RSU 5 Board of DirectorsWednesday 5 November 2025
Board meeting · 2 h 30 min · Watch on YouTube →
The summary is written by AI from a computer-made transcript, and it can be wrong. Each time links to that moment in the recording, so you can check it. A (?) after a name means the transcript does not make clear who was speaking.
Regular meeting of the RSU 5 Board of Directors held at Freeport High School. The board welcomed re-elected members Valerie, Kelly and Anna, new member Karen, and new student representative Maria Abadamarko; approved the October 22 minutes; and heard two public comments urging a bell-to-bell cell phone ban. Superintendent Tom Gray reported on staff vacancies, the early childhood task force and the state's 2028 pre-K mandate, strategic planning, and a budget workshop set for November 19 at Durham Community School. Department reports came from transportation (Jeremy), facilities (Glenn Reynolds) and Mast Landing School (Emily Grimm), whose chronic absenteeism figure fell to 3.65 percent last year. The main item was a long discussion of cell phones, pouch products and cost, ending in a motion instructing the policy committee to draft a bell-to-bell ban policy, which passed. Kelly Sink was appointed vice chair.
What was decided
- 0:00Approval of the minutes of the October 22 meeting as presentedpassed
- 1:49:53Instruct the policy committee to draft a cell phones and other personal electronic devices in schools policy executing a bell-to-bell ban in RSU 5; the chair announced at t=7234 that the motion passespassed
- 2:21:02Chair asked whether anyone objected to the superintendent purchasing pouches by the November 14 deadline if the principals recommended it; no objection was voiced and no vote was takenoutcome unclear
- 2:26:23Appoint Kelly Sink as vice chair of the RSU 5 Board of Directors, effective immediatelypassed
- 2:26:23Motion to adjournoutcome unclear
Votes on this board are weighted. Each director's vote counts in proportion to the population of the town they represent, so this page says only whether a motion passed, not how many voted for it. "Outcome unclear" means the recording does not state the result plainly. The software that turns speech into text can drop a "not".
Money discussed
- 1:02:17$35,000 Full cost quoted for Yonder phone pouches for all grade 6-12 students, including a discount.
Said: “the Yonder Bags, without any kind of grant or a special offer, are $35,000”
- 1:02:17$20,000 Reduced price for the same Yonder pouch order if a special offer or grant is obtained, with an order answer due November 14.
Said: “There's maybe a possibility of $20,000 with a grant”
- 1:07:36$80 Quoted price per base plate for the NewCase phone locking product.
Said: “it's 80 bucks a base plate and 20 bucks a thing”
- 1:07:36$20 Quoted price per individual NewCase phone case unit.
Said: “it's 80 bucks a base plate and 20 bucks a thing”
- 1:07:3613,000 Estimated district-wide cost of the NewCase product depending on quantity ordered.
Said: “it would be like 13,000 for the district depending on how many we got”
- 1:23:31$35 Charge RSU 1 students pay for a broken or lost pouch, with community service as an alternative.
Said: “if they break it or lose it, it's $35, or they can give two hours of community service”
- 1:28:41$35,000 Superintendent's comment on the largest pouch cost figure reported to him and the difficulty of finding it.
Said: “the largest number I saw there from Sam was $35,000”
- 2:10:44$5,000 Threshold discussed for whether a pouch purchase could be treated as a capital expense drawn from the capital reserve fund.
Said: “when you think that it's over $5,000 each individual one is less than $5,000”
- 2:21:02$20,000 Unbudgeted amount the superintendent said he could find by shifting money, while still informing the board.
Said: “but $20,000 we could find a way, and I would still let you know”
- 2:21:02two hundred thousand dollars Amount the superintendent said he could not absorb without board approval.
Said: “if it were two hundred thousand dollars then no”
Each amount is checked against the transcript. An item is kept only if the words quoted, and the amount, were said near that moment. Amounts are shown as they were said. The district's minutes are the official record. "Find in spending" opens a search of the district's monthly reports for related lines. Those reports name accounts, not companies, so the search shows where the money may sit, not the payment itself.
2 more mentions of money are left out, because their words could not be found in the transcript.
Worth knowing
- 5:19Open positions include 5.5 special education ed tech posts, two bus driver/custodian posts and a half-time custodian, with contracted services covering a teacher of the deaf, a speech-language pathologist and a one-to-one nurse; transportation is down three drivers.
- 30:57Mast Landing School's chronic absenteeism fell from 17.62 percent to 3.65 percent over three years; it stands at 6.05 percent so far this year with 46 school days completed.
- 1:02:17The Yonder special offer requires an order decision by November 14 and implementation by January 2026, a timeline the board doubts it can meet given policy first read in January and adoption no earlier than February.
- 2:05:38A board member objected to spending on pouches, saying the amount is roughly an ed tech salary and could instead go to staffing or curriculum; other members compared it to capital spending and suggested community fundraising.
What was discussed, in order
- 0:00Welcome, new members, minutes
The chair noted that Valerie, Kelly and Anna were re-elected the previous day, that Karen is the newest board member, and introduced new student representative Maria Abadamarko. Minutes of the October 22 meeting were moved and approved; no adjustments to the agenda.
- 0:00Student representative report
Maria Abadamarko reported on a November 18 field trip to St. Joseph's College for business and finance students, a Maine Medical mentor workshop, performances of 'Something Rotten' Friday through Sunday, trick-or-treating with mentees, anti-bullying activities in October, and chorus and band students qualifying for the District 3 Honors Music Festival in January. She said she and the other student rep will bring issues including the cell phone policy, bullying, hate speech, cafeteria sustainability and middle-to-high-school transition to the board. The chair added that the field hockey regional final was postponed for weather and that the girls cross-country team won a state championship.
- 0:00Public comment on cell phones
Annie Ware, representing the RSU 5 Alliance for Thoughtful Technology, urged the board to act swiftly on an all-day phone ban, citing an MSMA survey of 70 districts in which close to 90 percent were enacting or working toward an all-day ban, and offered help with fundraising for pouches. Kelly Delaney, a parent of three district students, spoke in full support of a bell-to-bell ban.
- 5:19Superintendent report: staff vacancies
Responding to a request from board member Danielle, Tom Gray listed 5.5 vacant special education ed tech positions (three at Morse Street School, 1.5 at Freeport High School, one at Freeport Middle School), two combined bus driver/custodian positions and a 0.5 custodian position. Contracted services are filling a teacher of the deaf for five hours a week, a speech-language pathologist for 30 hours a week and a one-to-one nurse.
- 10:21Early childhood task force
The task force met for the first time to understand the state mandate to provide child find and free appropriate public education to three- to five-year-olds by July 2028. Strengths identified include the existing early intervention team (occupational therapist, speech-language pathologist, early childhood special educator) and the fact that pre-K students with IEPs are already served by district staff. The hope is that by January the task force can bring the board options.
- 10:21Strategic planning update
The portrait of the graduate is close to complete and is expected to come to the board in December, after which a mission statement and core values will be developed, then action steps. A board member asked when the board weighs in; Tom Gray said the board will see the vision piece and that community input shapes the portrait.
- 10:21Budget process and November 19 workshop
Listening sessions were held in all schools and a staff survey was issued; the administrative team has reviewed the themes and began defining district-wide budget priorities such as professional development access, reasonable class sizes and resources for students with special needs. A special board budget workshop will be held at 5 p.m. on November 19 at Durham Community School, before the regular 6:30 meeting there.
- 15:30Retirement and hire
Bertha Hilton, kitchen manager at Freeport Middle School, has announced her retirement at the end of the year; the superintendent wrote a Forecaster article about her. Linda Duplessis has been hired as Morse Street School kitchen manager.
- 15:30Transportation report
Jeremy reported on 2024-25 goals: two buses, a van and a truck were disposed of, a comprehensive vehicle replacement timeline was developed with the finance director, and a new driver was hired although the district cancelled the summer job fair. The 2025-26 goals are a new safety and training schedule, a fleet maintenance recording system, and exploring scheduling methods for vans and buses for extracurricular and field trip requests.
- 20:34Transportation questions
Jeremy said no routes or trips have been cancelled, that the district is down three drivers across the combined towns, and that a state routing tool was tried but proved vague so the district kept its own method. He said RSU 5 is doing well compared with other districts he hears about cancelling routes and trips.
- 20:34Facilities report
Glenn Reynolds reviewed 2024-25 goals, including the articulated capital improvement plan built from the energy audit and comprehensive building assessment and the strategy for systematically replacing vehicles and equipment rather than waiting for failure. For 2025-26 the work continues through phases two, three and four.
- 25:42Building mapping and early childhood facility assessment
Glenn Reynolds described building mapping as a digital three-dimensional representation of buildings and systems, usable for facility management and by first responders. He also proposes bringing in a third-party group to assess buildings, HVAC and playgrounds for early childhood needs; he does not yet have cost figures. The superintendent said such a study supports long-term rather than year-to-year budget planning, and that DOE's earlier visit looked only at existing pre-K rooms and equipment.
- 30:57Mast Landing School report: chronic absenteeism
Emily Grimm reported chronic absenteeism fell to 3.65 percent at the end of last year, down from 6.3 percent at this point the prior year, and that Count Me In's executive director contacted the school after reviewing the state dashboard. She credited school-wide culture, Daily Mile, morning meeting, third and fifth grade buddies, and assistant principal Scott Emery's consistency in contacting families. She said the school is at 6.05 percent so far this year with only 46 days of school completed.
- 36:14RTIB supports and the teaching of reading
Emily Grimm described the SAIL self-regulation classroom staffed with an RTIB ed tech, modelled on the Bridges program in Durham. Revised reading units have been adopted at grades 3-5 with new vocabulary and, in third grade, phonics and morphology components; she said this year's third graders, the first cohort to have the K-2 refinements, show the strongest data she has seen in twelve years in the district. The school added a reading inventory and monthly reading celebrations, the first held on Halloween.
- 41:15Science, math and discussion of Mast Landing's approach
Asked about other subjects, Emily Grimm described second-year OpenSciEd implementation, a fifth grade ecosystems unit using adjacent woods, a third grade weather and STEM integration, and said math is awaiting the district curriculum review. Board members credited the assistant principal position and the 16 parent and caregiver group sessions; Tom Gray contrasted RSU 5's approach with consequence-based attendance practices elsewhere.
- 51:37Therapy dog
Asked about the therapy dog, Emily Grimm said Max makes a meaningful difference for some students, including one whose dysregulation he helps defuse, and that no students have allergy issues with him.
- 51:37MSMA conference reports
Board members who attended the MSMA conference in Augusta reported on sessions: Danielle (?) on a Gorham presentation about community and business partnerships for job shadowing and on an EPS/ED 279 budget session, Karen (?) on a finance session about a district with four business managers in five years, and another member on communication strategies, a free AI literacy program called Day of AI, and cell phone sessions. The board discussed offering new members a regular orientation on EPS and the ED 279, possibly through the finance committee.
- 1:02:17Cell phone pouch products and pricing
Tom Gray relayed pricing from Sam: Yonder bags at $35,000 for all grade 6-12 students including a 12 percent discount, with a possible special offer of $20,000, requiring an order answer by November 14 and implementation by January 2026. Reasons cited for Yonder included local use, flexibility and the ability to cut the bag open in an emergency; reasons against NewCase included hard plastic, difficulty opening and inability to hold smart glasses.
- 1:07:36Comparison of Yonder and NewCase
A board member reported NewCase has a three-year manufacturing defect warranty and priced it at about $80 per base plate and $20 per case, roughly $13,000 for the district, while Yonder's pin was described as the part that breaks most often and as potentially sharp. The board noted the Yonder grant requires implementation by January 2026, which may not be feasible.
- 1:12:51Whether to have a ban, and other implementation models
The chair steered the discussion back to whether the board wants a bell-to-bell ban before choosing a product. Tom Gray relayed feedback from colleagues in districts using Yonder that phones are effectively away even if not always in the bag; Maria questioned spending heavily on pouches and asked about lockers or bins, and members discussed off-and-away models such as Windham's and the problem of bathroom use.
- 1:18:13RSU 1 experience
A board member who attended a session with RSU 1 reported their legal counsel advised against a centralized collection point because of taking possession of personal property, that they use Yonder pouches with magnet tables staffed in the morning and handheld magnets at dismissal, and that consequences escalate from one-hour detention to suspension. RSU 1 reported a 50 percent reduction in suspensions and an increase in health center visits, and does not include earbuds in its restrictions.
- 1:23:31Policy versus procedure
Members agreed the policy should set direction without granular implementation detail, with the superintendent directed to develop procedure in tandem. Colin (?) said he supports a bell-to-bell ban but wants an educational and wellness initiative alongside it rather than just banning phones.
- 1:28:41Funding the pouches
Kara (?) asked about Yonder's funding guide and Title funds; Tom Gray said this year's Title projects are complete and it would have to be written in next spring, with uncertainty about federal grants. He said finding $35,000 would mean shifting money from elsewhere, and suggested a smaller initial purchase for repeat offenders as a way to start.
- 1:39:04Student perspective
Maria said she would not want to put her phone in a pouch, citing driver's ed, extracurriculars, and students who rely on texting parents about health problems, and suggested pouches only for repeat offenders. Board members responded that needing the phone is the reason for the ban, and discussed the education piece and alternative ways for students to reach parents.
- 1:44:25Evolution of policy and scope
Members noted a phone policy will change over time and that much will be figured out during implementation. The ban would apply to the middle and high schools, grades 6-12; smartwatches were urged for inclusion, and earbuds were raised because a phone in a pouch can still be operated through them.
- 1:49:53Motion to draft a bell-to-bell ban policy
On Tom Gray's suggestion, a motion was made and seconded to instruct the policy committee to draft a cell phones and other personal electronic devices in schools policy executing a bell-to-bell ban in RSU 5. Discussion followed about what bell-to-bell means for field trips, athletic travel and Region 10, and about medical exceptions such as diabetic pumps and 504 plans.
- 2:00:34Vote and timeline
The chair called the vote and announced the motion passes. The policy committee meets the next day and again in December, aiming for a first read in January and possible adoption in February, with the superintendent working with the principals' B team on procedure in parallel.
- 2:10:44Cost concerns and next steps
One board member said she opposes spending money on pouches that could fund ed techs or curriculum; others compared the sum to other capital spending and suggested capital reserve funds or community business sponsorship. Tom Gray summarised his marching orders: consult the B team on procedure and devices, develop the education piece building on existing work, seek community support, report back on digital citizenship instruction, and find a way to assess student experience before and after. A board member added that RSU 1 also applied the ban to staff as a modelling measure.
- 2:21:02Spending authority before November 14
Asked whether an unbudgeted $20,000 expense needs board approval, Tom Gray said it depends where the money comes from, that he could find $20,000 but not $200,000, and that he would tell the board. The chair asked if anyone objected to the superintendent proceeding by November 14 if the principals recommended the pouches; no objection was voiced.
- 2:26:23Vice chair appointment and adjournment
With Maura having left the board, a motion was made to appoint Kelly Sink as vice chair effective immediately; committee assignments will be taken up at the next meeting. The meeting then adjourned.
Financial reports for the period ending 30 September 2025
These are the district's most recent monthly reports dated at least two weeks before this meeting. They show each account's budget and what had been spent by 30 September 2025.
- Community Recreation/Adult Education
- General Budget Report
- Grant Reporting
- Report by Article
- Revenue Reporting
- School Nutrition
Every month's financial reports →
Elsewhere
Source & method
Regional School Unit 5: board meeting recordings on YouTube, and the agendas and minutes on rsu5.org
Each recording is turned into text by speech-recognition software and summarised by an AI language model. Every money item in a summary must quote words the speaker said, with the amount, and links to that moment in the recording. Agendas and minutes are the district's own files.
https://www.rsu5.org/board-of-directors-and-policies/board-agendas-and-minutes
Data as of 4 November 2026 (the date of the newest meeting listed); retrieved 19 November 2026.
