RSU 5 Board of DirectorsWednesday 14 May 2025
Board meeting · 32 min · Watch on YouTube →
The summary is written by AI from a computer-made transcript, and it can be wrong. Each time links to that moment in the recording, so you can check it. A (?) after a name means the transcript does not make clear who was speaking.
Short board meeting held at the Durham Community School gymnasium before the annual budget meeting. Public comment came from two Freeport Middle School teachers objecting to the selection of an outside candidate for FMS principal over an internal candidate, and asking the board to review how the selection process was designed. Superintendent Scrappa (?) described the hiring process and presented Pamela Crosby for the FMS principalship; the board chair clarified that the board's role is to approve or decline the superintendent's candidate, not to direct a different choice. The board took up two personnel items: principal at Freeport Middle School and a one-year librarian at Pownal Elementary (Mabel I. Wilson/Moore Street as said). One personnel item, 14C, was removed from the agenda. The meeting adjourned so the annual budget meeting could reopen 20 minutes later.
What was decided
- 14:10Motion for consideration and approval to employ a principal at Freeport Middle School for 2025-2026 (Pamela Crosby), moved and seconded by Beth (?) and Emily (?)outcome unclear
- 29:34Motion for consideration and approval to employ a librarian at the Pownal elementary school for 2025-2026, one year only (Emma Egan), moved and seconded by Cheyenne (?) and Kelly (?)outcome unclear
- 29:34Motion to adjournoutcome unclear
- 8:54Agenda adjustment removing item 14C under personnel from the evening's agendaoutcome unclear
Votes on this board are weighted. Each director's vote counts in proportion to the population of the town they represent, so this page says only whether a motion passed, not how many voted for it. "Outcome unclear" means the recording does not state the result plainly. The software that turns speech into text can drop a "not".
Worth knowing
- 14:10The principal search drew 15 applicants, six of whom were interviewed in two rounds; two finalists were interviewed by the board chair and superintendent.
- 19:13The chair stated the board may only approve or decline the superintendent's candidate and cannot direct that a different person be hired; the superintendent is the board's only direct hire.
- 19:13The superintendent said there was not a large pool of volunteers for the screening committee and that a few people were turned away, but not many.
- 24:19A board member said the board is legally barred from being told about individual staffing matters being handled by the superintendent, for privacy reasons.
What was discussed, in order
- 8:54Call to order and agenda adjustment
The chair opened the meeting of May 14, 2025 at the Durham Community School gymnasium, noting a full board except for Daniel, who would join shortly. Item 14C under personnel was removed for the evening. There were no minutes and no good news and recognition items.
- 8:54Public comment from Freeport Middle School staff
Stacy Alvarez of South Portland, a Freeport Middle School teacher, spoke on behalf of FMS staff expressing disappointment that staff voices were not meaningfully included in the principal selection and asking the board to review how the process was designed. Sarah Davis of Auburn, also an FMS teacher, said the internal interim candidate had rebuilt stability after the previous principal left mid-year and said staff would welcome the new principal professionally.
- 14:10Personnel: Freeport Middle School principal
The superintendent described the timeline: position advertised March 21, screening team selected March 31, applications closed April 11, a pool of 15 with six interviewed over two rounds, and two finalists interviewed by the board chair and superintendent. The committee was chaired by Assistant Superintendent Cynthia Alexander and included two building principals, a school board member, two FMS educators and two parent/community members. Pamela Crosby was presented, with degrees from the University of Maine at Farmington and St. Joseph's College and ten years as principal at Sanford Middle School.
- 14:10Board role and questions on the hiring process
The chair explained the board authorizes the superintendent to hire and may only approve or decline the candidate before it, not direct a different choice; the superintendent is the board's only direct hire. Board members asked whether the committee process and the way volunteers are solicited differed from past searches, and were told it did not. The superintendent said the process was fair and followed policy, and that few volunteers came forward for this particular search.
- 24:19Board comments on mentorship and confidentiality
One member asked the board to return to the question of mentoring and developing internal staff and how that relates to hiring, and to communicate that to the next superintendent. Another member said the board is legally not allowed to be told about individual staffing matters handled at the leadership level, which places considerable trust in the superintendent.
- 29:34Remarks by the incoming principal
Pamela Crosby thanked the FMS staff who attended, said she understood their position, and committed to collaborating, hearing staff and bringing stability to the school.
- 29:34Personnel: librarian, Pownal elementary school, one year only
Emma Egan was presented as librarian for 2025-2026, one year only. She is a Freeport High School graduate with a bachelor's from Bates College and a master's in library and information science from Syracuse University, with conditional certification as a library media specialist. The one-year term covers a staff member out on leave for a year.
- 29:34Second public comment and adjournment
The chair reopened public comment; no one spoke. A motion to adjourn was made by Laura (?) and Beth (?), with the annual budget meeting to reopen in 20 minutes.
Financial reports for the period ending 30 April 2025
These are the district's most recent monthly reports dated at least two weeks before this meeting. They show each account's budget and what had been spent by 30 April 2025.
Every month's financial reports →
Elsewhere
Source & method
Regional School Unit 5: board meeting recordings on YouTube, and the agendas and minutes on rsu5.org
Each recording is turned into text by speech-recognition software and summarised by an AI language model. Every money item in a summary must quote words the speaker said, with the amount, and links to that moment in the recording. Agendas and minutes are the district's own files.
https://www.rsu5.org/board-of-directors-and-policies/board-agendas-and-minutes
Data as of 4 November 2026 (the date of the newest meeting listed); retrieved 19 November 2026.
