RSU 5 Board of DirectorsWednesday 11 March 2026
Board meeting · 3 h 41 min · Watch on YouTube →
The summary is written by AI from a computer-made transcript, and it can be wrong. Each time links to that moment in the recording, so you can check it. A (?) after a name means the transcript does not make clear who was speaking.
The RSU 5 Board of Directors met on March 11, 2026 at the Freeport High School library, with two members absent. Public comment ran long, with teachers, students and residents speaking against proposed budget reductions to a high school math position, the community outreach coordinator, an ESOL position, middle school French, and ed tech positions, and Pownal residents speaking against facility scenario two. The superintendent framed next year's budget as the launching pad for longer-term sustainability and continued to recommend the 7% tier, while describing what he would add back to move between tiers: an instructional strategist, making the FMS Spanish position full-time, and two general ed techs. The business manager walked the board through a staffing retention spreadsheet, article reserves, facility reserves and undesignated fund balance. No budget vote was taken; the board asked for a roll-forward analysis of the add-backs for the next meeting and adopted a remote snow day plan, appointed Lois Kilby-Chesley to the Curriculum and Program Development Committee, and approved a letter supporting Pownal's fire/rescue and public works facility.
What was decided
- 0:00Approval of the minutes of the February 25, 2026 meeting as presented, barring errors or omissions; moved by Karen (?) and Lois (?)passed
- 3:16:41Appoint Lois Kilby-Chesley to the Curriculum and Program Development Committeepassed
- 3:16:41Approval of the plan for use of remote school days to offset cancellation of school due to weather; moved by Colin and seconded by Stephpassed
- 3:37:08Motion to take up business after 10 o'clock; moved by Chris and seconded by Colinoutcome unclear
- 3:37:08Approval to write a letter in support of the Town of Pownal's construction of a joint fire and rescue station and public works facility; moved by Kara (?) and Chris (?)passed
- 3:42:10Motion to adjourn; moved by Kara (?) and Steph (?)passed
- 3:04:40No vote taken on the 2026-2027 budget; the board asked Kelly (?) to bring a roll-forward analysis of the proposed add-backs to the next meetingtabled
Votes on this board are weighted. Each director's vote counts in proportion to the population of the town they represent, so this page says only whether a motion passed, not how many voted for it. "Outcome unclear" means the recording does not state the result plainly. The software that turns speech into text can drop a "not".
Money discussed
- 1:01:12$13,000 a year Payment to share a vehicle fleet facility with the Town of Freeport, without an MOU.
Said: “we pay I think $13,000 a year to share that facility”
- 1:22:08$416,637 Current balance in the Article 1 regular instruction reserve, with no addition proposed.
Said: “is $416,637, about three and a half, almost four teaching positions”
- 1:22:08$954,081 Starting balance this year in the Article 2 special education reserve.
Said: “We started a balance this year with $954,081”
- 1:27:24two hundred thousand Proposed transfer from undesignated fund balance to replenish the Article 2 special education reserve.
Said: “I'm proposing that we use two hundred thousand from the undesignated account to refund the article to reserve”
- 1:27:24nine hundred and sixty four thousand Projected Article 2 special education reserve balance after expenditures and replenishment.
Said: “it would leave article two around nine hundred and sixty four thousand”
- 1:27:24six thousand seven hundred and sixty eight dollars Balance of the Article 5 student and staff support reserve, with no increase proposed.
Said: “article five student and staff support that it has a balance of six thousand seven hundred and sixty eight dollars”
- 1:27:24$140,000 Proposed addition to the Article 6 system administration reserve for possible professional fees related to the district's future planning.
Said: “We're proposing to add $140,000 in previous years”
- 1:27:24$150,000 Alternative figure mentioned for the Article 6 system administration reserve addition.
Said: “So we're proposing to add $140,000 and saying maybe $150,000.”
- 1:27:24$60,000 Amount placed in the transportation article reserve when the article reserves were established, for out-of-district placement transportation costs.
Said: “we had put $60,000 in when we established the Article Reserves for Transportation”
- 1:27:24$1,450,000 Projected total in all article reserves at the end of next year if the proposals are adopted.
Said: “the article reserves would have $1,450,000 in them”
- 1:32:32$2,420,000 Capital projects reserve balance at the end of last year including the 25-26 contribution.
Said: “we ended at $2,420,000 with the amount that we put in in 25-26”
- 1:32:32$290,474 Total cost of replacing the Pownal Elementary School septic system, including playground components disturbed by the work.
Said: “the PES septic finally got replaced. The total cost of that was actually $290,474”
- 1:32:32$483,269 Expected amount to be expended from capital projects on life safety cameras and door access.
Said: “The expected amount to be expended on that is $483,269”
- 1:32:32$27,495 Track re-striping and turf curbing repairs at the track and field.
Said: “track re-striping and turf curbing repairs out at the track and field. That was $27,495”
- 1:32:32$55,000 Approved project to replace the failing DCS building automation system.
Said: “You've approved a project for the DCS building automation that was failing. That's up to $55,000”
- 1:32:32$30,000 Approved variable flow pump replacements at Freeport High School.
Said: “the varial flow pump replacements, you guys had approved $30,000 for that”
- 1:32:32$41,500 Approved Freeport High School tennis court design services.
Said: “The FHS Tennis Court Design Services was the most recent project, $41,500 that was approved”
- 1:32:32$481,000 Amount that normally rolls through the local budget for capital projects.
Said: “normally we have about $481,000 that rolls through the local budget”
- 1:37:39$81,000 Amount actually expended or anticipated out of the scheduled capital projects after roof work was delayed.
Said: “all that was really expended was $81,000 or anticipated out of the capital projects”
- 1:37:39$100,000 Facility study voted on by the board at the previous meeting.
Said: “lastly is the facility study of $100,000 that you voted on at the last meeting”
- 1:37:391.3 million Anticipated remaining balance in the capital projects reserve, with no new appropriation proposed this year.
Said: “So we're anticipating to have about 1.3 million, which we feel is comfortable”
- 1:37:39$190,000 Amount set aside in the tennis court reserve at the end of this year.
Said: “there'll be $190,000 that has been put aside for the tennis courts”
- 1:37:39$510,000 Proposed addition to the tennis court reserve from undesignated fund balance.
Said: “we're requesting to add $510,000 to the tennis court reserves”
- 1:37:39$700,000 Projected tennis court reserve balance after the proposed addition.
Said: “which will make the balance about $700,000”
- 1:37:39681,000 Rough estimate to replace the three asphalt tennis courts as they currently exist, before core borings.
Said: “it's about 681,000 right now we still need to do the the testing”
- 1:37:39$35,000 Annual contribution to the track and field reserve, proposed to continue.
Said: “we put about $35,000 into that at the end of the 25-26 year”
- 1:37:39280,000 Track and field reserve balance at the end of the 25-26 year.
Said: “at the end of the 25-26 year there'll be 280,000”
- 1:37:39$315,000 Projected track and field reserve balance after the proposed annual contribution.
Said: “so that'll that would leave a balance of about $315,000”
- 1:37:39a hundred thousand Heating fuel reserve established years ago as a cushion against fuel price increases; never used.
Said: “and then a heating fuel reserve of a hundred thousand that was established”
- 1:42:432.4 million Combined total of the facilities reserves: capital projects, tennis court, track and field and heating fuel.
Said: “that brings us to 2.4 a little over 2.4 million”
- 1:42:43$885,000 Total proposed appropriation from undesignated fund balance into the article and facility reserves this year.
Said: “we're proposing to appropriate $885,000 from undesignated fund balance this year”
- 1:42:4347 million Total proposed 2026-2027 budget expenditures.
Said: “this year's 26, 27, we're proposing 47 million. That's the total year over year budget.”
- 1:42:43$1.4 million Shared revenues budgeted to offset taxation.
Said: “We're budgeting $1.4 million in shared revenues”
- 1:42:43$15,000 Amount Community Programs' Laugh and Learn pays toward the cost of space it uses in district buildings.
Said: “you'll see that $15,000 is there. They're in the same amount of spaces as they were last year”
- 1:48:01eighty six hundred dollars The aspirations account in the superintendent's budget, used for team travel such as states or nationals.
Said: “we put it align it within the superintendent's budget for eighty six hundred dollars”
- 1:48:01$900,000 Historic level of undesignated fund balance used annually to offset taxation before the vehicle and equipment replacement plan and energy audit projects.
Said: “we were running about $900,000 in this line”
- 1:48:01$300,000 Example given of interest collected above budget, which would end up in undesignated fund balance.
Said: “if we collect $300,000 in interest, that's something more than what we budgeted for”
- 1:58:47$4,010,701 Estimated undesignated fund balance per the preliminary audit.
Said: “the estimated undesignated fund balance is $4,010,701”
- 1:58:473 million dollars Projected uncommitted undesignated fund balance after the proposed reserve designations.
Said: “where we would be looking to land is about 3 million dollars which represents 6.76%”
- 2:04:02$45 million Illustration of a district budget size used in discussing the former 3% undesignated fund balance statutory cap.
Said: “think about a $45 million budget with a million two allowed in your savings account”
- 2:09:1952.5 Approximate cost of each of the two elementary ed tech positions proposed as an add-back.
Said: “each of the two elementary ed techs, about half of $105,000, of 52.5”
- 3:00:58$105,000 Average cost of the high school math position under discussion, cited in weighing the budget impact over future years.
Said: “by not having that $105,000 on average for that position”
- 3:06:11almost $200,000 Potential loss to the district under a proposed change to the state funding formula before the legislature.
Said: “if we're losing potentially almost $200,000 with a new model”
- 3:11:28$692,816,667 Durham's state valuation per the ED-279, a three-year average.
Said: “the Durham evaluation for per the ED-279 is $692,816,667”
- 3:11:28$33.58 The 25-26 mil rate used in the estimated impact line of the budget document.
Said: “estimated impact based on the 25-26 mil rate of $33.58”
- 3:11:28389 million The Town of Durham's own stated property valuation, contrasted with the state's figure.
Said: “the town says the property is worth 389 million”
- 3:11:282.6 billion Freeport's town-stated property valuation, which the state values lower on a three-year average.
Said: “Freeport town says it's worth 2.6 billion and the state says it's actually worth less”
- 3:37:08no amount given Letter of support requested by the Town of Pownal for grant or match funding toward a joint fire and rescue station and public works facility; deadline tied to Senator Collins's appropriations pot.
Said: “they are applying for some I think some match funds or grant funds”
Each amount is checked against the transcript. An item is kept only if the words quoted, and the amount, were said near that moment. Amounts are shown as they were said. The district's minutes are the official record. "Find in spending" opens a search of the district's monthly reports for related lines. Those reports name accounts, not companies, so the search shows where the money may sit, not the payment itself.
4 more mentions of money are left out, because their words could not be found in the transcript.
Worth knowing
- 2:09:19The superintendent's recommended add-backs between tiers -- an instructional strategist, making the 0.6 FMS Spanish position full-time, and two general ed techs at Morse Street and Mass Landing -- would bring the budget to 7.05%, according to Kelly (?).
- 2:25:06The Freeport High School principal gave current math class size averages: Algebra 1 at 14.8, geometry at 16.6, Algebra 2 at 15.4, computer programming at 11.5, against ELA 9 at 18.25 and American history at 20.8. High school enrollment is 570, down from a peak of 645.
- 2:55:53Because RSU 5 committed to cohort 3, its deadline to assume responsibility for three-year-olds is July 2027, a year ahead of the statewide July 2028 mandate.
- 3:06:11A bill before the legislature would change the state funding formula to weigh income alongside property valuation; a board member said RSU 5 is among roughly the top 12 units that would see cuts.
What was discussed, in order
- 0:00Call to order and minutes
The chair opened the meeting at Freeport High School library, noting two members were absent. A motion to approve the February 25, 2026 minutes was made by Karen and Lois (?).
- 5:10Good news: Youth Art Month
Maria reported March is National Youth Art Month and the Scholastic Awards ceremony is March 14 at Portland High School. Five of the eight works selected from Maine's two congressional representatives are from Freeport High School: Lila Abbott, Nina He, Jaden Schultz, Allie McGee and Luana Senna. Allie McGee's work is in the Portland Museum of Art Youth Art Month Exhibition.
- 5:10Public comment ground rules
The chair read the ground rules: three minutes per speaker, identify name and town, comments directed to the board, no comments about specific staff members, and no board response.
- 10:12Public comment: high school math position
Marsha Wood, a Freeport High School math teacher of 13 years, Erin Abbott, a math teacher of 20 years, and Haley Goodspeed all spoke against eliminating a math teaching position, citing low PSAT/SAT scores, class size, loss of the computer programming program, and the strategic plan. Senior Jack Brogan later spoke on the same cut, arguing enrollment decline is partly driven by families losing confidence.
- 20:20Public comment: community outreach coordinator
Lisa Blyer, an English and alternative ed teacher at Freeport High School, opposed halving the community outreach coordinator position, listing job shadows, author visits, career exploration and at-risk student support. Rick Wilson, Community Outreach Extended Learning Coordinator at Brunswick High School, said more than 75 Maine schools have community outreach professionals and none of those positions are part-time.
- 20:20Public comment: ESOL staffing
Jill Hyland, an ESOL educator, said the proposed reduction of a full-time ESOL position would leave two educators covering five buildings pre-K to 12 and asked the board to maintain three educators across two and a half positions, citing the district's Lau plan and Lau v. Nichols.
- 30:33Public comment: middle school French
Taylor Dombroski, a sixth grade student at Freeport Middle School, asked the board to reconsider removing French and world cultures from the middle school curriculum. Sarah Davis, who teaches French and world cultures in grades 6-8 at FMS, said she was devastated by the decision and also asked the board to reconsider cutting ed tech positions.
- 30:33Public comment: Pownal Elementary School
Jim Donahue, a retired Pownal teacher of 35 years, described the school as the center of the Pownal community and opposed sending grade 3-5 students elsewhere. Andy Seymour invited the board to a PES kindergarten sugar shack visit. Kate Martins cited research on rural school dissolution and quoted the 2008 RSU 5 reorganization plan on attendance areas and transportation efficiencies.
- 30:33Public comment: three-year-old mandate and mixed delivery
Jenna Hsu of Pownal said Maine DOE guidance published in December describes a mixed delivery system partnering with licensed child care providers, and that the mandate does not necessarily require the district to create more space. She also noted conflicting deadlines: July 2027 in the district's February 11 document, and July 2028 in a Portland Press Herald article.
- 50:49Superintendent's report: resignations
Two resignations were reported: Amy Broadbent from Laugh and Learn Before Care, and Erica Mazao (?), assistant superintendent of curriculum, instruction and assessment, effective the end of the school year. The latter was not on the agenda and will prompt a search.
- 56:07Superintendent's budget framing remarks
Superintendent Gray said every reduction in the 6%, 7% and 8% tiers was developed with criteria informed by staff feedback and that all are legally sound. He said he still recommends the 7% tier, and that long-term issues include Morse Street, middle school integration at sixth grade, and the vehicle fleet facility shared with the Town of Freeport.
- 1:11:41Staffing retention spreadsheet
Kelly (?) walked through a new spreadsheet showing FTE for educators, ed techs and specialists by school for 25-26 and under the superintendent's recommended tier, with reductions shown in red. The print clerk, the community outreach coordinator reduction and the half-time middle school secretarial reduction are not on the sheet. Board members asked about the teacher of the deaf (an addition, not a cut), ESOL allocation at Pownal, and mileage for staff travelling between buildings.
- 1:22:08Article reserves
The business manager reviewed article reserve balances and proposed additions: Article 1 regular instruction, Article 2 special education, Article 5 student and staff support, Article 6 system administration, and transportation. She explained reserves are funded from undesignated fund balance and spent only with board authorization.
- 1:32:32Facility reserves and capital projects
The capital projects, tennis court, track and field and heating fuel reserves were reviewed, including expenditures for the PES septic, life safety cameras and door access, track re-striping, DCS building automation, FHS pump replacements, tennis court design services, and the facility study. No addition to capital projects is proposed this year.
- 1:42:43Revenues and undesignated fund balance
The business manager explained shared revenues including the Hunter Road fields agreement with Freeport, Medicaid billing, interest, Laugh and Learn space, and the move of four-year-old CDS funding to a separate fund. She explained why undesignated fund balance should be used for one-time expenditures, and gave the estimated balance and the state statutory limit.
- 2:09:19Add-backs between the 7% and 8% tiers
The superintendent said the administrative team's order of add-backs would be: an instructional strategist, making the 0.6 FMS Spanish position a 1.0 so all 7th and 8th graders get world language, and two general ed techs at Morse Street and Mass Landing. Kelly (?) said those three items bring the budget to 7.05%.
- 2:19:42Discussion of the high school math reduction
Lois (?) said she is very concerned about cutting a math position, particularly the computer programming teaching. The Freeport High School principal, Jen (?), gave class size averages across math and other subjects and said projected enrollment declines mean class sizes would rise but not to a level she would bring to the board as too large. Board members discussed enrollment projections, hiring and re-hiring cycles, and housing growth in the three towns.
- 2:45:33Instructional strategist impact
An administrator explained the strategist's role in building early numeracy instruction. The Morse Street or Mass Landing principal, Julie (?), said after two years of this work every kindergarten class had 89% or above meeting or exceeding the mid-year math benchmark, data she had not seen before.
- 2:50:42Board member framing questions
Stephanie (?) read a list of questions she uses to decide whether to support the recommended budget, including whether the process was transparent, whether children were considered first, whether it is fiscally sustainable, and whether supporting it aligns with the board's role to see the schools are well operated rather than to operate them.
- 2:55:53Facility study RFQ update
The superintendent said the facilities committee reviewed a draft RFQ earlier that day but has not advanced it to the board. The draft language is deliberately broad so as not to predetermine an outcome; the facility study would not be in hand until December. He also went to the Durham Select Board the previous night and plans visits to Pownal later in March and Freeport in early April.
- 2:55:53Three-year-old mandate deadlines
The superintendent clarified that the state mandate for all districts is July 2028, but because RSU 5 committed to cohort 3 its deadline is July 2027. He said the facilities reconfiguration decision cannot be preconditioned on solving the three-year-old question by a certain date, and that partnering with community providers was discussed at length by the Early Childhood Task Force.
- 3:06:11State funding formula changes
A board member reported a Portland Press Herald article on a bill before the legislature that would reduce Freeport's funding, placing the district among roughly the top 12 units that would see cuts. The superintendent explained the proposal would consider income alongside property valuation, and discussion followed on state versus town valuations in the ED-279.
- 3:16:41Appointment to Curriculum and Program Development Committee
A motion was made to appoint Lois Kilby-Chesley to the Curriculum and Program Development Committee, moved by Kara (?) and Karen (?).
- 3:16:41Remote school day plan for storm cancellations
The superintendent presented a plan to use remote days only to avoid going beyond the storm makeup days marked on the calendar. March 13 was repurposed as a half student day with DOE permission, offsetting one of four snow days; the last day of school is currently the Monday of that June week. Valerie and Chris said they would not support it, citing equity for working parents, power outages, and the value of an in-person June day; others said they trusted the administration's judgment.
- 3:37:08Letter of support for Pownal fire/rescue and public works facility
The board considered a request from a consultant working with the Town of Pownal for a letter supporting construction of a joint fire and rescue station and public works facility. Lois said she called Pownal town administrator Becky, who confirmed the project has been discussed for four years and will go to town meeting as a warrant article, and that a funding deadline remains open.
- 3:42:20Second public comment and adjournment
No one came forward for the second public comment period. A motion to adjourn was made by Kara (?) and Steph (?).
Financial reports for the period ending 31 January 2026
These are the district's most recent monthly reports dated at least two weeks before this meeting. They show each account's budget and what had been spent by 31 January 2026.
- Community Recreation/Adult Education
- General Budget Report
- Grant Reporting
- Report by Article
- Revenue Reporting
- School Nutrition
Every month's financial reports →
Elsewhere
Source & method
Regional School Unit 5: board meeting recordings on YouTube, and the agendas and minutes on rsu5.org
Each recording is turned into text by speech-recognition software and summarised by an AI language model. Every money item in a summary must quote words the speaker said, with the amount, and links to that moment in the recording. Agendas and minutes are the district's own files.
https://www.rsu5.org/board-of-directors-and-policies/board-agendas-and-minutes
Data as of 4 November 2026 (the date of the newest meeting listed); retrieved 19 November 2026.
