I want it considered. Three is very important, should be weighed heavily. And four is essential, I would be reluctant to support a decision that compromised this value. And then

the values that are already enumerated here are student educational equity, quality of educational programming, early childhood investment, middle school experience, community and town identity, financial sustainability, operational efficiency, minimizing disruption to families,

equitable distribution of change, and long-term enrollment sustainability. So that's, oh sorry, there's a couple more. Staff and professional community and transparency and community trust. And then there's space for board members to add

their own. So as you can already tell, there are lots of factors to weigh in this decision. So what I'm going to ask you to do now, if you wouldn't mind, board members, is to take Take some time. I've allocated 12 minutes. Let's check in after 12 minutes. I think that if I were advising you, I would advise a class.

Don't overthink them, because if you overthink them, you may actually disrupt your thinking. So just go through it. Rate them how you rate them. You're not going to be bound to this forever, but it's a starting point for you to think

and to talk. So I've got 7.33 on my clock right now. Let's go 10-ish minutes, and I will check in. And I know that the instructions I put here said maybe I'd play Peaceful Muzak or something in the background. I will refrain from doing that, although I will tell you that if I were in my history classroom, I would either be using a soundtrack on YouTube called Scottish Morse,

or I might be using Skyrim background music, which is really, really good for thinking. But, I mean, I've got my laptop. Tom, do you have a preference of which one we fill out that you're going to take, the blue or the white?

It doesn't matter. I just wanted to make sure you had a copy there in case you left one at home. We actually had that conversation for our evaluation system. I mean, you can do a .5 if you want. How's five more minutes? We'll wrap this up in just a minute or two.

1:14:27

Okay, so where I'm hoping you'll be at the end of your individual reflection time is that you'll have gone through and ranked or weighted each value with a one to four, and then you'll put a check next to the three that are your most important. And that's what we're going to go around and ask about what your three most important ones are and what weight you gave them. And then there's reflection questions,

which I hope you've had a little time to think about, and those will be what frame the discussion. And let's just go from there. So I'm going to start to my left, if you wouldn't mind. And Valerie, if you would just share, which are the three values that were your top three, and how did you rank each of them? Sure. So the three that I ranked top were 2, 8, and 11, and I did...

Can you name those for me? Yes. So Quality of Educational Programming. I also wrote an addendum to this one. I hope that's okay. Couldn't help myself. I wrote, this also includes appropriate and sufficient accommodations for students with IEPs and specialized learning needs.

Because that wasn't specifically called out, and I thought it was worth doing, besides NTSS, which I didn't think was sufficient. I really wanted to call that particular piece out. And then eight is minimizing disruption to families.

I also gave that a four. We have a broad spectrum in our district of affluent folks and less so. And so I feel like this is a different framing of equity that I support. And then my last one is staff and professional community, which I also gave a four.

Okay, thank you. Anna? I had a very hard time. At first, I seemed like my top three values were one, two, and three. student educational equity, quality of educational programming, and early childhood investment. But then I realized that all of those things that I value so highly are not possible

without value six, which is financial sustainability. So for that reason, that is my number one. And then my number two is quality of educational programming. Like Val, I had a little addendum that all communities feel the overall depth, richness, and rigor of what RSU 5 offers students.

And I very much like that NTSS was included there. And then for number three, the early childhood investment. I just really think that our communities would benefit so much, both working parents, parents in general. and biggest yet is the little people getting them to full day pre-k earlier um could just be a game

changer did you give them all fours i did how did you know yes check thank you thank you chris um it's it's hard not to give all of these all fours so you have to prioritize because like i think you said is if you don't prioritize any of them you don't prioritize anything yeah my um my ranking

was two for quality of education um i feel like that's kind of the reason we're here um but i think that's an incredibly important thing um and then 12 which is transparency and community trust i think that the the people who are paying our bills and the people who are serving is important to be

transparent and um and open with those people and then so my third one i i struggled quite a lot but I put community and town identity number five, and I think that understanding that the communities use their schools differently and how those schools are connected to that community is

really important, and they're all fours. All fours, thank you. Okay, Malik. All right, so my first run through this, I gave everything fours. I gave everything top of the list, and I did have to go through many, I mean, I worked

1:19:32

on this at home, I had to go through many times, and I used my pencil because I kept racing and revaluing but where I ended up is number one student educational equity I think it is essential that all of our students have an equitable

education regardless of what school they are in and I give that a four and on my second was number two quality of educational programming that should be top a list for our students. Education is the most important thing we do. So that was in my top

three. And then I'm going to quote Anna. My third was financial sustainability because we can't do any of this work without that. And that was four as well. Thank you. Michelle? I limited myself to one four. So my top one was number two, quality of educational programming. I think at the end of

date so my number one was my top choice was number two quality of educational programming I gave that a four I think that is the core of everything that we do hard stop and then my other my other two to fill out my top three were number

one student educational equity I think that's incumbent upon us to make sure that we are consistent and equitable in all the ways that looks across the district. And for my third was financial sustainability, very similar to Anna. Without that, I can prioritize everything, but if we don't have sustainability, we're going to have to make choices we don't want to have to make. So I think that always needs to be at the top. How did you weight them, Michelle? I gave, number two was a four, and the other two were threes. Thank you. Kelly? Yeah, similar to everybody that I've heard from so far, my number one was the quality of educational programming for all of the same reason. That is our product. That's what we're here for. We want to make sure our students get the very best educational experience that they can. So I did give that a four. My number two was financial sustainability. Just because we can't pay the bills if we can't over the long term

keep our taxes reasonable. It's going to be really difficult to keep operating and keeping all of our neighbors happy, so that's really important, especially, I think, as we go into the future and we know that costs are going to continue to rise, we're going to have to make some hard decisions.

And then finally, I really struggled with number three, but considering all of the conversations we've heard from the public recently and some of the concerns from certain communities, I really felt like number 12, transparency and community trust should be in our top three.

Because in the end, we're all neighbors and we want to all get along and we want this to be a joyous experience for our families and our students and it's difficult to do that if we don't trust each other. How did you... I ranked all of them four. Okay. Yeah. thank you okay yes this was very difficult and hard not to give them a

force and I actually have kind of a question because my first one is number two quality of educational programming I think that is why we are here however this the student educational equity to me isn't that built into the quality

programming, you would think. I think they're kind of one and the same, so I kind of feel like we should just lump those together as one. That's my feeling. So that was my first one. Did you give a four? Yes, I did. Both of those. She's trying to find a way to have four. I am. I am. And my second one

was the transparency and community trust I do feel like I mean we are all part of our community sitting up here we do know what it's like to not sit up here I think you know that we are at RSU 5 so we are together and I do feel that is very important and I gave that a four thank you very

Yep, and then my, can I do a third one? Sure. I have done a lot of thinking about what has been proposed and listening to and reading emails of the community, and I feel that my third one will be equitable distribution of change,

1:24:40

and I gave that a three. Thank you. Tara? I have a tie. my my first one though is number six financial sustainability for the same reasons folks have already said it's the foundation we it's a prerequisite really to anything else that we want to do so that was my first and then I gave

that a four. My second one was quality of educational programming. And I also gave that a four. And I just remembered, I have a question about number 11, staff and professional community. I'm not sure if this includes staff voice and experience, or if that would be another

category because i i or if that is part of the community trust but i feel like how do we value our teachers is uh is something that we might want to add and i'm not sure how i would rate that so that could be part of our discussion maybe yeah um so my my tie for third place um is student

Educational Equity, unless we can combine that with the quality programming, right? And the Transparency and Community Trust. I think that is, I value that significantly as well. So those both got, actually, when I rated, number one, Student Educational Equity got four, and the

Transparency and Community Trust got three. So it sounds like Student Educational Equity, and I don't You have to bring out the thumb screws to make you decide. Boo. I guess for the first, I chose number two for quality of educational programming.

I guess I thought the quality of what, I guess, education students are getting is kind of very important. And I guess it's something that we talk about a lot. So I gave that a four. And then I guess for number two, I guess for my second one, I chose number six, financial stability.

So I guess really to, like, as everyone has said, I guess, like, we can't really do any of this without, like, money and whatnot. And then I guess I chose number 12 about transparency and community trust. And I guess I gave that, like, a three. And I guess I did that because I feel like everyone should have, like, I guess opinion should feel, like, valued.

and I guess for, like, more conversations to be done, and I guess for, like, decisions to be made, I guess everyone has to feel as though, like, they can contribute and, I guess, feel respected, I guess. Moon, what ranking did you give financial sustainability,

or what weighting did you give it? I gave it a three. Okay, thank you. Steph? I'm going to try not to break the rules. My top value was student educational equity. And if everyone doesn't have equitable access, it's not high quality, in my opinion.

So that's why that's my number one. I ranked it a four. My second is quality of educational programming. I ranked it a four also. And then my third value was staff and professional community, because I don't feel we can execute

quality without that. And I ranked that a three and a half. So I broke one small rule. That's okay. Lois? So for me, I think I took a little bit different perspective on this. No. Imagine. Because since I've been on the board in February,

that topic has been panel. And what I've been talking to people about is, imagine if it was the Durham Community School that was closing. You'd be up in arms. Imagine if it was Moore Street that was closing, and we were shipping all those kids someplace else. So that's my perspective, and because of that,

1:29:45

my number one was number 12, which is transparency and community trust, because I think we have to be talking about what the possibilities are. Did you give it a four? Yes, all three of mine got a four. Number two was community and town identity, because particularly, well, it's Freeport too,

because I lived in Freeport for a while. The schools are the primary identity, in my opinion, of the towns. Durham has the get-and-go, and we have the school. Poundell has the corner store, which I'm not sure... Shortstop. And the school. And the people hang out, I don't know about Poundell,

but the people hang out in the Durham get-and-go and have their coffee every morning and that's it and so to me community and town identity is the school and then my third one is long-term enrollment sustainability because although today we might have more kids than we did I don't know five years ago I've

looked at that population in five years we might not and we might not partially because of the decisions we make tonight. Okay. But no decisions tonight. Not tonight. No. In the next few months. Sorry. So if I just sort of take stock of what I've heard so far, I don't have averages tabulated

here, but the value that got the most dings was quality of educational programming. That emerges as a clear number one. Number two is financial sustainability with six of you. A close second to that, though, is student educational equity. There are four. And then last, actually, the second

one is transparency and community trust with five of you. So, and then the others are scattered around the other indicators listed. So, what didn't get any votes or any mentions in the top three, anyone's top three, was the middle school experience, operational efficiency. That's it.

those two got no mentions, and nobody added any additional values at this time, although that was an option, and it still is an option going forward. We may even do this again if you feel this is useful when it's all done. So now it's time to just talk about this freely. So if you kind of

look at your prompter here, your instructions, I'll get it started, but this is really intended to just be somewhat free-flowing and then between kelly and me we're going to try to discern themes that that emerge when you talk about this and then we'll reflect those back to you so any surprises

anybody want to jump off of that is anybody surprised by something they heard or felt or observed when you went through this exercise someone say something that i know will be unpopular Actually, a procedural thing. Go on. I'd like to frame this as I likely would have a student discussion,

which is, Valerie is bravely going first. If you'd like to speak after Valerie, please raise your hand, and Valerie will choose her successor, and so on. And I may only jump in if I notice that somebody's been trying to break in

and just doesn't get called on. So, when I speak as myself, not as board member Valerie, but as person Valerie, I grew up in a community in Maine. I grew up in Oxford Hills. My elementary school was a combined elementary

school for two towns. So, if I'm being extremely honest, I actually don't understand the uproar for Pauno, and I have to keep being mindful of it, because I do respect all of the residents in and i respect their feelings and their outcry i don't relate to it um which is a struggle for me

1:34:51

um because we had two towns that shared a school my entire childhood i believe it still is occurring um and i don't think my education was worse for it uh it increased my community i had friends in both towns from a very young age um so while i don't i don't want to double negative here

So while I do value it, I don't relate to it. And I think that's why it scored as low as it did for me, because I don't relate to it. That doesn't mean that I think anything less of the panel residents that feel so strongly.

I hear them, and I am considering their feelings. But I confess that my rating is biased because of my personal experience of having gone to a community school that was multi-town and not feeling negative for it. It feels like a good time to share, unless I'm going out of order, the value I felt was missing.

I typed, and so I'll read because it's easier for my system. I said, a value I feel is missing is RSU-5 identity in community. And I believe we're missing an opportunity to view community in a broader, more robust and strength-based way.

And when I think of how we as a collective community could come together and view that as a unified, integrated, connected group of people who really care about the education of our students, I start to get really excited and hopeful and interested,

and I wonder what's possible. And so I think that that's a value that I'd like to see considered. It didn't rise to the top three for me, because I think there's others that are more important, but I think it's something that could be really helpful to start discussing as well. It's not a community identity that we've been discussing at all very much.

Yeah, I just wanted to talk about the two values that didn't get chosen at all. I almost feel like that maybe part of the reason for that is that, in my mind, they sort of fall underneath a couple of the categories that did rise to the top.

For example, operational efficiency. I see that as part of financial sustainability, so I definitely want to make sure that that's captured, even though nobody mentioned it as one of their top three. I do think it does fall under that other category, and we definitely should be thinking about that. And then the middle school experience, similarly, I see that as part of the student educational equity.

It kind of is a subcategory of that. So I just want to make sure that we are still recognizing that those are being captured maybe in our minds under these other categories that did rise to the top. I want to touch upon something that Valerie said and something that Stephanie said. I really appreciate how you framed that you value something,

but you don't relate to it. And with that one in particular, I think it was the identity piece. Maybe that's not actually the one that I'm thinking of. The disrupt, the disrupt, minimizing disruptions piece. I can, I feel like I can relate, or I have a little more compassion and empathy for the folks who have come

and said that they moved a panel for the school. And that has been really hard to hear and think about that school not being there for them anymore. It's really, I feel really sad about that. How I valued it in this exercise was rather low.

I actually gave that one a two, the minimizing disruptions to families. And I think that I'm looking at as change is disruptive. And we will find out if change is necessary through the study. But if we are going to be making a change, it can be hard, it can be scary,

it can be seen as something that we need to avoid. But I would love to be able to look at it as, you know, instead of a negative disruption, how can we find it, how can we look at it as a more positive, disruptive change?

1:39:51

And which kind of connects to what you were saying, Stephanie, too, which is how can we, what can we then achieve together as a district? It might look a little bit differently, but how can we then value the district? And what can we achieve together as a result of this change?

How can we lean on one another and support each other throughout? I think that we've heard a strong, strong community from a strong, strong community in Pownall in particular. And I trust that we can, that community, and we as a district community, can get through any change together.

And I want us to be able to look at it that way. Are you looking to jump in, Anna? Well, I was going to say, this is where they teach you in teacher school to just give some awkward wait time for a little bit. So, the floor is yours.

That is a great point, Kara, and it really also ties into what Stephanie was saying about RSU 5 identity and community value and getting excited for that, thinking about it, even if it is a big change. I'm kind of framing it in a different way. Two things that I noticed from

the share out was I felt we were missing a value of staff and professional culture that was pretty different than how I read the value listed in here. Basically that being like teachers and staff want to work for RSU 5. They have good pay, good benefits. They value the parent community and

their input is respected and utilized and they feel like they're working in a culture of joyful learning. That didn't make my top three because of all the others but I definitely thought that should be included. And then I also found it noteworthy that I was the only one that listed

the early childhood investment as the top three. And I was just curious how people were thinking about that. And I think for me, it was also interesting that no one included the middle school experience because I know we've talked a lot about that as part of why we may need to look

at a district reconfiguration to me the the quality of education really got to the middle school experience like it needs to be of high quality and so that kind of took care of the middle school for me the early childhood investment is like a program we don't currently have both

state mandated IEP for three-year-olds but also a yearning for full day pre-k um so yeah just curious other thoughts because I really do want to be open about learning and changing my thinking waiting for you calm calm me so I those were actually

really high on my list and they I felt that they felt both can fell under that equity of education and quality of education which is why they weren't necessarily my top three and I found that with a lot of these values is that

I can almost bucket them but those two specifically I felt like they were actually part of that equity in the quality education piece quality of education piece and I just wanted to go back to what Kelly said about the two

that we didn't mention and I just that I agree with Kelly that they were they were actually really high on my list but not in the top because again I felt like they fell under that the middle school programming just the the equity

of education and operational efficiency really I felt like it was part of that financial sustainability piece it's hard when you give us 13 values only three choices how can I well I think I have to acknowledge to the wind so a power in

doing something like this is that it can it can be a conversation starter and it can be a way for thinking to start coming out but then you run up against the limitation is that the thinking and the problem is so complex that these 13 boxes which are somewhat arbitrary are they can't be

seen as the end point that they're limiting in themselves and so it's just a way to get get it out and then hopefully we go beyond the way it's presented here and kelly yeah i was almost thinking as i was going through this exercise that i wished we had a way to maybe rank more than just the top

1:45:06

three like if we could have captured i don't know five or six of them or something just some of the ones that that do fall lower on the list get captured and we don't lose track of where they do rank in the in the well if it helps with that i'm going to collect all of your everything you wrote

and we're going to tabulate it and i'm going to bring it back to you next time so the full the full results will get shared out and i bet we'll talk about this again i'm sure we will so yeah i i did the same sort of bucketing technique to you know and my top three ended

up being sort of broader topics. But I think part for me, the one I really struggled on was that community and town identity, because I think community identity is potentially different than town identity, and how do those interplay with each other, and sort of how I came down on my

ranking on that, which I gave a two as important to be considered, but not one of the top, is when I think about equity, I think there is a piece of equity in, you know, equity can be a lot of things. It can be the middle school experience, right? It can be access to the pre-K, but it can

also be, you know, the ability to go to school in the town where you live, right? If two of the three have that, but one doesn't, like, is that truly equity? And where do we draw the line on when we're weighing these things on, you know, where does the benefit outweigh the cost or the

potential change. You know, very similar to Kara around the minimizing disruption, that was the only one I actually had as a one, because I think that is a byproduct of any change. And if we're doing it for the right reasons to elevate all of the quality and the equity and the change may be

difficult, but if we feel like it's in the best interest of the district, that's disruption worth having so for me it's important but it's obviously relevant um but it wouldn't it wouldn't keep me from doing what i think was the right decision for the district as a whole so kelly yeah um

we were having another conversation earlier about facilities here in the district and i was thinking about that as i was looking thinking about this community and town identity because we were talking about how much something would cost and what were the what were the you know what is the

cost versus the benefit and you don't know what the savings would be for any of these options yet so it's really difficult i think to to rank it until you know exactly what what it would cost for us to do this or what savings we would have so this is it feels very nebulous at this point

to be making to be having this kind of conversation because it is important but until i know what i would be giving? What would you be gaining? What would you be giving up? It's difficult for me to wait that. Yeah, I hear that. And that's something I consider when thinking of early childhood

investment. It's early childhood education and early childhood development is hugely valuable to me. And I value that highly. But in the context of this exercise, again, I have thought that I would like to see, um, us prioritizing before, I guess, before opening up early childhood outside

of what's being required, what's being asked of us and what is required of us. Um, I would like to see us feel more confident that we're meeting the needs of the other grade levels first. And that's what played into my, um, ranking that one. Can I ask about points of tension? So, um, where

did you find a significant tension between values and how did you contend with that? Is there anyone here who feels comfortable talking about that i mean i think for me it was that that identity question right because i do think i i did try to you know as lois said put myself in the shoes of

like if this was the school next to where i live would i rate that higher um i don't know um so for me that was you know like valerie said i understand it but i i don't necessarily relate directly, but I'm trying to, you know, leave space for that, so for me, that was, that was the hardest

1:50:09

one to, to value, and as it relates to sort of competing priorities, I mean, for me, it's two and six, right? Like, I would love to have every program, every opportunity, every, every, everything for our kids, but there are financial limitations of doing that, so to me, that's always the push

pull of of the tension that we do every year yeah i um i'm surprised like i wanted financial sustainability to be in my top three and i sort of in this exercise disallowed that for myself um because i too know and acknowledge that if we can't afford to do things we can't do anything

um uh so that was attention for me i continually wanted to put it top but sort of um gave myself that restriction particularly knowing what's happening in Maine with budgets and infrastructure and also costs that keep going up and up and up so that was

the point of tension for me early childhood was also a point of tension for me because I think there's like the short term and the long term there I think if we invest heavily in that I think our long-term vision in our long

term experience for students could be substantially improved if we can have earlier interventions and more robust programming earlier which a lot of data to support that perspective so there's tension there for me and then this is

another potentially unpopular perspective that I'll share my own tension with I think we're in this it kind of goes to the RSU 5 identity and community. When it's our job as school board members to support educational experiences and

equitable experiences for all students, when we talk about town identity, there's a lot of tension there. And so I think that that's an inherent in an RSU. And where the tension, I feel the tension in particular is that, especially when I'm holding financial sustainability, I don't know if it's the

RSU's responsibility to maintain town identity, and so that's a really hard, um, it, like, makes me almost want to cry, like, it makes me really sad to say that, knowing and listening to all of the perspectives, um, and how important some of these town schools are to people, um, it's really hard

to say that, and, like, that's why there's tension there, so, um, yeah, because I don't think that it's financially sustainable to, as an RSU, be providing a community resource. It's our responsibility to provide education to all students in our district.

This isn't, I guess, a tension necessarily, but your comment kind of made me think of one of the values that I would have tried to add and then how that kind of incorporates into that. But one of the things that I didn't necessarily see on the list was the, I don't know exactly how to word it, but the support programs that we as a district provide for those most in need.

So things like our life skills program, things like our ESLL program, things that are tangentially related to education, but that, for example, a private school might not provide. And so I think that those things are things that I would have ranked quite,

that I don't feel like necessarily fits into any one of these categories, at least not neatly. And that I would also use as an example of the RSU providing a community program, outside of our community programs. The RSU providing a community asset at a community program,

In addition to providing an educational program that I think is really incredibly important that the RSU continues to provide. So personally, I think that that is the responsibility of what we're doing here is to provide those community places and those community programs that support both those in the bottom as well as those that are doing, you know, doing well in our community, too.

so so that last comment you made actually made me think of uh the public comment at the end of last week where there was a palma community member who um i believe was child free but wanted to participate more in the community and specifically the school and ways that he felt removed or

1:55:33

ignored i think he might have said ignored um by his community and was and wishing that he had been reached out to. So that, I think that makes me think of ways the school district is a community builder, but also if we circle back to Steph's point of we're a community builder as an RSU.

I mean, when I think of growing up, I didn't think of my elementary school. I thought of Oxford Hills. When I say that's where I'm from, I say it's not always my town. I usually say my region, but we don't have that luxury here because our region is the high school, which is Freeport,

which is not Palinol and not Durham, which we have that push and pull happening again where we don't have a unified identity of our three towns. The way Oxford Hills is eight disparate towns. But when you say Oxford Hills, everybody more or less knows what region you're talking about.

Really? Oh, I could list, I mean, obviously list all eight. So I think, I know that's not included here anywhere, but it would be nice if we had a district identity that we could maybe also include somewhere of maybe taking a look at some kind of unifying identity and for lack of a better word identity

that is shorthand besides rsu5 which is clunky to say in a committee meeting we were in recently i i said put in the u and rsu sounds like that's what we need sorry maybe you should have gone with an intro on this jimmy says

yeah it's kind of on the daily but there was a different perspective than what you experienced in oxford hills i grew up in freeport i grew up in south freeport south freeport had its own school where the french school is now

we were then brought at the end of third grade to moore street we did not integrate well we went through school with our small little cliques. When we got to high school, Pownall and Durham joined us. And it was difficult for them. And we made it difficult, quite honestly. There was no

integration of let's all come together. Freeport remained Freeport, Pownall remained Pownall, and Durham remained Durham. And I didn't really pay any attention to it until I became part of Durham. And so I think we need to be careful that we let the towns maintain their schools

and don't artificially put the kids together if we don't have to. On the other hand, and this is something I haven't heard anybody talk about in the time that I've been here, and that is what I've heard is that it might be that there would be a lot, I believe this

is what I heard. There might at some point be a lottery to get kids without IEPs into the programs, and I'm not even going to say the panel school because that's not decided, but into the programs with IEP peers. I have a huge problem with kids with IEPs being segregated if in fact there isn't

the space for non-IEP peers to join. It becomes a special ed school or a special ed child development center, whatever you want to call it. That's a danger, in my opinion. It's also not least restrictive environment. So if it sounds like I'm against doing three-year-olds and four-year-olds,

I'm not against that. I have a master's degree in it. What I'm against is the segregation that comes along with it. In my, it's my opinion that If each town has the opportunity to have a preschool, or better yet, in my opinion, if services are provided to the local child care centers, the kids maintain that local community and still get their services.

2:01:06

I just, I don't want to ever think that it's going to become panels of special ed school. That's not a good picture for me. Thank you for that, Lois. I feel very similar to that. I have a family member who was in a special education classroom,

but within a school that all the peers were there. And I feel very strongly about that too, keeping kids with their peers and not separating and segregating. So thank you for saying that. I feel very similar to that. And I feel like my pensions were around that town identity and the

early childhood investment. And I feel like we could find another way to invest in early childhood IEP, pre-K, and still maintain identity of towns. And I feel it's very important. I've heard so much and just have really thought very long and hard.

And my opinion has been swayed from potentially, yeah, that would be a great idea. And sometimes towns have change. And, you know, like when I went to school, the grades only went up to fifth in our elementary school. And over the summer, they added a sixth grade. So I was the oldest twice. I was in the fifth grade and the sixth grade. So we rocked the school twice, which was great.

you know there are going to be changes within communities and within schools i i think that we need to find a way to not make one town supercharged with change and other towns not so supercharged with change and i feel very strongly about that now yeah come sort of along

those same lines i was thinking about the tension between the student educational equity and equitable distribution of change in the town identity and it's easy for us as board members to sit here and talk about these the tension between these two and some of us have more or

less investment in the question and i just want to kind of keep in mind that there are 11 of us on this board and there's we represent you know we don't necessarily represent um or we do but there are lots of voices out there outside of this board that we need to keep in mind and that's

why this process is going to include listening and an opportunity to hear those voices and get their input and while this is one piece of the process there is definitely going to be ways for the community to also weigh in about these values. If I could say a little bit about

that just that picks up on a thread from the last meeting so there was a public comment at the last meeting toward the end of the meeting about where in this process we're envisioning community input to happen and I did go to panel to

the select board meeting there and amidst a whole crowd of people and assure people that the community engagement strategy would be part of the study and so what we've completed the RFP for the study it's it's been put out

there it's on the school website now it will be posted in Portland Press Herald and the Kennebec Journal on Friday but what we have delineated is there's really two parts to this so what we've asked for is that the study itself when

they conduct it will have community engagement so that they can in formulating their recommendations way community sentiments and then after we get their report we've asked for a deliverable of suggestions for us to continue to pursue community engagement so that we can weigh their recommendations

so I just want to make sure that that's somewhat clarified we have taken the feedback and we've We've tried to make that a robust part of this process. Can I ask, did you say that they will be weighing the community input in their recommendations?

So yes, in the first phase, we've asked them specifically to base their recommendations in part on community feedback. And then we have to consider, put it out to the community what they've recommended. Okay, well we have about reached or exceeded the 70 minutes that we allotted to this.

2:06:23

And 70 minutes sounds like a lot, but I keep coming back to when I was teaching. That's roughly the length of a class period. So we're dismissed? Well, not yet. We have more things to do. So Kelly and I have taken notes.

Kelly's taken a lot. I've taken some. We will go back and try to capture the themes of this conversation and bring them back to you and to the public at the next meeting. And when I say the next meeting, I'm noting in my mind right now,

the next meeting is actually a very short meeting just before the annual budget meeting. It may not be next meeting. It may be a subsequent meeting before the end of this year when it's easy, when it fits into the agenda.

But we will not let too much time lag. But I appreciate your participation in this. And anything that you wrote down at the end of the night before your executive session, I'll collect so that we can do our work with it. Is there a way to make sure Collins is captured as well?

Yes. I'm sure he has some thoughts. Yes. He usually does. Great. Thank you. And thank you for this process. This is certainly, I think, new to any board that I've been on, and I think it was helpful to kind of have a framework and without a decision moving, but just a conversation.

I hope it's helpful now. I mean, right now we're in the abstract. I think it's going to change a lot when you get more from the abstract to the concrete and you're up against the decision point. But my aim is that that will not be a cold decision. It will have been talked about a number of times

and the thinking will have had a chance to shape and evolve. And it's a good opportunity to push back on us if we seem to be moving towards a decision that completely counters what we've said is important to us, like that's a fair question to say like, hey, eight of you said this was really important,

how does this fit into that? And maybe it's we've changed our perspective, but it's a fair question, right? So, yeah. I was just wondering, Tom, if you could comment a little bit on how you envision balancing this discussion with budget, because just my past two years on the board, it seemed

like the budget has just taken over and i mean we've had some pretty contentious budgets the past two years so i just it feels really hard to talk about anything else let alone something as significant as this um so i think that's a great point i think my honest answer at the moment is

i don't know but here's what i hope i really hope that we are set up next year to have a much easier budget conversation i think you did a lot of hard work in the budget that you adopted and and truly the hope is that that means we don't have that hard work later.

I hope we have the study in hand before we get into the budget. I hope we have it by November or December, and then when I'm bringing the budget to you in January, you have had time to chew on this already. Is there ever a time at this board for us to ask a question

that one of the constituents has asked that I can get an answer from, to take it back to them, or maybe they're watching it? Not typically. Yeah, I mean, are we talking about this? This is completely unrelated. No, it's about the reconfiguration. The process? Yeah. I'll ask the question. You can answer it or not. Okay. The question came up, if a child had an IEP for speech,

and the speech recommendation was two times a week, Would the child still be able to get services two times a week if the parent felt that the five-day, full-day, if that's what it ends up being, and I know that's a big question mark still, but let's assume that it's a five-day, full-day child facility.

If the parent only wanted the child to get services for the 30 minutes twice a week, would the services still be available? Would the parent take the child to panel? Would the bus pick up the kid and take the child to panel?

Or whatever it was. Or whatever. Correct. I've got it in my mind that that's. I can answer some of that right now. Okay. I mean, I can't, I can't, there's so many factors that could weigh in upon that. Yep. I can say that if the IEP requires transportation, we would be providing it.

2:11:40

If the transportation is not in the IEP and they needed some kind of, the parents felt they needed some kind of special transportation to and from at times when we're not offering regular transportation, that's not something we would necessarily provide.

And then in terms of, I can tell you how we're offering FAPE next year for the four-year-olds. Our offer of FAPE will be within our pre-case. So in other words, if you want to take us up on our offer of FAPE, which is a fair offer of FAPE, you're in our pre-K.

But I think, like, don't we have students now that, like, go to, say, a private school, but they qualify for those services? I believe that, like, if the parent wants to transport them for their speech twice a week, they can do that, which I think would be similar to what they're asking, yeah?

perhaps, the way I took it was, let's assume it's a four-year-old then, because by the time the program's going, the child probably will be four, even older. But I guess, I think the question was, if there's an IEP and the parent decides to only take advantage of half

an hour two or three times a week to get the speech services that the child needs does that child does the child who takes the part-time services eliminate a spot for a full-time one or it can someone come part-time and get the services they need without impacting a full-time

Those are great questions. I don't want to get too far out of my skis and answering them, but I can tell you what we're envisioning now is that students who we have to serve with IEPs would have dibs, basically, and that any other students would be on a lottery system based on the space that we have available.

And we would not be forcing parents to bring their kids to school for anything that they don't want to access. So they would be able to choose the whole program or only the parts that they want to fulfill the IEP. And because we have to provide that service by state law, we would have to give them a priority spot. Thank you. I think that will answer the question. Okay. All right. So we did not have any new business.

um we do have personnel so does anybody remember do i usually read all these names or do we just do it as a slate do i great do you remember kelly she's like the way that i've seen it done in other districts where i worked is done as a slate so as as attached yes okay great all right so do i have

a motion for consideration and approval to accept the nomination for the following personnel and to authorize the superintendent of schools to issue contracts for the 26-27 school year for both the slate of educators for a second year probationary contract as well as educators

for a continuing contract. Malik and Chris, thank you. Any questions or comments about what this is? So our staff are on a two-year probationary contract year to year and then once they finish their second year they move on to continuing contract so then they don't show up on our

agendas every year going forward um all right no questions all those in favor opposed all right and karen was absent yes she stepped out okay so nine one yeah got it not nine one eight one she makes ten okay all right uh so we're back to public comment we did have folks that hung in

there with us so uh same rules apply if you'd like to speak we ask you come up to the to the Podium, tell us your name, where you live, and three minutes for a comment. I'm Pat Alteri. I'm from Pauno. Proud parent of the RSU 5 students.

2:16:47

Just a couple of observations. First, I want to express my gratitude for the exercise that you just went through. It's hard to do, I have no doubt, and I see the deliberateness and care with which you're approaching this,

and I just really appreciate that. a couple of things that I didn't hear one is sort of I think zoomed into some of the things you did talk about but a value or a consideration I think you ought to have is just certainty and flexibility going forward if the

scenario two takes place or a significant reconfiguration happens you can't unscramble those eggs right and there was talk about like full day pre-k or serving students who maybe are three and four year olds without an IEP in the future. And if those are objectives, would Townell fit as an early education center

for 250 students or some larger group, or would it fit for a full day? And those are considerations that I think are really important. The other observation I'd make, I appreciate the sort of discord and discussion around town and community identity, and I personally put a lot

of value in that. I recognize, just like Valerie observed, I have a lot of bias there. I appreciate the observation of bias. On that point, I would note that it's not just town and community identity. It's very closely tied to student educational quality, right? And I've observed this with my

own kids who are shy and quiet and reserved, and they've blossomed by being a part of a community school, where they look around and see neighbors and parents who they treat basically like parents. And it's a really beautiful and wonderful thing. And I think that's consistent with

everything we know about early childhood development, right? Attachment theory is you start in the home and close, and if you feel safe there, you move a little bit out, and you get to know your neighbors, and you get to know your community, and then gradually you become comfortable the farther and farther out you go right and that's how we currently have our

schools set up and there's a question about middle school and how that will work and and I'm all in favor of finding an equitable solution that ensures that there are medical middle school students adapt well when they come to the high

school I encourage you not to let that get in the way of sort of the early childhood experience. And my last point, I just want to reiterate that for Durham and Freeport students who are three and four-year-olds with IEPs, so are sort of highest need students,

scenario two would involve at least 25 or 30 minutes extra of transportation time every single day right so I just I don't think you should lose sight of how important that factor is 25 or 30 minutes a day for three-year-olds with IEP unstructured on

the bus that can't possibly be what's best for the student thank you Mark again from 196 Merle Road yeah I just wanted to piggyback on what Matt was saying and And I tried to discuss that a little bit at the beginning, and I didn't hear it addressed too much.

But community identity, I mean, for me, I don't have it. I lived in, like, 30 different houses until I was 30 years old. So that's not something that I know or even would know how to value. I tried to point you to the RSU-5 formation documents.

I think that it is important for the board to consider these attendance areas when they're evaluating an option. And it's not necessarily, community identity is one thing that a lot of people do value, and so that should be kind of a sub-criteria under that. But you're talking transportation. So when you buy a house, like, location is, like, the most important value that you put into it and budget.

And so, yeah, you get the conflict. You don't get to live right downtown if that's what you want. You've got to live out in the suburbs because it's cheaper. But location is a super important value for a lot of different reasons.

So being close to your school, pretty important. I just wanted to reiterate that. Thanks, Rick. Hey guys, again, Taylor Steele from Poundell. I was, I think like most of us, so inspired by the students who got up here. it's hard for me to get up here and I'm much older than them um so I was so impressed by them

2:22:02

and I think like we're all doing something really right by these kids right um this community and you guys and our staff and the teachers um I think from if I'm going back months ago and hearing about the integration at the middle school level and the high school level as part of

just this discussion and how do we better do that um there are leaders in these in these communities these kids right and um i think how we can i i was when i was listening to them i was like this is what this is what this is this is they're listening they're talking how they're speaking to the groups

the theater kids the sports the this what about the kids who don't have the that right and who are coming in and getting them involved and i think that there's a really great opportunity be there to involve the students more at the middle school level, at the high school level

as well. And, you know, I have friends across all of the RSU and adjacent towns as well. My kids are involved in sports and they'll continue to do that. And the community, you know, we go to the farmer's market and see people and it's a wonderful thing to say hi

and familiar faces um so it's not for me uh the the the hesitation of like more combining at an earlier age or coming together at an earlier age um but really what what matt was saying and that the early education and keeping the kids you know closer less travel time all of these things that

are disruptive to their days and as their world expands expanding that community um within the school as well. But just that these students at the middle school and high school level, I think there's a real opportunity there to leverage them and their incredible skills and clearly better

public speaking than me. So that's all. Thank you so much. You did a great job, Taylor. But yes, those kids were very, very impressive. So all right. Do we hear from everybody for public comments? All right. Can I say one more? I just want to ask if you would commit to doing this again. I think this is such a

great exercise, and I think it would be really better informed once we have the data, right? I don't think there's much debate that if the study showed that there was like a 15% drop in the budget, if we did, if we reconfigured, we would all probably leave, like, I don't think there

would really be much question there, but I think once the data is there to inform you all, this will be a much more concrete discussion, so I want to encourage you to do it again. Yeah, thank you for that yeah i mean i think that one of the one of the reasons i think it's important to do an activity

like this before you have all that is to like get out there and say like what's important and then when you like i said earlier like if we chose a path that's completely counter to everything we said tonight then it's a fair question to say like well have your values changed or you just

you know when you're when you have a specific opportunity in front of you you just throw all out the window and look at just money, right? You know, not to say that financial sustainability wasn't one of the top ones, but, you know, I think it's helpful to sort of have the conversation

in the abstract first and then put those responses, right? Not that we can't grow and change and whatever over time, but kind of put those up against how we're making our decisions with concrete opportunities in front of us. I think that's really where the value comes. I'm guessing

that's why you had us do this. I mean, that's what I believe. If I keep coming back to the way that I used this as a teacher, I often used it at the beginning of a unit, at the end of a unit. If you're thinking of, okay, I'll choose one, the communism in China. You think about, you put yourself as a student, you put yourself in the position of a rural Chinese person in the 1940s.

What's important to you? And then you learn about what happened, and you think, what's important to you change based on what occurred? And it led to powerful learning and good discussions, and the learning of the historical events was far less important than learning to talk about them and think about why people make the decisions that they make.

I kind of wish you were teaching history here. Well, I just did. It's true. Thank you for that. We all learned something. all right um all right so i will move on to item 16 uh which is do i have a motion for consideration

and approval to enter into executive session as outlined in one mrsa section 4056a for the purpose of discussing the superintendent's evaluation cara and stuff thank you all those in favor not opposed wonderful thank you everybody just a reminder everyone needs to come out next

2:27:14

week 6 30 for the annual budget meeting yes if you leave all the things that you wrote on just leave them right here i'll collect them and then you'll get the purple filters yes okay it was

Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.