TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 23 September 2026
Board meeting · 3 h 18 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →
30,594 words in 38 five-minute windows.
Yeah, it's one of the weird frugalities that actually doesn't exist. Good evening. Ooh, all right, we'll move the mic back a little bit. Welcome to the RSU 5 Board of Directors meeting. It is Wednesday, September 23rd, 2026. We are here at the Freeport High School Library, and we have a full board here.
So we will get started with the Pledge of Allegiance. flag the united states of america and to the republic which it stands one nation under god indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay uh so in your packet we have minutes from
the september 9th meeting and do i have a motion for consideration and approval of the minutes from september 9 2026 as presented barring any errors or omissions thank you valerie and cara all those in favor great none opposed uh adjustments to the agenda no right correct
moving right along um so we will move on to good news and recognition and we will look to moon for our update everyone so not a ton has happened you know the last couple weeks but you know a couple things have happened here and there so last week on the 16th juniors and seniors had a had nami
Maine come to present to us for National Suicide Prevention Month and show the shared info about mental health, strategies to support those struggling, kind of ways to maintain your own mental health, and also resources for support if you're struggling or maybe your friend's struggling.
And also next week we also have Spirit Week, which is great. So Monday it's anything but a backpack day. Tuesday is Country vs. Country Club. Wednesday is Twin Day. Thursday is USA Day. And Friday is Class Colors, as we have our pep rally. And so hopefully that's going to be really fun. Also, I guess a great note is that also a lot of our sports teams are doing great this season. So it's really awesome to see how everyone's really thriving. Like, for example, the boys' soccer is ranked 10th. Girls' Cross Country is ranked top two right now. Football team is undefeated, which is really awesome to see. So I'm excited for the pep rally, or I guess homecoming game. So that's going to be awesome. And also the girls' soccer is ranked 7th. So really, everyone's doing great, and it's really awesome to see that. and I'll also today during advisory um the advisees made wrote on green sticky notes for
mental health and so we usually wrote just positive notes and affirmations just to support those who are struggling and kind of just and you'll see them in hard shapes around the whole school yeah that's about it thank you I did see those on the way in of course I was late for the
committee meeting so I didn't have a chance to read them so I will catch them on the way out thank you all right uh so we will move on to public comment um so how we'll we'll handle public comment was we'll ask you to come to the microphone uh give us your name the town where
you live and we ask you to keep your comments to three minutes and then we will carry through everyone we have thank you very much uh appreciate the hard work that you all do it's also nice to see, thank you. It's also nice to see the continuity. So we're trying a new system here, so. That's all
right. Can't throw me off. It's nice to see the continuity here, and people like Michelle, I know, have been working for years for our school system. I'm very grateful. My name is Jonas Werner. I live here in Freeport, and I'm here on behalf of Freeportfolio, which is a micro-nonprofit founded
less than two years ago by Freeport's residents John Egan and me based on the simple premise that poetry builds community. Since then we have worked hard to bring high quality free donation supported poetry programming to area residents of all ages. That mission is exactly why I'm here to ask for
your help to increase access and participation in poetry in our school system. We feel the middle school would be a great place to start because this is an age when students are learning to think in more complex ways, and poetry gives them a shared language for close reading, precise writing,
confident expression, skills that carry into every subject and into adulthood. As it has for all of us, whether we realize it or not, poetry has been part of all of our lives since we were born. Poetry has the power also to unite a room full of different people with different backgrounds
and different ages together around the same words. There are resources for our teachers already available, and they are core curriculum friendly. The Academy of American Poets maintains a full library of free classroom materials, including grade-level lesson plans, a weekly Teach This
Poem series, and Poem a Day, introducing students to a wide range of voices at no cost to the district. Free Portfolio is partnered with Freeport Community Library for National Poetry Month, an initiative supported by the Academy of American Poets. Free Portfolio is also connected with the
Academy's Education Ambassador, U.S. Presidential Inaugural Poet, Richard Blanco. Richard was the Freeport Folio Open Mic Featured Poet this past July and has offered to support Freeport students directly. In addition, we have also made important connections with the Maine Poets Laureate who treat poetry education in our school system as integral to their work. We welcome the opportunity to work with our schools, provide support,
and help bring more poetry into the classroom. we ask you to consider helping us to make this happen with our support and growing resources thank you if you have any questions happy to answer them but I'm just here to hopefully plant a seed and maybe y'all could help us make the
right connections to help make these things happen we're working with the library for poetry competition for students next year I'm working with the current Maine poet laureate right now to put together a workshop for National
poetry month for students um so we're already working to create events for young people but we'd love to be able to connect with some people at the middle school thank you thank you and have a good night good luck hi everyone i am kate mcgillia i'm a freeport parent and resident
um first one i just reiterate i'm really appreciative of all the work and passion teachers administrators district leadership and then you all and continuing to being open to continuous learning and I just want to remind everyone here we
all care deeply about kids and that the board you are the ultimate and only accountability to all students in the district being set up to learn in the state of Maine so I'm here as a parent to continue to advocate and work together
and name and pursue what we know must be true for all kids the foundations and ongoing instruction to result in what we know is possible that 95 percent of kids can become proficient readers. I'm therefore formally requesting board action in moving forward
previously named literacy priorities with clear measurable actions and timeline in advance of the school year 27-28 budget cycle in January. So I'm specifically requesting that the board move up evidence-based curriculum review for tier one instruction for K-3 literacy that occur in the
fall, that it's a rigorous and publicly transparent rubric and review process aligned with the main statewide literacy action plan and national standards, and then a request that these findings and recommendations are incorporated into the school year 27-28 budget cycle.
This was previously established as a priority for the school year, as we kind of talked about last year, the ongoing reading proficiency and lack of alignment of units of study and supplementary curriculum. So the literacy plan that you'll look at today, it's too late. It won't
be incorporated into the budget strategy. So this would need to be earlier in order to be incorporated into fiscal year, school year 27-28. Otherwise, it would mean two years of kids not having the instruction they need. And I'm sure that you all have seen the national and local concerns
about the lack of alignment of main curriculum, including RSC5, with what's been proven to set up all students for literacy success including students with disabilities students from poverty who do not have the resources for supplemental tutoring and I just want to rename that we really
need to do a side-by-side analysis we need to look at the main statewide literacy action plan the supplementary curriculum against means guidance and national standards and let the public be shared on valid student data using assessments aligned to national and state
standards disaggregated by subgroup for students with disabilities, students of color, students with 504s, and students from low socioeconomic status. I want to reiterate that the reading rope lower strands means that the tier one, so the general education curriculum that all kids get, it has to
be proactively built into that. There are nationally norm standards about how you determine if a curriculum is aligned to those foundations. Units of study read, write, ink, and does not meet those expectations via any independent evaluation. Thank you. Wow, it just keeps going. Thank you, Kate.
Sorry, we're figuring out our new system there. Yeah. Okay, do we have any other public comments? All right, we will continue. We have set aside time for you to have a rich discussion as a board about where do we go based on their recommendations. So, very important work. That
leads me to my next point, which is the Early Childhood Task Force. So we front-loaded that work this year because I wanted the task force and its considerations to be part of the Systems and Sustainability Study. So that task force has already met twice. It will meet one more time next
week. By that time, it will have some recommendations about how we move forward with early childhood. We won't have every answer at that point. And that's because we have a challenge with the timing of the information we know. So I want to sort of paint a picture of that. We stepped into this work last year, part of the state's cohort three. And as you know, we've taken on the responsibility for four-year-olds this year.
That was a relatively easy lift because we already have pre-K and we have the early intervention team. And part of what we learned last year is that we were already serving 75% of the four-year-olds who had IEPs. With three-year-olds, we're going to come up against constraints that we haven't
with four-year-olds. We've never worked with three-year-olds before. The rules for three-year-olds are different. We're close to maxing out the space that we have. And we don't have as much information yet about the individual kids that we will serve, those three-year-olds, and we won't
know the full picture of that until we get much closer to assuming responsibility. The state doesn't release that information until we are three months from the time of assuming that responsibility for those children. So as in so many areas of education, we are forced to live
in a bit of a fog for a while, and that is never comfortable. However, that stated, it doesn't mean that we shouldn't be thinking about. Some of the big picture things we do know this far out into the fog. One of them is, the three-year-olds are coming. Two. We're a visual just marching through the fog. Can you see it? Beautiful little three-year-olds coming out of the fog. Second, we will need to serve them. And we will need to serve them at a level and in a way that is congruent with our values. And what we have to determine as what that is. So here's another thing we know. The state promises that they will meet the
reasonable and necessary costs that the IEPs of those three-year-olds incur. I think it's reasonable and necessary for us to consider the fact that we may define reasonable and necessary differently from the state. And we do that often. We do that with K-12 education. We far and away
exceed the EPS funding for every child because we want our kids to have things like art and music and things that are very hard to afford if you just pay with the state subsidy, if you just deliver on the state subsidy. So, reasoning that it may very well be congruent with our values,
not just to sit at the minimum, but to go beyond and to really develop a vision for what this district wants to do with early childhood. We need to think about that now. We don't need to have the answer now, but we need to think about that now. And as we get closer to some decisions,
some of which will need to show up in this year's budget, and some of it which will definitely be integrated into Zeal's recommendations, that is where we sit now with this process. So I think one of the benefits of bringing the task force as early as we possibly could in the
school year is that it gives us as much time as possible to just, I think one of the things maybe we've learned over the past year is that when change, in the process of change, the very first step is just sitting with the idea of change. So that's what we have to sit with
right now. And we will flesh it out as we go along. But I want you to know that's where we are right now. I'm seeing an integration of figuring out what we need to do for early childhood and where it fits into the long-term sustainability of the district, which is the task in front of us.
And now I wanted to talk about a few facilities items. Shall we talk about the roof of this building? So we've had a bit of a calamity with the gym roof. I put it in my weekly updates. Unfortunately, the gym is not usable right now. The reason we got where we are is because the roofing projects were part of a longer-term plan, and we had intended to get both of those done over the summer.
Glenn made the decision to prioritize, and rightly so, the roof over the art room, because that space definitely could not be renovated when there were students in the building. And all early signs, including what the engineers told us, was that the gym roof could be done while there were students in the building. So they got into the art room over the summer. Then the art room took longer than expected because there was asbestos there, and it just took a while.
And so when they moved on to the gym and started to work on that roof, the way that roof was, Glenn could explain this better than I can, but the way it was originally constructed is that there was a rubberized, it's a flat roof, there was a rubberized mat, and there were river rocks weighing that mat down. It's called a ballast roof. It's being replaced with a different kind of roof that is secured in a different way. When the crew got up top and started working on it,
there was mortar at the top of the walls, and the core sampling the engineers had done on the roof did not take that into account. And so when they started working on it from the top, pieces of mortar from the top of the walls started falling down into the gym. So we stopped that process right away.
We got the kids out. Nobody was hurt. And then we just had to make decisions about how to go forward. Unfortunately, you know, the work can only happen during daylight hours, which are waning. And we just sort of have to get by. I'm kind of glad it's September, not January, while this is happening.
It's certainly been an inconvenience to staff and students, but hopefully that situation will be resolved soon. Glenn tells me that by the first week of October, meaning week after next, we should hopefully have that wrapped up.
Also, the middle school roof. There was work being done on the middle school roof the other day. And in the room in front of the gym, a drain pipe, an old cast iron drain pipe. The elbow failed and it flooded the room that's in front of the gym.
So that's been cleaned up. It's being aired out. But these are just the kinds of things that we're dealing with with older buildings. Finally, I just want to let everybody know that next week we have an additional facilities meeting.
This is an additional meeting beyond the regularly scheduled monthly meetings. And this is specifically to talk about tennis court options. And hopefully we will be in a position after that to bring to the board recommendations for what sort of tennis courts and how many tennis courts to go with and get that project going so that we can have tennis.
And the last thing I want to mention before I'm done is that, as you've seen, there has been an invitation to all of us up here for an upcoming regional meeting on September 29th at Falmouth Elementary School. It's from the Greater Portland Council of Governments. It's a workshop called Deepening Regional Collaboration, and it is intended to focus on opportunities that would merge and perhaps consolidate, I don't know to what degree or in what way, municipal and school services with the aim of containing costs and improving long-term sustainability in the region so that meeting is
occurring next tuesday night i will be attending all of you are invited to attend if it's going to include school administrators and school board members and municipal administrators and town government elected officials from the towns that it involves that's going to be a lot of people
so um you are cordially invited and that's all i have for tonight did they invite administrators from the schools too no it's district administrators oh sorry yeah and i think i think they did request an rsvp if folks were gonna go i believe yes they did okay so if you do plan to go please let them
know so they can plan accordingly for all the folks all right thank you so we will move on to item nine on the administrator, on the agenda, which is administrator reports. And we will start with Kelly Finance. Good evening. Included in your packet tonight are the expenses through August 31st,
2026. As you know, that's a pretty quiet time of year for the school buildings. And so short of encumbering staff, there isn't a lot of expenditures that are done. We are on track. The schools have been ordering, we'll be paying, so we should have a little bit better number of
where we think we're going to be beginning the school year when we look at next year's, I'm sorry, next month's report. Michelle did mention to me earlier today that she was hoping as part of my presentation, I could not only wear my finance hat, but my HR hat and actually talk
about the open positions in the district. So I quickly gathered that information. So as far as educators, we still have a posting for the teacher of the deaf. As you recall, last year during the budget process, we added that position. We were using and are still continuing to use a contract
service provider for that position right now, but we would really like to have a staff member fill that position. The other open educator position is the kindergarten teacher at Moore Street. But there is a candidate on your agenda this evening for consideration for that position. Moving on to
support staff, we currently have a school year bus driver position open. We have a year-round head custodian position open at Pondell Elementary School. We have a year-round custodian position open at Freeport High School. We have a pre-K ed tech three open. We discussed this at the last
board meeting. The board approved that position, so that is open. We have one gen ed ed tech. Superintendent Gray mentioned the resignation today. That is here at the high school and supports the multi-lingual learner program. And we have four special education ed tech three positions
open, one at Morris, one at Mass, one at the high school, and one at Durham Community School. And then, of course, Superintendent Gray mentioned the administrator opening for the transportation director, but we have not gotten it to a point where we can post yet. All right, thank you.
Questions for Kelly? You're clear? Thank you. All right, so we will move on to item 9B, which is uh mandy lewis our new assistant superintendent um will be providing an overview for of the rsu5 instructional practices for math literacy and technology i think she's gonna
well she might already be she's she's gonna use the yeah so we'll move screen and mandy before you start just i would just invite everybody to the ask on this is kind of like for the moon this is a huge topic. So Mandy has really delved into this and I think made it very digestible.
Thank you for that, Superintendent Gray. And thank you for inviting me to engage in this discussion. The first two months of me joining RSU-5 has included a lot of learning, a lot of opportunities to visit classrooms, engage with students, and see the great work that's happening. I can't be
more excited to join such a reflective group of educators here as superintendent gray shared I am here to give what I'm calling a landscaped landscape presentation on literacy math and technology for us to consider just to
ground the information that you're about to hear in our mission statement I wanted to take a moment to read that under our new strategic plan our goal is to empower and equip every learner with skills curiosity character and
purpose to thrive and live fulfilling lives in an ever-changing world the content areas that we'll dig into this evening I think are really also directly connected to three particular core values of cognitive growth real-world
relevance and emotional intelligence and character building just a quick overview of this presentation in the way that it's organized for each of the different content areas you'll notice that there will be some goal the goal of instruction, some key instructional components, key core curricular components, and then assessments
of learning. It is not all-encompassing, but really more just painting a picture. Ooh. There we go. More just painting a picture for future conversations on these particular topics. Okay. The Scarborough's reading group has already mentioned this evening,
Just to be thinking about as we look at literacy in English language arts to begin, those who are unfamiliar with Scarborough's Reading Rope, it's really giving us a visual to understand the overall goal of our work with early childhood literacy
in the two strands that work together. One strand really focuses on language comprehension, including vocabulary, background knowledge, syntax, and reasoning. The second strand really focuses on word recognition, including decoding fluency and automatic word reading.
Really, in order to build that early childhood literacy, both of those components need to be part of the program. Just a quick overview of the pre-K to 5 group of our work with literacy. You'll notice that current practices integrate foundational reading skills with opportunities to strengthen comprehension.
Listed here are some of the key instructional elements. I've had the opportunity to spend time in classrooms at all grade levels in this grade span in the first four weeks of school or three and a half weeks of school, and I've
been able to see the joy that teachers are bringing to the lessons and the key instructional components here that you're seeing. The curricular resources are kind of grouped in terms of Read Write Inc., Hegarty Phonemic Awareness, and the units of study in reading, writing, and phonics. the assessment of learning piece you'll notice a number of assessments listed
there I'll speak a little bit more about what we will be doing with this assessment information later on in the presentation in fact at our next board meeting we'll take a look at data in particular related to some of these
assessments as well as math and other data points as well to give us a better sense of where our students are as learners in relation to these areas Moving on to the next grade span of 6 through 8 literacy in ELA, you'll notice that the literacy instruction here emphasizes higher levels of reading comprehension, communication skills, and critical thinking, while also still building on strengthening the two components of the Scarborough's rope.
In terms of key instructional elements, you'll notice that there are some that continue from the earlier grades. You'll also notice that there are some differences. There's more opportunities for interactive learning in a less guided way, which is a natural growth as students progress
through the grades. You'll also notice that the core curricular resources move away from a more prescriptive curriculum and more toward standards that are articulated in the main learning results and the common core English language arts standards they
continue to guide our work and teachers use those standards in order to plan their lessons and units the assessment of learning is also provided there again we'll take a look at data from those different assessments later on as a as a
board together one additional detail to highlight the state has recently launched what they're calling a playbook which is a collection of resources for both literacy and math that really leans into the state literacy action plan and
the state math action plan and on Monday I had the opportunity to attend one of the launch sites and it is overwhelming to see the resources that are now available at the early grade levels as well as middle and high school, and I
think it will give us a really important opportunity to reflect on our practices as well. Then we continue to progress in the upper grade span, so grades 9 through 12, you'll notice here that students grow in their maturity both
in terms of how tall they're getting and how their brains are working, their social-emotional world, as well as their critical thinking skills. You'll notice that in the upper grades, teachers build on the foundational skills by advancing students'
sophistication of language through close reading and analysis, synthesis, and inference. The main learning results and the common core state standards continue to provide the backbone of the curriculum, and students have more options for their courses at this level. In fact, here is just
a snapshot of the course offerings for those who haven't had a chance to take a look at that information yet. Of course, there are some courses at the high school that are more prescriptive. When you think about the AP language courses and the goal of those particular courses,
the work that teachers do in preparing students for those AP exams is through a fairly rigorous and prescribed way in order to help students be successful. Just to look at what's ahead in terms of literacy, our fall data review, which will happen at our next board meeting,
will include information from the BAS, from Acadians, from the main three-year assessment, PSAT, and SAT. I'll speak about this at the end of the presentation as well, but the last page in the handout that you have is a quick cheat sheet with information about the
different assessments that you're hearing referenced here, and I'll speak about that at the end of the presentation. I also just wanted to surface the questions that teachers and administrators are asking I mentioned this at the start of this
presentation but I continue to be amazed by the reflective nature of educators that we have in RSU 5 and even if they are very open to the number of questions that I continue to ask as a new member here and they show great thought in ways
that we want to continue to improve our practice to meet the needs of our learners so some of the questions that we're grappling with include what information is the data telling us and not telling us about our students as readers and writers what is the role of systematic phonics instruction at what
point do we engage interventions and are the benchmarks we use appropriate one opportunity I think we have in particular in that question is to look at our practices district-wide in thinking about this opportunity of our new
strategic plan and opening up building to building conversations for consistency and equity to services? And then finally, how do we define our benchmarks across grade levels and schools? Those are just some of the questions that are being asked. On that note,
we're going to shift our thinking a little bit to get some information about math. When you think about our mathematics instruction, I think there's a lot of emphasis on active, collaborative, mathematical thinking. There's a lot of work being done this year to get our youngest learners
thinking like mathematicians. Not just engaging in the curriculum, but actually really wrapping their brains around and developing new synapses around understanding math. A note about mathematical thinking, again, as we think about our kindergarten classrooms, last year it was introduced a new
way of thinking about numbers through what's called a number corner, which features short daily workouts that introduce, reinforce, and extend skills and concepts related to the critical areas of study of math. Because of the success last year in kindergarten that has moved into
first grade, I had the opportunity to join a professional development facilitation yesterday by our learning strategists, our instructional strategists, where they engaged all of the first grade teachers. It was exciting to see the ways that they were helping students think again about
math, that mathematical thinking piece. I think just a couple of other things to note about our pre-k to five math instruction you'll notice that we have a variety of assessments of learning some of those listed up here are screeners the
difference between a screener and an assessment a screener is more indicative of where a student may be at that time in terms of direct instruction an assessment such as the main through year may be more of a end of time capture of
where they may be against a state standard I'll continue to talk about the difference between a screener and an assessment like the main through year to help us grow all of our understanding as we move into the middle grades grades
six through eight the emphasis continues to be on collaborative learning math becomes more complex and more problem-solving based some of the key instructional elements here some of our teachers were able to engage in some
building thinking classrooms work and having students up and more vertical and different roles to play while they work through problems. You'll notice if you observe different math classes that there's random grouping and regrouping of students and they're engaged in kind of real
world meaningful mathematical tasks. Our core curriculum for the middle grades, which actually extends into 9th and 10th grade as well is Big Ideas Math. We have some urgency to actually review our math curriculum because of the way Big Ideas is shifting. At the end of this year,
Big Ideas will look different, and we need to make a decision about whether or not we'll continue with Big Ideas as a resource, prompting us to finalize a curriculum review that I'll speak about in just a minute. Then again, we move into the upper grades where the complexity
of mathematical concepts and procedures continues to grow. Students have a lot of opportunity and different options as they move their way through high school. Trying to capture some of the key instructional elements at the high school level was a bit trickier just because of the nature of
some of the specific skill-based math classes, and I'll speak about that in just a minute. Again, at this level, teachers are leaning into the main learning results and common core math standards for core curriculum concepts. They also have specific resources such as those used for
advanced placement course planning. Again, assessment of learning is very similar to what you saw for literacy and ELA. We have the main through year assessment, PSAT, SATs. We also do have access to AP exam results too, which could be another thing for us to think about. To give you
just a snapshot of different courses available to students at the high school, I've provided them in what what I tried to group in different pathways one thing that may be helpful for the board as we look at our math curriculum review is just to
consider what the pathways are for students based on where they're entering in the information for the middle grades you'll note that one of the curricular resources was for polynomials we do have students who are taking a more advanced
level of math which puts them at a different level when they enter high school. So I wonder if there would be a future opportunity to look at what different pathways there are for students. Similar to what I shared with literacy and ELA, here's the snapshot of
data that you will see later at our next board meeting. We'll use the number sense screener, main three-year assessment, PSAT and SAT. Questions that we're grappling with this year, what is our data telling us and not telling us about math skill development?
What are our grade level expectations? I'll note that this work started previously. It did not come to a point of conclusion last year. So that's why I think for some of our educators, they're eager to continue to define this information.
How do we define our benchmarks across grades and schools? And at what point do students receive intervention? That goes back to our MTSS systems and an opportunity for us to make them consistent across the district. All right, finally, we're going to switch gears a little bit and think about technology.
Technology has direct connections to both math and literacy because some of what we use for instructional materials lives online. For our middle school learners in particular, you'll notice if you have a middle school student, their math homework is often utilized on their one-to-one
device. So we'll talk about that in just a minute. This gives just an overview of devices in the district so that we all have a sense of what students have access to in pre-k to five excuse me in pre-k and k there are clusters of iPads it is not a one-to-one
setup in grades two through five it does have a one-to-one setup but they are used very sparingly at that grade level at those grade levels there are particular instructional resources that are used you'll notice up there epic and
and Sora are particularly helpful to support our readers. There are also different intervention programs that live online as well. Grades 6 through 8 and 9 through 12 is really when we enter that one-on-one world more directly.
And I think we are not alone in asking questions about technology use, amount of screen time, and how it's being used or not used as an educational tool. I'll talk a little bit about some learning Tom and I had last week. We had an opportunity to attend the new legislative updates. Drummond and Woodson puts this on each year for educational leaders. One item that was highlighted was that there is going to be a survey, if it hasn't gone out already, it will be going out soon, to gather statewide information related to technology.
The state is trying to get a sense of what it currently looks like for our students to then provide more direct and specific guidance around some of the restraints, essentially helping to put up more barriers on access now that we know how clear the research is around the amount of screen time.
I'm excited for that work because I think we're asking those same questions here, and I know at the curriculum committee that will be a topic that we engage in as well. In terms of our technology work this year, later in the, I think it's in the December board meeting, there'll be an opportunity for Sam Rigby and I to give an additional presentation related to technology.
My hope for the curriculum work this year is to engage in different strands of review, artificial intelligence being one, getting a sense of what are the resources we're using for students to access online. Sam is being really helpful in gathering that information for me.
Thinking about how we're educating students around social media access and their lives online, as well as other digital literacy components. And so I think that we're excited to engage in that work as well. Just to summarize some of the next steps.
Again, tonight was really more of a high-level presentation to create a foundation of understanding for us, knowing there will be additional conversations about literacy, math, and technology. The Curriculum and Program Development Committee has already started our conversations about both math and literacy,
and they will be really helpful in determining how we navigate curriculum review cycles, knowing that this will be a new process for RSU-5. From what I understand, again, I'm only two months in, there have been curriculum discussion opportunities. I think what may have been missing from those was the review process
and looking at our work in comparison to standards, what we are being expected to provide our students with in terms of their education. And educators are really excited to dig into that work. And so I'm looking forward to that. Our goal was to start math, literacy, and technology this year.
I also recognize that in order to do that, we are asking teachers to leave the classroom. Research shows that one of the best things to do to maximize student learning is to have the teacher in the room. So, I want to thank the administrators for supporting that, and I know how precious that
time will be. And so, I'll make sure to have it be as meaningful as possible. I just want to acknowledge the support of this board in engaging in this work is incredibly helpful as well. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to be a facilitator of this.
As I shared earlier, in your packet, you do have an overview of just kind of a list that gives a quick snapshot of some of the screeners and assessments used, gives you a brief information about how long it takes, how it's administered, who looks at it, what we gain from it, and what some of the limitations are.
Please know it is not all-encompassing. In order to do that, it would have been a much longer document. That really is meant to be just a quick snapshot. So I'll pause there and see if there are any questions. Is that working?
Thank you. This is awesome, Mandy, and a lot of work. Under the questions we were grappling with this year, and perhaps this question came up and maybe it just didn't make it to the list of literacy and math, And I would hope that our teachers would want to put it on there, too.
I noticed on both it says, at what point do we engage interventions and are the benchmarks we use appropriate? I would also like to ask, what are we doing for students who are exceeding those benchmarks? Yeah, absolutely. And not just at the high school level where we offer honors classes or the middle school level where we offer polynomials in math.
What are we doing in literacy through K-8? what are we doing in math k6 i guess it would be um because those students exist too and meeting those students where they're at is also i feel equally as important to those that are not meeting
um those benchmarks yeah thank you for sharing that annie other questions for mandy i want to say thanks also um i guess i'm i'm just curious this is a snapshot of where we are not necessarily where we're going this is meant to be like a neutral document of this is what we're doing
Correct. Based on our conversation back in August, it felt like having a foundation of understanding as we then engaged in curriculum review cycles would be beneficial for all of us, including me. So this is intended to be what we intend the curriculum to be today and what we understand it to be today, not necessarily perhaps what others view it to be.
correct okay yeah sorry this packet is pretty um I'm impressed I'm not that it's just wow a lot of work thank you so much may I ask though when you when you did go in and do this so basically you assessed all of all different classrooms in different schools to get all a kind of an idea
of everything it's a great question um I actually used a collaborative process I wanted to make sure it was as accurate as possible. So I utilized time with our administrators, with our instructional coaches, with teachers as I had opportunities to engage with them, and certainly with my own
observations. And so I tried to use as many data points as I could in puddling this together. In a short period of time, which is really good. Thank you so much. Yeah, a really short period of time. Pretty sure it was the end of August when we dropped this on
your plate. So thank you for that. You know, one thing that I have said repetitively through the years, and since you're new, I get to say it again, is that, you know, I think our schools do a really nice job of finding, you know, identifying a need and finding a potential solution to those needs
and piloting different programs. And, you know, to the extent it's possible, it's great to be able to sort of share those those learnings across district and i think you know you alluded to that in your presentation and obviously this was you know like you said a foundational document so we
couldn't get into the nitty-gritty of you know this school does this and that school does that but really identifying the the tools that are are proven to be successful and you know advance the pilot right across the district so i'm excited to hear how that goes and one thing i'll add to
that, Michelle, is that in all of the conversations I've had, I think that educators are eager for that clear consistency of programming, and have identified that as a missing piece, I think, in their work. And so I look forward to that kind of collaborative effort, both in partnership with
educators, with data, with a curriculum committee, I think it's important work and exciting work. Yeah, and I think, you know, it's important to note that that work is already ongoing, right I mean there have been I think very intentional intentional work and
efforts I mean the one that comes to mind is is in middle school math right to try to bring the the kids from two different middle schools when they arrive in the same classroom at Freeport High School as freshmen that they are coming from a level playing field and there's been a lot of work to make that happen and I think it is so you know I just want to acknowledge the
work that is already happening and say I'm looking forward to the next I will also say thank you for this and the short notice very clear presentation I appreciate it I really also appreciate the questions we're grappling with this
year and each of these sections and I'm curious if you can shame share more about the strategies for answering these questions yeah what is your process what are you expecting that to look like that's great I think there are I think
that lives in several different places I think one place that it lives I have the opportunity to meet regularly with our administrators, both at the secondary level and at the elementary level, and I think that is a place where the conversation is ongoing. As we engage in curriculum review cycles, that will
include teachers ranging from all grade spans, interventionists, special educators, administrators, like that will be a real wide variety of educators in that process I think those questions in addition to others will be essential for
part of that process I think with our intervention team also looking at especially as we're we're engaging interventions and then I think with our chapter 104 team I have an opportunity to meet with them regularly as well and
thinking about how we're making sure to provide opportunities for students who are beyond expectations too so I think there are a lot of different collaborative opportunities um and and educators around the table grappling with those questions
and more i will acknowledge i did not capture all of them but those felt important to highlight tonight um i had a follow-up question i guess about um the math the tiered math in middle school do we is there an avenue for children or students that if they're let's say sort of near the top
of this not quite being in the fundamentals of polynomials or... Yeah, big ideas. Yes, and they end up in the other curriculum. Are they then just on that path now if they don't make it into the other path? Or is there potential for movement from one group to the other? I'm just concerned that once you're pigeonholed, you're in that group and now you're learning at this level and there's no way to either exceed or decelerate
if maybe that's more than you actually were prepared to do? That's a great question, and one that I think we're exploring with both our Chapter 104 team as well as our building administrators. I think we have an opportunity to be clearer about what options there are
for middle-level learners and what access points students then have at high school. And that goes back to, I think, as we look at, there's such a variety of options for students at the high school. What are the pathways to get students there? And so I don't have a very specific answer yet. It is one that we're working on through this year. Thank you. And I might be able to give you a little anecdotal information just from, and Moon might be able to as well, from just like how they pass through the classes at the high school. And I think, you know, Mandy's comment about paths might be helpful to see. Like, you know, traditionally the polynomials could go into either geometry or algebra two.
And then if you do Algebra 2, you could get to BC and AP Calculus. But if you came in as pre-calculus or pre-algebra as a freshman, you're probably not going to get to the BC AP class. But so to your question of kind of people in the middle, they do have the opportunity at the high school to take two math classes in a given year.
So I had one kid who started in geometry, and he doubled up so that he could take a calculus class as a senior. So they do have ways to, if you're like, oh, I really love math. He did not really love math. I don't know why he did it, but he did it. Maybe I made him. I don't know. So they do have, it's not like, oh, this is the class you took in seventh grade.
This is the path you march on until you graduate, right? there are ways to you know kind of step as you need to um i mean i don't know if it's the the cleanest route but i mean there are ways to do it are the students told these pathways i think
that's other things other places where there may be gaps is communication yeah yeah get this idea in their minds yeah like i'm in this path and now i'm doing this and now i'm doing that and this is the next step not given like this is the constellation i'm bringing back colin's
constellation constellation the constellation of things that you could potentially do as a next step you're not just having to do b because you've done a absolutely i guess as a person who also doubled up i would say like they also made it very clear like with guidance and also my algebra
one teacher like she they made it very clear like oh you can double up and if you want to take calculus senior year like that's you have the option of taking geometry and um i guess and algebra too which which is what i did and i made it very clear like kind of the expectations and
kind of the course coursework and really it was really quite easy doing both i didn't really find any struggles as mostly kind of were pretty tangible so i'd say they make it very clear that you can do it i was going to say the the guidance is is really helpful in that process
so what i'm hearing is although we are talking about pathways this is a little bit more fluid and flexible and individualized than just four pathways and you have to choose one of these four. Correct, that's my understanding too. I'll just echo again the thanks for the presentation
and also just the clarity that this is our current landscape and that we asked you to bring us up to speed in a way that allows us to then kind of dig deeper and you totally did that and we totally understand as well that you are on your own path of understanding what the heck it is that we do here. I have a couple of questions. I think the first is I think around,
and I know that you said that there's going to be a technology presentation later in December or something like that. I just wondered if you could speak briefly to what resources are currently made available to our teachers for either guiding them
in how students are using AI at different levels or what resources they're actually being provided to like lesson plans or curricula or anything around that? Yeah, that's a great question. I don't have a lot of information to share at this time. My understanding is that teachers are approaching that in ways that make sense for their content and their grade level. And that's happening the majority of the time at the high school. I had an opportunity to meet with representatives
from kind of a Southern Maine cohort around technology issues on Tuesday night. And I think we all acknowledged that there is no clear guidance yet from anywhere around how to best tackle this, both in terms of teaching students about what ai is how to best use it what what awareness they
need to have as well as how to make sure we're clear that this is a non-ai assignment when it's using a device versus handwriting i see and so i think my understanding is there's a lot of opportunity to have those conversations with teachers specifically at middle and high school
to better understand what is currently in place and how can we have a more strategic, clear curriculum around how we're approaching AI. Yeah, no, that's helpful. And I understood that sort of not having a sense of the total landscape.
I think my question comes from kind of curiosity here, but also sort of knowing that, for example, in Freeport Middle School, there was information sent home to parents provided by Common Sense Media that sort of outlines certain recommendations that Common Sense Media has. However, that's not in any way synced with anything that's actually being either demanded of the teachers or asked or frameworks provided for the students. And I find that troubling. And so I'll just, I already have a hat on, But with my policy hat on, I think I'm going to recommend to the board sometime in the next
month or two that we move forward on creating an AI policy. And there are actually many examples of that that have been implemented in the region. And some of them are more sort of a lighter touch. Like, for example, MSAD 75 has a sort of light touch guidance.
No one, I think, has gone quite as far as the public school system of New York City, but I would like us to look at that because I think absent the board providing that guidance, I could totally understand why teachers would feel a bit at sea in terms of trying to figure out what to be up to speed on and when to be up to speed on it and how to execute that.
So, I just wanted to take that. My other question has to do with the literacy, and I think I'll just sort of own that I find the larger conversation around early childhood literacy rather overwhelming, and there's a great deal of information that is out there.
um and so i think i will just uh own that i i currently don't know what i don't know and um i think this presentation is like a good start but like honestly like i think i'd like more soon um on sort of how to really think about early childhood literacy um i think some of the questions that
um i know that we've had conversations as a board previously um that have sort of flagged the question of like well we need to understand what we are currently providing and sort of how we are measuring that whether in quantitative
or qualitative ways but I'd like a better understanding of like what that actually looks like paired with that I think I'd also just to be very blunt like to understand either from our own experience or from other districts
experience where does the resistance come from to some of the changes that are asked by advocates for a different system how much of that is about entrenched ideology how much of that is about people so I think just getting the
board to a place where we have a better sense of really what that matrix of things is I think currently we had a one of our public speakers spoke earlier about sort of the desire for a sped-up process around early childhood literacy.
And I think, in theory, I feel that urgency as well, but I think as we have been echoing as a board for the last year or so, if everything is a priority, then nothing is a priority. And I think that currently I don't have a very good sense of how, for example, early childhood literacy
as a priority balances with the math curricula examination. I don't know how to think about that. I don't know how to, like, and I don't know how you all are thinking about that. I think my very last, I guess it is an actual question,
is, am I correct that if we were to shift into a, what is often referred to as a, was it science-based, evidence-based? Evidence-based curriculum, that that would require two years and 145 to 160 hours of professional development needed for the students,
sorry, for the educators to be trained in order to deliver that curriculum? I don't know the answer to that. I can certainly look into it to see. That's a new question for me. Anna. All really good questions. Thank you so much, Mandy. It's been really great to get to know you
a little bit for the first few weeks, and super helpful presentation. I am also struggling a little bit trying to understand, and maybe this is being fleshed out, and I know we're still working on the curriculum committee work plan, but how leadership is thinking right now about
prioritizing math versus literacy. I know at the curriculum committee, we are, we have the three priority areas of math, literacy, and technology. What I don't quite understand is it seems like there's a curriculum review for math now happening at the schools, but I don't know how literacy fits
into that. And so I'd like to hear more on that. And maybe we don't know yet, but that's something that does, like Colin says, it feels pressing to me. Yeah, sure. I think the idea right now, based on my understanding of where we were last year, and the fact that the math curriculum work
had started with the idea that the big ideas resource is going to shift, which has budgetary implications. A decision needs to be made on that piece before this year's budget cycle, Because without a decision, we would not have a math curriculum for grades 6 through 10
for many of our students. And so that's where I think some of the urgency comes in. In addition to that, I think what you'll notice when we have the data presentation in early October, our math data is showing that there are significant gaps for our students
with math when you compare it to state expectations, which I know we have some flaws in our state expectations and it is a measurement that's used for our student success. In terms of the literacy piece, I know the urgency that is being felt.
I also have a couple of wonders around starting that in probably December or January, knowing that teachers are going to be pulled out of classrooms to engage in a math curriculum review. That is not something that that is a final decision certainly input from others certainly
with Superintendent Gray's input and administrators input we can revisit that it felt like asking an awful lot of our internal resources to do such major curriculum review cycles in tandem I also wonder if we are going to engage in
a literacy review at the lower levels why not use it as an opportunity to look at literacy English language arts in the full vertical spectrum because you really miss an opportunity to look at standards pre K to 12 and that's why I
would just hesitate to do a K through 3 curriculum review and I also understand that that's where we're grappling with the most questions so that's just my thinking on it but certainly looking for other feedback and and guidance on it as
as well. This is more in response to, Colin, what you were saying. Looking at the list of instructional resources on the technology piece, given what I received from my daughter's middle school teachers, you're missing like seven or eight of them, and it's not any shade in your
direction. I'm just pointing out, I feel like the most egregious lack of continuity in our district is across our schools is the technology piece i feel like different schools classes grade levels use different rules guidances and policy and right now for ai we're just leaning on our plagiarism
policy so so what i just heard was our curriculum committee has three priorities which is basically everything which is math literacy and technology and math we have to figure out because it's going away, and literacy is always a challenge, and AI is going to own the world. So back to Collins.
If everything's a priority, nothing's a priority. Oh, how do we grapple with all these things? So all that to say, thank you for this presentation, Mandy. I think it is a great place of foundation, but, you know, to the points of the other board members, it's the starting point, right? And I
appreciate that you already have additional, you know, things coming in terms of presentations on the assessments. And I think all of those will help guide, you know, the work. What I can recall from previous curriculum reviews, like mass curriculum reviews of total systems, is you
really can't take on more than one at a time successfully. And they take one to two years to successfully do. So that's kind of what I have in my head. Back to Colin's question of, you know, like how much time and resources does it take to undertake? Like I understand they're
all important, but we have to prioritize, you know, the biggest fire, I guess. And we'll look to you guys to help us determine what that biggest fire is. And I will just put one more request on when that technology one comes back. And it kind of came from Colin's question, which was, you know,
I think we focus a lot on, like, what are the kids using and what are the kids have access to? I would love to include it in that presentation. Also, like, what are the teachers given? Like, what's their professional development? Because I do know from the presentation we had last year,
the sort of the spectrum of comfort and exposure to different technologies is vast within the distance, but good job. All right, so we will move on to 9C, which is our update from the Moore Street School and Goal Review. Julie Nickerson. Good evening. So I will start with
the review of last year's goals and um i appreciate listening to the dialogue and conversation about um curriculum and programming i think it is a you know when i sit there and think and reflect we've had a lot of change as an administrative team there's been systems that haven't necessarily
been in place for us to anchor in for change and i think one of the things that has already been said is just keeping in mind and in the words of will pidden you know change in schools is like trying to turn a tanker in you know in the ocean and it's not something you can do on it overnight
and um particularly with the plates of elementary teachers there are many priorities that we are we are tugged in and so um i'll reflect on the goals that we've worked on and kind of reasoning why we set goals for this year, and you'll see that they are focused in math. That is what our district had decided as a focus for our pre-K-5 work.
And obviously, these questions that have been raised about early literacy programming are things we're talking about at the admin level and having change in leadership across our schools. You know, it's a great time for us to be entering into those dialogues. And I think what happens often, just before I go into this, is, you know, we keep doing
things until we've made a collective decision to do something different. And I think we're kind of in that place. It's like we've been doing the things. We keep working to do better at what we're doing. And then we'll make decisions together as to how thoughtfully and what capacity we have
to support teachers and make change as we go. Anyway, just a little anecdote. So the first few pages in the packet are last year's goals. We have three goals. All schools for the last two years have had attendance goals to try and reduce our rate of chronic absenteeism. And I'm pretty excited to say with a lot of tenacity as a whole school,
but particularly the work of our assistant principal, Amanda, to really connect with families around those students. we've got last year we got our chronic absenteeism down to 3.98 percent which has the lowest kind of ever like a lot of the absentees things um was hypothesized as a result of kind of covid when
there was a lot more kind of choice and flexibility but this is lower than even kind of our pre-covid rates so i think um really tightening and getting really clear about what we are going to allow versus not and you know we have a very tight system around planned absences families anything
other than sickness families have to submit a form ahead of time we're approving five days that feels like a reasonable opportunity for families to take vacation during school time because we know that is you know a problem you know families want to stupid we know that you know so we
recognize that that is that is something that families can do and choose so we we accept that as an allowable absence but anything above that we're starting to have as unexcused so you know it's been it's been a process but I think it's it's you know people are clear on what it what
it is what it isn't we grapple with the level of sickness you know February and March are really tough times in little kids school you know there's a lot of sickness and illness going around at those times and we do want kids home so that we have to elevate the status of we want kids at
school in order to learn um the second goal was around family engagement um this has been a two year goal for us really thinking about ways to bring families back to school um we recognized that there was some residual kind of spillover from kind of doing things online or not having
families in school and um we offered a lot of different opportunities for families to come to school either experience um music class a PE class uh be in the the regular classroom to experience a learning um experience with their child um and you know we have done some parent education
evenings we offered coffee um during the day and then the afternoon and things and a variety of things have um created more interest than others always when the children are involved we get a really high attendance and turnout, um, less so when it's more just kind of parent information
things, but there are still a decent number that come. Um, that is one of the, um, I've been talking with our school counselor because those are the, uh, she has run some of those parent education nights. And, um, and we're wondering if we, if that is one place we do offer the online option,
maybe we'd get more attendance because childcare and things like that become a factor. Um, but again we this is not going to remain a goal specifically but it is still something we are thinking about and and wondering about different ways to offer different opportunities for families
because we also recognize that in order to have children and experience learning they're mostly during the day and most of our families are working and that's hard for them so we're trying to think about different ways to offer different ways to engage and we also know kind of in the
data and surveys, this is one very clear area. We're not going to please everyone. Some people like the detail in the newsletter. Some people don't like the detail in the newsletter. Some people want more information. Some people read it. Some people don't care about it. Some people want to be at school. Some people don't want to be at school. So it is very apparent in the
comments that are in the surveys we put out that there is polarizing opinions about how people want to engage so our commitment is to continue to offer a variety and hope that you know hopefully families feel connected to school and have good information about how and what their child's doing
and our third goal is around our instruction and and what I had presented really we're just trying to increase our data points by at least five percent in any given year and so we last year So we were able to do that in our acadience data,
which is measuring fluency of phonemic awareness and phonics skills. And then we increased by 2% on our BAS. But I will note that it is a different assessment. It is revised for this past year that we assessed. So there were some slightly different expectations. So, I mean, if you look at that longitudinal data, that assessment has changed three times across that longitudinal timeline.
and then our math has increased by 16 percent. So we're pretty excited about all of the change that we were able to make in those data points. One thing I will note in the data I've provided as I look at it you know I've tried to kind of track high level data for cohorts that travel
but those cohorts are really not apples to apples. You know we have kids transitioning out, kids transitioning in, kids with different needs kind of show up and come in and out. And one of the reflections, having just gathered incoming data for this fall,
there is definitely a noticing in students who haven't been with us through the years, and we are having to provide different supports. But it's what we do, it's data points we gather, and then our team responds as needed.
Um, in our new goals, do you have any questions about the review before I go into new goals? Yeah, this is great. We like to see this, these kinds of kinds of trends. And I'm just curious if you, I'm sure all of these things are due to a number of different
factors we realize, but do you think that you could identify some of the, you know, some of the key strategies or factors that might've helped you increase these, these numbers? Yeah, absolutely. So, our PLC work, so our professional learning communities, so the last three school, well,
this will be the third school year, we have really opened school with Hattie's research around the four kind of highest leverage impact areas that are, based on his research, to have the most impact on student achievement. And so that is creating a climate of connection and
I don't know what else. Belonging, thank you very much. The teachers know their impact, that their teachers really understand if their teaching is having impact on students. So mostly gathering assessment data in real time consistently um oh man i'm gonna look to him
and then student driving their learning is the fourth kind of place um so we've really focused hard on those things in a variety of ways so our plc work teachers are have increased so the data you see is only a fraction of the data we gather and um you know we have a lot of formative
assessment data so that's like the in the moment day to day how is this child learning what i'm teaching them um so we've really increased those practices with teachers and trying to simplify it in a way that is just down and dirty and messy teachers have a notebook with some sticky notes
in it and a little class list and something they're assessing but but there are so many discrete skills that are learned in the pre-K-2 phase that teachers are keeping track of all the time. So the assessment practices, I think, have improved and increased. We've moved from leaning
only on these benchmarking times to really kind of thinking about smaller incremental growth and monitoring. And then teachers are coming together to talk about what they're seeing. They've increase the way teachers have increased the way they kind of are observing students what
they're seeing in the writing we're really focused on asset space what can students do you can only um build on success so we're really thinking about what can a student do and what is the next move um and i think the other piece is about high expectations one of the things we were
recognizing was you know if you only look to the next benchmark you're never really reaching to kind of that next end and beyond and really in order for students what we recognized was in order for students to be solid at a benchmark they needed to be working beyond it and have lots of
practice so those are the kinds of things we're trying to think about pacing how quickly do we get kids play to a certain point and how much practice repeated practice do they need at that place in order to have that skill solid and um we use a lot of data walls which have a variety of
colors on them that mean things to us and would need a lot of explaining to other people but essentially you know we're looking at trying to move the next group of children and um and I always think about even children who we consider on benchmark, there's kind of shades of that. Did
you just make it? Because you just reached that in June and then we're about to have two and a half months off and then you're not going to have any practice. Or are you solid there? They are very different learners, especially when we go into the summer where there's potentially limited
practice. And what we noticed in our data also is that, you know, which are the kinds of kids that lose over the summer and then we have to spend time recouping so we are grappling with a lot of different things and trying to be really intentional about what we're teaching when
we're teaching it and the pacing that we do and that the high expectations piece also one of the things we played into was recognizing that each grade level has a role to play in how they contribute to the next. The complexity in second grade really changes. And so kind of just sniffing
a first grade benchmark means that kids aren't necessarily completely ready for the work that second grade has to do. So we started to put progressions of all the grades in front of all teachers. So pre-K teachers are thinking about what is their part in what second graders are
going to need to do further down the line. And that has proved to be a really powerful kind of dialogue and conversation across our teams and vertically having those conversations and really thinking about what do students need to be able to do as first grade writers,
for example, in order to then be able to write chapter books and research in second, which is what they need to be able to do and if if they're kind of approximating it in first they're not ready for that work so we've put a lot of work into that and seen all of that thank you
okay are we are we good is that before i move into new goals um so there's two primary goals for us for this next year obviously we'll keep working on the things we've been working on before they don't go away um but our you'll see that we've tied it to the new strategic plan so our first
goal is to primarily focus on math our district focus for professional development this year for pre-k5 is math um and so again if you focus on everything you're not growing anything so we like our school goal is about math and really thinking about this exactly what i've just told
you, but kind of with a very focused math lens. And really, I will just speak to the bold typed pieces. Those are kind of like the new layer for this year. The other things will continue and are carried on from the previous year. But kind of the bold type is really thinking about, so those
formative and summative assessment practices that I was referring to before, people have kind of grappled with doing that in literacy and like less so in math so now we're like okay what does this look like in math we have fewer data points of kind of
formal assessments in math which has always been true for k2 which is a struggle for us but we're kind of thinking about what are the formative assessment things we need to gather along the way to ensure our mathematicians are growing and developing along the trajectory that we
would want to see um so our starting point for that information is our number sense screener so i've provided that as a data point that is something that our teachers start the year really unpacking like they they are receiving a new cohort of children we are bringing the spring
data to put in front of them for them to think about who are our learners where are they starting who do we need to kind of um really get started with pretty quickly to make sure we're filling any gaps they may have um and again that that is another assessment that we look at do kids have
things automatic or are they having to you know work through certain problems in different ways um we will be providing math uh pd to increase the understanding of that progression so our strategists have done a day already with our pre-k5 teachers and particularly with k2
were that we're really thinking about the early number sense trajectory and what we recognized before we started this kind of new focus on math was that we are moving very quickly from or too quickly to pay traditional kind of paper pencil and algorithms for our youngest learners
and so we are spending more time with manipulatives thinking about counting collections really trying to support our teachers and therefore our students in increasing their mathematical reasoning and being able to explain how they're thinking,
why they're thinking, and multiple strategies to solve the same problem versus teacher tell children do so that they can be flexible depending on different problems they're presented with. So we have a lot of... If you kind of visit our math classrooms, which I hope you do, I think it's on it's our invitation this year you'll see children with a lot of working in
partnerships with variety of tools in front of them really thinking about getting curious and problem-solving patterns they're seeing and how they might explain that and being able to talk about their thinking with peers our so partnering with that so then we're also thinking about
increasing opportunities for student ownership and agency through this learning process. This is across all settings, but particularly in math, we'll kind of be focusing that. One of the things our leadership team did this last summer was kind of revisit those Hattie research things we had
talked about. And we looked at kind of what are the things we've improved and what are the things we're doing well. And we recognized there was a weakness in our student agency piece in terms of intentional practices so we're really thinking about um student ownership of of their learning
teachers voice out students really thinking and grappling with um productive struggle in many ways and the other part that uh i'll highlight in this section is our special ed um partnership with our general ed teachers so this came up today in our systems and sustainability conversation with
zeal and um actually they were talking about schedule and what kind of barriers we have in our schedule in terms of our ability to be flexible for students and one of the things that comes up for us is um basically the fact that we share our specialists with panel
dictates when children can have stem library and art and that has been driving kind of how we're able to group and regroup children because we try and keep them with their home class to go to specials and we don't want to pull them from those things in order to have their special ed services
so um one of the things we've done to try and tackle that is to think about um a regroup in our schedule so now our first and second graders eat and have recess at the same time so that we can be a little more flexible about how we provide opportunities for our special educators to have
time with our general educators. Because special ed is a layer on top of a robust tier one. And sometimes that is very challenging to provide when you have a schedule that is really dictating kind of what you do. So anyway, who knows whether the changes we've made are going to have the
impact we hope but at least we've made an intentional decision to try and have our special educators partner better with our classroom teachers so that those children who are being served by both have a more streamlined and focused approach because those are the students we're
really looking to move um in a way that we we currently are really um not moving our special population in a way we would we would hope um and then our second goal is a social emotional goal um this was embedded in our instructional goal last time as a piece that kind of threads through
everything we do in pre-k2 classrooms you know children are still developing how to interact with each other how to approach the their learning how to take ownership over that how to build independence. And so what we noticed last year, and this is kind of one of the things we grapple
with in schools, is how to continue our cycle of learning as staff changes so that we're keeping everyone at the same level, or we're maintaining the strength in practices that we have. And so for many years, when I was first principal at Moore Street, we spent a lot of time digging
very deep into responsive classroom practices, which are now very much embedded in kind of the personality of our school. But bringing new people kind of up to speed and on board with those practices is its own challenge. So we've pulled out this goal in alignment with the
strategic plan, really thinking about emotional intelligence and character building. So we're just refining. It's nothing new. These practices have been ongoing in our school. But what we're recognizing is as we've had pretty high staff turnover in the last three years like we need to
kind of revisit some um just practices about how are we intentionally responding to things we see in the classroom things that are popping up for different classes different students um and and recognizing some of those needs so i mean we we really pride ourselves in getting a proactive
approach and so this social emotional learning work is so that we can be proactive just as soon as things occur we can kind of get get in and respond to those needs and we are currently doing a book study so oftentimes we'll do books together to at least anchor us in some common
language and understanding and learning and then there's you know a variety of classroom observations or people sharing or people demonstrating in our staff meetings so that there's some shared learning that happens. And our data point on this, you know, one of the things
that we're really kind of thinking about is, you know, observing kids. I think sometimes as adults, and this is as parents and teachers, we like to jump in really quick and like we're either answering questions for our children or we're, you know, we're like carrying a backpack, we're doing
the things when really, you know, they need to be owning those things for themselves and sometimes just need a bit more time to think about the question they've just been asked, process and answer and respond. And so we're kind of thinking about that. How do we take a step back and observe
children? Because is it really what I thought I just saw? Did that child just defy me? Or did they actually not hear because the heat is really around, which is a real and true thing on Wall street um you know there's like some you know things that we're really thinking about okay let's
watch for the actual thing versus what we're what we kind of think mate or you know sometimes i think we're really um it's easy for us to be like oh it's all day you know this child is having a hard time regulating and it's all day so we always push people to be like okay let's really think
about that is it all day is it every day or is it just at this time so we we have teachers collect data around those things so they can be really thoughtful and intentional about what they do to help change and um and how we think about those things so all of this um work we're doing is
encompassing kind of a more holistic social skills development piece and it's not one thing it's what do your children need right now and how can you respond in a timely way any questions for me yeah I'm just curious. It looks like there's a lot of change or a lot of emphasis, I should say, on the social
emotional learning in the classroom. And of course, we all are parents here, or at least most of us. And so we know a lot of that happens at home, too. And I'm wondering if you could speak a little bit to how you're sort of training, helping
to present training opportunities to parents to help with the home piece of that. Good question. I think that kind of goes back to, you know, well, we try and put as much information in our newsletters as we can. There's a, you know, there's a plus and a minus to that.
And then I think there is places when if there is a particular, this is not going to be a good answer because I don't have a solid answer. I think it's just as we go. In many cases, we do try and offer those parent information, kind of like education night. And often it's about
you know what do what do people feel like they want to talk about you know because oftentimes parents of the same age children are grappling with similar things um and we did you know again we've had kind of limited interest in those things so i think we try and put out as much
tips and information as we can teachers will talk to specific families and engage with families at parent conferences um but i think we're still figuring out how to best approach kind of a more holistic education piece around some of those things i think um some parents reach out and
that's great to engage in dialogue um with them but i i think it it is a bit of a challenge for us are you is your question kind of um meaning the potentially we're seeing changes in schools and so how do we better support families to kind of so we partner better yeah I think so I mean
social emotional learning happens at home as much as it does in the classroom and so having that support from the parents know parents knowing how to support their kids I think is a really important piece to this problem or not problem but you know this aspect
of education so I just was curious if you had an intentionality and thoughtfulness about that part of the, I mean, I think we do, I mean, the intentional part is like our newsletters have become pretty robust at the classroom level. So one of the things I was doing weekly newsletters
and it, you know, you can tell how many people have read it and things like that, and they just were not getting read. And so it's like, hmm, classroom newsletters are read because there's kind of a little more kind of real time messaging. So we've kind of redirected some more robust
information that go in classroom newsletters than once were there so social emotional learning is piece of that too as things kind of occur and come up but it's something for us to continue to think about for sure. Thank you. Anna. Thank you Julie. Two things. One is I've really noticed the increase
of community events and inviting parents in and I think our community really appreciates that. I know I do as a parent and just the recent open house I think Moore Street School continues to mean a lot for the older kids too. I know for my girls the older ones being there they're like oh I remember
I sat on that spot on the rug and that teacher and it was just I didn't expect that and I could see that with other siblings as well. So thank you for that. My question is I'm new to all of this but with the goal of math classrooms will effectively differentiate tier one instruction
in math and I assume that's doing by small groups but I thought the whole point of tier one in the MTSS system was that it wasn't differentiated like you're going to tier two or tier three could you just explain that a little bit more about differentiation in tier one so I think in
any classroom that's heterogeneous you are always going to have a range so you're going to have children who so in a first grade in any given first grade classroom they have beyond that and So there is a grade level standard that really kind of a mini lesson is kind of presenting.
But then there's always going to be a different range of kind of where children are along the progression. And so that small group work, so is part of tier one, because, you know, you're not going to catch every child in a whole group lesson.
The reality of if you kind of live to my world and we're in classrooms, you, in fact, as an admin team, we watched a lesson observation via video. And, you know, if somebody took a lens on who is actually looking and paying attention
in any given whole group setting for pre-K two-year-olds, we might touch some, but small group is really where I believe we're kind of moving children it's an opportunity for teacher to really pay attention to what this particular child is doing and how they're responding to
problems that they're being given and and things like that so that's still part of tier one and individual instruction too so a teacher would meet one-on-one with children during kind of a workshop time that makes sense thank you and so is that not being done before in terms of at
the math level or it's just going to be more effectively done. Yeah. Okay. Essentially, we're trying to kind of just continue to be better. Valerie. Thank you, Julie. My question is if you could maybe speak a little bit more on the collaboration between gen ed and special ed
and how that's meeting the needs of our IEP students and how maybe we are maybe falling short? Yeah, I think one of the things we are wondering about is going back to that kind of high expectations. So I've shown this Hattie video three years in a row. There is this clip that
basically Hattie says, you know, children will meet your teacher's expectations. So if your expectations are low, children will meet low expectations. If your expectations are high, they are more likely to meet your higher expectations. So one thing that we hope the strengthening that partnership
is for both partners in that is to really think about keeping a lens for our special educators on what is the grade level goal. For those children, many of them need to grow more than a year in a year. So we're already trying to do more with them in order to get back on track otherwise they're just in this continued path of not making it or
the gap is just getting bigger for them so what our hope is that we this partnership will make us to think about you know just have us get curious about would this child be better served with more time in the regular classroom do they actually need this amount of pullout and keeping um our
special educators really for with a lens of what the grade level expectation is our hope is that like that's our goal right we we want to be dismissing children from special ed we want them to be able to spend all their time with their gen with their in the classroom like that's that's
our hope for them in terms of a long term and like you know i feel good about the work we've been doing with early childhood right like this idea of intervene early and not allow these gap big gaps to to form so the hope is as we strengthen the partnerships our regular ed
teachers can learn from our special educators in terms of differentiating sooner and really those children who might leave a classroom to go to a separate setting often have a very disjointed day so we're trying to like better align and streamline kind of our practices and
language used and things like that. I think it's going to be a process. So thank you. So my question was on the second goal for this upcoming year. I know it says like the staff will self-assess. How will you know if you've met the goal? I know it's hard with these sort of
qualitative goals. Yeah, no, I actually grappled with, and that's kind of a word, that's a word of the moment, I guess. I actually wondered about what is the data point for this and how will we know we've succeeded and I wondered about you know do I use our RTIB data do I use our office
referrals do we use and the thing is that doesn't really paint the picture because the needs of students ebbs and flows from year to year from class to class from teacher experience to teacher experience um and so like really it's a teacher learning goal and so I I think um I haven't given
the initial survey yet to teachers to kind of really think about where they're at my hope is that at the end of kind of this year and we've done some intentional learning around this they will feel better equipped to respond to a variety of social emotional needs that crop up um and
maybe there'll be other kind of pieces that help but i do think you know amanda and i are both in classrooms and so we see you know it is very apparent even with our teacher evaluation people feel better equipped to respond and I think sometimes you know with our new teachers
versus our veteran teachers something crops up or a parent reaches out with a concern and it feels like oh I got to respond to this parent and it's not until I I'll say I'm like oh this is because we got to teach into this part that we're like yeah you didn't know that
like you're just a new teacher of course like we have to do that thing so my hope is that teachers will be able to respond sooner and know to respond versus waiting for me to be oh yeah no you didn't know that thing i have to help you with that um i think those are kind of some of
the things that are driving the need for us to kind of do this thank you any other questions for julie all right now we're behind schedule sorry one of our goals this year as a board was to try and stay on schedule but they were good questions so i will just keep people aware of it and uh you
we might be able to pick up some time here and there all right so we will move on to item 10 on our agenda board comments and committee reports so a is board information exchange and agenda requests I don't know if we had anyone yeah this is more of a procedural question so I'm not sure if it fits in
this specific spot but it is related to what you had just said about us keep efficient and the timer I'm I'm worried that we timing public comment but not timing anything else and I realize that we're very new to this right but I um I'm keeping time on my
thing for what we have allocated but when it when it comes to the timer that that makes noise at people though I'm worried that if that's how we decide to do it uh we're effectively discouraging public comment and not doing the intention of keeping us efficient so you want to loop us too
well certainly to an extent during discussions I think that might be a good idea because that's um so that we're aware yeah right yeah i i mean and i think we're gonna have to think about process because i don't know if it's super easy to like because they're all different amounts of time like we'll work on that um yeah it's a i think it's a we can do a time up easily right so we could
if something is 10 minutes we could start it at zero and we can watch for it to hit 10 minutes um okay when we start yeah an easy way to when we start an item we can say like this had 10 minutes on the agenda 10 minutes on and go I can see that being a useful thing at least I think it's
a good discipline at the start you know maybe we get better and don't need it forever but um it's not a bad idea Colin well just point of clarification are you suggesting that having that object up there that is beeping at you as opposed to the object over here beeping at you is is make it will
discourage public comment because we've been doing the the product that process has not changed yeah i mean we've always timed them and had a sound beep when they hit three minutes right so but the the difference being i saw one of the the people give public comment that as it beeped
they left that's not been our kind of our mo going forward so it has it has it has been what we have asked people to do is when they hear it is to wrap it up right i i understand that so i don't want to discourage yeah i don't know i don't want you know 18 minutes of public comment like that's not what I'm trying to say here it's just kind of um I want to make sure that we are
we are clear that that's not a you stop now and the mic turns off timer because it is different in in how it it it's applied yeah and I don't think we all realized it was going to keep beeping like I don't think it was going to keep going so yeah this is definitely a learning process
yeah yeah but just to be clear the process has not changed correct yeah just yeah three minutes and we've always timed it and had a beeper sometimes they could hear it sometimes they couldn't that was mostly us trying to figure technology on this side us working on that side
so um but good yeah we'll we'll work on it to improve yeah i was just going to say it's a good point because really where we need help becoming more efficient is our own time discussing things not really for public comment so if i i think that if it's just up and we're like okay we allotted
20 minutes to this and we're at 40 sorry i know your time's up no we're counting up now we're in our 10 minutes of um information exchange okay uh other comments information requests okay turn off oh i have eight or nine minutes um that is the other problem of doing it this way
you're welcome uh oh for a muse of i was just reciting shakespeare we did say we wanted to hear more poetry from earlier it's true i can give you some of that um i would just like to Following up on what I said about my interest in moving forward with looking at an AI policy
for the district, could I just get like a temperature check of the board on that? And to be clear, I think what we would be, like what that would entail, at least from from my um uh perspective would be looking at what sort of policies exist um and what the
implications of them would be um for uh impact on um on effectively on learning but all but also on like what that would mean for how quickly we'd be expecting um teachers to have to hustle to figure out how to do something um i don't think we'd be looking at anything that would immediately obviously
we couldn't pass something that would immediately require a bunch of more training to happen within the next month but um how where are we on that i love the idea i think because it's such a huge sort of the elephant in the room across the district it's something that i think it would
be a great idea for us to have a policy um but because we know the technology is still changing and there's, I think, still a lot that we don't know about how to use it and what it's capable of. I do agree, Colin, that if we do pursue a policy that it would need to be one that is loosely prescribed.
We wouldn't want to put a lot of boundaries around this yet because I think that the technology is still evolving and it's something that I think we're going to maybe even need to revisit fairly frequently. weekly. So yeah, I agree. I think it's something we need to do, but I think we need to be very
thoughtful about how we think about how prescriptive we get. And yeah. I think it's an incredibly important thing to do and it changes very, very quickly. My assumption is that it will have to continually be updated and looked at as that continues to change as a very often update and
look at um if you want a temperature check my opinion would be especially in the lower grades really limiting the use of of ai technology for children um when it comes to teachers that's a different story uh but but really limiting the use of them using that to learn um it seems to me that
it it replaces the learning part of the learning a lot of times and i i really struggle with that so that's my temperature check yeah i mean if i had seven or eight minutes um to talk more about this i might uh say a few more things i'm going to say right now okay thank you um but what i think
i yeah that's great to hear i think also i think the only thing i would maybe i'm not maybe going to push back but i think like i think we should not treat um ai policy and ai and ai in education and ai in our awareness of of its uses as a complete black box like there is actually a fair
bit that is known. There are a lot of policies that have already been passed. There are state-level laws that have been passed. It's not that we don't know anything about what's happening. We know a great deal about what is happening. And so I think that I actually don't agree. I mean, I understand
the sentiment of it. Things seem like they're changing on a weekly basis, but I don't agree with that I think that I think if we were to pass something look at something and agree on it we would be I think we could safely be putting that in place for a you know a year or more you know
it's unless there we need to then like institute something about Skynet like for an emergency purpose but again I just but so I just wanted to say that yeah no I wasn't thinking that we would have to revisit on a weekly basis. I was really thinking like maybe more frequently than some of
our policies. Than the seven or eight years that some of them get revisited. I wanted to look this way to, I wasn't sure if you were all doing the, thank you Anna for that. Yes, I love that. Yeah, I think it's a great, I think it's a great idea. And, you know, similar to some of the other more
kind of broad policies that we have grappled with. There we go. We'll use it again. You know, over the years, it's one that's going to take some time and, you know, a lot of thought to make it in a way that's functional and has meaning, but also isn't overly prescriptive
in the need to be adjusted constantly. So yeah, I think if the policy committee wants to start that work um have at it yeah i think also just to be clear this is something where i'm not i just don't want uh tom over there i mean tom can have whatever feelings of hatred toward me he he needs to have
um yeah i did again i was uh um but just that uh this this is something that i that uh because i have extra time on my hands this is something that i like have spent a bunch of time working on and thinking about so I think what I my proposal would be that I would put
together a little portfolio of things and then send that to Tom and the policy committee to consider rather than having then asking Tom to do a bunch of labor before bringing that to us with the hope that maybe one day he'll invite me over
for dinner so I guess I'm actually the temperature read on that I'm along with that too. But if you look at the national news, and it was just in the news the other day, we've got three big wigs that are all in competition for each other asking Congress
and other people to, basically they're not slowing down, but they're saying we're concerned and we need guidelines. So we're not, this is obviously on a different level, but we're all in the same boat as to where are we at so I'm on temperature read definitely we need to look at
it continue to revisit it if issues pop up I think that we need to look at it even from Tom's perspective if something comes up in the classroom or comes up in a concern he obviously brings it to us but just looking at that and constantly looking at a policy just for the kids safety
because it's not just the kids. I mean, we're dealing with it in our things, our phones, everything. Look at what happened with the planes. So it's just, it's just, it's across the board, but I definitely think the kids need an installation of understanding safeguards
because they're going to be living in that world. All right. Any other comments in the one minute and 36 seconds? Got anything? Any other requests? No? Okay. Thank you Colin. We will not be using our time for thanking Colin. He's done with you. Thank you Moon.
All right so we will move on to 10b which is the Facilities and Operations Committee. Five minutes and go. Well fortunately for me I think Tom stole a lot of my thunder already during his superintendent's report so this is going to make it really simple. We had a Facilities and
operations committee on wednesday september 9th and in that meeting we talked about our energy audit phase one and two project update of which the roof projects were part and so since tom's already talked about those i won't really revisit that the projects were really diverse extensive
we had some roof project generators boilers building automation fire alarms i won't go through all of it lighting um but suffice it to say that we've done a lot on our facilities over the last year so there's a lot of progress that we've made um summer projects there were some
painting projects carpet in the central offices and uh one i think that people here might be particularly interested in is that in the mass landing school we have built in two quiet spaces rooms for students who need a moment. So if your student needs a moment, we now have a space for
them in the classrooms. Tennis court updates, we've heard a little bit about that already from Tom. I'm just going to go over the timeline quickly. As Tom already mentioned, the project went out to bid bidders last Thursday, the 9-3, and there was a virtual pre-bid meeting for those bidders that
were interested in the project on friday 9 11 bids are due back to um us at on thursday 9 24 and as has already been mentioned we'll be reviewing those on 10 7 so that is a meeting that the public i think we're meeting uh 9 30 oh i'm sorry you're right 9 30 that's right 10 7 is when we come to
the board the extra meeting is on 9 30 that is when the public is welcome to come construction if once we choose a bid a firm the construction may start as early as this fall if the bidders choose to or it may it may they may choose to push it out into spring depending on their
their preference construction we hope to have substantially complete by july 15 and final completion by august 15 so that the middle schoolers can actually start their season on time so that's our timeline on the tennis courts and finally we heard from glenn that palinal
elementary school water was tested and came back for positive for coliform bacteria information went to the main drinking water program and they determined that the water does remain safe to drink and use because the levels are still very low still they are going
to come actually yeah just in a couple of days they're going to come and shock the well and flush the system so that we can clear that all out and we won't have any concerns and then of course they're going to retest just to make sure that they've gotten rid of all of it so
that's all i've got any questions i think anna had a question yeah just couldn't remember where we were with the tennis courts are we getting a bid for the asphalt and the post tension and for three and possibly four just four thank you so we will look at the or you all will look at the
bids and we'll go from there yeah thank you chris i know the bid deadline's not here yet but do we have any idea how many bids we have i don't off the top of my head i think we know how many people came to the pre-bid meeting and it was six or seven yeah and the bids will be opened tomorrow
I know. That's how we know we're old. Valerie? I don't know if this number is possible to get, but my memory of the presentation on the tennis courts is that the post-tension is a bigger that we asked for. Yeah, I don't think, I mean, I don't know if they could, I think we have
information from the consultant on sort of the general maintenance costs of the two types of courts. So that will be part of the conversation. Not something we ask the bidders because it's not necessarily something they would even know or do. Okay, thanks. I'm just trying to think of
initial investment versus expenditure over time. Which one actually is? Time value of money. Oh, man. We're going to be doing some math. So we had this conversation. We were talking about the money piece but we were also talking about just the the pain you know have
the continual maintenance versus just not set it and forget it sort of not having to worry about it for a good long chunk of time so we're I think those two pieces are both in the conversation and I think the biggest thing that has
changed since we started the conversation to now is that Delta between the asphalt and the post tension seems like it is really shrunk I mean originally it was like it was double the cost and then it was 50% more of the cost and now maybe it's 15 to 20 percent more but when you weigh in the cost of
maintenance over time maybe it's actually either a wash or more more effective to do postage we don't know yet so once we have that's one of the reasons we got both of those so we could really you know at a point in time say
these is this is the difference in price and is it worth it or not right I'm I'm thinking of the tennis students who were here saying it's a real pain in the butt to be elsewhere and thinking of having to do that again when we need to do more
maintenance and all of that qualitative it's kind of yeah just absolutely that's something to consider but I will say I don't think that we're talking about though this level of maintenance on a regular basis this is this is an entire
reconstruction and what we would be talking about would be more like a resurface or something that would just be a week or two it would still cost cost money, it would still be a pain, but not the level that we're dealing with right now.
Yeah, we wouldn't lose a whole season. Did you have your hand up, Steph? I have a tendency not to look directly to my left, looking at your time. Yeah. Can you make it beep? All right. So we will move on to our next update is from Curriculum Program Development, 10 minutes.
And I will just remind folks that we also have another 15 minutes on the curriculum discussion a little bit later, so. Thank you. I like how I got more time than any of the other committees. All right, here's the first. You're new to the list. If you didn't want, you know,
we wanted to welcome you. Thank you. This is the first official report out from the Curriculum and Program Development Committee. Annie and Karen were at that meeting on September 8th, as well as Mandy, of course, and we had Kate there too, and Tom joined us, so it was a great group.
First, we appointed the chair, which is myself. Then we looked at meeting dates. We have since added more meeting dates, including October 20th and December 15th. We spent most of the time looking at the draft purpose statement.
We reviewed it and we finalized the statement that we'll be sharing out later this evening. And then we were able to take a look at Mandy's draft presentation that she gave us tonight. You're making up time. Well done. Other committees, pay attention. Because we haven't voted yet on this, whether it being standing, right?
All right. Any questions for Anna on her short and sweet update? Thank you for that. All right. So we will move on to generally not so short and sweet policy committee. Five minutes. Good evening. We met for actually a very efficient meeting on September 3rd, 2026 at 4.15 p.m. on Google Meet.
Just a reminder that the public is always welcome to come and observe the policy committee at work. It's really very action-packed and compelling. Kara tells great jokes. You just won't be able to be heard laughing at Kara's jokes because your mics are not allowed to be on.
But you're allowed to witness what we are doing. We were looking at a couple of policies that had to do with law change and then a couple that had to do with regular review. The law change was JLF, Child Abuse Reporting Prevention Education.
There was a discussion about that, but a number of questions were raised that we sent back to Tom and the team and also counsel, and we'll be returning to that as well. As part of that, we were also looking at JLFA, Child Sexual Abuse Prevention Response, which would be rescinded if we are to move forward with JLF.
And then we looked at, as part of our regular review process, BEDB, BEDD, and BEDH, all of which have to do with sort of the board kind of, I guess, sort of governance and procedure at meetings. And we had a good conversation about that. And those are the policies that we are bringing before you tonight.
Bless you, child. can you remind me um how we rescind a policy we just we do it we do it it's a vote though yes yeah sure okay if you could tell me the policy that tells us how we rescind a policy that'd be great just in it's in there yeah okay it's one of the ones on the website so i know we didn't talk
about that we talked about other stuff uh yeah i'll look in no i'm just i'm just it's not often we've rescinded a policy. So I'm curious, is it because it's basically getting folded into the other? It's getting folded into the new one. Yeah, rescinded may be an aggressive word.
But the other one's not new. It's just an update to an existing. It's an update to an existing one based on a law change this summer. So the requirements that the state has for reporting to DHHS have changed and the new sample policy that we're... Includes the response piece. It includes the response piece. Okay, thank you. All right, any other questions before we jump right into those policies Colin mentioned can we just keep it
going until 30 okay you have until 30. we bring before you to tonight three policies BEDB agenda BEDD rules of order and BEDH public participation at board of directors meetings for first read do we have to do it do we have to
take it let me get emotional yeah okay so do I have a motion for consideration and approval for the first read for the following policies, BEDB agenda, BEDD rules of order, and BEDH public participation at board of directors meetings. Chris and Melissa, thank you.
And just because we do have new board members, the way the process works for policy review is that committee, like Colin said, there's sort of three tiers of why they would look at a policy. One is it's the regular review. Two is it's a law change that requires us to review it. Or three,
if the board has made a request. So while it is a new policy, I would consider the AI policy, you're considering a board request. And so that'll probably pop up into that section. And then once the policy committee has done their magical work on the policies,
they bring it to the board for a first read, which is the board's opportunity to review, ask questions make recommendations on adjustments talk it through the board if there's substantive changes the committee will take that back and make
those adjustments or it may come back exactly as it came to the board as the first read and then once we have a second read of policies and vote on them then they become the policy of the district so that's kind of the procedural piece of that so sorry for our new members no that's great and also
Also, just as a, I suppose it's sort of an informal part of the procedure as well, we do ask that once board members have received the information in their packet, that they then send us questions in advance so that we have time to perhaps find the answers to
that. So because I didn't hear any, guys, I just think we can be really efficient tonight. You know what I mean? It's really efficient. Yeah, there you go. I'm going to click away from the Coliform Bacteria Wikipedia page that I pulled up mostly because I wanted to freak Anna out.
And let's look at BEDB, which is agenda. So this has to do with how the board sets the agenda for board meetings. And it's very structurally similar. There just are a number of sort of refinements to deadlines, to the distribution of the agenda, sort of distribution of agenda for regular meetings or special meetings, a process for adding an item to an agenda.
I'm not going to go through it in much more of a granular way than that, given that I didn't get any questions in advance. But I'm curious if anybody has any, like, six-second questions. Anna. I was wondering why it was struck out about the draft minutes, since we tend to do that
anyways. Kara, why did we strike out draft minutes? Where is this again? Under dissemination of supporting materials. The simple answer is that it just wasn't in the updated sample that we received from Drummond-Woodson. Yeah, I think we did discuss it, and it was something that, like, it was going to happen
anyway. or I think like it was just that but I think there wasn't yes I think it was because of the sample policy and we're trying to be good boys and girls and we don't really mark them as draft we just yeah yeah we had that whole paragraph had
been struck out for what we reviewed in policy committee and we suggested that just the last sentence of that paragraph be struck that sounds right so we didn't have that discussion it's sort of ironic though that the part you left is what we
don't usually get which is like additional documents around the policies But what we do get are the minutes, which we struck. It may be helpful for everyone to know that the reason that we've prioritized these board governance policies early in the year is to be efficient.
Well, there's that. But last year, there was a case that went before the main Supreme Court that rested on the board's ability to control public comment. And in that case, a main board's policies came under scrutiny because the issue at hand
was whether the board could regulate that public comment in areas of whether or not a person could disparage a staff member or what kind of language could be used. And so it became a really good idea for us to look at our policies around how we conduct
the meetings how the public notice is given and public comments so that we're in good shape with just so that we're buttoned up that way yeah and I was gonna get to that when we talked about BDH but I appreciate you know I appreciate you flagging it at first because it also is why we're looking at these three in tandem right because it's not that if we just had gone in and
mucked around with BDH to make sure that the way that people use their three minutes before they get beeped it just in scared just scared and beeped at that we wouldn't be addressing sort of the larger issues that are sort of interconnected there other questions about BDB agenda you did your seven
second pause move on love it let's talk about BEDD which is conduct of board meetings rules of order so the major the major change here is really that we have leaned pretty heavily on basically saying we just do what's in Robert's
rules of order and we're just now just being much more clear about what we're actually how the process actually goes so there's a there are a bunch there are bunch of changes here it sort of establishes the chairs were all in presiding over the meetings raising points of order process for appealing
the ruling I think there's some explicit permission in terms of the chair making and making and seconding motions and specifically allows the superintendent to participate discussion but not vote any other things that caught your
attention as you were going through this one. this is the one that just makes more work for Michelle and that's why we did it. heartfelt thank you. you're welcome. you're welcome. yeah I actually think this makes a lot of sense you know
to put a little more we even say common sense in here I mean we have had I will say I'm I'm happy to say I'll knock on wood that we don't have a lot of really contentious board meetings and almost never with the board but occasionally
with with members of the public on some some highly emotional topics but there was a point where there we made a change to a board and I just did it because it made common sense but there was questions about like oh well that's not in Roberts rules so I appreciate this thank you
something else oh I just on that point I think also just to say this was definitely when we were going through this all of these but particularly this one I think we were we definitely had a conversation about how like because we
have known Michelle and how Michelle runs meetings and how Michelle comports herself as a chair sort of like generally trusting the way in which that process goes but also reminding ourselves though the Michelle has promised to be on the board for another 15 to 20 years we don't know what the
future will be and we don't know who's going to be sitting in that seat and so So how do we make sure that we structure this effectively with worst-case scenario in mind and sort of understand sort of what the interactions would be between the larger board and a rogue?
There's no guarantees that won't be me. Yeah, that was an open door. That was an opportunity for you to walk through. Questions? I don't know. Personally, I like the stuff about the appeals and all that. I think that's nice stuff. Now we get to the real juicy stuff, the public comment, public participation at board meetings.
As Tom said, there was a court case that had exactly to do with this and sort of make and basically pointing out that there were things that boards sort of thought that they controlled or that were sort of common sense that really weren't in there and were not protected unless we actually say.
what they are. So this one, again, we had some good conversation about sort of like the default 30-minute total comment period and sort of how that, how we sort of establish that and then how that would be, I think the original, and Chris and Kara, correct me if I'm wrong, but the original
draft language here I think was that that would only be, could only be amended by the chair and we changed that to be the chair or a vote of the majority of the board so trying to make that a little bit more democratic there's there are for anyone
following along at home there are definitions concerning indecent and obscene speech that we did not write ourselves that the lawyer that lawyers that lawyers wrote but that's worth taking a look at and we definitely talked
about this question of sort of residents receiving priority over non-residents and sort of specific frameworks around personnel matters individual students and that sort of thing where people can stand and also where people can stand
yes exactly so during your three minutes while you're feeling the sort of the anxiety about getting beeped at you must do that behind the podium you may not move your body and do do a dance sort of getting close to the board where
previously you could have because there was no rule that said you couldn't put the dancing at the end I'll let you work on that part of it and I saw your hand raising up there yeah thank you I was just wondering if someone just to put it
in like if this actually happened if someone was behind the podium and saying let's was talking about a specific staff member that this clearly is not allowed what would happen we would just have her continuously beat them
just sort of hits the button like over and over again like it's a good question and it's happened before what you actually I mean generally what we have done is we've like I've I've interrupted and said, we can't, or your time is up, or we, and thankfully, generally, they stop.
I think my strategy has just been to talk over them until they stop. An extreme solution that I've seen done other places is that a board would have to go into recess if it's, you know, something they really cannot allow to go on.
Which we have also done, and I'm trying to remember if we did that, I think that was more interactions in the crowd. yelling back and forth with the speaker in the crowd, and that was getting a bit unruly, so we went into a recess, and that was when I got told that that's not the Roberts rule.
I think in the policy, what you're really looking for is you might request the assistance of law enforcement. And we've done that too. Yeah, I mean, we would definitely certainly ask them to stop. We would, you know, intervene in any way possible. I don't know if we have the ability to cut that
mic I mean that's a that's a technology question um if someone was truly like not stopping um sort of worst case scenario I don't know we might want to look into what our our nuclear option is if someone just keeps spewing something from the mic that we don't want I know we the other thing we do
do do do is is it 10 o'clock sorry um you put it in the policy one of the things we have done is when we have something that sort of goes awry like that, we will remove it from the video but it doesn't stop it from going out live stream but that is something else we have done. Yeah and just to say that is an important question and I think that if we could at the sound board back there look and see whether there's a big button we could push because I think it is a good point if like someone starts getting up there and either it starts disparaging a student or a staff member we don't want it to be just like technically not allowed as they say it
you know the rules yeah but actually I have a way to prevent it yeah so thank you for that question Melissa just being new at this um so I realize I'm reading through all this but did we at some point we had talked about when we were
training about sometimes that you like in certain meetings you would stop and if you had to discuss something for an executive session and we would like basically stop the meeting and go I know in some school boards they actually stop the meeting go in and then come back is that something that
would happen as well um I mean we could I mean that's really a scheduling thing um it's the only time I can sort of envision a potential sort of emergency executive session is, and we've had these questions from board members in the past, is around like if we had a hiring
that someone had a concern, because you don't see it until you get here, like if there was a major concern, you could request that, and I actually have the motion in my folder, like if we needed to go into executive session to discuss that.
Other than that, I can't imagine when we would need an emergency executive session. There are boards who just put it in the middle of their meeting and leave and come back or kick everybody out and they come back. We do it at the end because we're polite. Not that the others aren't polite, but we're politer.
Kelly. Okay. I have a question about some of these rules. Would they be something you would post to the public at each meeting so it's well known it's not a bad idea um you know we have we have had some things that we have posted or we have made available um we we actually we already do it
uh over there on the thing and but it probably could use an update with these with this policy assuming it passes first and second read we have a little like public comment booklet and i think these rules are in there. We certainly could do a better job of making it known that they're
there. And the other thing in my folder, in my magic folder of things, I also have a little sort of speech that when we have big public comment meetings, when we have a lot of folks that are highly charged about something, I read it. And it is a good point that it might
need an update based on this um but we do also have that that we i read was that what you're going to say yeah i do have another just technicality this is not in the spirit of the purpose of the changes made here but in the on page three of five it mentions a public comment
period not to exceed 10 minutes technically we have two public comment periods i don't know if that's important but I just thought I'd mention it because well you're thinking of this fascist feature where exactly where the post Michelle exactly the post Michelle is a rogue actor as you said so we want to make sure that the
rogue actor knows that they're being rogue I mean yeah I mean I guess I guess the question is whether this I guess this what this is saying is that we are we are committed by policy to one, and that the other is gravy. Do we want that, or do we want to
say we, as policy, have two public comment periods? Which do people want? That's an interesting question around the two comments, because I think we, did we add that to the, was that in the old policy? I didn't look to see if it got struck out. Okay, so we had just added the option, but never
we're required to have the option right we did it because we got some feedback about some people like to talk before we talk about things and some people like to tell us what they think about what we talked about and I guess I think I mean it's nice to have that public comment at the end for that very reason that people can comment on what they've seen and heard during the meeting so I don't know if you want to codify that in a policy or if that's just going to be something I mean I guess I would prefer to leave that to the the discretion of the board at the time um i mean i don't see any reason why we would remove
it but um i do think this sort of reads the board includes a public comment period not to exceed 10 minutes on the agenda i mean technically i have two of them i mean i don't know to me this is the minimum okay even though it says not to exceed well like do i have to like every meeting go we're
going to have another one but no but then you can you can modify it as we go along you can just say well there's a line yeah but I think I think I actually think that that brought bring us to that last point I think that yes I think that actually what this is in alignment with the spirit of the
conversations that we've been having around efficiency of meetings where I think that that it is that I think for example for a for a meeting where there is a great deal of of interest I think actually we are going to get to a place where you actually need to set it and say like it's not
until everybody goes it's like it's an hour or it's an hour and a half or it's three hours or whatever it is and like that is and then that is that is set and then we go from there that it's not it's that it's not fluid I think that is I think that is in here and also in the spirit of
what we've been talking about yeah and I 100% agree with that yeah so Valley I just have two things i want to flag for possible discussion hopefully um one is that that's 10 minutes is i guess including trundling time three people talking which seems low uh i also
the mathematician in me wants it to be uh divisible by three please so maybe 15 but you know we're talking about transition yeah um and then the other thing that we did at region 10 because i'm on that policy committee is we added um staff as being
prioritized as well because not all of our staff live within the district so there are times where their buy-in is just as important and we want to make sure that their voices are heard as well and so that's we added those folks um in our policy and i was just wanted to bring that up
for discussion so it would come under three we'll hear public comments from residents of the school unit first residents and employees is what I'm proposing so no tier between them I mean I think I guess I'm agnostic on that drifting toward I don't think we
should do that I think that I don't think I don't think that I don't know I guess I can't I just can't I mean again and I'm looking at a dystopian poster over there like I just like I can't imagine this in a situation in which we like would have staff and they would not be allowed to speak or they would be so i guess
that's but i guess that's me imagining a utopian a utopian future so i'll just own i'll just own that um but if the board would like to do that we should do that chris um i was going to respond to that just real quick but one um is there a reason that we don't like in the interest of
vagueness is there a reason that we're including a time limit specifically for that comment period or can we say something to the effect of the comment period is dictated at the discretion of the chair? Well, it does essentially say that in the last sentence, but to me, that entire section is setting a floor for public comment.
We will have at least a 10-minute public comment section. That's not the way it reads. It says not to, the board includes a public not to exceed. Like, that is like, I mean, a floor is not less than 10 minutes on the agenda.
right yeah a minimum of ten minutes but then you know then you get into well what's that what's the max yeah I mean I think I guess I don't know it's like I think the I think the reason maybe we the language is as it is is because it's
it's trying to center the efficiency of the board and the boards work and it is not like I think just to be like I'm just gonna be blunt about it it's not that is not meant to maximize public involvement that is not meant to
maximize the rights of the public to participate that's a lot that's allowing the board to decide if we don't want to if we don't want to have public comment for longer than 10 minutes we do not have to have that we then have to own the repercussions of what that is but that is I think that is what it is it is
meant to do, but just to say, I mean, just to say that out loud, I think that is what it is designed to do. Did the attorneys okay that? We didn't muck with that. Okay, so this is from the attorneys, the 10 minutes piece? Because, I mean, this is based on a law change, right? So presumably the
attorneys had a thought process here. This was not based on a law change, it was based on a ruling, Or it was in response to a ruling. This sample policy was changed recently in response to a ruling. Yes. Yeah. And does it have... I'm just... Because there is a law that says we have to have public comment. I don't know. The ruling does not speak about the time. It doesn't... Okay, that was my question. No, the ruling basically said, like, boards need to be clear about what they allow and
do not allow. Okay. And can't just make it up on... So you have to allow it, but you don't have to allow them to allow them. I think the language in... I was looking for it. I think the language in the law is, I think, is reasonable opportunity, is I think. So I suppose we could change it to that. Just in response to that, because it was a response to my comment. But that kind of goes to my point of, why are we specifying a time anyways, if we're also saying the chair can then just change the time? So if we're saying, like, we're required,
you know, the board includes a public comment, period. Yeah, and then at the discretion of the chair, this is a time, and then you guys have the ability to overrule the chair if you don't like what I set for the time. I mean, the standard is, you know, we have a 10-minute and a 10-minute, and we can adjust it as we need to. I think the only person that will actively hate that is Ginny.
Because we wouldn't then be putting on 10 minutes every time. Every time you would be choosing, before the agenda goes out, how much time you want to put on it. No, I mean, we don't have it in our policy that we have a second public comment period, but we still put it on the agenda for 10 minutes, right?
So we could just continue that norm. Would it be helpful if, for the second read, If I just do a little bit more research on what the statute requires, and then we can just, I think this is an important point. I'm sorry you've been beeped. I've been beeped. I swear to God, Steph. It's an important point, but it doesn't need to stop us from taking it to second read.
I would agree with that. Yeah. Can I quickly just, I'm going to endorse what Valerie said. I do, I mean, in my tenure here as a board member, there have been times when we've heard from staff members, And I've found that what they had to say was very important. So I do think that we should prioritize letting them be in the same category as residents
and not be pushed to the end just because they're not in district. All right, so we'll push that back to the policy committee to noodle on and bring back a recommendation, and then we can make... I mean, that's an easy enough shift at final read to make if we want to.
Yeah, so I think that, just to be clear, I think that we're basically passing... We're saying we're moving forward with this as first read, but we're going to make those changes before the second read. If we come back and you don't like it, you'll throw things at us.
Great. So we have a first and a second on the floor. So we move to a vote. All those in favor? None opposed. Great. So we have no unfinished business. So we will move on to new business. MSMA fall conference information and the discussion of the resolution and revised
revisions to the Constitution. We'll just lump those together because they're sort of the same the same topic. So in our packets, yellow. Yellow is what we're like. Well, yellow and white, I guess. Yellow is the information about the about the conference. It's October 29th and 30th.
Ginny is asking for folks that are able to attend or interested in attending to let her know by October 2nd so she can sign you up. She will take care of signing you up. This takes place at the Civic Center in Augusta. It's put on by
MSMA, the Maine School Management Association, so sort of the trade organization for school boards and superintendents. So it's attended by school board members from all over the state and superintendents and assistant superintendents from all over the state highly recommend if you're able to go that you take
advantage of this opportunity this is kind of the biggest professional development opportunity for board members I would say particularly for new board members it's a great it's a great event to just sort of you know immerse yourself into all things school board so they have some really good
keynote speakers. So it looks like the keynote speaker this year is AJ Giuliani. Don't know them, but I'm sure they're fantastic. They are a former curriculum coordinator and a tech director. So sounds like they're gonna have lots of things that we're interested in hearing about. So it's a two-day event. It's Thursday and Friday. There's a quick agenda in the back.
And then there's clinics. So there's five or six or seven clinic sessions. And there's a variety of topics to pick from. So you can just decide whatever strikes your fancy. And if you are only able to go for one day, that's okay, too. It's great if you can do both. But if you can only do
one, we understand. It's a big commitment of time. Just let Ginny know by the 9th. No, excuse me, the 2nd. She's yelling at the TV right now. October 2nd. Questions? Yeah. I just wanted to say that when I went last year, it was my first year, and there were several workshops about the
EPS formula and budgets, and going to those was incredibly helpful before we went into budget season. So just wanted to give that a shout out. Thank you for that. Questions on the conference? all right so we will move on to item 13b which is discussion of the new and revised resolutions
and revisions to the uh to the constitution i'm gonna let um i'm gonna let steph take this one because i believe you guys had a pre-meeting on this already right so we voted steph as the delegate for rsu5 and kind of how this works just for a quick overview for folks is every year they
have the uh the uh the what do they call it the delegate something what do they call it assembly delegate assembly there it is it actually used to be at the conference it used to be like a two or three hour block at the end of the first day um and then uh well then covet happened and it they
actually got more participation by doing it virtually because people from all over the state can participate. And this way they can block a whole morning and people aren't missing other sessions by participating. But it was very entertaining to go to when it was in person.
So basically what this does is, so MSBA, Main School Board Association, we have a group that lobbies for education systems in Maine with legislators. And then each year, there's a committee that sort of develops resolutions on things that they're going to
advocate for. Sometimes they're adjusting existing ones, updating them. Sometimes they're brand new ones. And so in order for the members, because this is a member organization, to be involved in that process, the committee, the MSBA board committee creates these resolutions, but then
they go out to the delegate assembly for discussion and votes. So what we're doing tonight is these are the proposed resolutions and amendments to the MSBA constitution. And we are, we're going to hear what Steph had to say about the original discussion about these around rationale.
They give you the updates and why they're suggesting it. And then typically what we do is we just give some feedback to Steph on what we, you know, are we generally supportive or not of the recommendations. Yeah. I also want to mention that I accidentally volunteered to be
the region 10 delegate um you weren't voluntold you actually volunteered uh apparently um so there'll be two of us for rsu5 great we'll have a voting block all right okay so i'm gonna um compete with anna for seeing if i can get under my allotted time um award and i guess the first
thing I wanted to note was that the resolutions are a guidance to boards they're not dictating any of our policies or procedures and that's still work that we still do and decide so to me that's an important thing to note
because I think we got pretty into the weeds last year and then the second I guess overarching theme is I've read through all of this and through the discussions that happened at the meeting that I went to every proposed change
new policy modifications whether they're they some have some that are significant or substantive and some that are non substantive and they all feel this is like an overarching comment that they all feel pretty aligned with our ethos as a board and several of the topics are things that we're discussing actively
either through systems and sustainability studies or things that we want to address in curriculum or things that we've been talking about as a board as well so there's a lot of alignment there it's sort of a my suggestion would
be maybe we talk we frame how we want to talk about this or if we do want to talk about it even because essentially if we wanted if we had input or thoughts or want to change we would have to submit that to the assembly ahead of time and
they would consider if they change the draft language before the assembly happened. And then it's essentially just a vote of yes, I agree with this, or no, I don't. You took out all the fun? Yeah. Well, people can make motions similar to Robert's rules, and so there's still a little
fun, quote unquote, on a Saturday morning. People used to get up and say the craziest things. It was fantastic. And sometimes they do, but for the most part, it's votes of yes, we agree with this, or no, don't um so i'll stop talking there and see if anyone has any questions or thoughts of how
they would like to engage um yeah so so usually there's a couple of different ones right there's new ones there's um substantive changes and then there's changes to the to the constitution um curious to know what the general consensus was at the assembly were was pretty much everybody in
favor of adopting these resolutions as written? No. At the meeting, the pre-meeting that I went to, there were no questions or concerns or anything that was voiced in terms of like asking for changes. And they have changed their procedure, I guess, this year to ask for them to be submitted
directly to the committee that drafts these resolutions and changes for them to consider sort of outside of the meeting. So that was like a shift in the procedure. And nothing that I heard in the meeting where anyone was asking for any changes, so inferred approval. And last year at
the assembly, overwhelmingly everything passed in the affirmative across all the districts. The only one that jumped out for me on the new ones was number four, the cost of special education. I think the first paragraph is factual. The rising cost of special ed represents a
challenge for districts. Agreed. MSBA supports increased state financial support. Also agreed. The middle paragraph was kind of where I had a question around studying the feasibility and benefits of regional education service centers. Maybe I just don't know enough of what that
actually means but that seems a little like counter to how we try to integrate our special ed kids as most as as highly as we can into our gen ed populations like this feels very like sending kids away to to to a regionalized school that that specializes in special ed
maybe i'm misunderstanding that but that's the only one that kind of felt like oh i don't know if I if we agree with that but really what it's asking is to study the feasibility and potential benefits so it's not saying that we think that this is what should happen we're just
looking at whether or not any part of this should be pursued so I see a little bit of a difference there but I think this is sort of just looking at whether this is a good idea or not yeah yeah I think that's just maybe where I guess I in my experience I understood it differently than Steph
articulated it is it's not this in my understanding this has nothing this has no bearing on what we do this is only recommendations to effectively lobbyists to go and try to advocate for law change that's my understanding that may be inaccurate but that's always been my understanding
of what this document is and so when we are signing off on it or not signing off on it we're basically saying like do we want our lobbyists to be advocating for this or not um and so i think you're i think it's i think it's a good question that you're raising on this one to
sort of say like is you know if if our if the lobbyist for msba were to go and try to get this passed would that be something we would be happy with um just so just on that so again i don't i don't know if that if i'm reading that correctly steph no i appreciate the clarification and um
essentially the point I was trying to make and maybe not articulately is this is ways that the body supports school districts both legislatively and through resources provided to districts but it's not binding to us in terms of our our
board level policies in any way but it would inform legislative efforts that this organization engages in and Michelle to your point the second sentence in the rationale section helped me with that and it reads a comprehensive state and local
response includes exporting regional service models strengthening in district capacity supporting the special education workforce and improving funding for high-cost high-cost placements yeah yeah I I'm not I'm not opposed and maybe maybe it's just I don't know what this
MEPRI group's goals are I don't know who they are so it could be that they have all the best intentions. And this is a great way to consider moving forward. And MSBA is supporting those efforts. MEPRE is through the University of Southern Maine. It's the Maine Education Policy
Research Institute. Yeah. So that's, I mean, they don't have skin in the game. Well, you never know. Maybe, maybe they are. I don't know. A lot of these research people, you know, there's a lot of things that happen, reasons why they form or don't form or do the research they do or don't do.
So, I mean, that was just one thing I wanted to bring up as something that just sort of jumped out at me. But, you know, like you said, they're not advocating that, you know, we start sending all of our kids to regionalized special ed.
I mean, it is a research, you know, do we want to support research? And if I had to guess, the likelihood that they're going to get funding from the state to do it is slim to none. So it's probably a moot point. one thing i noticed is the thing that we really kvetched over last time about that last sentence
in the ai they changed it more or less to what we were fighting for which i think is kind of hilarious because they refused last year which page which one are we talking about um it's five to be one r artificial intelligence in schools it's like the like fourth or fifth page oh i'm
way past that no okay the only thing i'm going to ask you to do stuff when you get there other than vote is ask them to number the pages in their packets what the pages not mine mine isn't either i have a five policy yeah i think it just depends on sometimes they might be but but okay the last
sentence currently reads ai is not a substitute for school work that requires original thought and i remember requires original thought we sat for what seemed like a really long time it probably was because we felt that ai kind of actually discourages original thought in if used in most
ways that it's intended um and they changed it and i i feel vindicated we told you so i love that some of these these resolutions have been in here since uh i was in kindergarten some of the stuff been working for a really long time um okay anything else that jumped out at folks in terms
of things that maybe we maybe it's easier to say is there anything that jumped out at you that you weren't in favor of us supporting no but i did want to make one other highlight i found a note to myself um their constitution and bylaws is adding a strategic planning committee and so that
felt like a fun alignment of you know lots of people engaging in strategic planning so well i'm glad we got ours done because now the consultants are going to be really busy, probably charge more. Is that really it? That's pretty much it for the bylaws. I mean, yeah, for the constitution,
right? It's just the addition of the strategic planning. There's a few other things, but nothing material. Okay, so everyone feel comfortable with Steph forging forward with our demanding page numbers and voting in the affirmative for everything else. If anybody wants me to live
text them about the fun on Saturday morning in October. Just let me know. You guys can be texting on the side. All right. So there we go. Look at us. Oh, we're 10 minutes ahead now. All right. Here you go. Here you go, Anna. So we will move on to 13C, which is consideration and approval to
change the curriculum and program development committee from an other committee to a committee TO A BOARD OF DIRECTORS STANDING COMMITTEE TO BE MADE UP OF THREE BOARD MEMBERS WITH THE FOLLOWING PURPOSE AND RESPONSIBILITIES. DO I HAVE TO READ THE WHOLE THING? OKAY. I'LL READ IT. PURPOSE. THE OVERALL PURPOSE OF THE CURRICULUM AND PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT
COMMITTEE IS TO ALIGN THE STRATEGIC PLAN WITH MAJOR CURRICULUM AND EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMMING INITIATIVES WITHIN THE DISTRICT, SUPPORT TRANSPARENCY AND COMMUNICATION REGARDING STUDENT LEARNING PRIORITIES AND OUTCOMES, AND TO RECOMMEND ACTION TO THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS.
responsibilities. The committee shall discuss district student learning priorities and outcomes with the goal of continuous improvement, provide a forum for community engagement and diverse perspectives related to curriculum and educational programming, support transparency and communication related to
major curriculum and program initiatives, provide periodic updates and reports to the board of directors, and to recommend district-wide curriculum initiatives assessments and curriculum alignments efforts occurring across schools and grade levels
to the board of directors so that's the motion thank you kelly for the motion do we have a second kara all right so i will turn it over to anna is this you yeah i think if you just have any um thank you so this came up at the end of last year when we were uh the members of the committee were
a little bit confused about the role of the curriculum committee and we looked at what was currently on the RSU 5 website and it seemed more like we were just supposed to be listening on to what's happening and we also heard a lot
of interest at the board level especially at our recent retreat that the board wanted to be more informed about curriculum and student learning outcomes and so we worked to discuss the possibility of changing the structure from an other committee
which is what it currently is which is just more like a sort of an observer committee to a standing committee which is what most of our committees are which actually has regular report outs such as I did tonight so there's more transparency there as well as more of a governance structure
And so this vote would be changing the structure, and we drafted the purpose and responsibilities to reflect that, and we also mirrored our purpose off of the other standing committee's purpose, so it sort of read cohesively.
so uh two small things one um should should we call the purpose the charge since that's what we refer to in our policy i'm assuming those are the same thing yeah so true yeah i think the only reason why we call it the purpose is that's what the other committees were calling it oh they're
wrong too or we change the policy to say purpose um my only my only other um i think this is great I think this puts some, you know, some good framework in place for what I think we've all been feeling felt a little nebulous in the past in terms of what our role is.
I still feel a little nebulous, but you guys are on the committee, so you're going to feel, like, great about this, and I'm going to also get there. But one thing I was thinking about in terms of responsibility, and I will say that one difference between an other committee and a standing committee is we can only have board members.
on standing committees. So just kind of want to target that so people realize why there aren't other members on this committee. A standing committee can only have board members. But in that front, I'm wondering if in the responsibilities, the second bullet says
provide a forum for community engagement and diverse perspectives related to curriculum and educational programming. I'm wondering if we could change community engagement to stakeholder engagement, because that might encourage staff inclusion in those discussions, etc. And I think
that's, for me, that's kind of the part that would be missing from the standing committee only having board members is sort of the experts in the room. And obviously, Mandy and Tom are experts in the room. But as we get into the weeds of, or you guys get into the weeds of specific curriculum,
it might be helpful to have other people there. And it might encourage that. I just might encourage the use of the word constituent engagement and that is just because i personally have have learned that the word stakeholder has connotations for a marginalized group that i didn't realize it had
oh i'm sorry i did not know that either okay it's learning for me constituent engagement okay i think that's a really great point and we actually talked a lot about that i think the the biggest reason why we didn't want to move away from another committee was because we liked
having you know parents and teachers on the board and lois was on it for a while and she had really great input um so i like that recommendation and also to note one of the things we're talking about doing is to have our meetings at the schools themselves and so it would make it easier for
administrators to come teachers staff etc um and just knowing that we want to hear from them and it in the responsibilities would be great I I have the last point of responsibilities recommend that word activates my what is our role as a board
tension and so presumably this is work that is done as Anna just mentioned like in schools with administrators and my reading of that is that it's recommend to the board so that that's that's the rule but then I may be reading that
incorrectly but that's my understanding is that the part of the responsibility of this committee is to do some thinking and then bring that thinking to the board that the board then I think is I mean I think you're right there is sort
of some nebulous territory there I don't remember exactly what our the language is around curriculum board but it's like one of our three things so that if it is that that feels appropriate because that's not changing anything about what the board is doing it's just asking the committee to have some responsibility in
educating us yeah and I think the district-wide curriculum initiatives that that is our purview right to as a board to vote on that the one that sort of sticks out for me is the assessment one like I'm not sure if as a board we
are we should be but I don't think that is something we would necessarily vote on or you might vote on a district-wide assessment system or particular assessment that is not necessarily state required okay you know you you might I'm
not suggesting that you do or don't but you might decide you know all kids in a certain grade in a certain subject will do a certain assessment because I mean like when they moved to I think it was the MEA I don't know they changed the
assessments frequently um it made me laugh when you said like the data changes each time um because that's exactly what happens it's useless when they change the test every time but um i do believe there was a period of time where we actually paid to continue it because we wanted that continuity
from from year to year um so i guess that that would be an example might be you know the state requires us to give the nwea at certain times right you can give it at other times if that's a data point that you want I think also just that I mean if
I'm under and again and I own that I'm still trying to wrap my head around the literacy thing but like just in the presentation that Mandy gave like it makes clear that read writing can fontes send panel benchmarks are assessments
and those are assessments that are connected to curricula so I think that I think that is completely I think that I think that is completely appropriate because basically saying like we would I think it's saying to the committee how
is the current you know a curriculum that we're using or curriculum that we might use how is that assessed and would that be a shift away from something we're currently doing or something new and then what would be the rationale for that so that's the way I thought about that but Mandy you can tell me if you have a
I was just going to add that I think in terms of the way the curriculum committee has talked already about data is really looking at those questions around what is the data telling us and what are we missing and that might be an opportunity for the curriculum committee to
then come to the board with a recommendation around that and so that was just what we're missing yes yeah yeah so that was something that um Colin your your thought just made me think of thank you yeah I guess um I think maybe what's missing in that last bullet for me and this is
just me holding that tension again is that we're doing this in collaboration with administrators right and that we're it's not like the curriculum committee is um doing its own research uh of like what the curriculum will be and then bringing that recommendation to the board right yeah
I mean I think what you're getting at stuff is right like there's a tension here and I understand that it's to some it's like oh my god like are they going to be micromanaging the curriculum that is not our intent at all um but i do think that the board also needs to understand that we
are the accountability i mean that's really like the only accountability our schools have lies with us um and so i think when we're talking about looking at the data and looking at what's missing and looking at what we're interested in and we're inviting stakeholders and our constituents in and
we want to make sure that we're reporting back to the board on any things we're noticing or if something appears to not be working or I mean it's all new and I think what's going to be really interesting is figuring out how we're going to do it in tandem with the general curriculum reviews
that are happening at the staff level, because I think that's going to be a really interesting process, because a lot of it's going to be happening in tandem, but then we're going to be looking at some things they're not. But I feel like if we just shy away from being like, well, we can't micromanage our school,
then we're at the other end of the spectrum. It's like, well, what are we doing here? So I guess it's good to name it as attention, and I think we need to keep it in mind. but um i don't know i just i don't really feel like we can just leave it blank um i don't think
you're suggesting that but annie maybe you can say it more i was going to say that i think that the sort of recommendation is more retroactive than proactive in terms of we are recommending this curriculum because we have you know googled it um i think it's more also exactly we're looking
at a situation where like we've been given the data and mandy and whomever else any other constituent has helped us sort of disseminate the data and we're like hmm there's a gap let's go back to finding figuring out and that's where then the proactive piece comes and i don't think that's for
us to determine i think our job is to bring to the board saying we found this and we're on it yeah i mean the way i envision it and and what i took out of what anna said that really kind of struck me was, you know, this doesn't surplant the curriculum reviews that are happening in the
schools in the in the district overall. But they may run in tandem. And I view this as sort of from the board perspective, because we do have a different lens than potentially the educators delivering the curriculum have in the classroom. But we are the ones who have to vote on that. So
I have often felt like maybe I was not as equipped as I would like to be making a decision like that and so that's kind of where I envision this committee coming into play as like as board members sort of doing some of that legwork to help us as a full board be prepared for those
recommendations that would come from Mandy and Tom. I appreciate the dialogue and I fully agree and it to me this is a place where the slope is slippery of um running the schools versus seeing that they're well run and i think it would be helpful to really keep an eye on that and keep
that as a priority to be watching that tension so okay i just have a question i think that i mean it's sort of it's connected i guess to steph's thing but i guess i was finding myself um and i've always i think the three times a year has not changed right that's sort of what it's been for a while I've always felt like in my heart of hearts that that is like vastly insufficient
um that it should effectively be like it should be month it should be monthly if not more frequent um be if indeed it is a sort of the the operation is really to sort of like to to um like really keep kind of an eye on what is happening and really have a sense of what's going on in the
schools um but that is in conflict with and it goes to sort of the quite like yes the googling um uh point but it's sort of like yeah what is really expected of the the of those members of the committee like what are we saying to the members of the committee that they should be doing and that they are doing outside of the meetings and then but also connected to
that is what are we basically baking into this that we're what's the labor we're creating um for uh staff um because i think like i think the place where we've been is that in its first incarnation the last couple of years i think it wasn't creating any labor for the staff and i
think that was a problem um so i think it should create some uh but i don't think it should create too much but like what's that balance of figuring out where um where is it that like their questions raised the the um that goes to uh the staff to go do some research but then where is it also where
annie and anna like go off and spend a bunch of hours researching something which is what we sometimes do on the policy committee right like the like we didn't ask the the that's not that's not fair we no we did not ask the staff um to send us possible language around the uh transgender
rights at the school. That came from our work that we did independently outside of that. So again, I just sort of wanted to air that tension. I'm not saying change it from three right now, but just sort of to say I think that whole tension is one. It's a messy one,
but I think it's an important one. So we have a little bit more detail in the motion around like membership and stuff as opposed so is the the blue sheet here is that front page going to be sort of the charge of the new committee should we include the membership should we include that
stuff on this page just to make sure yeah because I was gonna say the old one we have a little bit more in terms of I mean I don't know for standing don't you need to have three members I would say you have to yeah I don't I can't think of a standing committee that we have that has less than three. So yeah, I mean, I think three makes sense. It is a fair lift of stuff. So, you know,
share it. But yeah, no, otherwise, I think I appreciate your guys' willingness to do the work to get it to this point, and then to have volunteered to take on this work into the future. So we have a motion, and we have a second. Do we have any other questions or comments on this
before a vote? All those in favor? All right. Congratulations, you're a standing committee. All right. So we have one more item on the agenda. No, I'm sorry. We do have public comment. Before public comment, we have item 14, personnel. So do I have a motion for consideration and
approval to employ a kindergarten teacher at the Moore Street School for the 26-27 school year? Kelly and Karen, thank you. Okay. I am thrilled to present you this nomination to hire Polly Driscoll to be a kindergarten teacher at Moore Street School. We faced a resignation of Olivia
Gladder, who was in that position that we did not expect, but Olivia was done on September 11th. This can be a very hard time of year to find a teacher. However, we have found an absolutely crackerjack person who is currently working in RSU 57, has been there for quite some time,
is highly recommended, but has ties to this area and sees this as a wonderful chance to move closer to family and be part of this district. So I hope that you will support the nomination. Yeah, I was thinking like, oh my gosh, have we been without a kindergarten teacher? So I'm glad to hear that hasn't been the case. Valerie. I'm just curious where this RSU is. Oh, that's Western Maine. So it's where, it's like Waterboro, etc.
Okay. Massabesic High School. Thank you. Yeah. A high school usually is a great grounding area for... See, my problem is Massaby, Sigmorana, Cook, Meselonsky, in my head, they're all the same. Yep. I have no idea where any of them are. I know some are up by Waterville, I know some are out west. I do realize this is on YouTube, and like people... No, it's, I mean, there's no, I'm not... They're over there saying like Freeper, Poundell, Durham, can never tell them the difference. Yeah, no, I wouldn't expect them to, but like, it's just, I always think of those three high schools,
and I always mix them up in my head, so. The fact that you knew, now I forget which one you said. Just outside Leamington. Massa Besick. So there we go. Just outside Leamington. You think they're watching our board meetings, really? I know for a fact that Polly is. Well, she might be, yes. Welcome, Polly. She's not at the high school. She's a kindergarten teacher. All right. Now that I've completely embarrassed myself online. See, this is where I cut it out of the live stream.
So if you guys could mark that, that would be great. We have 10 minutes before you can go fully off the rails. Noted. Thank you. And dancing commences in nine minutes. All right. So we have a motion and a second. All those in favor? Hey, welcome, Polly. Public comment? All right. Then I would take a motion to adjourn. Kelly, Chris, all those in favor? All right. We are out of here 19 minutes before our agenda said we would be so
Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.
