TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 14 May 2025
Board meeting · 32 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →
3,060 words in 5 five-minute windows.
Good evening. Welcome to the RSU 5 Board of Directors meeting. It is Wednesday, May 14th, 2025. We are here at the Durham Community School Gymnasium. And we have a full board with the exception of Daniel will be joining us shortly. But we'll get started in the meantime
with the pledge. Okay. Kind of agenda I like. We don't have any minutes, so we will move on to item 5 adjustment I have one this evening under 14 personnel letter C we're going to remove that for this evening okay so we will move we don't have good
news and recognition this evening we'll move right on to public comment we ask if folks are looking to speak we ask you to come to the microphone give us your name where you live and comments limited to three minutes please my name is
Stacy Alvarez I live in South Portland Maine and I'm a teacher at Freeport Middle School and good evening I'm speaking tonight on behalf of the Freeport Middle School staff many of whom are here with me we understand that
a decision has been made regarding the next principal and as implied in the board chair's recent email it will not be revisited however we want to express our deep disappointment that our voices were not meaningfully included in the
process after the abrupt departure of our former principal the interim principal stepped in and rebuilt the trust stability and student-centered culture that our school so urgently needed she knows our school inside and out and she has strong ties to our students families and the broader
community we believe her leadership speaks for itself and we ask why aren't we investing in and mentoring the talented professionals we already have rather than consistently looking outside our district we respectfully urge the
board to review how the candidate selection process was designed and implemented and to consider whether it truly reflected the unique circumstances and needs of our school thank you thank you Stacey no podium so if I'm shaking
you won't see it. Okay, I'm Sarah Davis. I live in Auburn, Maine, and I teach at Freeport Middle School. I wrote something because otherwise I would get too emotional. I stand here in solidarity with my fellow colleagues. We are a close-knit school community and are passionate about teaching
and supporting our middle school students. We have had a tough year at FMS. Our new principal left us mid-year with no explanation. In the interim, one of our colleagues stepped in to take their place. Finally, we all felt some sense of order and stability.
We felt supported. So I am confused by the decision to pass over the highly qualified internal candidate who applied for the principal position in favor of another relative stranger to the person accepting that position tonight.
We are not here to express our displeasure with you as a candidate. I was not part of the hiring committee and therefore do not know what your strengths are, and I am sure you have many. we will be professional and kind and we will welcome you into our FMS community
but were I in your position I would want to know what the atmosphere in my future workplace is likely to be and how unhappy we all are to be losing a dear very talented colleague and member of our community thank you thank you sir just
give you guys a second okay so we will move on to we don't have items 8 through 13 on the agenda this evening so we will move on to personnel do I have a motion for consideration and approval to employ a principal at the Freeport Middle School for the 2025 2026 school year Beth Emily thank you okay I'd like
to start by just talking about process that was followed the we actually we advertise this position on Friday March 21st and on March 31st the screening interview team members were selected and on that committee there were it was chaired by assistant superintendent Cynthia Alexander we had
two building principals a school board member two educators from FMS and two parents slash community members on April 11th the application closed and then that screening interview team began their process which included confidentiality strength training screening applications reviewing
interview questions there were two rounds of interviews for candidates we had a pool of 15 total and six folks were interviewed for this position once the interview interviews were all conducted there were two candidates that went forward to be have received interviews from the board chair and myself and then one of those candidates is here at this evening for your
consideration the candidate this evening that we're we're bringing forward is Pamela Crosby Pamela has a bachelor's in elementary education for the University of Maine at Farmington she receives and she also received a master's in education from st. Joseph's College she holds both k-8 elementary
education certification as well as pre k-12 building administration certification her professional experience she's been an eighth grade teacher in math at Lake region high school and also an eighth grade teacher for science and math at Sanford junior high school she's had two years as an
assistant principal and at Sanford middle school and for the past 10 years she has hold the role of principal at that school references describe Pam as as having clear and respectful communication she's responsive she implements plans from start to finish she's approachable proactive a deep
thinker has a gift for working with all students she creates an amazing climate and culture where everyone feels part of the school community she's well respected by families and she's appreciated by her staff because of her
values okay just a quick reminder kind of a addendum to the process piece what the board's role here is in hiring so we authorize the superintendent to make all hires but for administrators and and for teachers those come before the board
for for basically to authorize her to do so so our choices are to approve or or decline the candidate that is in front of us today it is it is not in the board's purview to direct a different person be chosen if even if that were
the the preference of the board right so I just wanted to clarify that because there was it some of the emails may have have caused a little confusion on that front and what the what the board's role is our only direct hire is the
superintendent and the superintendent then hires all the folks below below that role so just wanted to clarify if there were any other questions on process we're happy to take that we do have hate that we're all in a straight
line at this meeting I'm sorry Cheyenne I can barely see you down there so we have a motion and a second do you have a question so the process that we used to find this candidate is the process that we go through every single time we we
send a email out to people asking if they would like to be part of the committee yes that work as far as selecting people on the committee so it may vary in size in terms of like we're currently in the process of choosing the
selection committee for the the superintendent search so that one will likely be larger because it's we have people from all three towns you know it'll be a larger committee than that but I would say for a principalship I
think that's probably the same the same makeup that we had in in private in previous principal searches yeah so there was nothing changed about the process and the way that we you know we opened it up to people that were interested in being part of the process correct okay thank you Maura thank you
Jean thank you Michelle and thank you to the teachers and everyone that we heard from it definitely appreciate hearing from folks and I did just want to ask with regard to the process it seems like there's some rumors going around about
the process that and I don't know because of certain aspects of the confidentiality of it if you can speak more to that superintendent scrappa if you can describe that in more detail I personally don't have any questions I
was I was the board member on the committee and I was involved in the process and I felt it was all handled very above board and consistent with how we do our hiring and have hired other candidates but I am concerned that other
folks may have some misinformation so I don't and I don't know again because the confidentiality of certain aspects of the process if we can share more but I just did want to bring that up in case we can I think what I can share with the
board is it was a fair process and it was fought it was followed the way we've followed processes in the in the past and by policy was followed correctly I have a question is I'm new to the board so when the committee is formed is it
available to all community members all parents all faculty all board members yes so it very similar to how the superintendent email went out whenever there is a administrative role in the district Jimmy will send out something
to everyone that's in the database that has given us their email and sought out volunteers and then can we talk about what the selection process of the committee looks like are we allowed to discuss that I am I don't know what I don't know what that
one looked like I think it varies depending on which one it is so I don't know if that was so and I will say they were not there was not a huge pool of people who wanted to participate in this particular search and so Cynthia and I
sat down to make sure that there was slots you know everything that we for folks that with those slots we said we wanted to to fill that they were all filled and they were but there weren't there were not tons of people there were a few people that were turned away but not a lot of people turned away okay
since I don't see if you are waving down there wave big and high but I don't think I see any other hands up for questions so we have a motion and oh he literally waited for me to look left he did I was just I was thinking yeah I
just want to echo the appreciation to the staff members and teachers who who shared their views with us and also thank you to the committee that was that was tasked with this and I've sure I didn't serve on this committee after I served on the superintendent hiring committee so I know that process and I
also know the the various levels of confidentiality that exist in that process I think one of the things that it's not it's more of something for us to return to but I think now would be a moment to flag it is I think this
question of this question of mentorship within the within the district and within the administration is one that we, um, we have heard, or at least during my tenure of four years, um, I have heard that is something that is, um, that is highly valued by, um,
the staff and by, uh, by the, by the teaching staff and by the administrators, um, and I have also just heard that raised as sort of one of the questions in, in this process is, um, what is the mentorship process like, uh, and how does that then relate to the question
of hiring? Um, and I think that, um, I will admit I had, I had never thought about those two things exactly in that, um, in that combination before, um, but I think it is something, um, that I would like, um, the board to consider how, how we can, um, think about that, how
we can communicate that to our superintendent who we will hire and then how that superintendent will be communicating that to the district in terms of what the understanding is around that and what the possibilities are around that because I think that is a really important thing we've heard that
before and I just think it's really important that we return to it I just wanted to again express how much everyone's and I appreciate everyone's involvement in this process and I know this has been a very difficult year for
the staff at Freeport middle school and I this is not a decision that I think any of us takes lightly and I know we have a very qualified candidate before us who I'm very hopeful will make a big difference in our school district and
I deeply appreciate all of you and your hard work and all the sentiments that you shared with us and I know that they were heartfelt and I I really hope moving forward that things will will be better and I wish that you know every
vote that I make on this board could make everyone happy but I know that it can't but I just want you to know how much all of you all of you are valued and how much we appreciate you and thank you for all you do thank you Maura
always give people the seven seconds thank you it's my seven seconds I think the only thing that I feel like should be stated publicly because it is something that I would admit that it was only something that really I understood
about the board's role about a year and a half or two years into my my time with the board is that we are not allowed to hear concerns about staffing issues during the year and if there is something that is the superintendent is
handling at a leadership level we are legally not allowed to be told that information because it would be a violation of that individual's privacy and that that is a was a difficult thing for me to realize to sort of come to an
understanding on and I will imagine there will be time could be times in the future where that will also be frustrating individually as a as a board member but I also after thinking it through obviously maybe not obviously I
do understand the the importance of that and how essential that is for respecting the the privacy of the of all of the employees at the school and and and also just that that does yes that does place that does really affirm how
much trust we place in the superintendent and how much we trust we have to place in that process and I just thought that that was an important thing that again is perhaps not sort of publicly sort of commonly known about
the process but I just thought that might be helpful for folks to know one last glance Collins way six and a half okay okay we have a motion and a second on the floor all those in favor opposed thank you welcome Pam very much are she
five and wow in a great way um to sit here and see how many staff members showed up from freeport middle school to show your allegiance and loyalty to a staff member is really heartfelt to me um i understand where you guys are coming from i'm sitting here and i'm listening
i can assure you i am going to do my best job to be a part of your team to work to collaborate to help the climate of culture bring stability and work with you and hear you and what freeport middle school needs I love kids I love education and I'm really looking forward
to this opportunity I've already gained so much respect sitting here listening to this crowd show up and listening to you I'm not going to disappoint you all I'm very much looking forward to becoming a part of your team thank you very much thank you Pam okay 14 B do I have a motion for consideration and
approval to employ a librarian at the Moore Street School panel elementary School for the 2025-2026 school year, one year only. Cheyenne and Kelly, thank you. And I bring before you this evening Emma Egan. Emma is a Freeport High School graduate. She has a bachelor's in
environmental science with a minor in education from Bates College. She has a master's in library and information science from Syracuse University. She has conditional certification as a library media specialists her professional experience she's been a teacher in at
the Brooklyn Waldorf School in New York she's been an associate librarian at Nightingale Bamford School in New York and an ESOL teacher and educational consultant and she did some remote work with that references describe Emma as
reliable patient creative creating thoughtful and engaging lessons she learns quickly incorporates feedback she's innovative works well with kids of all ages she's a supportive colleague approachable and a skilled librarian
thank you can you remind us what a one-year only position means we have a staff member who's out on leave for a year so so Emma will be filling that position thank you all right we have a motion and a second on the floor any
comments questions others in favor greats then opposed so we're back to public comment if we had anyone who one more one more opportunity for public comment we just same rules apply up to the mic three minutes all right then I
would take a motion to adjourn Laura and Beth don't worry we're not leaving for the night we just closed this meeting and we'll reopen the annual budget meeting in 20 minutes oh yeah we should vote sorry all those in favor
Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.
