TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 5 November 2025
Board meeting · 2 h 30 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →
24,363 words in 29 five-minute windows.
for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay, before we jump into the agenda items, we do have a few new members joining us this evening, and some returning members. So, we'll go through those real quick. So, Valerie and Kelly and Anna, who is not here this evening, were all reelected yesterday.
Congratulations. And Karen is our newest board member. Welcome. Congratulations to you as well. And then we also have our new student rep, Maria Abadamarko. So welcome to you, Maria. All right. So I would take a motion for consideration and approval of the minutes from the October 22nd meeting as presented by any errors or omissions.
Thank you, Valerie and Malik. All those in favor? Great. None opposed. Adjustments to the agenda? None. Wonderful. So we will move on to good news and recognition. We're going to throw Maria right in and throw it over to you.
All right, so is my mic on? Okay, just wanted to check. All right, so the updates are we have a field trip on November 18th to St. Joseph's College. This field trip is for people that are interested in business, finance, and accounting.
The other update is that we have Maine Medical Mentor Workshop on November 5th during the school day. It is from 9.05 to 10.30. This will be answering questions about the medical field as well as the schooling for that. For our Performing Arts Department, we have Something Rotten available to see.
We saw the preview during advisory. It was really good, very funny. Recommend seeing it. The showings are Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. Students and their mentees went trick-or-treating around the school. And congratulations to the ELA Department for winning Best Costume.
And all our advisories have participated in anti-bullying activities the month of October. And some good recognition to the chorus and band students that have qualified for District 3 Honors Music Festival. This will be hosted in January. Me and Moon will be sharing information about the pressing issues at Freeport High School with the board,
such as the cell phone policy, bullying culture of respect and belonging, addressing incidents of hate speech and bullying, working with food services to make the cafeteria greener, and supporting transitions from middle school to high school and other topics.
it's a lot going on thank you and right now it was supposed to be the regional finals for the field hockey team they were supposed to be starting well i guess not quite yet 7 30 but that got postponed due to weather so and also congratulations to the girls cross-country team
that won state championship this weekend so wonderful things going on all over the place and i'm looking forward to the play so this friday saturday sunday right wonderful great thank you for that all right so we will move on to public comments uh if we have folks that are
looking to speak we ask you to come up to the microphone give us the name your town uh and three minutes on the clock well for the the new people on the board and student reps my name is annie ware and i'm representing the rsu 5 alliance for thoughtful technology we're an organization
that started about a year and a half ago kind of brought forth by the book the anxious generation which talks about cell phones, not just in our kids' lives, but all of our lives and how we use them. And that is sort of morphed into just technology in general. And we use the word
thoughtful technology. I know it's a lot to say, but we use the word thoughtful technology because we don't want to be seen as anti-technology, but just we bring technology into our kids' lives with purpose that's data-driven and supported with evidence. So I'm responding to the last
meeting. I don't know where you guys are at in the intervening four weeks, if you guys have had conversations and talked with one another, done your own due diligence, but what I'm about to say comes from my response to that. And so I appreciated the superintendent at the very end
of the meeting talking about the addictive quality of these things for all of us. And so we have to ask ourselves, are smartphones addictive? Do they impact student achievement? Do they impact student mental health. If you answered yes to just one of them, we need to change what we're doing. It's
wrong, and our standard of care is better than that. All right, so having said that, we also need to act swiftly. The MSMA, I think the study is going to come out this coming week, but they put out a survey to all districts in Maine. 70 responded. Close to 90 percent of them are already
either enacting an all-day ban or they're working towards it, and they're starting the policy process. So where we're at, we're a little bit behind the eight ball compared to what's happening in our state. I want to respond to a comment made last meeting. I think it was from the student rep
who basically said, a lot of us are able to manage our phones. So why are you punishing us? And I really strongly encourage the board not to look at this as punishment, but rather we are looking at our students' well-being, right? We don't take cigarettes away from kids because we're punishing
them. It's in their well-being that they don't have them. But what if I can manage mine? I don't need to take it out when other kids do. And I give you this quick analogy of a friend of mine whose husband is an alcoholic. She's not. She can have alcohol in her house, right? But he can't. And so
guess what they don't and so I bring that up only is because sometimes we reduce access not because everyone struggles but because if enough people do it's our responsibility as a community to help everyone um at the last meeting the high school I think Jen spoke about strengthening
executive function and nothing roads executive function faster than constant distraction and the dopamine cycle of smartphones. It's just a fact. If we're serious about building skills, these devices have to stay out of these kids' hands the whole day. If we're talking about improving test scores because Maine's taken a huge dive, there's no arguing with that. This can help. This is like tenfold and it helps everybody. I know you're looking at your watch and I'm almost done. So what? Pouches, right? People have talked about them. understand that pouches cost money, right? Our particular group, we can't fundraise and collect
money, but we can help fundraise. We can help you guys fundraise if you need to. I've got to tell you, though, it's a lot of brownies at the bake sale to buy these pouches, right? And I feel like this is the one single thing that can help every single student in our building achieve academic
success, executive function, increased sociability. And I feel that it is in our best interest, our standard of care, that we take on the responsibility that we've been given and help our students. And I think this is the single greatest thing that we can do. And if you talk to any administrator or teacher that is already doing this and has done this, they will tell you
is the most impactful policy that they have implemented in their entire careers. And I believe I'm quoting, that's a direct quote from the principal up at Morse High School. Thank you. Hi, good evening, everyone. My name is Kelly Delaney, and I'm a short, straightforward parent.
I just want to thank you for giving us an opportunity to speak to this topic. I want to offer my full support behind a bell-to-bell ban here at RSU 5. I'm a parent of two high school and one elementary student in the district.
I also attended the last meeting and feel we know so much about the negative impact of phones in school, and I hope this collective moves quickly and decisively to make healthy choices for our youth. Thank you. Just in case someone's around the corner, do we have anyone else for a public comment?
Okay, wonderful. Thank you. All right, so we will move on to item 8 on our agenda report from the superintendent. Good evening, everyone. Before I launch into my formal report, I wanted to respond to a request for information from one of the members of the board, and that's Danielle. You had sent an email asking about vacancies, so I have that information. At the moment, we have
5.5 special ed edtech positions vacant. Three of them are Moore Street School. 1.5 are here at Freeport High School, and one is at Freeport Middle School. We also have 2.5 busstodian positions, or I should say two of them are busstodians, which means
combination of custodian and bus driver, and a 0.5 custodian position open. We also have a few specialist positions that we have had to fill with contracted services people. That includes a teacher of the deaf for five hours a
week, a speech-language pathologist for 30 hours a week, and a one-to-one nurse that a student requires. You're welcome. So now to my report. I want to confine my remarks tonight to three major topics that have been ongoing themes for me. One is early childhood, second is strategic
planning, and then finally the budget. So first about early childhood, last week we had the first meeting of our early childhood task force several board members here were in attendance the focus of that meeting is just was just to help everyone understand the mandate that the state has placed upon us to assume
responsibility for child find and providing free appropriate public education to three to five year olds by July 2028 at the latest it takes a while to just explain what the mandate is and folk not everybody in the room had even a rudimentary understanding of that so we also looked at the strengths
that we already have in place that we can build upon to help meet the need I think the foremost among those is that we have a very strong early intervention team that team consists of an occupational therapist a speech-language
pathologist and an early childhood special educator and these folks screen every pre-k student that comes into the three elementary schools where we have pre-k and they support those students through consultation small groups and
direct services if needed excuse me one of the strengths pursuit pursuant to that also is that all of the children who are already in our pre-k programs are being served by our staff those who have IEPs so that that's a strength to
build upon each of those specialists bring something very essential to the table and we will be continuing to rely on their expertise to help us go forward it just means that we're not starting completely from square one we
have other issues to think about we have to think about when we step into the work and how that can intersect with funding that the state is offering we have to think about how we configure the programs we already have to best meet the need so there's lots of thinking to do but our hope is that by January that
task force will have a really good grasp of the the need that we have and through bringing multiple perspectives to the table we'll be able to offer you some options to choose in terms of how we go forward. My second update is about
strategic planning so as you know we are in the middle of the strategic planning process. We are very close to the end of a major phase of that which is developing a portrait of the graduate, our hope is to have a portrait of a graduate to bring to
you by December to showcase to you. And the portrait of the graduate is really the end point from which we make decisions about action steps that go into the strategic plan. I can also tell you that after we develop that portrait of the graduate based on all kinds of community input,
our next steps are to develop a mission statement and core values and beliefs. So after that, we then get into the finer points of what are the action steps in our plan that will guide us into the future. So that's a rough, broad brushstroke of the work in the months that are ahead.
And finally, the budget. So earlier this fall, I took a new approach to gathering staff input and had listening sessions in all the schools. And I also sent out an individual staff survey to gather their perspectives about budget priorities.
So over the last few weeks, the administrative team has been able to review the data that came in from the staff. We have been digging into that feedback. We've identified themes that emerge. Importantly, we've been able to look at the very significant degree of overlap between themes that emerge in the staff feedback
and themes that emerge when the administrators themselves consider the same budget questions so that's a strength the next step that we have that we're engaged in and we started work on this morning in a meeting is to define
what our district-wide priorities would be that we would shape the budget around we have not finalized that but we we spent a lot of time in discussion about it today examples of what I mean would be things like access to professional
development or reasonable class sizes or making sure that resources for kids with special needs are sufficient etc etc we want to be able to use criteria like that when it gets down to nitty-gritty decisions about the budget to make sure that they are in line and consistent with the priorities that we
all establish as I have mentioned before we will have a special board workshop about the budget at 5 p.m. on November 19th that'll be at Durham Community School this is right before the regularly scheduled board meeting that
will be at 630 also a Durham Community School and at that workshop I will share concrete information about the context of next year's budget and I will ask you for your guidance about where we can go forward so that we all have clarity and purpose in that work. And that's my update for tonight. We have a lot of work ahead, especially
on these three topics that I keep bringing up, but they're big topics and they require a lot of forethought. So thank you for hearing me out. One last thing, not to skip to the next thing on the agenda because that's really Michelle's thing to do, but I just want to point out that we have a
retirement to announce and can i just go ahead yeah yeah so bertha hilton who is the dearly beloved kitchen manager at freeport middle school has announced her retirement at the end of this year and i would like to make sure everybody knows that i have written an article for the forecaster
that features bertha and i just submitted it today and it's already on our website and anyway just i want people to read it because bertha is a gem and she will be missed i already read it it's did you want to do the support staff hire well sure um i generally don't interview when you're
just doing your stuff feel free to i mean i don't want to stay in my lane um we have hired a uh moore street so excuse me moore street school kitchen manager and that is linda duplessis thank you um one question on the strategic plan can you remind us or me if everyone else remembers
when is the next time the board will see like do we do we see sort of that vision statement piece before the action steps start getting worked on to weigh in yes okay yes you will and we had some discussion at the last strategic plan meeting and and other folks who are here at the table were part of that discussion about at what point does the board actually weigh in to shape those I
I think that's an ongoing discussion. With regard to the portrait of the graduate, that piece is really based on all the community feedback, and we want to make sure that the community's role in the process is honored. So at further stages in the process, the board is a more active participant.
Thank you. All right. Any other questions on the superintendent update? All right. We will keep moving. Item nine, administrator reports. We will continue on with our department reviews and goal updates, and we will start with transportation and journey.
Good evening, everyone. The transportation goals for 24-25 last year were disposal of vehicles no longer adequate for inclusion in the fleet. Follow-up procedures outlined in the policy DN, school properties disposition.
We disposed of two buses, a van, and a truck. We developed a timeline for replacement of vehicles based on the evaluation of the fleet. We developed a comprehensive timeline for replacement of all vehicles. I'm in constant collaboration with the director of finance to maintain fleet replacement times.
Increase recruitment and retention of drivers. Attend job fairs, district hiring fairs, recruit new drivers. Collaborate with human resources, human resource coordinator to strategize advertisement methods. We added, district canceled the summer job fair, but we did advertise and hired a new driver.
The 25-26 goals is expansion of safety, training, and activities. Develop a new safety and training schedule for all transportation staff. Develop a system for fleet maintenance. Update a plan for recording the maintenance and repairs of the fleet.
Exploration of the most effective way to schedule van, bus usage for extra clerker activities. Field trip requests, research and explore pros and cons of different methods of scheduling to meet the demands of van and bus usage.
Thank you, Jeremy, for your update. I was wondering, have we had to cancel any of that, like not be able to provide? I didn't think so. We have not. That's a goal of mine also, is not to cancel anything. Roots or extra credit? I know you do a very good job at that, so thank you. Jeremy has done a fantastic job managing about a jillion things, so you have a lot of gratitude
from me. Thank you. It's a juggling act. I was curious about, I feel like we had heard about there was a state program that we could use to help with the rooting and that kind of stuff that that didn't cost the district anything did we i feel like this was probably last year that i
remember that did we end up using that or did it not be we used a little bit of a traverser oh right yep it ended up pretty being pretty vague and we ended up just going with our own okay way we did it last time and as far as i know first day of school went off with a bang
we didn't have any phone calls and we've been fine there were no kindergarten parents looking for their kids so it's always a win on the first day of school extremely big win and so two custodians are in the current openings is that is that i mean that feels like that's pretty good
for where we have been right it is okay we're down three drivers though in each town we've combined so oh we're good i mean this was a while ago but yeah uh and then the the summer job fair that we canceled was was was it scheduling or did we not think that we were gonna I'm not actually sure on
that I think it just became largely all of our teaching staff positions were open and last year when we had because we we had said it in July at our admin retreat the year before and then we and then that August we actually had a hiring fair and we had like two people show up to it and so we
We didn't actually, like, proceed with it. We didn't see that there was that much of a demand for it at that time. And it wasn't specific to drivers. It was all of our openings was the... Correct. Was the fair. Okay. Correct. Thank you. And we were largely just down to drivers and the edtech positions that are still open now.
Yep. Okay. Excuse me. Do you know how we're doing comparing with other districts? I mean, I know this is a problem for everybody, but I'm just kind of curious if we know what other people are doing to try to solve this problem and if it's something we can pursue also
we are doing well as far as what i'm hearing from canceling routes and trips in other districts we're advertising daily facebook all over the place trying to get drivers to come we're trying but as i said i think we're doing well compared to other districts other questions for johnny
thank you thank you have a good night all right so next up is uh glenn reynolds and our update on facilities evening everyone i think i'm gonna lower this down just a little bit so the facility goals for 24 and 25 the school goal is to ensure for both constant is to ensure all facilities are
operating efficiently and effectively we developed an articulate articulated capital improvement plan that includes items identified through the energy audit and a comprehensive building assessment. Develop a strategic plan outlined through financial investment and infrastructure and physical assets.
We also developed an articulated plan for vehicle and equipment replacement. We developed a strategy for systematically replacing assets based on objective criteria, not just when they fail. By determining the optimum time to retire a piece of asset or replace an asset by reducing operational risk, minimizing cost, and maximizing asset performance.
So for the facility goals for 25-26 are a continuation of the development of an articulated capital improvement plan that includes items from the energy audit and comprehensive building assessment. So as we continue along and we move through the potential phases, two, three, and four, as things come up, things fail, we'll continue to juggle things around to address those issues.
Same thing with the vehicle replacement and equipment replacement. If things fail, we'll move things around to replace those as well. Also, we're looking at doing a facility assessment for early childhood transition. So what we're looking at is putting a proposal together to bring a third-party group to come in to assess our buildings facility-wise.
They'll come in, take a look at the entire building, look at the HVAC, they'll look at the playground to make sure that we meet the needs for the early childhood development. And also building mapping. Now I'm going to wait for Michelle to ask me, what is building mapping?
So, building mapping is a process of creating detailed and accurate digital representation of a building physical space features and surrounding context using various data collection technologies. So, this process serves two primary applications, construction and facility management and architectural projection displays.
So, this will also assist us in the facility assessment part where we're looking at overall buildings. But this also can be an asset to our first responders because they can also have access to this. So given at any time there's, whatever the incident may be, they'll have access to our layout, say here at the high school, be able to pull up that map and be able to put an articulate plan together depending on what that needs is. So it serves as a multi-use for our facilities.
That's our goals. So I want to start, and this is really for all three of you, glenn kelly and jeremy um the the the huge step forward that i think this district took last year through that phased approach of both the vehicle replacement and the building plans and you know
the how we're gonna how we're gonna get all of these updates um both sustainability as well as life safety um that was a huge lift and it was something that um i think the three of you did an absolutely incredible job um not only figuring out what needs to be done but being able to put
it in a plan that the board could first understand and to get behind so um huge thanks to all of you guys for that um i think it was um in terms of facilities and transportation goals over the last several years i think that just knocked it out of the park like we haven't seen progress like that
in forever so really really well done um and so i'm going to ask another question about building mapping absolutely you knew i would i do um so is that like is that software or it is okay it's it's a group coming in taking a complete at a look at our at our buildings uh putting that uh collecting
all that data putting it into a software program so then you can look at a three-dimensional of our buildings, bird's eye view if you want it, or what have you. And it'll show the detail, HVAC classrooms, or what have you. So it'll give us a ton of data we can use that for pretty much
whatever we need to use it for. Okay. And then the early childhood transition, so that's different than the DOE coming in and doing an assessment of our space? When the DOE came in, they looked specifically at the rooms where we have pre-K right now, and they looked a lot at the equipment
in those rooms to try to determine what they could give us if we joined cohort three. They did not so much look at long-term, what if we added this, what if we added that, and where it could fit in relation to our entire, every physical plant we have.
So that's more what Glenn's talking about. Correct. And if we were to potentially join one of these cohorts, would they fund such a study? i would not say that they would okay you're kind of leading to my next question can how much does
some of this stuff cost so can you give like a i i don't i don't have that information right yet i'm only in conversations with them we need to schedule the time to have them come in and lay out a plan or what it would cut and i'm sure there's different levels if you just want the
bird's eye view or if you want the the cadillac what have you once i get that information i'll certainly continue to share that one of the points that we may want to consider this was something that was raised in our admin discussion today about the budget one of the themes that we are
going to continue to work on in presenting a budget to you is long an eye toward long-term sustainability versus just short-term getting through this next year and toward that end we should be looking at the needs that we will have going out a number of years and the facilities
that we have and how we can configure things in the most cost-effective way and the way that actually meets student needs the best and to do that we really need a good starting place a really comprehensive understanding of our facilities and how that intersects with student
learning the cost that we spend per student on different facilities etc etc so a study like that is something that can be useful in many dimensions are three and four together the early assessment are they are they using this mapping thing to try and find space for initially no so when i talk
with tom about it they were separate items but because of you know looking into them they can be use together so and i think they fit perfectly just what tom was talking about the long-term plan this will give us an opportunity to be able to look at from a bird's eye view at the high
school how can we use that better along with the outside or the third party coming in to tell us what options that we may or may not have but i so i think they flow very well together other questions for glenn you could let me off easy but okay thank you very much
Thank you, Glenn. We're sending all our questions for Emily. Nice landing school. Good evening. I was thinking about being here a year ago, and I had shared that we were working on chronic absenteeism and working really hard to have our students in the building as much as possible, and I think that number this time last year was 6.3, and that felt amazing.
So you can imagine our excitement at the end of the year when we landed at 3.65 percent for chronic absenteeism. This number means so much to us as a whole school community, in part because I think it is really reflective of our community
as a whole, every single adult who interacts with kids. We got an email maybe two weeks ago from the executive director of Count Me In, which is a prominent organization in Maine that partners with schools that experience chronic absenteeism and she had actually gone through the state
dashboard to identify the schools that had demonstrated the greatest improvements and reached out to us just to personally say nice work and can I pick your brain on what you're doing and so Scott Emery our assistant principal and I got on the phone with her last week and she just
underscored what I believe which is fundamentally if you're going to solve the issue of chronic absenteeism if you're working to get kids in the building every day school has to be a place kids want to be and a place of connection and belonging you can't um put you can't just problem solve it
on the back end when kids aren't showing up in other words you can't just like intervention your way out of this challenge um and that culture and climate's at the foundation of having students who come to school and so um when i share that number it really reflects the work our teachers
have done the work we've done as a system thinking about really critical parts of the development of 8, 9, 10, and 11-year-olds, things like Daily Mile, things like building kids' ability to social problem solve, which we know is just, like, at the heart of that age group that
there are social problems that come up, starting our day with morning meeting, having choice embedded in academics, having strong relationships. Last year, we started third and fifth grade buddies, which has been, like, a great point of connection for kids. And so when you see that number, it really is a reflection of all of those pieces we've
done at tier one for all kids we also did a lot last year to support those families and students who are struggling with daily attendance as well and Scott Emory our assistant principal was just instrumental in ensuring we could be consistent so for example any student who was on our watch list based on our
attendance team if that student isn't there they get a call the family gets a call that morning from typically Scott personally if not me our school nurse so families know, like we notice when your kids aren't here, when kids come back, they're seen
and welcomed back. When families need additional support, we're having those meetings, which Scott is facilitating to put in specific plans when students need it. And also really working to ensure classroom communities are positive places. And that means when kids are having a tricky time
that we have staff who are available to support them and follow up, both to help skill build for the child who's having a challenging time who might be dysregulated or making a choice that's interfering with the learning of other kids so we're working on that skill building piece as you
have seen through our goal present goal sheet with some of the work at the RTIB level but also that work is critical to creating a great learning environment for all kids independent of whether they need that targeted support or not so last year really was the pieces we were working on
we're really interconnected. Chronic absenteeism, RTIB, but those pieces support one another because we know when school and classrooms are a positive place, then kids are there. So we're really excited and proud of the work that was done last year. And as you'll see in our goals for the year ahead,
the hope is to sustain that work. Those numbers are the lowest, I mean, they're below pre-pandemic levels um even years ago when it wasn't even an area of focus typically numbers were between five and seven percent so we were thrilled to see something below five i pulled the data last night
we were we're at 6.05 percent um as of last night um which still puts us below where we were this year last time um this time of year it's like if you have a student who took a one-week vacation they're chronically absent because we've only been in school for 46 days so um we're going to
continue doing the work we did last year as well as we made some small refinements to our attendance process and the way we progress monitor students attendance and proactively and responsibly communicate with families and those were reflections that came at the end of last year and so those are some changes that are being implemented this year as well. Another piece
of continued work is the RTIB supports that we've been refining over the last year and two months So we have an RTIB EdTech, as well as a classroom that we call the SAIL classroom, and it's really a self-regulation space for students.
So students access it for a variety of reasons. We have students who have planned breaks in that space, might receive reinforcement, so they might earn time with a trusted adult. They also might access that space in unplanned times if something's difficult.
Students have specific tools they access in that space, and it's really about skill building. So learning to use those self-regulation strategies so when they encounter challenge, which is inevitable, that they will have those tools.
And Scott Emery partners closely with our EdTech to support that space. And the creation of that space, which was really built off the model, the Bridges model in Durham, has been a very positive shift. Whereas we have an ed tech position for many years, having a defined space for it allows it to be much more predictable for students and consistent for students when students need that support.
And then obviously the goal is to get those kids regulated and back into classrooms so they can fully access their learning as well. You'll see the third piece of work that we're deeply focused on this year is related to the teaching of reading.
So at the 3-5 grade span in the district, we've adopted revised units. They're similar in many ways to the existing reading units that we had in place with some revisions in response to feedback as well as research on the teaching of reading.
And so there are some new components, for example, a vocabulary component and at the third grade, a phonics and morphology component. and that is really an outgrowth of changes that were implemented at the K-2 span over the past
several years. What we were really excited to see this fall, which I didn't anticipate actually when we drafted the goals, is our third graders this year are the first cohort that had those refinements K-1-2 and their data is as strong as any data set that I've seen in the district in my 12 years in
the district that those changes that have been implemented k-1-2 clearly are impacting student learning and then those third grade revisions build upon those so for example the first two phonics units of this year are some
review of second grade phonics and then it transitions into things like prefixes and suffixes and that's what all students will get in addition to the implementation of those new units what we're really trying to do is not not focus on it as a curriculum adoption as much as an opportunity to deepen our
practices and knowledge of how you teach reading effectively and so we've been using some of our professional learning time to dig into what does it look like to teach reading at the three through five span well for example on the October 10th PLD because all students right now are launching informational
units we did some collective learning around what is strong informational reading look like how do we use text sets to support that how do you build background knowledge so students essentially have have something to kind of velcro their reading to and all these
elements that support strong reading at the 3-5 span the other thing we're doing is linking that strongly to standards and that was feedback we got actually from teachers last year is this desire to more deeply understand the standards at their grade span so when they're teaching a unit they're
not thinking just about what is this unit teaching, but what are the key priorities and goals we want students to have at the end of the school year. So that will be a big focus for our professional learning for the year. You'll also see that one of the ways we decided as a school,
in addition to the metrics, the benchmark assessment system, as well as the NWA that we have to assess progress, is also doing a reading inventory of our students. Kind of the question we grappled with is like, what is important to us to know about our readers in addition to their
things like fluency and comprehension um and we just feel strongly that our students should have identity as identities as readers and connect with being a reader long term this isn't about being a fourth grade reader but about about being a life reader and so as part of that we just
finalized um the reading survey we'll be giving students and then um last friday on halloween did our first kind of monthly reading celebration which um was the first time we had done it but was one of my favorite ways we spent Halloween which is we did a spooky reading celebration and
students could bring in blankets and we turned off the lights they brought in flashlights we played spooky background music and students read in their blanket forts um as well as read aloud to each other and it was magic um Tracy turned to one of our fifth grade teachers emailed me today
and she's like Emily I just want you to know that my fifth grade class just earned um a reward and they voted to have another reading tent celebration so it I think it you know it speaks both to the work we want to do around reading and having a love of reading but I also think it connects back
when we think of attendance and kids wanting to be at school is thinking about what are the ways we make school a place that speaks to kids that they have a sense of belonging they have a sense of joy that we can wear our jammies and crawl under some tables with some blankets and enjoy
books together, as well as really deepen our skills as practitioners in the practice of reading to support them and their growth. So that's our year ahead questions. Can the board come to the next pajama reading? I can let you know. The onesies, Tom, are really popular right now, like the full
jammy onesies so it's got to be k-pop demon hunters though right roomy questions for emily first i want to say as a parent of an mls student um she's had two fort sessions this year so far very excited we've already been doing it at our house so to have it at school is an extra treat
she too brings three bags now instead of just one on those days um i'm just interested i understand this is mostly really focused what are we doing for math and science anything specific yeah so a couple things and thanks for pointing out that like just because this is what's on a piece of paper there are lots of other things happening so for science last year all grade levels launched
uh the first open sci-ed unit um at mass landing school other schools launched the previous year so other schools are in different places with it and grade levels have the option to do a second this year I think it's to be determined which grade levels choose what what's been really interesting
and to me is powerful about having done something once is what grade levels now are doing is a more kind of thoughtful implementation of that so for example our fifth graders do an eco are doing ecosystems unit right now that's aligned to next gen standards last year they had these like nurse
log kits that actually were mailed so you can imagine like we got literally these boxes that showed up that said live animals and had crickets in them um and this year the teachers have been thoughtful about like what does it look like actually we're adjacent to woods let's go out into the woods and have students do this and observe um the ecosystem over time i happened
to walk down the path the other day when fifth graders were coming up and i was like talk to me what you said and the student was like there was steam and i was like talk to me about like what's hypothesis about this and they're like oh it was spores coming off a mushroom that were blowing in the wind and i dug you know the student to kind of dug down at the log and was finding millipedes
um and students are you know fifth grade other students are growing mold right now and exploring what conditions making hypotheses about the conditions that mold is best going to grow in which is like come visit our classrooms and see our mold spores um so teachers are being
thoughtful about that and creating more interdisciplinary opportunities so for example in third grade, which is wrapping up a weather unit, they did an integration with STEM. And students in STEM then, based on what they had learned about how different cultures build
structures to meet certain functions of different climates, then they in STEM created structures using those properties to look at different variables like wind. So I think that the beauty of being in year two is it gives more, people can kind of envision now and be more thoughtful
about cross-disciplinary opportunities um in math we as you know we're as you may know we're in a district in the process of doing district level curriculum review so we're we've been kind of thoughtful about not necessarily like layering on new elements but using the formative data
that we have to be thoughtful about how we're supporting um math learners as well thank you i just want to say i am always so impressed whenever i hear your reports and i just really appreciate how um holistic and relational your approach always is to basically any problem that
you that you address and you know clearly it worked really well with um the uh absenteeism and i i can see it's also working really well with your curriculum and reading too and i just with my own kids i really appreciated that approach so i know that that is why mass landing
is doing really well because of that relational joyful culture that you're creating in the school so thank you yeah as you're as you're talking through the absentee piece from last year and the results um the incredible results that you attained i mean i don't know there's sort of the
you know the natural rate of unemployment in the world right like it never goes below a certain percent like 3.65 seems really low right yeah if we're not like in clarity we are not trying to get low like there are students for unique certain students with complex medical needs like right
the goal is not zero yeah okay but I mean that number is just impressive I mean I love to see the the time the the trend um and from 17.62 to 3.65 and in three years is is pretty uh pretty incredible. And one of the things you mentioned that kind of resonated with me was like making it
a joyful place to be and not just dealing with what do we do when they don't show up. And the other piece that jumped out to me was 16 opportunities for parents and caregivers to attend parenting groups. To me, I don't know, I'm going to hypothesize that those types of
connections that you're not only building with the kids, but with the parents, I think those all add to the to the success of the mass landing school and i just wanted to say thank you thanks and i think it is it thank you for pointing out that it's multi-year work is that this work
like meaningful work is multi-year work right and it's all of these you know somebody said like what's the piece it's like there it's it isn't a piece it's the collection of those pieces and having the space and the time right to look to kind of like fine-tune each of those pieces
um because of the collective whole yeah it also sounds like it was a really good investment to hire an assistant principal to help with that part as well yeah i think i think what scott and that role have really provided um at the very foundation is consistency on so many levels right
consistency you know last year we had a student who every day i was coming in he'd have a check box in scott's office and if he came to school all week he played basketball with scott on friday right and the student would come in and like high five and mark the checkbox so it's like
consistency at that level it's consistency for teachers that know if a student is having a challenge that somebody is able to respond I can't tell you the number of times this week I've been in meetings where my radio has gone off and I knew that somebody was able to go
support it right so it means like when parents come in and meet with me I don't get interrupted in meetings or teachers don't have a student in their classroom who really can't be successful in that moment um and so that ability to respond and that also benefits all kids right so it's like
all of these pieces but having that capacity in the role has enabled a level of consistency that was not possible prior to that i was at a birth to early childhood conference recently and met some folks from the main engagement and attendance center from the doe and shared a little bit about
how well we're doing i know panel's also knocking it out of the park i believe with attendance and they would really love to hear from you and hear what you're doing to be able to share that with other schools yeah we had a team from rsu5 attend a state conference and i think they had everybody
up and they're like stand up you know if your chronic absenteeism is below 40 keep standing that's below 30 keep saying and and amazingly their districts with their chronic absenteeism 40 percent i mean it's just right it's it's mind-blowing um and finally they got down to 10
and i think four of our five administrators were still standing and scott was like go to five go to five and they didn't but i think it's a testament like we are we're having a lot of success at mass landing um i think there are other great pockets in the district and i think the other thing um is my hope is we'll also like some of this is about building habits early
and seeing the benefit of those habits being established in elementary school as well. So I anticipate there will also be kind of some trickle up. That's my hope, right, as we look, you know, nationally, middle and high school,
chronic absenteeism rates are higher. The same is true of RSU-5 as well. And because I have this inability to remember time, or it seems to go by too quickly, this is year three with the assistant principal? Year two. Oh, it was just last year? Oh, okay, we added Moore Street first, and then that's the end. Yeah, so I'm Samantha's third year and Scott's second. Okay, I had it switched to my head. Thank you. So I'm not as crazy as I thought. Great. Other comments? Colin's like, yes, you are. Other questions or comments for Emily?
Thank you. Thanks. Oh, sorry, did you have one? She hasn't left yet. It's not super important, but I am curious, since we're talking about RTIB supports, um you have a therapy dog in your building still this year we do max is and do the kids
do they relate well to him like does that actually kind of help you with your goals you know what i will be totally transparent i underestimated the power of having a dog in the building i could have like taken it early left it but i had a staff who was passionate about
it um for certain kids it truly makes a difference i i was talking um to our srb srl recently and i was like i have a student truly who it has kept classrooms from being destroyed right if that student is dysregulated and max is there it is like his ability to cognitively shift with that
dog is something i i do not max is a power i do not have um and i will say in fairness the kids who requested the additional blanket reading fort when they request the fifth graders also requested that Max be part of the blanket fort. So it is one of those things, like, does it make a difference
for all kids? No. Does it make a meaningful difference for some kids? Absolutely. And is there this sense of belonging with Max? Bizarrely, yes. And if you come to Daily Mile on a day that Max is there, it's like, who gets to walk Max? And who gets to, you know, have his leash and walk
with max and so i think for kids like going back to this idea of like it's a lot of things it's not there's not a thing it's like what is the landscape of things that create school to be a place that kids feel connection and for some kids that is a labradoodle right might not be for me but for the
kid that it is it's awesome okay this is just a logistical question for me what about people with allergies he's hypoallergenic so we have i mean no dogs are fully hypoallergenic we do not have any students who have allergies that have any issue with it yes that would be really sad so sad
i'm actually specially bread maxed to uh have absolutely zero in our stem classes exactly you can touch on that next yeah next next year i was just saying i hear tom brady's cloning his dog so maybe we can clone that yes i i feel that i you don't have to put your hand back
Well, you know, I feel what I have to say, just as I, you know, I've been in the school quite a bit. I've been in all our schools quite a bit. And the difference that I see here in RSU 5, and this is not just me blowing sunshine,
but I've been in other places where the approach to issues like attendance is consequence-based. And it comes from the belief that if we just consequence kids and families into complying, then somehow we'll get results. And you know what? They do get results, but they're not good ones. And that's not the mindset that we have here. And my experience is that that is rare, and we should really celebrate it. You could bring masks to a board lady.
Great idea. I love it. I have two doodles at home. We did have a school picture taken in a mass landing shirt, so stay tuned. All right, at least send that to the board, please. Thank you. All right, thank you, Ellie. See, good question. was important all right so that finishes our administrator reports for this evening we don't
have board comments or committee reports on here I would I guess I'll ask you guys I know we have a few things that we want to make sure we get to interested to hear I don't want too much time to go by after the MSMA conference for folks who attended if there was anything anybody wanted
to share on any sessions i know kara was kind enough to share some slides from a session she went to specific to the cell phone question on the agenda tonight but i wasn't sure if anybody attended any attended any other sessions that would like to share any feedback on before it
gets too far into the rear view danielle um stuff was there too but we went to one about the presented by the Gorham um I guess there's two of them I went to um the Gorham school presented um how they include their community and businesses and getting kids out into the community and doing like job
shadowing and things like that and she um she seemed the uh principal or she was the superintendent what just amazing very well put together like um I don't know like there's this amazing program for kids and local businesses that was very well supported um I think that would be something I
I think Dede Banal does a great job here, but I can see this going in, you know, we could do more and have more opportunities for kids. So I think that that would be something maybe to, I don't know, maybe Dede could, like, connect with somebody at that school or something like that to see what we could do to mimic that. And then the other one I'd like to was to learn how to figure out
the budget when it comes to the EPS. wow anyways um it was a lot but it was good to be able to understand that sheet i think a little bit more it's almost we were talking like there almost needs to be a class every year for new
board members on how to go through that sheet um again she did a pretty good job as long as she wasn't being interrupted by you know people asking tons of questions you could get through it and i feel now that i can look at the sheet and understand much more than i ever really could so again something i think i don't know how we get like her slides or maybe like a way to do that so
every new board member can like look at that because it's a lot so yeah and we've done it sort of at the board level usually it was around the cost sharing formula because really you need to have a pretty firm understanding of eps and the ed279 so eps is um essential programs and
services for folks who are newer. And that's essentially what the state uses to decide how much it costs to educate a student in your district. So they put some assumptions, class size, school size, where you are in the state, a variety of things. And so that's what the EPS formula is,
is like how much they say it costs to educate a kid. And then the ED-279 is the form that each district has that that says how many kids do you have what's the eps what's your valuation how much do you need to raise from taxes all the all the fun stuff that goes into the budget process um so
we've done that through the cost sharing formula to try and give everybody a baseline but it's a really good point that as people come and go off the board um you know that knowledge may or may not remain um so maybe it's something we could think about from finance um you know maybe that's
something we put on our finance agenda for you know to invite new board members once a year you know if you haven't been through a budget process yet we have a you know a conversation about what does it look like so thank you for that anyway karen i went to a lot of the same ones so i don't
have a lot of new information to share i did go to one about um finances as well and it turned out it was, the summary was not what I was expecting the actual, um, discussion to be, um, yeah, it, it was about, I want to say it was, and I think it's near where Tom used to be, um,
either Rockland or Rockport, because I often get those two confused, um, the superintendent has had four different business managers in five years, cool, yep, yep, so, um, um and how hard it's been so i did want to since kelly is here to say how thankful we are to have
her i mean generally but also specifically i'll echo that all right okay well i have a lot of notes and i wasn't prepared to summarize don't feel like you need to i mean it'll be on our next one i just didn't want people to be like oh that was too long ago but if you have notes and you
want to do in the next one that's a okay i will maybe do more next time but i did attend an interesting communication strategies session that I hope to that I think Stephanie you attended as well so I think we'll be bringing those notes to that discussion and there was also an interesting one about AI there's a
program called day of AI that looks that provides AI literacy toolkits and that are free and I think that's something that we might want to look into if I if we haven't already looked into that and then I went to a couple of different
cell phone sessions that might come up in our next discussion. Thank you. So was it the four of you that attended? Good. How was the keynote? Usually very good. Really inspiring. Always, yes. I was very amped after it. High energy. Oh, he was or you were? No, he was. Oh, he was. And then I was.
yeah okay yeah i i uh i don't know who sources their keynote speakers but every year i'm blown away so great job whoever that is out there i think it's aileen is it aileen yeah so um for karen and maria's sake so once a year msma which is the main school management association is kind
of the trade organization lobbyist group that um supports all of school boards in the state and superintendents in the state they have a conference a two-day conference up in augusta and they have a variety of sessions on everything from special education law to cell phones to
nutrition to therapy dogs maybe i don't know maybe maybe emily can do one next year um so uh it's it's a great um it's a great opportunity to get a lot of information about a variety of different school board stuff um so um highly recommend the unfortunate part about when you guys came on
this is right after um but um but they have it every year so next october something to look forward to yeah i just thought of one of i went to one that was about um advocacy and advocacy as a listening body which was quite interesting and one of the questions that i feel like we've kind
talked about maybe at our retreat um that was interesting to me was considering if you're persuadable when you're listening um and I thought that was like just an interesting question knowing that we sometimes have to make tough choices and have completing priorities um that's a question
that's sort of been rattling in my brain is yeah before we're listening are we persuadable I'm gonna like be thinking about that all right um so uh we do not have a policy on the agenda for tonight. And so we will move on to item 12, which is the cell phone conversation. I'm not
going to get a motion on the floor yet because I think we want to kind of decide the direction we want to go before we decide what that motion is. I do think there was some requests for information from the last meeting that we had that I think you had some updates for us. Yes. Let's start with
the problem with this product is that it's much more breakable it's not flexible so if you have to put not only a phone but a watch or perhaps if you think ahead like a meta glasses or something like that in there you're not going to fit them in there um it costs less than the yonder bag
but how does it open it like magic he should he did show me and now i can't remember how it opens I love that our 6th graders will figure that out in 12 seconds but our superintendent not so much that's how everything works so the yonder bag that is now closed and it just opens very quickly and you put it on the magnet the magnet is pretty heavy you can pass these around if you like, one can go this way one can go that way if you bear with me for just a minute my laptop is back in my bag, and I have some information from Sam. Okay, so yes, it's a new germ, new case,
the plastic one is called. New germ? New germ, new case. Pricing, the Yonder bags are $35 with no grant, which already includes a 12% discount. There's maybe a possibility of $20,000 with a grant, which would essentially amount to 50% off for us. He has pursued that, but we would have to
have an answer on ordering those by November 14th. Could you say those numbers one more time, Tom? Sure. So the Yonder Bags, without any kind of grant or a special offer, are $35,000 for all the ones that we would need. Which is how many? That includes a 12% discount. He didn't
give me a number of bags, but that would be enough for the high school and the middle schools. Okay, so all 6 through 12. Yes. So basically the same people we're giving a computer to. Correct. There is a possibility of getting those at $20,000, which amounts
to about 50% off the price. So that's if we were successful getting the grant, it goes from $35,000 to $20,000. Correct. The $35,000 includes a 12% discount. Correct. Okay. So, Sam cites some reasons to go with Yonder. It is a known solution that is already used locally at other schools.
It's relatively easy to operate. If you have an emergency, you can easily, like, cut through the bag. You can, you know, to get to that phone if there's a real need. The bag itself is flexible and pliable so that if you need to get more things in there, you can.
And it also, for that reason, is probably more durable in that it's flexible. He also, what he has for me is reasons to go with yonder and reasons not to go with new case. So the same thing. New case, more difficult to open, close, lock, and operate.
Made from hard plastic, which means they would be fast to break with drops and unable to cut through easily in an emergency. Built around the shape of the phone, would not be able to secure new form factors like smart glasses. You get an iPad in there?
What's the cost of the new corn? Did he not get that? He didn't supply that for me. I asked him on the phone just before we came in, and I'm going to repeat exactly what I said. It's less, but it's not a lot less. And the grants, are they specific to Yonder? It's a special offer from Yonder. But wait, there's more. The way Sam presented it to me, it's sort of like, if you make this deal now, you'll get this much off.
It's incentivizing. Sounds like the state with early childhood education. It does. So can I talk a little bit about some of the research I did between both the Yonder and Newcase? Because it seems like those are really the two options. At least I couldn't find any other real good options. The Newcase has a three-year warranty on it as far as manufacturing defects.
I don't know what they count as that. I'm pretty sure our high schoolers will blow through manufacturers' warranties pretty quick. Right. So what I read about Yonder was actually that it was less durable, not more. Maybe that's not true. But that's what I seemed to read.
Also, you talked about how in an emergency you're more able to get into the Yonder. But then we talked about how the new case is less durable and drops. So it seems like there's probably an equal ability to get into either of them. The thing on the floor is probably not the best way to get your phone out. That's an emergency situation, right? If you have a yonder bag, you can cut it open. If you wanted to get into the plastic thing, you might have to smack it and break your phone inside. The thing that I found on the yonder bag that was the Achilles heel was that pin.
It bends and breaks, and then it's a whole new bag, and it's a whole new process and like like you can just easily like i poked myself with it not even meaning to right you already broke it that was the thing that wasn't it wasn't so much the
bag it was actually the pin and it's locking mechanism that was the the thing that broke the most often and was like very easy to break on like usage all the time and i feel like um i feel like one of the things jen mentioned to me when she was telling me about going to the sort of training
session at portland high school for her for her for her kids um was uh they said the pin could be like used as a weapon with it i mean it is quite substantially sharp yeah um i i actually called the new case guy because they had a phone number and it was like really easy to do um it's 80 bucks
a base plate and 20 bucks a thing so what's a base plate and a thing so like the let's see the magnet that's the magnetic yeah they're both magnetic okay so it it's like it would be like 13,000 for the district depending on how many we got of course
so it is I would say substantially cheaper I mean if we're talking 20 with a grant versus 13 without a grant percentage yeah and in looking at the under grant it needs to be implemented by January 26 so if we don't think we
have the capability of implanting by January 26th. I don't think we qualify for that. So, um... Where's the other one? I want to, like, magnet it. I have a question. Are we allowed to say mean things about these products? Well, because we're on YouTube? Like, I'm just... I'm honestly asking, like... Mean things? Yeah, what are you going to say? I find that product ridiculous. Oh, you hadn't said the mean thing yet. I was like, what did we say? Do you know what this is based on? A VCR case? No, what it's based on. You know those security cases at Target or whatever where they lock things in them?
Yeah, yeah. That's what those are. Oh, that makes sense, right? Like where you have to go up to the technology thing for them to swipe it out? I don't know. I feel like I've had a bad experience with something like that in a past life or something. Like my emotional reaction to it. I just really don't like it. But that's completely aesthetic and emotional. Well, I also don't think, I mean, the aesthetic other problem is, is, I'm not even sure, like, I couldn't fit my watch and my phone in there.
Is that the only size? They have an XL. How much is the XL? How much bigger that would be? I don't think you can do that. So, part of what I'm just thinking as we talk about this is we, we may want to talk just conceptually about where we are with the cell phone ban.
Yeah. Before we get into this, yeah. Because if we say no ban, then these are all just fun, play, clear things to do with. yeah exactly it's sort of you know a moot point um did we have any luck i think one of the other things we were hoping to get was some feedback from some students that had from the schools
did we get any i don't know phoebe passed that along to you before okay um i do feel somewhat compelled to share that i have been you know this is anecdotal for sure but i do have a like a vast spy network across the state in schools, especially in Camden, which is a school that we've talked
about. I've been on the phone with quite a few of my former colleagues who are working through, who've just implemented a ban and have gone with Yonder. So the feedback that I've gotten universally is that the good news is the ban has been very easy to implement
and has definitely reduced, like, the phones are gone. The phones are not in use. The bags, kids aren't using them. They have bought the bags. The feedback from teachers is, generally speaking, the kids are coming in saying, oh, my phone,
or, like, waving a bag saying, yeah, my phone's in here. Well, the phone is in their backpack. It's away somewhere. But the phone is not really in the bag. It may be in the bottom of the backpack or whatever. But the desired effect is that the phones are away, and they're not fighting that battle.
So for what that's worth, that's pretty consistent feedback I'm getting from colleagues I trust that are in the middle of it. Ma'am. From just hearing how much yonder pouches cost, I feel like you would want them to be effective.
And Superintendent Gray made a good point that the phones are away at the end of the day because students don't want them to be taken away if they're not in the pouch. But if you're spending so much money on something, you want it to be put in use.
And I feel like maybe there are other ways. Because I feel like some classrooms are really strict about the phone policy, and they are a way. And I feel like students would figure out a way to get around the yonder pouches.
And I just feel like if you're spending so much money on something, you want them to be put to use. I'm just curious if you've heard about schools that have used other implementation strategies, such as centrally located lockers, that can be, so, you know, it can easily be seen,
like they're all on a wall or something, I don't know, but you can easily walk through it, oh, this person's phone isn't there, why not, you know. I'm just curious if there are other strategies that are used, like lockers or bins,
besides these pouches that they just take with them. I don't have a lot of information about that, sorry. Clearly, I'm not smart enough to use this one. It slides over and pops open. There are schools that have bell-to-bell bands that are off and away all day, and there aren't devices.
So I believe that that's... I think that's Wyndham. That's what Wyndham's doing this year. So there's an option that doesn't involve any device that's still a bell-to-bell band, right, in policy. So for me, the concern about that is, and it's the same concern as saying, well, at least it's
off and away and we're not seeing it. Um, I think one of the other big areas that we want to think about is like the bathrooms. Um, and you know, if I just have this not locked and I have access to it or it's just in the bottom of my bag, then, then I've sort of, um, you know, defeated the
purpose of of having the you know no phones all day right because i i could keep it out i could keep it away during all my classes and in the hallway and then lunch but i'm still using it in the bathroom um and to me that's one of my concerns i don't think anything is going to be
foolproof right like there is not a nothing is right there there's not a rule that's ever been made that hasn't been broken a kid hasn't figured out how to break that rule um but is the benefit of you know 90 percent um you know adoption and using it appropriately good enough so that it's
you know it lessens the the need for the work on the other 10 i don't know yeah i guess one of my concerns about not using any device at all is that we don't want to add to teacher burdens by implementing a cell phone ban like i don't want them to have to feel like they're policing kids
all the time right knowing it's in their bag and we shouldn't see it but like i mean one of the other things i heard was like in passing if you've ever been we were here yesterday during passing it is very busy in the hall there's no way teachers could know if kids had their phones out like there's no way you would know sorry so karen and i went to the same um presentation
she sent the slide deck for it for rc1 um couple things they considered a centralized location for our folks to put their phones in. But legal was worried about taking possession of personal property and what that might open up. So they kind of dismissed that as too big a burden.
They use yonder pouches at RSU-1, and they had three student delegates come and talk about the impact that it had on their schools. They've had it for over a year. Granted, it's through voluntary delegates, so you have to take some of that feedback with a little bit of a grain of salt because I'm sure they got some kind of bounty points for it.
But there was one student that stated that he was extremely offended that he wasn't being trusted and that the pouches were implemented when he thought putting it away was enough. and stated that in the later year in the spring that he found himself using the pouch anyway
because he wasn't able to control himself enough not to get further into the corrective action route because he would try to self-regulate and the temptation would be too much and he would be caught. So the piece of the implementation that I think if we do go pouch route, even more so for
the success that we want, would be getting the buy-in from the teachers of making sure that there's zero tolerance across the board. Because if you have anybody who's weak on that, then it's, you're going to lose your compliance right away. I think if the teaching staff aren't willing to
be zero compliance or zero tolerance at the beginning at the outside of like as soon as you see a phone this is the first step this is the second step and continuing to drill at home of this is just what we're doing now um it's not a punishment it's just getting used to the new one
um then you're not going to have compliance um and a lot of it is trust as well students are allowed to say it's in my car and they're trusted that it's in their car um but the proof is in the lack of phone in your hand and the reasonable lap time in the bathroom i think all of the normal
tells yeah and i'm just thinking back to emily grimm's presentation and how that that positive joyful um no it is not but but i do think that there could be an aspect where we do emphasize to the kids the benefits of putting these things away and really talk up how this is going to be
helpful for their well for their well-being and how that could actually kind of help with compliance as well yeah i think that of the students that came and spoke um they they also emphasize the the need to explain why i asked a question at the end like if student voice is very important to us
we might not be doing what the students want but is there a way we can communicate this best to students so that they can feel a little more on board um and that was one one piece is just making sure that they understand why and the benefits um they the staff in rc1 also said that
they weren't at a place yet of not having to ask them in the morning is your phone in your pouch or like where's your phone basically but they have a routine down they have a couple of tables with two magnets adhered to the tables, and they have two staff members on each of the, at each
of those tables in the morning, and they have the system down. If it starts to get backed up, it might delay kids 30 seconds. They also have people with handheld magnets ready at the end of the day, 12 handheld magnets that they can use in the afternoon, and also one
on the outside of the school building on the concrete that students can go right they can go outside and do that so I think that we have a lot to learn from that district they seem to really have it down it seems to be going well and they also have the you know first and second offense
students have one hour detention and the third offense a two-hour detention and the parent has to come get the phone if there's a fourth offense they have one day of in-school suspension and a fifth or more out-of-school suspension.
They've actually had a 50% reduction in suspensions, but they have noticed health center visits have gone up because students aren't just texting their parents saying that they're sick and they want to go home. They're actually going to the health center, so that was an interesting consequence.
And if they break it or lose it, it's $35, or they can give two hours of community service. And what you were saying, that it's not taking phones away. I mean, we are taking access to the phones away, I suppose, but we're not taking their phones by using, or they're not taking the phones by using a yonder pouch. So one thing also is that they do not include earbuds in these restrictions.
So that is something that we would also want to have some guidance around the policy, if we were to what we're including in this and then as far as this discussion goes too i think we we're deciding what this is to give the policy committee some direction on what to draft right
for a policy but we don't we're not necessarily creating or are we also policy committee creating a procedure because i think if i'm remembering the policy does not include how the how the schools are going to meet the policy correct yeah i would think we would probably not want to get granular
in the implementation into the policy because that gets tricky when you want to shift something um yeah i agree but i think that at least the way i'm approaching uh this conversation in the context of the self in terms of the policy is that um i think they i think they have to be linked
To me, I think we have to be clear. I think, I mean, my sense is tonight, were we to decide to ask the policy committee that I serve on to write a policy that outlines a bell-to-bell ban, we would also be, as a board, directing the superintendent to make that procedure simultaneously.
Yeah, right. Well, that's my understanding of what this conversation is. It's not a, it's not a, it's the, they happen, like, it's a complete deal of, like, we're not, we're not doing one and being like, well, draft the policy, then figure it out. Which I do not think is what you're suggesting at all, Cara. But, like, just to be really clear, like, I think that's what, that's how I'm approaching it tonight. And, yeah, and I guess just, I would say two things,
just very specifically on the question of the, on the question of the band. I, I will own that, you know, In May, when this came up, I was very impatient and very much at a sense of, I think I said on camera, everybody can go back and check the YouTube, that there's nothing new we can learn about this that will change our minds. And that sense of impatience is definitely one that I hear from some of the folks in
the community that are wondering why we have, why we have taken so long. And I remember Kara saying, no, we should take some time and walk through this to make sure we have buy-in from all of the stakeholders. If not buy-in with everybody saying yes and jumping off tables and building pillow forts because they're so excited about it.
But that everybody has felt engaged and everybody else has felt heard because we also have received input from other districts. But if you don't do that, any initiative will effectively fail. And it will fail in terms of creating a healthy environment for the students to learn within, and that is what we are mandated to do.
So while, again, my thoughts have not evolved at all in terms of my sense that do cell phones belong in an academic setting in middle school or high school? No, that's what I thought in May, and I think that now. But I think we're better as a board and I think as a district for having gone through that process.
um so cara thank you for um encouraging us to do so um the second thing i would say is that i am i'm absolutely in favor of a of moving toward a bell to bell ban um i'm uncomfortable doing so without and we talked about this at the last meeting but i'm uncomfortable doing so without
out a clear process that's implemented that is larger than just banning the damn phones, but rather a larger educational and sort of social wellness project to not, like, develop some really cool arguments to give to the high school students of, like, why this is
super cool that we should all do it but just saying like no we understand this is part of a large this is about this is about technological literacy it's about like the link between um technology and mental health um so i think on the one hand i'm very eager to direct uh tom to to
basically like let's get on them let's get them yonder bags um or the vhs uh tape recorder things which again, thank you Valerie so much for that amazing image and that's all I can think of because it's awesome on the one hand I'm like I really want to jump on that and be like yeah let's get that grant, like let's get that grant and let's get some fundraising going for that, on the other hand, and then implement it as Chris was saying to be prepared to implement it I would assume we would be trying to implement that first day back from winter break on the one hand I'm ready I'm ready to do that on the other hand I don't think we have I don't think we
have the resources certainly monetarily to make sure we're putting in place a healthy structure to make sure that when that ban does go into effect that the that the students feel the word I can think of right now is held in terms of
like understanding the impact of that and understanding and like how to provide support structures for that in terms of mental health and how to provide whether it's outside you know folks coming in from outside to talk about technology so that's the conundrum where I am right now look I'm totally
in favor of of telling myself as the head of the chair as head of the policy committee to start drafting that policy but it's the it's the timeline and it's the money that I just don't know how to factor in to that question. So I emailed a funding guide
that Yonder has put together to you, Tom, to see if they recommend a number of title funds that schools could use to help fund this. And I was wondering what your thoughts were on that. And your thoughts in general, are there, you know, I know where our budget's going to be really tight
this year and we're about to hear more about that and um so i i understand that i'm wondering if there's if there's any wiggle room with being able to fund especially if we were to make a decision by november 14th twenty thousand dollars and if you did hear from anyone in the community saying
they're willing to help fundraise because that's that's an amount that seems to me like a doable fundraising amount for a community if if there are enough people in the community who are willing to help with that and to make that donation, though this is also a tough time where there are a lot of donation needs out there. So I'm wondering what your thoughts are on the funding part. So in terms of the title grants, we would have to write that into one of our title projects, which for this year are done. So we could take that under advisement for next year and we would just have to figure, that's something we would be figuring out next spring and then And I guess the only caveat I have for that is who knows what's going to happen with title grants this year,
given where we were last year. But we'll jump off that bridge when we come to it. I have not yet heard back from anybody in the community who's offered to partner with us to fundraise, but it's early days, and we could certainly make an effort there.
In terms of coming up with, like, the largest number I saw there from Sam was $35,000. I'm not going to say that $35,000 grows on trees. Kelly and I could certainly look and try to find ways where we could find it. It would mean shifting money, sacrificing it somewhere else.
And we'd have to become granular and talk to you about that when we have a proposal. In terms of just my perspective of having worked in high schools for a really long time, I think that you have the, I think you can move forward with different pieces of this at different paces.
I think that you can decide right now where you want to go with just the access you want to provide for the devices. Whether that's a belt-to-belt ban or whatever it is, you can give that direction to the policy committee now.
And the policy committee, well, it's actually on the agenda for the policy committee tomorrow, but in anticipation that there will be some direction tonight. We can then also move forward with figuring out how you would like to have this implemented.
One of the solutions that has come to my mind frequently is to knowing and believing the, and I can see it, you know, having just been in classrooms with kids in high schools and dealing with disciplinary issues in high schools for a really long time.
I can see how somebody here mentioned that we're trusting kids when they say it's in my car, it's in my bag. One of the things that we don't, we don't want to put our teachers in a position of having to constantly power struggle every time a kid says that.
So solutions that I've heard about in other schools are that, that have made the investments in yonder bags across the board, is that they're using those, really, they're only using them in the extreme cases when you have a repeat offender.
So there may be a way to step into that that goes with a smaller number of yonder bags to use for cases that really need them, and then see how it goes and expand it over time, if cost up front is something that is an issue that might otherwise stop us.
so i think my overall point is that i don't know that you need to be concerned i don't know that you need to be concerned about holding back on a decision about which way you want to go with phones tonight because of the logistics we can figure out the logistics including the money
i just have a question about the under patches would the pouch be in your backpack or would it be in a certain classroom you would have it with you and have there been other strategies about putting phones up um the way certain teachers do it by having a name and a number track to it and
has it been reinforced more in classrooms because i haven't i haven't seen other sorts of strategies besides going straight to yonder pouches yeah i think you know what we've heard mostly from ways people have approached it um so the the phone tree piece which is not away all day because you guys
obviously have them between trees um in the hallways and at lunch um there's the off and away which is we don't want to see your phone don't don't take it out leave it in your car leave it in the bottom of your bag whatever that looks like for you don't bring it at all
um and and it does sound like there's a few schools that have gone that way i think that's that's windham that comes to mind this year um has has taken that approach and i think initial thoughts are that it works okay for them so far. And I don't, I don't know. The way I think about
that is for, for me, it's one thing to blatantly lie to a teacher who says, is your phone in your bag? Yes, my phone's in the yonder pouch and it's not. That feels like a, a more overt breakage of the rules as opposed to, well, they let me keep it in my pocket. Like, I don't care if I use it in
the bathroom. Like that, I don't know, maybe it's, maybe it's the same amount of rule breaking. It just feels like an easier line for kids to cross um we also have a new tool that's tracking it's an electronic pass system that's just been put into effect recently at the high school that is
you know it it tracks right away oh that kid's been in the bathroom for 15 minutes and there's a way to know that already it's pretty easy my question would be are we doing anything with that data right because i still think only because i have a son who's like yeah
I can't believe kids are just missing long periods of time and they don't see anything happening with that. But in his mind, it's this weird now electronic system to go to the bathroom. And so, you know, I don't know. I just wonder that's another thing that you're
adding to the teachers. We talk about we don't want to put all this on them to be checking the bags, but they're going to have to check the bags. Someone's going to have to check to make sure it's in there. Otherwise, it's 100%. We're just trusting you put it in the bag when you walked in the door. Well, except I do have to say this about that. We can't search a kid without reasonable calls. No, I get that. And that would amount to a search. No, no, I get that. I think what they do in Portland is they go, okay, here's my phone, here's my bag, boom, and they walk in the door. They walk past the staff person. Now, whether they close it or not, that's up for debate. Right. But the issue that we run into Maria with the phone trees is that if the intent is to have kids not engage with their phone at all, all day,
every time you go in and reach for your phone and put it in the tree, it's time and attention to let's talk about phones, let's reinforce phones. It's even a few minutes at the beginning of class where people have to think about, touch phones, put a phone away, and then at the end, same thing again. And look, like, whose phone isn't there? Oh, Maria, did you bring your phone? No, I don't have my phone. Like, they're wasting a lot of time, it sounds like. Both of my parents are teachers. My dad works here. I know how difficult phones are in a classroom. I always put mine up. And I think that the way of going, you only have a wonder patch if you're a repeated offender,
would be a strategy that I think students would be more happy about. Because I know myself and other people put their phone up. And, like I said, my parents are teachers. I want to make teachers' lives as easy as I can. But I would not want to put my phone in a yonder pouch.
Well, I don't want to put my phone. I have representatives on the school board. I have driver's ed. I have other extracurriculars that I need my parents to be aware of. Like, you can email. My dad works here. I could call his room. Some kids don't have that privilege. And they might rely on that text or that call.
Also, teens get sick. They have health problems. you just need to text your mom can I go home and I think being a repeated offender you deserve to be able to put your phone up but as somebody who is not I don't I feel like it would be a little
it wouldn't feel super fair to me but I understand why you would do it it's I think exactly what you said is is the is the existential crisis in this right because it feels like oh I can handle my phone you don't need to take it away from me but the fact that you feel like you need your phone
is the whole reason we need to take it away and we're actually giving you a gift to not even have to worry about it not to worry who's texting you who's who's posting on this and who's doing that um you know i i know it's crazy to believe but we never had phones and we all got our got to our
jobs and our sports and like it you know it sounds silly to say that but it's just a reset of it's just a sort of resetting our mindset around accessibility. Like, do you need to be accessible for those eight hours, or should you be able to focus on you and your friends and your classes
and your learning and not have to worry about that at all? It feels very, like, punishment-like when we say, well, I can handle it, but you shouldn't have to, I think is part of the point. Chris? I was going to say something similar, too. I imagine that most of the people here on the
board went to high school without phones and we still have those activities and um i i've heard that from students and like i do sympathize with it quite a lot i think that that in talking with what colin said about the education piece on this is not just talking about the mental health but
also talking about some of the logistics of hey if you need to communicate this is how you can do it because there's all these other ways that we can have these kids communicate with their parents or with whoever else they need to communicate with. And, you know, you said sometimes you just need to text your mom that you're sick
and you want to go home, which is another reason we heard that health visits have gone up. Nurses' visits went up. Which is actually a good thing because a nurse is just that one more point of contact of maybe the kid is sick,
the nurse can evaluate that in a small way, which could prevent some of the future issues. So I think that there's a lot of ways that maybe don't seem natural to the kids now, but that might seem more natural to us as adults who didn't live through that, that we probably should try to communicate with that type of thing.
Yeah, I think the education piece is huge. And I think I've said that since the beginning. We need to sort of shift that paradigm that this is because we feel like you can't handle it and more that you shouldn't have to.
And I think that's going to be huge. yeah yeah i think it was rsu1 that said they installed another phone line expecting there to be more phone calls from parents and students to parents and it was hardly used like maybe in the
first week it was used a bit more but but parents and students realized they had to really think do i really need to contact my parent right now do i and the parents might say do i really need to contact my student right now can i wait until 2 30 and people just realized that they didn't need
to be contacting each other as much during those hours, which I thought was really interesting. I do feel somewhat compelled to share an anecdote that is, I think, instructive. So one of the things that I, as a teacher, did many, many times was international trips. And I can't tell you the
difference in flavor of those experiences between when I was doing them in, let's say, 2008 versus is 2018, and in 2008, kids could not bring phones with data on trips, and in 2018, they could. And there's value in the experience of those kids going away to the UK or France
or whatever it is, and having their experience not necessarily being able to call home every time they felt anxiety about homesickness or whatever it was. And that led to a whole piece of education as we like step by step got into more experiences where the connection between
home and kids abroad was increasing every single time and educating parents and kids about the value of disconnecting and letting them have their experience and working through the bumps that come up. I just, I, as I listened to the conversation, I have to recall that and that
It really has been a dynamic I thought about and lived a lot. I would also just encourage us to, one of the things I've seen in schools that have implemented this, like so many other things, is that there's a large degree of no matter how much we plan out when we start,
there's a lot we have to figure out as we go, as we walk into the fog and things become clear. And I think we need to anticipate whatever decision is made tonight. There will be a significant amount of that. And then knowing that, we shouldn't necessarily feel that we have to have everything figured out tonight
to make a decision to take whatever the next step is. Follow up on that. I think that's a really good point. That this, whatever we decide on, we probably will evolve and change. I worked in a school a long, long time ago when smartphones were pretty brand new.
So I'm aging myself here. And we did a lot of work creating a cell phone policy, and it changed many, many times over the course of the first few years we had it. So I think that's something that's really important to keep in mind. I was just thinking, you know, since Emily's here, like, we're like 6 through 12.
I think there's 5th graders who have phones. Like, so what's, do we, you know, do we have to expand this? Like, hi, kindergartner, here's your younger bag. Like, I don't know. I'm just thinking about, to your point, we don't want to make it so strict and be like, look, we've outgrown it already. No, but the ban would apply to fifth graders. Certainly would apply. Right, and that's one of the reasons maybe we don't pay that. Oh, you make an exception just for fifth graders. Fifth graders are totally, totally capable of having their cell phones.
Yeah. I mean, I might... Sorry, sorry, I don't care. What about Max? Yeah. Karen? I just wanted to ask, and I think you may have just answered this question. It is middle school and high school. I wasn't quite clear on that. Yeah, I mean, I think a ban would be the district,
and sort of the execution of that policy would be, you know, in all likelihood, those bags for 6 through 12. Let me just have 5th graders to leave your, you know, meta glasses at home. I have one more thing. My child does not have a phone in 6th grade and will not have one for a few years. And she asked me, well, what do I do after school if my plans change or I want to go to the library. I said, we make a plan before I leave you in the morning.
And if it changes, there's telephones in the school. And she actually had to use it the other day because one of her clubs got canceled. And I got a phone call at home, and it said Freeport Middle School calling. And I was like, oh, dear. Yeah, so I answered it. And she said, hi, I need to be picked up. I'm like, okay, no worries. So it works. Yeah, exactly. I would also like to note the Freeport Library has installed a phone in the hallway. that is free for anyone to use. Yeah, that's good to know. Kelly? Yeah, I noticed in the presentation slides that Kara provided with us
that other schools have also included smartwatches in their band, and as someone whose child has texted me from her smartwatch during the day when she should not have been doing so, I would highly encourage us to include smartwatches.
Yeah, I think that's why the wording of this is cell phones and other personal electronic devices in school's policy. And this is something I think we need to think about too, right? Like if they have their own iPad that they use instead of their laptop,
is that included, is that not? You know, there's things other than, I mean, like I know I have a kid who has a laptop, she has her laptop, but she also has an iPad that she takes her notes on and does it all that way. Like, is that just things to think about? Yeah, I mean, I guess I would say I'm happy to keep talking about this because I enjoy everybody and what they have to say.
But I also might say, might we be the moment where we could ask Tom, Tom, based on your knowledge of the cell phone policies that you have started to look at because we have a policy committee meeting tomorrow, What is the information you need from the board, or we need from the board, in order to start to figure out, as you've put it, which variation we go with were we to pursue a ban?
I mean, just to be completely honest, as I read the room right now, I think the easiest way to do this would be for somebody to make a motion that basically mirrors what's in front of you. You know, if someone were to make a motion to draft a cell phone and other personal electronics devices in schools policy that executes a bell-to-bell ban, and if that motion were made and seconded and voted upon, and we see how it goes, that might give pretty clear direction.
But we don't have to do that until next year. It's not, like, required by the state. So let's just wait until next year. Yeah, I'd like to make that motion. Put down the book. Can we, how do I make it? What do we do? so do i have a motion for consideration and approval to instruct the policy committee to
draft a uh draft a cell phones and other personal devices electronic devices in schools policy to execute a bell-to-bell ban in rsu-5 so moved thank you have a second thank you okay i love us i'll be like if we were to institute a ban maybe if we didn't like but yeah let's get it on the
floor. Questions, comments? I feel like we need to know, is this a bell-to-bell ban? I said a bell-to-bell ban. Okay, sorry, yes. And I guess with that, one thing that we learned is that some schools will, in a situation where students are leaving school early for a field trip or for a
sporting event, are those students allowed to have that on the school bus, have the phones out on the school bus or not. I think that's something we would want to make sure we have some guidance. In other words, flesh out what bell-to-bell means. Yes, exactly. Thank you. What was my other thought with the kids? We're also at the tech school. What's that? Oh, and at the tech school. Right, that's happening at the tech school. That's an interesting one. Like, how does Region 10 play into this? Do they have their own? Please allow me. Too jip for that one, darling. Because I have joined the policy committee for Region 10, so we are currently reviewing the cell phone policy um currently it is just off and away
um it does not say anything about duration and it currently uh says both cell phone and smartphones so we're currently working on some refinements to change maybe smart phone to smart watches do people have phones that aren't smart anymore i don't know and they may exist
unless your kids are the ones that have them yeah so just i think that is a yeah i think so i think in terms of the policy that we would need to draft i think we would need to be looking at we would need to be looking at language that addresses
students during i'm thinking out loud students during academic school out instructional time but not in the build but not in the building or off-site so we would need to be drafting language around that. And also whether that's the same set of consequences or not. Are there things that you've seen, Tom, in the policies that this question of what gets included in smartwatches versus... Like earbuds, and one thing I feel fully comfortable sharing is that it isn't entirely possible and one might even argue advisable to include air buds because we can easily supply earphones that would be connected
to school devices that could be used for kids who need to be accessing something on that device for for instructional purposes you know some kids have like being able to listen to music or whatever for their IEPs but we can do that from a school device pretty easily so if you have air buds in
phone is in the yonder pouch what good are the earbuds i mean can you tie it to your could you tie it to your your laptop so why what what's the downside to having i mean if you can listen to music because i mean that's one of the things that i've heard um you know that is that is a coping
mechanism for some people who don't necessarily want the socialization piece of all the kids in the cafeteria like they'll put their earbuds in and listen to music instead um and i guess what's the downside of that. You could take a call. You could be on a phone call with your phone
in a yonder pouch if your earbuds were connected to your phone and your phone was on. It doesn't deactivate your ability to use the phone. I mean, let's be honest, kids in high school don't answer the phone. Not once ever. Sorry. It's just my kid. Yeah. One of the challenges
as RFC1 cited as being on earbud watch. So by not including that in their policy, that has been a challenging piece. And watch for people being on the phone. I mean, I know I have one kid that helped him focus in class to have one earbud in to listen to music, and that would be a challenge for him. But he didn't have an IEP that dictated it, so I guess maybe you could get one if you needed one. As an iPhone user, like if you had AirPods or something, you can ask Siri to do, like, anything.
Whether that's read your text, whether that's text somebody, whether that's, you know, doing an internet search, whether that's anything. So I think that's probably what they're worried about. Yeah, they're worried about it a lot. Okay. So we just have to find other ways to support people that may currently be using earbuds.
And that is probably not an inappropriate use of, you know, listening to music. But we just might have to find another way to support them for that. Another question, would there be any medical reason for someone to have a phone?
I have a niece who has, they're not cochlear implants, but she has some device under her skin. And she regulates it through her phone, whether it's turning up or down. There are some, and some like diabetics. Diabetics, yeah, with pumps. And there are ways to address that in the policy that will make exceptions for particular instances.
So like 504 implants? Yes. So because I'm also on the policy committee, we do have, we were in our packet given the sample policy from MSMA, and it includes different options that people can consider, and it also has a misuse of cell phones and other electronic devices section.
So I feel like that's something you would maybe want some guidance on. And kind of like what I was saying, RSU-1 has in first offense, second offense, the sample policy has something very similar and refers to the Student Code of Conduct
and the Health and Safety and Emergency Management Plan in the event of a school emergency and all of that. So I don't know if this is the type of thing where the policy committee just drafts something and then you give us your feedback then, or if we want to go through each of these pieces. My thought would be you guys are very capable,
and I'd put complete trust in your ability to bring forward what you feel is the best policy based on what you know about us and our district and our conversations and the recommendations. You know, for me, what I would like to give you first is you know the north star which is is there a banner is there not a ban so you had asked kind
of what like defining what a bell to bell would be um i can have a recommendation my recommendation is is pretty much simply a in the school and out of the school recommendation so in that sample policy which i saw too um it talked about bus transport and about how transport to and from
school the kids were allowed those phones um and then in theory transport for field trips or things like that the kids are also allowed those phones that's a gray area which i'm not sure we would like to do or not um but bell to bell meaning from the time the kids enter the school in the
morning to the time the kids leave the school in the afternoon yeah and i wonder if that's a distinction that could be made because you know in the procedure right because that may be that may be age-based right you know high school kids that are going on a two-hour bus ride for you
know a cross-country meet or something they they may want to give them access to listen to music or whatever on their phones you know kids on a field trip or younger kids that aren't going so far probably not as necessary so it could be you know that's one of the reasons i think you try not
to make the policy too too concrete and narrow so that you have that space to to tweak it based on the needs of of the kids there wouldn't be anything in the policy to to be able to i mean a teacher can at any point right now say, you know what, everybody, phone's away.
And, you know, the fourth grade teacher who's going to the local dairy farm for the afternoon could just say, kids, let's hope that not too many fourth graders have phones. Just using that as an example. What we're trying to do with this is to actually make it, take this out of
the teacher's hands so that they don't have to fight the battle. Sorry. So I think if it's a field trip that's instructional, for me that's within the bell-to-bell confines, but if it's a field hockey trip to a different region, they're not going to be pulling their cell phones out on the field generally, so it's a totally different thing.
like you might see them start whipping out their phones on a field trip and if they're in the back kind of knowing about but it's unlikely if they're committed enough to go on a field hockey trip that they're it's unlikely they're going to start pulling their phones out on the sidelines so it's funny um the girls soccer team had a playoff game on friday and one of the senior captains
at the front of the bus had a bag and she's like everybody's phone in the bag I mean it wasn't a super long trip but she's like I want everyone focused on what we're doing and you know it was a playoff game it was a little bit more high stakes and yada yada but I thought that was very interesting that that was driven by the captains and the coach was like yes he hates the phones yeah I think one of the things is just procedurally for us
I think I would want to make a step further on the policy side where whatever we drafted before we brought it to the board we would show it to some body at the high school and the middle school to sort of go over it in terms of either what we're missing
or where there are pressure points, because I think, yes, the two major, I guess for me, the two major spirits of this band are one, the preponderance of data points to there are no academic benefits to having academic or mental health benefits to having phones in the academic setting, and two, that it places an undue labor on the staff to have to manage it. So I don't want to create anything that accidentally sets up additional labor
for the staff. So I think I would just like that to be built in to whatever our... Yeah, no, I think that's a great idea. Just like when you write a policy that, you know, includes the impacts of the nurses, you run it by the nurses before it comes to us, right? Yeah, the unintended consequences of like, this sounds great. And then they're like, oh, you hadn't thought about this stuff. My question's about timing and like how feasibly quickly we could actually get through the process of policy writing and voting. So I'm going to, that's a great question, which we should get an answer to. I'm feeling like we're jumping past the vote. I don't think any of these questions would change someone's opinion of the vote, whether it's, you know, what does bell to bell look like, when do we start it, how do we pay for it.
Does anybody have a question or a comment that they want to make before we actually make the vote on the motion, and then we can kind of talk logistics. Okay, so we have a motion, we have a second. Right, Erica? Okay, great. I didn't write it down, so as long as you did, perfect.
All right, all those in favor? Opposed? Okay, thank you. Motion passes. All right, just wanted to get that sort of done so we didn't forget to actually have that vote, because I do think, I do think that step is an important one. Colin?
Yeah, I guess just to set Steph's question, I think the way I've been thinking about it, perhaps this is not accurate, is that if the board has given that mandate, which they have given, then that also empowers, sort of indirectly, I guess, the superintendent to start developing the timeline on how to implement the belt-to-belt ban with or without the policy
being in place is that accurate like so in other words like um technically without without a cell phone um policy per se uh you could either on your own initiative or with our direction say we have a delta bell ban and start implementing that um immediately i mean that's basically what
we did at the high school last year the high school decided they wanted to change how they were doing it it was in their handbook that we don't have a policy that says one way or the other they're able to do that, right? Like, in theory, we could say tomorrow morning, there are no forms in RSU-5. Which we're not doing. We're not doing. We're not recommending anybody
does. But logistically, you could. Right, but I just wanted to bring it, I wanted to make sure we're clear on that, because I think I'd want to, I would want to decouple our policy, like, policy language drafting and review process from the process that the superintendent and the administration would
make in actually moving forward to figure out how to how to move forward with the board's well I would say though that I think they should go in tandem right like we should necessarily institute the ban before we know what the
policy is going to look like because we may end up totally but yeah okay what happened just just just very technically we have to have a month in the first and second read. So if we were to be able to draft the policy tomorrow, which we're not going to be able to do, then we would bring that in, I guess.
My kind of hope is that we will set to work on this tomorrow in the policy meeting. We'll have another policy meeting in December. I would hope that we could have a draft of a policy to bring to the board for January for first read and at the same time i will set in motion conversations with the uh the b team
the principals group basically about how we would enact that in a procedure and so those two processes can work in tandem right which is very technically on that timeline january would be the first read if no one had any thoughts about it and we left it completely alone we would have to then
give it a month and then it would be february before we could pass it as policy so that's sort of the fastest timeline just for a policy perspective so that's why i was bringing up that the yonder grant it has to be implemented in january of 26 so if if we don't have that
capability based on the timeline we talked about right then we don't qualify for that grant three yonder yeah i mean so i guess my question is is this is this a marketing ploy to get you to buy it today like if we called december 1st would it be december 15th we had to make a decision by and
implemented by february like i don't know maybe i'm maybe i'm cynical no i thought the same thing i think probably if we decide to go with yonder pouches my guess would be that there would be some sort of deal at whatever point looking at the marketing material from yonder that's actually
what put me off from them they are very like that in a lot of different ways and so i i do worry that choosing them we would get stuck in some sort of some sort of system that we couldn't get out of um we know the magnets work it doesn't work because this fell off if i could oh that's the
yonder magnet not the just kidding i mean if i could make a recommendation just sort of from a global perspective about the products. I certainly understand there's a price discrepancy in the products and including in the timing. The amount of money that we're talking about, while it's not insignificant, in the global scheme of our overall budget is my personal opinion is that that shouldn't necessarily drive the bus. We want to be mindful of it, but it's like anything that you want to buy, but you're not ready to buy it. If we're just not ready to buy it, we're not ready to buy it. And so we'll move the process forward as efficaciously as we can and as thoughtfully as we can, and hopefully that coincides with a good deal that comes our way from whatever we decide to buy, if we decide to buy something at all. Right. I just wanted to make sure that it was pointed out so people weren't expecting it
but on that time. I appreciate that. They saved 20 grand! Yeah. I'm curious if they really wouldn't be flexible in, like, a month. Why would they even care when it's implemented. Once they bought it, they might not care. Because corporations care about, like, they care about people, and they care about the impact of... Yeah, well, I know that. That's true. I mean, if they know... Implementation includes finalizing the policy. I mean, if they know we're working on this... No, sorry. And, again, we want the policy and procedures to go in tandem, but if we know that the direction of the policy is going to be a belt of albania and it's still might be up to the administrators to come up with
the procedure how they're going to implement that policy i would like to ask the principals about more about now that we have this direction to dig into the issue of whether or not the devices are what they see as the best solution on the ground for them and we can get some good answers
to that in the next month or so and bring that to the policy committee and that can inform how we write a procedure. And I guess another point I would make about procedures, this is just based on my past experience, because the procedure does not take as much deliberation as a policy.
We don't necessarily need to be afraid to start with something that's relatively boilerplate and then fine-tune it as we go, because the fine-tuning is pretty easy. Which is why you don't put too much in the policy because that's a much more robust process to change um share what
you had to say so my only concern is i i get 35 000 20 000 doesn't sound like a lot of money but i do think it sounds like that's a salary for an ed tech maybe two ed techs i don't know and I think fine again I don't want the cell phones in the in the classrooms I don't I I I'm
not for the band for the bell to bell um and that's fine but I think I'm I'm really not supportive of spending money that could go towards getting ed techs or spending money on curriculum that I think we really need to update and spending it on a bag that most likely is not going to be used by
students and we're not going to be able to track it the teachers aren't going to be responsible for that and you know the person checking them in so I really want us to think about that because I think come April when we're like we don't have the money for a couple ed techs then I think
we're in trouble and and I think that that it's not fair to say to the public sorry you know again And I see the benefits, but I think we have to be very mindful of what this costs the public, right? And I just want us to think about that before we jump in to buy a bag.
I appreciate that you said that, and I just want to make sure that my earlier comments, I don't want them to be misconstrued. Like, I'm not saying it's insignificant. I think my overall point is that I don't want us to rush into a decision to save $15,000
if it's not the right decision for us yeah um kelly left but maybe we can check with her um i you know it's not fair to compare things um but i think about how we just spent you know 25 000 re-striping the track and you know items around the which we're investing in our
our um infrastructure which is important because we don't want it to crumble and then it costs more but I just wonder when you think that it's over $5,000 each individual one is less than $5,000 I don't know if it could be considered a capital expense that we could use the capital reserve fund for a small piece of it you know we
had some fair savings on some of the projects that we were working on in the capital you know the capital reserve this year in panel just just a thought as a way to kind of not dip into what might be a staff position I guess my my
counter to that might be that you know a half-time ed tech position could very well be taken up policing phone usage in our schools but you know it's it's yeah there's no way to know truly what that comparison is but but yeah it's not
nothing it's definitely there's a cost and I'm just afraid that off in the way is not going to be enough of a deterrent for the principals yeah I think just a couple things I think one I want to make sure I don't think you would have
it lost but I'm just gonna say it make sure I don't lose it the education because I think has to be bundled into it so I think Tom when you go to the principals I think like that like it's a it's effectively two questions one is
like what how do we institute the ban and the other is how do we create a an educational initiative around that in order to yeah in order to implement it again not in a way that as I was saying earlier to like try to smooth talk the
the students into believing our point of view believing our point of view but rather to like actually engage with the questions actually engage with the questions of addiction, actually engage the questions of mental health, actually engage with the questions of how these devices are designed specifically to
manipulate the human mind in these particular ways. So I think I just want to be very clear that that's my sense of what we are mandating Tom to do. The other is, that I think would be, I don't know, to, I think, Tango, you mentioned this earlier, this opportunity to engage with, was it GORM?
that has like sort of the way of engaging with the community and community businesses. I wonder whether there's some sort of opportunity here in terms of reaching out to some of the community, companies in the community to say, hey, like, again, like, will you, can you work with us to support
and create this kind of initiative, not just funding the bags, but sort of like create, again, kind of create some sort of initiative that would be better serving that. I don't know. I just think that might be kind of a, it's not a blanket fort. but it's more positive than not.
And as I'm thinking about that and just sort of implementation and potential timelines and you mentioned, you know, addiction, I think this is going to be a, you know, I think it is easier to do it at the beginning of the year. I'm not suggesting we wait, but when I think about like, oh, well, we come back from December break in January. Well, we are then two weeks before finals for the first semester.
I don't think the two weeks before finals is a good time to basically put 90% of our kids through withdrawal from their phones. Maybe it's the best time to do it to them. I don't know. But I'm just picturing the chaos that happens in this building during those two weeks if we were to do that.
But I would just encourage you when you're having those conversations with the principals, be like thinking about those types of things. Like, when would be the best time to tackle this from an implementation standpoint, from a, you know, from a buy-in standpoint, from a, you know, the sooner the better from a health standpoint, but we also have other things that we have to take into account.
Yeah, that education piece, to me, it's kind of got two pieces to it. There is the sort of the buy-in and educating kids around why this is important. And then there's also kind of the digital citizenship piece that I think we probably already have pieces of that maybe scattered throughout our curriculum. And I kind of would like at some point, I think we may have a place on our agenda where those might fit
to have an update on actually how we're addressing that yeah yeah and I second that third that on the education part because I think we're then not going to really be preparing them to go off to college when they're not gonna have a
yonder pouch let me just point that out and they have to be able no it may have to be able to manage that so we need to do some education with that and I think Like Jen mentioned doing an assembly, assemblies to me are fun times.
Kids aren't really paying attention to, hey, why are we putting our phones in a pouch? They're there to kind of celebrate something that's in their mind positive, which this would not be, I don't think, in many of their minds. But how about bringing it to health class or to their advisory? They meet every day with their advisory. I think that's a great opportunity to put something in.
That way all kids are getting it and all grades are getting it. And then a health class, you know, every 10th grader has to take that class. And maybe we come up with a digital, you know, stewardship class or something, you know, that kids can take.
Or maybe we require that for them to take as they maybe are a senior or a junior or something like that. Just a thought process to add to our curriculum. I can tell you that anecdotally I was at Mass Landing just this week and I had the real pleasure of going to all the third grade classrooms.
And while I was, well, there was a relevant SEL class, and the teacher was very deliberately talking about online dangers during games, and predatory behavior during games, and lots of kids, these were third graders who had lots to say about it, and so there are already
things happening, and I think where I will start with this is to ask our team, what are we already doing, and how can we build on that? I, um, using my own experience and examining my use of my phone and technology, I think
that, um, and I don't know if this is feasible, but it's an idea that I had, so I'm sharing of, I wonder if there's space to sort of monitor what's happening with students before and after the ban, um, and, like, monitor in, like, a curious way for themselves, because
my learning around technology has come from like restricting it for myself and then like seeing how that goes or then re-engaging and seeing how that goes um and so that there's i think that the restriction can be used as almost like a learning tool or a curiosity um
and i wonder if that might be help a helpful way to feel like we're still listening to students as the policy continues to evolve. We're actually curious about what it's like for you before and after. Just an idea. I think we could get Phoebe to help with that because I think the leadership committee does a lot of those questionnaires for the kids, right? So they ask them before and after kind of things. And I think they could easily probably do something like that. And I'm sure Phoebe would probably love to help us with that. Sorry, Phoebe. We miss you, Phoebe. okay so the next steps is you we have the vote thank you for that the policy
committee will begin their drafting tomorrow based on what they know now come will meet with the the B team around just brainstorming what the implementation looks like things to think about the policy committee will run
by their draft by those principals that will be mostly impacted so the middle schools and the high school to get their feedback um in terms of the method what i feel like i'm hearing is we really want to hear from that b team their you know knowing what the the board's position is on the
on the ban and our willingness to hear their recommendations for tools they would need to effectively um execute that we'll wait to hear from them on that is that what we're hearing is that what you heard too that is what i heard okay great yeah yeah in other years if there's
been an expense let's say twenty thousand dollars um that has not previously been budgeted for is that something that you've needed board approval for i would it would depend on what it is and where we take the money from where it comes from okay so there is a possibility if you
hear from the b team in the next couple of days that they're like i think we're on board with the underpouches we'd really like to be able to do that that you could by november 14th without our approval go forward with that i'm sure there's a way we could find that amount of money i'd have
to talk to kelly and get into the weeds on that but i mean if it were two hundred thousand dollars then no, but $20,000 we could find a way, and I would still let you know. So that's a good point. So is there anyone who, if the resounding opinion of the principals was that was the route they wanted to go,
is there anyone who feels strongly that we wouldn't want them to do that before we reconvened? All right, so I think you have a... So, my marching orders, as I understand them, are I will consult with B-Team about a procedure
that we would talk about whether or not we feel we need devices like yonder bags or new something. We will talk about that. We will certainly develop plans for an educational piece. And again, I want to reiterate, I always feel that it's important to be curious about and honor the work that's already happening.
So I'm going to start with really sussing that out and then finding where we should build upon that and the timing that would be optimal. I've heard that we should look into trying to find support for community businesses, from community businesses to help us either financially or with education or just in general.
We should try to figure out how we can build into the board's work plan for the remainder of the year. Some report back to you about how we are educating kids about devices and the dangers and the pitfalls and how we could build upon that.
And then I heard Steph's point about finding a way to monitor or assess pre and post. And I had not thought of that, but I think personally that's a great point. And I'm curious about, I also wonder if there's any data in that from the main youth health
survey. Anyway, we'll dig into this. That'll be an interesting one after all these bans go into place. I'm very sorry to bring this up now because I feel like you just put a bow on it and I'm about to tug. Another thing that they said in RIC1 is that they sort of unofficially instituted a staff
policy of also having the ballot belt. fan uh as a modeling device um and allowing students to report their teachers as uh accountability partners so um just maybe put out some fears on that i like that i mean you can have one of these
in like the teacher lounge right like they don't have to physically leave the building to access but you know during there okay good for the goose good for the gander is that what i'm hearing okay we do have a policy in place for staff but it's not about yes yeah yeah right they do have
a policy around cell phone yes tom i don't think this is a change to your marching orders but i just want to reiterate my point of like using that pre and post as a way of like continuing to listen to students and that we're listening so yeah yeah just on that i mean this is i guess
the English teacher in me, but like not, perhaps it's a more of a STEM data gathering exercise, but I was thinking of it also more narratively, like thinking of it in terms of like, is there a way for the is there a class for example, for the freshmen, where they could be doing like a writing assignment about that, that will be using that, so sort of again, sort of integrating it into to, again, my assumption is we probably have some learning goals
around organization of ideas, argument, right? Sort of like building that kind of structure in there. Again, I think that would be, again, I think that feels better also just as a pedagogical sort of approach to that. So, Steph, thank you for raising that. It's great. Okay, cross out number 12.
Not that it's never going to come back. It will be back, but Collins and Patience is at least somewhat satiated at this point. Okay, we do not have any new business on the agenda, but we do have organizational business. At the next board meeting, we will be talking about committees
because Maura has left the board and Karen has joined the board, so we'll look at committee assignments. But in the meantime, Maura was also the vice chair of the board, which we would like to get that spot taken care of tonight.
I don't know when we wait until, well, it's only nine. It's not bad for these things. So do we have any nominations or anyone interested in vice chair? jimmy was kind enough to flip the the policy around um duties of the chair and the vice chair
who was like making eye contact all right karen you're in i mean we did put karen next to me so we want to put poor karen right here at the front in morris spot so I appreciate that I want to do it okay I'll nominate Kelly you can second any other
nominations all right then do I have a motion for consideration and approval to appoint Kelly Sink as the vice chair for the RSU 5 board of directors to take effect immediately thank you Colin and Valerie all those in favor not opposed congratulations thank you
all right um personnel we don't have any as usual we've driven the public away um and uh i would take a motion to adjourn kelly and kara all those in favor great thank you guys
Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.
