TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 1 July 2026
Board meeting · 1 h 21 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →
11,715 words in 15 five-minute windows.
me. So don't, you know, don't be expected. Uh, public comment. Pretty sure you guys are all here for the presentation. So we will move on. There are no reports for the superintendent, administrator reports, board comments or committee reports, policy review. Look at us flying through our agenda. We're already on the second page. I promised Colin we'd
be out of here in plenty of time to get to the U.S. game starting. Uh, all right. Unfinished business. Here we go. So we do, we're going to be doing an update on the systems and sustainability study. Okay. So you will all remember the journey we've been on for the past year. And we recently
had put out an RFP for a systems and sustainability study that is going to anchor some decision making in the next year around district configuration. And we had originally come to you for $75,000, when we were thinking of that as a facility study, if this is going back
six months probably, then as our thinking evolved to incorporate more than just facilities into that study, based on some research that we had done, we came to you and asked for an additional $25,000 to increase the cap to $100,000, because it seemed that we would
probably need to incur that much cost. And then we received bids, and of all of the bids that we received, the finalists that we bring to you tonight comes from Zeo. We've had multiple discussions with Zeo, and they have a presentation to share with you. But the price tag exceeds what we had talked about.
So the reason for tonight's meeting is to allow Zeo to talk to you about what they're offering us for $150,000, and then to have a discussion among you, whether or not that's something you can endorse. Take it away. So are you going to present up here? Yes. Hi, good evening, everyone. My name is Jeff Melendez. I have been in education my whole
career, 25 years. I was a teacher, principal, superintendent, taught at the graduate level for about 12 years as an adjunct. There we go. Yeah. And founded Zeal Education Group, which we're a consulting firm that basically has expertise in just about every area,
conceivably, in education. We do superintendent searches. We actually found a replacement for Yarmouth and in South Portland, nearby, we did those two searches. We do audits, as we'll talk about a little bit tonight. We just did one at Kenney Bunkport. And we do work all around the country, really. Professional development and everything. We have about 120 people on our team with all different layers of expertise.
And this is a really cool project, and I wanted to just bring this up. This was a letter that Tom wrote back in March, and it really inspired me, and I put it in our cover letter as well. But, you know, just in the middle of the other is to step back and ask big questions about long-term sustainability
and about open conversations about topics that are close to our hearts, the way schools work. And so from my perspective as a lifelong educator, I really recognize how complex education is, And it isn't just about the books and the pencils and the students and the teachers. It's about the way the building works. It's about the way the building informs instruction. And it's the way you operate. And can you operate more efficiently and put those resources to better use for your students.
And so for this project, we put together a team here, myself, Andrew Dolloff, who today is his first day of retirement from Yarmouth. And he comes and finds himself back at a building. So that's pretty, shows his dedication. Andrew, do you actually want to use yourself real quick? Hi, folks. Nice to see you, Andrew D'Auliffe. Until 26 hours ago, I was the superintendent next door in Yarmouth for the past 12 years.
I've got over 40 years in education. I'm currently a professor of educational leadership for the University of Southern Maine. I'm happy to be assisting Zio in this proposal. Thank you. And two other people on our team, Joe Mishler is a former superintendent from Cincinnati, which is a former superintendent from New Jersey. And then EDI is a, and I'll let Lewis introduce himself, they are the architects. They are sort of complementary to us.
We've been working informally together for many, many years. I'll let Lewis introduce himself in one second. This is actually from 2003. This was a book that Prakash edited, and Lewis and I actually collaborated on a chapter on school safety.
So we are familiar as organizations with each other, but let me let Lewis introduce himself real quick. Good to see everyone. Lewis Sirota, I'm an architect. i have been since 2011 and uh we well i'll get more into edi um but we design schools all over
the world so i bring vast knowledge of what everyone is doing in their schools around the world um best practices and um i'll get more into it in a minute but i am from minnesota so i'm in from out of town uh and i had a great day with glenn touring all of your schools so
i feel up to speed on what's going on here uh at least from the facilities perspective i didn't see any teaching and learning um yet but um yeah go ahead um so this is a really uh kind of an interesting project and and um this is just something i threw our proposal into
we can't take any credit for this but the way what this speaks to me is about the merging of two sort of disparate points of view on schools. One is how do we operate, and that's the part that my team is going to facilitate, talking to teachers, looking at all of your documents,
looking at your enrollment, trying to make projections out, you know, 10 years with that, looking at the operational efficiency, staffing, all of the various needs that you have, transportation, kindergarten, all of those things. And then what Lewis is going to do and his team is going to do is look at your facilities and see how those can be improved, modified potentially,
or left alone, if that's the best recommendation. And we're going to present you recommendations at the end if we're selected to work with you about how best to do that. So I'm going to yield my time to Lewis because he's been in your district all day. He's got lots of photos and interesting stuff to talk about. And then we'll be open for questions and answers later at the end.
Is that? So, Lewis. Yeah. All right. So back to tell you a little bit more about EDI, because maybe you've read our books or been to our website. Maybe not. But basically, we're an architecture company with a unique position because we work with educators. And we look at our buildings not about the building,
The more about the learning that happens within the building, that comes first, and then how we organize the building, what happens in it, comes after we figure out how we want to teach, how we want to learn. So we work with educators, just like Jeff and his group, and our goal is really to improve learning, not just to improve the building for the sake of having a better-looking building, which is also important, but the education part, the kids, are the most important part.
So Prakash, the founder of our company, EDI, we've written many books. So everything we talk about is based on research that he's constantly doing. We actually have a director of research, and her job is, she's a doctor, she's just doing research full-time, figuring out what's best for the kids.
And then I, as the architect, problem solver, use all of that research in my decisions when I'm informing districts or schools what to do. So everything has a deep-rooted reason, and we work all over the world. So the ideas I have, they're tried and tested, most of them, so we don't just have this narrow band of what to do or what's going on.
This is a worldwide phenomenon about improving learning. And I wanted to give you all a little bit of a background on why we're not just analyzing the buildings for the carpet, the windows, the walls, the doors, and everything.
It's why are we talking about something different? And really, it's because learning over the next 20 to 50 years is evolving. It's ever-changing. As we can see here, there's some cell phone crates out front because clearly the kids can't be trusted with their phones.
And I know a lot of schools that approach it that way. It's fine. It's distracting. Some schools, which they do really struggle with this, they try and let the kids have their phone. And they try and work through that problem. That's their solution to where learning is headed because you have your phone at work.
So how are you expected to work when you have your phone and you work from home? you have to learn to be productive so that's kind of their take on that but anyways um everybody's different so learning is evolving or learning is evolving but school learning is generally not
evolving we have our curriculum it's staying the same and this gap is spreading between um how the kids are learning and what they're learning and where they're learning it so I love this kind of pyramid graphic is this is changing so lecture used to be an awesome way to
deliver content it still is but it's not the only way most of our buildings are set up just for lecture so we walk into these buildings and we see something I'll get into a little later called cells and bells it's just a bunch of rooms they're good for a narrow band of things when we design a
new school will offer recommendations like 99% of the time, we're looking at a larger pool of ways of learning. So discussing groups, working with your phone or tablet or computer, staying on topic, a lot of different things. So when we look at a building, we like to think, can it support
all of these things um or not so when we start looking at your buildings i'll be able to put together analysis and diagrams and charts to kind of show you where your buildings are at and i guess what would it take to get them to a point where where would you want to be and i mean
part of that question too is where do you want to be because we could design a school that would look like your current schools or just improve them or we could design something completely new and exciting but we want that direction really to come from you and the community so a lot of
what we're offering in our design spark sessions is gathering that feedback from the schools and all the communities into where do they think they want to move everything towards what are their good ideas because then we put that into together with ideas like ours as to where we want to head
and then the recommendations start but we are really good at collating all that data and putting it together so I like this diagram it really describes how we would be working so we have all of that data we're gathering and ideas on facility design that we brought from all over
the world and we have everything Jeff is doing which I kind of label on the right-hand side here education design and in the middle is that learning experience that we are providing for the students which is ever so important and
which is also why we're not just looking at the roof HVAC and mechanical systems we're looking at these specific things and this is in our scope of work so student well-being sense of belonging teaching and learning future readiness
educational performance. These are the things that we find are a better measure of your buildings and facilities than just the container. And we do four different surveys to kind of get an idea of where the buildings are at. So I'll go
over each of them. They're all important and when we put them together we really see a clear picture of where the buildings are at, where they want, where we want to push the buildings to be so we can promote student success. So number
one is some emotional readiness. And some of the important components of this are belonging, emotional support, the community within the school, relationships between the student and student, student and community, student and teacher, and
student voice and ownership. So do the building support these things? And some of What I saw today was a light effort towards these things like furniture outside the room, some couches, spaces like this, which this space would score like 90 to 100 because it has all those great things.
Some of the other spaces in the building, not so much. They would slip maybe below 70%. So we want to bring the good things happening in here all over the schools. I'm glad we're in this room because it's a great example of that. Another one, modernity of the campus, just modern campus.
So I'll be able to deliver, I guess, modern types of curriculum. So technology, innovation, real-world learning, sustainability and stewardship, adaptability to do new things because things are changing rapidly. Like in the last two or three years, this whole AI thing is becoming very important.
and will continue to be important, but like, when this building was designed, that wasn't even a thing, and were they even thinking about that? Your curriculum, too, does it support that? So we want our buildings to be able to kind of adapt towards future things as much as they can,
and we have a pretty clear picture on where that's heading, so we like to assess the campuses on whether it can support that or not another one i personally really like this one health and well-being quality um so just imagine yourself in an old outdated restaurant and you're eating
dinner and you're like yeah you have an okay experience food was good but imagine yourself in the fancy james beard well-designed restaurant you're going to have better conversation everything around you is going to support you enjoying that meal, and you're going to walk out feeling good,
feeling special, and that's the same experience we want to bring towards schools. We want the students to come in, feel comfortable, safe, secure, and then they will learn better when they're feeling all of those things, and that was a huge leap forward in our research in the last
two years was about health and well-being in schools and why do we do the things we do. Because we were just trying to design schools to look good and everybody liked them and everybody learned better in them. But then we took a step back and researched all the science behind that
and why are we doing that. And then we made the survey because we think all buildings should be moving towards being better in this category next one educational effectiveness and this is I think tying a lot more into what Jeff is doing it's
basically basically from an educational curriculum standpoint is the building supporting the teachers as they're trying to deliver that content curriculum and is it supporting the students as they're doing the work so say we
shifted more towards a student-directed model where we have a lot more projects, project-based stuff. Do the buildings have spaces that the students can do those projects in, or are they stuck in the classrooms kind of doing projects but
not really well? So if you decided you wanted to be more project-based learning, SEM focused, our recommendations to your facilities may be a little different. But when we do the analysis of this, we kind of just broadly say, is the facility supporting this?
So this is the very beginning part of our process, is doing these assessments. It really helps us understand where things are at now. And then we take a lot of what Jeff is doing in that vision box and kind of merge things together in order to begin offering planning recommendations.
And it's not just everything we're doing is coming from the community, the schools, students, teachers, leaders. So that's how we end up at a solution. I would never just look at the building and tell you 10 things that we should do.
We need to go through that process and understand everything in order to give you the best recommendations possible. And some of these could be higher level things of, like, do we renovate everything? Do we renovate and build new? Do we shift people around and do things in a completely different way?
So we can offer higher broad stroke recommendations. And then also, when we make those type of decisions, then we can come in and offer some very targeted, specific recommendations. I have some cool examples of what that would look like, but before I get to that, I think what I was going to do next is talk a little bit about the facilities and my initial impression.
Before I do that, I like to stop and offer questions on everything I've said so far, if anyone has any. I think you're just good to keep going. Sure, not a problem. Alright, so shifting to my impressions section, so I did, as I said, I toured all the schools, and it's very exciting seeing all the buildings, and a great tour guide back there that's waiting to go on a camping trip.
I can see. Anyways, so my intention was not to score the facilities or really do a deep dive. That would come later. I just wanted an opportunity to kind of see things. And if we are going to move forward together, I have a great starting point where I can really target the presentations and the content that we would give at each of the meetings to where I think the facilities and the community might be.
So, here are some of the early themes that I saw. Really, all the buildings were traditional Sells and Bells classroom, one classroom after another. Not the best connection between rooms, and a limited opportunity for teachers to really broaden their pedagogy.
And what that is, is how they teach. So, the room is, right now, the room is really dictating how they can teach, because they have a limited opportunity of things. they probably all can't use, they currently can't use a room like this where you could teach in
many different ways in this room. So you added water and VCD flooring, project area, you can really do anything in a room like this. And I think that's where a lot of schools are going is providing more spaces like this. So I think that every single building had massive potential
to shift to new models of teaching and learning so I don't really see any problem with say we did a full-scale renovation of every building you could probably do anything you'd want to do and of course that new model of teaching and learning is coming from you all is where you want to head
and I don't see any problem just from a planning perspective now the condition of the buildings is a whole other condition and size of the buildings and like how many students these can all hold that's a different story, but planning-wise, good buildings. So we could support different
demographics or age groups in really any of the buildings. We can create new space types, broaden curriculum offerings with minimal capital investment and changing things around. And my personal favorite is you have amazing sites, and I didn't see that much outdoor learning,
So massive potential to add that as some sort of an offering, even creating cutouts in some of the rooms to open directly outside and let learning spill in and out, especially in the younger kids age. Like the Reggio Emilia style of learning is really popular and that requires
this indoor and outdoor connection. It's possible in pretty much every school, just not done. And then another of my personal favorites is right when you walk into that school, there's opportunities at each school to have this signature identity where you walk in and it's kind of like a space like this.
It shows off to anyone arriving there that you have these beautiful learning forward environments and signature and identity for each community would be right there. And you all are trying to do that, so I notice an effort towards a lot of these things,
but, you know, the facilities, it's hard to improve facilities. It costs a lot of money and a lot of planning. So that's kind of a broad stroke, and I won't waste everybody's time going through each building because it was really, it was kind of the same narrative for each building, but I did go to all of them, and I could answer questions on each one.
wanted to and of course the last one I went to actually the first one I went to but Durham it's basically brand new so when we would be offering recommendations for the buildings we also would consider the age and condition of the building so
at this one I wouldn't do as much I would try to preserve as much as possible only add because we hate demolishing work that's already been done So we think about all that when we're working, doing our work. And of course
district office, stop there. Okay, so I think this is the last section. Part of our proposal is Pathfinders and this is something that often I feel like people don't really understand, so I wanted to share a little bit of what this might look like so this would be when we go to each school we like to offer recommendations specifically on what can be improved in that school and then you
can take those as summer projects first steps and if you are able to do some of these they can be huge opportunities to raise money and broaden the understanding of what you want to do to the entire building so often they're smaller targeted projects that just show people what's possible and then
everybody gets to benefit from them. Like say we had, say this building was unrenovated since like the 90s, doing a room like this would be an example of a Pathfinder. So I did two before and afters. With the power of AI, I actually
made some renderings here to show you what I think would be possible. So a lot of hallways in these schools, and we see hallways as opportunities for more learning outside of the classroom rather than just circulation and I see some
chairs and tables in the hallways leading me to believe that the teachers are already aware of this mode of teaching and learning so they probably would welcome what we're we're thinking and then just another hallway at mass
landing so before I show you those renderings those type of spaces would be part of maybe a learning community. And this is getting way too far ahead of ourselves. So this is just one example of where we might head. So maybe we have all these conversations and we start
to put the information together and we figure out where we might want to be on a scale of traditional to modern on school design. And this goes into some of the questions we might ask people. So we talk about teacher collaboration, teacher pedagogy, your
curriculum, the community involvement in the school, student outcomes, what leadership looks like in the school, and support systems within the school to make it all happen. And we think about where we might want to be on that
spectrum. So when we're asking people questions, we're asking interesting questions. We're not just asking, what do you want in your building? We will ask that, but we'll ask other questions and really test people and push them so we can get this clear picture of really
where we want to bring our buildings. So if I take a traditional school design, Cells and Bells as we call it, it's really geared towards traditional instruction delivery, And any time you push out of that, say a teacher tried to do team teaching or project-based learning, we have a zone of friction, well, they're going to struggle to do that.
They'll be able to do it, they won't be able to do it well, and they're going to want other things in their facility if they want to do it well. So when we're deciding what to do with a building, this looks a lot like a lot of your buildings.
So if we heard from the community and everybody that we want more team teaching, more project-based learning, more student autonomy, we're going to start doing things in the building that's going to push the scale the other way so we limit that zone of friction.
So, a very, very easy thing to do, say we didn't have a lot of money, is just allow, take down a few walls and allow those teachers to teach together. Even pushing it a little further would be maybe the teachers sharing rooms wouldn't just be two classrooms, but maybe one would be set up more for group learning, the other one would be set up more for lecture.
So, between the two teachers, they can explore a lot of different modes. And once again, this would come from them as where they would want to head. So generally, when I see things like I did, like the table and chairs in the hallways, spaces like this, I feel like the teachers and students are wanting to head more in this direction, which is why I put this in the presentation.
And if we're really starting to push things to the limit of these buildings, we're starting to think about groups of teachers working together and sharing even more variety of space. so maybe they're not having a dedicated room maybe they're just having a dedicated desk
within this larger zone where they're all able to do a lot of different things and they're working together to do it and if we have a lot of teacher turnover maybe we're still keeping some classrooms if we have a teacher that doesn't want to be a part of this and they want to be in their own room they still have the potential to do that so we're not limiting anything we're
just expanding it. And then, of course, if, say, we had full buy-in, like, we want to completely throw out what we have and do something completely new, we don't think about leaving a lot of individual rooms. We think about complete variety of space. And when we do projects like this, we
find ourselves somewhere along the spectrum here, and we design spaces specifically for where we want to go. So in your schools, these are the renderings I did. We have our existing hallway, and we want to have a more used hallway, and we want to provide more areas for students to
read alone or work one-on-one. Technology, better storage rather than lockers, spread the library out, it could look like the space on the right. Same thing at mass landing. We have underutilized space. So say this building had five rooms that weren't really
being used if we looked at utilization. And that's something we might do in our study is look at the utilization rate of the schools to see how much extra space we might have. So when we have extra space, we can do things like take rooms
out and provide more learning commons or spaces that support health and well-being and social-emotional readiness. So we move from the existing to the future. We improve everything that we talked about and we gathered in our
surveys. So the goal kind of full circle here is we analyze where things are at, we meet with everybody and we understand where you want to go and we lightly give some recommendations on where to go and then the next step after that is you raise the money and then
somebody or us jumps back in and tells you exactly where you bring your take your buildings to get to that point and so it's a long process but you have this great foundation to back up everything you want to do um when you do things in this way it's not just about facilities it's about the
students it's about learning and the facilities is wrapped up all into that so that is all so i could turn things over to questions on everything or what i said and jeff and i can answer okay thank you um i just i had a question for either of you is there a school you could direct us to
look at online that you've worked with, that this has worked well, that they've made some significant changes so we can see that in action? Absolutely. So Prakash actually just redid our website, and he wanted to make it, I guess, research forward. So if you go to our website,
you kind of start to learn a lot more about this, and we put a lot of our examples on there. There's whole section with example projects for this specifically we did this in Boulder Valley so they had a ton of outdated buildings and they decided to pass a
bond to just do new buildings so they decided that's the direction they wanted ahead but it was on the table that we would renovate all the buildings so they went to each community and designed a new building and it was done in this
exact same way where they decided what was important to them and we designed a new building for that but had they renovated it would have been a renovation of that existing building so any of the Boulder Valley schools on the
website would show you what that looks like but definitely go there and check it out a lot of cool stuff real close um i guess where i'm struggling is how so the history for us is we actually had to cut some positions for the first time in a while um so this feels aspiration on aspiration on
aspiration for me where we struggled to reduce our um ask of our taxpayers acknowledging that We keep having these great increases so that our families aren't struggling because of taxes. And that first quote that Jeff put up from Superintendent Gray is exactly, I think, where I am,
where we're trying to, I guess the same in reverse in that, for me, it's we're hemorrhaging money on possibly an outdated system. And while this presentation is lovely, I keep hearing dollars after dollars after dollars in my mind.
And I'm just wondering where this investment is leading us except for more money. Like, what is this investment that is going to save us down the road? And that's, I guess, my overarching question. Because even in the proposal, there are a lot of ads that are additional over and above the initial quote.
there's a request to have a dedicated staff from rsu5 there's the the additional note under each proposal price that says that there's also going to be service fees and travel expenses on top of what we what we expend and so i i'm trying to get there because we as
all we noted at the top we started a $75,000 ask and then we upped it realizing that we were changing our scope and now we're at twice what that initial approved amount is and and and more and so I'm trying to I'm trying to wrap my head around okay this sounds wonderful truly um but
are we going to be spending all this money to look at a dossier of more expenses is my my question of what what is it that we could do or what is it that is being offered that maybe isn't immediately going to cost us more money that's a great question i'll try to i'll try to answer
that a little bit um and it sort of goes to the question earlier about like what's the social proof what what have you done in the past um i can tell you we just did a project that started in February, or no, started in December for County Bunkport, and they asked us to do an
efficiency study, and that was looking at all of their, you know, human resources, curriculum instruction, special education, basically all the things that we're going to do here as well. In the short time that we had, it was very rushed, just because they were trying to get
it out before their budget. They wanted to impact their budget with it, and we found 150 recommendations worth about $1.6 million worth of savings that could be reinvested. So the reason we use the word investment is because, you know, I consider the insight that we'll be able to provide
as an investment. I can't guarantee because we haven't even started, but I anticipate that you should see similar. We should find things that will make your operations less costly over time. And that's a compounded effect. So if you save a million dollars in year one and you don't need those things, that has a perpetual impact.
You know, buildings, this is the biggest investment, and you know this as a board member, this is the biggest investment that the community pays for. Schools, buildings are expensive. Sometimes what happens with these studies, and I can give you an example from one we did in Virginia a few years ago,
they had and like many um northeast districts even from where i'm from we had uh i have a colleague former superintendent from a neighboring district at an elementary school with like 30 kids they had a full-time principal making 125 000 they had teachers they had to actually combine
k1 and then two three and then four five there might be some merits that actually but that's another story but um operating hemorrhage is a good way it's just a loss of money every year keeping the lights on the you know the inefficiencies we did a project for a school district in virginia
and they knew that ahead of time that they had that issue but they needed a third party to come in and and make recommendations we were able to recommend closing two elementary schools out of i think they had 11 um and that's not a very popular thing we don't want tom going out
saying, I've got a great idea, let's upset all the elementary parents and say we're going to close this school. We're a third party, and we are objective. You're right on that. And what they were able to do was take the money, the savings that they got from the two elementary schools that they closed,
they were the second lowest teacher salaries in the state of Virginia, and they were losing teachers to neighboring districts. they reinvested that money and now they're operating at with better teachers stronger teaching and learning and it's and so it's it's not that i don't think we have a magic insight
but we have it's almost like a professional tennis player has a coach and the coach can see things that maybe the player can't always see because they're playing the game and so that's sort of how we partner with districts is we you know we're going to listen to people we're going to you know
We're going to survey people. We're going to observe things. And so it's expensive, and I get that. I do get the reality, but I believe you'll find ROI. And whether I can see whether your question is natural because sort of the way that this has come out tonight in the meeting, I think we may lose sight of the fact that what Lewis just presented is actually just a part of the overall study, and it's the part that's about here's what you could do with your facilities, depending on what, how far you want to go with it, the real focus
of the study is, what are we going to do with our teaching and learning, and where are we going to put it, and how are we going to staff it, and some ideas from facilities may play into that, and a piece of context that I didn't share at first, but maybe I can now, is we
looked at, we got four bids, the other bids that were of a similar scope were about $40,000 more expensive so this this was I think that's important context so I appreciate you sharing that and I would say for me what you know what I'm thinking about the process and what we want to
use this for because I think you know your point is it's a good one Valley like if someone just watched this they're like oh my gosh they're just gonna come out with a bond to build all new schools And that is not the goal, right? But I think what we are tasked with or what we have agreed to do is to look at what we have, look at how we're doing it, right? And I think that Tom's point is a good one. It's like there's two components to this. There's sort of the operational audit, and that's kind of Jeff's team.
But that didn't really address the like, but what do we have and what might we do with that in a better way, right? And so then that was where Lewis's team came in on the EDI side to put those two things together to get to sort of a full robust scope of how are we doing it, how might we do it differently.
And I don't want to speak for you and your team, but I would imagine there are districts that don't undertake large bonds after you provide them the information, right? I imagine there are some things that we could probably do pretty easily that we don't even know exist.
because we don't do this all over the world like they do you know some some low-hanging fruit where we might be able to be more efficient to to expand the ability that our teachers have to to collaborate etc and and for me the other really big piece of this and and i think is really
important for this board to think about is the community involvement and the stakeholder engagement piece is is a big chunk of this cost but I think we need to do that you know we can't be the ones to say you know this is too expensive or we shouldn't be doing it this like we need that
outside person to to you know have an unbiased view of how are we doing it how could we be doing it and then we can move forward with some decisions um and the stakeholder piece I think is really important but it's it's frankly a material part of the cost associated with it
like in-person conversations with the communities with the staff with the administration all those pieces come into play to I think really get because I think we want to do some big things with this stuff in the next year it's not like what you know we're just doing this to see how we're doing like we have been tasked or have tasked ourselves with some pretty big decisions
about the long-term you know vision of this district with our new strategic plan I appreciate you put that in there thank you for that and I think while it's a lot of money I think it is an investment and it gives us a jumping-off point to
have some credibility when if we were to go out and say hey we want to we want to change things we want to look at a renovation we want to look at a reconfiguration or anything I think this is the starting place for all those
conversations. Colin. Yeah. Yeah. Hello. Is this one? I think maybe. Cool. Great. Thanks so much for the presentation. And yeah, I think that, I guess my read on also sort of the balance of what we're seeing tonight and then this proposal is that we have a real live architect here in the room. And when you have an architect available to you, I'm the son of an architect. I know you take advantage of that architect and their ability to put together presentations.
that are, like, architecturally and full of, like, pretty pictures instead of just, like, graphs and stuff, no disrespect to superintendents and the beautiful spreadsheets that they put together. So that's also my read is sort of just that we're – part of what we're getting is sort of the – is that pitch. And the other piece of it is just also to know that, yeah, if we do get recommendations from that outside body,
whether it's you or another entity, um, and they say, um, leave Durham alone, leave Poundell alone, leave Freeport High School alone, but you need to tear down Moore Street and build a skyscraper, we know, like, what the skyscraper
design is going to be considering, like, as we get in, as we get into it, and I think that's, again, that's how I'm, uh, kind of translating, uh, this presentation. Yeah, I really appreciate thinking about going in directions that maybe none of us had even anticipated going in
previously and just knowing that there's a team out there thinking about this in a deep way that we just can't get our minds around because we don't have that expertise and um i i also think about this as something that is not a short-term project so whatever it is that they recommend to
us and however much it may cost ultimately it's up to us to make the decisions about which of those pieces we implement and run and what that timeline looks like so there are some pieces that are really aspirational but amazing it doesn't mean we have to do them tomorrow so i appreciate
the fact that we can gather all of this information now while we have this these people at our beck and call and then we can make those decisions in the future once we have that information so i do appreciate that i do wonder i'm curious about why where we came up with the initial cost number
that we had anticipated and because clearly that isn't really very realistic based on the scope the 75 000 yeah so i'll give you the journey in my head um where we did a facility study in a district where i worked only a few years ago it was 2023 and they did a facility study by harriman
which is a local you know well-known architectural firm that study cost 75 000 so that is where i started. And then when the scope expanded, and we were thinking about, well, it's not just facilities, we wouldn't look at our operations. I happened to be at a new superintendent's
mentoring group led by Mr. Doloff, and the Kennebunk study that was referenced, their efficiency study came up and was discussed. And so I did a little bit more digging into that, and I found that they paid $67,000 for that. So that was when I came back to
to say, we're doing facilities plus, can we go at $100,000? And then when the bids came in, they were just much higher. There was one bid that was about $75,000, but it was a bid from a company that didn't show any previous work with public schools or locally.
They were all working with municipal governments that just didn't seem good. But that was mostly facilities-driven. That was mostly facilities-driven. It didn't have all the pieces. And as we, Kelly, I'll say we, I mean mostly Kelly and Glenn and I,
as we continue to talk about what we're trying to accomplish with this, it's really the due diligence to the community where some of these decisions could be very hurtful. And it just feels like we really have to do all of it to be able to look all the people of the community in the eye and say,
we really thought this through all the way. So I would have to own a learning curve on my part just about what these things are costing now, but that's where we are. A follow-up question quickly. I'm curious if anybody else besides the core administrators have had a chance to interact with the zero group yet?
Michelle has. Okay, so you have. Well, and Chris came as a member of the public when we opened the bids. So he didn't have a chance to interact with zero, but he saw all the bids. chris sabiaco but no educators yet no okay thank you um i have two questions one is and this is on
the proposal um on page 30 the scope clarifications and exclusions it says it's bulleting things that the proposal does not include which were listed in the rfp and one of them that caught my eye and i just wanted to understand it better was it won't include detailed
construction cost projections or professional cost estimating for any recommendations and i just want to hear about that because i know we talked as a board about how it would be important to understand what some of the recommendations would cost in order for us to make a decision
so i can speak to that from a facilities perspective is because i think our recommendations would be like very broad it'd be very hard to estimate them so any contractors we would talk to to gather data they'd be all over the place and it's actually a bad thing when you don't have
good information on cost because it's always higher and it will scare the community do you want a building like this where you have to put extra money yeah and then as a matter of fact is We could design a building that was involving the littlest amount of money possible, or the most amount of money.
It just depends kind of where we want to be, but we have to design the building to get that cost data. So we can go to our local contractor and say, what is the range of renovation looking at these days? And we can give that to you pretty easily. And then we can estimate based on square footage, just give you a general idea.
But that's far different than providing an actual estimate where people look at the drawings we do or the ideas we have and they estimate. It scares me always. That makes sense. I guess more that I'm wondering about is it sounds like we still will get cost, maybe savings projections. Like, oh, if we were to use this school this way,
this part this way, it could save this much. Will that still be included? I think that's Jeff's part. Yes. Okay. Yeah. So we will look for efficiencies that are, you know, apparent and some maybe not. And that's, we're going to look at all your documents. We're going to look at all your staffing charts, human resources, job descriptions.
You know, we can, and that's when people start getting nervous, right? Because it's like, it could impact people. A big one is in special education. There's an IEP, which is a contract that says we're going to deliver these services, and then there could be things that are where we're offering more services than are required, and that could be a decision that you want to maintain, or it could be, whoops, we're a liability here because we're not providing the services that we want to provide.
So, and, you know, teaching assistants, power educators, all those things, all that staffing, when you look at that, that's going to come into it. Thank you. And then my second question was about the timeline. And just, it seems pretty tight, given that it's July 1 today. How realistic do you feel like it is? And if you could just kind of talk us through it, I think that would be helpful.
Yeah, I mean, from my point of view, the summer is good, because people like Andrew on our team are now free to dedicate their time. three year-round now I just yeah yeah so so we can we can do that I think what will the challenge here's where the challenges is the validity of our
recommendations is only good is the information we're given so we're gonna need cooperation from directors and principals and people in the district office that can provide us with the documents that we need to review to the
extent that they're on vacation and we're waiting, that could be, but that's something we'd work out with Tom, is like, you know, how can we be reasonable, how do we make that as efficient and seamless as possible? Shared folders, Google Docs, Google Drive, so we'll
put those systems in place. It is a tight timeline, and especially with the fact that we can't really engage the teachers in these conversations until they return, which is what date is it end of august end of august so yeah so we yeah that's what makes me a little bit
nervous especially with the stakeholder engagement it's the predominance july and august or two of the three months and so many people are away um and i just really don't want that's a concern yeah yeah and and i know kind of ideally we want this november because then we can use it for
budgeting purposes, but for me, I would rather be two months later and have a really robust stakeholder engagement where we weren't like, well, we had these, but nobody came because it was over, you know, in July, and the teachers are back, and, you know, those sort of things.
Other questions? Carla just gave me a funny look. Other than it was today, the sooner we have information, the sooner we can start trying to make decisions um is that was the tightness of that timeline partially to try to inform the um
early childhood uh in part but more to inform our budget conversations yeah i know i understand the budget it's more like i think we're talking about budget for like the next five or ten years it's sort of the way is the way i the way i'm thinking about this so it's not so much um what skyscraper
are we going to build this coming year um so as i think as long as the um the we have a plan for how we would adapt to the early childhood needs if we did not have a full recommendation or if this completed uh by november i think that would be totally fine to to move that if that was
i can say a little bit about that um my you remember last if we go back a year well not quite a year we had an early childhood task force last fall my intention is to hit the ground running with that in september um with the question of we've got the four year olds coming what are our
options for the threes and i'd like to have that process played out by november i mean maybe this information that they're going to provide be helpful in that discussion well yes and no i don't think that the information they provide is going to be able to
give us that many options for immediately for next school year for when the three-year-olds come. I think it's more long-term. I think that's kind of where I don't really see how we would be making a budgetary decision in January. I mean, I know early on in the process and it felt this way to folks in Powell I know that we would try to shoehorn a decision into a timeline that could possibly change the entire purpose of the Powell school by the time we get the three-year-olds. I don't think that's realistic. I think that we're going to have to figure out what we can do for three-year-olds for school year after next, based on the options that are available.
And in the meantime, what we're starting here is the much longer-term process of what more seismic changes may we make. So potentially, the three-year-olds is not the permanent plan for the three-year-olds. It could just be our entry point.
yeah we we probably could help you think about that as part of the process because we're already in every one of the buildings so i don't know how you were imagining come to some early childhood task force meetings in the fall yeah yeah happy to join via zoom it's like yeah it's pretty easy
to once you're in the building offering recommendations to think about how you would do something or how you would not do it so even if you told us what you were thinking we could say that might conflict with some things you would do down the line yeah so happy to offer that advice
yep and to since people probably are curious two of the biggest options that are front of mind for me at the moment are a we can bring three-year-olds who need services in with four-year-olds so to the degree that we have space we may be able to bring some three-year-olds in
to be served with our four-year-olds and two a piece of information that was not available last fall is that the United Way is evidently going to be opening a big child care center in Freeport that may or may not have the capacity to help us provide a site for some services in town.
But that should meet the regulatory requirements of us meeting the needs at this facility. Yeah, they have to have a three-star rating from the DOE, and I don't know how that's shaping up yet, But I have had some talks with folks at the Freeport Town office about it, who are kind of a liaison.
So there may be possibilities that we couldn't have imagined last fall. So this might be a Kelly Wentworth question, but I don't know if it was earlier. And I mentioned the travel piece and the other expenses. If we approve $150,000, but we know it's going to be more than $150,000, do we have a sense
of what the additional expenditures might be, and should we include that in our approval now, or do we not need to do that? Could I ask a question, Clark, because I want to go back to your... I know about the travel. What other expenses were you referencing?
What a great question. I can pull this up. I don't know if it was in there. Well, this was our budget carrying this expense in that it says to support coordination efficiency, RRC 5 will assign a district point of contact to participate fully in the process. And in my mind, this person is on call at all times for zero EDI.
And so I was wondering, do we have somebody with this kind of flexible time? And if we don't, would this be an additional budgetary expense? I'm not going to do that as a new person. I feel like that's just, Jeff can call me when he needs to. Okay, great. The way it was worded was causing me some stomach pains.
I think they just don't want to have to, like, college school and coordinate, like, you know, you call one person and you coordinate all the things you need and the data collection and all that kind of stuff. Yeah, the way it's worded makes it sound like it's a dedicated person carried by us.
Yeah. I mean, I do think that spread over Glenn and Kelly and me and Ginny and Mandy and the principals, It's going to announce a whole person's worth of your work. But we're rugged. That's what I said about you, Tom. Um, do you, okay, and what's the answer to the question about do we need to include the travel piece?
It does say service fees as well, so that's service fees and travel. Jeff, do you have a sense of how much we'd be talking about in travel and service fees? Sir, service fees? Um... Is that the, is that the enrollment? But that's already picked up in here, right? Oh, that's included, yeah. Yeah. What line specifically are you looking at?
This is at the bottom of the investment options. At the very bottom, it does say, in addition to the service fees. These are the service fees. Oh, this is the service fees. This is like 150 is the service fees. Although we're also responsible for their travel expenses. This is what happens when I do a meeting after a long day of work. I mean, we're in July. For everyone's benefit, we try to be efficient in travel.
So we're not going to come out for a day, go back, come out for another day. We're going to try to spend a few days. You know, a lot of it is going to be based on that coordination with Tom and his team so that we're not coming on the wrong day when everybody's on vacation.
So we're, you know, modest, you know, we're not flying first class. Yeah, well, I expect the travel for Dr. Dahloff would be minimal. Minimal, that's right. He might ride his bike here. You can ride by scooter. You'll do it with the scooter. And there's no markup on that, obviously. We'll invoice you. Perfect. So are we talking something that could easily be taken out of a reserve account or something like that?
Or, yeah, through other parts. I mean, that was just my question. Should we be doing 150? Should we be doing 160 to uncover travel? I don't know. I think it wouldn't hurt if you felt amenable to 160. Yeah. I mean, does that seem about right?
And just understand that, you know, this is more for us and doesn't limit your ability to, like, you know. I mean, for my end, I'm thinking one trip. So maybe two people, we could, I mean, if we want to be lean, we could just do one person, but probably two people would be good.
So I feel like we could put together some sort of estimate, but, I mean, ten grand is probably more than enough. i think yeah and i mean i for our team it's going to depend on um you know being in those sessions with you um so yeah i think 10 is reasonable i don't i mean like i said i mean obviously we'll
cover your care expenses we'll be involved in the conversation i just want to you know maybe just just we don't have to come back is this what you're saying yeah exactly if it ends up being more than we need it's not a problem to transfer the rest of that money to yeah yeah yeah oh because
that that is the other piece of this is the um the recommendation um is that it's coming from the capital reserve right and so if we approve 160 and it ends up being 157.5 we move 157.5 leave the rest in the capital reserve so i'm assuming that by asking the extra 10 000 it's
just kind of just giving us a little buffer or like or just basically a little bit of a nest egg kind of just to give us an area because we know that there are going to be travel expenses we just don't know the exact amount so this would give us the ability to cover with a little bit
bit of comfort you know what we think that would be and if it's less than that we don't need it we'll leave it right where it is in the capital reserve thank you yeah well i'm just going to point out this is not money that we are having to raise it's already in the account we just are
giving ourselves the authorization to expect this right other questions on the proposal the presentations the deliverables obviously thank you for coming no problem thank you so much All right, I'm going to put, do we have a motion for consideration of approval to expend up to an additional $60,000 for voting purposes?
If we approve this, are we also approving the timeline, or is that something that can be further worked out? We're just approving the money to pay for it. Okay, great. Thank you. And I actually, now that I have a question from Mike, I actually don't see the deliverables.
page 22 before their team bios kind of the final systems will include yeah sorry do you want a second to let's do that are you good I'm good okay all right so do I have a motion for consideration and approve it to expend up to an additional sixty thousand dollars for the systems and
sustainability study for a total of one hundred and sixty thousand dollars additional funds to come from the Capitol Reserve. Colin and Valerie, thank you. Any other questions, comments? All those in favor? Great. Done a post. Thank you all. Thank you so much. Did Glenn just run out? Is he like jumping in his camper? He literally is one of his like, he's departing for camping. He's going off. Bye. Thank you, Lewis,
Jeff, Andrew. Thank you. See you soon. Can he take you guys out for a lobster roll? Oh, see, I was thinking of scales when he was talking about the beautiful place and the James Beard. Yes. Enjoy, it's fantastic. All right, so we have no new business. We'll move on to 14A personnel.
Do I have a motion for consideration and approval to allow the superintendent to create positions until the first board meeting in September for the Special Education Early Childhood Program with funding to come from the Early Childhood Subsidy from the state.
Valerie and Anna. Great. Tom. Yeah, so this is untrodden ground for us all, but the impetus for this is that now that we are going to be serving early childhood and now that we've communicated it to the community, it is as we suspected. If you build it, they will come. and we're doing IEP meetings for kids who are coming in from CDS,
and the number of kids who require a one-to-one, for example, is increasing. So we're just in this awkward period where it's the summer, and you did give me authority to hire, but what you didn't want to give me the authority to do is create positions. And that's what we need to do so that we can have these in place for the school year to start.
So the important limitation is that I wouldn't be creating positions It would only be for the Special Education Early Childhood Program, and these would be positions that should come from the state's subsidy for that, so it should be budget neutral for us.
I do want to add the important caveat that every expense in this category has to be cleared by the folks at DOE as reasonable and necessary, and as we write the IEPs, we are doing what we think is reasonable and necessary and hoping that they will agree, but it is kind of what we need to do to meet the needs of the kids.
Don't most of these kids already have IEPs through CDS? Well, they do, but now they're transitioning into public school. Oh, okay, so it's a whole new, yeah. Yeah, okay. And I got a little bit twitchy about the should we covered by the subsidy.
What is our, I think I know the answer to this, so it's kind of a set-up question, but what is our backup if it is not? So we will know if they consider the costs reasonable and necessary on a quarterly basis, because that's when they reimburse us. And our backup would be, we would need to find the money in Article 2. And if we needed to move money from one article to another, as that went along, we would have to come to you.
Okay. And we also have an Article 2 reserve that we could draw from if we needed to. Yes. Okay. Great. And so that's one piece that I don't love, but I understand. And then the other piece is, given how challenging it is to find special ed techs, are we concerned about the ability to find people for these positions? And if we can't, how are we going to deliver on the IEPs?
I'm less concerned than I was a few months ago, simply because now that we have a new contract that very generously increases the pay, we are, well, Emily Grimm said to me just yesterday, I've had great news, I'm interviewing for two ed tech positions, and I have four candidates.
Oh, okay, that's good. Not that we were, but we were in better shape than we were. Okay, great. Other questions? Yeah. So what is our guarantee on the reimbursement of that? Just I know that like they say should, but things are changing as you know, like you blink and it changes. So what is our guarantee on that? Or do we have one?
That is a great question. No, no, it's a perfect question. It's something that all of us, when I say us, I mean superintendents, board members, etc., have been asking since the state passed this mandate. So what the state has promised is that, and I don't have familiar, you may be, with what the mandate is,
but it's basically that three- and four-year-olds who have special education needs had been being served by CVS. now we have to do it. And the state is taking the money that it was giving to CDS and sending it aside to school districts, and they're saying that they will need all reasonable and necessary,
that's their language, programming needs for each kid with an IEP. So in theory, if the IEP says this kid needs a one-to-one ed tech, the state should recognize that as reasonable and necessary. We did, you know, when we were working this out last year
making the decision whether to join cohort three or not, we did run into difficulties around this because they changed what they felt was reasonable and necessary from one month to the next. So I can't sit here with a straight face and tell you that that couldn't happen again because it's a decision that lies with them. I say that only because I do home health care and I've seen promises for things and then just just because i can hear you but it picks it up for the first time i just understand mandates
because i i work in home health care and we have this state has changed mandates for us as well um in the last six months to what they're doing with rural education it's not much different than but it's on the medicare level um not that that's here or there but because of that they promise and
then sometimes things get cut and it's not again so that's why i asked so it's a very good question i really get it all right um do we have a guess on how many positions this might be i don't the i mean when i was emailing the board when i was emailing the board last week
they were literally coming in by the hour um which was when i was like okay we're getting something different than this. Since then, I haven't had any new ones. So they have finished out the kind of big push for IEPs at the end of the school year. The only thing I can think now
is a family's move in. Thank you. All right, so we have a motion and a second on the floor. Any other questions? All those in favor? None opposed. Thank you. All right, public comment? Alright, so then I would take a motion for consideration and approval to enter into executive session for discussion of a confidential record pursuant to 1 MRSA section 4056F.
Collin and Anna, thank you. All those in favor. Great, thank you.
Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.
