TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 4 November 2026
Board meeting · 2 h 48 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →
17,829 words in 22 five-minute windows.
okay and we are back thank you for the patience for all of those of you who were anxiously waiting our return sorry about that but we will carry on and try to get through our agenda expeditiously so item 6 do I have a motion for
consideration and approval of the minutes from the October 21st 2026 meeting as presented barring any errors or omissions. Anna and Chris, thank you. All those in favor? Great. None opposed? Adjustments. No? No. Great. Good news and recognition. Maria's had
plenty of time to come up with a nice long report for us. What do we got? Exactly. So first off, I just want to congratulate the Freeport Field Hockey Girls for winning Class B South Regionals today um their next game is november 7th 11 a.m at edward little so good job for them the endeavor
program hosted a mock debate at the meeting house arts in freeport on monday november 2nd the day before election day miss hunter's anatomy and physiology class went on a field trip to the une orata lab and got to have some hands-on experience in the medical field which was really fun junior
Nick Mallett was accepted as a sole representative for the Maine Music Educators Association Jazz Allstate Ensemble. Juniors Anna Reagan and Lucy Inkstrom were accepted into the top national singing conference hosted by the American Choral Directors Association in Minnesota which will be
in March. The theater department is wrapping up preparation for Sweeney Todd which will be debuting November 19th which I'm really excited for and lastly my really good friend Baila Bucati who is a senior is one of 51 students in Maine that have been named semi-finalists for the 2027
National Merit Scholarship Program based on PSAT scores so I'm really happy for her and very proud of her. Thank you. Sounds like a lot of great things going on. All right so we will move on to public comments don't think we had anyone hang out that's okay we will move on to no we don't
have a report from the superintendent look at us flying through the agenda all right administrator reports so we are going to start with 11a update from transportation department and goal review jeremy everybody i'd like to take a minute to thank our drivers and sub drivers
for all they do this last week has been stressful on them but we pulled it together we're down two drivers this week and wheels on the bus going round and round transportation department goals for 25 26 expansion of safety training and activities develop a new safety and training
schedule for all transportation staff october february october february 26 drivers attended the MAPT conference in Augusta. Develop a system for fleet maintenance. Update a plan for recording the maintenance and repairs of the fleet. October and December of 2025. Google Sheet continually
updated fleet maintenance updated on a regular basis. Exploration of most effective way to schedule van and bus usage for extracurricular activities in field trip requests. Research and explore pros and cons of different methods of scheduling to meet the demands of van and
bus usage. October and February of 2026, Carina software purchased, bus routes submitted for review. Transportation Department goals for 26-27. Establish a consistent professional development process for transportation staff that strengthen drivers' ability to provide safe, responsive, and student-centered transportation. Ensure all bus drivers register with the state. Transportation Safety Program. Access a variety of professional development opportunities. June 27. All eligible drivers are registered for the state training, records department, document,
precipitate participation in relevant training opportunities. Identified priority training needs are addressed through professional development. Driver feedback and available safety or operational data inform future training priorities.
Connection to the strategic plan related to 2B in the strategic plan, creating a culture where every student is valued. Training connect transportation with other areas of school operations, including student behavior, special ed needs, emergency response, communication with student well-being.
Number two, implementation of evaluate career software system to streamline, coordinate daily student transportation, field trip requests, athletic and extracurricular trips, and special education transportation needs. Conduct a SOF implementation through June 2027 to access functionality, identify areas for improvement, and ensure the system meets the needs of the transportation staff, school administrators, and families.
Following the evaluation and necessary adjustments, prepare for a full rollout to parents and families in fall of 2027. October through June of 2027, with the SOF implementation, this will give us enough time to test the software and ensure it will be ready to roll out for fall 2027.
The implementation of school transportation management software supports the district's commitment to creating a culture where every student feels valued by promoting equitable access to transportation and ensuring that individual students' needs are recognized and addressed.
The phased implementation will provide an opportunity to evaluate, process, gather feedback, and make adjustments to ensure the system supports the diverse needs of all students and families, helping every student feel supported and valued.
Thank you, Jeremy. You guys just started sort of the training on the system this week, right? We did. Yeah. Our field trip sheet is actually live now. Oh. Be careful. People are watching this. They'll start going and ordering up field trips.
Oh, they do. I have a question not necessarily about the training piece here, but curious. I feel like we had some discussions last year. Thankfully, not in our district, but in other districts, There were some accidents and safety issues, and there was discussions about ensuring all of our fleet were properly with all of the...
All of our route buses are now outfitted with crossing arms. Great. Which keeps the student six feet away from the front bumper, so no accidents could occur. They're out in the sight line, and they can be seen. Perfect. Thank you. The new buses were ordered and also come with pinch sensors on the doors, so they're up to date with that spec, too. Thank you. Chris. Firstly, I just wanted to say thank you for what you've done for our district and your many varied and evolving roles.
And then I really appreciate what the drivers have done too. And hearing you say that, definitely you can tell you stand by the drivers. I do. What is this Karina system? Is it an internal system? Is it something that parents would have access to at some point?
I should probably answer that. Okay. So Karina is a workflow software, And we spent Monday and Tuesday of this week and Friday of last week getting the administrative team plus a few additional people like our HR person, our bookkeeper, et cetera, to envision all of the processes where we have a workflow that is mostly now paper. A lot of our workflows have been in the 1900s. And they have to go through inter-office mail, like to hire somebody, for example. There's a paper form and it starts in a school and then it comes to me and then it goes to Kelly and then it goes to me and it goes around and around.
And there are any number of processes like that. And so we brought on board the software, which A, in itself is not that expensive, and B, is going to eliminate our need for other softwares that we're using because it will consolidate a number of things, invent electronic forms for them,
and then house them all on the website. And some of them are student-facing, public-facing. Some of them are staff-facing. It's going to take time to roll them all out, and it is literally within the past week that we've done this.
And when I introduced the idea at first, Kelly and Sam and I met, this is like last spring, we met with representatives from Karina, and there was some skepticism, but I think it's safe to say that particularly the past few days, as the team actually started building out these forms, it's great.
So we're just getting started, but it's going to be transformative. So this isn't just transportation. This is a workflow for anything in the district. Anything that we need a workflow for, but where we're really starting, where we had envisioned we would start, is transportation. The form that I was talking about was three copies. Yeah, a field trip request for him up until the last few days is literally carbon copies.
And it's a triplicate, actual triplicate. Starts with the principal, comes to me, then goes to Tom, sign off on it. Lots of paper. So we're moving ahead. We're moving into the 19th century or the 20th century. Hiring has been another area that I don't want to go on and on about this,
But imagine where we want to get a candidate in the position before we lose them, and any number of signatures have to happen. And let's say it's summer, and let's say that maybe more than one of the people who needs to sign is on vacation. It could be me, it could be Ashley, it could be Kelly, it could be a principal. How that slows it down, and in the meantime, a great applicant may have found another job. But isn't there, I mean, we have an online application system, right?
We do, but there are a number of modules to that. We don't have all the modules for that that you have to pay for. So a lot, we, that's front line. We'll still be using that. But in addition, there are our internal forms to make sure that, oh, let's say to verify that the criminal history records check was done or that the check on the main certification system was done. And all of those things need to be signed off on. So that's Karina. Very exciting. Have you seen it in that? Just like in another district or anything? No, just demos. but other districts in Maine are also using this.
It's kind of being rapidly onboarded. Emma and I went to a paperless school board meeting package session last week at MSMA. Also very interesting. I think Ginny would lose her mind, but in the end, I think she'd be really happy. Well, Ginny was part of this whole process, and everything is endorsed. Really? Yeah. Ginny's stamp of approval? I'm going to get a text. Kevin's like, I'm not saying that yet. Other questions for Jeremy? Thank you. Thank you very much. All right. So we will move on to item 11B, update from Facilities Department and Goal Review, Glenn Reynolds.
Evening, everyone. So for the Facility Department, goals for 25-26, the goals ensure all facilities are operating efficiency and effectively. The strategies and action steps is one, to continue to develop an articulated capital
improvement plan that includes items identified through the energy audit and comprehensive building assessments, and the timeline for that is 25-26, and the evidence of effectiveness is a capital improvement plan. Item two is continue to develop an articulated plan for vehicle and equipment replacement
by ongoing evaluations through physical inspections and performance analysts. The timeline for that is 25-26 with the evidence of effectiveness is the vehicle replacement plan. Item three is facility assessment of early childhood transition.
The timeline for that is 25-26 with the facility assessment of early childhood transition. Item 4 was building mapping, and that timeline again was 25-26 with the evidence of building mapping. The goals for the facility partnered for 26-27, the goal is to integrate findings from the System and Sustainability Study in the District Existing Life, Safety, and Emergency Improvement Plan to establish priorities in the next step for long-term capital improvement.
Strategies and action plans review the system and sustainability study findings with the district leadership team and consulting firm as appropriate. Timeline for that is 26 and 27. Evidence of effectiveness is to review and assess the system and sustainability study finding in relation to the existing life safety and energy improvement plan.
Connection to the strategic plan is to ensure that school infrastructure and equipment efficiently and effectively supports the infrastructure and extracurricular programming offered by instructional and extracurricular programming offered by the school districts. Thank you.
Item two is compare study findings with existing life safety, energy improvement plans, and identify alignment gaps in additional facility needs. Time flying flat is 26-27. Identify any additional evidence of effectiveness is identify any additional facility needs and establish priorities for future capital improvements.
Connection to the strategic plan is to, it provides a multi-year capital forecast, roughly three to five years out, allowing school boards to phase in purchases and avoid emergencies. Item three is collaborate with the district leadership team to prioritize identified needs based on safety, operational effectiveness, educational programming, sustainability, and financial consideration.
Timeline for that is 26 and 27. Develop evidence of effectiveness is to develop recommendations for next steps, including anticipated timeline and budget implementations as appropriate. Connection to the strategic plan is to capital allocation of and resources, optimizing operational, environmental, sustainability, community, stakeholder, and engagement.
Item four is building mapping, again, 2526, evidence of effectiveness, building mapping through the system and sustainability study. Connection to the strategic plan is to aligning physical infrastructure, safety, and resources with outreaching, overarching educational and operational goals.
So the building mapping, we put that off last year because we knew it was going to get picked up with the systems and sustainability. We did, and part of the vendor that we brought in asked us to do a 3D mapping. So I've reached out to, I've got pricing from one vendor I'm working on getting the second pricing from another vendor and having that done at most of our locations. Not all of them, but most of them. Questions for Glenn?
Matt, one question for Glenn. Thank you, Glenn. Sure. I'm curious as to what are you most excited about with the Systems and Sustainability Study? That's a great question. What am I most excited about? That's a tough one. All the work. Well, I mean, it's definitely going to open up a lot of doors, right? I was extremely excited when I first got here, and I mentioned this to some of the board members that were here. When I first got here, every time I kind of toured the building
and dug into the weeds, I'd have to go back to central office and apologize to Gene. And the reason why I was apologizing, that there was either something that either wasn't done correctly or there was additional problems that I was finding through the weeds.
So I'd stop my conversation. I'm awful sorry I have to tell you this, but I have to tell you this because this is not working. So when she brought to my attention that the board requested to do an energy audit, that's perfect for a facility director because it validates everything that I've been telling her from a third party that doesn't have any stake in our district,
just comes in and this is what you got. So the same thing with the sustainability. They're just going to come in and tell you what you have and what you don't have, and this is their recommendation. So I look forward to that. What I worry about is the overwhelming aspect of it.
We have some old buildings, and we have some old systems that are in those buildings. Some of you have seen those when we've done our tours, where we took the 51-year-old boiler out of the high school here. So it's exciting, but it's kind of nerve-wracking at the same time
because it can be overwhelming. And then trying to determine how that lines up with our energy audit and how we can streamline that and then become efficient and effective and also support the educational structure that we're trying to do
can provide a decent challenge for us. So, yeah, I'm excited but a little nervous. And some of you have heard this story, but it just seems like it fits with what Glenn was just saying about when he would go into buildings. And I'm sorry I have to tell you this. so uh when we were interviewing for glenn's position we came out to get him to bring him in
i think it was the first or the second interview very first yeah and um we had there's some kind of leak in the central office and so they were repainting we came out into the entryway and he was on a ladder in the roof like he couldn't help himself he didn't have the job yet and he needed
to know what was going on up there right so my wife's watching this so she's gonna kill me oh sorry no it's all good so like when i go to a restaurant i got you the job i know i did it did so that's why it's good um but when i go to the restaurant any restaurant any building the first
thing i do is i look up and i start looking at corners and you start looking at things um and she's like you got to cut it out it's like you just you just got to cut it out and you just do it for so long and i truly enjoy it so it gives me ideas that you can either commercial buildings
or commercial buildings it doesn't matter what's inside they all got roofs they all got plumbing they all got electrical so you can take something from those so it's it's good but it drives you crazy so usually they all have water they all have water michelle whether it's actually reaching
the building of working is is can be a challenge i will say um i appreciate you know the like but we have a driver that every day greets every kid as they get off their bus at mass landing by name men always says to me, like, this is grim, the best human beings in Freeport are coming off this bus. And I just think, like, if you were that kid, right? Like, if you were that kid,
and that's what you hear every day. So, huge second there, thanks. And I'm excited to talk with you about the work, both that we've been doing over the past year, and then the work that we're going to dig into going forward. So, if we're looking back a year, as you'll see, another
area of continued focus, this has been multi-year focus, so much so that you won't see it on our this year is reducing chronic absenteeism last year we ended just above six percent it wasn't quite coming off that year 3.5 it wasn't quite where we wanted to be but we still have a lot of
pride in those numbers which are a reflection both of work we were really intentional about doing at the tier one level so universally for all kids you may remember last year I talked about how somebody from the state had reached out just noticing the improvement we had and and the
conversation we had had with her is really like attendance work is universal work. You can't kind of intervention your way out of it. Interventions for individual kids and families are certainly important and part of it. But if school is not a place kids feel connected and
sense of belonging, it is really hard to ensure they're there. So we're really proud of that work. I pulled the data as of Monday night. We were at 5.3%, which I'm thrilled to say is lower than we were the same week last year, so we're still on track. And this is both an extension of all the
work our staff do, but Scott Emery, our assistant principal, has been really instrumental, particularly in partnering with students and families who have struggled to get to school regularly. Another piece we worked on last year were our RTIB structures and supports. You might remember
those are the systems and tools we have in place to support students in the same way we support students with academic gaps. We have students who struggle behaviorally with things like emotional regulation and executive functioning. And these are the systems that we've put in place and refined
really over the last six or seven years to support students in accessing their education and also supporting the general classroom environment in that way. That has been hugely supported through our RTIB ed tech role, which was preserved in the budget last year. We're immensely grateful for that
because that individual is a huge part of ensuring that support is accessible for kids throughout the day. And then the last goal area we established last year was around reading instruction. While it's, it may not kind of like, I think there's one note of it, I think it's
really important to emphasize that the work that we did last year and are continuing to do is built on the foundation that's happened pre-K2 at Moore Street. And we've tried to be very mindful of ensuring that the shifts they have made continue in our own practice. In fact, on Friday, I'm going
over to K2 classrooms at Moore Street and doing walkthroughs with Julie Nickerson and our instructional strategist with the same lens through math. It was like looking at what are the things and the refinements that are happening in classrooms so that when students get to third
grade, that growth that they've made K2, that we can kind of carry the torch from there and ensure we're building upon it. For us last year, this looked like a couple of things. In third grade, students had new phonics, or teachers had new phonics units. The beginning of those units really
is a review of some of the phonics work kids are doing in second grade, and then the back half of the year has a morphological focus, so looking on prefixes, suffixes, word parts, and that is universal for all students and was something that hadn't existed in third grade previously.
Other pieces in the revised reading units that we adopted that are included, one was explicit vocabulary instruction, and the second was interactive read-aloud plan. So we've always had interactive read-aloud as an embedded process
and practice in our classrooms. But what the plans have ensured is that when we're doing read-aloud of text with students, that the kinds of questions we're asking students, that the thinking we're modeling for them ensures that it's really at grade level expectations. So in other words, we want to ensure that the thinking work we're encouraging kids to do in classrooms matches the thinking work of that grade level and the rigor of that grade level. And so that hasn't allowed for more systematic work in that read aloud. We also did learning ourselves as educators, thinking about and exploring what best practices look like. We did a kind of a deep dive into informational text as that's a really critical part in units across grades three, four, and five. And then the other piece of work that we were really mindful of was a student facing one around the culture of reading in our building.
I think a reflection we had had as a staff, you might have noticed it with your own children, is the shift in technology and the shift in kind of what childhood looks like is that kids are reading less. And we know that reading at volume is really critical to kids developing as readers.
You simply cannot get better at reading if you are not reading lots of different kinds of text and lots of text. And so what we did is we did a school-wide survey, which ended up being very, our takeaways were different than we thought they would be around students' identities as readers and their reflections. In some ways, it was very affirming. Our kids had stronger reading identities, I think,
than we anticipated, which is amazing. Kids can talk about the types of books they love reading, what they're drawn to. They also found something that was really surprising is they described reading as like very restorative, this sense that like reading wasn't about academics,
it was about like regulation and having cozy spots and some of their feedback for us was like please protect reading as a quiet space like please make sure classrooms are quiet when we're reading um students were able to articulate the things they were working on a lot of kids
articulated that they loved graphic novels but they also were working to to reach and grow beyond graphic novels even like those kinds of insights to us were really powerful about thinking the kind of identities kids have eight as eight nine and ten year olds as readers and so we use that to
inform some of the work and fun we had across the year so we started some new practices that have actually carried over unintentionally into this year because kids love them one was something we call stop drop and read so for example in November Scott Emery played a turkey call
randomly at intervals during the day on the announcements and wherever kids were they stopped and read with the exception of bathrooms. But the beautiful thing about it that I underestimated is it meant all day kids and adults were carrying their books wherever they were. And so there's
something about that, right? Like seeing what people are choosing and kids seeing me with like my adult book club book and kids asking each other about their books. We also did something called March Book Madness. So we built brackets around 16 texts that homerooms that each picked
and the insanity around kids advocating for their books was just i had never estimated like i'd never anticipated this would become the thing it has now become i think i had like dozens of third grade boys reading hatchet which is a book a lot of kids don't pick up it's not super contemporary
but it's incredible it has amazing character development and the final two books ended up being um both books with very similar characters one is called the trouble with heroes which was published in the last two years hatchet is i read when in the 90s and kids were literally like
chanting in the hallways like hatchet hatchet trouble with heroes and then it got and came down to one vote we had kids who were submitting absentee ballots when they knew they weren't going to be there on voting day so i say all that to kind of qualitatively illustrate for you
the kind of culture of reading we're working to build and reinforce um and the beauty is a lot of those things are in place. And kids articulated a lot of those kind of new traditions being favorite parts of the year. And then the really great thing is it reinforces that we're all
reading, right? And reading is something we do not because it's required in school, but because reading is a joyful thing. And so that was some of the work that we did around reading. And you'll see we had some gains in reading. There are several ways we're looking at students' proficiency in
reading, you'll see that I've started disaggregating just for kind of my own reflection, looking at kids who are the 40th percentile and above, but also kids who are the 60th percentile and above, to be really mindful of ensuring, A, that like we want to be mindful of growing all kids wherever
they're entering, and also recognizing that the rigor, for example, you see on the BAS is more complex on that assessment. The comprehension work kids are expected to do is more rigorous than they are expected to do on the state assessment and so being mindful like often we'll see more correlation
between kids on on the main three year that are about at that 60th percentile and above aligning with our highest proficiency measures through the bas before i talk about kind of our transition for the current school year any questions about that work how do we get in on
the march madness for this year you want to like pick a book or you want to come vote both yeah well so it's interesting like i love talking about this stuff so i'll go down a little bit of rabbit holes so one of the things one of my takeaways is it got a lot of kids into books that i didn't
anticipate they'd read so last year we let homerooms pick but this year we're actually going to intentionally pick 16 titles that we know kids love or that are great launching titles into like new genres like dystopian right that kids like don't often like go to our start at
fifth grade they're like starting to creep into um so we're going to intentionally pick some older and more diverse titles with the intent that like what ends up happening is that it gets kids into books and then we're going to buy our ptc has thoughtfully funded us buying a box of books
for each classroom each year so we're going to buy those titles don't know how i spoiled it because the kids don't know this but they're going to get those titles at the launch of book Madness. I was just saying, I don't think they're watching. I mean, I know we're great, but I don't
think they're watching. It just takes one kid to show up tomorrow. I know, we're getting the books. So it's a practice that will continue to evolve. Thank you, Emily. I have one question. I was wondering if you could talk a little bit about the Reading Buddies program while we're talking about literacy. Oh, like third and fifth grade? So I think this is year three that we have paired
um all third and fifth graders with buddies uh we did it for lots of reasons um among them like developing leadership among our fifth graders helping our fifth graders like really see the responsibility they have as the oldest students in the building um deeper cross-grade correct
connection i think this district you know one of my reflections i think we have strong um grade level cultures and it's like how do we grow strong school and district cultures so having kids across grade. And a lot of the work they do is read together or share their writing together. But
it's really kind of grown into its own amazing thing. This year, we've gotten a little creative because we don't have an equal number of fifth and third grade classrooms, but we have made it work. And it's now, it feels like one of those things, three years in, it's like just what we do
and what we'll continue to do because the kids speak really positively. It's amazing. One of the moments I love most is fifth graders often find out who their buddies are before the third graders know in the first daily mile where fifth graders went out they're like oh like I'm waiting for my
buddy and um walking together and just like the power of that if you're a third if you're an eight-year-old who's in this new school to have somebody who's like looking for you seeking you out walking with you at the daily mile each day um has been really amazing and I realize you're
going over different things but do you found since you've implemented like some of the different things you didn't think that took off that maybe that have you seen an increase in the reading levels I know that we we define that in different ways of assessing but not even doing it in testing
just assessing from a day to day have you seen an increase in their levels of reading and understanding I think what I qualitatively what I see from that kind of student reading work from like a culture of reading is that kids have a strong ability to talk about who they are as
readers and the kind of thinking they're doing as readers um which facilitates that work it's not like this direct like okay this kid is like really passionate about how thinking thinking about how like both of for example the two final books in march book madness have incredible character
development that's really important work in the three through five span thinking about how characters change what their motivations are how that informs the theme of the text that's going of set them up when they go into middle school and beyond so it to me it's like vitally important
that kids think and talk about books in that way and that it's normalized right and I think that's something that this work has helped do is like we are readers right it's interesting I have a fifth grade teacher who like Monday kids turn and talk about their weekend reading and it's you know I
said to her it's like you almost feel uncomfortable if you hadn't read you must be like how do I like you know like this is what we do and we talk about books we share books we chant in the hallways about books we'd like kids who had face painted like hatchet on their foreheads like
it's and it's like it isn't about the face painting right it's about kids being connected to text and seeing books that like feel like an extension of them or part of who they are now of course there's a lot of other mechanics of reading that facilitate that but I think it's
hard to grow lifelong voracious readers without that as well thank you um i saw on the main three year for reading i saw the eight percent increase on the 60th percentile like that's huge yeah and i will say like you've heard from julia already part of that shift is we are getting kids who are
more skilled right so like looking when i look at the kids who are getting intervention sorry and i probably like interjected before you finished your question um some of that is is getting kids at a place and helping like maintain that that skill that they have and that's a good building
block until i was going to go next it's a one percent increase for the 40th percentile above like what were are there any things that you learned from getting that first group to move forward they're like oh we're gonna double down on that and make sure we target it in this new
direction instead what are those things yeah i think so i think actually the biggest like difference in those two groups it's a fascinating question is that the cohorts are slightly different because it's end of year to end of year right so that spring 26 data is current fourth fifth and sixth
graders the previous springs data is kids who are now fifth sixth and seventh so i think some of it is not if like we were looking at the exact same kids which i also do right as i'm like taking like okay who moved from not proficient to proficient or who moved from like a 40th percentile to 45th
or vice versa like who was proficient and then wasn't and why or who's proficient on the bas but not the main three year or vice versa so we look at all those pieces at an individual student level when we're looking at those cohorts like the cohort of spring 25 to the cohort of spring 26
that to me is like the reason we're seeing that difference is because our third graders came with such stronger skills which enables us to like maintain the momentum those kids were closer to benchmark it's like so when they come to third grade like we can continue lifting them at the
level and rigor of third grade if that makes sense but what what could you do like imagine you get to the end of this year yeah and the 40th percentiles like 88 percent of students are at that 40th percentile and above yep so you see that same eight percent increase again but for that metric
for the 40th percentile metric yeah like what could you replicate that you did for the 60th percentile metric for the 40th percentile yeah it would i would want a longer i'm gonna like hypothesize because i want to want like a more longitudinal decision because the state's about to change their assessment metric again um of course but if i like the things i i'm like that
float in my head these are like the things that kind of keep me up at night or like interest me at night. Yeah. And one is like, are we teaching to the rigor of the grade level? That's something I think about all the time. Like you are not going to move kids if you are not like thinking this is
where they need to be at the end of third grade. And how does my teaching match that? And if I had kids who aren't there, what are the supports? But like, we never, it's like, we, we can't kind of keep, we don't want to keep our, like lose track of what the end of your metric is. Right. So when
kids are moving, particularly at those, you know, at that proficiency level, like we're not talking about kids who are receiving intervention. It's like, what are we doing to ensure that the rigor of teaching, when we're doing read-alouds, when we're taught, when kids are in book clubs,
when we're talking to kids about what they're reading, that reflects the rigor of the grade level. And that teacher, something we've worked on the last few years is like teachers understanding if you're in third grade, you understand where the work goes in fourth grade. And if you're in fourth grade, you understand where the work goes in fifth grade, so that you understand the importance of your piece. I think that's part of it too. And some of the benefit of like having
teachers move across grade levels for that reason because then they'll bring some of that awareness so one thing i think is like how are we always teaching at the rigor of the grade level um oh i lost my other thought i had like two that that were questions that came right away
um if we have i think oh i'm going to talk in a little a little bit and this is is related but slightly different one of the things we've been thinking about on the other end is how we're servicing students who receive special education services because historically we're not good at
moving those kids, right? So one of the things, like if I were suddenly seeing like more kids meet that 40th percentile benchmark, my hypothesis is some of it is the impact of the work we're trying to do with kids who are serviced in other settings. So that could be special ed, but it also could be
RTI. And how are we, one of the things, and I'll talk about this in a minute, like how are we ensuring our special education services both respond to the needs we're seeing in kids, but also are ensuring kids still have access to grade level content and that has been something that has
been tricky at times so those are the two things that came right in in my head I know they don't direct like the second one doesn't directly answer your question I thought that was great and to summarize what I heard from that is like there's this like maintaining the rigor is probably the
biggest thing that you saw as moving kids forward and I think that reminds me of like the difference between holding a high bar and meeting kids where they're at it's like of course you have to meet them where they're at but it can't end with or it still has to result in getting to the standard at
the end and then my hypothesis then would be like if you thought that more for the students with disabilities or the students who are trying to break that 40th percentile threshold in the same way you do with the kids that are breaking that 60th percentile threshold we could see even more
of those wins yeah and you'll see i'll talk about that like some of the thinking we're doing around that piece when i chat about this year we haven't even gotten to this year any other before she moves on to this year trying to think the order i want to go in i'm gonna go because i kind of want
to like end with our biggest bucket of work so if you if you like start on the very end of the goals um the first is really continued work our team debated whether to include this there's obviously like a lot of work between the buildings that are articulated on this goal sheet um but my
leadership team felt strongly that this by having it on here it names the importance it has to us as a school community and that's ensuring that kids have opportunities to practice social emotional learning throughout the school day if you've been here for a long time you kind of know
my philosophy which is like sel is not standalone sel is like what we do all day long when a kid comes to me this happened last week in foursquare and said like that kid had poked me in the eye um and there were literally like people walking through the mass landing school parking lot who
was just on vacation talking to me about mass landing and a kid came up like that kid poked me the i doing four square like that problem solving right there with that student that social emotional learning right how kids greet each other in morning meeting social emotional learning um so this is
work that we've done over the years we've grounded in the castle standards we have a lot of structures that support this work through responsive classroom as one um but one of the learnings is like as staff change it's still valuable to come back to it like you can't do this work once five years ago
and they're like cool we've got it so some of it is just ensuring all staff as we've had some new teachers and new ed techs join the community that we all have shared in common language about how we support the development of these skills and then the other is to deepen some of the work that we've
already done so for example post-covid we were noticing that students were really struggling to solve social problems with one another they were looking to adults for help with everything so kids would come up in the lunchroom and say like hey stephanie tucker stuck her turn up out at me like okay like how are you how are you going to solve that um and so what we did to support that is we
developed with kids a building wide anchor chart of social problem solving strategies i carry it on my lanyard and the reality is like actually i don't even need it on my lanyard anymore because kids know them they come to me and i'm like what have you tried they're like well i asked them to
stop i took space you know they'll name what they tried but one of the things we're still noticing is kids are having a hard time distinguishing when they can use those strategies independently family and when they need the help of an adult. So yesterday, for example, during part of the PLD
day, our school counselor facilitated work as a school developing shared language about how we're going to talk to kids about, some people kind of refer to it as size of the problem, we're going to use slightly different language, but when kids can be independent in problem solving, when they need help, and when they need help like right now, like I'm going to throw up in the middle of a classroom. Other work we did, for example, is we've used for a long time through responsive
classroom there's terminology called energizers which are like activities that get kids moving their body maybe they're more alert we realize that there are times actually kids don't need an energizer they need something to settle themselves and so yesterday we were as a staff
kind of growing our repertoire of noticing and naming with kids like when we're helping them like upregulate and also when we're helping them bring their energy down with the idea that they develop an awareness of that for themselves and know it in the same way like when you're in a meeting and you need to go stand up and get a cookie, right? Just for the opportunity to stretch.
So that's what we added my cookie. What about your cookie? All of us. I had the cookie as soon as you came back. I just got a cookie when you started. I was so glad so many people got cookies. So that's continued work that we'll continue doing. One area we want to grow and expand it
is communicating more regularly and clearly with parents about how we're supporting that work so families can reinforce that work at home. Moving kind of up from from the bottom, the second practice you'll see is related to inclusive practice. No, sometimes when we talk about
inclusion, the thinking can be instantly that that is relevant to special education. It is, but we are thinking about that in a much broader sense. So we're thinking about all the ways in which students' identities and needs are met and supported to the best of our ability in our school
setting. Last year, this work really grew organically out of staff interest. A team of us attended a conference with the DOE, an inclusion conference, last fall, and through that grew just internal work and then reached out to the Center for Community Inclusion and Disability
Studies at UMaine, who offered some support with us as we were thinking about where we wanted this work to go. Last year's work was really around almost like needs assessment. What do staff feel like we need? What are entry points that are really accessible? What are much more
complex entry points as we think about the ways that we're servicing kids? And so some of the things we did last year, we shifted the way we do student placement in part to think about students who are receiving special education services who really can be accessing grade
level content, ensuring that those kids are clustered together, because what it means is they can then remain in the general education classroom and have push and support rather than pull those. If those kids are in four settings, I suddenly like can't, I don't have four adults
who can go to those settings. So what happens is those students would get pulled out, which is not providing those students the access they need. So we try to be more mindful through placement. The other thing that was really loud and clear for my staff is the desire for general
education and special education staff to have more embedded, iterative opportunities to collaborate about students. So this year, both resource room teachers have 20-minute blocks of time that are scheduled every week to touch base about kids with the idea that if we are trying to align
special education services with what's happening in the general education classroom, which is grade level content, those individuals need time to talk about what that looks like. So those are some of the smaller, or like I should say, more discrete practices that came out of last year.
We have obviously had much more, and this is work that I really do see as like ongoing multi-year work around some shared learning at the school level. Some staff have just asked like, can you just help me understand an IEP more clearly? Like when I'm looking at accommodations, what do those
things mean? What accommodations are great for all kids? Even if a student isn't identified for special education. We have lots of kids who have unique needs that are not identified for special education with multilingual learners, students who may have needs with executive functioning and
thinking about how we're supporting all of those students. And then also being really mindful. One of the things I valued this fall is I think it's resulted in like increased staff awareness and empowerment about thinking through how we're providing access to all students. So I, you know,
I had staff who were even like our school expectations posters on the wall are all language like let's throw photos on there as well so students don't need language to access last week we had for the first time so students do announcements every day
our students who have AAC devices talkers did the morning announcements for the first time which was like a huge highlight for me for the whole year and it was amazing the conversations that there's also graded in hormones as they heard their peers use their talkers and also for the students who
have not had that opportunity to have their voice be on the announcements to have their voice be on the announcements um and then also we're trying to be mindful of what are ways that we're bridging like creating more authentic opportunities for students with the most profound disabilities in
our school community to have very authentic relationships with their peers and um so for example last year like one small thing we started we had a basketball group of student who was like really passionate about basketball but didn't um doesn't yet have the skills to consistently play
in a way that is always safe or fair or like in a way that feels fair to other kids but creating an opportunity outside of recess for four or five fifth graders including the student to play together with high school students who came over and played basketball um with them so thinking
about how are we creating genuine opportunities for kids to engage in play or other experiences that develop relationships that are authentic with one another. And then the last big bucket of work this year, and this is a district area focuses around deepening students' mathematical
reasoning. We started professional development on this topic in August. We've had a professional Development Day in October, and then again yesterday, that focused on this work, and then have launched a book study yesterday as well, to deepen our understanding of how students develop
mathematical reasoning. We're looking specifically at the 3-5 span as well, but how they're transitioning from counting to additive reasoning to multiplicative reasoning. And through that knowledge, being able to both identify students thinking as we're seeing student work, being more
mindful of like what work and examples are we showing as we're having conversations about thinking in class, being mindful about, okay, where can I push that kid next? Like what level, what sophistication of thinking they're ready for based on what they're thinking? And then also
thinking about the opportunities we're creating across our math block for students to practice the kind of reasoning that we know is really essential to creating a foundation for the higher level math um that they will do as they develop um this again builds on some of the work
that moore street started last year um at k2 uh that will continue in the three through five span so questions about the work ahead questions for emily one of the strengths i saw from the achievement from last year on chronic absenteeism and on reading was the clarity of the goals like
5% increase or below 5%. And I don't see that on the mathematics schools. Oh, is it not there? There's clear baselines but it's not where you want it to be. Oh my luck. I'm surprised Ginny didn't catch this if I didn't put it in my revisions. It should say 5% as well, but let me... On the main through year? Yes. So thank you for catching that. And Ginny missed it. Ginny watching? Does she know? And And thank you for the, for the noticing, not just catching that, but also like just, I didn't
mention this with the reading work. It's like these pieces of work are all multi-year work, right? So it's like this mathematical focus in some ways is not like that we're no longer focusing on reading. And I feel the same way that I do about our attendance data. It's like,
we really wanted to get to a place where we have like multiple years of the numbers feeling like a place where we're like wow we are proud of that work um and i think you know for reading and math that's what we're looking for is like how do we you know it's work this year that five percent
target is where we hope to be but i anticipate in a year i'm back here and i'm like here's how we want to like here's what we learned this year here's some successes we saw here's where we want to keep pushing and where we feel like the opportunities are thank you all right one more
question on the strategies and action steps one of them is to review and refine the end of unit assessments yeah and i'm wondering if you have to explain more about like why that is a priority because i'd be worried that it could lead to like removing questions yeah and then that over
inflating results that then just build up when we get to high school yeah so a couple a couple points of clarification our end of unit assessments um with everyday math are distinct from the benchmarks we use in our, so numbers on screener and main through year. Um, one of the learnings
over the last couple of years has been that those end of unit assessments don't always, um, communicate the priority standards of the grade level, um, across the year. So it can be a little bit, you can imagine if you're a teacher and you're like, okay, I'm starting teachers right now are in unit three. I'm like looking at the end of unit three assessment, like thinking about,
okay, that's where kids need to be. But if the items in that unit, if the items on the assessment don't closely parallel what the priorities for the whole year are, it can be a little bit misleading. And what was happening is like sometimes kids were looking like they were more
proficient in a skill than they were. Or what was happening is some of the units had an item on it that might have been one day of instruction for the unit. The assessments in EDM are also quite long so one of the things that we in this process has been like a how do we lift ensuring
like priority standards for the grade are what really stand out on those end of unit assessments knowing teachers are collecting assessment data all the time right all day long they're looking at what kids are doing making notes of what kids are doing the second thing is how do we have those
assessments be a length that most students are completing them in one day that they're not taking two or three days of instructional time to collect that assessment data. And then the third is there were just some formatting things, both from like a communication standpoint to families, like the
cover pages were not always intuitive to families of like what their children were actually able to do or not do. And so ensuring both more clarity with the cover page, but also the items themselves, like sometimes just the layout of the page. So there's like been honestly like just a very
format-based review as well, which is obviously like less substantive than thinking about what items are kept or removed or clarified. Sometimes language wasn't intuitive to kids, which sometimes you just don't realize until you've given that assessment five times. You're like, oh, kids tend to misinterpret this thing. But the priority with that was really to ensure
that what we're assessing end of unit assesses is most closely aligned with the priorities for the unit and grade level thanks Emily and I can say we're at a curriculum committee meeting with Emily and I said this with endearment she is a real data
nerd we saw her wall and she digs in deep which is awesome I'm gonna just have a question on the collab collaboratively reflect on ways to refine or adapt everyday math I had a chance to visit Moore Street last week and it was a for math and the one takeaway that I found and this is again
my observation somewhat corroborated by by Julie and the administrative team there is that everyday math was not meeting the needs of the students in every way and so they were supplementing with other programs which not only took
up a lot of the class time because they needed to use that it also chewed up a lot of resource in that the building coach needed to take a lot of time to teach the teachers how to use this other curriculum, number corner. And I guess my question to you is, are you finding the
same things in 3-5 everyday math? You see her smiling? That's sort of the reaction that I got at Moore Street as well. Anna was there for it. And I just found it really surprising. So I was hoping maybe you could speak to, um, the ways in which that you need to refine or adapt everyday
math. Yeah. So I think, um, you've articulated a need that a lot of teachers would articulate as well. And part of the reason that we're in a curriculum review. Um, and in some ways I kind of have joked, no offense to my spouse, but like, I feel like everyday math, everyday math is like
a spouse, which is like, you know them like really well. And because of that, you kind of know their well too like it's easy to be like oh my gosh like this lesson is horrible or like what were they thinking with this but at the same time because you know them well like you know how to like work with that right so I think there are many teachers are making refinements and for a
couple reasons one is just it's a curriculum that's built around 90 minute lessons we don't allocate 90 minutes to a math instruction a day um in our building so like there's just that logistical piece but also like as we have have looked at the needs of our students and learned
ourselves like there are pieces where um it can be refined one of the things so so an area that we spent some time this fall looking at is something called open response which is a two-day practice um in each of the units that really is centered on mathematical reasoning and thinking
through what the second day which is it's it involves like making sense of other students thinking thinking revising your own thinking um but we spend some time like looking at those tasks and thinking of what the day two looks like more you know discrete examples are like what the warm
up looks like so every day starts with a warm-up um we have teachers who are now starting to think differently around how they use that warm-up time um to better support both development of reasoning and also support the goals of the unit. So there is a bunch of refinement that's being done. And what's tricky is that refinement is often like very thoughtful and intentional and impactful
for someone who knows the grade level content very well. It's harder if it's a teacher who's newer to the grade level, right? And that's where it can get tricky because if you don't, like if you haven't gone through that curriculum, Sometimes you can unintentionally make ill-informed decisions about what to let go, if that makes sense.
And so, you know, we're trying, it's this careful balance right now as we know we're in a curriculum review. It's like, okay, what's working, not working for ourselves? Like, how do we refine, like, the assessments or refine open response or rethink how we do warm-up to more closely align with both the strengths and gaps we're seeing in our students while also not recreating the wheel?
And I think that's where some of the frustration is like, oh, it's like in elementary teachers are prepping for every content area as well, right? So it's kind of a careful balance. I do think one of the things I keep coming back to in my own learning about mathematical reasoning is like the beauty of that learning is it's applicable to any content, like any
curriculum you're using, excuse me. So the learning we're doing this year, wherever we end up, and Mandy can probably put on your insight at some point on that like wherever we end up curricularly what we're learning about how
students develop skill will be applicable and relevant to wherever we are curricularly in a year from now. Thank you. Could you speak more on how the various specials courses fit into these goals particularly what I'm thinking of is they have the special opportunity of in most cases
having those students all three years and how that might fit within this framework. Yeah. So a couple places, and know our special team is often drivers of this work. So for example, social emotional learning, as I was talking just about the idea of like settlers and activators with kids, that came from that team, which was thinking like, hey, what would be the benefit to kids of having some shared practice across our space, right? And we often know, I think the greatest irony is like the kids sometimes who are, have the greatest volume of skill to develop, like either social, emotionally, or academically, are often the kids that we then expect to navigate so many different environments, like homeroom, classroom, intervention setting, five different specials locations, right? Maybe the sale classroom, and thinking of like, where are places we want parallel practice so that kids are not, you know,
the take-a-break spot in Mrs. O'Connor's gymnasium doesn't look that different than what take-a-break looks like in music or what take a break looks like in art or when we're shifting and we need to like calm our bodies we just came from PE and now we're coming to music and it's like okay how do we settle our
bodies for music class that we're not doing it 12 different ways with kids and so that team is often the team who's like how could we think about this more systemically and to drive that and that's a great example of like where they did that work as a team and then it was like actually let's like filter this out to the whole school the inclusion work also very relevant because those
are the only classrooms that service every single child in the whole building and so really thinking about what does access mean for all kids those are the spaces where it is immediately relevant every single day. Thank you Emily. Of course have a good night. All right so we do not have board
comments and committee reports but i am going to throw something in there to let folks know with karen's departure and anthony joining we do have two um uh i guess there's just one um committee uh opening for curriculum program development committee so uh it's going to be
on the agenda for the 18th um so we'll we look at committees and anthony and tom and i are going to meet for his orientation prior to that. So we'll give you a skinny on all the different curriculums, all the different committees that you might be interested in. And so that will be
on our agenda for the 18th for folks to be thinking about. But other than that, that's it for committee reports for this evening. We do not have policy review this evening. So we will move on to item 14, which is unfinished business. So do I have a motion for consideration and approval
to appropriate an additional $15,142 from the Capital Reserves for an overall total of $45,142 for the variable flow device replacement in the two-stage pumps in the FPAC area at Freeport High School. Melissa and Chris, thank you. I was wondering why Glenn was still around, but that's for this one. And so I don't know, is it you or is it Glenn that's giving us the update on this? Okay. Hi again. Yeah, so when we started this process, I came to you last year where the pumps up in the
boiler room, one of the pumps had failed, and we were down to one pump running. We were still a winner at that point, and the concern then was that the second pump failed and the FPAC, that side of the building, wouldn't get any heat. So the board approved a dollar amount so we could get those pumps replaced.
In that process, there was kind of some changes that were going on between the vendor, we work with which is emc who's also overseeing the energy audit portion of that this falls well into the energy audit phase um so i was working with one individual then i started working with
another one also in that same uh time frame um some of the vendors that were going to be providing bids we also also experienced a change in personnel some personnel on their side left for whatever reason so it delayed the process while we were working through that process um
we it just took a an extra period of time or an extended period of time to finally get the numbers in so we can uh replace those pumps when the prices came in because of things that are going on in the world we came up a little short on the estimated so the they gave me a budgetary number
when i first came to the board once they got into and started receiving bids this is kind of where where we landed on the bids um again that's just due to the events going on in the world unfortunately so um i'm sorry about the delay in uh getting this um but we could uh certainly use
that so we can get these pumps fixed so uh where this comes from is the capital reserve account so uh that's a designated account where funds are set aside for specific to building and facility issues, so that's where the original $30,000
came from, was from that capital reserve, and so for ease for accounting, the best option is to move the additional $15,000 so that we would have the full $45,000 to get those pumps redone. Yes, pumps and the variable flow. Variable flow valve.
Devices, yes, these are devices, not valves. So there's a four to six weekly time on those. So if we can get approvals, the goal is to have these materials in by Christmas break so we can do that during Christmas break when limited access with students and staff in
the building. Yes, sir. So did we replace that? So there was one pump that died, right? Did we replace that pump already? Nope, that's what this is. So we still only have one pump. We still only have one pump. Thankfully, when we were going through this entire process, we ended up going
into early spring and then summer so the call for heat went down um mechanical services came in and did their normal pm services to start up for winter that same pump that was running then is still running now it's in great shape still um but i still feel that if something were to happen
we would be in so not hot water no no hot water no no water thank you thank you yes indeed all right any other questions on this one so we have a motion and a second on the floor all those in favor great not opposed before glenn leaves one thing i just uh mentioned as i got my
cookie thanks emily um was uh i forgot to ask glenn when he was up here earlier about his facility tour uh highly highly regarded event if anyone's interested he did say he's willing to do it again this year so uh so maybe we can work on uh maybe a couple throwing out a couple of dates
to the board for for our newer board members uh usually what that entails is a chunk of time two or three hours and usually a morning and we go around to the different buildings in the school and you get to kind of see um he'll show you the variable flow device yes and also variable speed
device we have both in the district yes so it's a behind the scene look at some of the equipment that we currently have but also an update on some of the new equipment that we have installed to the energy audit so as I mentioned when I
first got here this is the first school district that I've worked in that the board has been willing to want to take a tour so it's exciting for me to be able to get you to see behind the scenes on what we're actually dealing with and
working with on a daily basis to keep the wheels of the district not just the bus is running right i also want to say too that when i was up in the ceiling at the at central office when before my job interview i we did fix that leak so that leak has been fixed i do want to
take that so for the record that's right for the record that leak is done 100 all right uh did we vote we did yeah yeah okay that's right i did i kept you up here to mention the facilities tour That's all right. So I'll send out an email with some selected dates and we'll pick something up.
Highly recommend if it works in your schedules. I always find it very informative. Thanks, guys. All right. So we will move on to item 15, new business. Okay. Well, this is where I have a sneak peek at the budget coming up for next year.
Deep breaths over there. And then in addition to the sneak peek, I would like to take your temperature on where you'd like to land. So if we look at wages and benefits for next year, bearing in mind that wages and benefits is over 80% of the overall budget, so pretty strong indicator of where we're going in general.
We are looking at, well, we have not negotiated the educator contract yet, so we don't exactly know where that will land, but looking ahead, anticipating what we might call a reasonable guess as where that might land. And I don't want to say what that is. We're looking at a status quo budget for wages and
benefits of about 6.17%. That includes that placeholder for educator negotiations. Now, there are a few other things to consider. First of all, that 6.1% is just wages and benefits. It's not the entire budget. It does not include a hire that you approved for us to make recently,
which was to add an ed tech at Mass Landing School. And we are paying for that this year out of a reserve account. Next year, we'll need to add that in to the entire budget. So that's about $55,800 currently paid for out of reserve. That addition would bring the wages and benefits
year over year to 6.32, as opposed to 6.17. And I can foresee some areas where we will more than likely, I can see myself bringing additions or expansion to the budget right now. And those include, we have deferred technology device replacements. We deferred a lot of that last
year. I'm talking about mostly at the high school. We're not going to be able to continue to defer all of that. Second, more support for the transportation department. I don't want to say what that looks like yet, but I can see myself recommending more in that department. Third,
early childhood and bringing on three-year-olds. Don't worry the state's got it. Yeah well you just set me up to say I think it is predictable that our diminution of what is reasonable and necessary to meet that responsibility may not be congruent with what the state says is reasonable and
necessary for them to reimburse and we'll just have to make decisions around that but I could foresee that that's an area where we might have an impact. And then last whatever the systems and sustainability study recommends for us to consider. I was just on the phone with Andrew
Doloff two days ago. He is working on the report. We will have it very soon. So that means we, well, that was the royal we at the moment. That was I will have that report probably within the next couple of weeks. The board will receive it in December. I will have it in time to confer
with the administrative team about what it may imply for next year's budget. And then, of course, bigger conversation about what it implies year over year is a much broader conversation that includes you all. So this is what I have for you tonight. And just for some context, those of you
who are here or paying attention last year will remember that it was roughly this time last year that I came to you and said, I'm looking at a year over year budget of about 10.5% if it's status quo. And what would you like me to do with that? So we're not there. And that's good news.
I'm anticipating that the budget conversations this year will be a lot easier, but what I think I need you to think about is where do you want to land for next year? So I would invite some conversation about that. I don't need that answer today. I want to plant the seed today and give you
some time to think about it and to consider what you think is responsible for next year, because 6.32% for wages and benefits, plus some other things. That could look like 7 or 8 by the time it's all done. And that's where we ended up last year. But that's also not nothing. So I need to,
that is what I have for you tonight. So Tom, I know that we don't have all the numbers and we're just starting this process. And I went to a thing at the session at the conference, which was very helpful being new um about how to how to do certain things and and and being responsible
for the board so and and i know you guys are on top of that but it was very um i guess my question is does that include like in the past this was does that include um the health insurance that's under the benefits part okay and i can say that in this district we have uh many districts are in
a position of kind of having to estimate what the health insurance cost will be, but our contracts are based on the previous year's health insurance, so we always know exactly what it will be, what our obligation will be. Thank you. Yep. This year's negotiation with the educators,
will that affect our 27-28 budget? Yeah. It will. Okay. Yeah. So the contract ends at the end of this year correct and then it will start before the end of before the beginning of this next year correct okay it will be the major factor right but in negotiating increases for them that won't
start until after that year is that how that works no exact no okay no so we don't know what the salaries and benefits under the educator contract will be for next year and we will we have the first ground rules meeting coming up on the 16th.
So if we could get this wrapped up by the new year. Wouldn't that be great? Unfortunately that's always a timing sort of disconnect that happens in the year of negotiations. The number that I just gave you is based upon a placeholder. And it's a placeholder that seems reasonable to think about right now given the trends we've
scene it may not be where we end up how long is the contract that you negotiate with them so our current contract is a three-year contract thanks tom i was wondering about the systems and sustainability study which you know as glenn said it's likely to be overwhelming um i imagine though
that any recommendations that we decide to move forward with a lot of those would be coming from capital reserve and not necessarily taxpayers' money? Or is that not the right way to think of it? Well, the capital reserve is the taxpayers' money still, but I think it's unlikely that there would be
major recommendations from that that we would move on for next school year. I mean, it's not impossible that that would happen, but as I sit here right now, I think it's doubtful that any kind of seismic change that they recommended is something we would implement in less than a school year. So I don't know if that helps. I mean, think about sort of the timeline process for tennis courts. Yeah. Right, and how long it took to make something like that happen, which is not nothing as it relates to dollars, but considering major changes to the schools,
it's pretty minor, I feel like. But potentially, we could make longer-term decisions that we might want to have impact next year's budget, potentially. Potentially. Yeah. Can I just tell when Colin's hand's almost going to go up?
That's my rare thinking face. I guess just to find a point on it, I guess I just wonder how much, as part of our recommendation, you know, our sort of saying this is the sort of territory we want you to look at. I guess I just wonder how much
we should just acknowledge sort of publicly, knowing that our staff and employees and negotiators are watching, that you have put that number, what was it, 6.17? 6.32, including the ed tech. Okay, so 6.32. It's just sort of, because I think this is something that has that has sort of come up in the past is sort of like the question of how aware is the
board but also how aware is the um the teacher teaching teachers union about the impact of the negotiation um and so i suppose i just sort of want to put out there that i think i would encourage us to just be very clear as we talk about it, to say let's say we say come back
I'm going to go high just for the sake of this is hypothetical, yeah, for fun for fun, let's say we say come back with 15 15% is what we want that would be said with an understanding that any negotiation that is above a 6.32
will necessitate a conversation about cuts, staff cuts. You're not wrong. We came up with it last year. I wouldn't be careful the way I say this, but we have these competing factors, right? And one is the overall level that we compensate all our employees, and then the other is the employees that we actually have that we're compensating. And then superimposed upon all of that is where we want to live within a budget.
So these things all do a dance with each other. And what I am asking you to think about right now is the big picture of what is that overall level of budget increase that you feel is responsible and sustainable for the community right now.
Yeah, no, absolutely. and I think I'll drop it back down to an actual thing we might do. So let's say we say between 8 and 8.5, that that would be reasonable. I think I would encourage the board to say that is the range we think is reasonable with a 6.32.
In other words, that's basically saying all those other things that you said might need to be in there are the, are the, are the, um, the, the territory over that. Correct. And so that, that as both we, as both you start to put together that budget, and then, um, and your administrators are thinking
about that, and also as the negotiations are going on, that is sort of a known quantity. They're just, we're being very sort of, like, we're being sort of clear, not that, like, that is the, that, like, is the number, but just to be clear that, like, if it came back at, and it was, like, 7.2,
there just would be an understanding that that would that would put us in a territory where we need to look at staffing cuts. Does that make sense? It does. So that's about it's a proposal it's a proposal that I'm making to the
to the board to consider that that again that's that's not going to avoid hard conversations it's just it's just being very clear that like that like just to be like that all the adults in the room understand that this is what um the downstream impact of
decisions are you're right about that and where wherever that number is the lower the number is the more likely it is that something has to give somewhere that's just the nature of the beast that mathematical reasoning that emily was referring to earlier math has to math i will
say that when we did this last year that was i mean we all those of us who were here know how difficult it was but that clarity at the beginning helped me go back to the team and say this is what we need to work with let's figure out how we get there with the least painful impact and we were
very purposeful about figuring out what is actually the least painful and we talked about it there and talked about it here, and that kind of conversation was healthy, tough but healthy, and that's, I mean, I hope we don't have to have as difficult conversations this year, but that's what I
would hope we would preserve going forward. I agree. I think that sort of setting that stage was helpful. I 100% agree with Colin about, you know, just understanding the impacts that come from the negotiation process. I feel what's a little bit different for me in terms of sort of
setting that range this year, and this is just my view on how I think about the math, is sort of the range of the 6, 7, 8 that we gave last year felt reasonable given the status quo increase being 10. And recognizing that anything below 10 was a shift to the left there. And I wanted to be
respectful of that and not slash programming and staffing and all of those things. I guess I would just be a little bit careful this year to say, oh, if six is wages and benefits and then we give eight, like oh we can add more things and still stay within eight like I feel like eight is as a
sustainable is probably is too high um and so I would be concerned that you know it'd be like oh well that's you know that's easy we can keep all the people and add these things and still say eight and a half and so it feels a little bit different to me than it did last year and even even at the
same numbers feels a little bit different and I'm not sure if I'm I've really processed it through yet but that's just kind of my initial initial take on it yeah I think last year was really helpful to have that tiered to have the tiers to consider and I don't
I don't know if you said that this is something you would do again or not but I'm wondering if this was also helpful for other board members I would like to I personally would like to see that again and and maybe at lower numbers this
year, five, six, or seven. I'd like to agree with Kara that I found them helpful. I think after the previous year with what I'm, I think we all have considered a fair statement of horse trading, I think having just a slate of choices of this is what our administrative team thinks
are three tiers, and it's one of these options, and leaving it at that, I think made us more of thoughtful in a productive way than a what can we keep that maybe it seemed less productive previously so i i like the the slate of options where we take them as take them or consider them
or discuss them as packages versus um trying to a la carte it line item yeah chris um i would also and and i realize this is this is work and i appreciate the amount of work that that went into this last year but um when i think of a budget especially school budgets i don't think of a
one-year budget i think of a budget that is over time and so seeing the projections that we had last year was very helpful for me in making my decisions um because it's possible that a higher budget one year could result in a lower budget the next year while you're on that i i want to
point out and this is just to give kelly a shout out what you're seeing this year right here is exactly the projection that it was last year if you made the changes that you did right and spot on that's great i appreciate it seeing the effects of the if there is changes to that um this year
would be helpful in making those decisions just being being new to this um and only seeing you guys online last year watching from as a just as a taxpayer whatever yeah thank you um what if is there some other things that you could like just to be
helpful like I know they mentioned the tier thing but there's some other tools and skills that you guys did to break things down that would be helpful to someone that was new to be looking at this I can summarize what we did last year, which I felt the process worked well in the end. First, we did get feedback from the staff
through a survey and through listening sessions. We've done that, and I actually spent this afternoon kind of going through all that data and extracting the themes from that. Then we sought guidance from the board about where do you want to land, and I got tiers of
six, seven, and eight percent. Knowing that to even get down to eight percent, it was going to require reducing like a million dollars, which is a lot of, when you think last year, a teaching position cost, an average teaching position was about $105,000. That's wages and benefits included.
And if you think that to get from 10.5% to 8%, it was about a million dollars, you can see that how many, so that could help visualize the impact of that change. And then as an administrative team, We developed criteria for where a reduction would have the most impact to kids or the least
impact to kids. And then we considered those criteria and we talked about where are the reductions that have the least impact to kids. And we put them in the tiers. And that's how we developed those tiers. And then when we brought them to the board, there was healthy conversation about explain the reasoning behind that, and we did,
and we considered multiple points of view, and that's how we arrived at the decisions that we arrived at. I do think we don't need to do it to that level this year. I don't foresee us needing to have so many painful conversations,
but to the point that Chris has, I would encourage all of you to consider this. Every year's budget sets the stage for the work that comes not just next year, but three, five, ten years from now. We are starting to have some sense of what that is for RSU-5. It's early
childhood, which could include full-day pre-K or full-day preschool. It's facilities that need investment. There is strong sentiment that a district middle school is something that has a lot of support from a lot of constituents. If we're going to do that, that's something that
would be bonded. We're certainly not going to need the state to pay for that. So if that's something we wanted to do, that's in the mix. And another thing that's in the mix that I feel compelled to mention consistently is that in three states, not to have those things in the
back of our minds as we consider how we go forward as a district and setting ourselves up to make the investments that we need to make. Some of those investments are in facilities. Some of them are in programs. Some of them are in making sure that we compensate our staff so that we attract and keep the best people.
Alright, so maybe I'm just feeling punchy, but... It's not even 10 o'clock. Dancing happens. Annie dances at 10 o'clock. That's not punchy time. No, it's punchy time. He's like, what have I done? given all that, and given Chris's encouragement that we treat it as a multi-year budget.
I think, I don't know, I don't think we can reasonably, nor should we, float early to the community that the budget is going down, or that it will be flatlining. Because none of the things that you just indicated would suggest any of that is possible. There's nothing about the
system sustainability study that would suggest that like we're going to like cut a bunch that we're going to i don't know somehow magically cut a bunch of costs so and uh investment is the is the language that you're using investment in this context i've i mean it can mean a lot of things
but i think it very specifically here means financial so i guess i i very much appreciate Michelle's, like, your sense of, like, this sort of general compass on, like, what is too high with an, with a eye to both, like, being responsible to the community and also sort of
understanding sort of historically what the community has, has been happy to, happy to support or willing to support. But I think it would be, I think it would be foolhardy for us to try to I think 5, 6, 7 is low, because 5 would mean staff cuts.
It almost certainly would. Well, it would. It would, because we also have to have some other things. Like, so it would. So, and I think we left last year, again, if we sort of, if we go back and are honest with our previous selves, is like, we did not last year feel that there was room for more cuts.
that was not how we left it. Like, we left it, like, we made some hard decisions last year about staffing, and with an understanding that that was setting us up, which, again, to your point, like, we, 6.32 or whatever it is, is, like, exactly what, what was planned for.
I just, again, I, I would just really encourage us to, to start the conversation without being honest with ourselves and being honest with the community that we're not in a time when we're going to go back to four or five or even six percent. I just don't, I just don't see how that
is, I don't see how that is possible. And I think it's, I think it's unnecessarily cruel to both the staff in terms of labor being asked, not to mention anxiety. And I also think it's cruel to the community to suggest that we might be able to, um, find some magical way of, of bringing that
down. Um, so I would just, I would encourage us, like, totally hear you in terms of, like, not, we shouldn't say eight and, like, so we've got room to play, but with an understanding that, like, like, probably it's, like, six, seven, eight, if not seven, eight, nine, with an eye toward what
Chris is talking about, with an eye toward, like, because we know there are going to be things coming up, because we know that there's going to be costs that are being set in place because we made the decision to do the systems and sustainability study. So I just, I would rather,
I would rather have that difficult conversation early and have that consciousness in the community early than to, I don't know, I just think it's going to be false if we approach it otherwise. That is my opinion. So, that would be my concern too. Thank you, Colin. That's very helpful. My other concern too is because we do have the three and four-year-olds. We do have the three-year-olds. We don't, and from the conversation that we had last time with them giving us the breakdown of what the plan is and everything and their goals, we still don't have an answer about the three-year-olds.
So, we're kind of, how can you budget when you have that unknown, which is what we're facing? Yes, hopefully we have parents that do, that we hopefully have the use or ability, resources, I should say, of some daycares where some kids are like, oh, we don't want our kids to go to public school, we're going to keep them here.
but it could go the other way because oh we have public education now they're going to cover it and we have to cover that part too so i'm kind of like that's where my mind goes is how do we keep it under a certain amount but also how to project that over i guess what chris is saying too three
to five years from now because especially if we go all day i mean we have to account for those staffing positions yeah i mean that's that's a decision on the board's part right like that's a that's a programmatic decision that would have to be made um that that wouldn't be necessarily
something that we wouldn't know um we might not know how many kids um like the exact number we would just have a general general sense based on what we were able to glean from from the state but yeah I mean it's there's a lot of it's hard because my hope is that some of the systems
and sustainability is actually going to show some efficiencies and pick up like that was one of the goals right it wasn't just like how do we build fancy new schools that that you know have an atrium in them it was like could we could we structure this differently to be more efficient either
programmatically or financially, right? That is, that is, I'm hoping there's some thing, some pickup there. Now, is it magically two or 3%? No, I totally recognize that. And I also appreciate the, you know, the not wanting to over-promise, you know, going from, hey, a status
quo is six and we're telling you to come back in with five. Like, I respect that and I understand that we don't necessarily want to create, you know, undue panic. There's just so many different moving parts, you know, similar to, I would say, the flip side of what we did last year, which was,
you know, we need to understand the impact of any cut. Like, what does this mean, you know, the impact? What does this do for kids? I think the flip becomes true on any ads, right? And, you know, that's new for you, because you've only been here this year when you're removing
some things. But historically, we have had a pretty robust process of like, if you want to add something, you've got to have a pretty good case to make for it to increase the budget for those. So I would encourage you to keep that in mind when you're thinking about like, hey,
these are some things we need to add. I would just be, wow, just a pit in my stomach to say the word nine. Because I think there are things that are going to come down the pike. And I just want to make a distinction between flatlining and five percent or six percent those are very
different things right like this is right so you know a flat budget would be a huge huge impact you know trying to maintain the level of growth to that six to seven that that feels different to me and maybe a little more attainable but I mean that's why we're not going to figure it all out
in one night. Chris? Yeah, I appreciate that. I also appreciate Colin's comment. In my mind, I think about times where we had 4% or 5% budgets. We also had inflation at 0% or 1%, and now we have inflation at 3.5%, 4%. Real inflation, higher than that. And so if you add 4% to 0%, you add 4% to 4%, you're at 8%. So these budgets are not... In my mind, 8% is a lot, but it is not outside of the realm of reality because of the landscape that we
currently live in. So just thinking about external factors of what actually causes us to make money, what actually causes us to have to spend money, and thinking about how inflation is in the country at the moment. These budgets are just not out of the realm of possibility and reality.
Just because you said at the beginning, we don't need to settle anything tonight. I'm looking for how you're thinking about this and i'm certainly one that something like this i have to i have to sit on for a little while to think about um i'm also it's my body saying it's 10 10
so my brain's um a little fried uh logistic i want to dance and i have to wait 50 minutes which feels like forever um no how is it that you want feedback from us will there be another opportunity for us to give that to you at a board meeting? Yes. How does that work? How do you want
that to work? The next meeting. Okay. We'll build into the agenda sometime to further discuss this, and I want to make it clear that wherever you come in, I will do my best to bring you the budget that is best for kids. What I need to know is you are the agents of the community. You are elected
by the community to represent the kids. And so what I need from the board is a dipstick on where the community is with this. I think that's the guidance I need from you. And, I mean, if you want to come in at 8% or 9%, that makes my life a lot easier, for sure. And we don't want that. Lord, you must know. But if that is not what you think is bearable,
I need to know it as soon as possible so that I can get to work with the team and make the best budget within the parameters that you set. Kara? Yeah, I'm also thinking about our strategic communications committee and how this is a priority in that group to be able to communicate our budget decisions
and considerations next year. And my recommendation for a 5, 6, 7, and to have a lower recommendation is to be able to show people, people who would want no more than 5% what we would have to cut, what would we be losing, which is what you were speaking about earlier, Michelle, too. I think it's important to have that understanding and that visual.
I hear you, though, Colin, on not wanting to create anxiety or more work for anyone, but I think in terms of communications and being able to explain to people what we're considering, I think having an amount that I think a number of our community members would like to see,
no more than 5%, I'd like to be able to explain to them what that would look like. Okay. So I think we all know our homework for the next two weeks to sort of ponder this, and we will revisit it two weeks from today, on the 18th, when we meet.
and you know this is this is in no way binding to what we decide in the spring right we are just trying to provide some direction um and i would you know i would encourage you to last year felt different in the terms of we hadn't really been at a position where we were cutting any amount
amount of positions that we otherwise would have right like we have moved positions around in the past like hey we don't need this we can move this here and i would encourage you to be thinking that way continue thinking that way and I know our administrators are used to that process of you
know really being thoughtful into what do you need like what can you deliver and you know I would last year felt different because we knew there were going to have to be cuts because 10 percent as a baseline plus all the other things right I think I don't know if anybody maybe maybe some
folks felt like we could have put that out and got it passed but it just didn't feel like that was the right thing to do so you had to get to somewhere so you needed to know how much to cut i would encourage you to bring to us what you think you need to run this district well
right and then and then be aware that there might have to be movements either way i guess just i i respectfully disagree on the like because what we were doing last year was in direct was in direct response both to having a beautiful new superintendent but was in direct response to the
like, the, um, whatever I, the word I would use after 10 o'clock that happened the year before, because some individual or group of individuals that was not this board decided that we needed to have, like, a 5.5% budget increase that came from nowhere, that it came
from a sort of vague understanding of, like, what the sort of, like, the community could absorbed but we but this board never told anyone did not tell the superintendent to aim for that so it did include cuts it included cuts that were not that were and we kept asking over and over and
again how are these cuts in service of the education of of young people and to be blunt the former superintendent could not answer that question and that's why we had such a difficult year so i just want to be i want like it is it is absolutely different like all three years are
very different but last year was not the first year that we have been faced with a question of cuts it was the year before that where it was handled very poorly yeah i mean i guess the yeah we can debate that on another day but um yeah i i will concede that that that's very true that that
is that was the impetus for for last year's because we felt like the previous year went so poorly as a budget process to give Tom the best chance of success, which I think you had last spring. So everyone knows their goal is to come back in two weeks with sort of a, so you want a number? That's what you're asking for? That would be the most helpful. Alright.
We still have no one in the audience for public comment. I mean, they're wonderful for people, but I don't think they're going to talk in public comment. So I would take a motion to adjourn. Valerie? Steph? All those in favor? Well done, guys.
Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.
