TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 3 June 2026
Board meeting · 3 h 46 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →
32,578 words in 42 five-minute windows.
good evening welcome to the rsu 5 board of directors it is wednesday june 3rd 2026 we are here at freeport high school library we sound like we're having a party we kind of are uh we had our our pre our pre-board meeting um celebration for our retirees and we'll hear a
little bit more about that in just a moment but we'll get started with the board meeting no care this evening, but everyone else is here, and we'll start with the Pledge of Allegiance. Do I have a motion for consideration and approval of the minutes from the April 29th,
2026, May 6th, 2026, and May 13th, 2026 meetings as presented barring any errors or omissions? Thank you, Karen and Steph. All those in favor? Great. None opposed. Adjustments to the agenda. Yes, we are going to add an executive session for a personnel matter at the end of the evening.
Okay. All right, so we will move right into good news and recognition, and we'll start with our recognition of retirees. And I think Pam goes first, yes? Great. The three-point medal? You have the list, though. All right, awesome. This is exciting to celebrate some really great staff members that I've gotten to know this year.
I'm going to start with Nick Whitty. They have the privilege of recognizing and celebrating Nick Whitty and the tremendous impact he's had on students and staff. Nick is focused, patient, thoughtful, and committed to helping students learn.
Throughout his career, he has impacted students, challenging them to think critically, communicate effectively, and discover their strengths. Nick's passion for literacy and writing has been evident from the moment you step into his classroom.
He has a unique ability to see potential in every learner and guide them to achieving more than they thought possible. Because of his dedication, students have left FMS prepared not only for the academic rigors of high school, but also with greater confidence in themselves as readers, writers, and thinkers.
Nick's love of literature is contagious, and his stories and insights have enriched the lives of students. He has a gift for making learning meaningful and helping students connect what they read and write to the world around them.
Nick, thank you for your years of dedication, your commitment to excellence, and the care you've shown your students and colleagues. On behalf of the entire FMS community, congratulations to your 19 years of dedication to educating our students.
We wish you happiness, adventure, and fulfillment in this next chapter. Thank you, Nick. I know Riley's going to say some words about Bertha, but how can I not? From the very beginning, Bertha's kindness stood out. She has a remarkable way of making people feel cared for.
Of course, many know Bartha through her delicious breakfast and lunches she helps provide each day. But what she brings to Freeport Middle School goes way beyond. She understands that a meal is more than about nourishment. It's about making students feel welcomed, valued, and cared for.
She takes pride in ensuring that her students have access to meals that are not only nutritious, but also prepared with thoughtfulness and with her whole heart. While we certainly will miss seeing her each day, I feel incredibly fortunate to have had the opportunity to know and work alongside such a wonderful person.
Bertha has left a lasting mark on our school community, and her kindness will never be forgotten. Please join me in celebrating Bertha, as we wish her the very best in her retirement. I'm really connected to these people in just a year, I'm telling you.
Phyllis. I am honored to express how fortunate I have been to know and work alongside the incredible woman we have been blessed to call our school counselor. While it is impossible to measure Phyllis's impact she's had on her students, families, and colleagues over the years,
it's evident in our stories, relationships, and lasting memories she leaves behind. Her influence extends far beyond the walls of our school and will continue to be felt for years to come. Phyllis is one of the kindest, most genuine, and compassionate people
I have ever met. She is an extraordinary gift for making others feel seen, heard, and valued. Her warmth, empathy, and unwavering dedication have made Freeport Middle School a better place for everyone fortunate enough to know her. Students trust her, they respect her, and most importantly,
they know she cares deeply about them. Every child deserves a safe place at school, someone who listens without judgment, offers encouragement during difficult moments, and celebrates their successes. For generations of students, Phyllis has been that person. While we'll miss her
tremendously, her legacy is not found in a single accomplishment, but in thousands of moments of kindness, guidance, and care she has shared throughout her career. Let's all come together to celebrate Phyllis Latham in her 37 years of service to our family.
Hello. I would like to start by congratulating all of the retirees that are here. And I wish you nothing but the best in your retirement. Tonight, I have the opportunity to honor two remarkable women whose contributions to our department will leave a lasting impact.
Their names are Reena Frank and Bertha Hilton. They share something important in common. Both have made our department stronger simply by being themselves. Reena joined RSU 5 in September of 1993. For 33 years, she has been a steady, dependable presence.
If I had to describe Reena, she's the kind of employee every organization hopes to have. She shows up rain or shine with a smile on her face. She greets people warmly and seems genuinely happy to see them. What stands out most about Reena is her consistency. Day after day, year after year, she has shown up and done her job really well.
She never sought attention or recognition, which is fitting considering she's not here tonight. And if she were, she'd be doing one of these, but that's just who Reena is in the best way possible. Her reliability, kindness, and dedication never went unnoticed.
The people around her knew they could count on her, and that kind of dependability is something truly special. In a profession built on serving students every day, people like Reena are the foundation that keeps everything moving forward.
For more than three decades, she has been a positive and steady presence in our schools. and we are incredibly grateful for her years of service. And then there's Bertha. Bertha joined RSU 5 in 2016, but her career in school nutrition began long before that.
Before coming to RSU 5, she spent 14 years serving students in Yarmouth, which is nearly 25 years of dedication to feeding students, supporting school communities, and caring for the people around her. If you've spent any amount of time with Bertha, it feels like you've known her much longer than you probably have. That's because Bertha has a gift that is increasingly rare. She truly pays
attention to people. She asks you how you're doing, and she wants to really know the answer. She checks in. She remembers. She celebrates people when they least expect it. A few of us have seen the handwritten list hanging in her office, with everyone's birthdays carefully noted.
Bertha never misses an opportunity to make someone feel special. Sometimes it's a birthday card, a thank you note, or flowers, but more often than not, it's food, a container of homemade soup, a tray of cookies for the office, or maybe a new recipe she insists that you try. If you've ever
received a card, some cookies, or a quick phone call from Bertha just to see what you're doing, then you've experienced firsthand the kind of person that she is. These gestures might seem small, but they are not. They are reflections of who Bertha is at her core. Someone who cares
deeply about the people around her. In school nutrition, we spend our careers nourishing others. Bertha has certainly done that through her work, but she's also nourished the people she works alongside. She's built relationships, created community, and made people feel valued. She's
been a manager, a colleague, and for many of us, a friend. Together, Rina and Bertha represent more than 57 years of service in school nutrition. That is more than five decades of feeding students, supporting schools and making a difference in ways both large and small. So thank you both for
everything you've given to this department, to your co-workers, and to the students and families we serve. The meals you've made have been important, but the relationships that you've built and the example you've set will be remembered. We are better because of your contributions and your
presence will be deeply missed. So please join me in congratulating them and wishing them both happiness, good health, and many wonderful adventures in retirement. And Julie Nickerson. I am here to recognize Diana Kosti, who is retiring as a first grade teacher,
although this is not where she started her 26 years at Mall Street School. She was an edtech in pre-K, working alongside the infamous Becky Bellings for many years. Diane has made a career of working with young children both at Moore Street and before that running her own child care
where she looked after other people's children alongside her own three boys. She has a depth of understanding of young children and a strong sense of what is developmentally appropriate for our youngest learners which has been her guidepost over the years. Diane wears many hats at our school
as well as being a strong and lasting presence on our first grade team. She's been on the leadership team, a mentor to many of our new teachers, is a musician who can lead a group when our music teacher is singing rounds or can be readily called upon to play her flute or sing
as part of any tribute to a retiring colleague. She's the first one to call when you need help after jamming the laminator. And I would be remiss if I did not mention that Diane is one of the most resolveful teachers I know. Before we all had document cameras in our
classrooms, I remember walking into Diane's where she had made her own by attaching an iPad to a stand that she had built and she made things work perfectly well with the resources she had. Diane has a gift for finding humor in the daily work of education. She always seems to have
the perfect funny story, student quote, or piece of student work to share that brings a smile to everyone's face. These moments not only brighten our day but also remind us why we do this work. Her ability to celebrate the joy and wonder of childhood helps foster a positive atmosphere
and strengthens connections among staff. Diane is so creative. She can whip up a sweet stuffed bunny for her granddaughter or a character costume for her colleagues in no time, as well as various outfits for the first grade mascot, Rashid. Each year, a highlight for students in Diane's class is her elephant and piggy skits.
This is something that Diane does because she knows the students will remember it. She takes extra time to help prepare students so that they can perform to their families at the end of the year. It is not an expectation, and it is truly above and beyond, and always well worth it.
All teachers work hard, and Diane is no exception. She can be found in her classroom early in the morning and often late into the evening, all to ensure that she is prepared for her students in the next day's learning. Diane's dedication towards each student, fortunate to call her their teacher,
and Wall Street School as a whole, have made a lasting impression, and she will be terribly missed. And I think my plants might die because Diana is the person who goes around school and does the things that nobody really has on their job list. And I think we're going to slightly fall apart.
I'm here to celebrate Carolyn Favreau. Carolyn, you're welcome to come up if you want to stand up here and be recognized. When I reflect on Carolyn's six years as an ed tech at Mass Landing School, one of the memories that really stands out occurred last spring. We were preparing to bid farewell to three fifth-grade students who Carolyn had worked
with incredibly closely over their time at Mass Landing School, and she, in their final week, spent hours creating handmade scrapbooks of photos from these students' experiences across the three years in their time at Mass Landing School. She printed those photographs and literally hand-sewed these beautiful books.
I share the story because, to me, it exemplifies the heart of who Carolyn is. Like the photographs in those albums, Carolyn truly sees students. Rather than viewing children through a lens of a disability or limitation, she recognizes and celebrates their strengths, their interests, their growth, and sees their potential.
As a result, she always seems to have a story to tell about a student's accomplishment, a new skill they have developed, or a moment that made her proud. I think, what is it like to be one of those kids that's supported by that staff?
Alongside her student-centered perspective, Carolyn brings warmth and sincerity to every relationship she forms. Whether interacting with students, colleagues, or families, she approaches people with an authenticity that is both meaningful and refreshing. Her kindness is genuine, her care is evident, and those around her really feel it.
In her final years in education, Carolyn continued to roll up her sleeves and was willing to do whatever was needed. From providing push in academic support and general education classrooms to working with one-on-one with students in our lift program, she demonstrated a wide-ranging skill set that
benefited our full school community. That commitment combined with remarkable flexibility was perhaps best illustrated when just months before her retirement, I think it was literally two days after she told me she was retiring, that we would need her to transition to a new building
in her final months of her career. Despite that, she willingly changed buildings to support a student who benefited specifically from her skill set. Given everything I've shared, it probably comes as no surprise that when I checked in with Carolyn a few weeks after her transition to Moore
Street this spring and asked how things were going, her face immediately lit up as she talked about this new student she was supporting. Rather than talking about the challenges of learning a new staff, new systems, new buildings, new expectations. She eagerly shared stories about
the student and the bond that they had formed. Even in this closing chapter of her career, she has focused consistently on what it means to serve students. Carolyn is concluding an 18-year career in education, exemplifying the very qualities that have made her such a valued
member of our school community and more recently Moore Street School as well. Her impact can be seen and the students she supported, the colleagues she's worked beside, and the joy that shines through when she talks about children. While we will certainly feel her absence, we are grateful
for all she's given to our schools and wish her nothing but happiness in her retirement. And like Erica, we have a staff member who does not like to be the center of the spotlight, but she may be streaming live from home where she's more comfortable. So it's my honor to
celebrate Cheryl Sleeper. Cheryl has served as the mass specialist at Mass Landing School for the past 10 years. While she's not with us this evening, her absence in many ways is reflective of the very nature of her work. She is one of the most humble people you will ever meet and has
never sought the spotlight. Instead, she shines that light on others, particularly her students. When Cheryl talks about her work, she rarely begins with herself. Instead, she shares stories about her students, their interests, their challenges, the creative ways they approach a mathematical problem and the growth that she has witnessed in them. She always has a vignette
to share that both honors and celebrates kids. These reflections reveal not only her deep understanding of her students as mathematicians, but also her appreciation for who they are as humans growing into themselves. One of Cheryl's greatest strengths is her relentless commitment
to knowing her students well. She approaches her role with curiosity and inquiry, seeking to understand each learner's mathematical thinking and problem solving. To support this work, Cheryl thoughtfully gathers and analyzes layers of formative and summative data, using this information
to tailor her instruction and respond to students. Her complex spreadsheets stand as a testament to the care, precision, and dedication she brings to her students. Beyond her expertise as an educator, she leads with a level of empathy that is truly extraordinary. Several years ago, at the start
of a staff meeting we were engaged in quick partnership conversations with colleagues and somehow a story came up about horseback riding in Colorado so Cheryl illustrated for me the beauty of riding this horse on some rugged trail in Colorado and as she was telling me the story
she noted that she was crying I was thinking like Cheryl I don't understand and she said all I could think about as I was riding this horse is how hard it was working and to me it is if you know Cheryl it is a testament to her level of empathy and care and that is how she was with kids that she
truly thinks about what they are doing what it means to live their experience and to support them all the way along the way of course the story has stayed with me ever since then because it's a testament to who Cheryl is she possesses a remarkable ability to place herself in the
experiences of others and to genuinely care about what they are carrying her compassion extends beyond our students to her colleagues and families as well. She consistently notices, understands, and cares deeply for those around her. As I reflect on Cheryl's service to mass
landing, her impact is perhaps best measured not by programs and her complex spreadsheets or years of service, but by the students whose confidence she has helped build. The influence of that work will continue long after her retirement. Given her unwavering focus on students, it feels fitting to
close with a few of their reflections. So these are fourth grade reflections. My favorite thing about Mrs. Sleeper is she's supportive. Even if a math problem is really hard, she finds a way to make it easy. Mrs. Sleeper is a very good teacher. I like it when she helps because she comes up with
strategies that help me do math. And then my favorite because it just so sounds like a fourth grader. Mrs. Sleeper is always there when you're in a funk. These words capture what so many of us know to be true. Cheryl has been a source of support, encouragement, and care for students
for the past 10 years at Mass Landing, and close to 40 in education. As she embarks on her retirement, we wish her many adventures, abundant time outdoors, which is a place she loves to be, and all the joy that comes from pursuing the things she loves most. And we are filled with
gratitude for her service. Good evening, everybody. I am representing Freeport High School tonight. We also could not pass up the opportunity to recognize Lena Frank. And Lena has just been such a light in our kitchen staff and in the cafeteria with students.
I think a couple of things, and I know that Erica already spoke so well about her. If you have enjoyed a good word cookie, as I like to call them, which I think everyone knows, Depending on how stressful the meeting is, that's how many cookies I eat.
Rina makes those cookies for us. But also the little secret fact is that she makes me an extra cookie that is waiting for me at the end of lunch. Every Wednesday that there's a board meeting, I'm a proud school lunch eater,
so I check in with Rina and the kitchen staff every day. She is always smiling, has some sort of comment about the day, always a positive spin on it um and because she's so humble and really doesn't like recognition our favorite thing to do is have 300 teenagers sing her happy birthday every year on her birthday
and um she will be incredibly missed so i just wanted to make sure that i mentioned her as well um but i'm here okay i'm here to recognize tonight john pertek and john pertek came to Freeport High School in 2017, and he's been an ed tech in our special ed department at Freeport
High School for the past nine years. John has worked with countless FHS students over the years, and many were some of our students with the most complex learning and or personal needs. John approaches his work with every student with respect, firmness, yet kindness, humor,
and empathy. He has held high standards for students, which means that for some, that's completing a complex research project, and for others, it means being able to walk independently from the cafeteria to a classroom. John recognizes and celebrates students' progress in whatever
form it comes. He has been instrumental in developing community partnerships for our school and our life skills program, and he has brought meaningful learning opportunities to our students, such as years of work with Wapenover Farm in Durham. In addition to partnerships
outside of school, John has helped create opportunities for our students to serve our own school community, such as through working in the Peace Garden. John has been one of the strongest advocates for maintaining the Peace Garden, which is a unique feature and a source
of pride for our school. I love it. My favorite comment is when he says, Jen, we need more plants. We need some money. In addition to keeping the garden in great shape, he's turned it into a living classroom where students learn about science, gardening, and a million other things that come
alive when they're working in the garden. John has also volunteered an incredible amount of his own time for the gardens around school and his time has been so very much appreciated. With John's support, students have gained skills that they will undoubtedly use throughout their
whole lives and he has also helped them gain an incredible sense of self-confidence. John's work has benefited our entire community as he cares deeply about our school. John will be very missed at FHS, and I hope that he enjoys his retirement immensely and maybe even comes to visit and sit in the Peace Garden once in a while. Thank you.
Well, hello. So tonight we are recognizing someone whose retirement marks truly the end of an era in an RSU 5. 23 years? Yep. 23 years. So in education that is long enough to see kindergartners grow up and graduate and start families of their own and then bring their children back from the very same school doors. Although there would be different school doors in Durham.
So over more than two decades, he or Will simply has not led, he hasn't led just a school, he has really become part of the institution itself. And I have to admit that standing here, I feel somewhat unqualified to deliver a tribute to him. Before I even arrived in RSU 5, we'll talk more later. I had heard of Mel's reputation, all of it deserved, before I even got here, and people spoke of him with a level of respect and admiration that is rare in any profession, and we school administrators have a profession in which can make us feel incompetent at the drop of a hat, and Mel does not seem to project that image at all.
The last summer I arrived as a first year superintendent and carrying around a healthy dose of imposter syndrome, I discovered that Will's reputation was not exaggerated at all. And quite honestly, Providence has been very kind to me in allowing my first year here to overlap with Will's final year as a principal, because what I have found in Will is what so many others have found, and that is an absolutely steady hand.
The profession can feel like roughsies, and Will is always a reliable point on the horizon. He's the North Star. He's both an anchor and a mainsail. He is not a figurehead. Do you see what I'm doing, Will? I'm doing this for you just so that you know it can continue.
But all of that aside, he is the colleague whose judgment you trust, whose advice you seek, whose honesty you can count on, and whose support you never have to question. Even if he disagrees with you, you leave that conversation better for having had it.
And when I asked his colleagues to describe him, certain themes emerged again and again. They spoke about his unwavering commitment to excellence and his high expectations for both students and staff. They spoke about his ability to see beyond an immediate challenge and understand the foundational work that is necessary for a school or a team or a district or a system to actually grow and change.
They spoke about his remarkable skill as a mentor. In fact, Will's assistant principals seem to have a habit of becoming successful principals themselves. Some have even mysteriously found their way to his hometown. People have also talked about his courage. He's never been afraid to say the hard thing in a difficult conversation if it was the right thing to say.
He has never confused the easy decision with the correct decision. And if you ever want to see just how fierce an advocate he can be, just tell him he can't do something for kids. You'll quickly discover what the line is between calm persistence and determined stubbornness.
They talked about his systems thinking, his ability to see not just his school but the whole district, and to help all of us see that big picture. and to be more deep strategic thinkers and then beyond that there's just the person that he is
there's the will whose opening day introductions of new staff somehow became longer and funnier and more entertaining than everybody else's the will who could return turn a routine meeting into a quick mini comedy show it's like an episode of called a midwife where there's
always a pantomime going on the will who could spend 20 minutes explaining the difference between structural and adaptive change and somehow people thank him and i'm pretty sure rumor has it there is not a single person in durham who has escaped a lesson on the managing
complex change chart that he weeps out at a moment's notice there's the will who whenever staff gather and changes on the horizon instinctively reaches for those nautical metaphors Some people had favorite books, some people had favorite movies. Will has the sea to its deepest depths.
The will who loves a good podcast and then loves telling you about it. 27 times. The will who still can't say garage. Like a garage. By the way that everyone understands, despite over many decades of opportunities to practice.
But perhaps most importantly, the one who understands that serious work does not require serious people and serious moments all the time. He has brought humor and humanity and curiosity and joy to the schools. And whether it is, and these are things that I hear about by reputation only, but the moon wagon?
Did I mispronounce? Um, WDCS, Carpool Karaoke, simply as willing as to laugh at himself. He has created cultures where people want to be there just because he's there. One colleague reminds me that he has an entire drawer in his office dedicated to nonsense.
Rigs, costumes, props, glasses. Most principals have drawers full of other things. Will has his role prepared for spontaneous entertainment. And that feels just right. He loves to direct a show. Hmm? Yes. He loves to bring people together. He really loves to help others shine.
One colleague actually told me that Will's greatest impact comes from helping others to be independent. Stop and think about that as an educator. All of us. He doesn't create followers, he develops leaders. He listens deeply and he asks very thoughtful questions and he helps others find their way forward.
And he is also constantly putting others ahead of himself. He is the person who sends a congratulatory email after an event. The person who writes home to celebrate a student's growth. The person who remembers details about your family and asks about them months later.
The person who makes himself the punchline of the joke so everyone else can feel successful. And he's the person who stays late and arrives early and genuinely embraces and celebrates the personal and professional victories of other people.
And that is what a leader is supposed to be. And it is evident in the school that he has helped grow here. Durham Community School contains bits of Rose Brilliance everywhere you look. The bricks line in the lower hallways because young children like to trail their hands along something as they walk.
The cafeteria windows that look out over the playground, which we designed to feel more like a family kitchen watching over a backyard than an institutional school. Thoughtful details that most people would never notice, but that reveal how deeply he understands kids and how intentionally he approaches his work.
So, Will, after 23 years at the helm of Durham Community School, your influence can be found in every corner of that building and in countless people throughout the district and beyond, you've shaped not only a school, but generations of students and educators and leaders and citizens.
And as you prepare to move the bridge back to the lifelike, and chart your next course, the wake you have left behind. And there it is. The waters of RSU-5 are better because you sailed here. And after just a year of working the road, look what has happened to me.
I suppose some things are contagious. So, on behalf of the board and the staff and the students and the families and all of us who have been privileged to serve alongside you, thank you for your leadership and your wisdom and your humor and your friendship
and just being you. And fair wins and following C's. And I think that concludes our retirees. Honoring of the retirees this evening. so you don't have to follow that but before you do i just want to from the board say thank you
from the bottom of all of our hearts i think i can say this as a for as a group to all of the retirees that are here that hopefully are watching at home or or even not but for all the time the effort the the the love and the care that you've put into all of your time in rsu5 and all of your
time to all the kids that you've ever impacted and um god i hate this day every year oh god um but i what our loss is hopefully your game to do wonderful things with your life and share your light with others and so thank you thank you so much so thank you now i will uh throw it to me
for our student rep. Hi everyone. I guess to start off like this week we had the start of our senior projects so it's been really great to see what everyone's been up to and I've been to I think probably eight so far in last week but I guess just a couple I've seen like I saw on 29th Maddie
Anderson first new project she had a play of the Wonder Wizard of Oz and so she had the advanced theater class uh produced that for with with her and it was really cool just to see like um how great like i didn't get to see it but i heard how great it was and how everyone did fantastic
and i also heard on the 30th that pylon colby lewis um for a senior for a senior project had walking for kita and walking for kita's community walk in support of the kita center's vital work for our community. And they do raising awareness for mental health, suicide, and topics that
impact many students and families and people. And so it's really great to hear that Colby Lewis was doing all that and support. And also, we had the Gulf of Maine Field Studies class. They had a pizza night. I'm pretty sure at the Maine Beer Company, where 20% of all food sales went to
equipment, maintenance, and the learning climate change. I'm pretty sure I'm going to take that class next year so I'm quite excited to see that and then also we had a charity walk for the Barbara Bush Children's Hospital and we also had a pep rally following that so it's really great to get
a nice it was a great day out really sunny so that was really great and then we also had activities such as like the watermelon relays where the sophomore class destroyed everyone but besides that it was really great and then we also had a class of 2029 trivia night so that was really
cool on the I think on happened on the 18th and so they hosted trivia I think just to raise money and also the boys and girls competed in the Western Main Conference uh last Saturday and so I heard the I guess the girls got second and the boys got fourth and we now have new records
I'm set we have Naomi in the triple jump I learned the triple jump Emma in the 400 Brielle in the pole vault and me Ian Jack and Alex in the 4x4 roulette and the 4x4 is the 4x400 so each person wants to 400 yeah that's it and the state track meet will be held this weekend here
at our lovely uh jambonite samuelson track and field facility and i think moon will be competing there as well in that four by four as well as some other events so good luck to you and to your whole team and the only thing i didn't hear in there is that i also hear there was
uh national honor society induction which you were inducted into so congratulations all right thank you for that busy time of year um all right so we will move on to public comment if we have anyone who'd like to speak we'll just ask you come up to the microphone uh give us your
name where you live and three minute comments good evening um i'm kate mcgilliot i'm a parent of two children um i'm a kind of a kind of new industry and a three-year-old and i'm really emotional because I just heard about how deeply each of the people in this room care about kids.
I was a teacher, I was a district-driven systems-level leader, sorry, and I'm also a literacy professor. I have facilitated national state-level changes at an educational nonprofit, and the hardest work I've ever done is teaching and working in a school. I truly believe that every person in
here wants to put kids first. I felt this. We moved here from Louisiana because we wanted to find a community where we where we can plant roots in public schools and we have found educators who care deeply about kids who care about kids growing a ton of empathy and I also just am asking people
to really consider putting kids first and to really look at what we're doing and ask yourself if it is putting kids first. I want to talk to you about the current reading curriculum being used in RSV5, and ask that you really consider how urgent this change is. Kids must be taught to
read. Unlike speaking, our brains are not programmed to read. They have to be taught. They have to be rewired. And for decades, many schools across the United States, as you probably know, used FNP and Lucy Culligan's units of study. Both of these are still used in RSV5.
These programs are not aligned to teaching the brain to read. The foundation of skills that many of you know when you think about sounding out words when you come across a word you don't know you probably still do it many states and school districts including massachusetts have been these
curricula mandated evidence-based literacy curriculum practices used within these are illegal in 20 states including Louisiana where we moved from we are still being taught to make kindergarten many states and school districts have come around and i've had conversations with
many of you in here that, and I understand the perspective that the curriculum has been updated. It has. It's been ready to include phonics. However, for all nationally known reviews, it's not comprehensive and systematic, and it's not explicit. Imagine trying to figure
out a puzzle, but you only have half the pieces, and then imagine that your teacher's telling you, please figure out the puzzle day in and day out. That's what it's like if you're not taught in an explicit systematic way, the foundational concepts. And the units of study
curriculum revamped doesn't do that. You have to start kids, every kid, with the belief that they can learn to read. It is the most critical predictor of all life success. And I'm sure every teacher in here, every leader in here, every parent in here has an example of why it's so
critical. Adding it on as an afterthought isn't that. It doesn't align to what we've all know is best for kids. It doesn't align to setting up kids to ensure that they have a fair shot before they're identified as needing an intervention or as having a disability. It's also not aligned to
federal requirements for a school in that you have to use core evidence-based curriculum before you identify kid as needing additional support. So I really ask you to consider three specific actions. I know how challenging change across the system is. We just heard a weird sort of talk about,
you know, in that retirement speech of all the things I go into, adaptive technical change, change management. Yes, and all of those things are adult things. So I'm going to ask you to consider the kids coming, my rising first grader, kids coming into kindergarten next year,
sixth graders that are still not reading, the 50% of kids from low-income backgrounds in this district who are not proficient in reading, the 30% of kids from overall who are not proficient and reading. There's a solution, and I think we're all aware of what that solution is.
Districts right next door did it. States across the country, 42 states, have done it and are moving towards and seeing the growth. We started some progress this year, so the steps and maps are clear. I'm asking you to consider three specific actions in the short and long term.
Introduce a district-wide policy that mandates universal literacy screening. So at least have data on where every kid is, progress monitoring throughout the year, and interventions for all children. This was started this year using Acadians, which is fantastic. It's happening.
People are seeing the success. The second thing is introducing a district-wide plan that mandates within two years all K-3 literacy curriculum is the one to high-quality instructional materials. Ed reports is the national standard. Maine has a new guide. The state is excited to support.
there's been change in local districts. And then pilot at least one classroom in the upcoming school year to implement a tier one evidence-based curriculum and assessment in literacy and to not use units of study. And then I ask you to compare the data and have a real conversation about if you
can in fact continue to not have half of the children from the LinkedIn backgrounds and 30% of kids overall be proficient in reading. When students are taught in a method proven to work for all kids first. Schools need less individualized instruction for meeting. There's fewer behavior
challenges. When schools implement this evidence-based tier one curriculum, they see transformative success. You can see this all over the news. And I know that this district is different. I know that you guys care about kids. I see it. I'm asking you to, therefore, because you care about kids, to really
examine if you're sure you know what you know. And start with the data that you already have. There are many parents who aren't here today. They don't have the resources. They don't have the time. They don't have the capacity to come and speak to you. Like me, they trust their schools. They trust their teachers. And many of these parents are thinking something is wrong with their child. They're thinking their kid is behind in reading. Maybe there's something wrong with them. Do they have a behavior disability? Do they have a reading disability? Do they have dyslexia? The majority of these kids don't. They just need to be taught the code. And the code is well established. And you can teach it. I taught it to high schoolers. And I took kids who couldn't sound out a word, and I made them proficient readers.
We can do it. There are people in this district doing it. So I hope you continue this work, and you really, really consider what it would mean to set every kid up for the success they deserve and they have a right to, and leave this board cycle with a clear plan in the short and long term to implement this change.
Thank you. So do we have any notes you wanted to? Yeah, I think Jen's getting up for public comments. Hi, my name is Lindsay Hahn, and I'm from Powell. And even though I'm from Palinol, I hope my comments are received and the manner I'm attending to be, and that is a wonderful partnership in good faith.
I want to thank Superintendent Gray and the board for taking time over the past several months to listen to the community members that would be affected by repurposing Palinol Elementary School. After the February 11th board meeting, when the proposal was first introduced, Superintendent Gray acknowledged the strong reaction from families and community members
and stated that his goal was really to listen as this exploration of the issues began in earnest. I believe that he has done that, and I'm grateful for his engagement and willingness to hear from residents across the district. I will admit that before that February meeting, I was not an active participant in School Board Matters. Like many parents, I trusted that the board would make decisions in the best interest of my children
and the district as a whole. Hearing a proposal that would potentially repurpose my children's elementary school, Challenged that assumption initially left me feeling shocked, concerned, and uncertain about the future of our wonderful school.
But just as Superintendent Gray has been listening over these past months, I have been listening too. Over the past few months, I have attended as many board meetings and subcommittee meetings as possible. I have spent time learning about the many complex and competing issues facing RSU-5. After that process, my initial shock and dismay have evolved into something more productive.
a deeper understanding of the challenges before us, a greater appreciation for the work of the board, and cautious optimism that decisions of this magnitude will not be made without careful consideration of their impact on students, families, and our communities.
And the most inspiring outcome of this process so far has been the extraordinary community engagement it has generated. The amount of support, talent, energy, and commitment from residents has been incredible. People with different backgrounds, experiences, and perspectives have stepped forward not
simply oppose a proposal, but to work together to find solutions. That willingness to collaborate, volunteer, and engage constructively gives me great hope for the future of our district. I continue to believe that strong neighborhood schools strengthen communities, fosters engagement,
and creates lasting connections amongst families. I also remain unconvinced that repurposing panel elementary school into a district-wide early education facility would achieve the goals that had originally been outlined. More importantly, I believe the structural change of this magnitude should be supported
by compelling evidence that the benefits clearly outweigh the costs, and I do not believe that evidence currently exists. As we move forward, I look forward to participating in the systems and sustainability study to the extent that I can. Community members from across the district and I are only committed to working collaboratively to find solutions that move RFC5 forward while preserving the strengths of each unique
tone. Thank you. Thank you, Wendy. Anyone else? I'm not going to show you about you because, you know, you're our last public member. Oh, really? Yeah. You good? You good tonight? Okay. Number four. Thank you. All right, so we will move on to item eight on our agenda report from the superintendent.
Okay. For this evening, I'd like to just switch things up a little bit first and inform me of some resignations before I launch into my report. And the first that I'd like to tell you about is a person who's just left the room, which I believe you already know about.
But Principal Galko has announced her resignation to become the principal of Harrison Middle School in neighboring Yarmouth District. And we are basically swapping her for the current principal of that middle school who is coming in to be our new assistant superintendent effective July 1st.
Jen's departure will be truly the end of an era at Freeport High School, and she will be dearly missed. Second, Amber Harrison, who is a Moore Street School pre-K teacher, has announced her resignation. Kelly Howard, who is a PES pre-K teacher, has announced her resignation.
And Fred Toppin, who is a district computer technician, has announced his resignation. And we have John Peartek, who you heard about a few moments ago, who is a Freeport High School ed tech, who has announced his retirement.
I would like to take a few moments tonight to focus my remarks on the strategic planning process. That's something we're going to be digging into in great detail at the next meeting, and I wanted to prepare you with some of the thoughts that I have about where we go from there.
First, there's a lot of people to thank. This has been a monumental process. It started before I arrived. It has involved as many members of the community as we could possibly involved. we've had students staff families community members administrators board
members contributing along the way there have been many many rounds of feedback as you know because you've received the surveys it has been remarkable I think that the final product will reflect that in its strength you will notice
speaking of surveys one final survey just went out this is a survey that asks for feedback not about the plan itself but about what within this gigantic plan we should work on first so I expect that at least a few of us are
feeling survey fatigue at this point but they should slow down but it's not a bad thing that we've taken so much input one of the commitments of the process from the beginning was that it would be inclusive and thorough and informed by
as many constituents as we could possibly reach out to and so we've had these surveys and we've had focus groups we've had public meetings and committee discussions and countless individual conversations and many many informal
interactions and those are all the tools that have helped to shape the plan next week we'll bring you that updated strategic plan for formal approval and I wanted to just take a moment to talk about what that means board approval is
obviously an important step for school districts strategic plan but with a week's lead time, I wanted to encourage you to think about and recognize that the strategic plan is not my plan. It is not the administration's plan. It isn't really the board's plan either.
It's the community's plan. And that's what all of those countless surveys and listening sessions have been aimed at. And although the board has an important governance role in adopting the plan so that we can use it as a continual decision point reference, the plan has been shaped by all
the people who live, work, learn, and raise families here. And it reflects thousands of individual comments and ideas and aspirations. And that's something we're celebrating. So as we move toward that adoption, I have been thinking about and talking
with the administrative team about what comes next. So the reality is that writing the strategic plan is the easy part. It's actually making the plan come alive and living the plan that is the will work so that that plan is not just a paper tiger. And that will not be determined by how good
the document looks or how many surveys we did along the way. It will be determined by whether the plan actually influences our decisions and our priorities and that that leads ultimately to the outcomes for students. So it's about what we do going forward. And for this reason, I believe
we need a structure that will help keep the plan visible and relevant long after we adopt it so my initial thinking is that we will establish a strategic oversight committee that will include representation from across all of our constituent groups similarly to the current strategic planning
committee it will have teachers and support staff administrators students parents community members and board representation, and this committee would not just be another implementation committee. It would not be managing the projects within the plan or directing the work of the staff,
but it would be consistently assessing whether or not the priorities of the plan remain relevant and what our work has been to carry out the action steps and where it should go next. And it would continually monitor and provide feedback, and I think most importantly, inform how we communicate about the plan.
And it would help us continually address questions like, are we actually making progress on the priorities we've identified? What evidence do we have that we're actually making that progress? What are the challenges? What's the feedback from the community as we go along?
What adjustments may need to be made? And I think the most important part is, how can we meaningfully embed this plan in the way we communicate, in both directions, in the way we communicate about our schools, and in the way that we seek communication? How do we make sure that it remains a living document, rather than something that slowly
fades away? One of the themes that has emerged repeatedly throughout the planning process has been how important communication is, because it's how we achieve engagement and transparency. So I'm thinking of the structure which I've recently discussed with the administrative team
and which we are shaping a framework for to be a vehicle for that. I think we would all agree that community engagement can't end when the plan is approved by the board. If anything, then it's even more important. And quite frankly, it's one of the most essential principles of decision-making in our society.
the ideas of our society, can endure because we allow for their continual interpretation and reinterpretation. It can't be just a snapshot in time. It's a living document. So that will provide both direction and stability and have an opportunity for regular review.
I think that needs to be the essence of the plan. And that does not mean we would constantly be changing course. It doesn't mean we would constantly be revising the plan. It would mean we would be constantly monitoring how the plan is working and making adjustments on the way and I
think that this also is very important as we look back to the conversation we're having about where how we configure our district going forward all of the conversations about organizational effectiveness and long-term sustainability those conversations have to take place under
the umbrella of the strategic plan. And the future systems and sustainability study, the decisions we make having been informed by that study, will kind of help us understand how our plan will continue to evolve. So over the summer, I will be continuing to refine an implementation structure, and it will
focus on a strategic oversight committee, and I will bring more detailed recommendations to the board regarding the framework for that committee when we get started next year but i wanted to use tonight as an opportunity to share with you that's what i'm working on and that when you look at the
plan next week so that you can see at least this idea that i have now about where it could go next because that's where the work begins it's those surveys they have gone out to students parents staff community the facebook page that's
all i can think of for the moment for those of us who don't have facebook i think they were posted on the three towns website because we don't have email addresses or to everybody who lives in town i believe they were all posted in sort of like the news blasts that go out from the three towns
This would have been a year ago. I did one a year ago, but is that the most recent one? No, the most recent one went out like a week before last. But I don't know if that, I think, because that only went out to people that we had email addresses for, I believe.
Yes. So, that probably... Surely you have my email address. Well, we can answer the question. I mean, we got it in our board email. You have it there. We got a copy of it, I believe, in our board email. To fill out? Well, there's a link to the survey. so you got it yeah I will check yeah I didn't see it um just I'm very much looking forward to seeing
the strategic plan uh next week I think just a couple of thoughts that occurred to me just on the because I came on when you were at the end of our last strategic plan um and I think just something I'm realizing as you're as you were describing what I think um uh sounds like a good
way to conceptualize what the strategic plan is isn't it it is the plan of the community um That was not how the strategic plan that we were working with before was presented, as I remember, just insofar as it really did feel like it was what the district leadership had said we were going to do.
And I just think that distinction, that distinction seems really important because I think that there were times when I remember looking at that strategic plan and looking at what we said we were going to do and then sort of like the indicators of whether we've done it and feeling a real disconnect.
And I think, and therefore, I think that kind of brought up feelings of like, well, why, why, why did we say that that was going to be our plan? And then why didn't we follow through on that? So I think that's sort of just one person's observation.
I think the other is, I guess I'm just going to be curious to see in the strategic plan what we see, if indeed it is what the community represented by this committee is presenting, how the feasibility of that plan has been evaluated.
Because I think asking the board to sign off on something where that feasibility has not been really clearly worked through, I think, just raises some sort of question marks for me. Because it's one thing to say, this sounds like a good idea.
It's another to say, yes, in the next five years, we are going to accomplish this, and we have the ability to do so. So that's more of a comment just as it comes up, but just that's some of what I'm going to be thinking about as we look at that.
I do. I also want to talk about cell phones. So I just wanted to give you an update about where we are with implementation of our new policy, which goes into effect July 1st. So some background. When the board adopted the policy, and I think that was January or February,
the discussion, you will remember, we were all in the room, we had had months of discussion about what the policy would look like, including whether or not, where we would ban phones, where we would have, whether we would allow them, for example, on buses,
all the things, right, we discussed all the things. So at that time, the policy that you wrote establishes a phone-free school day, and that's the language that's in the policy. And then it also says that schools would have some latitude in determining the procedures that would implement that expectation.
So we discussed a variety of approaches, including using younger bags or other storage systems at the time. At that time, we decided not to implement a district-wide storage solution. The decision was based on several factors. Cost was one, but it was not the primary factor at the time. And we heard consistently from students at the time that mandatory storage systems would be UAS punitive. So the board also heard from administrators in other districts. We administrators heard from other districts that sometimes those systems can be difficult to police.
So as a result, and at the moment I just want to make it clear, I'm trying to capture, I hope accurately, the consensus of the conversation among all of you when the policy was adopted. It was to begin with an off-and-a-way approach, establish clear expectations, and then monitor how the policy would work and go forward from there.
That was January or February. Fast forward a few months, the state passed a law. The state passed a law banning cell phones. That's great because our policy banned cell phones during the school day, but in the course of that, the state also appropriated money to school districts to help with that implementation, and what we're supposed to use the money for, if we take advantage of it, is anything that will help to enable a bell-to-bell ban.
it doesn't say you have to buy this or that or the other thing. It's somewhat flexible. With that said, we did not learn how much money we would be getting until just a couple of weeks ago in late May, and that amount was about $4,100, which is not nothing, but it's also in the grand
scheme of things, it's not a lot. So that has informed the conversations about what our implementation would be in buildings. And it does, it has meant that those conversations have shifted in tone just within the past few weeks, because that's new information. So I'm just offering that
to kind of explain why are we at implementation, having these discussions now, when the policy was voted on months ago. It's because some things changed in the interim. So with that information now available, the schools are working on their implementation plans, and they will have those
completed before the school year is out and ready to be communicated. We also just yesterday had a principal's meeting, and we spent considerable time discussing the areas where it has to be consistent across schools. A good example of that is, in often away, what does away mean? Does away
mean in your pocket does it mean in a backpack etc I'm not answering that question right now I'm sharing this as an example of what we are discussing in terms of implementation plans so we are close we're not quite there as of this
moment but we will be before the end of the school year and it will be clearly communicated for the board I personally believe that policy wise we're in the right place at the moment and I believe that because the board has adopted a
policy that complies with state law. And it allows us the flexibility to start in one place, see how it goes, and move to another place if we need to. I think that that's important. I think especially, in fact, I was just talking with Jen Gulko this morning on the phone about this. She was
sharing information from her Cumberland County Principals Group, which has been actively discussing this. What Jen tells me is that most schools are not quite ready yet with their plans because of the same factors that I just shared with you. And everybody is thinking that no matter what they
start with, they will probably end up in a different place a few months into the school year, depending on how it goes. There are some unique factors here in Freeport that we have to think about. One of them is open campus. So not every high school is situated in a downtown. And so the
number of students that we have who are 11th or 12th grade who leave the building and come back is perhaps higher than in many other places how does that fit into how we implement a phone the phone policy those are the kinds of details that they have to think about in the implementation
plan so at the high school there is a team right now of teachers and students who have been working on this. And they met again just recently. And they are close to hammering out a procedure for the school that will fall under the auspices of the policy. So I hope that this helps the board
understand where we are with this and why we are at this point right now. And I'm happy to take any questions that you have. Okay. Thank you for that. That was well put. I just have a question about all schools having similar protocol or will each school have their own way of doing things
across rsu5 i guess i'm just wondering about uniformity there'll be some similarities and some differences and i can't say at the moment exactly what those are i i'll return to the example of we agreed yesterday one area where we need to be consistent is when we say if we say
off and away, what does away mean? Because away can't mean, at Freeport Middle School, away meant we keep it in our pocket and that's fine, but you get to the high school and they say it has to be somewhere else. That won't work. So it has to be more consistent than that. But when it gets down
to the level of, for example, at the high school, there could be different rules for 9th and 10th grade versus 11th and 12th grade, largely because of open campus. So some of those are very specific to the conditions in the school. I don't think I answered your question that fully, but that's as much as I can do at the moment.
I think it does. It just brought another thought to mind that I think one of the reasons that schools and states are starting to go this route is because of the distraction. So if they're on your body and something's buzzing, that's still distraction. I have to agree, and I don't mind telling you that when we met yesterday, the administrators, we fully agreed with that. And, you know, while there are lots of conversations that we've had here recently that bear upon this, we just heard a presentation not too long ago from a group of students who felt that they would like to improve the sense that the student voice is heard.
And when this issue was discussed, the board actively tried to recognize the students when they said that putting phones away in a storage device, like a yonder bag, might feel punitive. so we definitely want to recognize that at the same time it's an adult decision and i think you
know i can represent for the adults in the room and certainly what i believe the phones are harmful and the phones are addictive they just are and our consequences are not necessarily as powerful as the addictive draw to pull the phone out um so what we're really engaged in the conversations are
if we use a storage device how can we do it in a way that works and doesn't completely disrupt the flow of the school how can we do it and still honor our desire to ensure the students feel that they were heard um and how can we do it in a way that minimizes power struggles because we don't
want to set up a situation in which we're constantly just confronting kids about where is your phone show me where your phone is that's not productive so those are some of the variables that the needle we're trying to thread. Chris? When we talked about that first, when we first adopted
the policy before the law change, I know we had talked about an educational component that came with that to the kids. Yes. And with the law change now, it's less of a, well, we're doing this because and more of a, the state says we have to. That said, I think it's still important to include some
sort of educational component and have you seen any progress on that um mostly at the middle school they're invoking a new course a special course in library studies and that would be a critical component of it but i also know that this is taught in other areas in the schools already
um i believe it's taught as part of an advisory curriculum i don't although don't quote me on that i'm trying to remember um the discussion that we had but we have absolutely recognized that that is a part of the expectation of the policy and we'll continue to work on it. Anna? Thank you for the update, Tom. A couple things was, just for the record, I want to say, personally as a board member, I did not feel as if when we were having the discussions around the storage systems and whether to do it or not, before the state law came, that really we got a sense as a board of what the different options were. I mean, all of this is so new, right? but like really I felt like we only heard about yonder and then we heard some very anecdotal
evidence that it wasn't working and they're expensive um so I feel like it's a I just I think things are now coming out that we're learning about alternative systems and I just feel like we didn't publicly discuss um and have time for that um and that's just what it is but
just to name that um i also wanted to ask about the funding allocation it's you know not much but it's something particularly for like some of the cheaper options do we know how like when will it go away is that do we have a sense of that my understanding at the moment is that it's a one
time thing um and you're absolutely right so our understanding of the products that are available is growing really fast. And I think new products are coming online all the time. One of the ones that we've looked at recently, which was referenced in some emails that the board received, are these lockers that go in classrooms.
Those are between $100 and $200 a piece. So for $4,100, we would not have enough to do every classroom, for sure. We'd have to be selective. If we wanted to go further than that, we'd have to find money somewhere else. I don't think that money is actually the biggest obstacle. I think really it's figuring out the logistics of it and, you know, you're right that the evidence is anecdotal, although it's anecdotal from every other school that I've talked to that has done it that suggests that having the expectation really does help and yet we still always have kids who, you know, who go, who won't follow the rules. And it puts us in a position of having to make a decision where will we confront and that's a fine line because we don't want to have unproductive power struggles. I think what I mean is I feel like we only really talked about Yonder and because of the cost about it and I didn't feel like we got
much input about some other stories. We talked about the ones I couldn't open. That was a random thing because, can I just say one other thing, Colin? Is that, and I, going back I know that our role as a board here isn't to say I think we should use this and I respect that the
administrators are working it out at least that's the policy that we passed is we're not saying that so I respect and I'm happy that these conversations are being had I will say that the storage systems I think it's they each hold like a hundred phones or something like that so I mean there are ways
to do it and I just wonder I'm hoping that these conversations are thinking about the funding and Like, maybe the kids who aren't able to put it away, and they need more of a consequence. They are. I can tell you that. And the storage devices are not off the table.
Particularly at the high school where Jen has kept me really informed. There are some folks at the high school who would really like to see us use them. There are some folks who wouldn't. Jen's trying to arrive at a good consensus point.
I'm pretty sure that whatever we try first, no matter what it is, we'll end up modifying, because that's the way things go, if we do it right. And I want to, I'm hoping to give them the grace to try an idea and see how it works. But I don't know if it helps you for me to say that the storage devices are actively being considered, and it's mostly like, if we use them, how and where could we use them in a way that doesn't disrupt the flow of the school.
Thank you. That makes a lot of sense. And I think my last piece, and then sorry, Colin, is are the discussions also focusing on the communication plans to parents and families? Because that seems just as important. Yes, I've communicated to the principals that this needs to be wrapped up this year, even if we feel like we don't have a perfect procedure yet, we need to have something in place that we can communicate to everyone before the school year is over, and then we'll communicate it again when school starts, and we'll give it our best effort, and we'll see how it goes and identify what needs to change.
And I think all I just wanted to throw in is, I think, just sort of, and what you touched on a moment ago, is just that very much, I'm speaking as the policy chair, I think, at this point. The way in which we constructed the policy over the course of all of the discussions and the input was very deliberately not making the board the determining entity for the technology or the methodology of that.
That was a very, like, I mean, I think, at least I tried to be very clear that that was the decision. Yes, part of it was certainly hearing input from, as Tom, as you said, hearing input from the students about the question of the sort of punitive nature of it, but I think that the way I understood our passage of that policy was very much that the expertise does not lie with us.
More, actually, do I think it really was, I think as I kind of go back on it, that that wasn't sort of an appropriate moment for us to sort of inflict our will upon the students in terms of sort of the management of this problem.
So I think that, you know, I very much did, when we passed that policy, it was sort of like, it's in all's hands, please don't screw it up. And things have changed since then. So I think, I guess I just wanted to say is that the sort of the question surrounding whether, I guess I was a solicitor to answer when you were saying them weren't presented with you as sort of the more full range of the technologies, I guess in my mind at the end of the day, that was not what we were supposed to look at.
That was the way, at least I was understanding the way we were, we eventually approached it in terms of passing the policy. I think part of what I viewed was policy and operationalizing it because something, feedback that we heard from Jen was that, and the students, was that different teachers were applying current policies differently in the classroom.
and so when i was thinking about this policy i was trying to think of how would whatever this policy says be affected by um internal variance among the teachers and when i think about off and away that seems vague enough and and um i guess still kind of clear that you shouldn't
have it out that we can allow for that and still need it whereas there are some things that i felt like risked us both not paying attention to what we were hearing from the students and also risked that variability causing a weird strife among staff and maybe a lessening of maybe respect is
the wrong word but something creating that push and pull of like well this teacher says i can do this or this teacher doesn't make me do that and then when you have that kind of policy that maybe hopefully everyone can get on board with i was worried about the way we were operationalizing it
and making sure that we were able to meet it more consistently because that's one thing that i heard from a jump was that we have a policy already that people are maybe not consistently applying that's not accurate and we did not have a policy at the district level in terms of how the no no
So that's, again, I think that's where, again, because the policy committee, our head is always, like, at this place is sort of the, is really a fundamental difference between when we talk about district-wide policy, what we mean is a document that the board has approved that applies to everyone.
And then there are the procedures that, sort of, the nature of the beast is that, basically, we trust the administration to make determinations on what those procedures are to operationalize it. So I think that part of the problem previously was that there was not a policy.
There was just sort of a procedure, but it had no teeth. And also, and so I think that, so I guess I just, just on that particular point, the other is also that just to that point about policy and procedure, it's something that like superintendents and assistant superintendents, since I have been on the board, have really emphasized that the board should not overreach and pass and, and get at two level of, two minute level in terms of creating policy.
Um, and that, that, uh, the procedure really needs to be left to, um, the illustrators. And I have taken that quite, I've taken that quite seriously, I've wrestled with it, I've taken it quite seriously, but I would say that this is a situation where, um, if, um,
we were to observe over the next year, let's say, or two years, I'm not sure what the right time frame is, um, if, uh, for whatever collection of reasons, um, a dog's breakfast is made of this because choices were left to the administration that maybe shouldn't have
been made, then it comes back to us, and we make a stricter policy. But I think that, again, I think it just goes to the, I guess I would just remind us of that as just a general principle for our policymaking, that that is, that's generally how it's supposed
to operate, and we're not meant to micromanage at that level, at least that is what the career educators and administrators have been at ease to communicate to us as a committee yeah i just wanted to second claim i feel very comfortable with the policy that we
as a board have adopted for the district i think it's good that we are not overly prescriptive about how we are asking the schools to implement this policy and i also wanted to thank superintendent gray for your remarks it sounds like you are you and the administrators are
having some really thoughtful conversations around this that you are with the data that you have you are considering a lot of these questions about implementation very carefully and I look forward to hearing more about what you come up with and I feel comfortable that you're making
those decisions and that we can adjust if we need to so I'm I'm feeling good about the process and I'm also looking forward to hearing more thank you not sure how to start this but yes uh Colin good points um very good points to keep in mind that we are not putting forth procedures for
schools the policy and very good point about consistency i think that's what i think i originally said like uniformity because if you have two parents and one's going to say yes to a kid where do you think the kid's going to go to the last parent right so i think that's the only
thing that was my concern was just more. If it's one school, like you said, there's an open campus here, so Freeport High School has one consistent box of rules or whatever it is, then you go and do those rules and keep them consistent instead of one teacher maybe, well, allow this, or one
teacher saying, no, it's got to be this way. It's going to be too hard for kids to manage otherwise. I think the uniformity is a good thing, but I don't want to tell someone how to do that. Yes, what they say is our job is to make sure that the schools are well-managed, not to manage the schools, right?
So I appreciate that. A couple of thoughts to Chris's point about, you know, the why behind the decision. I do think, you know, you say it yourself, Tom, like they're not good and they're addictive. and, you know, we can just take it away, which we will because we have to, but it's also the right
thing to do, and so I do look forward to the curriculum that goes around it. I don't think what we do now is adequate because I feel like if it was adequate, we wouldn't be getting the pushback from the student body, right, or even from parents, and so I do look forward to, you know,
that I think it's a parallel path with the implementation is the why and the true impact of the phones and the technology on their brains, on their environment, on their learning experience, on ours. So I definitely don't want that to fall to the wayside just because
oh well now it's a law and we have to do it. I still think that's our obligation to provide and um as i think about the money i mean i do think i do think we should take advantage of the funds that are being offered to us i do imagine it's a one-time limited limited time offer um
and uh you know if we don't have a storage solution that needs it just yet i i don't um i do like the idea of maybe it's you know we get some of those lockers for for for kids who need more support and can't handle whatever the implementation looks like, right? Maybe that's
a use. Maybe, I don't know if this is allowed, maybe it's to pay a speaker. I mean, we've heard about some incredible speakers that talk about the impact on their brains of these, of this technology. Can we use it for that? I would, I would, I'd like to see that too as, as, you know,
I, I hate to turn away money. So that's my thought. Yeah, I just, um, coming back to the communication piece i'm sure there will be a lot of communication with parents as you've already mentioned and i just want to make sure that that we as parents get a lot of the details about the
the education piece too i would like to know exactly how that's going to be implemented into our curriculum as someone who's going to be a parent of a high school next year it's going to be really relevant to me all right we haven't made it to the superintendent report yet guys
you got more i got more you ready for number nine i don't even think we're done with number eight yet board meeting oh yeah so in your packets this is under his but i'll give him a break from talking so much um blue sheet is the board meeting schedule for next year a couple of things
of notes um a similar a similar uh schedule of meetings to this year uh august 26th is the board retreat uh just a reminder to folks it starts at four we do start that earlier and this year it's uh it's going to be at the smith center um here here in greeport um and uh so if folks want to get
that on their calendar um that's the monday excuse me that's the wednesday before the week that school starts for students um and then everything else is pretty consistent the other thing i'll point out because it alternates each year is the annual budget meeting next year will be held at durham
because it was at freeport high school this year we alternate back and forth between the durham community school and freeport high school and just for folks who may or may not be familiar we don't hold it in panel uh because that gym if we if everybody showed up it would not be big enough
to hold everybody i think that's probably an issue um we'd like to have we haven't lately but But so we just alternate back and forth between FHS and DCS. Any comments or questions on those? Yeah, no less. Not about this schedule, but I just want to point out when you're doing the calendar for next year, putting graduation in the Durham town meeting on the same day is not a good look. Well, it wasn't supposed to be. I mean, we're always doing it on a Sunday, and there was an issue with the Merrill, so it had to move to a Saturday. I'm just asking that next year you not do the same thing. Yeah, that's already been actually determined. That's already, I think, on the calendar, for the student calendar. Yeah, no, it's unfortunate that that had to happen. But it's also the first year we've had the Durham community meeting. It's not something they've typically had to schedule around, because this is the first year they've done it in June,
because it's always been in April. So, I know. It's basically a year now from July to June. I know that, but this is the first year that it's that. This is the first time we've had our town meeting in June and not in April.
So, yes, I'm not sure the last time I missed a town meeting, but unfortunately I'll be at graduation. But, yes, noted. How many of the rest of you will get to have your birthday on a board meeting? There's one bonus of a July birthday. It doesn't happen. Oh, see? Wait, you're a St. Patrick's Day baby? Oh, that's fine. No. Can you mark that on the second one? Moon Day. Oh, moon has an election. He's got to win before he's here on his birthday. Okay, that's true. It's still his birthday. Good point.
I can probably almost guarantee we will not be here on his birthday. Whoever the other person is, it's like, that's your day. All right. Any other comments or questions on the board meeting schedule for next year? Okay. So now we've hit everything in here. Okay. Now we'll move on to administrator reports, which is you yeah i'm gonna i'm gonna represent for kelly tonight who couldn't be here um so with
regard to finance the report in tonight's packet includes revenues and expenses through april 30th and we are largely on par with last year um we are watching article six which is system administration very closely and we expect this article to go over and that's mostly because of
a three month overlap with Gene Scarappa and me at the beginning of the year. We have also had higher than expected legal fees this year. So we will be reviewing the movement of funds from one article to another, likely from article one, which is regular instruction, at the September meeting
once all the expenditures from this fiscal year are finalized. For those who aren't familiar, The board can approve moving money from one article to another. It requires a board vote. Actually, it doesn't require a board vote. The Finance Committee does it. The Finance Committee, sorry. Yes. And we usually do it by June 30. So I don't know if we want to check with Kelly on that. Well, she wrote this for me. Okay. Maybe she changed how she's doing it. It's historically done it at the very end. We talked about it this morning, she just said she'd like to see how it settles out okay that's fine um questions on that report
all right so we will move on to item 10 uh board comments and committee reports the information exchange agenda requests i will remind folks that are attending graduation your tickets should be in your purple folder tonight so don't forget to bring those home although
they'll probably be in your folder next week which is still before graduation so but all right so then we will move on to uh facilities the facilities and operations committee met on wednesday may 6th in the freeport high school library and we had in attendance a
robust a group from the community who was interested in our freeport high school tennis court update uh at this at that time director glenn Reynolds gave us the core sample reports and we um also discuss together the tentative timeline for installing the new courts which will be updated
and we will discuss them at the board level once we have more information about the specific design plans. We had several like I said several members from the community our tennis coach Molly Meyer several other people interested in helping fund and interested in the
tennis season next year, shared the difficulty of not having the playable courts here at the high school and some of the challenges that they've had, scheduling the practices and games off-site. So we've talked about how we can keep this process moving forward as quickly
as possible so we can get them back on the courts and playing as much as possible as soon as we can. We talked about the possibility of fundraising so that we can add an additional fourth court, which will help get more kids out and playing more frequently and also keep the matches moving and ending sooner.
Our board chair, Michelle, asked Director of Units to get a cost estimate for two complete sets of design plans and bit specs for both asphalt and post tension concrete options and we also requested an updated firmer timeline for the
installation of the post tension quartz so that we would have more information that might help guide whether or not we might have time to get them in by the next 10th season in the spring um and let's see um yeah so after all was said and done we decided as a committee to recommend
installing the four post-tension courts um and we heard we will be hearing soon about uh more uh timeline about how that will be coming coming to pass soon yeah um energy audit phase one Glenn gave us an update that the lighting projects about 70 percent completed at the mass
naming school and the next the next part well it actually is done now but as of this community meeting it was expected to be done in the next two or three weeks and then as of this meeting they were to start in the Freeport High School next which they have now been done. Also we had
some repairs to the upstairs restroom in the Freeport Middle School. They had to close it for a little while while they installed a new floor, and that is now complete. So that's my report. Lois. My takeaway from an email that we got from Molly Myers today,
I don't know, in the last couple days, either today or yesterday, was that no decision had been made on what kind of courts we were going to go forward with. And I had the feeling that what she was saying was to go with the less expensive one,
not the post-tension one. I think what she was, she basically wants us to get this process moving forward as quickly as possible. Yeah, and so the thinking was that if we do the asphalt courts, we wouldn't have to have the permitting process, which might...
And also it's potentially fundraising. Right, the fundraising piece. So the hope is that with the asphalt courts, we may not have to wait to get the money, which may not be a concern. It's more that to do three courts would not require as much permitting,
because if we do only three courts, that's replacing what we have. It's not adding more, and it wouldn't require the permitting process that adding a fourth court would. So the tradeoff is you might gain a little extra time,
although at tonight's facilities committee meeting, it doesn't look like it would prevent us from having to find other options for the spring season anyway. Well, we did get an updated timeline on our committee tonight, And it's like the estimate is like a month apart for the three versus the four court option.
Actually, yeah, it really wasn't material. So I think, and I don't want to misrepresent Molly's perspective, but I think Molly's concern is that if we said, geez, we want to do post-tension, and that might be a million two to do four courts. I think she's very much in favor of four courts. We need that for the program to run smoothly.
And unless the board is kind of ready to commit to covering the difference between what we already have approved and what four post-tension courts might come in at, she's afraid that if we only moved forward with that and then we couldn't come up with the 500, then we lose time and go backwards and have to go rebid and find another solution.
And I think her goal is how expeditiously can we get four courts in? And if that means they have to be asphalt, then so be it, I think is kind of the thought process. But we have a little bit more to talk about on that with a later item, so we'll give you a little bit more detail.
Do you, and you might not know this, I know that Glenn's not here. Do you remember, was it asbestos that was in the subfloor? It was asbestos. In the tiling. In the subfloor, in the subfloor, yeah. That's where I thought, I just wanted to confirm. Yeah, so they had to shut it down, did the abatement, and then retiled the bathroom.
Did you have a question, Anna? I think I'll hold off. We talk about more about tennis courts. Okay. But just to be clear, the asbestos was embedded in the mastic. It's not something that the kids were exposed to at any point.
okay so finance committee I have two meeting minute reports here in the package front and back we met on April 29th and this was our annual audit presentation where Marge Hall from lawyer associates comes and presents the
financial audit for the district to the finance committee which is which is always great time love when Marge comes and visits and there were no I would say one highlight for me is there were no um there were no management notes uh to the district around
major issues that they found which was great um things went really smoothly and they have already scheduled the dates uh when the cpa will be back to start the work for the 6 30 26 audit um they will be there on september 28th so that was the audit presentation and then we had a special
finance committee meeting on friday may 8th one of the things the finance committee did this year undertook this year was sending out a property and casualty insurance to bid and i think we've we've mentioned that process a few times throughout the year the may 8th meeting was the actual
opening of the the proposals from the two uh from the two companies that provided um proposals for the district um the um committee um scored and uh voted on um scored on the uh the rubric that was developed um for the packages for the two um i did not vote um i did not score i did not vote i am
was asked to join the trust because it's a, our current provider is the MSMA Property and Casualty Trust, which I am a trustee of. So I did not, I did not involve myself in the process to keep it hands off. And so the other two members and Tom and Kelly were, were scorers and, and the
uh the vote was made um and approved to stay with msma at this time um so kelly let everybody know about those results and um and that was pretty much that was because it was a special meeting that was all that was for was that opening of those insurance um bids questions on that okay
all right so our next committee report is the stipend committee so that you can that's me okay um so cara and i were the board members that attended along with the other committee members and the superintendent and eric hall the athletic director was our guest
to discuss um rationale for two of the state the two stipends that are on our agenda for later in meeting uh the two are the unified that unified basketball is currently being funded through a grant and approval of this stipend would allow the district to pay the coaches retroactively
and going forward if we keep unified basketball as a sport we would need to budget for the stipends going forward and then the second stipend is middle school swimming that had over 50 students express interest and this has been handled through the community programming and the
RSC5 community programs in the past. Handling it through the school would remove pay barriers for students. And it was noted that with so many students, an assistant coach might be necessary, even though it's not currently budgeted. So if it's determined that we need an assistant coach,
depending on the number of students, it will have to go through the stipend review process again. And the committee supported sending both of the stipends to the board as presented. So that's it's on our agenda okay all right who's next curriculum and program developments um so we
met i think i'm presenting on both our april and may meeting yep um so we met on april 29th myself karen lois tom was there as well as our guest kate mcgallicott who's here today um and we nominated a chair, which was determined to be me. Which was exciting. Thank you.
And we started off by discussing the purpose of the curriculum committee. There was some confusion both by myself as well as another board member, particularly because the current purpose that's on the RSU 5 website didn't seem necessarily accurate of the work we'd
been doing this school year where we've been meeting monthly. And Superintendent Gray clarified possible roles for the committee in its work with curriculum and assessment. He shared examples from his previous experience with curriculum committees in other districts. And we discussed also Lois
shared that when she was a teacher in RSU 5, which was up to 2012, teachers had more autonomy with curriculum than they presently have. So based on this discussion, it was decided that I would draft a new purpose. And also it kind of dovetailed into another conversation that the committee
expressed a desire to, I would say, a little bit different than what's noted here, is to examine the different organizational structures of committees and look at whether we think it's best for the Curriculum and Program Development Committee to remain as an other committee,
which it is right now, or to move to a standing committee, which is what most of our committees are. We also discussed the potential to include regular representation from administrators, teachers, and parents. And we established the following priority areas for next year.
We would continue curriculum work in math, which was the curriculum work for this school year. We wanted to look closely at practices in literacy instruction, particularly in early literacy. And we wanted to examine the role of technology in the student experience. And then in May,
We met again, and I presented on some of the research I did, or just talked about really the research I did in terms of the purpose of Curriculum Committee as well as the organizational structure in other districts. Not surprisingly, there's a full spectrum. I presented a drafts purpose statement for the committee to review.
The new draft emphasizes transparency, communication, and the role of the board in the area of curriculum. I underscored my respect that I hold for teachers, as well as building administrators, and a desire to make sure that the board respects educators as our curriculum experts.
And the committee discussed the value of having teacher representation and voice as part of its work, and we emphasized the importance of curiosity and taking the stance of learners. And the committee reviewed the purpose statement draft and suggested some revisions, which we will take to the Board of Directors.
And then Superintendent Gray recommended that at the next meeting, the committee review policies, BDE, Board of Directors Standing Committees, and BDF, Advisory Committees, to inform our ongoing discussion about the purpose and structure of the Curriculum and Program Development Committee.
And that was agreed. And then, really, it's our aim that early next school year, the curriculum committee will bring to the board a drafted new purpose statement, as well as recommendations on whether we think the committee should remain an other committee or if it should be moved to a standing committee. That's all. I just want to say thank you for all of that work
because I know that's been sort of a... Since I joined, that was something that was a little bit... uh maybe in a blind spot i think just in terms of how that committee was functioning and overseeing and sort of the interface between the administration and the board so just uh it's just really exciting to see everything that you're doing and that so thank you so much to you anna and all because you're the board you're the chair you're the chair uh and there's a lot of responsibility with
that and don't feel the burden of it at all just think about it as power I want to echo some of Colin's remarks. When you said that is all, I snickered because that was a lot. So I just want to acknowledge the committee on, like,
it sounds like two extremely productive meetings. Yeah, because this is a relatively new committee. Like, I mean, this was formed two years ago. So, yeah, we didn't have this committee previous to that. So in the spirit of evolving as needs evolve, there you go.
That's what it's doing. In your research and robust presentation, do most boards have curriculum committees? I would say yes, they do. It's really interesting to see. I would say a lot of them are standing committees. Some of them are others. Some of them are advisory. a lot of districts don't organize their committees by the way we do like ad hoc
or no we do advisory standing and other yeah so most that I found they don't do that organizational thing and it's like these are our committees in Maine in my robust presentation slideshow everything no just kidding All right, policy, Jim.
We had a very robust conversation at our last meeting about, actually, I'm going to amend that. We did not, it turns out, we did not have as robust a conversation about policy IJJ as we might have. So we were looking at, we had brought this to you before for first read, selection of educational materials, and y'all gave us some really good feedback on that, and we came back and did some work with that,
which we thought was robust. And between that reading and today, we just got some additional feedback from some of our library specialists that I think is worth talking about, is very important to talk about tonight. And so in a couple of moments, when we actually talk about the...
current policy and then some of the concerns that were raised um about about it um we'll just sort of get into that but i think i just i think i will i'll just say in the context of the meeting i think i just want to take um i want to take responsibility as the um the policy chair for
um not more directly engaging the library staff um sort of through that process uh there are hasn't been thinking it through their reasons for that, but that was very much an oversight in order to take ownership of that mistake. So I'm going to put a motion on the floor of relieving those ones in for tonight? For the second read? Yes? Okay, great. All right, so do I have a motion for consideration and approval for second read for the following policies?
IHBAC, child find. IMBB, exemption from required instruction. IJJ, instruction, excuse me, Instructional and Library Media Materials Selection, IJJE, Citizens Challenge of Educational Media Forum, JRA, Student Education Records and Information, JRAE, Annual Notice of Student Education Records and Information Rights. Kelly and Karen, thank you.
So as Michelle said, we're bringing all these before you for a second read. Other than IJJ, we have not made any changes to those other policies since you saw them last. So I will pause here for any thoughts or feelings about policies other than IJJ.
You can say them later too, but this is now the special time. So for IJJ, what we, and Tom and Chris and Kara in absentia in Washington, D.C., please jump in as appropriate. Most of our conversation had to do with what we find on pages 2 and 3 in terms of that list of the criteria for selection.
And we were thinking about sort of how, whether the criteria had to meet every criteria, had to meet some of the criteria, and so we did some tinkering. And the primary language tinker is at the bottom of page two, selection criteria that should be considered and claimed is the sort of the way in which we, in our discussion, determine sort of the, sort of how the board wants to be outlining what we want this process to include, but not to make it either a, it has to do all A through M of them,
or that it can be, you know, like has to meet five or something like that. Let me just pause on that. Chris and Tom, is that relatively accurate? Okay. So let me just pause on that. Does that make sense to folks in terms of how we have altered that?
Okay. So I think I just want to speak to the communication that we got um, um, from Heidi Cook, who's the library media specialist here at the high school. Um, and, uh, Heidi raises a number of questions around, um, so two aspects.
One is sort of the removal of language, um, that was, that was in the previous policy that, um, that was more, um, directly, um, articulating the districts, what I'm interpreting as the district's support for a robust library program and then
the other concern that she raised I'm gonna check my notes again just to make sure I'm not mischaracterizing with the only two what's had to do with who does that selection and what does that labor look like I think the first I think what
I would say is that I think this is I think when you're looking at this policy I mean the original title is instructional library media material selection so this is a this is a policy about the selection of materials and so when I at least was looking at it I wasn't looking
at it for our kind of philosophy of whether or not we support a library or not but that actually moves here right so if you look at the fourth paragraph on the original IJJ I'm just going to read from it. Quote, this is on page 1 of 7. Each school shall maintain a library media program that includes books and other print materials, multimedia materials, online internet resources, and information technology that support the curriculum. A certified library media specialist will be responsible for overseeing the school system's library media program under the supervision of the superintendent, etc.
But I think what our revision does not include is effectively sort of that sort of declaration of that. I suppose one question that when I got Heidi's notes raised for me is whether there needs to be some other policy that more directly addresses our support for the library program, because this is not what that policy is meant to do.
This is meant to address the selection process, but I very much agreed with, and currently agreed, not just in the past tense, I agree with Holly that the removal of that language, I think, does weaken, I think, the way in which the district is articulating its commitment to maintaining robust library services.
And I think there's a variety of contexts for that, but I think that there definitely are, we're seeing nationally, cuts to library services, as well as there's some relatively famous instances of this happening at the state level here in Maine, where entire libraries are being deaccessioned and losing all of their physical texts.
So, I wanted to share that and share my sort of reflections on that particular aspect. Before we move on to Heidi's other concern around selection, I guess I just wanted to sort of open up the floor for a second for other thoughts on that.
I mean, is there another policy that addresses that? I mean, I'm not sure if you need to say, if there isn't one, do you need to create a whole new one? Or could you just add some language back to this one that just sort of reaffirms that?
Yeah, I mean, I think that's a little bit the question. And I don't really, and I, again, I did not have time to do research on this and sort of see whether there are, there is no other policy that I was able to find that addresses library services, per se.
And I don't know if such things exist. Does Chris know that information? Okay. But, so I think, for the meantime, I think that I probably would be supportive of putting some of that language back into this particular document, and then perhaps just looking, perhaps within, or certainly in consultation with a labor media specialist, to just think about how we're supporting the labor system more generally.
I was going to say, I think, like, in thinking about it from a policy lens, the support for a library media program is not a policy. That wouldn't live in a policy. So while I do understand the critique of it, that we took that out, one, it wasn't intentionally taking that out.
At least I didn't feel that way. but it it doesn't feel like it would weaken our library program because i don't i mean if we were to create a policy that says we as a district like libraries like that doesn't seem like that
would that would fit with any of the rest of the policies that i've seen yeah i mean again i haven't looked i haven't looked into this deeply but i think that there is i think part of the way i would look at it is that it's a policy safeguard. So it would be that if, for
example, Tom in his, I guess in this case, finite wisdom, were to bring a proposal to us to say we want to cut physical libraries out of every school but panel, we could then refer to this document to say I think that's in
violation of this policy statement that we provide that. So I think it's not about so much about liking libraries, though. I do. It's more about sort of, again, I think it's more about how as when we're saying to Michelle's point that the schools are well run, that part of that
well running is including having libraries. This is the way I interpret it. I don't see a problem with adding some of this language back in just a sentence or two as a descriptor not necessarily as a prescriptive aspect of this policy but I don't really foresee this being a serious problem that
we will ever have an issue anybody's going to be talking about cutting libraries so I'm not really sure if it's necessary for us to add that language for that purpose but I think a sentence or two just to provide background isn't really going to hurt anything.
Michelle's not here, but... Thank you so much, Vice Chair. I would be supportive of adding that language back in. I don't think it diminishes to do so. I see her point of explicitly saying that we're going to have library specialists at each school.
That's somewhat prescriptive in terms of staffing and saying that we're going to offer this service as part of the library policy. So I think having that language in there maybe isn't the worst idea in the world. Yes, Tom. I think that we could pretty easily add at least the first two sentences of that fourth paragraph
back into the sort of preamble section, and it would not diminish the policy at all. You know, I think the major change that this provision does is summed up in what's done to the title, which it really broadens the scope of the policy from being just about library media materials
to how we select educational materials in general. A lot of the other changes are aimed at delineating that process. And I don't think that adding a few sentences that says, And part of that selection of materials naturally involves libraries and...
We like libraries. A place to put those materials. Um, I don't think that that can make it possible. I've been to send you guys like 45 emails of like all the sad stories of libraries getting bigs. No, I mean, no, like, you're gonna, you're gonna get it just like you got the really cool design thing.
What was it called? The, the, like, the bag, the bag, um... Bagology. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah, I appreciate that. I think from a process perspective, though, just for tonight, we could agree, or you could agree, if you wanted, you could pass this on second read with the provision that that be added back in or any other language changes that it doesn't need to prevent you from doing a second read.
no and i and i would agree with it i'll i'll say to my names that i assumed that schools had libraries and it just is something that they always had so i have no issue with putting those sentences so what you're saying is you're looking forward to receiving my emails well no i'm not looking forward to them because they're probably real events that i'd want to
happen but um i have no issue with adding some of that back in to have us have just a little policy protection in that way. Cool. Great. So I think if we will proceed, but brings that language back into the preamble. I think the other thing that just to flag from Heidi's communication is
that, maybe I should just read it rather than try to summarize it. So Heidi writes, quote, previously the language about personal evaluation read, quote, whenever possible purchase of print or non-part materials, multimedia, internet, and technology resources should be made only after personal evaluation by a library media specialist and or other appropriate professional staff. Reviewing aids may be used in the personal evaluation, end quote, of the policy.
Haya goes on, What does this proposed change in language mean for library media specialists ordering materials? Maintaining up-to-date and appealing library collection is a categorically different task from selecting textbooks and supplemental materials for direct instructional use.
is the expectation that each book should be physically or digitally reviewed, even if this were possible, where would this time come from? So I just wonder, again, I think that's a very valid question, so I just wanted to bring that, I suppose, primarily to you,
just to sort of see whether you had any initial thoughts on that, or whether... I have no problem with that suggestion. Just so that everyone is aware, we would never expect a library media specialist to read every single title that goes into the library. And they have metrics that they use, and there are reviewers, there are organizations that do this.
So it's not as if the books are just random. They are coming to our library media specialists through their networks, and they're recommended by authorities. So it would not be their responsibility to read every single book.
Just as it wouldn't be the algebra teacher's responsibility to read every single math problem in the new math textbook before we adopt a new math textbook. It's a really good problem. It's a really good math problem issue. I think her recommendation is that we, if I'm understanding correctly, is to put back in the language of whenever possible.
That would be fine. By my perspective, that would be fine. Yeah, because that allows that flexibility. I don't think it changes. I think we would just want to make sure that the addition of that language is only affecting the library media specialist selection process,
not the selection process more generally. Would you agree that that is true? I believe that I, hopefully I have summarized. Oh, no, and also she found a typo on page five. Turn your hymnals to page five. On Section B of Challenge Materials, in B it says if the complaint is not satisfied, meaning the person who had the problem, not the problem itself or the concern itself, which I think, again, we should do.
So thank you, Heidi, for catching that. That is the end of those particular comments. Anna. I really like a lot more now the criteria for selection. So thanks, Colin. The one question I had was, and I had asked this initially when we went for first read, but I don't see the word anywhere. Was there any thought behind why a word such as effective was not used?
Like, I see accurate, I see support student achievement, support the goals and objectives of the school system, but I don't see any whereabouts. I'm not sure if I remember talking about this or not, but there's certain library material that is not necessarily effective and that's not its intent or goal, like certain fiction books or things like that.
i know you had mentioned evidence-based at one point and we had discussed that and our kind of came to the conclusion that if it was accurate and current it would also be evidence-based because if it was not evidence-based it would not be accurate if that made sense that does make
sense but i think many people would disagree with that um i guess my because the bottom line says it's not expected that they address all criteria listed above it felt like well then effective should be in there. Evidence-based, I did say that. I feel like it might be a little
trickier, whereas effective, I think it's more of a general policy term that could be used. But I also appreciate if it felt like that wasn't needed, or if the other reason, the other criteria already captured that. Because we explain, this is not just library materials. This is all materials, yeah.
Yeah. I mean, I think I would just say ditto to what Chris said in terms of the database and accurate and current. That was the conversation we had. And I think, again, I think there's absolute conversation to be had there.
And yes, unfortunately, we do live now in a time when there's so many questions around how our country more broadly is having a conversation around how do we understand information, how do we understand accurate information, how do we understand factual information, how do we understand scientific information, how do we understand the difference between opinion and all of those other things.
So that is that. I think we didn't have a conversation that effective. I think I would, again, this would probably be something where I would put it, I would put that back to the educators. I'm looking at the first one, which says support student achievement of the content standards of the system of learning results.
I don't know, I guess my thought is I'm not sure how one, it seems like a harder thing to measure that it's effective versus that it supports. So, for example, and again, we're talking about sort of the range of different education materials, and I think the criteria that will be used in terms of a math textbook or, as our community member was talking about, in terms of sort of literacy or language acquisition, that's going to be different in terms of, like, how it does support it, the ways in which it supports it.
But again, I think that's, I would say, currently above my pay grade as a board member to say that that adding in effective would be helpful. It's just my honest answer to that. I'm curious if Tom's that alone. I just don't think it's necessary. I think it is implied in all of the other criteria that are listed there.
I do agree with Chris's point that there are some materials that we select that it's hard to apply the label effective to. Right, but that's why it says it doesn't have to be all of them, right? Like, we've already told that. Yeah, I guess I'm just thinking about, like, for example, if we were talking about the selection of a textbook dealing with the Holocaust, for example, right?
I don't think that, I just really wonder about whether, talking about the determined effectiveness of that book to be able to achieve acquisition of certain knowledge. I just don't think that's measurable in that way, where I think a language like support was. But again, I'm just saying that as a private citizen.
I think maybe why it's feeling important to me when I'm thinking about it is we have a lot of or we have some people in our community who we heard from a lot around the budget and then saying look our scores are going down and you're spending more and whether you know that's not actually parsing through the data but it just seems I don't know if disingenuous is the right word but like we have on here things like representing significant authors composers works from diverse groups all things that I very much believe in but then we don't have something like effective I mean, I understand we have things such as A and B and C, but I can see where people would, if they were looking at this, be like, well, where is the academic piece as much?
I mean, that's perfectly logical. Yeah, I just don't. I think, I guess what I might suggest for the purposes of this policy is that we don't add that language in currently, but that, I mean, quite honestly, that is like actually like a kind of curriculum kind of like, no, I'm not just like adding you, but like, no, I think that is one of the questions, right?
sort of like, how is it that we select materials to support the curriculum and the different goals that are laid out within each of the different, either within each of the different grades or the different subject areas, and how is it determined that certain resources
are quote-unquote effective or sufficient, or again, I think, I would just say I think Another lens through which I'm seeing it at the moment is when we select materials, we don't necessarily know how we're going to work with our kids when we select something at first. So it's easy to say how something would either A or B
support achievement of the content standards of the learning results or support the goals and objectives of our educational programs. It's harder to know. I'm not saying this very eloquently. We may not know how effective they are when we first try something, especially if it's something new. And especially if it's something that's like a book that's read
in one section of an English course. We wouldn't want to write this in a way that precludes our staff from trying new things. I think for me, because I was kind of feeling like maybe it needs to be in there, but Colin got me with his last point there. it seems more appropriate that our curriculum should be identified as effective, and the materials support that curriculum, which we have already predetermined
to be effective, or we wouldn't have chosen it. So I guess at the end of the day, I'm okay with how you have it written up. Well, I'm very grateful for the conversation, because I think that's a really important one, and I
appreciate, Anna, you also emphasizing, or just reminding us of the feedback that we've gotten from the community and some of those questions, which, as you say, are quite complex, and we have not fully addressed tonight. So just to be clear, we have not addressed those questions tonight. But yeah, thank you for raising that. With that said, if we're talking about a major curricular purchase, like, let's say, a literacy program that we're going to use across the board,
I would want to know that that's effective. That's different to me from the English teacher in the one section of AP Lit decides they're going to try a new novel this year, And there's not as easy a way to measure whether or not that particular novel is as effective.
And so this is talking about more individual materials, not general curriculum. This policy has to address all materials that we would select. Okay, got it. Thank you. That's satiating. So this policy does specifically not cover curriculum.
This policy covers things to enhance the curriculum. Yes, and it's all the curriculum. It really is. Every material we choose is the curriculum. I mean, I hear what you're saying, but in a broader sense, it's all the curriculum. No, so what I want to mean is that in the policy specifically, it says, you know, implement, extend, and enrich the curriculum and educational programs of the schools.
Yeah. Right, and this is not about the selection of curricula. Yeah. This document is not about the selection of curricula. Okay, so what we have in front of us with the adjustment to add back in a sentence about our commitment to maintaining libraries and fixing complainant.
Other than that, we are, oh, and the whenever possible. Those are the three adjustments to the policy from what you have in front of you. Okay, any other discussion or comments on these? Everyone comfortable with the adjustments as proposed? Because it's a second read, so once we vote on this, these become the policy.
Okay, so we have, and I'll give folks one more shot on any of the other policies that are also in the packet, but those haven't changed from our first read discussion of them. So I'm having a delayed response to your first part.
What I heard Carlin say was he made a mistake by not including the library media specialists in at least reviewing this. Not writing it, obviously, because that's not their job, but reviewing it. We're going to now take a vote on something that I don't believe we only have one library specialist.
I think we have four or maybe five. I'm just curious if you're feeling comfortable with moving forward, knowing that another library media specialist may have missed this topic and should be looped in before we vote this,
because I would be happy to make an amendment to pull IJJ out until next week when you've had the opportunity to have some discussions. Yeah, I think it's a really good question, Lois. I think where I'm at with it is that this being at second read
and the way this policy works with, what's the other policy? complaint one. IJJ-E. IJJ-E. I think my sense currently is that it's important that we get this language, that we get the policy on the books so that functionally, in terms of how
that operates, that that would be, um, in effect as of tomorrow. Um, I think what I, what I would say is that if, if we had, if there were any other concerns, um, uh, around, uh, any of the other language, um, I'd be, I'd be happy to commit us as a policy committee to reviewing that at the
beginning of the, beginning of the next school year in terms of, um, uh, would not, would not normally be on that regular cycle would be another five years, but as I said, because of that error, I'd be more than happy to say that's you know, if there are other concerns around that but I think it is important to pass it so that in terms of its functionality in the way that the students
and the families would be engaging with it I think that that's important to have operational tomorrow I guess what I would say to that does any sense? Or at least you've heard you say that excellent um i think part of it is an issue of time we don't have a
policy meeting between now and then we'd have to make one which is fine if that's what the board wants to do but um we were going to have one on friday but that's not going to work so it's it's in two weeks and then we don't have another meeting as board after that policy meeting until
the retreat in august so we couldn't bring it for second read until the retreat in august and we could not bring it we could not bring it for second read uh in august because too long of a time has passed we have to start with the first read um so i think that yeah to your point
i think that uh were we to decide which would be reasonable if we were to decide to as you say to pull it out um we would just we would not be able to have any new language about this on the books before the end of the year and yet what i believe i heard you say is that you're going to make the
changes that we're discussing right now and when it's put into policy those changes will have been made so we won't have seen it to vote on it what you're doing is tonight just in terms of the way in which we in terms of the policy review process is that if we say we're going to
make those changes we you are all saying make those changes and you approve those changes to be made okay so then I would like to clarify because I heard one person say the first two sentences of the paragraph um paragraph four on one of seven and I heard another person say a
sentence so what I've taken that's a good catch though it's sneaky what I've taken for notes is that we will add the first two sentences of the stricken fourth paragraph back into the preamble. We will put back in the language quote whenever possible when we're
talking about the library selection process and that we will fix the typo on page 5 about the word complainant. For perspective about process, we have through the course of this year, I think the policy committee folks will, this will resonate.
we're really making very good faith efforts to bring in constituents to talk about the impacts of the policy. I've also been working on a policy work plan for next year. One of the things that I took note of when I started here this year is that ideally we would want to be reviewing our
policies within five years, regularly reviewing. We have policies that have not been reviewed in over 10 years. And if we were to get to a place where all of our policies are on a regular five-year review cycle, we will need to approve five new policies a month for at least three more years.
So I'm just putting that out there that I don't want to fail to include feedback when we need it, And we need to also be as efficient as possible. So all of that aside, you as a board have to be comfortable with where every policy that's in front of you lands. So we offer that in the spirit of trying to create a whole context for you.
Yeah, so you've gotten feedback from one library media specialist. Can you just remind the board the source of the rest of these changes? Where did they originate, or what kind of feedback? Where we start is always with an updated sample policy from Drummond-Woodson.
Sometimes from MSMA, the Drummond-Woodson policies tend to be more current. And then we look at how that compares to our existing policy, and we modify it as we deem necessary. But that's where we always start. Right, so I assume the language in this one probably came from the MSMA sample policy,
probably not so much from Drummond Woodson, but the MSMA... From both, okay. Oh, this was from Drummond, okay. And how that language was informed was from specialists somewhere. They're always looking at the latest case law. Right. The statute of case law. Yeah, and I think what we find when we go back and look at policies that we've reviewed,
we will just find places where we have put a bunch of extra stuff in that doesn't pertain to the law. And that, I think, is what's here. Again, I think the misstep, I think, was what we tried to do is to look at the updated language and to see whether either substantively or conceptually there are things that we have developed about our own district
that that policy does not honor. And so I would say that the mistake here, I think, was that we sort of didn't, I don't think we paid it in addition to not drawing these particular specialists in, It was just sort of, I think, we weren't looking for that particular aspect of the distinction between library materials and instructional materials.
We just weren't looking for that, because that is generally not what this IJJ is intended to do. So we just weren't looking for that. So it's not that the other one is not any more, it's less legal. It's less equally accurate than this one, but the other one has more, the one that we
had before had a bit more of elements of the board's articulated spirit of how it should be executed. I guess for me, you know, I think it's a good compromise that if the board is comfortable with the policy before us with those three adjustments, and you will check in with the
other media specialists and if if there were concerns or things that weren't addressed that you were committed to putting it back on at the beginning of next year which is really the earliest we could get to it if we postponed it from today um i think that's a that's a good
compromise okay so we have a motion on the floor for a second read for all of these policies together um and we shall take a vote all those in favor post okay thank you lois did you vote against she did you voted for oh you did okay okay so item 12 uh unfinished business um we'll
get a motion on the floor and then we'll talk about it do i have a motion for consideration and approval to expend up to an additional five thousand dollars from the capital projects reserve fund for the design of four tennis courts plans to include both post-tension and asphalt options
Malik thank you and Kelly okay so this is kind of what we talked about with the facilities uh committee um limits um there's there's been a lot of discussion uh we got initial costs and drawings uh for both three and four courts three is what we have today four is kind of um
sort of the minimum of what most high schools are having to run a successful meet um and the two options are around asphalt which is what we currently have and post-tension so post-tension um historically has been a higher level product that had from what we had originally started
hearing was um very much more costly than the asphalt um when we sent out the um uh the proposal for drawings and initial estimates those cost differentials were much smaller than we anticipated so somewhere in the one to two hundred thousand dollar range for four courts but we are still hearing that there is a
there could be a significant difference between asphalt and and post tension and so in an effort to make sure that we have the best and most complete information available to us, what this request does is it allows us to have the firm who's
preparing the drawings prepare both a asphalt design as well as a post-tension design. And the reason they're different is because the groundwork underneath them is different. They're different structurally. So the plans would be different. So this way we could send them both
out and get an actual number, not just what one person says or another company says, but actual, you know, bids, and have the best available information to make a decision. You know, whether they're $100,000 difference for the two courts is very different than if they're $500,000
different, right? Because there is a significant amount of maintenance savings for one of the two over the life of the courts which would probably be made up for an additional 100 000 but might not be made up for an additional 500 000 so this would give us the ability to know chris so i've
i've thought a lot about these tennis courts specifically because they are so expensive in my head um i feel like we're putting the cart before the horse here i think as a board we have some estimates right they might not be specific estimates but they're at least estimates we've
already put 40 grand to that and is there a reason we didn't like i guess my assumption was that we were going to get designs to get estimates with the 40 grand what did we get for the 40 grand if we didn't get designs to get estimates so the 40 grand includes what we've already gotten to date
plus they are also managing the process on the back end so they are not done with what they've done so far right but the quotes that i saw have like like of the 680 000 250 000 is materials and labor the rest is management well it's also the construction of like because we have a the company
that we hired is not putting in the right that's the management piece and they're covered in the initial um the the quotes that we have for the others is you know there's a fair amount of contingency in there because they are early estimates right um because we don't have full
plans to to price and um and also the contingency and the profit for the builder right so that's that's kind of the piece i think that you're seeing on those lines um i lost i lost my thread so i kind of feel that before we spend more money to have more thoughts we should decide kind of as
board do we want to expand to four or do we not understanding that it is going to cost us more money either way um and instead of spending more money on something if we all decide that we actually are good with three and we want three i actually thought we'd already made that decision
to go yeah it wasn't out of it yeah yeah that was probably a month ago yeah yeah we'd have to go back and we've had so many meetings um yeah because we definitely had that conversation at the committee level it was at the committee level yes so that's not a board decision that's
a committee decision we didn't um the estimate that we approved in the budget was seven hundred thousand which is for three courts and almost certainly no that one hundred percent is so what we said was was we we made sure that there was enough to replace the existing courts in the
budget absent any fundraising grant opportunities because USTA yeah has grant opportunities which are in fact higher if you add like a new courts you get more money from them for those and the the consensus of both all of the
all of the coaches that we have for tennis that are involved in the in the program as well. Three is really inadequate from what we've been told. And so the committee said, I thought we voted on it as a board. Yeah, okay. But the direction that we gave CHA was to start
working on the plans for four. So should we choose whether we're voting for four or three before we decide to send money to put towards four well i mean the money is to have two sets of plans so um so okay so here's where i come from i i don't know how tennis works i don't know
how that works you you talked about how it's inadequate with three um when i looked at at some of the local high schools um there's a fair number of them that have four courts there's a fair number of them have less and you know we have that cohort of eight and there's there's
some at the bottom and some at the top and some of them have two and some of them have four i don't think you could even have a match with two if you had a team okay um i'm just trying to find the list because actually molly just sent us an updated list that we already had and i realized
they're they're my my kind of thought is that it makes sense to spend money so we don't have to spend money later and the post-tension seems like it does last a lot longer from my research but going from three to four then is four hundred thousand dollars more it's fifty percent more
going from eight hundred to one point two and that doesn't feel like we get the value there for which one for post-tension so in my mind i would vote for three post-tension which is why i kind of bring this up as like a but why are we spending money towards something that i would
advocate for it necessarily um and that's kind of why i said do we need to decide on three or four before we spend more money to think if that makes sense yeah i guess from the coach's perspective what they're seeing is they're seeing a lot more interest in the program but with only three courts
it's it's really difficult to get kids actually playing matches unless they're really at the top the ladder so if you have an extra court you can get more kids actually in the game playing the matches and the actual matches just they're a more reasonable length so it's it's really more
of a logistics and it's kind of an equity issue something that allows more kids to participate and then you know hopefully going forward they they want to see the program expand even further So, you know, if you're limiting the number of kids that can participate, you can't really keep growing the program if you can't put more kids on the court.
So I think that was one of my biggest concerns about not having the fourth court. Do you know how many kids are in the program currently? I don't, it's, it's over 30. I don't remember the exact number. And that's the high school and there's also middle school and community programs uses the courts.
The gist of those conversations around the three versus four that I remember was that, certainly you're right, Chris, that the biggest difference in cost was not going, we were somewhat surprised. It wasn't going from asphalt to post-tension. It was going from three to four. There is, I'm not a tennis player. Everything we're hearing is that there's a lot more functionality that they get by having four and a lot more kids that they can serve.
And part of the conversation was this is sort of a generational moment to choose the tennis courts we'll have for a long time, whether it's three or four or asphalt or post-tension. And we have used in the budget that hopefully will be approved by the voters,
we're using undesignated fund balance to ensure that at least we can replace what we have with the same exact thing, three asphalt. Some of the questions that went beyond that, though, is if we want to increase that to go for and or post-tension, how much can we count on for fundraising?
How much can we count on from the USTA grant? And what does the timeline look like? And I think that's the most recent piece of information that we wanted to try to nail down, because there was some question about whether if we stuck with asphalt in particular,
would that, and if we stuck with only three courts, would that make the permitting process take less time so that we'd have a better chance to run a season next year? What we've just recently found out is that probably not. So probably no matter what we're looking at, whether we go with three or four, or asphalt or post-tension, we're probably looking at still not being able to use the courts next year.
So that's not as much of a factor. And it really just does boil down to what gives us the most functionality for the longest period of time within what we feel we can afford. And that was one of the reasons to try and be able to get both, because we were hearing very different numbers around asphalt from CHA versus others.
Right. And, you know, that seems to be the reach that this would help us determine. So we clearly have a tennis coach watching. So she says there are no area high schools that have two courts. The only local high school that has three other than us is NYA, which is a class D school, I believe.
And there are 28 girls and 15 to 20 boys in the high school program right now. So I feel like that's worth it. Yeah, and I would just add in the middle school program, just because middle schoolers tend to need a little more corralling than high schoolers.
We've capped it at basically the number that can play on the courts at any given time. So having a fourth court is going to really help the high school program develop because we'll be able to get more middle schoolers out on the courts developing their skills before they hit the high school too. So the class B schools that we play in most of our sports, Yarmouth has four, Greenlee has four, Lake Region has four, York has three and two.
They're slightly separated, but they use both. Wayne Fleet, which is Class C, has four. Morse has four. So, I mean, that seems to be pretty consistent. Do they? But in comparing ourselves to the cohort of eight, that's all the ones that are above us in the cohort of eight, right?
But if you look at Lisbon, which has two... Lisbon is not in our cohort of eight. Is it not? No. Mount Ararat is, Brunswick is, Mount Ararat, Brunswick, Gray New Gloucester. I could not find Gray New Gloucester's courts, but... I'm not sure they have a tennis program, I don't know. They don't have any at the high school, at least. Okay. But I don't know if they have a program, so that could be why. Picturing their high school, I can't picture any tennis courts, but...
I don't have any problem, $5,000 is not that much, really. I don't have any problem doing this, but I guess I just want to state that I don't feel like the board has talked about three versus four as a board. I think that's important to me. And also
$400,000 is a substantial difference in cost. And so I think that that's just something that we have to keep in mind. I don't know what I would vote on that right now, but that feels like a substantial amount of money. Yeah, and part of I think what we're facing is trying to get the
information so that we could get nailed down a number so we know what that number is to see is is it attainable is it not um i think the other thing around the timing i think there was some interest like if we knew we could get three in place by next year maybe it's worth it to not
miss another season um but we're going to miss it sounds like we're going to miss that other season anyway so let's let's look at three versus let's look at four and if those come in like wow we can't do that there's nothing that says we have to take any of it like we can not um and and revisit it
but um yeah yeah i think from my understanding we were thinking about this in the committee we were really thinking about it in terms of the money and what we would need to do in order to get the money you know if we needed to come to the board to ask for money for the four courts versus the
three courts that would be a board vote um but you know i think the discussion was we've already approved the 750,000 as a board and if we needed more money and we needed to come back to the board for that money we would do it at that time or we may find other sources for the money.
So just to make sure you understand we don't yet know the clear difference between the cost between post-tension and asphalt until we get these poorer sketches which is why we're being us or the 5,000 that's correct and then how much longer will it take if we do these sketches yeah
in terms of the the amount of time between the asphalt and the post-tension we're looking at like a month it's not going to be a lot for the sketches oh for the sketches for the design no the design will be the same to get two sketches versus one yeah they've already started on the
post-tension. So we have like sort of preliminary, right? So what we're asking them to do is to take those preliminary two that they looked at and gave us small, like gave us estimates, which we kind of expected to come in like double for the post-tension and they didn't, right? We kind of
thought the post-tension was going to come in double and we'd be like, well, that's too expensive. Just take that off the table. What they brought to us was not that significantly different. um so basically what we're saying is is to really nail down what the difference is we we really need
to send two packages out to bid and see what we get back from actual vendors on the you know on the project that we said this is build this and then they'll tell us what they can build it for and then we know which one which way to go do we know at what point i don't know it does seem that
way um at what point we can and i don't even know if it's already happened apply start applying for these grants so that we can maybe have some ideas of backfilling some of this money or um because i mean i echo the concerns about i mean i suspected this when it came the first time is
if it was 400 that it would be at least twice because my husband's in the trades and i know how trades pricing is right now um so that's not shocking to me in any way i mean it sucks to be right um but is there a way that we can figure out how much potentially we can take off the top
i mean i think i would feel a lot better knowing okay yes the estimate's 1.2 but we've secured the usta has said that they would give us one or two okay 200k whatever amount and maybe i would feel better about an investment because i agree that post tension i feel very similar to chris
that post tension seems like a no-brainer to me because of all of the nice things that we've heard about it in terms of like we have these horrible pockets because asphalt is not great for our climate and that post tension would hold up better and um that's very attractive for a long-term goal
like i consider that an investment not um like i don't want to say a sinkhole but like asphalt seems like we would be constantly maintaining it like our rubber out on the field where every year we're looking for dead spots and trying to kind of catch up to to ways that's failing and post
attention sounds like the dream and so i'm willing to invest in the dream but then when you add another third because we want another quarter um i it it sounds harder for me it's harder for me to get there and i i really want to invest but also it's harder for me to get there but that's why
we're getting the information right that's what's going to help us make those decisions that's what the $5,000 is for, so that we know whether we're talking $500,000 or $100,000 to commit that upgrade. And I just want to answer your question about the grant. They will take the grant request once we
have construction docs, of course, because they want to make sure that we're building them well and that they're not giving us grant money. But what we have been told is, I think for four courts, we would be eligible for up to $125,000. Is that right? That sounds about right. Between $100,000 and $125,000, I think. I think it depends on who else applies, how much money is available and how many people they have projects to dish it out to.
Yeah, I think where I'm at is that I'd like the process to keep moving forward. I want us to get to having courts for our students as soon as we can. So I think if the vote tonight is about keeping that process rolling and putting ourselves in the best position to make a decision between, I think it's three options. It's between the three post-tension, four concrete, and four post-tension. If it puts us in a position where we really know how to make that decision and that we can then evaluate that and it will have no impact on the uh the timeline of of like short minimal impact um on when the uh science um it will have
it will have minimal impact on when the students will actually be be able to play with them then i'm i'm more for having that additional information because i like i mean again i see i see all of the arguments but i think i i would rather have more information than less yeah because i mean what we
are hearing is, you know, one of the numbers we're hearing is that we can do four courts asphalt for $800,000, right, which essentially is what we have with the grant. That's different than what CHA was saying, but we won't know that until we actually send it out to BIP. Did you have another
question, Chris? Oh, yeah, Malik. I was basically going to say what Colin said, but he said it much more eloquently than me, so thank you, Colin. Ditto to Colin. No, I think all we're deciding tonight is whether we're going to kind of continue that process we're not making a decision on three
or four or what we're going to pay to build those it's just two i will say it's leaning us towards four like i don't want to be disingenuous in saying that you know we can always go back to three if we want to what we will be getting is two sets of plans one for four uh post-tension
and one for four asphalt the facilities committee along with everyone who has been involved from the tennis program has stated that really four courts is what we need to be doing and I think the committee agrees with that so I just want to throw it out there that you know if if the majority of the board feels like no no three is plenty then we should probably pause and like change
that um i wouldn't encourage it but so just to clarify the preference of the committee and everyone involved would be four asphalt over three post tension absolutely okay yeah i mean like i said seth you know there's nothing that says we have to take a bit if we get it like if they both
come in way high and we're like nope um we can revisit and say okay now you know probably another $5,000 to get a set of plans for the three. But, you know, it is what it is. If it saves us $400,000 from not doing the other one, then maybe we'd have to do that. I mean, no options come off the
table for the board. It would sort of change the timelines to do that, though. Thanks for clarifying. I'm sorry if I missed out my step, Tom. No, I don't think you did. I just wanted, I just, I didn't want it to come back and, you know. It's all been really clear stuff. I mean, just everything is just really,
It's been like robust presentations. Hey, can we go back to your policy where you're like crossing things out and writing things in in the moment? As I said, we're robust right there. Yeah, okay. Other discussion? Questions we can answer in the meantime? Okay. I do think it creates a little timing question
about how we move forward with a decision if they come in over the summer. Ooh, good question, yeah. If we get to an inflection point where we need to make a decision on that, You guys interested in coming in for a meeting over the summer? If it's for tennis. Lois is like, I'm out. Can't have them all the time school. Ours are currently down, so no. So what the board would really need to come in for
is if we needed to expend more money for the construction of the courts. Or enter into the contract on which way we wanted to go. Which would be a money issue. Yeah, yeah, which I imagine it would be. But if you guys are saying that, not that we've decided, but effectively that we've decided
that for, we're going to be expending more money. Potentially. Once we get the bids, if we can get the 800 and we qualify for the grant, then maybe we're good. Is it just the finance committee that is going to choose the difference between the asphalt
versus post-tension? Well, that's what I'm saying. That would be the discussion, yeah. Because most likely the asphalt, let's say, let's say a scenario where the asphalt does come in under but the the post-tension doesn't i mean how does that work i i would say you know
if if ask for asphalt came in at 800 and post-tension came in at the million two they expected while i'm pretty confident how the board would feel about that i probably wouldn't feel comfortable making that decision at the facilities committee so we would probably come back and have that conversation but is there is there a world in which if we said uh which i don't think we should
but if we did say tonight let's just go with three like would we do we have time to vote on like can that move forward without an additional vote before the summer like are we ready to go i don't think so so it's either it's either way either way you have to have some sort of meeting
to approve it so i think that's an important point to make i think so yeah if we want to make a tennis court or four or three we need to have another meeting sometime it's pretty big yeah like that Someday we'll have a meeting, yes. It, you know, yeah, I think speed is, you know, is of the essence here to try and get these things moving to limit the amount of time that we are without courts because we are essentially already past the date where we could have them in place for next spring. I mean, the timeline we got today... Yeah, the timeline that we got today, they're looking at a bidding process in August.
I'm assuming that's when they'll go out to bid. and construction they're estimating october 2026 to august 2027 so if we had a vote in august i'm not really sure that it would be before our retreat yeah i mean we'll have a better
sense once they go out to big because then we'll know when they are due back um so it could be that our first meeting in september which is conveniently right here uh september 9th might be enough to not need to have another meeting so depending on when in august it comes back okay
everyone sufficiently confused this is always a great way to start a vote no i just want to make sure people are comfortable with what the request is for and what the deliverables of that will be i just want to know that i i don't want the finance committee to make a $400,000 choice
without coming back to the board. You said most likely we wouldn't, but I just don't understand. We don't have the ability to. We are not authorized to make such a decision. I just wanted to clarify that for the public. But you do have the ability, if the Asphalt 4 comes in under 750,
to make that choice. I don't think so. I mean, we would need to, I think, this is where I wish Kelly were here, in terms of entering into the contract for it, I think it would need to be a board vote for any. I commit to all of you that I will not sign a contract for any tennis courts ever, um, without getting your okay.
So, save, yeah, which I was going to say, I would never sign it anyway, it would never be me, it would be him, but I just wanted to make that clear for now. All right, oh my, okay. Um, all right, so, uh, we have a motion, we have a second.
All those in favor? Opposed? None. Thank you. Uh, this is you. Yeah? Yeah. Okay. This is going to be super quick, right? I mean, it'll be as quick as you all want it to be. Oh, no. So, in follow-up to the weighted values discussion that you have regarding district configuration,
you will find the results of that discussion tabulated in your packet, and I'll just take a moment to explain the way they are tabulated. So, this is item 12B. This is a spreadsheet that indicates how each of you weighted each category.
And in red are your top three. So each board member has three values that are in red, and those are the ones that you identified as your top three. And then down at the bottom, we have an average score for each of the values,
and that can give you some indication of which one's got the highest. and consistently, quality of educational programming definitely being the highest, et cetera. If you look further, you have the raw data of how each of you answered the narrative questions.
I don't even know if I answered them. Do I answer them? You do not. I do. I thought I was just supposed to think about them as you prepared to answer. You do you. And then I used AI to summarize the themes. And I'm not saying that the AI did it right, I'm saying I'm using that just as a way to frame it for you, for you to consider, and then draw your own conclusions about what the themes were, but sometimes it's useful to not have a person do it, actually.
I think that's a pretty good use of AI to take what potentially might be my values or my slant out of the interpretation of the results. But ultimately, it's up to all of you to decide what themes you glean from the discussion overall.
And then the back page is your... The back page is my overall. So, and I don't need to read it to you because you can all read them out loud, But I think if you would like to have a little bit of discussion or further discussion about how that exercise went for you, whether you found value in it, whether you feel you learned anything and you want to share that with each other, this is a good moment to do that.
Chris? Something after reading this kind of I want to point out is that these averages aren't really averages, not in the real sense, because we're not all using the same scale. If it was said to be like, okay, so we have, you know, these different categories, and we have 100% to work with, divide your percentages, then we could average them, and they'd be the same scale, but, like, you know, how I went about it, personally, was that I knew that some had to be 1s, and some had to be 4s, because if all of them are 4s and 3s, then you're prioritizing nothing by default, right?
And so, like, they're not the same scale. So we can't really aggregate it that way, I think. I mean, I'm going to challenge that, Chris. I think you're right mathematically. I also think that it tells you something about what the group's thinking was.
I think that's something at the top, but it doesn't tell you about anything in the middle. I mean, you know, yeah, I think you're, like I said, mathematically, yeah, that's true. but i mean all of our um all of our evaluations that we do i mean when you look at them you see
there's people who give everybody straight for us across and there are people who kind of approach it more similarly to you like well if everything's great then what's great um so you know and we use that that tool it's just a i would say it's not the thing we should like be like well that's the
number we should focus on those three um i think it's just a tool to kind of see overall kind of how they shook out um you know your idea of you know these i don't know how many there were i don't remember i think there was like 13 but but if you had to rank them one to 13 right like that
would be a very much easier way to track them by average right like in i gave it a one and you go to two and you give whatever and then add them all up and divide that average is probably more meaningful to the way you you consider it and i don't disagree with that at all um it's just i
I say that mainly, I think, because I don't want this data to go into something else that goes into something else that then gets seen as... This is our importance, yeah. Right, like, I want to, like, I want to, like, just kind of point out that this is, like,
good for a discussion, but not for reality, if that makes sense. Makes sense. Yeah, just to piggyback on what Chris said, I think I viewed it differently, and I gave force to the things that I knew I was going to say were the most important, because that's
what the assignment was. And I think it would have perhaps been helpful for us to have a place to explain how we ranked. Like when you gave something a two, what were you thinking? When you gave something a three, what were you thinking? And I think that would help inform how we got to our
numbers because the rubric did say that you value all things. And that's like the baseline given is that you're not saying when you give something a one that this is unimportant to me. You're saying this is less important to me than the rest and that's why i kind of personally kept the ones to
a minimum because in many cases there wasn't a most important and that's how i landed but i can see the others obviously felt differently and i also feel like quality of educational programming was kind of like a layup number one
um because of the rows that we're in and the fact that we all chose to run for an office for this position like it wasn't just like we were placed here it's something that we also value or else we wouldn't be here i'm going to give us a little bit of credit not every board every
member in the state of maine would have put that as their number one 100 that's really it's sad It's a hard truth, but it's true. So, Colin? Yeah, I didn't get a chance. I wasn't here for the first conversation, but I was able to fill us out. I think it is really valuable. I guess I would just, my sense is that there's,
I guess to Chris's point is that I don't think, yeah, that we should be packaging this up and putting it in new documents to say this is like, these are the board's top three priorities. But yeah, I don't think it's functional in that way. I think it is, however, I think extremely functional in communicating to us where we are as a board, and also communicating to the public who is watching that these are our priorities going into this conversation.
And it's not to say that, again, this doesn't have any, like, power to determine any decision, but it's just to say that I would say that I think this is a really good indicator of saying, like, as the board is going into this year, two-year, three-year conversation, I mean, going into our strategic plan, right?
This is not just pertaining to, which again I think is something that we really need to remind ourselves and remind all of the community members, this is not about the Poundall School. This is about the districts, resources, and how we are serving all of the needs of the students.
Is the question of the usage of the panel school and how that responds to that community's needs important? Absolutely. But this is not a document that is about house, elementary school. It just isn't. So I think that we should be using this as a way of saying, huh, okay, yeah, it's a good reminder that these are the things that really goes to the top. We have some narrative information as well that we can make use of.
And so that when we do start to get back actual data, we can have this as a reference point to say, yeah, that's like, it's not so therefore if we're making certain decisions that are prioritizing quality of programming over operational efficiency, for example, just picking one at random, like there's a reason, like there's somewhere that that's coming from.
Like, that's not a, it shouldn't surprise, it shouldn't surprise us, and it shouldn't surprise the public. Again, there's nothing here that we're, this is determining, but I think it is, I think it is, I think it is a very useful and functional document in terms of understanding how we are approaching this and where we're coming from from a values perspective.
Yeah, thank you, Colin. I think that's very well put. And I think just one thing I would add to that is that it helps us see the emerging broad themes and priorities. We don't need to look at it in terms of actual ranking of those priorities.
I don't think that that's where it's really very useful, but to see which ones did rise above the others, generally speaking, I think that is where this tool has value for us to kind of look at what factors here are the most important to us as we go into our sustainability study and have these discussions in the future.
i'm interested to see you know when you asked it was this a successful activity i think we'll know this is a successful activity when we get to the end of this process and we can tie back to what we said right like did this did we all you know and not that people can't change their opinions and
and don't grow in their thinking and all those things but it'll be interesting to see you know do we throw all of what we said was important out for something else or not so i just didn't I understand the last overall theme. Did at least one member noted that advocacy perceived as bad faith
is actively affecting how they weigh certain community voices? That's the last of that page. At least one. I think I can speak to that because I think it's summarizing the comments I had made in mine. And it had come in the heels of somebody from Palinol threatening to sue the board.
And I said that I wouldn't be taking bad faith threats when I consider um the future of the district i don't i personally did not appreciate um somebody coming here and telling us that they had saved money to sue the board or to remove themselves from the school
um that's not discussing the future of the district in a good faith way in my opinion um and we were writing this as people not as board members and for me that rankled me um I am entering this in good faith I appreciated this um exercise but it because it got me to a
place where I could name why I'm struggling with this panel um situation even though this isn't the reason we're doing it but it is um I think the reason we feel it so acutely um is that for me and I named it when we did this is that I don't relate to
needing a community school but i went to a district school that had multiple towns going into the elementary school and i don't relate to needing it and so when i consider it and when i give it weight it's because i'm listening to the community not because i intrinsically understand
it i don't but i still value the opinion of my community and i continue to listen and that's my good faith, listening, and consideration. And I feel like when somebody comes and tells me that if I don't agree with them, then they're removing support entirely without the work that we're trying to do to get to a consortium, then I feel like that's a bad faith argument and I don't agree with it and I don't like it. And I'm not going to sit and take it without saying so. And if it's helpful, I don't know if it is or not, but just to clarify, I think that the comments that we received was around money put into their municipal budget for withdrawal proceedings, not necessarily suing the board.
So just for what that's about, it probably doesn't make you feel any other than that, but anyway. I appreciate the clarification. It is getting late. I appreciate the clarification. It's not how it felt. Yeah, I understand. okay to be continued on this all right so new business um consideration so we have two stipends
on here i think we are going to tackle them separately um and uh so how these how these work is uh the stipend positions are kind of a two-part process part one is a stipend has to be created um and that goes through the stipend committee and that it takes into account time and there's
all sorts of parts and points and things like that in the creation of a new stipend um and so what we have before us today is the creation of two new stipends that came from the support of the stipend committee and then once those are created then the second part is um are they funded
or not. My understanding is that in the budget we have for next year, there are funds in there for the middle school swimming stipend. I don't know if there are funds already in there for the middle school unified basketball or not. Are there? I believe that there are. Okay.
um okay so um so if we if we were to approve these and we have the funds in the budget then that would be the okay for um eric to look for those two coaches for next year uh if we don't approve these but the budget is approved in total we would still collect those funds but we could
not spend them on these positions because these positions don't exist until we vote yes on these does that make sense we haven't had a new stipend in a bit so i just want to kind of go through that process with folks um so that's kind of how they work so what we're looking for um is a motion for
consideration and approval uh for the following stipend position pending budget approval and we We'll start with for middle school swimming. Do we have a motion? Colin and Chris, thank you. This is a new program based on student need. We have over 50 kids who have expressed interest. Steph explained this well when she talked about the stipend committee. It seems like, to me, a relatively small amount of money to help a lot of kids swim
and start them on their way to a lifelong sport and overcome cost barriers for some kids who are currently having to pay for it through community programs. I hope you'll support it. So I just want to make sure I understand the form. The stipend,
the cost of this stipend for me to approve it is the $2,228. That's right. Okay. So the other items on there are like what the rest of the program would cost. That's right. But the stipend that we're looking to approve is $2,228. Thank you. Chris. As an advocate for this,
I don't know how it works in Moore Street or in Durham, but at PES, every year from first grade through fifth grade, the kids go to bath and have a PE unit with Mr. T in the pool, and it's awesome every time. They go up for like five weeks, once a week. And it is amazing. We live in a state surrounded by water. Kids should know how to swim. It's a safety thing, so I think this is great. Yeah, I think PBS is the only school that has that program.
Well, we definitely don't have it in Durham. I don't know. Is it in Freeport? No. What was the center here? Yes. So when I read this before I came here, I read this as being competitive swim team. It is not. Thank you, it is. Then I would like to just point out that if, and I'm a swimmer.
I love swimming. Let me start by saying that. 50 kids or more showing interest in swimming. That's a lot of kids, needless to say, to put on to a competitive swim team. Some of those kids are going to be just sitting on the edge.
They're not going to be participating. When they're in community education programs, everybody gets to participate. I realize there's a cost to it, but perhaps there could be a way for kids who participate in a community ed sort of program to have that underwritten by the district, as it used to be,
and may still be, rather than having the parents have to pay for it. Having been a child who probably would never have swum competitively, being a kid that sits on the edge, crappy feeling. And so the reason I asked for this to be split out was because I'm going to vote against the middle school swim program,
but I did want to vote for the other one. So that's why I asked for it to be split out. But I just think that this is another opportunity, another example of people whose parents can put them into good lessons from the time they're two, their parents put them in soccer,
from the time they're four whatever the sport is and they're going to be the ones who get to compete whereas the kid that is just learning how to swim in fourth grade or whatever grade isn't going to be the competitive isn't going to be in the meat i don't think that's the way it works at the middle
school level i think that's really more high school at least than middle school sports in the tennis program and i assume it says non-competitive meets here i assume it's probably similar in the middle school swim program they don't it's not only the top swimmers they get to swim it's not
only the top tennis players they get to play that's really more at the high school level from my understanding is that kind of what other people think yeah i don't know but um i don't know either i didn't get a chance to finish but i'll just end there may i just say something about that
we forget that there's practices, so those kids are going to be swimming a lot in practice, and some kids might not want to compete, but they might want to go to the swim program to learn to be better swimmers, too. Yeah, and you know, when it's a school event, then usually there's
transportation, and it makes it a little bit more accessible to folks, and you know, there probably is other ways to deal with the cost of it, if we just funded the rec program, but I don't know if that meets all of, gets rid of all the hurdles kiddos might have.
I'll come right back to you, Lee. Do you have an access question? If it's currently being offered through WREC, I would imagine that Durham could sign up, whereas if it's through the middle school, would Durham have access to this program? So how the middle school sports have historically worked is if there's only one team that they play together. So like soccer, they each have their own because they have tons of kids that play both. But like football or lacrosse, field hockey, there's only one team in the district, and so both middle schools.
So this would likely have the same access as it currently does in that term? I would imagine, yeah. Plus, in a respect to Karen's view, I've never seen a pool that holds 50 kids at a time. Sure, you can have like eight kids in the lane, and they'll be clobbering each other.
it says 30 to 40 on here yeah i mean that's the other thing right like you know are you interested yeah who actually signs up it's never that many so okay um so in the motion and a second on the floor for just for the middle school swimming any other comments or questions okay all those in
favor opposed thank you all right do i have a motion for consideration and approval of the following stipend position for the middle school unified basketball karen and steph thank you So the second page in your green section here is the description for the Unified Basketball program.
A note on whether this is in the budget, just because my memory's been jogged. We actually have a grant for this. Creating the stipend enables us to pay the coach out of the grant. So we do have the money for this. Sorry it took me a minute to remember that. It's late. Okay, so we have a grant. So basically, we have the money, but we have nowhere to spend it unless we approve this stipend.
Correct. And then when the grant was up, presumably a year, then we could look to put it in the budget. Correct. Okay. Any questions on this one? I know Unified Basketball was added at the high school in the last, I don't know, five years, four or five years.
And it's hugely popular. Like, it's super fun to watch. The kids love playing. Really, really great, great program. And I'm actually really excited to see that it's going to extend to the middle school. Assuming it passes. Any other comments on this one? All those in favor? Not opposed. Thank you. Okay. It is after 10 o'clock, which means we have to take a vote on whether we want to continue
because we still have things on our agenda. So I would take a motion to continue through our remaining items on the agenda past 10 p.m. Kelly and Karen, thank you. All those in favor? Anna reluctantly puts her hand up. Thank you. I think that was unanimous.
Okay, so the next thing we have on our agenda is item 14, personnel. Do I have a motion for consideration and approval to employ a school counselor at Mass Landing School for the 2026-2027 school year? Steph and Karen, thank you. Okay, so this is a vacancy that actually is a couple
dominoes following. The original vacancy was at Freeport Little School with Phyllis Latham's retirement. We made that position, her retirement was announced several months ago because we were having reductions in force. We opened up a lot of positions that were available to internal
transfers across the district. Susan Albertini, who is presently the school counselor at Mass Landing, expressed a desire to transfer and she will be transferred to that position at the middle school that creates the position at mass landing and I am pleased to
bring you this nomination for Rachel Lenino whom I had the delight of meeting the other day in a second interview she brings several years of school counselor experience she has a strong understanding of the development strengths and needs of students in our grade span she is an incredibly
thoughtful and insightful person and she has also a lot of experience in outdoor leadership education in places like the leadership school in Trawalki. Really excited to bring her aboard. Wonderful. Questions, comments? All right.
All those in favor? No opposed. Thank you. This is where we have an executive session. Yep, we still have a public comment. All right, so we do have another public comment. If you want to share anything, I'm going to keep you to the three minutes, though. That's really fun. Okay. Okay. Yep. So just wanted to know. I'm going to ask you to share the name again,
Just please people jump around. Yes, okay, great. Kate McGilliot, anything else I'm supposed to share? Freeland. Yes, Freeport. Okay, I want you to know your mission as a board is to support RSU-5's educational vision, which includes that students graduate. Students cannot graduate if they cannot read. And so you had a few mechanisms today that you could have taken action on that most critical thing that you as a board are responsible for. One would be thinking about the high-quality or the curriculum review process, right, And so thinking right now, there is a process in place, a policy.
It does not include the word that you all were fixating on, effective. The better word in education world is evidence-based. It's well accepted. Look up edreports.org. You know, there's not a question about if a curriculum is working, okay?
So adding that would actually put an instrument for ensuring that everything that's in front of students is working and effective and evidence-based and not just what someone felt like they should put in front of students. You just did that process for library books. So you
implemented a process for something a kid might grab, right? But the things that is in front of kids every day that's determining whether or not they learn to read and graduate, there's not currently that level of scrutiny, right? And I just want to go back. You identified that you guys
care about quality of educational programming and student educational equity as values, right? and there's there is a next step you can take right you can say let's do something now right let's make sure we continue acadians we continue at least assessing and then we continue the
interventions of ufly let's at least try one teacher send them to the modules that main department of ed is offering over the summer literacy modules take maybe some of the money you just thought about for tennis courts for teaching kids to read teaching kids to swim
yes it matters teaching kids to read is your core mission right and so like when we're thinking about these priorities, I'm not hearing the core priority from you all, and you are the leaders of the district. You hold the responsibility of every child's future in your hands. You've had a lot of
discussion about this this year. You have a lot of data on it, and there's no action, and there's nothing in the budget on it. So I really implore you to take action in the same way you said, okay, let's put $4,000 towards tennis courts, and then let's come together over the summer for an emergency meeting. Think about that for kids learning to read. I want to see something on the agenda for
next week it's it's the last chance otherwise there's a whole nother year of 50 percent of poor kids not reading when they're coming in by third grade if you don't read by third grade your life outcomes are drastically altered so it's your decision hello i'm mark doley from panel um i
really appreciate that you guys went through that weighted values exercise i think that at least the way that I think it makes things a lot more clear. And I appreciate what Colin said, that this is not about panel, because it's not.
If you can nail this, and this is scalable to any size problem that you have or project that you have, I think I would challenge you to get even more general and not even think about it in terms of the current reorg. so it's a way to evaluate your decisions that you make what it's particularly important when
you can't hold everything in your head at the same time and a reorg like this is one of those but i i think that the the criteria there were criteria that were lacking and if you're missing those you're not going to be thinking about them so hopefully you can really nail that down
And a lot of them were already listed as missing. So, yeah, I just wanted to say thank you for that. And it's actually related to reading. You want to really think about how important something like reading is and where you want to spend your time. Because this criteria is basically like, where do I want to spend my time?
We have a budget. How much do I want to spend on reading? how much of my time do I want to spend on meeting? And I think that this tool can help you do that. So thank you. Thank you, Mark. All right. So we are going to move to the adjustment to the agenda.
Do I have a motion for consideration and approval to enter into executive session as outlined in 1 MRSA section 4056A for the purpose of discussing a personnel matter? Valerie, Emily, thank you. All those in favor, not opposed. All right, we're going to hop over to the science room across the hall so they can clean up in here. Yeah, yeah, yeah, we'll do that one after.
Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.
