Skip to content

TranscriptRSU 5 board meeting, Wednesday 11 March 2026

Board meeting · 3 h 41 min · back to the summary · watch on YouTube →

Computer-made transcript, not a record of what was said. It mishears names and figures and drops short words, such as the "not" in "does not carry". Click a time to hear the recording, which settles any disagreement. The district's minutes are the official record.

32,384 words in 43 five-minute windows.

0:00

everybody wants me to be right in the front okay so we're gonna get started i just want to let folks know if they have the desire to speak at public comment we ask that you sign in i don't know where okay oh there erica uh there's a blue

sheet over there um and it'll help us go through the list hopefully a little in an expeditious way um okay we'll get started so good evening welcome to the rsu 5 board of directors it is wednesday march 11th 2026 and we are here at the freeport high school library anna and kelly are not going

to be with us tonight so this is this is the full crowd and we will get started with the pledge of allegiance okay so do i have a motion for consideration and approval of the minutes from the february 25th 2026 meeting as presented barring any errors or omissions karen and lois

thank you. All those in favor? None opposed. Great. All right. We're not adding any items, right? I do have an additional resignation. Oh, under eight though. Okay. So that's already in there. Okay. So we will get started with good news and recognition. Maria. So March is National

Youth Art Month and this is the annual observance each March to emphasize the value of art and education for all children and to encourage support for quality school art programs and so March 14th is the Scholastic Awards ceremony this

ceremony will be held in Portland High School there's the address but yeah Portland High School and this is just to honor people that are in high school and that love art and that are very good at it and the Congressional Art Awards is

5:10

five of the eight works selected from Maine's two representatives to Congress are from Freeport High School. We have Lila Abbott, Nina He, Jaden Schultz, Allie McGee, and Luana Senna. And the Portland Museum of Art Youth Art Month Exhibition.

Each year, Main Art Education Association. Member teachers select one piece of great artwork from their classmates to represent the creative efforts of their students. And this year, my good friend Allie McGee was selected, and she is representing Freeport High School. her art is in the portland museum of art it's really beautiful you should go check it out

um and just congratulations to all of the students who have worked really hard and have beautiful artwork in the hallways so yeah that's all thank you so five out of the eight for the state are from freeport that's incredible congratulations okay well thank you for that

okay so we will move on to public comment um i i didn't do this last time and i apologize usually when we have a large group for public comment I try to read our just some remarks and some ground rules before we get started I know a lot of folks here have have joined us at before but just just to be thank you just to be

complete so in order for us to hear from the largest number of different voices each speaker will be limited to three minutes Malik will have a timer are going so when you hear the I don't know which one she picked the ring she

picked go off I just ask that you try to wrap up your comments or wrap up your thought so we can hear hear from from the most folks for those who have not participated at our meetings before just a few ground rules ahead of time at the

outset we ask each speaker to identify themselves with their name and their town of residence we ask you to try and be brief and not repeat yourself we know discussion discussions of school related issues can be emotional but please

remember that our children are watching we are neighbors so we try to always be civil and kind we don't permit profanity or shouting but I don't think that's gonna be a problem this evening and certainly no comments that disparage or

attack individuals or groups of individuals speakers should direct all of their comments to the board this is the opportunity for the board to listen to the opinions of the public that relate to the school and the educational matters it is not a public debate nor a conversation so no questions should be

directed to the board but the board as the board will not be responding but we're here to listen we are not a we do not permit complaints allegations or specific comments about specific staff members these are personnel issues which

the board is not permitted to hear in public we do have a policy around that so if folks wanted to share anything they could go through that policy so that thank you I appreciate everyone's patience as I go through those those

ground rules this evening and we will get started with Marsha Webb so what I'll do is I'll put the I'll mention the next person up so that you can kind of cue up behind so Marsha will be first and then Aaron Abbott would be next hello

good evening board members again my name is Marsha Wood I'm currently a high school teacher here math teacher however I reside in Raymond just moved there but I've been a high school math teacher here for 13 years one of the longest math teachers here in the high school I also coach field hockey and

lacrosse and I'm here to express my concern regarding the potential reduction of a math position here at the high school so recently the math department was told by our administration that our PSAT scores and our SAT scores were a

little low and moving forward they're going to be an area of concern. So given this goal I kind of struggle to understand how reducing the number of quality math teachers would support improving these outcomes. So a recent

study from the Learning Policy Institute states that through interpersonal relationships teachers can attend to the social emotional development needs of of the students and when this happens the students are better positioned to engage in math

and their learning making them more successful so one of the reasons that our math scores may be low is that not all students enjoy math shocking i know i know and many of them lack their confidence in their skills and their abilities but building strong connections

with students can help them feel more confident and more comfortable in the classroom which in turn can improve their confidence. So, as these students have a more positive mindset, when they sit down to take those PSATs and those SATs, they're, instead of giving up on those harder

10:12

problems, they now have the more confidence in their abilities. So, they're going to try the harder problems. They're going to try to persevere through that. They're feeling better about their math skills. They may not love math. You know, I'm not here to make them love it. I make, we're here

to make them tolerate it sometimes. So hopefully this would improve our math scores. In the 13 years here, it's very rare that we have found such a quality teacher that is so involved in this school and all the different aspects of it in such a short time here. This person in this position goes above and beyond her duties as a math teacher by being our department chair in just her third year here. Math team coach, working summer school, homework center, mentor coordinator, math curriculum on the math curriculum committee jv softball coach and starting a crochet club as a

volunteer but what is most important is the fact that she can relate and teach kids and get them excited or like i said at least tolerate math part of our strategic plan is about making connections and i really would think that someone that can connect and educate all levels of students from

the honors and the ap kiddos to the students receiving special education plans would want to retained it's rare that we can find such a quality teacher that fits all of the realms of what it means to be a highly effective teacher with this potential cut we would lose one of the

best things that have ever happened in our math department and while i would really hate to see that happen it would be such a loss for our department but even more so to our fhs students thank you for your consideration thank you marcia aaron and then after aaron haley could speak good

evening school board members. My name is Erin Abbott. I currently live in Yarmouth. I have been a math teacher for 20 years, eight of those at Freeport High School. I am here to express my deep concern regarding the proposed elimination of a math teaching position at the high school

and the immediate and long-term impact this decision would have on our students. Our department was recently informed that our standardized test scores in math have fallen below the state average for Maine. If our district is committed to improving student achievement in mathematics,

eliminating a math position moves us in the opposite direction. Reducing staff will inevitably increase class sizes, limit individualized support, and make it more difficult to address the very concerns we are being asked to improve. The position currently under consideration is held

by a young, enthusiastic teacher with an exceptional mathematical mind and a remarkable ability to connect with all students. She has been highly successful in building strong relationships with students across the spectrum, from AP courses to intervention classes. She collaborates

seamlessly with our ELL and special education departments to ensure every student has the tools and support needed to succeed. Perhaps most importantly, she has sparked genuine excitement about math and computer programming. Subjects that do not typically generate enthusiasm.

It has been incredible to see our students happy to attend math class. Beyond academic growth, their confidence in their mathematical abilities has increased, their overall mental health has improved and many have developed a new interest in pursuing math related careers in fields of study

after graduation. At a time when we are striving to raise achievement and support students in well-being, removing a dedicated and highly effective math educator would be a significant setback in both now and in the future. I strongly urge the board to reconsider this proposal and to

prioritize investments that directly support student learning and success for all of RSU 5. Thank you for your time and your consideration. Thank you, Erin. So after Haley, I have Lisa Blair. Hello, I'm Haley Goodspeed. I'm a Freeport resident. I'm here to urge you to reconsider

the proposed reduction of a math teaching position here at the high school. While I understand the complexity of budget decisions, this particular cut conflicts directly with the values outlined in our district's strategic plan, the emerging strategic plan.

Though still in dry form, the plan was shaped by extensive community input, students, families, educators, and community members. It reflects who we are and what we value. Belonging, opportunity, strong relationships, relevant learning, and equitable access.

15:14

I speak not only as a teacher, but as a member of the Strategic Planning Committee since its inception. I have seen firsthand how intentionally this work has been grounded in community voice and data. After 12 years teaching in RSU 5 and choosing to raise my family here,

I am deeply invested both professionally and personally in the long-term strength of this district. The teacher affected by this proposed elimination is an exceptional educator, as you've heard. She engages students across the full spectrum of learners, as you've heard,

ensuring meaningful growth for all. Unfortunately, without her, we're likely not going to be able to offer our computer programming program anymore, which has been a long-standing cornerstone of our STEM program since well

before I started teaching here. In that class, students who don't always see themselves reflected in other traditional social spaces, they find a community of like-minded peers, a place where curiosity and intellectual passion are celebrated. This course exemplifies our commitment to inclusive learning environments

where every student can discover and confidently pursue their passions. She also provides something we can't quantify but deeply need. Visible female representation in STEM. Representation matters. When students see someone who reflects their identity, thriving in advanced mathematics and technology, they are more likely to envision themselves in those fields. Her presence directly supports our commitment to diverse perspectives and belonging. Her impact extends beyond the classroom. As a department chair, I'm also a

department chair, so I sit in a lot of meetings with her. She shares research-based practices while completing her master's in education and has led efforts to reimagine the math curriculum through inquiry-based learning. She prioritizes critical thinking, problem-solving, and deep

conceptual understanding. Skills essential for the 21st century. In doing so, she strengthens the entire department and embodies our strategic plan's emphasis on innovation, collaboration, and relevance. As a district, we have intentionally invested in early career educators to strengthen long-term

retention. When we lose talented young educators, we undermine that investment. Sustainable excellence requires strategic retention, not short-term contraction. Finally, this proposed cut will increase class sizes everywhere, making responsive instruction

and meaningful relationships more difficult to sustain. Our strategic plan emphasizes belonging, agency, cognitive growth, real-world relevance, and inclusive culture. Eliminating this position works against each of those pillars. I'll skip through the rest. I respectfully ask that you consider not only the financial implications, but the long-term academic and cultural costs to our students in our district.

Thank you for your consideration and everything you do for our district. Thank you, Harry. Move that down for Lisa. Thank you. After Lisa, I have Jill Hyland. Okay. Good evening. My name is Lisa Blyer. I'm transitioning to talk about another proposed cut, and I'm an English

teacher, an alternative ed teacher. I've been teaching for almost 30 years. I've been at Freeport High School for 15 years now, and I have had the privilege of working alongside our community outreach coordinator. The proposal to cut this essential position in half is deeply

concerning and truly reflects a grave misunderstanding of both its scope and its impact. This position supports students, families, staff, administrators, really the entire RSU 5 community. Freeport High School's strategic plan, as Haley had spoken about, is to empower all

students to learn and grow. And a core pillar of this vision is community connections. That is one of our distinct goals at Freeport High School. And it commits us to, and I quote directly from the strategic plan, fostering and maintaining relationships with local businesses,

organizations, and community members in order to strengthen student engagement, student support, and learning through extended opportunities. A genuine commitment to community connection requires a full-time community outreach coordinator. Reducing this position sends a

clear message that this is not a priority. This position has a wide-reaching impact on students, a variety of students, supporting students pursuing job shadows, matching students with professionals, whether it's architects, engineers, supporting students who are more interested in

hands-on learning and skilled trades through field trips, guest speakers, career exploration, and it reaches students who have not yet figured out post-secondary goals and serves as a bridge to those opportunities beyond high school. Through this position, I have had first-hand experience with the person in this position

20:20

bringing noted main authors such as Lily King, Lewis Robinson, Monica Wood, to our creative writing classes. For at-risk students, this position has helped those who may feel disconnected find engaging opportunities and mentorship to support their success, from bringing Vietnam

veterans into classrooms, connecting students to post-secondary programs, and arranging career exploration in a variety of fields, from boat building to heating and plumbing, farming, animal rescue, cosmetology. Through this position, students find jobs, and students find future careers.

Reducing this position would weaken a vital support system, one that directly impacts student success, community engagement, and the culture of Freeport High School. These opportunities are part of what makes Freeport High School special.

And I know that as someone who has taught in other schools, this is unique. A place where families want to send their children, and RSV5 is a community where people want to live with this full-time position held intact. I urge the board to reconsider this proposed cut, fully preserve this position.

I also have sent an email that goes further into detail about what the roles and responsibilities are, if only scratched the surface in these three minutes, and most importantly, the impact of this full-time position. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Lisa. So after Joe, I have Taylor Dombruski.

Hey. Good evening. My name is Jill Highland. I live in Brunswick and work at Freeport High School. I'm here tonight as an ESOL educator and as an advocate for the multilingual students of RSU-5. This fall, I stood before the board when the district revised and approved its Lau plan,

a policy created to ensure that RSU-5 meets its legal obligations to multilingual learners. Tonight, I am asking the board to remember that those commitments are not optional. They are grounded in federal law and in the Supreme Court decision in Lau v. Nichols.

which makes clear that schools must do more than provide the same instruction. They must ensure multilingual learners can actually access it. The proposed budget includes the reduction of a full-time ESOL position across the district.

Our team is asking to maintain three educators across two and a half positions, not to expand the program, but to preserve the minimum staffing necessary to deliver the services outlined in the LOW plan and to remain in compliance with state and federal expectations.

The number of multilingual students in RSU-5 has not declined. We are serving essentially the same number of students this year as last year, and we continue to provide services in five of the six schools in the district.

With three educators, the program is proactive, collaborative, and aligned with our allow plan. With two educators covering five buildings, pre-K to 12, our program becomes reactive, inconsistent, and stretched beyond what is educationally sound or legally defensible.

As the district expands programming for three- and four-year-olds, these service needs will only grow. The reduction would force services into a primarily pull-out model, directly contradicting our own mile plan, which states that programs must minimize the isolation of multilingual learners from their peers whenever possible.

Guidance from the Department of Education states that multilingual learners must receive language support that allows them to meaningfully access grade-level curriculum, with language development and content learning happening at the same time.

Instruction must be delivered by an endorsed ESOL teacher. It cannot be replaced by MTSS or RTI. Language is not a disability. There was a comment that perhaps we've worked ourselves out of a job. In reality, we have done exactly what you asked us to do. We have provided and built independence through consistent, structured support.

At the high school level alone, this cut eliminates dedicated language classes. It eliminates co-teaching. It limits collaboration, and it replaces a structured, research-based program with generalized support that no longer meets the expectations outlined in our allow plan.

For the past four years, multilingual students in RSU-5 have graduated, gone on to college, because they had continuity, structured language instruction, and trusted adults guiding them through complex academic language tasks.

25:24

Annuity matters, relationships matter, stability matters, and the law matters. Our multilingual learners depend on us to make decisions that protect their rights to meaningful access to education. I want to be clear. I'm not here to protect my position. I have my resume ready. I'm going to land on my feet. These kids don't have that same luxury.

They are depending on you to make this choice and protect their access for education. I ask the board to honor your commitments that you made in the fall with our new law plan. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Jill. Thank you.

And after Taylor, we'll have Sarah Davis. Thank you. Hello, members of the RSU 5 board and community members. My name is Taylor Dombroski. I'm a sixth grade student here at the Freeport Middle School. Last week, I was notified that French and world cultures may be removed from the curriculum at the middle school due to budget cuts.

When I heard this, I knew I had to take immediate action to try and preserve this important subject. So that's why I'm standing before you today. French is a foreign language that is the fifth most spoken language in the world.

In fact, 28 countries speak French and over 320 million people. Learning this language means so much to me, especially as I believe that our world is a better place when we have a broader understanding of foreign cultures.

In trimester one, I was in world cultures and found I was learning more than just a language. I was learning culture, history, traditions, geography, and art, and so much more I could list on for days. If we lose French as a subject, this means Freeport Middle School students will lose the opportunity not only to learn a language, but also culture and history.

Many Mainers speak French, and not to mention, so do our neighbors in Canada. I want to go to a school that values creating opportunities, not taking them away. My point is, French is a language kids should discover at a young age and have the choice to continue to learn through high school and beyond.

Our French teacher is a wonderful teacher who teaches amazingly. She's inspired me to want to learn more about the world around me. We are lucky to have her in our school, and I hope we can find a way to keep her in this subject. I'm strongly requesting that the school board reconsider the proposal that removes French from our middle school curriculum. There must be another way to find money in the budget than to cancel an opportunity for kids to learn about foreign culture.

Thank you for your time. Thank you, Taylor. After Sarah, we have Jim Donahue. Wow, that was amazing. Thank you, Taylor. My name is Sarah Davis. I live in Auburn, and I teach French and World Cultures in grades 6 through 8 at Freeport Middle School, and I want to keep my comments brief. I'm obviously devastated by the decision of the administrative team to cut French at Freeport Middle School. I worry that future budget proposals will continue to carve away at world language programs in the RSU. French is the most widely spoken language in Maine after English,

and Maine has a rich francophone or French-speaking culture. Ironically, March is the month of la francophonie, celebrating the fact that there are over 321 million French speakers worldwide across five continents. The main reason I'm speaking here tonight is to thank all the wonderful people I have worked with over the past two decades at FMS. I have been privileged to work with so many amazing colleagues

and cherished students during that time. And so I just want to say thank you so much for enriching my life. Merci, gracias. I'd also like to ask that you reconsider cutting the ed tech positions. At FMS, we're stretched pretty thin. At the middle school, in terms of support staff and individuals whose jobs might be eliminated are extremely effective teachers, and their elimination would be a great loss to the community. So thank you so much. Thank you, Sarah. After Jim, I have Jenna Hsu.

Good evening. My name is Jim Donahue. I recently retired after 35 years at Pano School as the PE teacher, soccer coach, baseball coach, softball coach. I was a guidance counselor, the athletic director, and, yes, I even drove the school bus. Since retirement, I've had a wonderful opportunity

30:33

to assist with the ice skating program as well as the cross-country ski program with my son Trevor with the fourth and fifth graders. I've always maintained that Poundell Elementary School, and this is my strong opinion, particularly when it was K through eight, I always felt that that's

the way all children's education should be. During these kindergarten and first grade skating programs, I always make a point of introducing myself, and I always ask the parents about how their children's experience is here at Poundell. And without exception, these parents are just so

enthusiastic and so proud of what's happening for their children at Poundell School. Poundell's school experience, the pre-K through fifth grade school experience includes the ability to establish long-term, often lifetime personal relationships with classmates. We don't have this at other schools, particularly when we were K-8, children would know each

other for eight, nine years. They would establish relationships with teachers, with the bus driver, with the lunch lady. And again, this is very unique to a school. At Poundell School, the fifth graders have an opportunity to mentor the kindergartners in the classroom as well as on the playground.

Poundell School is a perfect environment for outdoor learning. The PE program that utilizes the outdoors with snowshoeing, cross-country skiing, ice skating, canoeing, and other activities, as well as swim lessons at the YMCA.

I believe these kinds of experiences make Poundell a truly special place. In the past three years, unfortunately, I have been to a number of former students or former students' funerals or celebrations of life. Many of these ex-students are 40, 50, 55 years old, and they always make a point of touching base with me.

And I can't tell you how many times they look back at their experience at Pono School in a positive light. Um, and I'll finish up with this, excuse me. I am so fortunate to have taught at Pownall School over the years. It is truly the center of the Pownall community and sending the grade 3 through 5 students off to another school

would be a disservice to the children of Pownall as well as a disservice to the wonderful town of Pownall. Thank you for giving me this time. Thank you, Jim. After Jenna, I have Andy Seymour. Hi, everyone. My name is Jenna Hsu and I live in Pownall. I have a young daughter who will one day attend RSU-5 schools.

So I just want to thank the board and superintendent for opening up a dialogue with our community to plan for the future. I think when community is involved in solving problems, the outcomes are always better, especially for children. And I have been spending some time researching the early childhood special education mandate

because the question I've heard coming up again and again is, where do we put the three-year-olds with IEPs? There's concern there's no space for the three-year-olds, and there's timing pressure of the upcoming mandate. These two factors also were framed as one of the primary drivers for the need to do a facility study sooner than later. So, again, the question still remains, where do we put the three-year-olds with IEPs? And I know that this board has discussed this too, but I just want to resurface that the Maine Department of Education is also trying to help us answer this, and they discuss implementing what's called a mixed delivery system.

So what does that mean? So a mixed delivery system is a system that allows us to partner with other child care facilities and licensed child care providers to support any overflow for children that have IEPs that are three years old that the current facilities can't support. So again, I know it was discussed, I think, in the February 11th meeting about this,

and one of the board members asked what it would look like to partner with community providers if that's a feasible solution to the space problem. And then the superintendent, you answered that it was discussed with the Early Childhood Task Force and confirmed it was possible,

35:37

but you mentioned it wasn't ideal and it was better to do it within our own facility. But I wasn't quite sure about, like, who that's better for, what's that better for, and I just think kids that are three years old that have a disability who need individual education programs

that need to be served in the least restrictive environment possible, I question, like, if putting them through to a facility that we have as a three-year-old is always the best solution versus, like, at-home care and, you know, individualized support.

So I do definitely respect the perspective that one dedicated facility could be really great as well once all the foundation is set up. But the DOE published guidance in December, specifically designed to address these concerns from many other districts.

And even my daughter's daycare, they're already getting up to speed on how they can actually better position themselves to accept students with IEPs. So really the question is whether the mandate here requires us to create more facilities

to support these three-year-olds. And based on the main DOE's answer is that it does not necessarily require this. And then two, one of the things I was researching is that six hours per week is the minimum full-time requirement to support three-year-olds with IEPs per week. I'm not saying you'd ever want

to strive for the bare minimum to support these children, but just to be clear that this mandate is not a full-time requirement for three-year-olds with IEPs. So I guess my next thought is that I just was like thinking about if it's been discussed a lot around, I know I can't ask questions, but just

like thinking about the process, I think I feel like I'm missing information about if we've talked about a mixed delivery system and what that might entail um i know this whole this whole mandate is is amazing for children but i it's going to be a huge administrative toll um to keep up with all

the requirements the doe is publishing training tutorials multi you know every few weeks there's new information all the time um lastly another point i want to make is that i want to confirm when this mandate is happening for a district so i know in the planning for futures proposal

on February 11th. It was listed in that document that the mandate deadline was July 2027, and then there was an article put forward recently in the Portland Press-Herald that was written that deadline was actually July 2028. So if the 2020 deadline in July is accurate

for this mandate, for us to start applying this mandate, then we've been given the extra time, a gift of a year, and there's definitely, I think, a lot of good roadmap and resources from the state and our surrounding towns who are of course trying to figure this out together so I'm just

wondering yeah if the just thinking about the the funding of a major facility study and appropriating up to a hundred thousand dollars for that if there might also be a need to start hiring a consultant or something to start supporting our district focusing more on how

we might make this work for the kids might be really interesting because again like these are individual education programs that need to be working best for the individual, not necessarily best for administrative burden. So lastly, I do agree that a facility study can also and probably

will be really important for this and for moving our district forward for the future and for like improved capital asset planning management, all of that good stuff. But based on DOE's guidance, the mandate for supporting early childhood education for students with disabilities does

not seem to require us to come up with more space and i think that's a really important fact for the community and the board to understand in our planning so thank you for your time i really appreciate it thank you jenna after andy i have rick wilson uh hi everybody uh andy seymour i'm

from paunal um before you go i'll shrug and sigh and say oh no another paunal angry resident i come with invitations tonight so it's going to be positive i apologize for the sunglasses i got an eye injury i'm not going to sing sunglasses at night but if you make a motion

and second it not totally against it but um i went i uh i moved to panel because um i grew up in a small town i want to live in a small town i saw people starting dairy farms i saw people starting farms and farm stores and all the rural things there's open spaces and i wanted

to participate in that um i also the uh the nine-year-old woman that runs the gas station refused to put card readers on the gas um machines so people would actually come in the store and have conversations with each other so what i uh noticed was that mindset coalesces uh at the

40:44

school and there's a lot of uh intangibles that make panel uh unique which uh mr d talked about a lot today and my modest dream went in town was to create a sugar shack so it's sugar shack season and vows bend to the sugar shack if you need an endorsement of that so um the first year ever to

have a pes sugar shack field trip was the year my son was in kindergarten and this year my younger son will be in kindergarten and i've made the commitment to always um to the the lovely and perfect kate dawson that will always have pes kindergarten sugar shack tours and um that's

coming up next Friday. Tom, I will send you and everyone an invite to that. So I'm hoping you will all show up. I also learned we have poetry enthusiasts on the board. Is that true or not true? So I brought a little something that I'd like to read. And I think a theme

we had a couple weeks ago was pedantic. Let's try not to be pedantic about the spelling, please. These are five-year-olds. But I wanted to share with you if I could. Dear Andy, Heather, and Maple. Maple's the yellow lab, if anyone's interested. They're original, I know. Sticky, sticky syrup that tastes so sweet. You are fun to make, and you are more fun to eat. Thank you for the syrup, and the visit, and everything. Love, all the kids, and Mrs. Dawson. So, maybe next time, we could call maybe you could help workshop the next poem next friday so tom i'll send you the

invite everyone's invited i want to i want to share why the uh the intangible things let's make them more tangible so you can understand what makes pound a special place thank you thank you so after rick i have kate martins good evening my name is rick wilson i'm the

Community Outreach Extended Learning Coordinator at Brunswick High School, and I'm speaking from both professional experience and personal conviction about the value of maintaining a full-time community outreach coordinator at Freeport High School. First, I want to acknowledge the district's

vision, because years ago, RSU 5 created this full-time position, and that decision has positively impacted the lives of thousands of students. I'm encouraging the board to once again show that same visionary leadership by keeping this role full-time central to the vision is the community

outreach coordinator and your community outreach coordinator has served with incredible distinction being a model creating a model program when I was creating a Brunswick's program I looked to here. Your coordinator is a collaborator statewide, has an amazing amount of respect

from everybody. And if she wasn't so, they were not so humble, we would have packed the place tonight with various colleagues that feel the same way that I do. And I know you've received some emails today, and one for me as well. I think of their impact as much like a 5-2

player in baseball. In baseball, coaches talk about the rare value of a 5-2 player, someone who can hit for average, hit for power, run, field, and throw. They impact every part of the game. A 5-2 player doesn't just fill a position, they influence outcomes in ways

you often can't predict. That's the impact that a community outreach coordinator makes. And that's the impact this community coordinator makes every day in Freeport. Across Maine, more than 75 schools have community outreach professionals doing this work.

None of these positions are part-time, and I don't know how it can be part-time. Community outreach coordinators are especially valuable because of how interconnected their work is. When they help a student find a meaningful opportunity, that improves engagement, it improves attendance, and purpose.

When they build partnerships in the community, those opportunities open doors for other teachers and programs. When they support a struggling student, they help keep that student connected to school. Reducing this role to half-time doesn't simply reduce hours.

45:47

it reduces relationships opportunities and access for students in baseball when you have a five to a player you don't take them off the field for half the game you keep them in the lineup because they make everyone around them better please don't reduce the momentum of a program and partnerships that took years

to build I urge you to consider not just a line item but the long-term impact on the students and on the Freeport community thank you thank you so after Kate, I have Jack Brogan. Hi, my name is Kate Martins. I'm from Pauno. Together with a group of

parents who have evaluated Proposal 2 through the lens of educational policy, I've looked at a range of studies on outcomes of rural school dissolution. We were overwhelmed by the research. In study after study, the results were consistent. Closing community schools is bad for students. I want to

briefly address the term dissolution. I realize that if scenario two moves forward, Paunel will still have a school, but it will not be the school that Paunel community members are fighting for. It will not be the place where teachers have created a cohesive, vertically aligned,

seven-year-long curriculum for our children. If scenario two is enacted, the town's youngest students will go to school in Paunel, but they will only make up about 10 percent of the children who attend the program. After one year, or possibly two if they qualify, they'll leave,

like every child in the school. After making the transition into the EC program, these five or six year olds from across the district will face another unnecessary transition. This doesn't sound like best practice. In addition to looking at academic research, our group also sought to

understand the stated goals of RSU-5, so we examined the official documents prepared and published in 2008. This body of documents laid the groundwork for RSU-5's official formation in 2009 and remains crucial today. In the reorganization plan document, page two presents the primary goal

of RSU-5's formation, which is, quote, to enhance and improve learning and teaching opportunities across the three communities, end quote. I feel it is the responsibility of this board to respect and protect this goal. On pages 26 and 27, the wording is precise. Quote, the new RSU board

should view the different schools as resources that may help to personalize the education of students. In general, decisions of placement of students in a school within the RSU should be based upon what is best educationally for the child. End quote. Later in that same document,

two of the five bullet points on the, quote, establishment of attendance areas, end quote, were in direct conflict with scenario two. These points are three, maintaining established neighborhood groupings, and four, transportation efficiencies. It is impossible to argue that

scenario two, if enacted, would, quote, enhance and improve learning opportunities, end quote, for panel students. If PES students are bused to and absorbed into existing classes at Durham community school, the result would yield more time spent on buses and less favorable student-to-teacher

ratios in classrooms. These are measurable, factual inputs, and they contradict the stated objectives and scope of RSU-5's founding principles. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Kate and Jack. And that was the last person I had on the list, so is that still accurate? My name is Jack Brogan,

and I'm a senior here at the high school. I'm here to talk about the cut of one of the math positions at the high school. I'd like to preface that I'm not just here to complain. I actually really want to thank Superintendent Gray for coming to RSC5. I've actually saw you at more games this fall than I ever saw some of your predecessors,

so that was great. But I've looked at the budget cut tiers, and it seems to me, Superintendent and the board have settled on a narrative that a shrinking student body justifies shrinking the core staff to students. I think that's a convenient but sterile way to look at a school. Instead of cut, cut, cut, we need to be honest about why that enrollment is dropping so fast. And it's dropping because families are choosing other options. An option my family chose was four years ago when we chose to move back to Freeport because it was home.

We left Portland because the schools there were a mess and we came here for the stability of the standard this district represents. But I have to be honest, the over 10% enrollment drop cannot be due only to the housing crisis that exists in other school districts and across this whole state.

50:49

I think some families are leaving because they've lost confidence in the day-to-day experience here. They're packing up and choosing to go to private schools like Chevers and Wainfleet that are sometimes nearly an hour commute.

And every time you propose to cut a core staff member who is vital to both the planning and teaching part of this building, you may be giving another family one more reason to pack up, accelerating the exact decline you're using to justify these cuts.

I had FHS Math 1.0 from Geometry my first year here. I didn't go into her room as a math person by any means, and I'm still not. This is a quote and contest. she turned a graduation requirement into a place where students and a lot of whom were not math

people actually engaged she doesn't just process a curriculum she genuinely teaches she runs the freshman mentor program she coaches and she even started a crochet club she does the invisible essential work that keeps us building from falling apart every year on the first day of school the

senior class sits through a graduation slideshow an advisor during the first day of school when you want to go out and enjoy with your friends you sit there in the f-pack and listen to the talk of one day everyone who starts here will graduate here and one day we will reach that 100% graduation

rate. But I think that goal starts to feel hollow if the people in this room that are pushing that idea are also deciding to gut the staff that actually build and sustain it. Maybe that sounds harsh, but I really don't know how else to put it. Regardless, on June 13th, the class of 2026

will be on the stage at Merrill Auditorium. The teacher, FHS Math 1.0, will be there with us too, regardless of what happens watching the students she taught including myself walk across i hope you'll all be there too it's a pretty good setting to see the result of your priorities

when you're sitting there in june watching the class of 2026 graduate you'll be looking at students who made it through in part because of the teacher you're currently choosing to cut i just hope you find that view as impressive as i do thank you thank you jack okay um all right so

we will move on to uh well first i want just want to take a moment to say thank you for everyone who came and spoke. I know that's not always the easiest, and I know folks have important things and families, and so I appreciate everyone taking the time, and obviously also the emails we

receive. Thank you. Thank you for the public comment. All right, so continuing with our agenda, item eight, report from the superintendent. So I have two resignations to report tonight. One is listed on the agenda. That's Amy Broadbent from Laugh and Learn Before Care, and then also

not on the agenda Erica Mazao the assistant superintendent of curriculum instruction and assessment has tendered her resignation effective the end of the school year okay so that will prompt a search and we'll hear more about that

yes okay all right so we will move on we do not have any administrator reports board committee reports policy this evening we'll move right into item 12 which is unfinished business for the budgets okay so I have some remarks

tonight to kind of frame the ongoing discussion that we're going to have around the budget and the audience has left some of the audience I had actually Actually, I had looked forward to a chance to talk to, to sort of have present for this discussion

some of the staff members who have offered perspective. And I think I want to say, again, I said last meeting, I write remarks and I kind of like 50% follow them, so I'm not on script at the moment. And I don't think that I heard any invalid comments

from the staff. I heard comments that strongly reflect that perspective and those are valid. But as we continue the discussion, what I'd like to return to is a theme that I drew out in previous meetings and to try to connect some dots over the course of time of the discussions we've had because I think that that's an important lens. In fact, for me, it's the most important lens through which to view the entire conundrum we're facing and that is that it is very easy to get to focus on the reductions that are right in front of you.

Every reduction actually represents hours of discussion about what are we keeping and how are we finding the proposal to reduce that is the least impact to kids. And that's true for every one of the recommendations that's in the 8% tier,

56:07

the 7% tier, the 6% tier. All of those represent discussions from as many angles as we could think of on the team about, we have criteria by which to shape this discussion, largely informed by staff feedback early in the year. Where do we, how do we get to 7%, 8%, 6%? Those represent our insight about what

is the least impact on kids. None of them were developed casually or lightly. They also, I can assure you, are all sound proposals from the perspective of our legal obligations, every single one of them. They reflect very careful consideration about where reductions might occur in order to

really sustain the core experiences that matter the most. And that is not to say that everything on the table doesn't have value in itself. It's just that if everything is a priority, nothing is a priority. That's really where we are. If everything is a priority, then nothing

is a priority, and we have to make choices. So later this evening, I'm going to share some information that helps illustrate what those preserved programs and opportunities look like Kelly has actually passed something out that we've

developed since the packet was and we can turn our attention to that in a bit but that's in an effort to demonstrate what we will be preserving even if we make reductions I will also be able to share some thinking about what a budget

that's somewhere between the first and second tier looks like because I've heard some requests from board members of what what we would do to get there so I can talk about that. With that stated, I will say plainly, I still recommend the 7% tier,

largely because of what I showed you at the last board meeting about where it goes over the long term. I don't know if that looks familiar, but another connection that I'd like to draw as we talk about this further is just where next year's budget fits into the conversations

that have now been started about sustainability beyond next year. And I have to admit that as I worked with Ginny to sort of plan out this, I thought about, I was a high school history teacher, how am I going to plan this unit? Where are we going to start, and where are we going to arc, and where are we going to end? Definitely purposefully structured. This is how I would have structured a unit in a high school class because there is a theme, and I'm going to develop that theme more explicitly now.

It's been somewhat implicit, and tonight it's going to become more and more explicit. And the theme is basically whatever we do with this year's budget is our launching pad for wherever we go next. And I don't think we can lose sight of that.

So over the past couple of meetings, I've shared some scenarios that look at how we might position this district for long-term sustainability. I, and we have used the term long-term sustainability, I would actually argue that the ideas that I've presented are really medium-term.

ideas. They're not actually long-term ideas. The things that we've talked about now are the things that we'll need to have a solution for within a number of school years that you can count on one hand. But there's also the two-hand stuff that we really have to be thinking about now. For example,

we've alluded to some of these, but we haven't really put them on the table yet. How long can we really realistically expect all of our facilities to hold up before we have to make a major investment. Moore Street comes to mind right away. I don't think Moore Street's going to

keel over right now, but I would bet sometime within this many years, we're going to have to do something about Moore Street. That's just a guess, but I think it's a good guess. Is there a point where the discussion about middle school, I think one of the, as I listened after I put some

ideas out there for discussion, one thing that seems to resonate loudly with many, many people is middle school integration, and I'm also hearing integrating all the middle schools at seventh grade is probably good, but sixth grade is even better. I don't think we get to sixth grade without

some kind of major investment, a facilities investment. Freeport Middle School cannot house six, seven, and eight from the whole district, even if we wanted to do that, and I don't know that we want to, but we couldn't right now. We don't have a solution for that. Another thing that

1:01:12

we have to think about and that, in fact, I was just discussing today with the Freeport town manager is our vehicle fleet. We do not have, and this district has not had a good solution for how to house and repair the vehicle fleet for quite some time. Now, has that risen with the

imminent issues that we are discussing? Has that risen to the top of the list? Absolutely not. We're sharing a facility with the town of Freeport. We don't actually have an MOU to do it. we pay I think $13,000 a year to share that facility. It doesn't have a lift if we need to

fix a bus so we have to outsource it. It really isn't enough space and what Sophie's comment to me was is that we are getting to the point of bursting at the seams. We'll need a solution for that at some point. So those are some very concrete like literally brick and mortar things

to think about with long-term sustainability. But it's really more than that. That's where my thinking starts. Sustainability is really about our people, because that's what schools are really all about, both from the perspective of the kids in the schools and the adults in the schools.

So just to kind of circle back to an original point, we know that one of the biggest reasons why we're facing a cliff right now is because wages, salaries, and benefits are going to go up substantially next year due to contractual obligations. And I said it then, and I'll say it

again, that that's actually a good thing for this district. We need to be a district that pays people well and competitively so that we are attracting and keeping the best people in an environment where the districts around us are certainly adopting that mindset. That's extremely important. So yes,

we have a decision to make around how we cope with that, but I do think if I look back at I wasn't part of previous negotiations, I think that was a good investment in the district. There is a flip side to it, and that is that if we want to have competitive compensation for our staff,

we cannot necessarily maintain every position if we're coming up against it. We cannot necessarily prioritize both things. There have to be choices, and the choices are yours, not mine, but that is a lens through which I'm seeing it, especially in the environment in which we now live. If we look

at this through a broad district-wide lens, but also a short-term versus long-term lens, which is again one of the classic ethical dilemmas that I've talked about in the past, we should be looking to be able to ensure that our people are compensated fairly and competitively, and we have to weigh

that against what positions we preserve. And we shouldn't be wanton or careless in striking that balance, but there is a balance to be struck. This also does not mean, and I want to be careful in the way I, and very deliberate in the way I say this, that the positions that have been

identified for reduction, I am not saying that they lack value. I'm not saying that they are extra. Every position that we have right now does contribute to the work that we do, And there are some wonderful individuals in some of those positions that have been labeled for reduction.

I need to state very plainly, we cannot consider, the board cannot consider, we could not consider as administrative team, who is in those positions when we made these recommendations. We have to follow the contract that was mutually negotiated.

We can't talk about people. We have to talk about positions. That is the only fair way to have that conversation. So what it means is that we have to curate the resources that we have as carefully as possible for now so that over the long term, we can continue to pay people well.

And to put that into more immediate perspective, right now we're negotiating a support staff contract. Next year, we're negotiating the educator contract again. So the financial decisions we make right now around this budget

will determine what we're able to do in those negotiations. They determine what our wiggle room is. They determine what our options are. And when you step back and look at the full landscape, these are only some of the challenges that this district will face in the time before the current kindergartners will graduate from high school.

1:06:20

That's like that two-hand range. So they're not hypothetical. They're just not right in front of us. And I'm not sure if this is the way budgets have been presented in the past or talked about, but that's the way I want to talk about it. And that's the way I see it. So that is the perspective that I'm trying to bring and I think the team is trying to bring when we present very painful decisions to you.

And the truth is there's going to be any number of unknown factors that intervene in the years ahead. I mean, I don't even know what price of gas is going to be next week. I'm pretty sure it's going to be high. But I definitely know this. Our future flexibility, our ability to pay people well,

ability to build the new building when we need to build it to adapt to have the right programs that we need is definitely very much contingent upon the choice that is made with this year's budget it's not just about balancing numbers for next year it's about the position we are in to go forward and look

to the future that's really what I got Kelly has some information that I'd like to have her share first Kelly do you want to talk about reserve accounts what do you want to talk about first Kelly we have the spreadsheet of what we keep

versus what we say nice I think maybe talk about the spreadsheet from keep versus save and do we do we want to project it for the audience and for those at home that would be great I'll just I just kind of want to walk through this

the spreadsheet for you we won't necessarily go line by line unless you want to um i just want to conceptually talk about the sheet um how to read it and um i don't know how to fill space when i need to talk about the spreadsheet itself so um it comes at the request

um i think anna's asked for a couple of times um in order for her to to make an informed decision she kind of wanted to know if we made cuts what it would look like i didn't go to all the levels staffing I didn't do like office secretary office secretary support the

print clerk what I focused on were educators and education educational technicians to see the library okay Sam libraries not showing up today a little technical difficulty I'll just for those at home I have requested that Jenny put

this on the website as well but I will just conceptually start talking through it for the board so it's broken down into different categories so at the top at the very beginning is general education so those are all the general

education classrooms and as you've all learned as over time the configurations at Durham Community School and the middle school are different for when you get into like the 6th, 7th, and 8th grades. And so what looks like it's a duplicate of, it's duplicate. Durham uses like a

7-8 kind of model and Freeport Middle School uses a 6-7-8 model. So there's a lot more lines that I would have liked to have been on here, but it was the best way to show truly what was there. So that starts with gen ed. There's educators at the top. It then goes into like wellness, PE, music band,

chorus, drama, art, Latin, French, and Spanish. We then get into general ed ed techs, and that is utilizing the pre-K ed tech, library ed tech study hall, and what we call bench sub. There is one left, and it looks like Sam, I can get it now. Yeah, and then we go into what I'm considering

1:11:41

more their educator positions within a CBA but they're more like specialists in the sense of nurse guidance counselors social work librarians multilingual gifted and talented and then they are instructional and strategists and I did

reflect JMG even though they're contractual to the district and they're not actually our employee they are they are providing classroom space in the schools especially in Durham's configuration so I wanted to make sure to represent that on here and then we get into MTSS which is the RTI type programs

I continued with the same model of educators and educational technicians and I broke it down for the teaching so MTSS the math and literacy for the for the for the teachers that's RTI a right because it's the academic but it is

broken down between math litter and then literacy and then MTSS behavior is the RTIB program that we have been talking about it then I then go on to the early and intervention team which are those that we discussed that will actually

they'll remain our they're on our teaching staff now within our local budget this is the team that's going to be supporting the four-year-old CDS transition so their funding source will move to the CDS money however they'll

still be part of the education team so I kept them on here and then we move into the realm of special education we have educators the educational technicians and then specialists and in that category it's like the special education

coordinators teacher of the deaf social work speech language pathologists OTPT school psych, and BCBA. So that kind of like walks down through the list. And then it's by school, as you can see, Morse Street, Mass Landing, PES, DCS, FMS, FHS. And then there's a total column

collectively. And then we'll just move over to the yellow boxes. That's 2627. This is showing you based upon the superintendent's recommended tier of reduction, what the impact actually looks like. It continues in the same flow. It's just, and what I tried to do were the items in

red. If you kind of like scroll down the sheet and we'll look at the first example at Mass Landing, it was a grade three teacher. So you can see that it's red because we're going from five to four in that grade level with the recommended budget. Just talk about the numbers at the top. I mean,

probably self-explanatory, but I'll just mention that the bold numbers that are like for classroom educators, that is like the total for that whole column within that category. So those are all the educators within the gen ed classrooms for those particular schools. The numbers at the very top

are combining all of the positions together. So it's taking all of the educators, teachers, and specialists from all of the various levels and adding that total at the very top, just to put it in perspective, like here are the FTE for ed techs and teachers for 25-26. Here's what it will

look like if we move forward with a superintendent's recommended level of cuts. And I tried to make it so you could still see it. Hopefully it's not too small, but again, if it is, it's available online in PDF form and you can make it a little bigger. So I just wanted to provide that context. Again,

And it's not every position that we're proposing to eliminate. I didn't, because we would get into way too many multiple tiers and trying to, so the two that aren't on here are the print clerk, and then the reduction of the community outreach

coordinator, because not under the collective bargaining agreement, and then the reduction of the secretarial support at the middle school, the halftime reduction there. Okay. So if there aren't any questions about this spreadsheet, it looks like Karen has one, Michelle.

Is it okay if I acknowledge her instead of you? Okay. You can see me sitting there. Sorry. Thanks for this, Kelly. I just wanted to make sure that I'm understanding the specialists on the second page. We don't have a teacher of the deaf, but we're losing half an FTE. So that one is actually in the positive. So instead of a negative, it's a positive.

okay just wanted to make sure yeah sorry thank you for pointing that out no worries within special education we were adding two positions that's where the changes so that we're adding a point five teacher of the deaf currently that is being funded we could not fill the position so we're doing a contractual

1:16:52

service and that is being funded with a special ed article to reserve and then we are also we there is a contractual speech language pathologist that we had posted but also could not fill that person is also being paid out of reserve

and but it was proposed to add to this year's budget because as as we'll talk about it kind of leads into reserves a little bit but one thing that we did talk about the establishment when we established the article reserves is that if they would either be used for a one-time expense that was not going to

continue on and we wouldn't want to necessarily spike the tax rate for or it's an unplanned expense that shows up much like these two positions that show up through the year but they're an ongoing expense so they're there they only get paid out of reserve for one year then we pull it forward to the board to include in our local budget Chris um I noticed that in the ESOL

category it looks like we we added a need at panel for ESOL is that correct based upon so it's not that we added a need we built in space for because currently there aren't any students in panel but with the current the model moving forward of two

when I spoke with assistant superintendent this is how the allocation would break out and there would be room for that person to be in Durham and PES as well if needed. Gotcha okay but we don't have any we don't have any need that we see at this point is that right? Yeah right that doesn't

mean that somebody doesn't move in like we experienced before a couple days before school a couple years ago if y'all remember correctly so it wasn't necessarily in panel but it was in the other communities and so basically what I tried to do is show I asked what does it look like this

year what is it anticipated to look like next year and there is space built in in the event that there's a need in Durham and Poundle, and that represents 0.25. Any other? Valerie? Thank you. I know Michelle can't see me.

This is a question more broadly that is just, I'm just trying to understand what we think of it as ESOL, but I think there are a couple other shared services site folks. How do we budget the transition time from site A to site B?

Is that something that's accounted for anywhere? We pay mileage, and we do account for it, but I don't know exactly which line we pay for it when you come for it in. Well, we don't, I mean, a teacher gets paid for a certain number of hours,

whether they're traveling to or from a site midday. A lot of times what we try to do in most cases is actually, because we'll get a little more complicated, school times are all different, right? Depending upon what school you're at, times are different, especially if it's like the BCBA is one person district-wide.

They may or may not, like, visit more than one building in a day. Sometimes you try to consolidate schedules. If speech services are needed at a particular school, you would consolidate them all to one day, potentially, if you could, depending upon, you know. So we really try to work to reduce mileage, if at all possible, and to maximize time, but that's not necessarily always possible. But the travel time, unless it's, if, so, I'll be careful with this.

If somebody starts their day in Poundell, and they work in Poundell all day, and I'm not, like, paying them from home to Poundell, but if somebody started their day in Poundell, but then had to go to Durham to service students and ended their day there, they could put in for mileage reimbursement from Poundell to Durham.

So if you transition from one building to the other, and that's contractual through the collective bargaining agreement, that we pay mileage to those staff members, And obviously they're getting paid to drive over there because it's during the work day.

So if there is a trip, it's not just that. Thank you. I was just wondering the mechanics of that. Clustering is usually best, though, and it's just easier on people's scheduling, too, if we can. Get it. I know you think you have a teacher's voice, but... To follow up on that, so if it's one of the subcontractors, what I'm going to call a subcontractor,

Like you said, you couldn't fill the position, and so you contracted off. Is that person hired on the salary scale, or do they negotiate their own salary? And if they negotiate their own salary, is it hourly, or is it salary-salary?

1:22:08

No, so we're using agencies that these people work for. So it's a contractual agreement with the agency. We pay the agency, not the person. And it's typically an hourly rate. Do they get paid for their travel and for their full? Not by us. By the agency. Got it. Do we pay the agency that? I have not seen that travel separate. It looks like it's included in the overall cost. I haven't seen it broken out separately. Thank you. But the two people that I highlighted are at one building.

Oh, they're at one building anyway. Yes. But I don't see that they're charging us mileage for that person to commute from their place of employment. Thank you. And we always continually post those positions just in the home.

As the superintendent said off of Mike, we do post for those positions. I don't want you to get in trouble tomorrow. So we do have those positions posted, and we have kept those positions posted, and we regularly monitor whether or not anyone applies because we do have, even though we have a contractual agreement,

we do have an out with that contractual agreement in the event that we find a staff member because obviously we would like to hire the staff member versus contract. Are we ready to move on to reserve accounts? Okay, so in your purple packet, there was a new handbook.

The only thing new in the handbook are the last two pages. So, and we had talked about this in the past couple of years, we've established what we call article reserves, and article reserves are set up, as I mentioned briefly before,

they're by article, we'll just back up a little bit, our budget is appropriated by article, as we all know when we go to the annual budget meeting, when you guys sign the warrants, we have an article for regular instruction, we have an article for special education,

Student and staff support, school administration, system administration, transportation, facilities. I'm not going to name them all. And so in an effort to try and stabilize the budgets for, like I said, either larger one-time expenses or actually putting contingencies in for the what-ifs

or what if three students come in and it's pushing us over our class-size policy and now we have to do something about it. We established these article reserves using undesignated fund balance. Undesignated fund balance is the amount of money that's left over at the end of the year

from our budget that we have not expended or we have overcollected on our revenue. And ultimately, we don't have authority to spend that until it's approved through the budget process and on a warrant article at the annual budget meeting.

so a couple of years not last year the year before we established the article reserve accounts and so annually we talk about what the balance is in them do we want to add to them do we feel like they're comfortable you know comfortable balance and i like to also report about what we're using

them for um because while we come to the board for things and that we're expecting to expend for um sometimes at the beginning of the year and we're talking about budget in january or march or april right so i'll just walk you through um where we're at with our current established ones

um article one regular instruction there was no use in 2526 for that um as you'll remember previous in a previous last year we used it for a teacher at mass landing school that ended up being needed but the current balance in that account and we're not proposing to add any

is $416,637, about three and a half, almost four teaching positions if we actually needed to add them back or if there was a need that arose. Okay, and then I will move now down to Article 2, Special Education. Again, that's one of our larger items that we've expended from in for the past

two years. We started a balance this year with $954,081. And I'll just remind everybody the reason that we put almost a $500,000, $600,000 influx into that line last year because when we were doing the budget process last year, we weren't sure if we were going to have ESCA funds

or local entitlement funds. So we actually pushed the amount that we receive in local entitlement into this which puts it at the nine hundred and fifty four thousand eighty one dollars because we had some use this year we're looking to replenish a

1:27:24

little bit so I'm proposing that we use two hundred thousand from the undesignated account to refund the article to reserve account what we've used it for is some one-on-one nursing that was needed a teacher of the deaf at

point five in a speech language pathologist currently the one-on-one nursing that this was proposed for that is no longer needed so we had a small expense and that's why you don't see it added back into the budget where you see the teacher of the deaf and the speech language pathologist came back through in the budget process this year so with those expenditures and the replenishment it would leave article two around nine hundred and sixty four thousand article five student and staff support that it has a balance of six

thousand seven hundred and sixty eight dollars we don't feel that there's a need to increase that but we will keep and maintain that account article six system administration that is where the school board is is budgeted my office is

budgeted in the superintendent's office is budgeted within the system administration lines. That is where you see the audit. That's where you see if we do strategic planning or any of those types of things that's typically running through this line. We're

proposing to add $140,000 in previous years. We used it for the strategic planning because that was like, I want to say it's a one-time thing. It's an every so many year type of thing. So we wouldn't need that money in the budget. But one of the things that has kind of come clear as we've

been through the last couple of weeks is that there may be some professional fees related to whatever we're going to look at in regards to what the district looks like over the next 10 years, or what the future of the district is. And so we don't know if we're going to spend the money,

So we also, so we don't want to put it in a local budget, but what we'd like to do is to allocate some of that money out of undesignated and into this Article VI reserve in the event that something comes up for the board that we may need to actually expend some funds on that isn't a normal expenditure as part of that process. Is that in addition to the facility study? Yes, it is. You'll see the facility study a little later in the capital.

And, you know, this could be a variety of things. We talked about earlier today in the facilities committee when we were looking at the RFQ. You know, we may decide from that that we can do the large facility study, but then what if next year the board wants to say, okay, let's dig deeper into something at the middle school or let's dig deeper into something here, there, or whatever, which would require, like, further investigation into. So we wanted to make sure the board had the flexibility of the funds in order to do that. So we're proposing to add $140,000 and saying maybe $150,000.

It's really just trying to have some sort of fund for you to do that in. If we put that in and take it out, it brings us down to about $3,000. Again, it only gets spent if it's needed. And then we had put $60,000 in when we established the Article Reserves for Transportation because that is

one of another one of those areas if you had an odd district placement and you have to transport children there's an additional transportation cost for that that we don't necessarily that we're currently not budgeting for so we have

that reserve account just to explain where they sit they're still considered part of our undesignated fund they're just reserved for a particular purpose so if you're looking at our audit you will you will see on the undesignated not

that all of you are really like doing some heavy reading but if you look on our audit when it when it gets published within the next few weeks here you'll see that under the undesignated where it's it's listing out all of the

components of undesignated fund balance it's in the reserved column it'll show you like article 1 reserve and show you that it's adding up there so the total balance at the end of next year if we move forward with it as proposed would

the article reserves would have $1,450,000 in them. Mallory, sorry. Do we keep so much in special ed, or as earmarked as special ed, because of the possibility of a high-need student where we need to place them outside the district, or are there other reasons? That's exactly the purpose. Yes, so in the process, you have students in a referral, right,

1:32:32

which means that they could possibly end up in an out-of-district placement or they may not, and we might be able to program in-house for them. This would allow for both things, right? If we did decide we could keep them, if we just added this staff member or this particular service,

we would have a pot to go to to tap into that, or if we strictly had to put them out. The other thing is the cost of a residential placement is very significant. There are districts around us that have recently had students move in with residential placements, and they were looking for ways to fund that.

So that's why we are holding it there and trying to replenish back to that level. So just so I understand, this assumes... So there's some additions in the upcoming year, right? So $200 for special ed to replenish, and then $140 into system admin.

But the amounts coming out of special ed are the ones in this year, not next year's. Correct. Whereas the one in Article 6 is next year's expense. It was just, why are you putting that money in? So I was trying to identify what the thought process was behind it, that that's a possibility.

the nurse, the teacher of the deaf, and the speech language that's in this current year showing, so I was just trying to show the drawdown. Got it. Okay. And then, so that million four fifty assumes we spend all one fifty that week out of there. Okay, correct. Thank you. Yeah, it's the

total of that outside column. So moving on to what we, versus article reserves, they're more what we consider facility reserves. This is encompassed by capital projects, tennis courts, and the tennis and track, and then some fuel reserves that we have for our facilities. So the capital projects balance at the beginning,

where we ended at last year, what we put in, we ended at $2,420,000 with the amount that we put in in 25-26. And these are the expenditures. They're either fully expended or anticipated expended before the end of this year, where the timing may work out a little weird on the facility study depending upon when we can get it out and get it done and when payments are due. But the PES septic finally got replaced. The total cost of that was actually $290,474,

and I will say that as part of that, the playground was disturbed, and so we had to replace some playground components. That's part of the number that's included in the PES septic plan here. Life safety and life safety projects, which were camera and door access.

As we recall, last year we had brought forward a life safety proposal and we were initially proposing to use strictly undesignated fund balance to pay for it. With all of the uncertainty that we had around title funds and grant funding,

the board chose to move particular projects into undesignated fund balance versus spending the full undesignated amount on all projects. So it was split between local budget and capital projects. The two items that stayed into the capital projects fund were cameras and door access. The expected amount to be expended on that is $483,269.

We came to you this year for track re-striping and turf curbing repairs out at the track and field. That was $27,495. You've approved a project for the DCS building automation that was failing. That's up to $55,000. The high school, the varial flow pump replacements, you guys had approved $30,000 for that.

The FHS Tennis Court Design Services was the most recent project, $41,500 that was approved. And then one of the things as part of that life safety shift around that we had done, normally we have about $481,000 that rolls through the local budget.

And last year during that time, we opted to move some of the life safety projects we were proposing into that slot in the local budget, and then we ended up pushing out the capital projects into reserves. And because some of them were roofs, replacing sections of roofs, those can only be

1:37:39

done in the summer. And so because we didn't know enough at the time in order to have the proper planning, those projects were delayed. So ultimately, all that was really expended was $81,000 or anticipated out of the capital projects that were scheduled. And then lastly is the

facility study of $100,000 that you voted on at the last meeting. So we're not proposing any increase to that, as you can see, because there was a significant amount pushed in last year based upon the life safety proposals and the capital projects that got moved into this group.

So we're anticipating to have about 1.3 million, which we feel is comfortable, and we don't feel that we need to appropriate any undesignated into the capital projects account this year. I'll now move on to the tennis courts. So the tennis courts, we've been saving for the tennis

courts for several years now, because they've been talked about since when I was here before, we were talking about them when I left in 2016, and we're still talking about them when I got back in 2023. And so, but in the meantime, you established a reserve account to start putting

money away to replace the tennis courts. You did something. Perfect. So there's, at the end of this year, there'll be $190,000 that has been put aside for the tennis courts with some recent, Very rough draft of estimates for tennis court replacements, and what we've done is we're

requesting to add $510,000 to the tennis court reserves, which will make the balance about $700,000. This actually would cover the cost of replacing the courts as they exist. So that is three courts asphalt. that's um the estimates oh it's about 681,000 right now we still need to do the the testing

the court the core borings for the material under the the tennis court so it's like a very rough number but we were asking for a number so that we could use it for budgetary purposes um there are there are discussions about asphalt post-tension there's discussions about three courts four

courts what we felt was prudent was to at least budget for what we have which is three courts asphalt so yes and so superintendent Gray wants to remind us all that the courts have been deemed unsafe to play on and so we are searching for

alternative alternatives right now for our students for the spring season for tennis so that they can still continue to play practice and post matches hopefully on another turf, on another court. I call it turf, but it's a court. So that's the

recommendation for the tennis court. And when I talk about the other options, one of the other thoughts, there's potentially grant funding that's being sought. There's potentially some fundraising that may happen. And then depending upon what the, when the, when the prices come back and what the

board decides to go through, we can remind, I can remind you all that we have that capital reserve account as well, that 1.3 million that we might be able to tap into if it goes above, if we're above the 700,000. We would use a combination of funding potentially. That's a few, a month or so out. So

I just wanted to know, let you know, we're preparing for it. We're proposing to use 510 to get where we would need to be. I'll move on to the track and field reserve. That was also established while I was gone because the track and field came in and started being used so annually

we put about $35,000 into that at the end of the 25-26 year there'll be 280,000 we're asking to continue that contribution of $35,000 a year to continue to build for an ultimate replacement of the track at some point so that'll that would leave a balance of about $315,000 and then a

heating fuel reserve of a hundred thousand that was established when i first got here probably 2011 2012 um and we have not we'll knock on some wood we've never had to use it and what this the heating reserve is really set for is typically we're looking at historical data

we're getting pricing we're putting stuff into the budget nobody expects gas to be four dollars a gallon almost right now, right? That affects us as well for heating. So the reserve was set up years ago in order to give us a cushion for those types, that type of expense. So while we haven't

1:42:43

had to use it and it currently holds $100,000 in it, who knows? We might have to use it fairly soon if prices continue to rise because we are still heating. So if you add all the columns in the facilities reserve, that's the capital projects, the tennis court, the track and field, and the

that brings us to 2.4 a little over 2.4 million and I'm just gonna try not to scroll quickly but I'll just bring you back to the top in the italicized words there the reserve account funding so we're we're proposing to appropriate

$885,000 from undesignated fund balance this year to to to put into these article end or facility reserves this is my first year so I'm gonna go back to some pretty rudimentary questions undisputed fund balance is whatever we've

collected that we could not spend yes so so our revenue sources and I'll just slide up because I'm in the in the budget document itself right so and I'll just kind of to start at the top, your expenses are at the top, right? So this year's 26, 27,

we're proposing 47 million. That's the total year over year budget. We then start subtracting revenues out. So the first line there is shared revenues, and this is where you usually see the largest flux. We're budgeting $1.4 million in shared revenues, which means we're keeping that

out of taxation because we're expecting this revenue. So if we slide down a little bit to the bottom of that sheet, and I'll try and make it a little bigger for y'all, the shared revenues that we're budgeting for are, we maintain the Hunter Road fields for the town of Freeport,

and they pay us to do that. That is a contractual agreement that we have. We are in, I believe this is year, this will be, 26 or 27 will be year three of a five-year agreement. We have historically budgeted an expense for a shared employee with the town of Freeport, which would be like a

custodial type grounds position. And then we put this offsetting revenue in. It's never come to fruition. It was there when I left in 2016. It was back in 23. We've never filled it. I took it out of the expenses and I've taken it out of the revenue. We're not, we've never done anything with

it, so I don't want to continue to show it. State agency client slash Medicaid, that's for students that are under the care of the state who we are providing services for that we can actually bill. The Office of Instructional Support does that billing, and so that's a number based on an

average. However, when we bill, it's based on actual students. So if a student moves in, a student moves out, again, which is why I typically try to do it based on an average. The next line is interest. So obviously we have undesignated fund balance, which sits in a bank, um, and we are in

interest on it. So, um, that is a revenue that the district receives. So we offset taxation with it. Again, this has been one of those, it's one of the lines that overperforms, uh, that had been overperforming and I crept it up over the past couple of years, but I was hesitant to move it

this year, based upon everything going on. So I did, I did leave it flat and felt comfortable with that. So as you know, Community Programs has a laugh and learn program, and which they actually charge parents for, or they get funding from DHS for particular students. They do utilize space

within our buildings, and because they charge for it, we ask them to help cover some of the cost of the space that they're in. So you'll see that $15,000 is there. They're in the same amount of spaces as they were last year, and so we've kept that flat. The thing that changed this year, as

you know, we are currently providing to some of the children under CDS, some of the four-year-olds, we are providing services to them through our early intervention team. We have an agreement with CDS that we can bill for that. But now that we're going to become part of Cohort 3, they're our responsibility. We assume FAPE, they're ours. So the funding for that is going to be coming into the CDS fund,

1:48:01

which is going to be a separate fund than a local budget, which is Fund 2213, not that y'all care. So while we see a negative here, as we talked about earlier, those staff members are also going to move out. so um then then we go on to um we call it the aspirations account really this is taking money

from undesignated it's largely in there we put it align it within the superintendent's budget for eighty six hundred dollars this this is typically used when um a team makes nationals or team makes states you know what i mean and there's some overnight expense or it's a doesn't happen every

year. This is the pot of money if they ask the superintendent. They've done their fundraising. They haven't met their goal. Is there something that the superintendent could offer and the district could support with? That's what this $8,600 typically covers. Most times it's OM,

if you have the mind, that end up going. And then the ultimate undesignated fund balance. So this is the amount of undesignated fund balance that we typically use each year to help offset taxation. Prior to the implementation of the vehicle and equipment replacement plan and the energy audit

projects, we were running about $900,000 in this line. And what that means is we're taking money, we'll just be playing with it, right? We're taking money that has been taxed previously or collected previously, we are then appropriating it and subtracting it out of the expenditures so

we're not taxing for that same money again. We've increased it slightly because part of the presentation for taking on the expenditures for the energy audit and for the vehicle and equipment replacement plan, we wanted to try to levelize what was entering the budget annually to incrementally

take that on over a 40-year period. So what you see here, anything above the $900,000 is what we're using to help implement that plan. And so those shared revenues of the $1.4 million, if we collect $300,000 in interest, that's something more than what we budgeted for, that would ultimately end

up in undesignated because we've over-collected for that. The other way that undesignated fund balance gets increased is at the end of the year. When you settle it all out, what does our budget look like? We budgeted a certain amount, we spent a certain amount. If there's anything left, that

lapses into undesignated fund balance. And again, I will get on my soapbox, which I've gotten on for 16 years now. And I strongly feel that undesignated fund balance should be utilized for one-time type expenditures and not for expenditures that annually run through your budget. Because if you spend it

and you don't replenish it, it's an automatic cliff, right? So if we spent all $44 million dollars, didn't collect any extra, right? I would not be increasing undesignated fund balance at all at the end of this year. I would remain flat, but I would be spending that $1 million because

I've used that to offset taxation, right? So that's not really a revenue that I give myself. What I'm saying is, is if I need to spend all $44 million, I'm going to pull out of my savings account a million dollars right because it gets spent and it reduces it and if you continually do

that to save positions or to pay your electric bill or those types of things which are annual expenditures eventually you will run out of money and then your budget may not go up but you now don't have a million dollars to use you automatically have to tax people a million dollars more than you

had in the previous year. That's why I get on a soapbox for one-time expenditures. So an example of what would go into that would be like, we have, what was it, five or six open special ed tech positions? We've budgeted for those salaries, but we have not paid those salaries.

Correct. Right. So that would then go into that undesignated fund balance, is that right? At the end of the year, yes. It would ultimately add to it, as long as we didn't overexpend somewhere else. Right, so it was however many much, $300,000, right? Right. Next year would be $1.3, roughly. Well, we wouldn't necessarily increase this number that we're using for the budget, because, again, you don't want to create the cliff. What it would do would allow the undesignated fund balance to grow

1:53:34

that you could potentially use for these one-time expenditures that we're trying to use it for tennis courts right we're going to do it once every 25 years so you know that's it's it's really that way of trying to so if i if so let's just use the example

if we didn't have the reserve account for the tennis courts and we needed to come up with $700,000 if i push it into the local budget that's $700,000 that then gets pushed to the local taxpayers through the formula and then next year we're done the tennis court so that $700,000 is

not in there, right? So your rates go like this. And so for me, it's a method to utilize the reserve accounts, set those up so that we don't have to tax people for any unnecessary expenditures. Because typically what we were doing before that, we would put an amount of contingency in.

In the event that something shows up, we had money to go to. It was called contingency. It was a line item within the budget. That is now gone. And we have these article reserves sitting outside the budget. At the annual budget meeting each year, we go through an article that says we want to put

this money in and we want to be able to spend from it. And then we come to you at the board level and say, this need has arisen. We have the money here. Can we have the permission to spend from it? Sorry, continuing on that. So just so I can wrap my head around this, because this is very out of

my wheelhouse but if we were to let's say all of a sudden fill you know three hundred thousand dollars worth of those positions for next year um would then the following year we would then have at that line 700,000 or is that not right that line so okay so um i'm trying to know

in the shared revenue using of the undesignated oh right yeah so no the undes like as i mentioned before we try to use a stable amount in the in the revenue side and the reason for the stable amount is usually we're trying to land somewhere around our true unexpended items annually um

so part of it is i mean it's a variety of things like those positions are one thing that feeds it there's the other thing like any open position we assume somebody's coming in at a certain point in the scale and we make assumptions about their insurance and you know some people may come in

higher. Some may come in lower. They may take single. They might not take family. Like, so there's, there's a variety of things because what, what's different about us than say any other business is we can't go negative, right? Like we cannot go below, you know, we cannot spend more

than we say we're going to spend at that annual budget meeting. So we have to make assumptions in there so we don't put ourselves in a situation where we get even close, right? We want, it's this fine line between we don't want to tax and collect too much we don't want to take more than we need but we need to take enough to cover those question marks through through the budgeting process and because there's so many

different things that sort of play into that pool they tend to even out to roughly the same amount each year so it might be this year the positions don't get filled but next year it's because insurance was less but like they tend to

even out. And we don't say, okay, I know there was five unfunded positions, so I'm automatically going to increase that amount. Because again, the higher you raise it, the harder it is to make up. So if we were to truly spend that money, I mean, we saw what a turnkey budget looked like this year

for just salary and benefits. So without, the point is, is that while it sounds like a viable solution to buy down a tax rate for one year. That's all you're doing is buying down a tax rate for one year or saving positions for one year. Next year, you're going to have to figure out

how you're going to have to fund that because you're already starting behind if you don't replenish what you're utilizing. And that's why I say that million dollars that you kind of see on that bottom line, that's kind of where I've seen the target of where we've been landing

um at the end of at least the past three years that i've been back so without if we hadn't had this cushion and we'd had that i think it was a septic failure panel we would do what we would have had to send out have a vote what what would have been yeah so so if we didn't have reserves

that we could that we were authorized to access yeah we would have to have an emergency town meeting to essentially give us either the ability to, this is, this sort of came up with the tennis courts, right? When we wanted to start the design work, we weren't off, we had the savings, we called

1:58:47

it tennis courts, but we weren't allowed to use it because we didn't ask. So there's two things. One, it could be that we have it, we're not authorized, in which case we have to have a meeting to ask permission. And if we had no reserves and we had a failure and we needed to, to basically have a,

Gosh, I don't even know what that would look like. Can we do an interim billing to the towns if we had a town meeting that said we needed to collect another $500,000? You could do an assessment, but I don't know how they're going to do it if their tax bills have already been sent out. Right. Which is why we don't want to get into that situation. Correct. And the cost of doing an annual budget meeting and then a budget validation referendum, you'd have to do those steps. Right, so basically we have to do a mini budget process. Right. So this is also more cost effective because we're not doing all of the wheels that it takes. Absolutely, yes, correct. And although they're designated into account, they're still sitting in an interest-bearing account making us the interest. They're just assigned somewhere so that you guys have access to them with the correct vote. Can I ask, maybe we don't know yet

because I know the audit isn't complete, what is the undesignated, or what do we expect the undesignated fund balance to be after we assume we're making these designations. It's like I thought you were going to ask that question. It's like she knew I was going to ask. It's weird. Kelly's in my brain. So yes, the actual, while the audit hasn't been finalized,

there is a preliminary audit that I've been reviewing, and I agree with the number, so I'm putting it up here. So the estimated undesignated fund balance is $4,010,701. We're proposing to use $1,028. That's the number we just looked at plus the $8,600. That would be an assigned use.

And then Article 2, replenishing $200. Article 6, $140. We're not giving anything to reserve this year because of the large influx last year we're adding five proposing to add 510 to the tennis court and 35 to track and field here's the number that i was kind of talking about the annual number this is

where i'm kind of expecting it to land again just an estimate because we're still we haven't you know done our spring ordering for you know like the final semester of the year so my best guess of 16 years of experience looking right around here which would leave us what we would consider uncommitted because once you say we want to spend it on our we want to put it over into they're considered committed at that point so where we would be looking to land is about 3 million dollars which represents 6.76% of the 25-26 citizen adopted budget there is a state statute regarding how much undesignated fund balance you can have currently that sits

at nine percent and it's if anybody wants to look it up it's MRS title 20 a section 15689 b6 and yeah so I had to look it up and I thought I would share because i did um so so we're allowed to have according to state statute four million right

around four million dollars um historically the number had been at five percent which is why i'm showing you that um during the cove if you all remember during covid we got a lot of um covid relief funds um and so for several years and we had all done our budgets at that point and then

we all got the influx of money. And so, especially during that COVID year, when students weren't in our building, there was remote learning going on, the expenses weren't as high, a lot of districts were pushing higher than the allowable number. And so, the legislature allowed for the 9%.

That was supposed to expire in this year, 25-26, but it has been extended. So, I'm showing you both numbers because I'm trying to stay somewhere within the target so that if it goes down to 5%, we're still relatively close. Now, I will say nobody's policing it at this point, but it is in

the funding statute as part of your subsidy calculation that if you were over that, they could potentially withhold subsidy in any amount over that. So it's mixed. Right now, we're sitting at 6.76 with the recommendations that I'm making to you tonight. Yeah, that number, I mean, when I

2:04:02

first got on the board, that statute was 3% and nobody lived within it because that felt extremely tight for districts. I mean, think about a $45 million budget with a million two allowed in your savings account. Like, that's not a lot. I mean, you know, that's a septic in a roof and the world

ends right um so you know going up to nine they sort of settle back to five but back up to nine so um and just a reminder that the ones that we have sitting in capital in article two in article one in tennis courts those don't count towards those percentages because those are considered

designated so as long as we say what we're going to do with them we can have as much as we want not that we want to collect more than we need because this is taxpayer money but we can have a safe amount any day other questions for Cameron?

that was everything for show and tell that was show and tell so now we get to the deliberations piece for the board thank you for the additional information um for the recommendations um i guess i will i will put it out to the board of of what's your

pleasure in terms of uh where you want to start because i'll just remind folks the goal um the goal is that we adopt a budget two meetings from now uh and in a perfect world at the next meeting which is a week from today we have one on the 18th um we would come to essentially the number

comfortable with. So, you know, if folks have additional questions around what's being recommended about, you know, we do still have our administrative staff here, so if there were additional questions for them, now is your opportunity to ask those. You had mentioned that you were going to talk

about, like, the potential for between seven and eight percent. We've talked about that as an administrative team a couple of meetings ago I responded off I gave a response off the cuff but it was not really discussed with the team at that time so it since then we've had the opportunity to do that and the short answer is that if you wanted to get somewhere between the seven and eight percent what I would recommend adding back in order of what helps kids the most is first is the instructional stratus just position that is in tier two and then second

would be something that's not necessarily evident when you look at what's in the tiers at first. It would be to make that 0.6 Spanish teacher at Freeport Middle School a 1.0, so that we can really maximize the degree to which those kids are getting world language. And Pam could talk

more about this than I can, but that would mean that we could ensure that all 7th and 8th graders get world language. So that would expand it from just 8th to 7th and 8th. Correct. And then the third add back would be two general ed techs

at Moore Street and Mass Landing. And that would basically be what gets you between the two tiers. One at each. I think there's only, we're only pulling one from each, so we wouldn't, yeah. What is the number between those two tiers? Yeah, because I feel like we're saying between 7 and 8, but really 7 is 6.5

right, according to here. So maybe understanding you know what the yeah the impact of so i can kelly can i'm i can get kelly to be more exact with this probably but i can eyeball it for you so the instructional strategist the rough cost of

a teaching position is 105 000 and then with the freeport middle school spanish position the current uh the way that's currently structured is that it's a 0.6 teaching position 0.4 ed tech position, we feel that the 0.4 ed tech duties could be absorbed. So really, we'd be adding,

2:09:19

and an ed tech is basically half the cost of a teacher. So we'd be adding in 0.4 of a teacher, but losing 0.4 of an ed tech. So we're really adding 0.2 of a teacher to make that teacher whole. So $21,000? Yes. And then each of the two elementary ed techs, about half of $105,000,

of 52.5. So another 105. What I don't know, which we just haven't had time to work out yet, is just in terms of this long-range projection, what that does. So off-the-cuff math, 105,000 out of 47 million is 0.22 percent. So it's a, call it a quarter of a percent per full educator, full-time

teacher. Roughly. All right. Yep. Gotcha. So that gets us to about, that gets us roughly to that 7%, 7.1 7 point yeah and this recommendation doesn't get you exactly halfway between 7 and 8 percent it's closer to the 7 um that's what we would recommend adding back so just just so i'm clear

the ed techs are more street and mass landing even because presumably the the idea well in my mind i guess i'll preface this with how i look at this conversation around these sort of what you would add back first, um, to avoid the a la carte version, um, is, you know, if the board feels like

we could support something a bit higher than 6.53, we would be looking to add back the instructional strategists. If we felt like we could go a bit higher than that, we would add back the, we would increase the Spanish, and then, so we would do them sort of down the line. That's how

I would get you there. Great. Um, so then my question is between two and, so we wouldn't get to three unless we had done two and my I'm just asking the question around maybe I should look at this to confirm my thinking before I say it the ed techs at

Freeport middle are dropping from from what in the proposal the current proposal and then we will be losing another point four essentially that's right but you the recommendation would be to add back at the other schools not to keep one of the ones at the middle school that's right and we talked about

this extensively the other day in our admin team meeting and the strong sense from the school administration is that they will be okay without those positions and that the positions have greater impact in the lower grades okay so I

hope this is okay to ask you'll tell me if it's not I've read the contracts now both the ed tech one and or the one support staff and for the what I call teachers but you call educators so it's just semantics but I can't find anywhere

what it the increases from this year salaries to next year I know that that the support staff is being negotiated right now but I don't know what the increase is you keep referring to but we have contractual obligations and I can't

imagine but I may be wrong that the contractual obligation is six and a half percent increase next year it's tell me what it's about that Kelly can you help me over the educators for the educators really educated contract next year yeah

it's six and a half yeah well yeah because I so contractually in the agreement it says 5.5 thank you there are steps associated with that so it's It's more than the 5.5 when you add steps. Right, so total wages is 6.5. So it's for an individual, but the increase is a 5.5% increase.

That was a contractual agreement. For someone at the top of the scale. The scale grew by 5.5%. Thank you, that's what I wanted to know. Good, thanks. For year over year. Yes. And I did kind of push the numbers, and it brings us to 7.05.

For year over year. One, two, and three. for what the superintendent just recommended, if we were to add them back, yes, that's for the two ed techs, the coach, and making Spanish full-time, yes, the strategist, sorry, yeah, so I am interested

2:14:36

to hear why that was the first, why that was the first suggested add back from the tiers, or eliminating that cut. Yeah, I'll stop my question there. When we discussed it as a team, what the strong feeling was is that the instructional strategists are having a

multiplied effect and that they're really working very closely with the administration to help teachers improve their practice and that that is showing up in student data. And so the impact we're getting from having those people is very strong.

And so right now, we have five strategists. The initial recommendation was to go to four. So it's not necessarily as easy as one per building. Do they split? The original recommendation was to go to two at the elementary level.

So FMS and FHS had no change, and then the other ones essentially dropped. So we only have one at the high school. and if I mess this up somebody raise a hand well I'm looking at you I was saying trying okay gotcha yeah so right now we have one at the high school 0.6 at the

middle school and those two are recommended not to change yes Durham has 1.4 recommended to go to 1.06 I'm gonna figure that out and then and then the elementary school is two and those each two individuals and each dropping to 0.6

7? Yes. Okay. Figure it out because Durham's a K-8 school and one strategist is middle school 6-8, so 0.6 0.4. Oh, I see. Got it. Okay, so one person splits their time between for Port Middle and Durham? For the middle school. For the middle school. Yep.

So it's really the amplified effect of one position across multiple schools and grade levels. Okay. Sorry, Lois, I didn't mean to preempt you can i ask what your fourth choice would be is there another one i have not gone that far with

the team so i hesitate to go out on a limb with that yes um i could talk i could come back to you at the next meeting i would like that i mean if we're not going to make a decision tonight if we're going to make a decision tonight then i'll have to make a decision tonight and decide how to

vote but right we don't tonight's not the decision okay um i would like that okay may i say why of course. Jinx, you owe me a Coke. I'm very concerned about that math position. The high school math position? Yes, I am. And I know we've had this conversation, but I just want everyone to know

that I am very concerned about getting rid of a math position, especially when I heard that that particular person is the person who does all the, what I call, I think it's coding, but What the computer stuff that I don't know about, but you know what?

Somebody who's 17 does. And so I think it's really important that we look at what the impact on the long term is by getting rid of a math position, my opinion. Yeah, I guess since Jen's here, I would be interested in either from you or from Jen.

I can certainly see the perspective around our concerns about scores, et cetera. I also see, you know, the point in time where that position was added relative to where we are now from a population standpoint. You know, those are sort of on opposite sides of the scale. But I found our last speaker this evening very interesting around, like, are we perpetuating

uh, shrinking, uh, population by what we're, by what we're contemplating. Um, I, I, I don't think it's quite that simple, but, you know, it's an interesting, it's an interesting concept to think about. Um, and, you know, when, when we say that we're concerned about math scores, um, and then

2:19:42

this is the proposal, um, I'm interested to hear how, how in my brain I can, um, reconcile those two things good evening everybody from the high school um i also have this cough i can't get rid of so my voice goes down i feel like that's every time i'm at this microphone um i think one of the

things that i want to make sure um that i'm reiterating that superintendent gray said is that um this our decisions that we're making about the budget aren't about an individual teacher's strengths. It's about, or their impact on our school. It's about looking at what's in front of

us and managing what is in front of us and what's responsible. I think that in the past, I have come to this board when we have felt that class sizes are too big. And I, over the time that I have been the principal here, I've asked for multiple positions that we needed when we found that we

didn't think that our class sizes were manageable or other reasons why we were asking for an increase in staff when we look at class sizes across the district that's one of the things that we always have to consider all of our work that we

think about in math is K through 12 and that includes staffing that we're thinking about at the schools and where the needs are and all of us have the goal of making connections with kids and building their skills. And so I think we're thinking about that across all schools,

not just one at the high school. And certainly our math scores are things that we are consistently working on. We're really excited about the work that the K-12 math committee, who's meeting right now, is working on and thinking about the results that we want

for our graduates of high school. We start those conversations in pre-K, in kindergarten, in math, and think about what we're doing all the way up, and that those may mean potential changes that we're making at all those different levels. And so when we think about class size, it's certainly one factor that we're always looking

at. But when we're thinking about improving scores, our teachers at the high school, I've had the opportunity to meet with all of the teachers, 6 through 8, when we had our February early release day, and I've met with a number of teachers in the K-12 math committee. Everybody

is working on this and thinking about how do we make the best experience for kids. And so when we're looking at class sizes at the high school specifically, these are the numbers that I shared a few weeks ago. The average size class in our Algebra 1 right now is 14.8. Average size in our

geometry classes is 16.6. In the honors level of those two classes, the average size for Algebra 1 honors is 12.5. The geometry honors is larger, 19.5. Algebra 2, the average size is 15.4. Honors is 15.3. Honors pre-calculus is a larger class size, that's an average of 22.

However, calculus is an average size of 14, and computer programming is a class size of 11.5. And when we are looking comparatively just at a few of our other classes, our average size in ELA 9 is 18.25. In chemistry, it's 17.5. In American history, it is 20.8.

And Foundations of Art, which is predominantly 9th graders, beginning with their visual art, is 18.25. So on the whole, right now, our math classes as a department have the smallest averages across the entire department. There's other classes at school that might have very small numbers.

I explained this before, something like AP Music Theory. It's one of our smallest classes, also one of our most challenging classes in this building. And that's a very niche study, and we're fortunate to be able to offer that class.

That teacher also runs the band and has 60 kids in band. And so that's where we're looking at those numbers. Those numbers don't always appear as even as they seem. Across the board, we asked for an increase in our math teachers a few years ago,

and our populations have gone down. Even with, there's always an impact to us, with the reduction of a math teacher, these class sizes, and the decrease in the total number of students at the high school, these class sizes will increase, but not to a point that we feel that we,

2:25:06

I would come to the board and say, our class sizes are too large. Even with the reduction of a teacher, these class sizes may not get to where American history is at twenty point eight and so those are some of the things

that we are looking at we are certainly always trying to improve achievement in math and I think we are working on that so hard all those teachers that I'm seeing seeing do exceptional work and thinking about how to enhance their

instruction in math and it's not just dependent on class sizes thank you for that Malik yeah thank you for that explanation that's really helpful I'm curious about the, we heard about computer programming and some STEM offerings, and will

those offerings be affected by a reduction of one full-time teacher, or will those offerings still be available? So specifically computer programming, there is no other, there's no teacher in the math department who teaches a STEM course other than computer programming.

Computer programming used to be a part of the science department, and then we shifted it um two years ago to be a part of the math department and so that what we do every year is we um adjust teachers schedules and we base that on teacher strength and student need so we look

at that so it might be that a teacher's teaching geometry one year and then the next year they're teaching uh pre-calculus they might it's maybe not a surprise that it can be very challenging to actually teach pre-algebra more so than honors honors pre-calculus or calculus

and so in some years we've rotated who is teaching pre-algebra and so we are just for those of you who have a middle school student we're just right now in registration process so we haven't determined teaching assignments yet and

so we look at the number of course signups as I said there's a average class size of 11.5 in those classes right now. And so we'll look at what the sign-ups are and then determine who is able to teach that class and how we would provide that.

And if, for instance, and this is just a what-if, the honors calculus, the AP honors calculus, were to reduce to, I don't know, six next year, six kids sign up for it. Is that the person that then, is that, I know it's It's not the person that's riffed, but does that class go away

because there are only six kids? Or are there other opportunities that you provide online, at Bowdoin, whatever, for someone who's so gifted in math that they don't need pre-calculus? They can be in honors calculus, God forbid. I can't even imagine. And we have some awesome mathematicians in this school. We do have some 9th and 10th graders who are in our AP classes, which we'll have to do that already.

Whether we offer that or not, we are incredibly fortunate to have so many different opportunities for students to access early college classes. Some of those are for dual enrollment credit. We also, part of my budget lines each year is to make sure that we have some funding for online classes,

for classes that we can't offer, and that a student has gone out above and beyond. So that is something that we've been able to offer since I started at Freeport. We've had students do linear algebra and differential equations.

If you're ever looking for something super fun on a weekend to look at, check those two courses out. And they've done them through online at MIT, they've done them through USM, through Bowdoin College. But when we have a course that only gets down to six, we do our very best to still offer

that. So right now, AP Calculus BC, which is the second level of AP, so that is in the building, that's the highest math class that we offer. It depends each year on how many students are ready for that level. This year it's very small. So right now that class is

at five. Whereas our class that's just before that, that's the prerequisite to it, AP Calculus AB, that's a larger class. So it depends on the cohort that comes through and what their readiness is but I don't anticipate us having to eliminate a course this is an

2:30:07

area I'm struggling with as well my initial question has been you know if if we are having concerns about scores how is this going to help scores and student experience in in this subject and I know that's not really how we're

looking at this year's budget that none of these reductions are really intended to help the students it's really more what what is the least impact and that's helpful to kind of reframe at the same time I'm still struggling with how that this is an area that is already impacted and so how is how is this

an area that has the least impact I know you just walked through the class sizes compared to the other class sizes it does seem that to me that math is one subject that would really benefit from those smaller classes with the individualized teaching

that can really be required and I know that all of the subjects would the teachers would prefer to have smaller classes with more individualized teaching I'm just I'm I don't know if I have a particular question other than I

I guess I do want to better understand how we'll help to reduce, help to increase the scores and the student experience in math without that teacher. So I think that what I had shared before is that this work on the curriculum, that the teachers are consistently doing that.

We've been doing that for years at the high school where they're looking at assessments together. they're looking at like what's the most powerful type of learning that we can provide for students in class in math which has changed very much in the last

decade of how how kids think about math how they are doing math by hand technology all sorts of things so I think that curriculum work is really powerful and collaborating with the grades levels that that precede the high school I think

that that work also is what we really focused on how do we take that and make sure that our students are achieving at higher levels in addition to that at the high school we have now had this I have to look back but I would say at least

five years and this was based on our pre-COVID math committee that we have a class that's called math support so that's a half block class it's very small sections i think the largest we've had is 11 students in that section and so that's an additional 40 minutes of math

that students in algebra 1 or geometry who are struggling take in addition to their math class we had it for algebra 2 we didn't have as high of a number of students who are enrolled in that and so that's led by a math teacher and so the way that at the high school that we have a 75

minute block and then we cut them in half the intervention blocks are cut in half so that teacher will see um you know fewer than 10 in the first half fewer than 10 in the second half and what we have also added this year that i spoke about earlier in the year is what we call falcon

lab. So that's any student who's struggling in any class. We've set the threshold of a 76 or below in any class is then shifted into one of these intervention blocks where they can focus on any of their classes. But we, it's with either a math teacher, social studies teacher, science teacher,

or ELA teacher, and we try to prioritize the class that they're struggling the most. So then they are in that class. They could potentially be in their Algebra I class, plus in a math support class, plus in what we call a Falcon Lab.

So they would have 75 minutes of math instruction with their class, and then they'd have 75 minutes of support in some way, shape, or form. Looks different for each student, how they're accessing that and utilizing that.

We use those as interventions. Then we also have our advisory system, which our advisory system is academically focused, where we use our callback system, where teachers can reserve kids and call them back. So those are all of the different ways that all of our teachers, including math teachers,

are using to help enhance skills and understanding for the kids who are struggling. So that's some of the ways that we will still do that, regardless of what the class size is. I don't anticipate with the numbers, overall numbers, of our school going down and the projected enrollment goes down for the next three years that these sizes, I do not predict that they are going to drastically increase.

2:35:12

They're going to increase, but not drastically so. So you say projected enrollment is going to go down the next three years, and maybe I just don't have these numbers in front of me. When I do the quick math on how many eighth graders we have, our average is 147, where our current average at the high school is 138 per cohort.

And then after that, you have a slight drop, and then you have 157, and then you have 156. And it seems to me like our projected numbers are actually going up, not down. So on the projected enrollment scale right now, we're at 570.

I was looking at the totals. So when you look at the totals for the high school, then we are at 570 right now, which our highest since I have been here was at 645. We're at 570. It's projected to go to 555 and then down to 543 and then come back up to 555.

Those are the numbers that were the last time that I looked at the projected enrollment. I didn't look at it this week but those are the numbers that we see because in some years we've had these bubble classes of 160 high 150s that when you look at the chart that is not what's

predicted to be coming to us right now so from what I can kind of see here is it it looks like that's not predicted to come to us the next call it two or three years but it is predicted to come to us in the next five years because we have in our current sixth grade we have 157 our current

fifth grade we have 156 so like those are big classes big cohorts for for that so in three years we might not but in five years we might and I guess one of my this is more of a statement um one of my worries is that we we are firing and hiring and firing and hiring and especially

like you mentioned the the jack's comment the student we had he mentioned stability um and i think that not only is that stability for our kind of tax base but it's also stability for the teachers we hire and that that's important to kind of project as a board and so one of my worries is

okay so for the next two years we decided we have we have small class sizes but then we're going to have to hire again in four years right yeah i think i i think you're right um you know so then it becomes like what's your time horizon that we want to carry you know it's hard yeah it's

hard to judge um and and i will say um and maybe maybe this isn't true it's just something that floats around in my head i also think that it's not a one-to-one move from the middle the high school is where most people are regardless of kind of why like people will switch at high school

they may go through their local schools and then choose to go to a private school um so you know i don't think if we went back to you know some of the smaller classes and looked at them at in the fifth grade would it would have been the same number of kids you know so i don't know if there's

a normal number that we sort of expect to divert off to to to a different high school or not i I don't, maybe someone knows the answer to that, but, but yeah, I mean, it's, you know, we certainly don't want to, and I totally understand your point, Chris, like, if we knew that, you know,

next year would be an unusually small year, but there, you know, it was coming right back up the next year, I would 100% agree with you, but, you know, two to three years, and then, you know, everything gets fuzzier the farther you go out into the future, right, the ability to predict

goes way down. So, you know, I would be hesitant to say that I wanted to necessarily keep the status quo because five years from now, we might need it. That's what I do with my closet. It never works well. I keep things way too long. I think I'm on those lines. Like, when we got to 645 students,

I was prepping to come to the board and say, this building was made in the renovation to add another floor and we're getting close you know we were pressed for advisory everyone was sharing a room that's just not the case right now most teachers do

not share their room have their own room for advisory and we feel the impact of the numbers and I think that then we are responsive and I have come to the board to say as I did for the math position and said you know we're at this

point where we feel like we need to increase staffing right now and I think that's what we look at closely every year. I certainly hear, as Michelle said, I hear what you're saying. I think that if we were in this place where we thought 645 was the number where

we were staying, that was a press on this building and how we were offering all sorts of structures that we had put in place. And now next year, it will be almost 100 students fewer than that yeah i appreciate that thank you i think eating lunch like everywhere in the building

2:40:24

because they used to it was crazy lois can you tell me in the anticipatory numbers that are for fifth and sixth and seventh and eighth whether or not any of the future growth in apartment buildings for instance the one that's going in i think it's down on depot in freeport there's

tons of building that I see in Pownall in the last couple of years. It's been a lot. Durham, I know we don't encourage building because of whatever, for whatever reason. And so the numbers in Durham, it doesn't seem like there's so much building going on. But when you figure

the numbers, are you figuring in the numbers of possible families that are going to move in to various new housing so yes i mean i think we when we meet with the towns we kind of talk about where their housing starts um where have they been historically i think freeport's have kind of gone

up because of some of that housing but what they have told us and what seems to bear out since some of those housing projects have come online is that most of those in freeport anyway aren't directed towards families with kids in school they're either like brand new out of you know very young

professionals young families that that aren't in school or young couples that aren't in school yet or they're retired they're not you know they're not targeted towards families with little kids so we haven't seen a huge increase in that from my understanding and in Pownall and and Durham

there what it seems to be happening certainly more in in durham i'm not as familiar in panel but they've been clustering into subdivisions but really the number of housing starts hasn't really gone up before they were sort of scattered throughout the town but the total

numbers haven't increased as much you know it's one of those things that i think we've always taken a look at we have done enrollment studies in the past my personal opinion is they are a complete waste of money because they just make things up but um because they won't tell you their

their strategy on how they come up with their numbers um so clearly i don't believe them but um yeah we haven't sorry it's a sidebar um yeah i know if you can't show your work i don't believe it um but you know we haven't seen sort of the growth in the towns resulting in huge spikes in

the schools from my understanding. Is that true? Yeah. What I can say is in the projected enrollments that we unrolled when I first presented the budget that are in the slideshow from, gosh, January 28th, those projected enrollments take into account as best as we can, as well as we can,

the growth that we would anticipate. One piece of data that I can collect, I don't have it at my fingertips so I can certainly get it is over the past if it's five years or seven years how many people how many students in the eighth grade have chosen not to come to the high school we could do

that data point what's hard is that there's so many factors that are in that a student who moves who loses housing who chooses to go to private school whose parents split and they go to school in a different town so there's a lot of factors that we would not have so but

it's certainly data if that's something that the board wanted we keep all of those records of who did not enter the high school who went to FMS and DCS the other flip side of that is how many students are transferring in which this fall was incredibly high and more so than usual and so those are the numbers

that we can look at but again we don't have how many of those kids were originally RSU 5 students and are returning, how many are brand new? There's some kids who've moved here from Florida. And I was like, I'm very sorry. This is not the winter to do that. But we don't have that context in the numbers, but if that's something that the board was interested in,

we keep all of those records. Other questions? Okay, I want to take something back I said. I was making a joke about keeping things for five years, and this is clearly not something that's you know, funny talking about positions. Um, and it's just sitting on, sitting on me that I said

that and it wasn't intentional around positions. As you said, every single one of the positions is important and valuable. And I appreciate every single person who works in this district and you probably didn't care to hear that, but it, it was just weighing on me and I wanted to say it.

2:45:33

So, um, other questions. Oh, hi. Hi. Um, I just wanted to piggyback on something Jen said, And I know probably now it was, she made a comment 10 minutes ago, but it got me thinking a little bit differently. And she started by talking about math instruction is really 13 years of math instruction.

So we can talk about high school math, but I think we work really hard as a principal and administrative team to think about the instruction kids are getting from age four until when they graduate and thinking about what that picture looks holistically.

And it got me thinking about the question about the instructional strategist and why that had come up as something the administrative team decided to prioritize. And Julie's probably going to give me a look because I'm going to put her on the spot. But the instructional strategist, awesome. I gave her a little forewarning, like, hey, Julie, I'm going to throw you under the bus. But the instructional strategist in her building has been working particularly hard to think about early math instruction to build the foundation that benefits kids across that span.

And I think it will be helpful for you to hear a little bit about what that work looks like, both so we can continue this thinking about math instruction being pre-K to 12, and also to illustrate a little bit more about the value and also just like what that role looks like when you're thinking about an instructional strategist.

Yeah, you've heard from me before about like our goals have been math and really trying to improve our math instruction. And with an urgency of, you know, we need to not let gaps form, because the bigger they get, the harder it is to fill. And we see that just from children moving through our grade span up to second grade. But if they're hitting second grade with those gaps, it's just so much harder for them to maintain and keep up.

So the work we've been doing the last two years with our instructional strategist has really been to develop our math understanding of the development of the early numeracy progression. And so our strategist has led our whole staff through understanding reasoning

at the K-2 level. And we just have finished our kind of mid-year math assessments, and I we have every kindergarten class 89% or above meeting or exceeding the benchmark at that time we haven't had that data since I've been the principal there um so it just kind of speaks to

the impact that the strategist has when providing professional development and working with our teachers and we're working to get like it's not just individual teachers getting coaching we're working as teams to really build and deepen our understanding and our strategist is leading that

work with with everybody tom joined um one of our staff meetings uh recently where our strategist was running exactly that so there's a lot of deepening teachers understanding but then practicing the skills together and then bringing those to to classrooms and that is we're just seeing this

tremendous impact so you know when we when we came back to the table in terms of what would we add back we value our strategist so much because of we just see the direct impact they're having both on teacher instruction and then the impact on on learning too thank you that's it's helpful to sort

of zoom out a little bit and look more district-wide which is why I think we appreciate the feedback of the admin team so much in these discussions to be able to kind of look at it from from that lens yeah um yeah I wait I guess I I have like zoom out thoughts and I just wanted

to make sure that that was okay with everyone to share at this point okay um yeah so i feel like part of the pain of a decision like this it happens when we zoom in and understandably so um and so i don't know if you all have the same thing where after board meetings you just keep

thinking about them over and over again you can't stop but um in the spirit of trying to help myself stop do that. I sort of asked myself, what do I need to ask or answer to make myself comfortable in supporting the recommended budget? And I came up with a list of questions that I thought that

I would share. So these are the questions that I'm asking myself. Do we have administrators, teachers, and staff that are experienced, skilled, trustworthy, and dedicated to providing the best we can for our students? I believe the answer is yes to that. Was the budget created with thoughtful,

transparent, and collaborative processes involving administrators, teachers, staff, and the board? I believe the answer is yes. Was the budget created while considering the board's input to the amount it believed the towns and taxpayers could or would bear? The answer is yes. Were appropriate and

2:50:42

adequate time and care put into the creation of and the decisions around the budget? I believe answers yes was a budget created while thinking of children first and were decisions made based on how they would affect children and their education also

yes is a budget fiscally responsible and sustainable for the district and does it consider long-term impacts of current year budget decisions we've been talking about that a lot has the impact of any budget cuts been thoroughly investigated

through the lens of how it would impact students and the district's ability to manage any associated impact? And that's what we're hearing a lot about tonight. Have those potentially impacted by budget cuts been treated with kindness and respect? And will these cuts be

communicated with transparency and timeliness? I think that continues to happen and has happened so far. Has time and space and openness and compassion been provided to and for those who question or disagree with the recommended budget? And are we considering those opposing

Opposing voices and perspectives I believe the answer is also yes and then the last one that I considered is would supporting this budget be aligned with my role as a school board member to not operate the schools but to see that they are well operated and to leave the administration of the schools up to the superintendent and I think supporting the a tier of the budgets that have been presented to us would also be in alignment with that so that's been how I've been thinking about it lately and I just wanted to share with you all and offer those as

potential questions to consider too. Thank you, Stanis. Chris? I feel like I'm the only one with questions, but can I ask? That's usually me. Feel free. This is a question that is not specifically related to the fiscal year 27 budget, but is related to the projected that we talked about. Can you give us an update

on that process? I know you talked about doing that. I'm not sure if this is an appropriate time for that, but. Sure. So we just came from a facilities committee just before this at which we presented a draft RFQ to put out to bid to call for people to do that facility study.

The facilities committee has not yet chosen to advance it to the board because we want to consider it further. The language in that draft was specifically aimed very broadly so that it did not give any impression of predetermining an outcome.

And that's a very conscious choice. There were some members of the public there who I'm really glad turned up to just participate in that discussion. And so the next steps are to continue to refine that draft of an RFQ. And the intention

is to, once it clears the facilities committee, to bring it here to the full board so that it can be presented publicly in a fully transparent way and then to put it out to bid. And that process will take a long time. Our current

estimate is that we wouldn't even get a, we wouldn't have the facility study in hand until December of this year. So that's a long process. And in the meantime, we are creating space to just let this idea of change sink in and to listen. I went to the Durham Select Board last night.

I haven't arranged to go to the panel select board later this month and to Freeport in early April. I happened to land at the Durham select board at a really good night because it was dump night. And trash night, dump night.

Lois and Steph were also there. So, and gratefully, they put me first on the agenda, for which I was really, really happy. But that meant that there were quite a few people there. I mean, there must have been like 50 people there who had lots of questions.

And I didn't give a presentation. I talked for a little bit about the background of all of this, what we're doing with our budget, and the ideas that have been presented about possible long-term stuff. People asked lots of great questions. I would say that lasted, what, half an hour, 45 minutes, something like that.

The trash conversation lasted longer. I bet. Who doesn't like to talk trash for a long time? So, and part of what we have put in the RFQ actually is a communication and community engagement strategy. So I think, you know, right now, obviously we need to do everything we can to listen and be forward thinking and seeking out, seeking input.

2:55:53

But when we get further into the process, there is tremendous value in having these kinds of steps originate from outside my office and be moderated and curated in some degree by an objective party. So the short answer is there have been some very concrete steps recently, but no major decisions are going to happen for a very long time because that's how long it takes to do it right.

So I hope that helps. I also actually want to say, along those lines, I want to be really clear about this. There is obviously one of the problems we have to figure out is what to do with three-year-olds. And there was a public comment earlier about ambiguity, about the date.

So that is understandable ambiguity. The state's mandate for all districts to take on the responsibility is July 2028. but now that we have committed to cohort three, our deadline is now July 2027. So there's two deadlines, but the one that's for us now is 2027. And my major point, though, is that yes, we need

to solve that problem, and we cannot precondition any facility's reconfiguration decision on needing to solve that problem by a certain time. We have to give that process as much time as it takes. We cannot try to shoehorn a three-year-old solution in, you know, within, we just can't do

that. So I want to be very, very clear that my intention is to point out all the problems we are trying to solve and not to conflate the time. These are two separate timelines. We will figure out what to do with three-year-olds, no matter what happens with our buildings. We will have a

solution. And the solution that was mentioned about using partnering with community providers was discussed at length by the Early Childhood Task Force. And there are problems with that solution, but it also has possibilities. So we don't need to do that for four-year-olds

because we already have pre-K, and a pre-K has the capacity to absorb any new kids that we would have. Three-year-olds is a different matter, and we have next year to figure that out. I appreciate that. Thank you. Shifting a little bit. Am I correct in my calculations that

the budget that we will make for next year, I'm sorry, that we will make next year, so the fiscal year 28 budget, is the budget that will be impacted by the new collective bargaining agreement with the educator here. Has that negotiating process and anticipated requests from the union

been taken into consideration in the estimates we've made in terms of the impacts over the next couple of years? It has for the support staff contract, which we're currently negotiating. It's too early to do that for the educator contract for next year. So I think what Kelly used um to roll it out the years i think we had two years that we don't have a contract yet

i think she assumed the last year of the contract is what would be the increase for those two years as well last year of the contract so it would continue on that you know it would continue on that curve right so we didn't assume it was flat like there was going to be no raise we just assumed the same raise for next year would be the raise in the following two years right yeah that's super

helpful i guess i guess as i'm just trying to um uh i'm very much this evening finding myself thinking about um that document that i don't have anymore because i lost it um the uh just the scenarios in terms of what the impact will be um the next couple of years on the budget as

it's anticipated at the i guess it was the 10 and then the seven um yeah that that beautiful that beautiful baby. Um, um, and I think I'm just realizing that I'm, I'm, I'm putting a lot of weight on that, um, in my thinking about things. Um, you know, as, as I was listening

to the conversation around the, um, both when you said that the, um, you know, what the first three, um, positions that would be, uh, added back in, um, or I guess it would before position, sorry, that, and then the discussion of the math position at the high

3:00:58

school, you know, what my thought just kept going back to was, yes, but what is the impact on the future years? And I don't think that's a wrong thing to be thinking about. I think that's why we asked Kelly to put that together, is that we wanted that information.

but I guess I'll just own that I don't know how much, I don't know how much to rate that, um, and, um, and so I guess that doesn't, I guess all, I guess all I need to say is that in that, that's not, I think, um, I think, I think avoiding getting into sort of what we were referring to, uh, as horse trading in terms of, like, adding, like, like, uh, positions back in at the, at the will of the

board. I guess these questions that we're raising, for example, are in the math position. I guess I just don't know how much we need to take into consideration the benefit that we get from a budgetary perspective by not having that $105,000 on average for that position and therefore having

that not compounding over the years versus the potential benefit of that. What I don't want to do, and this is to your point about we can't, you know, as we get further out in time, it gets fuzzier and fuzzier. I guess I just want to be really clear with ourselves, whatever it is that we decide next

week, just that we're owning the estimate of the impact next year, and that we're owning if we say yes, go to 7.05, and then we run those through, that just, again, knowing that That's not gospel, but just sort of, like, owning that that sort of, it's at least, probably at least that, right?

And I guess I just want to be really clear about that, because I think in the conversation about the math strategist, again, everything that we're talking about and everything we're saying, both in terms of the concerns about it,

but also the rationale for it, I mean, it all comes down to me, like, to, okay, if we keep the math strategist, who else do we lose? Like, is it the health teacher at the middle school? I think that's really what I meant when I said... No, I know. No, I know, but that's what I mean, is that it's sort of to say if we're okay with both increasing,

like, it's either we're okay with increasing budget and therefore we're increasing the percentage and therefore we're okay with that this year and then we're okay with that for the years to come, or we are asking for another choice to be made,

either one that's currently in the 6% to be moved up, or some poor person that currently isn't even, doesn't have this on their radar at all. So I guess, I don't know, I guess I just wanted to sort of articulate that as the way I'm trying to approach this evening, and just, I guess, in terms of the math position,

I understand the logic for the proposal. I think the, like, the class sizes totally make sense. I think Jack's well-articulated point and others about sort of what the impact is on our ability to perhaps increase scores.

I think we just got it on that maybe, like, we're not going to be able to do that. Like, we're just saying, like, that's not something we can prioritize right now. and not because otherwise we say no it is a priority so like get to work math department

we're taking away one of your staff members and also you've got a lot of work to do which again i don't know that's not to your point that's not our responsibility really but but like that would kind of be what we'd be saying right at first um so i don't know i just

wanted to sort of put that out as we're thinking about this i think i'll just say for myself i I'd love to know what the impact of adding those four positions back in. I think for me, going from the 0.6 to the 1.0 for Spanish is a must

because I'm just not comfortable cutting the language program to the extent where it's only for 8th grade at FMS. But I just would really like to know what the impact of those other choices would be. So basically that colored spreadsheet. So maybe Kelly could come with that layering in the, those.

This one here. Yeah. So the roll forward. Yeah. And then just know, I mean, again, and then know, all right, if we're saying 7.05, like we're owning that for this year and we're saying that we believe that we can pass that

3:06:11

in our, um, in our district and then also owning whatever the impact of that is next year, knowing that, um, I mean, I guess all that we would probably also be saying to ourselves and sort of in advance of the contract negotiations is like okay you you know kind of what we are

kind of what we're wanting to hit like this is sort of where we are and if it's going to be over that there's going to be downstream impact of that which again it's not bad like that's like it's just perfectly it's being perfectly transparent about it exactly so like i'm fine and i'm fine

with that um yeah colin i i don't know like i it's hard to know that weight i think of the future but sometimes when when i've thought about like the future implications i'm also thinking about what would what additional flexibility might we gain in the future by making a tougher decision

now and so that's just a concept that i'm thinking of as well as like we know we've got a lot of tough stuff coming down the pipeline and so would making a more difficult decision now that we don't want to make give us more options to consider when we have to make bigger bigger choices or

like choices of wanting to like grow or expand opportunities or expand offerings because if we're constantly in this tension of right at the cusp of what we can ask taxpayers for we're not going to be, we're not going to have the space to do those things. Um, so that's just my thought.

Yeah, I just, I think, I think that's a really, again, I think that's a really smart way of thinking about it. I guess I'll just also own that, um, uh, here in public and on the internet that, like, I don't see any, I don't see any way in the next five to 10 years that, uh, this,

like, budget increase is going to be flattening out. Like, like, I'm not anticipating we're going have any like really true flexibility in the next couple of years we could have more but if we if we again if we're if we make some tough decisions now but just like um just to be clear like i'm

expecting it to you know remain around six or seven because of all of the factors that we're talking about i don't i don't see a way that that would that um at least again in my in my experience historically on the board which is limited um even though i now realize i'm one of the older

people in the park well to colin's point uh to colin's point i read a really thrilling news article yesterday in the portland press heralds where there's a bill in front of the legislature that would actually reduce free ports funding by quite a bit so um that's also in the back of my

mind of potential legislature changes that would not be favorable to our district in particular um we were in the i think the top 12 schools that would see cuts so in the state or not schools districts or units um which i think is really eye-opening um and something that is unfortunately

making me feel more toward the seven or whatever i don't even know what to call these anymore um they uh yeah um legacy tier two um only because as colin said like this isn't gonna get easier it it's not trending that way

and i think we have to be really eyes wide open about our cuts that we for many of us are painful and horrible, but I think potentially necessary if we're losing potentially almost $200,000 with a new model. Could you share the article? I did not

see it. Oh, yeah. I'll email it to the group. For those who are uninitiated, the state is considering a new modifications to the funding formula, which are really long overdue, but there are new factors that they would consider. And one of the most prominent is to consider income versus just property

valuations. And the attempt there is to try to better account for communities where the property valuations have skyrocketed, but people's incomes have not, which is a lot of communities in Maine. So it's a different calculus. And based on the way that shakes down right now, it looks like this

district would get less. This is not law yet, but it is before the legislature, and it's supported by many important groups. It's going to be supported by the Maine State Superintendent's Association, for which I don't speak. I am a member, but I don't speak. And also, I believe, by the MEA.

3:11:28

And I just want to point out, as we're thinking about the long-term impact of the budget, that they believe it's next year that panels town property revaluation happens and I think that we will see an increase in that and I think derms is coming up soon

as well so so those are town valuations those are completely separate from how the state does their valuations no it well I guess I can't say we'll have no impact. But the state are, because towns, and I will own that my town has a, I don't even know the

last time they re-evaluated properties in Durham. It's a long time. Anyway, we don't even get the full, like, homestead exemption because our equalization rate is so low relative to market value. And because there are towns like that, that haven't re-evaluated in 10 plus years,

And they're putting them in the same sort of funding EPS formula as cities that revalue, you know, basically do an adjustment every single year to market. They do their own valuation of all the towns, which is why if you look at the ED-279 and look at the valuation for the three specific towns, it's different than if you looked in your tax commitment book.

It's because that's what the state says is the current market valuation of your towns. so the towns can individually make their own decisions but um the state has their own i mean not to say they're not tied in some sort of way but it's not a direct connection like that so yeah

so these these numbers right yes these are not the town i mean those are the town numbers because that's it comes from your tax bill sorry that like the Durham state valuation ed the freeport state valuation the panel state yes those are those are from the ED-279 and so whether whether panel you know reassesses of Durham reassesses it doesn't change any of this is that correct that is that is cool doesn't

necessarily mean so like if you looked this is a good actually a good example so so if you look at Durham on that page right so the Durham evaluation for per the ED-279 is $692,816,667. That's an average. They average over three years to prevent spikes and valleys.

So that is the average of the valuation according to the state for the town of Durham. Go down below to the line that says estimated impact based on the 25-26 mil rate of $33.58 and the taxable valuation. the town says the property is worth 389 million versus the state saying it's worth 693 million

so they're not tied thank you for pointing out that page that's a good example whereas if you look at freeport's freeport town says it's worth 2.6 billion and the state says it's actually worth less but that's an average of three years so it could be in a rising rate environment 2.5 so

they're a lot closer okay so i'm hearing one request for information for next week which kelly will pull together for us yes as a direction of the superintendent sure we'll talk um any other questions comments all right to be continued i'm just i'm just um i'm just going

back through my notes and i just i know there were a number of um a number of comments this evening that we're about sort of meeting our legal obligation and you did say that you assert that we are but I guess I would just I will also go back through my notes and if there's anything there that I think is that I can't think of right now I will forward that to you Tom just to sort of confirm that we are I have full faith we are doing that because of my trust in the administration but I just want to make sure that we honor those concerns absolutely okay um so uh item 13 is new business um lois got herself uh looking to get herself

assigned to the curriculum committee so do i have a motion just because um she's currently for official members of the committee we do take a vote so um do i have a motion for consideration and approval to appoint Lois Kilby-Chesley to the Curriculum and Program Development Committee.

3:16:41

Kara and Karen, thank you. Any comments? Other than thank you for volunteering. All those in favor, you can vote. Unless you want to vote opposed. You can do that too if you want. But too bad you're on it. The vote passes. Okay, so that was 13A. 13B, I will get a motion on the floor and then we'll have a discussion. do I have a motion for consideration and approval of the plant for use of remote school days to

offset cancellation of school due to weather? Is that a motion, Colin? Okay. And Steph, thank you. So as I've discussed it a few times now, we are, we did officially get permission from the Department of Education, from the commissioner, to repurpose March 13th, that's this Friday,

as a half student day. So that means technically speaking, we have not, we have used four snow days, but we've offset one of them. So we're at three. Thank you folks. That puts the last day of school at Monday, June 21st. It's the Monday. 22nd. It's the Monday of that week. So in, yes. So in an

effort, because we're already well into June, in an effort not to go beyond the marked days on the calendar, which had been already indicated as potential storm makeup days, I present to you this plan to keep remote school days sort of in the back pocket in case we use them. We would not

invoke this unless we were going to go beyond the Wednesday of that week, which is the 24th, So that means we have two more regular snow days before we would go to this plan. And I will unapologetically say that we are intending this to be a serviceable but very easy and respectful plan all the way around,

both for the staff and for the families at home. The highlights of this plan are for all grades, educators will be available by email during the normal school day hours. Of course, that's different depending on which school you're in, and that during that school day, educators will offer an hour of Google Meet office hours, which will be at different times, and that will be decided at the building level.

For grades pre-K to 5, we will actually send physical materials home. For grades 6 to 12, it will be online through Google Classroom. and we're asking students to check in using a Google form that we will send out for attendance

purposes. Kids who receive special services will access those services remotely during the course of the school day, and those teachers and service providers will work that out with the parents, will be available by email and through office hours. And parents or guardians will ensure that

students are engaged with the remote learning activities as assigned report attendance promptly and support students in learning and accessing services remotely moving on I don't I don't intend to read this whole document to you

I'm just trying to give you the highlights we've tried to make reasonable exceptions that fit within the collective bargaining agreements for work hours for both the educators and the support staff and for administrators

we've noted that there are some positions that simply require the person to be present unless it's really extreme weather and we close the buildings but for example you know fields and grounds people the people who shovel the walkways etc they would need to come to work the one one

thing to be mindful of is that we have to to for a day to count as a remote day we have to supply lunch. And that means, realistically, we have to send lunch home the day before, or we have to send out drivers in the middle of the weather event to deliver lunches to everybody. We're not going to

do that. So the plan would be, if we call a remote day, I will call it the day before, and I'll call it by 1 p.m. Does this increase the likelihood that I'll call it, and then it'll be beautiful sunshine the next day and it'll be a jk well yes it does but that's just a risk we'll have to run

3:21:41

the paper says 11 11 i'm yes it is 11 okay a.m sorry 11 a.m if it's a monday we'll have to call it on friday on friday yeah yeah but we have two more days before we get there i know well so i guess the question is is this something that would be in place next year yes if you approve it then

we just we have this in our back pocket and we don't have to invent it again unless we change it uh i am extremely unlikely to vote for this um i mean i think you already do that i just wanted to explain my thought on it uh for the rest of the board uh from my personal

experience as a parent um earlier this year we had a snow day where i had to go to one of my hospital sites, and my husband had a site visit for his job, and it was a snow day. And so I can't bring, because of HIPAA, shockingly, I can't bring my children with me to the hospital. So they ended

up going to the job site with my husband, which would make this totally untenable for us. Two years ago, we had a late storm in April. We lost power for three days, which is a no-go for internet. So that would have been impossible for us as well. So I'm really concerned about the equity of this

proposal in terms of folks where there are two working parents that can't parent actively, making sure that they're educating while also doing a job that maybe they can't not do. I also have concerns about our support staff that maybe have to take PTO to cover these days where others

or not that's how it works now is it well for vacation like on a snow day they okay yeah um yeah from a parenting standpoint for me this would be um maybe not impossible but for sure um a barrier and it makes me concerned especially since one of those storms was in april um and

would have been almost impossible um that wouldn't be me electing to not send my kids to school i I mean, I guess technically it would. But there's a cost barrier for me. Whereas anyone who's unwilling to extend into the summer,

they can elect to not send them at the end of the summer, and that's a different election in my view. We can discuss the differences in quality of education of home days versus a late-in-the-year in-person day. But for me, I just, particularly since this would carry into future years,

my quans, and I said it when we discussed the calendar in January, is that we are too far away from camp time, from, we're just off cycle. We've gotten too late in the year start, and now we're going too late in the summer.

And that, to me, is what needs to be fixed and not teaching from home. i will tend to agree with with valerie on this for probably different reasons but um just because we have different situations but i as a as having a second and third grader i would see them getting

significantly better education going for another day in the summer than having a blizzard bag type of situation that would happen um and i also worry that we're then setting a precedent for that going forward i say all that acknowledging the work that's done in this and really appreciating the

work that's gotten into into this idea but i i really struggle to see that kids would get a better outcome from having this versus having another day in the summer yeah i'll just say reading this did give me some real flashbacks to covid um at the same time i i would i do think

that you know every family is going to have a different situation every every child every age group and if we're if we're talking about our own children and what we're thinking i think my kids would probably learn more in a remote day than they would in the last day of school that's end of June mid to end of June so it is something that I would

3:26:43

like to see as an option though I'm I'm hearing what you're saying Valerie too and I'm it's a concern is this is the intention is that it wouldn't be our policy for snow days in general in the future it would just be if we exceed a

a certain amount and then we would shift to this is that the current thinking is that yes we would only use this to keep us from going beyond the days marked on the calendar as snow making and they're five because we love data do we know how frequently in the last ish years we've gone over

five i don't the good news is that with climate change it's going less and less of an issue so right we're also my life lost her job working on that so i don't know i don't know maybe uh you know, it's all up in the air. Luckily, next year's calendar looks a bit different,

so we're not extending as late into the summer day. Right, yeah, that was one of the things I was going to point out, is this was sort of an unusual year with we started later than almost we ever do, and then the way the winter break fell, it was two full weeks, which we haven't had,

in. I can't even remember the last time. So, I mean, all of those things pushed us farther and farther into June. You know, to Valerie's point, that is, you know, that was unfortunate this year that that's the way it happened. You know, that varies year to year with how the calendar works

and trying to get that squared away with the other two districts that we have to align with. you know i i definitely wouldn't be supportive of this being our you know instead of snow days we're going to do this i don't think this is you know should be our our go-to plan um i am curious

if this has to be approved by the doe to count or if there's a certain number of kids that have to participate for it to count like if we have a plan that says we're going to do this and not one kid checks in? Does it count? The DOE does not need to approve this plan. The school board needs to

approve the plan. But they get to decide we have to provide food, but they don't care about the rest? Well, that's a federal regulation. Okay. So to count as a school day, you have to provide food? Yep. Okay. You have to do lunch. So as long as the school board approves the plan,

we are set to use it and to my best understanding the regular requirements around attendance would apply. Which is what? I don't remember the cut off off the top of my head. So like there could be a random Tuesday where no kids showed up and it wouldn't count as a day? Yes. Like maybe

June 23rd or something like that? That's a great point. What if it's the last day of school? You got to keep coming guys until someone shows up. Valerie. If a child can't attend a remote day due to access is there a way to get that excused yes i mean i would say that's probably similar to on

you know on a storm day if we have school but there's families that don't have power if they call and say we don't have power like i think that is an excused absence is that something that could be added to this it certainly could be yep yeah because i i think you're i mean there are will be

scenarios where it's just not workable um well so my perspective on this is this is a lot of trust. I don't really see Tom randomly calling the day if it's just going to snow and making it a remote day in April. If it's a blizzard and they're predicting 17 inches of snow like New

York got two weeks ago, I would hope you would make it a remote day. But if it's just a storm, we have to look at what the ultimate outcome of that storm might be. If it's two inches, maybe it's not a remote day. I mean, and I can tell you exactly how that process works. I'm up at like, you know, four in the morning, but Jeremy and the road commissioners are up an hour before that, and I get a call and say, how's it look? And they say, we got to cancel or we got to delay. I just take the advice of the people on the ground.

3:31:50

Except you now have to decide before it even started. That's true. So that would be sitting with the team and making a call. Well, yeah. I mean, and I guess that's the other thing, right? So if at 11 o'clock in the morning it's looking like 2 inches,

you're probably not going to call it. But if we get 20 inches, sorry, guys, it's an extra day in June. Yeah, because then we really would call it as a non-remote day. We don't have to use this, but you could cancel school for any number of reasons, right?

I mean, just because of water. Just because you want to. Exactly, Tom, that's why we hired you, for that kind of whim-based supervision of the schools. Yeah, that was just what I was going to ask, so if you didn't call it on Friday, because it was supposed to be beautiful, and then we got a foot of snow, you would just, we're not going to, it's going to be a snow day.

i think the only thing i was going to add is like i think this i was going back to stephanie's questions and i was like how many of these questions apply to this um and i think it's you know it's very helpful i think they're great questions i think i think at the end of the day i guess where i'm following i really appreciate the way valerie and chris talked about it i think

for me i think that i don't think the administrators would have brought this to us if this was bad for the kids and their families like i just i think this is the this is the best option they could come up with um based on the factors that uh are there and i think to again

to stephanie's point it's like um we either trust that they can run the school um or we don't um at at a certain binary level um again um when it gets to your sort of whims of just sort of like Oh, my wins are so bad. I'm starting to doubt myself in decisions I've made in the past on hiring committees. But, yeah, I think, again, that's the way I'm thinking about it. It's just that I think that we wouldn't have been brought something that would be bad for our kids, especially given what all of the teachers know about the experience of children during COVID. That would be something.

That'd be really something if they did that. And it's, you know, back to the question of flexibility. It's not financial flexibility, but it provides an avenue in the appropriate scenarios. It doesn't lock you into using it, but it gives you the opportunity if it fits, right? Yeah. Can you explain, is this a

district guideline? It's not a district policy. It is not a policy. What is it? It's a remote snow day plan. It's on green. Obviously, it's on green. I don't know, Tom. I think we'd kind of like to see it. It's a policy committee. I think it'd be really fun. Take a look. Oh, sorry. No, we don't. I guess I was under the understanding that the DOE had requirements for how to use remote school days. Maybe they don't anymore.

I checked with the deputy commissioner, and he said, no, you just need your school board to approve it. That's crazy, but okay. Okay, any other further comments or questions? We do have a motion and a second before Kara leaves in case she wants to vote.

Oh, she's just getting a cookie. What? We already have the motion on the floor before 10. We can finish whatever we're talking about. We just can't start something new. Any other comments or questions? Nope. All right, all those in favor, oppose.

all right that passes um okay so now we have to take a motion to take up business after 10 o'clock i really hate this motion the fact the number of times we've had to use it there's only one more thing left on the agenda other than public comment so um so i'm thinking it's going to be

pretty quick so do i have a motion thank you chris second colin all those in favor you can you can vote no it's okay Kate Brown always used to vote no on this okay um okay so one more motion here so do I have a motion for consideration and approval to write a letter in support of the town of panels construction of a joint fire and rescue station and public works facility

Kara and Chris thank you so in your packet is a little letter on blue apparently it's for letters that we received from a consultant that's working with the town of panel they are they are applying for some I think some match funds or grant funds to help support the construction of the project

3:37:08

and they are asking for a letter of support from us as the school district saying that this would help the community and you know that is where the students are part of our district the back is the uh the sample letter that she was kind enough to provide to us um generally i i would

i i am supportive of this um but they sent it to us last week with like a quick turnaround and i felt a little bad because i you know tom and i didn't have the authority to say that the board wanted to write this letter without talking to you all so lois so because all of my questions

were not answered in this, I called the town of Paunel and I talked to Becky, who's their town administrator. And I asked several questions that I was concerned about. I don't need to go over every one of them unless you want me to, but she assured me that this had been talked about for four years in Paunel, that the community's familiar with the topic because I couldn't tell whether this was a bunch of people just coming together saying, hey, let's ask for a letter of support. I didn't know who this person was or who she represented.

Becky assured me that it's been on the table. It's going to go to the town, at the town meeting as a warrant. They're actually getting the warrant language approved by the lawyer as we speak. And so having had those questions answered,

I'm thinking that this is a good thing to do because, yes, the date may have passed for Shelly Pingree, but it has not passed for Senator Collins, who holds the bigger pot of money. So Senator King and Representative Pingree both hold money,

but because Senator Collins is, I believe, the head of appropriations, she has a huge pot. And so that deadline for that pot of money is April 19th. No, it hasn't passed yet. I think it's the 19th of March, although I just said April.

Now my brain has gone blank on whether it's April or March, but we haven't gotten to that date yet, and they can get that letter attached to their application for Senator Collins in the hopes of being able to access Collins' money.

Yeah, I read her letters that she was contracted by the town, but thank you for confirming that. I mean, I don't know who's contracted by the town, and I don't know who's representing who anymore, Well, thank you for doing that extra legwork.

It was my pleasure. I had a chance to talk to Becky. So you feel comfortable with this after that conversation? Yes, and if anyone has any questions, I do have the answers written on a scrap. Any questions, comments? All right, we have a motion and a second. All those in favor? Great, none opposed. Thank you. All right, so we will get that letter drafted and over to them ASAP so they can attach it to their projects. all right so that is all of our new business we have no personnel we do have

public comment and we do have a few folks who who hung in there so we will provide the opportunity if anyone's interested in speaking same rules apply no one's diving at the opportunity okay well then I will take a motion to

adjourn Kara and Steph all those in favor thank you see you next week

Source: the district's recordings on YouTube, turned into text by speech-to-text software. No wording corrected.